You are on page 1of 120

, ,

2015 , 4 (54)

2015


20151



.

.

.

: 279
ISSN:2226-9185

. 5 .

: - 46,
, -1
: +(976)-11-315735
: 315735
: www.legalinstitute.mn
: lawjournal@legalinstitute.mn

EDITORIAL BOARD
J.Amarsanaa

Academician

B.Amarsanaa

(LL.D)

J.Batzandan

(Ph.D)

J.Bayartsetseg

State Secretary, Ministry of Justice of Mongolia

B.Boldbaatar
Secretary General, the Secretariat of the State Greate
Hural of Mongolia
J.Byambadorj

(Ph.D)

D.Ganbat Chairman, the Standing Committee of Law of the State


Great Hural of Mongolia

B.Gunbileg

(Ph.D)

D.Dorligjav

Minister of Justice

Ts.Zorig Chief Justice, Supreme Court of Mongolia


O.Munkhsaikhan

(LL.D)

S.Narangerel

Academician

Ch.Unurbayar

(Ph.D)

D.Solongo (Ph.D)
Kh.Temuujin

Member of the State Great Hural of Mongolia

P.Tsagaan Head, the Office of the President of Mongolia


Sh.Tsogtoo

(Ph.D)

Ch.Enkhbaatar

(Sc.D)

J.Erdenebulgan

(Ph.D)
Editor-in-Chief
E.Batbayar
Acting Assistant Editor
B.Gonchigsumlaa
Designed by
D.Munkhjargal

State Registration Number:279


ISSN: 2226-9185
The National Legal Institute
publishes this law review five times
per year.

Address: Ulaanbaatar-46, Chingeltei District,


Chinggis khaan Square -1
Phone:+(976)-11-315735
Fax: 315735
Website: www.legalinstitute.mn
E-mail: lawjournal@legalinstitute.mn


/ , /


(Sc.D.),
(Ph.D.), .

- .

-
-

,
.

32

, : ,

38

52

:
.

66

- ,
(Ph.D) .
- - ,
. -

, ,

,

78

83

- , (Ph.D),
.


, .

89

96

- - , (Ph.D) .

- .

, ,
107

CONTENT
BEFORE CREATING A LAW (UNDERLINING ARTICLE AND INTERVIEW)
Analyzing the Constitution of Mongolia with a basis of its
Economic concepts
Prof. Lundendorj.N, Sc.D, PhD

Sainkhishig.J, PhD Candidate at School of Law, National University of Mongolia

Legal Principles in Criminal Law Theory of Crime characteristics


Legal techniques
Erdenebat.G, Deputy Prosecutor of the Prosecutor General of Mongolia,
State Vice Counsellor of Justice

32

LEGAL THOUGHTS: REFLECTION


Perspectives on Legislation of Assessment for Mandatory Auction
of Immoveable property

38

Cybercrime: Regional territory and Specialty of activity

52

Economic guarantee of Court: Court budget

66

Doljin.S, Ph.D, Lecturer at Private Law Department, School of Law, NUM

Khurel-Ochir.Ts, Lecturer of Information and IT at School of Law, NUM

Altansukh.J, Legal specialist at Ministry of Energy

IMPLEMENTATION OF LAW, EFFICIENCY, ISSUES


Challenges and Reform of Criminal Procedure Law of Mongolia

78

Issues on Improving the State secret of Mongolia

83

Byambaa.J, Ph.D, Professor at School of Law, NUM

Batkhishig.B, Ph.D Candidate, Senior Researcher at National Intelligence Academy

Issues on Release from the Punishment by Amnesty and Pardon

89

Placement of State power and Facing challenges

96

Unurtsetseg.O, Ph.D, Lecturer at School of Humanities and Social Sciences,


Mongolian National University of Education.

Tuguldursuren.D, MA Candidate at School of Law, NUM

LEGAL RESEARCH OVERVIEW


Forensics 107
Research report of National Legal Institute

/ , /


(Sc.D.),
(Ph.D.), .

-
.

.

,
,

() .

,
,
,
.1



,

.
,


, ,
, ,



, ,
, ,

.


.



,
,

, ,

-
,
, ,
,

.

Buchanan, J. M. (1990) The Domain of Constitutional


Economics. CPE 1, p. 2.
1

2015 4 (54)


,
, ,



, ,
,
.
,
,

,



,

,
,

.

-

,
,
,
, ,
,

,
.
,
,

.
: -
,
.

,

,
,
,

,
,


.



(),
()- , ,
,

, ,

. ,
,
,

,
.
,

,
.

,


.


.

,

, ,
,

,
2
,

,

10

/ , /

, ,
2 ,
,


.



, ...



?..., , ,



3 2
.

2


. <
>, <
>
,






.
1992
,
,

,

.


.



.
,
,

.

.


,


1

.

,





-

< >
.




.

,
.

,
-

,
.

.
,
,
, ,
.Sanjeev Khagram, Paolo de
Renzio, Archon Fung, eds, (2013), Open Budgets: The Political Economy of Transparency, Participation, and Accountability, p. 2.
2

, :
, .,
2014, 602-604- .
3

11

2015 4 (54)




,

.
,

,

.
,

,

.5
,
,

.



.



,

.6

, , ,
,






?

-


.4


.
-

,

,
.

.
, , ,
,

.



.


.



.
,
-
.




.
,


.

,
,

< > . Buchanan, J. M. (1990) The Domain of Constitutional Economics. Constitutional Political Economy 1: 1 18.
5

The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume


16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 4.
6

, 306- .

12

/ , /


.
, ,


,
.


2 .



,
,
.


9 .

, ,
,
,
.

.

(,
,
..)
,


.

,
,

7
.




. -


8

.


.





.

.




20-



,


.


.

.1950-
,

Congleton, R. (2003). The Contractarian Constitutional


Political Economy of James Buchanan, p. 3.
7



.
9

The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume


16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 3.
8

13

20-
,

.
2015 4
(54)
.


.1950-

.12

.

.

V.

Rule-based policies

Discretionarypolicies

1.
,
7 Congleton, R. (2003). The Contractarian Constitutional Political Economy of James Buchanan, p. 3.

.
8 The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume 16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 3.
9

.
,
5




10
.
.
13 .
,



.





.



11

. ,
.



. ,



-

.
.




. ,

, ,
.

,




.
10
,


.
. The collected works

of James Buchanan (2001), Volume 16 : Choice, Contract,
and Constitutions, p. 8.

,


.
The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume 16,
Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 46.
11

Douglass C. North, Institutions, Institutional Change, and


Economic Performance, (New York: Cambridge University
Press, 1990), p. 3.
12

Buchanan, J. M. (1990) The Domain of Constitutional


Economics. CPE 1: 1 18.
13

14

/ , /

14
.



(

)
. ,
, ,

,

.


.
,


.15 .


,




.

16

,
,

...
,
, , ,

.17

.
,


, ,
,

. , , ,

,



,

.18



-



.
, -
,

,


,

...



...

, : ,
, ., 2014, 25-26- .
15

-


.
16

, : ,
, ., 2014, 28- .
17


.
14

18

15

, 28- .

2015 4 (54)

.



...



( )
.19
, ,
, ,
, , ,
,




,
,
,

,


.


