You are on page 1of 21

Traditional skills Kami 1

A QUEST FOR THE TRADITIONAL KNOWLEDGE TRANSMISSION OF KAMI PEOPLE: A


CASE STUDY OF BHANSAR, TANAHUN

Submitted To:

Tribhuvan University
Faculty of Education
Master of Philosophy

By
Bishnu Prasad Mishra
M. Phil. 2st Semester, 4th Batch, 2008
Faculty of Education
Tribhuvan University
M. Phil. Program
2009
Traditional skills Kami 2

A QUEST FOR THE TRADITIONAL KNOWLEDGE TRANSMISSION OF KAMI PEOPLE: A


CASE STUDY OF BHANSAR, TANAHUN

Background of the Study

This study is carried out for the partial fulfillment of the Master in Philosophy in Caste
Education and Development and conducted in ward no 5 of Bhanu VDC of Tananun district where
some households of Kami. Nepal is country where there are total numbers of castes, indigenous
peoples and religious groups are 100 and three are unknown. Various studies give us the picture of the
forest of complex social structure as well as counting trees of caste/ethnicity, language and religion.

Peoples assumed that the traditional profession of Kami is diminishing because it is not
feasible for the livelihoods. Kami are discriminated due to their occupation. But the Kami peoles of
Bhansar are still engaged in their traditional occupation. Kami have been relegated to do caste-based
work as black/goldsmith. They said that they are being continued their traditional occupations due to
poverty and lack of other means of livelihood. Bhattachan et. al. (2002) found in their study that there
is high degree of caste-based discrimination from the upper caste Hindu (48.1%) and the Indigenous
Nationalities (38%) to the low caste Hindus or untouchables even today. Caste- based discrimination
is equally observed between the high caste Dalits and the low caste Dalits.

The purpose of this study was to find out the the types of discrimination against Kami peoples
of Nepal and to identify the skills and mode of transmission of skill and knowledge from one
generation to the other generation. This study was carried out in the Ward no 5 of Bhanu VDC of
Tanahun district. The nature of the study is qualitative. Therefore I used the qualitative approaches to
study. The present study reports my findings in regard to the transmission of Kami People's
traditional skills and knowledge from the older generation to the younger, discuss the changes and
factors that affect or impede transmission. I conclude with a discussion to the likely effects of loss of
traditional knowledge and skills, and some of its concern aspects.

Statement of the Problem

The knowledge and skills acquired by the Kami peoples of Nepal is a one of the indigenous
skills. The skills of Kami peoples have the characteristics of indigenous knowledge. It is local
knowledge. Local knowledge refers to: local knowledge held by indigenous people or local
Traditional skills Kami 3

knowledge unique to a given culture or society (Berkes, 1999) (Cited in Deckens, 2007). Indigenous
knowledge is different broadly from other knowledge. It is transmitted orally, experiential rather than
theoretical knowledge and learned through repetition and it is constantly changing (Ellen & Harris,
1996) (Cited in WB, 1998, p. 2). It is necessary to identify the kind of discrimination against the
Kami people and the skills and the mode of transmission of skills and knowledge they have.

Objective of the Study

The main objective of this study is to find out the types of discrimination against Kami
peoples and to identify the skills and mode of transmission of skills and knowledge of the Kami
Peoples of Nepal.

Research Questions

To fulfill the objective of the proposed research, I seted the following questions:
1. How the caste of Kami is formed?

2. What are the bases of discrimination against the Kami?

3. How the Kami Peoples are discriminated in the Nepali society?

4. What the skills and knowledge do Kami people have?

5. How do the skills and knowledge of Kami peoples transfer from one generation to other
generation?

Delimitation

This study is purely academic and qualitative. The purpose of this study is to fulfill the partial
requirement of Master in Philosophy in education of Tribhuvan University. Due to its nature and
purpose; I did not have adequate resource and time to cover large extent of sample from different
geographical, socio-economic and gender representation. I did not include the female from the
households where I studied because they were not involved in the activities of Aran. I limited my
study in two households and two persons and only limited area.

Traditional knowledge pertaining to belief systems, spirituality, and cosmology were also left
out of the scope of this study. I limited my study on what skills did the Kami peoples acquired and
how did they acquired along with what skills were transmitted to their children. I did not go ahead to
explore that what additional skills and programs they need to promote their traditional knowledge and
what was the affect of modern technology to their skills and knowledge.
Traditional skills Kami 4

Literature Review

Origin of Caste System in Nepal

Nepal is a Himalayan, landlocked, secular, Federal Democratic Republic lying between the
People's Republic of China in its north and the Republic of India in its south. One of the scholar stated
that anthropologists has identified four racial groups in Nepal by looking at the physical features of
the Nepalese peoples (Bhattachan, 2008). These are: Mongoloid, Caucasoid, Dravidian, and Proto-
Australoid. Bahun-Chhetri, the dominant caste group belongs to Caucasoid racial group. The majority
of populations belong to Mongoloid and Caucasoid races. The population of Dravidian and Proto-
Australoid is nominal and they are confined in some pockets in eastern Terai region. Caucasoid is
divided into varna and caste groups. Mongoloid, Dravidian and Proto-Australoids are the indigenous
peoples and do not belong to Hindu Varna and social hierarchy. It is recognized as multi-ethnic and
multilingual country in Asia. The racial, religious, cultural and social systems are diverse according to
the diversity in geography. Brahmin, Chhetri, Tharu, Bhantar, Teli, Dholi, Musahar, Sarki, Damai,
Kami etc are Indo-Nepalese living basically in the Terai and Hill. Similarly, Rai, Limbu, Magar,
Gurung, Tamang etc are Tibeto-Nepalese residing in the Hill and Mountain. They have their own
socio-cultural identity and economic status (Gyawali & Acharya, 2003).

