OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

L\ ITED STXI ES DISTRICT COURT S()t:THf.RN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

I' . ·····-·--------1 ! ,\JUSTA RECORDS LLC: ATLA.?\TIC ! : RH.'ORDl'\G CORPORATION; BMG

I MUSIC; C\PITOL RECURDS LLC tku

I CAPITOL RECORDS. ISC.; EU;:KTRA ENTERTA[NMI-.~:NT (iROUP INc'; ll\TERSCOPE RECORDS; LAFACE

R[;:CORDS LLC; MOTO\VN RECORD COl\·lPANY. LP,: PRIORITY R.EC'ORDS

I LtC: SC);,\Y Ml_~.sJC t-:0:TERTAIl\'_v!t:-:;-.!'['_ rku :

. SUNY [Ji'vlG \lUSIC r:,NTl~RTAI.NI\'lFl'.-T; I

: U:\Kj RECORDINGS. n.c., and WAH.:-..;EF: I

I BROS. RECORDS INC ..

i

Plaintifs.

I I

I

: U:\-IE WIRE LLC: I ,11\·H: GROl.:P LLC

: rvIARK CiORTON; GREG BILD.sO:-.i; and I r..U.C;, l.II\!lE WIRE L\[l.HL Y LlMlTH)

. PARlNl·:RSHIP.

y,

, J

Defendants. I

, J

._._- --- ~~-- .. -.-.--... ,,-_· ....... ··.11. " .. __ .•• •.. ,._ .. 1

212 805 7900

P.01/17

: :

I

j J

i I

USDSSONY DOCUMENT

. r . .•

ELECI'RONl~·FILED :~

.~j ;:;.'

DOC" - " .. ',

DA~:.~· /_~ (:- 2.-:(J11 ~ /:. ,

06 Civ, 05936 (Kl'vlW) ECF CASE

IPROPOSI~DI CONSENT

1 I

IN,JVNCTION

j ,

j

I

~ :

Plaintiffs ,\RISTf\ RECORDS LLC: .'\TLJ\f:'JT1C RECORDING CORPORA'nON:

B~(G :vIUSIC CAPITOL RECORDS t .. i.c. .ka CAPITOL RECORDS. INC.; ELEKTRA LNT[RT:\l;\:\'IENT OROUP INC.; [NTn\~,C()pE: rp~CORDS; LAfACE RJ'TORDS LLC:

MOTOWN RECORI) COMPAN'(_ L.P,: PRI01Ur\' RECORDS LLC; SON'Y MUSK ENTERTAINME:--:T. Iku S():\Y B[\lfG tvlt;SIC l.:Nfl~:RT-'\INMt::'NT: UMG RC:C:ORDINGS_

, ,

INC,: VIRGIN RECORDS AMERICA. J:'-Ic.: and WltRNF:R BROS_ RECORDS INC

(collectively. "Plnin1ifC-;") LInd UML WI1U,: l. i.c. LliY:lE (]RUt.JP LLC; and MARK GOI~TO:-'; {(,;()lI~Lti\cly. "Lime Wire"] (,-pruimilf.;· and Lime \\:jl:e arc referred to jointly herein JS_ the

"Purtjcx") hereby stipulate as follows:

\VHERL\S, Plaintiffs have filed a yk tion li_1l~ .'1 PermuL11.!1U Injunction r\g,}in51 Lirnc Wire (Do!;. No. 234): and

OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

P.02/17

j\'!O(IOIl It1!" Permanent Injunction.

. '

:"i()\V. 'J H FREFORE. dw P:mic:; <1J;! l:l: dj"ld sllp~di,ll": (l:~ lollows:

II J 'l'he P'cl'lll!IIlr'lll luju.ictiou that J.ppcar:; b~I".lw shall be deemed 1;;"11t~I'cd as all 01 tlcr

l'rrun ClJIILt:~lilig <.IllY such matters at anv POltl\ 11l the li1i$.nk)l1. il'lf;]uding Oil uPlw,al (except any ch .. lIh:Hl!c to dllO Consent lnjunction, inc!\IOl1",g the P~I'm~lIll.?nllnjul~('lioll. !llll.ll'w\lid1 Lim, Wir.::

m.IY contest iii any court only Oil appeal utter the ~ nuy 91~a flnaljudgmrnt i 11 this action). 1.1 Ill":

Wil'l: reserves 1\:; nrguments ~l~ ttl the C(lun\ li~!hilh)-' ji':'h:~l"IlIil1i1li(Jl1:; in the Opiruon und Order !Jllkl'':c:.l i\'l~\y II, J010. and mll,'nd!'"{il.lll M~'IY ~5" :!.OlO (,'Order") (Doc, No. JJ3, ;Imel1dll1g Doc, No 216) 111 any l!ppl~:lllh.H IlIil)' follow the ~,ltr/ oru ji[,~l.d .II.1dl!,111cnt in this action, Lime Will.,

