(n2

)

Final Repor t/Chargeshect No: .

(3) Date

(O{l

(i)/\ct: ~,.le.C ._

Sections

(il)Act: _

Sections

(li~) Ad: _

Sections __ ~ _ . __

(i ) Others Acts and Sertions , ._._. . .

(OS \ TYllC of Fi n81 Form/Re port - - 0;1 ot Charge sheeted for want 0Pevt d t~n( ;c':

"Y-'-'-'l"l'rl'll '

l. 1_ tc •

Xlrt Unoccurrcd False/Mistake offact/Mistak.~: ofJ ,;.1\"i/:<') 1·

·(;ogl1izab.i.,'_ .. 'Civil Nature ~ __ ~ (tick ;JppiiuJ.l)!.e porricn)

If Chargeshected: Or iginal/Supplcmcntary (Hek <l.ppltcD b1t: port ion)

(ern

(a)

Father's Name:

{it}) D(~tails of Properties/ A,--, ic!(--'s/Documents recovered/Seized duruu; :c,~ll~ investigation and l'elil'ri upon (separate list can be attached.Jf n8(Y~;·':~('.ry).

.. L.ristf attac.hed-~--

isl. -TiJroperty i EstLnctte~)Property ! Frolll - ---·-'·--;-l:·i,;>:;)

! No, I Description : Value (in I Register No. i whom/whore :

I I Hs.) I I recovered Or' :

I I I : c"" d

~"""7. ·'1 ~.-~. c--------!---- " i · __ A __ ~_+-"ell~. ::-; _ .... _--}

~.!:_--l- .. -;-----.~-----.-j- -- ., ----+ '± ! ':-----~--

iii '

~~ -.- _ .'. ~~ _ ~,..A ~_r ~L __ 0---

; - - ~I

,

V~-tlE~T.~ler ver.itied

_.I~'"·l·l·) D . ',- '-.' .'

~_. _ L arc; r·\.~a_:rl·l Lh;·UI

(IV) Sex : . ~_(v) Nationality: . __ .: __ (vi) Passprci ~<n __

DateofIssue: Place ofIssue : . _

(vii) Religion: . - __ (viii) Whether SC/ST/ onc:

~

,

(be)

Occupation: _

(x)

Address: .... , .. _

Whether verifled

(xo' Provisional. Criminal No. . . ._

(xu) Regular Criminal No.Of knownl , . _

(xiii) Date of Arrest

(xiv) nate of release on bail . ~ _

(xv) Date on which forwarded to Court_.

(xvi) Under Acts & Ssctlons .. .. _

(xvii) Name(s) of bailers/ sure ties and addressj, _

'(xvlii) Previous convictions with case reference ...... _.

(xix) Status of the accused ._, . _

(Forwarded/Bailed by Police/Batledby Court/Judicial (:u~;-tod:v/ Absconding/Proclaimed offender)

1,1.2) Particulars of accused persons - not charge-sheeted (t1~,. seii,Fall; ';fJJ'0t fo:: each accr sed)

fl' ,-j

(i)

Whether verifled

',\ iii) Place of Issl1(" :

-(II)

(xiv) Suspicion approved, ,. __

(xv: Status of accused (suspect)_QJl bajL Ey_I~ou_[t

(Bailed by po.ice/bailed by court/ in judicial custody, ;3: "~;i '~Illt_ii iJ~;! proclaimed offender/r.ot arrested)

(xvi) Under Acts & Sections . _

Whether vertfied

(ii~ Father's Name : _~?1u;j_ GhitrahahadllL (iii) Date/Year 01' Bi?'trl:_

(Iv) Sex: t:'i<',l,lg (v) Nationality : (vi) Pa ... ssporr Nu:

(vii) Date of Issue:

Ox

Religion: B.tru:i_u

(xi) Occupation; __ ~ , _

Address: L-14,_;2Bctor-25._,l_(:!lvavu Vih~L~J:Joidr_;, Distt. Qj]ut-;_rn Budhlt;!g'.li', UP ._

(xi.ii) Provisional Criminal No. ' _

(xiv) Suspicion approved . ,, _

(l?r:~IIC!d by' police/bailed by CUU1'[/}f1 jil'-~i(-:ic11 custody/ ahs{:u~u:_~ilj~l ~ )~-ocbimed c rfend.c)" not. arrested)

(ji) Father's Name : _:,'S_l_L0hjv _~\Fni.U: __ , (iii: Datt~/''r'i:;ar ur Ej,-r(I:

(iv) ,Sex : M~9..lf (v) Nationality: .. ,___ (vi) Passuo:'t ,v

(vii)

Date ofIssue:

__ . __ (viii) Place of Issue :. __ .. ,

('v\

1 .. :,,'1../

Religion: HJnd'J

ex) \VlleU1er SC/S'I'/ one:

, (xi)

Ocr:upation,:_ . __

Address : Fla1 No. :35-A, Kanch::millrH,,(l ADartmeuL Sf:C';;~;-', Sfc-20, Nni(j~l, up,

"

_.' ,_

Provisional Criminal No,

,:uspicion approved _

(xv) Sta tus of accused (s us pect) 0 n !2ai 1, B v Co !.1r~

(Bailed by police/bailed by court/In judicial cusrodv/ a:j:'~r:():H:jn,;/ proclaimed. offender/uot arrested)

(xvi)

Under Acts & Secrions '~ .. _'_

(xvii) lLl1Y special remarks including reaSOLS tor not charge 3be('tjni~

(IV) (1)

Wheth,er verifled_~ __

(ii) Father's Name: S.il. I2QJnilln M_i;_~lldal (iii) Date/Year o~· i"~ L,', :1:

'\', i v ',I Q fl."_." " T'!,'~l"ll,t", ('\,) N at i ," r I" 1 : 'L': ' (\11) P ',K:' "" :'" :',,:,,'

_ '~).~ _.;__ "'-_ (~ _ 1_ , ._.. .) • __ ,,~. __ ' .. _ ~ ........... ~j,;:J - \ - ,

I late of Issue: __ . _

_. __ (vi ii) Place ofIssue : __

Religion: Hjnciu

I'X) \V11etl1er SC/ST/ OBi ':

" :

f '\ ~. , ~ •• ', I

lB:lj t'i'! by puuce/bcHlf:d oy court/ in judicial custody'! ;jlS(:\jlHli ni',' prorluitned (;!i'dlcir::r/not arrested)

(Attach :-;ppara(8 she=r if required)

- " - ---. ~ -. -- ,-.-- -'---'--'! --------- --r--;;-:-~-- ..

i FatiF',-'si I Date/ I Occllpatiol1 i Address

i Husband's Il~"(11.- of I I

i N:~~·p\·:L ~1jrtr~ I !

-, -t,:"~_))'-~':'-:':"::""- -- --- -j' '?" - -~.:~- ! __ .- tl

_ ,_~ _ . .__ - ---r:~~ .:.~ "_ (j _

1 -1'_ ~-L·~f· 1)1"

I -.

I c~~-i(i~-!1C\i in

til.:: !CJ!dt~iT'C!

, ') ! I

(l6)

Refer Notice served Date

Dt:spatch,;d on .

Yes 11'·Jo

Submitting the Final K.{;J:)or+' ( ~h;:rr;(;.":l1L'H

- A . ~,L "< c>.,_Q

Name _ _ .. _ .. : .. : .

,,\ ntJ of)

~~.z_ ~ ::>,"";

i..zc,111k .~._._ .. , .. __ . ~, ..... _. __ ... _ .. :~_ -

A.Gf <.'-.':~ l\DDL SL_::

~::;)L CHIi'"liE<, ,

.Ialvayu Vihar. ')cd-2.5, Noida was round murdered iI: lh: ruominu u'

)6.05.08 in her 1"00rn. On the bas is of written complaint r.x.cived lroru Dr.

consent [or transfer of investigation of this CJSt: to C B j_ lhcr- aftcr "

"'~ft- . 'ebv the invcstiuation of this case was transferred to C BI 111 Ii! :.!ar:Ci;"

.... '-.~ 1

investigation by UP Police (l6.5.20G8 to 31.05.2008)

On i 6 _ ~. 200iS 1)[". RaJ esh Talwar in his written complaint had :l[lC_f'.l:d that

his servant Hernraj had killed his daughter in the night of 15/10.05.)008 and

that he was missins. However the bodv of Hernrai. servant Cit" Dr Rajesh

- '.