The caste culture is seen as originating in the increasing social differentiation, segmentation,
and stratification of the Hindu society. Its history dates back to the Vedic period (6000-4000 BC).
According to Saraf (1986.107) the Aryans were a homogenous and cohesive group in the early
Rigved period, in the middle Rigved period, the group was divided into Brahmin and Kshetriya on the
one hand and Vaisya on the other , in the late Rigved period the group further divided giving birth to
Sudra caste by the end of Brahmanic period, and in the post- vedic period some of Sudra were
classified as Asprishya (non-touchables) and sprishya (touchable) (cited in Koirala, 1996, p:10).
Similarly, in the further quoted the opinion of Khatri and Dahal (1987). They have presented the
origination of caste differently. Koirala (1996) quoted that:

Prior to the writing of the book Purusukta (1000-500 BC), the ancient society
was divided into different classes: as economic class, power class and religious
class and service class. These class themselves were the Varna. The religious
class was known as Brahman Varna, the power class was Kshatriya Varna, and
the economic class called Vaishya Varna (ibid).

As in most of the societies of the world, so in India, the son inherited his father's profession.
And so in India there developed families, who professed the same family profession for generation in
which, the son continued his father's profession. Later on as these families became larger, they were
Traditional skills Kami 5

seen as communities or as they are called in Indian languages, Jat. Different families who professed
the same profession developed social relations between them and organized as a common community,
meaning Jat. Kami peoples are adopting the work of iron from the beginning of the caste system.

Varna, as enunciated in the Brahminical test, e. g., the Rigveda (10.90.12) or the Manusmriti,
categorized the people in the Indian society into four categories. The Varna system should however be
differentiated from the cultural, non-religious, caste-system. Manu divided the work in these ways.
The Brahmins' primary vocation is to learn the Vedas and other sacred texts teach and pray. The
Kshatriya's chief occupation is managing their kingdoms and military service. The Vaishyas are
occupied with economic activities (agrarian and trade) and the Sudras are skilled workers and service
providers of all types (http://www.en.wikipedia.org).

The discussion above implies that Hindu culture though came from Sanatana Dharma has
legitimized division in the society. For example the Bhagvat Gita says: the four castes are created by
Krishna by the same stuff but they are classified into four castes according to their qualities and
actions. But the Rig Veda i.e. Hymn 11 (cited in Nirula, 2005), which is credited for being the
genealogical roots of caste system mentioned it differently. It reads the Brahmin was his mouth, of
both his arms was the Rajanya made. His thighs became Vaisya, from his feet the Sudra was produced
in the context of describing Birat person (the Brahma).

One of the scholars writes that the resign Jayasthiti Mall (1260-1395) was a period in which
the caste system was systematized in Nepal. He reorganized the Newari society in the Kathmandu on
the basis of Manusmriti writing. It was Jayasthiti Malla's activities that planted firm roots of caste
devision and untouchability in Nepali society (Kishan, 2005).

Dalit is the latest and politically correct, of many terms used for untouchable Shudras. The
word dalit(a) comes from the Sanskrit - root dal that means held under check, suppressed, or crushed,
or, in a looser sense, oppressed. The term scheduled castes/scheduled tribes are also used in the Indian
legal system to refer to this group along with non-caste tribes (Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia). In
South Asia' caste system, a Dalit; often called an untouchable; is a person of Shudra; the lowest of the
four castes. Included are leather-workers (called chamar), scavengers (called Bhangi or Chura), street
handcrafters, poor farmers and laborers (http://www.alrc.net).

The word Dalit literally means a person immersed in a swamp. Traditionally, Dalits have
been treated inhumanely as Untouchables. Although untouchability was abolished by the New
National Code of Nepal in 1963, its practice still continues. The women belonging to this community
are living in a swamp of illiteracy, exploitation, marginalization, absolute poverty and, above all,
caste discrimination (Bisowarkarma, 2004). The word Dalit comes from the Sankrit root dal, which
Traditional skills Kami 6

means to shatter, to break into pieces and to step on. The literal meaning of the word Dalit are
Shattered; over-burdened; suppressed; squeezed; stepped upon; kneaded; ground down; shamed by
being required to bow to someone else's feet; or silenced through suppression (Kishan, 2005).

There is a serious problem in understanding the context of Dalits in Nepal for two reasons: i)
the term Dalit itself is a politically coined word, meaning the poor and oppressed persons. This
meaning is less sensitive than the term Harijan or Achhoot or so called untouchables, and ii) The term
Dalit, is understood as untouchables or Achhoot or the term connotes in the sense of Old Legal code
of 1854, Pani nachalne choit chito hanlu parne jat (caste from whom water is not accepted and whose
touch requires sprinkling of holy water). It seems that the first term is used by Dalits for their
convenience whereas, in practice, the meaning is loaded with the second in addressing the problems
of Dalits in Nepali society (http://www.carenepal.org).

This problem of definition has created two issues i) there is an inclusion and exclusion in the
list of Dalits. In 1997, Dalit Vikas Samity identified 23 various cultural groups as Dalits and Dalit
Ayog (formed in March 2002) forwarded the Bill to the government identifying 28 cultural groups as
Dalits in Nepal in Nepal, and ii) As the list of Dalit fluctuates, so is the size of population of Dalits,
ranging 2 million to 4.5 million in various sources.

Hindu society has traditionally been divided into several traditionally been divided into
several groups, castes or communities called Jatis. The phrase Hindu Caste System mixes up two
different schemes the Varna (class/group), which is the theoretical system of grouping found in
Brahminical traditions and some medical codes, and the Jati system prevalent in Nepali society since
historical time. The word Varna means order, category, type, color (of things), and groups the human
society into four main types as Brahnins (intelligentsia, priests, scholars, teachers), Kshatriyas
(warriors, nobility), Vaishyas (merchants, farmers), and Sudras (Workers, service providers, laborers).

