P. 1
crimethinc - Expect Resistance

crimethinc - Expect Resistance

|Views: 110|Likes:
Published by Effetto Farfalla

More info:

Published by: Effetto Farfalla on Apr 10, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

02/06/2013

pdf

text

original

a note to troublemakers

the only way we can kill the beast of our own influence is honesty. is openness. living in a
market is no excuse for perpetuating one's own power.
freed from the gods of art and naturalism, our ideas will live or die. but at least we will live.
death to crimet hl nc
when you're done, go outside. the embrace of new f rontiers should never mean the
abandonment of the old .
XP CT
Expect Resistance
I had long awaited a book that
resisted all parallels with other books
save the use of ink and type: a book
through which I might wander, losing
myself in labyrinths and coming upon
fantastic citadels to which I could not
retrace my steps; a book into which
I might plunge, skipping pages as a
little girl skips rope, never to return
to the world in which I'd began­
emerging instead in another, or at
least equipped to build one.
If you've never doubted the integrity of your
superiors or their right to demand your obedience,
nor felt the sting of wishing for something that
could not be found on department store shelves
or voting ballots;
If you've never fallen so deeply in love that it
seemed you had been sleepwalking through life
until that moment, never daydreamed desperately
in a board meeting or math class, never been car­
ried away by extremities of emotion while every­
one around you remained unmoved and oblivious;
If you've never suspected that real life must
be elsewhere, somewhere beyond the shopping
districts and suburbs, off the highway, over the
fields and oceans;
If there is no part of you left unfulfilled by
stock options and prime time programming and
cutting edge digital technology-
then perhaps this is not for you.
But if you have a secret self, read on.
~
Crimethink is the stirrings of a new world, smuggled across every
border in the heads and hearts of a dissident nation of millions, thrown
through plate glass windows on notes tied to bricks. It is everything that
evades control-the stolen sick-day at the seashore, the shared meal free
when the manager is away, the city street liberated for an hour during a
demonstration, the dream that rebels and comes true.
Crimethlnc. is the underground railroad
from this world to the next. Hop on.
N©! 2008 Crimethlnc. ex-Workers' Collective,
surviving in defiance of all odds and adversaries.
Come and get us, motherfuckers.
Printed in Canada by unionized workers
on 100% post-consumer recycled paper with soy-based ink.
All texts and images plagiarized and rearranged by collective process.
Anything composed in any language is obviously the handiwork of the
millions who developed the words and ideas that constitute it, not just
the experts listed in the credits. Please reproduce, translate, and adjust
this and all books at will, with or without citing sources.
This is neither a true story nor a work of fiction.
This is a chronicle of things that are going to happen.
Additional copies of this book are available for $8 +postage.
A variety of similar materials can also be obtained from
Crimethlnc. Skeleton Crew / PO Box 13998/ Salem OR 97309,
or by means of www.crimethinc.com
"When the great explorer was dying, hisfriends gathered by his
bedside and imploredhim to rescind the parts of his bookthat
had seemed incredible to them-to water down its miracles by
means of judicious deletions; but he responded that he had not
recounted even half of what he had in fact seen."
They will say* that we refused everything to make a beautiful
but utopian negation-as if it were just a work of art we were
out to create. They will say that, like generations of nihilists
before us, we uttered that grandiose denial and then were driv­
en by it into the wilds of oblivion and annihilation, that "the
air of crimethink is unbreathable for the masses of humanity."
They will praise the product-product being their specialty­
and deny the evidence. They will imply that we could not have
lived-but we do live, we liver-and so we give you these frag­
ments, this poorly charted record, to spit in their faces ...
or whisper in their ears as they sleep.
A book like this is just the scattered dust from explosions
in the lives of strangers, hastily scribbled notes from bygone
days when freedoms were fought for and won. Like all such
dust, these embers and ashes may retain a certain charge that
could help precipitate explosions in other lives. Otherwise,
they're useless. Don't stir them up unless you're in the busi­
ness of starting fires.
*They will say this, at least, if we fail.
I. THE FANTASY REBELS ...
It Begins 14
The Secret World 18
New Wings for Flighty Youth 22
The Invitation 26
The Rebellion of the Dead 29
On the Threshold 32
The Stillest Hour 34
The Fault Line 35
Wolves 37
Indulge and Undermine 40
At Sea 43
We Can Make Our Own 44
Mapping 48
AMap 50
Dreams 71
Alchemy 73
Beyond Democracy 74
Two Councils 90
Divided and Conquered 96
The Eviction 1°4
Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychologyof Possibility 108
And the Crowd Goes Wild 116
One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World 123
Other Encampments 132
You Can Run but You Can't Hide 136
All Roads Lead to Roam 137
Infighting the Good Fight 147
Hitting the Wall 163
On the Battlefield 168
II.... BECOMES REALITY
183 The End of the World
184 Some Run for Cover-We Rush to Bear Witness
186 Disaster
196 Off the Cliff
199 Failure
203 Crash and Burn
222 Adultery
235 Betrayers and Betrayed
239 Abomination
243 Reform and Revolution
256 Despair
264 Believing in Miracles
269 Hope
273 Explosions
277 History as We Live It
291 Extinction
296 Nostalgia
297 Darkness
304 The Future
307 Countdown to Civil War
312 Leaving the 21
st
Century
314 Dear Reader
315 Where We're Going
III. AFTERWARD
322 Inflamed Appendix
331 Disconnecting the Power
332 About the Authors
339 Hijack the Moon
345 The Explosion of Stars
346 The Future is Unwritten
I t all started when Kate got back from
Seattle and swore she wouldn't pay rent anymore. Of course, it all
started long before that-when Elijah showed me how to hide a
chicken patty under my salad so I could afford a complete lunch
from the school cafeteria, when Kate's father called up the power
company and told them to disconnect him from the grid, when
Pablo stormed out of the airport instead of flying to see his boss­
but those personal revolts didn't gain a common thread until we all
met at the encampment.
Kate wasn't a student; after high school she had proceeded im­
mediately to a series of retail jobs. Along the way she discovered
a passion for organic gardening and ended up living in collective
houses with students and environmental activists who had a lot
more money than she did. It had been sucking her dry trying to
pay bills the rest of them barely noticed. She knew people who had
sworn off rent before, but most of them were from wealthier fami­
lies and could rely on a whole network of couches maintained by
others like them. For Kate to decide she could do the same thing
was pure craziness.
14 . It Begins
One of the students Kate had lived with was involved in the
campus anti-sweatshop campaign, and the administration was still
dragging its feet on the previous year's agreements. The issue came
up at sorneone's birthday party, and Kate suggested the students set
up a protest encampment that could double as housing. I'd never
have expected them to be up for it, but three days later Kate was
setting up her tent in the quad with a big banner alongside it and
student activists were stopping by between classes to hold signs
and hand out fliers.
Two weeks later, it was clear that the administrators had no in­
tention of following through on their promises; they were simply
waiting for the protesters to return to their dorms. Little did they
know what was brewing out there on the quad! Once it appeared
the camp might last, others began filtering in, bringing with them a
heady mix of wild ideas and grim determination. The newcomers had
a different idea of politics than the student activists-they weren't
just interested in changing school policy, but also in changing their
own lives and everything else in reach. Like Kate, they were more
invested in continuing the occupation than working out a compro­
mise with the administration.
My friends and I had been waiting for something to do with the
city's excess, the food and furniture and construction materials we
gathered in our raids on its soft underbelly; we turned these into
meals and camping gear and took them to campus as our contribu­
tion. We invited others there to join us on our outings, and soon
we were bringing back more than anyone needed. We started send­
ing bags home with cafeteria staff and maintenance workers, then
moved on to making deliveries to their neighborhoods.
The next week, school officials approached the organizers of the
anti-sweatshop campaign, offering to negotiate if they'd call off the
occupation. When the latter broached the subject to us, we refused
to budge; the students had to announce that the occupation would
continue, lest it become known that non-student squatters had in­
filtrated it. Finally, the administration threatened to remove the
encampment with or without the students' cooperation.
They'd waited too long to play that card. There were articles
about the encampment in every newspaper; if the school sent po­
lice against us, they'd have to answer for it to a national audience.
More importantly, we'd made connections with the invisibles who
It Begins. 15
powered the infrastructure through which the school drew life. A
strike was brewing among campus workers; we had already assured
the ones we knew that we could provide them with food and sup­
port through it.
The encampment became a nerve center for a community that
hadn't existed until we all started sticking our necks out. My friends
and I began each day in the undergraduate library, utilizing a loop­
hole in the computer lab to print out hundreds of pamphlets and
fliers. We brought these back to the encampment and set them
out on a table of free literature; all afternoon we'd discuss politics,
economics, and liberation with the students who came through. In
the evening, we met with campus workers and other locals. These
meetings sometimes ended in bitter conflicts over how far we could
go, what our goals were, and which compromises were worth mak­
ing; not every student, squatter, or worker was ready for a head-on
confrontation with the authorities, but those of us who were found
each other and plotted accordingly. Diego and I would finish off
the night driving around to every grocery store in town; the em­
ployees at some of them had started setting big boxes of produce
aside just for us.
Together we had traveled to the extreme limit of our notions of
what was possible; our camp was pitched on the far side of them.
Political science majors began concerning themselves more with
the practical aspects of the struggle against hierarchical power than
the theoretical objections their professors raised against it. Anthro­
pology students started looking at their own lives as experiments
in subversive socialization. Criminals and dropouts envisioned a
thieves' guild that could coordinate citywide actions to power an
underground gift economy. Chefs fantasized about being able to
cook whatever they wanted for people and purposes they cared
about; dishwashers like myself discovered how much more gratify­
ing it was to wash our friends' dishes for free than strangers' dishes
for pay. We looked past our tents to the surrounding buildings: they
too could be ours.
As a child, I'd had a daydream in which a messenger came to res­
cue me. He would appear unannounced and whisper, in a voice no
one else heard, "Grab your things-I've come to take you home." Later
on, every time I walked past an empty, running car I would imagine
leaping into it and driving far, far away. Still later I contemplated
16. It Begins
suicide, which is what adults do when they can't bear their lives but
can't imagine changing them. Diego and I were driving back from
a construction site with a trunk full of barricading supplies when I
realized how long it had been since I'd had any such thoughts. My
companion behind the steering wheel was that messenger; the ve­
hicle we were riding in was that stolen car; my old life was behind
me, and I was still alive.
By the time they finally evicted us, we thought we were unstop­
pable. Kate and I were in love, students were dropping out, workers
were on strike, and the whole campus was in an uproar. We laughed
giddily in the back of the squad car, joking about what to do next.
The enormity of what we were up against had yet to hit us.
Exiting the police station that night, we shuddered in the cool
air, and all the things we'd never noticed before about the world sud­
denly snapped into focus. There were storm clouds close overhead,
great white snow banks reflecting the light of the city as they sped
past; they spoke to us of other lands, things to come, days ahead
when everything would be very different from what we'd known­
ourselves most of all.
It Begins. 17
You can taste it in the shock and roar of a first, unexpected kiss, or
in the blood in your mouth that instant after an accident when you
realize you're still alive. It blows in the wind you feel on the roof­
tops of a really reckless night of adventure. You hear it in the magic
of your favorite songs, how they lift and transport you in ways no
science or psychology could ever account for. Perhaps you've seen
evidence of it scratched into bathroom walls in a code for which
you had no key, or you've been able to make out a pale reflection
of it in the movies that are supposed to keep us entertained. It's
between the words when we speak of our desires and aspirations,
still lurking somewhere beneath the limitations of what we feel to
be possible and permissible.
When poets and radicals stay up until sunrise wracking their brains
for the perfect sequence of words or deeds to fill hearts or cities with
fire, they're trying to find a hidden entrance to it. When children es­
cape out the window to go wandering late at night or freedom fight­
ers search for a weakness in government fortifications, they're trying
to steal into it-for they know better than the rest of us where the
doors are hidden. When teenagers vandalize a billboard to provoke
all-night chases with the police or anarchists interrupt an orderly
demonstration to smash the windows of an army recruiting center,
they're trying to storm its gates. When you're making love and you
discover a new sensation or region of your lover's body, and the two
of you feel like explorers discovering a desert oasis or the coast of an
unknown continent-as if you are the first ones to reach the north
pole or land on the moon-you are charting its frontiers.
Some find it in the sensation of danger: the feeling that, for one
moment that seems to eclipse the past and future, something real is
at stake. For others, it is a place of safety and sanctuary in a world
of thoughtless brutality and destruction.
Maybe you stumbled into it by accident, once, amazed at what
you found. The old world splintered behind and inside you, and no
physician or metaphysician could ever put it back together again.
Everything before became trivial, irrelevant, ridiculous as the ho­
rizons suddenly telescoped out around you and undreamt-of new
paths offered themselves. And perhaps you swore that you would
never return from whence you'd come, that you would live out the
rest of your life electrified by that urgency, that thrill of discovery
and transformation-but return you did.
The Secret World. 19
Common sense dictates that this world can only be experienced
temporarily, that it is just the shock of transition and nothing more;
but the myths we share around our fires tell a different story: we
hear of women and men who stayed there for weeks, years, who
never returned, who lived and died there as heroes. We know, be­
cause we feel it in that atavistic chamber of our hearts that holds the
memory of freedom from a time before time, that this secret world
is near, waiting for us. You can see it in the flash in our eyes, in the
abandon of our dances and love affairs, in the protest or party that
gets out of hand.
You're not the only one trying to find it. We're out here, too­
some of us are even waiting ahead there for you. Please know that
anything you've ever done or considered doing to get there is not
crazy, but beautiful, noble, necessary.
When we talk about revolution, the idea is that we could enter
that secret world and never return-or that we could burn away
this one, to reveal the one beneath entirely.
zo . The Secret World
Before the first arrow whistled from a bow, human beings dreamed
of flying. Wingless, they lay on their backs in prickly fields, watching
birds. Their descendants exchanged tales of flying carpets, winged
horses and sandals, witches on broomsticks, women who put on
magic coats and became swans. Sorcerers and shamans sought to
elevate themselves through mystical experience; folk scientists plot­
ted to steal flight from the angels as Prometheus had stolen fire
from the gods.
Eleven centuries ago Abbas Ibn Firnas, one of the first avia­
tion pioneers whose name is still known to us, launched himself
off a mountain on a homemade glider. He was sixty-five years old.
Inspired, an English monk modeled wings according to Ovid's de­
scription of the feathered cloaks Daedalus made; these bore him a
full furlong through the sky, though he broke both legs upon land­
ing. Marco Polo returned to Europe to report that the Chinese were
sending people aloft in kites; Leonardo da Vinci drew up designs
for a helicopter; three centuries before the famous flight at Kitty
Hawk, a Turkish scientist shot himself a thousand feet in the air
in a rocket and coasted safely into the Bosporus. Hundreds, if not
thousands, died in similar efforts to get a little closer to heaven. It
was a worldwide obsession.
A few generations later, I sat in an airport waiting for a delayed
flight, an anonymous commuter in an irritated crowd. I closed the
book and returned it to my briefcase, reflecting that my species' love
affair with flying had cooled. Perhaps it was the long lines at the se­
curity checkpoints: there were new restrictions on liquids in carry-on
bags, and passengers had to make their way through several gauntlets
of barking men in starchy uniforms just to vie for seating. Perhaps
it was the piercing tones over the intercom followed by announce­
ments of further delays; perhaps it was the itch of the stale, sterile
air, or the bizarre idea that somewhere out there there were people
who wanted to fly planes into buildings with us inside them.
22 . New Wings for Flighty Youth
Once upon a time, orators declared that air travel would bring
people together, erasing borders and prejudices to inaugurate a new
era of universal amity and understanding; I reflected on this as my
fellow passengers fussed with their cell phones, fastidiously avoid­
ing eye contact with each other. Futurists had raved that the speed
and brilliance of flight would inspire transcendent bliss; waiting on
the runway, where the Wright brothers' hearts had pounded, my fel­
low passengers would flip idly through catalogs and pull down the
shades to block out the sun. The challenge of flight had commanded