, 2


.



. ,


.



.


,
.
, ,



.
, ,

,

,
.


,



.20



,

.



.

.

,
.21
,
,
,

.
,
,
,

, : ,
, ., 2014, 20-27- .

21

The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume


16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 54.
20

. , Jurisprudence- :
, . ., 2011, 170-197.

19

16

/ , /

,

,



.22
-

23

.

?
, ,
.

,
.

,

.
?




23
.
.

,
,

?
,

,
.

, ,
,

,
,


.
,

, ()



,



,



(

)

2.

,

. ,



.
,
24
2.
22

Political

.
Constitutional
Economy
by James
Buchanan, ,

Rowley,
Charles,
Schneider,
Friedrich
(Eds.)
Readings
in
.

Public
Choice and
Constitutional
Political Economy,

2008,

p. 284.

23

Tony Prosser, (2014), The Economic Constitution, Oxford


University Press, p. 9.

Tony Prosser, (2014), The Economic Constitution,17


Oxford University Press, p. 9.
The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume 16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 307.

23
24

2015 4 (54)

.24
,

.


,



.


.
,



. ,
-

.



.

,

.

,

.25



.




(1)
,
, (2)
(3)


, (4)
, ,

,
.26

,
.

, , ,



.27
,
(1)
,
(2)


,

,




.
-
,

-

The Legal Framework for Budget Systems: An International Comparison, OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4,
No. 3, 2004, p. 15.
25

26

The collected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume


16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 307.
24

18

, p. 27.

, ,
, , ,
: , 1949, 10, , 104a115, , 1949, 7, , 83-91, , 1948, 3,
//
54-59, , 1978,
7, , 128-136, , 1999 7,
, 81-92, , 1999, 3,
, 126-135, , 199125, ,
122-124, , 1992, 11, 125132, , 1992, , 111-119,
, 1997 10 , 216-227, , 2011,
, 36-44, , 2009 8, , 99106, .
.,
:
?
, 2015-1 /51/, 64- .
27

/ , /

2 .

.
5.

(Specificity):,

.


.
6.

(Balance):


.

. ,


,
,
,

,


.

,
2004
:
10 .28 :
1. (Authorita
tiveness):

.


.


7.

(Accountability):

.



.
8.

(Transparency)
9.
(Stability): ,


.
,

.
10. ,
,
(Performance):

,



.


2. 1 ,
(Annual basis):
3.

(Universality):

,
.

, .
.
4. (Unity):
,
,
.
,
The Legal Framework for Budget Systems: an international Comparison, OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4,
No. 3, 2004, p. 133.
28

19

2015 4 (54)


-

.

, ,

, .
,

.




,
.
:

:
,
.



.

:




.


.
- .

,


:


,

2
.
, ,




.29

,


,

.
,

2
,
,

,


.

,

,
,


.
,



,

., :
, , ,
, 2015-1 /51/, 19- .
29

20

/ , /


.
,
(2011)




.
3 31


, 30


.
225- (1997)


.31

.

1990 5

1990-2008
2012
76 , 45

.33
,
, ,



,

34


.
4
.35
1.
2.
3.
4.

.
1980- ,

(fiscal rule)


.




.32

.

.

, , ,

The Legal Framework for Budget Systems: an international Comparison, OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4,
No. 3, 2004, p. 10.
33


3 2(b).
30

- ,

, http://www.iltod.gov.mn/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/Comparision-of-FRL-FSL-related-Acts-in-other-countries.docx
34

,
: . , . .
31

Schaechter and others, Fiscal Rules in Response to the


Crisis. Toward the Next Generation Rules, IMF Working
Paper 12/187, July 2012, p. 5.
32

Ringa Raudla, Budgetary Institutions, Encyclopedia of


Law and Economics, 2014, p. 2.
35

21

2015 4 (54)

2006

1969, 2009

2004

,
,

2011

2011

2011

2012

2013

, ,
,


.



.
.
,
,
,

1924
,
5 (37-46 ), 1940
- , 8
37 (61-69- )
,

,
.
1924
37
,

,
, 41

...


,


.
1940
1924
.


, ,

1.

36
,


.
,

, -

,

,
,

.
,
,
,
,

.
Schaechter and others, Fiscal Rules in Response to the
Crisis. Toward the Next Generation Rules, IMF Working
Paper 12/187, July 2012, p. 5.
36

. , . ,
: , ., 2004, 49, 153- .
37

22

/ , /

, ,



. 1960
,


.

.
,
,

,
, , ,
,

,


.
,
,
, ,

,

,
,38

39
.
,
,


.


,
,
,
- ,


.


1992

1992 25
1 7-
, , ,
...- ,
... ,
...

,


.
2
2- ... , ,

,
...

,



.


, ,
, ,
,


,

.

, 1992
,

.
- 16.3, 5.2, ,
16.4,
- 5, 6 , 16.3, 16.4, 16.8, 16.17, 16.8,
19.1, ,
(- 5.2, 16.3.) ,
- 6.2, 6.3 .
38

39

23

5.4

2015 4 (54)



77



.
,



580 .,
30
290 ., -
162 .42 7


,

-
.
,
,
,




.
.

.
, ,

.

,

.
,
, , ,

.43

,

,


.
.

1.

.


.



,
.
,

,
,

.
, 20122014
40,
3
41, 1,5
.,
2012 10 25-
52
,
.
40

,
2.6
. 20162018 , - 2015 5
22- 51 ,
, 2015 22/883, 1069- .
42

3


. http://jargaldefacto.com/
, 2015.06.17.
41

43

24

, 1082- .

/ , /

,44 , ,

45



, ,


.46
2010
,
,
,
,



,

.
.
,
,

.


,

.

2012.11.08-

- 2013




,
, ,

,


.

,

.


,


,
,

.
2.

?

,
,


,

.

,
,
47,


, ,


() .

,
,

. 2010 -



.

, ,
, ,
5
. OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 2012 Supplement
1 Budgeting in Luxembourg, p. 16.
44

Mehmet Alpertunga Avci, The Constitutional Identity of


the Public Budgeting on the Scale of theEuropean Union
and Optimum Constitutional Budgeting, Mediterranean
Journal of Social Sciences, Vol 6 No 2 S2, March 2015, p.
140.
45

46

1. ;2.
- ; 3.

- ... ;4....
- 40 .
47

p. 137.

25

2015 4 (54)



. ,
, ,



-

.
, ,
, ,

.
- 6.2, 6.3


,
,



.


,
.
, 2015



58.3
14
.48 -
34
530
, 34
1.6 3


40
, -
58.3
.

-
,
, ,



.

-
5 ,
2015 3
, 49
,
. ,
,
- 40
58.3 ,
-
2 5
. 2010
2018

.
,
,

.
3.




.

,


,



.50
2014
-

2016-2018
, - 2015 5
22- 51 ,
, 2015 22/883, 1066-
.
48

2015-05-21, 2015-02-18, 2015-01-20, 2012-08-17, 2011-1223, 2011-02-10,


http://www.legalinfo.mn/additional/?lawid=503
49

50

26

: , .

/ , /

2015

,
2


.

18.2- 6.1.4



51




.