The Hindu Varna system is a classification based on a number of social categories. People
categorized in the four Varnas were origionally and are still engaged in predetermined occupations. As
long as the concept of Varna was not equivalent to caste, Varna division was only a division of labour
and the Varna name was equivalent to a particular type of work.

Although there is controversy on the use of the term Dalit, the Dalit movement of Nepal has
accepted the term (Bhattacha et al 200; Viswakarma 2001; Dahal et al. 2002). They have defined the
term Dalit to refer to those peoples who belong to Hindu castes and who have been placed at the
bottom of the social hierarchy as Sudra and treated as untouchable by upper castes (Bhattacha, 2006).
The national code 1854 and the Dalit movement consider Chyamkhala, Pode, and Kasai as
Traditional skills Kami 7

untouchalbes or Dalits but the latter claimed that they belong to the Newar indigenous nationality, but
not to Dalits.

From the discussion above there is no one accurate definition of Dalit. According to Gyawali
and Acharya (2003), the untouchable castes of Nepal may be divided into three different categories as
follows:

1. Caste living primarily in the southern plains of Terai including Dum, Teli, Sundi, Musahar,
Dusadh etc,
2. Castes that are predominantly found in the middle hills. These include Kami, Damai, and
Sarki who have large population than any other untouchable caste in Nepal,
3. Newari speaking Tibeto-Burman language is indigenous group of the Kathmandu valley.

Dalits remain at the very bottom of Nepal's caste hierarchy (DFID & WB,2006). Even now,
the government and many development/aid organizations use euphemisms such as occupational
castes, backward classes, marginalized, and disadvantaged groups, instead of referring to them as
Dalits. The hesitation to use the term Dalit deflects attention from the everyday reality of caste-based
discrimination in Nepal. According to the 2001 Census, Dalits comprised 13 percent of the population
but the figure is contested. Discrimination based on caste is prevalent mainly in parts of Asia and
Africa. UNICEF estimates the discrimination based on caste affects 250 million people worldwide
(Wikipedia, 2008).

It is said that Kami belongs to the Arya, in the Sudra, so they are included in the Varna
system. The Kami caste group peoples were calling as Sunar, Kami, Lohar etc. They write different
surnames.

Population and Settlement of Kami Peoples

The word Kami is the synonym of English word blacksmith. The word blacksmith refers to
iron, which was known as the black metal, and smith, meaning a smitter of metal (as in tinsmith or
silversmith). Kami are rural people known for metal working. They are divided into two groups:
black smithes and gold, silver, and copper smiths. They supplement smiting with agricultural work.
As a rule, Kamis are Hindus. They worship different Hindus deities, and they go on pilgrimage to
Hindu sacred sites in Nepal. Some have converted to Buddhism, and other religions, as well as
Christianity, probably to be free of discrimination.
Traditional skills Kami 8

Kami is a Dalit community from Nepal which belongs to the Indo-Aryan ethnic group.
Kamies are essentially blacksmiths who are scattered in almost all hilly districts of Nepal. Kamis are
black-smiths, who are along with their traditional caste occupation of making and repairing iron tools,
also practice agriculture. Within the Kami group there is more professional group called Sunar (gold
or silver-smith) who makes and repairs gold or silver ornaments. Historically, they were economically
dependent on their clients for livelihood and used to provide their services to their clients through the
traditional Indian Jajamani system such as Bali or Khan. This system also exists in many parts of
Nepal even today. These days, some Kami males and females are relatively better educated than
Government Organizations (NGO) and corporations such as banks, etc.

In the Eastern and Central Hill regions, Kami are a homogenous group where as in the
Western and Far-western Hill regions, they are divided into sub groups with different occupational
categories such as Koli, Lohar, Mahar, Pouri, Chunara and others. Among the Dalits groups, Kamis
are treated highest in social rank and they never accept cooked food and water from the Dalit groups
lower than them. They marry within their own groups.

This is the largest Dalit group in Nepal in terms of population size. According to the 1991
census, the population size of Kami was 963,655 or 5.2 percent of the total population but within Dalit
group, their percentage is 43.8 per cent. They are distributed throughout the kingdom but their
concentration is heavy (population size with more than 10,000) in 39 districts. Jajarkot, Achham and
Dailekh districts have the highest percentage of Kami within these districts. In terms of ranking the
population size of various ethnic/caste groups within the district, they rank second in six districts and
third in another ten districts in population size (CBS, 1991). According to the 2001 Census, there are
total of 895,954 Kami in the country of which 96.69 percent were Hindu and 2.21 percent were
Buddhists (http://www.en.wikipedia.org).

Bases of Discriminations

One of the scholar stats that Dalits are discriminated against on the basis of caste and
untouchability (Shrestha, 2003). Kami peoples are belongs to the Dalit categories so the bases of
discrimination against Kami peoples are bases on caste and untouchability. Two studies show that
most Dalits suffer from discrimination practices involving food and drink (38.9%) and prohibition of
entry into houses, temples and other public places (28.3%). Both studies show that incidence of caste
based discrimination is higher in the western region than in the eastern region of the country (ibid).
Discrimination against Dalits is the overwhelming reality of Nepal's social structure. However, there
are hierarchies and discrimination within the Dalit community with Kami, sonar and Lohar (identified
by the surname Biswakarma) at the so-called top of the hierarchy.
Traditional skills Kami 9

Nature of Discrimination

The nature of discrimination against Dalits is different. They are discriminated in different
forms such as social and cultural discrimination, traditional caste-based occupation and forced labor,
discrimination in education, denial of entry, low participation in activities of the government,
nongovernmental organizations and donors, social boycott, weak exercise of political rights, and
atrocities against Dalits (Shrestha, 2003). Dalits are discriminated in the religious and cultural
spheres. According to the respondents of this study they are not allowed to practice Hindu rituals,
norms and values in the same manner as other castes. Some literature states that the Dalits are
converted into Christianity to escape from the discrimination against them (cited in Shrestha, 2003).
But the situation in my study area is a bit different from other site of the Tanahun district. They pray
Narayan in the month of Kartik. They invite so called high caste at the Narayan Puja. All the
arrangement needed for Puja performed by the so called upper caste such as Brahmin and Kshetris.
Brother in low (Jwai) performs as the priest (pandit). The Kami people engaged during the Puja
activities.