the passions of the boldest and bravest of my ancestors; when our
plane took off, after ignoring the droning safety presentation, their
heirs would peer briefly out tiny double-plated windows at the
carved-up landscape before settling back to watch-a movie! Ten
thousand generations had dreamed of flying, and we needed movies
to numb our boredom in the air!
Maybe flying was simply not that exciting, after all. Some long­
sought miracles turn out to be letdowns; perhaps most do. Of course,
this explanation didn't account for the fervor in Antoine de Saint
Bxupery's writing, or the forces that impelled him and others to
keep flying into increasingly perilous situations until their luck ran
out. Nor did it account for the experiences of people I knew myself:
hadn't Chloe described stealing her uncle's hang glider as the most
exhilarating experience of her youth?
The alternative was less readily apparent, and its implications
were more dramatic. What if flying, as we knew it, wasn't flying at
all? Emotionally insulated from the adventure of getting into the
air, physically isolated from the landscape below, deprived of any
sensation of being airborne save a mild nausea, we might as well be
crowding into the locker of an isolation tank. My fellow aeronauts
would disembark at an airport identical to the one they had left,
impatient to get on with their busy lives; there was no longer even
a pretense that they were part of anything glorious, that they had
anything in common with the daredevils and voyagers of times past.
Perhaps the shamans of prehistory had known more about flight
than businessmen with their frequent flier miles ever could.
And if flying was not really flying, what about travel itself, or din­
ing, sex, work, friendship, romance, life? What if they, too, were not
themselves? Everyone around me was staring blankly into television
sets hanging from the ceiling. Some secrets are hidden in plain view.
New Wings for Flighty Youth. 2]
Could it be that I had never lived? I had traveled, but every­
where I'd been people spoke my language, accepted my currency,
affirmed my assumptions. I lived in rented apartments built and
maintained by people I'd never met; I didn't know how to build a
house, or even fix my own plumbing. I bought food products from
the supermarket without any idea what was in them or where they
came from; I didn't know what it was to hunt and kill an animal
or rely on a garden for sustenance. I had donated to charities, but
never seriously done anything to address injustice or even interact
with the ones who suffered it. I had voted for politicians and signed
petitions, but never organized anything in my community, never.
stopped a bulldozer or started a riot. I had dreams and aspirations,
but it seemed I'd watched more action movies on television than
I'd ever had adventures in real life. There were things I loved doing,
goals I hoped to achieve, but I'd spent a lot more time working to
pay for that rent, food, charity, television.
I'd been reflecting on these questions for months before I'd ar­
rived at the ticket counter, but the situation at Gate Ten cast them
in sharp relief. I wanted so earnestly to live, whatever that meant,
but I was cocooned in a society that seemed to make that impos­
sible, that sold itself to its citizens on precisely the grounds that it
made that impossible.
I was like everyone else there except I didn't have a mortgage, a
family to feed, or a prescription drug habit to maintain. Perhaps I
could find a way out. Of course, I had no idea what to do or where
to go; all I had to go on was the vague notion that there must be
something else out there. However I looked at it, certain facts of
life seemed non-negotiable: without an income, for example, I imag­
ined I would never ride in an airplane again unless I somehow got
myself deported.
I considered that possibility. How many people can say they've
been deported, anyway? Plenty, but not many from my social class.
That was another kind of insulation, another layer of the cocoon.
Was I really desperate enough to dive off a cliff, knowing I would
land somewhere or cease to exist? I couldn't deny that something
stirred within me at the thought. What irony: the real flight my civi­
lization offered held no attraction for me, but the proverbial leap
into thin air made my pulse quicken. In making that leap, I could be
an explorer like my ancestors, a pioneer like Abbas Ibn Firnas.
24. New Wings for Flighty Youth
If I did, everyone I knew would accuse me of jettisoning myself
from the world like a misguided Icarus. I would have to fight off
the conviction, instilled in me since childhood, that those who do
not play their parts in society are failures, parasites. On the other
hand, if ...
But at long last my flight had pulled into the gate. We all lined
up dutifully to board in order of economic status. That plane was
never going to alight in the Bosporus or fly too close to the sun. If
I wanted anything other than the future that was already written
for me, I would have to strike out on my own.
New Wings for Flighty Youth. 25
Until 'our most fantastic
demands are met,
fantasy will always be at war
with reality.
It hijacks history classes and funerals, waylays secretaries on the
way to the coffee machine, turns rails into slides and shopping malls
into playgrounds-it sends lives spinning out of control. Movie di­
rectors endeavor to harness it, travel agents to peddle it, political
parties to enlist it; but fantasy, like those who pursue it in earnest,
can serve no employer.
Now that every continent has been conquered and every coun­
tryside explored, nothing is more precious than passages to new
worlds. Mass-manufactured faiths are haunted by a thousand dreams
of escape-and fancy weaves better wings for flighty youth than
pragmatism ever fashioned our forebears.
As revolutionaries, of course we are fighting for our daydreams!
When we cannot stomach another hour of this, we side with those
moments we surprise ourselves, flashes inwhich anything feels pos­
sible, peak experiences that may last only instants-and therefore
with every inhibited impulse, forbidden pleasure, unexploded dream,
all the stifled songs which, unleashed, could create an upheaval like
no one has ever seen. And when the dust settles afterwards, we will side
with them again.
Call this escapist-perhaps it is; but what class of people is most
disturbed by the idea of escape? Jailers. Right or wrong, selfless or
selfish, possible or impossible, we're getting out of here.
The invitation to a newworld may take a lifetime or more to
extend; self-imposed outcast status may be established in order to
receive the transmissions, to give the seeds soil in which to grow.
The one who does this is not jettisoning herself from life after all,
but providing it a port of entry-quietly metabolizing the garbage
of the old world into the new one, just as other "parasites" do.
The Invitation, 27
Have we ever complained because we are misunderstood, misjudged,
misheard or unheard? That fate is our distinction: we would not
take ourselves seriously enough if we wished it were otherwise. All
that is great happens far from the marketplace and from fame; in­
ventors of new values and architects of new paradigms have always
hidden in the margins, starved in the ghettos, acted in the-shadows.
There is not yet space in streets or newspapers for the parcels we
have to deliver.
But beware-left untried, fantasies can
become vampires draining the life out of their
hosts; they may one day serve others, but they
can only contribute to the subjection of those
who never dare attempt them.
All along, he'd assumed he was only at the beginning of the grand
narrative of his life, that he had time to kill before setting off on
the adventures he described so compellingly to me in advance. Only
in the end did he discover that he'd been a peripheral character in
a very different story.
Death had been waiting from the outset for the decisive mo­
ment at which to call his body to mutiny. The crew abandoned their
posts, doused the lanterns, set the vessel aflame, and scattered on
the wind.
There were still things I wished I could ask him, conversations I'd
hoped to revisit, but it was too late. He'd become a memory, a sort
of archetype existing only in those he haunted; the mystery of those
unfinished discussions was carved into the world forever. I still had
his emails in my account, but there was no one on the other end.
What any of us would give for an audience with one of our ar­
chetypes! Some of them have passed into eternity without even
having had to die.
Death finalizes the gulfs that separate us from each other-and
from ourselves, from our own pasts. It interrupts the storylines
we project onto our lives, dispelling the connections between the
isolated moments of our experience-leaving them trapped, mute,
in eternity.
That void not only circumscribes our existence but surrounds
and isolates each instant, rendering them all irrevocable and pre­
cious beyond measure. We fear the very thought of it because it
forces us to acknowledge that we can never return to a single mo­
ment of our lives.
I hadn't reflected much upon death before Daniel died. I was
still in shock when we went to the memorial service. It was unnerv­
ing to feel so heartbroken and yet so numb, so incapable of engag­
ing with my grief. Even surrounded by others in mourning I still
felt isolated, alone in my thoughts and my sorrow, with no outlet
for the desperate urgency that possessed me. If there was a time to
The Rebellion of the Dead. 29
wail and rend our hair, to leap onto tables and shout out songs in
his memory, to swear to avenge his senseless death with our own
momentous lives, it was upon us. We were not up to the task. The
faces around me looked listless, even bored.
I hadn't reflected much on death until then, even though I'd
known I was going to die since I was a child. That is to say: I'd been
boredfrom before I could remember with the fact of my own mortality.
Was I in denial, or simply so bored with everything else that it
didn't matter?
The next morning, I was back on the fourth floor with the view
of the identical building across the street, shuffling through the
faxes that had come in over the weekend. My breakfast remained
in the desk, uneaten, and the phone kept ringing. I hadn't always
been bored; even in that office, I'd surreptitiously read the books he
lent me and we'd shared some good conversations over the phone
and instant messager.
An electronic memo arrived from down the hall: the coffee ma­
chine was jammed and it was up to me to fix it. What if he had
known he was going to die, what then? Would he have counted
backwards from that day, lived differently? Would he have frozen
up in the face of that terrible knowledge?
Coffee had somehow spilled all over the counter; it was soaking
into the box of doughnuts. I picked up the box, moved to throw it
away, paused with it in one hand and a wad of napkins in the oth­
er-I would be in trouble if there were no doughnuts, could I save
them somehow?-just long enough for the phone to ring.
I let it ring and tossed the doughnuts in the trash. What if I could
know in advance when my own death would come? It was waiting
ahead of me, as sure as Daniel's had been, as sure as all of ours are.
If someone could look at time from above, taking in the sweep of
history all at once, we would all appear as the walking dead, moving
obliviously along our preordained tracks towards inexorable ends.
That wasn't much of a stretch-I knew my work schedule day
by day through the end of December. Ten years ago, a summer had
been an eternity; now entire years were flying by in a blur inter­
rupted only by deaths, marriages, and other catastrophes. There is
no more commonplace observation than this, but to my knowledge
no one has yet set out to study why children and adults experience
the passing of time differently.
30. The Rebellion of the Dead
I unplugged the coffee machine and carried it with me to the
elevator. In innumerable other office buildings, innumerable other
secretaries were struggling with innumerable other coffee machines;
innumerable elevators bore innumerable employees to innumerable
washrooms; innumerable phones rang and rang and rang. They were
like a physical manifestation of the inevitability of our lives and
deaths, a machine pushing us at maximum speed along our preor­
dained tracks. I pressed the button for the top floor.
Death is the ultimate imposition upon and boundary to our free­
dom, but it only formalizes the renunciations we make ourselves,
moment by moment, throughout our lives. I imagined all the oc­
cupants of those office buildings rising in mutiny like the cells in
Daniel's body.
I got out at the top floor and walked to the spot where the jani­
tors sometimes went to smoke. No one was there. I opened the win­
dow and dangled the coffee machine out by its cord, eleven stories
above the pavement. I let it go. It shrank from view until there was
a distant crash; a pedestrian lurched back absurdly in surprise.
. Fuck it, I said to myself. Behold, thefirst dawn the worldhaseverseen.
This is the rebellion of the dead.
The Rebellion of the Dead. 31
That day I quit my job, threw my wallet in the
trash, and set out to break every rule I knew.
It took a very long time.
Oh, if only that were true! I did no such thing. Even walking out of
the airport, I was mostly playacting; I wasn't about to build a glider
and launch myself into the abyss. Making that one defiant gesture was
difficult enough-it felt like a rupture in the very fabric of reality. I
was not the sort of person who cancelled a business trip after driving
to the airport! It was not until much later that I would develop the
ability to wrench myself out of routines without flinching.
34 .The Stillest Hour
Internally, I still mirrored my society. The forces that comprised
me, though increasingly at odds, were arranged in a strictly regi­
mented hierarchy; I harbored private resentments, illicit longings,
impulses to rebel, but all these were kept in check. In my heart, as
in the city where I lived, there were vigilant police, restless ghettos,
unaccountable tyrants, decimated wildernesses, hoarded treasures
rusting in vaults. My associations with others were like the diplomatic
relations between nations: non-aggression pacts, behind-the-scenes
machinations, authoritarian powers negotiating over the heads of
oppressed masses separated by well-guarded borders. There had been
times when a renegade faction had precipitated an upheaval, such
as the affair with Chloe that destroyed my marriage, and everything
had to be reworked; but the essential order, and above all the com­
mitments that safeguarded it, had always remained unshaken.
The fundamental change that took place that afternoon was in­
visible, though it ultimately had spectacular effects. From that mo­
ment forward, I identified with the insurgent currents inside myself
against the society that proscribed them. I had always regarded them
as something foreign and dangerous, flirting with them but keeping
them under wraps; but at the airport, when I'd permitted them to
take the reigns in broad daylight, the world had not come to an end.
I'd crossed the line between flirtation and indulgence, discovered
that something lay beyond it, and wanted more. If my own habits
and obligations obstructed my path, so much the worse for them.
I knew there was commercial skydiving for people like me, ad­
venture tourism and recreational drugs and all sorts of other pres­
sure valves, but I was determined to hold out for the real thing. All
the career options and status symbols I'd worked my whole life to
accumulate were starting to look like so many constraints and cha­
rades. I would let the wild streaks within me deepen and spread
until I could set off, with my own wildness, a chain reaction that
could make the world hospitable for them.
Every revolution is essentially the revolt of a people against
itself. The hands that raise skyscrapers are the same ones that as­
semble barricades. Like a body in upheaval, painfully transforming
itself into something else, people seized by insurgent desires wrest
themselves from everything they know and attempt to reconstitute
themselves as a new society.
The Stillest Hour I The Fault Line. 35
Every struggle that takes place in a society plays out within each
of the individuals within it. The same fault line that opens in a bou­
levard between riot police and rioters runs through the private lives
of each officer and dissident. If enough of them can win their per­
sonal struggles against servility, addiction, fear, and inertia-that is,
if that which is oppressed within each individual triumphs-then
likewise the entire society can remake itself.
So I kept my job-barely, after canceling that trip-but where
once I'd focused on advancing my career, now I regarded my leisure­
time pursuits as my true vocation and aspired to increase their scope
accordingly. Once I'd invested my earnings in the stock market,
savings accounts, even golf clubs; now I smuggled every resource
I could out of my workplace and sought a new calling in which to
invest myself. My extracurricular activities became the center of
my life. In this, I joined a nation of students doodling in anticipa­
tion of the bell, nursing home inmates counting the days to their
next visit, spouses yearning for forbidden romance, and employees
who, like me, had concluded that their professions were not paths
to self-realization but barriers to it.
That is to say-I was like them, but I didn't know where to start
to connect with them. My colleagues didn't dare give any indication
of their true feelings; I barely ever saw my neighbors; I felt separated
from old friends and family by an unbridgeable chasm. I was at an
impasse, an insurgent without allies fighting a war without fronts.
All that changed when I stumbled upon the occupation.
36. The Fault Line I The Stillest Hour
At first, we were like wolves, just out for ourselves. We'd discovered
petty crime-shoplifting, scams, graffiti, vandalism-and we prac­
ticed it the way other people practiced religion, sports, or drugs. Like
Pablo, we thought of ourselves as being at war, but it was a private
war, six of us against six billion of them. Like most service workers,
we hated our bosses, but hadn't worked out a critique of authority;
we'd resented our teachers in school in the same instinctual way,
just as our mothers had resented our fathers without using words
like patriarchy. I didn't think of myself as opposing capitalism-for
me it was much more specific: I wanted to escape the conveyor belt
that brought piles of dirty plates into the dish room, and the stench
of industrial cleaner mingled with rancid grease, and the nights I
woke up scraping filth off phantom dishes in my sleep.
If delinquency didn't enable me to escape all that entirely, at least
it carved out a little territory apart from it. The first time I stole
a pair of shoes, I was so conditioned to my place at the bottom of
the social ladder I stole the cheapest ones in the store. A year later,
I was accustomed to dining on the finest organic cuisine, products
intended for only the wealthiest shoppers: why not grab the most
expensive items, if I was risking the same charges?
Wolves. 37
This shift in diet was accompanied by radical changes in my self­
esteem, which led to new trains of thought. In a very concrete way,
the foods I was permitted by law to eat reflected my value in society.
As a dishwasher, I literally couldn't afford the products I stole; did
