You are on page 1of 36

PUBLIC REDACTED VERSION

ORAL ARGUMENT IS REQUESTED

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS


FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

No. 01-3202

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Plaintiff-Appellant,

v.

AMR CORPORATION, AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC., and


AMERICAN EAGLE HOLDING CORPORATION,

Defendants-Appellees.

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS
(Honorable J. Thomas Marten)

REPLY BRIEF FOR APPELLANT UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

DONNA KOOPERSTEIN R. HEWITT PATE


RENATA B. HESSE Deputy Assistant Attorney General
ROBERT D. YOUNG
J. RICHARD DOIDGE CATHERINE G. O’SULLIVAN
NINA B. HALE ROBERT B. NICHOLSON
REBEKAH J. FRENCH JOHN P. FONTE
KARL D. KNUTSEN DAVID SEIDMAN
JENNIFER L. CIHON ROGER W. FONES
MAX R. HUFFMAN CRAIG W. CONRATH
MARK J. NIEFER Attorneys
Attorneys U.S. Department of Justice
U.S Department of Justice Antitrust Division
Antitrust Division 601 D Street, N.W.
325 7th Street, N.W., Suite 500 Washington, D.C. 20530-0001
Washington, D.C. 20004 (202) 514-2435
6#$.'1(%106'065

+0641&7%6+10                                       

+ 6*'+0%4'/'06#.%1561(#/'4+%#0I5#&&'&
%#2#%+6;+5#0#224124+#6'/'#574'1(%156+0
6*+5%#5'                                     

++ 6*''8+&'0%'5*19'&6*#6#/'4+%#0I5%10&7%6
(#+.'&#224124+#6'%1566'565                  

+++ 6*')18'40/'065*19'&6*#6#/'4+%#0.+-'.;
917.&4'%172+6524'ɦ.155'5             

+8 01/''6+0)%1/2'6+6+10&'('05'#22.+'5+06*+5
%#5'                                         

%10%.75+10                                         

%'46+(+%#6'1(%1/2.+#0%'                           

%'46+(+%#6'1(5'48+%'                               

K
6#$.'1(#76*14+6+'5

%#5'5

##2QWNVT[(CTOU+PEX4QUG#ETG(CTOU+PE(F
VJ
%KT                                          

#FXQ+PEX2JKNCFGNRJKC0GYURCRGTU(5WRR
'&2C
                                             

#FXQ+PEX2JKNCFGNRJKC0GYURCRGTU(F
F%KT 

$CTT[9TKIJV%QTRX+66)TKPPGNN%QTR(F
UV%KT
                                             

$TQQMG)TQWR.VFX$TQYP9KNNKCOUQP6QDCEEQ%QTR75

                                       RCUUKO

$WUJPGNN%QTRX+66%QTR(4&
&-CP           

%QCUVCN(WGNUQH2WGTVQ4KEQ+PEX%CTKDDGCP2GVTQNGWO%QTR
(F
UV%KT                                 

&54GFK/KZX5KGTTC4GFK/KZCPF%QPVTCEVKPI%Q(F

VJ%KT                                       

+.%2GTKRJGTCNU.GCUKPI%QTRX+$/%QTR(5WRR
0&
%CN CHH F(F
VJ%KT                 

,CPKEJ$TQUX#OGTKECP&KUVKNNKPI(F
VJ%KT        

.QU#PIGNGU.CPF%QX$TWPUYKEM%QTR(F
VJ%KT     

/QTICPX2QPFGT(F
VJ%KT                 

KK
/WNVKUVCVG.GICN5VWFKGU+PEX*CTEQWTV$TCEG,QXCPQXKEJ(F

VJ%KT                                  

0GWOCPX4GKPHQTEGF'CTVJ%Q(F
&%%KT         

2CEKHKE'PIKPGGTKPI2TQFWEVKQP%QX-GTT/E)GG%QTR(F

VJ%KT                                  

2JQVQXGUV%QTRX(QVQOCV%QTR(F
VJ%KT         

4G/CZ+PVGTPCVKQPCN+PEX4GCNV[1PG+PE(F
VJ%KT
                                             

4GC\KPX$NWG%TQUUCPF$NWG5JKGNFQH-CPUCU+PE(F

VJ%KT                                      

4QVJGT[5VQTCIG8CP%QX#VNCU8CP.KPGU(F

&%%KT                                      

5RCWNFKPIX7PKVGF6TCPURQTVCVKQP7PKQP(F
VJ%KT
                                             

5VGCTPU#KTRQTV'SWKROGPV%QX(/%%QTR(F
VJ%KT
                                             

6QFFX'ZZQP%QTR(F
F%KT                  

7PKVGF5VCVGUX/KETQUQHV%QTR(F
&%%KT EGTV
FGPKGF5%V
                          

('&'4#.56#676'5

75%h                                          

(GF4%KX2
E                                     

KKK
/+5%'..#0'175

2JKNKR#TGGFC*GTDGTV*QXGPMCOR#PVKVTWUV.CY
FGF    RCUUKO

,CPWU\1TFQXGT2TGFCVQT[2TKEKPIKP6JG0GY2CNITCXG&KEVKQPCT[
QH'EQPQOKEUCPFVJG.CY
2GVGT0GYOCPGF            

.CYTGPEG5WNNKXCP9CTTGP)TKOGU6JG.CYQH#PVKVTWUV
        

4KEJCTF2QUPGT#PVKVTWUV.CY
FGF                      

KX
+0641&7%6+10

6JKUECUGKUCDQWVRTGFCVKQPYJKEJKUFGHKPGFWPFGTUGEVKQPQHVJG

5JGTOCP#EV75%hCUKCDPQTOCNLDWUKPGUUDGJCXKQTVJCVOCMGUPQ

DWUKPGUUUGPUGGZEGRVHQTKVUCDKNKV[VQJCTOEQORGVKVKQP/WNVKUVCVG.GICN

5VWFKGU+PEX*CTEQWTV$TCEG,QXCPQXKEJ(F
VJ%KT

 9GFGOQPUVTCVGFKPQWTQRGPKPIDTKGH
75$T VJCVVJGOQUV

QDLGEVKXGYC[VQFGVGTOKPGYJGVJGT#OGTKECPIUEQPFWEVYCUTCVKQPCNGZEGRVHQT

GNKOKPCVKPITKXCNUKUVQEQORCTGVJGEQUVUQHVJGGZVTCECRCEKV[YKVJVJGTGXGPWGU

KVIGPGTCVGFDGECWUGVJGTGKUKPQTGCUQPEQPUKUVGPVYKVJCPKPVGTGUVKPGHHKEKGPE[L

HQTCPCKTNKPGVQCFFECRCEKV[QPCTQWVGKHVJGCFFKVKQPCNTGXGPWGUIGPGTCVGFYKNN

HCNNUJQTVQHVJGCFFGFEQUVU5GG2CEKHKE'PIKPGGTKPI2TQFWEVKQP%QX-GTT

/E)GG%QTR(F
VJ%KT 9GUJQYGFVJCV#OGTKECP

GPICIGFKPCECNEWNCVGFEQWTUGQHRTGFCVKQPVQRTQVGEVKVUOQPQRQN[KPPWOGTQWU

&(9EKV[RCKTOCTMGVUYJGPGXGTKVRGTEGKXGFCVJTGCVQHNQYEQUVECTTKGT

K.%%L JWDHQTOCVKQP#OGTKECPKPWPFCVGFVJG.%%UITQWVGUYKVJUQOWEJ

OQPG[NQUKPIECRCEKV[VJCVKVFTQXGVJG.%%UDGNQYVJGKTDTGCMGXGPNQCFHCEVQTU


9GWUGVJGUGCDDTGXKCVKQPUK1RL
FKUVTKEVEQWTVIUQRKPKQP K75$TL

IQXGTPOGPVIUDTKGH K##$TL
#OGTKECPIUDTKGH K)#L
IQXGTPOGPVIU
CRRGPFKZ K##L
#OGTKECPIUCRRGPFKZ K)5#L
IQXGTPOGPVIUUWRRNGOGPVCN
CRRGPFKZ 



K$'.(UL 75$TP#OGTKECPMPGYVJCVVJKUUVTCVGI[YQWNFDGKXGT[

GZRGPUKXGL75$T%'1%TCPFCNNECWVKQPGFKPCFXCPEGVJCVVJGTG

YCUKPQRQKPVVQFKOKPKUJRTQHKVLD[KORNGOGPVKPIKVWPNGUU#OGTKECPYCU

EQPHKFGPVKVYQWNFKIGVVJGO=VJG.%%U?QWV=QH&(9?LCPFCNNQY#OGTKECPVQ

TGEQWRKVUNQUUGUVJTQWIJOCKPVGPCPEGQHOQPQRQN[RTKEGU)#75$T



1PKUUWGUQHHCEV#OGTKECPFQGUPQVFGP[VJCVKVUUVTCVGIKUVUGZRGEVGF

VJGKPETGOGPVCNECRCEKV[VQNQUGOQPG[4CVJGT#OGTKECPCTIWGU
##$T

VJCVOGVJQFQNQIKECNHNCYUKPVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUKPETGOGPVCNEQUVUVWFKGUFQQOKVU

ECUG6JGTWNGUQHCRRGNNCVGTGXKGYQHUWOOCT[LWFIOGPVU
75$T NGCFVQ

CSWKEMTGLGEVKQPQH#OGTKECPIUCTIWOGPVYJKEJKUCTGCTIWOGPVQHEQPHNKEVKPI

GZRGTVQRKPKQPU5GGKPHTCRR#OGTKECPIUENCKOVJCVKVECPPQVEJCTIG

UWRTCEQORGVKVKXGRTKEGUCV&(9
##$T KUUKOKNCTN[WPVGPCDNG

RCTVKEWNCTN[KPNKIJVQHVJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVIUHKPFKPI
KIPQTGFD[#OGTKECP

KPFKECVKPIVJCVKVFQGU1R

1PKUUWGUQHNCY#OGTKECPHCTGUPQDGVVGT+VCTIWGUVJCVCUCOCVVGT

QHNCYCPFGEQPQOKEUCFFKPIOQPG[NQUKPIGZVTCECRCEKV[KUPQVRTGFCVQT[WPNGUU

KVECWUGUOCTMGVYKFGCXGTCIGXCTKCDNGEQUV
K#8%L VQTKUGCDQXGRTKEG+PUQ


CTIWKPI#OGTKECPOKUTGRTGUGPVUOCTMGVYKFG#8%CUVJGGZENWUKXGLWFKEKCNN[

GPFQTUGFVGUVHQTGXCNWCVKPIRTGFCVQT[EQPFWEV#PFKVOKUUVCVGUVJGTGCUQPUHQT

YJCVLWFKEKCNWUGQH#8%VJGTGJCUDGGP9KVJQWVLWFKEKCNUWRRQTV#OGTKECP

QHHGTUCPGEQPQOKETCVKQPCNGHQTWUKPI#8%
CNNGIGFRTQVGEVKQPQHKGSWCNN[

GHHKEKGPVEQORGVKVQTUL YJKEJGZRGTVUTCPIKPIHTQO0QDGNKUV2TQHGUUQT5VKINKV\VQ

,WFIG2QUPGTFGOQPUVTCVGKUHNCYGF5GGKPHTCRR'SWCNN[WPCVVTCEVKXGKU

#OGTKECPIUENCKOVJCVEQPUKFGTCVKQPQHQWVQHOCTMGVTGEQWROGPVKUNGICNN[

KORGTOKUUKDNGGXGPYJGPGEQPQOKECPCN[UKUOQUVKPFKECVGUVJGPGGFHQTCPVKVTWUV

EQPEGTP##$T5EJQNCTN[CWVJQTKV[CPFEQOOQPUGPUGEQORGNTGLGEVKQP

QHVJKUENCKO5GGKPHTCRR(KPCNN[#OGTKECPIUGHHQTVVQLWUVKH[C

5JGTOCP#EVOGGVKPIEQORGVKVKQPFGHGPUGVJCVYQWNFCRRN[YJGPVJGRTGFCVQTIU

RTKEGUCTGDGNQYCPCRRTQRTKCVGOGCUWTGQHEQUVCPFTGEQWROGPVKUCUUWTGF

##$T KUKPUWDUVCPVKCN0QCRRGNNCVGEQWTVJCUCEEGRVGFVJKUFGHGPUG

YJKEJYQWNFRTQVGEVKPGHHKEKGPVOQPQRQNKUVUCPFVJKU%QWTVUJQWNFPQVFQUQ

5GGKPHTCRR

+6*'+0%4'/'06#.%1561(#/'4+%#015#&&'&%#2#%+6;
+5#0#224124+#6'/'#574'1(%156+06*+5%#5'