10 01-
11
15-
45 .52

,

. , ,
3
, , 4

.53

,

-
,
,
,





, ,
.
4.



, ,


.
,




.
, , ,

,

,
,
.54



, 216218

.55

,

,
,



-
. Schaechter and others, Fiscal
Rules in Response to the Crisis. Toward the Next Generation Rules, IMF Working Paper 12/187, July 2012, p. 21.
51

52

The Legal Framework for Budget Systems: An International Comparison, OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4,
No. 3, 2004, p. 28.
54

8 .

The Legal Framework for Budget Systems: An International Comparison, OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4,
No. 3, 2004, p. 91.
53

Krzysztof Prokop, (2011) Biaystok Law Books 7 Polish


Constitutional Law, p.187.
55

27

2015 4 (54)

,


.
,
,
-

,

,

.
,
2013



,
-

.
(2011)



. , 1948
34, 47


,

,

.56


.57

-19.6- -


,


.
2015 02
13- 02
58

.





.
5. ,

6


.


.
,
, ,

,
.

,

,
.
-


.
,

http://www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr/conseil-constitutionnel/
english/constitution/constitution-of-4-october-1958.25742.html#TitleXI
56

,
, ,
, ,

58

, , The Legal Framework for


Budget Systems: An International Comparison, OECD
Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4, No. 3, 2004, p. 39.
57

28

/ , /

.



,
,


.

(,
)
( , )

.




,
.


,
,
,
,
.


.
, ,

.



.


,

. ,



( ),

,


.




.
, ,


.
,

,

,

,

.

,
, ,
, ,
,

,


.




,
,

,
,
,

.

29

2015 4 (54)


,



,


,

.
(1) ,
, ,

,
,
,

, ,
,


,
(2) ,
,
, ,


,
(3)






.

1992

2013
2012


2007
2015
02 13- 02

2016-2018
, - 2015 5
22- 51
,
, 2015 22/883
2012 10
25- 52
.
. ,

. , . ,
:
, ., 2004.
. , . ,
.
, ., 2009.
. , Jurisprudence : , . .,
2011.
- ,

,

, 2015.06.17.http://
jargaldefacto.com/
,
,

, 2014.05.06,
: http://www.parliament.
mn/sgh/sc/categories/2588/pages/13846
,
,
:
,


1. :
. ,


2010
2011

2015

30

/ , /

., 2014.
, :
, ,
., 2014.

, : . ,
. .
,
: ..

Union and Optimum Constitutional


Budgeting, Mediterranean Journal of
Social Sciences, Vol 6 No 2 S2, March
2015.
Ringa Raudla, Budgetary Institutions, Encyclopedia of Law and Economics, 2014.
Sanjeev Khagram, Paolo de
Renzio, Archon Fung, eds, (2013),
Open Budgets: The Political Economy
of Transparency, Participation, and
Accountability.
Schaechter and others, Fiscal
Rules in Response to the Crisis. Toward
the Next Generation Rules, IMF Working
Paper 12/187, July 2012.
Tony Prosser, (2014), The Economic Constitution, Oxford University
Press.
Krzysztof Prokop, (2011) Biaystok Law Books 7 Polish Constitutional
Law.
The Legal Framework for Budget
Systems: An International Comparison,
OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 4,
No. 3, 2004.
OECD Journal on Budgeting,
Volume 2012 Supplement 1 Budgeting in
Luxembourg.

2. : ,

Buchanan, J. M. (1990) The
Domain of Constitutional Economics.
Constitutional Political Economy 1.
The collected works of James
Buchanan (2001), Volume 16 : Choice,
Contract, and Constitutions.
Congleton, R. (2003). The Contractarian Constitutional Political Economy of James Buchanan.
Douglass C. North, Institutions,
Institutional Change, and Economic
Performance, (New York: Cambridge
University Press, 1990).
Mehmet Alpertunga Avci, The
Constitutional Identity of the Public
Budgeting on the Scale of the European

---o0o---

31

2015 4 (54)

-
-
.
,
,
, , ,
,





,


.
,

,




,


, .

-
elements of
crime mensrea,
actusreus
,

.



(straftat)


,
.




,


. Nullum crimen
sine lege



,


1.

2,


Principle of legality Nullumcrimen sine lege,
nullapoena sine lege ,

.
.. Nullumcrimen sine
lege .
. 1/2007 83-114 .
1

Corpus delicti

.
elements of crime
.
.. /,
, /., 2015. 4 .120
.
2

32

/ , /

(Tatbestand),

(Sachverhalt)
)

(Tatbestandmassigkeit),
)
, )
3
3.





.


,

.
,


.


, , ,


-
-

,
,




.


,
.



,
,

,


.






,




,

.



.

,
,
.
,
,




,
, ,



,
,


,
,
,

., ..
. .:, 2001. -590-616
.
3

33

2015 4 (54)

.







. ,


145.1


145.2- ,


145.4


10-15 .


2 ,







.

,





57


,
,



.
,

166
, ,
,
,

,
,
,




.






.


2 4, 12


5.
166
, 369 , 80
, 7





.



32, 35
.
4

137, 142, 165, 166, 169, 186, 194, 224,


237, 256, 280, 281
.
5

34

/ , /








.



.
,

,

,






.





,

. ,



, ,
,
,


-
,


.



.



16



,
.

, , 2

. 4





.

4

.

,



4

.


4
.
,

2002





.

35

2015 4 (54)



.









,



.
,


,
,



,


.

,





.
4

, ,
,
.
,





,
.




.



.




,
,

.

,

.



.
,




,



,



,
.




,

36

/ , /

.









6.

,
,


.






.










.

---o0o---

., ...
. ., 1998.
-298 .
6

37

2015 4 (54)



, ,
, .
1 25000-350001

.
170-210
,








.
,




,



.

,

2

.


,




-
,
(Ph.D) .

:
,

:





, , ,

,


.
.

,

, ,

,
,

.

. 2012 , 21

. 2014 , 20

2

38

, : ,

.





.

50-70

.

.

.





, , ,

,


,


.

,



,

.3



.

-

,
3, 2014 ,
39 .

,



.





.




,

,
,
,

www.courtservice.mn,
., 2014 , 20-
3

, 3, -49, 2014 , 43

4

39

2015 4 (54)


,



.

, ,
,

.6
36 36.2

.



.

.7

.







. 8


,

,





.


.
5


,


.

, 2002 , 34-
, 34.1.1
6

, 2009
, 5- , 5.1
7

, 49, 3, 2014 43-

,
., 2014 , 3, 40

40

, : ,

,

.
14
14.1
,

,



9
.
, ,

.
:



10 .
2015 1 12-

,

- .

,



.
.



. ,

10250-1031611

.

15

14
.
,

5-

.
5-
.



.

.

.



25

., , 2014 , 3, 49,
40- ,

9

, 49, 3, 2014 43-


. www.legalistion.org

10

11

41

2015 4 (54)


. 1.


, 2/

;

.


.
2
.



.
1. /
/
2.

3.

90-
.



. 1/
,
2/ 1





.


.
,
,

. 10 000

10
10 000
5 .



.


.
.



,
. :



,



.

.

42

, : ,

65 1



. 35



43
1


,

.


15


. 16
. ,

. 2.

. 17 .