Talwar who was alleged to have killed Aarushi, 'was recovered on l7.05.()~

from the terrace of the residence of Dr. Raiesh Talwar. 'The post II ortern or

r J", I . - -,. D So' '1 K- U-_·r " - no

ueceaseu Aarus 11 ·':V:iS conducted by r.. UBi urnar onare on 1 U-)-"t'>.

The scene of crime was inspected by the Investigating UHlc,--T n!l 1 h _.::; .200;"

. I'

\. 'lrUJUS l~~.·~H~~. ill t!1;_'L-

i"

i·. '

.; ".

.jl(,,:j rr .

;_',-i,', _;", h ',-'" ~",' C'_," 1- '_,/'-',J:, fr« !1' [r""",, ,,; '1 ,-, -, ,,, r' , I" I' - ",' ') _., - i.. " .

~ _. ,'~ ,'- - -,' j -' ,''' .. '' ",: ": ',:- 'I. : -,. :_, '''-J l:~);: . _'; , ,.

'l;]1 ''{() (1)- ') 008 The rcafte r r1j' R' 'lJ' esh Talwar \.I!" c- sent r ,', : u di ci cd ( ... '" j nd '\i

1 _ I _~ _ ~ . ~ • ~ 1 ........ .::;~ . ._ ....... ~ ~ J, (.." L ,-~,', . ,(t,_;! ............ z _ ~ \ j .j ~ ...... {.oj. J ~, t . -rr, '~.'

on 3D.O).200S_

Investigation by C13I (31.5.2008 _. til! date) .

.t. The Cn! took Dr. Rajcsh Talwar in custody from Ol.{i.,_;)~ to ()4.U() 0;-:.

During this period be was mtc:-mgated in detail but no ,,-:"', c"ry \\,!:-) n:i;J~·

iu j-'i'~i':1 cusrodv remand of ""f"I,- ·ll Raiesh Talw: .. - '\,,;,1<; -1'" required in nK

.1 ~"\,- ~'L....._(,~ , '-'~... 'l 't,.~ .t ' .. L I ~.") ~ 'J ,,_ L a.. "f"'r! f.o5o.l. I . I

interest 0 f j usticc". ']"he Hon bl. C ourt granted- bail to Dr. \'.:l_le~h Talwar on

j 1,07,08.

Sequence of events revealed during investigation.

T nvcsri C"; i : on has revea 'I ed d',~, l ! ;,- t'-' a"1 ~<:1'1 i ~l lwar was ['>"1- rL",' - \ i F\,11 N o ; ..

1..1 ......... _~:::---~.4.~J.'" '1 _ ,~.... ~ .......... ~........ ....il.J....... J ./j,. \,..1". ~ '-"J ~ ~ .... ,"I"f ...__..~" ~._~ L.:::~ .._~ ~ ~........ ..

"
I .
i
j.
~
Yo

>;
;,
~
'~
oJ.
t
'~.:
I'.
~
"
Q
o , I ~.,' • -; Le ,

made of piywood partition.

split AC. During the night of incident both the ;\Cs wert. I.:i.!h: ,Jist;l;;c:v

, t J hI'" '1- 1 I d ' .

ocrween t 1('. oeo 01 tl1l' 1. 8 war coupie an. AilfUSIH 'X~~S

,'\~l:'U:Jli was a student ufDI'S. Noida. reading in class 9!il.

o. On 15/5/08 afternoon alter school ':\"<1S QVCL Aarushi "Y2~' ;'''~<'C:d UP hy her

mother Dr. Nupur at about 1.30 p.ru. After returning 1<' Llwlf" residence.

Aarushi and her mother stayed horne. Before lunch Dr. \l~md:n1(l Talwar "\'j\)

Dr. Dinesh Talwar (brother of Dr. Rajcsl: Talwar) reached

[)I'. 1:;'., jesh Ta lwar 'l.' ;\; o :(h 1-')' I' Vandana T 'li v '",' r~T' ;,': J" II r' T'll". ': ,. "1'-J

~ ...._(-'.._... L..t. 't'l'L i c l : ~ '- 1 ~.(.!,-. _'- {. •. l.t i c l (: .... "\ [it. !.J L. : ..... , ; _ \ I .... ~ 1 ~ .• 1\

Aarushi had lunch together.

r v., \! '111(i'IJl<! Talwar ["'IIl'1 in.« 1 ,j',cr" 'ill

L.J ~. .... ': J t: ...... L ¥\ '"'-_ ..... _ _;;.. ... _ _. _~ ~ ~..... -L

"'10 ",'\

"') - )\'_

-lpm, 'when she left to pick up her son and then went L her! ,'·:.:ijC!1l:': :11 i h'-1:'-':

t r • ~) N'- ,~ 1 " , . h J ,,--.,'

I\Jms_ 1. r. 1 upur I arwar lett Aarushi at 1 orne ann went 1:) :)~'!" CllI~]r_:. :---id':

returned at around 7_30 P.M. and both of them thereafter remained ;)1 !-t;ll:it'

lill return ,)4-'D1--- Rajesh Talwar if' t11(' 11:1°11,

_ \. 1. _ .\._, _ • _ " .... _ \- r (J.i __ 1 1 ... ..".. ,:;:.1.1..

Or! 15/05i2008 at around 9.30pmo Dr. Rajesh Talwar retu: [' ~'(_! horr«:

car driven by his driver Umcsh, who then went to park the ('J;- ill thL' !~:J.L~g-,.:: of Sh1'1 Chitnis, father in law of Dr. Rajesh Talwar. Uruesh Iher.::::dL'! \v,~:!l to the residence ofDr. T21l\va1' and handed over the keys of th.: n,' and ktg or Dr. Talwarto Hemraj. At that timc,Umesh saw Dr. Nupur ~~nl!>\a:u~;~l, rieur the ouung table and Dr. Talwar coming out from his bedroom

· .

t :,._ .

. "...! locl f ,. 1 h . 1 . f)' r ' • , ,.

gnu \.100r OC[( rom insme nut coutd 11m do so L r. I\UDur [. I,ll nn;n,~1_! Uk:

the door mav be. locked from outside at which Bharati kd~\ 1 Jr. Nunur i_,

~ "

Dr.Nupur had called the mobile No, of Hcmraj a: ",r I urn. l>l;:ni

1 '. I I' h -- . .

<1"C.a ano opposite tnc < UI.)!' (l! Aarus ns room respecll;/cly.

BUlh were

weeping and were idling maid Bharti "Dekho Hcmraj K;<l

Hai?". When maid Hharti 100r::;;o in Aarushis room, she ~:_:\V ltG,' !i\.::id hnd:"

.......

cove-red with a white bed ShCt.:L Dr. Nupur removed the :,;he\.~t i'rorn her l~lCl~

"f t'I'C residence of T-11\\'-"I'-'" to inform th i' neiehbour. n-..' ih:s Iir:::,: 01,',' or

\,)~ 1.. .... 4V., ~l ...... 'l .. ,-(_ t1 ."),~ .1_ 1 .,_ .. \......1.~+ ......... ..._ ._,_... '"

two neighbours had come hi the flat. Dr. Nuour abo icler.ln Incd her oarenrs,

...... ..I,. _ ..I..

~.: "fi-

;-:

Dr. Durrani and Dr. DillC:-.rl Talwar. The narcnts of NUDur wV'C the rJrSL tu

, ,

reach the residence or D;·. Rajesh Talwar Police were informed nv Lh-,

Or recei ving inforrn.ui. .n. local police l cached the SjlO[ ami CUUUl~CL!"'::!_[

neccssarv fonualiucs. Thcv were informed bv Dr. Talwar [hal l]uw:;j had

1"'1'\''''[ includins (',;1" _r },' .