2TGFCVKQPKUFGHKPGFCUDWUKPGUUDGJCXKQTVJCVOCMGUPQDWUKPGUUUGPUG

GZEGRVHQTKVUCDKNKV[VQJCTOEQORGVKVKQP+VNQIKECNN[HQNNQYUVJCVVGUVUHQT


RTGFCVKQPUJQWNFVQVJGGZVGPVRQUUKDNGGXCNWCVGVJGDWUKPGUUUGPUGQHEQPFWEV

WUKPIUVCPFCTFDWUKPGUUFGEKUKQPOCMKPIETKVGTKC6JCVOGCPUEQORCTKPI

KPETGOGPVCNTGXGPWGCPFEQUVYJGPKPETGOGPVCNEQPFWEVUWEJCUCFFKPIECRCEKV[

ECPDGENGCTN[KFGPVKHKGF5WEJCEQORCTKUQPTGXGCNUVJCV#OGTKECPIUECRCEKV[

CFFKVKQPUOCFGPQUGPUGGZEGRVHQTVJGGNKOKPCVKQPQH.%%U#OGTKECP

JQYGXGTCTIWGUVJCVVJGGZENWUKXGVGUVHQTRTGFCVKQPUJQWNFDGCEQORCTKUQPQH

RTKEGYKVJ#8%QXGTCNNWPKVUUQNF6JKUVGUVFQGUPQVEQORQTVYKVJVJG

FGHKPKVKQPQHRTGFCVKQPKUPQVUKORNGVQCRRN[KPVJGCKTNKPGKPFWUVT[CPFYCUPQV

KPHCEVVJGDCUKUQPYJKEJ#OGTKECPOCFGKVUECRCEKV[FGEKUKQPU

#OGTKECPIUXCTKQWUTGURQPUGUVQQWTUJQYKPIQHRTGFCVKQPCTG

WPEQPXKPEKPI+VUCUUGTVKQP
##$T VJCVVJGIQXGTPOGPVKUGGMUVQCXQKFVJG

PGGFVQOGGV$TQQMG)TQWRIUUVTKPIGPVUVCPFCTFULKUKPEQORTGJGPUKDNGDGECWUG

VJGIQXGTPOGPVTGNKGUQP$TQQMG)TQWRIUVYQRCTVVGUV$TQQMG)TQWR.VFX

$TQYP9KNNKCOUQP6QDCEEQ%QTR75
 UGG75$T

#OGTKECPIUGORJCUKUQPVJKURQKPVOCMGUUGPUGQPN[KPNKIJVQHKVU

EQPUKUVGPVGHHQTVVQRTGVGPFVJCVCRRNKGFVQVJKUECUG$TQQMG)TQWRUQOGJQY

OCPFCVGUVJGWUGQHTQWVGYKFG#8%CUVJGGZENWUKXGTWNGQHFGEKUKQP6JG

IQXGTPOGPVCITGGUVJCV#8%ECPDGCWUGHWNVGUVRCTVKEWNCTN[CUCUCHGJCTDQT


HQTEQPFWEVYJGPKPETGOGPVCNQTOCTIKPCNEQUVECPPQVEQPHKFGPVN[DGOGCUWTGF

WPNKMGVJGOCPKRWNCVKQPQHECRCEKV[CVKUUWGJGTG$WVVJKUCPFQVJGTCRRGCNU

EQWTVUJCXGEQPENWFGFVJCVOCTIKPCNEQUVPQV#8%KKUVJGDGUVKPFKECVQTQHVJG

EQORGVKVKXGJGCNVJQHVJGKPFWUVT[L2CEKHKE'PIKPGGTKPI(FCV#8%

KUOGTGN[WUGFCUCUWTTQICVGHQTOCTIKPCNEQUVYJGPCRRTQRTKCVG75$T

)#'XGP2TQHGUUQT#TGGFCVJGQTKIKPCNRTQRQPGPVQHVJG#8%VGUV

EQPENWFGFVJCVFGHGPFCPVUUJQWNFPQVDGCNNQYGFVQTGN[QP#8%YJGPOCTIKPCN

EQUVKUKIPKHKECPVN[GZEGGF=U?CXGTCIGXCTKCDNGEQUVL2JKNKR#TGGFC*GTDGTV

*QXGPMCOR#PVKVTWUV.CY{ECV=?
FGF 
K#*L 6JCVKU

VJGECUGJGTG)#

#OGTKECPKUEQTTGEVVJCVKECRCEKV[CNQPGVGNNUVJG%QWTVPQVJKPICUVQ


0QEQWTVQHCRRGCNUJCUCFQRVGF#8%CUCKFKURQUKVKXGLOGCUWTG##$T
P6JGECUGU#OGTKECPEKVGUGKVJGTFQPQVCFQRVCP[UVCPFCTFGI
#FXQ+PEX2JKNCFGNRJKC0GYURCRGTU(F
F%KT QT
NKMGVJKU%QWTVWVKNK\G#8%CUCRTQZ[HQTOCTIKPCNEQUV'I5VGCTPU#KTRQTV
'SWKR%QX(/%%QTR(F
VJ%KT 
K+FGCNN[=YG?
YQWNFNQQMCVVJGVTWGOCTIKPCNEQUV$WVDGECWUGVJGVTWGOCTIKPCNEQUVU
QHRTQFWEVKQPCTGFKHHKEWNVVQIGPGTCVGVJKU%QWTVCVVGORVUVQGUVKOCVGVJGOD[
WUKPICXGTCIGXCTKCDNGEQUVL 

1WTQRGPKPIDTKGHEKVGUVJGGFKVKQPQHVJKUXQNWOG#GFKVKQPKU
PQYCXCKNCDNG2CTCITCRJPWODGTUCPFVGZVQHEKVGFOCVGTKCNCTGVJGUCOGKP
DQVJDWVRCIGPWODGTKPIFKHHGTU+PVJKUDTKGHYGEKVGVJGGFKVKQPIURCIGU
YKVJVJGGFKVKQPIURCIGUKPDTCEMGVU$[4WNG
L NGVVGTYGYKNNRTQXKFG
RCIGPWODGTUHQT#*EKVCVKQPUKPQWTQRGPKPIDTKGH


KNNGICNKV[L
##$T DWVKVUCTIWOGPVVJCVGORV[UGCVUJCFPQGHHGEVQP.%%U

##$T KUCPCVVGORVCVOKUFKTGEVKQP%QPVTCT[VQ#OGTKECPIUUWIIGUVKQP

WPUQNFUGCVUYGTGDQVJCPKPGXKVCDNGTGUWNVQHKVURTGFCVKQPCPFVCPIKDNGGXKFGPEG

VJCVKVUECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPUYGTGKTTCVKQPCNGZEGRVHQTVJGKTCDKNKV[VQGZENWFG

.%%U+PVJGGPF#OGTKECPCFFGFVJTGGUGCVUHQTGXGT[CFFKVKQPCNNQECN

RCUUGPIGTKVECTTKGF75$TP#OGTKECPJCUPGKVJGTTGHWVGFPQT

GZRNCKPGFVJGUGHKIWTGU6JCVGZRNCPCVKQPKUHQWPFKP#OGTKECPIUDWUKPGUURNCPU

#OGTKECPKPETGCUGFECRCEKV[VQCVVTCEVRCUUGPIGTUCYC[HTQOVJG.%%UCPFHQTEG


6JGIQXGTPOGPVIUGZRGTVUGXCNWCVGFKVJGGPVKTGRCEMCIGQH=RTKEKPICPF
[KGNFOCPCIGOGPV?FGEKUKQPUVJCVCEEQORCP=KGF?VJGECRCEKV[EJCPIG=U?L
)#P

#OGTKECPOKUNGCFKPIN[UWIIGUVUVJCVKVUECRCEKV[TGOCKPGFNCTIGN[
WPEJCPIGFCHVGT.%%GZKV##$T6JGFKUVTKEVEQWTVHQWPFVJCV#OGTKECP
TGFWEGFHNKIJVUQP&(9/%+&(9+%6CPF&(9%15HQNNQYKPI.%%GZKV
1R/QTGQXGTECRCEKV[KGVJGPWODGTQHUGCVUFGETGCUGF
FTCOCVKECNN[
=4GF? QPVJGUGVJTGGTQWVGU)5#

#OGTKECPUWIIGUVUVJCVUQOGQHVJGEJCNNGPIGFECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPUOC[
JCXGDGGPYCTTCPVGFKPNKIJVQHJKIJNQCFHCEVQTU
##$T DWV#OGTKECP
PQTOCNN[JCUPQVCFFGFUWDUVCPVKCNECRCEKV[KPOCTMGVUYKVJUKOKNCTQTGXGP
JKIJGTNQCFHCEVQTU
)# PQFQWDVDGECWUGKVMPGYFQKPIUQ
YQWNFJCXGDGGPWPRTQHKVCDNG+VUECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPUYGTGU[UVGOCVKECNN[
WPRTQHKVCDNGYJGPCPFQPN[YJGPEQPHTQPVKPI.%%U)##OGTKECPIU
HWTVJGTUWIIGUVKQP
##$T VJCV&GNVCIUGZKVKP-CPUCU%KV[TGSWKTGFKVPGCTN[
VQFQWDNGKVUPWODGTQHHNKIJVUKUYTQPIDGECWUGKPUWEJEKTEWOUVCPEGU
#OGTKECPV[RKECNN[TGFWEGFECRCEKV[QTCFFGFNKVVNG5GG)#


VJGODGNQYVJGKT$'.(UD[K=4GFCEVGF?L

)##OGTKECPIUUVTCVGIKUVUCPF%'1MPGYDQVJVJCV.%%RCUUGPIGTUYQWNF

TGURQPFVQVJGUGECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPUVJWUK=4GFCEVGF?LVJG.%%UCPFVJCVVJG

TGUWNVKPIGORV[UGCVUYQWNFK=4GFCEVGF?