that mean I didn't deserve them? My manager, who never got his
hands dirty, could take for granted luxuries I had to risk jail time
just to taste. The counselors at school had told us people ended up
with jobs like ours because they didn't get enough education, but I
could see through that right away-wherever there were restaurants
and cafeterias, somebody was going to have to wash the dishes, and
it sure wasn't going to be the owners. Some of my coworkers had
been to college and had nothing to show for it but debt.
When I reflected on the poverty I'd seen growing up and the
centuries of destitution there must have been before that, it out­
raged me that anyone would condemn stealing as immoral. Could
anyone really argue with a clean conscience that all that privation
was not enough, that poor people throughout history should have
had to go without all they had stolen, as well?
So we developed a broader analysis of what we were fighting
against, but our motives remained schizophrenic: we despised rich
people, their privileges and their sense of entitlement and above all
the injustices they heaped on others, but envied their lifestyle-even
though it made them soft, even though it necessitated the exploi­
tation of others. Living in constant conflict with the law kept our
senses sharp and spiced up a day-to-day existence that would other­
wise have been utterly demoralizing, but it didn't make things any
easier for others of our social class-at the most, I could take some
groceries over to my mom's place, but I had no idea what to do for
everyone else on her street.
After the first few arrests hit home, we had to look for a more
sustainable approach. A couple broke off to pursue careers as hard­
core criminals; the rest of us scaled back the more hazardous ac­
tivities and stepped up everything else. We focused more and more
on the surplus of our society-it was less carefully guarded. And
what bounty! Why fill our pockets inside the store with one eye
on the security guard when we could fill up a whole pickup truck
out back?
That was how I finally came to question my own materialism.
I'd been raised to want things I could never have-sports cars, gold
38. Wolves
watches, designer sunglasses and furniture. Everyone in the coun­
try was chasing that same mirage, and somewhere there were waste
dumps overflowing with all those things-one of them wasn't far
from my old neighborhood. At distribution centers I would look
into dumpsters packed to the top with perfectly good juice and
shake my head in disgust. Wage slaves like me were throwing away
our entire lives working to make things we could never own, and
our society was shoveling them right past us into the trash. I didn't
want anything to do with it, even as a thief.
Driving around at night, gathering copper to sell or merchandise
we'd damaged during the day, Diego and I would mock the ubiqui­
tous billboards. "Look at that one," he'd point out, "Nice cowboy hat,
gringo! And to top it off it's called 'Colt 45' -ever notice how every
fucking malt liquor company has a name like that? We're supposed
to identify with the brand names, to feel tough and powerful as we
wreck our livers-but the barrel's pointed at us."
"And the crazy part is I still want the stuff. What else am I gon­
na do with the rest of the night?" This was a couple months before
we met the students who invited us to the encampment. "I know
how toget everything for free, but I've got no idea how to get free
myself."
"For that, we'll need a bigger gang," Diego deadpanned.
Wolves. 39
·..AND UNDERMINE
Have you noticed that exhortations to indulge yourself are always
followed by suggestions! Proselytizers seek footholds to claim ter­
ritory within you, salesmen grasp for handles to jerk you around
... from new-age prophets to advertisers, from pornographers to
radicals, everyone exhorts you to "pursue your desires," but the
question remains: which ones! The "real" ones? Who decides which
those are?
It's a war for your soul on every front. And those much-contested
desires are ill constructed, anyway-they change, they're dependent
on external factors, culture, the whole context and history of our
40. Indulge and Undermine
society. We "like" fast food because we have to hurry back to work,
because processed supermarket food doesn't taste much better, be­
cause the nuclear family-for those who still have even that-is too
small and stressed to sustain much festivity in cooking and eating.
We "have to" check our email because the dissolution of commu­
nity has taken our friends and kindred far away, because our bosses
would rather not have to talk to us, because "time-saving" technol­
ogy has claimed the hours once used t? write letters-and killed all
the passenger pigeons, besides. We "want" to go to work because in
this society no one looks out for those who don't, because it's hard
to imagine more pleasurable ways to spend time when everything
around us is designed for commerce and consumption. Every crav­
ing we feel, every conception we form, is framed in the language of
the civilization that creates us.
Does this mean we would want differently in a different world?
Yes, but not because we would be free to feel our "natural" desires­
no such things exist. Beyond the life you live, you have no "true"
self-you are preciselywhat you do and think and feel. That's the real
tragedy for the man who spends his life talking on his cell phone and
attending business meetings and fidgeting with the remote control:
it's not that he denies himself his dreams, necessarily, but that he
makes them answer to reality rather than attempting the opposite.
The accountant regarded with such pity by runaway teenage lovers
may in fact be happy when he arrives home from work in time for
his favorite sitcom-but it is a very different happiness than the
one they experience on the lam.
If our desires are constructs, if we are the products of our envi­
ronment, then our freedom is a question of how much control we
have over that environment. It's nonsense to say a woman is free
to feel however she wants about her body when she grows up sur­
rounded by diet advertisements and posters of anorexic models. It's
nonsense to say a man is free to live as he pleases when everything
he needs to do to acquire food, shelter, companionship, and a sense
of accomplishment is already established and all that remains is for
him to choose between prefabricated options. We must make our
freedom by forging the realities which, in turn, fashion us.
This sounds like a lot to ask. But change, revolutionary change,
is going on everywhere all the time-and everyone plays a part in it,
consciously or not. Our lives are vastly different today than they
Indulge and Undermine. 41
were even a mere decade ago. The question is simply whether we
take responsibility for our part in the ongoing transformation of
the cosmos, acting deliberately and with a sense of our own power,
or frame our actions as reactions, participating in unfolding events
. accidentally as if we were purely victims of circumstance.
Forget about whether "the" revolution will ever happen-the
best reason to be a revolutionary is that it is a better way to live.
It offers you a chance to lead a life that matters, gives you a rela­
tionship to injustice so you don't have to deny your own grief and
outrage, keeps you conscious of the give and take always going on
between individual and institution, self and community, one and
all. No institution can offer you freedom-but you can experience
it in challenging and reinventing institutions. When school chil­
dren make up their own words to the songs they are taught, when
people show up by the tens of thousands to interfere with a closed­
door meeting of expert economists discussing everyone's lives, they
are rediscovering that self-determination, like power, belongs only
to the ones who exercise it.
If, as idealists like us insist, we can indeedcreate whatever world we
want, then perhaps it's true that we could adapt to any world, too.
But spending your life in reaction and adaptation, hurrying to catch
up to whatever is already happening, means being perpetually a step
behind, at the mercy of history as it unfolds. That's no way to go
about pursuing your desires, whichever ones you choose to pursue.
Don't be too hard on yourself about the fragments of the old order
that remain within you. You can't sever yourself from the chain of
cause and effect that produced you-not with any amount of will­
power. The trick is to find ways to indulge your programming that
simultaneously subvert it-that create, in the process of satisfying
the old desires, conditions that foster new ones. If you need to follow
leaders, find leaders who will help you depose them from the pedestal
you put them on; if you wish to lead others, find equals who will help
you dethrone yourself; if you have to fight against others, find wars
you canwage for everyone's benefit. When it comes to dodging the im­
peratives of your conditioning, you'll find that indulgeand undermine
is a far more effective program than the old heritage of "renounce
and struggle" passed down from a humorless Christianity.
42. Indulge and Undermine
One of my most disappointing discoveries was that I desired so little.
After long disuse, my passions were stunted like bonsai trees: trite,
typical, boring. I'd hoped to throw myself at their mercy, to follow
their tyrannical dictates and thus, even in leaving the beaten path,
retain some sort of guide through the wilderness. Without that, I
was totally at sea.
The limits of my desire were a sort of cage, no less than the
limitations imposed by civil society. Even after I followed the cof­
fee machine out of the office, I had no idea where to start. Should I
take my meager savings and go to Ecuador? Visit family in Southeast
Asia? Move to New Mexico? Would life really be more immediate
or authentic there? Should I take up mountain climbing, or apply
to graduate school, or dedicate myself to volunteer work? I was sur­
rounded by banality, trying to choose between cliches. I wanted to
be lit up, electrified by the world in every moment-but for that to
be possible, the world and I would both have to change.
Likewise, if I was to share adventures with others, it was up to
me to infect them with new desires. As it was, I knew no one with
whom I could undertake anything more audacious than a night out
dancing. I tried to imagine myself as a seductress, inspiring friends
and former coworkers with hedonistic fervor the way others drove
suitors to distraction, suicide, and feats of bravado. I couldn't imag­
ine a role for which I was less suited.
And yet I was determined that my life would be something out
of the ordinary; if I could not undo Daniel's death, at least I would
avenge my own. I counted the days, my savings trickling away as I
Waited for the right opportunities and compatriots to come along.
Based on my experience leaving the office, I surmised I'd be able to
recognize them by the terror they would inspire in me.
At Sea. 43
History is not something
that happens to people­
it is the activity of people.
Culture does not dictate
human behavior-
it is the sum of human
behavior. Technological
progress is not a force
of nature, either. There is
no civilization without us
civilizing, no capitalism
without us capitalizing
and capitulating.
44. We Can Make Our Own
These are hard things to remember in the boss's office, let alone
working the checkout line at Wal-Mart. The mass media encour­
ages us to feel sentimental about "our" achievements: the space
shuttle soars, the disease is cured, the star gets the girl at the end
of the movie.
But we can make our own music, mythology, science, technol­
ogy, tradition, psychology, literature, history, ethics, political power.
Until we do, we're stuck buying mass-produced movies and compact
discs made by corporate mercenaries, sitting faceless and immobi­
lized at arena rock performances and sports events, struggling with
other people's inventions and programs and theories that make less
sense to us than sorcery did to our ancestors, shamefacedly accept­
ing the judgments of priests and agony columnists and radio talk
show hosts, berating ourselves for not living up to the standards
set by college entrance exams and glamour magazines, listening to
parents and counselors and psychiatrists and managers tell us we
are the ones with the problems, buying our whole lives from the
same specialists and entrepreneurs we sell them to-and gnashing
our teeth in smothered fury as they cut down the last trees and he­
roes with the cash and authority we give them. These things aren't
inevitable, inescapable tragedies-they're consequences of the pas­
sivity to which we have relegated ourselves. In the checkout lines of
supermarkets, on the dialing and receiving ends of 900 numbers, in
the locker rooms before gym classes and cafeteria shifts, we long to
be protagonists in our own epics, masters of our own fate.
If we are to transform ourselves, we must transform the world­
but to begin reconstructing the world, we must reconstruct ourselves.
Today we are all occupied territory. Our appetites and attitudes and
roles have all been molded by this world that turns us against our­
selves and each other. How can we take and share control of our
lives, and neither fear nor falter, when we've spent those lives being
conditioned to do the opposite?
rtw. are the onl ones currenttq workin in meanina as a mediu m . 45
cancer out of control, a monster riding the humanity that gave birth
Individuals cannot be autonomous­
to it into an untimely grave. We need a culture that is a dialogue,
we are formed by relationships: an interplay between us and the languages we think and speak and
without them, we do not exist. One cannot create meaning in a
live in-not a monologue arriving out of a loudspeaker.
Fighting for this, we attack the average, deny the universal, and
vacuum-but neither can one be anything but at the mercy of and
alienated by a meaning that arrives from on high. One must make ! nurture the anomalous.
meaning with others, cooperatively, for it to be meaning-ful. Free- ,
dom is not standing alone, man versus humanity-those who set
out to "pursue their desires" as individualists forget that even those
desires are socially constructed. Neither is freedom to be found in
unquestioning obedience to law: a free human being is not a law­
follower or a law-breaker, but an inventor and reinventor of laws,
a part of a tribe.* When we want to rebel against the limits a cul- "
ture imposes, we call it "ideology," or "conformity"; but we cannot
escape culture itself-we carry it with us as we flee, leaving a trail
of it in our wake.
Culture is made up of languages-languages of words and num­
bers, of concepts and assumptions, of conventions and expectations,
of problems and solutions, of answers and questions. Languages
write our lives: they set the options whenever we make a choice,
however free we may be in selecting. At the same time, it is our
use of them that makes them what they are and reproduces them.
Terms in languages work only because we hold them in common;
language-writing is the ultimate collective activity, the common
denominator of all social activity. To be free of language is impos­
sible in human relations-as we know it, that universe not only is
described by language but exists as language.
Languages enforce their constraints upon us-that is to say, those
constraints are us-but every time we adjust a concept or subvert an. '
expectation, we remake ourselves. It is in this constant redefining
of terms, the ongoing creation and negation of forms and assump­
tions, that freedom becomes possible.
A cancer of mass-produced, impersonal, prefabricated culture
threatens our species. A creature does not die "of" cancer-a creature
dies by becoming cancer, when its cells begin reproducing sameness at
the expense of diversity. A culture that sets up a million franchises
with workers in matching uniforms executing identical tasks is a
* In former times, culture was developed in tribal groups, on a small enough
scale that everyone could participate.
46. We Can Make Our Own
Like I said, the real turning point came when we got involved in the
encampment. I grew more in the course of that month than I had
in several years. Finally, our rage and marginalization, not to men­
tion our hard-won skills, were assets rather than barriers; finally, we
could wage our secret war out in the open, in a way that connected
us to others rather than isolating us.
My friends and I were very different from most people there,
but it was such an intense experience that it drew us all together;
those who shared it as a common reference point were bonded for
years afterwards regardless of how their paths diverged. I hadn't had
much interest in college students before, and the ones with whom
I'd crossed paths had made it clear they had no interest in me; it was
only when all the barriers of Class and habit were removed and we
were joined in a common project that we could interact as human
beings rather than social roles. I'd been on the opposite end of that
same dynamic with older workers-I faulted them, unjustly, for
failing to escape the fate I feared awaited me, and I imagined they
resented me for my youth and mobility-but at the encampment.
there was no young or old except in terms of how long people had
been involved.
Time itself passed differently. Because I never knew what would
happen next, it often felt like I'd lived through a week by the time I
lay down at the end of the day. In the heat of that urgency, our differ­
ent pasts and uncertain futures fell away and all that remained was
the concentrated rush of the present. Coordinating to provide for
everyone in the camp, staying up late preparing for rumored police
attacks, sharing the daily triumph of maintaining the occupation
against all odds, we grew together into one organism.
48. Mapping
Once, we'd evaluated activities according to how much they
paid; now we looked at them in terms of how rewarding they were
to experience and how beneficial they were for others. Before, we'd
sought our own material interests, taking it for granted that there
wasn't enough of what we wanted to go around; now we sought
social interests, and found that even crowded four to a tent we felt
wealthier than ever before. At first, I'd just wanted to get out of
the dish room-now we were talking about making a clean break
with Western civilization and building a new society in its midst.
The fears that had kept me in place, the bad habits that had tied
me down, the unhealthy assumptions I'd developed about human
nature and my own potential-all these came into sharp focus as I
discovered what it meant to do without them.
Day by day, step by step, we were mapping an entirely newway of
living. The encampment was the laboratory in which we began this
experiment, but it was also a beachhead from which to extend it.
Mapping. 49
totalitarian order in which the whol:l
I ?! relations is dominated by patho- I
logical patterns, isolated resistance to any I
one symptom of that domination-the de- I
pletion of the ozone layer, police brutality, I
child abuse, racism, employee ennui-can
only fail. Those who desire change must
contest the totality itself, the basic para­
digms as well as their specific manifesta­
tions. This sketch of six oppositions is not
intended as a complete map of the wO"c
of human relations, but as a I·
I diagnostic tools for the individual
l'"h" own ,n,)y,i, 'nd re"r I
f
I( •
I
II
We move in spiral
paths, imploding
or expanding C>,

