P. 1
rahmanhadiq for Ali Sina

rahmanhadiq for Ali Sina

|Views: 521|Likes:
Published by rahmanhadiq
letter to ali Sina
letter to ali Sina

More info:

Published by: rahmanhadiq on Jan 25, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





World’s Greatest Showman

Ali Sina on Zakir Naik:
And Now
Rahmanhadiq for Ali Sina
A review oI
The Qur’an and the Bible in the Light of Science

By Ali Sina
Revision by;
Rahmanhadiq (2010/12/12)
In 2000. a televised debate between Dr. William Campbell representing Christian view point and Dr.
Zakir Naik representing Islamic view point took place.
Rahmanhadiq: Rahmanhadiq: Rahmanhadiq: Rahmanhadiq: A man named Ali Sina (an abbreviation of Ali = King,
Sina = Satan in the World, abbreviated of course KSW) is like a
soldier who was defeated in a battle and fled into hiding in a
ditch ran ass. Then after a safe condition and no more war, he
talk nonsense everywhere proclaiming that he is a hero.
Whereas in the debate that, the King of Satan is do not anymore
and nothing. He only eavesdrop to find information like an
espionage ditch Rats. Then think to decide defensive or escape.
Apparently, after witnessing greatness and greatfull opponent
that comes with a full charrisma, He ran to prepare for his new
strategy. Then Ali Sina (the King of Satanic in the World,
abbreviated KSW) was imprisoned at the base of the deepest
oceans to get his voodoo and make the formulation of spells to
explain the cause of his defeat for his followers to be learned
by the spirits of the ancestors that still haunts. In this
presentation, we will see that Ali Sina is, can we be the most
concrete example as a devil can only show the attitude of
hatred, enmity and pit against for human life, a fair, safe,
prosperous and dignified in the world.
Pakistan Daily Times wrote:
On December 7, 2005, a TV channel (QTV or Al-Noor) showed a debate between William
Campbell and Zakir Naik, which showed the other side of the polemic. In the past it was Zakir
Naik trying to prove other religions wrong; this time it was William Campbell rebutting his

This was fair enough. If you don’t want your religion criticized don’t do it to other religions.
When Dr. Campbell criticized Muslims for claiming scientific discovery in the Quran one had to
listen. - (Rahmanhadiq; Events debate between Dr.Campbell with Dr.Zakir Naik is very Iair with
the spirit oI honesty and openness and very Iar Irom a sense oI hatred and hostility. but KSW
Ieeling that the show is based on the Ieeling oI hatred. animosity and mutual blasphemous only.
The debate was in order to maintain the truth rather than seek victory or drop someone only. Only
KSW who think there is anyone who wins or loses. Apparently KSW want to pick and choose
Irom the debates to quickly spreading the seeds oI hostility and hatred between Muslims and
The TV channel took a fair decision, but when Dr. Campbell began cutting close to where it hurt,
the program was suddenly taken off in favor of na’at. If this was done out of fear it was not a good
decision and showed Dr Naik in a bad light. (Later news is that Dr Naik won the debate.)
(Rahmanhadiq: indeed excellent committee's decision to cut scenes that are sensitive which may
lead to conIlict between Christians and Muslims. this proves that the committee intends to present
a Iair event without a sense oI hatred. but instead want scene sensitive KSW is to serve as his
IoodstruI to embed the hostility seeds between Muslims and Christians. That's the nature oI Satan
wherever he is).

Muslims are convinced that Dr. Naik won that debate. In Iact once you watch the video. unless
you know the Quran and Islam Iairly well. this is the impression that you get. Dr. Naik was so
conIident and so boisterous throughout the debate that anyone watching would think the same.
Or did he? I went through this debate and have analyzed the talk oI Dr. Naik paragraph by
paragraph. In this paper I have shown that Dr. Naik misrepresented every statement he made on
the Quran. There is not a single claim that Dr. Naik has made about the Quran being miraculous or
scientiIically accurate that is true. ( Rahmanhadiq; This coniecture is only true Ior the KSW. but
not Ior people who have sacret hearts and common sense).
I have entitled this paper. World’s Greatest Showman. because aIter watching his perIormance. in
my opinion. it describes him best. (Rahmanhadiq; I turn this Title into ” Ali Sina is the King of
Satanic in the World). Dr. Naik is a magician. Magicians make you believe they cut people in
two. make obiects disappear and reappear and make rabbits come out oI an empty hat. But in
reality none oI that happens Magician (Rahmanhadiq; but the most appropriate to Ali Sina is the
King provocateur). The ability oI the magician is to make you believe in things that do not happen.
Dr. Naik uses a diIIerent kind oI tools to perIorm his magic (Rahmanhadiq; A magician is much
more admired and appreciated than a liar and a loser as KSW. Ior a magician to bring the power
and satisIaction Ior the audience. while a provocateur will be investigated by police to put him in
iail). He uses words. He can make his audience believe in things that are not true. In this paper. I
am going to show his tricks and what he uses as setup to make things look diIIerently
( Rahmanhadiq; Please note that the KSW was not present in the event. so he does not believe in
the miracle story. even iI he was present then he used his mask. KSW is to deny the reality oI the
event with a spirit oI the hatred and envy). By the time you Iinish reading this paper. you'll be able
to detect them too. But that is not all. Since all the Muslims use the same tricks. although not with
the same proIiciency oI Dr. Naik. you'll be able to detect their tricks too (Rahmanhadiq; This is
what the KSW was giving a sermon to his Iollowers that are his spirit haunts and his ancestors
who are still shackled to revenge).
A good magician is dexterous and his moves are swiIt - so swiIt that they are hard to detect.
However. iI you replay his acts and watch then in slow motion. or even Irame by Irame. you may
be able to catch his tricks. This is what I have done with Dr. Naik's talk.
This paper will eventually be available Ior Iree download and also in a printer Iriendly Iormat. It
may even become available in a book Iormat (Rahmanhadiq; was preparing a rebuttal book to
KSW). I hope all those who have seen the debate between Dr. Campbell and Dr. Naik and were
swayed by Dr. Naik's showmanship read this paper to see how he deceived everyone
(Rahmanhadiq; but KSW like a oversleep hero instead who is talking like a possessed man).
Anyone who has seen or heard Dr. Naik owes it to himselI to read this paper. He rehashes the
same things in all his talks. Here. the tricks oI a master magician are exposed. Read it and pass it
There is no doubt that Dr. Naik is great. One must acknowledge the merits oI his opponent. His
greatness is in his ability to twist the truth. He is dexterous with words and has an excellent
memory Ior remembering the verses oI the Quran. II he was a lawyer and I was a criminal. I
would want him as my attorney (Rahmanhadiq; it was already Ior KSW to supposed the
acknowledges greatness oI Dr. Zakir Naik. because KSW is too small in Iront oI him. But iI the
KSW is a criminal do not expect to ask Ior help to the saint. KSW could have caught directly).
You can watch the debate by clicking on the links at the bottom oI this page while Iollowing the
transcript in the Iollowing pages. When it comes to my responses. you can click on pause and read
what I have written.
I say it with all certainty that this paper demarks the end oI Dr. Naik's glory and will bring down
his empire (Rahmanhadiq; KSW established as the losers itselI. who want to destabilize the
throne DR. Naik that too Great and Noble Ior KSW). Once his Ians read this. it would be as iI a
balloon is punctured. They will see through his veneers oI lies and chicanery and his tower oI
cards will crumble (Rahmanhadiq; ruins oI the tower it will be Ialling on KSW and his Iollower.
and then will be buried alive under the ruins.).
The prooI is overwhelming. Many oI them may write to him asking him to respond. Dr. Naik will
not because he cannot. Perhaps he would come with silly conditions like he did beIore. asking Ior
a Iace to Iace debate or demanding that I organize a conIerence attended by 10.000 people. or raise
the reward oI $50.000 dollars that I am oIIering to anyone who can prove me wrong to one million
dollars. Most likely someone else will respond saying Ali Sina is not important Ior Dr. Naik to
waste his time on.
These are oI course lame excuses. There is nothing one can say in a Iace to Iace debate that one
cannot say in writing. The problem oI a Iace to Iace debate is that one can play 'magic' and Iool the
audience. while this is not possible in a written debate. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW papers is only a
incitement and hatred that are not qualiIiedt to be reply by the ripsnorter DR.Naik. supposing that
KSW was reIused waves on the beach with the palm oI his hand. Let alone that rahmanhadiq
banishes Ily Naughton like KSW this.) ".

ً ُ هَ ز َ نَ آ َ ِ َ ْ ا ّ َ نِ إ ُ ِ َ ْ ا َ َ هَ زَ و ّ ُ َ ْ ا َ ءَ ُْ َ و
17:81 Truth has (now) arrived. and Falsehood perished: Ior Falsehood is (by its nature) bound to
perish." (Rahmanhadiq; This Verse aptly applies to the KSW. which will be buried alive in a
hole that is being prepared himselI.)
When this verse was Iirst proclaimed (when Muhammad conquered Mecca) it was anachronistic
because then it was Falsehood that had taken over the Truth with Iorce. treason and tricks
(Rahmanhadiq; the spirit oI KSW hatred to be more passionate to crushing truths presented by
Dr Naik. so he submitted declaration that a Ialse will be destroy the truth by a cunning way.
violence and betrayal as he wrote above. This is the nature oI KSW).
Finally. thanks to the Internet. this violent Iorce has become helpless and Truth is reemerging.
You can say that verse was Ialse when uttered. But ironically. it was prophetic because it is very
true today. Today Truth is back with vengeance and Falsehood is bound to perish (Rahmanhadiq;
there are still prophetic verses oI the Qur'an that match Ior KSW " As to those who reiect Faith. it
is the same to them whether thou warn them or do not warn them; they will not believe").
II you want to contact Dr. Naik. here is his email: inIo(drzakirnaik.com
The Qur'an and the Bible, in the light of Science - Part 1
(Sabeel Ahmed) Auzubillahi Minash Shaitanir Rajeem, Bismillahir Rahmanir
Rahim..…(Arabic)…In the Name of Allah the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. Dr. William
Campbell, Dr. Zakir Naik, Dr. Mazachis, Dr. Jamal Badawi, Dr. Samuel Nauman and Mr. Sam
Shamoon, distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, As Salaamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi
Wa Barakatahu… Peace and Blessings of Almighty Allah be upon all of you. On behalf of the
organizers… the Islamic Circle of North America, I, Syed Sabeel Ahmed, welcome all of you to
this unique event … a dialogue on the topic – ‘The Qur’an and the Bible in the light of
Science.’ Again on behalf of Dr. Campbell, Dr. Zakir Naik, Islamic Circle of North America,
this dialogue is being held in a spirit of friendship, understanding each other’s view points. A
brief introduction of ICNA’s activities - Islamic Circle of North America. The goals of Islamic
Circle of North America, are to motivate Muslims to perform their duty of being witnesses
unto mankind, offering educational training opportunities to increase the Islamic knowledge
and to enhance the character. ICNA is also active in opposing immorality and oppression of
all forms, supporting efforts for socio-economic justice, civil liberties in the society,
strengthening the bond of humanity, by serving all those in the need, anywhere in the world,
with special focus on our neighborhood across North America . For today's unique dialogue,
the two main moderators are Dr. Mohammed Naik representing Dr. Zakir Naik, and Dr.
Samuel Naaman representing Dr. William Campbell.It is my duty to ensure a fair and proper
conduct of this meeting - therefore we request our speakers as well as the audience, to
maintain due decorum for a healthy dialogue.With that, I would request Dr. Samuel Naaman
to give the introduction of Dr. William Campbell - Assalamu Alaikum.
(Samuel Naaman) Thank you brother Sabeel Ahmed - It is a pleasure and honour to be
here with you this evening. And first of all, I myself with a group of our brothers and sisters
from the Christian background, really like to thank the Islamic Circle of North America, and
the local people who have organized this unique event. They have done a great job - they
have worked very hard. And now we have come to the last moment, to be here. Dr. William
Campbell did his medical work, in Cleveland Ohio at Casewestren Reserve University . He
worked for twenty years in Morocco , where he learnt Arabic. After 7 years in Tunesia, he
wrote his book, answering Dr. Maurice Bucaille. He is a convinced Christian, who likes to
explain the Injeel or the Gospel, to everyone. At age 74, Dr. Campbell is retired with 10
grandchildren. And we are really thankful, and we are really happy to be with you tonight -
Thank you.
(Dr. Mohammed) On behalf of the Islamic Research Foundation, I Dr. Mohammed Naik am
pleased to be amongst you all along with Dr. Zakir. It is a pleasure to be here for this unique
event, and have the good pleasure of having scholars like Dr.William Campbell, Dr. Jamal
Badawi, Dr. Mazzacus, as well as my co-colleague Brother, Dr. Samuel Naaman, here with us.
I on behalf of Brother Samuel and myself, present the format for the dialogue. The format as
agreed and decided fair, by both our speakers is, Dr. William Campbell would first address
you for 55 minutes on the topic - ‘The Qur’an and the Bible in the light of Science.’ Then Dr.
Zakir Naik at the far end, would make his presentation for 55 minutes on the same topic. This
would be followed by a response session, in the which Dr. Campbell would respond to the
matter presented by Dr. Zakir for 25 minutes, followed by Dr. Zakir too responding for 25
minutes, to the matter presented by Dr. Campbell. Lastly, we would have the open Question
and Answers session, in which the audience may pose questions to each speaker alternately,
on the question mikes provided in the auditorium. After the mikes-questions are handled, we
would allow questions on index cards to be provided by volunteers in aisles, and in the order
selected at random, by the coordinators and the advisors, to each of the speakers. Ladies and
gentlemen... to address you, today… Dr. William Campbell.
(Dr. Mohammed) May I announce, after the talks by both the speakers and the response
session, we would be having an open Question and Answer session. So those who have come
late, kindly note, we’ll have questions on the mikes, followed by questions on index cards.
Ladies and gentlemen, may I call upon Dr. Zakir Naik to present his talk.
(Dr. Naik) …(Arabic)… Respected Dr. William Campbell, Dr. Maracuss, Dr. Jamal Badavi,
Br. Samuel Nauman, Dr. Mohammed Naik, my respected elders and my dear brothers and
sisters, I welcome all of you with the Islamic greetings… ‘As Salaamo Alaikum Wa
Rahmatullahi Wa Barkatahu. May peace mercy and blessings of Allah Subhanawataala be on
all of you.
The topic of today’s dialogue is ‘The Qur’an and the Bible in the light of Science.’ The Glorious
Qur’an is the last and final Revelation which was revealed to the last and final Messenger
Prophet Mohammed, peace be upon him. For any book to claim that it is a Revelation from
Almighty God, it should stand the test of time.
Are Miracles Real?
(Dr. Naik) Previously in the olden days, it was the age of miracles - Alhamdulillah, the
Qur’an is the miracle of miracles. Later on came the age of literature and poetry, and Muslims
and Non Muslims alike, they claim the Glorious Qur’an to be the best Arabic literature
available on the face of the Earth. But today is the age of science and technology.
(Ali Sina) Right from the onset, Dr. Zakir Naik makes two assumptions that are both false.
The first is the claim that “in the olden days, it was the age of miracles”. We do not have
any proof for such claim except the fairytales of the ancient people passed to us as "holy
scriptures". Even then we see that Muhammad disclaimed being able to perform any
miracles. Unable to perform miracles, he claimed that the Quran is his miracle. But the
Quran is no miracle at all as you'll come to see in this paper. (Rahmanhadiq; How could
KSW want to believe the news of truth, even when shown the evidence on his eyes, then
he will reject it by saying that the science of witchcraft or magic. KSW was talking with a
sense of hatred and the attitude of hostility toward Islam, not with scientific thinking and
science in polite and ethical).
Dr. Naik makes another false statement and says that "both Muslims and Non Muslims
claim the Glorious Qur’an to be the best Arabic literature available on the face of the Earth".
This is not true. Only Muslims make this claim. If Non-Muslims believed in this why they
don't convert? (Rahmanhadiq; by strange question of KSW, how a non-Muslim an
acknowledged al qur'an and became Islam, KSW is more confused apparently) Non-
Muslims have found many errors in the Quran, not only scientifically and logically but also
grammatically. Many actually believe this book is the most asinine book ever written, not
only because it is violent but also because it is confused and very tedious to read
(Rahmanhadiq; this is true for KSW, that his book will not be bored and best-selling
read by his followers in the kingdom of devi). Some of the earlier verses rhyme, but there
is no beauty in this book. Ali Dashti in his Book 23 years of Prophetic Career gives us a
list of such errors. Also M. Rafiqul-Haqq and P. Newton show more than a dozen of
grammatical errors of his book (Rahmanhadiq; KSW also introduce some of his helpers,
his friends and servants, who conspired to block the truth proclaimed by the verses of the
Qur'an presented by DR Naik). here
Einstein's Religiosity
(Dr. Naik) Let us analyze whether the Qur’an is compatible or incompatible with modern
science. Albert Einstein said… ‘Science without Religion is lame, and Religion without Science
is blind’.
(Ali Sina) For one thing Einstein did not believe in a personal God but advocated
cultivating Good, the True, and the Beautiful in humanity itself. He wrote: “I do not
believe in the God of theology who rewards good and punishes evil. My God created
laws that take care of that. His universe is not ruled by wishful thinking, but by immutable
laws.” [1]
And when he spoke of religion he did not have religions such as Islam in mind. He wrote:
“I have found no better expression than "religious" for confidence in the rational nature of
reality, insofar as it is accessible to human reason. Whenever this feeling is absent,
science degenerates into uninspired empiricism.|2|
Elsewhere he wrote: “The sense of the religious, which is released through the
experience of potentially nearing a logical grasp of these deep-lying world relations, is …
a feeling of awe and reverence for the manifest Reason which appears in reality. It does
not lead to the assumption of a divine personality—a person who makes demands of us
and takes an interest in our individual being. In this there is no Will, nor Aim, nor an
Ought, but only Being.
Einstein’s religion was a sense of veneration of the subtleties, the intangible, and the
inexplicable that lay behind all the discernible concatenations of natural phenomena. It
was not the “revealed” religions that he spoke of. He called his religion a "cosmic
religious sense". "What I see in Nature” he wrote, “is a magnificent structure that we can
comprehend only very imperfectly, and that must fill a thinking person with a feeling of
'humility.' This is a genuinely religious feeling that has nothing to do with mysticism."
Therefore it is misleading and hypocritical to quote Einstein who opposed the idea of a
personal and demanding god as taught in Islam to take advantage for a kind of religion
that he detested. Einstein's idea of religion was completely distinct from what Islam
stands for. Islam is not in harmony with science. It is against it and therefore it is not the
kind of natural religion that Einstein was talking about. It is the opposite of it. When
Einstein said science without religion is lame he was not speaking of Islam which is a
blind religion that opposes science.
Rahmanhadiq; Einstein did not say that he adheres to a particular religion, but at least
he can respect and appreciate the religious people with his words very wisely conveyed
in an inaugural speech when he received the Nobel prize in 1921. This means that
Einstein is able to think clearly with his heart to respect the rights of others so he
appreciated by all the nations and other human on this earth. Unlike the KSW is that in
addition to anti-religion, but he also hated all those who have a religion and a more
sadistic again this KSW to sow hatred among religious communities. After witnessing the
seeds hatred thrives in the hearts of people who consumed the issue and the idea of
race-lamb, then he would clap their hands watching Christians and Muslims clashed with
each other.
KSW is to take literature from books that are not written by Eisten, but cites the opinion of
his friends who had nominated inconsequential news, that his friend who claimed Eisten
interviewed during his live. The information he got from the internet show his gang as
well. While DR Naik take these wise words that are ever spoken pearls of wisdom and in
immortalized by Eisten to all the famous people who never heard it. Speech by Einstein
it will not be obsolete by the rain and not cracked by the heat, it remains immortal words
all of time. While the speeches delivered by the KSW is always cause hurt feelings that
people who hear it. KSW mouth like a sewer water splashes that spread of bad smell
everywhere. Speech and incitement KSW will always cause divisions and clashes
between religious communities. Satan King of the World title in nominated is deserved for
him. Ali Sina deserved the Nobel prize was awarded to category Human figure in the
field of Hatred and pit. Ali Sina is predestinated as KSW by his Creator.
(Dr. Naik) Let me remind you that the Glorious Qur’an is not a book of Science…S-C-I-E-N-
C-E, It is a book of signs S-I-G-N-S… It is a book of Ayats. And there more than 6000 signs…
Ayats in the Glorious Qur’an out of which more than a thousand speak about science. As far
as my talk regarding Qur’an and Science is concerned, I will only be speaking about scientific
facts, which has been established. I will not be speaking about scientific hypothesis and
theories, which are based on assumption without any proof, because we all know many a
times science takes U-turns.
Dr. William Campbell who wrote a reply to the book of Dr. Maurice Bucaille… ‘The Qur’an and
the Bible in the light of history and science’ - He says in his book, that there are two types of
approaches. One is a concordance approach - Which means a person tries to bring
compatibility between the Scripture and science. And the other is the conflict approach, in
which a person tries to bring a conflict between Scripture and science, like how Dr. William
Campbell has done very well. But as far as the Qur’an is concerned, irrespective whether a
person uses a conflicting approach, or a concordance approach – As long as you are logical,
and after a logical explanation is given to you, not a single person will be able to prove a
single Verse of the Qur’an, in conflict with established modern science.
Dr. William Campbell has pointed out various alleged scientific errors in the Qur’an, and I am
supposed to actually refute in the rebuttal. But since he chose to speak first, I will be refuting
a few points in my talk - I will reply to the major part of his talk, mainly dealing with
Embryology and with Geology. The remaining InshaAllah, InshaAllah, I will try my level best
to reply in the rebuttal.
I have to do both - I cannot do injustice to the topic. The topic is… ‘Qur’an and Bible in the
light of Science.’ I cannot only speak about one Scripture - Dr. William Campbell hardly spoke
about one or two points about the Bible, which I will deal with InshaAllah. I will speak about
both InshaAllah, - I want to do justice to the topic.
(Ali Sina) Up to here is introduction and promises. From hereon he begins with his

The Big Bang in the Quran?
(Dr. Naik) As far as Qur’an and modern Science is concerned, in the field of ‘Astronomy’, the
Scientists, the Astronomers, a few decades earlier, they described, how the universe came
into existence - They call it the ‘Big Bang’. And they said… ‘Initially there was one primary
nebula, which later on it separated with a Big Bang, which gave rise to Galaxies, Stars, Sun
and the Earth, we live in.’ This information is given in a nutshell in the Glorious Qur’an, in
Surah Ambiya, Ch. 21, Verse No. 30, which says…. (Arabic).... Do not the unbelievers see…?
…. (Arabic)…. ‘That the heavens and the earth were joined together, and we clove them
asunder?’ Imagine this information which we came to know recently, the Qur’an mentions 14
hundred years ago.
(Ali Sina) In his fervor to make the Quran look scientific Dr. Naik overlooks the fact that the
theory of Big Bang precludes the concept of creation. If the Big Bang is true then the story of
the creation and Adam and Eve must be false and vice versa.
Dr. Naik should have at least studied the theory of the Big Bang before commenting about it.
The theory of the Big Bang stipulates that about 13.7 billion years ago a tremendous
explosion started the universe. Prior to that event all of the energy that was later
transformed into matter was contained at one infinitely small point (not nebula). This
explosion, not only gave birth to the particles that gave birth to the matter, but also to space
and time.
Rahmanhadiq; in his fantasy, KSW imagined that the universe is not just happen without
cause and without any purpose. He thinks that the stupid people who perform the ritual
worship for the Creator of this nature only. He considers the process of creation is just a hoax
in which no reason and not quality. He thinks that he is more worthy of worship than what is
revered by followers of the religion anywhere in this world. KSW is just believe in the things
that are material and otherwise throw out things that are non-material that can not be
proved with his reason. So any evidence or theories that explained to him, then he would not
trust even reject it. He will reject anything out of evidence submitted by the religious
community, especially the most hated of the Islamic community. Naturally, if he would look
for other arguments are suitable according to his reason to refute the explanation given by
the great man who feared by him “ Naik DR”. KSW concluded that universe was occurred from the
explosion from a very small element (may be from an atom or a bacteria) and then transformed into a
vast universe that unaccounted extent and amount. Thus KSW thinking about this the Big Bang theory. He
does not believe that this universe originated from Nebula. According to the fake Professor that the
unlimited universe is derived from the breakdown of smallest atomic nuclei. I do not know where he got
these weird science. Of course very unrealistic postulate Professor Ali Sina from the descriptions verses of
the Qur'an. Proved that the KSW invent a story by the way of his own thoughts.)
Big Bang actually consisted of an explosion inside the room itself was not such a bomb blast
in which fragments fly out. All galaxies are not clumped together / united, but rather the Big
Bang set the foundations for the universe. Hence the idea of "separating heaven and earth" is
The Big Bang actually consisted of an explosion of space within itself unlike an explosion of a
bomb were fragments are thrown outward. The galaxies were not all clumped together, but
rather the Big Bang lay the foundations for the universe. Therefore the notion of “separating
the heaven and the earth” is meaningless. (Rahmanhadiq; context of the heavens and the
earth in the Qur'an is one unit that shows the universe itself. Not like that is in the KSW of
this subterfuge, which makes interpretation of the meaning of blurring of the Qur'an that it
has become a target to destroyed).
This is how the Big Bang took place

Furthermore, how can this tiny planet of ours be separate from the universe? Our Earth is a
planet of one of the billions of galaxies that comprise the universe. In the following photo you
can see a small portion of the universe. The galaxies are scattered everywhere. Each galaxy
contains several hundred billion stars. The earth is a planet revolving around one of the stars
that comprise our galaxy, known as The Milky Way. Where is the separation between the
heavens and the Earth?

This is what the Qur'an says:
21:30, ‘The heavens and the earth were joined together, and we clove them asunder’

(Rahmanhadiq; this verse indicates a truth that fits with the basic principles of Big Bang
theory, which was once the earth is a unity of the Universe who later underwent separation
to form the universe as we see today. Unlike the unity in KSW mind that united his hatred
with sly).
This is not an allusion to the Big Bang. It is the rehashing of the Genesis:

And God said. "Let there be an expanse between the waters to separate water Irom water."
God made the expanse and separated the water under the expanse Irom the water above it. And it
was so.
God called the expanse "sky." And there was evening. and there was morning—the
second day. Gen 1: 6-9

So if this is a miracle, the credit should go to the Bible and not to the Qur'an. This fable,
like many others, is borrowed from the Bible. 0
(Rahamhadiq; many particulars between the Bible and the Quran which have in
common, this suggests that the two books were ever derived from the same author is
from the creator of this Universe. So did the Gospel with the Torah also has much in
common. Human that clear and fair-minded will take the wisdom of this fact. While KSW
utilize this point for their own interests which is to incite the two sides to boast and boast
his book and so each seed planted to berate each other.) .
However, the origin of this tale dates back to pre biblical stories of Babylonians and
The Qur'an is full of legends borrowed from the Bible and the fables of the Pagan Arabs.
These in turn were based on the myths of ancient Sumerians, Babylonians, Canaanites,
etc. Muhammad’s cosmology is the cosmology of the ancient people. In pre-Hebrew
Semitic myth two watery tumultuous beings, one male and one female, Apsu (sweet
water) and Tiamat (salt water) give birth to a variety of sea monsters and gods. In the
ensuing chaos Tiamat, the female creator, tries to take control. Her descendants unite
against her, choosing one of their number - Marduk, the god of Babylon to lead them.
Armed with a hurricane and riding a tempest drawn by four fiery steeds, Marduk meets
Tiamat and her evil accomplice Kingu in battle. He kills them both.

The great god Marduk slaying Tiamat the dragon goddess of salt water. She is the personification of the
Untame, Primeval Forces of the Universe before established order and the mother of all gods.
After the death of Tiamat her conqueror forms the heavens and the earth by cutting her
body open "like a cockleshell" and lifting up one half to form the sky while leaving the
bottom half as the earth:
"The lord rested; he gazed at the huge body, pondering how to use it, what to create
from the dead carcass. He split it apart like a cockleshell; with the upper half he
constructed the arc of sky, he pulled down the bar".
(Rahmanhadiq; it seem thought deceitful KSW once, he thought that the testimony in
the book of the Al Qur’an is a fictional story. And he wants to change the views human
beings that so religious books that exist in the world today. And he just convey gossips
that lead to division among religious people on the earth. He wants to combine his
hatred lies with the emotion itself.)
So clearly Muhammad is not talking about the big bang. He is rehashing a biblical tale
that was borrowed from ancient mythology.
You can read more on this subject here
21:30 presents also another problem. It contradicts with the verse 41.11
"Moreover He comprehended in His design the sky. and it had been (as) smoke: He said to it and
to the earth: "Come ye together. willingly or unwillingly." They said: "We do come (together).
in willing obedience."
(Rahmanhadiq; Apparently the KSW did not understand a word parable and metaphor. It is
caused that he was not able to use his Ieel and magnanimity as owned by a normal human
Iigure. II it is said to him that this verse contain the meaning oI the parable. then oI course this
KSW will reiect it. because he does not have the view in that direction. His Ieel already blind oI
the Ilavor to value oI truth Irom the deepest in-depths oI his heart).
OI Course . Grammatical delivered by the Creator in the Qur'an is Iull oI meaning and easily
understandable by those clodhopper and clean heart oI scholars. KSW oI course will not be able
to understand it because the Ieelings and conscience have been accumulated all kinds oI dirt
Irom hazardous waste and toxic oI goods materials).
So which story is the right tale of the creation? Were the heaven and the earth joined
together and Allah clove them asunder or were they apart and Allah told them to come
Of course both are false. The earth is inside the sky and part of it. They can neither
come together nor separate. The Qur'an gives us two versions of the creation that
contradict each other and both are scientifically wrong.
(Rahmanhadiq; KSW thought was so funny. He asked some questions that are
alternative, but then the question was answered by the piece by refusing to answer
both questions at once. "Both of them wrong," as the style of his language. However,
if the above verses more scrutiny will have a profound meaning, that the phrase
"Heaven and Earth" is something of unity, the unity of the universe. Proverbial that
KSW is thinking "What Chicken Eggs or earlier?" and then he denied and answered
for himself that no There were present ahead of the two. For reasons wich he still would
reject any truth values are submitted to him. In the fact that he would never accept the
truth that is in some books of any religion, especially the book of the Qur'an).
Does the Quran say the Sun and the Moon Revolve Around Their Own Axis?
(Dr. Naik) When I was in school, I had learned that the Sun in respect to the Earth - it was
stationary - the Earth and the Moon, they rotated about in axis, but the sun was stationary.
But when I read a Verse of the Qur’an saying, in Surah Al–Ambiya, Ch. . 21 Verse No. 33, it
says…. (Arabic). … ‘It is Allah who has created the night and the day.’…. (Arabic)…. The sun
and the moon…. (Arabic)…. Each one traveling in an orbit with its own motion. Now
Alhamdulillah, modern science has confirmed the Qur’anic statement. The Arabic word used
in the Qur’an is ‘Yasbahoon’, which describes the motion of a moving body. When it refers
to a celestial body, it means it is rotating about its own axis. So Qur’an says the sun and
the Moon, they revolve as well as rotate about their own axis. Today we have come to know
that the Sun takes approximately 25 days to complete one rotation.
(Ali Sina) Dr. Naikr claims that the verse 21:33 which says the sun and the moon follow
their orbits means they rotate around their axis because the word َ نُ َ ْ َ yasbahun
means rotating around its own axis. This is simply not true. Dr. Naik is fabricating
evidence and twisting the meaning of the words. Yasbahoon means swimming. The
word here implies that the Sun and the Moon float in the sky around the Earth and not
around their own axis. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW thought this was awesome, he imagined
that each of the floating or moving among the billions of stars in the vast space, not
rotating on its axis. KSW is to imagine that the earth, moon, sun and star clusters and
planets were just swimming alone in the vast space.
AL Quran does not provide some data from a celestial body which is rotating and which
does not rotate so that the man must examine His own. The sun in the Qur'an stated is
as celestial bodies that circulate in an orbit ("all (the celestial bodies) swim along, each
in its rounded course in an orbit."), This is true when viewed from Earth, but not when
viewed from other constellations. And the Quran also said that " Thou seest the
mountains and thinkest them firmly fixed: but they shall pass away as the clouds pass
away ", Well now a fair use of reason to understand the meaning of the sentence verse,
because verse is submitted to the Arab people are ignorant of that era. Now we would
have to signal the sentence with great wisdom with a wider meaning. Proved that the
verse does not contradiction with the current understanding of astronomy. Conversely
KSW imagine himself swimming in a sea of his own excrement is very wide and he did
not want to know where to save himself, so he was forced to swim hiccup in his water
This is what Muhammad observed and this is what he said. He stated what was
obvious to him and to everyone else in his time who had no understanding of how the
solar system works (Rahmanhadiq; KSW imagined that the prophet Muhammad as an
expert astronomer who lived in the days of this millenium century, so he thought that
Muhammad was the real astrology experts, KSW is a professor of astronomy that would
explain his knowledge to Muhammad. Apparently Professor Ali Sina is going to come
back to 15 centuries ago to explain the astronomical science to the Arabic people who
did not knew astronomy like as today. And on the Earth was round and rotates on its
axis only, the new believe in 16 centuries by Nicolaus Copernicus at 1533 AD , and the
earth rotated on the Sun believe after at this 17th century by Galileo. According that
the Qur'an always precedes human scientific discovery)..
See how this word is translated.
They Iloat. each in an orbit.
swim along. each in its rounded course.
each in an orbit Iloating.
all (orbs) travel along swiItly in their celestial spheres.
Sher Ali
each gliding along smoothly in its orbit.
each Iloating in its own orbit.
each swimming in a sky.
each Iloating in a sky.
each moving swiItly in its sphere.
|the celestial bodies| move swiItly. |each| in |its respective| orb.
As one can see, Dr. Naik is in error. By bundling the Moon and the Sun together, it is
clear that Muhammad thought they are alike with one being brighter than the other
(Rahmanhadiq; this verse was down ward at 15 centuries ago, while discussing was
happened at 15th centuries after, then that Dr Naik might give a different meaning, but
in principle the moon and the sun is a celestial body that floats and swims in a sea of
vast space, so the statement The Qur'an does not infringe the fact. But KSW is looking
for a gap to create doubts to mankind, Yeah! This is a vicious traits that are always
hostile to mankind).
Fifty-seven Muslim majority countries have an average of ten universities each for a total of
less than 600 universities for 1.4 billion people; India has 8,407 universities, the U.S. has
5,758. From within 1.4 billion Muslims Abdus Salam and Ahmed Zewail are the only two
Muslim men who won a Nobel Prize in physics and chemistry (Salam pursued his scientific
work in Italy and the UK , Zewail at California Institute of Technology). Dr Salam in his
home country is not even considered a Muslim.
Over the past 105 years, 1.4 billion Muslims have produced eight Nobel Laureates while a
mere 14 million Jews have produced 167 Nobel Laureates. Of the 1.4 billion Muslims less
than 300,000 qualify as 'scientists', and that converts to a ratio of 230 scientists per one
million Muslims. The United States of America has 1.1 million scientists (4,099 per million);
Japan has 700,000 (5,095 per million).
A quick calculation reveals that the likelihood that a Jew wins the Noble Prize is 2088
times higher than a Muslim winning it. If all the science is in the Qur'an why all the
Muslims are so backward?
One of these eight "Muslim" Noble Prize winners is the Egyptian novelist Naguib
Mahfouz. One of his best known works, Children of Gebelawi (1959), has been banned
in Egypt for alleged blasphemy. In 1994 at the age of 82 yrs Mahfouz was stabbed by a
man of Allah. When asked if he has ever read any of Mahfouz's books, the servant of
Allah responded: "I never read any of his filthy books". (Rahmanhadiq; this is what the
tactics and strategy to pit the human race, the first of all he generates a sense of boast
or a sense of pride from the class of people,and then humiliate the other class people,
after the bait was consumed for those who incited then he hostilities immediately set fire
by him so that people will rise up feeling humiliated their emotions. If the person was
emotionally humiliated, then this KSW smiled seeing the movie, and he's ready to pour
gasoline so that the fire was quickly growing. After that there will be strife, slander each
other , blasphemy each other, mocking each other, so he make facility to chided each
other directly or provide the best arena to fight. It is a debate forum which he called the
FFI is located at www.faithfreedom.org. Where this site is a battle arena, facilitated by
the KSW with a lot of sponsors behind it. KSW is acting as a facilitator, provocateur,
moderators, mediators, promoters as well as the main trainer in the battle that was
disgusting fighting. KSW was feeling very proud of the results of his work after seeing
the millions of humans who had eaten his goat and war all-out without a stop there. Of
course the King of Devils is a lot of benefit from the ingathering of his labor, not only
from advertising but also from political destruction of religion, where secular countries is
not like the rules of religion to gain material adverse impact and their trade . They
assume that religion is an obstacle to progress and world trade, especially Islamic
religious believers who are very fanatical about their religion. In fact they hate the
religion of Islam that have sharia law which is contrary to their concept. Only the religion
of Islam which have yet to be mastered by the desire them, they are not able to weaken
the Islamic religion and its adherents are very fast to his faith. Instead they have
managed to weaken and castrated other religious and hinder them. Living Islam the
only religion that still survive and the strong belief in ummah, if Islam can be destroyed
or annihilated then people like KSW will surely rule the world and destroy anyone who
opposed his desire, where the value of goodness and truth value will vanish from this
earth's surface. Later there will be no longer value truth, justice and compassion in
between fellow human beings, where human will grow under the shadow of desire
deceitful men like this KSW. Of course they hate Islam and adherents. To fight Islamic
frankly they have no good reason, so that through this KSW is they work hard to quickly
achieve their desires. They surrounded the religious ideology of Islam from all over to
fight, harass, humiliate and advocates against the Islamic peoples. It is clear that the
KSW is much to benefit themselves the mission of this magnitude. So actually, this
KSW as the ringleader of a large his shown Plays, he was the puppeteer of all hostility
and unrest among the religious people in this world. But how foolish we as religious
people incited by his political to pit the human race. Ali Sina as type Fir'un this
millenium century.)
Does the Quran say the Universe is Expanding?
(Dr. Naik) It was Edvin Hubbel who discovered that the universe is expanding. The
Qur’an says in Surah Dhariyat, Ch. 51, Verse No. 47, that…‘We have created the expanding
universe’ - The vastness of space. The Arabic word ‘Mohsiana’ refers to ‘vastness’ – ‘the
expanding universe.’
Regarding the topics on Astronomy, which Dr. William Campbell touched, I will deal in the
rebuttal, InshaAllah.
(Ali Sina) Dr. Naik claims that the verse 51:47 talks about the expanding universe. This
is not so. Muhammad is simply saying that the universe is vast and not that it is
expanding. This verse reads:
ُ -َ ' '´ -ِ إَ و ٍ -ْ -َ 'ِ - 'َ ه'َ -ْ -َ -َ - ء'َ -´ -'اَ و َ ن·ُ ·ِ -·
See how this is translated:
YUSUFALI: With power and skill did We construct the Firmament: for it is We Who
create the vastness of pace.
PICKTHAL: We have built the heaven with might, and We it is Who make the vast
extent (thereof).
SHAKIR: And the heaven, We raised it high with power, and most surely We are the
makers of things ample.
The fact that the universe is vast is prosaic and obvious. There is no mention of
expanding universe in this verse. Any illiterate man could look around himself and see
the world is vast. To the ancient people even the Earth looked vast. To us it looks very
small. Some modern translators of the Quran have tried to give a scientific spin to the
Quran and have translated the word continuity stating that the universe is expanding.
This is not true. The word َ نُ ِ ُ has no such connotation
Whatever the translation of the meaning and significance that the universe is "Board" or
"Extend” or Dilated," as that imposed by KSW, the notion that too in accordance with
reality as seen by the people of this century. Because the universe is indeed very vast,
and even until now no one man could calculate the extent, even with the most
advanced equipment of any kind.
So in this case Al Qur'an does not tell lies in accordance with the broad sense of the
word. And if the word َ نُ ِ ُ means "broad" was interpreted as the verb "extend" and
indeed all official commentary from Islamic countries justifying that the word َ نُ ِ ُ
means the verb is Spreads. In this latest astronomical science (Hubble) to prove that
the universe is moving more and more widespread after observed during 50 years of
this. Even according to the theory of the observed expansion of space and is supported
by Hubble shows that most stars are shifted towards the infrared rays which means the
stars will continue to move away from this earth. In this case the Qur'an also says do
not lie. The statement revealed it has been perpetuated long before discovered the
theory of the Universe expansion by astronomers. This means that the Qur'an was
ahead of human invention.
And much more declaration of Al Qur'an that conflicted by the mouths of nosy like this
KSW proved and then blocking his mock-challenged or ribbing . AL Quran is the only
book which states that the universe is broad and increasingly widespread. Similarly, the
widespread sense of resentment KSW to the verses of Qur'an that can not enter in his
reason. KSW is feeling great and just think that the universe is static and not
expanding. KSW like swimming across the breadth of the universe as explained above
Water Cycle in the Quran?
(Dr. Naik) In the field of ‘Water cycle’ that Dr. William Campbell pointed out, certain
things. The Qur’an describes the water cycle in great detail. And Dr. William Campbell
mentioned 4 stages. In his book he mentions 4 (a) and (b) - the last one he did not
mention in the slide - I don’t know why? It says... ‘The Driplinition’…‘The Water table.’ He
missed out here - Maybe because it was not mentioned in the Bible. He said there is not a
single Verse in the Qur’an, which speaks about ‘evaporation.’ Qur’an says in Surah Al-Tariq,
Ch. No. 86, Verse No. 11, that….(Arabic)…. ‘By the capacity of the heavens to return.’ And
almost all the commentaries of the Qur’an - they said, that this Verse of Surah Tariq, Ch.
No. 86, Verse No. 11, refers to the capacity of the heavens to return back rain - meaning
(Ali Sina) I don’t know which commentator said such a thing but if anyone has, he is
mistaken. Let us read the first part of this Sura:
086.001 By the Sky and the Night-Visitant (therein);-
086.002 And what will explain to thee what the Night-Visitant is?-
086.003 (It is) the Star oI piercing brightness;-
086.004 There is no soul but has a protector over it.
086.005 Now let man but think Irom what he is created!
086.006 He is created Irom a drop emitted-
086.007 Proceeding from between the backbone and the ribs:
086.008 Surely (Allah) is able to bring him back (to liIe)!
086.009 The Day that (all) things secret will be tested.
086.010 (Man) will have no power. and no helper.
086.011 By the Firmament which returns (in its round).
The entire Sura is gibberish. It just makes so sense. You can hardly find any text as
obtuse as this. (unless you look in the Quran.) Let us use our intelligence and see if we
can make and sense of it.
1) It appears that Muhammad is saying that each person has a star that protects him.
This is fairytale fit for children. (Rahmanhadiq; here clearly visible gibberish KSW is
not able to use the clear mind to understand what is written in the verse of the Qur'an.
Yet there is no sentence which says that Muhammad is protected by a star on the
verse. There are his boasting only. Meaning sense of this KSW thought suitable only for
rancid swashbuckler who do not understand anything. Basis of the KSW job just to
make people hurt, and a sense of satisfaction will come when people feel sick with his
words. Looks like KSW has a psychopath disease which can no longer be cured by
medication and therapy whatsoever.)
2) Then he says that man is created from the emitted drop, (semen). But we now know
that 50% of a child’s genes come from her mother.
(Rahmanhadiq; KSW of course not created by the emission of semen or sperm from
his the father, but he created from the flames of hatred and cunning fire. KSW is truly
evil figure who masquerade as humans to weaken the faith of religious adherents. He
said not with his brain but with the intention own rottenness. Whereas all normal men
who had intercourse must have felt shooting his sperm into the womb of his wife.
Qur'anic verse mentioned above have not touched on about gene or a mother's egg
cell, because in those days of medical science or Embryologi not exist at all and any
body does not know that women also have an egg. The paragraph could be understood
by anyone in the days of ignorance first. So the Qur'an information in accordance with
reality and not a lie. Not like this KSW is always present his cunning).
3) Then he absurdly claims that semen proceeds from between the backbone and the
ribs. This is also false. Sperms are created in the testicles. This is not scientific.
(Rahmanhadiq: Human taste this passion only know how to enjoy lust with a voracious
ego attitude . The context Al Qura'an verses above are not told about the production of
sperm cells. But these verses describe how the sperm or semen was emitted. Bones
backbone loin is located at the lower of backbone. Right at the top of the coccyx have a
point or center point of stimulation is called G-Stimulus. In women, the point G-stimulus
there are about as deep as the index finger in the vaginal area, while in men there are
as deep as half the index finger from the rectum . That's the center of the strongest
stimuli that possessed by humans. If this point gets a good stimulus in the form of
friction or by the influence of sex imagination, then the nerve impulses to the brain will
immediately instruct the testes to produce sperm strong enough to be fired. While in the
sternum are the heart organ ready to pump blood into the penile shaft as much as
possible at the time of ejaculation or sperm production at its peak. So with the
stimulation experienced by women when aroused strong G region which can result in
orgasm or satisfaction of the peak. Both of Ejaculation and Orgasm can accelerate the
convergence of sperm cells with egg cells that are embedded deep within the womb.
Sperm cells emit less powerful will be difficult to penetrate the barriers that are along
the canal to the uterus. In this case the role of organs in the chest cavity becomes very
dominant. Among them are stirred up incredible passion, or lust increasing sexual
desire, desire that increasingly drive the passionate heart triggering and increasingly
tight and increasingly tense muscles that cause the more rapid the blood flow to the
penis to increase the quality of erections and so ready to fire in the sperm of seeds that
have been produced in the testes. Without cooperation between the important organs in
the chest, such as cardiac and respiratory rhythms with a maximal stimulating to require
testicular sperm, the sperm jets will not be perfect. So the Al Qur'an is not wrong to say
that among the breast bone and tail bone are inter-organ influence the process of
transmitting the sperm.)
4) Then he gives assurance that after people die and their bodies have become dust,
they will come back to life. This is simply ludicrous.
(Rahmanhadiq;, of course, if the KSW is to die later, his body was not going to be dust,
or become the bones. But his body will be preserved in international museums to be
witnessed by the next generation as an example only instigator evil man who ever
existed on this Earth. Earth will not be willing to accept his bones. His body will be
preserved and displayed side by side together near the bodies of Ramses ).
5) Why they come back to life?... To be judged and to receive their punishments and
rewards. So Muhammad did not believe in the survival of the soul. He thought the same
bodies that are buried or eaten by animals and worms will come back to life and the
punishments and rewards are all carnal and material.
(Rahmanhadiq; KSW is thought that after he made the sick hearts of all people and
make the people of Islam and Christianity with the political recriminations and to pit the
human race, then he still free of state law that would charge him. He thinks that, there
will be no single State Law to impose sanctions against such to his crimes. So how can
the human race can Demand that crime has ever done so far? And if humans were
contemporaries with KSW has been dead all, and to whom they have ever been
wronged by the KSW will be Demand justice? He thinks that after he died later, nothing
will be demanded more, he felt free from all mistakes. It seems that justice will never
exist in this world and he is free from any claim.
Know that after all the people of muslim contemporaries die, they will take proceeding
justice to the creator of this Universe, only He can serve as a handle to a judge who will
follow up these pit the human race when he is still alive in the world before. Of course
KSW would not be able to resist their own fate, surely he too would die and felt the
torment before facing death. So be patient, yeah! believers, God is suspending
punishment for him, as stated in the last paragraph in the letter of the Al-Qur’an above
that is " Therefore grant a delay to the Unbelievers: Give respite to them gently (for
awhile)". Human life in this world is not long, only a fraction of seconds when compared
with the lifetime of this nature before the Day of Judgement. So to be patient.)
6) Then he swears “by the Firmament which returns (in its round)”. Firmament is the
stars, the sun and the moon, not vapor and rain. Muhammad saw that every night the
stars are coming back and every day the Sun is returning. These heavenly objects were
known as the firmament. This verse has nothing to do with evaporation and rain. Please
pay attention how often Dr. Naik twists the meanings of the words to make his point
prevail. The word used is 'sama'. It means sky/heaven and it can also be interpreted as
firmament but it can't be translated as rain.
All we need to discard the Qur'an as a book of God is one error. Only in these few
verses we found at least six.
(Rahmanhadiq; The God did not swears by sentences ““by the Firmament which
returns (in its round)”. KSW is lie! However Allah swears by sentences on verses 18:1-
3 that written by “By the Sky and the Night-Visitant (therein); And what will explain to
thee what the Night-Visitant is?- (It is) the Star of piercing brightness;-“. KSW wanted to
teach Muslims about the interpretation of the Qur'an was, but so far he's constantly
trample and humiliate Al Qur'an for no apparent reason, he could only show a sense of
hatred and malice alone.
ِ ءَ ّ َ اَ و = And (by) the sky
ِ تاَ ذ = To whom there is / there are / contain
ِ ْ ّ َ ا = Rain / water droplets thereof (the sky)
So says the sky and said rain in the verse completely separate and not equal spelling.
But the strange minded KSW according with his imagine to make it equal.
While the swears of God who delivered at verses above suggests that, when the
moment came early evening, or before sunset, or before the time of sunset, will come
and see the various stars that glow that the sun rays can penetrate, whereas stars was
far behind the sun.
("By the Sky and the Night-Visitant (therein);- And what will explain to thee what the
Night-Visitant is?- (It is) the Star of piercing brightness;- "). This indicates that these
stars have their own light. unlikely that the star is a reflection of the sun's rays, because
of its distance behind the light source is sunlight. For comparison, also observe the
planet Venus who also shines. But it will be visible after the sun began to set, which
Venus light will vary with the star's light from deep behind the sun. This means that the
star also has its own light that is not dependent on sunlight. Try to compare it with the
light of the moon or other planets ray luminous only when reflecting the sun. A scholar
who would understand the verse with great thankfulness to the God. Because this is a
little hint about the properties of light emitted by the Sun and stars. This is a hidden clue
for people who want to think clearly.
Instead KSW will always ridicule the truth, maybe he knew it. It was obvious that he
was trying to hide the truth behind the malice and hatred.
(Dr. Naik) Dr. William Campbell who knows Arabic, may say…‘Why did not Allah
Subhanawa Taala specifically mention….(Arabic) …. Meaning… ‘The capacity of the heavens
to return back rain.’ Why did not Allah mention specifically? Now we have came to know
why did not Allah do that, in His Divine wisdom. Because today we have came to know that
besides - the Ozonosphere… the layer above the earth - Besides returning back rain, it even
returns back other beneficial matter and energy of the Earth, which is required by the
human beings. It does not only return back rain - Today we have come to know, it even
returns back waves of Telecommunication, of Television, of Radio, by which we can see TV,
we can communicate, we can hear the radio. And besides that, it even returns back the
harmful rays of the outer space, back on the other side, and absorbs. For example the sun
light… the ultraviolet rays of the Sun light is absorbed by the Ionosphere. If this was not
done, life on the Earth would have ceased to exist. So Allah Subhanawataala is far superior
and for more accurate, when He says…. (Arabic)…. By the capacity of the Heaven to return.’
And the remaining things as he mentioned is there in the Qur’an - You can refer to my
Videocassette. The Qur’an describes the ‘Water cycle’ in great detail.
(Ali Sina) Wow! What a great logic. Why the Quran does not talk about the stage of
evaporation? …Because Ozonosphere returns other beneficial matters such as radio
waves too. That is why!
Instead of answering the question, Dr. Naik tries to distract his audience by talking
about red herring and by introducing non sequitor arguments.
But wait a minute! Didn't Dr. Naik say that "the Firmament which returns" is about the
capacity of heavens to return back rain? Obviously Dr. Naik could not even convince
himself. After assuring us that "almost all the commentaries of the Qur’an - they said, that
this Verse of Surah Tariq, Ch. No. 86, Verse No. 11, refers to the capacity of the heavens to
return back rain - meaning ‘Evaporation’", he goes on to give us the reason why Allah did
not mention this stage in the Quran. Come on Doctor! Don't make this too easy for me.

Rahmanhadiq; the KSW really do not understand at all with what has been explained
by Professor DR Naik magnitude .. Ali Sina is disadvantaged students among other
students, so that he never graduated from college matter ever given by Dr Naik, why he
hated this great teacher. His heart really disobedience on this one. For that,
rahmanhadiq will help the students of this sad for the next examination to graduate with
Is not since beginning last class great teacher Dr. Naik has explained that the verses of
the Qur'an was not a book about . S C I E N C E, but the book S I G N of Signs?.
Qur'anic verses that are basic instructions for people to know more about the
disciplines that will understand further.
Qur'an can be used as signs or directions for humans is not one step to interpret the
science discipline areas later in the future. The Qur'an does not explain in detail about
the technology or science that will be cultivated by humans later. Because human
beings have been equipped by God with reason and intellectual perfection. So problem
on naming an invention or technology to get the results of research and then draw a
conclusion, the Qur'an does not provide an explanation. All men are welcome to study
the universe in accordance with their capabilities and technologies owned. About
Atmosir layered earth and has a function to protect life on earth, was discovered in the
IXX century. While Al qur'an already provide basic instructions since 15 centuries ago
that the air layer above the Earth serves as a roof or a protective and also consists of
various layers which each have determined the function and usefulness. Living humans
who must prove the truth of these verses and examine what are the functions and
usefulness of each layer of the Earth's atmosphere. Does that paragraph statement
false or true to the principles of science and technology that has been carried out by
humans?. And it turns out that paragraph statement did not conflict with what is proven
by science. But the basis of the Ali Sina minded deceitful, he wants Ozonosphere
words written in the Qur'an as well as the use of each should be described in the verses
AL Quran. Pupils are somewhat backward thinking this can only be understood by what
it says, because he was not able to understand the hidden meaning behind this
sentence. In terms of the verses of the Al Qur’an written with many parable, so that the
necessary wisdom and magnanimity philosophical character, a matter that is not owned
at all by this KSW. He must be fed in order to understand with what is written in verse.
But even if he understands so he pretended not to understand and then create another
story that contrary to the understanding of the verse. How to think KSW is like that, if he
did not understand then he would to say that his teacher was Stupid.
However, additional tutoring is certainly not a lot of help and even cause the KSW is
getting confused and dazed. And in the next semester of college would fall again.
Finally he was at the Drop-out from campus DR Naik who has a lot to give lessons
Philosophy of Truth. But a few years later he appeared again to against DR Naik
teacher after studying with the kings of demons on the ocean floor. Now he's got big
balls to beat the teacher in order to avenge . KSW is already feeling very confident with
the stock of voodoo that he taken out of the King of devil in Pacific Ocean.)