,

WLllIU11 r:I~" 'lny appeal ti"\1111 or otherwise ~l'IlLC'~(:11 any court this Consent h~iI.lJll·liIJ!I.. illdlllljn~

1111: PCIIlICll)cm Injunction below. prior to the ':Ill!"y Ill""l. lJl:"'I.iudgm~n·. in [hi~ aU!!.)11

r~1 Tac I';'lnic" agree (hut 1I11'; C'1.1111": h;18 .i"lri~(.Ji<.;lioll to enter this Cnl1,~nt 11ijulJ(;liull.

including the Permanent lnjuncuon l)~J(lw. ai.d W ctlior~e, lhe same rllrSllaJll HI the terms hereof.

PERMANE.'fI' L\J UNVTION

The Court enters (1 P~l'mal1~l1( Iujuncuon in t'~lI'(Jr !lrlh~ j;jail:dl't's, ll.ml :Ir-:IIII~[ Lime Win; PLlt',:LlaI1L to 1/ \; S.C, ~ 50:! and Federal R\i1" ()f"Cjvi! PTc:CL'Jl.lrr:" (,) ;l1ld III accordance with the

I::"

OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

P.03/17

us wl'll lI;i tor common law copvrizht iulriuzcmcn: lind ~lI'lk~lr cornpcuuon as to Plaintiffs"

• Luue W;r~ "il1t~llli,H1;llly ¢11CJLlrtlP. .... d dirl:l-I;t infl'ingcml!nC iJy Lime Wire users. (Ol'd~r:.lt 29.)

ThL~ Um,,\l,.iTl' cli<"lu ,M'Lwar,: is used "D~·tl"r\\!h('Jmillgly for lnfringerneut," und ;1:11'w~ I'm inJ'rin!.:emem on n 1l11l!i~i\-,j' sr:~ll:(~" (_Ii/. ill "II. ~1.)

Wtru ll.NrH, tI«, ~H 32.)

I .irnc Wire marketed it!;elf to :-J.'\pslt'r u~e:rJ, who were known copyright

(Ilrrili~~r!;:. 2,nd promoted Lim. Wire's Int)'i:J:!~ing capabll.tlcs. (Id at 33-34.)

• Lime Wire ";:1l:1:"ely :lSSi!\lcJ i'lfringing lISW rs" ill their infringement efforts and

.. Liruc \-Virt: Iailed ru unplemern allY n1(~II!l~lli,!nllll~'~hnnlOlli('lll h:lrrrl',rs or d~~ign choices aimed nt Jiminishilll! i,ll"lill;l(:TIlcn,1..: (lJ. at l~.J

i'

I'hc result oftli.s u ud other acts evldcuciugPlnlurlfls' inrcm Il:'l,~ hl'(~tl JI,rrfllgenk'n! ol' PI~)il'1li1r~;' \V(lt'k~: on u "massive ~t:8k," (M. ill 33,) Lime Wire has JIl "cnouuous 1L~t;1 IJiI~~',"

(It!. (li ~6,l In JU!l~ 01"1005. Lim", ~l,'il'~ proclurrncd rt~df'Lh" "indl.<.:Hl'y stundard" for peer-to-peer ril"-->!'ilrill::J.. arui eSIllm,wJ that mere (han 3 billion 5011.~~ ~'>"'';: uownioeccd through peer-to-peer ii!<.:-sh.:..tfillg c:v~ry JIlondl (Plnimlffs ' ~(~Hcrnl,;lll oft.ndisputed F(ll;~~; ("SIT') ~Il/U,I ''[.lI..Jlcllrly 1;]1 of the 1ik~ shared <l11~j duwulouded by l,iI11L\\"rn~ '.!~l·r,s,il\\' j~np7'rightf:'d, and nol authorized ri,) I' (rL,)~ diwihullon through LI!1\(.'V,:ll'c," (UtJ",-.!. 31·J2) Pla;iIl1ift~' cvidcncc u: ~lII!lLlI;,tI)

1

'!

OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

P.04/17

.illd~m.:n\ 1'~llth.;,. SI,\1Wcd 11.011 9H.3~"1I \Jrull dtJwlIl\'~U.ll~l!ljo,;~l~ umuug Liruc Wirc k~t:I'~ 1l1~ (ill' unauthorized fik,~. and m .. my of those fik~ contain om; f1i" I'laintiffs' protected \HIlL. (mJI' 'J!

roo.r io.i

motions, l.imc Wire h:l$ connnued to he J lO(oI ()f clll)ic~ fl,',lI' rnmpant infringcrucnt of Plninti tH WIII'''~ Slll"'~ [lily 10D!!. th~ Lime Wire client software Ihl~ bM]1 downloadeu horn the

,

, .

flOlll juxr rha: one website -1,</" exclusive ot downloads Irom Lime Wircs own website ' 1(1 more than ~O() IlIilli,llll ("Ild ruunting). In short, Lime \.vil,·~·S. already enorruous inswlled b(l.~""

,

lhe LimcV'/i~~ client :;(]ftwarc nut only continues 1,0 be dowuloadcd. hut CJI~IJ I,;LII)ljllllt::~ In

I~(' Il'''tl I'or the widesprccd illh'lng~mcml~ Ill:!' Lime Wi,'/; intended to induce. Lime Wire is still i" IJP'T,HioJl lod:J~'.llff~)rdjl,g its user base unlimited a ccq~i; to the nulhons ofunnuihorized files

,

aY~iliJ.hk ['Of down lo.ul. Lirru- Wirc's lil1bi!il~' W,I:I cstnbiished based 1m <l subset 0( 30 Recordings, iii nccordnncc with Jlld!.\I'~ Lyrwh's insmlclio'n:l, (S~!I! Order at :i 11.7,) ~vel'Y 011~ 01."

those 3\1 Recordillgs i:'i ~,ill hilly availah!c for downluud through Lime Wire, (Declaration of Jrlliun SOil,!! (';Snng Dccl.'·)~, 4.) Plilinliff5 also ~ul)lllillt=;l'~v;dt=Il[~'~ 1I1t1l hundreds of'recordings

, ,

1\,,11 "" l!t,~ Y'~'us 21)I)S ltlH[ 200\.1 arc also avuilable lor immediate download through the Limcwirc System 'llli! SoHt"'II"1.:. (Song D~(;1. ~:(! 5-6.)

Bused (In !hi~ record CJ('holh [II'IIVl~ll urcnrlonal il'!hlc:~rllJ;l), of lnfnngcmenr, ilild 1,;{)11'11'U~J inducement of illl'I'illgclllcr;l even iltCc:f !I.,- n.lIl!'I:li'lUlJ it lbbk, rhc evidence warrants

',1,

il1}J,JIlCliv~ re-llc/ 101' PhlilHiff3, Indeed. in "nilbtlLHI~ cil~(~:-" \!.ht'l't:' courts have found defendants liublc (lll sllll,m:JI')'.iut!gm~nlIM 111JlIc:ng i:di-i'1.g~'Ill\;i'll, tJ,C,~iUlI"; cuurts have J18Jd li1:1l111L! 1,I,linlitf CI,)PYI'L~,_Il1 1.""IH.'r~ are I:!nli,l~d to a permanent mjunctron, notwithstaudiog that illrLhcr

Iuigruion (im!luciing Oil the issue of dallmel~.~) rornnins. S,,~ :iJ.,'(., ,\'f~/I·()-(;()h/l'YI1·,I{t'."""~· .'~;rlltti(),I·, /W' , \' (;J'lJh/<,!J', LId. ) 1 H F, Supp, 1d 1197. l?" I (CD. C~ I. ~n071 (,'(;I"(Jk If(,I' i?el}l(IJ)({):

OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

Colunibiu Pictures lnilus., /I1C, F Fung, ;\0, CV 0(1-5571-; S;VW (Jex) (D()L. No. -426) (C,)), Cd., May ~O. 20 I 0) (Declaration of Kelly Klaus C'Kl.,us Odd,"), Ex, 2); Arista Rl!corJs. et. al. 1-', Usenet.com Inc .. l\i'o. 07-CV-!l822 (HAl (Doc, No. 284) (S.D.:-.J.Y., Ocr. 8,20(9) (Klaus O~cL

r·:;o.;. I).

To obtain a pcrmancut injunction. Plainti (ls nHlsl show:

(i) tim! [they] h.l[vtJ suffered an irreparable injury: (2) that remedies available at Jaw. such ,IS moneta. y damages, arc inadequate 10 compensate (I.\r lhn t injury; (3) that, considering the balance of hardships between the pbintiff and defendant, a remedy in equity is W'lIT~IIHCd: and (-I) that the public interest would not he disscrved by u permanent injunction.

Sa{i!l~er \" Colttng, F. 3d. , 2010 WI. 17291.2(1, at ~7 (2d Cir, April 30. 20 10)

... I. ._ .... _.___ ,, __ ,_ ,

(quoting dim'. Inc. i-, Merclixchang«, I..LC. s·n 1.;.S, ~~:s. 391 (::WOo»). E~H.:h ortbe four factors weighs in favor of a permanent injunction.