ana new loves.
."'"
/'
-
.
-.
CU­
7JI"""
t)
CI)
relinquishing everything
\\0
to become what we hate
or finding the faith to
discover new possibilities
_.
_
/

"illtl,
g
<
:J
CD
I( •
-

......


r


AMap·51
50. A Map
The more full and free-life
The more you can recognize the
is, the easier it is to recognize
opportunities life offers, the more
all the opportunities
you can.: take advantage of them
treasures it has to offer
Life
The trt9te your life is in your The more you approach life
ownhands, the more it is an as a game, the more ftUl
liberty and pleasure and free it becomes
Play
The mprepleasure you take in The more freely you.gwe and
your the more freely receive, the more youtJife can
you share the fruits be a game rather struggle
Gift Giving
The morlfiYOu share with others,
the more share with you, and The more you love,
the more til:tatn.kful you are for one the more freely you];;....
another's existence
Love
The more you love, The more you
the more you trust the more you can love
Faith
The you trust the world, The more you recogiU..\te the
the more wonderful things treasures life has to offer. the
you recognize in it more faith you have in it
Abundance
The more full and free life
The more you can recognize the
is, the easier it is to recognize
opportunities life offers, the more
all the opportunities and
you can take advantage of them
treasures it has to offer
The lessyc:>u trust the world, the
The less you live, thf#less you
less you$ee what it has to offer
see what the world has to offer
Survival
more you think you
The more you
need to survive, the
the less you live
er you have to work
Work
and
feel the need to be receive, the harder have to
comp ed for your sacrifice work to provide fo
more you work, the The less freely you
rself
Exchange
present where
The more you depe
must be negotiated,
force, the less you CWIJ::IVI::
is not practiced
and receive freely
for its own sake
Force
depend on force, The less you trust, ore
you have to fear you depend on
The
Fear
The less you
The more ypu fear the world, the
what the world has to offer,
less you ref9pgnize what it offers
the less you trust
Scarcity
The less you trust the world, the
The less you live, the less you
less you see what it has to offer
see what the world has to offer
Abundance
All of us can be rich . . .
Abundance and scarcity are not just measures of the resources that
exist to meet needs-they are different ways of regarding both re­
sources and needs, which become reflected in the world.
Abundant resources exceed the need for them; they may even
multiply when utilized. Most of the things which set life apart
from survival-love, friendship, confidence, imagination, courage,
adventure, experience-are available in abundance: the more you
partake of them, the more there is of them for you and everyone
else as welL
Abundance and scarcity are above all the manifestations of op­
posing approaches to life: ingenuity or inertia, faith or fear. If we
restructure our values and assumptions about what the cosmos has
to offer us, we can enter a new world of plenty.
Scarcity
... not all of us can be wealthy.
Scarce resources exist in limited supply, and there may simply not
be enough to go around. A scarcity economy is driven by the con­
siderations necessitated by those conditions: the "laws" of supply
and demand are imposed first of all by a shortage, real or perceived,
of needed goods.
It might seem that scarcity is simply an inescapable fact of life, but
it's not that simple. Not all scarcities are imposed by circumstances­
often, we impose them upon ourselves by the ways we assess and
apply our assets. In out technologically advanced, post-industrial
civilization, tools and amenities that were unheard of before are
plentiful, yet most of us distinctly feel there to be a shortage of the
things we need. This should not be surprising, for our social and
economic systems depend on there not being enough for everybody.
Everyone can have a full life-but not everyone can have a full wal­
let. Our society institutes scarcity and deprivation, by framing life
as a desperate rush for limited material wealth and status.
It used to be said that the only free men are the hobo and the
king. They are indeed the only ones who can claim to be lords of all
they survey-though for utterly different reasons: the former pos­
54. A Map
sesses the entire world by releasing it, while the latter still owns only
what he can conquer. Here we can see the paradigms of abundance
and scarcity in action as philosophies of life. Likewise, the scaven­
ger who thrives off the excess of his society sees opportunity and
adventure where the executive sees only hunger and destitution; the
non-monogamous lover sees love as something that only increases in
richness and depth by being shared freely, while the possessive hus­
band regards it as a precarious prize obtained by sacrifice and hard
labor, which must be hoarded and caged; the would-be rock idol or
movie star needs a million anonymous fans watching his actions to
validate them-selfhood itself is subject to scarcity in a spectator
society-while the woman in a supportive, egalitarian community
generally attains self-confidence and happiness to the extent that
she helps others around her do the same.
Here's a story: once upon a time, human beings lived in a relation­
ship of trust with the earth, seeing it as a wellspring of abundance.*
• "Paleolithic man [sic,throughout], a hunter/gatherer who understood the value
of sharing and mutual assistance, 'had' nothing-why hoard things when the
whole world is yours? Later, Neolithic man, who toiled in the fields, sometimes
produced a surplus, which he bartered with others-and thus for him a shift
occurred from being in the world to having things, mere parts of the world. The
hunters and gatherers never curbed their materialistic impulses-but they never
made institutions out of them, either. Homo Economicus is a construction, the
result of ten thousandyears of 'subjugation': that is to say,etymologicallyspeaking,
life under the yoke."- Finnegan Bell in Hunters and Gatherers through the Ages
AMap·55
We ate fruit, which grew freely around us, naturally wrapped in a \
biodegradable peel and containing seeds from which more fruit trees
would grow after the fruit was eaten. Today we eat candy bars, for .
which we must exchange our labor, of which supplies are strictly,
limited-and when we throwaway the wrappers, which are manu-oj
factured from plastics and chemicals foreign to nature, we can be 0
sure that we are adding to the slow accumulation of garbage that ;,,!
makes fruit trees less and less abundant. Our ancestors lived in condi- ~
tions of feast or famine, celebrating when their cups overflowed and:
whistling through leaner times, never diminishing their faith in the . , ~
bountiful earth by measuring what it gave them; for us, everything '(1 0
is a transaction, an occasion for computation and calculation.
Life,
Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness
Life is existence when it feels worth waking up for in the morn­
ing. Life is written about in epic poetry, love songs, Shakespeare's
plays and sonnets; survival is treated in medical textbooks, urban
planning reports, and ergonomics presentations. Life is glorious,
heartbreaking, extravagant; survival, without life, is ridiculous,
burdensome, absurd.
Survival,
Safety, and the Pursuit of Property
Survival is life reduced to imperatives, whether biological (get air to
breathe! get food to eat! get laid!) or cultural (get air conditioning to keep
cool! get a television to keep up with what's going on! get a sports car to
attract a mate!). It's often ambiguous which class specific mandates
fall into, as in the case of the computer programmer who cannot
feed himself without a can opener; but the essential character of
these needs is that they appear non-negotiable.
Survival resources tend to be seen as scarce-there's only so
much food, water, housing, and medicine in the world; but as the
famous tramp responded to a bourgeois man's query ("you've got to
eat, haven't you?,,), "yeah, but not as much as you eat."
Our era is characterized by ever-increasing standards of survival.
The minimum standard of living to participate in society is always
AMapo 57
560 AMap
rising, and it's a full-time job keeping up: getting the new format for
video-viewing, learning to use the new computer program, treating
yourself with the new prescription drug ... This constant techno­
logical and cultural acceleration is the consequence of an economic
system based on competition, in which continuous innovation is
necessary both to sell new products and to keep up with everyone
who uses them.
Many anthropologists believe that people spend more time working
to meet their "basic" needs today than ever before. Prehistoric human
beings spent the greater part of their days in creative leisure, while
with all our labor-saving devices we waste most of our lives earning
money to pay for them,using them to mow the lawn, waiting in traf­
fic to buy more batteries for them ... and of course, the more time we
spend providing for mere survival, the less time we have to live.
Play
Head for horizons. . .
Play is what takes place when all the problems of survival have been
solved and time and energy remain. Play is not constrained by exter­
nal demands-the player establishes her own goals and meanings in
the course of acting. Play takes place in a condition of freedom­
that is to say, it is the condition of freedom. In play, the individual
interacts with the forces around her rather than reacting to them,
creates the context for her actions as she acts rather than passively
being shaped by the situation: it is thus that self-determination is
possible. You can see play today in the collages on teenagers' walls,
in the eccentric furnishing of squatted buildings, in the break be­
tween skirmishes when the insurgents dance, in the movements of
lovers' bodies together.
The resources for play are available in abundance. The more
one plays, the more others are enabled and encouraged to do the
same; true playfulness is infectious. One can't play long at others'
expense-being "free" at such a price ends up taking a lot of work,
as in the case of the successful executive, and doesn't lend itself to
much real, spontaneous play, as the ennui typical of the trust-fund
playboy demonstrates.
It's ambiguous whether many of the things currently called"play"
actually warrant the title. Is it play when an office worker goes golf­
58. AMap
ing with his boss? How about when a group of men play football
together according to a strict set of rules, with a struggle for domi­
nance as an ever-present subtext? How about when a young man
comes home from work so exhausted that he doesn't have enough
energy to do anything but "play" video games?
Children come into this world knowing all about play-at least
until they've spent a few years cooped up in small rooms with the
television on. We can win back that lost innocence, for them and for
ourselves, by approaching everything we do as a game rather than
a struggle or responsibility-by creating environments in which
we can run wild.
The best-kept secret of capitalism is that play activities can also pro­
vide for our survival needs: think of all the retirees who start gardens
and build bookcases! Except in extremities, work is unnecessary.
AMap·59
Work
... not destinations.
Work provides for survival, nothing more. It always appears as a re­
sponse to necessity, whether that be the need for food and shelter
and life insurance, the establishment of social status, or the obliga­
tions of the Protestant work ethic. Work answers to imperatives;
play creates its own rules.
Gift Economics
We know everything is priceless . . .
In stark contrast to exchange trading, gift-giving is its own reward.
In a gift economy, which exists whenever anything is freely shared
and no score is kept, the participants receive more the more they
bestow. Everyone who has shared a real friendship or a morning of
incredible lovemaking knows intuitively that when the opponunity
presents itself, human beings return to this natural relationship.
Life itself is the greatest gift. It is absurd to think one could de­
serve life in all its complexity and magnanimity in the first place­
let alone good or bad fortune, the moment of stillness at sunrise,
60.AMap
the flavor of avocados, the sensation of riding a galloping horse!
Anyone who has lived and paid attention knows the best and worst
things life has to offer are things no one could ever earn.
My liberation, my delight, my world itself begins where yours
begins. Nobody can command my services because I have, of my
own, pledged to give all-and gratuitously, for that is the only way
to give.
Exchange Economies
... they say everything has a price.
Liberty ends where economics begins. Get your money's worth-earn
your keep-there's no such thing as a free lunch: exchange economics
posits life as a zero-sum sport between bargainers who maneuver to
outbid and outwit each other in order to gain control of pieces of a
fragmented world. Free trade, the free market-these are oxymorons:
where systematized competition is free to bend all humanity to its
prerogatives, ultimately no one is free to focus on anything else.
Exchange economics presupposes a one-dimensional scale of
value, according to which everything can be appraised: if an avocado
costs a dollar, and a new sports car costs $20,000, then a sports car
must be worth exactly twenty thousand avocados. But such equa­
tions are absurd. Canyou calculate the financial value of a friendship,
the exchange rate of a clever joke for a meal tenderly prepared, the
comparative worth of the sound of birds singing in the trees against
the current market value of lumber? Those who would measure such
things miss everything that is beautiful and unrepeatable about
them; once one recognizes this, it becomes clear how pathological
such calculations are in any context. To assess the commercial value
of experiences and sensations, let alone trade in the very lives of the
human beings around you with an eye to your own advantage, is to
flatten the world for yourself and everyone you touch.
The machinery of exchange eats quality and shits out quantity,
enslaves process to despicable product, teaches that practical ne­
cessities and moments of joy and spiritual redemption alike must
all be earned. There is something of the old Christian theology of
guilt and salvation in the ways those who hold stock in the values
of exchange speak of hard work and entitlement. In their eyes, any­
thing free is suspect at best-nothing obtained without sacrifice,
AMap.61
without an exchange, can be worth anything-and the act of paying
for things, with the compensation they receive for abdicating their
lives, is itself more important than anything they could buy. It is
the way one buys oneself out of the hell of worthlessness to which
the tramp and the failure are assigned, not without a little jealous
spite. For such people, human beings do not "deserve" happiness,
comfort, even existence itself, unless they pay for it-with suffering.*
It should come as no surprise that some employees see things this
way: if they didn't, they would have to face the possibility that they
have been wasting their lives.
Likewise, those who would refuse this system of exchange are
confronted with the same accusations of valuelessness by their own
bodies, when they find that they cannot get food to eat or a soft place
to sleep unless they give up some part of themselves for it. Once
some people in a society begin hoarding and trading for their own
benefit, all who interact with them must adopt the same miserliness
and self-interest to survive-and the most ruthless ones inevitably
end with the most power, just as magnanimity and largesse find
themselves disenfranchised. The world now waits for a generosity
that can defend itself
Relationships of Love
Cooperate and celebrate . . .
Love is self-assured, fearless, generous. Love does not make demands
or judge according to standards-love celebrates, consecrates the
unique, makes beauty and beautiful. To feel love is to be grateful for
the past, present, and future, to feel for a moment that there is mean­
ing in existence. To be in love is not to be deluded or destitute, but
to gain a sixth sense with which to perceive the real splendor of the
universe. To experience love is to be connecteddirectly to the tragedy
of existence-which is not that there is not enough beauty in life, but
that none of us has the breadth or depth of self, or the time on this
planet, to savor fully the magnificence the world lavishes upon us.
Love makes war upon any peace which in fact is war system­
atized and concealed, for love is a ruthless enemy of senseless con­
* We, on the other hand, have ceased to use words like earn and deserve; we ask,
instead, what would be best for everyone, and leave it at that. Revenge doesn't
interest us-it's just another from of exchange.
AMap.63
flict and waste. It is love, of liberty when not of one's fellow be­
ings, that makes it possible for us to coexist in pursuit of our own
desires rather than languishing in thrall to that fat old god Discord.
Those in love come to identify each other's needs with their own,
ultimately making no distinction and overcoming the self/other di­
chotomy that is at the root of Western alienation. Thus in love we
find a way to surpass ourselves, to exalt each other and ourselves in
the course of living.
Relationships of Force
... or live and die by the sword?
When you live in fear, the only way to approach the world that
makes sense is with a gun in your hand. Just as the ones who see
scarcity everywhere they look create a world of shortages, those who
depend on force to relate to others create a necessity for it, and their
children inherit this cycle.
Coercion comes in more subtle forms than rape, "peace-keep­
ing" bombings, and economic sanctions. It comes camouflaged as .
body image standards, psychological pressures that compel people
to repress their desires, laws enforced by public opinion as well as
thugs in uniform. It may be disguised as a seemingly trivial argu­
ment between friends (for anyone who seeks to establish rank, even
in knowledge of trifling things, seeks a lever with which to exert
force on his fellows), or that quiet self-mutilation which lovers and
relatives sometimes use to manipulate each other-the inverse and
identical twin of macho aggression.
Some call this a democracy-did you get a say in what the bill­
boards you pass every morning say, what they go on repeating inside
your head all day, the trees they cut down by your house to make
room for the new gas station? How about the preservatives they put
in the food you eat, or the conditions in the factories that produce
them? What about your wages at work, or how much money the
IRS takes from you? These aren't just inevitable "facts of life"­
they are the manifestations of conflict as the system of human rela­
tions, every man for himself andforce against us all.* The leagues of
* Walk down the street. Look around. The skin cream advertise­
ments proposing an unreachable ideal for women's beauty, urg­
ing them to ransom their self-confidence by pouring their income
into corporate coffers: violence. The fruits and vegetables for sale
in the grocery store, which will be thrown in locked dumpsters to
rot before they are shared with the hungry a block away: violence.
The taxes on the sales of those vegetables, which pay for prisons
to hold men who will slave there as their ancestors did in chain
gangs and slave plantations, not to mention bombs to be sent as
foreign aid to governments who oppress and kill their own: vio­
lence. The employees who work at the stores, so they can afford a
disproportionately small portion of the goods and services made
by others like them: violence. The hospitals, insurance companies,
psychiatrists, manufacturers of prescription drugs, waiting like so
many circling vultures for the bodies and minds of these people to
weaken and betray them, poised to plunder their bank accounts
and drive them and their children back to work: violence. The hush
in the air, the absence of friends rejoicing together, of the shouts of
children at play, for the children are all at home with video games
and television and no one wants to be here, everyone wishes they
were somewhere far, far away, farther even than the palm-tree­
spotted scenes on the billboards advertising vacation resorts and
malt liquor ... violence, violence. You may not see one altercation,
one bruise; but the feeling in the air is the feeling of war.
AMap.65
64. A Map
intimidating red tape and the battering of women, the biased news
coverage and the inhumanity of factory farms, the jockeying for
ascendance between colleagues and countries, all these are simul­
taneously expressions of the strife at the heart of our civilization
and weapons which, used by factions fighting for survival on its
terms, perpetuate it.
Living under the reign of coercion strips you of your faith, leaves
you ready to use force on others, to treat them as the world has
treated you. It is well known that the playground bully acts out of
feelings of worthlessness, that the teenage hoodlum is moved to
vandalism by insecurity and frustrated yearning; how much self­
loathing and desperation must then be in the hearts of the moguls
and power-brokers whose machinations keep the global market run­
ning? Whether dishwashers or directors, all who cannot feel safe
enough to create and pursue their own dreams seek compensation
in wealth, status, or more overt forms of power over others.
Under such conditions, people come to see all human relations
as a conflict between mutually exclusive interests; it's no wonder
many have a hard time imagining howhuman beings could live with­
out the coercion of supposedly beneficial forces. But competition
and combat are themselves barriers to freedom, no less so than the
repression authorities insist is for our own good: conflicts distract,
control, and simplify all who are subject to them, just as police do.
The terror-mongers insist that hierarchy is necessary to protect us
from the violence inherent in our species-but hierarchy is simply
the large-scale manifestation of the violence intrinsic to this particu­
lar system. The fact that hierarchy can be absent-between friends,
in moments of widespread teamwork, in other societies-is proof
that we can live without its attendant violence, too.
Ultimately, all conflicts come down to relations of force-even
those known, up to this point, as revolutions. Our dream is not to
win another war, but to stage a total revolution, a war against the
condition of war, on behalf of those beautiful moments when we
can be thankful for each other's existence.
AMap.67
Faith
Invest in the future . . .
One either invests oneself in the present or the future: either reacts to ,
existing circumstances and their demands, or acts to change them. You
can spend all your energy surviving according to the terms set by the
market economy, the expectations of your parents and peers, and the
weight of your own inertia-or you can risk everything to make those
considerations obsolete. To succeed in the latter, you'll need faith.
Faith is the opposite of superstition. Faith means believing in
the boundless possibilities of the universe and setting out to explore
them. It means knowing that if you leap off a cliff, you're bound to
land somewhere. Faith means trusting that the world is wider and
richer than you could possibly see from where you are, and there­
fore not feeling pressure to plan out the rest of your life from here.
You might be better off just sketching a route to the horizon: from
there, you'll be able to make out new vistas and make new plans
accordingly. Heaven help those who make long-term plans today
and stick to them, whose lives will never be greater than what they
can imagine right now!
68. A Map
Faith means embracing your desire: knowing what you want,
that it is good, that it will come true. Faith enables you to relax­
relaxing allows you to act freely and learn from the consequences.
Faith is the engine of the self-fulfilling prophecy. It equips you to
rely on your intuition and grants you power over your fear. Whether
yoUare confronting a police line or giving birth to a child or a song,
faith is indispensable for capital-L living.
Fear
... or protect yourself to death.
Force cannot rule alone, for one can only rule over the living. Force
can establish domination only in combination with fear; fear, on the
other hand, can rule even in the absence of force.
Fear dictates that, in the mind of the ruled, beyond the frontiers
of obedience, there is only darkness, nothingness, the unthinkable.
Chaos, failure, damnation, and death are projected onto this un­
known; this is ironic, in that what one projects can only be based
on what one knows. We can deduce that those who fear the un­
known reveal the world they know to be a place of terror, and that
those who most fear setting out for the horizon stand to gain the
most from doing so.
But the one who lives in fear moves only to consolidate the
present. He is n o ~ capable of free action-he is too busy reacting
in advance to things that haven't even happened yet. He can only
conceive of the future-any future-as a threat. He trusts nothing
to chance, and thus chance cannot entrust him with more than he
already has.
Fear lies at the root of all violence and coercion. When one trusts
her companions and the surrounding world to provide, if not what
she thinks she needs, at least something equally weird and wonder­
ful, she too can be gentle and generous. If she feels threatened by
them, she grows defensive and aggressive, strikes out blindly, be­
comes possessed by resentment and cruelty. Vengeance becomes her
motivating force, more powerful than any other desire: anything to
take revenge upon the world that has made her feel so unwelcome
and worthless. Acting on these impulses, she spreads them to others
like a plague. Fear, like faith, is self-perpetuating-until something
breaks the cycle.
AMap.69
Whatever your path in life, you must develop a healthy
ship to your fear, or else it will truly be a terrible master. We
about "primitive" peoples' rites of passage-but we are the
tive ones, coddling our fears rather than confronting them. Wfi'
never come of age. ..
Are you living deliberately? Do you approach risk willfully, ori
do you deny yourself things out of fear? What are you afraid of?;"