.

10
10.1.1.
,


,
9 1.


.
1.


2.

,
,



21 21.1
,
.
21.4
,


. 21.5.



.
19.1



.

,
10 1


.
1.

43

2015 4 (54)




1.





.

74-
5 2



.
2.

16.2, 28.2 5



,

.


.

74-
5
5 .

, 3.

, 4.





. 5.

,
6.


, 7.
,
8.
. (2)





48.6.




. 50.1




77
. 77 .

,




.
, ,

.
,

.
: 20-27
. 20
1


. 2.

.



.

44

, : ,

36
1
,


. 2



.
2
. 3




.
45.2


30
45.1-
. 39


,

.
47.1

14

.
,
43
2
2



.
6


.
44
1





.



,
.

65
,


15

, 2014
4 16- \48




.

12
:
:


.


.


.
12-

.

:


.


12/1
.
12

45

Civil code, Itali, 2001, 705 page

2015 4 (54)




.
:



,
.

: 2

2





.
:
,



1
.
-

7-
.


2002 7
1- .

. ,

,
.

-

.



.

,



.
-


,
,

. ,


,

.

.

, .

/
/- .

:

.

, .



,
.


.



,
.

.
,
, ,
,

46

, : ,

, 13


.


.

,


,
,
.


.



.
10.







.
11.




.

.
12.




.


(),

.




.

14



.

, 7.




-
.
(2008.12.30-
-306
)
8.






.
9.
76




.,

., 2014 ., 73
13


, 2007 ,
14

47

2015 4 (54)

13.
,



(
)
.
14.


.
-



15,
25


15, 25
.

:15
Principles,
definitions and model rules of European
private law /DCFR/ pages, 5645
I.
7:711-7:714-
,


. :
1.,


/
/,
/
/
.
2.



.
3.
.
4.



.
5.
,


.
.
1.



.
2.

,
, ,

,
,
.



,

,


.

,
,
,

Principles, definitions and model rules of European private


law, 562 page
15

48

, : ,



,
//
,


3
.
2011
, 54-

.



,






.

,

,


,

.




, ,
,
, ,


,


,

, 2

.


,

.
2011-

, ,

, ,




,

,


,

.
:
, ,

,

.
, ,


,

,
2007 136

.

2011-

.

.
,
.

49

2015 4 (54)





.

.


.




.



.


.


.




. /
, ., .
/.16

.
.

177.1

2014 12 05-





, ,

,
,

70 ,




.

,
50
.

70,
50 .



.
70, 50



. : 100
70
,

70.500.000
,
.

. 100
,
,


2
,

,



.

,


.
.

- ,
, 2010 , 28
16

50

, : ,


.
,

-


90 ,
70

,
.


2

.

2-3 ,
4-6
.

, ,

,
,

,

,
, ,

.

10250-10316



.

.



25


. 1.


, 2/

;

.




,

.

---o0o---

51

2015 4 (54)

:



() .

,
,
.
,

,
.
,
(
)

. , ,

( , , ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
, )
.
:

2 (2014 )
- 17.46 . 3
- 17.61
.

(2015.06.30- )
- 280,742,5324

- - ,

. -

:

:
(Cybercrime),

(Specific features of malicious


programs),
(Financial data theft), X
(Personal data
theft),

(Distribution of rogue
antivirus programs),
(Substituting search results),
(Extortion under cover),

(Specifics of malware distribution),

(Infecting legitimate websites),
(Fooling
search engines), (Spam),
(Cybercriminal
infrastructure),
1 (Web hosting for malicious
content), (Domain zones),
(Botnets)

,
1

https://www.cia.gov/index.html

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2001rank.html
3

52

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats14.htm

, : ,

- 71,727,5515
57,266,690
55,221,000

6 (2015.06.30- )
- 87.9%
- 73.5%

:

,
,
, ,
.
,




.

, ,
-

.

(2012 1-
)7
- 38.8%, 31-
- 28.8%, 101-
- 36.8%, 42-
- 36.3%, 44-
- 43.5%, 18-
- 32.1%
iOS8 Android OS9
10
5

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats4.htm#europe

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm

,

.

:
Windows11
Android
Mac OS12


20- 13
.


,


.



.

,
. ,
,




.
,




,

http://securityaffairs.co/wordpress/8926/cyber-crime/malwarebotnet-cyber-threatswhat-is-happening-to-the-cyberspace.html
7

Apple- iPhone , iPod touch, iPad


.
8

Microsoft . Windows
10 , ,
.
11

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats14.htm

(. Operating system, OS)


-
.
10

Mac OS - Apple Macintosh


.
12

13

53

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm

2015 4 (54)


. ,
2012

62.4% Windows 7
.

.

DEP14, ASLR15,

,
.


4 .

:
, 2012 1-

-
.




.

.

.


Trojan-Banker,
Trojan-Spy.win32.Zbot,
Trojan-Spy.Win32.Spyeyes,
Backdoor.
Win32.Sinowal

.



,
.


.

.

,

.
,

.


,
.


. ,


,

,
16

.

Data Execution Prevention -


.
14

Address Space Layout Randomization -


,
.
15

Trojan Horse -
,

16

54

, : ,


Trojan-Banker,
(
Trojan- Spy,

Backdoor
:
, PayPal, EBay)


Trojan-FakeAV
,
,

Trojan-PSW, Trojan
GameThief, Trojan (Steam,
Spy
WoW, Facebook, Skype
..)

Backdoor, Trojan
Spy
,
Trojan-Clicker,
,
Trojan. Win32.

DnsChanger,

Backdoor

Trojan-Ransom

,
.

, ,



.

,

. :
Sinowal (Mebroot) -

(backdoor).
,
.

Zbot (ZeuS) -
.


2
.
SpyEye -
.
Zbot (ZeuS)- ,
.
2012
, ,

Backdoor.Win32.Sinowal
(Mebroot)

70%, Trojan-Spy.Win32.
SpyEye 41%, Trojan-Spy.
Win32.Zbot 25% .

PayPal
,
Ebay



34%, 9%
)

()
,
.

(, , , ,
,
)

,

,

.
:
-17

,
,

.. .


- - ,

. E-
, 6
.
17

55

2015 4 (54)

. ,
,

Zitmo
.

Zbot (ZeuS)- .
Zbot


,

Zitmo

.



. 2010
Trojan-Sy.
Win32.Zbot- 3
600 9
. 18.

.


SQL19
injections20,


.


(account),
,

, robots.txt21
web applications22-
.


.

.
23
24



.

.
,


.

, (
)
.

,
,
.

18

SQL -
.
19

20 SQL injection - SQL query- (Query -


)
query
,
.
.
.
.

. , ,
( ) robot.txt
.
21

Web application - ,
, client (
)
.
22

Malware (Malicious software) - .


, .
23

Phishing -

. phishing attack
.



.

, , .
24

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/09/zeus-raid/

56

, : ,


,

.

,

.

26.

.


.
2011 12- 2012
1-


.


,
-

. 2011 6-

3
960.000
, 72
. (
)


.


.


,
.

25
.

, ,


(2011-2012 )


,



.

,


.