Kami have been relegated to do caste-based work as black/goldsmith. They said that they are
being continued their traditional occupations due to poverty and lack of other means of livelihood.
Before fifteen years ago the women and children are also forced to work in the households of their
landlords. They do not get justifiable wage for their labor. If they do not work for others, they works
as help of their husbands in the traditional jobs of Dalits. Those who had worked in Haliya Pratha
(bonded labor) or Khala Pratha (forced labor) were not earning from their work. They get food grains.
But now the situation has been changed. The children from Dalit community are attending school and
seeking alternate profession. Two young children from my study sites are working as a constable in
Nepal Army and one of the sons of another house is working as a Bus driver. The boy who is working
as bus driver went to labor market to search a job but he was unskilled labor. He have had not any
modern technological skills and he was suffering from financial resources to conduct new industrial
activities or trade in the market so he started working as cleaner (Khalasi) in the bus. He learnt to
drive the bus then he had applied for driving license. After nine months he requested the bus owner
and started to drive the bus. Now his economic status is rising day by day. However, they are still in
Khala Pratha. Dalits who are able to get a wage-earning job suffer from unfair wage system.
According to the bus driver the job owner always bargain for minimum pay and try to engage more
hours in working days.

Discrimination in education

Untouchability is practiced in schools, be they government - or NGO- supported schools.


Teachers do not take care of their Dalit students. In remote areas of Nepal, Dalit students could not sit
Traditional skills Kami 10

beside the so-called high-caste students. There are documented cases in NGO-supported schools of
isolating Dalit students when eating School-supplied food, and treating them badly. Scholarships for
Dalit students are inadequate if not irregular.

Likewise, the so-called high-caste teachers do not want Dalits to become teachers because
they do not want to do the traditional gesture of giving respect to them. They also do not want to eat
and drink together with them as is the custom among teachers. Competent Dalit teachers are
discouraged from occupying higher executive positions in schools.

Denial of entry

Dalits are denied entry into the houses of higher castes, temples, hotels/restaurants, teashops,
food factories, dairy farms and milk collection centers, among others. They can go to schools, offices
and work places. However, there are newspaper reports that in some schools in Jumla region, Dalit
students sit outside the classrooms.

The denial of entry into private houses of higher caste people extends to their cowsheds in the
case of the far western Nepal. They have a belief that if a Dalit enters the cowsheds and touches the
rope of cows or buffaloes and the water pot, the animals will die or will give less quantity of milk.
The prohibition on entering temples prevents the Dalits from participating in the religious activities
inside the temples. They have to be content with worshipping outside the temple building. Dalit
women who enter the temple are humiliated by the temple priests as well as by higher-caste people. A
Dalit who drinks tea in a teashop has to wash the cup used otherwise the proprietor will beat him/her
up.

Low participation in activities of the government, nongovernmental organizations and donor's


agencies. Government official generally ignore, and at times ill-treat, Dalits seeking services from the
government. Treated like second-class citizens, services are generally delayed. They are also abused
by addressing them with disrespectful words (such as using the word tan instead of Hajur or tapain).
Dalit women development programs of the government or donor agencies are elaborated without the
participation of the Dalit women themselves. This leads to the implementation of development
programs that are not applicable to the Dalits.

Social Boycott

The so-called social boycott, a practice of exclusion of people from their families and group,
is normally resorted to in case of (i) Inter-case marriages, where a higher-caste man marries a lower-
caste woman. It also happens when non-Dalit women marry Dalit men. In both cases, the women bear
Traditional skills Kami 11

the brunt of the disapproval of the marriage; (ii) Failure to follow traditional norms and values
(applicable to Dalits and non-Dalits); (iii) Refusal of the Dalits to undertake their traditional caste-
based occupation, such as disposal of dead animals.

Weak exercise of political rights

Key positions in political parties are mostly held by higher-caste people. Dalits, prevented
from holding these positions, are always discouraged from exercising their political rights. Political
leaders pay lip service to Dalit communities in order to collect votes. Political parties mobilize the
Dalits only to serve the interest of the party (Shrestha, 2003). Representation of Dalit women in party
politics is almost negligible. Though the constitution of Nepal has reserved seats for women, which is
limited to 5 percent of the total seats for national and local elections, political parties deny any seat to
Dalit women. At the same time, Dalit women are not empowered to use the opportunity granted by
the constitution.

Atrocities against Dalits

Dalits suffer from a number of atrocities such as battering, mental torture, rape, break-up of
inter-caste marriage, false allegations, etc. Higher-caste people do not hesitate to beat Dalit women in
public places, if they are found to break laws, or norms and values of the Hindu tradition.

Methodology

This chapter includes the methodology and procedure of this study i.e. nature of primary and
secondary data and information, process of information collection, research design selection for the
study, processing and analysis of information and process of report writing by following the
qualitative research methodology.

Source of Information

Because of the nature of study I used qualitative research methodology. I have applied the
following methodology to fulfill this study which is given detailed in the following sections.

Source of Data
Traditional skills Kami 12

I tried to collect the information from both primary and secondary sources. All the house hold
of the Kami peoples who reside in the Ward no 5 of Bhanu VDC of Tanahun district are the source of
information for my study.