What are you saving yourself for? Do you own your body? Preser- :1
vation of the flesh is futile-we all die someday. The question is!,
what happens first. .:)
1i
There are two possible responses to fear. One is to cower.
other is to follow your fear, to use it as a guide, to track it out past:
the limits of the world you know. Don't save yourself. Don't spare
yourself. Some things can't be written or told. Go search.
I arrived at the university on assignment. My editor had long known
that I'd lost faith in the racket; he was waiting for a suitable pretext
to fire me, and in the meantime sent me to cover the least desirable
stories. I had attended pie-eating competitions, senior citizen golf
tournaments, exhibitions of Victorian furniture. I didn't expect this
to be much different.
When I showed up the occupation was already in full swing. It
looked like the outpost of a medieval army: banners painted with
inscrutable proclamations, cauldrons of stew steaming over an open
fire, sooty-faced barbarians conferring in the crisp morning air. It
seemed inconceivable that something like this existed in my own
century, let alone zip code.
The young barbarian who showed me around the site seemed to
regard me as the anachronism, however. She was personable enough,
but didn't bother even pretending to take me seriously. Every ques­
tion I asked was turned back around at me:
"And which organizations provide your funding?"
"Which 'organizations' provide your funding?"
"Come on, you must be drawing resources from somewhere." I ges­
tured at the tents around us just as two bleary-eyed ruffians stumbled
past with cardboard boxes full of produce. "You don't expect me to
believe you're doing all this without sponsors, do you?"
"Is that what you think? No wonder you're a reporter."
This was terrible form for anyone hoping for sympathetic cover­
age; we journalists are notoriously thin-skinned and have the instru­
ments of revenge continuously at our fingertips. Could it be that
these savages truly didn't give a damn about good press?
Dreams. 71
70. A Map
, t
I
, I,
That would be something new. Everywhere I went, people fawned Scarcity, propriety, cruelty, routine-these things seem like laws
of nature, at least until you experience otherwise. You can't blame
those who cannot imagine more-only show them it exists.
Just as the alchemists of bygone days strove to change lead irito
gold, to create new possibilities by rearranging existing elements,
we must make fortune from misfortune and magic of the mun­
dane. The alchemist understands it is the forces that count, not the
materials-the relationships, not the things. Any situation, every
situation, can be revolutionized-you simply have to enter know­
ing your life is at stake.
on me, jostling each other out of the way for the chance to tell their'
trifling stories. I was the doorkeeper at the gates, of power and public,
opinion, a character straight out of Kafka; in a society that viewed,
the whole world 'through the media lens, I was, like the fairy in Pi­
nocchio,the only one who could make them real. This was doubly
true of radicals and protesters, however dubiously they claimed to
regard my employers.
My interlocutor didn't have any interest in becoming real-she
was content to remain imaginary, along with the medieval encamp- "
ment around us and the objectives of this protest, if any even existed.
I had to admit, it was almost refreshing to encounter someone for .:
once who had no interest in me at all. Instead of breaking off the !
interview to hammer out a dismissive dispatch, I continued pressing, c
her witth questions, though with less and less conviction. Finally,
I gave up and sat down, narrowly resisting the impulse to put my
head in my hands.
"I don't get it." The open tent flap to the left revealed three sleeping "
young people, naked and androgynous, entwined in an embrace that re- '
pudiated two thousandyears of Christian doctrine. On my right, a man ?
I took to be a janitor rifled through a crate of tools, finally selecting a,
hacksawand a bowling pin. "All this is like a dream, and I never dream."
That had come out more maudlin than I'd intended. She seated
herself at my side, looking at me for the first time with compassion..
"Like the king who never had any dreams until the wizard made him "
sleep in a pigsty,"
7::1.. Dreams
Our contest is with gravity, with the weight of inertia. It is up
to us to shake it off-or turn it to our advantage. For the slothful
man, gravity is a force to be feared, a hated master; he finds in it
an argument against motion, action, life itself. But for the dancer,
gravity is indispensable. Without it, she would have nothing to play
against, no counterpoint for her strength and skill. She flies all the
more gracefully for being born without wings.
We must dance with our apprehensions, our agonies, our histo­
ries, or be paralyzed by them. With lightness of foot, we can trans­
form our centuries-long history of destruction and disappoint­
ment into a mere prologue, the tragic overture before a beautiful
symphony-justifying and absolving ourselves, and the world we
know, in the process.
If there is anyone foolish enough to want this world the way it
is, let him have it-let him have it!!-and perish with it. For the rest
of us, alchemy is our only hope.
"Unfortunately, some people have careers and responsibilities," I
mused aloud, inviting her to help me excuse myself. "Not everyone
can drop everything and set up\camp here like you. I have bills to
pay, appointments to keep ..."
She took my hand and led me breathless from the ruins. "Life is
not retrospective," she confided. "Let's not be, either."
Alchemy / Dreams. 73
Beyond
Democracy?!