(Dr. Naik) Regarding what he said about the Bible, he showed stage 1 and stage 3 in the
first slide, and in the second stage 1, 3, and then 2. ‘That the rain water is taken up’… he
says… ‘and then the rain water comes down on the Earth.’ This is the philosophy of
Phasofmillitas, in 7
century BC. He thought that the spray of the ocean was picked up by
the wind, and send to the interior as rain. There is no cloud mentioned there. In the
second quotation Dr. William Campbell gave - First is, according to him, ‘evaporation’ which
we agree. We don’t mind having the concordance approach with the Bible. ‘…Then rain falls
down, and then are the clouds formed.’ - That is not the complete water cycle.
Alhamdulillah, the Qur’an describes the water cycle in great detail, in several places. How
does the water rise, evaporates, forms into clouds - the clouds join together, they stalk up,
there is thunder and lightning, water comes down, the clouds move into the interior, they
fall down as rain, and the evaporation of the water table and Alhamdulillah in great detail.
The Qur’an speaks about the water cycle in great detail, in several places. In Surah Nur,
Ch. No. 24, Verse No. 43, in Surah Rum, Ch. No. 30, Verse 48, in Surah Al-Zumar, Ch. 39,
Verse 21, in Surah Muminun, Ch. 23, Verse 18, in Surah Rum Ch. No. 30, Verse No. 24, in
Surah Al-Hijr, Ch. 15, Verse No. 22, in Surah Araf Ch. No. 7, Verse No. 57, in Surah Rad,
Ch. No. 13, Verse No. 17, in Surah Furqan, Ch. 25, Verse No. 48 and 49, in Surah Fatir, Ch.
No. 35, Verse No. 9, in Surah Yasin, Ch. 36, Verse No. 34, in Surah Jathiya, Ch. 45, Verse
No. 5, in Surah Qaf, Ch. No. 50, Verse No. 9, in Surah Al-Waqiah, Ch. No. 56, Verse No. 68
and 70, in several places, Surah Al-Mulk,Ch. 67, Verse No. 30, the Glorious Qur’an speaks
about the ‘Water cycle’, in great detail.
(Ali Sina) Here is where Dr. Naik outperformed himself. His Muslim audience became
ecstatic and started applauding and cheering as if he was a pop singer performing their
favorite number. He said all those verses from memory, like pulling one rabbit after
another out his had. (Rahmanhadiq; scene is intensely disliked by Ali Sina, he does
not like it when there are people who feel a sense of Islam and feel proud of the news
the truth of the verses of the Qur'an, his heart like cut into slices and then bright red
eyes bulged after seeing and hear the people of Islam are satisfied with the news of
truth proclaimed by his former Professor like this. Of course, this KSW is preparing
spells more powerful to voodoo his teacher,) Impressive indeed. Let us quote these
verses and see if there is anything miraculous in them. While you are reading, note how
often Muhammad forgets that the Quran is supposed to be the word of Allah and Allah
should not refer to himself in third person.
(Rahmanhadiq; of course is like a supreme ruler who was delivering His panegyric for
his servants, God will use the words of the full glory of meaning. The word "We" used
by those who deliver in front of the Miraculous His servants, showed that He is the
Biggest and Respected figures in front of His assistants and at the same time we said it
shows the appreciation and respect to all the helpers. As for who can be considered as
an aide hand him among others, those are his angels, His Prophet, the servant whom
the pious servants, and all natural that obedient for Him.
Conversely KSW inappropriate to use the word "We" because it is a respectable word
inappropriate spoken by this man like Ali Sina. In memory of his brain will never find the
word "We" because he was never able to appreciate the man, he is the devil is an
enemy of man.
The word "We" is one of the meanings of identity when the Creator Himself to creation
creature introduced. Not only the word "We" are in use by the Creator in the Qur'an as
his identity to communicate with the creature creation, the others being: God, Him,
Thou, Lord, and His. While the words (God, He, Thee, God and His) that is called by
the KSW as the third person pronoun, is a term that is always spoken by the Angel
Gabriel when he was speaking or delivering the verses of Allah to Muhammad SAW, or
when Gabriel tells of a prophet who is speaking about the name of the Creator to his
Only in the book of the Qur'an alone, the words of the identity of the Creator is more
fully addressed and the introduction to the human race. Placement or naming words
that identity, varies depending on the contents of the context and intent of the Word
verse which He revealed.
YUSUFALI: Seest thou not that Allah |3
person| makes the clouds move gently. then ioins
them together. then makes them into a heap? - then wilt thou see rain issue Iorth Irom their
midst. And He |3
person| sends down Irom the sky mountain masses (oI clouds) wherein is
hail: He |3
person| strikes therewith whom He pleases and He turns it away Irom whom He
pleases. the vivid Ilash oI His lightning well-nigh blinds the sight.
There is nothing in this verse that requires any knowledge beyond what was possessed
by any primitive man. Muhammad is stating his own observation that was clear to
(Rahmanhadiq; Actually, the KSW is not capable to lie the truth of the description
verse above, but he still to jape. Actually he was not to mock those verses, but he was
a fool of himself. None of the above verse description that can be rebutted either by the
man lay, as well as by scientific evidence. But KSW is still violates the truth of the
verse. Because he was not able to see the truth at all . That is in the thoughts and
feelings is a sense of hatred, incitement and to pit the human race. Had no more people
who fought in the arena that already well-developed with great cost, then surely he will
lose and there are many sponsors that money away so that land acquisition would be
difficult to afford him anymore.)
YUSUFALI: It is Allah |3
person| Who sends the Winds. and they raise the Clouds: then does
He spread them in the sky as He wills. and break them into Iragments. until thou seest rain-drops
issue Irom the midst thereoI: then when He |3
person| has made them reach such oI his
servants as He wills behold. they do reioice!-
This is again what anyone can observe and one does not need any scientific
knowledge to witness such a natural phenomenon. However, as for rejoicing for rain,
this is clearly from the point of view of those who don’t see much rain. There are places
on this earth that rain most of the year and people rejoice when there is a day sunshine.
This shows these verses are written by one whose knowledge was limited to Arab
(Rahmanhadiq; any normal human being would justify the notion that verse that
corresponds to the fact that observed by anyone. However, KSW is still not accept the
truth of the verse, he still wanted a clearer explanation of what he's seen so far. KSW
expect that the fall from the sky was not water, but gold or money, so he does not need
to work hard to pit the religious community. Then he felt very jealous of the Arabic
peoples, especially in the city of Mecca which gets no rain, but have abundant wealth
so that people prosper without the cost of advertising campaigns for their tourism. Even
fruits that never grew up in Mecca because of lack of rain, was come to the city like a
flood from all over the world. All of it adds to the hatred, envy and jealousy which
increasingly accumulate in his feelings. Whereas in the Arab States that rain rarely
YUSUFALI: Seest thou not that Allah sends |3
person| down rain Irom the sky. and leads it
through springs in the earth? Then He causes to grow. therewith. produce oI various colours:
then it withers; thou wilt see it grow yellow; then He makes it dry up and crumble away. Truly.
in this. is a Message oI remembrance to men oI understanding.
Does one need to be a scientist or a prophet to know that rain falls from the sky and
that the spring waters are from rain? Everyone knew for millennia that during draughts
springs dry out. Everyone also knew that all vegetations depend on water. Muhammad
is explaining the commonplace and then says it is truly a message of remembrance for
men of understanding. This is nonsense. There is no message in these natural
phenomena. Only those who do not understand the laws of the nature think there is a
message in there.
person plural| send down water Irom the sky according to (due)
measure. and We cause it to soak in the soil; and We certainly are able to drain it oII (with ease).
It is quite clear that water falls from the sky. As for sending the water in due measure,
this is false. Some places on earth get flooded by excess of rain and other places are
parched with draught. Any farmer knows how to irrigate his land better than Allah. “We
cause it to soak in the soil and we are able to drain it off” are just banal statements that
add nothing to human knowledge. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW analysis of the paragraph
above, only limited to his ability to read the text contained that verse. No wonder he did
not graduate, graduated from the courses given teachers DR Naik, so that eventually
he had to Drop-out. He think that the phrase " send down water from the sky
according to (due) measure, "as only the amount of rain that poured out to a place that
can cause flooding and landslides, on the contrary if the amount of rainfall less then
lowered it dry, area. to the extent that his can understand the hidden meaning of the
verse. In fact, he laughed at it as a description paragraph a verse that has no meaning .
Then he pretended to be smart to teach Muslims with verses above. It is as he was the
more worthy of a great teacher replaces DR Naik professor who considers retirement.
In fact the sense of the sentence is much deeper than what can he read from the text.
The size of the water is meant by the verse hints that water that evaporates from the
earth into the atmosphere will condense to form beads of water that is so fine that will
form a large cloud, which then clouds will be rejected by wind in accordance with air
pressure and temperature differences around them. Then the dew that formed it will
continue to grow into water droplets, up to "a certain size or weight" where the water will
fall because of the influence of gravity or other effects that cause the rain was still has
not gone down well or evaporates back. There are several factors that cause a decline
in rainfall such as the thrilling thunder cloud, cloud come to blows between large
groups, the difference in air pressure, temperature and humidity levels in the area. God
had arranged it with a provision or a role that can not be created or modified by
humans. Then it would rain down at random in accordance with the conditions that
allow for the come down in the area. No one man can manage Rain falling in a
particular place with a certain amount expected. God wills it with its provisions. Until
humans now only able to predict where rain will fall, but was unable to determine where
the rain must fall. While KSW is just seeing the size of which meant by the verse is
based on personal profit wich want rain down depending on the place of hope. But he's
still not able to do nothing of the arrangement derivatives rain somewhere. The
sentence that read " ِ ضْر`ا ÷ earth ¸ِ · ÷ in/on ُ -'ّ َ -َ ´ْ -َ 'َ · ÷ hold (“ We made the
water hold on the earth"), interpreted as an ordinary incident to him. He just knew that
farmers can also adjust the water reservoir or by making a dam larger to regulate water
supply to withstand the water. So it's useless he meditated on the ocean floor for
revenge to Master the DR Naik. Because his thinking is still too weak to defeat the
nemesis. For that he should be imprisoned again, not in the ocean but in the heat of the
earth's core center 6000
C for 5000 years. Though the understanding and meaning of
the phrase "We made the water hold on the earth" much deeper than just make a dam
like the one in the mind of the Ideot this. The question is: why water which serve as the
main object in this verse? Are not there other liquids than some water existing on this
earth? This means that water is a liquid substance that has an interesting phenomenon
and is very important compared with other liquids. Take a look at oil or liquid fuel such
as gasoline or diesel fuel and so forth. If this material is allowed to evaporate or burn,
the liquid will be lost and gone, never to return because they have been transformed
into other compounds that can not be returned as usual. Even the liquid fuel is getting
more and more reduced on this earth, and on one day of fuel will be spent by humans
without nothing for our children and grandchildren later. How about if the water also has
properties such as the fuel, which after burning or heated and then he yawned and not
come back into the water, then this earth will drought because the longer the water will
increasingly exhausted or lost into another element or fly into space. But it turns out we
never run out of water on earth, the water on earth is still so much forever. It is like as
the water remain on hold this earth. Water only change phases such as liquid, ice and
steam that never disappeared or been on this earth, as long as the earth was still not
destroyed. Otherwise try to compare with CO2 gas (carbon-dioxide) which increasingly
accumulate in the atmosphere of this earth, causing the greenhouse effect and the
increasing air temperature from year to year due to industrial exhaust emissions, forest
fires and other air pollution.)
YUSUFALI: And among His Signs. |3
person| He shows you the lightning. by way both oI
Iear and oI hope. and He sends down rain Irom the sky and with it gives liIe to the earth aIter it
is dead: verily in that are Signs Ior those who are wise.
This verse contains no explanation about what causes the lightening. Muhammad says
lightening is to frighten people and to give them hope. Is this the scientific explanation
of lightening? Then he states the obvious that the rain falls from the sky, which gives
life to the earth. Then he says this is the sign for those who are wise. No, it is in fact a
sign for those who are foolish. Rain is a natural phenomenon. It is not a sign from
anyone. It just happens on its own thanks to the effect of sun on earth. Fools who have
no understanding of the natural laws think it is as a sign. Further ahead we will see how
Dr. Naik ridicules the Bible for saying that rainbow is a sign from God and explains how
rainbow is formed in a scientific language. So if rainbow is not a sign how can rain be a
sign? Muslims are incapable of seeing the errors of the Quran, even when they can
easily see similar errors in other books.
(Rahmanhadiq; The contents of the head of KSW a very dirty and rotten indeed, even
his own feces he put into his head, so that he no longer knew where the value of a truth
and where the value of malice. He was only able to use their brains these dirty rotten for
pit the human race intention to instill religious communities, especially between
Christians and Muslims who he thinks is the humans who easily made as a goat. He
began rubbing his goods by accusing his teacher to mock fun of the book of the Bible,
so that Christians will be consumed this negative issue. Though the debate between
DR Naik and Dr. Campbell has passed and amongst them there was no hostility at all,
they argue openly and fairly in accordance with their respective expertise. They are the
chosen hero who can remove a sense of hatred and resentment which was witnessed
by people crowded even the entire world. If KSW participate or want to organize an
open debate with DR Naik, he should announce publicly the challenge and a lot of
mediators of Islam or Christianity who are willing to facilitate it. But because of the small
guts and do not dare, so he always be behind back the mask with the pseudonym Ali
Sina. The world feels narrow for him, he felt unsafe in this world, he feels there are
always people who want to follow him or kill him, thus he always avoid himself from the
public. So maybe he did not dare to hold debate openly with Dr. Naik or any other
Islamic clerics in Fair and honest that was attended by all religious people in this world.
Expertise for this KSW is only able to turn out the existing facts, spread hatred and
defamation. His Mouth like a sewer smell the stench spread everywhere, so many fly-
green lava landed and followed him. KSW is only able to assess the extent Qur'anic
verses are written, but he did not understand the hidden meaning and philosophy
behind the verse. The verse is full of parables and allegories or metaphor to knock the
mind rather than the noble-hearted scholars and virtuous character perfectly. While he
defines the phrase " He shows you the lightning, by way both of fear and of hope, " as
the phrase is not meaningful at all and there is no scientific clue anything in it, so he
thought the verse is just a sign for "stupid people who do not understand the law laws of
nature. " He thinks he's smart, but he was only able to understand the verse to the
extent by ordinary natural 'arguments, he did not understand the law of cause and
effect and the law of love. Because of this Too clever Boy think that the nature are
just happen, nothing is set, there is no God as the creator. His egosentric nature does
not Benefits to give anything to the others. He considers that this earth was already in
its hands so that fingers can find and control anywhere in this hemisphere with its
Internet channel. He has never experienced the adventure alone, so he gone in the
jungle, in the middle of the ocean, in the dark and without light at all, in the midst of
heavy rain with lightning flashes, Thunder boomed and interspersed by light striking
lightning, then he was arrogant with his naturally lucky. Likewise with the phrase " He
sends down rain Irom the sky and with it gives liIe to the earth aIter it is dead " is only
understood as a common natural occurrence caused by temperature by sunlight
shining on the earth so that there was rain. He seems to ignore the occurrence of rain
at a time when the middle of the night or in the polar regions that are not illuminated by
sunlight for months, or when in the area of Africa or Australia who drought for months
that caused none of biota to live as if they were asleep in the region it, but after the
rains come, we knew popping back that living creatures that come originally from
somewhere. As if he ignores this extraordinary event at all, maybe he thought that it
was he who should govern this universe.
So the verses above description fits with the discovery of science and natural
occurrence, nothing to the contrary. Though Muhammad never go or surveri into the
countryside to the Continent of Africa or Australia during his lifetime.)
person| send the Iecundating winds. then cause the rain to descend
Irom the sky. therewith providing you with water (in abundance). though ye are not the
guardians oI its stores.
Is here anything that no one at the time Muhammad knew?
(Rahmanhadiq: KSW was also agreed with the description verse above, but this
arrogant man feel ashamed to admit the truth of the above verses, so he's still just
insulting and ridiculing, teasing description verse above. Proved that Ali Sina has a very
dirt heads that filled by not useful matter. Whereas the above verses have been
commemorating the people who do not know for benefits as KSW like this. He was
only able to enjoy the Benefits of water for himself, but he never felt grateful with what
he has to use for free on this earth. He is not concerned with the Creator of the water,
even his body consisting of 90% water, he did not care at all. The Verse above has a
deeper meaning about storage water that could not be done by humans on this earth.
Even the transitional season rainfall only, man can not do anything, let alone determine
the location where the falling rain. If God wills not to restore the water vapor floating in
the atmosphere, then who could return it ?. Does KSW to be a power to think more
than that? Let alone for setting season, the weather or the rain water poured out, even
for himself, he can not do anything about it. He was unable to prevent the death of his
own, he could not connect the hair he has been cut or his nails alone. So it is clear that
these proud people like KSW is a duplicate of the Fir'un in our Millenium century.)
YUSUFALI: It is He |3
person| Who sendeth the winds like heralds oI glad tidings. going
beIore His mercy: when they have carried the heavy-laden clouds. We |1
person| drive them to
a land that is dead. make rain to descend thereon. and produce every kind oI harvest therewith:
thus shall We raise up the dead: perchance ye may remember.
There is nothing scientific in this verse. But we see a false statement. Not all winds
carry glad tidings. Some of them are devastating. Also most of the rains do not fall on
dead land but on very wet lands. Then he makes a non sequitor claim that like the
produce that come out of earth, one day the dead will also be raised from it. This is
absolutely unscientific. Those who choose to believe in this balderdash do so by faith,
not by reasoning and certainly not because it is scientific. There is no resemblance
between a produce growing out of the earth and dead rising from their tombs. Are we
going to grow on a tree? The whole idea of resurrection is unscientific and ludicrous.
Not only that, it also contradicts the Quran itself. Resurrection suggests that all the
people who are dead are reduced into nothing until the Judgment Day when they will
be raised and will be sent to their permanent places. However 3.169 says: "Think not of
those, who are slain in the way of Allah, as dead. Nay, they are living. With their Lord
they have provision."
Do people rise from dead to receive their punishment and rewards on the Last Day or
are they living and receive their rewards and punishment right after their death? A liar
often contradicts himself.
( Rahmanhadiq; surely man who indulge think Envy would not like to read the verses
above, because there is the inscription "good news" that hurts his ears. Impossible for
KSW can feel happy when he heard the Muslims accept the news joy of their Lord. This
is painful news for him. He did not accept it. Ali Sina is rely too much on the capacity to
think, so he just thought something was there, if detected by the five senses.
Of course he would reject hard news about the Day of Resurrection or life after death.
This is in sharp contrast with the ability to reason. His ability is not in setting for minds to
something that is supernatural. His life just for the world and ended up in the world as
well, so that the ability of his imagination is setting for this. He did not know why he was
born into this world, for him the important thing is to enjoy this life, after he death drop
the case. So now he will do something hurt to others, he felt happy after a painful one,
he'll do anything contrary to the values of goodness or religious norms which he said
would allow it to achieve the ambitions and goals. Of course, KSW is very important for
his business, he does not care about anything done in the fighting his goats, because
he did not make any rules in the arena of mutual contempt, blasphemy and each other
that hate each other. Because of that he had thrown the true value and his humanity
far to the bottom of Ocean.
For livestock and plantation owners, who want to devote the coming of rain clouds will
certainly bring joy and hope, but KSW does not care whether or not the rain that came
before him, the rain did not affect anything to him. In fact, he charged that it would bring
disaster Rain flooded, landslides, while the rain that never came to the city the barren
desert or arid land so as not to bring fertility evenly on the surface of the earth.
Conversely, if the rain does not fall down, then destroyed crops. So is the wind that can
wreak destruction to somewhere. Until that's where his ability to take the wisdom or
philosophy of the verses above. Though the causes of floods and landslides are
voracious human activity that always cleared the forest so casually soil absorption is
reduced and soil strength to withstand the load is not strong rain which caused
landslide of the soil or flash floods. If it remains wilderness will surely protested bring
Benefits for the plain below it because the water would be released slowly. If it can not
be done of course human beings also have the ability and technology to create large
dams for water can be stored and distributed to farmers to survive in the long dry
season. That is not understood by this demon, he did not care where the food source
that had been consumed and from which he drank water that came from. Overall it was
far from his life philosophy. So it is clear that the verse, also is an allegory or a parable
for those who can appreciate the gifts given by the Creator of human being.
So is the parable of rain that can grow plants that die from dry land during the dry
season, which after the rainy season, we knew came back from the sidelines of the
ground like mushrooms grow.
That's the parable of the emergence of humans after many centurys tomb buried in the
ground when the Day after of Resurrection later. KSW of course would not believe even
ridicule information therefore he mock it verse. Same with disbelief to its emergence
into the world of the womb even though he did not want it, neither does the real death
not wished later. So really he was not able to do anything for himself, he also resigned
to his fate later, he did not know what will happen to him after his death, but he always
refused any kind of truth that told to him, however he did not know what will happen on
him later.)
person| sends down water Irom the skies. and the channels Ilow. each
according to its measure: But the torrent bears away to Ioam that mounts up to the surIace. Even
so. Irom that (ore) which they heat in the Iire. to make ornaments or utensils therewith. there is a
scum likewise. Thus doth Allah |3
person| (by parables) show Iorth Truth and Vanity. For the
scum disappears like Iorth cast out; while that which is Ior the good oI mankind remains on the
earth. Thus doth Allah set Iorth parables.
Okay, this is just a parable. Nothing scientific here!
(Rahmanhadiq; The swashbuckler KSW does not understand the word scum. All he
knew of the foam was only the white colored sticky, gooey-sticky on his lips when his
mouth foaming by magic formula. It froth will lost along with empty talk not benefit for
humans. He spoke that God makes parables for himself, but he did not understand
what is meant by the parable is, so he had a loose tongue forever. KSW onwards do
not see any value of Science in the verse above. This is because he does not
understand a parable. Because the sentence in the above verses can be understood
only after understanding the meaning of allegories, while the KSW was blind about the
parable word.
The word froth or foam is not only compared with the sticky foam at his mouth when he
was talkative, but more than that. Before the water evaporates, the water is broken into
very fine particles resulting from the temperature and pressure by result of differences
between air and surface water. The specialty of water, is not having to wait for the
temperature of 100
C to evaporate, but the evaporation process can be triggered by
differences in surface temperature and air pressure. This is what is meant by the
process of foam development to particle of water or vapor as referred to in verse
above. Even in heavy metal smelting furnace in the iron industry, gold, tin and others
also have a float or floating material such as foam on the top surface of the liquid metal.
This is a common occurrence that can not be denied the truth by science and
So Al Qr'an telling the truth with the verse, but at that time, Muhammad had never seen
a metal furnace in the Arabic country.)
person| it is Who sends the winds as heralds oI glad tidings. going
beIore His mercy. and We |1
person plural| send down pure water Irom the sky.-
YUSUFALI: That with it We |1
person plural| may give liIe to a dead land. and slake the thirst
oI things We have created.- cattle and men in great numbers.
More pablum and prosaic banality!
(Rahmanhadiq; Apparently KSW can talkative only, then swore of curse after reading
the description verse above, without giving a reason for the reasonable and logical. He
thought to understands the verse not use his reason, but by his knee. It's really an
resentment person human figure. The above verse explains that the form of rain-
derived water is very clean water because the method is processed exactly with distilled
water to produce pure distilled water. That meant a clean rainwater in paragraph above.
But the truth of the verse harassing by KSW. While the next verse, besides containing a
parable, it also has a very profound scientific significance, in terms of philosophy of life.
This verse means that all living things on earth this, including the figure of Ali Sina,
utilize this water for life. However KSW, do not appreciate the water that is in his body
was. Really can not thank people who in life and his living. Maybe he had never go for
survey in the African continent or Australia, where after the dry season for several
months and no visible biota that can live, but during the rainy season, all live and grow
back like a fungus that emerged from the sidelines of the soil . KSW is belied this fact
with the argument made-up caused his displeasure to the teachings of religion.
YUSUFALI: It is Allah |3
person| Who sends Iorth the Winds. so that they raise up the
Clouds. and We |1
person plural| drive them to a land that is dead. and revive the earth
therewith aIter its death: even so (will be) the Resurrection!
YUSUFALI: And We produce therein orchard with date-palms and vines. and We cause
springs to gush Iorth therein:
YUSUFALI: And in the alternation oI Night and Day. and the Iact that Allah |3
person| sends
down Sustenance Irom the sky. and revives therewith the earth aIter its death. and in the change
oI the winds.- are Signs Ior those that are wise.
YUSUFALI: And We send down Irom the sky rain charted with blessing. and We produce
therewith gardens and Grain Ior harvests;
YUSUFALI: See ye the water which ye drink? Do ye bring it down (in rain) Irom the cloud or
do We? Were it Our Will. We could make it salt (and unpalatable): then why do ye not give
YUSUFALI: Say: "See ye?- II your stream be some morning lost (in the underground earth).
who then can supply you with clear-Ilowing water?"
This is the list of the Quranic verses about rain that Dr. Naik recited so triumphantly to a
rhapsodic Muslim crowd who muffled his voice with applauses. Is there any hitherto
unknown scientific information in these verses? Note that Dr. Naik confidently assured
his audience that the “Glorious Qur’an speaks about the ‘Water cycle’, in great detail.”
What detail is there? What the Quran describes has been observable by any primitive
man since eons. This is the book that a billion Muslims think is a miracle. The only
miracle is the willingness of some humans to be fooled. The Quran is a book of asininity
and not of miracles.
(Rahmanhadiq; KSW was feeling very ashamed to admit the truth of the verses above
as a consequence he refused to cover his privates with out explanation verse that
actually recognized by anyone who lived on this earth. But he's still harassing verse
which he admits the truth in his heart the deepest. Such characteristics of hypocrites as
KSW. Muslims do not need to prove the existence of demons or Satan to the human
race, because Ali Sina is itself an example of the most obvious of the intentions of
Satan that we ever know on this earth, although he never showed his face is clear from
behind his mask, but the words and his writings show that he was Satan.
He was not able to sort out logically and systematically from a string of verses, so he
does not understand how Al Qur'an explain the stages of the formation of rain water to
go down again to the surface of the earth. He deliberately rejected the truth news for fly
garbage landed on his body did not run away from it. So he felt very hurt and his head
throbbing watching the audience clapping their hands to give applause to the DR Naik
when submit his explanation. KSW is not happy when people praise the greatness of
someone other than himself. KSW is to get a compliment like that received by his
Master DR Naik, but none of the normal human response to his hatred.
He thinks that Dr Naik had obtained a glorious victory of the debate, whereas DR Naik
himself never felt any gain victory. Presented by Ali Sina ‘s Professor (DR Naik) is just
something that is not indisputable truth by anyone either by science or by the logic of
healthy thinking.
Unlike KSW is always looking at other people's opinions with a cynical and full of
hatred. Of course this is what he wanted. It is to pit the Muslim participants to the
Christian religion to enter into an arena that has prepared by him for the clash and
mutual verbal abuse, thus increasing their site many followers and sponsors.).

Do Mountains Stabilize the Earth
(Dr. Naik) Dr. William Campbell spent maximum time on Embryology’… about half his talk
- quite a lot on Geology - and touched on other six topics - I’ve noted down. In the field of
Geology, we have come to know today - the Geologists, they tell us, that the radius of the
Earth is approximately 3750 miles, and the deeper layers, they are hot and fluid, and
cannot sustain life. And the superficial part of the Earth’s crust, which we live on, it is very
thin - Hardly 1 to 30 miles. Some portions are thicker, but majority one to 30 miles. And
there are high possibility that this superficial layer, the Earth’s crust - it will shake. It is due
to the ‘Folding phenomenon’, which gives rise to mountain ranges, which gives stability to
this Earth. And Qur’an says in Surah Nabaa, Ch. No. 78, Verse No. 6 and 7…‘We have
made the Earth as an expanse…. (Arabic) ….and the mountains as stakes.’ The Qur’an
does not say, mountains were thrown up as stakes… mountain as stakes. Arabic word
‘Autaad’ means ‘stakes’… meaning ‘tent peg’. And today we have come to know in the study
of modern Geology, that mountain has got deep roots. This was known in the second half of
the 19
century. And the superficial part that we see of the mountain is a very small
percentage. The deeper part is within - Exactly like a stake how it is driven in the ground.
You can only see a small part on top - the majority is down in the ground - or like a tip of
the ice berg…you can see the tip on the top and about 90% is beneath water.
The Qur’an says in Surah Gashiya, Ch. 88, Verse No. 19, and Surah Naziat, Ch. No. 79,
Verse No. 32 ….. (Arabic) …. And We have made the mountains standing firm on the Earth’.
Today after modern Geology has advanced, and Dr. William Campbell said that… ‘By the
theory of Plate tectonics - It was propounded in 1960, which gives rise to mountain ranges.’
The Geologists today do say that the mountains give stability to the Earth - Not all
Geologists, but many do say.
(Ali Sina) Dr. Campbell already explained how mountains are formed in a scientific
language. Everything Dr. Naik says is just absurdity. He says “not all geologists" but
many of them say mountains give stability to the Earth. He thinks science is like Islamic
jurisprudence that each mullah can have his interpretation. Will he give us a few names
so we can verify what exactly these "geologists" say and check their credentials? I hope
they are not graduates from Al Azhar University.

The Earth's surface is made up of a series of large plates (like pieces of a giant jigsaw
puzzle). These plates are in constant motion traveling at a few centimeters per year.
This motion is called continental drift. The edges of these plates, where they move
against each other, are sites of intense geologic activity, such as earthquakes,
volcanoes, and mountain building.

Convection currents beneath the plates move the plates in different directions. The
source of heat driving the convection currents is radioactive decay which is happening
deep in the Earth

When two tectonic plates collide they press against each other until the land is lifted
and folded over itself.

This movement often causes one plate to push on top of another one.

As one plate slides downward into the earth, it begins to melt pushing the other plate
upwards forming mountain ranges.
In some places continents collide, in other placed they drift. Continental plates break
when a plume of hot magma rises from deep within the mantle pushing up the crust and
causing pressure forcing the continent to break and separate. Lava flows and
earthquakes would be seen. In the diagram below you can see that the continental
crust is beginning to separate creating a diverging plate boundary. When a divergence
occurs within a continent it is called rifting. A plume of hot magma rises from deep
within the mantle pushing up the crust and causing pressure forcing the continent to
break and separate. Lava flows and earthquakes would be seen.

This is an example of a divergent
plate boundary (where the plates
move away from each other). The
Atlantic Ocean was created by this
process. The mid-Atlantic Ridge is
an area where new sea floor is
being created.

As the rift valley expands two
continental plates have been
constructed from the original one.
The molten rock continues to push
the crust apart creating new crust
as it does.

As the rift valley
expands, water
collects forming a
sea. The Mid-
Atlantic Ridge is
now 2,000 metres
above the adjacent
sea floor, which is
at a depth of about
6,000 metres
below sea level.

The sea floor
continues to
spread and the
plates get
bigger and
bigger. This
process can be
seen all over
the world and
produces about
17 square
kilometres of
new plate every

The ocean floors are continually moving, spreading from the center and sinking at the edges.

When continental plates collide the melted rock rushes upward along cracks and weak
spots, bursting out as fiery volcanoes.
There are several kinds of mountains:
Dome Mountains are formed when melted rock pushes its way up under earth.
Fault Block Mountains are formed when faults or cracks in the earth's crust force
some materials or blocks of rock up and others down.
Fold Mountains are formed as layers of the earth react to forces
pushing in on either side, much as a piece of paper folds when
pushed together.
Volcanic Mountains are formed from by hardened lava after
spurting out of a volcano.
Residual Mountains are mountains that are really plateaus that
have worn down from erosion. Source

Cross-section of the French Alps: from University of Leeds. No sign of roots!

Satellite view of Pennsylvania Appalachians is an example of fault block mountains.

View north over termination of Rundle Thrust Sheet, Rocky Mountains.
What happens if push the tablecloth from its edge sliding it across the table? It wrinkles.
That is more or less how mountains are formed. They are wrinkles caused in the crust
of the earth.
Ironically without these devastating earthquakes life on Earth could not have evolved.
The movement of continents allows carbon dioxide to be released to the atmosphere.
This is essential for the photosynthesis of plants and it also keeps the temperature of
the Earth constant which is necessary for life to evolve [1].
If you have Quicktime installed, you can click on these animations and see how
mountains are formed.

Mesozoic Subduction
Description: Illustrates
the geological
processes commonly
Iound at subduction
zones. The Basement
rocks oI much oI
CaliIornia were Iormed
in this way
Himalayan Collision Plio-Pleistocene Oblique
Shortening against the San
Andreas fault
Description: In the later
stages oI rotation.
readiustment oI the plate
boundary resulted in north-
south shortening oI the
Transverse Ranges

Miocene: Rifting and
rotation, volcanism,
crustal upwelling and
deposition in marine
Description: Rotation
oI the Transverse
Ranges and eruption oI
the Coneio Volcanics
during Miocene time
Formation oI Big Southern
Butte. eastern Snake River
Plain. Idaho
Description: Describes the
Iormation oI Big Southern
Butte. Big Southern Butte is
a 300.000 year old complex
oI two rhyolite domes and
older basalt Ilows that rises
2500 hundred Ieet above the
Snake River Plain. The
domes Iormed when rhyolite
magma ponded beneath the
existing Snake River Plain
basalts. pushing them up.
Dike Emplacement at
Craters oI the Moon
National Monument
The Craters oI the Moon
lava Iield spreads across 618
square miles and is the
largest young basaltic lava
Iield in the lower 48 states.
The area contains more than
25 volcanic cones including
outstanding examples oI
spatter cones
Source: http://emvc.geol.ucsb.edu/downloads.php
This should suffice as proof that the Quran is wrong and mountains are not like pegs to
keep the earth from shaking. Remember that Dr. Naik repeated several times, "All we
need is one error to prove it is not from God". Later I will explain where the idea of
mountains being like pegs and holding the earth beneath us from shaking with us has
come from.
(Rahmanhadiq; In the above presentation, Ali Sina displays reasoning about the
formation of the Volcano. Although a bit smelly Scientific explanation, but he only
adopted one of the impressions on a website that claims to be the only theory about the
true Volcanic formation. Though the last few years alone, there are many theories or
postulates, which was found by geological experts revealed according to the latest
results in the field. Each new discovery was found by geologists will break a pre-
existing theory, or generate new theories which sometimes contradict each other, or
vice versa can also reinforce each other or produce a theory that really new at all. KSW
only shows the locations where he had meditated in the mountains area and then
connecting the results as a valid conclusion .
In the theory presented by this Mountain’s expert, completely ignoring the formation of
mountains which caused the influence of Earth's hot core temperature reaches 5000
C. He imagined that the mountain in the mountains range as pull tablecloths that
became tangled, where on the peak will form the mountains while on the folded of
cloths will form the valleys. That’s reasoning of fake Prosfessor was worked, because
he was copy just from viewing internet that caused him conceited. He was only able to
copy-paste it, so he could only explain it with the sophistication of the ancient theory by
the animation program. Though the formation of the mountain was more dominant,
influenced by the pressure due to the turbulent heat the Earth's core, than on Earth
motion or plate fracture. Precisely plate movement or fracture the earth's crust caused
by the occurrence of strong pressure from turbulent heat contained in the magma layer
of the Earth's core.KSW ignores the influence of geothermal pressure against the
formation of mountains.
As we know that our earth spherical with a radius of about 6500 km. The surface of the
earth is not flat, is caused by pressure from within the earth and cause the change of
the various pressures on its surface. From the scientific evidence, indicates that the
layer of earth just contains 20% solids, ie the lithosphere layer (depth about 100 km)
where this form of coating or surface of mount and Many diagnostic layer is formed and
to the lower layers of soil, a layer of Asthenosphear (thickness of 100-2000 km ),
Innermost layer (outer and inner core of the earth) reaches a depth of approximately
5500 - 6500 km thick in the form of magma with temperatures reaching 5000
C -
C degrees centigrade, followed by a layer above a layer called the mantle (depths
of 2500 -3000 km) are also in the form of hot magma temperature of 2200 o C.).
Therefore the layers of the earth consist of 60% - 80% water and magma.
The water as a stabilizer of turbulent magma temperature and heat. So actually existing
solid surface of the earth, in the form of plate or crust of this Earth, only a thin layer
(approximately 35-100 km) that seemed to float above the heat of magma ranging
between 2000 ° C - 6000
C, as well as blanket spread out, then spread over the mud
and hot embers that flare up underneath. That's the blanket that is spread over activity
all of living things.
So at this layer, certainly happens that when strong vibration (on a scale of 5 rhicter)
produces earthquakes. This is because the central layer of the Earth deposit enormous
of heat energy that could explode at any time when the earth was not designed with
cooling system and a sophisticated damping system who created the Creator, because
of the effects of instability that comes from the depths of the Earth. Where the earth's
core hot comes from? How is the relationship between volcanic and tectonic
earthquakes? From the results of scientific discovery, showed that the top layer of earth
is always shifting and movement. The reason is the existence of a powerful heat source
that comes from the inner layer of the earth. Very high heat causes the rocks and
mineral elements into a liquid and a variety of gases trapped in the magma. This means
that there are about 40-50% of the volume of earth, containing hot magma stored in the
interior of the earth. Magma is hot it will expand and rise upwards pressing plate and
the earth's crust that was on it, causing the plates away from each other.
When magma reaches the top of the cooler, then it will shrink and magma solidified
because of the stages or refrigeration process. As a result, these plates will move back
to fill the magma chamber shrink and condense it. When the plates move back, it will
form again, the cracks that cause the bottom of the magma pushed upwards between
the cracks. If the liquid magma has a large enough force, then a layer of solidified
magma that has been pushed upward will continue in stages until it reaches the earth's
surface and formed a volcano. This process will occur over and over again so that the
surface of the mountain that grew higher as well. That is due to the pressure of magma
underneath the volcano crater that emit bursts of vomit magma and rocks blocking the
crater of the mountain top. This can be proved that the bulk of the mountains are very
old age will rise very high.
The Consistency of magma can change from liquid to semi-solid and then become
solid during the cooling process. The characteristic of semi-solid Magma can withstand
any vibration or shock caused by the banging of plates that move and collide them. The
semi-solid magma layer is like a layer of foam , spring or brake, which can reduce
vibration originating horizontal or vertical direction.
So it is clear that there is a causal and stabilizing mutual relationship between the
formation of volcanoes with plate movement that caused the collision or earthquake.
This can be proved, where the region's wealth of volcanoes, so there are many shifts
and movements of the plates, as shown in the picture above the globe presented by
fake Professor Ali Sina, although the presentation is out of date. Vice versa, if there are
more and more movement of tectonic plates and broken fragment in the area, the more
spread there is also an active volcano there. Tectonic and Volcanic Tremors vibration
will continue to occur and will not cease as long as the earth is still hot, but who feels up
to the surface of the Earth or the so-called Earthquake (usually in the top 5 on the
Richter scale), not so much. This is because the active mountains that have been stuck
in these sensitive areas centuries ago, have been shown to function to stabilize the
vibration so as not to fall down weeping the human settlements thereon. So the Al
Qur'an verse description Lukman letter number 10, which reads “He set on the earth
mountains standing firm, lest it should shake with you “, not contrary to scientific
discovery in the field of Geology.
Besides the vibration damper, volcano crater also act as the pores of the earth to
release the steam heat and other harmful gases trapped to neutralized into the air.
Imagine that if there were no active volcanoes, where the strong pressure gases is
removed?, Surely the world will explode because of all the sewer gas is sealed.

When looked at the surface of the earth, perhaps viewed as a small mountain but if traced the inside of
them, then associated with the center of the earth underneath or a very hot magma, and between one
mountain to another could be interconnected.
So really what is described by the verse in the Al Qur'an, that the volcano is like as a
crossbar or pegs whose their roots far piercing in the earth. For more details, just
imagine, when the body of Satan such as Ali Sina planted on top of the crater and then
the hot magma suck him deep to the Earth's core.
Likewise the Qur'an information that has been explained that the earth is always
moving as the movement of tectonic plates that have been proved by scientific
discovery in this Millenium century, namely the letter An Naml number 88 which reads "
Thou seest the mountains and thinkest them firmly fixed: but they shall pass away as
the clouds pass away". This verse has a meaning that is wide enough, not only shows
that the Earth is moving in accordance with the movement of the plates, but the Earth is
also moving quickly which indicates that the earth is moved by way of rotation (even
moving to orbit the sun), as clouds move over the surface involved. So this Al Qur'an
Description has been ahead of scientific discovery in the field of geology, even to
explain about the rotation and orbit the earth at 14-th century before. Truth testimony
this Al Qur'an is not irrefutable evidence, but this verse written long before humans
millenium century to prove it. But KSW is still denied it, because he had just come down
from his isolated location to acquire magical power in a volcano crater.
So clear that the formation of volcanoes and earth crust movements , also caused by
the influence of turbulent pressure hot magma from the deepest part of the earth. But
the fake Professor “Ali Sina” ignores the Earth's core heat effects on the formation of
volcanoes. Maybe all of time before he did not feel the heat with fire or magma of the
earth core, because he had just put through preparation and training to punishment on
the heat of hell fire. KSW is already preparing Physical training to fell torture will be give
to him.

(Dr. Naik) I have not come across a single Geological book, and I challenge Dr. William
Campbell to produce a single Geological book - Not his personal correspondence with the
Geologist. That does not carry weight. His personal correspondence with Dr. Keith Moore ….
Documented proof. And if you read the book ‘The Earth’ which is referred by almost all the
universities, in the field of Geology, one of its authors by the name of Dr Frank Press, who
was the advisor to the former president of USA, Jimmy Carter, and was the president of the
Academy of Science of USA. He writes in his book that…‘The mountains are wedge shaped -
It has deep roots within. And he says that…‘The function of the mountain is to stabilize the
earth.’ And the Qur’an says in Surah Ambiya, Ch. No 21, Verse No. 31, in Surah Luqman,
Ch. No. 31 Verse No.10, as well as in Surah Nahl, Ch. No. 16, Verse No. 15, that…‘We have
made the mountains standing firm on the Earth, lest it would shake with them and with
(Ali Sina) Dr. Frank Press, in his book The Earth writes: "The thickness of the crust
varies from about 35 kilometer to 10 kilometer in a section extended from continent to
ocean. Under a high mountain the crust thickens to as much as 65 kilometer. The
following Figure suggests that the continental crust floats on the denser mantle like an
iceberg on the ocean. Icebergs float because they are less dense than sea water.
Flotation comes from a large volume of ice that lies below the sea surface. When
Archimides’ principle of buoyancy is applied to the flotation of continents and
mountains, it becomes the principle of isostasy, which holds that relatively light
continents float on a more dense mangle; most of a continent's volume lies below the
sea floor for the same reason that most of an iceberg lies below the ocean surface.
(rahmanhadiq; that is no-logical theory by Ali Sina . Whereas deeper more into the
earth, temperature become so colder. And then he told that at 65 Km under the
ocean or deeper more, the temperature is more colder like ticker more of ice layers.
The crazy Professor ). Nature has contrived that large topographic loads like
mountains and continents are compensated – that is supported primarily by buoyancy
rather than by the strength of the crust." (page 663-664)

The lithosphere is topped by a relatively lightweight crust. Seismology reveals that the crust
varies in thickness; it is thin under oceans. thicker under continent. and thicker under high
mountains. In the above picture the horizontal distance is much larger. (Rahmanhadiq; the Iact
that KSW did not understand and mistaken with his mind to interpreted that books. Realy Ali
Sina is the Fake ProIessor and the impostor man )

Now let us see what the Quran says:
And the mountains. how they are Iirmly Iixed. (Q. 88:19. 79.32)
And the mountains are as pegs (Q.78.7)
These are not scientific statements. Every illiterate person living in the 7th century knew
that the mountains are fixed. Also mountains do not resemble pegs.
Rahmanhadiq; KSW rejected of the authenticity of Al Qur'anic verses mentioned
above, only shows the hatred and malevolent of him alone. Because he was unable to
explain exactly which part of the verse is that contrary to the science findings at this
Millenium century. He was only able to argue but not able to link rebuttal is more
reasonable and detailed to deny the truth of the verse. He just showed his hatred only.
He imagined himself upright as the establishment of a mountain, His arrogance more
higher from the Himalayas mountain “ Everest”. But he's totally blind to the parable that
are stored in the verses of the Qur'an, so he will not be able to explore the implicit
meanings that are exposed in the writings of Al Quran is full of meaning. KSW is
thought the vast mainland or continens like ice cubes floating above the ocean like the
force of law “Archimidest “so that the continent can movement, and also about the
formation of volcanoes above ground due to folding, which is like a tablecloth. It's really
the way Ali Sina from this).”

(Dr. Naik) The function of the mountain in the Qur’an, is given to prevent the Earth from
shaking. Nowhere does the Qur’an say that the mountain prevents the earthquake.
(Ali Sina) What could possibly "preventing earth from shaking" mean except
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is a disciple of Dr. Naik is the most stupid among other
students, so he did not understand well the speech professor. Apparently his friend
contemporaries need to help provide assistance him for the next semester he was able
to graduate with mediocre grade. Well, try to see a good sentence uttered by our
lecturer said, "The mountain was unable to withstand the shaking of the earth." This
means that the earth will continue to vibrate even though there are many mountains are
in it. The mountain was not to prevent or eliminate the earthquake, but is meant by the
verse of the Qur'an is mute earthquake vibration for uninterrupted human activities on it,
not shaken with them. What is still not understood well , Ali Sina? If not, then the better
to Ali Sina was repeat again next semester.)

(Dr. Naik) And Dr. William Campbell said - He writes in his book, and even the talk, that…
‘You find in the mountains regions, there are various earthquakes, and mountains cause
earthquake.’ Point to be noted - Nowhere does the Qur’an say that mountains prevent
earthquake. The Arabic word for ‘earthquake’ as Dr. William Campbell knows Arabic, is
‘zilzaal’ or ‘zalzala’- But the words used in these three Verses I quoted, it is ‘Tamida.’
‘Tamida’ means ‘to shake’, ‘to ‘sway’, ‘to swing.’ And Qur’an says in Surah Luqman, Ch. 31,
Verse No. 10, as well as Surah Nahl, Ch. No. 16 Verse No. 15…‘We have put on the earth
mountains standing firm, lest it would shake with you. It is ‘tamide bikum’…‘Shake with
you’, Indicating, if the mountains were not there, if you would have walked, if you
would have moved, even the earth would have moved with you - If you would
have swayed, even the earth would have swayed with you. And we know normally
when we walk on the Earth, the Earth does not shake, and the reason for this is, according
to Dr. Frank Press and Dr. Najjat who is from Saudi Arabia, and he wrote a full book on the
Geological concepts in the Qur’an, answering almost every thing what Dr. William Campbell
has said - in detail.
(Ali Sina) High mountains are formed through collision of tectonic plates. In planets
where tectonic plates do not exist or do not migrate, there are no continental collisions,
earthquakes do not take place and mountains do not form. As the result life does not
evolve. [2] There are nearly 70 planets and moons in our solar system. None has
mountain ranges like those on Earth, suggesting tectonic plates are not moving. Yet it is
absurd to say that one cannot walk on the surface of these planets and moons without
making the ground beneath them shake. Can anyone say anything stupider than this?
In fact the reverse is true. In planets where high mountains don't exist, the ground is
very stable.
(Rahmanhadiq; This KSW Looks like is making a new theory that is not scientific. This
shows in fact that he could only show his pride boasting. Empty kegs have loud sound,
this metaphor was suitable for Ali Sina. KSW is only able to sell his goat droppings
drugs to people who do not understand or to his friends the green fly that landed in his
mouth. Then found out who he really is. He is nothing more than a useless loser. He
must have seen with the eyes of his feet during isolated inside a volcano crater, that
any earthquake caused by the Earth's plates, it will form a new volcano again. how
many volcanoes that formed after the quake caused by those fragments?
Did not have explained that the terrain or land where human activity just like a thin
blanket that is spread out over live coals or hot-melt magma underneath, then naturally
it often happens motion of plate due to pressure and encouragement from the turbulent
heat underneath. Not like a block of ice that floats above the ocean, such as those he
described above .
Then the cracks are formed due to collision of tectonic plates, will cause the magma
pushed upwards (if fault it reaches a layer of magma beneath it) and then cover the
cracks, and then followed by cooling and forming a semi-solid magma. Not all collision
of tectonic plate broken would result in a volcano, but almost all the collision can
activate a nearby volcano in the plates were. This shows that the base of the mountain
is interconnected as a result of magma underneath. While under basic of volcanic
magma that there are also semi-solid that is able to dampen vibrations caused by
collision earlier. But if the magma is urgent is too strong then the roots of the mountain
adjacent to the area to be active to remove the hot lava mud or magma. Not all
collision or folds will produce a vibration to surface because there is a sophisticated
vibration damping system below of the earth.
And then KSW say that there are "70 planets and a moon in our solar system." This is a
new invention of the fake Professor . So the scientists was founded nine planets in our
solar system, even Pluto is now rejected from the solar system, so stay 8 which is
recognized as a planet. But the professor Ali SIna said that this remarkable 70 plenets
been found in solar earth. Even the professor has explained the principle of the
mountain on the other planets. Maybe he is already back from planet of solar system,
so he made sure about the formation of the mountains on the other planets. Really this
KSW swashbuckler. Let alone to go to other planets (Venus, Jupiter or Pluto, etc.), to
land a plane there just is not no human creature capable of the earth. Theories about
the formation of the mountain on another planet is merely conjecture, but the fake
Professor was fully sure to his conclusion. Ali SIna is not a fake professor but a crazy
Is not the lesson above already mentioned that in many mountain areas, so many
earthquakes, contrary to not any mountain area not infrequent earthquakes. This shows
that there is a causal and stabilizing mutual relationship between the formation of the
Volcano with the number of earthquakes or collision in the area. In this case, the
mountains serve as the points or nodes that can help withstand the shock. Is not it clear
that if in case, the surface of this earth there are no mountains at all, therefore break it’s
earth because there is no system that is able to release the trapped heat and gases
through the chimney (crater) and reduce the shock from the bottom. So the Qur'an
verse statement is not wrong with the existing reality. Only Ali Sina is not able to accept
the truth. That is in the KSW mind is just a sense of envy and hatred.
(Dr. Naik) And Dr. William Campbell in his book, he writes that…‘If mountains prevent the
shaking of the earth, then how come you find earthquakes in the mountains regions.’ I said,
No where does the Qur’an say, mountains prevent earthquake. Earthquake is ‘zilzaal’ - and
if you see the definition in the Oxford dictionary, it says… Earthquake is due to convulsion
of the superficial crust of the Earth, due to relief of compressed Seismic waves, due to crack
in the rock, or due to volcanic reaction. The Qur’an speaks about ‘zalzala’ in Surah Zalzaal ,
Ch. 99 - But here it speaks about ‘tamida bikum’- ‘to prevent the earth from shaking with
(Ali Sina) Note that this shaking, according to Dr. Naik is not caused by the volcanic
eruptions or tectonic movement. It is not the kind of earthquake we know. It is
something else. This shaking is the result of people waking. But as everyone knows,
the earth does not shake when we walk on it. The reason? It's thanks to the mountains
that prevent this shaking. How can even one suggest that tiny beings like humans can
make a continent shake by simply walking on it? This goes beyond absurdity. It's
outright asininity.
( Rahmanhadiq; KSW was not able to think clearly about what his teacher Dr Naik had
explained. His teacher said according to the conclusions of the greatest geologists
under the earth, where is the collision of tectonic plate of the earth's crust is a fracture
or movement of earth crust. While that is a volcano eruption is volcanic eruptions which
cause vibration while the tectonic movement is the movement of tectonic plates of the
earth that generate faults or folds so that the skin of the earth tremble. But KSW is not
understood thoroughly, so he turned the phrase into " This shaking is the result of
people waking " .. So do not be too indulge hatred and then not understand
consequently what is conveyed explicitly by his teacher).
(Dr. Naik) And in reply to the statement…‘That if mountains prevent earthquakes, how
come you find earthquakes in mountainous regions?’ The reply is, that - If I say that
medical doctors, they prevent the sickness and disease in a human being, and if someone
argues…‘If doctors prevent the sickness and diseases in a human being, how come you find
more sick people in the hospitals, where there are more doctors than at home - where
there are no doctors.’
(Ali Sina) What a ridiculous analogy! Patients go to hospitals AFTER they get sick
because they are living and thinking beings and that is where they can get medical
attention and get better. They do not become sick in hospitals (unless the hospital is in
an Islamic country with Islamic hygiene). Is Dr. Naik trying to compare earthquake, a
natural phenomenon, to humans? (Rahmanhadiq; this is the man who does not
understand the example of a parable or metaphor, and indeed from the beginning he
did not understand with an expression of comparison, he thought of the parable as
materials science that must be solved by mathematical formula equation. OK! Crazy
Do the earthquakes happen first elsewhere and then decide to conglomerate in
mountains? This analogy is utterly ridiculous; yet Dr. Naik’s Muslim audience became
so elated that they spontaneously cheered and applauded. Excessive (Rahmanhadiq;
but KSW nearly fainted heard laughter, like thunder booming) One black guy was
almost falling off his chair of excessive laughing. What these people were laughing at?
At their own stupidity? Now the world can see them and laugh at them. It’s as if the
more stupid is a statement, the more Muslims enjoy it. (Rahmanhadiq; where no devil
could see his reflection in the mirror so that he does not know himself. But the devil was
a creature of the ugliest, most obscene, most ignorant and the most cursed by
childrens). This reveals the deplorable intellectual bankruptcy of the wretched Umma.
(Rahmanhadiq; in terms of KSW was talking nonsense merely).
Believe me, absurd thinking is the trait of Muslims. Sometime ago I read an essay about
a Muslim child asking his religious teacher that the Quran says Jinns will be sent to hell
to be punished but the the Quran also says that Jinns are made of fire, so how fire can
be hurt by fire? The teacher slapped the child and asked him if it hurts? The poor lad
responded yes, with tears in his eyes. "Like that!", responded the teacher. "My hand is
flesh and your face is flesh but it still hurts". (Rahmanhadiq; this story has been
changed by KSW , what it really is the question was a son demon who does not
believes in if he burn and feel pain when being tortured in hell later, he asked his
teacher Dr Naik at that moment. But the devil was screaming pain when Dr Naik
slapped him. It's all sick, let alone again if later burned alive in hell, of course more pain.
It's really good that KSW has created a suitable story for him).
Muslims do not think it will fool the things Foolish Muslims think this is such a great
reasoning. This is the fallacy of wrong analogy. But the Muslim brain is not equipped
with enough rationality to think deep. (Rahmanhadiq; not from the beginning of KSW
is always arguing with reasons that are not rational at all, even though his teacher was
delivering some lessons over and over again for him).. He WANTS to believe and any
nonsense will do. (Rahmanhadiq; The Provocateur Ali Sina, if he does not understand,
then he accuses his teacher stupid ). There are several sites that have written against
me. I receive numerous emails from Muslims who have neither read my articles nor
those written by Muslims trying to refute me. And yet these people tell me that I have
already been refuted and give me links to the same silly sites. They WANT to believe
that I am refuted. They will believe anyone who claims he has refuted me without
searching the truth of that claim. The Muslim mind works in bizarre
ways. (Rahmanhadiq; useless to provide rebuttal to the KSW was, because he still will
not understand it, and will spend of time in vain to serve him, as will not bring much
beneficial in this discussions. He will be inconsequential to talk about things that are not
relevant to the main topic .)
Here Dr. Naik is trying to explain with this harebrained example why most of the
earthquakes happen in mountainous regions. But didn't he say that the Quran is not
speaking of earthquake and that tamida is not zilzala? If the Quran is not talking about
earthquake at all, why he tries to justify this verse with this silly example?
(Rahmanhadiq; this verse is not talking about the incident Earthquake, but about to
KSW own stupidity.) If he is satisfied with his answer that tamida is the result people
walking on earth, why talk about earthquake? Why cause more confusion? It's because
the more confused is your audience the better you can fool them. (Rahmanhadiq; in
fact this verse is talking about the arrogance of pretending KSW exceeds higher
mountain in the Everest and piercing beyond the earth's core. The sound of the verse is
"you never can penetrate the earth and at all times you will not be as high as
mountains." 37 : 17). Dr. Naik is smart enough to know that ‘tamida bikum’ or ‘to
prevent the earth from shaking with you’, is a bit too stupid to be swallowed even by
Muslims who would generally gobble any nonsense eagerly, so he amuses his
audience by telling them that it is okay that earthquakes mostly happen in mountainous
regions, despite the fact that the Quran says mountains are like pegs that prevent earth
from shaking with a ridiculous example of patients and doctors. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW
think that the audience who participated in the event that debate confused with
exposure by DR Naik, whereas the KSW is confused it because he can not use his
reason well. But he was only able to show his hatred after hearing all the people
already understand was described by Professor Dr Naik. Whereas in attendance at the
ceremony were the intellectuals and scholars who have an average understanding was
far above him. He is only capable of boasting and feeling sore ears to hear the truth of
Koranic verses 'an delivered by someone who knows better. While the Ali Sina is just
an beaten who did not get seats to sit down with intelligent human beings. If the KSW is
also present, then surely he would fall asleep or making trouble there, because the
event not be given for an idiot man).
Oceanology of the Quran,
(Dr. Naik) In the field of Oceanology, the Glorious Qur’an says, in Surah Furqan, Ch. No.
25, Verse No. 53, that…‘It is Allah who has let free two bodies of following water - One
sweet and palatable, the other salt and bitter. Though they meet, they do not mix. Between
them there is a barrier which is forbidden to be trespassed. Qur’an says in Surah Rahman,
Ch. 55 Verse No. 19 and 20……. (Arabic) ……‘It is Allah who has let free two bodies of
flowing water. Though they meet, they do not mix. Between them there is barrier, which is
forbidden to be trespassed.’ Previously the commentators of the Qur’an wondered…‘What
does the Qur’an mean? We know about sweet and salt water - But between them there is a
barrier - though they meet do not mix. Today after advancement of Oceanology, we have
come to know, that whenever one type of water flows into the other type of water, it looses
its constituents, and gets homogenized into the water it flows. There is a slanting
homogenizing area, which the Qur’an refers to as ‘Barzak’ ‘unseen barrier’ And this has
been agreed upon by several Scientists, even of America , by the name of Dr. Hay - he is
an Oceanologist.
And Dr. William Campbell writes in his book that…‘It is an observable phenomena. The
fisherman of that time knew there were two types of water… salt and sweet So Prophet
Mohammed during an expedition to Syria , he may have gone in the sea, or he might have
spoken to these fishermen.’
Sweet and salt water is an observable phenomenon, I agree - But people did not know that
there was an unseen barrier, until recently. The Scientific point to be noted here is the
‘Barzak’ - not the sweet and the salt water.
(Ali Sina) If the separation of sweet and salt waters is an observable phenomenon, as
it seems that everyone agrees, then how could no one know about it until "the
advancement of oceanology" made its knowledge possible? What Muhammad is
referring to is precisely that and nothing more. There is no “invisible barrier” between
two waters, which is “forbidden to be trespassed”. There is no barrier of any kind - no
barzakh at all between waters. Waters don’t mix immediately because of different
temperature and density but they eventually do, just like when you pour cream in a cup
of coffee. It takes time to mix; that is why you stir it. Those who saw this phenomenon
must have relayed their observation to others using figurative speech saying waters
don’t mix AS IF there is an invisible barrier between them. Our ignorant Muhammad
took this literally and claimed there is an “invisible barrier” between them, which is
“forbidden to be trespassed”. Nothing can be further from the truth. All waters mix and
there is no barrier, invisible or otherwise between them. When two rivers, carrying
sediments of different colors meet, or when sweet water coming from rivers flows into
the blue salty water of the sea, one can see the line of demarcation sometimes
stretching for miles until they gradually blend. Where the waters merge, i.e. what Dr.
Naik refers to as the “slanting homogenizing area”, is not a “barrier”. It is the opposite of
it. There the waters are not forbidden to trespass but actually merge.
It is amazing that Muslims emphasize on the flagrant errors of the Quran as its
miracles. Who would buy this nonsense except a totally ignorant person?
So, do not isolated too long alone in the cava of ghost or in a volcano crater, but came
to the meeting between the river in the bottom of the sea. KSW this regard has been
exploring the entire on Earth, so he thought that he already knew all the miraculous
events on earth. This proves that he just an impostor man, selling soy sauce which are
not qualified, like a frog under the shell, then made a speech in front of crowds that he's
the most smart, he already knows everything. These are the characteristics of a demon.
That man do not know this himself, do not understand at all with that referred to "the
confluence of two water do not mix, as if there were gaps between them." He thinks that
the information of Al-Quran is not scientific, because he can do proved that all of the
rivers is "definitely the river water mixes with sea water." The devil of estuary can only
observe that the flow of river water is dirty brown colored in a flow of the river
eventually united in the middle of the sea. But he had never seen the river below the
ocean where the water entered to the ground of the sea where river water is not mixed
or separate themselves with sea water. As seen below (see here);

Mr. Jacques Yves Costeau directly to the river below the sea

Mr. Jacques Yves Costeau near river seabed

water taste of that river is fresh and sweet, look Mr. Jacques Yves Costeau "emerging from the river

Mr. Jacques Yves Costeau
These are who dive Oceanografer experts , French nationality, called "Mr. Jacques Yves
Costeau ". This photo has been immortalized and have been aired on the Discovery Chanel `TV
show ', in almost all countries of the world. Nearly everyone has witnessed the truth of these
Qur'anic verses, except this KSW is certainly not willing to watch this documentary at all. Then
he spread his lies to the world. Now it was he ignored by TV viewers, when he know. But
unfortunately he never realized his stupidity that. The spreader of issues and this hatred is
really a useless human being and the main culprit for mankind.
According to information from this diver; "One day while exploring under the sea, suddenly
Captain Jacques Yves Costeau to see some fresh spring collection-a very savory taste fresh
because it does not mix / do not merge with the salty sea water surrounding , as if there are no
walls or membranes that limit both. The bizarre phenomenon unnerve Mr. Costeau and
encouraged him to find out the cause of separation of fresh water from salt water in the middle
of the ocean. He began to think, lest it just hallusination or imagination while diving. Time
continues to pass after the incident, but he never get satisfactory answers about the strange
phenomenon. Until one day he met a Muslim professor, then he tells the bizarre phenomenon.
The professor thought of the verses in the Qur'an about the meeting of two seas as written at
letter Ar-Rahman verses 19-20) which : let the two seas to flow through both later met, among
them there are not exceeded the limits of each." Then proceed with the description of Al Furqan
verse 53 which; "It is He who let the two seas to flow (adjacent), which is fresh and fresh again
another bitter salty again, and He made between them and the boundary walls that block."