2011 ,


, 3-
Mac OS X

.
2011 6-

(900.000
Kaspersky Lab )
25

http://threatpost.com/head-russian-payment-processor-chronopay-arrested-062511/75368
26

57

2015 4 (54)


(, , ,
)

10

Trojan-Downloader.OSX.Flashfake


Backdoor.
Win32.Zccess (ZeroAccess)
(27.7%), (11%)

.


DNS27/hosts
28

,


.
, 2011
Mac OSX
,
TrojanDownloader.OSX.Flashfake

. 29- 700.000

1% Mac OSX ,
84%
,
.

Backdoor.Win32.ZAccess ,
2012 7

-
,


.

5

Trojan.Win32.Dnshanger
14
.

DNS (Domain Name System) -


, , IP
. IP

.
27

IP
.
28


,

.
29

58

, : ,

.30




-
.
,

,
,

.
-


,
,

,


.
, ,

.




.

, , ,
,
,
,

,

.

, Ukash, Epay, PayPoint



.




. ,


.

,

.

31
,

http://www.fbi.gov/newyork/press-releases/2011/manhattan-us-attorney-charges-seven-individuals-for-engineering-sophisticated-internet-fraud-scheme-that-infected-millions-of-computers-worldwide-and-manipulated-internet-advertising-business
30

Worm - .


.
31

59

2015 4 (54)


.


.

,

, 2012 1- (
Kaspersky Lab-

)

20% ,
)
21%-41%
,
, ,
30%-
.



. :

;

();
,

.

,
(), 2012 1-
( Kaspersky Lab-

)



. 2012

80%

.

,
( 40 )
.

,

.

,

60

, : ,

() .



.
32
.

,

.



.

. , 2011
,

Adobe
Acrobat
Reader,
FlashPlayer (5
4- )
Java . 2012
Adobe-

.
,
5
(2011 II )

Exploit. JS.
CVE-20104452. I
Exploit. JS.
Pdfka. exr
Exploit. JS.
CVE-20104452. t
Exploit.
Java. CVE2010-0840.
d

3. 4%

Oracle Java
(JRE)

3. 0%

Adobe PDF
Reader

2. 9%

Oracle Java
(JRE)

2. 6%

Oracle Java
(JRE)

(2012 I )

Exploit. JS. Pdfka. fhh
Exploit. Java.
2011-0611. bt

CVE-

Exploit. Java. CVE2011-3544. ct


Exploit. JS. Agent. blb
Exploit. JS. Agent. fhp

(%)
20. 1%
10. 8%
6. 9%
5. 6%
4. 7%

Adobe PDF
Reader
Adobe
Flash
Player
Oracle
Java (JRE)
Oracle
Java (JRE)
Adobe PDF
Reader



(Black Hat SEO33).
,

.



.


.
,
.
,

(%)
Exploit.
Java. CVEOracle Java
20. 6%
2010-4452.
(JRE)
a

SEO (Search Engine Optimization) -


( )

http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/-
.

33

32

61

2015 4 (54)

(
,
..)

,


.

,
..)
.

.


()-
.
2012

69%
.


.



,
.

.


,
,
, ,

.


. 2012


2.8%-4.3%

.
2012

2.5%-
.


, 2010-2012


.
.


.



.



, .



( 34, ,

34

62

, : ,



.



.



, , love.me.
(.it)

it (do.it,
get.it)
.
10-
(.eu), (.de), - (.us)

,

.





.
.net, .com,
.info, .org .
44.5%

.

.




.



- .
: ,

,

,
,

.


.


.

,

.

TDSS,
DNS
hangers- . 2011
,
41.5%
TDSS- .

,
15
( )


(.in), (.ru),
(co.cc)
.
Co.cc

2011 Google



. (.com.es),
(.it)-
,
. (.me)

63

2015 4 (54)


.

1000
100-150
. .
10
.



,

.





,
.
,

)
.
, FlashFake mac-
,
Mac OSX

80%
.

,
.

70%
.

()

80%-
. 2012
,

40%, 37%, 36%,
29% -35-
.

- 39%,
37%
.

,

,

.


, -

,
.

,

.
(
,

..)
.
2012


( Sinowal 70%,
SpyEyes 40%)
67%
.


, DDoS ,



.


,

35

64

, : ,

,
,


.

---o0o---

65

2015 4 (54)

.


,

.
...



:


,
,

,
,
.

,

,


, .

,

.

,
,
.


. 1



.


.:


.


.

,

,
, ,
.


,




.

,

.. . ., 2008 , 138139 .
1

66

, : ,




. 2

,
,
.
,



.


/
/ . 49-
3 ,


.
. -

:
48.3-


,

,
,
,

,


,

.

,

.3

,


.
-
1993 - 12
6
2002 - 14

3

,
, ,

,

.

,

,




. ,
,

,
.
1.


,
,
,

,

.
1992

.

/
48.3/. 2012 - 2

., , (
) (: , 2004), 24.

., : ,
, 2:153.

67

2015 4 (54)

2.




.


,

.






9.

,
,
,
.


.

,
,


,



.10
2012
-

.4

,




.5 ,

,

,


.6
7

2012


. 2012
/
/- -


,
.


,
.

,
,


8
.
., ., 20
(: , 2013), 13.
4

.,
( , 2014), 9.
5

. ,
, , (:
, 2010).
6

, ,

.

, ,
.
9

2013

,

91.3
. ., ?
( ), , . 2
(2013).
7

, Tvind-
Tvind




. Jesper Wittrup, Budgeting in the Era
of Judicial Independence, International Journal for Court
Administration, April 2010, 6, http://www.iaca.ws/files/Jesper_Wittrup4-2010.pdf.
10

- 2014

2013 0.65 , 2014
0.85 , 2015 0.82 . .,
., (2014 ), 64.
8

68

, : ,

3.


30-40



.


.
,



,



.



,
.

,
,

.
2012



,


.

-

40/32


,
. 2002


, ,




,
,
,

.11
,

,


, ,


,

.
2012
- 28 285


, - 23
23.5

,

.
48- 3



., ., ,
, , (:
, 2013).
11

69

2015 4 (54)


,
.




,

.
, - 1969 12
-

1970
20


16.5

5
. ,

.12
, 1991

.
Sol Watchler

966.4


10
.


...

889.3


.


Guomo-


.13


,

.






.





.
2014 58.4 ,
3.4

61.8
.

(GDP)
15474384.9 15
474384 900 .14

0.399
0.4



.

2013
1- :15

,
, 2015, http://www.1212.mn.
14

Guiliana Palumbo et al., Judicial Performance and Its


Determinants: a Cross-country Perspective, OECD Economic Policy Papers, no. 05 (2013): 20, http://in.oecd.org/
eco/growth/FINAL%20Civil%20Justice%20Policy%20Paper.pdf.
15

G. Gregg Webb and Keith E. Whittington, Judicial Independence, the Power of the Purse, and Inherent Judicial
Powers, Judicature 88, no. 1 (2004): 15.
12

13

., 16.

70

, : ,

1.
-

4.1.

-

1993 2002
-


.
1993 -

.

,
- (,
1993, 35.1.2/); ,
(,
1993, 60.1);

, -
(, 1993,
35.1.3/); -

,
(, 1993,
35.1.3/)


,

.16
2002 -
-

.
,
-
(, 2002, 62.1.2)
,
(,
2002, 62.1.3) .