L)#75$T2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IUECTGHWNOGCUWTGUQH

EQUVUCPFTGXGPWGUSWCPVKVCVKXGN[EQPHKTO#OGTKECPIURTGFKEVKQP

#OGTKECPCNUQKIPQTGUVJGHCEVVJCVVJGEQUVUQHVJGCFFGFHNKIJVUYGTG


#OGTKECPWPEQPXKPEKPIN[ENCKOU
##$T VJCVKVUFQEWOGPVUCTG
KPUKIPKHKECPVKUQWPFDKVGUTGHNGEVKPI#OGTKECPIUEQORGVKVKXG\GCNL9GCITGG
VJCVEQWTVUUJQWNFKIPQTGFQEWOGPVUVJCVOGTGN[TGHNGEVCKITGGFFTKXGPFGUKTGVQ
UWEEGGFCPFINGGCVCTKXCNIURTGFKECOGPVL##2QWNVT[(CTOU+PEX4QUG
#ETG(CTOU+PE(F
VJ%KT #OGTKECPIUFQEWOGPVU
CTGOGCPKPIHWNDGECWUGVJG[CTGPQVJGCVGFDNWUVGTDWVEQNFN[ECNEWNCVGF
CPCN[UKU6JG[CTVKEWNCVGKPFGVCKN#OGTKECPOCPCIGOGPVIUUVTCVGI[VQK
=4GFCEVGF?LVQK=4GFCEVGF?
L
)# CPFVJWUKIGVVJGOQWV=QH&(9?L

)# UQVJCV#OGTKECPEQWNFIQK=4GFCEVGF?LD[TGFWEKPIVJGK
=4GFCEVGF?LCPFETGCVGK=4GFCEVGF?LQPVJGTQWVG)#
75$T#OGTKECPIUFQEWOGPVUVJGTGHQTGCTGRQYGTHWNN[RTQDCVKXGQH
YJGVJGTKVUEQPFWEVOCFGDWUKPGUUUGPUGQPN[D[GNKOKPCVKPIEQORGVKVKQP
K='?EQPQOKECEVQTUWUWCNN[JCXGCEEWTCVGRGTEGRVKQPUQHGEQPQOKETGCNKVKGUL
6QFFX'ZZQP%QTR(F
F%KT SWQVKPI4QVJGT[
5VQTCIG8CP%QX#VNCU8CP.KPGU(FP
&%%KT

$QTM, #EEQTF2JQVQXGUV%QTRX(QVQOCV%QTR(F
P
VJ%KT 
EQPUKFGTKPIUKOKNCTFQEWOGPVUUJQYKPIYKNNKPIPGUUVQKPEWT
NQUUGU #OGTKECPIUENCKOVJCV2JQVQXGUVKUPQVKCRTGFCVQT[RTKEKPIECUGNKMG
VJKUQPGL
##$TP UKORN[RTQXGUQWTRQKPVVJCVRTGFCVKQPECPQEEWTD[
K5CVWTCVKPIVJG/CTMGVLYKVJECRCEKV[(FCV


KCXQKFCDNGLQTKKPETGOGPVCNLEQUVUEQUVUKVEQWNFJCXGUCXGFD[PQVCFFKPIVJG

HNKIJVUCPFVJWUVJGEQUVUOQUVCRRTQRTKCVGN[OGCUWTGFKPVGUVKPI#OGTKECPIU

EQPFWEV$CTT[9TKIJV%QTRX+66)TKPPGNN%QTR(F
UV%KT

 %QPVTCT[VQ#OGTKECPIUUWIIGUVKQPVJGKUUWGKUPQVUKORN[KYJGVJGT

#OGTKECPUQNFVQQOCP[UGCVUCVVQQNQYRTKEGUL##$T4CVJGTVJG

KPETGOGPVCNEQUVQHCNNVJGCFFGFUGCVUOCVVGTU)##U$CTT[9TKIJV

GZRNCKPUKHCHKTOKHCKN=U?VQEQXGTVJGUGHCXQKFCDNGIQTHKPETGOGPVCNIEQUVUKV

YQWNFFQDGVVGTVQFKUEQPVKPWGRTQFWEVKQPL(FCVUGGCNUQ$TQQMG

)TQWR75CV
UWIIGUVKPICPKKPETGOGPVCNLOGCUWTGQHEQUV 

#OGTKECPYTQPIN[ENCKOU
##$TP VJCVECUGNCYOCPFCVGUC

OCTMGVYKFGRTKEGEQUVCPCN[UKU6JGECUGUJQYGXGTOCPFCVGQPN[VJCVEQPFWEV

ENCKOGFVQDGRTGFCVQT[KOWUVDGECRCDNGQHRTQFWEKPIVJGKPVGPFGFGHHGEVU

QPVJGHKTOIUTKXCNUL$TQQMG)TQWR75CV+PQVJGTYQTFUKVOWUV

DGCKVJTGCVVQEQORGVKVKQPL$WUJPGNN%QTRX+66%QTR(4&

&-CP /QUVQHVJGECUGU#OGTKECPEKVGUCTGFKUEWUUGFKP/QTICPX

2QPFGT(F
VJ%KT YJKEJGZRNCKPUVJCVVJG[KCNN

HQEWUQPVJGDCUKESWGUVKQPQHYJGVJGTVJGCNNGIGFRTGFCVQT[CEVRQUGUCIGPWKPG

VJTGCVVQVJGQXGTCNNEQORGVKVKQPL6JGTGVJGEJCNNGPIGFEQPFWEVYCUHQWPF


KPECRCDNGQHGNKOKPCVKPIEQORGVKVKQP*GTG.%%EQORGVKVKQPYCUGNKOKPCVGF

#*HWNN[CITGGUYKVJVJGIQXGTPOGPVIURQUKVKQP+PHCEV$TQQMG)TQWRIU

HQEWUQPDGNQYEQUVRTKEKPIKPQPN[VJGKIGPGTKELUGIOGPVQHVJGOCTMGV

75$T FKURGNU#OGTKECPIUKLWUVCHTCEVKQPQHVJGOCTMGVLCTIWOGPV


#OGTKECPYTQPIN[ENCKOUVJCVKVJQUGECUGUFKFPQVKPFKECVGVJCVQPN[
HCJCPFHWNIQHUCNGUYGTGCVKUUWGL##$T(QTGZCORNG/QTICPKPXQNXGF
UCNGUVQQPN[QPGEWUVQOGT(FCV#PF,CPKEJ$TQUX
#OGTKECP&KUVKNNKPI(F
VJ%KT GORJCUK\GFVJCVDW[GTU
DQWIJVCNNGIGFN[RTGFCVQT[JCNHICNNQPUKKPEQORCTCVKXGN[UOCNNCOQWPVUL
NGUU
VJCPQHVQVCNUCNGU CPFK=D?GECWUGQHVJKULCDGNQYEQUVRTKEGKYQWNFPQVDG
NKMGN[LVQGNKOKPCVGEQORGVKVKQP+FCV
GORJCUKUCFFGF 

#U#*GZRNCKPU
{ECV=? 

+PCNNGXGPVUVJGTGNGXCPVNKPGKPYJKEJVQOCMGRTKEG
EQUVEQORCTKUQPUFGRGPFUQPVJGPCVWTGCPFRWTRQUGQH
VJGRTGFCVKQPCPFQPVJGOGEJCPKUOD[YJKEJ
EQORGVKVKQPOKIJVDGKORCKTGF9JGPVJGGHHGEVQH
CNNGIGFRTGFCVKQPKUVQYGCMGPQTGNKOKPCVGCP
KPPQXCVKQPHTQOVJGOCTMGVKPQTFGTVQRTGUGTXGCRTG
GZKUVKPIOQPQRQN[QTQNKIQRQN[VJGTGNGXCPVCTGPCKP
YJKEJVQOCMGRTKEGEQUVEQORCTKUQPUGODTCEGUVJG
KPPQXCVKQPTCVJGTVJCPVJGYJQNGOCTMGV

$GECWUGCFFKPIECRCEKV[YCU#OGTKECPIUKOGEJCPKUOLVJGCFFGFECRCEKV[KUVJG
TGNGXCPVKNKPGLQTKCTGPCLKPYJKEJVQOCMGVJGEQORCTKUQPU

#HVGTKVUGZVGPUKXGTGNKCPEGQP$TQQMG)TQWRIUHQTOWNCVKQPQHVJG
KCRRTQRTKCVGOGCUWTGQHEQUVLVGUV
##$T 
#OGTKECPIUETKVKEKUOQHVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUTGNKCPEGQP$TQQMG)TQWRIUCRRNKECVKQP
QHVJCVVGUVKUEWTKQWU##$T0GKVJGTCURGEVQHVJGQRKPKQPYCUCENGCT
JQNFKPIKPVJGECUGYJKEJRTGUGPVGFQPN[CPKUUWGQHTGEQWROGPV75CV
$WVDQVJCURGEVURTQXKFGWUGHWNIWKFCPEGVQVJGEQWTVU