Between mediterran sea and atlantic ocean , there are the boundary wall that block two seas.
Second verse These mutually reinforcing and complementary, so evident truth. Though the
location of the river was not found in the Arabian sea region but in the regions of Latin America
(at gulf of Mexico) it have never been visited by the Prophet Muhammad. Whereas the
description of 25:53 verse in the ocean that is proven in a meeting between the
Mediterranean and the Atlantic Ocean, precisely in the Gibraltar strait. Experts gad
been suspected that separation of the two seas are caused by differences in salinity,
temperature differences and differences in density of sea water. The existence of a new
dividing line is clearly visible when viewed from a satellite, on the contrary will not be
visible when observed from the ship or from the boat. This is a miracle of the
explanation of the verses of Qur'an that can not be denied anymore. Description of this
paragraph had been proved in 20 centuries, after the capture of images by the camera
or sensing via satellite. And the prophet Muhammad that have submitted that
paragraph had not seen the satellite at all, because at that time there was no satellite
technology like this melinium century.
But Ali Sina will never admit it. Because of his hatred of the verses of the Qur'an exceeds the
ability of his reason, so he's always talking nonsense without direction like the devil with the
filthy voodoo.
Finally Mr. Costeau had converted to Islam, because he is an example of a good man who has
a clean mind and heart to accept a truth that comes from the Creator.
But the atheist Ali Sina, will always deny the truth, spread hatred, to pit, brag, defamatory, being
arrogant, reject the existence of God who has created himself and the entire universe.
Embryology in Quran
(Dr. Naik) In the field of Embryology, Dr. William Campbell spent approximately half of
his talk on that. Time will not permit me to reply to every small thing which are illogical. I’ll
just give a brief reply, which will be satisfactory InshaAllah. And for more details, you can
refer to my Video cassette – ‘Qur’an and Modern Science’, and my other cassettes on…
‘Qur’an and Medical Science.’
There were a group of Arabs who collected the data dealing in the Qur’an about
‘Embryology’ and the Hadith dealing with Embryology. And they presented it to Professor
Keith Moore, who was the chairman and the head of the department of ‘Anatomy’, in the
University of Toronto , in Canada - And at present he is one of the leading scientists in the
field of ‘Embryology.’ After reading the various translations of the Qur’an, he was asked to
comment, and he said… ‘Most of the Verses of the Qur’an and the Hadith are in perfect
conformity with Modern Embryology. But there are a few Verses which I cannot say that
they are right neither can I say that they are wrong, because I myself don’t know about it.
And two such Verses were the first two Verses of the Qur’an to be revealed, from Surah
Iqra or Surah Alaq , Ch. 96 Verses No. 1 and 2 which says…(Arabic)… ‘Read, recite or
proclaim in the name of thy Lord, Who created, Who created the human beings from
something which clings - a leech like substance’. Regarding Dr. William Campbell’s
statement that…‘To analyse the meaning of a word, we have to see what was the meaning
at that time when it was revealed’-At that time when the book was written. And he rightly
said that to analyze the meaning, we have to analyze the meaning at the time it was
revealed, and to the people whom it was meant for.
See my response below.
Is Islam for All Mankind?
(Dr. Naik) As far as this statement of his is concerned, regarding the Bible, I do agree with
it totally - Because the Bible was only meant for the children of Israel , for that time. It is
mentioned in the Gospel of Mathew, Ch. No. 10, Verse No. 5 and 6, Jesus Christ peace be
upon him tells his disciples… ‘Go ye not in the way of the Gentiles.’ Who are the Gentiles?
The Non-Jews, the Hindus, the Muslims. ‘But rather go to the lost sheep of the house of
Israel .’ Jesus Christ peace be upon him said in the Gospel of Mathew, Ch. No. 15, Verse
No. 24… ‘I am not sent, but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel .’ So Jesus Christ and
the Bible were only meant for the children of Isreal. Since it was meant for them, to analyze
the Bible, you have to use the meaning of the word, which was utilized at that time. But the
Qur’an was not meant only for the Arabs of that time. Qur’an is not meant only for the
Muslims. The Qur’an is meant for the whole of humanity, and it is meant to be for eternity.
(Ali Sina) Here again the Muslim audience broke in applause and the sign of joy was
visible from their countenance. To them it was victory after victory. However, had Dr.
Naik told them that the Quran says that Muhammad has come only for the Meccans
alone and the people around it they would not have rejoiced that much.
(Rahmanhadiq; Only limited view of KSW to see the meaning of the debate, he will
never be able to understand a problem with reason is clear. His Ears and eyes
immediately sick to hear religious people hear good news)
006.092 And this is a Book which We have sent down. bringing blessings. and conIirming (the
revelations) which came beIore it: that thou mayest warn the mother oI cities and all around her.
The mother of cities, Umul Qura, is Mecca. The same thing is confirmed in verse:
(Rahmanhadiq; this paragraph describes the purpose of verse Al Qur''an revealed that
fix the previous books.
Though the book is repaired it is the Torah and the Gospels and Psalms. Third book
down on the Jews of Palestine to which the Qur'an down in Mecca. Two different places
and different nations too much. Long before the Jews and Persians always humbled to
Arabic peoples, but the description of al qur'an much improved and far more complete
and perfect than the teachings and rules of their religion. This means that Muhammad
received a stronger mandate and the legal owner of the Creator or the author's
previous books for improving for all mankind. The book is not only aimed at Arabic area
but who are outside of arabic environment, in accordance with the sound of the
paragraph above. So there's no reason to say that this verse was intended only for the
Arabs alone. KSW has been misunderstood in taking verses to pit against for Muslims
with Christian people. Who is in his brain is just hatred and pit against for human being
042.007 Thus have We sent by inspiration to thee an Arabic Qur’an: that thou mayest warn the
Mother oI Cities and all around her. (Rahmanhadiq; this verse to iustiIy and reinIorce the
inIormation above verses that the Qur'an is not iust aimed to the Arab nation in Arabia. but also
including other nations outside oI it.).
In other places Allah says to Muhammad that he has come for the people who did not
receive guidance yet bringing to them a book in Arabic so they can understand. The
implication is that the Quran is not for non-Arabs. The Quran further says:
032.003 “Nay. it is the Truth Irom thy Lord. that thou mayest admonish a people to whom no
warner has come beIore thee: in order that they may receive guidance.”
036.006 In order that thou mayest admonish a people. whose Iathers had received no
admonition. and who thereIore remain heedless (oI the Signs oI Allah).
(Rahmanhadiq; this verse in the previous paragraph statement that al qur'an given to
mankind anyone who is not never get the correct instructions about the revelations of
God. This means that this verse can give clues to people who have not previously get
the truth or in the process of seeking the truth. Only Satan and demons that can not
accept and acknowledge the existence of the Holy Qur'an because they were not
included descendants of the fathers of mankind. KSW certainly not human, but he was
the devil that intangible human to hostile all mankind who believe in God)
The people of the Book, i.e. the Jews, the Christians and perhaps the Zoroastrians had
their own messengers and their guidance. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW obviously just talking
to his an empty pipe dream, something that maybe in his mind already become a valid
conclusion at all.). The only people who had not received guidance were the Arabs,
specifically the Arabs of Mecca and its surrounding. So, it is clear that Muhammad
claimed that he had come only for the Quraish and not for the people of the Book and
the rest of mankind. (Rahmanhadiq; apparently it devil has a mind that the sentence
"Thus have We sent by inspiration to thee an Arabic Qur'an: that thou mayest warn the
Mother of Cities and all around her" is a very narrow limits which he said no more than
1 km
, whereas word “around the outside” or have a deeper understanding than just a
boundary locations. That is about the value of a truth proclaimed by a man who knows
no boundaries place, space and time. If that delivered it a truth, then someone else will
take it or adopt it to be applied in their life, wherever he is. Wherever it was good value
to be in, then the true man-advised counsel each other to exchange information and
helping each other. However, Ali Sina has been hurt first before people get the value of
truth . KSW will never recover from the illness chronically)
Of course, as he became powerful, his ambitions grew and he changed his mind later.
Few Muslims know about these verses. What do they say about them? If they truly
believe that the Quran is the word of God, they should stop their da'wa and Jihad. The
people of Mecca and its surrounding have already converted to Islam. If Muslims
believe that the Quran is the word of God, how do they dare to disobey Him and make
da'wa elsewhere. (Rahmanhadiq; not only the Arabs who willingly embrace and follow
the teachings of Muhammad with willingly, but the Indonesian nation whose population
far exceeds the population of Arabia and was never colonized or visited the Arab
country, to willingly embrace the teachings of truth proclaimed by the Great Prophet.
Because the truth is not going to look at the distance, tribe, nation and dignity but will
always be sought and benefit it and then carried out by people who have a sense of
right and good faith. Meanwhile, the KSW will continue to hinder the people to get the
truth and do good faith. Personal demons are already gives a chance to act contrary to
the value of goodness and truth. It is already known by all human beings are religious).
Even if Muhammad said they should attack other countries and convert others into
Islam, they should not listen to him but do what the Quran says. (Rahmanhadiq; thus
the incitement tactics presented by this KSW). Whose word is more important? That of
Allah or that of Muhammad? These verses should also convince the non-Arab Muslims,
including the Egyptians, the Syrians, the Iraqis and all others now known as Arabs that
Islam is not for them. Islam is only for the Meccans and its surrounding. They must
leave Islam, if they truly believe that the Quran is the word of God.
(Rahmanhadiq: Indonesia's population has never been attacked or colonized by the
Arabs, but the values of truth proclaimed by the great prophet, who makes all the
people in Indonesia follow him. Truth is not going to know the distance and difference in
the nation. Ali Sina is felt has failed to deter the human race to seek the truth and
practice it for good. Even at this millenium century more and more people are capable
of the respectable and intelligent human use common sense and a clean think to
accept the truth of the teachings that have been delivered by the Prophet all the time.
But KSW will continue to try to extinguish the truth wherever he is. He was only have a
sense of his hatred in order to his followers not move or leave him.).

(Dr. Naik) Qur’an says in Surah Ibrahim, Ch. 14, Verse. 52, in Surah Baqarah Ch. No. 2,
Verse 185, and Surah Zumar Ch. 39, Verses. 41, that the Qur’an is meant for the whole of
human kind. And Prophet Mohammed, may peace be upon him, was not sent only for the
Muslims or the Arabs. Allah says in the Qur’an in Surah Ambiya Ch. No. 21, Verse No. 107--
----(Arabic)----That We have send thee as a mercy, as a guidance, to the whole of
(Ali Sina) Verse 14:52 says “Hatha balaghun lilnnasi”. Nas is people – any number of
people. It could be people gathered in a room. It could refer to the inhabitants of a
village, a town, a country and not necessarily ALL Mankind. (Rahmanhadiq; there is
only an Ali Sina's idea of this. He said that what is meant by human in paragraph above
are who located any where at all. Not limited to the amount he assembled and in one
room only. That is, the sentence was addressed to the whole human race wherever it is
located including existing society in Indonesia. So actually KSW does not recognize the
breed of mankind this earth, he knew just the satan who entered in his gang alone.) For
example nas is used in verse 7.116 when talking about the magic performed by the
magicians of Pharaoh who bewitched the eyes of the people ‘nas’. Are we supposed to
understand that all mankind were bewitched? (Rahmanhadiq; KSW thinks that people
who follow the teachings of the prophet has been bewitched. He was only able to use
words that show disappointed that with one word "Magic", because he not able to
accept the reality that has happened. As long as he is only able to convey his voodoo to
show his bewitch for no faith peoples.) The same word is used in 2:185, 39:4 and
21:107. In all these verses Nas means "people" and not all mankind. If we assume that
the word 'nas' used in these verses means all mankind then we have to admit that there
is flagrant contradiction in the Quran for the verses 6:92, 42:7, 32:3 and 36:6 clearly
state that the Quran is for the people of Mecca and its surrounding.
However, Muhammad also claimed to have been sent to "creatures of both worlds".
lilAAalameen. means everything in both worlds. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is still reject
the word "Annas" means mankind. Of course he rejected such a notion, because he is
a creature of imitation derived from the class of Ghosts and the spirit evil. Ali Sina does
not have a good principle in his life which can only indulgence in lust and looking for
satisfaction to himself, he actually wants to be a happy man in his life but he always
failed. He always had a deep depression in his life, he was always overshadowed by
anxiety wherever he is, he always felt hopeless because he was never able to achieve
his wish that it was not logical. In fact the word " lilAAalameen " has a very deep
meaning that will not be able to be understood by Ali Sina this. His definitely logical will
not be able to open a philosophy of words “ruhmutan lilAAalameen “.ruhmutan
lilAAalameen said not only grace, mercy, guidance, news and a good way for humans
only, but more than it is for all living things created by the creator. But very sad because
Ali Sina is the man that can not be called a human being and can not also be
incorporated into ghost, but he is a class of so-invented creatures like devil, Dracula,
vampire and so on.).
It means everything in both worlds. (That includes dogs and pigs) (Rahmanhadiq;
these verses are often used by Ali Sina and his followers on their site which considered
as a new religion in this melinium century.) This is because he is a megalomaniac
narcissist narcissists and people are talking big. He even claimed to come as mentors
for the genie, who is a supernatural creature. The narcissist has a big idea about
themselves. (Rahmanhadiq; These the second of Ali Sina’s sentence that’s often
conveyed in every lecture on his site. Indeed, Muhammad is better to sent by the
Creator to the human group and genie, while the KSW is like an endemic disease that
is always thrown out because the contagious diseased and stinking. Ali Sina only sent
out for himself and then incited and cast a foul smell everywhere by his mouth is more
disgusting than last the dog ringworm vomiting)
Narcissists have grandiose ideas about themselves. In a Hadith Muhammad makes his
Allah say to him: “Were it not for you, I would not have created the universe.” [3]
(Rahmanhadiq; no hadist like this. This is the fantasy tradition of Ali Sina only. Ali Sina
is the Biggest lier)
Muhammad ibn Ali has narrated that Muhammad said: "Among all the people of the
world God chose the Arabs; from among the Arabs he chose the Kinana; from Kinana
he chose the Quraish; from the Quraish he chose Bani Hashim; from Bani Hashim he
chose Me. [Tabaqat V. 1 p. 2] This man was full of himself - a true narcissist. So much
for the alleged equality in Islam. Arabs are the chosen race. Arabs have known that
always and they treat non Arab Muslims with disdain. If you are a non-Arab Muslim, you
are accepting to be inferior. (Rahmanhadiq; in fact today, more than 1.5 billion human
beings express themselves Muslims on this earth, meaning that for every 4 people is a
Muslim and be 50 years from now will be 1:1. This is what is actually prevented by the
KSW , he is not willing to accept human values of truth and he will try hard to prevent
this. But by his efforts will be in vain and eventually he killed himself or kill others who
do not like by himself .)
Embryology continuation
(Dr. Naik) So as far as the Qur’an is concerned, you cannot limit the meaning only for that
time, because it is meant for eternity. So one of the meaning of ‘Alaqa’… is ‘leech like
substance’ or ‘something which clings.’ So Professor Keith Moore said… ‘I did not know
whether the early stage of the embryo looks like a leech’ And he went into his laboratory
and he analyzed the early stage of an embryo under a microscope and compared it with the
photograph of a leech, and he was astonished at the striking resemblance. This is a
photograph of a leech, and human embryo.
(Ali Sina) Are we supposed to believe that Dr. Keith Moore, who was the chairman
and the head of the department of Anatomy, of a major university did not know how
human embryo looks? (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina try again his ancient method, which
rejected any value of truth with the term " Are we supposed to believe? “. Where is no
provocateur who believe in the truth because in his mind there was only dirt and in his
soul there is only hatred and incitement ) The truth is that Dr. Moore and Dr. Bucaille
fooled Muslims by telling them what they wanted to hear and in this way they
ingratiated the Saudi King who in turn lavished them with a lot of petrodollars.
(Rahmanhadiq; once again KSW uses spark of a very foul his mouth odor. With his
disbelief, then he accuses others are inconsequential spreading lies when he did not
know what he was throwing with his false accusations. Ali Sina is really the figure of
Satan instigator and spreader lies and the most immoral for pit against for human life).
For a detailed story of the deception of these two charlatans see Abul Kasem’s article.
“How the Westerners Found $cience in the Quran.) (Rahmanhadiq; what else
cunning trap would be thrown by Ali Sina?)
The truth about embryology is already explained by Dr. Campbell. He demonstrated the
pictures showing that scientifically speaking, there is no resemblance between the
human embryo and leech. Furthermore he explained in detail where Muhammad got his
erroneous idea about embryo being a congealed clot of blood, like leech and chewed
meat. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is not able to receive if he had been formed from a
blood clot in his mother's womb . Because he's not human beings, because he does not
come from the father's sperm, he was a creature of imitation descent of voodoo or
dracula that unknown his origin. So he opposed that human fetuses at first still a blood
clot in his mother's womb. Lets translate that words; ّ َ »ُ ` ÷ then . 'َ -ْ -َ 'َ = ÷ the
sperm. َ ªَ -ْ =ّ ُ -'ا ÷ as (a drop of) become. ً ªَ -َ 'َ = ÷ ‘Alaqa’, a clot of congealed blood).
He got it from ancient Greek philosophers. These ideas were popular among the
ordinary Arabs at the time of Muhammad. They were wrong and so was Muhammad.
(Rahmanhadiq; it was obvious that Ali Sina is not completely understood by medical
science. But he talks like a professor of world-renowned a Gynecologist. He did not
read the development of medical science, because his book is a collection of spells that
is how he create to take some money for all kinds of battles that have no rules. Though
medical science on the subject of content and embryologi known in the 19th century
after the discovery of a core element of life that is chromosomal in 1900, 14 centuries
after Muhammad's birth. So if Muhammad was accused of stupid about medical
science or the science of genetics as it is today, then it is reasonable, because at the
time of his life, there is no science of Genetics, Gynecology and embryology. He just
submitted an information from the Creator of this nature. Surely God will prove it
through the discovery of Gynecologist , Emryologist, obstetrician, and Geneticist. The
science of medicine and science Gynecology evolving today. However the medical
science has begun to uncover the truth of the writings of Al Qur'an, which used to be
very ridiculed by people like KSW this. But now there are still Human outdated back up
to mock the truth of the Al Qur’an verses like Ali Sina who do not know himself).
As for Alaqa, Dr. Campbell also proved that in Arabic, it means clot and not something
that clings as Dr. Bucaille has suggested. ( Rahmanhadiq; Dr Naik explain that
‘Alaqa’… is ‘leech like substance’ or ‘something which clings.’ , but Al Sina take
understanding that ‘Alaqa’ meanning ‘leech’. Ali Sina was a driveller, talkative, lier,
prevaricator and soon. Apparently KSW flattering higher the ability of DR Campbell,
because he had long lived in the Middle East that has fluent to speak Arabic. Yet the
language of Al Quran is much higher silver lining of the lingua franca in the Arabian
peninsula. Moreover, if only just a match and adjust a word in al quran with
understanding the scientific language. Moreover, a lot of parable has a very broad
meaning which should be viewed not with the mind or of reason but with clarity and
honesty think. The word 'Alaqa' means a blood clot which scientifically is an early form
before embrio development into a fetus in the womb of the mother, and this is not
disproved by any ginecologist experts. Unless Ali Sina who do not know this himself.
But if the sense of the word 'Alaqa' is translated as something of a leech, then that too
can be viewed from the observation of technology, from which side of human view. A
Keith Moore have the same views with Dr Naik in view of a blood clot attached to it, like
leech, because of the resemblance to the properties of blood-sucking leeches, although
not exactly the same. So depending on the perspective of the imagination. As the
following picture;)

This figure shows the age of the fetus at the age of 3-4 weeks. The
fetus is still shaped embryo. Anyone who looked at this embryonic
form will think like a leech, but other people might not look like
that. This problem of capability and one's imagination.

Dr. Campbell also showed that all stages of the growth of the embryo described in the
Quran are wrong. (Rahmanhadiq; In the debate, which might be of opinion among
them is the same. But even so, they have expressed their belief in the event that took
place in sportsmanship and fair. All viewers can judge who is right or who is wrong
according to reason and logic of each. If Dr. Campblell think so is better than compared
with KSW attitude that can only be spread incitement and hatred from behind the walls
of his house. KSW is only to convey contempt and hatred for no apparent reason and
was unable to maintain his lier in a forum that just and fair debate.)
He demonstrated this with pictures. No one can prove something different than what
the X rays reveal. (Rahmanhadiq; images demonstrated by DR. Campbell is a
scientific interpretation of results rather than binoculars attached directly to the
substance on the mother's womb at the time of formation of the embryo, so other
possibilities are there in fact is still there. But Dr. Campbell has expressed his opinion
openly and appreciated by all participants well. He deserves the award by arguing that
he believes it. Unlike Ali Sina, who was just able to catapult his oath from behind the
wall. That's how human traits not responsible.)
(Dr. Naik) What Dr. William Campbell showed you is the other perspective of it. If I show this
book - it looks like a rectangle - If I show you like that, it is a different perspective. That diagram
is given in the book - The diagram which you saw on the slide is even there - And I’ll deal with it
(Ali Sina) Here again the gullible audience became euphoric and clapped without realizing
that Dr. Naik is engaging in the fallacy of suppressing the evidence. (Rahmanhadiq;
apparently KSW is very allergic hear applause) . Dr. Campbell showed the picture of the
embryo from the front and from the side. Dr. Naik wants to convince his audience that they
should look at it from one angle only – the angle that it most resembles a leech. Of course
one who is determined to be fooled would be willing to look at things by standing on his head,
if that helps him to see them from the exact angle that would reconfirm his unreasoned faith.
That is why Muslims are unable to see the truth. Their tunnel vision does not allow them to
see things from all angles. If only they changed their perspective a little, they would see that
Islam is nothing but a big lie. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is not understand the meaning of a
parable. Therein lies his dyslexia. He translates the meaning of a parable with mathematics
formulation, of course not disconnected it at all. Though his big Teacher DR Naik explaining
a parable, that " If I show you like that, it is a different perspective". The teacher did
not explain the form of leeches that should be viewed from the direction of one side of view
only. This is of the Ali Sina the spreader slander for human life)

(Dr. Naik) Professor Keith Moore, after about 80 questions were asked to him, he said… ‘If you
would have asked me these 80 questions, 30 years ago, I would not have been able to answer
more than 50 percent - Because embryology has developed recently in the past 30 years.’ He
said this in the eighties.
Now, do we believe Dr. Keith Moore whose statement is available outside in the foyer - his
videocassette is available… ‘This is the truth’...’Anna-ul-Haq’... recorded statement. So will you
believe Dr. William Campbell’s personal conversation with Professor Keith Moore, or the one
mentioned in this book, with Islamic edition as well as the photograph that I had shown to you?
And in the videocassette available outside you can see it - He makes those statements. So you
have to choose which is more logical - Personal discussion with Dr. William Campbell or his
statement on Video. Like how Dr. William Campbell showed my video - 100 percent proof what I
(Ali Sina) This is again a false reasoning. What Dr. Moore said to Dr. Campbell and what he
said in the videos intended to be sold to Muslims could be two different things. He would
have made a fool of himself telling Dr. Campbell what he says for Muslim consumption. We
are not here to probe whether Dr. Moore is a liar or Dr. Campbell is reporting him
erroneously. We must look at the medical science. (Rahmanhadiq; of course Either Dr.
Campbell or Dr. Naik already read the contents of each book each other before appearing to
the forums. Of course they explain in the debate was principle problems only about to
different views, while analysis of the description can be read and explored in the book of
them that have been provided by outside the building committee. So the debate between of
them is open and fair. The audience can read more detailed description of books that has
been traded by Speakers outside the building. So there is nothing hidden in the debate either
indoors or outdoors. However, KSW is only able to spread sedition and suspicions that are
not logical to incite hatred spread ). We don't need the opinions of the experts when we can
easily find the facts on our own. Appealing to authority is called argumentum ad verecundiam
and this is another logical fallacy. (Rahmanhadiq; impossible to an arrogant Ali Sina trust
the opinion of an expert as powerful as Professor of Genetics anywhere in the world.
Because the scientists have delivered the news of truth that most feared and hated by
hordes of demons of KSW . That's how he shows pride and his proud bearing. Likely he was
the most correct only, while another man was wrong because someone else is only
confirming information the Qur'an ). We must see whether what the Quran says is supported
by science or not. We must not accept the words of anyone just because they are authorities.
They could have some ulterior motives. They might have lied and misrepresented the truth
for some personal gain. The ultimate authority is science, not Dr. Moore, Dr. Bucaille or Dr.
Campbell. Dr. Campbell has proved his case backing his argument with pictures. Unless
someone can produce pictures that tell a different story, the claims of this doctor or that
doctor are irrelevant. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina has been continually addressed by babbling
hatred to his follower). Once things are demonstrated to us, we can dispense with the
opinions of authorities. (Rahmanhadiq; that's the difference between truth proclaimed by a
man who has the expertise in their field, compared with that delivered by a man named Ali
Sina. KSW in only able to convey a notion with the intention of hatred and incitement, while
the experts took the conclusions of the study which long time and complicated according to
the findings of the research and according to scientific principles and fair.)
(Dr. Naik) ‘Moon is reflected light’ - I’ll come to it later on.
And whatever additional information he got from Qur’an and Hadith, it was incorporated later into
this book…‘The Developing Human’ - the 3
edition and this book got an award for the best
medical book written by a single author in that year.
(Ali Sina) Is Dr. Naik telling us that Dr. Moore got an award for the book he wrote claiming
the ridiculous Quran is scientific? Who gave that award? Al Azhar University or the Grand
Mosque in Medina? What is the name of that award?
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is felt hurt again to hear someone else gets the award other than
himself. Of course because he will never get the appreciation of human beings who have
honest thinking. Clearly appreciation was not given by the Islamic university, but a famous
university in Canada).
(Dr. Naik) This is the Islamic edition that was put forward by Shaikh Abdul Majeed Al-Jindani
and certified by Keith Moore himself. The Qur’an says in Surah Muminun, Ch. 23 Verse No. 13,
and Surah Haj Ch. 22, Verse No. 5, and no less than 11 different places in the Qur’an, that the
human beings have been made from a ‘nutfa’ ‘minute quantity of liquid’…like a trickle that is
remaining in the cup. ‘Nutfa’ in Arabic… a very small quantity. Today we have come to know, that
in one seminal emission, in which there are several millions of sperms only one is required to
fertilize the ovum. ‘The Qur’an refers as ‘nutfa.’
(Ali Sina) Any 12 year old boy learning to play with himself and discovering his bodily
functions knows that semen is no more than a few drops. (Rahmanhadiq; it mean that Ali
Sina is feeling embarrassed and not willing to admit the truth of the Al Qur'an verse caused
his hatred. So in this case, al qur'an does not say wrong. Apparently Ali Sina is often
learning to play with himself and discovering his bodily functions to release his own sperm).
Arabs called that nutfa. Where does the Quran say anything about millions of sperms? What
Muhammad saw was a drop and that is what he was talking about. He did not know that this
drop contains millions of sperms. He thought it is this drop that becomes alaqa, which is of
course not true. (Rahmanhadiq; as noted earlier, that Muhammad was not an expert
embryologist who live in this 2-millenium century. He just convey what has been written in the
al qur'an it. The task of men to prove the truth of the verse. So far, the trial of fun of by the
culprit was always evident. However, Ali Sina is still close his eyes from the truth that has
been proven by scientific discovery of this 2-millenium century. The verses al quran not
“Sceince” but “the sign”. Verses of the Qur'an is a sign or something which can be used as
basic instructions to guide the results of scientific itinenary. Al qur'an does not teach the
things exhaustiely and technology issues exactly. But KSW is request for more, so that Al
Qur'an must explains how many sperm are emitted. This showed his childish, because so far
he never wanted to learn properly and diligently. Ali Sina is already in setting to spread
hatred and slander that is not useful. He will not be able to use a logical minds to discover
science, which is based on research results correct. His brain is full of guesses and hunches
that are not scientific. In his mind there was only dirt and rottenness and spread the rotten
smell everywhere. In order help Ali Sina to pass the embryology course that has been
repeatedly described by his Master Dr Naik, then Rahamanhadiq have to help him. If he does
not pass next semester too, so he's better at Drop-out and ordered to be imprisoned again
just below the volcano crater or studying more qualified to oppose his Master. Well,
rahmanhadiq will repeat the lesson given by our Teacher Professor Dr Naik , ranging from
early lessons last semester.; Rahmanhadiq will start from the origin of human events that are
created from the soil, in accordance with what is conveyed by the verses of the Qur'an;
“Man We did create from a quintessence (of clay); (QS 23:12)”
But Ali Sina it likely will not be belived to al quran description above, because the information
was intended to mankind only. While Ali Sina is not a descent human beings , he was
imitation of compatriots ghost haunts or a group of vampire who lost in the midst of human
life, so that he can not mingle in human being.
The above verse gives clues that humans were originally derived from soil or charcoal ( the
basic material for organic and an-oraganic compounds);, then human was reproduction
(bred) with a sexual way, in which the seedlings or seeds of male (sperm) are embedded in a
woman's uterus as described by the next verse which reads ;
“Then We placed him as (a drop of) sperm in a place of rest, firmly fixed; (QS 23:13)”
Context of Surah Al Mu'minin verse 13 above explain and give instructions to us about
putting sperm in a solid place in the womb or the mother's womb. Scientific question: whether
the uterus is a strong place? It turns out scientific evidence explaining that the true mother's
womb is a very strong to withstand the results of fertilization that are embedded in the uterine
wall. Does Dr. Naik dumbest student named Ali Sina, still do not understand well? Or still
does not believe that scientific evidence? If KSW do not also believe, the better for him , it
was to enter again into the womb of his mother, if indeed he has a mother. If he did not want
too, then better go to hell alone.
Then the description verse 13 is reinforced again by the surah of Al Qiyamaah verse 37
which reads;
“ Was he not a drop of sperm emitted (in lowly form)? (QS 75:37)”
From Al Qiyamaah verse 37 above indicated that the pregnancy is due to spill sperm into
the woman's uterus. So the Quran has been explained that the incidence of human embryos
is a result of a meeting between semen sperm with something in the womb.
At the time this verse was revealed, there is no gynecologist and obstetrician all. At that time
people do not understand about the egg, especially if a woman also has egg in her womb.
This reasoning is far from the reach of human knowledge at the time. But the AL Quran was
delivered with a style that is acceptable to everyone, including people of ignorance in the era
of Muhammad. This is indeed a reality, where every male who copulate will feel the release
of sperm. That is the reality conveyed by the Qur'an. In this case, al-Quran does not mean
that there are no eggs from the woman's body. Development of new modern science find any
eggs in the woman's body after the 20th century, long after the revelation of the Qur'an. In
the surah Al Qiyaamah verse 37 above, God still has not insisted on the existence of eggs
inside a female body, the duty of men to examine it later in life.
The God was the most Gracious, compassionate and give again a few clues hidden in the
Qur'an in surah Al-Insaan verse 2 which reads;
“Verily We created Man from a drop of mingled sperm, in order to try him: So We gave
him (the gifts), of Hearing and Sight. (QS 76:2)”
In Surah Al Insaan verse 2 above, God challenged for humans to investigate something that
mixes other than the sperm. Looks like God in the Qur'an convey His instructions with a very
simple for the peoples of the prophet Muhammad at the time of that ignorance.
The next question is: What happens after sperm embedded in the woman's uterus or after
fertilization ? Whether the formation of human was directly or several stages? how reality
discovered by science? How the AL Quran explain? Is Science observations according to
instructions of Al Quran?
If we look at the process of human events ranging from fertilization, zygote formation and
zygote splitting (still in the form of blood clot), then he is stuck in the wall of mother's womb to
suck blood (like a leech), then form a sheath ( placenta), followed by the formation of other
body organs, then formed fetus, then the fetus continues to grow and develop into a fetus
(baby), to perfect until he is ready to be born.
Stages of human events in the belly of her mother had explained in the AL Quran, long
before the medical scientist to prove, as stated in the letter of Al Mu'minuun verse 14 which

'َ -ْ·َ -َ ´َ · ِ ='ً -'َ = َ ªَ ·ْ -ُ -ْ 'ا 'َ -ْ -َ 'َ =َ · ً ªَ ·ْ -ُ - َ ªَ -َ 'َ ·ْ 'ا 'َ -ْ -َ 'َ =َ · ً ªَ -َ 'َ = َ ªَ -ْ =ّ ُ -'ا 'َ -ْ -َ 'َ = ّ َ »ُ `

َ .-ِ -ِ ''َ =ْ 'ا ُ .َ -ْ =َ أ ُ ªّ َ ''ا َ كَ ر'َ -َ -َ · َ ·َ =' 'ً-ْ 'َ = ُ -'َ -ْ'َ -ْ -َ أ ّ َ »ُ ` 'ً -ْ =َ ' َ م'َ =ِ ·ْ 'ا

“Then We made the sperm into a clot of congealed blood; then of that clot We made a (foetus)
lump; then we made out of that lump bones and clothed the bones with flesh; then we developed
out of it another creature. So blessed be Allah, the best to create!”(QS 23:14)
Next verse explains that the drop (a drop) or one of sperm emitted, will fertilize something in
the uterus (egg). This is perpetuated by the information verse on sarah Al Qiyamah 36-37,
which reads;
“Does man think that he will be left uncontrolled, (without purpose)?36, Was he not a drop of
sperm emitted (in lowly form)? (QS 75:35-36)”
Then proceeded by the formation of embryo that is still a blood clot attached to the mother's
womb. This is reinforced and perpetuated by the next verse description of surah Al Qiyamah
above letter, which reads;
“Then did he become a leech-like clot; then did (Allah) make and fashion (him) in due proportion.
(QS 75:38)”
After a week of 3 - to 5 take place the formation of an embryo in the form of a lump of meat
which continues to expand in the womb.
In the lumps of meat that continues to expand it, start the formation of bone and skeletons.
Furthermore, the bone has been formed, bonded by the nearest meat to form the muscles
according to the location and the function of these bones. Maturation and improvement of
the composition of bone, meat and other vital organs continue until reaching week 8, and at
the end of the 9th week the embryo is shaped baby (fetus) or a small man who continues to
experience more robust growth until the waiting time of his birth.
So there are three phases of transformation of human events in the mother's womb. First is
pre-embryonic phase of conception until the formation of zygotes which still form blood clots,
the second phase of embryonic (embryo) in the form of lump meat or vital organs and the
formation of bones, the third phase in which the fetus or newborn infant occurs organ
formation process improvement vital organs and binding of the bones with muscle tissue.
Then Fetus continue improvement to form a more perfect until the waiting time of his birth in
the week to 38 up to 40 (read the book "Williams P., Basic Human Embryology", 3. Edition,
1984, s. 64.).
Phase change or human development in the womb of Mother, has been immortalized by the
Al Qur'an 1,400 years ago before can be found by gynecologist . While the medical expert on
the world proved after the 20th century. As in the letter Az Zummar verse 6 which reads;
“ He makes you, in the wombs of your mothers, in stages, one after another, in three veils of
darkness. (QS 39:6)”
Three darkness is meant by the paragraph above, has a fairly broad sense. Among others
may be 3 phases of change shape as already observed above (zygot, embryo and fetus) and
can also form of 3 darkness when the baby is still tasteless in a sealed envelope (placenta).
Only food that is derived from maternal blood to be entered into the sheath potential baby.
Even bacteria and sperm will not be able to penetrate the dark veil of the placenta. The third
layer is a layer of the placenta consisting of amnion, chorion and Alantois.
Some other interesting things made by God in the Al Qur'an about human events in the
uterus, among others;

A.. The sex of the baby to be born
According to the Qur'an, the sex of a baby who born had been given by seed (sperm) from
the Father. As enshrined in sura Am Najm verses 45-46, which reads;
“That He did create in pairs,- male and female 45, From a seed when lodged (in its place) 46
(QS 53:45-46)”
Verse above describes the human events both men and women who are determined by the
semen (sperm) emitted. Then after a day of Judgement, man will be raised again with
different forms of events that go unnoticed by humans.
Branches of science that develops as genetics and molecular biology have scientifically
validated the accuracy of information provided this Al-Qur'an. It is now understood that sex is
determined by sperm cells from the male, whereas women do not play a role in the process
of determining the sex of this.
Chromosomes are the main element in the determination of gender. Two of the 46
chromosomes that determine gender. Two pairs of chromosomes are "XY" in men, and the
pair "XX" in females. Y chromosomes carry genes that encode the properties in men,
whereas the X chromosome carrying the genes that encode the properties of womanhood.
Formation of a human cross originated from the merger of one of these chromosome pairs in
both men and women. In women, the second part of sex cells, which split into two events
during ovulation, carry X chromosomes. In contrast, a male sex cell produce two different
sperm cells, one containing the X chromosome, and the other containing the chromosome Y.
If a chromosome Y sperm `joined and paired with a female egg cell that carries the X
chromosome, then the baby to be born male baby's sex. Meanwhile, if one cell spermas with
X chromosome of men joined and paired with an egg cell that carries the X chromosome,
then the baby to be born female gender.
In other words, a baby's sex is determined by which chromosome from the male who joined
or paired with a female egg cell. This means that the process of arranged marriages of
couples it’s chromosome that determines sex, whether the X meet X or X met Y?.
B.. Imperfect of pregnancy
Sometimes on the phase formation from zygote to embryo stage experience events that are
not perfect so there will be a miscarriage, pregnancy failure or bleeding. But the failure or
miscarriage of pregnancy rarely occurs after the fetus is turned into a fetus because of its
position in the uterus has been very strong and perfect. Failure and miscarriage often occurs
during the first trimester. It has been told by the Al Qur'an mentioned in sura Al-Hajj verse 6
which reads;
O mankind! if ye have a doubt about the Resurrection, (consider) that We created you out of
dust, then out of sperm, then out of a leech-like clot, then out of a morsel of flesh, partly
formed and partly unformed, in order that We may manifest (our power) to you; and We cause
whom We will to rest in the wombs for an appointed term, then do We bring you out as babes,
then (foster you) that ye may reach your age of full strength; and some of you are called to die,
and some are sent back to the feeblest old age, so that they know nothing after having known
(much), and (further), thou seest the earth barren and lifeless, but when We pour down rain on
it, it is stirred (to life), it swells, and it puts forth every kind of beautiful growth (in pairs).
( QS 22:5). "
Description sura Al-Hajj also strengthens the explanation contained in the sura of Al
Mu'minuun verse 14, as described above was, that is about the phases of the formation of
the fetus in the womb .. There is nothing contradictory in the description of the verses of Al
Qu'an, all mutually reinforcing and complementary.
Thus miracle of Qur'anic verses that Allah revealed to Prophet Muhammad. Though he can
not know in detail the scientific developments in present century, because he is an illiterate
person, with absolutely no scientific education. So it is true that Muhammad only convey
Revelation he received from God. actual omniscient and all-right on the testimony of the
Qur'an is Al Allah. The conclusion is that the Al Qur’an was not written by Prophet
Muhammad SAW, but the word and revelation from Allah SWT. Supreme true God with all
His Word. MashaAllah?
Of course the excitement and the good news of the sentence delivered by rahmanhadiq
above will be rejected by the KSW, because he is not a descendant of man, because he was
disguised as human beings. He hated to hear the good news, especially that delivered by the
verses in the religious books, especially the verse of the Qur'an. Actually he's afraid of the
information conveyed by the Qur'an, but he hid his fears by making the opinion and
compensation in a way opposed to the Al Qu'an. He's scared to death that rapidly growing
Islamic religion which is already seeing signs that direction, so he did not have room to
spread hatred and his scolding, he will be isolated and die himself. For that he invited anyone
who would join him to oppose the teachings of Islam and Muslims anywhere in the world. But
he was not aware and have made a big mistake, even with the hostile attitude of truth
proclaimed by Islam, the more and more people are interested to learn the values of the truth
of Islam . And finally he will be desperate to see the fact that will happen, how not longer
than a lot of the peoples troop after the truth of islam.

(Dr. Naik) Qur’an says in Surah Sajda Ch. 32 Verse no. 8…‘We have created the human beings
from ‘Sulalah’ - That means the best part of a whole. The one sperm which fertilizes the ova out
of the millions of sperms, the Qur’an refers to as ‘Sulalah’…‘best part of the whole.’
(Ali Sina) Here are various translations of this verse:
Then He made his seed Irom a draught oI despised Iluid;
YusuI Ali
And made his progeny Irom a quintessence oI the nature oI a Iluid despised:
Then He made his oIIspring Irom semen oI worthless water
Then He made his progeny oI an extract. oI water held in light estimation.
Sher Ali
Then HE made his progeny Irom an extract oI an insigniIicant Iluid;
Then He continued his reproduction through a certain lowly liquid.
then He Iashioned his progeny oI an extraction oI mean water.
then He made his stock Irom an extract oI despicable water;
Then ordained his progeny Irom germs oI liIe. Irom sorry water:
and aIterwards made his posterity oI an extract oI despicable water;
Thumma iaAAala naslahu min sulalatin min ma-in maheenin
Far from calling nutfa or semen “the best part of a whole” Muhammad is saying that it is a
despised fluid, ‘ma-in maheenin’. Isn ' t it clear that Dr . Naik is not at all concerned about
lying ?
(Rahmanhadiq; turned out to Ali Sina is looking for another way to divert the topic question
previously he did not understand at all, and even not able to refute it. Then he took a
sentence stating that "semen is despicable". With that way, he incited mankind in order to
oppose the description of al qur'an who had insulted humanity. He used the ancient
technique to incite and hate to anyone who ever read the description of al qur'an it. It is a
further proof, that he did not also understand a sentence parable information contained in the
above sentence. He was only able to analyze the meaning of this parable with its
mathematical formula. This proves that Ali Sina is a human figure that has no conscience
anymore because it was filled by hatred and pit politics to human being, he just relies on the
power of thinking which turned out to contain feces.
Whereas someone who has a conscience and the right mind would understand and realize,
that the human actually comes from something that emanated from his own genital tool that
also as a place that smelled of urine disposal of urine, which if this semen was allowed to rot
or smell very fishy once. Hence, man should realize about their origins and the story, so she
would not be proud and arrogant as that is always shown by the KSW of this. That's the
meaning of philosophy contain in that sentence, but the Ali Sina is never realized at all.
That's because he always indulge the evil desires, evil).
(Dr. Naik) And Qur’an says in Surah Insan, Ch. 76 Verse No. 2…‘We have created the human
beings from ‘nutfatun amshaj’…a minute quantity of mingled fluid’ - referring to the sperm as well
as the ovum - Both are required for the fertilization.
(Ali Sina) Amshaj means thickened or mingled. Muhammad saw that sperm is a tick liquid.
Nutfa means sperm - precisely the liquid that contains the sperms. It does not mean the
zygote or the embryo. (Rahmanhadiq; turns out reason Ali Sina is really disorder. He writes
that the word “Amshaj” means something that is thick or a mix. He not know that at the drop
of semen that contains only one kind of material that is "Sperm" which is ½ of the existing
elements of chromosomes in human beings?. Perhaps he thought that semen was a mixture
of his brain that dirty stinking. It is clear that the KSW does not understand about
embryology, but acting smart exceeds an expert profersor of Ginecology and any Embryologi
in this world. KSW is required to write the Qur'an word ” Zygote or embryo to prove its truth.
This is how KSW deceive and spread incitement and hatred to twist the facts. Ali Sina is the
man who acted smart.)
023.013 Then We placed him as (a drop oI) sperm ‘nutfa’ in a place oI rest. Iirmly Iixed.
023.014 Then We made the sperm ‘nutfa’ into a clot oI congealed blood;
Mother, in Muhammad’s embryology is only an incubator. She does not contribute genetically
to the formation of the embryo. (Rahmanhadiq; visible once this KSW speech rhetoric style,
this shows that he does not understand about the scientific at all. KSW is, is really no logic.
Whereas in the previous paragraph already explained, that in the womb of semen emitted
(the term now is "sperm"), which of the "drop of semen" (cool word now is "the single sperm
cell" of the millions of other sperm), will be mixed with something. And the following
description of al qur'an explained that the mixture ( the term now is "spema meeting with the
egg"), will be stored in a sturdy place called the womb (the term is "uterus"). In the next
development will be a blood clot. Though this lesson was taught by the teacher several times
and assisted by an of Dr. Naik’s assistant to Ali Sina, but he still can not hear it. Instead he
turned talks and accused the pregnant woman as an incubator. That incitement is not quality
that always smell exhaled from his mouth. At the time the verse was revealed to Muhammad
, medical science has not been there at all any more about the information that in the uterus
of female egg cell is also there. Muhammad was told only, and it turns out the experts and
Ginecologist and Embryologist in this millenium century has been proved right. KSW
belonging envy and jealous indulgence only without being able to accept the facts.)
036.077 Doth not man see that it is We Who created him Irom sperm? ‘nutfa’
075.037 Was he not a drop oI sperm ‘nutfa’ emitted (in lowly Iorm)?
There is no allusion to 'two sexes' or female egg in any of the verses speaking of embryo.
Here is how other translators of the Quran have translated nutfatin amshajin
(Rahmanhadiq; His incitement stance is not qualified in by the mouth smelly gutter again. It
seems the disease is no longer curable. Whereas in the previous paragraph already
explained the meaning of mixing sperm in the mother's womb. Many of Al Qur'an has a verse
that clearly and precisely describe and explain human events. So can not just use a single
verse, by ignoring other verses related to the topic discussion.)
Pickthall: drop oI thickened Iluid.
YusuI Ali: drop oI mingled sperm.
Shakir: small liIe-germ uniting (itselI)
Sher Ali: mingled sperm-drop
Arberry: a sperm-drop. a mingling.
Palmer: a mingled clot.
a couple of translators also have tried to be smart like Rodwell who has translated it as: “the
union of the sexes”. But this is only Islamic deception.
Dr. Campbell said that “The Qur’an agrees with Galen here, when it says in Surah 76:2, ‘We
created man from a drop of mingled sperm’” Dr. Campbell is too generous. Galen knew that
woman must also contribute something to the formation of the fetus, although he erroneously
thought this something is congealed blood. But Muhammad did not think any female
contribution is needed. Mother was only an incubator in his mind.
(Rahmanhadiq; So people who think clearly and be honest should be found the meaning of
the parable that conveyed by the description of Al Qur’an verse with the words "mixed" it.
Medicine experts of the world in this millenium century has proved that “mixing” is between
sperm cells and egg in the uterus. So the words "mixed" in the description of al quran verse,
it is not a lie even match with the invention of modern medical science. Only KSW was not
able to accept the meaning of the word mixed, according to the contents of his brain that
have been mixed between hatred and incite it.)
(Dr. Naik) The Qur’an describes the various embryological stages in great detail, of which the
slides were shown to you - Dr. William Campbell; he helped me to complete this topic. It is
mentioned in Surah Muminun Ch. 23, Verses No. 12 to 14 - The translation is that…‘We have
created the human beings from a ‘nutfa.’ – ‘A minute quantity of liquid.’ Then placed it in
‘qararen makeen’ - a place of security. Then We made it into an ‘Alaqa’ - a leech like substance -
something which clings - a congealed clot of blood. Then We made that ‘Alaqa’ into a ‘Mutga’ a
‘chewed like lump.’ Then We made the ‘Mutga’ into ‘Izama’…bones. Then clothed the bones
with ‘leham’… flesh. Then We made it a new creature. Blessed be Allah Who is the best to
These 3 Verses of the Qur’an, speak about the various embryological stages in great detail. First
the nutfa placed in a place of security - Made into an ‘Alaqa’. Alaqa has got 3 meanings - One is
‘something’ which clings’, and we know that in the initial stages, the embryo clings to the uterine
wall and continues clinging till the end. Point No.2, that it also means a leech like substance, and
as I discussed earlier, the embryo in the initial stages, does look like a leech. Besides looking like
a leech - it also behaves like a leech - It receives its blood supply from the mother’ like a
bloodsucker. And the 3
meaning which Dr. William Campbell objected to - that is the right
meaning… ‘the congealed clot of blood’- And that is why Qur’an has a scientific error. And I do
agree with him that Dr. William Campbell did not agree. He said how can it mean a congealed
clot of blood, because if this is the case, then the Qur’an is wrong. I am sorry to say Qur’an is not
wrong - Dr. William Campbell with due respect to him… He is wrong. Because today…today…after
advancement of embryology, even Dr. Keith Moore - He says that… ‘In the initial stages, the
embryo, besides looking like a leech, also looks like a congealed clot of blood, because in the
initial stages, of the stage of ‘Alaqa’, 3 to 4 weeks, the blood is clotted within closed vessels. And
Dr. William Campbell made it easy for me - He showed you a slide. It will be difficult for you to
see - But this is the slide he showed you.