• Ct\,_l. 1~ .... ~ ... Lt.~j.~0 .-

i/' i.:

~ ......... ....---.,

[iJ' »>

inside his residence after having a look at the blood stainer: (iOOf handle. T:;t~ blood stained marks on the stai s between the Hat of Dr. Raiesh_ Talwa. and

~~~_~~_~ "._' ~ .. __ .. ,.__'~_r-~· _ _ _ ~ ~ ... • __ .. _ .• ~~ .____ _ _ _._ .. ' _ _ .•

his terrace were seen bv other persons alse. PD IDC of!.!ct::rs <\I::~() \V':,1l ,~l:t'

~" .- .' - -~ .. - ~ -_ ... _.....:...: ~--- ~~'.'. . - - -

............. , 0-

saw the blood stains and directed tht~ IO to get it opened hlE police Lti kd LC

instead ofwasring time [11 ilk nat should search rClr'llc~~H;;~l

body was taken LO the cremation ground in Noida \VI1"l'_- (_;ie laS! I'll':'; '. ~~~

undue haste in thoroughlv cleaning the floor and wal ls i,[' ,\arl1shi':; r"OIl'

with soap and water. The blood stained mattress on the h,:,; <)1' ;\;wl;-~i< :,1)(:

other blood su ir cd articles were carried by them to the ler:'::i:'_'~~_ o)~ rindjni-~

the terrace door locked. they asked for the key of the 1 crrace <.in! lr i, d' ttl'."

adjacent Hat belonging to Shri Punecsh Tandon. Ihe b100,j ~,Lciined itJ~:lFC~;~,

I r f' Sf . p _, l' d ' " ,

c~c. were t 'own on the terrace or , in _ uncesn an: on an.; Tn(:. D,:.jT;)Cc.:- coor

was locked.

others went [0 the: crcmai ion ~n 11 md for collecting the ash::' rile' ;.ish<..:s \\;_~rl~-

!S. li:\:v;tigation also revealed ibn Dr. Dincsh Talwar. 1k .<.?';h'i ; .f1::uclh::~i)

.-'~" >.;;:;;-" and Ski K _K_ Gautam. Reid DSP were in contact with ,',;,(')1 other sine;::-'/( .//

-' l6/)/O(5. Dr. Sushi! Chaudhary had contacted Shri K.K. (rmnam on i ()is/I);;

and had told him about the murder of Aarushi, At that ti'11t:' !1'_~ U):1V\.·VC,' Li't.:

request of Dr; Dinesh Talwar that rape should not DC' :n(:nt iUliui in tlE~

postmortem report.

10. Tnai on 17/5/08 monuug, Dr. Sushil Chaudhary telephoned S]]11 K .K.

Gautarn and insisted that Sh. Gautarn should ace, r-~j)any him to th-

residence I, Dr 1"{aJ"''''!1 Talwar -\"!I'CT" i)' Dinesh Talv.ar ,,,·\',,·,1 q,.: K ~:

__ .. ~ .... v ..... , __ • "-'- .J> 'j. " ... ., 'II !. .... _. • ... ~"-,~1_. j_~ .. ~"".(,." ,,"-I...).'-.'-"\., ~J, .. l-~ _ ... ~ ... ,

Cautam, in the bedroom ()j' Dr. Raj esh Talwar, i() get the illd: ()rlh; door nf the terrace opened through policl:. Shri K.K. Gautam \Vt~I1t :-'1' Uil' stairs to

lile- 1!'I-["Ci' door andsaw 1,:,\{),l stains (\11 the stairs '-'fOr, (1' rr,.; r marks '1-~1 trent .-1'"

_... ",... u .................. _,._~ L, 'v l !\.~ ... U .. {~_l •• ~ ,.~ ......... , .... 0(1 __ ." u..._~..._~ ......... ;--- • .L __ .... ~ ~.. _. ~ ~-- .......

terrace door. He telephonically contacted local police officers. Idler a. few

m:IlUlCS, police reached the terrace and asked for the keys iu tbl: lock. They

\h~re told that the keys were not available. The lock of ti:e door Vl,!S then

broken. As soon as the dour was opened, all those .present saw that there

were blood marks on the roof as if a body has been drugged. AbQdy.l1'l.

advanced stage of putrification was seen lying, to-wards: ·the left side. of-the roof near the external unit of the air conditionen. The body was covered -"'.~th

a cooler panel taken from the cooler situated on th.: roof J\"cioublc bed em; -:

. .

Talwar from the other side of the roof lrnmcdi.nclv on discovery 0) noely,

* other police officers also reached the spot. Dr. Dincsh ; '.1\<:1' wh.i was

f

i_

:,-

';.

';P\.1l and o~l.J.~t?ing the bod y' lle also did ® ... Lid.Qntj}_y Lh,~ h'ld} - Later on i:"";-:--:

__ , ._,. _._ .-,.- • L_ , .. _._ .... __ ._ •• L ---~---y- ~-- ... ~,- _w 'C..

run awa v. 1';1'- j) aiesh '}'" 1· var

. ",1 u. ..-' .I., __ • ""\'(~1 "'L, - j .(..t.l ,,"I( c..:. .,

1I mediately! alter th:il

17. Investigation relating to postmortem of Aarushi ~Fl.~ nfinlA! revcale:

the following factsr-

r '\.<'1 rus hi:

i;l!j ~- The hymen (If /-:':ql[<..:hi '>'::<: '-uprured and "/;';i:; hLi'iillt:..: ,;:ll tC,~l dl~d .,:vEE

'" ~~~.

0)' fihriated.

The vaginal orifice ut" deceased Aarushi was unduly la:~\'. and the mouth o:

cervix was visible.

No signs of rape were visible .

.. !_

,-

\'!:.

~;. The tin e of death was between 12 111 idnight and 1 :00 am ill T.h,"~ night

,\1. As P''::i' doctors who COI1CiUCled postmortem there was us .. : ·,'if two types O,'i'

r~---~----~-

: .. ~.:_._);.i+:-., 'Q1e __ Q_Li,U~_i_!:1_i_uEY _v'!~-'i c£u:sc;-:.~t_flf.5.t and Vi/as sufficient to cause death. ~L:'

. ,I

incised wound on the neck was caused later.

;~; L

:.$;. ~~

~~ ~.

~I II.

~

I

i

1iO ..

I i'/ The blunt mjury was caused first .and w~ sufficient to cause de~th.l1,c

.~ incised wound on the neck was caused later.

f Hemraj:

I.

XIiI. The blunt injury in respect of Aarushi was on the front ::1([;:' of h:1' tac. {If!

her forehead aud in the occinital 1'''0(1'1-')11

< ........ _\.,oo"lj ........ L_ '.... ... l ... ..._ ,._._ l~_ ........ _. ~ ~ . .c.t ......... c \._ -

The time of death was between 12 midnight and i :00 am in the niahi.

- -

lhcrc was usc o r two types of weapons during assault/murder:

weapon being a heavy blunt weapon and the other being very sharp and light

.-~ - --- ._- - .~~- .~-~

instrument.

No food was found in the stomach of Hemraj.

The blunt injury is on the l-ack side of his head.

,

.. '

,.,' .

. ~ .

v ,

-,j.

')_

As per the statement of doctors who conducted postmom.:n. the i;-lj~_ijes i(

the neck of both the victims were caused bv small ~U1(j sharn wcanon b'): ~:

.J ~ f·· ..

-'''J r1 ,0, hv '·1 Khukri

.. I ! {l. .... ,_ ....... I ... , .. _. ..,_ ,01, __ •

clarified and confirmed through Expert opinion.

The: scene of cru.ie \"ias inspected bv an expert from FSI __ (_ ;:-\11Jhirni~ar_ i k

, , .

S'.,-iH: detailed report in which he »ointed out that the crim.: 1;;1() heeTl

... - !,.

committed by SOI1H»nC v -ry dose to Aarushi. He has ,__lSi~ «pined lhat j h,_-

body of Hcmraj was dragged on the roof with a sheet.

~. ,.' CfS-' i r_ • t h dr - , , " .

r.xperts WJI11 L- have a so conrmneo hat t e ag marl'. 'JJ1 ~_nl; rom 1:';

from the blood soaked body be inu dragged after being keot m :: ~),:d sheet.

r: <.J I ~ ,

Tht:: experts have measured the zclf dubs and have opined about .the

"I v J,

seized from Dr. Rajesh Talwar is identical to the.dimensions of the l!1JUl:Y

-.-~:-~'~ . .1;::

found on both the victims.

., ...

, ,

The opinion of the experts 13 available to establish that no binlogii:aJ flu..'

were available on the undergarments and pyjama of Aarushi. '1 be' opinion h;}:-; also established orcsencc ()( a wet circular mark on the 1,(";1 si,:.:,~>! h .. eiow

The doctors who conducted the post mortem have stated lha~ ;hc cuts [0 tb..:

~\ neck of both the victims were caused by a small Shall' 1:-,c;li-,1ln(_"ll. wi'i,

~~:

~ surgical precision and h~' a surgi .ally trained person.

~

~"

TiK experts opined that blood of Aarush: was found from the bed sh('c:

olood stained palm print found on the terrace wall and tl e Pt:l"s:l!vi i..:lc1tbillU

f l-kmr2j. That DNA of none of the servants was found Oi'! . I) of theexhibits collected from the crime scene.

Finger prim of the servants or family members were not found on any of the

exhibits collected from the scene of crime.

No biological fluid or DNA could be recovered from the golf sticks handed over by Dr. Rajesh Talwar.

Two of the Golf sticks from Golf set handed over hy Dr. Rajesh Talwar were cleaner than the other Golf sticks of the set.