Sample Size and Sampling Procedure

However, all of the Kami peoples who reside in the ward no 5 of Bhanu VDC of Tanahun
district are the population of my study; I have take two Kami peoples called Ram Chandra Kami and
Chaire Kami as the sample of my study. I have taken them because they are involved in the Aran and
they make the tools that make by the Blacksmiths. And, they are experienced in a Aran for a long
time.

Information Collection Procedure

For the sake of collection of information, I have applied three types of procedures that is in-
depth interview, observation, and document study. I have studied the documents related to
Blacksmith (Kami peoples) from World Wide Web, library and the books that are available from
various ways.

In-depth Interview

To find out the skills and knowledge that Kami people have, I apply the in-depth interview. I
realized that in-depth interviews involve open-ended questions. So I used a topic guide but I did not
rely on a structured question set. I also used probing techniques to encourage my respondents to give
the fullest answer as far as possible. The respondents were requested to provide information in the
form of facts, attitudes, opinions and intentions about the concerned matter (Joshi, 2001). I looked at
how interchangeable respondent's answers to the questions relate to their actual experiences. This
technique was used to explore topics in their own right, to provide more depth about a subject.

This technique also helped me to provide more depth about a subject or individual cases than
a quantitative survey. Thus I was very conscious while gathering my information and I continue my
interview until I could get the theme. I used in-depth interview to obtain descriptions of the
experience and to develop descriptive narratives. It helped me to know about the knowledge; skills
and attitude of Kami peoples, by this I got chance to hear them and know their views. Each interviwee
was asked to answer three particular question (1) did you learn the particular skills? (2) If yes, how
did you learn the particular skill? And (3) How old were you when you learn the skill?

Observation
Traditional skills Kami 13

I gathered data primarily through close visual inspection of a natural setting. My respondents
were in the working in the Aran. I observed the furnace and the natural working condition of the
respondents. From of information gathered from direct observation were field notes, with detailed
behaviors, consersations, or setting. Direct observation as a research method is most appropriate to
open, public settings where anyone has a right to be or assemble. They can also stand-alone, to
explore topics in their own right in depth, or can complement quantitative enquiry
(http://www.google.com.np.np).

I used the framework provided by Ruddle and Chesterfield (1977) to analyse the sequence of
learning traditional skills. These authors identified eight stages or process of the learning complex: (1)
familiarization or the identification of the skill to be learned; (2) observation of the teacher
performing the skill; (3) helping with simple steps; (4) helping with the entire skill complex; (5)
performing the skill complex under supervision; (6) becoming as assistant or apprentice to the
instructor; (7) independent performance f the skill complex by the apprentice and ability to
experiment with the task; and (8) becoming a peer (or equal partner) to the teacher (Ohmangari &
Berkes, 1997, p. 204).

While using the observation method, I kept in mind things like: what should be observed?
How the observation should be recorded? etc. When the observation is taken without defining the
style of pertinent data of observation is known as unstructured observation (Kothari, 1993:47).

Analysis and Interpretation of Information

All the information collected is organized for easy references and uses. Further they are
grouped or classified under different headings. The collected secondary and primary information are
analyzed in relation to objective and scope of the study project.

Inherited Skills

I started my study from studying the literature regarding the caste system of Nepal, and the
literature related to Dalit. This study gave me insight and opened the door to think upon Dalit. During
my study I observed the working activities of two Kami peoples called Ram Chandra Kami (Illiterate,
57 years) and Chaire Kami (Literate, 58 years). I kept in mind what skills and knowledge do they have
and how to perform their activities? Similarly, I conducted in depth interviews both of them regarding
the skills, knowledge and how have the knowledge and skills transfer to the next generation or how
they know the skills they acquired. Study of literature related to Caste and Dalit along with
observation of activities of Aran gave me insight for the conduction of in-depth interview. The
procedure that I apply is mentioned in the concerning sections.
Traditional skills Kami 14

Kami has the knowledge and skills, which has been handed down from generation to
generation through spoken word and practices. Kami peoples are rich sources of traditional arts and
crafts which are unique examples of material folklore (Diwasa, & Bandhu, 2007, p. 16). Kami peoples
are important traditional bearers of craftsmanship. I asked with them about the skills they have. They
gave me a list of skills of making Sickle, Axe, Khukuri (knives), Kodalo (hoe, spade), Khuda (a kind
of swords), Kalash, shares (plough tips), Frying Pan, Fan, Gun, Kol, nail, chisels, sickle with serrated
blade (Karauti), pickaxe, washer, nut, sword, dagger, spear, soup spoon, fork, and skills of making
Aran (furnace) and the parts of it, etc. Similarly, the informants needed some additional skills related
to their work in Aran. These skills are Pine Halne (Hardening), Pwal parne (making hole), joining,
estimating the ingredients for joining the metal, skill to estimate the required heat for bending of the
iron, Koila Banaune (preparing coal), Pata pitne (smitting), Bangaune (shaping and reshaping the
rod), making socket and fitted to handle, ferrule, etc.

During my visit, the Kami home showed me the traditional weapons making process. I
requested to Ram Chandra Kami to explain the basic tools that all Kamis peoples use in the furnace
(Aran). He shows me three kinds of basic hammers, according to him these are the basic hammers of
all Kamis: Big one is 5 KG; Medium one is 1.5 KG and small on is 0.5 KG. Most Kamis will have a
couple more of various size and weight, usually one small one for work on bolsters and buttcaps.

Learning and Teaching Approaches

My informants pointed out that traditional skills that they acquired were not taught by formal
education, in the abstract. Their way was learning by doing (Preston, 1975, 1982) through
apprenticeship. The apprenticeship started as soon as a Kami child became at the age of ten, the child
was expected to help with and share in the work of Aran. The child was not usually given verbal
instruction but encouraged to learn skills by playing and by imitating adult through participation in
the Aran activities. Children learned skills from parents, grandparents, older siblings, and members of
the extended family with whom they concerned. Parent had the main responsibility for their children's
education. However, members of extended families were readily available to take over teaching
responsibilities whenever needed.