This is exactly what Professor Keith Moore said… ‘Looks like a clot, in which the blood is clotted
within closed vessels. And during the 3
week of the embryo, the blood circulation does not take
place - it starts later on - Therefore it assumes the appearance of a clot. And if you observe the
conspectus - that is after abortion takes place, you can see it looks like a clot.
(Ali Sina) This picture does not look like a clot. Of course if you don't have a microscope you
may see it that way. But that is not a scientific statement. Anyone could have seen an
aborted embryo and say it looks like a congealed clot. Is that scientific? Where is This part is
already explained by Dr. Campbell who showed why the Quranic description of the
development of the embryo is all wrong. (Rahmanhadiq; here's how a former student who
never graduated, asked to his teacher. If he did not understand at all, then said that the
professor did not understand. Looks like this idiot students must be fed on, to be able to
explain what he did not understand. It seems Ali Sina is not follow the final level courses in
medical school, this little boy should have to repeat to start all over again, from elementary
school again. He does not understand reading an anatomy drawing venous blood flow and
aortic blood flow, of course, because he did not see any blood drop on the picture. So he did
not deserve was present at the event that debate, because his level is not allowed to
participate. If he was present at the event, of course, the committee will busy preparing
microscope facilities and other learning tools specific to the Ideot this. Or maybe he already
had enough to eat a meal in the form of immediate fresh blood from the woman who a
miscarriage as soon after. Even from the abortion of pregnancy under 40 days, still form
blood clots, which indicates that the fetus was still not resemble a child or fetus. )
Dr. Naik is repeating what Dr. Campbell has already refuted without trying to counter his
arguments. It was, first the Greeks who came up with these stages of the embryonic growth,
not Muhammad. And the Greeks were wrong. (Rahmanhadiq; this shows that the KSW was,
not knowing that in the days of Greek medical science had not been present at all, let alone
on the development of human embryo or fetus in the womb of the mother. So evident that Ali
Sina is talking not to use the brain but with who is in his pants and lust. So he put the blame
to the Greeks or the Arabs who did not know the science Embryologi).Even if this explanation
was true, no credit goes to Muhammad because he was only rehashing what others had said
a thousand years before him. (Rahmanhadiq; sentence delivered by the KSW, shows that
he knows the pregnancy news of old information that comes from the philosophy of the
Greeks only. So it is worth the Ali Sina have to learn again starting from kindergarten).
The Quran says that humans are created from nutfa (a drop of semen). Then placed in a
secure place (womb). Then We made it into a clot of blood, 'alaqa'. (No mention of female
egg.) Then We made that 'alaqa' into a ‘mutga’ a ‘chewed like lump.’ Then We made the
‘mutga’ into ‘izama’…bones. Then clothed the bones with ‘leham’… flesh. Then We made it a
new creature.
Well, this explanation is wrong. There is no need for me to repeat what Dr. Campbell already
explained so clearly. Mr. Naik thinks by repeating a lie often enough, it becomes true. But not
in this case! This description of the development of the embryo explained in the Quran is
scientifically wrong. (Rahmanhadiq; found out that the Ali Sina is not understood to what has
been described by the teachers on the development of the embryo in the womb. He was only
able to argue but does not explain the reasons that make sense to reinforce his opinion. The
crab boy was not able to speak the language scientifically correct, because he could not
speak the language of science at all. What is in his brain is his own feces so that he could
only spend a very bad smell nose piercing. The swashbuckler is indeed not worth discussing
participate in the event of Dr. Campbell by Dr. Naik, his ability is very limited. He's just
boasting challenging his teacher, but by learning to Recall 10 thousand years he will not be
able to defeat his teacher. The proper course, why if the Ali Sina is always avoided if invited
to an open debate in public which was witnessed by the whole world, because its ability is
very limited.)
(Dr. Naik) Only one line answer is sufficient to answer all the allegations of Dr. William Campbell
is that, the stages of the Qur’an while it describes the embryological stages, is only based on
appearance… Appearance. First is the appearance of the ‘Alaqa’, a ‘leech like substance’ as well
as a clot of blood.’ And Dr. William Campbell rightly said that some ladies come and ask… ‘Please
remove the clot’ - It does look like a clot. And the stages are based on appearance. It is created
from something, which appears like a clot, which appears like a leech, and is also something
which clings. Then the Qur’an says… ‘We made the ‘Alaqa’ into ‘Mutga’ – a chewed like lump.’
(Ali Sina) Here our good doctor is making a major shift of strategy. Now, he is no longer
insisting that the Quranic description of the embryo is scientific. He says that the Quran talks
about the “appearance” that exist between a clot, a leech and the embryo in its different
stages of growth. If so, why claim that the Quran is scientific and miraculous? In the past,
women had miscarriage way more than today. The fetus was aborted and they could see that
it remotely resembled, first to a clot of blood and then to a leech. In the absence of a
microscope this is all they could see. So, where is the miracle? Why make so much ado
about it saying “how could Muhammad have known this 1400 years ago?” when such a
prosaic knowledge was available to anyone for eons? In fact as Dr. Campbell noted,
Hippocrates described the embryonic growth much more accurately.
Rahmanhadiq; The KSW is not understood the scientific language and the language of
parable, so that he thinks that the teacher is speaking in the language of collogial. In fact
presented by the teacher is a parable or a comparison that is when a woman miscarried
during pregnancy under 40 days or the medical term "the first of trismester." This period is a
critical vulnerable period or miscarriage in consequence of the embryos are not strong
enough retained in the uterus wall. In the century of this millenium, at a critical time during
pregnancy, usually the doctor will give tonic womb as "alylestrenol" with the name of the drug
patent “Premastone” (Wow.. it’s promotion .. Doc.!).
That KSW is in translating the language metaphor conveyed not by scientific language, but
merely spread hatred and incite the audience who was not watching the debate within his
cricket fighting site.)
(Dr. Naik) Professor Keith Moore took plastic seal, and bit between his teeth to make it look like
a ‘Mutga’- The teeth marks resembled the ‘somites.’ Dr. William Campbell said… ‘When the
‘Alaqa’ becomes a ‘Mutga’ the clinging is yet there - It is there till 8 and a half months- So… the
Qur’an is wrong.’ I told you in the beginning, the Qur’an is describing the appearance. ‘The leech
like’ appearance and the ‘clot like’ appearance, is changed to the ‘chewed’ like appearance. It yet
continues to cling till the end - There is no problem. But the stages are divided on appearance -
Not on the function.
(Ali Sina) Alaqa either means something that clings or clot of blood. One word in one
sentence cannot have two different meanings. If alaqa is something that clings, then the fetus
should be called alaqa during all its gestation. Why then the Quran says it becomes mutga?
If it’s only the appearance to the clot, then we should discard Dr. Bucaille’s suggestion who
says this word should be translated as “something that clings”. If the Quran is clear, then why
this much confusion?
This, like other "scientific statements" made in the Quran, could have been observed by
anyone and there is nothing scientific in it. If I say the Moon looks like melon, I am right. But it
is not a scientific statement and I can’t be credited with divine knowledge for having said
something as banal as this. Therefore this hullabaloo about the Quran having predicted
modern science is hogwash.
Conclusion: If the description of embryo in the Quran is intended to be scientific, then it is
wrong. If it is only a reference to what it looks like, this was known to everyone at the time of
The verses of the Qur'an was not a science but a clue or a sign. The term used by the Qur'an
does not have the same term given by modern medical science. Al Quran only provide initial
guidance as a basis or a term that has very deep meaning, can also a parable, metaphor or
allegory. So Al-Qur'an can not be blamed when using terms that do not smell the technology
or medical terminology today.
The term used by the Qur'an is only a guide who never lie or contrary to the evidence in the
field of medical science. So in this case the word "Alaqa" became more widespread, because
the word is not referring to the function of a noun, but rather meant as an adjective from the
observed. This means that if the word "Alaqa" was defined as blood clots, then the term does
not infringe the principle of the discovery of the early stages of human embryo formation.
Indeed, the word will be different meaning when interpreted as the word "fetus" . Had these
words be interpreted as something inherent in the womb, then the term is also suitable,
because it does not conflict with the results Embryologi discoveries in the field, especially in
the early embryo stage is formed.
So God planted his words that are global and have a deep meaning, so that can understand
and knew by all levels of society from all aspects of any science. This is one the Qur'an
miracle that is not owned by any language in the other books. Because the terms used by
other books, always will be expired due to a recent discovery that could replace the discovery
This proves that the language be planted in the Qur'an by the Creator, was the Universal and
flexible language that can not be destroyed by any force. Though the language and terms
used in these verses existing 14 centuries before modern medicine was found, but the words
of the Al-Qur’an was never cracked by the turn of the period.)
(Dr. Naik) Later on the Qur’an says… ‘We made the ‘Mutga’ into ‘Izama’…bones - Then clothed
the bones with flesh.’ Dr. William Campbell said, and I do agree with him, that… The precursors
of the muscles and the cartilages… that is the bones, they form together - I agree with that.
Today embryology tells us that the primordial of the muscles and the bones - they form together
between the 25
and the 40
day, which the Qur`an refers to as the stage of ‘mudga.’ But they
are not developed… They are not developed. Later on, at the end of the seventh week, the
embryo takes form of human appearance - then the bones are formed. Today modern
embryology says the bones are formed after the 42
day, and it gives an appearance of a
skeletal thing. Even at this stage when the bones are formed, the muscles are not formed. Later
on, after the 7
week and the starting of 8
week, are the muscles formed. So Qur’an is perfect
in describing first ‘Alaqa’, then ‘Mutga’, then ‘Izama’, then clothed with flesh, and when they form
- the description is perfect.
(Ali Sina) This description is wrong no matter how many times it is repeated. I quote again
what Dr. Campbell said in the conclusion of his talk on embryo: “There is no time when
calcified bones have been formed, and then the muscles are placed around them. The
muscles are there, several weeks before there are calcified bones, rather than being added
around previously formed bones, as the Qur’an states.” This statement is scientific. The
Quran is not.
The KSW is better for not talk nonsense, because he talks seem folly always. Discovered
that he would not understand to what has been described by both speakers. It was obvious
that Ali Sina is too small and very stunted when confronted with these two distinguished
speakers above. Between the opinions of Dr. Campbell and Dr. Naik has much in common
so that Dr Naik approved research that results of Dr. Campbell in some of postulates.
However, the KSW is to create a different conclusion, so far once baked with fire.
Dr. Campbell concluded that the formation of bone and meat at the same time, it is approved
by Dr Naik, but from the results of some recent research indicates that there are some who
still have not developed bone called cartilage. This cartilage had been developed in the flesh,
to perfect during the 7-8 weeks later. So in this case, AL Qur'an does not tell lies. But Ali Sina
is to imagine a description by understanding the Qur'an is very much different, he thought the
bones were affixed to the meat at other times and place. So he imagined that, meat that has
been formed that will be attached to the bones that are growing at different locations. That
way of thinking, no wonder he did not pass of any lesson given by his teacher Naik DR.
Whereas the above verses of the Qur'an does not describe such a case, but his brain is
always error, so he was reading from talking like a magic formula. He had just acquired it
from the ocean floor.)
(Dr. Naik) As Professor Keith Moore said that… ‘The stages - that how it is described in modern
embryology… stage 1,2,3,4,5, is so confusing, The Qur’anic stage on embryology describing on
the base of appearance, and the shape, is far more superior.’ Alhamdulillah.
(Ali Sina) This is ludicrous. How can the Quran be superior when it is all wrong? Josef
Goebbel, Hitler's minister for propaganda said: "If you tell a big enough lie, frequently
enough, it becomes the truth." This is what Dr. Naik wants to achieve. He wants to repeat a
lie frequently enough, until it becomes true. I am sorry. It does not work in this case. The
description of the embryo in the Quran is all wrong. It won’t become true even if it is repeated
a billion times. Bones are not created first to be covered with flesh later. Period!
The New kid graduated elementary school, wants to teach about science Embryologi totally
weird for himself, of course highly improbable. KSW is felt very hurt when heard Dr. Naik
said the word "Alhadulillah" a very deafening for his ears. KSW is very allergic to the greeting
that was played by the teacher. Though his teacher Dr Naik has just submitted a figure of
speech or metaphor of the journey is so complex science of embryology and so long for a
century recently. But in the end produce a conclusion or postulates similar to what is already
conveyed in the verses of al Qur'an. Though these conclusions Qur'an existed long before
the experts get it Embryology, although the journey from the study for a long time and
winding road once. KSW is still not accept that in the process of development of the fetus in
the womb of the mother begins from meat. But the swashbuckler this does not explain the
scientific reason at all, this shows that the Ali Sina is just windbag only. In fact, he wants to
impose its conclusions to the audience with the words "Period" without reason acceptable to
common sense. Wow.. The Psychopath man.)
(Dr. Naik) Therefore he said… therefore he said that… ‘I have no objection in accepting that
Prophet Muhammed is the messenger of God and that this Glorious Qur’an has to be a Divine
Revelation, from Almighty God.’
(Ali Sina) If Dr. Naik is speaking of Dr. Moore, it should be noted that he did not convert to
Islam. This tells us that his interests were this-worldly. He did not see any miracles in the
Quran. He simply fooled the Muslims and laughed his way to the bank.
Dr Naik said that Dr Moore believes that Muhammad is the messenger of God and the Al-
Quran is a revelation from God, this is very painful ear of KSW. With these words he
immediately concluded that Dr. Moore had converted to Islam. Anxiety of the Shrimp brain is
terribly concerned, but his teacher did not say that Dr. Moore has been with the greeting of
Islam. This shows that the KSW was just thinking with his hatred was not wearing a clear
sense and reason at all. Even Satan could read the thoughts of Dr. Moore that he did not
believe in the miracle of the Qur'an, whereas Dr. Moore delivered his speech in front of the
student at visiting to various universities in the Middle East. That's how Satan pit and inciting
to the religious community in the world. Then he went on his inciting to think that Dr. Moore
went to the bank to take some money. So prove that, an acronym true name for Ali Sina, Ali
= King, Sina = Satan, the Devil of World.)
Does God Punish People?
(Dr. Naik) It is mentioned in Surah Nisa, Ch. No. 4, Verse No. 56, It speaks about ‘Pain.’
Previously the doctors, they thought that the brain was only responsible for feeling of ‘pain.’
Today we have come to know besides the brain, there are certain receptors in the skin, which are
responsible for feeling of the pain, which we call as the ‘pain receptors.’ Qur’an says in such
Surah Nisa Ch. 4, Verse 56, that… ‘As to those who reject Our signs, We shall cast them into the
hell fire, and as often as their skins are roasted, We shall give them fresh skin, so that they shall
feel the pain’. Indicating that there is something in the skin, which is responsible for feeling of
pain, which the Qur’an refers to as ‘pain receptors.’
(Ali Sina) Let me change the subject for a moment and tell you about my cat. I
have adopted this animal since he was a kitten. I bought for him all sorts of toys
so he would not get bored. I personally played with him even when this meant
putting aside my work. I took care of him; fed him with expensive food because
he would not eat anything else. I wash him regularly and do everything a
responsible owner would do to keep a cat happy. He gets into fights with other
cats and sometimes hurts himself. I take him to the vet to make sure his wounds do not
become infectious. I have been a good owner to this cat. (Rahamanhadiq; when Ali Sina has
a right to have a cat ?, it's not his name ownership rights, but custody or the right to care for.
Ali Sina liar) However this little animal is very ungrateful. He never comes to me when I call
him. He does not even turn his head to acknowledge that I exist. He slightly moves one ear
when I call his name and then ignores me. But when I sit down to write and don’t want to be
disturbed he insists to sit on my lap and even if I put him down ten times he just keeps
coming back. It is all about him and what he wants. I leave my work and groom him with a
brush to remove his falling hairs. He loves it and purrs loudly and rolls over exposing the
parts that he wants me to brush. But as soon as he feels comfortable he starts emitting putrid
gasses right under my nose. I think he does not have any respect for me. I am very much
offended by him and his behavior and I am thinking of punishing him. He has been very
ungrateful and rude. I think he deserves to die. But I don't want to kill him just like that. I want
to torture him and make him die a very slow and painful death. That is because he is very
ungrateful and I am very much offended. I have thought to crucify him so he can't move.
Then chop his fingers one by one. Then put him over a bonfire and burn all his fur and skin. I
will do that very slowly so he suffers a lot. Then I'll pour on his little body boiling water and
watch him scream in pain while he is still tied to the cross and can't move. Then I'll leave him
for some times to suffer in agony. Then come back and start dismembering him alive. With a
pair of scissors, cut first his ears and tail inch by inch so he can suffer a lot and then
dismember him live and burn him. You see, I am very compassionate and merciful. That is
what my friends say about me. But I am also very just. Justice must be done and this cat has
been ungrateful to me so he must be punished. Okay, calm down. I am just kidding.
( Rahmanhadiq; despite the ravings Ali Sina is already far digress and has nothing to do
with scientific problem submitted by the teacher. But as the assistant of Dr. Naik,
rahmanhadiq will be explain and discuss the problem about cats were included as additional
topics by Ali Sina . Apparently Ali Sina wants to divert discussion to other topics, so he will
give a parable, but from the talks earlier , KSW did not understand about the parables or
metaphor at all. But suddenly he wants to tell a story for the purpose of parables. In this
case, he took samples of a cat to identically between "KSW with a cat" with "man with his
Lord." Of course the comparison is not equivalent, because the relationship between
humans and cats is a fellow creature relationship, while the relationship between man and
God is the relationship between the Creator with the created.
KSW Of course will not be able to make an equal comparison in parables, because he was
unable to create anything on this earth. It is a big lie if Ali Sina says that the cat belongs to
him. Exactly, when KSW is able to create a cat? Let alone to kill the cat, even for painful, he
have no rights to do at all. Whatever the animal is consumed by Ali Sina into his stomach, he
was not right to eat it without permission or told the name of God. If he had been consuming
animal without permission or told the name of Allah, then he can be said to be a robbers and
thieves of the animal belongings of God. Only God who created the animal that had
swallowed up by anyone on this earth.
Ali Sina is like a passenger who does not have a ticket, then he pick another passenger
tickets, and then accuse other people who took it, so he arrived at the next station. However
his journey of life still is not over, he lived on earth only for a while before his life was taken,
before the court a more just dropped for him.
Furthermore all samples taken for parable was totally irrelevant, because the Cats are
animals that can not be equated with the figure of a man who has feelings and intelligence
are far higher than any animal. Animal does not have the manners in the cultural life, from
the first animal remains settled only. But if the cat was used as a sample to be confused with
the figure of Ali Sina, of course, exactly right now, because Ali Sina has exactly the same
nature with quadrupeds. Even wild animals like Tiger or Pig also have a much better
character than on Ali Sina, because these animals do not know the feeling of resentment, no
animosity for spread among animals, and not too willing to be humiliated like Ali Sina.
So the comparison is inserted into the story by KSW is, of course not acceptable to the man
who has a conscience and the ability to sense a far more perfect than a cat. Evil or a bunch
of wildest animals will not be any more evil than the man who has such properties that have
been shown by a man named Ali Sina this. The figure of Ali Sina, far more dangerous than in
animals or humans that most evil ones, because Ali Sina is the man that has properties like
the devil. So once again proved that Ali Sina is not understood by the parable let alone make
the story a true parable at all.
Until now, on this Earth, only humans who can lead and be above all the creatures of life.
Humans are social creatures that high intelligence and his ability to rule the earth, so that
when the desires have mastered the capacity to think, then nothing can deter his desire.
Similarly, the KSW is that has been dominated by his own desires so that's good reason are
not working anymore. This means that Ali Sina has the character, attitude, nature, ability and
imagination, much more evil and dangerous to human life than any wildest animals in this
If people who do not have a conscience like Ali Sina is given the trust or the power to lead
man and nature on this Earth, then the damage this natural destruction and destroyed the
livelihood of human beings who are always longing for peace, harmony and progress of
welfare. What if there are thousands of people who have a character like Ali Sina, while
religion has been successfully be broken up? Would have been unimaginable anymore what
consequences, especially if the religious of life has been replaced with the teachings and
principles of Ali Sina's life was. This is actually desired by the KSW is, he does not agree with
religious life, he hated with the teachings of any religion, because he was an atheist who
does not believe in God and the rules of any religion.
He together with his gang want to destroy the values of religion, because religion prevents
him do as he pleased, because religion would hinder his free attitude, because he did not
want regulated by any rules. And the loudest impede his desire is the religion of Islam. So
Islam is the main target for him to have been destroyed. Currently, the KSW has been
entered into the beginning stages of instilling a sense of hatred and managed to facilitate the
dispute within his site that it is global. At this stage, it seems he already feels confident to
proceed to the next stage, so that other religions are focusing on attacking the teachings of
Islam from all sides and from all over of the world for achieved his goals. That the
characteristics of Satan that intangible as human beings. )
I love him. I love him particularly because he has independence. He is a lot like me, a
freethinker, a free spirit, and just like me, he is not an appeaser. I am not offended by him. I
will not be offended no matter what he does. (Rahmanhadiq; it’s on own showing by Ali Sina
that nothing can stop him in the act of freedom. He admitted that he was the same with cats
who do not want to like peoples. KSW also admitted that he did not want to be regulated by
any rules. Whereas he wants to regulate religious so until not have any rules at all. But
strangely he did not have the rules any more. Ali Sina’s Doctrine is the disorder itself.)
Wouldn't it be insane to be offended by a cat? There is nothing a cat can do that could offend
us humans. Cats are not intelligent and we do not expect much from them. (Rahmanhadiq;
supposed to Ali Sina is aware of this with can be applied for in the life of respectable and
honor society)
But what if I was serious? Wouldn’t you say that I am a maniac, insane and dangerous? Of
course you would. Of course I am not going to hurt my little cat.How could even one think of
torturing a cat or any animal? (Rahmanhadiq; humans do not have any rights against other
creatures to be treated arbitrarily, the cats are not entitled to, let alone against other human
beings, because KSW is not the figure of the creator of living beings. But the way the mind
next KSW is to blame nature of the creator which he said no right to impose penalties on
anyone as he has done to cats)
But think about it! Isn't this exactly how Muhammad described Allah? Do you really believe
that the maker of this universe is a psychopath sadist? If these qualities are not befitting for a
sane human how can they be befitting for God? Allah, as described by Muhammad is even
worse. I could probably torture my cat for a few hours in this sadistic way until he dies and is
put out of agony. But the god that Muhammad described will continue torturing humans for
eternity. He is far worse than any sadist you can imagine. Isn't this an insult to the Creator?
Don't you think that holding such belief is blasphemy? When you talk of hell and eternal
punishment for disbelief, you are attributing insanity to God.
KSW, of course, had no right and not be torturing that cat, it is a predestinate, because the
KSW did not have any power against itself especially to cats, even more so to humans. But
the Creator would have powers beyond what was ever thought KSW. If KSW is always to
spread hatred and slander are not responsible, then who a man has hurt by him had to
demand? As long as his time spent to insulting and slander a man who has been credited
with changing the face of the world to the values of goodness and truth, although that person
has died. Then to whom the peoples who have been abused and that slander to demand a
justice? And how Muhammad’s follower feeling had been contempted by KSW? Is KSW
thinks that he can be free just like after he’s death later?. Sure KSW does not believe that at
the time of his death later there is still the ruling against for his life. During this time he had
felt proud and arrogant, insulting a man who have died and insulted all of humanity a religion,
then who else will give him justly punished for that mistake? It's okay he does not believe, but
actually he did not understand what would happen after his death.)
“Hell” is the most prevalent subject in the Quran. This theme recurs no less than 200 times.
The Quran is full of warnings and threats of punishment and gruesome details of divine
torture. What does this tell us? It tells us that Muhammad envisioned God as a psychopath
sadist. Allah is not God. He is Muhammad's own alter ego. He is the personification of
Muhammad's narcissistic wet dreams. Muslims do not worship God. By attributing sadistic
qualities to Him, they blaspheme Him.
Isn’t this enough to see that Muhammad was a crackpot? Is it possible that the maker of this
vast and magnificent universe be so petty and so insane that he could be offended by what
we humans think? If a cat can't offend us no matter how bad he behaves and how ungrateful
he becomes, would God, a reality infinitely bigger than us be offended by what we believe?
The difference between me and my cat is infinitely less than the difference between God and
we humans. If we are not bothered by what a cat does and consider punishing a cat insane,
how can we attribute this insanity to God? If we can love an animal unconditionally, without
expecting him to thank us why can't God love his creation unconditionally? Is God less than
us humans? How can God be so petulant to punish humans in such a sadistic way for not
believing in him? Why is he so desperate to be worshipped? Certainly God can't be like that.
(Rahmanhadiq; so narrow-minded and understanding of an Ali Sina insulting the God. KSW
is just shows the nature of His ego alone, without would look in the mirror of the sort so far.
He wants to live freely without going to set up, but otherwise he would not care to other
people by his free attitude. So he wants to abolish the penalty of God addressed to him, by
inciting others in order to have the same mind with him).
Muhammad lied. That fiend had no understanding of God. How pathetic is this that a billion
people follow a pervert psychopath to tell them about God! As a narcissist he thought
despotism is the utmost glory. He wanted people submit to him through fear. That is why
Allah is a despot. While God can't be anything but Love. Imagine you own a vast garden;
somewhere in that garden there is an ant colony. You may or may not be aware of its
existence. Now imagine one ant tells to other ants that he is your messenger and that you
have ordered that all ants must worship you and obey him and that if any ant decides not to
obey your messenger, you would one day gather the disbelieving ants and punish them by
throwing them in a huge bonfire. This is ridiculous. Why should you care if ants worship you
or not? The thought of it is laughable. Yet this is exactly what is happening to us humans. A
charlatan like Muhammad proclaimed himself to be the messenger of the owner of this
universe, and has managed to fool the gullible people that they should obey him or they will
be barbequed in the Landlord's cosmic bonfire.
This is stupid. This is pathetic indeed. But the tragedy is that today a billion people believe in
this charlatan and his sadist deity. There must be a limit to stupidity. Or is there?
If you don't give a damn about ants worshipping you, why should God care whether we
humans worship him or not? Who do you think you are? Have you ever thought about your
insignificance in this universe? You are nothing! You and your world do not even count. Do
you think that you are so important that the maker of this universe and perhaps billions of
other parallel universes depends on you to worship him and if you don't show him your rear
end five times a day he will be so disappointed that he would sadistically burn and
dismember you for eternity? (Rahmanhadiq; There is limited understanding and reason for
the Brain of Shrimp as Ali Sina, to know the religion and sense of religious surrender to his
Lord. Then the atheists Ali Sina mock it. That's the nature and the work of Satan and demons
to the faithful on this earth.)
The whole concept is just insane. This is the acme of stupidity. And this is the very
foundation of Islam. Islam is based on stupidity. It is a shame to be called a Muslim. There is
no glory in foolishness. As these truths gets out, and I urge everyone who agrees with me to
spread this message, the whole world will come to see Muslims are fools. If you are a
Muslim, you and your children will become the laughing stocks of the thinking humanity. You
become the butt of jokes, despised and derided. Soon it will be an insult to call one a Muslim
just as it is an insult to call one a fascist or a Nazi today. Do not persist in stupidity. Do not
make a fool of yourself. The fallacy of Islam is as clear as the sun.
We can forgive the foolish people of the Seventh Century Arabia who fell prey to this
charlatan’s lies, but can we forgive educated people today, who still want to be fooled?
If Muslims were capable of rational thinking, only this would have sufficed for them to see
that Muhammad was an impostor mad man and not a prophet of God. His imaginary god was
his own alter ego, a lot like himself, a sadist, a psychopath. Allah is everything Muhammad
wanted to be - a tyrant, one who does whatever he pleases and responds to no authority;
one who is worshiped, one who is feared. Being loved and feared is everything a narcissist
dreams of. Muhammad invented Allah to live his narcissistic dreams. And one billion
followers are unable to see the ploys of one mentally deranged man. This is tragedy. No
wonder Muslims live in such a misery. They follow a psychopath as their prophet and worship
a sadistic deity - the figment of the mind of that psychopath. How pathetic!
If it was not so depressing, it would have been funny that Dr. Naik should choose such a
macabre statement of the Quran to prove its alleged miracle. What part of this stupid verse is
miraculous? All it reveals is a sick mind of a fool. Dr. Naik speaks from the position of utter
ignorance. In the old days no one knew that brain had anything to do with sensing pain or
even thinking. Aristotle thought that brain acts like a radiator to cool the body. Thinking was
done with heart, they believed. We still say memorizing things by heart. People feel pain right
where it hurts. Pinch or slap yourself and see where do you feel it? Do you feel it in your
brain? You feel the pain right where you are hurting yourself. So what part of this simplistic
statement is miraculous? Muhammad is stating the obvious. There is no miracle in these
harebrained verses. They do not reveal any science. They reveal Muslims' deficiency of
intelligence and the characteristic of their sadistic god.
KSW was want that all religious people do not believe in punishment or reward contained in
their respective religious teachings. He wants to eliminate religious thinking about the
rewards of law which he said does not make sense. He said that religious believers should
realize that God has only just affectionate nature, making it impossible to God is punishing
people that hard. Even the devil is comparing between a sense of love himself to the cat with
the love of God to man. If he just can not bear to punish an innocent cat, then why did God
do not let a guilty man? KSW is equated human nature with animals like cats, he thought that
cats also have a feeling, a thinking intelligent as humans, have compassionate, have the
ability to do evil, have a plan that can destroy nature and other human life.
KSW wanted to illustrate a parable that is more real, that he is more forgiving to the cat, let
alone act the evidence he had a cat that throw dirt onto the clothes. KSW feel have the
nature of love beyond love of God to man, he just could not let the cat go without
punishment, then why did God have to punish an innocent man? That simple thought, he felt
very love to cats, but strangely he hates religious people who actually have many virtues
than a cat. KSW is actually just want to lead the way religious mind to abandon the beliefs
which he considers stupid. KSW has a mind and reason is very simple to remove the
attributes of God which he does not deserve owned by the figure of the Creator. KSW give a
limit to the attributes of God according to the selfish ways of his thinking, because the nature
of God who can punish it, would restrict their freedom to do as he pleased without limit.
Though each of any religious teachings have limitation norms of human treatment to other
humans or to nature, so that it is not a human being can do to others as pleased himself. If
the rules were not obeyed or violated, the penalty of retaliation will be subject to him. This is
the law of cause and effect of balance.
Actually religious laws more flexible than the rules that apply within a democrazy state or the
state of democracy, because the rules that apply to the state of democracy will be the judge
directly after the evidence revealed in a court, while the law of religion is tolerant and flexible
for patient was later suspended the sentence after his death or after in the afterlife will be.
Religious law still gives a grace period to let the villain was enjoying life on this earth,
because people who still profess to be patient to suspend the sentence for the time being. A
good religious believers are still to be patient after be hard done unjustified, reviled, insulted
and abused by another man because he has no power to demand justice to the state
authorities, so that he surrender penalty is the fairest one day to the Creator after his death
However, KSW is still not received, any form of punishment given to him, in despite of a form
of punishment that are stored in the minds of people who insulated will be run out. Finally he
feels has the absolute freedom by unlimited, even beyond the nature of God, known by the
religious ones. So the depiction of evil traits described in the teachings of religion have been
met by a human figure who initial “Ali Sina” like this. Even within Christianity there are any
legal or retribution against people who are always doing evil to others who reviled, this is
perpetuated by Jesus in Matthew 13: 36-42;
13:36 Then Jesus sent the multitude away, and went into the house: and
his disciples came unto him, saying, Declare unto us the parable of
the tares of the field.
13:37 He answered and said unto them, He that soweth the good seed is
the Son of man;
13:38 The field is the world; the good seed are the children of the kingdom;
but the tares are the children of the wicked one;
13:39 The enemy that sowed them is the devil; the harvest is the end of
the world; and the reapers are the angels.
13:40 As therefore the tares are gathered and burned in the fire; so shall it
be in the end of this world.
13:41 The Son of man shall send forth his angels, and they shall gather out
of his kingdom all things that offend, and them which do iniquity;
13:42 And shall cast them into a furnace of fire: there shall be wailing and
gnashing of teeth.

In the above verse, Jesus explains the parable of the Last Day or the end times
and the torments of hell fire. The field is a metaphor for life in the world, those
who sow the good seed that has been likened to a person during his lifetime
doing good in the world, while tares likened to evil doers, while the enemy for
those who do good is the devil or demons, then the mowing results or who reap
the good and the errors that are the angels.
That is the angel assigned to separate the good seed with weeds that are not
useful in the latter days later, while the harvest is the Day of Judgement or day
of the end or the end of time. Then the tares or the wicked or arsonist will be
collected and burned in the fire of hell. Who threw the arsonist is the angels of
kingdom of God that messange by child or children who do good for people
who live in this world always have been wronged by the sinner that. The
criminals and the makers of sin will be collected and dumped into the kitchen
(stove) the glowing fire. So that's where there will be wailing weeping and
feeling pain unlimited by a parable from the gnashing of teeth sinner it.
Ali Sina is not able to provide the right reason and right to eliminate the
religious teachings and replace it with a new indoctrinating, so for that he did
the strategy fighting to pit human race in religious communities, with the aim of
destroying the entire teaching religion in the world. Sniper tactics by him
considered the most powerful is to spread hatred, slander and spread of
detestation to produced and provoked emotion for religious people. If religious
people who believer already emotionally against it, then he has managed to
provoke outrage assess religious community, especially to the hated Muslims.
Because if the people are emotional, usually no longer road again his reason
and incapable of rational thought. That is actually desired by the devil like this
human intangible. If Muslims have been provoked emotions, then he clapped
his hands and laughed himself. He accused a prophet has a psychopathic
disease, but actually he himself who suffer of diseases that danger for human
life. The disease is very chronic so that he did not realize it at all. Ali Sina is not
a normal human being who does not understand what he was saying, maybe
he's too old to learn the science of the devil so that he talked nonsense and not
necessarily the direction, there not have the slightest good value, his fiddlestick
not qualified at all so that he could only hurt the feelings of religious people
throughout by his mouth.
KSW is a real atheist, but he's also like a chameleon who can change the color
so that he is everywhere in the wily and cunning disguises. He pit the Muslims
and Christians even though he himself is not the adherents of both religions.
After the two religions that hate each other, debating each other, deriding each
other, and mutually blaspheming, the devil is getting satisfied and applauded
enjoy a fun fight for this crazy psychopath.
He himself was not able to damage of religion alone, so he pretended to help
the followers of Christianity who does not understand his religion, to attack
Islam together. Only people who provoked emotions and do not have any
reason that can be hooked by the KSW of this fraud, to each other on his pride
site on www.faithfreedom.org. But they really do not realize that their actions
are not commendable, it is not going to weaken and hinder the development of
Islamic religion in the world. On the contrary, where such heinous way, every
day and every turn of the year more and more people are saying shahada
sentence upon this earth. It is a fact that is irrefutable by anyone at this time.
Then the KSW was denied information presented by teachers verses the
amount of Dr. Naik, when the real devil is already feeling frightened of the
threat of Qur'anic verses devoted to him. So in that verse description he sued
with answers that are not scientific at all, even if the KSW was once seen never
to follow developments in medical science in the century, this millenium. He has
been too long meditated under a volcano crater that he still follows the myths of
the devil.
KSW is thought that the pain is felt it had nothing to the nerves in the brain, this
is proof that he did not know the medical science and he is the gibberish man.
And already many years ago the experts found that there was nerves in the
brain centers that can receive and deliver stimulation of sensors / receptors in
the epidermis and from the skin to the nerve centers in the brain. If the sensor
is still on the stimulation threshold, then the pain can still be detected by a
nerve center to be felt at the site of stimulation. But if the sensor stimuli that
exceeds a threshold, it will cause people to faint, so it will not feel any pain. So
is the skin tissue, where the under layer of skin epidermis have nerve points
that can receive stimulation to feel the pain if there are outside influences, such
as scratches, pinch, even to feel the effect of temperature or stimulus of sex. If
the epidermal layer peeled off due to accidents of fire as a result stage 2, the
sensor nerves there will be lost so that the skin will not feel any pain at all.
Surah al qur'an presented by Dr Naik is a parable with a style that is in its
meaning. This verse gives metaphor that people can not evade the pain,
because the torture was the nerves in the skin.

The atheist Ali Sina does not understand about Islamic teachings truely, then
he spread self-delusion. He just assumed that the God of Islam is the cruel
punishment, and only requires worship throughout Him at any time. That's how
rumors spread by this instigator every day. Though God's punishment was
more addressed to Ali Sina is an always incite, that spread lies and planting the
seeds of hatred in the breasts of mankind. This KSW deserve such punishment
in the afterlife even more weight if he can anymore.
Whereas in the Islamic teachings, God will not punish anyone except for the
mistakes he has made. As for people who still make mistakes, the mistakes will
continue to accumulate and eventually he could not escape from these
rewards. Man is called human Infidel. The term of Infidel is more directed to
people who would not accept the values of truth and oppose the truth even
reject it without good reason, he deny the truth of the just-eaten by hatred or
incitement which is spread by Ali Sina, so as the people who incited is no
longer able to use his reason a more just and full of wisdom.
This is perpetuated by al Qur'an in sura al Baqaraah verse 81 which reads;
“Nay, those who seek gain in evil, and are girt round by their sins,- they are
companions of the Fire: Therein shall they abide (For ever).( QS 2:81) “
Even followers of animist religions who worship idols or other gods, which he
had never received the correct information about the Lord of hosts, then the
Qur'an never defines the demand for them in this world. Except if they oppose
the truth that has been communicated to him and hostile to goodness value
delivered it with hatred and incitement. Punishment given by God to someone,
not because he does not worship God, but is caused by evil deeds ever done
during his life.
Before someone dropped justly punished, al qur'an explains there will be fair in
court that led directly by the Judge who is God's justice.
While Polytheisme or Pagan is an act that intentionally committed by a person
in accordance with their knowledge to incite and get someone else to worship
idols or gods other material, while others may not understand what he had
done. That is not the people who worship idols that are pagan, but people who
ordered and understood that more idolater, when else who made more aware
of and understand the meaning of polytheis. Perhaps only people who worship
these idols do not understand or have never come to their descriptions, so that
they are dragged to the deed that he did not realize, then that is said to
polytheist here, not the pagan but those who give it polytheist science. They are
eternal in hell, because they have been taught something that is false, even
though it knew provocateur like Ali Sina.
The Qur'an is called the instigator pagans are people of the books scribe who
has misled many of mankind, but they hide the truth. While the Qur'an says that
those who continue to commit crimes, inciting people to do evil, hatred, is the
devil and satan. Satan can be either Genie creatures and can also be derived
from a class of human beings who continue to commit crimes without being
able to be made aware by anyone. What is meant by the devil here is a man
who named Ali Sina this. So the religious teachings of Islam are not as depicted
by this KSW.
(Dr. Naik) Professor Thagada Shaun, who is the head of the department of
Anatomy, in Chang Mai University in Thailand, - Only on the basis of this one
Verse, he proclaimed the Shahada, in the 8
Medical conference in Riyadh, and
said …(Arabic)…. That… ‘There is no God but Allah, and that Prophet Mohammed,
peace be upon him, is the Messenger of Allah.
I started my talk by quoting the Verse from the Glorious Qur’an from Surah… from
Surah Fussilat, Ch. 41, Verse 53, which says…(Arabic) ‘That soon We shall show
them Our signs in the farthest reaches of the horizons, and into their souls, until it
is clear to them, that this is the truth.’ This one Verse was sufficient to prove to Dr.
Thagada, Thagada Shaun, that Qur’an is a Divine Revelation. Some may require 10
signs, some may require 100. Some, even after a 1000 signs are given, they will
not accept the truth.
(Ali Sina) Professor Thagada Shaun must be a fool. Heaven knows if such an
idiot actually exists or he is a fabrication of Muslim wishful thinking. These
verses are stupid. Not only they reveal that Muhammad was a sadist, they also
contain no scientific information whatsoever. Muslims have based their entire
faith on logical fallacies. "Doctor so and so has confirmed the Quran so Islam
must be true" is an asinine argument. There are many more authentic doctors
and professors born and raised in Islam who reject this cult and have left it.
They find Islam and the Quran utterly stupid. Why not listen to them?
Ravings of the Ali Sina has been no showing that he is a man who can talk as
well. Ali Sina is talking not use the brain, but a sense of hatred that is not useful
at all in a healthy discussion to seek the truth values of honest and fair. It is
that his Shrimp’s brain has no capable scientific at all, he just refused a fact
without any logical reason, however he can use convey a abhorrence sense,
suspicion and hatred to the religion of Islam.
Ad Hominem in the Quran
(Dr. Naik) Qur’an calls such people, as in Surah Baqarah Ch. 2, Verse
18…(Arabic)… ‘The deaf, the dumb, the blind, they will not return to the true path.’
The Bible says the same thing in Gospel of Mathew, Ch. No. 13, Verse No. 13…
‘Seeing they see not, hearing they hear not, neither will they understand.’
(Ali Sina) This is called poisoning the well or the famous ad hominem fallacy.
The Quran fails to give one solid argument that cannot be successfully refuted.
Instead of proof, Muhammad tried to undermine the intelligence and sincerity of
those who did not agree with his irrational claims. He did not stop there. He
then went on ordering his demented followers to fight, and wage war against
the unbelievers, to crucify them, to cut their fingertips and to slay them
wherever they find them.
Ali Sina is pretended to be offended by the term made its own 'ad hominem'.
Whereas he was speaking casually insulting blindly before with cursing
Muslims for no reason and scientific evidence whatsoever. But instead he felt
offended by a warning delivered by his teacher who are written in the Qur'an
and Bible verses.
This indicates that Ali Sina was most afraid of with scripture verses that echoed
into his ear hole. He felt burned by these verses, so he's mad is talking
nonsense there-here without clear what he's talking about, like someone who is
epilepsy. Apparently the Ali Sina is not able to use his senses, because the
eyes and his heart was blind, brain and mind is very dirty which can no longer
be cleaned at all. Better for he was be imprisoned again under the volcano
crater, rather than making an inconsequential chatter and unclear.
The Quran vs. the Bible
(Dr. Naik) And regarding the other parts of ‘Embryology’, I will deal in my rebuttal
InshaAllah, if time permits - I have to do justice to the other part also… regarding
‘Bible in the light of science.’ At the outset let me tell you, that Qur’an says in
Surah Rad, Ch. 13, Verse. 38, that… ‘We have given several Revelations.’ By name
only 4 are mentioned - The Torah, the Zaboor, the Injeel and the Qur’an. The
Torah is the ‘Wahi’ the ‘Revelation’, which was given to Prophet Moses, (peace be
upon him). The Zaboor is the ‘Wahi’, which was given to David, (peace be upon
him). The Injeel is the ‘Wahi’, the ‘Revelation’ which was given to Jesus, (peace be
upon him). And Qur’an is the last and final Revelation, which was given to the last
and final Messenger Prophet Mohammed, (peace be upon him).
Let me make it very clear to every one, that this Bible which the Christians believe
to be the word of God, is not the ‘Injeel’ which we Muslims believe, was revealed to
Prophet Jesus, (peace be upon him). This Bible according to us, it may contain the
words of God - But it also contains words of Prophets, words of historians, it
contains absurdities, obscenity, as well as innumerable scientific errors.
(Ali Sina) Both the Bible and the Quran contain absurdities, obscenities and
innumerable scientific errors. (Rahmanhadiq; how could KSW actually had
insulted the holy book of Islam and Christian religion, wants to talk about truth
and goodness. What kind of goodness that can be expected by the Atheists of
this curse.) However since the thinking Christians and Jews know that the Bible
is not the verbatim word of God, but stories written by men who allegedly were
inspired but nonetheless fallible, they take their scriptures with a grain of salt.
This allows them to adapt to the changing time and let their intelligence be their
Because Muslims think the Quran is the verbatim words of God, they can’t
change it. They are stuck in the 7
century and can’t go forward. Other religions
are living. They are growing and changing. Islam is fossilized. This will bring the
downfall of Islam. Because Islam is unchangeable it is bound to break and fall
apart. Precisely because of this reason, other religions have a future, but Islam
has none. Other religions will survive this century and many more, but Islam will
not. Islam will meet its death, thanks to its own rigidity. It is pathetic for Muslims
to point out to the errors of the Bible in response to the errors that exist in the
Quran. The Christians and the Jews can overlook those errors and attribute
them to the fallibility of the scribes. The Biblical prophets were humans and
they could have erred. This is a luxury that Muslims can't afford. They must
either accept the Quran as one package or reject it in its entirety. This claim of
authenticity that Muslims think is the strength of the Quran, is actually the
cause of its fall.
Jesus said: "I have much more to say to you, more than you can now bear. But
when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all truth". John 16:12 -
The spirit of the truth has come. It is the new age of enlightenment. The gates
of knowledge and understanding are flung open and new truths are being
revealed every day. Christians know that knowledge of God is not limited to
what is in the Bible. They know that truth is infinite. They are open to learn new
things. Muslims don't know that. Muslims foolishly think God’s knowledge is
limited. (Rahmanhadiq; just Muslims who are always preaching about scientific
information for the power of God, which surpasses all whatsoever.)
That everything He wanted to say He has already said it in the Quran and there
is nothing more to learn. They think the hands of God are tied and his wisdom
is dried out. That is why Christianity, and all other religions that allow change
are alive and Islam is dead.
Apparently this KSW speaking outside oif the context of Islamic religion, nor in
the Christian understanding of language. What might the Ali Sina has to
understand very well about the book of Christian people, so that he dared to
represent the church leaders to speak on behalf of Jews and Christian, which
he said "Jews and Christians know that the Bible is not merely the word of God
entirely, but the stories written by people who claim to be inspired but still
wrong, they do not take them with the verses at face value ". As if the atheist is
concluded that the teaching of Christian religious leaders are no longer adhere
to the teachings of their Bible contained the book. So he thinks that Christian
religious leaders have left the joints of their religion by way of thinking as
desired by the KSW of this. With its conclusion, the KSW was satisfied with the
attitude of the Christian faiths that are not glued anymore to the verses in the
scripture, to be transferred to the Spirit of Truth. To explain the Spirit of truth,
this atheists who are changing of colors, spoke as a Christian religious leader.
He took a verse in the Christian holy book which will be published as above.
The KSW is to translate the word "Spirit of Truth" is " knowledge and
understanding" that implemented to "science and technology" that has made
the goal for Christian faiths, so that the "new truth revealed every day." That
reasoning of Ali Sina. This atheist is to give praise and appreciation to
Christians who are not taking full scripture, but have started turning to worldly
interests to achieve progress in science and technology, according to a
democratic society. That is the atheist concludes that Christians are better than
before because it was able to follow the progress of modern humans in the
country of democracy, without having to follow rigid religious doctrine. Because
of the verses in the Bible is not the verses of God, but comes from writers who
have the holy spirit.
Instead of this Satan, Islamic religion which he considered still shackled with
the description of al quran verses that can not be modified or engineered to suit
the times and science. That's how Ali Sina's view, the underlying purpose of his
life just to satisfy in the world alone, so he justifies all means to gain advantage,
including insults, hate, inciting and pit all religious communities to achieve its
mission. The atheist does not have any views about the philosophy of the
cultural life as well as what happens after death, the important thing for him is
to pursue the needs and desires after death it is game over. To achieve his
purpose, he concocting a negative conclusion from the teachings of Islam
according to his hatred of logic and passion alone. Then the results were
formulated by hatred in the form of negative slander and gossip, then spread
this issue to damage the joints of the teachings of Islam to the world through his
pride site in www.faithfreedom.org. Though described by his teacher DR Naik,
is precisely the joints that support the Islamic religion and requires Muslims to
learn and follow the development of science and technology. However, his set
thinking of power is dead, so he just talk nonsense and do not touch on the
topic of science altogether.
(Dr. Naik) If there are scientific points mentioned in the Bible - there are
possibilities - why not? It may be part of the word of God, in the Bible. But what
about the scientific errors? - What about the unscientific portions? - Can you
attribute this to God?
(Ali Sina) And what about the unscientific portions of the Quran? The Quran is
completely unscientific. There is absolutely nothing scientific in this book while
everything it says is nonsense. There is not a single scientific statement in the
Quran that was unknown at the time of Muhammad.
Nagging is expressed by the KSW, showing that he did not receive any truth of
the verse of al qur'an, without explain with the scientific reasons. But that is just
given hatreds far deviate from the topic of the question, like he was fishing for
new problems from behind the walls of his house. This shows that the Ali Sina,
not a man who has thought and the Spirit of truth, he only favors only hatred
alone without guided by right thinking and scientific.
So appropriateness, Ali Sina is being rewarded for that is worth the public
utterances, so rahmanhadiq give lessons how it feels when someone insults
and berating himself. But it seems, this devil is not be effected by the cursed or
insulted though, because he already has no sense of compassion for mankind
and also do not have Spirit of truth altogether. So do not expect much, in case
this demon can not be resuscitated or not to spread hatred again to the Islamic
(Dr. Naik) purpose of my presentation on ‘Bible and science’ is not to hurt any
Christian’s feeling. If while presenting, if I hurt your feelings, I do apologize in
(Ali Sina) Dr. Naik is gauging Christians with Islamic yardstick. It’s Muslims
who get offended, make riots, burn churches and embassies and kill innocent
people if their religion is criticized. Christians have been taking criticisms for a
long time and if those criticisms were correct, they have changed their ways
and beliefs. That is why I call Christianity a living faith and Islam a dead and
fossilized faith.
Clearly visible, that the sentences which were prepared by the KSW, was
sentence to provoke hostility and hurt. Though his teacher Dr Naik, has limited
the problem is only in problems the relationship between "Science with the Holy
Book", in terms of scientific perspectives. Moreover, Dr Naik is especially
apologized to the audience, if there are words that are not pleasing to the
assessment of the Christians. That's two big speakers were arguing with the
high spirit of sportsmanship and openness, then throw away feeling offended
However, the KSW is getting the opportunity to malign intent discriting and
slander Islamic religion, and lure the people who had been thought that
christian always harassed by the Islamic religion. It is view of Satan Ali Sina's in
the sense that the words of Dr Naik, i,e view from the negative side and then
spread incitement that are not qualified.

(Dr. Naik) The purpose is only to point out, that a God’s Revelation cannot contain
scientific errors.
(Ali Sina) Well, thank you doctor Naik! We will hold you to your own word and
expect you to explain how the Quran with so many errors can be God's
Revelation. It’s clear that the Quran is wrong and the adamant denial of
Muslims, their riots, hooliganisms and threats do not make it right. Few Muslims
will bother to read this rebuttal, but most of those who do will first think how to
kill me. Why instead don't you exert an effort to refute me and prove me wrong?
Apparently Ali Sina is already having some materials sufficient to reject the
truth that will be delivered by his teacher Dr Naik. Apparently, Ali Sina has
prepared voodoo from his ancestral to refute the information that will be
delivered by a former teacher Naik DR. Well we will just wait spells and his
voodoo that will shown by KSW is, whether reason can still make sense and
have the correct scientific language, or merely just a nagging, as long as he is
modeling before.
Creation of the Universe in the Quran
(Dr. Naik) First we deal with Astronomy. The Bible speaks about the creation of
the universe. In the beginning, 1
Book, Book of Genesis, 1
Ch. , it is mentioned -
It says… ‘Almighty God created the Heavens and the Earth, in six days and talks
about a evening and a morning, referring to a 24 - hour day. Today scientists tell
us, that the universe cannot be created in a 24 hour period of six days. Qur’an too
speaks about six ‘ayyams’. The Arabic word singular is ‘yaum’ plural is ‘ayyam’. It
can either mean a day of 24 hours, or it is a very long period, a ‘yaum’, an epoch.
Scientists say we have no objection in agreeing that the universe - it could have
been created in 6 very long periods.
(Ali Sina) Here Dr. Naik is vividly revealing the hypocrisy and the double
standard that characterizes the Muslim mind. The story of the creation stated in
the Quran is borrowed from the Bible. So, logically, what is true about the
original version is also true about its copy. What is good for the goose is also
good for the gander. However Dr. Naik says that the days stated in the Bible
should be interpreted as 24-hours days while the days stated in the Quran
should be interpreted as unspecified periods of time - eons. Why this double
standard? It is because the Muslim mind is a sick mind, bereft of fairness and
This story, whether in its original version stated in the Bible or in its plagiarized
version rehashed in the Quran is fairytale. No scientist has ever said that the
universe has been created in six phases. Geologists have divided the history of
the Earth in several epochs, which have nothing to do with the Biblical and the
Quranic version of creation, but the history of the universe is not demarked by
phases. This is clearly an error.
Furthermore the Quran contradicts itself in relaying this fairy tale.
Apparently student Ali Sina is not able to argue his professor Dr Naik
Description. He just expressed his frustration only. Back he was only able to
regurgitate his stomach contents of foul, curse and revile. There is nothing new,
scientific rebuttal that can be conveyed. There is no argument that can refute
any testimony that his Master. He was only able to talk throught hat without
understanding the topic presented by the teache DR. Naik, and then convey his
grudges with a different problem with the topic. Ali Sina, who was acting smart
Arrogant want to teach the teachers with a old spell. In fact, he accuses the
Koran copying the Bible information. An accusation without reasonable excuse
is not presented in a scientific discussion. It is clear that Ali Sina is not using
common sense, in his mind there was only his own feces like a case with a
Prawn, he was only able to convey a sense of hatred and incitement only.
So whenever the a man talk by arrogant, the empty keg loud sounds, empty
rice will be higher standing than those contained. He only believed in reference
to the human scientific discovery, because till now human beings have not
managed to find out how long this nature is created, then he rejected the Bible
and the Qur'an information. But he did not have another opinion at all, even
spells as not useful in this book. Then Ali Sina only able to compare the
findings of experts on the formation of Earth's geology, not the universe, which
he divided into various phases are not 6 stages. The shallow thinking of KSW.
Later he changed the subject talks into another problem, namely delivering the
others al quran verses, which he said conflict with scientific discovery, below.
Though the verses had been discussed by the professor DR Naik, on the last
semester, but he still did not pass away, then he must repeated on this
semester. For that rahmanhadiq as an assistant of professor Dr. Naik, will
provide additional assistance or private concern to help this student is, for the
next semester, he was able to graduate with mediocre value.

Six or eight days of creation?
041.009 Say: Is it that ye deny Him Who created the earth in
TWO Days And do ye join equals with Him? He is the
Lord of (all) the Worlds.

041.010 He set on the (earth). mountains standing Iirm. high
above it.
and bestowed blessings on the earth. and measure therein
all things to give them nourishment in due proportion. in
FOUR Days. in accordance with (the needs oI) those
who seek (Sustenance).
041.011 Moreover He comprehended in His design the sky. and it
had been (as) smoke: He said to it and to the earth:
"Come ye together. willingly or unwillingly." They said:
"We do come (together). in willing obedience."

041.012 So He completed them as seven Iirmaments in TWO
and He assigned to each heaven its duty and command.
And We adorned the lower heaven with lights. and
(provided it) with guard. Such is the Decree oI (Him) the
Exalted in Might. Full oI Knowledge

Total days of creation

Sura 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, and 25:59 say that God created "the heavens and the
earth" in six days.
The combination of two words "heaven and earth" in Al Qur’an verse, explain
that the heavens and the earth is the universe itself. The word the heavens and
Earth, shows a unity of the universe. This means that Earth is part of the
universe. The sky , which has been seen by Ali Sina , was not the layers of the
universe but the layers of atmosphere.
In total or the whole universe was created for 6 days (ٍ م'ّ َ -َ أ = ayyamin, period).
The word of “ٍ م'ّ َ -َ أ ” has a broad meaning. Can a period, the stages, could also
be a period of time and could also be the process. This depends on
understanding and from scholars who discuss it. Because the words were not a
noun, not a word resulting from discovery of human technology, but more
instructions or a sign or it could be a metaphor.
But this is contradicted in Sura 41:9-12
041.009 : Say: Is it that ye deny Him Who created the earth in TWO Days And do ye
ioin equals with Him? He is the Lord oI (all) the Worlds.
Rahmanhadiq ;
Say: Is it that ye deny Him Who created the earth in two Days? And do ye ioin equals
with Him? He is the Lord oI (all) the Worlds.( QS 41:9)”
In this case, of course KSW think that this paragraph of “41:09” describes only
the earth that was created two days, while other stars or planets, would be
another time. However, if the earth is included as part of the universe, it means
that not only the earth that formed in 2 days. Of course including the planets,
sun and other stars, who also created in 2 days. Moreover, this verse does not
describe any process and what has been formed for 2 this time? What is new in
the beginning stages or already complete or already perfect, as we witnessed
But when connecting it with the verse Letters 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, and 25:59
above, then of course this paragraph states that the formation of the earth in
two days, only at the early or first stages of creation, because creation lasts for
6 total period. In the mind of the lowest student academic achievement, he
dreamed that the earth was created two days, then after that God will create
other celestial objects, such as weaving or knitting of people are like birds that
fly come to make a nest. Though the verse does not explain and give an
explanation like the one in his mind. So worth it, as long as he is not pass of the
courses given by the teacher DR. Naik ever.
041.010 : He set on the (earth). mountains standing Iirm. high above it.
and bestowed blessings on the earth. and measure therein all things to give them
nourishment in due proportion. in FOUR Days. in accordance with (the needs oI) those
who seek (Sustenance).
Rahmanhadiq; It turned out that this verse is closely related to paragraph 41:9
, as has been described by the pathetic student named Ali Sina. This means
that this verse describes the continuation of the process of phase 2 of the next
creation. This verse explains the process of creation or subsequent stages of
refinement stages of ecosystem that can support life living on it.
The period or stage of formation is much longer than at the beginning of the
second stage of the previous period. In this refinement stage, in strengthen the
position of the mountains to the vibration damping system or function as well as
the pores of the earth, as well as defense systems such as atmosphere of
earth that serves as the roof of the earth, then after that put up more of different
kinds of food , namely a variety of plants that complete and balanced to prepare
for the arrival of living things.
This verse gives little hint that, plants was created earlier than the animals or
perhaps gradually, because the plants are not depending on animals, just the
opposite animals in desperate need of plants as a food substance. So if these
two texts are combined, the creation of the earth are the two stages. Namely, 2
periods at the beginning stage, then proceed 4 periods longer in the period
after that. So the total is 6 periods, or 6 days, or 6 stages.
The question that should be asked is: what happens during the first 2 periods of
heavens creation and the earth (the universe) this? Is this KSW have the
answer? Definitely not! Because until now there has been no explanation from
the gods are to be adored. God that is worshiped by Ali Sina is the Science and
technology experts, which turned out to date do not have any clues about the
formation period of the universe. Even about how the size or extent of this
universe, none of the gods of Ali Sina able to answer. So Ali Sina will be silent
when asked these problems. Because of that, the King Satan of the World “Ali
Sina”, do not act arrogant and pedantically. Man!.

041.011 ; Moreover He comprehended in His design the sky. and it had been (as)
smoke: He said to it and to the earth: "Come ye together. willingly or unwillingly."
They said: "We do come (together). in willing obedience."
Rahmanhadiq; This clause provides that appointment prior to the creation of
the earth and other celestial bodies in the sky as it is now, at the origin, the
heavens and the earth it comes from unity in the form of smoke. Fumes or
gases which are part of the elements forming the celestial bodies of uviverse
including the earth.