##$T

%KVKPIPQCWVJQTKV[#OGTKECPCTIWGUVJCVOCTMGVYKFG#8%OWUVDG

WUGFDGECWUGKVKPFKECVGUYJGVJGTCPGSWCNN[QTOQTGGHHKEKGPVTKXCNECPDG

GZENWFGFHTQOVJGOCTMGV##$T6JKUJQYGXGTKUOGTGN[

#OGTKECPIUKPEQTTGEVVJGQT[YJKEJ2TQHGUUQT5VKINKV\GZRNCKPGF
)#

 KUFGHKEKGPVDGECWUGKVKYQWNFCNNQYVJGKPEWODGPVVQFTKXGQWVCHKTO

YJKEJEQWNFUWRRN[VJGOCTIKPCNKPETGOGPVQHQWVRWVCVNQYGTEQUVVJCPVJG

KPEWODGPVL)#,WFIG2QUPGTTGEGPVN[TGCEJGFVJGUCOGEQPENWUKQP

4KEJCTF2QUPGT#PVKVTWUV.CYCV
FGF 
K2QUPGTL 

6JG#*ICUQNKPGJ[RQVJGVKECN
75$T RTQXKFGUVJGDCUKUHQTC

ENGCTGZCORNG6JGTGHKPGTRTQFWEGUICNNQPUCFC[CVCPCXGTCIGEQUVQH

CPFKVUEQUVQHCFFKVKQPCNICUQNKPGKU5WRRQUGCPGYGPVTCPVECP

RTQFWEGICNNQPUCFC[CVCPCXGTCIGEQUVQH#NVJQWIJVJGGPVTCPV

ECPUWRRN[CNNKPETGOGPVCNQWVRWVOQTGGHHKEKGPVN[VJCPVJGKPEWODGPV

#OGTKECPIU#8%VGUVYQWNFCNNQYVJGKPEWODGPVVQGZENWFGVJGOQTGGHHKEKGPV

GPVTCPVD[UGNNKPIWRVQICNNQPUCVCRTKEGQHYJKEJKUDGNQYVJG

KPEWODGPVIUKPETGOGPVCNEQUV6JWU#OGTKECPKUHNCVYTQPIVJCVKEQORGVKVKQPKU


.%%UKCTGPQVDWTFGPGFYKVJKPGHHKEKGPVYQTMTWNGULCPFECPJCXG
QRGTCVKPIEQUVURGTOKNGDGNQY#OGTKECPIU1R


VJTGCVGPGFQPN[YJGPUGTXKEGKPVJGOCTMGVCUCYJQNGKURTKEGFDGNQYEQUVL

##$T
GORJCUKUCFFGF 

++6*''8+&'0%'5*19'&6*#6#/'4+%#015%10&7%6
(#+.'&#224124+#6'%1566'565

#OGTKECPHCTGUPQDGVVGTYKVJKVUEQPVGPVKQPVJCVHQTOGVJQFQNQIKECN

TGCUQPUVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUVGUVUFQPQVCEVWCNN[OGCUWTGKPETGOGPVCNEQUVU

##$T6JGRTQDCVKXGYGKIJVQHVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUEQUVGXKFGPEGRNCKPN[

RTGUGPVUCIGPWKPGKUUWGQHOCVGTKCNHCEVQPYJKEJVJGGZRGTVUFKUCITGGF(GF4

%KX2
E 6JWUKPVJKU%QWTVIUFGPQXQTGXKGYUWOOCT[LWFIOGPVOWUVDG

TGXGTUGF5RCWNFKPIX7PKVGF6TCPURQTVCVKQP7PKQP(F
VJ

%KT 


#OGTKECPKPEQTTGEVN[CTIWGUVJCVVJG#*J[RQVJGVKECNKUKPCRRQUKVG
DGECWUGGXKFGPEGVJCVOCTIKPCNEQUVGZEGGFU#8%KKUPQVRTGUGPVJGTGLCPFVJCV
YJGPGXGTKVCFFUHNKIJVUVQCTQWVGKVUKOCTIKPCNQTKPETGOGPVCNEQUVQHCFFKPI
UGTXKEG=KU?NQYGTVJCPVJG#8%QHCNNHNKIJVUQP=VJG?TQWVGL##$T+H
JQYGXGT#OGTKECPYGTGVQCFFCHNKIJVCVVTCEVKPIQPN[QPGCFFKVKQPCNRCUUGPIGT
VJGOCTIKPCNCPFKPETGOGPVCNEQUVQHECTT[KPIVJCVRCUUGPIGTYQWNFDGVJGGPVKTG
EQUVQHVJGCFFGFHNKIJVHCTITGCVGTVJCPVJGCXGTCIGEQUVHQTCNNRCUUGPIGTUQP
VJGTQWVG2TQHGUUQT$GTT[GZRNCKPGFVJCV#OGTKECPIUOCTIKPCNCPFKPETGOGPVCN
EQUVUGZEGGF#8%JGTGDGECWUG#OGTKECPCFFGFUQOWEJECRCEKV[VJCVKVUTQWVG
YKFGNQCFHCEVQTUFTQRRGF)#

6JGFKUVTKEVEQWTVIUCPCN[UKUQHVJKUKUUWGYCUDTKGHCPFET[RVKE1R
#RCTVHTQOVYQETKVKEKUOUVJCVCTGRNCKPN[YTQPI
UGGKPHTCPQVGU 
VJGEQWTVCRRGCTUPQVVQJCXGCFFTGUUGF#OGTKECPIUEQPVGPVKQPU


2TQHGUUQT$GTT[GZCOKPGFVJGEQUVUQH#OGTKECPIUEQPFWEVWUKPIHQWT

VGUVU

6GUV9JGVJGTKPETGOGPVCNEQUVGZEGGFGFKPETGOGPVCNTGXGPWG

6GUV9JGVJGTNQPITWP
OQPVJ #8%GZEGGFGFRTKEG

6GUV9JGVJGTRTKEGYCUDGNQY#OGTKECPIUOQPVJEQUVOGCUWTG

RGTUKUVGPVPGICVKXGRTQHKVCDKNKV[ CPF

6GUV9JGVJGTKPETGOGPVCN
CXGTCIGCXQKFCDNG EQUVGZEGGFGFRTKEG

2TQHGUUQT$GTT[HQWPFVJCV#OGTKECPHCKNGFGCEJVGUVGXGT[YJGTGKVYCU

CRRNKECDNG)#

 6JGUGVGUVUWUGVJGUCOGEQUVCPFTGXGPWGCEEQWPVUVJCV#OGTKECPWUGFVQ

OCMGFGEKUKQPUCDQWVTQWVGCPFHNKIJVRTQHKVCDKNKV[KPENWFKPIYJGVJGTVQUGTXGC


2TQHGUUQT$GTT[CRRNKGFVJKUKTCPIGQHVGUVULVQCXQKFOKUNGCFKPI
KPFKECVKQPUKPCTTKXKPICVJKUEQPENWUKQPVJCV#OGTKECPGPICIGFKPRTGFCVKQP
)#9JKNGYGHQEWUQPVJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVIUGTTQTUYKVJTGICTFVQ6GUVU
CPF#OGTKECPIUETKVKEKUOUQH6GUVUCPF
##$T CTGKPEQTTGEV
)#

#OGTKECPETKVKEK\GU6GUVUCPFDGECWUGVJG[ECPPQVDQVJDGCRRNKGFVQ
CNNGRKUQFGU##$T%QPVTCT[VQ#OGTKECPIUENCKOU6GUVYCUCRRNKGFVQ
.QPI$GCEJ)#CPF6GUVYCUCRRNKGFVQVJGUGEQPF-CPUCU%KV[
GRKUQFG)#CUYGNNCUVQ%QNQTCFQ5RTKPIU)#/QTGQXGTVJG
NCYTGSWKTGUCPKCRRTQRTKCVGLOGCUWTGQHEQUVUCPF2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IUECWVKQPKP
CRRN[KPIVJGVGUVUQPN[YJGTGCRRTQRTKCVGKUJCTFN[ITQWPFUHQTETKVKEKUO#UJG
GZRNCKPGFKPQVGUVECPDGCRRNKGFKPCXCEWWOLCPFJGWUGFKCTCPIGQHVGUVUL
VQDGEQPHKFGPVQHJKUTGUWNVU)#


TQWVGCPFYKVJJQYOCP[HNKIJVU)5#
#OGTKECPK

=4GFCEVGF?L 
K

=4GFCEVGF?

L )#2TQHGUUQT$GTT[HQWPF#OGTKECPIUEQUV

CEEQWPVUTGNKCDNG
75$T PQVKPIVJCVVJG[CTGKFGUKIPGFHQTFGEKUKQP

OCMKPIL)#CEEQTF)5#2TQHGUUQT/CJGTVJGIQXGTPOGPVIU

CEEQWPVKPIGZRGTVFGUETKDGFVJGCEEQWPVKPIU[UVGOCUKOQFGTPUQRJKUVKECVGFL

CPFKEQORCTCDNGVQVJGDGUVL)5#/QFGTPOCPCIGTKCNCEEQWPVKPIU[UVGOU

UWEJCU#OGTKECPIUKTGRQTV=?EQUVUVJCVTGHNGEVGEQPQOKETGCNKV[L
)5# CPF

#OGTKECPIUU[UVGOKYCUFGUKIPGFVQECRVWTGQPN[VJQUGEQUVUVJCVCTG

KPETGOGPVCNVQHNKIJVCEVKXKV[L)5#

2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IUCPCN[UKUQH#OGTKECPIUEQUVUCPFTGXGPWGUYCUECWVKQWU

CPFVJQTQWIJ*GGZRNCKPGFYJ[JKUVGUVUCRRTQRTKCVGN[OGCUWTGFEQUVU

)#*GKFGPVKHKGFKPETGOGPVCNEQUVUD[CPCN[\KPICPFTGLGEVKPI

KRQUUKDNGPQPRTGFCVQT[GZRNCPCVKQPULHQTEQUVKPETGCUGUCPFVGUVKPIHQTKHCNUG

RQUKVKXG=?LHKPFKPIU)#UGGCNUQ)#

*GCNUQEQPVTQNNGFHQTXCTKQWUHCEVQTUCHHGEVKPI

EQUVU)#P*GWUGFVJGUGXGTCNVGUVUVQIGVJGTCU


ETQUUEJGEMUVQCXQKFOKUNGCFKPIKPFKECVKQPUQHRTGFCVKQP)#*G

GZRNCKPGFYJ[JKUEQUVVGUVUYGTGCRRTQRTKCVGVQKFGPVKH[RTGFCVKQP)#

#PFJGEQPFWEVGFCTGITGUUKQPCPCN[UKUVJCVKFGPVKHKGFCUVTKMKPI

RCVVGTPYJKNG#OGTKECPIUECRCEKV[EJCPIGUYGTGU[UVGOCVKECNN[RTQHKVCDNGKP

OQUVOCTMGVUKPENWFKPIOCTMGVUYJGTG#OGTKECPEQORGVGUYKVJ5QWVJYGUVVJG[

YGTGU[UVGOCVKECNN[WPRTQHKVCDNGKP.%%OCTMGVU)#

#OGTKECPCTIWGUVJCVGXKFGPEGDCUGFQPKVUFCVCKUKPCFGSWCVGDGECWUGKV

KFKFPQVCEVWCNN[OGCUWTG=KPETGOGPVCN?EQUVUCPFTGXGPWGUL##$T


GORJCUKUCFFGF EH1R#OGTKECPENCKOUVJCVKVUCEEQWPVUECPPQV

DGWUGFVQECNEWNCVGVJGKPETGOGPVCNEQUVQHCFFGFECRCEKV[DGECWUGVJG[FQPQV

KKUQNCVGVJGEQUVUCEVWCNN[CVVTKDWVCDNGVQVJGECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPUL##$T

#OGTKECPIUQPN[FKUEGTPKDNGTCVKQPCNGKUVJCVKVUCEEQWPVUGORNQ[EQUV


5KOKNCTN[#OGTKECPUC[UVJCV6GUVCTDKVTCTKN[OGCUWTGUTGXGPWGD[
KIPQTKPIKUGCUQPCNXCTKCVKQPUKPVTCXGNFGOCPFCPFRCUUGPIGTOKZVJCVOCMGPQ
VYQOQPVJUCNKMGKPVJGCKTNKPGKPFWUVT[L##$TUGGCNUQ1R$WV
2TQHGUUQT$GTT[WUGFVJTGGFKHHGTGPVVKOGRGTKQFUVQKGZCOKPGVJGTQDWUVPGUUQH
VJKUTGUWNVLYJGTGRQUUKDNGKGSWCNK\KPIUGCUQPCNKV[HCEVQTUL)#
/QTGQXGTCNVJQWIJ#OGTKECPETKVKEK\GU$GTT[IUKFGPVKHKECVKQPQHVJGCXGTCIG
RTKEGRCKFD[KPETGOGPVCNRCUUGPIGTU#OGTKECPIUEQPFWEVCNOQUVWPKHQTON[
HCKNGF6GUVWUKPICPCNVGTPCVKXGECNEWNCVKQPDCUGFQPVJG
JKIJGT CXGTCIGRTKEG
RCKFD[CNNRCUUGPIGTU)#P


