Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a sense of
inferiority
by Dorothy Rowe
2
Paul always thought of himself as the little guy up against the big guys.
Actually, he wasn’t little at all, but one memory from his early childhood
had fixed in his mind his idea that he was small and weak. He was four
years old, and he and his father were having a shower together. His
father’s voice was booming over his head, telling him not to be silly, the
water wasn’t cold, and there was his father’s massive body next to him.
He looked down at himself and knew he’d never be the man his father
was. Other men could be as strong and powerful as his father was, but
he never could.
Chrissie felt like a little girl always looking, wistfully, through a window
pane, watching the world go by. Wonderful people were out there doing
wonderful things, but she was so plain, untalented and uninteresting
that there was no place for her in that world. These wonderful people
were the people her mother called ‘they’. ‘They’ were the important
people, the rich and famous, the politicians, lawyers, doctors, actors,
celebrities, the neighbours who had good jobs and lived in better houses
than Chrissie’s family did. Not that ‘they’ ever noticed Chrissie, but if
‘they’ did ‘they’ would know that Chrissie never measured up to what
‘they’ wanted.
Even as we feel this, we also feel angry. Why should others have so
much and we have nothing? We find that we can distract ourselves
from the shame of being inferior by concentrating on our resentment
of others. So we swing between shame and resentment, and in
neither state are we happy.
How we feel about ourselves also determines our big life choices – the
work we decide to do, the relationships we make, and how happy or
secure we feel. If we value ourselves, when life goes well we feel happy
and secure, and when life goes badly we assure ourselves that we’ll be
able to cope. If we don’t value ourselves, we never feel happy and secure,
even when everything goes well in our life.
Paul
Paul had always wanted to be a professional footballer. He had been
one of his school’s best players, but his father made fun of his efforts
and Paul lost heart. Not knowing what to do with his life, he studied
accountancy but, even though he earned good money, he hated his
job. He coached a junior football team but, whenever he encountered
a young lad with real football ability, Paul felt very sad.
Chrissie
Chrissie became an assistant in a chemist’s shop and dreamed of meeting
Mr Right. What did turn up was Harry, whom her mother liked because
he was steady; steady to the point of being immobile. Chrissie felt that
she’d better settle for what was on offer because the kind of man she
wanted wouldn’t want her.
Both Paul and Chrissie believed that they were born inferior and would
be inferior until the day they died.
Paul
However, Paul’s father didn’t use his size and strength to protect Paul.
Instead he used it to punish Paul and to make fun of him. Even when
Paul was old enough to look his father in the eye, and strong enough
to beat him in a fight, he was still afraid of him. Paul dared not even
raise his voice to his father, and just the tone of a simple question like,
‘And what have you been doing today?’ made Paul curl up inside. Paul’s
mother always fussed over Paul, making sure he was well fed and healthy,
but she was frightened of her husband, so she never protected Paul
from his father’s harsh words and blows. Paul was angry with both his
parents, but he didn’t express it. Never daring to stand up to his father
confirmed his feeling of inferiority. He didn’t want his mother to stop
looking after him, so he expressed his anger towards her by being sullen
and resentful. Paul envied those boys who took jobs away from home
and had exciting careers, but he felt tied to his parents. He’d tell himself
he could leave home and get a great job but, even as he thought this,
he knew he wouldn’t.
Like Chrissie’s mother, many parents worry about what ‘they’ might think,
but will use phrases such as, ‘What will your grandparents (or aunt,
uncle, teacher, neighbour, police or school friends) think?’ to encourage
their children to do well with the talents they undoubtedly have.
Chrissie
Chrissie’s mother didn’t think that Chrissie had any talents. How could
she? Chrissie’s mother thought that she herself was inferior, and therefore
her daughter must be inferior too. She was scared that Chrissie might
draw attention to herself in a way that reflected badly on her, or would
remind her of her own lost opportunities, so she put a stop to anything
that Chrissie might shine at. When Chrissie, a good dancer, wanted
lessons, her mother wouldn’t pay for them. So Chrissie told herself that
she didn’t want them because only snobby kids went to dancing lessons.
She stopped practising her dance steps in her bedroom and, instead, spent
her evenings watching television with her mother.
6
If their parents show them that they see themselves as not being as
good as other people, small children are likely to conclude that they
must be inferior too. If parents tell their children that they are not as
valuable or talented as other children are, their children, like Paul and
Chrissie, conclude that this must be so. Even when parents value their
children, other life experiences, such as doing less well in school than
others, encountering discrimination through racism or disability, being
poor or living as a refugee, can create or worsen feelings of inferiority.
Paul and Chrissie had heard about books and classes where people learnt
how to become self-confident, but they were sure that this didn’t apply
to them. They were absolutely certain that they were inferior to other
people. Everything they encountered in society told them that this was so.
7
Take, for instance, the class system. Some people try to argue that class
no longer matters in the UK today, but that’s nonsense. We’re all very
aware of when a person has a title in front of his name, or talks with
a particular accent, or went to a particular school. Many upper and middle
class people are greatly troubled by feelings of inferiority, but that’s not
how other people see them. They’re seen as being superior because they
belong to a certain class. Many working class people see themselves
as the equal of anyone else but, unless they’ve acquired the accent of
the educated classes and keep the details of their background secret,
they’re likely to be discriminated against by those who pride themselves
on their birth and accent.