A. Pbintjffs Hllve Suffered rnc'pnr.abJc Ha~m And Wi" Continue To J)u So Absent All Injunction

Plainti ll" s haw suffered - and will continue to suf!(;r "~ irreparable harm from Lime

Wi 1'1;::' S i nducemcnt ~)r widespread infringement of their \"':0I:k5, "Irreparable harm" is UrI "injury that is neither remote 11l1r speculative. but actual and imnlin;;:n! and that cannot be remedied by an

award or monetary damnges.' Forest CilJ' Va/I.' Ilous., IlIe,v, Town ofN. Hempstecu], 175 F,3d

[-l4, 15J (2(1 Cir, (999): SIN a/so Fail'dey Transp, Ma111l0' .''{ 1) v, VVubH'C Corp., 559 F .3d 1 10,

liS (lL! Cir. :W()9)_ AS'l direct result of Lime Wires int~t1I;()tlillly inducing wick-spread infringement. Plaintiffs are continuing to suffe- at least ihrer forms of harm judicially recognized

W be irreparable.

I In the well-known cases involving two other (If Lime Wires predecessors .n Napster and ;\iJ1l5tl.::l" ". tnc courts issued injunctions against the defendants even without a summary judgmtnl nf li:!hilily .. Se« A&A.f Ret~()f'd\', inc, v Nap.\'r'~I·, 1)1,· .. 284 r.3d 1091. 1099 (9lh Cir, 2001) (affirming Distnct (:OUll'S order to shur down the Napster service): /11 re Aimster C '(JPyrighl liligation. ~34 f.3d M), ()% (7th Clr, 200~) (affirming Injunction against Airnster).

P.05/17

OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

P.05/17

i I

Fir,I·I. Plaintiffs race irreparable harrr bt::C<lL1SC i:t <IS virtually certain that they will he

entitled to an enormous damage award after trial that \\/i:11 far exceed Lime Wire's ahillty to pay

See (jmkJ!a Rf!JJ1(1J'ul. 51 S F. Supp. 2d at 12 I 7 c'nec~lLls,c: it Ii; extremely unlikely that

[defendants] will be able 10 compensate Plaintiffs monetarily for the infringements it h'1S induced

in the past, or the infringements it could induce in the luturc ... Plaintitfs have and will continue 10 suffer irreparable harm,"): Aimster. 334 F.3t.lllt 655.:

As in Grokster .1I1d Aimster, PlaintiJ}; have beenand will be irreparably harmed because '-im~ Wire will most likely be: li a ble lor more in dUl1lll.g:e~! than it will ever be able to ptlY. See

,

Grokstcr Remand. 518 F. Supp. 2d at 1217, I\!o: they al'~ entitled to do, Plaintiff., seck statutory

damages under the Copyright Act as a remedy for Lime, v.Virc's unlawful conduct. (first Amended CO\l1plainl-:1~i 74. 87. 99). Where tile defendant's conduct is willful, the range of

srnnuory damages runs from $750 10 S 150. OW. See J 7 U S.c. § 504(a)(2)-(c). "1'1 [11 order [0

prnvc wiJ1fulnr.:ss. ,I plaintilf must show thnt the dctcndmu knew Or should have kno .. vn thut its

conduct constituted copyright infri ngemem." Brandl \T, :rjgihy &. :1 Iatlier. Inc., 7T2. F. S upp. 1,:l59. 1364 (S.D,N, Y. 1991). Plainti fls' unccntrovcrted evidence has proven "IIl.11 L W intended

LO encourage infringement by distributing LirncWirc" givc:n in pan "L W'~ awareness of substantiu] infnngcrnem by users"; "that L W :(r1C\V that Iiimc Wire users were committing i

copyriglu infringement"; and that "l_tJllt massive scale ~l'illfringt'mcm committed by UJ1l~Win:

,

users, and L \V' s kno\Vkdg~ of that infringement. supports ? I1nding tl181 LW intended to induce inlnngcmenr." (Order ar 31~33.) This evidence, along with numerous other items detailed in the

,

sumrnary judgment record, shows Lime WIre almost certainly will be liable Ior :iliHutory damages where the upward limit for each statutory award is 5150.000, S(f(1 Grokster j(erlumd,

I

518 j-', Supp. 1J l.ll 1 ~17 (noting the "potential relationship between inducement and a finding or w illtulness"}.