.
, .,
., . :

1-




(0.4
)

,




.


.
4.


,


. : 1)
-
;
2)
; 3)

.,
, 45.
16

71

2015 4 (54)


/- 6.1.1/


-


. ,
2014
2013
0.65 , 2014
0.85 , 2015 0.82
.21



.22

,
-
2014, 2015

.

-

.

- 6
6.1.1-



. ,
- 6 6.1.1

32 32.1
,
32.2-
8.4
,
8.2-

,

,


30-40
. 17
...

-
...18
.
1993 2002
-


.


1997
0.39-0.48
.19
.:20

,


.

...


...
.






.

2012





( ), 31.
17

18

, 36.

19

.,
, 45.

21

., : ,
, 2:147.

22

., .,
(2014 ), 64.
., : ,
, 2:147.

20

72

, : ,

,

.
- -


-
.

-
.



. ,
, , ,

/ /

. 23

.


38.2-



,

. ,




,


-
.
4.2.

,

,
.
()-
2008 :

- 6
6.1.1



, ,
,
, , ,

,


38
38.2
. -
6.1.1

,


. -
6.1.1-


( )
,
?
, , ,
, , ,

.

... .24


.
, 2014
,
,

, ,
:
() ( , 2013), 45, http://
resource3.sodonvision.com/shuuh/file/2014/4/121ftuvyc
s1mfghi0s4wup5dh/%20,%20%20
%20.pdf.
23

., ,
( )
(, 2008), 5354.
24

73

2015 4 (54)


7
.25
-
7- ,
6-
-
.

,

. 2014
,



-
, -
1.2 , 58.4
, -
916.5

3.4

,
0 .26

,



.

. 23.1-



,

,

.
23.5-

,

. ,


. - 2014



6- .
1.
27

-
2011
36, 54-

-
2013
45

4.3.
,

,
,
,
,
.


,
,

.
2012

1 400

1 500

2 700

2 900

3 200


,

1.5 - 2


.

., .,
(2014 ), 75.
25

26

., .,
(2014 ), 49.
27

., 65.

74

, : ,





.28


(
)
23.4 ,
35



. 2015
10-
2016 -



.29
23.4, 35
,

-
, - 23.5-

,


- .30

48-



, - 20.3-
... , ,
,

,
,

23.1-

,
, ,

,

.


,
,

2012
,

.


.


.



,
,



,
,

.31



. ,
- III


.
(1990)- 72- 3-

,
(1994)- 110-


125- , 360-

http://www.judcouncil.mn/main/2413--.html,
.
2015 11 6.
28

2016
,
, , October 16, 2015,
http://www.parliament.mn/news/open/categories/30/pages/25223.
29

,
, October 16, 2015, http://
www.judcouncil.mn/main/2345--.html.
30

., ., ,
, , . 4.1.
31

75

2015 4 (54)

46

.32


,
,


.33
,


.
5.


/
/

.

.
1. 6 6.1.1

,

,
.
/- 6.1.1/
/
38.2,
8.2, 32.2
/-




,

-
;
2.

23.5-

,

; 23.1-


, ,


;

Jackson, Judicial Independence: Structure, Context,


Attitude,
3637.\\uc0\\u8220{}Judicial
Independence:
Structure,
Context, Attitude,\\uc0\\u8221{}
36\\uc0\\
u8211{}37.},plainCitation:Jackson, Judicial Independence: Structure, Context, Attitude, 3637.},citationItems:[{id:724,uris:[http://zotero.org/users/569746/
items/32A6W9W6],uri:[http://zotero.org/users/569746/
items/32A6W9W6],itemData:{id:724,type:chapter,title:Judicial independence: Structure, Context,
Attitude,container-title:Judicial
Independence
in
Transition,publisher:Springer Science & Business
Media,page:19-86,source:Google
Books,abstract:Strengthening the rule of law has become a key
factor for the transition to democracy and the protection of
human rights. Though its significance has materialized in
international standard setting, the question of implementation is largely unexplored. This book describes judicial
independence as a central aspect of the rule of law in different stages of transition to democracy. The collection of
state-specific studies explores the legal situation of judiciaries in twenty states from North America, over Western,
Central and South-Eastern Europe to post-Soviet states and
engages in a comparative legal analysis. Through a detailed
account of the current situation it takes stocks, considers
advances in and shortcomings of judicial reform and offers
advice for future strategies. The book shows that the implementation of judicial independence requires continuous
efforts, not only in countries in transition but also in established democracies which are confronted with ever new
challenges.,ISBN:9783642282997,language:en,author:[{family:Jackson,given:Vicki
C.}],editor:[{family:Seibert-Fohr,given:Anja}],issued:{date-parts:[[2012]]}},locator:36-37}],schema:https://
github.com/citation-style-language/schema/raw/master/
csl-citation.json}
32

., 37.the question of implementation is largely unexplored. This book describes judicial independence
as a central aspect of the rule of law in different stages
of transition to democracy. The collection of state-specific studies explores the legal situation of judiciaries in
twenty states from North America, over Western, Central
and South-Eastern Europe to post-Soviet states and engages in a comparative legal analysis. Through a detailed
account of the current situation it takes stocks, considers
advances in and shortcomings of judicial reform and offers
advice for future strategies. The book shows that the implementation of judicial independence requires continuous
efforts, not only in countries in transition but also in established democracies which are confronted with ever new
challenges.,ISBN:9783642282997,language:en,author:[{family:Jackson,given:Vicki
C.}],editor:[{family:Seibert-Fohr,given:Anja}],issued:{date-parts:[[2012]]}},locator:37}],schema:https://
github.com/citation-style-language/schema/raw/master/
csl-citation.json}
33

76

, : ,

3.



;
4.

7


.

---o0o---

77

2015 4 (54)


,





. (., .

., 2003 )
,
,

,

. ,

.


,

.


.

,



,
,
,
,
,

,
,

.



:

-

- ,
(Ph.D),
.





. :
.



.
.
,


. ,

,
,
,
,
,

,

?
?

78

, ,

, ,





,
.
//

,

.



,

.
,

.

.
,
,

-
,
.,
.



.


.

:



.

.





(-
50

. -
. ., 2011. 3040 ).

.

//




.


10 .
-, -



.


,


. ,
82

2009

.



,
,

.

., .
/, /

, ,
/ /

79





. .


,
,


.
,
(V)
(
)
, ( Z)
(
)
,

V ()
.

. :

,
,






,
,

,
,

, ,




2015 4 (54)

,



.



,

.

,


.

.



.

.






.



,

.




.
,


.
-

.

-

.

80

, ,

125

(
, ., 2003.31-33
)

,


-
2 -
, -
15-




.
-



.




.
.,
.

.
,

, ,

.

.


,

.

,


,
.

- ,




.
,



.
,

,



.






.
,

.



.





.

.


(-
)

,

81



2008-2014

.

,


.
, ,
,
,

,
, ,
.

, ,
, ,

,



.

,


, ,


.

.

2015 4 (54)

, ,
,

,


.
,

. ,

,

,
-

.

,
.
,

.

,
.



.


.
,

---o0o---

82

, ,


1995
2004


.