Human blood could-not be detected on the khukri whichbelonged to suspect

Krishna.

. :·:t~i~;,- . :;~<':.

Investigation revealed.that the seer e of crime in the room of Aarushi 2.;:, well

. ~ -"'~ ... -

r I.... ,

as on the roo: V:hr;re the body of Hemraj was found was-heavily drcsseo.

1 ~ _'.' - I

The important f;.~; -i" which show dressing of the scene of crime arc fGfic,,:tcd

"

in the photographs of the scene of crime. These includes>

'file body of Aarushi "vas lying undisturbed on her bed inspire o: u~;,-_- of

violent force in the assault.

17

iV.

i;'.'

Vll.

"

.' ,

: I : '_~ .,.

. .. -

__ '..:\ ,.'::'(:0 \:t. i\Ji (~ il~I_)CiC

, '~:.'

usc of violence/force.

The string ofpyjama of Aarushi is visible in untied condition.

~-'h ' 1" A l •• • II d .

1 e rower garme ts 01 !\_arusm appear 10 i e pu ,C UPi! ~·;\VIl.

cleavage is visible.

A circular marks of wetness is visible below the pd·vi...:. 'If'-.;:J :_)!' tht: hody Ill'

," t I • ,... . . . . 1 . 1 b < .,

l he. SCrlOO_ nag 01 Aarusn: IS seen ,ymg. near ner o ly -"V I t["1\ lU'

it.

pattern area but there is no blood droplets on it.

,.~. x. Dragging marks of body of Hemraj towards the outdoor unit d' »: ~_ The.

'~i:'

~ quantity of blood ncar the AC is more than the quantity oi'"iu:,d i!l the: ~pr.~t

:~,~

~ from where the mark of dragging begins.

:~xi, ]lte neck of Aarushi was slit later OIl-

f~ V'"

.~xii. .:Position of door key of Aarushi's morn

~1!i' ./ •

. ~ / parents who were custodian of the key.

ii e-

.r;",

':~x:v.

. ';,~ ,.

was found uncxpla incd (},y

The body of Hemraj was dragged to the corner on the roof

The body of Hemraj was Cf~'\:r:,:;d. by panel of a cooler.

.

. .;.

1:;-:V1 Th.. door to the roof was !()('.kcd for the first time in the r:iz.hi 'l~- iiF:id;';:,it

The grin on the roof was cr;'.-,--~;·~d b. t a double bed cover.

rrorn stair case side.

wipe:' with a doth.

~. ,

'f.t

t •

:, :_'.: 1,::,:-; l~rl.~:~~L>J :Hlt

: ;". "

;5 draining of blood ::md another is splashes of dr(\pkr:-~_

left eyebrow slim-lis

Investigation with reference tf) the murder

Talwar VT"S ,-. mernb er 01£' Golf Club Nf)T'rI Id,

£..._~ C. :., ,-,-,. 1,.L. llfe 1 L \.. _ '--"'l.u ..... .,. .... v:J.·vr...:.

practicing golf using two gulf sticks which wer .... ' ken: i:l hi~ :-);;'1(_1;-- 'ar

g!\'...:n for servicing{ At that time, the driver had taken ,)ui hoth ll,l; (ie_ \._

sticks and had kent them in the room of Hernrai. In the ~}huL l:_:,i'ap!i:, OJ' '-(1)::'

... _. ~ .... _. _

of Hen raj, taken by CFSL on OJ.Ou_OR, only one golf stick is vixiblc. a;:~l

the: other one was found missing. DLRajesb Talwar was unable L \ ;.;xnL.-:i:;

< ,

the missing golfstick while in police custody remand.with cut. '- 'j

": '" , --_)

1. During investigation, on 'being asked, Dr. Rajesh~Talwar handed over :L~_: complete golf set comprising of 03 woodenclubs'{Nos.jl , 3_,& )), 07 iror, clubs (Nos. 3 to 9), 01 iron club marked "P" and 01 iron putter 10 ( 'h!. T:!\.

golf set taken over from Dr. Rajcsh Talwar was sent to cXf"Gi 1S. 1-',:n :'1 :::'

The 1.)1)1'f scr V,';ICC subjected I(} Test ldcruificarion P"l~·'_,,:;. l,-\, rL--i---:;'l" "I]" '_',i"_

... l,..... C..... - ~.._... ...~,J .~ .............. '" '... •. u ........ _... ... .:. l U .... '~~............... • ~_ ."'-_.._ ~ ........ j .

Rajesh Talwa: i.<,::. Shri Umesh in presence of indcpend .nt \,\lU,':,SS Sh:-:

Urnesh identified Golf stick No.4 and 5 as the golf sticks which \VCTC: k c»t

~ !

_I-~-"----~'- -..-

by him in the room of Hcrnraj. On being asked 10 reconcile: the earlier ,- ;~"i~-l~n'-~ ~(~If qick-:~~!itll---';~~'-o':~-L"-=;;Oll of cornn 1 etc cTolf <;1"; r» P",:""J, 'i';"11,-\:;1"

_" .. , .. 0 o· .. ~ t· ...... 1 l ._ ..... '['''' ....... b'" I...,. ...... ~, - •• _ ...... _,' ...... _. ~ ... ~ < ... -.

informed that his cousin Ajay Chadd a and his wife Dr. Nl ;)1;!r twd foun:d, Oil:'

. - .

["olf stick in the loft of their residence whenjhe ion W."; 1)(:":i;:, cleanc.:

Dr.Talwar ncar the room of Aarushi, that the golf stick had ;:. stce he,~d, \L!L as soon as the golf stick was found in the loft, Dr. Nupur r:L!\'.::~' and S!Fi

golf stick. This "recoverv" of the zolf stick, from the loft. V.-~i:' m:::_ intimat . ..;c:

..:_.. ... -L..-'" ~

by either the Taiwars or Shri Ajay Chaddato anyone i"ldudir;~.~ eEl fer lT1C!fC

than " vc'<>r

< 1 ,........ Q • .L ..

During investigation Dr. Rajesh Talwaf;yDr. Nupur Talw CiI, Dr_ Dincsh Talwar, Dr. Sushi! Choudhary, Dr. Ritcha;§axeIia.,. suspect servants namely,

".1'

Krishna.iRaj Kumar & Vijay Mandal w~f~ subjected to various scientific ~'.-

tests :-1 c·J uding I ie Detection Test Br.~rr.i'f Finge rintinc -i .," ~"i'1 Narco

"V~r_ !!._ tl_,L~ _i \,.::(,,_:: 1 .... , _ ..... ...;,1.- ...... ~~ . rc- _"-_ .1.l...':":" _ ...... _J~ .... __ .b. ......

Analvsis Tests. The kst results for all the suspects ':.-,:, ;',;L:~l{l 1"0 he

inconclusive

'- -.~. ~ ~; : ~ ,

'i~. .

", ..

gaps, with lust activity at .~.:~L.~:I}l_. when the :-,'ct~C:- \,i<L:: uili"l<'L'.": switched cff. Ailer that the router has been swiiche.: .in :i~ ~).U t ::t.IL

Talwar made a call on the mobile phone of Hernraj.

ii.. ::. The opinion U7' the internet sc vice provider as well ~,.~', l~",)1l1il;aJ ~x.FC:;:-:'

.~ - ~ .

.....

1 ~ . , .,

cpartmenr, there was no power cut !n tll;i:' arc.: on tnat

particular night. However. the details of intern "[ activity d-,Iring .lav-time

,

on 16/05.1:2008 shows that the router was switched cc~ and off on a

I umber of occasions with IUI1LC Q:ans, even when the :)nJi~'(' and visitors

~ ~ t ~

were in the apartment. The opinion of experts is unable I'; cxp lain this activity of router on l"6w sarisfsctorily. Unexplained ;-.:,~u,;r activity on

o . ,

16" makes this-piece of evidence not fully reliab le_

111.

Aarushi used to remain busy on her mobile till YveII after :nicinjgbt ami

sometimes upto 1.00 a.m.

On the nizht of incident, her mobile phone

_. -.

was used last ai. 21 . 10.25 hrs, and it was switch~d off after t~12L Some of

.'~~:.. .

the I' lends of Aarushi had tried hi contact' her?!"!. her mobile phone but -it .

was found switched off,

. \ ': :-';:~,'. r

One of her friends -Anmol had. even tr;~G to

contact her on tilt iandlinc number at around 1-::.()() midni~,~ bu: there

:;:..

Phone book erc.) relating 1.0 Aarushi was available in .hc mobile phone.

iv. The call details of Hemraj do not show any interaction with any or ,lil;:

three suspect servants on 15.5.20Q.8. On 16.5.20(lO~ :ij O{).()(LOl f...[vl ;:

call has been received for two second.s.1:l1:e call wiginatc'cl from 1te.

per the tower location, this mobile phone of Hemra: '·'J;lS lnc:atL:d ill tbw

rime in the area which includes the residence ofDr. Rajcsh Talwar.

v. On 15.5.2008 Dr. \.,~iesh Talwar has returned to his hnmv at around q .·~Ii

PM. On this delle, the 13:-:[ activity on this phone is en ': ~ () 1 h,"_;" and thc'

.:

i..

LIJWer location shows that he was at. his residence. i'~txt ,\(:y i.c, on

phone is ill the r,.::sidl:nc~ of Dr. Rajesh Talwar.

'. ,"

, l

u;: 15.5.2008, there is no activity on the mobile P;lllih" 01 Dr. N12pur

Talwar after 19.40.07 his. At that time, the tower ]O:::lt:'::!, :nd~cate.s that

she was at her residence. Her phone remained inactive Li.l lX.).200g at

01.07.40 hrs,

The. CDR activity of Dr. Dinesh Talwar reveals his close uneracrion witt Dr. Sushi! Choudhary and the loop of calls between Dr. lYnesh T;:hvar,

Dr. Sushil Choudhary and Shri K.K. Gautam.

~} '~.

fiJi)

'"\'

t~