Many people believe that, if you don’t have a good job and lots of money,
you’re nothing, and so much of what we see appears to confirm this
view. Businessmen and financiers who have made themselves immense
fortunes by dubious means can receive public honours. Bosses who’ve
failed to do their job properly pay themselves huge salaries, and rich
people who’ve broken the law use their wealth to avoid going to jail.
8
Why are we given these messages? It’s so that those people who are
enjoying power, prestige and wealth can continue to do so. We’re lied
to in order to keep us believing that we’re inferior. Although these
messages have nothing whatsoever to do with our true worth, we
may take them to heart and feel even more inferior. But then a certain
passionate, primitive pride comes surging to the surface. How dare other
people have so much more! It’s not fair!
Paul
Paul blamed his mother for making him feel weak and inferior. All her
fussing – that’s what had ruined him. When he saw other mothers fussing
over their sons, he’d be so angry he couldn’t bring himself to speak to
them. He was attracted to women, but he couldn’t help feeling that
women were stupid and dangerous. His first marriage ended disastrously
and his second marriage was rapidly going the same way.
9
Chrissie
At school, Chrissie had barely noticed that some of her fellow students
came from Caribbean or Bangladeshi families but, at home, she’d hear
her mother complaining about what the council did for 'the Blacks and
the Pakis’, which they didn’t do for her. However, after Chrissie had given
up her dreams of being a dancer, she found that if she listened to her
mother’s complaints, and added a few of her own, she felt better, as if
in some way she’d got her own back. What Chrissie didn’t notice was
that she was becoming very frightened of strangers.
When we tell ourselves that, even though we are inferior, we are not so
inferior as some other people, we can’t get to know that these supposedly
inferior people are really just like everybody else. We see them as strange
and dangerous and, when we encounter them in the ordinary way, we
are too nervous to act with confidence. We can end up feeling foolish,
and believing the supposedly inferior person is laughing at us.
We are always in danger of blaming ourselves for any disaster that may
befall us. Thus it’s very easy for us to turn the natural sadness, which
follows a disaster, into the prison of depression.
It’s the hidden reward within the pain that keeps people persisting in
doing something that they know is harming them. This is why people
will go on believing that they are inferior, even though this belief brings
them so much pain. There are advantages to holding this belief, and
people won’t give these up, despite their unhappiness.
• When other people take responsibility you can blame them when things
don’t turn out the way you think they should. Whatever happens, it’s
not your fault.
• You envy those you see as being better than you, and when these
‘betters’ fall from grace, you can feel very joyful. It’s what they deserve.
Tabloid newspapers give you many opportunities to feel this joy in
another person’s discomfort.
• You can protect yourself from the pain of feeling pity for people who
suffer, by telling yourself that people, especially the people you see
as your inferiors, deserve the punishment they’ve got. So you don’t have
to worry about people who are hungry, or ill, or have been forced from
their homes by starvation and war.
• When you see family or friends enjoying advantages you lack, you can
make them feel uncomfortable by talking about ‘poor me, lucky you’
whenever you meet.
• You can tell yourself that, if other people hadn’t forced you to be
inferior, you would have been one of the most superior people in the
world. By remaining inferior, you never have to put this to the test.
Paul and Chrissie wasted their lives by feeling inferior. Don’t you do
the same.
References
Guide to life Dorothy Rowe (HarperCollins)
Depression: the way out of your prison (3rd ed.) Dorothy Rowe
(Brunner-Routledge)
Useful organisations 13
Mind
Mind is the leading mental health organisation in England and Wales,
providing a unique range of services through its local associations, to
enable people with experience of mental distress to have a better quality
of life. For more information about any mental health issues, including
details of your nearest local Mind association, contact the Mind website:
www.mind.org.uk or MindinfoLine on 0845 766 0163
If you would like to order any of the titles listed here, please
photocopy or tear out these pages, and indicate in the appropriate
boxes the number of each title that you require.
Please add 10 per cent for postage and packing, and enclose
a cheque for the whole amount, payable to Mind. Return your
completed order form together with your cheque to:
Mind Publications
15–19 Broadway
London E15 4BQ
tel. 020 8221 9666
fax: 020 8534 6399
email: publications@mind.org.uk
web: www.mind.org.uk
(Allow 28 days for delivery.)
Name
Address
Postcode
Tel.
Mind works for a better life for everyone with
experience of mental distress
Mind does this by:
• advancing the views, needs and ambitions of people with
experience of mental distress
• promoting inclusion through challenging discrimination
• influencing policy through campaigning and education
• inspiring the development of quality services which reflect expressed need
and diversity
• achieving equal civil and legal rights through campaigning and education.
For details of your nearest Mind association and of local services contact Mind’s helpline,
MindinfoLine: 0845 766 0163 Monday to Friday 9.15am to 5.15pm. Speech-impaired or
Deaf enquirers can contact us on the same number (if you are using BT Textdirect, add the
prefix 18001). For interpretation, MindinfoLine has access to 100 languages via Language Line.
ISBN 1-903567-59-9
No reproduction without permission
Mind is a registered charity No. 219830