Multiplied by the many thousands ofvurks at iSSll~·· (he other component ill a calculati 011 n1' stututory durnagcs+-it is clear that, <.I:,; ill (in~ks/e/', the amount of potentia]

OCT-25-2010 17:45

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

: '/

;j(,llll[UfY UdHl<lI.'t:"S :1( I >SLl~ here "is ,,(I sta!-!gc:ing'· UHlt' i:( "\\lIIJ I" very probably bo,l well beyond'

1

1.,lIl1\: \\"jr~':s ",!!uL~jpa[cd r--sourccx." Grokstcr RflJl"~Jd, SIR F. Supp. :Z~1~! 12J 7,

Second. PlainliCfs ;lrt~ being s~lb.ieckd to 0. different, bur 110 h-ss irreparable, type of il~ilirr trorn the nature ofthe il1fri;'~l"'lIleJU That [.illW \"';I(C 1\11~ :induL:ed, speclflcnlly from the continued

digital copies (!i' PlalmiiTs· ccpyriahlcd work:; \vill cUl\iinul< to tacilitate generations or lnfringement. SC!f/ Grokstnr RI!IfIW2<1, 51::.1 l', :;upp, :~J CI,l :17. j 7. L;Qch !ii'll!! an ilkl;(1I1 copy tll'lIlll.'

I ,

tJfP1ai!Ui(f:;· copvrightcd works is d(,w11109.d~d tbt(JUllh'Jhc: I.il\lI~Wirc scftwarc. !hut ~OPy nlilY

,

then be LI~¢!l 1(\ spawn cO\lIllk~~ dcrlvarivc infringing copies, This inflh:h expoucrulat harm 011

jlhlinlilr..- exclusive I'I~hts, Sc:r: TWI!Jrlil'lh ("Mil liT' Fox Film Corp, I'. Streeter, 43g 1:. Supp, Jd

1065, J on. I (In n.:! (D, .'\(1'-:, J006) (ever Y user ·'who receives one of the [;(.I[1,) .. TiuJncd 1.1.'01'1-:£

/through rhe lH:::l·r·lo-pe<:r sCI'I·i~~J is ill (11m c;'·I:l>lbl,~ o.rul~,;) tr(lf)(;j111tril1~ perfect copies ofthe \\"01'1<5, ... A~CllfLiin1)Iy. the process is potentially npon,elHiaJ l'.:nhcr thI111Iint:D.f. 1111<:<Ill:lliIlH \'-\l1llally lIn"l~lI'Pilblc iJifrinl.l,:~m~nl or lhe copvright."). nl.!I.::III~L· (]'lma.!,pl~ C11JIllOI aJdn;~~ tbi:s t:1I111inu.;d vulnorabiliry, Lirue \\,in~'!-: i!J{Jlll.:ud mll'illg,CI1\';;~1; L'HN:~ irreparable nann. Se« FUll'.I! ('Ii_\! /)111), Hous, In; .... 175 r,JJ at r 3.; thrum that cannot hcrcmedie.l by dnmcges ~Lw[1rd I:;; irrepurublc).

Third, Pl'linljf'l'~ Ihc~ irrcpurubre harm kelIlJ~" Lil)~~' WiN f,-wilitalO the UIK!Ulilnri'f.I"(]. i'rc~ .. 1i~lrib~ltiol~ of Plnintiffs' r:npyr!ghred w()r/(:l -- )Jrcci~:l.:ly :11(' surne product 'Ila! PJ<lil1lij'j:~ 1)(1 .... mi.Iions to market Hf1J !;ulj to C(ln~Lllrl~p,. Sl'Jll}Jf!,~/', lOll) WI. I 77."))"!C, :II "'\.I-IU, ··l·! [he avnilubility or' 1'1\:1.' in{ringillg copies of Jlli:lllllif.'s· works': Ihlo\!~h Lime Win- '·il'rep:trably

Flmg, ;\0. l,'V 06·55 n SVW(JCN):ll ,;-4 ([(k~L'.s Decl.. F ... 1). As (i n:folrh of Lim" \vil~'s

i nducemem, gl,mer;)(it)ll.; of pUlr:mial purchaser: 01' !'I,limlff~" rrl)dllCl~ have mstcad l,lrown II11 1J~lU:-;[1111H'd H'J dowlllMding Ihc:il 111l(sic tor I'I'O'C, ,\j,,'(1 .lklnj,(;o(dll)'JI""lloYIl/, .\~1{(1i(),\' Inc. ~",

7

P,07/17

,I'

.' ,.