After an extended period of learning by watching and helping (Rudlle and Chesterfield's
learning stages three and four), the child was encouraged to attempt and repeat the observed skills.
Depending on the complexity of the skill, the apprentice started to perform one part of the skill
complex and eventually learned the entire skill complex. Mastery of the skill complex was a gradual
process and only achieved by trial and error.
Traditional skills Kami 15

In the process of trial-and -error, the parents were patient and supportive even if the
apprentice failed many times, as long as he was diligent. The apprentice was told, keep trying, and
never give up until you get it right. Furthermore, he was expected to follow the prescribed ways to
master the skill. When he did it properly, the parent praised him saying yes (that's the way).
Informants of the study also identified the age range 13- 18 years, as the key time period for mastery
of most of the skills used in the Aran.

Among the skills of making sickle, fork, soup spoon, and hoe are transmitted very well. These
skills were learnt by the new generation because these skills are useful for their earning purpose.
Some skills such as Khukuri making, Gun making, Kalash making, and Kol making were not
transmitted to the new generation.

Ram Chandra Kami (63 years, illiterate) is resident of Bhanu VDC ward no 5 of Tanahun
district. He has four sons and one daughter. Among four sons only one son is doing the traditional
profession. I discussed with Ram Chandra Kami and his son about the knowledge and skill transfer
from one generation to another generation. Ram Chandra Kami's forefather used to make Khukuri,
Banduk (Gun) and Kol (the mill for Mustard) but now days they do not make these tools. They don't
have the skill to make Khukuri and Gun because his father did not let to learn to make Khukuri and
Banduk. I asked him why did your father do not let you to make Khukuri and Banduk. He argued that
these tools will be misuse. It could destroy the social cohesion.

Similarly, When Ram Chandra Kami was at the age of 23, one of his friends from Kumal
family is going to marry. The Kumal community has unique custom in marriage ceremony. When the
bride groom to the house of bride with Jantis (peoples who go to the house of bride with the bride
groom), five sacred girls lead the Jantis taking Kalash in the hand of the girls. The bride groom search
for the Kalash here and there but he could not find it. Then the bride groom request to Ram Chandra
Kami to make the Kalash. Ram Chandra Kami has had seen the Kalash before four years ago, at that
time he had remembered the structure of the Kalash hardly. He requested him to sketch the figure of
Kalash, his friend has sketched the Kalash on a paper. With the help of this sketch he had started to
make the Kalash. He had finished it after two days endeavor. His friend thanked him a lot. From this
phenomenon he became able to make the Kalash. Here he learnt to make Kalash through experiential
rather theoretical knowledge (Ellen & Harris, 1996) (Cited in WB). He has experienced through trial
and error and he has tested his experience in the rigorous laboratory. The Kumal friend of his
reinforced him to go ahead.

Chaire Kami was born a Kami in caste and work. For as long as anybody can remember his
forefather were Kami. At perhaps age 5 or 6 he begins helping his father and grandfather in the Arun.
Traditional skills Kami 16

He learns to pull the chain of the bellows. He gathers charcoal. He brings water for the quenching
pitcher. He learns the names of the tools and procedures.

When he becomes around 14 years of age he is using the hammer and does much of
the pounding of iron that goes in the shop. He can make a few simple farm implements by himself.
Sometimes his effort produces a quality tool, sometimes not. His forefather and father do not get
chance him to take the full responsibility because they feel he is immature and cannot prepare the well
finished tools. His father does not give him to make the artistic work. His father does not allow him to
make axes.

By the time he is 20 he can fire up the the Aran by himself and can produce many items. He
can make a sickles but it sometimes will be perfect. Kami peoples used the Khalati (traditional fan
that help to fire the coal) which is made of from the leather of the goat. I asked with Chaire Kami
when and how the Khaliti started and made up. According to him he doesn't know when it is started to
use and who was the profounder of the Khalati. But the Khalati that he is using is made by him. He
has been known to make the Khalati by experiencing. He has got chance to watch to make the Khalati
when he was at the age of 10. He never tries to make Khalati before the death of his father. The
Khalati that was made by his father did not perform properly after the two years of passing away of
his father. Then he has tries to make the Khalati, he has bought a leather of goat from his neighbor.
He kept the wet grains of Mustard inner side of the leather and he tanned it for a month. After one
month it became soft and easy to handle. Then he started to make Khalati. He learned to make it
through repetition. After few years, here he does not remember the date, he has visited the Kailali
district, the western Terai, he has seen a new type of fan which is made from iron, which is easy to
handle. He watched it minutely. After his returning to home he started to make the new type of fan.
He called it Deshi Pankha. Now he is using this Deshi Pankha, it facilitates him and easy to handle.
Now he can teach to make the Deshi Pankha. Here he has learnt to make the Deshi Pankha through
repetition. He told me that the production of tools is changing day by day. New tools are reproducing
and the old one is lost.

Ram Chandra Kami explained me how they join the two pieces of metal. He told me that at
the very beginning the Kami peoples were not the idea to join. He had tried many times but do not get
any idea. He fired the pieces of metal in the Aran and he becomes sad not having knowledge about to
join. He threw away the pieces of burned iron on the ground, some amount of mud and stone covered
the pieces. After sometimes the pieces get tied together. From this accidental event the Kami has
know the way to join the metal. At the time of explaining he showed me practically.

He brought some white stones, he called it Darshan Dhunga, with him and it looks like
granite mixed with some quartz and mica. It is collected on the higher slopes of the forest. He washes
Traditional skills Kami 17

the stone in the water first. Then he grinds it keeping on the big based stone and keeps some drops of
water on it. Then he keeps it on the pieces of iron which is to join. After this he keeps the pieces of
iron with the dust of stone and soda into the Furnace (Aran). He fires the pieces of iron; it heats to
proper color and water quench by slow pour from a pitcher.