~~~ ~~

;B'out during earlier phase of investigation by UP police. ;'h;:-; was iurthcr

,ii -

, :' trengthened by various cir ; urr stances showing that there \\'QS no possibility i)l

, . ."

i~l GeI;:tH.:~·

Involvement of servants, Krishna, Rajkum ar & v'ijay MandaI.

iii)

Involvement of parents.

Involvement of intrudr-rr.

The possibility of involven cnt of intruders other than tk· ::cr~:ant:; \V~:s n1k,~:

~. No evidence has come forth which to suggest forcibk entry from the

outside.

b.

-.

No evidence has come forth about

motive on tho: pan of anv outsider.

. ~

c. No contact was made by any outsider with either Hemr .. j 01:' Aarushis

parents.

d. There is nothing to suggest that the outer most door has been latched/locked.

e. Evidence has come forth that only the family mernbc-s and Hernraj were last seen the house before the crime and onlv !'~::':Ilts were first

.' l

seen after the crime.

f.

Aarushis door cannot be opened by an outsider without a key.

g.

The. :_-:u~E'd ofthe colonv examined has 'stated that no outsider was seen

....... .,.'

. '.

house .

h.

N'..: intruder \\,.H.dd bother to dress of SCL'!H __ : o·fccime.

.tv.,

.~

No intruder will lock the terrace door.

L

An intruder is unlikely to take liquor inside the tlat after \.~u]ilnliu_:ll~}:'·

double murder when they know that parents arc sleepins; in th·.; i1.':X

room.

v..

j~ii

~~f

'.?-ii) Involvement of servants.

:A;5cokhl bv Dr Raiesh Talwar 1..1'('" inak inu '1 (1('1"1t::11 cast I"IlL'" "I)Tt/'j 1,; k- '-; .. J'7":'4 ':Y~:";

"~ ........... ~ "-) ~ '-..I"' •. r., .. <.~j I! ~~ ... "l.l t~"'. C,-. ' ......... .." _t., .. V_} !.~.l .l: __ ~~,._ .rl_

~l'l:"t.

C":~;i't~,r ,1ni·l'11. -c rj Ofl this 1t was Fe!' that Krishna a' 101' awith t11-.;: (-'(1'1"1" :"":",,!i l·'·i,,~-,L.:

~I~ '-"_ I;.~E-_ i, .. 11."'-..... ~ ~ a~ .. "'_ l L.._(l 1..., • _ (..t. .l.e.:..."" W.l 1.. ... .I...,_,._ ~. -.......~ 1._ ... - - • ~ ..... ~ .'-_~

;:£t. - . ,,- ,

iiPighl have committed the crime to take revenge against Dr.Rajesh Tal \-\ :F. Krishna

'~

:~nd Raj Kumar were ,~cpalis known to Hemraj and had access to the home 'iT'

IDr.RaJ· esh Talwar, their possible role in the crime was investizatcd.

-~ . . ,~

I .

~l;:·. During, the. initi~J investigation by car suspect:sedanu; narnclv Krishna. , ajkumar ann VIJay Mandai were arrested and intensrve mvesngauon \\'ilS carried

- ~ ~ , .

i~;ut n:garding their possible involvement. However, it was conclusivci- c~;ub!ish~:~

~~ 'i' T •• " d 1 . r - ,. 11 .

'waY !1C servants COULd not nave conmuttc t re crime ror tile roi o-;,;vmg '_,'~~:;on:;:-

e .

.

~.

,,-

:,.~.

"'

;~:.:

r1{it rel iable.

,;

:.-:.

;:.'

,I(

IlL There is evidence that family members of Krishna were "vj~rll~S:; '~i :)

presence at his house during night.

IV. There was no interaction on telephone between any of the servants 0:1 t1-::.:'

"

v. Hemraj was a teetotaler.

V1. Servants would not have had the guts to assc.nblc ill LhG blL.';'~'

Dr.Talwar when both the doctors werepresent in ~h,~ llll".',~:.

VII.

Dr.Praful Durrani to fetch Dr.Anita Dun-ani. Thev hud rcnchcd h:·;~ll:' "

around 11.30 when Raj Kumar had prepared a meal h), Dr.Anita J)Ui"t~ini who took the food after 12.00 in the night due tn her i;i:-:1. They w~;:11 . sleen at around 12.30 in the night.

'.

Minimum time to reach Aarushi's house by hyCyi~k' i'i 20 !~1i~:u:'·.;:"

whereas the tin c of death is between 12.00 to 1.00 A!'"L So. it :::

impossible for him to have reached the scene J1' crime within t~_.·_,

estimated time 0 f assault.