"Just be thankful you live in a democracy!"
.. :'c
- c::--. i'r=.:...
.--­
Nowadays, democracy rules the world. Communism is long dead,
elections are taking place in all those thirdworld countries you see on
television, and world leaders are meeting to plan the "global commu­
nity" we hear so much about. So why isn't everybody happy, finally?
For that matter-why do so few of the eligible voters in the United
States, the world's flagship democracy, even bother to vote?
Could it be that democracy, long the catchword of every revolu­
tion and resistance, is simply not democratic enough? What could
be more democratic?
Beyond Democracy. 75
Every little child can
grow up to be President.
No they can't. Being President means occupying a position of hil
archical power, just like being a billionaire: for every person who,
President, there have to be millions who are not. It's no coincidem.:
that billionaires and Presidents tend to rub shoulders; both exist i.
a privileged world off limits to the rest of us. Speaking of billio..
aires, our economy isn't exactly democratic-capitalism distribut
resources in absurdly unequal proportions, and you have to st
with resources if you're ever going to get elected.* .
76 . Beyond Democracy
'Let'S suspend our misgivings about democracy long enough to consider wheth­
er, if it were an effective means for people to share power over their lives, it
could be compatible with capitalism. In a democracy, an informed citizenry
is supposed to vote according to their enlightened self-interest-but who
controls the flow of information under capitalism if not wealthy executives?
They can't help but skew their coverage according to their class interests, and
yOU can hardly blame them-the newspapers and networks that didn't flinch
at alienating corporate advertisers were run out of business long ago by com­
petitors with fewer scruples.
Likewise, voting means choosing between options, according to which possi­
bilities seem most desirable-but who sets the options, who establishes what
is considered possible, who constructs desire itself but the wealthy patriarchs
of the political establishment and their nephews in advertising and public re­
lations firms? In the United States, the two-party system has reduced politics
to choosing the lesser of two identical evils, both of which answer to their
funders before anyone else. Sure, the parties differ over exactly how much to
repress personal freedoms or spend on bombs-but do we ever get to vote on
who controls "public" spaces such as shopping malls, or whether workers are
entitled to the full product of their labor, or any other question that could
seriously change the way we live? In such a state of affairs, the essential func­
tion of the democratic process is to limit the appearance of what is possible
to the narrow spectrum debated by candidates for office. This demoralizes
dissidents and contributes to the general impression that they are impotent
utopians-when nothing is more utopian than trusting representatives from
the owning class to redress the grievances caused by their own dominance,
and nothing more impotent than accepting their political system as the only
possible political system.
Ultimately, the most transparent democratic political process will always be
trumped by economic matters such as property ownership. Even if we could
convene everyone, capitalists and convicts alike, in one vast general assembly,
what would prevent the same dynamics that rule the marketplace from spill­
ing over into that sacred space? So long as resources are unevenly distributed,
the rich can always buy others' votes: either literally, or by promising a piece
of the pie, or else by means of propaganda and intimidation. Intimidation may
be oblique-"Those radicals want to take away your hard-earned property"­
or as overt as the bloody gang wars that accompanied electoral campaigns in
nineteenth century America. Thus, even at best, democracy can only serve
its purported purpose if it occurs among those who explicitly oppose capi­
talism and foreswear its prizes-and in those circles, consensus makes a lot
more sense than majority rule.
capitalism
+
democracy
=
one dollar, one vote.
.1'
~ j
.'
Even if it was true that anyone could grow up to be President, thad
wouldn't help the millions who inevitably don't, who must still,,;
live in the shadow of that power. This imbalance is intrinsic to the:::
structure of representative democracy, at the local level as much as'
at the top. The professional politicians of a town council discuss \
municipal affairs and pass ordinances all day without consulting.:t
the citizens of the town, who have to be at work; when one of those";
,
ordinances displeases citizens, they have to use what little leisure'[
time they have to contest it, and then they're back at work again}
the next time the town council meets. In theory, the citizens could,j
elect a different town council from the available pool of politicians'
and would-be politicians, but the interests of politicians as a class."
always remain essentially at odds with their own-besides, voting:
fraud, gerrymandering, and inane party loyalty usually prevent them:!
from going that far. Even in the unlikely scenario that a whole new;,
government was elected consisting of firebrands intent on undoing]
the imbalance of power between politicians and citizens, theywouldj
inevitably perpetuate it simply by accepting roles in the system-for ..
the political apparatus itself is the foundation of that imbalance. ,
To succeed in their objective, they would have to dissolve the gov­
ernment and join the rest of the populace in restructuring society!
from the roots up.
But even if there were no Presidents or town councils, democracy"
as we know it would still be an impediment to freedom. C o r r u p - ~
tion, privilege, and hierarchy aside, majority rule is not only inher-i
ently oppressive but also paradoxically divisive and homogenizing <
at the same time.
78. Beyond Democracy
The Tyranny of the Majority
If you ever found yourself in a vastly outnumbered minority, and
the majority voted that you had to give up something as necessary
to your life as water and air, would you comply? When it comes
down to it, does anyone really believe it makes sense to accept the
authority of a group simply on the grounds that they outnumber
everyone else? We accept majority rule because we do not believe
it will threaten us-and those it does threaten are already silenced
before anyone can hear their misgivings.
The average self-professed law-abiding citizen does not consider
himself threatened by majority rule because, consciously or not,
he conceives of himself as having the power and moral authority
of the majority: if not in fact, by virtue of his being politically and
socially "moderate," then in theory, because he believes everyone
would be convinced by his arguments if only he had the opportu­
nity to present them. Majority-rule democracy has always rested on
the conviction that if all the facts were known, everyone could be
made to see that there is only one right course of action-without
this belief, it amounts to nothing more than the dictatorship of the
herd. But even if "the" facts could be made equally clear to everyone,
assuming such a thing were possible, people still would have their
individual perspectives and motivations and needs. We need social
and political structures that take this into account, in which we are
free from the mob rule of the majority as well as the ascendancy of
the privileged class.
Living under democratic rule teaches people to think in terms
of quantity, to focus more on public opinion than on what their
consciences tell them, to see themselves as powerless unless they
are immersed in a mass. The root of majority-rule democracy is
competition: competition to persuade everyone else to your position
Whether or not it is in their best interest, competition to constitute
a majority to wield power before others outmaneuver you to do the
Beyond Democracy. 79
same-and the losers (that is to say, the minorities) be damned," At
.
the same time, majority rule forces those who wish for power to
appeal to the lowest common denominator, precipitating a race to
.the bottom that rewards the most bland, superficial, and demagogic;
under democracy, power itself comes to be associated with confor­
mity rather than individuality. And the more power is concentrated
in the hands of the majority, the less any individual can do on her
own, whether she is inside or outside that majority.
In purporting to give everyone an opportunity to participate,
majority-rule democracy offers a perfect justification for repressing
those who don't abide by its dictates: if they don't like the govern­
ment, why don't they go into politics themselves? And if they don't
win at the game of building up a majority to wield power, didn't they
• The disempowerment of losers and out-groups is central to democracy, in con­
trast to forms of decision-making in which everyone's needs matter. It is well
known that in ancient Athens, the «cradle of democracy," scarcely an eighth of
the population was permitted to vote, as women, foreigners, slaves, and oth­
ers were excluded from citizenship. This is generally regarded as an early kink
that time has ironed out, but one could also conclude that exclusion itself is ii
the most essential and abiding characteristic of democracy: millions who live j
in the United States today are not permitted to vote either, and the distinc- ,I
tions between citizen and non-citizen have not eroded significantly in 2500
years. Every bourgeois property owner can come up with a thousand r e a s o ~ ,
why it isn't practical to allow everyone whose interests are involved to share'
in decision making, just as no boss or bureaucrat would dream of giving his .
employees an equal say in their workplace, but that doesn't make it any less "!
exclusive. WHat if-we must at least broach the hypothesis-democracy arose "
in Greece not as a step in Man's Progress Towards Freedom, but as a way of
keeping power out of certain hands?
Democracy is the most sustainable way to maintain)
the distinction between powerful and powerless
because it gives the greatest possible number of
people incentive to defend that distinction.
That's why the high-water mark of democracy-its current ascendancy around
the globe-corresponds with unprecedented inequities in the distribution of
resources and power, Dictatorships are inherently unstable: you can slaughten
imprison, and brainwash entire generations and their children will invent
struggle for freedom anew. But promise every man the opportunity to be
dictator, to be able to force the «will of the majority» upon his fellows rathe
than work through disagreements like a mature adult, and you can build ..
common front of destructive self-interest against the cooperation and coll
tivity that make individual freedom possible. All the better if there are eve:
more repressive dictatorships near at hand to point to as «the» alternative,
you can glorify all this in the rhetoric of liberty.
80 . Beyond Democracy
get their chance? This is the same blame-the-victim reasoning used
to justify capitalism: if the dishwasher isn't happy with his salary,
he should work harder so he too can own a restaurant chain. Sure,
everyone gets a chance to compete, however unequal-but what
about those of us who don't want to compete, who never wanted
power to be centralized in the hands of a government in the first
place? What if we don't care to rule or be ruled?
That's what police are for-and courts and judges and prisons.
The Rule of Law
Even if you don't believe their purpose is to grind out nonconformity
wherever it appears, you have to acknowledge that legal institutions
are no substitute for fairness, mutual respect, and good will. The
rule of "just and equal law," as fetishized by the stockholders and
landlords whose interests' it protects, offers no guarantees against
injustice; it simply creates another arena of specialization, in which
power and responsibility are ceded to expensive lawyers and pomp­
ous judges. Rather than serving to protect our communities and work
out conflicts, this arrangement ensures that our communities' skills
for conflict resolution and self-defense atrophy-and that those
whose profession it supposedly is to discourage crime have a stake
in it proliferating, since their careers depend upon it.
Ironically, we are told that we need these institutions to protect
the rights of minorities-even though the implicit function of the
courts is, at best, to impose the legislation of the majority on the mi­
nority. In actuality, a person is only able to use the courts to defend
his rights when he can bring sufficient force to bear upon them in a
currency they recognize; thanks to capitalism, only a minority can
do this, so in a roundabout way it turns out that, indeed, the courts
exist to protect the rights of at least a certain minority.
Justice cannot be established through the mere drawing up and
enforcement of laws; such laws can only institutionalize what is
already the rule in a society. Common sense and compassion are al­
ways preferable to the enforcement of strict, impersonal regulations.
Where the law is the private province of an elite invested in its own
perpetuation, the sensible and compassionate are bound to end up as
defendants; we need a social system that fosters and rewards those
qualities rather than blind obedience and impassivity.
Beyond Democracy. 81
It's no coincidence "freedom"
is not on the ballot.
Freedom is a quality of activity, not a condition that exists in a vac­
.
i
~ .
~
uum: it is a prize to be won daily, not a possession that can be kept
in the basement and taken out and polished up for parades. Freedom '.
cannot be given-the most you can hope is to free others from the'
forces that prevent them from finding it themselves. Real freedom
has nothing to do with voting; being free doesn't mean simply be- .;
ing able to choose between options, but actively participating in
establishing the options in the first place.
"Look, a ballot box-democracy!!"
If the freedom for which so many generations have fought and died :
is best exemplified by a man in a voting booth checking a box on a
ballot before returning to work in an environment no more under
his control than it was before, then the heritage our emancipating
forefathers and suffragette grandmothers have left us is nothing
but a sham substitute for the liberty they sought.
For a better illustration of real freedom in action, look at the.
musician in the act of improvising with her companions: in joy- f
ous, seemingly effortless co­
operation, they create a sonic
and emotional environment,
transforming the world that.
in turn transforms them. Take ;
this model and extend it to ev­
eryone of our interactions with ;
each other and you would have
something qualitatively diffef- ]
ent from our present system--'a .
harmony in human relation­
ships and activity. To get there
from here, we have to dispense.
with voting as the archetypal
expression of freedom and par­
ticipation.
82 . Beyond Democracy
Representative democracy
isa contradiction in terms.
No one can represent your power and interests for you-you can only
have power by wielding it, you can only learn what your interests
are by getting involved. Politicians make careers out of claiming to
represent others, as if freedom and political power could be held by
proxy; in fact, they are a priest class that answers only to itself, and
their very existence is proof of our disenfranchisement.
Voting in elections is an expression of our powerlessness: it is
an admission that we can only approach the resources and capabili­
ties of our own society through the mediation of that priest class.
When we let them prefabricate our options for us, we relinquish
control of our communities to these politicians in the same way
that we have ceded technology to engineers, health care to doctors,
and control of our living environments to city planners and private
real estate developers. We end up living in a world that is alien to
us, even though our labor h a ~ built it, for we have acted like sleep­
walkers hypnotized by the monopoly our leaders and specialists
hold on setting the possibilities.
But we don't have to simply choose between presidential candi­
dates, soft drink brands, television shows, and political ideologies.
We can make our own decisions as individuals and communities,
we can make our own delicious beverages and social structures and
power, we can establish a new society on the basis of freedom and
cooperation. Here's how.
What are the democratic
alternatives to democracy?
Consensus
Consensus-based decision-making is already practiced around the
globe, from indigenous communities in Latin America and direct ac­
tion groups in Europe to organic farming cooperatives in Australia.
In Contrast to representative democracy, the participants take part
in the decision-making process on an ongoing basis and exercise real
Beyond Democracy. 83
control over their daily lives. Unlike majority-rule democracy, con­
sensus values the needs and concerns of each individual equally; if
-one person is unhappy with a resolution, it is everyone's responsibil­
ity to find a new solution that is acceptable to all. Consensus-based
decision-making does not demand that any person accept others'
power over her, though it does require that everybody consider ev­
eryone else's needs; what it loses in efficiency it makes up tenfold
in freedom and accountability. Instead of asking that people accept
leaders or find common cause by homogenizing themselves, consen­
sus process integrates all into a working whole while allowing each
to retain his or her own autonomy.
Autonomy
To be free, you must have control over your immediate surroundings
and the basic matters of your life. No one is more qualified than you _
are to decide how you live; no one should be able to vote on what
you do with your time and your potential unless you invite them
to. To claim these privileges for yourself and respect them in others
is to cultivate autonomy.
j
I ~ Autonomy is not to be confused with so-called independence: in
actuality, no one is independent, since our lives all depend on each
other.* The glamorization of self-sufficiency in competitive society
is an underhanded way to accuse those who will not exploit oth­
ers of being responsible for their own poverty; as such, it is one of
the most significant obstacles to building communityr In contrast
to this Western mirage, autonomy offers a free interdependence be­
tween people who share consensus.
Autonomy is the antithesis of bureaucracy. There is nothing
more efficient than people acting on their own initiative as they see
fit, and nothing more inefficient than attempting to dictate every­
one's actions from above-that is, unless your fundamental goal is
to control other people. Top-down coordination is only necessary
when people must be made to do something they would never do
* ·Western man fills his closet with groceries and calls himself self-sufficient."
-Mohandas Gandhi
t The politicians' myth of "welfare mothers" snatching hardworking Citizens'
rightful earnings, for example, divides individuals who might otherwise form
cooperative groups with no use for politicians.
84 . Beyond Democracy
of their own accord; likewise, obligatory uniformity, however hori­
zontally it is imposed, can only empower a group by disempowering
the individuals who comprise it. Consensus can be as repressive as
democracy unless the participants retain their autonomy.
Autonomous individuals can cooperate without agreeing on a
shared agenda, so long as everyone benefits from everyone else's
participation. Groups that cooperate thus can contain conflicts
and contradictions, just as each of us does individually, and still
empower the participants. Let's leave marching under a single flag
to the military.
Finally, autonomy entails self-defense. Autonomous groups have
a stake in defending themselves against the encroachments of those
who do not recognize their right to self-determination, and in ex­
panding the territory of autonomy and consensus by doing every-­
thing in ~ h e i r power to destroy coercive structures.
Topless Federations
Independent autonomous groups can work together in federations
without any of them wielding authority. Such a structure sounds
utopian, but it can actually be quite practical and efficient. Inter­
national mail delivery and railway travel both work on this system,
to name two examples: while individual postal and transportation
Beyond Democracy _85
systems are internally hierarchical, they all cooperate together to
get mail or rail passengers from one nation to another without an
ultimate authority being necessary at any point in the process. Simi­
larly, individuals who cannot agree enough to work together within
one collective can still coexist in separate groups. For this to work
in the long run, of course, we need to instill values of cooperation,
consideration, and tolerance in the coming generations-but that's
exactly what we are proposing, and we can hardly do worse at this
task than the partisans of capitalism and hierarchy have.
Direct Action
Autonomy necessitates that you act for yourself: that rather than
waiting for requests to pass through the established channels only
to bog down in paperwork and endless negotiations, you establish J
your own channels instead. If you want hungry people to have food
to eat, don't just give money to a bureaucratic charity organization­
find out where food is going to waste, collect it, and share. If you
want affordable housing, don't try to get the town council to pass
a bill-that will take years, while people sleep outside every night;
take over abandoned buildings, open them up to the public, and
organize groups to defend them when the thugs of the absentee
landlords show up. If you want corporations to have less power,
don't petition the politicians they bought to put limits on their
own masters-take that power from them yourself. Don't buy their
products, don't work for them, sabotage their billboards and offices, ',1
prevent their meetings from taking place and their merchandise
from being delivered. They use similar tactics to exert their power :)
over you, too-it only looks valid because they bought up the laws ..
and values of your society long before you were born.
Don't wait for permission or leadership from some outside au­
thority, don't beg some higher power to organize your life for you.
Take the initiative!
How to Solve Disagreements