I questioned to Ram Chandra Kami about the raw material for recycling the agricultural
materials. He reminded me that he uses the leaf-springs of trucks. He told me that the spring leafs are
very strong than other iron. I am interested how he know that the spring leafs are more hardened. He
told me his father told him about the iron used in different instrument then after when he started to
engage in the Aran work he has experienced the hardness of the steel.

I asked him how you know to cut off the iron as desired length. Then he explained me that the
Kami heat a spring at the length they want and use a chisel to cut off the desired length. They can
guess within a couple of ounces without weighing even through scales is available. They start the
forging process, heating and pounding, forming the plate from tip to tang. When the blade is as close
to final form as they want to get it they harden it, heat to proper color and water quench by slow pour
from a pitcher.

I request him how he knows to make the handle of the sickle. He explained me that his
forefather used to make Khukuri. When his forefather used to work in the Aran, he always watches
the activities of forefather minutely. And he added but his forefather does not allow him to make
Khukuri. He started to make Khukuri from the waste iron rod. He finished the blade of the Khukuri
but could not make the Kajo (socket). He had request to the forefather to make the Kajo but he told
him that Khukuri banaunele Kajo banauna sakdainas (you can make Khukuri then why don't you
make Kajo?). This statement of forefather hurt him. He started to cry. His mother suggested him to
make another Kajo in a patient way. He again started to make the Kajo. Now he is able to make the
new Kajo. His forefather saw the Kajo that he prepared, and then he told him that he is in right
position. From this event he learnt to make the Khukuri. Here he used the trial and error method to
make the Khukuri.

Water was the quenching medium for many years ago or so. It was used in Nepal since the
beginning and a Kami's skill is largely passed down from one generation to the next. The hardening of
the sickle blade is really an art rather than a skill. When I was age of 15 I often used to go Kami's
house to sharpen the blade of sickles. I used to observe the activity of him very minutely but this time
he giving me a lesson in hardening the blade of sickles, he calls this pine (hardness), setting the pine.

I asked him how the pine is sets. He explained me by saying color is very important. He
requests me to see the color. The blade is not hot enough. He again call me see this color. Now the
Traditional skills Kami 18

blade is too hot. It is just right. Again he requests me to see at the tip of the blade. He is saying me see
the color at the cho. These all must be just right before you start to pour the water. When the color of
the blade becomes just right he began to pour water from his pitcher.

He is explaining me the way to pour the water. According to him you cannot pour too fast and
you cannot pour too slowly. You must pour just the right amount at just the right speed. He add that
watch the blade change colour. You will see red, purple, green, in various shades and then black. If
you do not see the color change seven times you have missed and must begin again.

Conclusion

However, the Kami peoples are discriminated due to their occupation and their occupation is
not feasible for their livelihoods they are still involved in Aran. Caste based discrimination is equally
observed between the high caste Dalits and the low caste Dalits. The knowledge and skills that Kami
people have is a one of the indigenous skill of Nepal.

Dalit is the latest and politically correct, of many terms used for untouchable Shudras. The
word dalit(s) comes from the Sanskrit - root dal that means held under check, suppressed, or crushed,
or, in a looser sense, oppressed. The word Dalit literally means a person immersed in a swamp.
Traditionally, Dalits have been treated inhumanely as Untouchables. Politically Dalit is poor and
oppressed and excluded peoples and religiously it is known as impure. Kami is a Dalit community
from Nepal which belongs to the Indo-Aryan ethnic group. Kamies are essentially blacksmiths who
are scattered in almost all hilly districts of Nepal. According to the 2001 Census, there are total of
895,954 Kami in the country of which 96.69 percent were Hindu and 2.21 percent were Buddhists.

Kamis as Dalit remain at the very bottom of Nepal's caste hierarchy. Even now, the
government and many development/aid organizations use euphemisms such as occupational castes,
backward classes, marginalized, and disadvantaged groups, instead of referring to them as Dalits.
Kami peoples are discriminated against on the basis of caste and untouchability. However, there are
hierarchies and discrimination within the Dalit community with Kami, sonar and Lohar (identified by
the surname Biswakarma) at the so-called top of the hierarchy.

The nature of discrimination against Dalits is different. They are discriminated in different
forms such as social and cultural discrimination, traditional caste-based occupation and forced labor,
discrimination in education, denial of entry, low participation in activities of the government,
nongovernmental organizations and donors, social boycott, weak exercise of political rights, and
atrocities against Dalits. Similarly, they are discriminated in the religious and cultural spheres. Now
the situation is different. The constituent of Nepal has abolished the discrimination based on caste,
Traditional skills Kami 19

race, gender and other and the illiteracy is diminishing. There is no legal provision of denial of entry
in the temples and participate in the social and ritual activities. The attitude towards Dalit is changing.
The profession of Kami peoples is gradually changing with the rise in education level.

Kami peoples have the traditional knowledge and skills of making different tools that use in
the agriculture activities. The skills and knowledge that Kami peoples acquired should be known as
indigenous knowledge and it is a glory of Nepal and the occupational special skills of these peoples. It
is transmitted orally, experiential rather than theoretical knowledge and learned through repetition and
it is constantly changing. They have the knowledge and skills, which has been handed down from
generation to generation through spoken word and practices. Kami peoples are rich sources of
traditional arts and crafts which are unique examples of material folklore. Kami peoples are important
traditional bearers of craftsmanship.They have the skills of making Sickle, Axe, Khukuri (knives),
Kodalo (hoe, spade), Khuda (a kind of swords), Kalash, shares (plough tips), Frying Pan, Fan, Gun,
Kol, nail, chisels, sickle with serrated blade (Karauti), pickaxe, washer, nut, sword, dagger, spear,
soup spoon, fork, and skills of making Aran (furnace) and the parts of it, etc. Similarly, they have
some additional skills related to their work in Aran. These skills are Pine Halne (Hardening), Pwal
parne (making hole), joining, estimating the ingredients for joining the metal, skill to estimate the
required heat for bending of the iron, Koila Banaune (preparing coal), Pata pitne (smitting),
Bangaune (shaping and reshaping the rod), making socket and fitted to handle, ferrule, etc. The skills
of making tools are transmitted generation to generation but some of tool making skills are not learn
by the new generation. The skills that learn by new generation depend on the economic value and
demand of their customers. Parent had the main responsibility for their children's education.