The house of Dr. Durrani was locked from inside hy Dr. Durrani himsel:' and it was difficult for Raj Kumar to.have got out.

- '_,.-'-'

The \V~tchrnel1 n arming the a:atc oftheSociety.at bOi.!J ll:,_' ;-':::C(>'5 did no:

see any moverncni of Rajkumar OIl that night

~ Xi There were no phone calls between Raj Kumar 'l.I1(] ':Tl\ {If tIc''':' other 1.(1:"";':

IX.

x.

\'1' !')a' K'u f~'''' ~ : ~ 1t·:, Man tal '(' (1' ,I:,jl.j:~" J.'-f.,·,.l .. :.,·.l.-.··.~;.~!;.'f __ !

••. 1. _\. J j_ ilLt] \VE:-: i,' .: J<i1(1\·iTl :,-, v l.lay ~ ".0, aii 1 [ :>. -, '".,. _.'.- _.,.

with Krishna.

,",

iii)

iv)

0,)

Vi

: ! '. I, \ : ._~ ::; .' .. ~ ',\.

would have no need to do so,

When the Police .. arrived at the SOC on morning of 1 ().).){)Ok C'ley

Dr.Rajesh Talwar ig.norcd the request for plUV idi !1.' the kc:,/:; to ',',;~._'"

the lock to the terrace cvcn when blood stains ',,/nc found cn the c!cn:,

terrace,

vi) Request for non mention 01 . .:LpC in P.M. p:·oc,;..:~,di;L~.".

vii) The call details and statement of Shri K.K. (TCuolun~ indicate tna; detection of dead body of Hemraj was not amere "::'tiIlCl(:cnc'o,

viii)

IX)

x)

(

-',

Talwars themselves but this was not intimated L.) dilyi;:,xlY IiJI' almost L.o

The facts and circumstances revealed that the mur .... icr was caused by a golf stick which indicates that the assault was initiutcd. ~I1 tIl''': basis of 'a;gmve and sudden provocation.

'J@tbefore the postmortem was to oegin;Dr. Dine-so Talwar made 1);",

.,~~~.' , ~ -

Siinil Dohre to talk tn some one on phone under tll'-' impression thatn:_;;

·:t " -;. .;',.

vi~ talking to D· j"'ngra, Head of- Forensics, /\lUvlS, N~\',' D'~ltt:

which sows clear attempt to influence the .ioctor doinz L.'-1~

postmortem.

.' . ~

xv. Name of Vi jay Manda! did not figure even in the Narc, I T·:<-:l.

,~, T" kri - - t' 'K . I I I " '1 d

XV!. ilK r.nu T1 in possession o~' ~ nsnna was <) unt edged ,ill,: fl:1' no traces <)1

human blood or fingerpri ItS.

XVII. Narco report. of Krishna and Raj Kumar had mentioned chat til'-' mobil..

phone of Aarushi was sent to Nepal whereas the mobile dbOi1c; oi j icmraj

Vias destroved. BOWCVCf, during investigation these l"svclhtii)i1S \'/\_:rv

. I..,. ....

found to be incorrect since the mobile phone of Aarusni was n __ 'C,(I\·cTCi..i

from NOIDA and the mobile phone of Hemraj was found active withi»

the territory of Punjab.

The custodial interrogation of all the three suspects important discrepancies.

not

·)1nvn!v.(?-reent of Parents (Dr.Rajesh Talwar & Dr.Nnpur Talwar).

The UP Police during their investigation had suspected Dr.Rajesh Talwar tc have committed the crime due to grave & sudden provocation OIl fine ing his daughter in a compromising position with Hemraj, Based 0:1 the investigation conducted by them, UP_l~olice had arrested Dr.Rajesh Talwar and. taken him on Police remand. The investigation by eBl revealed certain peculia. circumstances which. point towards involvement of the parents in the crime. Some of the important facts and ci__;_-":"';ulstances are a.'S hc1O\-'i':-

i) During pre-test interview at FSL, Candhinagar, Dr_ !<':!.ll'sh T:)l.var

::l1d 1 )r,Nl..H)ur Talwar have: stated ihat thcv used to Inci-;_ tile: ()\_"drI,'Ulll

. - .

'I'· '\-'[-" '11/' (il'1-iI10 'l:ot,,-

\ 4; (.... II ~.. ..j,';:. ~~ 1 l~--.:t.! ~ _

~

',' [-,1_:i, ,·,)'1\'1 hi' i'l)"rwd f-'lm ,i'e il·,<;i(1l" without 'r t,r" '~'.' .:i!,_r

"' ...... 'L~_~ ,,-I, .'/I ................... _ ....... ~_. ~rl _'.' • • .~ ~ I,~t ~ - -

_\ .:

•• 1-,

Rajcsh Talwar and Dr. Nupur Talwar, they hac! found lil,-, door to tn;

16.5.2008- They could not explain as to whether 1he,'/ had locked ~!(_

traceable in the morning of 1 ()_~.2008'.

t herefore. could have been opened onlv either bv Aan.shi herse] i r'Uili

.J J' J '

inside or by the parents of Aarushi from outside by US!!!); the KCY0'

ii)

The scene of crime was heaviiv dressed up which could only have

beer-done by the parents. The major dressing up of SU,,_" 'N<'E revealed

as follows:-

the bodv of Aarushi was found covered ... vith a white '-".:d sheet.

-' _

The bed lin'er1 of A ar US hi was found undisturbed.

e Evidence 'of postmortem cleaning of the private parts (11' Aarush:

e The body of Hemraj was dragged to a corner and covered by 3.

• Lockingthe door to the staircase for the first time on the ni~'1t of

- :1

.: (~~~~-

• T-~xis~nceofblood stains/drag markt)'and wiped blond stains on the

Q Presence of '1 scotch bottle without glasses on the ,Jil!!!!;!. table of

Dr.Rajesh Talwar with blood of both the victims I,)', it i:h.li '~~k;)

involvement of inmates as it was unlikely that an ~;;.!-'{_kr \v~~:.:i,i

, -

~ !iC

which make it difficult to string together the sc:qu<.::nc;-,.· ~)r eve-us and- motv..

behind the gruesome murder

responders ('0 examine 't·!" scene O~l' crim e D'"07'"\.->_,'!': ',",1 ,./)II.'('_l "Ii n.: ";·1';

.......... 1 ~~~ ••. L"'~ i.~ .....• J' ~ ........ ) ""-' .. _., ! 'L.. ! .. '-.::'J ._' ~ ,_~ •.• 1 ..... - • t~._ ,:1 .. '~.l '

available evidences \.\' hich could be available Cinhi,_) >':1\.' '~":,\ resp(luk,_

the evidence an.~:-

No blood of } Iemraj was found on tnt: bed <lc(_~l and nillow !)~.

Aarushi. There: is no evidence to prove that J knmij was killed in tlh_:

room of Aaru._<;111.

"',

n. Dragging mark on steps only indicate that murder nas taken place

somewhere other than the terrace.

in. On the clot! es of Dr. Rajesh Talwar, only the h!n, -J(j ofAarush: WL'S found but there was no trace of blood of Hemraj.

TIle clothes that Dr.Nupur Talwar was Wr_,~r' :~g

no blood was t:;;;,,~ juring forensic cxaminatio..

v

Murder weanons :'~" ;:l-.... not recovered

. . ,

1111!!leo ~ :.~ 1C l \

, :

i"'.!, I. ,\ \

, .

rno rung itself." In spilt of best efforts, ijw" ,ilr:_~;,crprint could 'l')L

identified.

The guards of the colony arc mobile during night and at the eI1t2'aE:',_ they do not make any entry, Therefore, their statements regardii1!.' movement of persons may not be foolproof

viii. Scientific tests on Dr.Rajesh Talwar and Dr.Nunur Talwar have .. :.

" .

VlL

conclusively indicated their involvement in the crime.

IX. The exact sequence of events between (in tk:: 1l1lt_TVelling night of! -,

16/05/2(08) 00.(1,<

lid night to 6:00 !li\1 in the i1l0rn1IW, is not C CT.