\,i

OCT-25-2010 17:47

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

(fm/(\[4!j"_ LId.. Sil::- 1.1);, ()[ 3. <,)28-29 (lOU:')) pligiwl ,di,SlribLitLOll ofcopyrighted material

thn::dll:ns l'Op)Tigl1t holders <IS never before. bel.:(lIJ'i~ J;,\!:~ry C()py is id~11(lcal to the original. ~opyin!! i:>. e;lsy. ~md many people (c~p"iaJ;:i illl; ~(lLlJlg) use tiJ~-sh:l[ing software to dOWllJIIlJd cllpyril,;;illl'u works"); A&M R<'£{)I·l~ .. [nc, v .. \'''(,'[«1', II'J~'" :239 1~.3cll004, 1017 (9th Cii. 20()[)

i

(citing. "N"p!;l(~r·s deleterious effect On the r:C:.~l~1I1. <lTld liHUI'C di~itllJ downtocd market"). Tnut

n, PI.dntiff:, HIIl'e N(I Adj)qu~t1l..I'{(:mech" .J;I.-t Law

WI ""11"'. as here. lhe uelendunts will Iw unable 10 p:ly rim likely award or\LIIll;I!Y~~ :"(l;l~l\\'ing trial, [11l·= <ld~qLJ:JC)i-()f-lc_gl1I-I'cm~dy analysis mirrors the irrepurabic harm inquiry.

u.s.c. ~ 504n,:j, that remedy at 111\, .. »Irnns: certainly win he inadequate tCl compensate l'JamliIf:i

,~iJ';-SPJ"I;,ld dixsemlnatlon 01 the Lime Win: ~ r ,I\w:m.! hllS I'dl Plnil'tltb' copyrigllfl'd works vulncrub]« (0 JJ1!1s.~ih' and contrnuing illf}ingclIll:nL by mpJiotls upon millions of LI'''=I"''. l\·l()I'COVI.:I". whill'. damages wiIJ be part l}f1h~ approprlate remedy filr puat infrin~t=lll'~rlf, lh·y

With rcspec: In the b:lI;mcc oJ"hurd:dllpS. t!1I: "massive scale" ol mfringcntcut thrnugb lh~ :.illl~\'Vir~ clrent [UIS Ccl~I::;CJ er~rl( and irTcf1(lra~1c- iL1jl;ry [I] Pbintif[~. and anv 11[lrct8hip 10 J .iuir: \Vile·' by Llle ill_illllClIO:1 is fell" nuuveighcd by rh.u injurv. «tl.J.::rm 'n) Lime \.\11[1.1 cuunot b.::

P.08/17

I ,~

'\''

i .,1"

,',

OCT-25-2010 17:47

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

D, The P,-!btic Jntcrcst Favon all Iujunction

The injunedol1 will not harm. but rutner will S,CI"VI:, the pulilic interest. The public illhlrc.',1 ::; ~I.:I'\'(::J by lll'iJolding l'Op~right protections and, ~i\':cll the harm C,111M~d hy Lime Witc, a

II. TERMS Of' THE PIW,MA:\'ENT IN,]L:-.lCT10N

A.

I) j!l'i 11 i tit)1I ,~

GO)'lIIII. and ~aci1 orthem, lind their officers. ]ll;(~J1[!o;" (fi~c¢tor!':, servants, employees, ~ar"·'r"f'.I;()n~. independent coruractors, uuorneys, dislribul<';.I't!, corporutions, Pilrl::lIl~ subSidll.lI'IC$_ aff!liatcs.

(i) A 1\)' and nrl versions ofllw xoftware progran: that Lime Wile h<J~

di-;Iribu(c-d under th~ names "LIHIr:"\Vir~:' ·-r.ill1e\Vir~ !:1r\t:IC," ';Limt!Wjl'(' EXtO:I1dcd flU)", or I

"I,iltl.:Y.'iJ'c ['IUr III :'I1Y (HI1!'!I' program of COlll>lill:.lble fl'1M~l'jDnaI:ty rcg:lrdlc;;;; or rht: trade lI,lJ'I"~

lIlld::1 which LiLl1': \Vi\'c has distributed:

(ii)

Lime Wire:

(iii)

P,09/17

" .

. \ '\',

",

"

"/ )

OCT-25-2010 17:47

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

I

(I) any Sy,ll'l11 or ~Olhqll'~ Llp!: I:, :lLlb~tilJltj,J!I~ .. l:t1Jllp:wabl(;1 t() the

Lime Wire Sy.~I~JlI .uid SoH\\'<ll'e, including but llol limlle:,1 LO rmstW!n;!, Aoquisition. Bt:ilrl-'Iix Cubos. Gnuclell~!Gn~ld)"IA, Olk'l;lI1~llell.!J,. KC~a3Y, MPJ. Rockel, Phex, Poisoned, Sharcazu,

lnjunction. uud/or

pllrpo;;..: Dr a lWJt'~II!lllI~C' the uncuthonxcd n:j:IIIIJlIC[irm, ~li,;tribulioJlI connnunicntic» I" Ihe public (whethe r by \run~lliit[illg or maklng :.t\~,iJobl~), ""hli::. l~erfoJ 1'i1<:!IIU'. or other exploituuon

(1) "Copvriglucd Wwh" rn earis "LIII;{)I~J':rjght(;d W\.)IJ..:::, (or f1nrrilll"\~ thcrcol ),

whether now in existence ,I{ luter created. in \\ hich any Pldil;lLi ('I' (ineluding its parents.

