Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bowden
Parties:
Facts:
Procedural Posture:
Bowden filed IIED suit against the D in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City.
Jury found in favor of Bowden and awarded $25,000 in damages for IIED.
Defendants filed for JNWV on the IIED claim. The circuit court granted the motion.
Bowden appealed.
Issue:
Whether Bowden’s injury was severe enough for a claim for IIED?
Holding:
No.
Ruling:
The court affirms the circuit court’s granting of JNWV for the IIED claim.
Rule:
Legal Reasoning:
Court focused on Bowden’s severity of distress. The court found that for
emotional distress to be considered severe, it must be so acute that no reasonable
man could be expected to endure it. The court reasoned that Bowden’s distress may
have been just uncomfortable. None of the effects of Bowden’s emotional distress
indicated that he had been severely disabled with prevented his ability to carry out
his daily activities. Not only did Bowden continue his normal activities, but he got
medical attention just before litigation started.