- -

and Dr. Nupur Talwar, individually, in the commission o! CfL'1lC.

x. A board of experts constituted during earlier investigation team h2:

given an opinion that the possibility of the neck being cut by khukr.

cannot, be ruled out, although- doctors who have conducted

Xl.

postmortem have said that cut was done by surgically trained 'person with a small surgical instrument.

There is no evidence to explain the presence of Hemrsj 's mobile i=l

Punjab after murder.

1·.'

xu.

-t_ ..

The offence has occurred in an enclosed flat hence no eye witness ar.:

. ~i. -

, ,

available.

xiii. The blood soaked clothes of the offenders, cJotht':;; used ~-G ::+::~:' d'"f~

can ied and dragg,-:d on the root, the bed cover which was USC(: l"

· - ....

r , • ! .: . .', ~ ~

and incomplete understanding of the sequence

rCC()VCi)' of one weapon of offence and their link! u either the servants ~ j-

the parents.

Sub uitted please.

Acirii Sl1n(li I'll' jolt:'<;£;

,. ......~.- .or ..... v --'"'-"' ",

eEL SC.l.L New Dclh:.

r

.,

8. Dr. Noresh F-:cj, Sio Sh. Oevraj Rio 4/2, DOC-for:" Av..'CJsc Rojkiyu :

! Chikitsol Porisor. Sec.30, Noida. i

---.--- ..... -~~-- - ----.~-----~--- --_&--- --~----',

9. Sh. Rovinder Kumar Tyogi Sio Shri Rom Niwos Tyagi R/o Village:; :

Sultonpur. Sec-128, Naida, Distt- Goutam bu jh l'icfJor, U~·tCi I Pradesh.

_'JL~~----l---'--------- -. --- .- - ----------

10 ISh. Ajay Kumar S/o Sh. Surjeet Singh, R/o 50 B, Plot No F-4, UdY'Jg I

V'h ~ PI")·'·' J

i .ae ~eC-UL, l'!OiOQ. . _ _ .. _. _

11. Sh. Dinesh Kumar, 5/0 Sh. Bhushan Singh, Rio 3rd f~ioOfr BloCK No. I

- J

3, Sec.-3D, Distt H ·tal N - U.P. !

12. Dr. Ritcho Saxena, Rio 4/2; Doctors Awo'S, RCjKlya- Chikit~a!ya-l

Parisar"Sec.30, ~oida_ ., ,," _.- . __ _j

13. Ms. Sonchito 0/0 Sh. Sonioy Sood Rio 381. Pocket E Mayur vihcr j

Ph 1 -'.,~ •. , . t

'. 1.., Delhi. :'.' -; .: I

14. Ms. AsnaD/o Sh. Sanjay SirohtR/o 522. Sec-37, (-.ioIOo. ---~'-~'-. I

'-. ;,~ , 'I'

---i---~------ - --- .. '~ --,_. ----------------{

~~. 15'1 Ms. Rageshwori Schay, Dl~, Shri Rajec;h Sohoy. ':'/0 C-4-103.,'

'~. I CO itat'A ori[r::_,_:~:t::: r Vasundharo, Delhi. . _~_. _:.~

:Jf! 16. Sh. S~=mko!p Arora S/o Sh. Rakesh Arora, Rio A,-11t3. c;urolmol vihor. i

'"1t--- Delh!. __ .___ _ _._. ,__ _ . __ . . __!

'_ " 17, tvs. Vidushi Durroru. Die Sh Prafull Durroni. Rio Flo: k_-; i\-35, 8luck- I

• ' . I

~-- ... --.U;. K·:mch9.Qj~i!..c~)U _0J~(:H·mer~L~Eic;·--?},-~e_L?(1_:_ _ __ _ __ !

,~: H3·1 Sh. Anrnol ;\pC]f\I/\';1 S/o Deepak Agarv\/o!, Pin Hn; ,'; -:', ' () 400,_

~;. L~E:l_~ ·21, ~9ic1C~. _ __ __ ~ _ __ .. _~ _

r~ 1'1. I Sh Sc:njoy Sin~,:, S/u Sh Kom!opot Singt:. R/-) . c; ,J_: i'.!iti,cci I

~ \ t-.' -. i -

::- __ ; _.: ~ O! ~~~\ _LL. P :... _ _ _ _ .. _ _ _ _ _

2C \ Sr POr-y, Kuni'1f <: 1 P<lb0 RCiT\ C/O Rojpol Shcrrr-o I

;

Name of Witress

._._..;.. __ .--'_.--- ---.----- -----------._-_.'----- -- - -

. Mr,Punish Rei Tondon, S/o Vice Admiral (Retd.) /\v,mi~,!-, ~;> i! TlFldor .

, 0 Flat No. L-28 ~~ctor-25, Jalvoyu Yihar, N_Qi9~ ._ _ _ _

Dr. Rohit Kocher. Sio Sh. Rojinder Kurnor Kocnor. Rio C-ll0, Se(::- 41, Goutam Sudh N or. Noida uttar Pradesh,

Dr. Rajeev Kumor vorshoni. S/o Sh. Sohan Pol. Rio B-6. Gyonde8!" ortment. M,o r vihor. Phose-I. Delhi.

4, Sh. K.K Goulorn S/o Late R.L Goutam, Rio D-130, .::;nc 36, Noid".

·--0~ ~anT~Y ~h(:!~JhOn ~ pes, .Si~-Lote-~5r '. -R.--_r.- ~~--~h~;~J-r~c~~-~C~~:·i

.r , 'MO' 91strote DI-tT f':B N -'g-'or U'f) Rio ,. - 2 <oc ... 'r-·r'·· S-o-'--' r--",,:,. I

t." ... ~ ~:-..._.:;; ~u ~. -\...7-[1 ~"-',j_t,;l._!..1\:.:;.,~,\iV~/ ... +t ,

I Distt Goui'arn 8udh Naaar, U_P. . ,

.-----~-- ---~.- .. ---------- ~----.-- .. ,.~- - - -

6. ! Dr Lalit Verma Rio E··18, Hudeo Place, Andrews G, 1;11. 1<':;Ii/ C);.,ir,i.

1 -

'a----"------ --.----. -- --, ---.------ . --------.- - - - --

'Dr. Sunil K. Dohore. S/o ,..;h R.D Dohore Rio J-13f. S(jcfor-19, :

Noida.

i,_- __ , ... +-N-it-h.-o=-1-r-.i,J:!c2i~0:lLF~.- _. .,. .. _ _ _ __ _ _ ... __ ..

24. Sh. Rom VI5(10\ S/o Sunder Lal. Rio C/o Sh. ~~Clk:cdl, bc;hirl(; Kr>·

Com t"-iithar"L Naida U.P. __ . .~ ._ _ .

25. Sh. Digambar Singh, S/o Sh Pani Singh. Rio \/j[i(J~y.: 8< PO: i\\c)~'

Distt:Foridabad PS:Chayso,_Haryar2__<;l_: ._

26. Sh. Umesh Kurnor Shcrrno. S/o Sh. Shiban Shorrno. ~Vo C/C ;

Kishan near Sharma MarkeL Village Chcurn. PoouTiath f'~r. ;:-,-

22, Naida. _. ._._. . , •

27. Const. Pawan <urnor S/o Laie Prem Singh. i'-i( ).-:)72/A~', ['.S. SC:~' .: , Naida.

I--~_~~'_C-" '_ . ----

28. Smt. Sunitu Rano, 5.1. Win Sh. Ajay Singh. FUc }jD:~:;,. ~~u. 3C .. ,;:.

40 Police colonv. Noida. '

!-----t~.:....:....-:-:.;.-":....:- .. .1...;_ '-.-- .-- •• --.----- • - -.- - •. ' •

29. Shri Chunn! Lal Gautam, H.C. S/o Late Shri !<c;;;! S'vl/(J[UOP CC:llj .

R/o VilloGe Moro, P.O. Khamini, P.S. Vrind{'J'~]"''''''' j'L MuiilUi\;.

-.-~ ---------_._--- - - _.