Without Calling the Authorities
In a social arrangement that is truly in the best interest of each par-:,l
ticipating individual, the threat of exclusion should be enough to
86 . Beyond Democracy
i
'
,
)
~
discourage most destructive or disrespectful behavior. Even when
it is impossible to avoid, exclusion is certainly a more humanitar­
ian approach than prisons and executions, which corrupt police
and judges as much as they embitter criminals. Those who refuse
to respect others' needs, who will not integrate themselves into
any community, may find themselves banished from social life­
but that is still better than exile in the mental ward or on death
row, two of the possibilities awaiting such people today. Violence
should only be used by communities in self-defense, not with the
smug sense of entitlement with which it is applied by our present
injustice system. Unfortunately, in a world governed by force, au­
tonomous consensus-based groups are likely to find themselves at
odds with those who do not abide by cooperative or tolerant val­
ues; they must be careful not to lose those values themselves in the
process of defending them.
Serious disagreements within communities can be solved in
many cases by reorganizing or subdividing groups. Often individuals
who can't get along in one social configuration have more success
cooperating in another setting or as members of parallel commu­
nities. If consensus cannot be reached within a group, that group
can split into smaller groups that can achieve it internally-such
a thing may be inconvenient and frustrating, but it is better than
group decisions ultimately being made by force by those who have
the most power. As with individuals and society, so with different
collectives: if the benefits of working together outweigh the frustra­
tions, that should be incentive enough for people to sort out their
differences. Even drastically dissimilar communities still have it in
their best interest to coexist peacefully, and must somehow negoti­
ate ways to achieve this ...
living Without Permission
... that's the most difficult part, of course. But we're not talking
about just another social system here, we're talking about a total
transformation of human relations-for it will take nothing less to
solve the problems our species faces today. Let's not kid ourselves­
until we can achieve this, the violence and strife inherent in con­
flict-based relations will continue to intensify, and no law or system
will be able to protect us. In consensus-based structures, there are
Beyond Democracy. 87
no fake solutions, no ways to suppress conflict without resolving
it; those who participate in them must learn to coexist without co­
ercion and submission.
The first precious grains of this new world can be found in your
friendships and love affairs whenever they are free from power dy­
namics, whenever cooperation occurs naturally. Imagine those mo­
ments expanded to the scale of our entire society-that's the life
that waits beyond democracy.
It may feel like we are separated from that world by an uncross­
able chasm, but the wonderful thing about consensus and autonomy
is that you don't have to wait for the government to vote for them­
you can practice them right now with the people around you. Put
into practice, the virtues of this way of living are clear. Form your i
own autonomous group, answering to no power but your own, and'
chase down freedom for yourselves, if your representatives will not
do it for you-since they cannot do it for you.
!
I
~
j
I ~
I
88. Beyond Democracy
"
Whoever they vote for,
we are ungovernable!
Nature abhors a vacuum, and civilization is no different; so it was
that one by one I found ersatz versions of everything I'd set out to
experience. I'd wanted wild romance; I was dating a nice boy who
went trespassing with me on the weekends. I'd longed for adven­
ture; I was applying to schools in hopes of getting funding to study
abroad. I'd wanted to do something that mattered with my life; after
months of flailing around, I'd settled for a little environmental ac­
tivism. Had you asked me then whether these satisfied me, I might
have said they did; I had nothing to compare them to. I might also
have told you that I only made it from one moment to the next by
imagining everything around me on fire.
That was my state of mind in the audience of the city council
meeting as I waited to speak about the water table. Rita and I had
fidgeted quietly through a seemingly interminable succession of for­
malities, gripes, and pitches; now, if I remembered correctly, there
was only one name left on the ledger before hers.
Watching the speakers before us-homeowners outraged about
speed bumps, businessmen putting in appearances to smooth over
back-room deals-it was clear we were out of our league. These peo­
ple didn't give a damn about water or anything else; they had their
hands full keeping up with their own bureaucracy and thought too
highly of themselves to aspire to anything more. The citizens there
couldn't see beyond their own property rights; the only ones that
struck me as remotely interesting were the two shabbily dressed",
young men seated at my right. One of them was the only other \ ~
brown face in the audience, besides a few people I took to be city ';
employees. Heaven only knew what kept the two of them there-it ')
didn't look like they had any property to speak of.
When you've decided that spontaneity and passion are, if not your !
basis for life, your only hope of escape, the pressure can be trernen- i
dous. Nothing is more terrifying than the moments when it seems,
impossible that anything exciting will happen, and those moments')
succeed each other like Chinese water torture. I had been living
under that pressure since Daniel's funeral, and had started to taktf'
90. Two Councils
",
refuge from it in a contrived cynicism-the inverse of the enforced
optimism I'd had to adopt for job applications and presentations
like this one. The longer I sat there, the more it turned my stomach
to think about trying to make a case to those bureaucrats; it was
hard enough convincing myself it mattered what they thought or
did. But the councilmen had finished their remarks, and the woman
who had been complaining in coded language about Latino youth
appearing in her neighborhood was returning to her seat.
The young man to my right leaned confidentially across the
empty seat between us. "Watch this," he whispered.
His companion stood up and walked slowly to the podium,
brushed back disheveled black hair, and began shuffling through a
sheaf of dog-eared papers. The rustle of those papers over the PA
speakers was the only sound in the room for almost a full minute. At
last, he began in a mumbling drone: "Several men meet their deaths
at the hands of a monster. Two monsters from the Department of
the Interior come to look the situation over ... "
As he continued, the faces around me shifted slowly from disin­
terest to disbelief. Finally, a councilman attempted to cut him off. At
that point, the boy next to me called out in a booming voice: "Your
honor, what my colleague is getting at is that it would be a grave
mistake to evict the occupation from the university. But first, let
me add something on the subject of monsters, which-"
The councilman turned his attention to the second speaker; he
was better prepared to deal with this kind of disruption. "Let me
remind everyone that those who speak out of turn will be removed.
There is a standard policy for signing up to address the Town, which
anyone can make use of, and it is not fair to other citizens to mis­
use this venue."
The hoodlum at the podium straightened up and threw back his
shoulders, and his dark eyes narrowed like a hawk's. "But we have
something of great importance to convey to you about this matter,"
he continued, in pompous parody of the officials. "You see, those
who do battle with monsters-"
The mayor had turned bright red and was pounding his fist on
the table: "Get to the point, get to the point!"
It hadn't occurred to me until then that they intended to make
the bureaucrats lose their composure. My neighbor kicked his chair
back and leaped onto it, waving his arms and roaring like a madman:
Two Councils, 91
"The point is, we all tried to be good citizens,
behaving ourselves and trying to beat each
other out for promotions and spending our
money on soft drinks-and we ended up
dishwashers and doormen, waiting in line
at the free clinic to have our rotten teeth
pulled by student volunteers! It's a fucking
PYRAMID SCAM and you know it! The
point is, there are fifty of us on that campus
who aren't afraid of you because we have
an entirely different future ahead of us than
anything you can offer-and if there are fifty
today, there'll be fifty thousand tomorrow,
because people are dying for something else
and some of us are ready to LIVE for it,
TOO!! The point is, I'm warning you-you're
dealing with fucking ANARCHISTS!
We didn't sign your social contract! If
you're willing to coexist with us, we'll share
everything we have with you, we'll go to any
length to work out conflicts-but if you want
to be the boss, if you want to give orders and'
always be in the right, then whether you',
have a security guard or a whole civilization:
behind you we're going to have to FIGHT
until one of us is DEAD, because one
thing we will NOTdo is BE RULED!!!
Are you listening to me?"
92, Two Councils
A man in a uniform was struggling to make his way down our
aisle; in the second subversive act of my life, I stretched out my leg,
making him stumble just as he reached for the orator's arm, The lat­
ter, having completed his address, leaped to an empty chair behind
us and bounded that way from row to row all the way to the back of
the room, dodging audience members who clutched their purses and
briefcases as he passed. His partner met him at the door, loose papers
filling the air behind him; I could see now that these were handbills.
It seemed certain that the two would be apprehended there, but at
that instant there was shouting and movement from the other side
of the room as a cloud of smoke appeared from between the seats.
When I looked back to the door, they were gone.
Even after the smoke had cleared and a functionary had gathered
up most of the papers, the meeting did not resume for some min­
utes. Not only had the incident thoroughly rattled everyone, but it
appeared the young man who had been at the podium had taken
the microphone with him.
Rita and I filed out along with much of the audience as more
men in uniforms bustled about and town officials conferred in ir­
ritated knots. Some of the people around me were silent; others
spoke in hushed tones. A few were actually laughing. I was relieved
not to have to make our presentation, but the rest of what had hap­
pened hadn't yet sunk in. I glanced at the handbill I'd picked up:
If it were not for the prisons they threaten to lock us in, we
might see that we are all in prison. If it were not for monsters
like the sweatshop profiteers, we might see that capitalism
has made us all monstrous. We visit zoos tosee what
becomes ofthe wild ones, we sit in audiences tolearn that
we are not musicians orprotagonists
-or city councilmen, I thought to myself.
I pushed open the door and stepped out into the cool autumn air.
Hanging across the building opposite Town Hall was a homemade
banner as long as a city bus. In enormous scarlet letters it read, simply,
EXPECT RESISTANCE
Two Councils, 93
A few days later the ones who had instigated the fracas at the town
council meeting were my new best friends, but it was another month
before I learned of the protracted discussions that had preceded it.
After the university announced that they were definitely going to
evict the encampment, word had reached the occupiers that city
police would be brought in for the eviction. There followed a series
of meetings that began late in the afternoon and continued into the
early hours of morning.
Although I wasn't there, I can imagine based on later meetings
how it must have played out. At first there was quite a bit of dissen­
sion: some argued that the occupation had served its purpose and it
would be most empowering for the participants to quit while they
were ahead, while others contended that if the goal was to exert
leverage on the administration by offering a deterrent to working
with noxious corporations, that could best be achieved by forcing
them to carry out the most expensive and embarrassing eviction pos­
sible. Eventually implacable camps crystallized on opposite sides of
this issue, and the group split up into two separate meetings so each
could establish what its goals were and what it asked of the other.
Some hours later, it had been negotiated that the fifty-odd occupi­
ers who desired a confrontation with the university would remain,
but that they would release a statement to the effect that they no
longer had anything to do with the student group. It had been im­
portant until then to blur the line between the student organiza­
tion and the rest of the occupiers to maintain the "legitimacy" of !
the occupation, but now that a messy eviction was inevitable that
association was a needless liability.
Those who remained faced the challenging task of organizing i
the defense of the encampment. This was particularly complicated
because there were almost certainly police agents among them who
would not only report proposed illegal activity but also attempt to
steer the planning in the least advantageous direction possible. First,
as a group, they agreed on their basic goals and guidelines: making
94 . Two Council,
the eviction costly was a higher priority than positive media cover­
age; no one was to be injured, but destruction of property was not
ruled out; resources for legal defense would be shared according to
need with all those arrested, regardless of charges. Next, everyone
split into smaller groups to strategize with people they knew and
trusted. This ensured that those who shared longstanding friend­
ships could make the most of their comfort and experience while
police agents ended up with other i s ~ l a t e d newcomers, planning the
aspects of the defense that required the least security. Once some of
those groups had hashed out their own plans, they sent delegates to
other groups to propose collaborations, sharing only the information
that was necessary for joint coordination. By this time, it was late at
night; small circles of conspirators dotted the grass around the en­
campment, while elsewhere on campus spokespersons of the more
cautious groups held hushed consultations in twos and threes.
None of this happened easily, I was told. At every step, there
were arguments, ruptures, hurt feelings and angry accusations. At
the time, these must have seemed the inevitable price of organiz­
ing in stressful circumstances with people from such a wide range
of perspectives; much later, it became clear that we hadn't taken
conflicts seriously enough from the beginning. We lost the follow­
ing round of struggle because no one addressed the rifts when they
first appeared.
Two Councils. 95
Once upon a time, it was said that capitalism reduced the
industrial worker to an appendage of flesh on a machine of iron.
Today, that description can be applied across the board: each of
us is a mere appendage of flesh on the vast machine that is our
society, for our communities and lives are divided into isolated
sectors to such an extent that the totality they comprise appears
entirely beyond our control. If we want to change the whole of
life, we must somehow become whole again ourselves.
Divided &
Conquered
Separation: The Disintegration of Self
Modern man's daily activity is as atomized as the cities that cir­
cumscribe it. He experiences existence as an ongoing conflict be­
tween achievement, romance, responsibility, fitness, relaxation,
and pleasure because all these pursuits seem to be mutually ex­
clusive. He would like to spend more time with his wife, but if he
doesn't stay at the office another hour he won't be able to advance
his career, and then he has to go to the gym to offset the effects of
lunch ... and there's that damn vacation to plan for, not to men­
tion world news to catch up on, before he can even think about ro­
mance. He downloads music over the internet, but never has time
to listen to it; he would like to get involved insome kind of volun­
teer work, but doesn't know where it would fit in his schedule. It's
hard enough just keeping up with his favorite radio program, and
even that doesn't provide him with much relief from the strain of
his busy life. Meaning, of course, is absent everywhere when life is
this disjointed; as none of his activities engage him completely, he
cannot find lasting satisfaction in any of them.
Compare this with the integrated, holistic life of the hunter­
gatherer. For her, there is no distinction between working and
playing, between taking care of her practical needs, enjoying her­
self, and spending time with her children, friends, and lovers. She
moves through the world, deriving sustenance, physical fitness, and
companionship from the same activities, weaving a daily life that
is both challenging and familiar: at once adventure, livelihood, and
religious ceremony.
Perhaps you've experienced this kind of life before in an enter­
prise that incorporated every aspect of your being into a perfect
equilibrium. If we cannot reintegrate our lives, we will squander
them trying to make impossible choices between equally indispens­
able pieces of ourselves. Likewise, if we want to make revolutionary
social change, we have to find ways of living that are revolutionary
in their very nature; for activism, environmental conservationism,
Or social responsibility as separate domains of life-as hobbies,
or even as day jobs-can never outweigh the effects of the rest of
our lives.
Divided & Conquered. 97
ethics
entertainment
" m i l Y ~
-.
Homo Fragmens
romance
work
JOHN BROWN AT THE AGE OF 58.
98. Divided & Conquered
Crime or Miracle:
A Complete Human Being
Specialization: The Division of Labor
Just as our individual lives are fragmented by compartmentaliza­
tion, our society is fragmented by ever-increasing specialization
as every sphere of life is relegated to the care of experts. Every
profession is divided and subdivided: from scientist to chemist,
from chemist to biochemist, from biochemist to pharmaceutical
neurobiologist until no one outside a handful of authorities can
understand the questions, let alone the answers. At that point, the
division of knowledge itself becomes authoritarian, for it grants
small groups of people vast power over others who are incapable of
informed participation in decisions that affect their lives.
Becoming a specialist is a self-selecting process: only those will­
ing to concentrate on one subject to the exclusion of all others can
excel at it. Thus engineers and computer programmers are willing
to build weapons of mass destruction and crack the codes of "sub­
versive" groups for the government, for they have never taken the
time to reflect seriously on the effects of their efforts-they simply
do what they have learned to do for whoever provides them the
opportunity and salary to do it. An expert who does his job well
without ever reflecting upon how his work impacts the social whole
is potentially extremely dangerous; without such men, there would
be no nuclear weapons. At the same time, without an analysis of
the part they play in society, each of these experts experiences so­
ciety as an external force acting on him without his participation,
even though it is comprised of people like himself.
Specialization discourages all of us from being well-rounded
human beings. Entertainment is left to movie directors, car mainte­
nance to automechanics, social change to professional politicians or
amateur activists. The more complicated technologies become, the
more obscure the language used by those in the know, the fewer of
us are able to exercise any control over our environments: "Call the
repair man," we chant, intimidated into ignorance and impotence.
Many question authority in the political sense, but few are prepared
to question the authorities on technical matters.
For an example of the impoverishing effects of specialization, con­
sider how rarely adults who are not recognized as "artists" partake of
the joys of aesthetic creation. What is meaningful about a painting
cannot be captured by purchasing it in a gallery and hanging it on
Divided & Conquered. 99
___ ,... ues with his comrades late one
--'6 .. oout narrative and form, and has a sudden exhilarat- "
ing insight. This is something we could all take part in, each with our'
unique talents; but by the end of elementary school, all but a few of
us have learned that we cannot paint, cannot sing, cannot dance. ~
myth of the divine inspiration of artists and the expert credentials of.
the art critics who deify them-just like the genius of scientists and"
the arcane knowledge of locksmiths-have fooled us into denying':
ourselves some of the sweetest gifts life has to offer. .,
Segregation: TheSub-Division of Communities'
Any schoolchild knows racial segregation didn't end with the Jim;­
Crow laws, or when they started bussing students from the ghetto,:'
to detention rooms at predominantly white schools. Classes and,.
races still live apart, separated by the walls of gated communitieqj
the windows of restaurants and automobiles, and invisible barrierS!
a thousand times more difficult to traverse. This is not a holdover,
from an earlier era, but an essential part of the capitalist world'
order, just like the walls that separate Mexico from the United,
States and Palestine from Israel; borders are open for commoditiesi
and closed to human bodies, except when those bodies are them,\"
selves valuable commodities-tourists, for example. With the
barriers in place, communities cannot learn from each other, can,
not exchange resources or intermingle, At the most, they intersec_.
through the market and mass media-white kids buy hip hop al­
bums and think they know about life in the 'hood.
But this subtle apartheid goes further: wherever there are w:
between communities, there are inevitably walls between Indrvi
uals within each community and walls within individuals as we_;"
"Every man for himself" means" ... against himself," insofar as
must renounce all the parts of himself that reside in other peopk
if we were really out "for ourselves" we would demolish every b
rier that separates us, for healthy relations with others are the m
precious form of wealth. The proverbial white picket fence of