So this verse tells the origin of the formation of this universe is a collection from
smoke or gas, or gas is very dense. After that, smoke, or gas, or gas which is
solid, were separation or explosion or development (big bang theory), as
already described by Professor DR Naik above. This need not be repeated
again because it was described earlier, except for Ali Sina, who never want to
understand this.
As disingung ever before, that the verses al quran is not a science book, but a
book that contains instructions or signs, which should be in thought with clear
opinion and clean. Al qur'an verses of wisdom with the submission of the form
of parable or a metaphor, so that the necessary wisdom to thought . This
needs explain to Ali Sina, whose his brains are still empty, because he did not
understand at all with the meaning of a parable of the word or figuratively. The
words in the sentence ""Come ye together, willingly or unwillingly ", is a
metaphor expression or figure of speech which implies a very deep and wide.
Of course, people like Ali Sina will not be able to understand the parable,
because he did not have a way of thinking is good and right. At most, he would
convey scolding of babbling again. The sentence of the verse can be
understood scientifically that, God has created a control system such that the
whole His creation are being under the control system them. None of the
celestial objects that escaped the control systems that have been completed by
Allah SWT. For example, the earth rotates on its axis while orbiting the sun, sun
shine, as well as other planets in the solar system of the sun, the comets
across the solar system at random, a galaxy or cluster of stars, which other
control systems were poorly understood and still under observation by
astronomy experts. This means that after the separation stage or stages of
development from the center of the smoke is completed, then God created the
control system in accordance with the nature and character of each of these
heavenly bodies. This is an early stage or the period beginning from a total of 6
periods, as defined by the previous verses. That is, this initial phase lasts for 2
days, as defined in the Letter-41.9 12 mentioned above. Then after stage 2 of
this period, will be continued next with 4 days which is the stage of ecosystem
improvement of the condition of each of these celestial bodies, such as:
whether the planet is prepared to support the system of life (the Earth) or not ,
or other conditions for the improvement of the object. So the creation of this
universe does not just happen, without process, without the will, with no plans
and no goals have been determined by God).
041.012; So He completed them as seven Iirmaments in TWO Days.
and He assigned to each heaven its duty and command. And We adorned the lower
heaven with lights. and (provided it) with guard. Such is the Decree oI (Him) the
Exalted in Might. Full oI Knowledge.
Rahmanhadiq; this paragraph was perfected of verse 41-9 previously. If the
verse 41-9 was explained that the formation of earth and sky in 2 days or 2
periods, then in 41-12 this verser explained that the seven heavens and even
then created in 2 days or 2 periods. So it is clear that the seven heavens as
well as the earth, there were the celestial objects that called the universe, in
accordance with the understanding of these two verses. Once again need to be
explained to Ali Sina, who was gazing at the rainbow of blue on the sky, that he
saw the sky was not the real but only a layer of Earth's atmosphere, while the
sky is actually much further and would not be seen with penetrating eyes that
While the notion 7th heaven still not be solved by astronomers, it does not
mean al qur'an to tell lies, but the human sciences has not been able to touch
it. Even the breadth of this universe can not be predicted by space experts.
Then two verses above more closely related to [41.10] verse. If the 3 verses
were merged or combined, will produce a more complete guide that stage of
the early period is the second period or days was to create a balance system of
the orbit or other control systems that have been determined by the Creator, so
entirely of them submissive and obedient .. In this case all the celestial bodies
have been functioning properly, but still not ready to accommodate the system
of life because it is still unstable (such as heat still volatile, the atmosphere has
not been perfect, the land has not been formed or is unstable). But in the initial
2 days of this period, has occurred the system of rotation and orbit of a
balanced and stable. For example, the sun was shining while planets do not,
there are planets has some months and the other are not, and had been
formed the galaxies and clusters of the other stars, has occurred system that
balanced orbit. So the whole control system has been established and
controlled to the celestial bodies in accordance with the nature, condition and
characteristics of each. No more the system that are beyond the control and
entirely subject to the control system which is under the authority of God the
Creator of the universe.
So after that, proceed again to the next stage which is 4 the next period. At this
stage is to improve conditions in their respective planets or other celestial
bodies. This is stated in a letter [41.10], which reads;
He set on the (earth), mountains standing firm, high above it, and bestowed
blessings on the earth, and measure therein all things to give them nourishment in
due proportion, in four Days, in accordance with (the needs of) those who seek
(Sustenance).(QS 41:10)”
Then the paragraph description above is made clear again by a letter An
explanation in Nazi'aat verse 27 to 33, which reads;
What! Are ye the more difficult to create or the heaven (above)? (Allah) hath
constructed it27: On high hath He raised its canopy, and He hath given it order
and perfection 28. Its night doth He endow with darkness, and its splendour doth
He bring out (with light) 29. And the earth, moreover, hath He extended (to a
wide expanse) 30; He draweth out therefrom its moisture and its pasture 31; And
the mountains hath He firmly fixed 32;- For use and convenience to you and your
cattle.(QS An Naazi’aat 79:27-33)”
This verse is perfected and complete description of the preceding paragraphs.
This verse describes and gives an indication that indeed God has raised this
universe. Raised tantamount to expand, because the man looked up at the sky
instead of the underground. So the true explanation of Professor Dr. Naik, that
the sky be dilated or elevated, according to the observations of this 2-melenium
century astronomer.
Then after that perfect balance is achieved, then the next God to give an
explanation with a sentence longer parable that reads " Its night doth He endow
with darkness, and its splendour doth He bring out (with light) " This sentence
should thought with a broad understanding and deep. This means that, at this
stage will form a balanced system and function of orbit each celestial bodies, so
formed the rotation and orbit of each of these celestial bodies. For humans on
earth, what is meant by day and night would have been due to the rotation of
the earth so that there are parts that hit the earth's surface sunlight (daylight)
and there is a closed (night). This stage is the completion of phase 2 period.
Then followed again by a parable or allegory sentence anymore " And the
earth, moreover, hath He extended (to a wide expanse); ". Even this sentence
must be addressed with a clear thinking and analysis, because even this
sentence is a metaphor and as well as guidance very valuable for people who
have wisdom. Where is this sentence shows that after 2 days, the earth was
prepared to be improved further which will be ready to spread for living things.
The sentences of “hath He extended “ or the word “ َ هَ َ د = spread out area,
carpet or rug “ could be interpreted as a parable, that allow or provide
facilities for living things to stay on top.
If a verse 30 and letter Naazi'aat An Al Fushshilat 41:10 merged it would
appear that more complete explanation how the process or the stages of the
earth was spread. In the letter Al Fushshilat 41:10 “spread out” indicated that
this earth is meant is in the process of physically stabilize the earth cemented
with soil like mountains which serves to dampen vibration and also grow all
kinds of plants as food for animals that will inhabit, as well as with the earth's
atmosphere that functioned not only as a roof (protective) but also as a place to
restore water clouds come together and return to the surface of the earth so
that the flows of springs from the sidelines of the land.
This is reinforced by the sound of words " For use and convenience to you and
your cattle. " This sentence has a deep meaning and also a hidden clue, that
after the formation of the Earth system and its natural condition was stable,
then the availability of various plants and perfectly balanced, then the next all
kinds of animals deployed in this earth. Then the plants and all kinds of animals
of this antiquity, each processing the earth's land surface is becoming more
fertile as, for example the formation of the fuel content in the soil as petroleum,
or coal. And then the next God would prepared a more intelligent creature that
is by known with human. Man this is the future that has been destined and
planned by the Creator to keep, maintaining, treating, processing and
managing the balance of nature and the population of the earth. For that God
has equipped man with perfect intelligence to be able to perform those tasks.
But humans are also equipped with lust and desire to profit from the processing
of this earth. So if humans are just selfish and indulge personal desires, then
the damaged and destroyed this earth will pass carnage among fellow human
beings to fight each other interests.
For God's compassionate to give a good guidance how to improve the way the
human mind sensory of heart for maintaining the balance and good living
among them. Between human and nature, as well as between man and fellow
Rules and guidelines set forth in the teachings of each religion that contains
many lessons, lessons and the rules established by the Creator to all mankind
without exception.
At first, that religion is one, comes from God, but during the course of time, the
teachings of each religion has been changed in accordance with the desires
and human desires to obtain progress, the good and benefit of life on earth.
The changes are really going to make it better, but the changes are only
looking for temporary profit will lead to disaster in the future.
During the course of time, changes that are not true religion will lead to disaster
for mankind, so that God sent again a prophet (noble hearted human beings)
who have noticed the wisdom and truth to fix things broken. There are so many
prophets sent down during the journey of human life on this earth, all prophets
taught about the value of goodness and truth.
Conversely there is also a creature that is named by Ali Sina, who always
instigate, instill values of hatred, provoke them, destroying the values of
kindness, so some deluded people back to perform reprehensible.
Ali Sina, is the most obvious examples and precise, to see and make it as a
sample of the existence of an intangible human devil. Satan is not imaginary or
fabricated information from any concept of religion, but the real thing, as has
been shown by Ali Sina this.
Total days of creation 8
Rahmanhadiq; turned out the Shrimp’s Brain is counting wrong again.
Somehow he calculates, out to 8. This proves that words can not be trusted. He
wants to destroy and deny the information of Al Quran verses. Magic formulas
turns out that he got from his ancestors is empty incantations that no value
Ali Sina is certainly not a figure of a man, because he can not count and only
find fault with religious teachings of Islam, without studying and study it first.
That is, the incantations which was read during this just a scam its just to create
hatred, incite, provoke and slader them to among religious communities. And
the better he returned again into the volcano crater to be imprisoned again, or
he burned as an exercise fowith the heat of hell fire in the Hereafter.
This is a clear contradiction. Furthermore, verse 7.54 says “Your Guardian-
Lord is Allah, Who created the heavens and the earth in six days, and is firmly
established on the throne (of authority): He draweth the night as a veil over ,
each seeking the other in rapid succession."
This verse has been discussed by his assistant Dr Naik, so no need to be
solved again. Because, if it repeat again, he would not understand, even how
many times to repeated, he could never understand because in his brain itself
is just a foul-smelling feces which spread everywhere.
This statement can be accepted as poetry but it is not scientific: Darkness is
the absence of light, therefore the cannot be compared to a "veil" drawn over
the day. (Rahmanhadiq; this evidence that Ali Sina is incapable of
understanding the meaning proverb of the words in the parables, he even made
another spell strange which heard in the human ear.)
Also this account is anachronistic. The Earth is part of the universe. It is a
speck floating in a vast ocean of empty space. It could not have been created
before the sky. Even if everything else in the Quran was right, just this gross
error is enough to reject this book as a book of God. (Rahmanhadiq; turned
out to Ali Sina does not understand what he's saying. He was like a man who
was reading the spell with wild language. He comprehend the language of holy
verse with his mind a very narrow and dirty, so she did not want any care
delivered in a sentence verse. KSW is only able to collect the materials
submitted by the team gossip success of negative news about Islam, then
spread the news without investigated. KSW consume negative news and
gossip every days, then devour it greedy , then mixes it into a more vicious
slander, then vomitted to anyone who is willing to swallow his saliva that. He's
never wanted to understand the slander flung, whether the gossip is true or
false, which is important to him wasdirectly spread the gossip did not
understand at all.
Daily food for him is all bad gossip about Islam, then with pride and this demon
make for the magic formulas and pass on his pride website. Actually he does
not have the ability to think anything, he just pretended to get smart. The
contents of his head just a foul-smelling feces and very stinging nose, just like
brain of Shrimp. That attitude is the KSW Narchis.
(Dr. Naik) Point No.2 - Bible says in Genesis Ch. No. 1 Verses No. 3 and 5,…‘Light
was created on the first day.’ Genesis , Ch. , 1 Verses, 14 to 19… ‘The cause of
light - stars and the sun, etc. was created on the fourth day’. How can the cause
of light be created on the 4
day - later than the light which came into existence
on the first day? - It is unscientific.
(Ali Sina) The Quran says Allah created the Earth in two days. Then he set
mountains on it and covered it with vegetation in four days. Then he designed
the sky which had been as smoke. (Sky's creation comes after the creation of
the Earth) Then he entered into a cute conversation with two inanimate objects
– the sky and the earth and told them "Come ye together, willingly or
unwillingly." They said: “We do come (together), in willing obedience." This is
stuff for children’s fairytale.
There are 3 main things that are not understood by the Ali Sina, among others,
that first he did not understand a parable in the holy verses of the Qur'an, the
second he does not understand that these verses are displayed in the holy
Qur'an is not a story as a chronological sequence of events contained in the
Bible book shelf, the third he has no scientific analysis to assess the truth,
because the contents of his brain is full of foul-smelling feces.
Then back Dr Naik's assistant Rahmanhadiq to help provide additional private
on the student named Ali Sina is, in order he did not spit to everywhere with her
mouth which was foul smelling.
Did not we already described by Professor DR Naik in a lecture last semester
that at the initial stage of the second period, contained a parable, " "Come ye
together. willingly or unwillingly. " and then in another verse reappear again a
parable or metaphor which reads "Its night doth He endow with darkness,
and its splendour doth He bring out (with light)”. This sentence appeared
before proceed to 4 days or the next stage. And only a scholar and people who
have wisdom and understanding was the one who is able to understand the
language of metaphor or figurative language above .
If these two verses and two parable or metaphor merged, it would appear a
clear understanding that in the early stages of the first two functioning of the
system's orbit and rotation of the whole of nature, including in this case the
solar system orbital on our sun, as well as the already functioning of each
respective celestial bodies (like the sun that produces light, the planets and the
moon did not light etc.).
So this verse is explained as a whole, not only about the system and the
rotation of the earth's orbit around the sun, but also against all other things in
the universe. So parable or metaphor and purpose of the verse must be
understood more broadly, deeply and with a clear heart and surrender to God.
Actually there is no explanation in the verse, which says that heaven or earth
that was created earlier (lunch or prophecy is earlier), but Ali Sina make
conclusions based on testimony that he consumed from other internet
impressions and then copy and paste it without analyzes first the gossip. This
proves that the KSW is a those who are lazy to think, he just uses other
people's opinions, and gossips news spread that he was not understood at all.)
But it is an embarrassment for grown up adults to believe in this fatuity. “So He
completed them as seven firmaments in two days, and He assigned to each
heaven its duty and command. And We adorned the lower heaven with
lights, and (provided it) with guard.”
What are these seven firmaments? Muhammad is talking about the ancient
pagan myths. The pre Copernican concept of the universe was geocentric, i.e.
they thought that the Earth is flat and is located at the center of the Universe
which consisted of solar system only.
Rahmanhadiq; until now there has been none astrologers or astronomers get
a picture or estimate how much area of universe exactly ?. But the Qur'an has
to submit information 15 centuries ago, that the whole universe that has the
seven heavens. While the sense of the word "sky" is written in the al qur'an also
has a broad meaning, not just layer atmosfor this earth, but is all the celestial
bodies other than Earth, which can also consist of various levels or layers that
are in this universe.
In this case it does not mean that the Qur'an has told a lie but it is people that
have not been able to prove it. Earth scientist and human technology has not
reached a high level. As a comparison only; to reach the nearest galaxy of our
own solar, namely "Adromeda", it would take 2.5 years and even then using the
plane as fast as lightning or as fast as the speed of light. But this Narchis KSW
takes Benefits of news that has been entered into editorial staff that did not
understood, then make a magic formulas become an insult and derision.
Though he did not have any opinion about it, he could only boasting without
being able to provide good scientific to answers and correct.
How many testimonies of the verses al quran previously ridiculed and made fun
of by people like Ali Sina, but when proven, either through scientific discovery
or by chance, then they clam up on speaking terms. Such as the river below the
sea that taste fresh and salty and bitter, embriyologi theory, information about
the occurrence of rain, a pair of genes in the chromosome and so forth. Many
of the details of Quran verses that have been proven and can not be denied
anymore. But the devil is a case of Ali Sina would close her eyes tightly.)
They believed that the Sun and the Moon along with Saturn, Jupiter, Mars,
Venus and Mercury that are the seven known objects of the heaven are deities.
(Rahmanhadiq; al qur'an does not say that the seven heavens are seven
planets. This is the reason dwarf by the Ali Sina, who worked with his
assistants from the time of first Greeks).
These were the only bright objects people could observe with their naked eyes
moving in the sky while the stars appeared to be fixed.

They believed that each one of these planets/gods had its own sphere or
firmament. These layers are not the same as the orbits that we know. The
planets did not orbit the Sun but they all revolved around the flat Earth in this

Moon Mercury Venus Sun Mars Jupiter Saturn
The closest to the Earth was the Moon and the farthest, was the Saturn.
Therefore the concept of the 7 layers of heaven is based on ancient astronomy,
where each celestial body occupied a crystal sphere, one placed on top of the
other like layers of an onion. The stars were tiny lamps attached to the lower
sphere and they were there to adorn the sky like Christmas lights and also to
be used as missiles thrown at the Jinns to keep them away from climbing the
sky and listening to the conversation of the Exalted Assembly. i.e. the
assembly of gods. Reference to this Exalted Assembly is made in 37.8
(Rahanhadiq; this information is only fantasy Ali Sina only. This verse does not
say such things. Only he's just a match and adjust discovery Greek scientist
era to the Al Qur’an verse. This proves that Ali Sina is the spirit of the ghost
haunts the bead comes from the ancient Greeks. This proves that Ali Sina was
never willing to learn before, he just collects material from his editorial staff then
spreading gossip without studying it properly.
According to astronomy historical travel, until the sixth century BC, people still
thought that the earth is still a vast plain that underneath of the earth were fire
or hell. Then the theory is improved by Pythagoras who lived in the sixth
century BC , exactly between 582 SM – 496 SM. Postulated of Pythagoras
can be seen in the figure below;

However Pythagoras’s theory can not be accepted because they are
unrealistic and inconsistent with reality, ie putting a ball of fire as the center of
the universe. Then the theory of Pythagoras in repaired by Ariestoteles in the
year 335 BC. Ariestoteles lived between 384-322 B.C. According Ariestatoles,
which became the center of the universe are earth, not fire. Then the
Ariestotel’s theory was developed by Caludius Ptolemy in the 2nd century BC.
Ptolemy theory is better known as the Geocentric theory. Theory Ariestotels-
Ptolemy described by the following diagram;

Postulate of Ariestotels and Ptolomeus lasted for several centuries until the
middle of 15th century AD. In the mid-15th century, the Geocentric theory of
Ariestotels and Ptolomeus was correct by Nicolaus Copernicus that stating at
the center of the universe is the sun, not Earth. Copernicus did not publish his
book for fear of the Church authorities who have set only one theory of
Geocentric as a form of the universe. According to Copernicus, the universe is
in the following path;

Copernicus Potulat is known as Heliocentric, ie placing the sun as the center of
the universe. The opinion of Copernicus is strengthened by the discovery of
Galileo with his telescope after observing the circulation of the planet Venus,
Jupiter and other solar planets surrounding the sun. Galileo lived in the middle
of 16th century, ie between 1564 to 1642, long after the verses Al Quran
delivered by the prophet Muhammad. But unfortunately, Postulate and
statement of Galileo make him vonnised by judgement to life imprisonment by
the church because Gelileo want to substituted of church’s provisions about the
theory Geocentris. Gelileo was decisioned home convicted in 1622 and in 1642
he died. Galileo's conclusion about the Sun as the center of the universe, it is
also wrong, because at this time astronomers have proven that the sun is a
small object inside the Milky Way Galaxy.

The sun is only one point from one of the stars are from our Milky Way galaxy image

Location solar sun direction indicated by arrows in Milky Way galaxy

Whereas in the 5th century AD, Al-Quran has explained that the earth rotates,
the Earth and moon around the sun in accordance with paragraph description
21:33, which reads " It is He Who created the Night and the Day, and the sun
and the moon: all (the celestial bodies) swim along, each in its rounded
course.". and 27:88 wich reads; “Thou seest the mountains and thinkest them
firmly fixed: but they shall pass away as the clouds pass away “. The sun
rotates and moves even within this universe, according to testimony 36:40
verse, which reads'; “It is not permitted to the Sun to catch up the Moon, nor
can the Night outstrip the Day: Each (just) swims along in (its own) orbit
(according to Law).” . And strengthened by 36:38 verse which reads" And the
sun runs his course for a period determined for him: "

This proves that Al-Qur'an had preceded the scientific discovery of millenium
century, but many peoples do not understand it. )
This is what Muhammad is talking about. This is not science. It is mythology.
The Biblical story of creation, from where Muhammad got his information, is
also mythology. Dr. Naik, like all Muslims, is capable to see that the story of the
creation narrated in the Bible is mythology but he thinks that when Muhammad
plagiarized it, the same mythology became science. Muslims are magic
thinkers. (Rahmanhadiq; actually Ali Sina does not have any scientific ability
at all, he was only able to speak with a copy-paste the opinions of his editorial
staff, then mixes it into a speech of hatred and derision. KSW is only capable of
cursing from behind the wall and from behind the mask is ugly. Same as with a
dog that was barking as he stuck out his tongue, then driven out by people who
feel disgusted to see it. People who think sane and have a good conscience,
will not ignore this raving lunatic, Ali Sina like a dog that kept barking and
desert caravan passed.)
Not only Muhammad believed that the sky has seven layers, which is ludicrous,
he also believed that the earth has seven layers too.
065.012 Allah is He Who created seven Firmaments and oI the earth a similar number.
Is this scientific? Below is a cross section of the Earth showing its layers. As
you can see the Quran is wrong again.


Rahmanhadiq; please note that the model of images displayed by the KSW is
an old-fashioned image that has expired out of dated. At this time Geological
experts have concluded that more better results than those aired by Ali Sina
this. Shown by the KSW is just a basic overview of the magma layer within the
bowels of the earth, but not about the latest layer of earth in accordance with
the development of science and technology. This proves that he is only capable
of cheating and telling others that he was the expert.
(Dr. Naik) Point No. 5, the Bible says in Genesis, Ch. No.1, Verse No. 11 to
13…‘The vegetation, the herbs the shrubs, the trees - they were created on the 3

day And the Sun, Genesis, Ch. No. 1, Verses. 14 to 19, was created on the 4
How can the vegetation come into existence without sunlight, and how can they
survive without sunlight?
(Ali Sina) The same exact absurdity is stated in in the Quran. How can Dr.
Naik see this error in the Bible and he is so blind that he can’t see the same
error in the Quran? (Rahmanhadiq; That's when Ali Sina talking, boasting like
a great orator in the style of excessive rhetoric. But he was not able to use his
reason to give an analytical and scientific reasons to refute the explanation
given by his teacher Naik DR. This proves that he is not able to think properly.
Though his Master has given a logical reason for their opinion, but Ali Sina is
just asking unuseful curses that are not scientifically. Discovered that the KSW
does not have the ability at all.)
(Dr. Naik) Point No.6, that the Bible says in Genesis, Ch. 1, Verses No.16,
that…‘God created two lights the greater light, the Sun to rule the day, and the
lesser light the Moon, to rule the night. The actual translation, if you go to the
Hebrew text, it is ‘lamps’…‘Lamps having lights of its own.’ And that you will come
to know better, if you read both the Verses – Genesis , Ch. No.1, Verse. 16, as well
as 17. Verse No.17 says…‘And Almighty God placed them in the firmament, to give
light to the earth… To give light to the earth.’ Indicating, that Sun and the Moon
has its own light - which is in contradiction with established scientific knowledge
that we have.
(Ali Sina) The same error also exists in the Quran. We will discuss that later.
Once again, scolding of the KSW has no excuse and materials that can refute
his teacher thought. He is showing the griping and frustration only. He was not
able to use his brain which contain a filthy dirt itself. But he has promised to
discuss it to his teacher later. We'll see how he will explan to his teacher.
Although not give directly, but he is pending in subsequent discussion. Does his
explanation just vituperation or scolding else?. Ok! let us follow!
Length of the Days of Creation
(Dr. Naik) There are certain people who try and reconciliate, and say that the six
days mentioned in the Bible, it actually refers to epocs - like the Qur’an long
periods - not six, 24 hour day. It is illogical - you read in the Bible, evening,
morning - It clearly states 24 hours, it indicates. But even if I use the concordance
approach - no problem. I agree with your illogical argument - Yet they will only be
able to solve the 1
scientific error of 6 days creation, and second, of first day
‘light’ and 3
day ‘earth.’ The remaining four, yet they cannot solve. Some further
say that… ‘If it is a 24-hour period, why cannot the vegetables survive for one 24
hour day without sunlight?’ I say ‘Fine - If you say that the vegetables were
created before the sun, and can survive for one 24-hour day, I have got no
objection. But you cannot say the days mentioned are 24 hours as well as epochs -
You cannot have the cake and eat it, both. If you say it is long period, you solve
Point No.1 and 3, the remaining 4 are yet there. If you say the days are 24 hours
day, you solve only Point No.5 - the remaining 5 are yet there - It becomes
unscientific. I leave it to Dr. William Campbell, whether he wants to say… ‘It is long
period’, and say that there are only 4 scientific errors - or say… ‘It is a 24 hour
day’, and say there is only 5 scientific errors in the creation of the universe.
(Ali Sina) In the Quran plants are created between the 3rd and the 6th day and
the firmaments i.e. the sky, the sun and the moon are created in the 7th and 8th
day. So the same difficulty exists also in the Quran.

Now! KSW is spewing his saliva like a King Cobra snake that squirts poison.
Turns out he did not understand to what has been described by his Master DR
Naik, then he made up new stories that make no sense at all.
As is already known that Ali Sina is totally unable to understand a proverb,
metaphor and figurative language that is in the holy books verse, so he
translated the holy book of Islam just as his good feelings. So, at any time KSW
will not understand forever, and certainly next semester the Ideot Student failed
again. If he try again, he thought that his teacher is stupid.
A Elementary student Ali Sina is grumble only. He said that the Bible and the
Qoran is the same, but out of nowhere he put the number 7 and 8 it.
Contradictions in the Bible and the Quran
(Dr. Naik) Regarding the concept of Earth, there are various Scientists who have
described… ‘How will the world end.’ Hypothesis - Some may be right, some may
be wrong. But either the world will perish or the world will live forever. Both cannot
take place simultaneously – It is unscientific. But this is exactly what the Bible
says. It is mentioned in the Bible, in the book of Hebrews, Ch. No.1 Verses No.10
and 11, and the book of Psalms, Ch. No.102, Verse No.25 and 26, that…‘Almighty
God created the Heavens and the Earth, and they will perish.’ Exactly opposite is
mentioned in the book of Ecclesiastics, Ch. No.1, Verse No.4, and the book of
Psalms, Ch. No.78, Verse No.69, that… ‘The earth will abide forever.’ I leave it to
Dr. William Campbell to choose which of the two Verses are unscientific - the first
pair or the second pair. One has to be unscientific - Both cannot take place. The
world cannot abide forever as well as perish – It is unscientific.
(Ali Sina) Yes indeed, there are many contradictions in the Bible. But there are
even more contradictions in the Quran. I will list a few of them at the end of this
paper. Let us mention one of them here.
22:47 and 32:5 say that Allah's day equal to 1,000 human years. But 70:4 says
that it equal to 50,000 years.
Apparently Ali Sina is not able to answer the questions of his teacher Dr. Naik,
then he turned the other topics to prop up his teacher. But let it be, it's strategy
which is played always. No need to Dr Naik explains what is not understood by
the Ali Sina, Rahmanhadiq ready to help him in order he did not fail in the next
In the letter Al Ma'arij verse 4 says that the day whereof 50,000 years, whereas
the letter indicates that the daily Al-Hajj was the same as 1000 years. The
Shrimp Brain accused that of this paragraph is contradiction, is it true?. let us
discuss the explanation paragraph that has been entered into the editorial staff,
then to copi-paste to publish, but he did not understood that verse altogether.
Before discussed the problems above, the question is: Does the word "days"
referred to in the second veses above is a synonym? Is not understanding the
word "day" can have different meanings?
For that let us discuss it. At Al Ma'arij paragraph 4 reads;
“The angels and the spirit ascend unto him in a Day the measure whereof is
(as) fifty thousand years: (QS 70:4). "
This verse uses the word " ٍ مَْ , Yaummin " which means time, period, or
days in the plural. The word "Yaummin" translated in english that is
commensurate with the word "day". The word "Yaummin" means a schedule or
cycle, or period. Context of the above paragraph describes the arrival of an
angel on God's schedule is every single time rotation length of time equal to 50
thousand years according to the calculation time on earth. So the verse
describes the journey time to see God's angel Gabriel. The word "yaumim" in
the paragraph above, may be meaningful as a unit of time travel or maybe also
as a ratio of the distance between the earth with the center of the universe or
the place where God set the entire universe that could be Gabriel in the speed
that we can not specify. Allahualam! God who knows only.

Surat Al Hajj verse 47 which reads:
"And Lo a day your Lord is like a thousand years of your reckoning (Sura
This verse uses the word " ً َْ , Yauman", which in the English language is
translated by the word equivalent of " day". Yauman meaningful words are
repeated word form that shows the number of such periods, periods, or days in
the unit value of God number. This verse relates also to the verse 54 of Al
A'raaf which describes the times, those times or days of the creation of the
Universe by God.
"Verily your Lord is God who created heaven and earth in six days (period),
then He is seated on the Throne (Sura 7:54)."
This verse uses the word " ٍ مّ َ َ أ , Aiyamin" which in English translated by the
word equivalent of " days". Aiyamin word meaningful amount of time, the
number of days, the number of times that is the nature of the word time job,
time, or the day that they are many. Context of this verse describes the time-
period, or periods or days of the creation of the universe by God. This verse
explains that the creation of the universe lasts for 6 days or 6 stages, where
each step of the same bunch of 1000 years of computation time on Earth.
Compare with the following paragraph;
And they say: "We never will be touched by the fire of hell, except for a few
days." (Surat al Baqaraah 2:80)
This verse uses the word " ً ّ َ َ أ, Aiyaman" which in English translated by the
word equivalent of " days". Aiyamin word meaningful amount of days, the
number of days, or several days.
Try to compare it again with a letter of al Asrh paragraphs 1 to 2;
"By the time (day). Behold, the man really is in loss, (qs Al ashr 103:1-2) ",
This verse uses the word " ِ ْ َ ْ ا , Al A'srh" which in the English language is
translated by the word equivalent of "day" or "period". The word "Al A'srh"
means the nature of time, period, or a road of time. As the time can not be
stopped, or the nature of the timer that can not be retroactive, or the nature of
time travel that continues to run indefinitely.
Try to compare it again with the word " َ مَْ , Yaumal" in the letter of Al
Baqaraah paragraph 85;
"Do you believe in sebahagian Scripture (Torah) and sebahagian breach
against the other? There is no reward for those who do so of you but disgrace
in this life, and on the Day of Resurrection they shall be returned to a very
severe punishment. Allah is not unmindful of what ye do (Qs Al Baqarah 2:85)”.
The paragraph above the word " َ مَْ , Yaumal" which in English translated by
the word equivalent of "day". The word " َ مَْ , Yaumal" significant "event time"
or " for a moment”, or “point in time”, or at the time”. The phrase " ِ َ َ ِ ْ ا َ مَْ ,
yaumal qiyama" in the verse above is translated in the English with a "day"
whereas this sentence is more accurately translated as "when the apocalypse"
or "when Judgement."
That's how God delivered His word to the grammar is very careful, beautiful,
calculating, full of meaning and full of meaning for people who want to think and
So there is no contradictory information from the second paragraph above, as
submitted by the Copy-Paste Worker as KSW. The provocateur KSW is always
looking for conflict among religious communities and in religious teachings.
If there is a difference of meaning in translation or interpretation of the second
words above, then it's not because the verse in Al Quran is wrong, because the
original language al qur'an it still remains unchanged until this day. But the
translator that have not been able to make interpretations or an equivalent right.
Is Sky a Dome?
(Dr. Naik) Regarding ‘the Heavens’, the Bible says in Job, Ch. 26, Verse 11,
that…‘The pillars of the Heaven will tremble.’ Qur’an says in Surah Luqman, Ch. 31,
Verse No.10, that…‘The Heavens are without any pillars - Don`t you see? Don’t you
see the Heavens are without any pillars? - Bible says heaven have got pillars. Not
only do the Heavens have got pillars – Bible says in the first book of Samuel, Ch.
No.2 Verses No.8, as well as the book of Job Ch. No.9, Verse No.6, and the book of
Psalms Ch. No.75, Verse No.3, that… ‘Even the earth have got pillars.’
(Ali Sina) In the verses 41:9-12 that we already discussed, Muhammad says
that after creating the earth and putting in it the mountains so it does not shake
with people and covering it with vegetation then he erected the sky. َ ِ إ ىَ َ ْ ا ُ
ءَ ا
The picture we get here is that the sky is like a dome. First the foundation which
is the earth is built and once it is finished Allah turns to the sky and lifts it up,
as if it was a tent, and adorns it with stars.
(Rahamanhadiq; basic Ali Sina who are unable to use his reason, but by his
fantasy narchis. So learn better and diligent, do not cheat only without studying
at all. So do not pretend pretentious yourself. Description of Al Fushshilat
paragraph 11 of these not talking about that the earth has poles or have a
dome. There is Ali SIna’s machination. So do not be too high imagination. Or
maybe just Ali Sina is awaiting an elf which have come down from behind the
The versed 13.2 and 31.10 do not contradict the Bible. They only state the
obvious that these alleged pillars holding the sky in place cannot be seen.


Surah 13. AR RA'D verse 2 said

ِ شْ·َ ·ْ 'ا َ 'َ = ىَ ·َ -ْ -ا ّ َ »ُ ` 'َ +َ -ْوَ ·َ - ٍ -َ -َ = ِ·ْ -َ ·ِ - ِ تاَ و'َ -ّ َ -'ا َ ·َ ·َ ر يِ -ّ َ 'ا ُ ªّ َ ''ا
“Allah is He Who raised the heavens without any pillars that ye can see;
(QS 13:2)”

While Letter 31. Luqman verse 10 said ;

'َ +َ -ْوَ ·َ - ٍ -َ -َ = ِ ·ْ -َ ·ِ - ِ تاَ و'َ -ّ َ -'ا َ ·َ 'َ =

“He created the heavens without any pillars that ye can see; (QS 31:10)”

KSW can not read also, or blind eyes as well as stupid. Yet in the paragraph
that clearly stated without any pillars or no pole at all. But he's totally blind to
the letter in the word “ without” or "no" on verses above.)

002:022 syas that the sky is bana َ ِ ءَ اَ وء . While in reality sky is just and
empty space. See how bana is translated:
(Rahmanhadiq; Arabic writing (َ ِ ءَ اَ وء ) was not readable "bana "!! From
where KSW is getting these weird science?. what Language is this? This
proves that Ali Sina is not able to read the Qur'an, then pretended to want to
teach Muslims with the book of al qur'an. So who is Ali Sina exactly ?. This
proves that Ali Sina is not from the State of Iran, who he claims in his pussy
website's. Where there are people of Iran are not good at reading the Arabic
letters. But otherwise Ali Sina could not speak Arabic, let alone read the
writings of Al- qur'an. Apparently Ali Sina really a culprit in disguise and hiding
out from behind his mask.

The 2:22 verse reads;

ً ء'َ - ِ ء'َ -ّ َ -'ا َ .ِ - َ لَ ·ْ -َ أَ و ً ء'َ -ِ - َ ء'َ -ّ َ -'اَ و 'ً -اَ ·ِ · َ ضْر`ا ُ »ُ ´َ ' َ .َ ·َ = يِ -ّ َ 'ا
َ ن·ُ -َ 'ْ ·َ - ْ»ُ -ْ -َ أَ و اً داَ -ْ -َ أ ِ ªّ َ 'ِ ' ا·ُ 'َ ·ْ =َ- `َ · َ 'ْ»ُ ´ 'ً ·ْزِ ر ِ تاَ ·َ -ّ َ `'ا َ .ِ - ِ ªِ - َ جَ ·ْ =َ'َ ·

Who has made the earth your couch, and the heavens your canopy; and
sent down rain from the heavens; and brought forth therewith Fruits for
your sustenance; then set not up rivals unto Allah when ye know (the
truth) (QS 2:22)”.

The word “ً ء'َ -ِ - َ ء'َ -ّ َ -'اَ و = wassama ‘ a bina ‘a “. For َ ء'َ -ّ َ -'اَ و = sky “ and ,”
ً ء'َ -ِ - ÷ covering, canopy “.
The contexts of 2:22 verse indicated that the word of َ ءَ ّ َ اَ و = sky or atmosfire
, whereas the word of ً ءَ ِ = covering or roof. The Geologist had been
proved at 20
century that the fungtion of the earth atmospheres as covering
and protected earth from UV-radiation of sunlight , meteor falling and etc. The
earth atmosphere consist of seven layers that are (1) Troposfer, (2)
Stratosfer, (3) Ozone layer (protected from sunlight UV radiation), (4)
Mesosfer, (5) Termosfer, (6) Ionosfer, dan (7) Eksosfer.
Who hath appointed the earth a resting-place Ior you. and the sky a
Who has made the earth your couch. and the heavens your canopy;
Who has made the earth a resting place Ior you. and the sky as a canopy.
Who made the earth a resting place Ior you and the heaven a canopy
Sher Ali
WHO made the earth a bed Ior you. and the heaven a roof.
The One who made the earth habitable Ior you. and the sky a structure.
who assigned to you the earth Ior a couch. and heaven Ior an edifice,
who made the earth Ior you a bed and the heaven a dome;
Who hath made the earth a bed Ior you. and the heaven a covering.
who hath spread the earth as a bed Ior you. and the heaven as a covering.

Biblical cosmology as understood from the Book of Enoch
On the right is a representation of Islamic cosmology
as understood from the Quran and hadith. The flat
earth is floating in the middle of the ocean surrounded by insurmountable
mountains of Qaf and the dome of sky is supported by invisible pillars. The sky
has seven layers each layer is a firmament for one planet. The lower layer of
the sky is adorned by stars.
Now we can see why Muhammad said mountains are like pegs that prevent the
earth from shaking. If the earth is flat and is floating on water, (an idea that was
confirmed by the fact that water gushes out when a well is dug out), then if you
jump on it, it could rock with you like a small boat. To stop the earth from
shaking you need to secure it to the bottom of the ocean and that is the function
of the mountains that like pegs, firmly keep the earth from shaking. Dr. Naik
assured us that mountains, like icebergs, go deep into the earth and only a
small part of them are visible.
This picture makes everything clear. The function of mountain as pegs is
described in the Quran 31:10, 16:15 and 21:31
"And He has set up on the earth mountains standing firm, lest it should shake
with you;"
That's the Ali Sina was fantasizing about the meaning and significance of
information Al-qur'an’s letter 31.10, 16:15 and 21:31. This signifies that he only
brought the science of the voodoo, during isolated inside a volcano crater. He
got some magic formulas of stories of ancient Roman nation, then adopted the
story to copy-paste into the understanding of Al-qur'ans paragraph above.
Whereas, Al Qur’an rejected it. It's useless as long as it provides assistance to
this stupid students like this, it turns out he's still senile.
Indeed the level of Ali Sina is not sufficient to learning with human being,
because his brain does not contain any human memory to remember, so that
anything communicated to him , directly forgot by himself. KSW is currently
selling soy sauce with a waffle senile, out of nowhere he gets a hadith that
accused as myth. Even if there is such a hadist, then it does not come from
people who understand al qur'an, maybe just one match and adjust it with the
knowledge of Quran in the Greek era, or can be derived from his gang.
Seest thou not that God has made subiect to you (men) all that is on the earth. and the
ships that sail through the sea by His Command? He withholds the sky from falling
on the earth except by His leave: Ior God is Most Kind and Most MerciIul to man.
Yusuf Ali realizing the absurdity of this verse deceptively has added (rain) in
parenthesis after the word sky. No other translator has done that and there is
no mention of rain in the Arabic version.
ِ ضْرَ ْ ا َ َ َ َ َ نَ أ ءَ ا ُ ِ ْ ُ َ و
(Yusuf Ali's translation of the Quran is the most deceptive and the least
trustworthy. If you have to read the Quran in English I suggest read several
translations simultaneously and trust the most damaging translation because it
is the most truthful. All the translators of the Quran have done their best to
disguise the absurdities and the violence of the Quran by choosing less
incriminating words. Yusuf Ali has gone out of his way to do that. Rashed
Khalifa is even wrose. He did not stop at mistranslating the Quran. He actually
changed it completely. No wonder Muslims killed him.)
What does 22:65 mean? Ibn Khathir the greatest commentator of the Quran
�(..without any pillars that you can see.) meaning, `there are pillars, but you
cannot see them,' according to Ibn `Abbas, Mujahid, Al-Hasan, Qatadah, and
several other scholars. Iyas bin Mu`awiyah said, "The heaven is like a dome
over the earth,'' meaning, without pillars. Similar was reported from Qatadah,
and this meaning is better for this part of the Ayah, especially since Allah said
in another Ayah.� And �(..that you can see), affirms that there are no pillars.
Rather, the heaven is elevated (above the earth) without pillars, as you see.
This meaning best affirms Allah's ability and power.�
So scholars debated whether the dome of the sky is sustained by invisible
pillars or it is hovering over earth without pillars miraculously thanks to Allah's
power. But everyone agreed that the sky is a dome.
There are other verses where the Quran says Allah is holding the sky from
falling on the heads of people just to show them a sign of his mercy.
55:7 And the Firmament has He raised high
88:18 And at the Sky. how it is raised high?-
13:2 Allah is He Who raised the heavens without any pillars that ye can see;
ُ ِ ْ ُ َ و = And hold him (anything), ءَ ا = (existing) in the sky, this
sentence has general , broad and deep meaningful.
The question is, what are detained in the sky? Is there something in the
heavens endure it? What is the meaning sky in this verse? To answer this
question, can not imagine by any imagination , as been done by this KSW.
He imagine that detained in the sky is heavenly bodies with a buffer large
dome-shaped, but not visible. Maybe he just returned from the upper sky.
Though the verse is not intended that way. Al qur'an verses must to be
understood with rational though pattern, analysis, science and scientists. So is
not answered by an empty chimera. Only people like KSW translated the
meaning of the verse as a form of dome or support poles of the earth to the
sky. If there are Islam people who interpret so of course thus it's not cause the
verse that says like that, but the translator that match knowlege understanding
with the development of science in today. Whereas , Al Qur’an rejected it.
So understanding these verses with the phrase " He withholds the sky from
falling on the earth except by His leave " Could be interpreted by a wider
understanding, namely: "all the heavenly bodies will be retained (not fall, nor
thrown) from the control system (orbit) that have been determined by the
Creator. And objects that follow the terms of the previous verse is "Come ye
both according to my commandment, willingly or unwillingly."
If the metaphor of verse " He withholds the sky from falling on the earth
except by His leave (Qs 22:65)" combined with the metaphor of verse: ""Come
ye together, willingly or unwillingly.(qs 41:11) ", it would appear a more
accurate understanding of " God keep the balance of objects - the object in an
orbit of each ".
So there is no pole and no buffer as well as in the mind of the brain's Shrimp Ali
Sina. The brain’s Ali Sina like a brain's Shrimp!.
Several times this KSW is inability to understand a pareble or figurative
language in the verses of Al Quran. So what's true though immortalized AL
Quran verses that focused on KSW that get lost in the meaning of a word

Letter 2. Al-Baqarah - Verses 26;
"Allah disdains not to use the similitude of things, lowest as well as highest. Those
who believe know that it is truth from their Lord; but those who reject Faith say:
"What means Allah by this similitude?" By it He causes many to stray, and many
He leads into the right path; but He causes not to stray, except those who
forsake (the path),"(Surah Al Baqaraah 2:26)"

Letter 17. AL ISRAA '- Paragraph 48;
"See what similes they strike for thee: but they have gone astray, and never can
they find a way. (Surah al-Israa '17:48)."
Letter 17. AL ISRAA '- Paragraph 89;
"And We have explained to man, in this Qur'an, every kind of similitude: yet the
greater part of men refuse (to receive it) except with ingratitude! (Surah Al-
Israa '17:89)."

Letter 29. AL'ANKABUUT - Paragraph 43
“And such are the Metaphors We set forth for mankind, but only those
understand them who have knowledge(Sura al Ankabuut 29:43)."

(Ali Sina)
There are other verses where the Quran says Allah is holding the sky from
falling on the heads of people just to show them a sign of his mercy. There are
other verses where the Quran says Allah is holding the sky from falling on the
heads of people just to show them a sign of his mercy.
55:7 And the Firmament has He raised high. 88:18 And at the Sky. how it is raised
high?- 13:2 Allah is He Who raised the heavens without any pillars that ye can see;
Rahmanhadiq; seems Ali Sina would like to offer his glibberish again. Well
we're going to test the truth, whether the explanation of that verse the same as
what is in the mind of this KSW.
First we will see an explanation the surah Ar Rahman 55 verse 7. Actually
verse 7 of this surah Ar Rahman is still associated with some of the previous
verses. This needs to be delivered to Ali Sina , so that he does not distort the
meaning of the verse.
For that we start from verse 5 to verse 7 of Ar Rahman 55 which reads;
“The sun and the moon follow courses (exactly) computed 5; And the herbs and
the trees - both (alike) prostrate in adoration 6. And the Firmament has He
raised high, and He has set up the Balance (of Justice), (QS 55:5-7)”.
Description of this verse begins functioning of heavenly bodies, the moon and
sun that can be used as the calculation time for humans, this verse has the
meaning implied that there is something that the system can apply to the
movement of the moon and the sun was observed from the earth, so it can
serve as basis of calculation in determining the number of days for humans on
earth. For this, the people must observe and learn. And it is true today, the sun
and moon calculations have been used as a tool for human day and time, long
before Ali Sina came into this world.
After that followed by “And the herbs and the trees - both (alike) prostrate in
adoration”. Both the plants and the two celestial body that (heaven and earth),
made its submission to the system that has been determined by the creator, in
which men must learn them. Then proceed again with the object raised to the
sky (that is to expand the space.) .
Furthermore, implanted a word "balance". The word "balance" is a metaphor.
The meaning was quite broad. It could mean the justice of God to the entire
universe, but also could be interpreted as a system that can maintain the
balance of all these heavenly bodies. So the verses above have a very deep of
meaning, which will not be understood by the KSW of this negative thinking.. s
Furthermore, let us see again the next verse;

“And at the Sky, how it is raised high?- (Qs 88:18)”.
The verse uses a verb "elevated". Something odd, if the Ali Sina is still imagine
that between the heaven and the earth have dome or stairs that the longer the
game is raised (the dome is elastic and stretchy ye?). Of course this is not
possible and in the Ali Sina only. Return this verse states that the universe is
expansed or higher, in accordance with the observations of experts astronomy
current (Hubble's theory). So it's useless KSW is belied the verses of the
Qur'an as it conveys the lesson above earlier. He can only reject a verse, but
take other verses that mean the same time to reject these verses (then caught
him lying and stupid). That method is performed by the stupidity of this KSW.
Furthermore, let us see again the next verse;

“Allah is He Who raised the heavens without any pillars that ye can see; is
firmly established on the throne (of authority); He has subjected the sun and the
moon (to his Law)! Each one runs (its course) for a term appointed. He doth
regulate all affairs, explaining the signs in detail, that ye may believe with
certainty in the meeting with your Lord (QS 13:2)”.

Somehow Ali Sina took the verse above to declare that the sky is have a pole,
even though they may reject the statement that paragraph or the pole vault.
Therefore, diligent study boy!, learn the true, must not cheat and copy- paste it,
must not be included the report that was piled on the editorial desk, must not
speak if you do not have the right knowledge, do not use the shrimp’s brain,
just embarrassing KSW.

What Supports the Earth?
If the dome of heaven is raised above the earth supported by invisible pillars,
what supports the earth?

According to Islamic cosmology, the earth, seen in this picture as a disk is
surrounded by the sundering seas which are restrained by the encircling Qaf
Mountains. It is supported on the back (sometimes horns) of an ox that stands
on a fish in a bowl and all that is carried on the shoulders of an angel. This
picture is reproduced in one of the most enduringly Arabic geographies of the
Islamic Middle Ages Ajaib al-Makhluqat (The wonders of creation) by the
Persian author Zakariya Qazwini (d. 1283 or 1284).
Rahmanhadiq; apparently KSW is still using the reference nation of ignorance,
which are obsolete. Whereas verses of the Qur'an described above do not say
such things. It turned out that the KSW was, had just returned from the
hermitage for more than 1000 years. He makes the expire of date reference.
Maybe he had just delivered the news from the Islamic era of ignorance that
still does not understand the science and unable to understand the verses al
quran well so that they had to match their knowledge with the verses of Qur'an,
or maybe just the news come from the hordes of the KSW is also that has
always been to spread negative gossip.
The following is the Medieval Islamic Map of the World

This picture is by'Umar bin Muzaffar Ibn al-Wardi. published in Kharidat al-
'Aja'ib wa Faridat al-Ghara'ib. (The Pearl of Wonders and the Uniqueness of
Things Strange). Late seventeenth century. At the center of the map are the
two holiest cities of Islam: Mecca and Medina. The map shows China and India
in the north and the "Christian sects and the states of Byzantium" in the south.
The outer circles represent the seas. The manuscript is a cosmology, not
meant to be accurate geographically, but only to present the reader with a
systematic overview of the existing knowledge about the world at the time.
Rahmanhadiq; the pictures was copied paste by the KSW is not a truly world
map, but is an overview map of the strength of religious groups or a nation that
controls a vast area at the time.
The following hadith sheds more light on the nature of the seven layers of
heaven and earth. Narrated AbuHurayrah
While Allah's Prophet (peace be upon him) and his companions were sitting clouds
came over them and Allah's Prophet (peace be upon him) asked. "Do you know what
these are?" On their replying that Allah and His Messenger knew best. he said. "These
are the clouds (anan). these are the water-carriers oI the Earth. which Allah drives to
people who do not thank Him or call upon him." He then asked. "Do you know what is
above you?" On their replying that Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him) knew
best. he said. "It is the Iirmament. a ceiling which is guarded and waves which are kept
back." He then asked. "Do you know what is between you and it?" On their replying
that Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him) knew best. he said. "Between you
and it are Iive hundred years." He then asked. "Do you knew what is above that?" On
their replying that Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him) best he said. "Two
heavens with a distance oI Iive hundred years between them." He went on speaking like
that till he counted seven heavens. the distance between each pair being like between
Heaven and Earth. He then asked. "Do you know what is above that?" On their replying
that Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him) knew best. he said. "Above that is
the Throne. and the distance between it and the (seventh) heaven is the same as that
between each pair oI heavens." He then asked, "Do you know what is below you?"
On their replying that Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him) knew best, he
said, "It is the earth." He then asked, "Do you know what is under that?" On
their replying that Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him) knew best, he
said, "Under it there is another Earth with a journey of five hundred years
between them," and so on till he had counted seven earths with a journey of five
hundred years between each pair. He then said. "By Him in Whose hand
Muhammad's soul is. iI you were to drop a rope to the lowest earth it would not pass
out oI Allah's knowledge." He then recited. "He is the First and the Last. the Outward
and the Inward. and He is omniscient." (Tirmidhi commented that Allah's Messenger's
recitation oI the verse indicates that it would go down within Allah's knowledge. power
and authority. Ior Allah's knowledge. power and authority are everywhere. while He is
on the Throne. as He described HimselI in His Book.) |1|
Muhammad ibn 'Abd Allah al-Kisa'i writes: "And He commanded the rock to
settle beneath the angel's feet. The rock, however, had no support, so God
created a great bull with forty thousand heads, eyes, ears, nostrils, mouths,
tongues and legs and commanded it to bear the rock on its back and on its
horns. The name of the bull is al-Rayyan. As the bull had no place to rest its
feet, God created a huge fish, upon whom no one may gaze at because it is so
enormous and has so many eyes. It is even said that if all the seas were placed
on one of its gills, they would be like a mustard seed in the desert. This fish
God commanded to be a foothold for the bull, and it was done. The name of
this fish is Behemoth. Then He made its resting place the waters, beneath
which is the air, and beneath the air is the Darkness, which is for all the earths.
There, beneath the Darkness, the knowledge of created things ends. [2]
Rahmanhadiq; seems that Ali Sina uses the discovery of ancient references to
reinforce his opinion that this earth has a pole in accordance with the literature
of Bedouin who have successfully fooled by the Greeks ancestor of this KSW,
for scientific discovery at the time fit the description AL Qur ' an. So it's useless
to him bob up and down past that did not usefulfor the development of science
today. Humans may be wrong in making conclusions or theories from the
results of his findings, but the Holy Book that comes from the Creator would not
contain errors, as is often done by mankind.
Inheritance Who Taught Allah Math?
(Ali Sina ) One of the most obvious mathematical mistakes of the Quran can
be found in the division of the inheritance. s
Rahmanhadiq; KSW Apparently it wanted to divert the topic to the other, to
trick people to get out of his religious teachings. Back Ali Sina is collecting
news gossip that had accumulated on his desk editor for transmitted. But
unfortunately the culprit was never understood and did not want to read it first
before spreading the slander that. The KSW is indeed not have good thoughts
and right, so he does not care if the news is true or false, because he never
wanted to learn at all. Each semester the student of this DR Naik is always just
fail and fail again with the courses given by the teacher.
For that, rahmanhadiq will learn the verses are delivered by the KSW. Is gossip
that planted by Ali Sina is still scientific or not, or simply to convey his
frustration right?
How many days required God to destroy the nation Aad?
- 54.19 on the unlucky day, -> One day.
- 41.16 within a few days of bad luck, -> plural precursory at least three days.
- 69.7 for seven nights and eight days continuously;


The letter 54.19 reads;

“For We sent against them a furious wind, on a Day of violent Disaster,”
(QS 54:19)

Seems Ali Sina is again not able to use his senses. Whereas the above verses
describe “on a Day of violent Disaster”. But KSW is thought that the time
constant was equal to the time in a day. Is there a sentence written in verse
one day? Of course Sentence " a Day of violent Disaster ", meaning more than
one day and not a long time but not all the time for forever.

41.16 within a few days of bad luck, -> plural precursory at least three

The letter 41.16 reads;

“So We sent against them a furious Wind through days of disaster, that We
might give them a taste of a Penalty of humiliation in this life; but the Penalty of
a Hereafter will be more humiliating still: and they will find no help. (QS 41:16)”

Rahmanhadiq; re-Ali Sina shows lack ability to count. Submitted by the verse
above is the phrase "through days of disaster ". But he counted to 3 days.
So we do not have to believe with KSW greeting that always wanted to plunge
the religious community.

- 69.7 for seven nights and eight days continuously;

Rahmanhadiq ;

“ The letter 69.7 reads; “He made it rage against them seven nights and eight
days in succession: so that thou couldst see the (whole) people lying prostrate in
its (path), as they had been roots of hollow palm-trees tumbled down!”(QS 69:7)”

Rahmanhadiq; This verse actually wrote the phrase " seven nights and eight
days in succession, " , but Ali Sina was also unable to understand and read it
right. This verse clarifies all of the preceding paragraphs that he want to deny
the KSW of this curse. It turned out that this verse explains that “ on a Day of
violent Disaster “seven nights and eight days”. So there is no information that
these verses contradict each other, even contrary complementary and mutually
reinforcing. So this proved that the KSW does not understand at all with the
verses of the Qur'an. He was only able to spread slander and a sense of
resentment just.

so what's true in immortalized by the verse of Qur'an which reads;

“And yet among men there are such as dispute about Allah, without knowledge,
and follow every evil one obstinate in rebellion! (Sura AL HAJJ 22:3)”.

What God day equals 1,000 human years (22:47, 32.5) or 50 thousand years of
human (70.4)?

Rahmanhadiq; this paragraph have already been discussed in past lessons,
but Ali Sina has been continually repeated request, because he had not
understood at all. Repeated useless, because it will spend the time and will not
make the student who will not understand this.

-According to paragraph 56.7 there will be THREE distinct groups of people on
the day of court, but the verses 90.18-19, 99.6-8 mention only TWO groups
(right and left hands).


The sound of paragraph 56.7 is;

“And ye shall be sorted out into three classes 7. Then (there will be) the
Companions of the Right Hand;- What will be the Companions of the Right Hand
8? And the Companions of the Left Hand,- what will be the Companions of the
Left Hand 9? And those Foremost (in Faith) will be Foremost (in the Hereafter).

KSW was totally blind, he did not read the continuation of the verse after that.
He was only able to read the paragraph number 7 only, whereas the verse after
it is removed just like that. In fact the whole paragraph that explains that there
are 3 groups of people are in the afterlife. Those that are: 1. Companions of the
Right (go to heaven because they do much good). 2. the Companions of the
Left Hand (go to hell because they always do evil like Ali Sina is) 3. Group who
will enter Paradise (those Foremost (in Faith) without inhaled (the prophets).

The letter 90.18-19 reads;
“ Such are the Companions of the Right Hand 18. But those who reject Our
Signs, they are the (unhappy) Companions of the Left Hand (QS 19.18-19)”

Rahmanhadiq; verses to tell about the people who are in their places in the
next. The people who are in heaven or the right group of them told each other
with advice and good faith, while on the left are the criminals or those infidels
who suffered in a fire in a sealed furnace. Apparently the Ali Sina would like to
invite other people to follow him into the fire, because that is where the he
The letter 99.6-8 reads;
“On that Day will men proceed in companies sorted out, to be shown the deeds
that they (had done) 6. Then shall anyone who has done an atom's weight of good,
see it 7! And anyone who has done an atom's weight of evil, shall see it
(QS 99:6-8)”.
Rahmanhadiq; verse is not talking about groups of people residing in the next,
but it illustrates about something that will happen at the time of Judgement.
What is clear is intentionally spreading of the KSW to this verses, because he
himself felt fear of the torments of hell fire, so he invites his friends to reject the
description verses above. But he himself did not understand what would
happen to him one day after his death. He also does not have an answer where
the goal after his death later. In fact all religions believe in life after death, as
well as retaliation against crime punishment has ever done. But this KSW to
deny information these verses in different ways.
- Who take the life: Angel of death of 32.11, the Angels (plural) or 47.27 "God
took the soul (person) when the death of" 39.42.
The letter 32.11 reads ; “Say: "The Angel of Death, put in charge of you, will
(duly) take your souls: then shall ye be brought back to your Lord." (QS 32:11)”
Rahmanhadiq; this verse describes the existence of beings called angels who
got the assignment or job to take the life or spirit of man ( “put in charge of you
“) before his death. Then there is a sentence " then shall ye be brought back to
your Lord. ", which is a metaphor or allegory, which means that everything
related to the actions that have been done by humans, it hold responsible to
God, after his death later.
The letter 47.27 reads;
“But how (will it be) when the angels take their souls at death, and smite their
faces and their backs? (QS 47:27)”
Rahmanhadiq; verses reinforce and complement the previous paragraph
statement explaining that the man given the task to pull out later when the
death is the Angels. Classification angel named Israfil.

The letter 39.42 reads ;

“It is Allah that takes the souls (of men) at death; and those that die not (He
takes) during their sleep: those on whom He has passed the decree of death,
He keeps back (from returning to life), but the rest He sends (to their bodies) for
a term appointed verily in this are Signs for those who reflect (qs 39.42)”.

Paragraph 39.42 provides guidance that God has the power and absolute
power of life and death of a human. The Soul or spirit of human being is under
the control of the owner is God. This means that a person's life is governed by
the will of God, either when he has not obtained a soul (spirit), when he was
born, before his death, after his death and at the time of eternal life in hell or in
heaven. This shows that the power of God is higher than the angels. The angel
assigned only kill humans, but God controls all human life. KSW will not be
willing to accept this reality, because he felt he was not human, so no one could
pull out his soul. He sure will live forever on this earth.

How many engles announced the Birth of Yesus by virgin of Maria? One engle 19.17-
21 or many of angles (3.42-45)?

Verse 19:17 reads;
“She placed a screen (to screen herself) from them; then We sent her our
angel, and he appeared before her as a man in all respects.(QS 19:17)”
The word "We" are embedded in sentences is not a figure of an angel, but as
another name of "God" who at that moment the angel Gabriel told Muhammad
about the coming of the angel met Mary. While the word "Our Angel" here is not
the figure of God, but the figure of the angel “Gabriel” who will carry out the task
from God in a way to meet Mary in person.
So it is clear that the KSW does not read the verse, but he only heard the story
of his office boy, then feel very happy and laughed out loud after hearing the
story, then scream head off tell to the general public. That nature of KSW
namely Ali Sina.

Verse of 19.18-21 reads;
“She said: "I seek refuge from thee to (Allah) Most Gracious: (come not near) if
thou dost fear Allah. 18". He said: "Nay, I am only a messenger from thy Lord,
(to announce) to thee the gift of a holy son 19. She said: "How shall I have a
son, seeing that no man has touched me, and I am not unchaste? 20" He said:
"So (it will be): Thy Lord saith, 'that is easy for Me: and (We wish) to appoint
him as a Sign unto men and a Mercy from Us':It is a matter (so) decreed." (QS
(Rahmanhadiq; The above verses tells of a dialogue between Marya by the
Angel Gabriel, not a dialogue between God and Marya. However, the KSW did
not read at all, because he only heard the story of his gang.
(Ali sina) One of the most obvious mathematical mistakes of the Quran can be
found in the division of the inheritance.
The laws of inheritance are spread out in several Suras. One can find
references to them in Al-Baqarah(2), Al-Maidah(5) and Al-Anfal(8). But the
details of these laws are spelled out in the Surah Nisa (4).

Q. 4:11

“Allah (thus) directs you as regards your Children's (Inheritance): to the male, a
portion equal to that of two females: if only daughters, two or more, their share is two-
thirds of the inheritance; if only one, her share is a half. For parents, a sixth share of
the inheritance to each, if the deceased left children; if no children, and the parents are
the (only) heirs, the mother has a third; if the deceased Left brothers (or sisters) the
mother has a sixth. (The distribution in all cases ('s) after the payment of legacies and

Verse 4:11 says that if a man has only one daughter, she gets half of the
inheritance irrespective of other heirs. But since the same verse says that the
portion of the male is twice that of the female, her brother is supposed to get all
the inheritance. Isn’t this a discrepancy? Certainly there is an error in how this
law is written. Yet the problem is aggravated further when the share of other
heirs like parents and wives are taken into consideration.
This verse explains about one man who wanted to distribute his inheritance to
his family. Where is the person who will make inheritance as not married or
widower status, how the division of his estate to his family?. If he does not have
a parent then the property falls to the children, whose composition is already
described above, but if the man's parents also have the parents will get a part,
in accordance with the above composition. While his ex-wife did not get the part
at all because maybe he was married again or had died. Hence paragraph
above are not talking about the wife at all, because the wife is not considered to
For example, if the deceased has an child (male and female) and also have
parents. How do the distribution? ;
For example, the dead leaves have 2 boys + 2 girls + 2 parents;
Parents of each received; (1 / 6 +1 / 6) of the existing property.
Time treasures 2 / 3 part is for their children with comparative compositions;
Male: female = 2: 1 because the child Qty 4 (2 male +2 female) then;
Two sons each received; (2 / 6 +2 / 6) of the estate remaining
While the 2 children each woman received;
- (1 / 6 + 1 / 6) of the estate
So the total distribution is'
1 / 6 +1 / 6 + (2 / 6 +2 / 6) x2 / 3 + (1 / 6 +1 / 6) x2 / 3 =
1 / 3 + 12/18 = 1 / 3 + 2 / 3 = 100%
(Ali Sina) There are cases when the total of the shares assigned to the heirs
exceeds the patrimony. Take for example the following.

According to the above verses, if a man dies leaving behind a wife, three
daughters and his two parents,
His wife’s share of his inheritance is 1/8. (In what ye leave, their share is a fourth, if
ye leave no child; but if ye leave a child, they get an eighth)
His daughters would receive 2/3 (if only daughters, two or more, their share is two-
thirds of the inheritance;)
and his parents each will get 1/6 of his inheritance. (For parents, a sixth share of
the inheritance to each, if the deceased left children;)
When you add all these Iractions the sum is more than the total oI inheritance.
WiIe1/8 ÷ 3/24
Daughters 2/3 ÷ 16/24
Father 1/6 ÷ 4/24
Mother1/6 ÷ 4/24
Total ÷ 27/24
Now take another example. Say a man is survived by his wiIe. his mother and his
It turned out that Ali Sina want it to take share of their parents by means of
(4.11) verse only. If you use this clause, means the wife is considered to not
exist. Because the men who died were not married, as widower or his wife or
his wife's death had remarried. However Ali Sina get to input the name of his
But instead, if he use another verse 4:12 to take a ration of his wife. If this
clause is taken, then the automatic quota parents will fall. Whereas the
provisions of this verse apply only for a husband or wife who died but had not
have parents anymore. So this verse does not include the right of parents,
because he was not there.
But Ali Sina is take the two verses at the same time and concurrently, causing
the division is to be unfair, because there will be heirs who do not get the part.
Apparently Ali Sina, the wish is delicious just to get the estate of another
person. The dead also counted. Really the greedy of Ali Sina. So the verse
where you want to use? So if you do not understand do not put on the dog , to
get smart and only grumble again. Ye Ali Sina " the Gossip repairman ".
(Ali Sina) Q. 4: 12
“In what your wives leave, your share is a half, if they leave no child; but if they leave
a child, ye get a fourth; after payment of legacies and debts. In what ye leave, their
share is a fourth, if ye leave no child; but if ye leave a child, they get an eighth; after
payment of legacies and debts…”
The wiIe receives 1/4 oI the inheritance. (In what ye leave, their share is a fourth, if ye
leave no child;)
the mother 1/3 (if only one, her share is a half. For parents, a sixth share of the
inheritance to each, if the deceased left children; if no children, and the parents are the
heirs, the mother has a third;)
and the sisters 2/3. (If there are two sisters, they shall have two-thirds of the inheritance
(between them)
When we add up these Iractions they too are more than the total.
WiIe1/4 ÷ 3/12
Mother 1/3 ÷ 4/12
Sisters 2/3 ÷ 8/12
Total ÷ 15/12
Rahmanhadiq ;
Sura An Nisa’a verse 12 describes the distribution of the inheritance of "a
husband or wife who died ".
What about the husband / wife who stayed?
** For her husband
-If his wife had no children; Section husband = ½
-If his wife had a child; Section husband = ¼
** For Husband who died
-If the husband had no children; Section wife = ¼ of the property
-If the husband had a child; Part of wife = 1 / 8 of the property
In this case the parent is considered absent or dead.