I tl!) of,lic United ~l~I(;S Cupyril_'.l)T !\.C( (II \ 1,,~.C. * 106), III Illlr.kr state or common law.

10

P.10/17

\'/ 'I:

i

. "

!

, .':

~ \ "

..

" \,1

i

, r,

. , " ',~,

'I';

'I ~, ' ','

,,1,"

OCT-25-2010 17:47

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

, I

,:

prrur to LIll;; date ofLhl~ Pr-rrnuncm tujuncuon.

li)

(iJ

::;.1' .~l i '.111 and son ware. llS <lppJ i"::'LblC'. I tl I'(\PY, reproduce, d()Wlllond. db II i hlll.r. communlcate 10 (flo,) pubhc (whetkr by transmuting or Il1l1kinu av",ilablt:·). IJpJoad .. lint 1\), transmit, puhlicly

(k)

I

"hngcrpl"intinglh:hnc.Jogy" ro,,)f.;'I'~; '1\) (he IJHli;( d'(er:1 ive avai 11IbJe means

o!' corneru-rccoguiticn mll~rillg b~I~l!d on r~Gn~:niLjn!~ Ih,~ lll'liquc: content of UI} underlying audio-

, ,

recorded (rulll a r:ltiio or Idcl'I:JlOIl. C!L.:.). lillri whicll is :otVllil:[lbl~ from COllllllc:rc:iaJ vendors such

II

P.1V17

','

.( "

, ~I'

'i

''\,

" ,

. ~ \ ~

/'"

OCT-25-2010 17:47

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

B.

:my cO)iYl'lgll1 in U11)' and all Copyrighted WJrk;, illdll~tillg withon: limiraticn by <!ugaging III MV

«I) 1.:~)pyiI1~. reproducing, d(n\.'I)IIHI1i~lg. distributing (which hereinafter sr.al

include without limitation lnilkil1!,!-" sour d recording ur ;~\ork available for dlstribulion by

(i)

TIJ copy. reproduce. downJLwd. Ji.~tribllle. connnunicatc to rbc

reproduction. dowr lu.uiing, disti'ilnIUJ1g. comrHI;licmil1!! to the public, uploading. lillUllg io, Imll~mil1jJl!.'. public p(!('!onl1[lm.;c. UI any mi)r:'r t.!:\pk)lt.ati~l;l.'

JjJ{~I:i1)' or lndirccrly OI'Ui1lin~: UT ~l~s'istillg ill or ~lll))ilWlil1lt the lJ;n:r:.I[IOll

I:::

P.12/17

'\/"

I I 1\

II \ l~

I'i

..' ~ • I • I

"

II /

'"

I ~\

, , ,

• • I~~

. ,~

" \ " ~,

'\

,/", I

OCT-25-2010 17:48

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

I " I

t,li~pl:1yjJlJ,!" 01' p.;:rmilril1~ to be displayed any aJ\l:ftisiMiJ ill. thro~lgb or by m~tln,~ lll' 1'"

(~"~':J'S thrnl.lg,h the Liurc Wirc System und sor ware, nnd"t(,) prevent and inhibit f11111re

il1~J\Jdil~1:' wrtho ut iirniunion by

(d) IlIdl,lJiag il C~}p)'righl FiI(~I' in the ~("Il11CY SI.lrlWU~, including (10 the

L:xl"lll Il,WL!~Ulf:V tQ curuply with this P<lragrClplt) creating a new ~'eJ'~,iO(1 (~f tl\(: r .ime Wirc SY!;HCIll

J3

P,13/17

I .-:

! \ ~ '1

I ~.

OCT-25-2010 17:48

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

curujily with the requirements of [!li~ Permanent Ill_illl~cti()Jl. J r Pli:lin[iff~ con~icfn the N~'"

version (0 \,";,)1.,1<: any ~)[ the terms or this Pcuuancnr 'lnjlInctioll, Plall1tifb shul] inform II II- Cnurt

{I/ if it is pcrmiucd to <linrihull!' n N\;w Version. l.iTll~ Wire must usc all

froll' 1.I·gncy "ioi1W(U'C In the N';;~I' V~r"i01\.

(I) po~ril\!,!:!\ m':~~l.g'" <111 the \~~.hsM" within the LjJllt;Wi]"(-~ System

(ii)

L!mo.::\Virr: SySlt:!11l and Software:

(iii)

signIJi~<ln[ 41~~~I.' (1llcluJing without limitruion [In)" source c.o~c. objccr r.odc, other technology. durnuir; 11:111W~. trademarks. hr;lJ)ds.lI.s~(!If.. <'T f.<;lod,vill in 11J;}: way related L() the LilileWirl~

P.14/17

• ~ !I . ,

. ~ ..