The works they perform depends on the demand of their customers and and the technology
that exists in the market. Therefore some of the tools they do not make these days. And, the
techniques they use are changing gradually as the time and the trends of the consumers. The skills that
the Kami people have is our indigenous skills. It should be preserve and strengthen according to the
demand of the time and should accommodate according to the changing of the technology. It is
believed that their occupation is not feasible for their livelihood, in this context the government
should support them modernizing their occupation and strengthen the market.

Discrimination against Dalit is overwhelming reality of Nepal. The constitution has abolished
all kinds of discriminations but it is still existence in practice, which is against the humanism and
principle of democracy. To justice to them the discrimination should be diminished in practice for this
education can play critical role in the society. Therefore, the government should focus on the
education of Dalits like Kami. And, the discrimination within Dalits can be solved through education.
Traditional skills Kami 20

The law and regulation against discrimination should be implemented strictly. These entire endeavors
will contribute to build the society according to the humanism and democratic norms.

Reference

Bhattachan K.B. and et.al. (2004). Dalit’s Empowerment and Inclusion for Integration in the
National Mainstream: Strategy for Influencing Policy and Institutions. Kathmandu: Dalit
Empowerment and Inclusion Project.
Bhattachan, K. B. (2008). Minorities & Indigenous Peoples of Nepal, Kathmandu: National Coalition
against Racial Discrimination (NCARD)
Bhattachan, K. B. (2008). Minorities & Indigenous Peoples of Nepal, Kathmandu: National Coalition
against Racial Discrimination (NCARD).
Bhattchan, K. B., Hemchuri, K. Gurung, Y. B., Bishwokarma, C. M.; 2002. Existing Practices of
Caste-based Untouchability in Nepal and Strategy for a Campaign for Its Elimination,
Kathmandu, Action-aid Nepal.

Bishwokarma, P. (2004). Violence Against Dalit Women in Nepal. Nepalnews.com Dalits' Fate In
Nepal: The Kathmandu Post, December 31, 2005.

CBS, (1991). The Population Census of Nepal, 1991, Kathmandu: Central Bureau of Statistics,
Kathmandu, Nepal
Dekens, J. (2007). Local Knowledge for Disaster Preparedness: A Literature Review, Kathmandu:
ICIMOD
Diwasa, T., Bandhu, C. M. (2007). The Intangible Cultural Heritage of Nepal: Future Directions.
Kathmandu: UNESCO, Kathmandu Office. Retrieved on July 10, 2009 from
http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0015/001567/156786E.pdf at google.com.np
Gyawali, D. & Acharya, S. (2003). Educational Status of the Musahars A Study of Rangeli VDC,
Morang, (Eds.), In Educational Innovation, Kathmandu: Centre for Educational
Innovation and Research, II (1), November 2003

http://www.alrc.net/mainfile.php/60 written. Retrieved on May,2007 at www.google.com.np.

http://www.carenepal.org/care_nepal_library/stratergy/175PDF/fulldoc%20i.pfd. Retrieved on May


19, 2009 at google.com.np

http://www.Cooper-research.com). Retrieved on August, 2007 at www.google.com.np

http://www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kami_(caste). Retrieved on June 3, 2009 at www.google.com.np.


http://www.prickttsfort.org/Resources/Blacksmithing%20of%20the%2018%20Century.pdf. Retrieved
on July 12, 2009 at google.com.np
Traditional skills Kami 21

Joshi, P. R., (2001). Research Methodology. Kathmandu: Buddha Academic Publishers and
Distributors.

Kisan, Y. B. (2005). The Nepali Dalit Social Movement (L.A. Vasily,Trans.) Lalitpur: Legal Rights
Protection Society Nepal.

Koirala, B. N. (1996). Schooling and the Dalits of Nepal: A case Study of Bungkot Dalit Community
(Ph. D. Thesis). Canada: Universit of Alberta.

Kothari, C.R. (1993). Research Methodology: Methods and Tecniques. New Delhi: Johari for Wiley
Eastern Limited.

Nirula, (2005). Dalits: A Bruised Dignity. The Pure and the Impure. New Delhi: Nangia S. B. for
APH Publishing Corporation.
Ohmagari, K & Berkes, F. (1997). Transmission of Indigenous Knowledge and Bush Skills Among
the Western James Bay Cree women of Subarctic Canada, In Human Ecology, 25(2).
Retrieved on July 28, 2009 at google.com.np

Shrestha, A. (2003). Dalits in Nepal: Story of Discrimination, Hurights Osaka, Retrieved on June
24, 2009 from http://www.hurights.or.jp/asia-pasific/no_30/40.htm at www.google.com.np.

WB & DFID, (2006). Unequal Citizens: Gender Caste and Ethnic Exclusion in Nepal, Kathmandu:
Author
WB, (1998). Indigenous Knowledge for Development: A Framework for Action. Knowledge and
Learning Center Africa Region: World Bank. Retrieved on June 29, 2009 from
www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/ikrept.pdf at google.com.np
Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Retrieved on May 24, 2008 at www.google.com.np.
www.iiav.nl/enzines/email/Links/2002/April.pdf. Retrieved on June 4, 2009 from google.com.np

You might also like