CNNQECVKQPU##$T$WVEQUVCNNQECVKQPKUCMG[RCTVQHOCPCIGTKCN

CEEQWPVKPIVJCVRGTOKVUTGNGXCPVCPFUGPUKDNGTGEQTFKPICPFCUUKIPKPIQHEQUVU

)5#)##OGTKECPKIPQTGU2TQHGUUQT/CJGTIUEQPENWUKQP

VJCVVJGRCTVKEWNCTEQUVCNNQECVKQPUKP#OGTKECPIUU[UVGOYGTGKTGCUQPCDNGLCPF

VJCVKVJGVTGCVOGPVQHEQUVULKP#OGTKECPIUCEEQWPVURTQXKFGUKTGCUQPCDNG

OGCUWTGUQHRTQHKVCDKNKV[HQTGXCNWCVKPIDWUKPGUUFGEKUKQPUTGNCVKPIVQYJGVJGTVQ

CFFECRCEKV[VQCTQWVGL)5#CEEQTF)#*GHWTVJGT


#OGTKECPUWIIGUVU
##$T VJCVVJGEQUVKPETGCUGUKFGPVKHKGFD[C
DGHQTGCPFCHVGTCPCN[UKUOKIJVPQVDGKCVVTKDWVCDNGVQVJGECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPUL
DWV#OGTKECPFQGUPQVUWIIGUVCPQVJGTECWUG6JGFKUVTKEVEQWTVYTQPIN[
URGEWNCVGFVJCVVJGKPETGCUGKPEQUVUOKIJVDGFWGVQNCDQTQTHWGN%QORCTG1R
YKVJ75$T#OGTKECPJCUCDCPFQPGFVJKUCTIWOGPV/QTGQXGT
2TQHGUUQT$GTT[ECTGHWNN[CPCN[\GFYJGVJGTQVJGTECWUGUGZKUVGFCPFHQWPFPQPG
)#

6JGUWRGTKQTKV[QHEQUVCNNQECVKQPQXGTUKORNGECUJCEEQWPVKPIKUHCOKNKCT
VQCP[QPGYJQJCUHKIWTGFQPCEGPVURGTOKNGDCUKUVJGEQUVQHWUKPICP
CWVQOQDKNG
KPENWFKPIGZRGPUGUVJCVCTGHTGSWGPV
GIICUQNKPG RGTKQFKE
GI
UEJGFWNGFOCKPVGPCPEG CPFQEECUKQPCN
GIPGYVKTGU #NNQECVKQPQHUWEJ
EQUVUQPCRGTOKNGDCUKUOCVEJGUTGCNGEQPQOKEEQUVUVQVJGCEVKXKVKGUYKVJYJKEJ
VJG[CTGCUUQEKCVGF
)5# CPFCXQKFUVJGGTTQTUQHQXGTKPENWUKQP
GI
EQWPVKPIVJGGPVKTGVKTGTGRNCEGOGPVEQUVCICKPUVQPGVTKR QTWPFGTKPENWUKQP

GIEQWPVKPICNNQVJGTVTKRUCUKHVJG[FKFPQVRTQFWEGCP[YGCTCPFVGCTQPVJG
VKTGU #OGTKECPKORNGOGPVUVJGUGRTKPEKRNGUKPKVUCNNQECVKQPFGEKUKQPU
)5#
K
=4GFCEVGF?
L )5#
K
=4GFCEVGF?
L 


GZRNCKPGFVJCV2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IUEQUVOGCUWTGEQPUGTXCVKXGN[GXCNWCVGUVJG

KPETGOGPVCNEQUVUQHCFFKPIECRCEKV[VQCTQWVGDGECWUGKVGZENWFGUUQOGEQUVU

NKMGN[VQXCT[YKVJVJGCFFKVKQPQHECRCEKV[)5#)##OGTKECPIU

GZRGTVENCKOUQVJGTYKUGUQVJGKUUWGKUFKURWVGF/QTGQXGT2TQHGUUQT$GTT[TG

FKFJKUVGUVQOKVVKPIVJGRCTVKEWNCTEQUVU#OGTKECPEKVGUKPKVUDTKGH
##$T

EKVKPI## CPF#OGTKECPUVKNNHCKNGF)#

#OGTKECPIUENCKO
##$T VJCV2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IU6GUVUCPFCTG

NGICNN[KORTQRGTKRTQHKVOCZKOK\KPILVGUVUKUKPEQTTGEV#OGTKECPHCKNUVQ

EQPVGUVQWTCTIWOGPV
75$T QPVJKURQKPV#OGTKECPIUCFFKVKQPCN

EKVCVKQPUVQ2TQHGUUQT5VKINKV\IUVJGQTKGU
#### CPFVQ

RTQRQUGF&16VGUVU
## FQPQVEQPEGTP2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IUVGUVU

6JTGGKORQTVCPVRQKPVUCTGENGCT(KTUVVJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVHCEGFIGPWKPG

KUUWGUQHOCVGTKCNHCEVCDQWVVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUEQUVGXKFGPEGQPYJKEJVJG


%KVKPIKVUGZRGTV&T&QTOCP#OGTKECPENCKOUVJCVKVUCEEQWPVKPI
U[UVGOKPCFGSWCVGN[UJQYUKPETGOGPVCNEQUVDGECWUGKVKCNNQECVGUEGTVCKPEQUVU
FQYPVQKPFKXKFWCNHNKIJVUCPFTQWVGUVJCVCTGPQVFTKXGPD[CEVKXKV[CVVJGHNKIJV
QTTQWVGNGXGNL##$T$WV2TQHGUUQT/CJGTGZRNCKPGFVJCVK&T&QTOCP
CRRNKGUVJGYTQPIEQPEGRVQHCXQKFCDNGEQUVKPJKUCPCN[UKULYJKNG#OGTKECPIU
CEEQWPVKPICRRTQCEJWUGFD[2TQHGUUQT$GTT[KKUUGPUKDNGCPFKUEQPUKUVGPVYKVJ
EQOOQPRTCEVKEGKPOCPCIGTKCNCEEQWPVKPIL)5#UGG)##U[GV
CPQVJGTEJGEM2TQHGUUQT$GTT[TGECNEWNCVGF6GUVWUKPICPCFFKVKQPCN
KKPETGOGPVCNHNKIJVEQUVOGCUWTGVJCV#OGTKECPWUGUL#OGTKECPUVKNNHCKNGF
)#


GZRGTVUFKUCITGGF5GEQPF2TQHGUUQT$GTT[IUVGUVUUJQYGFCDTWRVUKIPKHKECPV

CPFRGTUKUVGPVNQUUGUQPVJGCFFGFECRCEKV[)#6JKTF

#OGTKECPGZRGEVGFNQUUGUYJGPKVRNCPPGFKVURTGFCVKQPCPFPGXGTENCKOGFVJCV

VJGNQUUGUYGTGFWGVQCIQQFHCKVJOKUECNEWNCVKQP

(KPCNN[#OGTKECPUKORN[KUYTQPIVJCVKPETGOGPVCNEQUVVGUVUCTGVQQ

KXCIWGLQTKEQORNGZLHQTDWUKPGUUFGEKUKQPOCMKPI##$TP#U

#*GZRNCKPUCHKTOIUCPCN[UKUQHYJGVJGTVQGPICIGKPRTGFCVKQPKUKPQ

FKHHGTGPVLHTQOVJGGPFNGUUDWUKPGUUFGEKUKQPUKVTQWVKPGN[HCEGUUWEJCUYJGVJGT

VQCFFCPGYRTQFWEVQTGPVGTCPGYOCTMGV#*{ECV=?UGG

75$TP+PGCEJKPUVCPEGCKTCVKQPCNHKTOOCMGUCPKPXGUVOGPVQPN[

CHVGTECNEWNCVKPIVJCVVJGCPVKEKRCVGFRC[QHHUGGOUVQDGYQTVJVJGEQUVUCPF


#OGTKECPKUYTQPIVJCVKUVTCKIJVHQTYCTFLUKORNKEKV[OCMGU#8%VJGVGUV
QHEJQKEG##$TP9JKNG#8%QPEGKYCUVJQWIJVVQDGCLWFKEKCNN[
OCPCIGCDNGOGCUWTGQHEQUVFGVGTOKPKPICXGTCIGXCTKCDNGEQUVJCURTQXGP
FKHHKEWNVCPFEQUVN[L.CYTGPEG5WNNKXCP9CTTGP)TKOGU6JG.CYQH#PVKVTWUV

 #KTNKPGUEJCTIGOCP[HCTGUQPCUKPINGHNKIJVUQPQUKPINGHCTG
RTQXKFGUCWUGHWNEQORCTKUQPYKVJ#8%CPFYJGPCKTNKPGUUGVHCTGUVJG[FQPQV
MPQYYJCVRGTRCUUGPIGT#8%YKNNDGUKPEGVJCVFGRGPFUQPJQYOCP[
RCUUGPIGTUHN[/QTGQXGTNCTIGN[VJGUCOGCPCN[UKUQHEQUVUKUTGSWKTGFHQT
#8%CPF6GUVUCPF)#9JKEJEQUVUCTGXCTKCDNGFGRGPFUQP
VJGOCIPKVWFGCPFFWTCVKQPQHVJGEJCPIGUKPECRCEKV[QWVRWVCPFQVJGTHCEVQTU
VJCVOC[ECWUGEQUVUVQXCT[#PFYJKEJUWEJEJCPIGUCTGTGNGXCPVOWUVDG
FGVGTOKPGFD[TGHGTGPEGVQVJGEJCNNGPIGFEQPFWEVYJKEJCNUQFGHKPGUVJG
KPETGOGPVHQTRWTRQUGUQHFGVGTOKPKPIKPETGOGPVCNEQUV


TKUMUL#*{ECV=?6JWU#OGTKECPNKMGCNNTCVKQPCNHKTOUWUGU

CPKPETGOGPVCNEQUVVGUVTQWVKPGN[YJGPKVCUMUYKNNVJKUEQPFWEVOCMGOQPG[QT

PQV!*GTGVJGCPUYGTRNCKPN[YCUKPQVLGZEGRVHQTVJGGNKOKPCVKQPQH

EQORGVKVKQPVJCV5GEVKQPEQPFGOPU

+++ 6*')18'40/'065*19'&6*#6#/'4+%#0.+-'.;
917.&4'%172+6524'ɦ.155'5

#OGTKECPRTGFCVGFKPHQWTOCTMGVUVQRTQVGEVKVUUWRTCEQORGVKVKXG

RTQHKVUKPVJKTV[OQPQRQN[OCTMGVUHTQOVJGVJTGCVRQUGFD[.%%GZRCPUKQPCPF

JWDHQTOCVKQPCV&(9)##OGTKECPCEEWTCVGN[RTGFKEVGFVJCV

RTGFCVKQPYQWNFDGKXGT[GZRGPUKXGL
1R)# KVGXGPVWCNN[EQUV

#OGTKECPOKNNKQP1R$WVHQTGUVCNNKPI.%%JWDHQTOCVKQPCV&(9

HQTLWUVVYQ[GCTUYCUYQTVJCVNGCUV=4GF?OKNNKQP)##OGTKECPENGCTN[

JCFCTGCNKUVKEGZRGEVCVKQPQHTGEQXGTKPIKVUNQUUGUHTQOVJGEJCNNGPIGFEQPFWEV


+VKUPQVUWTRTKUKPIVJCV#OGTKECPIUFQEWOGPVUTGXGCNKVUEQPENWUKQPVJCV
KFKOKPKUJ=KPI?RTQHKVULD[CFFKPIECRCEKV[YQWNFDGYQTVJYJKNGQPN[KHKVIQVVJG
.%%UKQWVLQH&(9CPF#OGTKECPRQKPVUVQPQGXKFGPEGVJCVKVRGTHQTOGFCP
#8%CPCN[UKURTKQTVQCFFKPIVJGHNKIJVU