Mrs. Bhorf Mondol, W /0 Shim MandaL P/o i:luqoi, Sec. B .. 1+·_

• ~ .... ~.j

1-- __ ----.;......:B_a_Q;_n_.s __ ~9JlL~t~()ANi!hS~~~ N ',ida, U.P. __ .. , ... . __ ._ _

31. SmLBimla Sorkor. W /0 Sh Rajkumar Sorkcrr. ~'/,) C~/() f~i';ho(" hCi_.' .

Nithari Noido.

- -- ~~- _--_ .. - --~ - - - - - ~ -- _. ---

32. Smt. Kalpono Mondo!, VI /0 Sonjay Monci( :1 . .JhuQUi Bast!, ~> .. '

Market Sector-S. Noida.

'·£'i.I~-----1----~--··-·--------·---·--------·-·--- - - . -- ---- ---

33. Dr. Chonder Bhushan Singh, 5/0 Sh. She-mel SiriUh, f<:;stt. Frofcss, __ ,·"

MAMC, R B-235,_f0yadar~~ni Vihar,_t<.Je~_p!c~Jhi .. ~2._.

34., Dr. Oinesh Kumar, S/o Sh I.R_ Arvo. Associore Professor', M.:;MC

-S4C p . . V'- Ph I r'\ jh-01

I ,OCKei-4, Inor . ose-I, LJ.~I;~~_. _

Sh. Bal Swaroop Sharma S/o Shri Kripa Rom Shorn'-io Rio Viik:;T Nithori Sec-31 Naida.

mll-----l~~~~::::---.:...-'::..:..!...:_:::::.:~~-----·--------·-·-- - -- --- - ..... _ - .'- _,-,,--- - -

Sh, Deepak Kanda, Nodal Officec Bhorf P,;"rel Urniied, D-·.";_

la lrid!. Estate, New Delh' . . _

'$hri R. K. Sinqh. (Nodal Officer)·/'Bhorti Air1'e! u. nited, D·~ 184.- O. .»:

. ·~Phase-I DeihL :( " _._ _ .. '" _

Sh. M. N. Vijayan S/o Late fvt K. Narayanan, Nodo! Office'!., Tat Teieservlces, 2A, Old Ishwor t~_ogar,'Mainjy'.!Qthllra Rued, D~liJL_ Sh. Oeepak Tomer S/o' Shri S. S, Torno]' hsSt. Nnrinj -Officer

~M __ --+_\:......:r":':.~-:::=-::;:::.,:..::-fo::..:.n.;:::e~.i~:-45,-F_b.ase-iL UK!HO In dl!.?tri Q! _rye a , _D~l!2L _ __ .. __

Sh. Bhupendra Singh Awosya, Scientist 3, CerHn, Dept~·.

1, t' T 'I E'" ,.,. ,,..' r '( '- r > ,

morrnouor recnno o~JY, -Iec:rron!cs Nik\·';l~.1tl, CJ, '-..-\.,7..;.' ,~orn;:;ie:'

Lodhi Road, Delhi: . , _ _ ... .._

PL Kriposhonkor Tripothi, slo Lote Shyc]rOl ~;i ."·!,:inr rio C:ret::ntic·'

___ ,._,"",-. J1Qr_ N_(_~i~jz~. _ _ ._______ _ __

Sh. Rojesh KU{',r,r', S/o Shri GCineshi L'.:Ji, \f:-:, , ".j,j(j, ':1:::;1:. S:J:.D:· _+-.:..:.;!.-=- . .:....h:__::'o:_u~::_:'s.(~J~o ':,-Hydel ~glony, Plot !--:l.9_,.!\.:' .:" . :ruf-- i 6, ~'·k)ldo.

S· ", . c:, " ,,' Dj H N '-.-7-' \""',

r1~ .)Of)f()T ,jt' 0 )f:~ f -, C]f\/,,,.'Orlj f'" 0 . C)-.JI j ~',: Hi /;! 1('i:, [\j'~\JKV·1· .:;" "

39~

40.

41.

43

· . ~

: ; . ~, .. );.

Sh. Kuk.:leep GisT S/o Sh. /\nond Sinnh et',i ~,/o 3/.6, T'j~.;r1:'_ Ext Nevi D3ihi.

·li:f:I------+------- .- .-- -- .-- ---- . --- -

Sh. t'/\C_HIOj PU":,.\Jf S/o SiI_ JOQrner Siri~Ji I, !. /'J i'louse ::)1' ;::_:.;')

__ I_§_L_t~1_clJ;drn_o th, S9U 111 EXTrl, Deihi _ _ __

-t~~----'i

Sh. Joginder- Kumar', S/o Late P.R Kurrnn f:;c(,!, f-~!(J U·17/J\ .. ~:, .

"'~~--~-----_-- ---------------- -_--- .-

55, ISh. Shufiqoor Rehman S/o Shri Subhar :r]j~(-1h Rio r'U~(~. 6;:: :~

fiats, _Cv~9_912ub9n AQ_artrr:l~.nt,_ Sec-~2._NofgSJ__ .._

~ r r-r '" S' I K ki S/ l_j - " - R I r, .' " ". " .'

,)0. ~11. heer ,Ingn or I 0 lIon ~in:;Jn lO ',_, c.t oo, ;;ocr:_ ,_);, '

.;>~~~---+_D_;_c_s t._T - Go,:! tsm Bu_s:~ h Naqar, U J) - .

57. Sh. t)yos, S/o Sh.Bolkishon. Room No.20, Cio Jondish Ci-~':JI_-

_~_-+.~S-=o~d:__,_;;o·c~yr Coiony, Naido. ._ __ _. . ~ _

58. Srnt. Kusum W /0 Sh. Byes - Rio Roorn-2Ct, Sor iorpur colonv. i U.P

- ... - ---- ~ ._-_-----_._--_..-...--- -- ~. - -~ -' -- --~-- -

Sh. C. K. Roy 5/0 Late Ramesh Chonde: =:ov _Rio IV!-238, S,:'c:

,~I:-- __ +--.Jol~gy-l!__y·ihar, Noida . ~ _

Sh. l.oxmon Singh S/o Sh. Han Singh 'FUc 8 .. 36, Gaii No.2, No r, near East of Lon! Delhi-94

r--:-----T-..=.""~~:.:--:__:--;-=~--::=:...--:::::--:---::-::::--:---:~::--:::::-:::--.-:----::------.--.-- - - - -- -~ --

61. Sh. Koshinoth Johri Rio L-14, Sec. 25, Jcdvoyu vihor. Noido.

52.

Naida.

54. ' Sh. Sonjoy Thakur S/o Sh. -- ltgopoi Thclkl If ;< I,:) /:..,-;.;. :1[[ (;(1"':' , , Delhi··29.

59.

60.

~=:-~-+----- _.-._._----------_----- - - -- ,,_--

62. Sh. Bilirn Bahadur Thopa S/o Late Brloktn P,fJhoour Thopa F:_!:-',

_------.;._J __ ....:o_;.lv_~~~_.'t_~ar~, Scc.)5, Noid a . __ . .. _. _ __ _.___ _

63. Sh. Je evcm Shormo S/o ~),edi Ram Pontt: Rln 553, Sec-29, :-'.i,

U.P.

-----+ .. .::-----.- - --.--

.----.- _ .. _-- -_ .... - -

, i .-' '.' I v: I - (j)" . ~ c- I -- , IC"~" ,

,),1, :';! ," ~!(J!l";, ukon (0, DcnjC!(.l8 ,> 0 '. .11U;' : -': '" :\,",:i, ,;/:.) ~:-. ,

1,1 .r. 1:, - ;-~,,; ':':) Ii ;_f-xtn_:_f.?_~: 9_k~_rlf2_lJlg, ~~ __ I 1_

67. < i: :.~,_ ;, ,~~~l,:h(j(~vl S/C) Sh (;~\/~S(]cl}I_'~~~ ~~i ',I /,-; - •. ;'/. \!~-;~~~.: ,.:. :'.,_!/

l'}:

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful

Master Your Semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Special offer for students: Only $4.99/month.

Master Your Semester with a Special Offer from Scribd & The New York Times

Cancel anytime.