,
,


,

.

,
,
.

3


,
, ,
,
-,

, , ,



, , ,
-

, , ,
, .
.

,
, ,


, , ,


,
.


,

.

,

,

.
,

,
.


, ,

, ,
,
,

.
,


. 10
, , ,
, , , ,

83

2015 4 (54)

,
,
,

.

3
. :
-
;
- , ,

,
-,
, ,
,
;
-

.

,
,
,

.

,



.



. : 1-
2
-

, ,
, , ,

.




.
, ,
.

2- 1

(
) ,
, -,
, ,
, ,

(
)
.


,


.




.

3- 1
(
)



,

16
( )-
( )
( ) 2
,
.




. 1993.06.21, 5485-I


. 1999.03.10 349-I
2


. 2010.07.19 170-3

84

, ,



.

16
,



,



.

4- 1

(
)- -
, ,

,
,

5
( ),
( ),
( ) 3
.

, ,

-
,

.
, ,

.

,

5- 1

( )

,
,
, , , ,
-

.
,
, .





.

6-
2


,
, ,
, ,
- ,
,
-


.



.



.

7


, ,
,
, , ,
, ,
,


.
,

,
,
.



.


,
1994.04.14 1476-XII
4


1996.12.30 3-94
6


, 1993.05.07 848-XII


2008.11.27. 245

85



. (11 )

8-
(

,

,
, , ,
, ,


.

.

,

.

. ,

9- 1
,

25
,
, ,

,


,
1
.



,

2015 4 (54)

.

10-

,

,
,

,
,

, , ,
, ,

.

,


, ,
,
,

.
-

11-
(State secret)
.
93
1
-


,

, ,
.12 -


,
,

. (93
2) ,

Law on State Secrets and Official Secrets, November
25, 1999. No. VIII-1443 Official translation.
10

Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB) As promulgated


on 13 November 1998 (Federal Law Gazette I, p. 945, p.
3322).
11

1994.01.21
3855-XII
8

Classified information protection act, 2002.04.30 Official


Gazette No. 45/30.04.2002

German criminal code. 13 November 1998, Federal Law


Gazette (Bundesgesetzblatt) I p.3322

12

86

, ,



.
-




,

,

.13

,
, ,

. ,
,


.


,

:

.
3.

,
, ,
, , ,
, ,




.
4.




.

,

.

3





.







.
3

, ,

,
-


, , , ,



.

1.

.

.
2.


,
,
,
.


.





www.asia-business.ru/law
. 5 1988
13

87

,
.


3

2015 4 (54)

,
,
,
, , ,
, ,
,

.

---o0o---

88

, ,

,

,


.


.2

,



.

.


-
, ,
, , , ,
, , , , ,
, , , ,
, -, , ,

.

.-


, , ,
,

.3

- - ,
(Ph.D) .

: ,


,
,
,

,

.


()amnesty,
, .
,





.1

(
)
1

Britannica encyclopedia. 2489

. ..
/ .. . .
..:, 2009. .401-402.
448.
3

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/amnesty

89


,


.






..,
.

.
200-
1794

.

:
,
.

.
,


.





.4.




.



.

,

2015 4 (54)





.
133-
9-

,

5
.



.

,
,
.
,
, , , , ,
, , ,
.



. 6

.

,


.
,

25


2015 8 11
. .
2015 07 02-
24 00

, ,
, , ,
, 2002
5

. ..
/ .. . .
..:, 2009. .402. 448
6

,
.. 2009 , 121
4

90

, ,

.

.
:7
,
;

;

;

.






.


.


.



-


. 9



.

,
,

,

. 2002



.10
2008

,

.
2015
8 7-

.

2006
800

2400, 2009
1000
2071
.
,



,

,

,

.8


,
.
,
,

.


,
.

Pender .The traps in amnesty for taxes. http://www.calchamber.com/Chamber_in_the_news/020305_Amnesty.


htm
9

, 2015, http://
www.legalinfo.mn/
7

. , , 2012.
184

. . .,
201. 183

10

91

,
,

,
, ,

, ,

, ,
,

,





.11

,
,

,


.



.
, ,


.

,


.

,
.
:
, , , ,
, , , ,
.


AMNESTY

2015 4 (54)




.

,


. ,

,
.
25

.

.

.

.
,
, , ,


.

.

,
,

.
, , -
,


,
.
,

.

,
,
,

.


, 2015, http://www.legalinfo.mn/
11

92

, ,


.


18-
.12

.

.

,
. -

,
.13







.
1966

-
-

14 6- 4-


. ,



.15




.


12




. , ,
, ,
. ,
, ,



. , ,


.
PARDON POWER


(pardons, amnesties,
clemency, grace, mercy)
.



. :
92-

93-

98-


.

102- 1-
,
,
,
,
.





. 103-

https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/pardon

13

Britannica encyclopedia. 3360

14

http://www.amnesty.mn/mn

19661216 2200(XXI) , 1976 3


23-
15

93

.
- 2-
2- 1-

.

.
,
, ,

.
16

Office of the Pardon Attorney




.
1865



.
-
,

. 50-
3-
,

.
71-




.


85-
113

2015 4 (54)


.
47-
1-

.

(Grundgesetz) 60-
2-
( )

.
452-

.


,


,

. 17



. ,

. 33

Ruckman,P.S., Jr. Executive Clemency in the United


States: Origins, Development, and Analysis (1900-1993).
Presidential Studies Quarterly, 1997. P.251-271.
16

. . .,
2012. 185
17

94

, ,


.
PARDON POWER








.





.


, ,

.
129


. ,

,


.
,

,

,


. ,




.


,




.

,
.



,

.





.

.

---o0o---

95

2015 4 (54)


,
1215
/ /,
1222 , 1357


//

,

2 .
,

,
.

,


,




, ,
3

, /constitution-
, /

.

/1614-1657/ ...

,
,
4


,

-
.

,


.




,

/
,
seperation /division/ of powers1
.

,
,
,
,


.



,

.. . /,
/. . 2002, 6
2

.. :
, . Legis . .2003.
1 /2/. 8
3

.., ...
. .2001. .730, ..
. /
/- seperation of power .
1

96

. . . 1937. 110-112

, ,

.

.
,
. ,





,
, ,

, ,
.

,

,


. /16321704/, ,
.. /1681-1755/
,

,


. , .. 1748


, 5


, -,

.


, -
,

, .
., ., ..

,




6.
5




,

.
1992

,

,
, ,
, ,
,
,
.

-
, ,

,
, ,
, ,

.



,
,

,

.(
,
Separation of power )

,

.7

. . 1983. 220

..
. . . 2001.6-7.
14
6

. .
. 2014. 17
7

97

,

,
,

.
,
....
.

,



.8




,
, ,



.


. ,

.

,
,



.
,


.

.
,
,
, .


.

,

2015 4 (54)

,



,
,
.


60 ,
,


.
,

.

,

.


,
.


,
,

,
.
,






.
,



.



.




.

.
. 2005
8

98

, ,

,
,




. :


.



.

,
//,



.
,

.


.9



.


.


. ,


.


,

.


,

.




.

.


,
.10


.

,


.

,

.

., .
,
. . . 1997. 230/
/
9


. . 1999.
77-78
10

99

,
,
,
. ,
,


.