#OGTKECPFQGUPQVCFFTGUUVJKUECNEWNCVKQP6JGFKUVTKEVEQWTVNCDGNGFKV
KURGEWNCVKXGL
1RP DWVVJGVYQ[GCTRGTKQFYCUPQVQHHGTGFCUC
RTGFKEVKQPQHJQYNQPI.%%JWDUCEVWCNN[YQWNFDGHQTGUVCNNGF4CVJGTKVYCU
WUGFVQUJQYVJCVVJGRTGFCVQT[UCETKHKEGKGCUKN[LEQWNFDGTGEQWRGF)#
*CFVJGVYQ[GCTRGTKQFDGGPCRTGFKEVKQPJKPFUKIJVFGOQPUVTCVGUVJCVKVYQWNF
JCXGDGGPEQPUGTXCVKXG


$TQQMG)TQWR75CVYJGPKVKEQOOKV=VGF?KVUTGUQWTEGUVQ

RTGFCVKQPL#*{ECV=?9JKNGVJGIQXGTPOGPVPGGFPQVUJQY

VJCV#OGTKECPCEVWCNN[TGEQWRGFKVURTGFCVQT[KPXGUVOGPVVJGEQPVKPWKPICDUGPEG

QHCP[.%%JWDCV&(9
75$T RTQXKFGUUVTQPIGXKFGPEGQHCEVWCN

TGEQWROGPVCUYGNN

$WUKPGUUUVTCVGI[FQEWOGPVURCKPVCENGCTRKEVWTGQHVJGDGPGHKVUCPFEQUVU

VJCV#OGTKECPIUOCPCIGOGPVKPENWFKPI%'1%TCPFCNNTGCUQPCDN[GZRGEVGF

HTQORTGFCVKQP5GG75$T#OGTKECPPQYEQPVGPFUVJCVVJGUG

FQEWOGPVUKPFKECVGKUWDLGEVKXGDGNKGHULCPFHCKNVQRTQXKFGVJGTGSWKUKVG

KQDLGEVKXGGXKFGPEGL##$TP$WV$TQQMG)TQWRIUTGHGTGPEGVQ

KQDLGEVKXGGXKFGPEGL75CVECPPQVUGPUKDN[DGKPVGTRTGVGFVQGZENWFG

ECTGHWNN[HQTOWNCVGFUVTCVGIKEDWUKPGUURNCPUCPVKEKRCVKPIVJCVVJGGZENWUKQPQH

.%%UYQWNFOCMGKVRTQHKVCDNGVQWPFGTVCMGOQPG[NQUKPIECRCEKV[CFFKVKQPU


#OGTKECPIUENCKO
##$TP VJCVVJGUGFQEWOGPVUFQPQVUJQYKV
GZRGEVGFUWRTCEQORGVKVKXGHCTGUCHVGTRTGFCVKPIJKPIGUQPKVUOKUVCMGP
EQPVGPVKQPFKUEWUUGFRTGUGPVN[VJCVKVYCUPQVEJCTIKPIOQPQRQN[HCTGUDGHQTG
RTGFCVKPI

+P$TQQMG)TQWRVJG%QWTVYCUPQVRTGUGPVGFYKVJUVTCVGIKEDWUKPGUU
RNCPUFGVCKNKPIVJGRTGEKUGRTGFCVQT[UEJGOGCNNGIGFD[VJGRNCKPVKHH4CVJGTVJG
RNCKPVKHHTGNKGFQPFQEWOGPVUOGTGN[KURGCM=KPI?QHCFGUKTGVQUNQYVJGITQYVJL
QHIGPGTKEEKICTGVVGUYJGPVJGFGHGPFCPVIUEQPFWEVFKFPQVKVJTGCVGP=?KPC
UGTKQWUYC[LVQCEJKGXGVJCVGHHGEV75CV5GGCNUQPQVGUWRTC


9JGVJGT#OGTKECPCPVKEKRCVGFRTQHKVKPIHTQOGZENWUKQPKUYJCVVJGTGEQWROGPV

KUUWGKUCNNCDQWV

#OGTKECPEQPVGPFUVJCVVJGCDUGPEGQHKTGNGXCPVUVTWEVWTCNDCTTKGTUCV

&(9LOCFGUWRTCEQORGVKVKXGHCTGUKORQUUKDNG
##$T CPFVJCV

TGEQWROGPVQWVUKFGVJGHQWTOCTMGVUKPYJKEJRTGFCVKQPQEEWTTGFKUKTTGNGXCPVCU

COCVVGTQHNCY+F$QVJEQPVGPVKQPUCTGYTQPI

C#OGTKECPKIPQTGUVJGHCEVVJCVPQKPSWKT[KPVQKUVTWEVWTCNDCTTKGTULKU

PGEGUUCT[YJGPVJGTGKUFKTGEVGXKFGPEGQHUWRTCEQORGVKVKXGRTKEKPI5GGGI

4G/CZ+PVGTPCVKQPCN+PEX4GCNV[1PG+PE(F
VJ%KT

 
TGXGTUKPIUWOOCT[LWFIOGPVKPNKIJVQHFKTGEVGXKFGPEGQHOQPQRQN[

RQYGT %QCUVCN(WGNUQH2WGTVQ4KEQ+PEX%CTKDDGCP2GVTQNGWO%QTR

(F
UV%KT 
FKEVWO 6JGFKUVTKEVEQWTVHQWPFVJCVHCTGUKP

OCTMGVUUGTXGFD[5QWVJYGUVCPF.%%UYGTGKEQORGVKVKXGRTKEGULCPFYGTG

KUKIPKHKECPVN[LNQYGTVJCPHCTGUYJGTGVJGTGYCUPQEQORGVKVKQPHTQO5QWVJYGUV

QTCP.%%1R+VHQNNQYUVJCVVJGKUKIPKHKECPVN[LJKIJGTHCTGUKPVJG

OQPQRQN[OCTMGVUCTGKRTKEGUCDQXGCEQORGVKVKXGNGXGNLCUTGSWKTGFD[$TQQMG

)TQWR75CVSWQVGFCV##$T&GURKVGVJKUUWRTCEQORGVKVKXG

RTKEKPI#OGTKECPJCUOCKPVCKPGFFQOKPCPVUJCTGUKPVJGVJKTV[OCTMGVUYJGTG


VJGIQXGTPOGPVCNNGIGFKVJCFOQPQRQN[RQYGT)#+P

VTWORGVKPIVJGTKUGQH.%%EQORGVKVKQPCV&(9
##$T #OGTKECP

KIPQTGUVJGHCEVUVJCVKVJCUHCEGFPQPQPUVQR.%%EQORGVKVKQPKPVJGUG

OQPQRQN[OCTMGVUCPFVJCV.%%GPVT[JCUDGGPHCTITGCVGTCVQVJGTOCLQTJWDU

VJCPCV&(9)#

#OGTKECPIUCUUGUUOGPVQHOCTMGVUVTWEVWTGCNUQKUDCUGFQPCJKIJN[

UGNGEVKXGTGXKGYQHVJGTGEQTF#OGTKECPRQKPVUQWVVJCV&GNVCQRGTCVGFCOQFGUV

JWDCV&(9DWVKIPQTGUUVTQPIGXKFGPEGVJCV&GNVCIURTGUGPEGFKFPQVPGICVG

#OGTKECPIUOQPQRQN[RQYGT)#UGGCNUQ1R#OGTKECP

QDUGTXGUVJCV5QWVJYGUVUGTXGUOCP[FGUVKPCVKQPUQWVQH&CNNCU.QXG(KGNFDWV

QOKVUVJGETWEKCNHCEVVJCVPQPGQHVJGOCTMGVUCNNGIGFVQDGOQPQRQNKGUEQWNF

JCXGDGGPUGTXGFD[5QWVJYGUVCUCOCVVGTQHHGFGTCNCXKCVKQPNCY)#


#OGTKECPIU&(9RCUUGPIGTUJCTGJCUTGOCKPGFQXGTYJKNGVJG
EQNNGEVKXGUJCTGQH.%%UJCUDGGPCTQWPF)##OGTKECPENCKOU
VJCVVJKUHKIWTGKKUOKUNGCFKPIL##$TPDWVKVUWUGYCURTQORVGFD[
VJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVIUTGOCTMVJCVVJG.%%UIRCUUGPIGTUJCTGCV&(9JCF
KKPETGCUGFUKIPKHKECPVN[L1RUGG75$T6JGHKIWTGKUHTQOVJG
UCOGRCIGQHVGUVKOQP[
)# #OGTKECPEKVGFKPWTIKPIVJGEQWTVVQOCMGVJCV
TGOCTM5GG)5#

#UFGVCKNGFD[VJGFKUVTKEVEQWTV
1R UGTXKEGCV.QXG(KGNFJCU
DGGPTGUVTKEVGFD[HGFGTCNNCYYJKEJRGTOKVUEQOOGTEKCNUGTXKEGHTQO.QXG
(KGNFKPCKTETCHVYKVJOQTGVJCPUGCVUYJKEJCNN5QWVJYGUVIURNCPGUJCXG
1R
 QPN[VQRQKPVUKP#NCDCOC#TMCPUCU-CPUCU.QWKUKCPC/KUUKUUKRRK
0GY/GZKEQ1MNCJQOCCPF6GZCU#OGTKECPIURTGFCVKQPKP9KEJKVCQEEWTTGF




D#OGTKECPCPVKEKRCVGFTGEQWROGPVHTQOVJGGNKOKPCVKQPQHCEVWCN

EQORGVKVKQPKPVJGHQWTRTGFCVKQPOCTMGVUCPFHTQOVJGGNKOKPCVKQPQHRQVGPVKCN

EQORGVKVKQPKPVJGTGOCKPKPI&(9OQPQRQN[OCTMGVU6JGQWVQHOCTMGV

TGEQWROGPVYQWNFFGTKXGDQVJHTQOFGUVTQ[KPIQTFKUEKRNKPKPIVJGVCTIGV.%%U

VJWUGPFKPIVJGKTJWDDWKNFKPIVJTGCVCPFHTQOUKIPCNKPIPQPVCTIGV.%%U

75$T 5KIPCNKPIFGVGTUGPVT[D[PQPVCTIGV.%%UVJTQWIJVJG

GUVCDNKUJOGPVQHCKTGRWVCVKQPHQTRTGFCVKQPL6JGTGKUPQUWRRQTVHQT

#OGTKECPIUCTIWOGPVVJCVQPN[KPOCTMGVTGEQWROGPVKUNGICNN[TGNGXCPV

6JGUWRRQTV#OGTKECPQHHGTU
##$T KUOCKPN[CHGYYQTFURNWEMGF

HTQOCUGPVGPEGKP$TQQMG)TQWRVJCVFKTGEVUEQWTVUVQEQPFWEVKCENQUGCPCN[UKU

QHVJGUEJGOGCNNGIGFL75CV4GEQWROGPVKPCNNVJG&(9

DGHQTGHGFGTCNNCYCNNQYGFUWEJUGTXKEGVQ-CPUCU9KEJKVCJCUPQVUWDUGSWGPVN[
DGGPUGTXGFHTQO.QXG(KGNF

#OGTKECPKUEQTTGEVVJCVPQECUGEKVGFKPQWTQRGPKPIDTKGHUSWCTGN[JQNFU
VJCVQWVQHOCTMGVTGEQWROGPVKUNGICNN[TGNGXCPV
##$T DWVKVKUCNUQVTWG
VJCVPQECUGUSWCTGN[TGLGEVUKV#OGTKECPENCKOUYGKUGTKQWUN[OKUEQPUVTWGL
4GC\KPX$NWG%TQUUCPF$NWG5JKGNFQH-CPUCU+PE(F
VJ%KT
 ##$T$WVYGEKVGFVJGECUGQPN[HQTKVUFKUEWUUKQPQHCPCPCNQIQWU
CPFUWEEGUUHWNUKIPCNKPIGHHGEVD[CPGPVTGPEJGFOQPQRQNKUVVJCVKEQPUVKVWVGF
YKNNHWNOCKPVGPCPEGQHKVUOQPQRQN[RQYGTL(FCV