I ~ ..

OCT-25-2010 17:48

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

, ,

I

SYH~m lind Software]; ,HId to .. II ~IJI"CeS~OI'~ (ran~(o:)r.:6s" 11C(:IlSC~:S. or other cl,,"ir:l1('t~g, and .dl

5. Lime Wire must lik .1 report on its progress wiih rlle COLIn within H days ...,1"1h-:

(a) ('cn!fy lh:lI cll:i!ributioi1_ ~illi:_'i !l1lI! flrlvf.'rlisiog has stopped:

Ill) identify whur Sl~p~ )1,1 ve been (:,Ike;1 to cllmply with lh~ reqllh'~melt(S cf

, :

1<:1

qllllntify [he pi ",-i~e dfC(;[ or the identified steps 1)[1 the cHlgoing.

Inli'jl\~\:illCl\t lit" 11)(' Copyrighted Wvrk~. inc! ,'llillg bur (\~(, limjt~d to luctlti(ving: huw many songs t'lHu1ing on the then-cu. I 1~1!1 Blllboard J'klgai.'ini: Top 200 )i~1 ;1rI~ or remain availabie for

made 10 comlm[ (llle"ill!:l il1rringcmcm as n:qllirt:=d hy PUf\,graplll.

, '

() 'I' Lime \Virl: (01' allY indrvidut.l defendant) <;dls, leases, licenses, ~OI1Y..:r1\. givl.:~

away, [r:ms-I~J's ~)I' otherwise <l~:;igm ;l1] Dr any .;;ignificMt ~'!l·t lJl' the business. CgU(lY. opera-ions

I:;

P.15/17

\ /1 I,

, "

\ . ~!

"

\ ~

" II'I \ v'

, " '" ,

,

OCT-25-2010 17:48

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

l. Nuthilli!.- ill this P,~mlaIH:nt jtl.'~IJ1~ti()t'1 $Jill~,J lill,i, the ~i~hl of Pb.imlITs W recover

all mnneys available under ]",w 011 ':1I':UIIJIj[ of Lirne Wi~'c's violuncns of law. 111I'ludlng wirhout

hmil'lI.ion ull dGlI1l:l~l~~ nilowe d under 17 I..':.R.C § 504 ~II' !lily and all lnfringerucnta of Plaintiffs"

!lll,i the costs of this SUI!.

8.

9.

The ('ol.ln ~hHJI maintnir: Ct11l[:Jluillg jIJri~di('.d()11 over this acuon, illdlldinl!. with

Pcrrnuncut I nj \111Cliol1. for tile purpose or C"~\IJ:I'i nil tjlllll j lIcl~:ment against Li me \\"irl:' on the

If>

P.15/17

I 'i',

'/ '/ \

r , '

,"

\' "

, .~'

\', .

.. , ..

OCT-25-2010 17:49

JUDGE WOOD

212 805 7900

10.

STll'riJ o\Trm A:-.lD AC.iREI~[) TO 0:-; UCIII\L.r OF PL~1,iNTJr'f:'i ,\No UME Wflt(;, SY TI·l"IR COUNSeL OF' RCCORIi

Dared: ~,:l010

_&?b().~

- p,icll1l IJ:1'>Ont":l"~ut;' 1-:"

/\(1orl1~)1 to, rl"inl;f;"~

Mlln~er, TI)Ue~ &: Olson LLr'

:155 f;im,li!1 Grund Avenue. J51h nor Log All!!I~l<:', C~IJtorilia 90071-1 560

(3 13) ;6~3-?1 00; (21 J) 6117- 17(1' (i'~x) K~I:iy,.Klalls@mto,col1l

AHOl'J1Cf rhr nf'reltd~nIS

Wi bOil So[\~,illl Guuocjl:11 & Rm;:Jli r t: 1)0 l Ave~;~~ of Iba Ar\,erica,. 40th "'001 New Vri!k; N'~w York lorll9

(2(') 9~$o·~IjOO; (lU) \!\)9-5BI)I) (F",,) rnsom nli:r@w'ltr.t:nn1

P1..IRS:U,,\N"r TO ST(PULATJt)!';. IT:S SO OIW'·:P,ElJ.

D'll.:.I, I!I..:~,U. 10 I 0

._/~»1.,1 WntJ..,

K.lMBA M. WOOD

U nitcd St~I~~ Dislt"ICI Jud~c

P.17/17

"

j

I,

, I

\'" '.

r> II

,I

., "

I

,

, I.

',

TnTAI P_17