, ,

,
.
,
,


.

.


.
,

.



,
,

.
1992-1996




. 1996


,

.

.
1992 1

13-

100

2015 4 (54)


. ,
,

,

.
1.

2-





.












.

.




.






.
2.

1-
,


, ,

,


.
,

.
, .

, ,


.

-



.
,

.
,

.
8-

,


.
3.

2-






.


,
.


101


, ,

. 75
50 2000
75-
.
-

,

.
4.

6- ,



,





,

,

,


.

,
,
.
-
39
,
20
.


(51 )

.

5.

1-


,

,


,

.


,
,
.
20-



,

.
6.

1.2-
,




,



,
,

, ,
, ,

, ,


,



102

2015 4 (54)

.

.

.

.

, ,
.

,
/
/
,

.
//-


//





.11
7.

2-

,
,







.


. ,

. . 2006,
146
11

, ,

,

-
.
,
, ,

, ,

,
.
,
,

.
,


.
,
.12


. :
81- /,
/, 82- /

/, 83- /
/, 84- /
/, 130- /

/, 131-
/

,
/, 177- //, 178-
/
/

.



2010


.
, 82

. :



,
/ /

13 .
,


.
,


.






.

,




.
,

, ,




.

,




.


, -
. , 2010,
235
13

.
, 2014, 83
12

103





. , Rule of law



,



.


:
1.
2.
3.
3 14.
: -




, ,


.
-


,


.
-

, ,
, ,

.
.





. , .

,

Ugo Mattei. Three patterns of law: Taxanomy and change in
the worlds legal systems, 45Am, J.Comp. L.5, s12
14

104

2015 4 (54)


Gesetzesstaat /
/- 15
,

. .

16,
17,
18
,

.


.


,


.
,


.
,

,
,
. .,
. , 2011
15

. :
-
-

-

.
16



,
,
.
17


,
,
,
.



,


.
18

, ,

,

,
,

,

,

,
2010 12
23-
.

, ,
,
,


,

,

,



,
,
.

,
.

:
.
,

,
.

,


,



.
.


.
,
,

105

,
() , ,
() .

.
,
()
.19



,
,





.

.

.

,


-
,
.



.
,



.

, , ,


.

,
, ,

.



,


.
19


,
, ,


.

---o0o---

106

2015 4 (54)

, ,

/ 1- /


1998

1 .

2005
,
2007



.
,
,

,


,

,


-
.





,


.


.

,


.- ,
. ,
., . . .,
2015
1

107

,


.
forensic
science
police science

,

,,


, , , ,
,




. :
1.
,

,
Forensic science, forensic
exmination Police science-
, ;
2. ,

;
3. ,

,
, ,
;
4.
,

, , ,

,




. ,


, ,

,
.


,
,
, ,
, ,
,
, ,
,


,
.

, ,

,
,

. 2009
-
(National Academy of Science)
-



.2
Strengthening Forensic Science inthe United States: A
Path Forward
2

108

2015 4(54)

:






,



,

.
, 2011
,

.3

(
),
(, ),
( )

,
.
,

,

.



,


,
, ,


Ross, Alastair, Forensic Science in Australia: Where does
Australia sit in relation to Trends and Issues in the International Context?, Current Issues in Criminal Justice, Volume
24/No.1, p.121
3

, ,

.


.
,
,


/
/
. ,





.







,

,

,
2
.
Forensic science-

Forensic science
,
, ,


,

,
. forensic

109

, (forum)
.
forensic

. forensic
science , ,
,
,

,

. Forensic science

(criminalistics),/

(forensic
pathology),
/

(forensic anthropology),
(forensic
odontology/
forensic
dentistry),/
(forensic
engineering),
(toxicology)



4.
forensic science






,
.

.


.


.
Police
science-

Police science ,
, ,
,

/
/, ,
4 Max M.Houck, Jay A. Siegel, Fundamentals of Forensic
Science (Second edition), 2009, pp.4-5


(the administration of justice)

.






. 1980-





.

/
/-
, ,

.

police
science


.
police
science ,

, , ,



,



.
police science
,
,

,
,

110

2015 4(54)

,
,
,
,

.5


6

,
, ,
,

, ,
, ,


.

.


1958 , 1998


.
,

- . ,

1990

,


.

, ,

1990


, .
Jack R. Greene (ed.), The Encyclopedia of Police Science (Third edition): Volume 1 A-I
index, 2006, p.xix- .
5


.
6

, ,

-
,

,


, ,

.
-
,
, ,

,



.7




,
,

.
,


,




forensic science
.
2005

,

/,
,
/ ,



,

7

. 2014 . 74- .

111


,

, ,
.
,





.

,

.
,
,


,


,

.


,


,
.
,

,

,


.

,
, , ,


,
,

, ,


.

,


.

,


.



2005 47 8
.

.
,



,



,

.

,

,

http://net.jogtar.hu/jr/gen/hjegy_doc.cgi?docid=A0500047.
TV / : 2015.05.21/
8

112

2015 4(54)


.

,
,


.



.

.
,

,

.
-
.
,

,

,

,

,

,

.

,

.

, ,




. ,



,





.


, ,

,

.

,



,

.

113

,

,
,


.


, ,

,
,
,
.


,

. ,

,
,


,
, ,

,
.
,


,


,

,

.



-





.

,
,



,

,

, ,

.
//-



.
//

,



,
,
,
,
,

.

.




.

,
.

114

2015 4(54)

.



.
,

( )
.


;
;
;

.





.

2 .


,
,
,
(
)-
, ,
.

forensic
science

.

, ,

.
(
),
(, ),
(
)
,
.
,



.




,





.


.

.


),
.


.
,
,

/
/
.

115



, ,

,
,


,

.

.




,



,

.


, ,

.


, , ,
,


,

,
,

.


XX

,
, ,
,

.
,
,
,
, ,

.

,
,

.

,


,

,




,
,
. ,
,


,



. ,
,



.
,

, ,
,

.
,
,
,

. XXI

116

2015 4(54)


,
,
,




, ,

. ,



,

,
, ,

,

.


,

,




.
,


,
,
, ,
,
.

,

.


1958 , 1998

. ,

, ,

1990


,


. , ,

,


/forensic
science/- ,

.

,
,




,
,
.

, .





,



,
,
.

117

.
,

.


//
/
/ .

,

,
,
, , , ,


,


,


.



, ,

,


.
,

,

.


,



.


,


,

,
.
,


,

,
.



, ,

118

2015 4(54)


,

.



.

,


,
, ,
,




,
.

,

, ,


.


2 . :
,

, ,

,




.

,


,



.


,
. 3-4




.



,

,


2 .

,


.

119

,
,
,

.


, , ,

,
, ,
,

.





.

, ,
, , ,
, , ,

,






,
.





.
,
,

/ 3/
,
, ,
, ,
, ,
/,

,
,

(
), ,
, ,
, ,
, ,

.



.
,






.



.
,



, ,
, ,


. :
1.

,

.


;
2.



, ,

,
,
;

120

2015 4(54)

3.





;
4.



,
,

;
5. ,


;
6.

,

;
7.

,

;
8.


, ,

,

.


,



;
9.