OQPQRQN[OCTMGVUKUDQVJVJGKUEJGOGCNNGIGFLCPFVJGUEJGOGVJCVYCU

OGVKEWNQWUN[RNCPPGFD[#OGTKECPCVVJGJKIJGUVNGXGNUQHVJGEQORCP[5GG

)#75$T/QTGQXGT$TQQMG)TQWRJCFPQFKHHKEWNV[

YKVJVJGRNCKPVKHHIUVJGQT[VJCVTGEQWROGPVQHVJGRTGFCVQT[UCETKHKEGKPIGPGTKE

EKICTGVVGUYQWNFQEEWTVJTQWIJJKIJGTRTKEGUHQTDTCPFGFEKICTGVVGU5GG75$T



#OGTKECPCNUQQHHGTU#FXQ
##$T YJKEJKPFKTGEVN[UWRRQTVUVJG

IQXGTPOGPVIUTGEQWROGPVVJGQT[D[PQVKPIVJCVQHVGPK=R?TGFCVKQPOCMGU

GEQPQOKEUGPUGLQPN[DGECWUGQHVJGRQVGPVKCNHQTCRC[QHHQWVUKFGVJGRTGFCVKQP

OCTMGV(FCVPUGG75$T#OGTKECPKIPQTGUVJKURQKPV

CPFCFXQECVGUCTWNGVJCVRTGENWFGUCPCVVCEMQPRTGFCVKQPKPVJGXGT[UEGPCTKQKP

YJKEJRTGFCVKQPECPDGOQUVRTQHKVCDN[GORNQ[GF

9KVJQWVSWGUVKQPKPIVJGGEQPQOKEUQWPFPGUUQHVJGIQXGTPOGPVIU

TGEQWROGPVVJGQT[#OGTKECPCTIWGUVJCVVJGEQPEGRVQHCKTGRWVCVKQPHQT

RTGFCVKQPLUJQWNFDGTGLGEVGFCUCOCVVGTQHNCY5KIPKHKECPVN[VJKUCTIWOGPV


#OGTKECPYTQPIN[CUUGTVUVJCVVJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVKP#FXQ(5WRR
P
'&2C KGZRTGUUN[TGLGEVGFVJGUCOGV[RGQHTGEQWROGPV
VJGQT[VJGIQXGTPOGPVOCMGUJGTGL##$TP6JGNCUVUGPVGPEGQHVJG
EKVGFHQQVPQVGYJKEJ#OGTKECPQOKVUOCMGUENGCTVJCVVJGRNCKPVKHHIUVJGQT[YCU
QPGQHETQUUUWDUKFK\CVKQPTCVJGTVJCPTGEQWROGPV


RTQXKFGUPQDCUKUHQTTGLGEVKPIEQPUKFGTCVKQPQH#OGTKECPIUUWDUVCPVKCN

TGEQWROGPVVJTQWIJRTGXGPVKPIVJGVCTIGV.%%UHTQOGZRCPFKPIUGTXKEGCV&(9

/QTGQXGT#OGTKECPIUCTIWOGPVTWPUEQWPVGTVQVJGITGCVYGKIJVQHUEJQNCTN[

CWVJQTKV[6JGNGCFKPICPVKVTWUVVTGCVKUGGZRNCKPU

=#?FGHGPFCPVIUICKPU
RQVGPVKCNTGEQWROGPV HTQORTGFCVQT[RTKEKPI
ECPGZVGPFDG[QPFVJGDGPGHKVUQHFGUVTQ[KPIQTFKUEKRNKPKPIVJG
=RTG[?HQTVJGRTGFCVKQPOC[KUKIPCNLQVJGTKPEWODGPVUCUVQYJCV
CYCKVUVJGKTRTKEGEQORGVKVKQPQTUKIPCNQWVUKFGTUCUVQYJCVCYCKVU
VJGKTGPVT[6JGRTGFCVQT[DGJCXKQTECPFGVGTHWVWTGEQORGVKVKQP
DGHQTGKVQEEWTU+PVJCVGXGPVVJGCPVKEKRCVGFXCNWGQHRTGFCVKQP
KPENWFGUVJGDGPGHKVPQVQPN[QHFKUEKRNKPKPIVJGKOOGFKCVGVCTIGVDWV
CNUQVJGDGPGHKVQHFKUEQWTCIKPIHWVWTGEQORGVKVKQPD[QVJGTU

#*{FCV=?,WFIG$QTMJCUGZRNCKPGFVJCVKEJCUVGP=KPI?TKXCNULKU

CHQTOQHRTGFCVKQP0GWOCPX4GKPHQTEGF'CTVJ%Q(F
&%

%KT ,WFIG2QUPGTHKPFUVJGEQPEGRVQHTGRWVCVKQPHQTRTGFCVKQPUQWPF

2QUPGTCV#PFQPGQH#OGTKECPIUGZRGTVUURGEKHKECNN[UC[UVJCVKEQWTVU

UJQWNFEQPUKFGTLKV,CPWU\1TFQXGT2TGFCVQT[2TKEKPIKP6JG0GY2CNITCXG

&KEVKQPCT[QH'EQPQOKEUCPFVJG.CY
2GVGT0GYOCPGF 

#OGTKECPIUTGNKCPEGQP#FXQ
##$T KUOKURNCEGF#FXQFKFPQVTGLGEV

CNNTGRWVCVKQPCTIWOGPVU4CVJGTKVFKUVKPIWKUJGFVJCVRNCKPVKHHIUTGRWVCVKQP


#UCTIWGFKPQWTQRGPKPIDTKGH
75$TP QVJGTECUGUKPXQNXKPI
KTGRWVCVKQPLKUUWGUCTGKKPCRRQUKVGL#OGTKECPFKUCITGGU
##$TP CUVQ
.QU#PIGNGU.CPF%QX$TWPUYKEM%QTR(F
VJ%KT 


VJGQT[HTQOQVJGTTGRWVCVKQPVJGQTKGUCPFTGLGEVGFVJGRNCKPVKHHIUDGECWUGKV

KORNKGFKDCTTKGTUVQGPVT[KPCNNOCTMGVUL(FCV#OGTKECP

TGEQIPK\GUVJCVVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUVJGQT[KUFKHHGTGPVCPFCRRNKGUOQTGPCTTQYN[

DWVWTIGUVJKU%QWTVVQTGLGEVKVDGECWUGKVKNKMGN[YQWNFRTGXGPVUWOOCT[

LWFIOGPVKPGXGT[ECUGLKPXQNXKPIKOWNVKRNGOCTMGVUL##$T6JKUKU

HCNUGUWOOCT[LWFIOGPVECPDGDCUGFQPKUUWGUQVJGTVJCPTGEQWROGPVCPFKV

EQWNFDGDCUGFQPTGEQWROGPVKPVJGXCUVOCLQTKV[QHECUGUKHVJGKPHTGSWGPE[QH

VJGOWNVKRNGOCTMGVUEGPCTKQKPTGRQTVGFECUGUKUCWUGHWNIWKFG

#OGTKECPCTIWGUVJCVKVKUFKHHKEWNVVQKFKUVKPIWKUJ=?DGVYGGPCTGRWVCVKQP

HQTRTGFCVKQPCPFQPGHQTCIITGUUKXGNCYHWNEQORGVKVKQPLUQVJCVVJG

IQXGTPOGPVIUTGEQWROGPVVJGQT[KEQWNFNGCFVQHOKUVCMGPKPHGTGPEGUIQH

RTGFCVQT[EQPFWEVL##$T
GORJCUKUCFFGF 6JKUOKUCRRTGJGPFUVJG

IQXGTPOGPVIUVJGQT[+VKUPQVVJGEJCTCEVGTQH#OGTKECPIUTGRWVCVKQPVJCV

FGVGTOKPGUNKCDKNKV[DWVTCVJGTVJGEJCTCEVGTQHKVUEQPFWEV6JGQPN[FKUVKPEVKQP

YGECNNQPVJGEQWTVVQOCMGKUDGVYGGPCTGRWVCVKQPHTQORTGFCVKQPCPFC

TGRWVCVKQPHTQOCIITGUUKXGNCYHWNEQORGVKVKQP*GPEGVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUVJGQT[

DWVVJGEQWTVIURQKPVKPVJCVECUGYCUVJCVKRTQQHQHOQPQRQN[RQYGTLECPPQVTGUV
QPEQPFWEVCNQPGKRCTVKEWNCTN[YJGTGCEQWTVJCUCNTGCF[FGVGTOKPGFVJCVVJGCEVU
KPSWGUVKQPYGTGPQVGZENWUKQPCT[L+PVJKUECUGKRTQQHQHOQPQRQN[RQYGTL
FQGUPQVTGUVQPEQPFWEVCNQPGCPFVJGEQPFWEVKPSWGUVKQPYCUGZENWUKQPCT[


QHTGEQWROGPVTGSWKTGUPQFKUVKPEVKQPVJGEQWTVFKFPQVCNTGCF[JCXGVQOCMG

CDQWVVJGNGICNKV[QHVJGEQPFWEVGUVCDNKUJKPIVJGTGRWVCVKQP

(KPCNN[#OGTKECPENCKOUVJCVVJGIQXGTPOGPVHCKNGFVQUJQYCPCEVWCN

KTGRWVCVKQPHQTRTGFCVKQPL##$T$WVVJKUKULWUV#OGTKECPIUVCMGQPC

FKURWVGFKUUWGQHHCEVCPFVJGTGKUUWDUVCPVKCNGXKFGPEGQPVJGQVJGTUKFG5GG

75$T6JGVCTIGV.%%UYKVJFTGYHTQOUGXGTCNOCTMGVUCPFYGTGPQV

TGRNCEGF
75$T CPFVJGTGTGOCKPUPQ.%%JWDCV&(9/QTGQXGTVJG

KUUWGKUPQVYJGVJGT#OGTKECPCEVWCNN[JCUTGEQWRGFDWVYJGVJGTKVJCFC

TGCNKUVKEGZRGEVCVKQPQHTGEQWROGPVYJGPKVWPFGTVQQMKVURTGFCVKQP

+801/''6+0)%1/2'6+6+10&'('05'#22.+'5+06*+5%#5'