This verse also explains about someone who died but had no wife and no
longer her parents, what parts of his half brothers ? ;
-If his brother 1 male + 1 female; Part sister = 1 / 6 of property
-If his brother more than 2 persons; Part sister = 1 / 3 of property
So the priority order of the division of the estate according to the Qur'an is;

"Child> Spouse> parents> brother"
Furthermore, the sound of verse 4:176 is
Q. 4:176
“If it is a man that dies, leaving a sister but no child, she shall have half the
inheritance: If (such a deceased was) a woman, who left no child, Her brother takes her
inheritance: If there are two sisters, they shall have two-thirds of the inheritance
(between them): if there are brothers and sisters, (they share), the male having twice
the share of the female. Thus doth Allah make clear to you (His law), lest ye err. And
Allah hath knowledge of all things.”
Verse oI q 4:176 above should be corrected again that is;.........
They ask thee Ior a legal decision. Say: Allah directs (thus) about those who leave no
descendants or ascendants as heirs. II it is a man that dies. leaving a sister but no child.
she shall have halI the inheritance: II (such a deceased was) a woman. who leIt no
child. Her brother takes her inheritance: II there are two sisters. they shall have two-
thirds oI the inheritance (between them): iI there are brothers and sisters. (they share).
the male having twice the share oI the Iemale. Thus doth Allah make clear to you (His
law). lest ye err. And Allah hath knowledge oI all things.
Paragraph letter An Nisaa 'verse 176 describes about someone who dies, no
children, no wife and no parents.
What about all his brothers are still alive?
-If theirs were female and the male
They are part of the property = ½
Where, if the property is not shared then the male relatives who inherit.
But if about to split, then the part of males 2 times of females.
if the number of his female relatives over 2 people , their part are = 2 / 3 of
Of course after it issued bills and debts
Verse An Nisaa '11-12 and 176 reinforce each other and add each other.
Ye Ali Sina deceitful, the wish that the division of property according to his
favorite course, without wanting to understand the distribution method that has
been established by each verse. KSW this cheating taking the verses that
benefit themselves only. This is because she has no conscience, he did not
have a sense of wisdom. Ali Sina is like to take all these verses together
without any sort it out properly in accordance with a predetermined method and
he also removes all the wise values based on the priority scale. That the result
of apportionment was chaotic dan disorder .
Imagine if Ali Sina is to serve as judges, how can he do justice?
For that right, we will discuss the following explanation of KSW;
- If the KSW is to take the mother (parents) as much as 1 / 3 according to verse
4:11, then automatically wife who died or have been divorced do not get it all
right. Because this verse is used only to heirs who do not have a wife, or
widower. Especially against his brothers, of course not be get a part by using
this verse.
- If he uses the wife as much as ¼ according to verse 4:12, then automatically
the parents will not get this part, because this verse does not give any part of
parents who have died. This verse can also be used with a wise and fair
consideration, because this verse also applies to the beneficiary who does not
have a wife, deceased parents, that you are getting part- his brothers.
- Then Ali Sina divided sections for the two sisters as much as 2 / 3 by using a
verse (4;176). While this verse can only be used if "the beneficiary does not
have a wife, do not have parents anymore, nor have children", so that you
are getting part-brothers.
Then KSW dividing force by way of inheritance by his favorite way ruffled with
this verse without regard for justice and proper manner. Of course, the division
of property becomes unfair and uneven, so that there are heirs who do not get
the part at all.
Seen once greed Ali Sina in dividing his estate. Here's how greedy man share
the inheritance to his followers. He had depraved the verses of the Holy Qur'an
with as good as it desires without understanding at all with what is meant by the
So evident that Ali Sina does not have any mind at all, His brain is completely
empty as the brain shrimp, even already replaced with his dirt, so that he could
not count and do not understand the problems.
But the basis of KSW, he still feels proud and arrogant and instill a sense of
inciting hatred and pit the whole of the religious peoples.

Inconsistency in the Bible and the Quran
(Dr. Naik) To make it easier for Dr. William Campbell, to answer to the points I have raised, I
will just mention it in brief -The points that I mentioned. The first point was that -‘The creation of
the Earth and the Heaven - the universe was in six, 24-hour days. Light was then before the
source of light –
Point No. 2. Three - Day came into existence before creation of Earth.
Point No. 4 - Earth came into existence before Sun.
Point No. 5 - Vegetation came into existence, before sunlight
Point No. 6 - Light of the Moon is its own light.
Point No. 7 - The earth - Will it perish or will it abide forever?
Point No. 8 - The earth has got pillars.
Point No. 9 - The heavens have got pillars.
Point No. 10 - God said… ‘You can have all plants and all vegetation, including the poisonous
Point No. 11 - The scientific test the falsification test, of Mark , Ch. No. 16, Verse No. 17 and 18.
Point No. 12 - A woman remains unclean for double the period, if she gives birth to a daughter,
as compared to a son.
Point No. 13 - Using blood to disinfect the house, against plague of leprosy.
Point No. 14 – How do you find out the bitter water test for adultery?
Point No. 15 - Eighteen different contradictions in less than 60 Verses of Ezra, Ch. 2, and
Nehemiah , Ch. 7. I did not count them as 18 different - I counted them only as one.
Point No. 16 - The total is different is both the chapters.
Point No. 17 - Are there 200 singing men and women, or are there 245 singing men and women?
Point No. 18 - Was Jehoiachin 18 years old, or was he 8 years old when he began to reign?
Point No. 19 - Did he reign for 3 months, or 3 months 10 days.
Point No. 20 - Did Solomon have 3000 baths, or 2000 baths?
Point No. 21 - Is that Basha, how could he invade Judah , 10 years after his death?
Point No. 22 is - Almighty God - He said, I put up a rainbow in the sky, as a promise to the
human kind, never to submerge the world again by water.
I have listed only 22, out of the hundreds available unscientific points in the Bible… scientific
errors - And I request Dr. William Campbell to answer them. And irrespective whether he uses
the ‘concordance approach’ or the ‘conflict approach’… as long as he is logical, he will never be
able to prove scientifically, all these 22 aspects I have told him. We agree in Jesus Christ (peace
be upon him) - to him was revealed the Injeel. This is not the Injeel - It may contain part of God
- But the other unscientific portion is not the word of God.
I would like to end my talk by giving the quotation of the Glorious Qur’an, from Surah Baqarah,
Ch. No. 2, Verse 79 …. (Arabic)…. ‘Woe to those who write the book with their own hands, and
then say this is from Allah, to traffic with it for a miserable price. Woe to those for what they
write. Woe to those for what they earn.’ Wa Aakim Dawana Anil Hamdulillahi Rabbil Aalameen.
(Ali Sina) Dr. Naik says that there are errors in the Bible. Sure there are. But he himself
gives the right answer. (Rahmanhadiq; apparently KSW provides true value to his Master
DR.Naik. certainly the instigator has a hidden intent. What his purpose of the cunning devil
give a compliment ?) The Bible does not claim to be the verbatim word of God. It is written by
tens of authors during the course of 1500 years. So it is expected that such a book contain
errors and contradictions. These contradictions, however, are in the details. The essence of
the message of the Bible has remained the same from Genesis to Apocalypses. This is quite
a feat. Many cathedrals in Europe have taken centuries to build. Multitudes of generations
have worked on them. But there is grace, beauty and wholeness to these buildings. This
shows that all its builders have followed a master plan. This could be said about the Bible.
(Rahmanhadiq; turned out to see the truth of Christianity KSW of the results to build a
magnificent civilization with buildings. To the extent that the instigator is able to see the truth
of the religions) Here we have one single book written by numerous authors during a span of
fifteen centuries and despite that its message has remained constant. On the other hand, the
Quran is written by one person and yet the Medinan Suras are diametrically different from the
Meccan ones conveying an entirely different message. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW apparently
wanted to instill a sense of pride to the people of Christian and then lowered the Islamic
peoples. The goal is clear to pit Christians and Muslims).
Here is a comparison between the Meccan verses and the Medinan ones. They do not seem
to belong to the same book at all. (Rahmanhadiq; The verses in the book of the Qur'an is an
integral and inseparable from one another. There is no verse Mecca and Medina, there is no verse,
which is seen by Muslims is not the place down the verse, but it is the truth value of verse)

2:256 : There is no compulsion in religion
9:123: Oh ye who believe! Murder those oI the disbelievers and let them Iind harshness in you.
(Rahmanhadiq; Apparently KSW cutting a partly the verse of 2:256 is to achieve its goals.
Though the verse has a much different purpose than what is intended to the instigator. Verse
2:256 above is ; ” Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error:
whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah hath grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold, that
never breaks. And Allah heareth and knoweth all things (QS 2:256)”. Verse 2:256 is giving
hints that the right religion (doctrine) is will have very different goals with the wrong religion
(doctrine). People who have the true teachings of their Lord, he will obtain good results, and
vice versa. So the true teachings do not require coercion to come into the hearts and minds.
This principle applies universally in all the philosophy of human life in this world. If all humans
live in peace with their religion, without disrupting the lives of other religions (eg, no slander,
inciting, hinder worship), then apply the principle of balance that is no compulsion in religion.
But when Muhammad came to convey the teachings of truth to his family and companions,
the Quraish government prevented and intend to kill Muhammad and his followers.
As for the verse 9:123 does not stand alone. The Verse is related to many previous
paragraph contained in the letter of At-Tauba, starting from verse 38 to verse number 123.
The letter of At Tauba verse 129, amounting to more general and explain in more detail
about the culture and characteristics of the Quraish infidels and hypocrites who always
wanted to destroy Muhammad and his followers at the time. Surah At Tauba is a lot to give
instructions and directions on how to behave in the face of difficult times in battle. So come
down verse 9: 123 which requires that the people of Muhammad to take the fight and be
tough to unbelievers (who oppose, defamatory, ridiculing, teasing) they are located around
the lives of Muhammad at the time.
73:10 ; Be patient with what they say. and part Irom them courteously.
8:12 ; I will instill terror into the hearts oI the unbelievers: smite ye above their necks and smite all
their Iinger-tips oII.
Rahmanhadiq; Back the instigator Ali Sina take 2 pieces of verse which he said contradicted
each other. The instigator is taking verses that have been cut into pieces to be engineered so
that the opposition goals. Though the two verses are connected to form a unity to fight those
who oppose the truth of God, such as Ali Sina.
Verse 73:10 is still relating to the next paragraph, which reads ; “And have patience with what
they say, and leave them with noble (dignity)(qs 73:10)”. Context of this verse is not talking
about problems or forbid armed conflicts, but about God's decision against Islamic people
hypocrites who do not want to perform prayer, worship and charity issued by the reason
which made up.
Likewise with the verse 8:12-13 which is still in touch with the next verse which reads ;
“Remember thy Lord inspired the angels (with the message): "I am with you: give firmness to
the Believers: I will instil terror into the hearts of the Unbelievers: smite ye above their necks
and smite all their finger-tips off them 13. This because they contended against Allah and His
Messenger: If any contend against Allah and His Messenger, Allah is strict in
punishment.(QS 8:12)”. Context of the paragraph above explains the reason for the
revelation of these verses to Muhammad, which is to fight against the wicked (disbelievers)
who wanted to eliminate Muhammad and his followers. So these two verses do not have any
contradictions relationship. but the KSW would like to take advantage to pit those verses.

109:6 : To you be your religion. and to me my religion.
3:85 : Whoso desires another religion than Islam. it shall not be accepted oI him; in the next world he
shall be among the losers."

(Rahmanhadiq; Context 109:6 paragraph describes the attitude of Muhammad in answering
questions the Jewish and Christian clergy who wanted to invite Muhammad into their religion.
While the verse 3:85 explains that God gave freedom to man to seek the truth of a religion,
the end will be in the teachings of Islam. But after the people that get to the truth (Islam), then
he came out of that truth, then God has decided justly punished him. This is because the
person is not seeking truth but look for an excuse to damage the Islamic religion, such as Ali

20:103 ; ThereIore be patient with what they say. and celebrate (constantly) the praises oI thy Lord.
2:191 ; kill them wherever you Iind them. and drive them out Irom wherever they drove you out.

(Rahmanhadiq; 20:130 paragraph above is still closely related to some previous paragraph.
In the previous paragraph tells causal experienced by the opponents of truth proclaimed by
the Prophet to his people himself, but the prophet is no longer able to change the crime that
has exceeded the limit of his people. Then the prophet prayed to god for the punishment
inflicted on his people. God granted the prayer of the prophets, and destroy them, before
Muhammad. In 20:130 verse above, God gives direction to Muhammad in order to remain
patient until at some point that Muhammad and his people already have enough strength to
face the army of infidels. This means that Muhammad should not despair to struggle to
convey the message of truth from god, because in one day God will show and give strength
to Muhammad and his followers in the face of the power of God's enemies.

While the verse 2:191 is still associated with a previous paragraph, which reads; “Fight in the
cause of Allah those who fight you, but do not transgress limits; for Allah loveth not
transgressors 190. And slay them wherever ye catch them, and turn them out from where
they have Turned you out; for tumult and oppression are worse than slaughter; but fight them
not at the Sacred Mosque, unless they (first) fight you there; but if they fight you, slay them.
Such is the reward of those who suppress faith (qs 2:190-191)”. Context of the verse above
describes the reasons why Muhammad and his followers should provide resistance against
the enemies of God. This clause also provides instructions that God has to prove the truth of
verse 20:130 above so that Muhammad was given the strength to face the enemy of God.
So there is no conflict with the second verses above, but the KSW are looking for an
opportunity to create destruction on the verses of the Quran. Daily food menu of KSW is
demagoguery, chicanery, slander to undermine the values of truth of a religion.
2:83 ; Speak good to men...
9:5 ; Slay the idolaters wherever you Iind them
(Rahmanhadiq; KSW come back to performs trickery and cunning. He cut a verse at 2:83
with a goal to create a contradiction with verse 9:5. Though both the verse does not mean
that. KSW is cheating, really evil nature of this demon.
Verse 2:83 reads; “And remember We took a covenant from the Children of Israel (to this
effect): Worship none but Allah; treat with kindness your parents and kindred, and orphans
and those in need; speak fair to the people; be steadfast in prayer; and practise regular
charity. Then did ye turn back, except a few among you, and ye backslide (even now)(QS
2:63)”. The context of the verse tells of the advice of God delivered by the prophets of the
Jews to his people that they may worship God, do good and say to all mankind. But Ali Sina
who fraudulently cut sentence in that verse, so have a much different meaning than the
original. That means the devil to deceive mankind, as exhibited by Ali Sina this.
Verse 9:5 is displayed by Ali Sina is just a piece of sentences that have been beheaded by
his evil purpose to incite and damage the content of the Qur'an and Islam. This proves that
Ali Sina is a wolf who is cheating in his evil mission. whereas verse 9:5 is closely related to
some previous paragraph paragraph reads ; “And an announcement from Allah and His
Messenger, to the people (assembled) on the day of the Great Pilgrimage,- that Allah and
His Messenger dissolve (treaty) obligations with the Pagans. If then, ye repent, it were best
for you; but if ye turn away, know ye that ye cannot frustrate Allah. And proclaim a grievous
penalty to those who reject Faith 3. (But the treaties are) not dissolved with those Pagans
with whom ye have entered into alliance and who have not subsequently failed you in aught,
nor aided any one against you. So fulfil your engagements with them to the end of their term:
for Allah loveth the righteous 4. But when the forbidden months are past, then fight and slay
the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them
in every stratagem (of war); but if they repent, and establish regular prayers and practise
regular charity, then open the way for them: for Allah is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful (QS 9:3-
The context of this verse describes the announcement of Mohammed to the Quraish who
had defeated in battle in taking the city of Mecca. After gaining victory, Muhammad made a
new provision in the government and canceled all treaty ever made with the Quraish before.
Furthermore, Muhammad gave a time limit for 4 months to the Quraish to implement the new
provisions. For those who do not accept the new provisions, should leave the city of Mecca,
while the fight may be fought and even kosher killed, but for those who surrendered and
asked for protection should be freed to be moved somewhere else that is safe for them. That
rule in a war that has been established by God to Muhammad in order to not be arbitrarily
accepted. This principle also applies anywhere in the world, where every ending armed
conflicts, the party that wins will create a new provision to make some new rules. Even after
World War II ended in 1945 AD, the allied countries that win also gives provisions and
penalties for the losers like the Japanese, German or Italian. So the principle of the verses of
Al Qu'an above is a procedure to adjust the government after armed conflicts in which the
winner must refrain from arbitrary action on the losing side.

10:99 ; II it had been thy Lord's Will. they would all have believed. all who are on earth! Wilt thou
then compel mankind against their will to believe!
2:193 ; Fight them on until there is no more fithah (opposition) and religion becomes that oI Allah.
(Rahmanhadiq; context of verse 10:99 is about the love of God to the human race is given
the right to think and decide what religion is good for him. God only requires sincerity and
submission to believe in him, otherwise Allah does not accept one's faith because of forced
or pretend or expect something self-interest alone. Not that people were given absolute
freedom to do whatever they can, as humans continue to be done by a wolf named Ali Sina
this. Ali Sina want to change the verse into his imagination to spread incitement, slander and
lies to damage the value of kindness in the human soul.
While the verse 2:193 is still connected to 3 previous paragraph, which reads; “Fight in the
cause of Allah those who fight you, but do not transgress limits; for Allah loveth not
transgressors 190. And slay them wherever ye catch them, and turn them out from where
they have Turned you out; for tumult and oppression are worse than slaughter; but fight them
not at the Sacred Mosque, unless they (first) fight you there; but if they fight you, slay them.
Such is the reward of those who suppress faith 191. But if they cease, Allah is Oft-forgiving,
Most Merciful 192. And fight them on until there is no more Tumult or oppression, and there
prevail justice and faith in Allah; but if they cease, Let there be no hostility except to those
who practise oppression (QS 2:190-193)”.
The verses that describe the attitude of the Gentiles like Ali Sina who always do the slander
and cheat to mankind. Ali Sina is always attacked the religious teachings of Islam by way of
cunning, vicious lies and slander. Ali Sina is an example of that verse for a crime he always
did every time the Muslims without any logical reason and correct.
50:45 ; We well know what the inIidels say: but you are not to compel them.
9:14 ; Fight them. and Allah will punish them by your hands. cover them with shame. help you (to
victory) over them. heal the breasts oI Believers.
(Rahmanhadiq; Again demon of Ali Sina featuring verse 50:45 which was cut partially, not
completely. This verse explains that Muhammad only convey of verse Al-Qur’an explanation
to mankind, rather than forcing must obey. While those who oppose the truth of the verse,
the Hereafter will get a penalty, due to ignorance and crime, and he did during the du globe.
As for verse 50:45 reads ; “We know best what they say; and thou art not one to overawe
them by force. So admonish with the Qur'an such as fear My Warning!(QS 50:45)”.
While the verse 9:14 is still in touch with 3 verses before and can not be separated. But Ali
Sina is very dirty, cut out these verses and take the necessary verses its course. The wolf
would cheat intentionally banging verse 50:45 with verse 9:14, so it looks self-contradiction.
Though the two verses that have different purposes according to conditions prevailing at the
time. The whole verse is; “In a Believer they respect not the ties either of kinship or of
covenant! It is they who have transgressed all bounds 10. But (even so), if they repent,
establish regular prayers, and practise regular charity,- they are your brethren in Faith: (thus)
do We explain the Signs in detail, for those who understand 11. But if they violate their oaths
after their covenant, and taunt you for your Faith,- fight ye the chiefs of Unfaith: for their oaths
are nothing to them: that thus they may be restrained 12. Will ye not fight people who
violated their oaths, plotted to expel the Messenger, and took the aggressive by being the
first (to assault) you? Do ye fear them? Nay, it is Allah Whom ye should more justly fear, if ye
believe 13! Fight them, and Allah will punish them by your hands, cover them with shame,
help you (to victory) over them, heal the breasts of Believers 14, And still the indignation of
their hearts. For Allah will turn (in mercy) to whom He will; and Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise.
(QS 9:10-15).
The context of verses 9:10-15 describes the properties of perfidy and hypocrisy of the
leaders of Quraysh and the Jews. They always deny that the agreement has been agreed
and will try to cheat with the mock-hoax, incite and defame. so come down those verses, for
cheating people of Muhammad against them, especially its leaders who have done evil and
underhanded politics.
Ali Sina is only able to commit fraud to deceive his followers by way of delivering lies,
cunning and slander are very painful for the feelings of Muslims.
45.14 : Tell those who believe. to Iorgive those who do not look Iorward to the Days oI Allah:
8:60 : Against them make ready your strength to the utmost oI your power. including steeds oI war. to
strike terror into (the hearts oI) the enemies. oI Allah and your enemies.
Rahmanhadiuq; verse 45:14 also has a good philosophy for human life. This verse is
addressed to Muhammad to advise his followers to give up, do not hold grudges and let the
stupid people doing evil. am left surrender to god, because then the god who will give
punishment to the man. bad guys are referred to in this paragraph is Ali Sina who could no
longer aware of and can not stop cheating and spread hatred.
Verse 8:60 is still associated with a 5 verses and 2 verses before and after that can not be
separated from each other. Entire paragraph is an integral and inseparable. As for the verse
5 sub-paragraph is telling about the circumstances that occurred just before the war. Then
finish to the verse 8:60 which intends to provide spirit for Muslims to immediately make the
line to confront the criminals who are always doing dishonest, violating the agreement and
continue doing mischief. Actual provisions of this subsection is not contrary to the law
principle applicable national law on democracy principles. A sovereign democratic state,
would have to have legal tools to ward off evil deed will be done by a group of people or
someone who will do mischief. The law would be a warning for criminals. While the verses
8:61-62 which describes the treatment can be given to these criminals, whether imprisoned,
punished, made aware of or returned after the conscious. Overall the verses above show a
causal relationship then ends with the completion of a balanced and in harmony to achieve
goodness and peace in a sovereign government. But instead, Ali Sina utilize this verse 8:60
to spread his provocation and spread the news to the hordes of vicious slander him. KSW
certainly do not want to understand the statement that verses is true, because his soul was
very dirty, evil nature has exceeded the limits, has the chronic psichopath disease, so that he
will continue to spread hatred without any reason to anyone he encountered. This proves that
the KSW is not a man who can be invited to think well, he descended from the devil.
The thinking majority of Christians and Jews say that the authors of the Bible were humans
who were inspired by God. This is clear from the Bible itself. You can see the names of the
authors on the top of their books. In nowhere in the Bible, both in the Old or the New
Testament, you are led to believe that it is God that is speaking. It is always a human, giving
the message of God in his own words. God is referred to in third person. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali
Sina seems to speak on behalf of Jewish and Christian clergy. is it true that the conclusion of
this KSW? Whether it is true that most church leaders said such a conclusion by this KSW?
Is not Ali Sina a true atheist? How an atheist talk on behalf religious teachings ? Then he
says that " God is referred to in third person ", is not this sentence show that Ali Sina does
not understand what he wrote?. so that no sane person is speaking.)
If I listen to a talk or see an event, I may go and tell my friends what I have learned. I can
give the spirit, the essence of the message in my own words. But since I am using my own
words and my own expressions it is very possible that I make a few mistakes. Even though
the message is great, I am a human and humans err. My listeners know that. They listen to
my words and take it with a grain of salt. At the same time that they listen to me and become
inspired by what I tell them, they use their own intelligence too. They do not switch off their
brains putting their entire trust on me. They are always on the guard to see whether what I
say makes sense or maybe it is my own interpretation and misunderstanding. However the
main thing is that my errors and my lapses of memory do not invalidate the message that I
am delivering. I am an honest human being, but fallible nonetheless. Because of that people
can tolerate my errors and use their own intelligence to grasp the essence of the message. I
do not become automatically a liar if I err. That is why even if there are hundreds of errors in
the Bible; the more astute Christians and Jews do not get vexed. They look at the message,
not at the messenger or the words in which the message is delivered. They look at the
content, not at the container. The essence of Christianity is good. It is a message of love and
forgiveness. Despite hundreds of errors that exist in the Bible, this message is supreme and
its value cannot be diminished.
(Rahmanhadiq; KSW believe that the Bible writers all get messages from God. Even though
the authors of the book of the Bible that had made a mistake. But all of that message is the
message of truth that comes from God. KSW is considered that there are many mistakes in
the Bible, but teaching Bible remains the teaching of the truth because there is only a
teaching of love in it. But strangely enough do not believe that KSW is a Muammad also
received the Revelation from the Lord. Even if there is only one mistake in the book of the
Qur'an, the KSW reject all book of the Qur'an. KSW is showing a sense of resentment only,
he has no sense of justice, the logic is closed by envy. The words that he wrote in the
paragraph above just showed a teaser words to pit Muslims and Christians .)
If one message is heard by thirty people, each will relay it differently. It is impossible that all
of them tell you the same story in exact same words. The details may vary but as long as you
see there is consistency all of them are telling the truth. This is how you should interpret the
contradictions in the Bible.
The Quran is a different story. The Quran claims that it is the verbatim word of God. Here lies
the difference. If it is the verbatim word of God, it cannot have one single error. If it has a
single error, it can’t be the word of God, and if it is not the word of God it is a lie.
(Rahmanhadiq; really very simple once thought was Ali Sina, Al-Quran verses that contains
just one mistake, he refuses all book details al-qur'an. Otherwise if the book of the Bible
which he said contains a lot of things that are not true because fault of the writers, then he
side with the book of the Bible. Explanation of Ali Sina shows that he does not have any
principles in his life. Ali Sina as a commentator or a soccer game spectators. He blamed the
players who are not able to score a goal when kicking the ball in front of goal or blame the
coach who could not score. Though Ali Sina only talk, and do not have any skill in football
game. he wanted to teach soccer players and coaches, but he himself did not have any
ability in that sport. Ali Sina is a king of Gossip. Ali Sina is the king of incitement who ever
lived in this world).
That is why I find the effort of Muslims to brush off the criticism made against the Quran by
bashing the Bible, pathetic. (Rahmanhadiq; back these demons cast his incitement by
accusing people of Islam spread the slander on the teachings of Christian religious. It's really
the king instigator). The Quran is the only book believed by its followers to be the exact word
of God. No other book of any other religion makes this claim. That is why the Quran is in
such a vulnerable position. (Rahmanhadiq; KSW really do not like to see Muslims as
fanatical about their book. On the contrary many verses in the Al Qur’an which states that the
Navy Gospels, the Torah and the Psalms, a longtime comes from God who submitted to the
prophets of the Jewish or Christian people. So natural that if during the course of time would
be a mistake by the writers of the Bible book. Al Qur'an lowered to improve their mistake,
instead of deleting it altogether. Only people who has a conscience, the ability to think and
have a broad science can choose the correct verses among the three holy books are.
Conversely Ali Sina, with a lack of ability to throw the accusation that far away for the
purpose and strategy of fighting sheep.). We can find scientific errors and absurdities in all
religious books but still hold to the good and the beautiful that exist in these books and
overlook the bad part. This we can't do with the Quran. All we need to show that the Quran is
false in its entirety is one single error. One who sits on the taller branch, falls
harder. (Rahamanhadiq; already shown and discussed by rahmanhadiq about Ali Sina
above all charges, was presented by KSW is simply lies and slander only, it is demagoguery
and race-sheep between Muslims and Christians. Ali Sina is a big liar that ever lived on this

Moon Light
In the part 2 of his talk, Dr. Naik said:
(Dr. Naik) And he said that if it means a reflection of light and he quoted Sura Nur 24:35 that
Allahu nooru alssamawati waal-ardi (Allah is the light of the heaven and the earth). Read the
complete verse. And analyze what it says. It doesn’t say Allah is the light, ‘Nur’; it says Allah is
the light of heaven and the earth. It is similar to light, a niche and within the niche there is the
lamp. The lamp is what is there. So Allah (swt) has got light of his own and even reflects his
light. Like you see halogen lamp – like which are here. The lamp inside is like a siraj but the
reflector is like moon. It’s reflecting light. The lamp, the tube, is having the light of its own, but
the reflector of the halogen lamp is reflecting light. So both two in one! So Allah (swt)
Alhamdulillah, beside having light of its own, as the Quranic verses, in the niche there is a
lamp. And that lamp, light of Allah (swt) is its own light. Allah reflects his own light.
(Ali Sina) Earlier Dr. Naik ridiculed Genesis 1:16 for saying ‘God created two lights the
greater light, the Sun to rule the day, and the lesser light the Moon, to rule the night.' The
same error also exists in the Quran.
010.005 It is He Who made the sun to be a shining glory and the Moon to be a light
(Rahmanhadiq; explanation of this verse has been described previously. The sun which
gives light expressed by the word " ً ءَ ِ dhia'an" whereas for a luminous moon ray was
written by the term " اً رُ , Nurran". Al qur'an convey different terms for the two incident
beams. Of course there anything mystery or clue that to be learned, why al qur'an provide
distinct terms of both celestial body that shines it. Al-Qur'an is not a science book but a book
signing. Of course this keyword differences indicate that the difference between the Moon
with the sun rays. This mystery is just missed in the 10th century and it is believed that the
moon does not produce but the reflection of light rays from the sun. Al qur'an is a book of
instructions that must be observed with great wisdom . a lot of scientific evidence that is
embedded and hidden in the verses al quran which must be observed with a wise and
prudent. Of course, Ali Sina is not able to see it with honesty logic. He's still not understand
when it's written as luminous source of ray or reflection ray on that verse. Ali Sina will not
use logic to think clearly and fairly, he was only able to read what is written only. )

025.061 Blessed is He Who made constellations in the skies. and placed therein a Lamp and a Moon
giving light;
(Rahmanhadiq; in this paragraph which says the moon and the sun gives light equally called
by the term ", اً ِ ُ , muniraan". means is luminous, giving light, both produce light. The
provisions of this verse is universal on the properties of light that can produce both rays of
light sources or from light reflections.
071.016 'And made the Moon a light in their midst. and made the sun as a (Glorious) Lamp?
(Rahmanhadiq; This paragraph gives a more detailed explanation and more specific for the
properties of a ray. This verse explains that the Sun is the source of ray or lamp, or as a oil
lamp. Al-qur'an provide sunlight term with the word " ً اَ ِ , Sirajaan" , which means fire,
lamp or a light source. Whereas for the light of the moon which is seen from the man on this
earth, the Qur'an calls it with term of the word " اً رُ , Nurran", which means to a shine,
giving a light. For people who think, will arise a question; Why moonlight called " اً رُ “,
while the sun is called the “ ً اَ ِ ‘ ,Sirajan” this declaration had explained by AL-qur’an
at fifteen century a go, whereas phenomenon of ray reflection was found at 10 century,
proved that the moon does not produced rays but are light reflection of rays from the sun. It
is evident that al-Qur 'an not to tell lies, al-qur'an precede scientific discovery. But Ali Sina
who came from ancient times to force the logic to say stupid and make a fool of his
Dr. Naik insists that the Quran makes it clear that the light of the Moon is borrowed light and
to prove that, he claims 'nur' means reflection. This is not a fallacy but a blatant lie. Let us
read the complete verse as Dr. Naik suggests. (rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina as an intelligent
person, but actually he is more stupid than a donkey. He did not understand and do not want
to think, then said that his teacher “Naik DR” is a lie. But actually the case he was the one
who tell lies. That's a state of being mentally ill or a psychopath who had chronic like Ali
[24.35] Allah is the Light oI the heavens and the earth. “ The Metaphor “ oI His Light is as iI there
were a Niche and within it a Lamp: the Lamp enclosed in Glass: the glass as it were a brilliant star:
Lit Irom a blessed Tree. an Olive. neither oI the east nor oI the west. whose oil is well-nigh luminous.
though Iire scarce touched it: Light upon Light! Allah doth guide whom He will to His Light: Allah
doth set Iorth Metaphors Ior men: and Allah doth know all things (Sura. AN NUUR 24: 35)”.
Apa arti perumpamaan ini? Saya berkonsultasi dg Ibn Khathir utk penjelasannya (anda
boleh meliwatinya. Saya tulis intisarinya dibawah ini). theholybook.org/en/a.47288

The Parable of the Light of Allah
`Ali bin Abi Talhah reported that Ibn `Abbas said:
[ُ ا ُ رُ ِ تَ ـَ ا ِ ضْر اَ و]
(Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth.) means, the Guide of the inhabitants of
the heavens and the earth. Ibn Jurayj said: "Mujahid and Ibn `Abbas said concerning
the Ayah:
[ُ ا ُ رُ ِ تَ ـَ ا ِ ضْر اَ و]
(Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth.) He is controlling their affairs and their
stars and sun and moon.'' As-Suddi said concerning the Ayah:
[ُ ا ُ رُ ِ تَ ـَ ا ِ ضْر اَ و]
(Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth.) by His Light the heavens and earth
are illuminated. In the Two Sahihs, it is recorded that Ibn `Abbas, may Allah be pleased
with him, said: "When the Messenger of Allah got up to pray at night, he would say:
« ُ ا َ َ ،ُ ْ َ ْ ا َ ْ َ أ ُ َ ِ تاَ َ ا ِ ضْرَ ْ اَ و َْ َ و ، ِ ِ َ َ َ و ُ ْ َ ْ ا َ ْ َ أ ُ رُ ِ تاَ َ ا ِ ضْرَ ْ اَ و َْ َ و ِ ِ »
(O Allah, to You be praise, You are the Sustainer of heaven and earth and whoever is in
them. To You be praise, You are the Light of the heavens and the earth and whoever is
in them. ) It was narrated that Ibn Mas`ud said, "There is no night or day with your
Lord; the Light of the Throne comes from the Light of His Face.''
[ُ َ َ ِ ِ رُ ]
(The parable of His Light) There are two views concerning the meaning of the pronoun
(His). The first is that it refers to Allah, may He be glorified and exalted, meaning that
the parable of His guidance in the heart of the believer is
[ٍ ةَ ْ ِ َ آ]
(as a niche) This was the view of Ibn `Abbas. The second view is that the pronoun
refers to the believer, which is indicated by the context of the words and implies that the
parable of the light in the heart of the believer is as a niche. So the heart of the believer
and what he is naturally inclined to of guidance and what he learns of the Qur'an which
is in accordance with his natural inclinations are, as Allah says:
[َ َ َ أ َ نَ آ َ َ ٍ َ َ ِ ر ُ ُ ْ َ َ و ٌِ هَ ُ ْ ]
(Can they who rely on a clear proof from their Lord, and whom a witness from Him
recites it (can they be equal with the disbelievers)) [11:17]. The heart of the believer in
its purity and clarity is likened to a lamp in transparent and jewel-like glass, and the
Qur'an and Shari`ah by which it is guided are likened to good, pure, shining oil in which
there is no impurity or deviation.
[ٍ ةَ ْ ِ َ آ]
(as (if there were) a niche) Ibn `Abbas, Mujahid, Muhammad bin Ka`b and others said,
"This refers to the position of the wick in the lamp.'' This is well-known, and hence Allah
then says:
[َ ِ ٌحَ ْ ِ ]
(and within it a lamp.) This is the flame that burns brightly. Or it was said that the
niche is a niche in the house. This is the parable given by Allah of obedience towards
Him. Allah calls obedience to Him as light, then He calls it by other numerous names
as well. Ubayy bin Ka`b said, "The lamp is the light, and this refers to the Qur'an
and the faith that is in his heart.'' As-Suddi said, "It is the lamp.''
[ُ حَ ْ ِ ْ ا ِ ٍ َ َ ُ ز]
(the lamp is in a glass,) means, this light is shining in a clear glass. Ubayy bin Ka`b
and others said, "This is the likeness of the heart of the believer.''
[ُ َ َ ا َ َ َ آ ٌَ آَْ آ ى رُ د]
(the glass as it were a star Durriyyun,) Some authorities recite the word Durriyyun with
a Dammah on the Dal and without a Hamzah, which means pearls, i.e., as if it were a
star made of pearls (Durr). Others recite it as Dirri'un or Durri'un, with a Kasrah on the
Dal, or Dammah on the Dal, and with a Hamzah at the end, which means reflection
(Dir'), because if something is shone on the star it becomes brighter than at any other
time. The Arabs call the stars they do not know Darari. Ubayy bin Ka`b said: a shining
star. Qatadah said: "Huge, bright and clear.''
[ُ َ ُ ِ ٍ ةَ َ َ ٍ َ آَ ـَ ]
(lit from a blessed tree,) means, it is derived from olive oil, from a blessed tree.
[ٍ َ ُ ْ َ ز]
(an olive,) This refers to the blessed tree mentioned previously.
[ َْ ٍ ِ َ َ و ٍ ِ َْ ]
(neither of the east nor of the west,) means, it is not in the eastern part of the land so
that it does not get any sun in the first part of the day, nor is it in the western part of
the land so that it is shaded from the sun before sunset, but it is in a central position
where it gets sun from the beginning of the day until the end, so its oil is good and pure
and shining. Ibn Abi Hatim recorded that Ibn `Abbas commented on:
[ٍ َ ُ ْ َ ز ٍ ِ َْ َ َ و ٍ ِ َْ ]
(an olive, neither of the east nor of the west,) "This is a tree in the desert which is not
shaded by any other tree or mountain or cave, nothing covers it, and this is best for its
oil.'' Mujahid commented on:
[ ٍ ِ َْ َ َ و ٍ ِ َْ ]
(neither of the east nor of the west, ) saying; "It is not in the east where it will get no
sun when the sun sets, nor is it in the west where it will get no sun when the sun rises,
but it is in a position where it will get sun both at sunrise and sunset.'' Sa`id bin Jubayr
[ٍ َ ُ ْ َ ز ٍ ِ َْ َ َ و ٍ ِ َْ ُ دَ َ َ ُ ْ َ ز ُ ءِ ُ ]
(an olive, neither of the east nor of the west, whose oil would almost glow forth (of
itself)) "This is the best kind of oil. When the sun rises it reaches the tree from the east
and when it sets it reaches it from the west, so the sun reaches it morning and evening,
so it is not counted as being in the east or in the west.''
[ُ دَ َ َ ُ ْ َ ز ُ ءِ ُ َْ َ و َْ ُ ْ َ ْ َ ٌرَ ]
(whose oil would almost glow forth (of itself), though no fire touched it.) `Abdur-
Rahman bin Zayd bin Aslam said (this means) because the oil itself is shining.
[ٌر َ َ ٍ رُ ]
(Light upon Light!) Al-`Awfi narrated from Ibn `Abbas that this meant the faith and
deeds of a person. As-Suddi said:
[ٌر َ َ ٍ رُ ]
(Light upon Light!) "Light of the fire and the light of the oil: when they are combined
they give light, and neither of them can give light without the other. Similarly the light
of the Qur'an and the light of faith give light when they are combined, and neither can
do so without the other.''
From this tafsir we learn some possible interpretations of the following words:
Light = guidance; obedience to Allah
Niche = heart of the believer
Lamp = heart of the believer; Qur'an and the faith that is in his heart
Olive tree = Not given in the tafsir
pure, shining oil = Quran and Sharia
light over light = faith and deeds of a person; Quran and the faith.
This by no means explains the parable. The parable remains incomprehensible. How did Dr.
Naik come to the conclusion that God is within a niche? What is this niche that houses
Dr. Naik says "Allah beside having light of his own ... [He] reflects his own light." How is
this possible? Assuming that God is within a niche, (which is a ludicrous concept) how can
He reflect His own light? How can any luminous object act also as its own reflector? When
Dr. Naik says Allah reflects his own light, he is dabbling in absurdity. Is the light coming to us
from the Sun direct light or is it a reflection? What is this niche that Dr. Naik is talking about
that houses Allah and reflects his light? This verse is gibberish.
Rahmanhadiq; this verse is certainly not to be understood by Ali Sina, because he did not
understand at all with the intention of the parables. Whereas in the verse 24:35 it is written
the word "parable or metaphor". But Ali Sina who think him very smart, explaining the
meaning of the verse with mathematical equations. Of course this can not be done. Not all
the verses al quran must be explained with scientific explanation, or with mathematical
equations. A lot of the verses of the Qur'an can only be understood with sincerity and
thinking clear. The Qur'an verse contains a lot of philosophy of life so that the necessary
wisdom to think. Words of “ light” in the verses al quran has meaning very broad and in-
depth. Meaning of the word "light" is as guidline, as a clue to where a good and safe, as the
direction to get happiness. Light said in Verse 24:35 is a parable. But Ali Sina discuss it with
his formula mathematical equations, so he becomes confused and dizzy own. But the verse
can also be understood scientifically, where the light of God is like a ray of reflection which
does not cause a sore of eye or glare. Ray of light was very bright and beautiful but not
blinding and painful sight. Not mean that God is the same with light reflections. Really mad
the devil viper Ali Sina. Whereas Dr Naik does not say that God is light, but Allah has the
bright of light, because light does not dazzle the eye is like the light reflections.
So the word "light" or "Nur" itself is a pretty broad word meaning, both in terms of parable,
metaphor and scientific terms. Its the same thing with the characteristics of light that has a
dual nature in the form of wave properties and particle properties. As a wave of "light" that
white light consists range of colors with different wavelengths. Start of visible light, UV rays,
Infra red rays to radio waves. While the "light" as the particle shows that the spectrum of
each wavelength has an energy level different also. So it is not wrong if the Qur'an says that
the word "light" has a very broad meaning and very deep.)

(Dr. Naik) Dr. William Campbell says that… ‘The Qur’an says that… ‘Qur’an is nur’… It is
reflecting light.’ Of course - The Qur’an is reflecting the light and the guidance of Allah
Subhanawataala. Regarding Prophet Mohammed Sallallahu alaihi wasallam being Siraj - Yes he
is. The Hadith of the beloved Prophet is giving guidance to us. So Muhammad Sallallahu alaihi
wassallam – he is also ‘nur’ he is also ‘Siraj’- Alhamdullillah. He has his own knowledge also -
Alhamdulillah. He has the guidance from Allah Subhanawataala-Alhamdulillah. So if you use this
word ‘Nur’ as reflected light, and Munir as reflected light, yet Alhamdulillah, you can
prove it scientifically that the light of the moon is not its own light, but it is the
reflected light.
(Ali Sina) Of course you can. Also if you translate the word "slay" in verse 2:191, "And slay
them wherever ye catch them" as "love" and change the meaning of other words used in the
Quran that incite Muslims to hate others and be violent, we won't have any problem with
Islam at all. By changing the meaning of the words, not only we can make the Quran look
peaceful but also make it look scientific. (Rahmanhadiq; In detail explanation above, has
been explained very clearly that a lot of information the Qur'an contains keywords that are in
accordance with scientific discovery. To understand a word that is inserted into a parable, it
is necessary clarity of heart and cleanliness of the soul to understand it. So is the equivalent
of a word should be interpreted with the understanding that worth it, not vice versa. That is a
word that antagonistic or antagonist may not necessarily be the same. Just as the word "kill"
can not be synonymous with "love" or the word "crime" can not be synonymous with the word
"good" as well as the word "sin" can not be synonymous with the word "reward". Of course
KSW will not be able to distinguish the meaning of the opposite words, because he has
blinded his eyes to understand Al-Quran verses, then generalize all the meanings of words
according to self-delusion. But Ali Sina did not want to understand at all because in his soul
there is only hatred, incitement and defamation cruel. Ali Sina never want to see his
reflection in the mirror, because he realized that his shadow is very creepy, like Monster. So
do not expect that he will realize with the deceitful.)
Sadly we can't translate the words contrary to their meaning. Nur is not borrowed light. It is
light. Munir also does not mean borrowed light. It means 'luminous'. Dr. Naik is simply playing
the Islamic game of deception, taqiyyah. What is impressive is that he does it with absolute
conviction and certainty. This must be how Muhammad convinced his followers. He lied to
them with such an authority that they believed. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina again spread
provocation by garble the facts. If he does not understand a question, then he's looking for
another way to create a new slander. The character Ali Sina is very similar to the properties
of cursed the devil. Anything that told to him, certainly he will reject it. Ali Sina always play
the words and make sport of news in the verses qur'an. Now he wants to pretend to teach
DR Naik by cunning.)
In response to Dr. Campbell who quoted 24:35 showing that even God has been called
Munir, Dr. Naik gave an amazingly absurd explanation with such a strength and authority
that his audience clapped. He said that God is like a lamp inside a niche, the niche reflects
the light of God. Now this sound utterly stupid but the way Dr. Naik presented it, sounded
very plausible. Derisively he sneered his response and made his audience believe "how can
anyone not see this obvious truth?" Yet what he said was plain nonsense. (rahmanhadiq;
once again Ali Sina convey his lies, out of nowhere he put the word of “Munir” that does not
exist at all in the verse 24:35 above. There was the word " ِ -ِ ر·ُ -ِ ' . Linu rihi", but he wrote it
into “Munir”. Ali Sina was not able to read the Qur'an. But he claimed to be descendants of
Arabs who come from Iran and ex- Muslim or murtaddin. Ali Sina giving notice a false
statement by his own admission. Whether the real purpose of Ali Sina to pit islam and
Christian congregation, and how he was so very hate Islam? By His destination he spread it
with incitement and defamation?. " ِ -ِ ر·ُ -ِ ' . Linu rihi", is a parable says that can be interpreted
as “guides to His Light” or "provide guidance", or "right path". Meanwhile, ”Munir” said that
referred to by Dr Naik certainly not the word "Nur", but the “reflection of light”. Dr Naik said: "
and Munir as reflected light, yet Alhamdulillah " the point is if there is someone who
says that Allah the form of rays of light reflection, then he replied " Alhamdulillah ". DR Naik
did not say that God is “Munir”. But Ali Sina immediately conclude that God is Munir.
The word "Nur" in al-qur'an is repeated 43 times. Which is 13 in the form of "al-Nur" and 14
in the form of "ma` bi al-idāfah rifah "and 16 times in the form of" nakirah ". The context of the
verse is addressed directly to God, but there are also addressed to His books (the Al-Qu’ran,
the Torah, and Gospel), some are addressed to believers or people hypocrites, and There
are designated to month, the sun and there is also a stand-alone. So the word "Nur" has a
very broad sense and meaning is very deep. Can a parable, metaphor and connecting it with
the word of faith. 24:35 verse, the God’s light indicates that light is a word methaphor,
allegory or parable, so that the entire verse is to be understood with a deep understanding
with kindness and cleanliness think. Understanding God’s light in paragraph above are as a
metaphor of God rather than as the name or nature of the creator. Nūr in this verse that God
does not show tangible light, but light it is something that in metaphor to God. Words
“nūruhu” and “li nūrihi” in this paragraph support the statement. Then verse 24:35 must
understood with God’s light that is in the faith of someone. According to Ghazali, he
understood the parable as an illustration of the potential human comprehension. Mishkat like
sensuous spirit or the senses (sensory spirit) and the lights like a reasonable (soul `aqli,
intelligential spirit) which receives information from the senses and then process them so that
gave birth to the meanings and ideas (which is limited by the" glass "), glass like the
imagination of man (spirit fictional) that holds the ideas (limit and give shape), the logic of
reason is like a tree (ratiocinative spirit) who obtained data from the sense and combine it all
and conclude that abstract knowledge, while the oil is like the holy prophetic spirit (ruh al-
Quds al-Nabawi), ie, revelation, inspiration or intuition. The holy Spirit of prophecy
specifically its oil almost shine, even though the fire never touched. When you have been
touched by fire, the spirit had been "a light upon light." While the fire is the most
appropriate metaphor for the "divine spirit" who resided in nature above. This fire was also
assumed by the fire that appeared to the Prophet Musa. behind Mount Sinai.
Some time before Ghazali, Ibn Sina had pondered the meaning of this verse. Niche is the
ability of receptivity (qūwah Isti `dādīyah). The olive tree is contemplation. Oil from the olive
tree is suspected. Glass is a habitual sense. While the fire is the Active Intellect.
Nasafi, similar to Ghazali, also understood the parable as the equivalent to the souls
possessed by human beings. According to him, humans have five spirits: 1) a natural spirit
that lies in the hearts of the right side, 2) animal spirit that lies at the heart of the left side, 3)
psychic spirit in brain, 4) the human spirit in the spirit psychic, and 5) ruh sacred in the
human spirit. Holy Spirit as fire, the human spirit such as oil, spirits psychic like axes, animal
spirits, such as glass, and natural spirits like a niche.
But Ali Sina discusses the notion paragraph above with a mathematical formula, of course he
will not can to finish. That's how Ali Sina play of word. That's how Ali Sina's strategy play of
words, very cunning Ali Sina indeed ).
Dr. Naik has refined sophistry to an art. I don’t think I have ever seen anyone lie so
convincingly and with such an authority and sway. What he says is all chicanery. Dr. Naik is
a flamboyant deceiver. Most of the audience were Muslims and many of them were Arabs. Of
course they all knew that nur means light and not borrowed light. But no one objected. They
all went along and took part in this transparent game of deception, partly because they
wanted to believe in this lie - truth would have been painful - and partly because Dr. Naik was
so authoritative that left everyone spellbound. "How can one lie with such an authority?" they
must have thought to themselves. "So he must be right. Maybe we were wrong all along.
Maybe the dictionaries are wrong."
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina was study the text of al-qur’an from the dictionary.. Deserves he
has never become more intelligent, he was self-taught but was ashamed to ask his teacher
Naik DR. But he denied from behind the wall of her house.So learn the truth Ye!, so that not
out of date. Peviously been described that that the word "ر , Nur" has broad meaning and
depth. May as the parable words but can also as light. Nur is the adjective of a light ray
reflection beam. Howere it different from the light source. The word "sirajan " is a term used
by the Qur'an to the source of light coming from the sun. Both “sunlight” and “moonlight”
together produce the " Nur " both. Contrary Al Qur'an never write the word " ray reflection”
(Munir) ", because at that time about the nature of science there is no light at all. Knowledge
about the properties of the rays are found in the 19th century. But AL Quran has given
instructions to distinguish light from the moon with light from the sun with different terms. AL
Quran is not science but the guidance of a book that should be studied further.)
Let us review some of the verses of the Quran where the words nur and Munir are used and
see if it can be interpreted as borrowed light.
He bringeth them out oI darkness into light
We have sent down unto you a clear light
There hath come to you Irom God a (new) light
We did reveal the Torah. wherein is guidance and a light
We bestowed on him the Gospel wherein is guidance and a light.
Praise be to Allah. Who hath created the heavens and the earth. and hath appointed darkness and
Moses brought. a light and guidance Ior mankind
Is he who was dead and We have raised him unto liIe. and set Ior him a light
Then those who believe in him. and honor him. and help him. and Iollow the light which is sent down
with him: they are the successIul.
Fain would they put out the light oI Allah with their mouths. but Allah disdaineth (aught) save that He
shall perIect His light.
Is the blind man equal to the seer. or is darkness equal to light?
We have revealed unto thee (Muhammad) that thereby thou mayst bring Iorth mankind Irom darkness
unto light
We verily sent Moses with Our revelations. saying: Bring thy people Iorth Irom darkness unto light.
And he Ior whom Allah hath not appointed light. Ior him there is no light
He may bring you Iorth Irom darkness unto light
And as a summoner unto Allah by His permission. and as a lamp that giveth light
Nor is darkness (tantamount to) light;
Is he whose bosom Allah hath expanded Ior Al-Islam. so that he Iolloweth a light Irom his Lord
And the earth shineth with the light oI her Lord
On the day when thou (Muhammad) wilt see the believers. men and women. their light shining Iorth
On the day when the hypocritical men and the hypocritical women will say unto those who believe:
Look on us that we may borrow Irom your light! it will be said: Go back and seek Ior light!
and the martyrs are with their Lord; they have their reward and their light
He will give you twoIold oI His mercy and will appoint Ior you a light wherein ye shall walk.
So believe in Allah and His messenger and the light which We have revealed.
Their light will run beIore them and on their right hands; they will say: Our Lord! PerIect our light Ior
us. and Iorgive us!
As you can see in none of these verses we can replace light 'nur' with "borrowed light" or
"reflection of light" without changing their meaning drastically.
(Rahmanhadiq; previously been described that the Al-qur’an does not find the words
"reflection of light (Munir)". The word "Nur" has been represented as reflected light and also a
source of light both. There is no difference between the properties of the ray reflected with
the nature of light coming from the source of light. They produce the same beam
characteristics both. So the holy Qur'an will not elaborate anymore because someday people
will see for himself. Information and proof that the moon does not generate its own light, but
reflected light from the sun , not known at the time of AL Qur’an at 15 centuries ago, not
known at all by astronomers at the time. Of course not possible verses of the Qur'an,
explained the theory of reflection rays from the moon. Because Al-qur'an not a book of
science, but the signs for further study by a thinking man. While the nature of the dualism of
light beam was discovered in the 20th century. Now the physicists are able to prove that light
is a wave and a particle nature as well. While the nature of the dualism of light beam was
discovered in the 20th century AD. Now the physicists are able to prove that light is a wave
and a particle nature as well.
According to Huygens in 1670 AD, that light is a wave. Postulate of this Huygen hold on to
the observation that sunlight can penetrate the empty space until it reaches the earth without
a decrease in intensity and was not influenced by gravity. Then Huygens theory was refined
again by Michael Faraday in 1859 who said that light is also electromagnetic waves. Michael
Faraday's theory is strengthened by some experts as Gustav Kirchhoff in 1877, Ludwig
Boltzmann in 1859, Gustav Kirchhoff in 1877 and a peak yield kwantum theory by Max
Planck in 1899. Postulate of Max Well this new breakthrough made by Albert Einstein in
1905 with a photoelectric effect experiment. Einstein concluded that the particle nature of
light as well. Albert Einstein's conclusion was demonstrated after observing a beam of light
that illuminates the atom can excite electrons out of orbit of electrons and produce energy
. And from the results of further research in 1924, Einstein finally stated that the light has
a dual nature or the dualism of nature and the wave nature of particles. Einstein's postulate is
reinforced by Louis de Broglie in 1924 that proves that the electrons also have the nature of
particle-wave duality, to the blaze wave-particle duality theory.
So at this milinium century, physicists agree that the dualism of light as a transverse
electromagnetic wave and the flow of particles called photons. Further development occurred
in 1953 with the discovery of the maser beam, and laser beams in 1960.
From the findings over the past 100 years, then it was revealed that light has a meaning and
aspects that are very broad and deep. Qur'an 15 centuries ago has explained that the word
light has a very wide scope, can be as light source, can be as light reflection and can also be
significant as a figure of speech. So the word "light" that does not mean a rigid noun which
only focused on one object only. But the word is meant by the verse of light AL Quran an
adjective or a figure of speech that can be expressed in a parable, as it is written in many of
the verses al quran.)
Nur is a common day to day word. Every Muslim whether Arab or not knows that nur means
light and not borrowed light. But when it comes to defending Islam and protecting it from
being ridiculed, they remain silent and go along with the lie. All these Muslims in the hall
listening to Dr. Nailk's charade felt that it is their religious duty to take part in this taqiyah and
not object when someone lies for the glory of Islam. This comes so natural to Muslims that
they do it subconsciously. They think they are fooling others. In reality they are fooling
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina assuming that the Islamic people in attendance witnessed the
debate are people who fool or fooled by Dr Naik. Yet after all the accusations Ali Sina
discussed this, it turns out he does not have any ability at all. Turned out to Ali Sina only
good at inciting, slanderous, lying and he was the one who ideot actually.)

Zulqarnain and the Setting place of the Sun
(Dr. Naik) The other point that Dr. William Campbell raised was regarding Sura KahI 18:86. The
Sura says the sun setting in murky water. in turbid water. Imagine. sun setting in murky water!
UnscientiIic! The Arabic word used here is: it’s wajada meaning. it appeared to Zulqarnain. Dr.
William Campbell knows Arabic. Wajada means… you can look in the dictionary also; it means it
appeared. Allah (swt) is describing what appeared to Zulqarnain. II I make the statement that a student
in the class said 2¹2÷5 and you say “oh Zakir said 2¹2÷5. I didn’t say. I am telling that the student in
my class said 2¹2÷5. I am not wrong. the student is wrong. There are various ways to try and analyze
this word. One is this way. according to Muhammad Asad. that vaiada means it appeared to. It
appeared to Zulqarnain.
(Ali Sina) Dr. Naik is again trying to give a new meaning to a commonly used Arabic word.
Wajada means “found”, not “appeared”. All the ten translators of the Quran that I consulted
have translated this word as found. URL. Dr. Naik is lying again. Let us read the verse:
(Rahmanhadiq; Thus the characteristics of an provocateur. If he does not understand, he
did not want to ask questions and learn properly. But he immediately spread the slander and
provocation. It’s really very cunning of Ali Sina. As already mentioned earlier that a word
written in the verses of al quran has a very broad understanding and in-depth, so it must be
understood with the cleanliness of thinking. There are many words which are written in al
qur'an has various synonim meanings. Depending on the context written verses, sentence
structure, word form, the form of text and others. For example, the word "Nur" has various
synonym meanings of "light", "faith", "guidance", "omen", "gift" and others. Text of the
word " ً ءَ , maa’a , water" has the meaning "water", "life", "source of life" and "coolness",
Whereas for text of word " ِ ّ ِ د, adhin , religion" written in various forms of words such as
"ad-din “ or "ih-din" also has various synonim meanings of "teaching", "religion",
"retaliation", or "court". This is because the Qur'an is derived by using arabic language or
human language that has many deficiency. Not only the Arabic that contain the word with
many meanings, any language in the world is also like that. The word "like" can be
interpreted as "happiness" or " as ", the word " Mouse " can be interpreted as" rats " or "
cursor tool ". in Indonesian language " bisa " can be interpreted as " capable ", or "
snake venom ". Many of the words in the verse of the Qur'an is the word metaphor and
metaphor that can not be interpreted by the root of word or words basis, but with the wisdom
of thinking. This is not because of lack of perfection of language in that book, but equivalent
language that must be disclosed by a living person of mankind wisdom and good thinking .)
And he Iollowed a road.
Till. when he reached the setting-place of the sun. he Iound (wajada) it setting in a muddy spring.
and Iound (wajada) a people thereabout. We said: O Dhu'l-Qarneyn! Either punish or show them
The word wajada is used twice. Are we supposed to understand that the people whom he
saw were not real but also an apparition? How could he reward and punish such imaginary
people? Again we find the same word in the same sura:
(Rahmanhadiq; Apparently fraud of Ali Sina, if he was not able to understand the sentence
of the verse in its entirety, then he takes a word which he said should be defined with one
word. Whereas previously, had explained that the text in the words of al-qur'an meaning of
having a broad and in-depth , depending on the context of the verse. In this case the word
"wajada" is not a noun tense or the progressive tense, but a figure of speech which should
thought with a wider meaning. Please note that the word "Zulkarnain" above is not a noun
sense from a person's name but a figure of speech to the position or title of a goverment who
ruled at that time. Some names are directed against one's title contained in the verses of al-
qur'an, among others are: "Fir'un", here fir'un not the name of a king, but the title of a king
“Ramses”, as well as the name "Al Aziz" (verse 12:51) is not someone's name but the title or
position a person in a government in Egypt. The word "Zulkarnain" means "have two horns
", referring to a ruler who holds a" Deserves ", or a ruler who has extensive powers on the
earth at that time. At that time, Zulkarnain dominated widest area reaching the western
region in Africa (about Morocco and Tunisa) to the eastern reaches of Afghanistan and
southern China and also including europe continent. May be Zulkarnain in this verse is
addressed to the king of Great Alexander or not, because this King is the group of pagans
who worship the pagan idols. By the time he was exploring the area in the west, he arrived at
a place where there is a black sea . Zulkarnain arrived at the place when just before the sun
will go down. This verse shows that Zulkarnain arrived at the westernmost region of his
realm. From time immemorial until today, all people would see that the sun sank west, maybe
people thought that the sun is really sinking to the west. And every body known that at the
time when Zulkarnin to watch the sunset on a sea of black. But at the time of this milenium
words "Sunset" is a figure of speech, because it was not the sun that moves toward the west
but the earth rotates with its axis. The words "Sunset" or the “sun rises " which are written in
verse Al Quran is also the metaphor word, because at the time of Muhammad and the earlier
era is not known by anyone that the earth rotates. Actually the context of this verse is not
talking about “ sunset”, but rather about the event or experienced by Zulkarnain at the time
he reached the new land is found. The word "wajada" that are embedded in the verse has a
meaning and understanding of a broad and in-depth. The metaphor Word of “Wajada”
would be meaning as "somewhere", could be the "time", could as the word "see", "witness",
"when" or "for a moment". But Ali Sina reject the metaphor word of "wajada" is “seen”. He
imposed his will that the metaphor word of "wajada" must mean " found ". Had the
character like Satan was given freedom to interpret the verses of Al Quran then he would
destroy, trample and humiliate the verses AL Qur'am that very hated by himself.)
18.92 Then Iollowed he (another) way.
18.93 Until. when he reached (a tract) between two mountains. he Iound. (wajada) beneath them. a
people who scarcely understood a word.
Rahmanhadiq; as noted above, that the word "wajada" is a figure of speech that synonym
with the word "sunset" or "sunrise". Therefore, the word "wajada" is a synonyim word that
has meant very flexible. When Zulkarnain came to a place in the west or east, then at the
scene that he had something like the smoke, the presence of high mountains, the sea is
black, or when in the evening where the sun was nearly drowned. And in that event, the word
"wajada" planted in the context of the verses above has the figurative meaning or metaphor
are quite broad and flexible. Wajada words can be interpreted as a "witness", "view", "find",
"found", "when" or "when it". Placement of the word "wajada" in the verses above are to
beautify the grammatical structure of sentences. This depends on an understanding of
people who translate of word "wajada" according to his imagination, because the word
"wajada" is a metaphor word in the verse of the Qur'an.

Was this also an apparition?
Here are two other verses where wajada is used:
3:37 And her Lord accepted her with Iull acceptance and vouchsaIed to her a goodly growth; and
made Zachariah her guardian. Whenever Zachariah went into the sanctuary where she was. he Iound
(wajada) that she had Iood.
28:23 And when he came unto the water oI Midian he Iound (wajada) there a whole tribe oI men.
(Rahmanhadiq: the word "wajada" in the context of the verses above indicate that the word
(wajada) is a figure of speech. In the verses above the words "wajada" can be interpreted
with the synonym understanding that is very flexible, namely: "find" or "watch" or "found" or
"prove". so that the translation the word "wajada" became the word "see" or "find" does not
change the sense of purpose conveyed by the verses. The most important thing is the
message of the verses and the purpose of the verses. While the word "wajada" in the verses
is not the main keywords. So Ali Sina vain to directs the Islam people to impose his will to
incite and defame. The words are arranged in the al-Quran is very sturdy, calculating,
beautiful grammatical and strong composition, and is valid forever, so that no one could
change it and ruin it. God has promised to preserve and maintain the purity of the verses as
written in the letter AL Hijr verse 9, which reads: " We have, without doubt, sent down the
Message; and We will assuredly guard it (from corruption). (Qs 15 Al-Hijr 9)".
Dr. Naik lied. Then he went on to shift the blame on Zulqranain and said it is not the fault of
Allah for saying what Zulqranain had mistakenly assumed.
If so, why Allah did not make it clear that Zulkarnain had made a mistake? Since in those
days everyone thought that the Earth is flat, this was the perfect chance for Allah to set the
record straight and clarify that Zulqranain was mistaken because the Sun does not set in
waters; it is the Earth that is rotating making you think it is rising and setting. If this was said,
then we would have accepted that the Quran contains scientific miracle. As it stands now, it
contains nothing but error and scientific blunders
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is a person who does not want to admit his stupidity. In case he is
not understood in reading Al Qur'an, he assumes that al-qur'an is the same verses with the
contents of his head like a dirty shrimp’s brain. If he did not understand then he went on to
say that the news was a lie, he could not use his brain which contains only hatred,
incitement, and all kinds of goods that dirty and stinking. This proves that Ali Sina is the devil
in disguise as humans. Humans are too smart or crazy, want to advise and teach the true for
God to write in His book. In fact already evident from the previous explanation, that ali Sina
really do not understand the parable words, he is blind with metaphor or figurative words. So
with his lack he feels more clever to incite and spread the magic formula of defamation,
incitement and lies. This proves that Ali Sina is already severe disease that is psychological
disease “ psychopath” who dangerously for human life in the world.)

(Dr. Naik) Point # 2: The Arabic word used is Maghrib. It can be used Ior time as well as place.
When we say sunset. sunset can be taken Ior time. II I say the sun set at 7 PM. I am using it Ior time. II
I say the sun set in the West. it means I am taking it Ior place. So here iI you use the word Maghrib Ior
time. So Zulqarnain did not reach that place oI sunset –use it Ior time- he reached there at the TIME oI
sunset. Furthermore you can solve it in various ways.
(Ali Sina) The verse in Arabic says Hatta itha balagha maghriba alshshamsi. This literally
means: Till when he reached the setting-place of the Sun. All the translators have invariably
translated maghrib as "setting-place" and not "time of setting". The structure of the sentence
does not allow for such an interpretation.
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina, who claimed to be ex-Muslim or murtadin was never carry out the
maghrib prayer, so he translates the word maghrib as a "place of sunset". That's how Ali
Sina spread the meretriciousness to people who do not understand the verses of the Quran
neighbor. Though all Muslims know that the word of “maghrib” it means "testimony time"
is time to pray when the sunset. So the phrase " Hatta itha balagha maghriba alshshamsi " is
a clue about the timing of an event that is on "when the sinking sun." But Ali Sina is
deliberately playing the words to deceive his followers who have never known al qur'an at all,
so anything that delivered by a wolf in sheep's clothing will be approved or justified by his
But the most interesting part of Dr. Naik’s statement is his last sentence. He said, “You can
solve it in various ways”. That is the main point. If the Quran is the book of God, it should
have been clear. There would have been no need for Muslims to try to solve its problems in
every imaginable way. Why should there be several explanations for each verse when at the
outset the book says "this is a clear book with no doubt in it"? Did it appear to Zulqranain that
the Sun sets in murky waters or did he just reach that place at the time of sunset? Do you
see how Muslims desperately try to find ways to explain the unexplainable?
Rahmanhadiq; A truth value can be explained or tested in many ways, the point is that such in any way
that truth is tested it will be met partly true. Conversely, a value of lies only be forwarded with many lies, too.
One lie will be covered with thousands of other lies. So that a lie will followed by lining up behind it lies a lot.
if the writing on the al qur'an about sunset or sunrise is a word or term that is wrong or
inappropriate, whether considered as an error of at time before people find out that the earth
rotates and up to modern times, then the entire newspaper, magazines, electronic media
and other print media are still writing the phrase "sunset", sure everything can be said as a
human folly and lies of the modern age of course. Human at this millenium century is still
accepting and using the words "sunset" or “sunrise”, of course that those words are words
that are very stupid for people who live in this modern age, including Ali Sina. This is
because all this modern century man think that the words "sunset" or “sunrises" is just a
metaphor of words only. Al qur'an not be blamed for writing the words " sunset” or "sunrise"
as seen by Zulkarnain in the Black Sea, because the event in AL Quran revealed long
before, where all the people in those days no one knows if the earth rotates. So if Ali Sina
does not agree with the word "sunset" or "sunrise" to express the time, then he should seek
the most appropriate new term to replace it. But it was not possible to do because all men
are currently more familiar or like the words above.
But strangely Ali Sina blame those words written in al qur'an verses. This is how lies and
chicanery that is being shown by this KSW.)

The reason Muslims need these “various ways" to explain the obtuse verses of the Quran is
because the meaning of these verses are not clear. They sound irrational and Muslim ulama
know that. Therefore they bend backwards and perform all sorts of mental gymnastics to
make them look plausible. One comes with one silly explanation which is not satisfactory, so
someone else offers another explanation and so on. The only correct explanation is that the
Quran is not the word of God. When you read tafsir, you see that virtually for every verse in
the Quran the Ulama have come up with several interpretations but none of them is
convincing. This is proof that the Quran is a book of confusions. If the Quran was true, there
would be no need for any interpretations and tafsirs. It would have been clear to all those
who read it. Truth is only one, but falsehood can be many. The Quran is the only book that I
know that cannot be understood without external help. So much for a book that claims to be
a perspicuous book 5:15, explained in detail 6:114, conveyed clearly, 5:16, 10:15, easy to
understand 44:58 , 54:22 , 54:32, 54:40 and in which there is no doubt 2:1.
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina will not be able to understand the verses of the Qur'an throughout
his life, because his eyes were blind of course, his mind was closed and a sense of truth in
his chest has been lost. Ali Sina is just looking his ugliness to the verses of the Quran from a
translation-book or from the dictionaries that he got from his gang, but he did not understand
at all by writing AL Quran. He just delivered gossip that he got from the editorial staff, though
the later became a magic formulas to hypnotize his followers. Then he tries to make the
contradiction between a verse al qur'an each other, whereas he did not read it properly. So
A- qur'an would not be understood easily by people who have properties such as Ali Sina,
only those people who positive thinking and good-tempered that can understood the meaning
that is contained in the verses of Al Quran correctly. Ali Sina see Zulkarnain’s stories from
the words "wajada" only. He was only able to divert the eyes of people with a word "wajada",
that's it.

Here is a piece of the story of Zulkarnain as follows; Zulkarnain is a ruler who like to wander
to expand the influence of dependent territories. By the time he reached between two
mountains between Armenia and Azzarbaijan. At the request of residents, Zulkarnain build a
fort. The archaeologists found the fort at the beginning of the 15th century AD, behind Jeihun
in Balkh and the expedition referred to as "Babul Hadid" (Iron Gate) near Tarmidz. Among
which ever through that area is Timurleng, Shah Rukh and Germany scientists and Spain
archaeologists Slade Verger Klapigeo in the year 1403 H. King Qisythalah in Andalus ever
sent Spanish nationality archaeologist out there to meet with Timurleng.. "Babul Hadid" is the
connecting road between Samarqindi and India. Many people thought that the wall made by
Zulkarnain in sura Al-Kahf. While the so-called Gog and Ma'juj by Qur'anic verses are part of
the Mongols from the North are often damaging and destroying the lands they conquered. It
is narrated in surat Al-Kahf verses 95-98. When Zulkarnain arrived there, he meets the
demand of local residents to make a parapet. Then Zulkarnain asked residents to collect iron
ore and then poured into the valley between two hills to make a wall divider. Zulkarnain then
asked that the fire was lit up bright red seeds bers, then he asked to collect copper ore for
iron is poured over it to cover the holes and making the metal surface becomes slippery.
Then formed and there stood a slippery metal wall can not be climbed. The Qur'an does not
say so lying about that story, but Ali Sina's call it a story of people who do not appear

(Dr. Naik) Even if Dr. William Campbell says… ‘No No, the basic assumption is too much - It is
not… ‘Appeared to’… it is actually this.’ Let us analyze it further. The Qur'anic verse says… the
Sun set in murky water.’ Now we know, when we use these words, like ‘sunrise’ and ‘sunset’ -
does the sunrise? Scientifically, sun does not rise - neither does the sunset. We know
scientifically, that the sun does not set at all. It is the rotation of the earth, which gives rise to
sunrise and sunset. But yet you read in the everyday papers mentioning, sunrise at 6 a.m. sun
sets at 7.00 p.m. Oh! The newspapers are wrong – Unscientific!’ If I use the word ‘Disaster’, Oh!
There is a disaster’ – ‘Disaster’ means there is some calamity which has taken place. Literally,
‘disaster’ means ‘an evil star.’ So when I say… ‘This disaster’ every one knows what I mean is ‘a
calamity’, not about the evil star.’ Dr. William Campbell and I know, when a person who is mad,
we call him a lunatic - Yes or no? At least I do, and I believe Dr. William Campbell also will be
doing that. We call a person ‘a lunatic’ – He is ‘mad.’ What is the meaning of ‘lunatic’? It
means… ‘struck by the moon’ - But that is how the language has evolved. Similarly sun rise, is
actually, it is just a usage of words. And Allah has given the guidance for the human beings also -
He uses so, that we understand. So it is just ‘sunset’ - Not that it is actually setting - Not that sun
is actually rising. So this explanation clearly gives us a clear picture, that the Verse of the Qur’an
of Surah Kahf, Chapter.18, Verse No 86, is not in contradiction with established science - That is
the way how people speak.
(Ali Sina) Earlier Dr. Naik told us that this was an error committed by Zulqarnain who
thought the Sun is setting in murky waters and Allah is simply reporting what appeared to
Zulqarnain. Here Dr. Naik is shifting position and is saying that Allah is only using a figurative
speech. Which explanation is the correct one?
Yes indeed the word sunset, although technically wrong, is still part of our lexicon, but this
does not explain the difficulty that we find in the Quran. Is Allah speaking figuratively? Verse
018:085 says:
And he Iollowed a road.
Till. when he reached the setting-place of the sun.
And 018:089
Then he Iollowed a road
Till. when he reached the rising-place of the sun.
The text does in no way allow us to take the setting and the rising places of the sun
figuratively. The story is clear. Zulqarnain followed a road till he reached the setting place of
the Sun. He took another road till he reached the rising-place of the Sun. Anyone can see
sunrise and sunset from anywhere in the world. This is hardly worthy of mention. But only
Alexander the Great (Zulqarnain) who was believed to have conquered the world form one
end to another had the unique privilege to see the setting and the rising places of the Sun.
That is why this story was deemed to be important to be mentioned.
All the explanations offered by Dr. Naik are excuses. In these verses maghrib cannot be
translated as the TIME of sunset. None of the translators have made that mistake. The
expression used is not figurative. The verse is talking about an event that actually took place
and was observed by Zulqarnian and not something that appeared to him.
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina do not satisfied and not want to understand about the meaning of
the word “ maghrib “ is the time of prayer when the sun sets. He forced his desire the word
of “maghrib “ as a place of sunset, so he forced the minds of his followers to remain
convinced that the "maghrib = place of sunset" in the sea. He could only affect non-Islamic
people who never maghrib prayer to swallow any such notion. But if he says the word
“maghrib = place of sunset” to the people of Islam, then he will be ridiculed because they
have made a joke that is not funny, the embarrassing stupidity. Ali Sina is only able to fool his
followers who do not understand at all.

(Ali Sina) Well let us read the verse and see who is putting his own words in the Quran .
Hast thou not seen how thy Lord hath spread the shade - And iI He |3
person| willed He could have
made it still - then We |1
person| have made the sun its pilot.
Yes everyone knows that shadow is caused by the Sun and not just today but always. My cat
knows it too because when it gets hot, he seeks a place of shade. But Muhammad says that
if Allah willed he could have made the shadow stand still. How that is possible? The only way
that is is possible is to make the "moving" sun stand still.
Rahmanhadiq; iI verse above contain many parables and allegories sentences. People like
Ali Sina is not possible to understand it perfectly, because he only saw these verses from
impossibelity side only. Ali Sina thinks that god is impossible to make a shadow that extends
or retracts. If Ali Sina is willing to think and fair, then in the verse there is the phrase " if He
person] willed He could have made it still.." . This sentence is a metaphor and also an
important clue that should sense with gracious mindset. Actually, Ali Sina has been
understand a little of the intent verse, but then turned his intention to destroy his logical, so
that his soul closed with hatred and arrogance own lust. Of course, all-powerful of God with
his will to create everything in this universe, as well as against Ali Sina himself. So nothing is
impossible if God wishes for it. If Allah willed, of course, He can make it be a silent shadow.
This sentence is a metaphor for human beings in times of ignorance used to be. Why God
did not write it with the phrase "if God will of course the sun and the earth be silent", but not
by the shadow. But it turns out sentences that are listed in that paragraph is more wise and
prudent to understand and be understood by humans at that time. But at the 2-Millennium
century, the verse is to be understood by thinking more critically and analysts as god has
provided a thoughtful explanation. Had the shadows it made permanent, not elongated and
do not shorten, or not left-leaning or not leaning to the right, then for people who think it will
interpret the phrase "non-rotating earth and the sun was still in place." hidden meaning in
verse states that the earth or sun moving. Apparently a few centuries later proved that the
earth rotates while the sun still a distant place. Several centuries later proved again that
which causes the sun leaning to the left or right caused by the earth on its axis inclination
angle 23.5
. Proved that the words that are planted in the verse is a language that can be
understood by anyone and is valid forever. so there is nothing strange in these verses, the
strange thing is Ali Sina's desire to destroy the reality and the truth value of that verse).
Rahmanhadiq; re-Ali Sina divert the main topic of the issue, that discussed the verses al
quran not some Hadist. Of course the purpose is to provoke them between Hadist with Al
Qur’an verses. In fact Dr. Naik only discuss about “The Qur’an and the Bible in the Light of
Science “. To reinforce his opinion and provocation, he takes some hadist to deny the truth
of the verses of Al Quran. Truth verses al quran can not be tested with the Hadist, although
the Hadist was considered valid even, in fact the opposite is true. Truth Hadith should be
tested with the verses of the Al Qur’an verses. If Hadist does not match the explanation of
the AL-Qur'an verses, the hadith must be rejected. So it's useless the provocateur Ali Sina
take much Hadist to strengthen his opinion. This will not be discussed because of outside
legal basis presented by Dr Naik. Whereas previously, the instigator Ali Sina has been
damaging the verses of the Qur'an, and now he's about to give the Hadist that do not clear
the source and also has damaged. it does not need to be discussed, let the culprit was
received retaliation in hell later. If a psychopath who was recurrence of the disease, the
better he would consulted to a doctor first before continuing the haranguing.

Let us consult Bukhari and Muslim and see if they can shed some light on this problem. .
Rahmanhadiq; Back Ali Sina divert the main topic of conversation, who should discuss the verses of Al Quran
into a discussion of the Hadist. Of course the aim is to provoke them between Hadist with the Qur'an verses.
In fact Dr. Naik only discuss the verses of Al Quran in the light of science. To reinforce his opinion and sly, the
instigator Ali SIna takes some Hadist to deny the truth of the verses of Al Quran. Yet the truth of the verses of
Al Quran can not be tested with the Hadist, although the Hadist was considered valid even if, in fact the
opposite is true. Truth Hadith should be tested with the verses of Al Quran. If hadist does not match the
explanation of Qur'an, the hadith must be rejected.
Rahmanhadiq will not discuss the Hadist handed on by the KSW is because beyond the basics of law presented
by Dr Naik. Whereas previously, the instigator Ali Sina has been damaging the verses of Al Quran, and now
he's about to give the hadiths to poke fun, ridicule the verses of the Qur'an. So no need to be addressed, let
the culprit was received retaliation in hell later. If his psychopathic was relapse, then he better consult a
doctor first before continuing his speech.

Bukhari 4.53.353
The Prophet said. "A prophet amongst the prophets carried out a holy military expedition. …and when
he reached that town at the time or nearly at the time oI the 'Asr prayer. he said to the sun. 'O sun! You
are under Allah's Order and I am under Allah's Order O Allah! Stop it (i.e. the sun) Irom setting.' It
was stopped till Allah made him victorious
Muslims 1.0300
Abu Dharr reported: I asked the Messenger oI Allah (may peace be upon him) the (implication oI the)
words oI Allah. the Exalted: The sun glides to its appointed resting place. He replied: Its appointed
resting place is under the Throne.
Bukhari 4.54.421
Narrated Abu Dhar: The Prophet asked me at sunset. "Do you know where the sun goes (at the time oI
sunset)?" I replied. "Allah and His Apostle know better." He said. "It goes (i.e. travels) till it prostrates
ItselI underneath the Throne and takes the permission to rise again. and it is permitted and then (a time
will come when) it will be about to prostrate itselI but its prostration will not be accepted. and it will
ask permission to go on its course but it will not be permitted. but it will be ordered to return whence it
has come and so it will rise in the west. And that is the interpretation oI the Statement oI Allah: "And
the sun Runs its Iixed course For a term (decreed). That is The Decree oI (Allah) The Exalted in
Might. The All-Knowing." (36.38) This hadith is also reported in Bukhari6.60.326. Bukhari6.60.327.
Bukhari 9.93.528. and Muslim1.0297
Bukahri 4.55.556
Narrated Abu Huraira: We were in the company oI the Prophet at a banquet and a cooked (mutton)
Iorearm was set beIore him. and he used to like it. He ate a morsel oI it and said. "I will be the chieI oI
all the people on the Day oI Resurrection. Do you know how Allah will gather all the Iirst and the last
(people) in one level place where an observer will be able to see (all) oI them and they will be able to
hear the announcer. and the sun will come near to them…
So it is clear what Muhammad thought about the function of Sun in the sky. He thought like
any other ignorant person of his time. He thought the Sun is a lamp that thinks and worships
Allah; that it goes around the earth and if Allah orders it to stop in midair it will and if He tells
it to rise from the West, it will obey. This is the cosmology of Muhammad.
Bukhari 2.018.167
Narrated Abu Musa:
The sun eclipsed and the Prophet got up. being afraid that it might be the Hour (i.e. Day oI
Judgment). He went to the Mosque and oIIered the prayer with the longest Qiyam.
This is again another proof that Muhammad had no understanding of a natural phenomenon
such as eclipse. He was afraid of it and thought this is the sign of Allah that the world is
ending. Why would he be afraid of the Hour of Reckoning if he had nothing to fear?
Obviously he was well conscious of the fact that he was lying.

Solomon’s Death
(Dr. Naik) Dr. William Campbell spoke about Solomon’s death - Surah Saba. Chapter 34. Verse 12
to 14. and said that… ‘Imagine a person standing on the stick. and he dies. and no one come to know.
etc.’ here are various ways to explain - Point no 1. Solomon peace be him. he was a Prophet oI God.
and it can be a miracle. When Bible says that Jesus Christ peace be upon him. could give liIe to the
dead. Jesus Christ is born oI a virgin birth. Which is more diIIicult to imagine’ - Being born oI a virgin
birth. giving liIe to the dead… or standing on a stick Ior a very long time. Which is more diIIicult. So
when God can do miracles through Jesus Christ peace is upon him. why cannot he do a miracle
through Solomon Alai Salaam. Moosa Alaika Salaam parted the sea. He threw a stick - stick become a
snake - Bible says that… Qur’an says that. So when God can do that. why cannot God let a man rest
Ior a long period? Any way I have give him various diIIerent answers - No where does the Qur’an say
that Sulaiman Alaika salaam rested on the stick Ior a very long period - No where does it say. It iust
says that… animal…. May be some say… ‘Ant’… may be other animal oI the earth came and bit -
May be possible. May be. that Sulaiman alaika salaam was iust dead. and any animal may have shook
the stick. and Sulaiman alaika salaam may have Iallen down. But I assume - I use the conIlict
approach with the Qur’an - because irrespective whether you use the conIlict approach or the
concordance approach. the ayat I quoted in the beginning oI my talk Surah Nisa. Chapter 4 Verse. 82.
says… (Arabic)… ‘Do they not consider the Qur’an with care?’ Had it been Irom anyone besides
Allah. there would have been many contradictions.’ Irrespective. whether you use the conIlict
approach or the concordance approach. iI your logical. is you will not be able to take out a single
Verse oI the Qur’an. which is contradicting - neither a single verse which is against established

(Ali Sina) 34:12-14 say that Solomon was dead for a long time while standing and leaning
on his staff and no one noticed it until a creeping creature of the earth gnawed away his staff
and he fell.
Now, this story is ludicrous. Dr. Naik can’t explain it logically. So, instead he resorts to the
favorite Islamic tactic - the fallacy of tu quoque; and says that in the Bible there are more
incredible stories. This is not an answer. This is a logical fallacy. Just because the Bible has
many unproven and unscientific stories, the ridiculous stories in the Quran do not become
(Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina does not understand the statement of Dr. Naik, this is caused of the
passion of hatred that has accumulated in his soul. Al Quran tells the story of Moses as well
as the Bible, this shows that Dr Naik did not lie to the audience with a story that conveys it.
Regardless of whether the story in the Bible or the Qur'an is more correct. but Ali Sina, who
has a desire to incite and provoke them, then he took the point of this for political purposes.
He wants to pit Muslims and Christians by using their books. That cunning devil who initials
Ali Sina..
Then he sneers and says "it could be a miracle". This is also a logical fallacy. There is no
proof that any of the miracles claimed in any book has ever happened. There is no scientific
proof for miracles. Dr. Naik is using one fallacy to prove another fallacy. If we take miracles
as proof, we have to take every charlatan for his word. This debate was about science not
miracles. Scientifically speaking the story of the dead Soloman standing on his feet leaning
on his staff for days or maybe months without anyone noticing until termites or other creeping
creatures gnawed at his staff is ludicrous.
Dr. Naik says “Anyway, I give him various different answers”. Truth is only one. Various
different answers that are illogical and can be refuted do not make up for one solid and
logical answer that can’t be refuted. If the Quran was true, one logical answer would have
sufficed. When a suspect is interrogated, one way the investigators determine whether he is
lying or telling the truth is by seeing how many times he changes his story. If he keeps
changing his story and gives various answers to the same question, the cops determine that
he is lying. The very fact that Muslims come up with several answers to every question is
because none of them is convincing. Truth is only one, lies can be many.
(Rahmanhadiq; A truth value can certainly be tested in many ways. If the test is a truth, then
any method of testing done, would be toward the correct result. Conversely, if the test is a
falsehood or lie, as he always delivered by Ali Sina, then surely be found out that he lied. So
any way he defended the reason lies, all lies will be uncovered. To cover up the lie that it
conveys, then Ali Sina was forced to do a lot of lies that followed, even he does not hesitate
to take cunning way to spread incitement, libel and fighting amongst religious. Ali Sina is
intentionally telling a story about him being interrogated by the police chief named
Rahmanhadiq, and it turns out the whole answer to Ali Sina is a lie of all.
actually KSW is also not able to analyze why the death of Solomon was not known until so
long. There are so many miracles that happen in human life which can not be solved with
logic. As the dead prophet Jesus, the prophet Moses split the sea, the prophet Solomon
dead for so long without being noticed. All of it certainly can not think with logic, even Ali Sina
would not be able to think of the incident according to logic. Even on the birth and death later,
Ali Sina will not be able to think or reject it. That is a fate that can not afford countered by ALi
Sina. ALi Sina is a little boy who would not thank to his creator and Ali Sina is a proud man
who is not handy.).
As it is clear; we considered with care and have found much discrepancies and stupidities in
the Quran. This book is quite possibly the most asinine book ever written. There are
hundreds of statements made in the Quran that are absolutely wrong and yet there is not a
single claim that could not have been know by an ordinary illiterate Arab during the time of
Muhammad. In fact we see that many men of Quraish were a lot more intelligent and more
knowledgeable than Muhammad.
Rahmanhadiq; This pride of Ali Sina. He felt so great with his knowledge, but knowledge
that comes from knowing the experts in this 20th century. Funnily enough cleverness again
he compares himself with people that lived 16 centuries ago. As an ordinary human being,
can be accepted that Muhammad and his followers do not know many new discoveries are
found in this 21st century. This proves that the Prophet Muhammad only convey the
revelation he received from the creator. Many statements AL Quran verses that have been
proven true, and many more which can not be proved by the ability of this millenium century
men. Ali Sina has accused the verses of the Qur'an is the most stupid book, but he himself
did not have the handbook, except spells which contains the formulation of hatred and lies.
This proves that Ali Sina does not have any grip on the philosophy of life. Ali Sina has an joy
or a very strange hobby is like accusing, inciting hatred and spread to other humans. Ali
Sina's disease is not known cure and remedies.
All we need to prove that the Quran is not from God is one error. We already found many. I
can show hundreds of them. But let me make this easy on Dr. Naik and all the Muslims. I
challenge any Muslim to show me one verse from the entire Quran that could not have been
said by an ordinary man living in the seventh century Arabia. Show me one single verse that
is miraculous and I will withdraw all my charges against Muhammad and the Quran and pay
you $50,000 US dollars in reward. If you can’t show me a single verse that is miraculous,
why are you clinging to this cult so tenaciously? Remember that the test of a book that claims
to be the word of God is that it should not have a single error. We already found tens of them.
What I am asking is actually much simpler, forget about the hundreds of errors in the Quran,
just sow me one single miracle if you can and I withdraw all my charges.
Truth is that the Quran has hundreds of errors and not a single miracle.
Rahmanhadiq; according to Ali Sina's philosophy, to prove the falsehood in the verse of the
Qur'an, just by one mistake, then all the verses of the Qur'an should be rejected. But oddly
enough that it conveys the above accusation turns against itself. Ali Sina convey a lot of lies
and cunning to destroy Al-Quran verses. Ali Sina is vain effort to destroy verses AL-Quran in
a way that falsehood. Indeed, "to prove a truth, must be tested with the truth and the right
way. " On the contrary "to establish a falsehood or lie can only be done with falsehood and
lies too. " Ali Sina's philosophy of taking the second. Then Ali Sina challenged Muslims to
show just one verse of al-qur'an that contain magic value for himself. This is something that
is impossible, because the eyes and soul are closed. Whatever verse al-qur'an give unto to
him, it would be rejected by many ways, as we have seen from many of the description
above. So it's useless he offers the cunning bait, because there are no Muslims who believe
it anymore.

Perhaps a better offer Rahmanhadiq turned to him again, and asked for Ali Sina showed
teachings or doctrine is best to replace the verses of the Qur'an which he thinks is not true.
Indicate doctrine or philosophy of life of the best Ali Sina that can be tested for human
goodness in the world planet. No need as much as the verses AL Qr'an which numbered
more than 6000 verses. Rahmanhadiq just ask Ali Sina to submit 10 Verses only of doctrine
or philosophy of life is the best Ali Sina is different from the verse of the Qur'an.
If Ali Sina is able to show the 10 best Doctrins are goodness for human life in this world, then
Rahmanhadiq will enroll as a best Ali SIna’sa student and the next Rahmanhadiq will not
defend the teachings of Islam again. This is the challenge of rahmanhadiq back to Ali Sina Ali
Sina said if true.
There are no Muslims who are interested in Ali Sina's reward, including Rahmanhadiq. For
Muslims and possibly also for other religious leaders hope that Ali Sina is not doing anymore
lies, cunning, incitement, slander, insult and harass Muslim religious community in particular
because it is so painful hearts and their feelings. If Ali Sina's accusations that contain
elements of truth, may still be acceptable, but if it just shows hatred, and his desire for
revenge by way of falsehood and deceit. Even with the cheating ways, leading to Islamic
teachings on the human heart closer and more human beings to believe the truth of the
verses of the Qur'an, so that every year more and more people who say the shahada. So
stop cheating in ways like that.
(Ali Sina) Since Dr. Naik presented 22 out of many errors of the Bible, let me present a short
list of many errors of the Quran for him (or anyone) who cares to respond. All we need to
prove that the Quran is not from God is one error while even hundreds of errors in the Bible
do not necessarily disqualify it as a message of God.
Rahmanhadiq; A peculiar principle of Ali Sina, if the Qur'an contains only one error of 20
paragraphs which he proposed, then the entire book of the Qur'an should be rejected. But if
the Bible which he said contains a lot of mistakes can still be received and will not be
rejected. What is the real purpose of the statement of Ali Sina's weird is this? Of course, to
insult the verses of the Qur'an, and evoke a sense of pride the people of Christian with the
power of their Bible, then pit between Muslims and Christians in the arena that has been
prepared. Virtually all the verses which will be published below has been discussed in great
detail in the previous discussion. But Ali Sina still feel proud and feel dissatisfied convey
these lies and stupidity. .
Let me make a caveat that I do not believe any message is from God. I do not think God
sends messages or intervenes in human affairs. I am simply taking the side of fairness.
This list starts with the false claims made by Dr. Naik about the Quran. It then continues with
another short list of absurdities that exist in the Quran.

1. Verse 21:33 says the sun and the moon yasbahun. This means both of them navigate or
rotate around the earth and not around their own axis as Dr. Naik has claimed.
Proved that Ali Sina is still using lies and stupidity in analyzing the verse 21:33.
Nothing is written in verse 21:33 that " both of them navigate or rotate around the
earth and not around their own axis " Consider again the information is written in verse
21:33 that;...
Verse 21:33 reads ;
َ ن·ُ =َ -ْ -َ - ٍ =َ 'َ · ¸ِ · ّ ٌ.ُ آ َ ·َ -َ -ْ 'اَ و َ .ْ -ّ َ -'اَو َ ر'َ +ّ َ -'اَ و َ .ْ -ّ َ ''ا َ ·َ 'َ = يِ -ّ َ 'ا َ ·ُ هَ و
the meaning of the phrases;
َ ·ُ هَ و ÷ wahuwa . mean “and it is he”.
يِ -ّ َ 'ا ÷ allazi. mean “Who”
َ ·َ 'َ = ÷ khlaqa. mean . “created”.
َ .ْ -ّ َ ''ا ÷ layla . mean. “dark. the Night”.
َ ر'َ +ّ َ -'اَ و ÷ wa nahara. mean . “ be a light. bright . and the Day”.
َ .ْ -ّ َ -'اَ و ÷ wa syamsa. mean. “and the sun”.
َ ·َ -َ -ْ 'اَ و ÷ wa qamara. mean. “and the moon”.
" ّ ٌ.ُ آ ÷ kullun. mean “each other . available to it “.
¸ِ · ÷ Ii. mean “ in. between. then”.
ٍ =َ 'َ · = falakin mean “ each of them " ,
َ ن·ُ =َ -ْ -َ - ÷ yasbahun mean “they Iloat/swim”.
A li Sina assume that “all (the celestial bodies) swim along " the moon and sun
around the earth while the earth motionless. Yet according to the results of scientific
discovery "that the earth rotates", not the sun round the earth. It turned out that Ali
Sina force his analysis for discredit Al-qur’an verse. Though there is no sentence in
that paragraph which states that "only the sun and moon orbiting the earth." Ali Sina
has done lying and cunning in analyzing and concluding verse, and then incited his
followers to reject the verse.
However, if analyzed in greater depth, there are 3 main objects discussed by verse.
The first is the object of the experience of day and night, of course in question is the
earth, and the second is the Sun and the third is the moon. Then proceed with the
sentence " kullun fi falakin yasbahun , Each one of them", which describes a pair of 2
or 3 things that space. There are only 3 possibilities of the couple, the earth-moon, the
earth-sun, or sun-moon. But strangely Ali Sina conclude that what is meant by the
verse that is the moon-sun couples only, without a clear scientific reason, but with a
sense of hatred and incitement alone. And if he wants to read and analyze information
from the next sentence, the mystery of theAl Qur’an verse that has been ridiculed by
Ali Sina like this would be replied.
The sentence reads, " all (the celestial bodies) swim along “" This means the spouse
of a celestial body must be qualified in accordance with the sound of that paragraph
the sentence that is " each in its rounded course." The question is: Which pair of two
objects that are circulating in an orbit?. Is pair of earth-moon, the moon-sun or sun-
earth? It turned out that this verse description unanswered 10-15 centuries after the
verse was delivered by Muhammad. It turns out that this verse is meant by a pair of
earth-moon. It has been proven by science that the earth and moon each have a path
to the sun, while the moon also orbits the earth has.
Then proved that the words are embedded in the sentence paragraph " each in its
rounded course “ or “Each of them was circulated in an orbit", is a very good grammar
and applies throughout the ages, to be proved by Sain 10-15 centuries later.
What is Ali Sina is able to prove that the sun has orbits or orbit? If not able, why Ali
Sina concluded that circulating it is the sun? Ali Sina please just do not believe in the
message of God in the paragraph above, but in fact he has lied to himself.
Surely proof that the earth is spherical and rotates the new trust after the publication of
the book of Nicholas Copernicus in 1512 AD, entitled "On the Revolutions of the
Heavenly Spheres." Far after the revelation of the verses of Al Quran. While the Earth
orbits the sun was believed to be in the 20th century AD, from the evidence of Galileo
by teloskop creations. But the heliocentric theory that revealed by Copercicus and
reinforced by the findings of Galileo, was later abandoned by astronomers milienium
this century, because the sun was not the center of the universe, but a point in the
Milky Way Galaxy. All the stars inside the Milky Way galaxy turns out this magic
surrounding a central galaxy. As has been describe in the previous image.
Qur'anic verses that describe the relationship between earth, moon and sun of the
most complete, contained in a letter Yassin verse 37 to verse 40 which reads;
َ نُ ِ ْ ُ اَ ذِ َ ْ ُ ه َ رَ ّ َ ا ُ ْ ِ ُ َ ْ َ ُ ْ ّ َ ا ُ ُ َ ٌ َ َ و 37
ِ ِ َ ْ ا ِ ِ َ ْ ا ُ ِ ْ َ َ ِ َ ذ َ ّ َ ّ ٍ َ َ ْ ُ ِ ِ ْ َ ُ ْ ّ َ اَ و 38
ِ ِ َ ْ ا ِ نُ ُْ ْ َ آ َ دَ ّ َ َ َ لِ زَ َ ُ َ ْرّ َ َ َ َ َ ْ اَ و 39
َ نُ َ ْ َ َ َ ٍ ِ ّ ٌُ آَ و ِ رَ ّ َ ا ُ ِ َ ُ ْ ّ َ ا َ و َ َ َ ْ ا َ كِ رُْ ْنَ أ َ َ ِ َ ْ َ ُ ْ ّ َ ا لا 40
“And a Sign for them is the Night: We withdraw therefrom the Day, and behold they are
plunged in darkness 37; And the sun runs his course for a period determined for him:
that is the decree of (Him), the Exalted in Might, the All-Knowing. 38. And the Moon,-
We have measured for her mansions (to traverse) till she returns like the old (and
withered) lower part of a date-stalk. 39. It is not permitted to the Sun to catch up the
Moon, nor can the Night outstrip the Day: Each (just) swims along in (its own) orbit
(according to Law). (Q Yassin 36 : 37-40) “.
The words were composed in the verses above is the arrangement of words that
contain meaning in order to consider further. The People will accept it with a verse
description of what it is in accordance with what they see every day, whereas for the
scholars of Islam will agree to this information such as a grace from God. While
scientists will not be satisfied before these verses prove that the information must be
consistent with developments in science and logic.
The fact that the Earth is spherical and round are recognized after the 10th century AD
(four centuries after the Qur'an is derived), whereas the Earth and the planets
circulating a new solar rotate are recognized and discovered in 1512 by Copernicus
(10th century after Al-Qur ' Years down). Then, further on into the 20th century found
that the sun is only a small part of the cluster of stars called the Galaxy (the Milky
Way's theory). All of the stars within the galaxy was moving around a point in the
universe. So in this case concluded that modern science proved the sun also moves
together with other stars in a galaxy.
According to the Word of God in surah Al Jatsiyah 13, that we must learn about the
existence of the Earth and other celestial objects based on the visible signs and
analyze clues that said of God, so that lessons can be drawn for people who want
thoughtr and celebrate God's grace ;
ِ َ َ و ِ تاَ وَ ّ َ ا ِ َ ُْ َ َ ّ َ َ َ و
ٍ تَ َ ِ َ ذ ِ ّ َ نِ إ ُ ْ ِ ً ِ َ ِ ضْرا
َ نوُ ّ َ َ َ َ ٍ مَْ ِ
“ And He has subjected to you, as from Him, all that is in the heavens and on earth:
Behold, in that are Signs indeed for those who reflect. (Q Jatsyah 45:13) “.
Notice the signs of natural events and complete with information such as the verses
“ Behold! in the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the alternation of night and
day,- there are indeed Signs for men of understanding,- ( Ali Imran 3:190)”.
“ He it is that cleaveth the day-break (from the dark): He makes the night for rest and
tranquillity, and the sun and moon for the reckoning (of time): Such is the judgment and
ordering of (Him), the Exalted in Power, the Omniscient (Al An’aam 6:96).”
This verse means that the incident took place day and night over and over again and
that is happening every single day and night cycle (24 hours). Which caused the
daylight is the sun rising in the eastern horizon, while the cause tonight is the sunset in
the west. Does that mean the sun rises in the east? Could the sun rises somewhere in
the east of the earth? Vice versa if there where the sun sets in the west? Are these
words in the form of figurative or literal sense? Had the sunrise-sunset in the east-
west, there are two possibilities, namely: 1. shaped the earth a vast plain, 2. There is
somewhere on earth where the sun out of its nest and then returned again to his home
in a place opposite. But why can the sun rises and sets at different places on earth?
This fact depends on the direction of where we are and look at it? If we were in the
middle of a vast sea, the sun rises and sinks in the sea, if we were in the middle of the
desert, the sun rises and sets in the ground, if we were in a mountain then
disappeared and the sun emerged from behind a hill.
The conclusion was that the words sunrise and sunset are euphemistic words
metaphor to state the direction of movement of the sun. For while we can infer that the
sun moves round the earth's surface. Is this true?. For people who think, will take
another conclusion. Because there are two possibilities, the sun moves round the
earth or possibly the earth rotate itself. How do we prove it.? Sure we need a
statement from al-Quran verses another. Because we can not choose one of two
possible conclusions, but there is only one clue. So we need information from other
Verse that we use to get clues is Yaasin 39-40, which reads;
“And the Moon,- We have measured for her mansions (to traverse) till she returns like
the old (and withered) lower part of a date-stalk 39. It is not permitted to the Sun to
catch up the Moon, nor can the Night outstrip the Day: Each (just) swims along in (its
own) orbit (according to Law). (Q Yassin 39-40) “.
For people who think, then this section is a sign and also instructions for answering
the question "Did the earth or the sun moving? And how the relationship between the
movement of the moon, earth and sun? Conversely verse above will provide an
opportunity for opponents of the verses of Allah and His righteousness and then lied
saying "How could it take the moon and sun night if possible preceded the afternoon"
Like the sun and the moon was racing in the toll lane? Or whether the moon and the
sun was the brother of current neighbors romp? A question to the childish, a silly
question, questions from people who have always ridicule of the Koran.
If we observe a description verses above, then we can take some lessons and then
a. At the time of the change of moon light on the moon, we can observe that the moon
always faces toward the bright sunlight coming. At night, we saw the moon shining on
the west side or direction of the place of sunset, and when we see the moon during
the day then we see the moon that glowed in the direction of sunrise (east) side of
which is subject to our perspective to moon, sun and earth. On the surface of the
moon-stricken section for light and other parts are not shiny. This proves that the
moon is bright part that reflect the sun. This means that the moon gets light from the
sun that is the same light source is received by the earth. The sun was certainly very
far. This was proven when at night we can still see the light of the moon and
impossible the earth is the vast plains because it would cover or blocking the sun ray
toward the moon. Light of the moon's size will always change once in a period of 24
hours during the month. If the moon was observed amounting to 28 changes shape. Ie
starting from the crescent shape - to a full round (moon) - and back again to the sickle
shape that direction opposite from the first crescent shape.
Changes in the form of first-moon , full-moon dan old-moon , the ray direction is
always directed to the source of sunlight, then there is only one possibility that is
"moon-shaped ball" because the only ball that can produce crescent-shaped shadows
and it is not possible in a circle (like a mirror circular).
b. We've made a conclusion that the moon-shaped ball. Now how to prove the earth
was spherical and whether the moon rotate the earth or vice versa?. If we look at the
statement that the light of moon is always changing from day to day (lunch and dinner)
for 28 days. Then while watching the moon changes, we also observe the journey of
the sun (rising and setting) that its movement always towards the west each day. So
we can conclude that the moon is what surrounds the earth for 28 days. Moon and
Earth are both spherical and receive a single source, namely from the sun rays are
very distant places. No way the moon and sun around the earth once. If the moon
and the sun rotate earth together, of course, light of the moon will always changes
every an hour in a 24-hour cycle, depending on which direction the sun shining on the
moon visible from earth.
c. The next question is "whether the sun around the earth or the earth rotates? 'If the
sun around the earth then ,of course , the shape of moon light will change during the
24-hour cycle. While we are witnessing is the moon changed its form only one time in
24 hours. Then the following conclusion was that "the sun around the earth is
impossible". Then why are there day and night? So the most appropriate answer is
"the earth rotates on its axis" while the sun is still far away. This is evidenced by the
occurrence of day and night alternately in accordance with the rotation of the earth. So
we can conclude that the Earth rotates on its axis with a cycle of 24 hours to rotate
once. When the Earth rotates on its axis, this means that the Earth moves around its
axis and people like being active on a large vehicle. The question is: Is there any
information in the Qur'an which indicate that the Earth is moving?. As already
explained above that there are no verses that affirm on the earth's rotation in the
Qur'an, but God delivered with euphemistic words signs that always raises the puzzle
as a clue.
Paragraph that can be used for this analysis that the earth moves, we can learn from
An-Naml 88 which reads;
ّ ُ ُ َ َ ِ هَ و ً ةَ ِ َ َ ُ َ ْ َ َ ِ ْ اَ ل ى َ َ َ و
ّ َ ُ آ َ َ ْ َ أ يِ ّ َ ا ِ ّ َ ا َ ْ ُ ِ بَ ّ َ ا ّ َ َ
َ نُ َ ْ َ َ ِ ٌِ َ ُ ّ َ ِ إ ٍ ءَْ
“ Thou seest the mountains and thinkest them firmly fixed: but they shall pass away as the
clouds pass away: (such is) the artistry of Allah, who disposes of all things in perfect order: for
he is well acquainted with all that ye do (Q An Naml 27:88)”.
Of course, this verse is a description of the signs. God delivered His word with the
word allegory with a very broad meaning. This verse does not mean that the mountain
was still in place, but moving. Based on the results of the discovery of geological
experts, states that the plate layers of the earth is always moving which can cause
tectonic earthquakes are caused by the collision, the folds and crevices, although its
moves only a few centimeters every years. But this movement is too small to
compared with the motion of the Earth due to rotation. This means that this verse also
explains that the mountain was moving because he is above the earth that moves.
This also means that whatever is on earth will come to move because he is above
the earth's movement. Even the clouds in the air also moves in the earth's rotation, in
accordance with the instructions above Al Qur’an verse.
2. Been able to conclude from the information Qur'an verses above that the earth rotates
are ball shape and for 24 hours on its axis, the sun still give light from afar, while the
moon moves around the earth forever and 28 days, and finally we can also conclude
that the earth and months together do not produce but receive light rays from the sun.
Question was: Are there any verses in the Quran which explains that the moon is
reflected light from the sun produce?. Certainly God does not explain in detail about
the moon that reflects the light from the sun, but Nuh 16 states;

ً اَ ِ َ ْ ّ َ ا َ َ َ َ و اً رُ ّ َ ِ ِ َ َ َ ْ ا َ َ َ َ و
"'And made the moon a light in their midst, and made the sun as a (Glorious) Lamp?”
(Q Nuh 71:16)”.
In the above verse, Allah (God) has given sign or instructions to those who think that
there are two different terms of understanding of the meaning of light. The above
paragraph uses the term اً رُ ("Nur") to the light produced by the moon and ً اَ ِ
("Syamsa Siraajan") to the sun that shines like a lamp. This means that the Sun is like
a lamp, torch or lamp which is the source of light for the month so that he reflects the
light. God has given the correct guidance of the theory of "Reflection rays", long
before the design can be scientifically evident.
4. So what is conveyed by the true of God in the Qur'an verses above. A God in the
Qur'an does not contradict with the findings of science. Only people who believe and
think that is able to think of the riddle or clue in to say by God in the matter of the
above verses.
5. The next question ; whether there is the Words of God in the Quran which explains
"How long month in one year? For that we refer to the Taubah verse 36 which reads;
اً ْ َ َ َ َ َ ْ ا ِ ّ َ ا َ ْ ِ ِ رُ ّ ُ ا َ ةّ َ ِ ّ َ نِ إ
َ -ْرَ أٌ ªَ · 'َ +ْ -ِ - َ ضْر`اَ و ِ تاَ و'َ -ّ َ -'ا َ ·َ 'َ = َ مْ·َ - ِ ªّ َ ''ا ِ ب'َ -ِ آ ¸ِ ·
“ The number of months in the sight of Allah is twelve (in a year)- so ordained by Him
the day He created the heavens and the earth; of them four are sacred: that is the
straight usage. So wrong not yourselves therein, and fight the Pagans all together as
they fight you all together. But know that Allah is with those who restrain themselves (
Q At Taubah 9:36)”.
Description of AL Qur’an verse above indicate that if the change of moon cycle light
has been running as much as 12 times (12 x 28 days) then it is said as a matter of
months a year in the calculation. In observations, there are about 29 days and 28 day
in a month, and this can be use to determine the number of days in one year.
The question is whether it is true that one year was equal to 12 months? Are no more
or no less than these numbers?
To answer this question, we must pay attention to the signs of nature that is how the
position between the moon and the sun as seen from the earth in accordance with the
description of God in the surah Yasiin at verse 40 which reads,

“It is not permitted to the Sun to catch up the Moon, nor can the Night outstrip the Day:
Each (just) swims along in (its own) orbit (according to Law). (Q Yassin 36:40) “..
The meaning and the sense of the verse above indicates that as if the moon and sun
move together from the East to the West. Both never precede each other and both
also never collide. Except during a solar eclipse events. Incident solar eclipse is an
event that could provide clues that the position of the sun was far behind the moon
and they do not collide but odds. This means that paths route between the moon and
the sun is different, in accordance with the words " Each (just) swims along in (its own)
orbit (according to Law) ".
The next question is: "Why are there events lunar eclipse or solar eclipse? How many
times have eclipse events in a year at one place?. If we notice and observe in one
place on earth, a position between the moon and sun in a year, so one day in that
year we will see the positions where the moon and the sun is at the closest position.
When it reached the nearest position, ie shortly after the sun and moon together, then
look towards the sun precedes month to sunset, as if the sun to finish first in the West
The next question is: If the rotation of the earth rotates from west to east, should not
the moon that moves faster than the sun movement to the westward because the
sun was very far behind the moon? Imagine when we are in a car that was speeding,
where as if a tree or power pole beside the road seemed to be moving backwards
faster than a mountain far behind that tree. So by logic, should the Sun that are far
away will be preceded by months of moving quickly to the westawed. But we observe
exactly the opposite, that is where the sun was moving more quickly toward his
sunset. How can we explain this phenomenon?
To explain this phenomenon, then we should be able to answer the question; in the
direction where the moon orbits when moving the earth? Whether toward the east or
the west? Even if the months in the sky not orbiting the earth, then surely the moon
seems to move more quickly to the west than the sun as the moon was closer to
Earth. Conversely, if the moon is a satellite of the earth which moves follow the
direction of rotation of the earth, the sun should appear to move more quickly to the
west than the moon. So when we see the Sun move faster ahead in a westerly
direction, then we can infer that the moon moves follow the direction of rotation of the
Earth that is toward the east, while sun Silence in distant places. Because the earth's
rotation toward the east causes the sun is moving faster to sunset.

Which direction the moon orbits the earth? To answer the question of this, so once
again we have to observe natural phenomena " It is not permitted to the Sun to catch
up the Moon, nor can the Night outstrip the Day: Each (just) swims along in (its own)
orbit (according to Law). " Attention during the full moon appears, then mark the
position of the moon in the sky and record again on what time we watched it, and
noticed again the next day or tomorrow that month position at the same hour as
yesterday. So we will see that the moon was like back a few degrees to the east. This
shows that the moon orbits the earth moves eastward. Or place the Earth on the left
(opposite the direction of clockwise rotation). Just imagine when the pilgrims were
performing “Tawaf” around of Kaaba.
So we can conclude that the Earth rotates on its axis as movement pilgrims circling
“Tawaf” area as well as the Moon around the Earth is like the pilgrims around the “
Ka'bah”. In next writing "Revolution Earth" we will discuss about the movement of
Earth around the Sun, according to the Qur'an.
It can be imagined, if Allah SWT give we some satellites or moon to our earth, like the
planet Jupiter has 16 moons. So the calculation time will become more complicated.
Or vice versa if the earth does not have a month like the planet Saturn which only has
a few rings, then the time will be very complicated calculations.
That God with great care verses convey information with grammar and calculating
neatly arranged so that anyone can accept the truth either by obedience and faith in
God is logically thought.
In fact this verse was revealed by God in the 15th Century ago and until now proven
Hopefully this information will be reflections and increase awareness for those who
believe in Allah.