#OGTKECPFQGUPQVUKIPKHKECPVN[EJCNNGPIGVJGIQXGTPOGPVIUUJQYKPI

75$T VJCVCOGGVKPIEQORGVKVKQPFGHGPUGKUDQVJWPCXCKNCDNGWPFGTVJG


#OGTKECPIUUVCVGOGPVQHHCEVUOC[DGTGCFVQUWIIGUVVJCVVJGVCTIGV
.%%UGZKVGFHQTTGCUQPUQVJGTVJCPRTGFCVKQP##$T$WV#OGTKECPFKF
PQVCTIWGVJKUKPKVUUWOOCT[LWFIOGPVOQVKQPCPFKVUOCPCIGOGPVFKFPQVUJCTG
VJKUXKGYYJGPKVRNCPPGFCPFKORNGOGPVGFKVU.%%UVTCVGI['I)#

5WP,GVKUKOCLQTEQPEGTPL )#
RTGXGPV9GUVGTP2CEKHKEHTQOK
=4GFCEVGF?L 6JKUYQWNFDGQPGOQTGFKURWVGFHCEVWCNKUUWGCVVTKCN6JG
IQXGTPOGPVIUGXKFGPEGYCUOQTGVJCPGPQWIJVQUWTXKXGUWOOCT[LWFIOGPV
K6QTGSWKTGVJCVhNKCDKNKV[=KPKPLWPEVKXGCEVKQPU?VWTPQPCRNCKPVKHHIUCDKNKV[QT
KPCDKNKV[VQTGEQPUVTWEVVJGJ[RQVJGVKECNOCTMGVRNCEGCDUGPVCFGHGPFCPVIU
CPVKEQORGVKVKXGEQPFWEVYQWNFQPN[GPEQWTCIGOQPQRQNKUVUVQVCMGOQTGCPF
GCTNKGTCPVKEQORGVKVKXGCEVKQPL7PKVGF5VCVGUX/KETQUQHV%QTR(F

&%%KT EGTVFGPKGF5%V
 


5JGTOCP#EVCPFHCEVWCNN[KPCRRNKECDNGJGTG+VFQGUPQVFKURWVGVJCVVJGVGZVQH

VJG5JGTOCP#EVKUFGXQKFQHCP[OGGVKPIEQORGVKVKQPFGHGPUG+VFQGUENCKO

VJCVVJKU%QWTVCUYGNNCUVJG5KZVJCPF5GXGPVJ%KTEWKVUJCXGTGEQIPK\GFVJG

FGHGPUG
##$T DWVKVIKXGUVJKUICOGCYC[D[EQPEGFKPI
KF VJCV

PQEQWTVQHCRRGCNUJCUGXGTTGEQIPK\GFVJGFGHGPUGYJGPVJGRTGFCVQTIURTKEGU

CTGDGNQYCPKCRRTQRTKCVGOGCUWTGLQHEQUV#PFCU#OGTKECPUC[U
##$T

 K=K?HCFGHGPFCPVIURTKEGUCTGCDQXGLVJGCRRTQRTKCVGOGCUWTGQHEQUVKVJGP

KVFQGUPQVPGGFVQTCKUGCOGGVKPIEQORGVKVKQPFGHGPUGL

#RTQRQUGFFGHGPUGVJCVOGTGN[OGGVKPICTKXCNIURTKEGGZEWUGUYJCV

QVJGTYKUGYQWNFDGKNNGICNRTGFCVKQPKUWPFGTUVCPFCDN[YKVJQWVUWRRQTVKP

RTGEGFGPVHQTKVYQWNFWPFGTOKPGVJGIQCNUQHVJGCPVKVTWUVNCYU+VYQWNFOCMG


#OGTKECPRNCEGUUWDUVCPVKCNYGKIJVQPNCPIWCIGKPCFKUVTKEVEQWTVQRKPKQP
YKVJKPVJG0KPVJ%KTEWKV
##$T DWVVJG0KPVJ%KTEWKVUWDUGSWGPVN[
FKUCXQYGFKV%QORCTG+.%2GTKRJGTCNU.GCUKPI%QTRX+$/%QTR(
5WRR
0&%CN CHHIF(F
VJ%KT YKVJ
&54GFK/KZX5KGTTC4GFK/KZCPF%QPVTCEVKPI%Q(F

VJ%KT #OGTKECPIUTGNKCPEGQPVJGGFKVKQPQH#*
##$T KU
JCTFVQHCVJQODGECWUGVJGVTGCVKUGPGXGTGPFQTUGFCOGGVKPIEQORGVKVKQP
FGHGPUGQHVJGMKPF#OGTKECPCFXCPEGUCPFCU#OGTKECPEQPEGFGU
KF
VJGGFKVKQPGZRTGUUN[YQWNFPQVCNNQYVJGFGHGPUGYJGPVJGKPEWODGPVCU
JGTGHNQQFUVJGOCTMGVYKVJGZVTCECRCEKV[#OGTKECPIUCVVCEMQP2TQHGUUQT
*QXGPMCORHQTGZRTGUUKPIVJGUGXKGYUKPVJGGFKVKQP
##$TPP
 OCPCIGUVQDGCVQPEGCDWUKXGCPFHTKXQNQWU+PJGEQPUWNVGFYKVJVJG
IQXGTPOGPVQPVJKUECUGCPFYCURCKFHQTPKPGJQWTUQHYQTM


$TQQMG)TQWRIUDGNQYEQUVRTKEKPIRTGTGSWKUKVGUWRGTHNWQWUYJGPKVKUOQUV

KORQTVCPVYJGPCPGPVTGPEJGFJKIJEQUVOQPQRQNKUVHCEGUPGYOQTGGHHKEKGPV

EQORGVKVKQP#PFKVYQWNFTGYCTFVJGRTGFCVKQPQHCPKPGHHKEKGPVHKTOYKVJVJG

OCKPVGPCPEGQHKVUOQPQRQN[

(KPCNN[CUCHCEVWCNOCVVGT#OGTKECPECPPQVCXCKNKVUGNHQHCP[OGGVKPI

EQORGVKVKQPFGHGPUGDGECWUGKVWPFGTEWVKVUTKXCNUIRTKEGUD[QHHGTKPIITGCVGT

XCNWG1R+VUHTGSWGPVHNKGTRTQITCO##FXCPVCIGQHHGTUUKIPKHKECPV

XCNWGVQRCUUGPIGTU#OGTKECPFQGUPQVFGP[VJGXCNWGQHVJCVRTQITCO

4CVJGTKVCTIWGUVJCVKVUJQWNFDGKIPQTGFDGECWUGKVUXCNWGKUKKPVCPIKDNGLCPF

DGECWUGVJGIQXGTPOGPVKEKVGUPQGXKFGPEGKPVJGTGEQTF
VJGTGKUPQPG

RWTRQTVKPIVQSWCPVKH[VJGXCNWGQH#OGTKECPIURTQITCOL##$T6JGUG

CTIWOGPVUCTGFKUKPIGPWQWU#OGTKECPMPQYUHWNNYGNNVJGXCNWGQHKVUHTGSWGPV

HNKGTRTQITCOCPFMGGRUKVQPKVUEQTRQTCVGDQQMU#PFUWEJFCVCKUKPVJG

TGEQTF)5#/QTGQXGTKH#OGTKECPYGTGEQTTGEVVJCVKCP[CPCN[UKUQH

SWCNKV[KUKPJGTGPVN[URGEWNCVKXGCPFWPEGTVCKPL
##$T VJGFGHGPUG

UJQWNFPQVDGCNNQYGFDGECWUGKVECPPQVDGCFOKPKUVGTGFEQPUKUVGPVYKVJVJG


0Q.%%VCTIGVGZEGRV8CPIWCTFJCFCHTGSWGPVHNKGTRTQITCOCPF
8CPIWCTFIURTQITCOYCUKPHGTKQTVQ#OGTKECPIU1R6JWUKVKU
KTTGNGXCPVVQFGVGTOKPGKD[YJCVOCTIKPVJGXCNWGQH#OGTKECPIURTQITCO
GZEGGFUVJGXCNWGQHCP.%%IURTQITCOL##$T


RWTRQUGUQHVJG5JGTOCP#EV

%10%.75+10

(QTVJGTGCUQPUUVCVGFJGTGCPFKPQWTRTKPEKRCNDTKGHVJGITCPVQH

UWOOCT[LWFIOGPVUJQWNFDGTGXGTUGF

4GURGEVHWNN[UWDOKVVGF

&100#-112'456'+0 4*'9+662#6'
4'0#6#$*'55' &GRWV[#UUKUVCPV#VVQTPG[)GPGTCN
41$'46&;170)
,4+%*#4&&1+&)' %#6*'4+0')1I57..+8#0
0+0#$*#.' 41$'46$0+%*1.510
4'$'-#*,(4'0%* ,1*02(106'
-#4.&-0765'0 &#8+&5'+&/#0
,'00+('4.%+*10 41)'49(10'5
/#:4*7((/#0 %4#+)9%104#6*
/#4-,0+'('4 #VVQTPG[U
#VVQTPG[U  75&GRCTVOGPVQH,WUVKEG
75&GRCTVOGPVQH,WUVKEG #PVKVTWUV&KXKUKQP
#PVKVTWUV&KXKUKQP &5VTGGV09
VJ5VTGGV095WKVG 9CUJKPIVQP&%
9CUJKPIVQP&% 
 

#UUKUVCPV#VVQTPG[)GPGTCN,COGUKUTGEWUGFKPVJKUECUG


#OGTKECPIUENCKO
##$T VJCVKVUCPVKEQORGVKVKXGEQPFWEVUJQWNF
DGGZEWUGFDGECWUGKVYKNNDGVQQJCTFVQHCUJKQPCRRTQRTKCVGTGNKGHYCUPQV
GZCOKPGFKPVJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVYCUPQVOGPVKQPGFKPVJGFKUVTKEVEQWTVIUQRKPKQP
CPFVJGTGHQTGECPPQVDGWUGHWNN[EQPUKFGTGFD[VJKU%QWTV'EQPQOKUVUHQTDQVJ
VJGIQXGTPOGPVCPFVJGFGHGPFCPVUCITGGFVJCVCRTQEQORGVKVKXGTGOGF[ECPDG
HCUJKQPGF)#


(GF4#RR2
C

% %'46+(+%#6'1(%1/2.+#0%'

+4QDGTV$0KEJQNUQPCOGODGTQHVJGDCTQHVJKU%QWTVJGTGD[EGTVKH[

VJCVVJKUDTKGHEQPVCKPUYQTFUCUEQWPVGFD[9QTF2GTHGEVWUGFVQ

RTGRCTGVJKUDTKGHCPFVJWUKUYKVJKPVJGYQTFNKOKVCVKQPUGVD[VJG%QWTVIU

QTFGTQH5GRVGODGT


41$'46$0+%*1.510


%'46+(+%#6'1(5'48+%'

+4QDGTV$0KEJQNUQPCOGODGTQHVJGDCTQHVJKU%QWTVJGTGD[EGTVKH[

VJCVVQFC[/CTEJ+ECWUGFEQRKGUQHVJGCEEQORCP[KPI4'2.;

$4+'((14#22'..#0670+6'&56#6'51(#/'4+%#VQDGUGTXGFD[

(GFGTCN'ZRTGUUQPVJGHQNNQYKPIRGTUQPU

/CTM'9GDGT'USWKTG
)KDUQP&WPP%TWVEJGT..2
5QWVJ)TCPF#XGPWG
.QU#PIGNGU%#

&GDTC,2GCTNUVGKP'USWKTG
9GKN)QVUJCN/CPIGU..2
(KHVJ#XGPWG
0GY;QTM0GY;QTM


41$'46$0+%*1.510