3. Verse 51:47 says the universe is vast and not “expanding”. Dr. Naik is wrong on that.

Rahmahadiq; an atheist named Ali Sina attempts to force changes the meaning of a
word in the AL-Quran. Ali Sina who do not have the correct science attempts to force
changes the words. Though he just fooling his followers and just can impose his will
on his gang alone. Actually, the verse has been discussed in previous topics, but Ali
Sina was very confident to change the minds of Muslims to change the meaning of the
word. Once again , Proved that Ali Sina want to fool the people of Islam, though he is
the fool.
4. The description of water cycle claimed by Muslims as miraculous is incomplete because the
stage of evaporation is missing and what Muhammad has described has been common
knowledge since man became homo sapience. Dr. Naik says verse: 86:11 talks “specifically
about the capacity of heavens to return back rain” i.e. the stage of evaporation. This is clearly
not so. This verse is about the return of the firmament (sun, moon, start) that happens every
24 hours.
Rahmanhadiq; already explained to the a senile man before, that the Quran is not a
book science and technology, but the basic guide book or sign of people to not get
lost in the search for truth. Ali Sina requires a more detailed process of evaporation
stages in the verses of al-qur 'an, complete with terms and technology, in accordance
with the terms that he proposed. Useless man is equipped with a great brain and mind
that God had to intervene to explain how the process of falling rain. Al-Quran only to
deliver the basics and principles of its course, after that man was allowed to prove
themselves. Then Ali Sina's understanding of the verse 86:11 deflect into the earth's
rotation of repeated and again after 24 hours. That's how the capability of Ali Sina to
analyze that paragraph in accordance with shrimp brain.
Verse 86:11 reads:
" ِ ءَ ّ َ اَ و = wasama ‘i , mean “ and (for the sake) the heaven, “
ِ تاَ ذ = zattin , mean “contain substance:, ”
ِ ْ ّ َ ا = al rajj ’ i, mean, “which returns (in its round) or rain, ".
Of course that mean the heaven in this verse is atmosphere of earth, not outer space.
when Ali Sina seen rain in outer space? There's just crazy of thinking of ali Sina. Does
the earth layers containing clouds or rain disappear into outer space? if the water in
the layers of the earth's atmosphere was not back on earth, whether Ali Sina has been
calculated the amount of water on the earth that are still left? Instead, if he does not
understand, then do not make analysis of the strange and absurd..
5. Dr. Naik says verse 21:30 talks about the Big Bang. I showed that this verse is actually about
a pagan mythology.
Rahamanhadiq; Ali Sina deny the truth of verse 21:30 with the analytical thinking
that verse is not intended to prove the Big Bang theory, but he forced his idea that the
verse was a pagan mythology. As for verse 21:30 reads: " Do not the Unbelievers see
that the heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before
we clove them asunder? We made from water every living thing. Will they not then
believe? (Surah 21:30) ". It is evident that Ali Sina is not able to read this verse
correctly. He wanted to fool his followers, but in fact he has make a fool by himself.
The character Ali Sina is compatible with what is presented by the Al-qur'an Following
2:13, which reads;
" When it is said to them: "Believe as the others believe:" They say: "Shall we believe
as the fools believe?" Nay, of a surety they are the fools, but they do not know. (Surah
2:13) ".
He considers all Muslims stupid, but he himself did not realize that he is stupid..
6. Dr. Naik said that Islam is for all mankind. I showed that in verses 6:92 and 42:7 Muhammad
said that he had come for the people of Mecca and its surrounding and in verses 32:03 and
36:6 he said that he was sent to people other than those who had already received divine
guidance. According to these verses Muslims must stop propagating their faith in the Christian
Rahmanhadiq; Actually the verse delivered by Ali Sina has been discussed in great
detail previously. So no need to be discussed more, because it will not change the bad
nature of Ali Sina. People do not need to spread the teachings of Islam to western
people, both Christian and non-religious. But they alone with the consciousness of the
righteousness of Islam unconditionally. Ali Sina is only able to spread hatred and
incitement to prevent individuals from obtaining the truth. So be in vain folly committed
by KSW, because that way then more and more people who accept the true religion of
Islam. .
7. Dr. Naik claims that the Quran says ‘We have created the human beings from ‘the best part of
a whole’. The truth is that the Quran says 32:8 human progeny is made of a ‘despised fluid’
(ma-in maheenin).
Rahmanhadiq; This is a strategy to pit and make a contradiction between a verse by
verse each the other. This verse has been discussed in previous topic, but Ali Sina
remains convey his cunning to slander and destroy the truth of the verses. Ali Sina is
not understood the context of each verse at all, who can see only the words "fluid
despised" course. Because this point is usefull for him to ridicule the verses of Al-
qur'an. He was getting a chance to ruin it, but actually he just can making a monkey
out of himself.
8. Dr. Naik claims that no one knew that skin has pain sensors and everyone used to think that
pain is sensed by brain. That is rubbish. The truth is the reverse. The function of brain in
sensing pain is a recent discovery. Pain was felt where pain was applied. In the old days
people thought the function of brain is to cool down the body like a radiator and heart is the
thinking organ.
Rahmanhadiq; Indirectly Ali Sina agrees with the truth of the above verses, but he
felt ashamed to admit it, because in his soul there is only hatred, so that he forgot
what he was talking about. Verse 4:56 reads " Those who reject our Signs, We shall
soon cast into the Fire: as often as their skins are roasted through, We shall change
them for fresh skins, that they may taste the penalty: for Allah is Exalted in Power,
Wise (Surah 4:56)”. This verse clearly states that the feeling sick is something that is
in the skin. From the results of scientific discovery shows that the brain only as a
memory or as a parameter to determine the pain threshold. If the skin still healthy and
intact, then the pain sensors will remain active and brain still work to measure the
pain. So if Ali Sina burn in hell, then the skin will not be damaged and the pain it will
continue to feel. The first of all go to hell later is Ali Sina is, without calculated the good
deeds at all. .
9. Dr. Naik claims that when the Bible says the world was created in six days it is talking about
24 hours days, while when these same claim was plagiarized by Muhammad and rehashed in
the Quran it suddenly changed its meaning to "periods of time" or "epochs". Why a day in the
Bible and a day in the Quran should be different is something only Dr. Naik knows. Despite
that the universe was not created in epochs.
Rahmanhadiq; ignorance Ali Sina on the paragraph above, are described in detail in
the topic before, so no need to be discussed again because it will not change the bad
nature of Ali Sina.
9. The definition of embryology in the Quran 23:12-14 is wrong. Nutfa (sperm) does not become
embryo (which in the Qur'an is erroneously called Alaqa, a congealed clot of blood). The role
of the female egg in Quranic embryology is missing. And bones are not formed before the
flesh. Just to mention two of several errors in these verses.
Rahmanhadiq; the verse has also been discussed in previous talks. Ali Sina is only
able to deliver his unknowledgeable only. If he did not understand then he went on to
spread his slander and cunning evil. It’s does not need to be discussed again as it
will not change the bad nature of Ali Sina.
10. 10.5, 25.61 and 71.16 say that both the Moon and the Sun are lamps “emitting light”. Dr. Naik
simply lies when he says Nur is reflected light. Nur is direct light and Munir is an object that
emits light not something that reflects light.
Rahmahhadiq; Ali Sina can not diference which is lamp and where the rays of the
description verse. Actually, the verse has been discussed previously. Already
explained that moon and sun are producing rays both called "Nur". So the word "nur"
represents a source of light as well as light reflection, because they both produce
light. But in the description verse 712:16 stated that the sun serves as a lamp or lamps
(ً اَ ِ , sirajaan) this means that the sun is the source of light that can produce "nur" or
light. But the moon is only able to produce "nur" only and not as a source of light. So
it can be concluded that the moon glow as it gets light from the light source is from the
sun that serves as a lamp. Al qur'an already explain this natural phenomenon long
before astronomers proved. So Al-qur'an not tell lies, but Ali Sina is meant to convey
his lies.
11. 18:86 says… ‘Until, when he [Zulqarnain] reached the setting of the sun, he found it set in a
spring of murky water’. Dr. Nail lies when he says this “appeared” to him. If it was only the
appearance then such a thing can appear to anyone, anywhere; why mention Alexander?
Alexander had become a legend and common folks believed that he had conquered the world
from “one end to another”. Only he, who had been to both ends of the world, could have
witnessed this amazing phenomenon of rising and setting the sun in murky waters. These are
the waters/oceans that the ancient folk believed surround the dray land.
Rahmanhadiq; estimated life of the Great Alexander in 315 BC tender, or 2325 years
ago. so if Zulkarnain considered was Alexander the great, then during the 2325
obviously has a lot of changes from land or properties or color of the ocean in an
estuary bay or river of black colored. Because the clause does not specify the location
where sea black color view by Zulkarnain. But Ali Sina wanted to go back to ancient
times with a time machine, to prove the explanation verse above, or want to prove the
truth of the black colored sea after 2325 years have passed. Instead Ali Sina blame
Zulkarnain who see the sun set into the sea, whereas if he saw the sun sink himself
then he like does not feel the existence of a mistake, even all the people who live in
this modern age can still say watch the sunset at sea. Bear witness moments of
sunset at Kuta beach on the island of Bali, of course very beautiful charming. Then a
mad man Ali Sina states that the verse 18:86 states Zulkarnain had to end of the
world. It is clear that Ali Sina has created the statement fake. No information on the
above verses that say that Zulkarnain had to the end of the world in the west and in
the east both.
12. 86.4 implies that stars are protectors of people. This is fairytale.
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina shows again his ignorance after reading the description of
verse 86.4. Whereas 86; 4 verse was not explain that the keeping of each soul is a
star , but suddenly Ali Sina talk the lie news that the star guard of the human soul.
Proved that Ali Sina did cunning again and he never felt ashamed to do the lie
repeatedly. He still feels proud and grinning broadly convey his lies..
13. 86.7 says sperms proceed from between the backbone and the ribs. This is wrong.
Rahmanhadiq; This verse has been discussed in previous topic, so no longer need to
be repeated. because AII Sina would not understood at all and will not change his bad
14. Will people be raised from dead on the Last Day to receive their punishment and rewards
6.36, 7.57, 2.260, 21.21, 30.50, 35.9, 43.11, 72.7, or do they receive it right after their death. ?
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina tried again to convey some verses that do not like by himself.
It will be discussed whether the purpose of ali Sina to convey those verses?
paragraph 6; 36 reads;
"Those who listen (in truth), be sure, will accept: as to the dead, Allah will raise them up;
then will they be turned unto Him. (Surah 6:36)"
This verse is a reality that can not be disagreement by humans. How could the human
corpse or those who are unable to accept the truth explanation can be given truth
values. No need to look for examples that far, samples of the most obvious is Ali Sina
this. He can be a good example of the explanation verse above. Although Ali Sina is
not willing to accept the values of the truth of the verses of the Al-Qur'an, but he could
not refuse his death, and maybe he still does not believe that after death he will be
raised again to account for all actions that have been delivering a lot of lies and berate
to the religious people who he thinks all stupid.
verse 7:57 reads;
"It is He Who sendeth the winds like heralds of glad tidings, going before His mercy:
when they have carried the heavy-laden clouds, We drive them to a land that is dead,
make rain to descend thereon, and produce every kind of harvest therewith: thus shall
We raise up the dead: perchance ye may remember. (QS 7:57). "
Actually, this verse has been discussed in previous topic. so no need to discuss anymore,
because they will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina.
The 2:260 verse reads;
" When Abraham said: "Show me, Lord, how You will raise the dead, " He replied: "Have
you no faith?" He said "Yes, but just to reassure my heart." Allah said, "Take four
birds, draw them to you, and cut their bodies to pieces. Scatter them over the
mountain-tops, then call them back. They will come swiftly to you. Know that Allah is
Mighty, Wise." (Surah 2:260) "
This verse gives a lesson that Abraham could receive a conviction after watching
dead birds that have been cut into pieces to life again with the permission of the
Creator. Of course, Ali Sina is not to receive such evidence, he does not believe in
stories like that, because he does not believe in God. Ali Sina is just believing in God if
has seen with his own eyes. This proves that Ali Sina is not able to use the
intelligence of his brain to understand the incident itself and the death that will be
encountered later. His ability to think new limited material that can be seen. He did not
have a good philosophy in his life, he just brought the teachings of how the method to
convey insults, insult, incitement, and spread slander. That he had his teachings to his
website at www.faithfreedom.org.
21:21 verse is interrelated with a few verses before and after , it is;
“Or have they taken (for worship) gods from the earth who can raise (the dead) 21? If
there were, in the heavens and the earth, other gods besides Allah, there would have
been confusion in both! but glory to Allah, the Lord of the Throne: (High is He) above
what they attribute to Him ! (QS 21:21-22)”
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina incapable of understanding the above verse at all, because
he does not acknowledge the existence of God. Ali Sina confusion to understand the
intent of the verse above, how could God can bring the dead?. it is impossible so he
thought. Yet about the incident herself she did not understand why he suddenly comes
on this earth. but he never booked a place on this earth to his parents before and even
he too sure on that one day he will meet his end, and then parted with all his men and
never come back again. He do not know where the goal after he died. His ability is
only for material gains alone. So many strange things in him that he did not
understand at all. Actually, the above verse is addressed to people like Ali Sina. Ali
Sina is more trust and obedient to the expert than who created the science of the
science or who created this universe. Ali Sina lie the existence of God because he
wanted to use the rest of his life to make all his wishes without rules, then he insult
and abusive God. And he really was, not insulting and demeaning god, but to show
how he insulted and abused himself. So whatever he wants and he gets on this earth
would lost himself because he did not have any power to everything on this earth. So
people are just being arrogant just shows stupidity. Then he invites his disciples to
poke fun, ridicule verses of the Quran and invite the Islamic people to remove the
verses from the book of the Qur'an.
verse 30:50 reads;
" Then contemplate (O man!) the memorials of Allah's Mercy!- how He gives life to the
earth after its death: verily the same will give life to the men who are dead: for He has
power over all things. (Sura 30: 50) ".
The phrase " gives life to the earth after its death " is a phrase that has the intent very
broad and deep of pareble. This sentence could mean that the water can turn all living
beings on the earth's surface. But it also means that before the water created, the
earth is in the form of inanimate objects that no living thing on it. God is able to create
the live on the earth's surface that were previously empty, it is not something difficult
for God to revive a dead person or to destroy the entire universe is on the Day of
Judgement. But Ali Sina does not understand why he must die, and he did not believe
that he will turn on after his death. this is because he does not want responsible all
the resulted at the end of the period. He's not going to live again after his death later,
he did not want to face torture hell fire which is very afraid of it. But he could not resist
death at all. Ali Sina is a small boy, weak creature, but he was very arrogant.
Verse 35.9 reads;
" It is Allah Who sends forth the Winds, so that they raise up the Clouds, and We drive
them to a land that is dead, and revive the earth therewith after its death: even so (will
be) the Resurrection! " (Sura 35:9)
This verse contains a very broad philosophy of life, both in terms of scientific and
spiritual terms. In scientific terms, this verse indicates that in order to distribute the
available water in the ocean then created a process of evaporation of water, then
water will be collected at the Earth's atmosphere. Then the wind blew function and
give away or distribute water that collected in clouds, after that the water will fall
randomly across the surface of the earth, so take palace the rivers, lakes and grow all
the plants and turn on all sorts of creatures living on the surface this earth. Earth that
was once dead shall live again. It makes no sense if God is not able to turn everything
that experienced death. This verse is directed to people like infidel Ali Sina who does
not believe in life after death. At the beginning of a sentence, this verse provides a bid
for a systematic scientific thinking, then at the end of the verse concludes with a
sentence for comparison can be thought of by people who understand the power of
God to all life on this earth. The parable of this paragraph explains that the bodies that
will be raised such as inanimate objects are alive after doused in water. Like
Mushroom fungus that emerged from the soil.
. Paragraph 43.11 reads;
" That sends down (from time to time) rain from the sky in due measure;- and We raise
to life therewith a land that is dead; even so will ye be raised (from the dead);- (Sura
This verse has a philosophy that is very high and wide, both in terms of scientific and
spiritual terms. At the beginning of the verse is given a scientific reason to think
further, and then delivered a sentence at the end of paragraph reflection, to compare
what would happen in the future after the death of living creatures. Overall, this verse
is a causal relationship and the end of the equilibrium value between cause and effect
it. Actually the scientific reason of this verse has been discussed in previous talks, so
no longer need to be repeated because it will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina.
Paragraph 72.7 reads;
" 'True, there were persons among mankind who took shelter with persons among the
Jinns, but they increased them in folly 6. 'And they (came to) think as ye thought, that
Allah would not raise up any one (to Judgment)., (Sura 72:7) "
This verse tells a communion between human beings forecasters with jinn (demon)
who wants to find proof or foretell the coming of an apostle. This verse is addressed to
the soothsayers and the People of the Book who want to know when and where an
apostle was to be born. If the apostles were born in their neighborhood, they feel
proud, but if the apostles were born outside their offspring then they want to be
enemies and if necessary kill the prophet. However, the devil from among the jinn did
not managed to steal information from the angels or the signs of astrology system
they've learned before. As a result they do not realize that the prophet Mohammed
had lived together with them without being aware, the likes of Moses prophet lived
together with Ramses family. Like that the God made a plan that can not be known by
whoever, too. This verse also applies to Ali Sina, because he can not know his fate
later, he was not know when he will die, where he was going to die, how his death,
whether due to illness or maybe a murder or suicide as well, it all can not be predicted
at all. He was very arrogant but he has a lot of weakness as a creature that is not
useful for society.
15. 31:10 says “He set on the earth mountains standing firm, lest it should shake with you”.
Mountains do not stop the earth from shaking with us. It is ludicrous to say if mountains were
not there the earth would have shaken by people walking on it.
Rahmanhadiq ;
Verse 31:10 reads ;
“He created the heavens without any pillars that ye can see; He set on the earth
mountains standing firm, lest it should shake with you; and He scattered through it
beasts of all kinds. We send down rain from the sky, and produce on the earth every kind
of noble creature, in pairs. (QS 31:10) “
Here's how ali Sina concluding paragraph description above. He does not believe that
the mountain can defuse the power of the quake, and then he concluded that where
there is no mountain definitely no earthquakes. That analysis of the information
verses. KSW not be able to use his mind to think more rational and good. He was only
able to use the hatefulness instinct, incitement and cunning to destroy the value of
goodness and truth. In fact this verse was already discussed in previous topic, so no
need to be explained, because the bad will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina.
16. 78:7 says mountains are like tent pegs or stakes. This is false.
Rahmanhadiq ; Ali Sina not believe that the mountains as pegs or as a vibration
dampening system generated by earthquakes. Then he deceive the people to enter
into his house to watch the fight and verbal abuse against Muslims. Ali Sina is not
providing a good method but plunged the people into his sly trap.
17. 78:6 says ‘Have We [1
person] not made the earth an expanse?’ and the verse 20.53 says
"He [3
person] Who has, made for you the earth like a carpet spread out”. 2:22 says the
earth is a bed for you, and the heaven a roof. This is obviously wrong. Neither the earth is like
a bed nor the skies are like roof.
Rahmanadiq ; All the verses are delivered by KSW is a parable and figure of speech which
must be understood with the pattern of good thinking, clean and true. Ali Sina's analyze this
verse with mathematical formulas, so that he could not find results, as a result he made a libel
and incitement and cunning convey. Actually, this verse has been explained in great detail on
previous exposure. So no need to be repeated again because the bad will not change the ugly
nature of Ali Sina.
18. 16:66 says: “And most surely there is a lesson for you in the cattle; We give you to drink of
what is in their bellies -- from betwixt the feces and the blood-- pure milk, easy and agreeable
to swallow for those who drink.” This is rubbish. Milk is not produced from between feces and
blood. This reveals Muhammad's ignorance of anatomy.
Verse 16:66 says:
“And verily in cattle (too) will ye find an instructive sign. From what is within their bodies
between excretions and blood, We produce, for your drink, milk, pure and agreeable to
those who drink it. (QS 16:66)“
Actually, this verse implies a very high value. This verse is a parable of a comparison
between the food value with a halal-haram. This verse is not telling and not explain
where milk production in the body of animals or the formation of milk. The same is
described in verse 86:7 of how semen is emitted between the breastbone and the
sulby. Verse 16:66 has a position that equivalent with verse 86:7, which is about the
properties of the object in question. Verse 16:66 describes the nature of the milk is
removed from the body of animals. As already stipulated in the holy books either AL-
Quran and Bible in the book, that the blood and animal excrement (faces) of fresh
material that is forbidden to eat dirt and even excretions of the body (Faces) or the
blood ‘s menstruation is unclean and should always be cleared from the body. But
Allah issued a fresh fluid directly from the body that kosher (halal) to be eaten that is
the breast milk, however milk is also an ingredient excreted by the body. Even milk is
not mixed at all with blood and dirt of the body, so that milk is a pure material that can
be enjoyed and consumed at any kosher (halal) if desired. For those who think
healthy, will come a question: "Why did God create the milk which is the result of body
waste but lawful and not mixed with blood and dirt. People who think reasonably and
properly be assessed that Allah truly compassionate and most merciful. Had milk also
is prohibited, then that would a lot of human would malnutrition. So it is clear that
verse not told about the place or the process of milk production in the body of animals,
but to explain a thought or a comparison to be grateful by normal human thinking.
Milk is not a drink favored by Ali Sina, he prefers the dirt is excreted by the body such
as blood, menstrual blood, his own feces, saliva and urine itself.
19. 6:38, says that ‘There is not an animal on the earth, nor a being that flies on two wings, but
forms communities like you’. No animal on earth forms communities like that of humans.
Rahmanhadiq ;
Verse 6:38 says ;
“There is not an animal (that lives) on the earth, nor a being that flies on its wings, but
(forms part of) communities like you. Nothing have we omitted from the Book, and they
(all) shall be gathered to their Lord in the end.(QS 6:38)”.
These are the characteristics of the proud and the arrogant boy, he considers that the
animal beings that live in groups among species is not something to be cherished and
protected. Ecology experts and environmentalists have seen and proved that in the
world of animals such as ants, bees, wolves or a group of birds or fish have similar
levels of social life with humans. Although intelligence of animals are not the same as
humans. Social level of the animals remained unchanged from the past until now.
Apparently Ali Sina wanted to fool his followers with the information that he did not
know at all, or maybe he also pretended not to know. Even his pet cat who was
always proud and loved it also has a sense of brotherhood with fellow other cats, but
Ali Sina imprison the cat so the cat is separated from his friends. But at some point the
cat was dead and Ali Sina could not do anything about it so that Ali Sina and his Cat
will be seperated forever. Ali Sina is not able to turn a dead cat or to collect or gather
together in his graves. This proves that Ali Sina is not able to do anything against the
cats even against itself. Conversely verse 6:38 above shows that all human beings
and animal life will return to its creator that is God. Ali Sina does not believe that verse
because he thought he would collect all the animals after he died later. That the minds
of these mentally ill and psychopathic disease.
Milk is not a drink favored by Ali Sina, he prefers his dirt excreted by the body such as
blood, menstrual blood, his own feces, saliva and urine itself
20. 55:19-20 says there is a barrier between two waters “which is forbidden to transgress”. There
is no barrier between any waters. All waters mix.
Rahmanhadiq; Verses 55:19-20 are described in the previous topic and need not be
repeated again because would not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina. Ali Sina imagine
it must be mixed with water as the mixture of lies and chicanery that is in bad
character of Ali Sina.
21. Verses 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, and 25:59 say the universe was created in six days while verses
41:9-12 say it was created in eight days. Then again in 2:117 we are told that “He [3
saith to it: 'Be,' and it is”. These are three different versions of creation – six days, eight days
and instantaneously. At least two of them must be satanic verses. Which ones?
Rahmanhadiq; This verse has also been discussed in previous topic, and no longer
need to be repeated because it will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina..
22. 2:29 says “He [3
person] created for you all that is in the earth. Then turned He to the
heaven, and fashioned it as seven heavens”. This version of creation is anachronous. This is
like saying first the child was born and then the mother. Is this another “miracle of Allah” or
another blunder of Muhammad? The same error is found in 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, 25:59 and 41:9-
Rahmanhadiq; Actually, this verse has been discussed in previous talks, was the
conclusion that there is he in the brain of Ali Sina only shows ignorance and tricky
only. So these verses do not need to be discussed because it will not change the bad
nature of Ali Sina.
23. 79:28-30 contradicts 2:29 and says “He raised its canopy (sky), then He created light and
darkness “and after that He spread the earth”.
Rahmanhadiq ;
Verse 79:28-30 reads;
“On high hath He raised its canopy, and He hath given it order and perfection 28. Its
night doth He endow with darkness, and its splendour doth He bring out (with light) 29.
And the earth, moreover, hath He extended (to a wide expanse) (QS 79:28-30)”;
Verse 2:29 reads;
" It is He Who hath created for you all things that are on earth; Moreover His design
comprehended the heavens, for He gave order and perfection to the seven firmaments;
and of all things He hath perfect knowledge. (Surah 2:29)"
The sentence " He raised its canopy, and He hath given it order and perfection " gives
clues that the universe will continue raise and will continue to be refined and the
appropriate sentence statement with scientific discovery in the field of astronomy from
the Big Bang theory. While the phrase " Its night doth He endow with darkness, and its
splendour doth He bring out (with light) " provide clues that light and darkness created
by Allah, The meaning of light and darkness of this paragraph is due to the rotation of
the earth. Al-Quran has given instructions with a sentence that is very wise, in the
form of a parable that can understood by a layman and can also be thought of by
people who want to understand the parable. While the verse 2:29 is more emphasis
on God's will to maintain and manage this universe continuously without stopping. The
meaning of seven heavens is the entire universe. While the phrase " Moreover His
design comprehended the heavens " is a figurative sentence that shows that God
governs the whole universe from an unknown place by anyone. Both verses are
considered a contradiction by Ali Sina, it was mutually reinforcing and complementary.
Ali Sina analyze sentence imagery with a sense of hatred and incitement, so he did
not get the slightest light to see the truth..
24. 21:30 says “heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before We
person] clove them asunder?” But 41:11 says “Then He [3
person] directed Himself to the
heaven and it is a vapor, so He said to it and to the earth: Come both, willingly or unwillingly.
They both said: We come willingly.” So were the heaven and earth joined originally and Allah
separated them or where they separated and Allah joined them? There is a contradiction. One
of them must be a satanic verse. Which one?
Rahmanhadiq; Between verse by verse 41:11 21:30 mutually reinforcing and
complementary. As already discussed in previous topic, that verse 21: 30 is a parable
or metaphor sentence that shows that this universe is a unity at first and then
experiencing separation. While paragraph 41; 11 also is a figurative words or parables
that give clues that before the earth formed, the universe is still a smoke. After that the
earth was created with the sentence parable too "" Come both, willingly or unwillingly.
They both said: We come willingly " which given the guidance that all system created in
preformance in balance and under control or the system has been created by the
inventor. So there is nothing contrary of both verses, the two are complementary and
mutually reinforcing. The misunderstanding of al-qur’an verses by KSWi made thoses
material as mock-burlesque.
25. 65.12 says "Allah is He Who created seven Firmaments and of the earth a similar number".
This is false. Neither the sky nor the Earth are made of seven layers.
Verse 65:12 says 'It is Allah Who created the seven heavens and the earth that way.' This is
wrong, both heaven and earth is made of seven layers. Paragraph above also assumed that
the heavens and earth have their own will and to obey or to rebel against the command of
god. It's great for fairy children but not science. Same paragraph also anachronistic. How can
the creation of plants and animals preceded the unification of heaven and earth? Dr. Naik by
clever see mistakes in the bible who say the creation of plants preceded the creation of the
sun. But he failed to see the exact same error in the Quran. If the bible wrong on this point, a
total replica of the Koran as well.
Rahmanhadiq; analysis and conclusions of Ali Sina on the verse 65:12, indicates that
he belonged to the devil who oppose the grace of God. He did not fill his brain with the
ability to goodness think, but seeded of hatred everywhere, so he lost direction
analyze the paragraph above. As already mentioned before that the sky is the seventh
in that paragraph is not only a layer of earth or atmosphere but also all the universe.
As already known that a layer of earth's atmosphere consists of 7 layers including; 1)
Troposphere which is the layer closest to the surface of the earth's atmosphere, (2)
Stratosphere, (3) Ozone layer that contain ozone to absorb UV rays from the sun, (4)
Mesosphere , (5) thermosphere, (6) ionosphere, and (7) Exosphere. Meanwhile, about
the universe, amounting to 7 heavens has not yet been touched by astrologers. Then
the entire universe be submissive and obedient to the conditions set by the creator to
them. Except Ali Sina, who is the accursed Satan, that punishment for him being
suspended. Paragraph above are not talking about the creation of animal or plant like
the one in the mind of this Ali Sina. Ali Sina's interpretation was far out of the
paragraph above, so he makes a ridiculous story as opposed to verse. In his
ignorance, and then he accuses that Dr. Naik is stupid and tell lies..
26. Paragraph 41.12 says 'And We adorned the sky close to the light' It's clear allusion to the star.
Dg weigh the earth as a base, such as who made the Quran, is the lowest layer of the star
from the sky as the sun, moon and other planets in the solar system is on it?
Rahmanhadiq; This is nonsense from ali Sina’s analyst to parable in the verse above.
Once again proves that Ali Sina did not understand at all with the intention of the
parable. Then he makes a story that has nothing to do with the verse. Please note that
the root words or names to the word "star" there is more one texts listed in the Al-
qur'an. Not like the word of “ِ ضْرا = ardha, earth” or “ َ ْ ّ َ ا = syamsa, sun “, or
“َ َ َ ْ ا = qamara, moon”. The word of “star” in Al-qur’an have several text , such as ;
“َ مُ ّ ُ ا = nujuma , star “ or “ ً َ آَْ آ = kaukaban , star “ or “ ً وُ ُ = burujjan , the group
of stars “. In the case that the word of “star” have more one meaning in Al Qur’an
verses. Questions should be asked is: why the words "star" is present in several
texts? Is the diffirent text of star in Al-qur’an would give the diffirent set of meaning?
To answer that question, human need 14 centuries to be able to understand. It turns
out the word that the “star” can not be interpreted with one word, because that
luminous star looked from Earth is not one type, but consists of a variety of names.
Among the name or type of star that is; galaxy, comet, planets, meteor or an other
light. All kinds of stars produce the visible light that resulting in the same light from the
earth, so that in ancient times, these celestial bodies so-called the star. At the time the
Qur'an was revealed, no one person who can tell which is the galaxy, which ones and
where also the sun, another planet or even a meteor. The words of the star can be
interpreted as a planet, can also be a galaxy, comet or other suns. And then the word
of “star” is a metaphor words.
However, the “Star” in 41:12 verse, itself interpreted from figure of speech or words
that follow something of the word "sky" or something that follows the word ", light", but
not from the sun or the moon. So no the word of “star” in the 41:12 verse. The
definition of a nearby shining on the verse 41:12 is the nearest planet from Earth that
also produce light similar to the star. It was a venus plenet which has the closest
position to Earth. The planet Venus is often called the Morning Star because they
produce very bright light at the east before the dawn. Verse of 41; 12 does not explain
about the layers of the 7 heavens, but Ali Sina have been presumptuous to conclude
that paragraph as layer of 7 sky. And the verse does not state that the star is the
lowest layer of the heaven, followed layer straight down the sun, moon and other
planets respectively. But those statement become from Phytagoras and Ariestatoles
postulat that explained before, not from Al-qur’an verses. KSW tell a lie again. Ali
Sina like a madman who are dreaming to get a fallen star.
27. Verses 22:47 and 32:5 say that one day God equal to 1,000 human years, but the verse 70:4
says that one day God the same as 50,000 years.
Rahamanhadiq; This verse has been explained and discussed in the other topic and
do not need to be repeated again because the will not change the ugly nature of Ai
28. Verse 65:12 says 'God (third person pronoun) He created the seven heavens and the earth
that way.' This is the mythology rather than science.
Rahmanhadiq ; Actually, this verse has been explained in previous discussions, but
Ali Sina, who was senile still did not understand at all..
29. 13.2 says “Allah [3
person] is He Who raised the heavens without any pillars that ye can
see” and 31.10 repeats the same absurdity. 22:65 says “He [3
person] withholds the sky
from falling on the earth except by His leave.” Clearly Muhammad thought sky is a ceiling that
can fall on earth and it is a miracles that it does not fall.
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina is still not understood about the parable of the above
sentence, so he was intrigued with the understanding that paragraph. Then he
imagine that the sky is not piled as high dome shape that is surrounded by smoke and
the stars. Thus if people who are mentally ill were talk by the spells that is not
understood. Actually, this verse has been discussed in a topic previously, need to be
repeated because it will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina..
30. 54:19 says Allah destroyed the people of Aad in a day. 41:16 says it was days (three or
more) 69:7 specifies seven nights and eight days in succession? At least two of these
versions must be satanic verses.
Rahmanhadiq; The News submitted by Ali Sina is the reversal of facts. This verse
has been discussed in earlier talks and is not necessary anymore, because it will
change the ugly nature of Ali Sina..
31. At the Last Judgment, people are divided into three groups 56:7 or two groups 90:18-19,
99:6-8 ?
Rahmanhadiq; This verse has also been described in previous topic, and need not be
repeated because will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina.
32. Who takes the souls at death: The Angel of Death 32:11, THE angels (plural) 47:27 or Allah
Rahmanhadiq; This verse already discussed in the past and will not be repeated
because it will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina.
33. How many angels announced the birth of Jesus to the Virgin Mary? One angel 19:17-21 or
several angels 3:42-45?
Rahmanhadiq ; This verse has also been discussed at the last topic and need not be
repeated because it will not change the ugly nature of Ali Sina.
34. Who was the first Muslim? Muhammad 6:14,163, Moses 7:143, some Egyptians 26:51,
Abraham 2:127-133, 3:67 or was it Adam 2:37?
Rahmnhadiq ;
verse 6:14 reads ;
“ Say: "Shall I take for my protector any other than Allah, the Maker of the heavens and
the earth? And He it is that feedeth but is not fed." Say: "Nay! but I am commanded to
be the first of those who bow to Allah (in Islam), and be not thou of the company of
those who join gods with Allah." "(Surah 6:14)
The words " to be the first of those who bow to Allah " is a metaphor words rather
than sentences comparison to the first people who converted to Islam. This verse is
one of the pillars of prayer which should be read in the beginning of Muslim prayers. If
this verse read by every Muslim, whether this means that very many Muslims who first
became a Muslim? the intent of the words " to be the first of those who bow to Allah "
is "no doubt and I take place a Islam".
6:163 paragraph reads;
" No partner hath He: this am I commanded, and I am the first of those who bow to His
will. " (Sura 6:163) "
This verse was the same editorial with verse 6:14 where the words "first" is not a
sentence of comparisons from people who converted to Islam, but is "really believe
and live in Islam “. Actually Ali Sina want to lie his own followers. Sina's eyebrows
consequently must bear the sins of lying that conveyed to incite.
Qs 7:143 paragraph reads;
" When Moses came to the place appointed by Us, and his Lord addressed him, He said:
"O my Lord! show (Thyself) to me, that I may look upon thee." Allah said: "By no means
canst thou see Me (direct); But look upon the mount; if it abide in its place, then shalt
thou see Me." When his Lord manifested His glory on the Mount, He made it as dust. And
Moses fell down in a swoon. When he recovered his senses he said: "Glory be to Thee! to
Thee I turn in repentance, and I am the first to believe." (Surah 7:143)
The phrase " I am the first to believe " here does not mean a sentence comparison
from someone who first convert to Islam, but an adjective that means "direct" or "no
doubt". Evident bring Ali Sina does not understand the verses of Al-qur’an at all, which
is in the mind are just lies and cunning. He's not want the green fly running away from
a foul mouth odor.
35. The food for the people in Hell will be only "Dhari" 88:6, only foul pus from the
washing of wounds 69:36, or will they also get to eat from the tree of Zaqqum 37:62-
88:1-6 verse reads;
“Has the story reached thee of the overwhelming (Event) 1? Some faces, that Day, will
be humiliated 2, Labouring (hard), weary, 3- The while they enter the Blazing Fire, 4-
The while they are given, to drink, of a boiling hot spring 5, No food will there be for
them but a bitter Dhari' ( Qs.88: 1-6)”
Context of this paragraph indicate that the people who are in the country Hell do
activities such as life on earth first. They work and trying to keep his situation from the
atmosphere of a sad and tormented. But they do not have a choice to get out of the
country, there are a variety of food, but they suffer from it when eating it. Ali Sina was
actually very scared to read this paragraph that addressed to the demon named Ali
Sina this.
Verse of Q69.36-37 reads ;
"Nor hath he any food except the corruption from the washing of wounds 36, "Which
none do eat but those in sin." (QS 69 - :36-37)”
This verse describes the instructions that in other parts of the country Hell no food at
all, except for blood and pus subsituter of porridge and drinking water.
verse Q37 :63-67-rings;
" For We have truly made it (as) a trial for the wrong-doers 63. For it is a tree that
springs out of the bottom of Hell-Fire 64: The shoots of its fruit-stalks are like the
heads of devils 65: Truly they will eat thereof and fill their bellies therewith66. Then on
top of that they will be given a mixture made of boiling water.( QS 37:63-67) "
This verse hints that somewhere in hell the other, there is a dense tree fruit. The tree
was named by Zaqqum trees that looks very scary, very tall trees that towered from
the bottom of the hell. Only a tree that's as basic materials that can be consumed by
the population there. But they are not able to restrain themselves from hunger,
because there is no other choice. After eating the fruit that they feel very thirsty, but
there is only drinking water is very hot.
So there is nothing contradictory from verses that accused by the lier devil, all the
verses are mutually and complement each other.
36. 2:221 says “Do not marry unbelieving women (idolaters), until they believe”. 9:30
makes it clear that Jews and Christians are unbelievers, have deluded away and
“Allah's [3
person] curse be on them”. And yet 5:5 says it is lawful to marry women of
the People of the Book .
Rahmanhadiq ;
The 2:221 verse reads;
" Do not marry unbelieving women (idolaters), until they believe: A slave woman who
believes is better than an unbelieving woman, even though she allures you. Nor marry
(your girls) to unbelievers until they believe: A man slave who believes is better than an
unbeliever, even though he allures you. Unbelievers do (but) beckon you to the Fire. But
Allah beckons by His Grace to the Garden (of bliss) and forgiveness, and makes His Signs
clear to mankind: That they may celebrate His praise.(.Qs.2: 221)”
This verse clearly forbids people of faith (Islam) is married to unbelievers or infidels.
This provision applies both to themselves and to the parents or guardians who marry
them. Unless they have faith before marriage. This means that the believer can only
be married to believers and unbelievers vice versa, with the Gentiles. The reason is
because those who disbelieve will drop the faithful along with their children so that
they will be losers in the hereafter will be. So before already better cancel it. A believer
is more noble side.
while the verses 9:28-30 reads;
" O ye who believe! Truly the Pagans are unclean; so let them not, after this year of
theirs, approach the Sacred Mosque. And if ye fear poverty, soon will Allah enrich you, if
He wills, out of His bounty, for Allah is All-knowing, All-wise 28. Fight those who believe
not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by
Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the
People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves
subdued 29. The Jews call 'Uzair a son of Allah, and the Christians call Christ the son of
Allah. That is a saying from their mouth; (in this) they but imitate what the unbelievers
of old used to say. Allah's curse be on them: how they are deluded away from the Truth
30! They take their priests and their anchorites to be their lords in derogation of Allah,
and (they take as their Lord) Christ the son of Mary; yet they were commanded to
worship but One Allah: there is no god but He. Praise and glory to Him: (Far is He) from
having the partners they associate (with Him) 31. Fain would they extinguish Allah's light
with their mouths, but Allah will not allow but that His light should be perfected, even
though the Unbelievers may detest (it) 32. It is He Who hath sent His Messenger with
guidance and the Religion of Truth, to proclaim it over all religion, even though the
Pagans may detest (it).( Qs 9:28-33) "
Context of this verse tells of the provisions of God to Muhammad when planning a
peace agreement proposed by the infidels of Mecca quraisy. When the unbelievers
quraisy offers living in harmony together, worship together and prosper together in
Masjidilharam. But God forbid togetherness in this way, although they promised to
assist the glory of the Kaaba. God instructed Muhammad to continue made every
effort to defend the city of Mecca as a center of Islamic teachings. God requires that
Muhammad held the city of Mecca and make the Muslims are superior to those who
disbelieve. After that all forms of idolatrous temple that smells or acts that are
prohibited (haram) can no longer in the Masjidilharam until now. This verse also
explains nature unbelievers who think God has a child from a class of Jews and
Christian, even they worship and pray in the name of Jesus. Both these groups have
actually been disbelieved and their disbelief continues, even the Christians have to
spread it to the whole world. To prevent the infedel against those who do not
understand, God again sent a messenger. The teachings spread by the infidels that
will ruin the next generation. The apostle sent by God it was Muhammad who came to
bring the truth in the verses of the Qor’an. The conclusions and opinions are
expressed by the mouth of unbelievers that God is childless and the child god was
also right to be worshiped, is a misdirection and they tried to extinguish the light of
God. Truth in the Qur'an will be proved.
5:5 verse reads;
“This day are (all) things good and pure made lawful unto you. The food of the People of
the Book is lawful unto you and yours is lawful unto them. (Lawful unto you in marriage)
are (not only) chaste women who are believers, but chaste women among the People of
the Book, revealed before your time,- when ye give them their due dowers, and desire
chastity, not lewdness, nor secret intrigues if any one rejects faith, fruitless is his work,
and in the Hereafter he will be in the ranks of those who have lost (all spiritual good). (qs
5:5). "
The context explains about the harmony of the people who have been given
instructions by God through His book and they run it with the provisions of the Book in
truth. They believe in Allah, they do not shirk or associating partners with God with
others. They are a small part of the followers of Prophet Moses and Prophet Jesus, who still fight for
tawheed religion, so that they are lawful wedlock among them is the religion willing by God
37. 9:17 and 9:69 say the good deeds of unbelievers will not be rewarded. Yet 99:7
promises “whoso doeth good an atom's weight will see it”. 2:62 promises rewards for
Christians and Jews. But then again the Quran says they are blasphemers 5:17, 72-
73, have deluded away from the truth, are unbelievers and curse of Allah be on them
Rahmandiq ;
Back Ali Sina takes a few verses in order to pit Muslims and Christian peoples.
verse 9:17 reads;
" It is not for such as join gods with Allah, to visit or maintain the mosques of Allah while
they witness against their own souls to infidelity. The works of such bear no fruit: In
Fire shall they dwell17. The mosques of Allah shall be visited and maintained by such as
believe in Allah and the Last Day, establish regular prayers, and practise regular charity,
and fear none (at all) except Allah. It is they who are expected to be on true
guidance.Qs.9: 17 -18)”
The context of this verse actually strengthen the statement in verse Sura 9:28, as
already noted earlier. It is logically impossible that disbelievers and polytheists prosper
and glorify the mosque and its congregation. Something of impossible. Even if there
are groups of disbelievers pretend to do good by helping to build a mosque, then his
deeds will be in vain in the sight of Allah. In this verse Allah knows that only the pious
and do good works that can glorify God's house.
Paragraph 9: 68-69 reads;
" The Hypocrites, men and women, (have an understanding) with each other: They enjoin
evil, and forbid what is just, and are close with their hands. They have forgotten Allah;
so He hath forgotten them. Verily the Hypocrites are rebellious and perverse 67. Allah
hath promised the Hypocrites men and women, and the rejecters, of Faith, the fire of
Hell: Therein shall they dwell: Sufficient is it for them: for them is the curse of Allah,
and an enduring punishment, 68- As in the case of those before you: they were mightier
than you in power, and more flourishing in wealth and children. They had their enjoyment
of their portion: and ye have of yours, as did those before you; and ye indulge in idle talk
as they did. They!- their work are fruitless in this world and in the Hereafter, and they
will lose (all spiritual good). (qs 9:68-69) "
This verse again reinforce the previous paragraph, which explains the hypocrites of
the unbelievers who will plan nefarious deeds behind their good performance.
Because they justify all the way to achieving its mission. Why do people believe so
just trust the people who are always being hypocritical?, Despite ostensibly for their
unjust deeds and forbid them from doing good and godly. Among the hypocrites, will
make a plan and conspiracy to bend the faith of Muslims. Although most Muslim
people do not know, but God knows everything and God's actions threaten them with
a very painful punishment in the next. In verse 69, gives an indication that believers
should not feel pessimistic because of the wealth and progress made hypocrites
because God has also given an equal share to the faithful once. And do not slander
believers do as was done by hypocrite peoples.
while the verse 99:5-7 reads;
" For that thy Lord will have given her inspiration5. On that Day will men proceed in
companies sorted out, to be shown the deeds that they (had done) 6. Then shall anyone
who has done an atom's weight of good, see it 7! (Sura 99:5-7)”
This verse describes the resurrection of the dead, like a fungus growing from their
grave. Each person will be unable to hide his crime at all. Everything will be disclosed
and taken into account. The Error of Ali Sina has been piling up so much, so he had
ridden by his own wickedness. But Ali Sina never realized the error at all, so he never
experienced remission of sins or apologize by the Lord. While there are no good deed
at all and has no value because he is opposed to God and the truth proclaimed by the
verse 2:62 reads;
" Those who believe (in the Qur'an), and those who follow the Jewish (scriptures), and
the Christians and the Sabians,- any who believe in Allah and the Last Day, and work
righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord; on them shall be no fear, nor shall
they grieve. "(qs 2:62)"
Actually this verse is out of the topics discussed by DR Naik, but even so, needs to be
explained also to humans who have the instigator of this hobby, so he does not
spread slander everywhere. Actually, these verses apply to all human being by equal
rights to be treated fairly in considering all the charity worship. The meaning of the
verse is the adherents of the teachings of Tawheed which do not shirk in his religion
according to what has been delivered by their prophets.
verse 5:17 reads;
“In blasphemy indeed are those that say that Allah is Christ the son of Mary. Say: "Who
then hath the least power against Allah, if His will were to destroy Christ the son of
Mary, his mother, and all every - one that is on the earth? For to Allah belongeth the
dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all that is between. He createth what He
pleaseth. For Allah hath power over all things.". (Q Surah 5:17) "
This verse gives an indication that the prophet Jesus Christ never said that he is God
to be worshiped by the disciples of or by his followers. Even within the Bible there is
no direct statement from Jesus that he is a god who must be worshiped. But the
conclusion was based on the interpretation or analysis and opinions that
codetermination by presbytery in the simenary at “the Creed of Nicea”, Mei-20, 325
AD. And they know that the book of the Bible is not a book that taste of Jesus but of
many writers in it. So those who make the conclusion is called an infidel in AL Qur’an
verses. They have made their opinions, analysis and conclusions are incorrect and
inciting others to do what they want.
Although Al Quran verse does not mention specifically of the events at Nicaea, but
claims the verse does not lie and prove that these historical events actually happened.
The people who decide or are concluded at the seminary can be categorized as an
object of the verse 5:17. So the Qur'an does not tell a lie about the incident. The
people who decide or are concluded at the seminary that is meant by the verse as
infidels who has taught courses that are not true. They make opinions, analysis and
conclusions are far deviated from the teachings of Jesus which problems does, then
get someone else to do what they want. AL Quran it as a class called infidels, just like
Ali Sina who always spread false news and inciting the people who do not understand.
Paragraph 5: 72-73 reads;
'" They do blaspheme who say: "Allah is Christ the son of Mary." But said Christ: "O
Children of Israel! worship Allah, my Lord and your Lord." Whoever joins other gods with
Allah,- Allah will forbid him the garden, and the Fire will be his abode. There will for the
wrong-doers be no one to help 72. They do blaspheme who say: Allah is one of three in a
Trinity: for there is no god except One Allah. If they desist not from their word (of
blasphemy), verily a grievous penalty will befall the blasphemers among them. (Sura 5:72-
73) "
This verse is to strengthen and complement the information paragraph 5:17 above.
This verse explains that Jesus ordered his disciples to worship God not making a God,
even Jesus threatened them with the torment of hell if sin is shirk. And in the next
verse is more clear that the people who have changed courses Yesus and make
Jesus as Lord, then they are forbidden entry into the heaven of God in the next. They
are infidels together with Ali Sina, who always opposed, hostile and insulting to Allah
and His Apostle .
38. Contradictory teachings: On wine and intoxicant drinks.
a) “You obtain from them intoxication (sakaran) and goodly provision.” 16:67 = It is
Rahmnhadiq ;
verse 16:67 reads;
" And from the fruit of the date-palm and the vine, ye get out wholesome drink and food:
behold, in this also is a sign for those who are wise. (Qur'an 16:67)"
This verse tells about the good side and bad side of grapes. The whole of this century
man will know the truth and not a man denied that verse , except for human instigator
named Ali Sina is because he did not want to leave the habit of drunk with the wine.
Only someone who has a good mind that can utilize the wine for health not to damage

b) “Do not go near prayer when you are intoxicated (sukara) until you know (well)
what you say,” 4:43 = stay away from booze when you want to pray
Rahmanhadiq ;
verse 4:43 reads;
" O ye who believe! Approach not prayers with a mind befogged, until ye can understand
all that ye say,- nor in a state of ceremonial impurity (Except when travelling on the
road), until after washing your whole body. If ye are ill, or on a journey, or one of you
cometh from offices of nature, or ye have been in contact with women, and ye find no
water, then take for yourselves clean sand or earth, and rub therewith your faces and
hands. For Allah doth blot out sins and forgive again and again. (Sura 4:43) “
This verse is very clear and strictly prohibit people who are drunk to pray with a logical
reason. But Ali Sina change that paragraph to be "allowed to get drunk and do not
pray" so that Ali Sina comprehend and make inferences from the verses of the Qur'an
for his personal interests and needs also to his followers.

c) “They ask thee concerning wine (al-khamri) and gambling. Say: "In them is great
sin, and some profit, for men; but the sin is greater than the profit." 2:219 = It can be
both good and bad but it is more bad than good.
Rahmanhadiq ;
2:219 paragraph reads;
" They ask thee concerning wine and gambling. Say: "In them is great sin, and some
profit, for men; but the sin is greater than the profit." They ask thee how much they are
to spend; Say: "What is beyond your needs." Thus doth Allah Make clear to you His
Signs: In order that ye may consider- (Q Sura 2:219)"
Subsection above truth value can not be denied anymore. Everyone in this millenium
century knowing that in wine there is content the alcohol high enough that can
damage to brain tissue. Alcohol is what is drunk and causes material damage sociality
dan civilization. All doctors agree that alcohol causes damage in the brain tissue.
However the field of chemical materials alcohol is a material very much usefully, even
this case can not be denied by anyone. So usefulness or damage caused by alcohol
depends on the purpose usage. Man who live in a subtropical city still use some
alcohol to warm the body but not to drunkenness. Not only syriah law in the Qur'an
that prohibits drinking alcohol, even more democratic state forbid its citizens to drink
alcoholic beverages caused destructive body. But Ali Sina took the verse to his
advantage because drinks alcohol and even then there is value even though it's good
to drink until drunk. That's how Ali Sina’s analysis provisions of sharia law to ridicule

d) “O ye who believe! Intoxicants (al-khamru) and gambling, (dedication of) stones,
and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,- of satan’s handwork: eschew such
(abomination), that ye may prosper. 5:90-91=completely bad.
Are all these verses from the same god? How come something that was first “a goodly
provision” became an abomination and Satan’s handwork ?
Rahmanhadiq ;
Verses 5:90-91 reads ;
“O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by)
arrows, are an abomination,- of Satan's handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye
may prosper 90. Satan's plan is (but) to excite enmity and hatred between you, with
intoxicants and gambling, and hinder you from the remembrance of Allah, and from
prayer: will ye not then abstain? (QS 5:90-91)”
Verses 5:90-91 it places an equal footing between the gamble, the ritual of offering
sacrifices to idols, play the guessing game with the arrow keys to try his fortune and
other nefarious deeds with deeds drunkenness. So what is meant by drunkenness
here is an act which is equivalent to other heinous mentioned in these verses 5:90-
91. the word "drunk" here is a parable says that means doing bad deeds for
destructive themself and to the others, as valuable as any other heinous act as
explained by the verse 5:90-91. Proved that Ali Sina do not know the meaning of the
verse properly, because he was not able to distinguish the value of good and evil. Ali
Sina’s mind are all kinds of crimes, so he's blind to what was taught to him. The
farmers get value from the sale of wine for the purpose of healthy body because many
contain vitamin C and antioxidant when eaten fresh. That is what is meant by given
provision is good. On the contrary a factory owners produce wine for sale at the
drunks in the discotheque and the people who are addicted, this is what purposed with
the deeds of the hated and evil deeds. But Ali Sina and his followers feel proud
drunkenness because he did not have any rules and teachings in his life.

I stop here. It is easy for me to show 1000 errors only in the Quran and thousands
more ridiculous tales in the hadith. Remember what Dr. Naik said: All we need to
prove it is not from God is one error. If he can't answer to all of them, it means the
Quran is not a book of revelations. However, he won't even be able to answer to
ONE of them.
Rahmahadiq; Ali Sina felt easily convey 1000 reasons to dismantle Al-qur 'an falsehoods,
but it conveys that is a lie at all. He did not understand at all with the verses of the Qur'an
and then submit his stupidity to the people who do not know, then revealed all the cunning
that done. Ali Sina does not have the slightest knowledge about the verses of the Qur'an,
except the information it collects from his editorial staff without studying properly. And then
He process the information that not true to a concoction of vile slander and incitement. Ali
Sina does not have a good philosophy in life, this can be seen from the way he twists the
truth to slander and lies. Cunning, Lies, Hate, Incitement, Defamation, Scolding and ways to
insult was a daily menu for Ali Sina and his followers. It can be seen on his website at ;
http://www.faithfreedom.org. This site is the site most heinous ever in the world. Ali Sina is
showing he is happy to bring a new religion and make it as a prophet to the teachings of the
most unethical on this earth. Of course Ali Sina felt proud of his new doctrine, because this
teaching has never been applied by previous civilized nations. However, if Ali Sina’s
teachings was the good doctrination, please indicated the Ali Sina’s indoctrination for 10
teaching or 10 verses only, that usefulness for all human being in the world .

In the rebuttal part Dr. Campbell said:
"Well Dr. Naik has brought up some real problems - And there are also these problems that he has
said. I do not deny them. and I don’t have good answers Ior them."
This admission made the Muslim audience extremely happy and they clapped with ioy.
Why would Dr. Campbell say such a thing? It is because Dr. Campbell is an honest man. He does not
have an answer to the errors that exist in the Bible and he is not going to twist the truth and lie. The
Bible is Iull oI errors. But as I explained. those errors do not diminish the value oI its core message.
Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina considers himself as a jury to determine the losing and winning side,
but he was not a Christian nor a Muslim, he was an enemy of Christianity and also enemies
of islam. Ali Sina does not understand at all with Christian teachings especially the teachings
of Islam. On the contrary he wants to teach how to fight each other in ways blasphemy and
berate each other in that site. Ali Sina does not qualify as a judge, but as a loser who should
be thrown into the fire of hell. Ali Sina is concerned nothing to debate of Dr. Campbell and Dr.
Naik, but suddenly he appeared screaming like to be a fair juror, when in fact he want to pit
on both sides.
Then Dr. Naik took the microphone and triumphantly reminded his audience that Dr. Campbell
answered to only two oI the 20 criticisms that he brought against the Bible. "Dr. William Campbell did
not reply to my 20 points," boasted Dr. Naik. "and he started speaking about ‘Prophesy.’ What has
‘Prophesy’ to do with ‘Science in the Bible.’"?..."Dr. William Campbell cannot understand the Qur’an
- That does not mean, Qur’an is wrong."
Rahmanhadiq; re-Ali Sina throw circumvention deceptively to incite and pitting between
Muslims and Christians. Though the event had been arranged by protocol so orderly. So not
true when Dr. Naik accused had grabbed the microphone to deliver his victory. There are no
winners and no losers in the debate. The winning is the truth value itself and the value of
falsity itself. Each audience already have the answer themselves. Ali Sina saw the debate in
terms of hatred and incitement alone, so he feels as a judge to decide his case.
As I showed in this paper. the one who does not understand the Quran. and has even a lesser
understanding oI science is Dr. Naik. Dr. Naik's answers to the criticisms brought against the Quran
are all wrong. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina who do not understand the verses al quran and Ali
Sina are atheists, provides conclusions and a statement that Dr Naik did not understand the
book of al Quran itself. Weird. Ali Sina statement is tantamount to saying that a patient who
does not understood by his own words. A crazy man)
Both Dr. Campbell and Dr. Nail presented their arguments masterIully and with great erudition. Dr.
Naik Iurthermore impressed his audience by reading the Quranic verses Irom memory. But his skill in
memorizing verses oI the Quran should not be mistaken as the truth oI his argument. As I said. Dr.
Naik is a great magician and he is good at what he does. But what he does is not true. He has mastered
the art oI deception. Both speakers were right when they pointed out to the errors and absurdities
contained in the holy book oI the other. However. Dr. Campbell. in my view is the winner oI this
debate. That is because Dr. Campbell proved to be an honest man. a true scholar. He knows the
diIIerence between truth and Ialsehood. He is not willing to IalsiIy the truth iust to win the debate.
When he was shown the errors oI the Bible. he did not try to lie and present lame apologias or twist
the meaning oI the words as Dr. Naik oIten did. He simply said I don't have good answers Ior them.
This quality has endeared him to me and I have utmost respect Ior Dr. Campbell.
Rahmanhadiq; a man who posing a jury. Want to give an evaluation. Ali Sina states that
both parties really has shown his ability to dismantle their errors books each, and Ali Sina
feel very proud and laugh to see that both fighters were equally battered. This is a part of joy
from a person who is suffering from psychopathic illness. But when there are participants
who expressed cheerful applauded for the accuracy delivered by Dr Naik, suddenly he
becoming sick of this vicious teeth, recurrent allergic disease, he really did not like seeing
people happy to receive word of truth. Ali Sina said that Dr. Naik been doing science magic in
front of the participants with his ability to memorize the verses of the Qur'an. Then Ali Sina
praised the attitude to DR Campbell of an honest look at truth and falsehood in the book of
the Bible, instead he accused DR Naik has committed fraud with the verses of the Qur'an is
memorized by it. Ali Sina accused that Dr Naik has been carry out the fraud because Ali Sina
considers that he is more aware and understand the verses of the Qur'an than Dr Naik. It
was strange and funny once the KSW’s statement, where is he studied the Al Qur’an verses
?, with the result of an extremely embarrassing?. In fact already evidenced from the above
analysis that he was not able to read the text al qur'an at all, then he was going to allege that
Dr Naik had committed fraud. Yet all who submitted Ali Sina's rebuttal on this book only
shows his ignorance, so he's a lot convey lies, cunning and even damage the verses of the
Quran. This proves that Ali Sina is not a monster or human but satan figure in disguise as
UnIortunately I can't say the same about Dr. Naik. Dr. Naik did not come across as an honest person.
He attacked the Bible Ior the same errors that exists also in the Quran. This was like a pot calling a
kettle black. That is intellectual dishonesty.
Unlike his opponent. when the errors oI the Quran were presented to him. Dr. Naik denied the
obvious. He even tried to give completely new meanings to common words such as nur (light) which
he said means "borrowed light". wajada, (Iound) which he said means "appeared to him". ysbahun
(Iollows its orbit). which he said means rotating around its own axis. museoon (vast). which he said
means expanding. sama (sky/heaven). which he said means rain. etc.
I know Dr. Naik will not respond to this paper. But iI any Muslim can. I would be glad to hear Irom
Rahmanhadiq; do not have to Dr. Naik who had to intervene to respond to Ali Sina's writing
this, a lot of the little boys of Islamic peoples like Rahmanhadiq who can reply and unpack
the falseness Ali Sina’ books. This provision has been predicted and confirmed in the verse
17:81, which reads: “ Truth has come and falsehood has vanished ". Verily falsehood is
something that must vanish. (Surah 17:81) ". Actually Ali Sina will not be able to oppose the
truth proclaimed in the verses of the Qur'an, so he did a lot of fraud by deception and
damaging and deliver his cunning.
By now. you should know why Islam has advanced so Iar. It advanced through Jihad. i.e. terrorism
and throw lies and deceptions. You all know about Islamic terrorism. I hope aIter reading this paper.
you have also come to see the Iace oI deception and chicanery oI Islam. Dr. Naik personiIies that
Iace. (Rahmanhadiq; statement that is the main purpose of Ali Sina wrote this book is to
attack the teachings of Islam and the adherents of the Islamic religion to spread negative
gossip. Ali Sina want to spread his gossip and cunning that the religion of Islam has teaching
crime on this earth. whereas none of the verses in the al qur'an who told his people to do
terror, and even reverse many Qur'anic verses which Muslims threaten to do something evil
or do chaos. Statement of Ali Sina is already far to deviate from the matter of topic presented
by Dr Naik.)

Dr. Naik thinks every Muslim should be a terrorist. Based on the inIormation I have received. it
appears that he might have set up a tainting camp Ior Islamic terrorism. (Rahmanhadiq; re-Ali Sina
makes a funny gossip and slander. This is the main goal of Ali Sina to create and
disseminate these writings. All opinion think of Ali Sina is conveyed in this book is a real lie.)
I urge all the good people oI the world and specially the Indians to expose this conman. Promote this
article and let Muslims and his Ians know that he is a liar. (Rahmanhadiq; Ali Sina deliver and
can spew poison snake cobra to poison the person who has delivered the good news. Has
now been shown clearly that the committed fraud and deceit is Ali Sina himself. Ali Sina is
the greatest showman. He wrote the title of this book "World's Greatest Showman" for
himself. It was he who was behind the crime that he was purposely hiding all this time. The
aim is to undermine the teachings of Islam for the sake of his mission to make religious
teachings of Islam destroyed on this earth.)
Dr. Naik thinks he would win with deception. Let us prove that truth is more powerIul. Let truth
shatter his lies and tier down his tower oI cards.
Rahmanhadiq; Hopefully the book replies and answers will be open minded think of Ali Sina
toward the better, so he has a philosophy of good life for himself and follower and also
goodness for all mankind on this earth, I hope Ali Sina want to think and learn better before
accusing and spread the slander and incitement.)
--- O ---

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->