suburbs, now hypertrophied into cinderblock and barbed wire, .
dicates a pathological drive to deprive oneself of all the nutrien
--0 ., Loncelveo,('
Separated spatially, socially, and psychologically, unable to rec- ;\:
ognize themselves in each other, people rarely seek common cause.t'
Instead, each group tends to blame others for its woes: the library:;
would get the necessary funding if only it wasn't going to the
guistics department, the African-American community would be:1;
able to pull itself up by its bootstraps if it wasn't for the Korean:
merchants leeching off it. Even political activists, in taking on sin-i
gle issues rather than addressing the root causes of modern misery,,'l
find themselves in competition with other activists: Will Congress;
prioritize forest protection legislation this session, or focus on abor-]
tion rights? Is the revolutionary subject of history the proletariat, '!
or the oppressed peoples of the Third World? Such isolated,
tually exclusive campaigns and frameworks can only maintain th¢'C;
underpinnings of our powerlessness; we need to transform our sickl,
society, not treat its symptoms one by one.
End Segregation! Reintegrate Our Lives!
As you read this, somewhere in the world there is an underground']
circus or punk rock band on tour. Unbeknownst to themselves and'(
others, they carry with them the seeds of an ancient social structure.]
Responsibilities are shared and valued equally within the group, andj
whenever someone wants a break from something or is curious to learn':
about something else she switches roles with another person. No
member's participation is any more or less important than any other's,/
whatever their individual strengths may be, for the cooperation and"
contentment of each is crucial to the functioning of the group. Each ,;J
member's daily activities satisfy her various desires: she feels at home
with her friends while she travels through new environments,
makes art that simultaneously entertains and educates, she gets exer1!
cise loading and unloading equipment, she learns newthings repairing1
the van and interacting with locals, she has adventures collecting
and other supplies through urban hunting and gathering that does not;!,
conflict with her anti-consumerist ethics. Best of all, she no longer haSJ
to distinguish between her own needs and those of the people
her, and this eliminates most of the stress of interacting with others.
Together all the participants function as an extended family, to
an extent that over time they are able to lose some members and gain!
others without losing their customs or closeness.
102. Divided &. Conquered
\
This spills over into their interactions with those outside their
clan. If there are no hierarchies or rigid divisions within a group,
there need not be artificial boundaries between that group and oth­
ers. They can move through a variety of social and cultural circles,
giving and receiving freely, limited only by their own sociability.
Yes, we'd have to downsize and rework our whole civilization
to follow the lead this merry little band offers, but for the past few
centuries we've been struggling to deal with the difficulties of not
living in such communities-and we haven't had much success. If
we're going to struggle anyway, it might as well be towards a uto­
pia in which our lives can encompass everything the cosmos has
to offer.
Divorces
Production Consumption
Art Life
Work Play
Lovers Friends
Intimacy Sexuality
Farms Supermarkets
Management Labor
Theory Action
Rich Poor
Youth Age
White Color
Men Women
Entertainment Education
Exercise Relaxation
Words Deeds
Technology Nature
Self-interest Generosity
Poetry Resistance
Workplaces Apartments
Business Pleasure
Divided &. Conquered. 103
We knew we couldn't hold out against the city police, so we de­
':
\
I:
cided to upstage them: if the administration was going to evict our
encampment, we'd evict the university first. There were a couple
dozen of us in teams of twos and threes; we divided the campus into
nine zones, agreed on a time, and split up.
I got the main cafeteria on account of my rapport with the em­
ployees. I wanted to check in once more anyway, since this was ,;
probably the last time they'd see me on campus.
After two watchful circuits around the building, I hung aroundl
the back door until a couple students came out. Another group of
students was coming down the stairs close on their heels; after they'
passed I waited on the landing until the door clicked shut before!
slipping the can out of my pack and spraying NO SWEATSHOPS:
NO EVICTION NO QUARTER across the wall. I sprang up the::
remaining stairs three at a time before anyone else appeared.
In the weeks I'd spent at the university, I'd never gotten over!
the shock I felt every time I entered the cafeteria. The sheer t o n ~
nage of unguarded food was exhilarating for someone used to hav'"
ing to shoplift it one candy bar at a time, but it was also infuriati
to see it here, unappreciated and often unused. In the course of
hour, more food left on the conveyor belt into the dish room th
my mother brought home in a month-and on the other side of
wall, invisible to the students with their symbolic logic and art hi,
tory homework, guys like ~ e were dodging jets of scalding wat
to process all that waste.
I strolled up to the fruit display, exchanging a wink with Wl
ter as he refilled one of the cereal machines. I'd underestimated:
backpack was big, but there was no way all those apples, orang'
and bananas would fit in it, let alone the bagels I had my eye on.
104. The Eviction
There were designer book bags unattended on the tables behind
me, but however privileged and ignorant their owners were they were
just innocent civilians in the war I was fighting now. I had to come
up with something else. The watch I'd borrowed read 11:59.
I went into the restroom and pulled out the garbage bag under
the paper towel dispenser; sure enough, there were several unused
bags folded neatly in the bottom of the can. When I'd taken out the
trash at the diner two jobs ago, I'd always done the same so I didn't
have to get a new bag from the utility closet every time. I snapped a
bag open in the air and slipped it into the front pocket of my sweat­
shirt. On the way out, I grabbed a paper towel and held it doubled
between my fingers and thumb.
I pulled my hood up and took a left out of the bathroom. No one
was looking at me; three hundred students were gossiping, shoveling
food into their mouths, and shouting for their friends to save them
seats without the slightest idea what was coming. I didn't glance
up again. In ten paces I reached the fire alarm. I gripped the lever
through the paper towel and pulled down.
Until that instant, my whole being had been taut, trembling
in fear of the deed I was to perform. I'd woken up twice in the
three hours I'd tried to sleep; right up to the moment the buzzer
tore the air and everyone leaped up in shock, there was a part of
me that could not believe it was really going to happen. Unexpect­
edly, as soon as it was done, I was completely at peace. Now there
was no time to worry about consequences and complications; I
inhabited my body like an animal, with tasks to accomplish and
predators to escape.
I walked straight to the fruit display. Without glancing at the
pandemonium around me, I upended the shelves of fruit one after
another into the garbage bag, then shook all the bagels out of their
display case into my backpack and pushed in the one-gallon pea­
nut butter can for good measure. Walter had left a full cereal bag
by the cereal dispensers; I dropped it in with the fruit as I took off
at an oblique angle to the flow of students making for the exit. The
garbage bag bumped against my legs as I ran. I struggled to hold it
Out to the side, but it was heavy.
We hit a bottleneck at the stairs. As soon as I was through the exit
door, I pulled my hood back; there were no cameras here, the kids
around me weren't paying attention, and if anyone behind us was
The Eviction . 105
interested in me they'd have to fight through a lot of traffic. As we
reached the stairs and began our slow descent, NO SWEATSHOPS NO
EVICTION came into view over the heads of the crowd below.
The mood shifted here. What had been a routine drill for some and
a frightening situation for others suddenly took on a new character.
Conversations grew more animated; someone let out a whistle.
As we stepped outside, I could hear other alarms in the distance
alternating faintly with the one immediately behind us in a complex
call and response pattern. There was already a thick crowd around
the building mingling with the crowds pouring out of other build­
ings: students holding half-eaten hamburgers or notebooks they'd
just been writing in, some yammering into cell phones, others silently
taking in the spectacle-and interspersed among them professors,
janitors, librarians, dining hall managers, secretaries, administrators.
Normally, most of these people would be inside, segregated accord­
ing to class and position, but here it was as if all the buildings on
campus had been upended and shaken out to show the true compo­
sition of the university. It was ironic that only a total interruption
could bring together all the different people who.constituted it and
give them something in common.
All the cafeteria employees were sitting or leaning along one low
brick wall, including the Latino dishwashers whose existence was
such a carefully guarded secret. I set down the heavy garbage bag
behind a trash can and made my way over. Someone had brought
out a little radio, which was cheerfully singing gospel music in a
tinny, indomitable voice. Ethel and Velma were there, laughing at
something with Joe; it really was intolerable that anyone would
have to be inside on such a lovely sunny day.
"Hey y'all, how's it going?"
"Enjoying the sunlight, that's all! How you doing?"
"Pretty good! Listen, I want you to know I probably won't be',
seeing you here for a while"-I nodded in the direction of the caf- ,
eteria, from which the awful buzzing could still be heard-"but we'll "
be by with a bunch of stuff again Thursday." With surprise and a ;
little dismay, I recognized a woman in the crowd from the action
the night before-she'd been sitting right next to me in the audi­
ence. What the fuck was she doing here? "Tell Luis we'll go over to
the apartments, too. I've gotta get going, I'll see you soon."
"All right then! Be safe!" Ethel raised an eyebrow meaningfully. !
106. The Eviction
A couple campus policemen were making their way through the
crowd with sour looks on their faces. I'd never seen anyone look so
disagreeable in my life. It was time to get my bag and go.
I'd made it twenty paces from the crowd when I sensed someone
behind me. Resisting the urge to look around, I sped up and scanned
my surroundings for escape routes.
"I'm sorry-can you direct me to the encampment?"
I broke and glanced over my shoulder. It was my neighbor from
the previous evening.
I did some quick thinking-she and I had crossed paths at the
town council meeting, and only a few of us had known there was
going to be an action there, so it was unlikely she was working for
the police. "It's across the quad. I'm not headed there right now."
"I'm sorry to bother you-" She was panting a bit to keep up;
I was too, lugging my great big bag and hurrying as fast as I could
without breaking into a run. "-I just want to get involved, and
maybe you can help me to-"
"All right-listen, I need twenty minutes to take care of some­
thing, then I'll meet you right here. OK?"
She was with Kate and me that evening when all of us were ar­
rested.
The Eviction. 107
"It was not a column but a mob, an awful river that filled the
street-the people of the abyss, madwith drink andwrongs, up at last
and roaring for the blood of their masters. I had seen the people of the
abyss before, gone through their ghettos, and thought I knew them;
but I found that I was now looking on them for the first time.
"This fascinating spectacle of dread surged past my vision in con­
crete waves of wrath, snarling and growling, carnivorous, drunk with
whisky from pillaged warehouses, drunk with hatred, drunk with lust
for blood-men, women and children in rags and tatters, dim fero­
cious intelligences with all the godlike blotted from their features
and all the fiendlike stamped in, apes and tigers, anemic consumptives
and great hairy beasts of burden, wan faces from which vampire soci­
ety had sucked the juice of life, bloated forms swollen with physical
grossness and corruption, withered hags and death's-heads bearded
like patriarchs, festering youth and festering age, crooked, twisted,
misshapen monsters blasted with the ravages of disease and all the
horrors of chronic malnutrition-the refuse and the scum of life, a
raging, screaming, screeching, demoniacal horde."
-Jack London [socialist, reformist, etc., etc.], The Iron Heel
108. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility
Crowd Dynamics and
the Mass Psychology
of Possibility
An account of spatial movement,
an allegory of social movement.
"A sociologist is an authority on crowds
like a policeman is an authority on people."
-Bill Buford, AMONG THE THUGS
If you go to the experts to learn about crowds, you will read that
they are mindless monsters: people gone mad or returned to their
primitive state, animals out of control, flocks of sheep that must be
properly dominated lest they become packs of wolves. The rabble
long to be roused, to be hypnotized by their own brute force, and
that is all there is to it. Such crowd theory gives the impression that
the theorists are simply apologists for their patrons' crowd control;
the analysis is so one dimensional, the tone so superior, that you'd
think the closest they ever came to the subject was in peering down
from the high, narrow windows of their ivory towers.
And you'd almost be right. But in fact, they too are submerged
in a crowd: it is simply a bigger one, so much bigger that it is un­
recognizable as one so long as the observer remains within it. The
crowds they purport to explain are dissident microcosms of the
same form; these can be identified as crowds only because they are
distinct in some way from the colossal crowd that is the theorists'
society. Inevitably, these smaller masses look crazed and irrational to
Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility. 109
the specialists of the status quo,
because-for however brief a
time-they are acting accord­
ing to a dissenting sense of
reality and value. So there are
always at least two crowds in
any equation: in the case of the
mob that riots and loots a shop­
ping district, for example, the
I'M ASKIN6
MYSSL-F THS
SAMe
QUSSTION,
eSRNARO _
HOW L-ON6 CAN A MA!?JS
HAL-L-UCINATION L-AST,
PROFSSSOR? AND CAN IT
as AS OSTAIL-SO AS THISft.
~
other crowd is the one that built
the shopping district, that owns the
shops and organizes advertising cam­
paigns to promote their wares, that
takes it for granted that that space is
best utilized for buying and selling.
The fact that this dominant crowd is
also a mob, only a more entrenched
and institutionalized one, may only
be apparent from outside it-for in­
stance, from the perspective of one of the looters.
Reality itself is determined by consensus-that is to say,by crowds.
What is possible, what is impossible: these are decided collectively,
according to what people believe to be so. The world we inhabit is
not made up merely of physical or sensory facts; these raw materi­
als gain meaning as signs, tools, customs, and so on from their social
context, and the resulting forest of signs is the greater part of what
we mean when we say reality. It is these social conditions that create
individuals, including the values-that influence their choices; but, as
these conditions are themselves the result of individual decisions,
they only persist because people choose to reproduce them.
Why does this happen, then, in the case of notoriously unpopular
social conditions such as war, pollution, and miserable employment?
Generally, people make choices based on what they consider to be "re- i
alistic" rather than onwhat they desire, and what they consider realistic'
depends onwhat they believe others consider realistic-this is howthe, .
stock market works, for example. Thus, any given social order rests on;
a kind of mob mentality, a collective psychosis-and is by no means"
guaranteed to be in the best interests of those who comprise it.
When people do not recognize themselves as part of a crow
110, Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility
l'
but think of themselves only as sovereign individuals who just so
happen to speak, vote, shop, think, and feel the same way thousands
or millions of others do, they tend to see reality as fixed and undis­
putable. This is the first kind of crowd, the most primitive kind-a
crowd that lacks awareness of its own existence. This sort of crowd
is no less powerful than other kinds, but the power it has rarely
does anyone any good, as it is never wielded consciously. Crowds
of this type are characterized by an inability to question their own
assumptions and a total denial of responsibility for their actions;
when eighty million televisions sets go on in unison at the end of
the workday, that's an example of such a crowd in action.
The second'kind of crowd is a crowd that is aware of its exis­
tence, but not its power. A good example of this is the mass of fans
at a sports or entertainment event. People will go to great lengths
to come together in such settings, to feel the excitement in the air
when a great number share a common space and focus.* Let's not
be coy about this: there is something thrilling about being part of
a crowd, something fundamentally pleasurable about feeling your
experiences and reactions mirrored in the ones around you. The
disappointment many voice at low-turnout events indicates a com­
mon awareness that it is the atmosphere generated by the mass, not
the supposed main attraction, that makes such affairs interesting.
Yet the members of such crowds do not think of themselves as the
authors of the situations they create. It is their money, their atten­
dance, their interest alone that make these possible, but they attri­
bute this power to others outside themselves-the organizers, the
promoters, the Rolling Stones or Atlanta Braves.
But sports fans don't always limit themselves to buying tickets,
shouting chants, and filing in and out of stadiums. Sometimes they
get carried away. Every promoter who brings together a great crowd
in order to sell them back their own togetherness runs the risk that
some of his customers will take things too far and engage in some
street sports of their own-football hooliganism, for example. The
usual pundits decry this as barbaric, uncivilized behavior, but it is
* People in crowds types two and up tend to lose their borders-think of the
audience packed tight at a concert. By contrast, people in type one crowds,
who won't acknowledge that they form a crowd at all, tend to emphasize and
reinforce the borders that separate them: imagine the same people packed
tight in a city bus the following morning.
Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility, 111
actually more cultured, more civilized, than mere spectatorship: these
are people initiating their own activities, not just following instruc­
tions like automatons. Joining in large-scale street fights, provoking
riots and confrontations with police-these otherwise senseless ac­
tivities give the participants the opportunity to form the third kind
of crowd: the crowd that is aware of its own power to determine
reality. This is the crowd as protagonist, as subject rather than ob­
ject; the fact that people willingly join in such violent, unpleasant
activities is not just evidence of how screwed up they are, but also
of how desperate they are to experience themselves as something
other than passive vessels of commerce. Small wonder such misbe­
havior is so contagious; once a crowd gains a sense of its ability to
reinvent situations, peanuts and popcorn-even front row seats to
someone else's game-lose their luster. This is not to say that every
renegade crowd is a good crowd-lynch mobs are, after all, mobs­
but only to point out how, in a society based on segregation and
passivity, any self-generated, self-determined group activity is se­
ductively subversive.
All the same, a crowd that has a sense of its own power is not
necessarily liberating for those who form it. As a crowd, they may
be free from the domination of other crowds, but this is no guar­
antee that any of them are free within the crowd. Individuals who
know they are powerful together aren't always aware of the part
each plays in creating that power, nor do they necessarily know how
to join in deciding how it is applied.
Crowds are vulnerable to authority, to being controlled by mi­
norities or outsiders, to the extent that each participant is unaware
of how to employ his agency in the group. Conversely, a crowd is
capable, flexible, and likely to act in the best interests of its mem-.
bers to the exact degree that all within it are conscious of their own '
power and familiar with applying it.* The fourth kind of crowd, then, ,
is the crowd made up of individuals who recognize that the crowd:
is nothing more than the sum of their individual choices, and make,
* This stands in stark contrast to the military model of group participation, in .
which each individual is systematically broken of his sense of autonomy and t
independence so he can function more efficiently in a strict chain of como' '
mand. The implication there is that it is conformist, hierarchical unity that
gives power to a group-but could it be that one of the primary purposes of ..
armies is to strip power from their members, to create defenseless crowds un- :
der the pretense of defending them?
112. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of POSSibility
r
those choices accordingly. For such a group, mass
activity is a chance to share selfhood with others,
for people to multiply themselves by one another-not a cover un­
der which to abdicate responsibility.
' The affinity group of political activists, in which decisions are
made by consensus among a group of friends who not only have de­
veloped their conception of what is meaningful together but also
are in the habit of acting on it decisively, is a microcosm of such a
crowd. The do-it-yourself music counterculture, in which pleasure
itself is refined and redefined through collaborative experiments
in aesthetics that influence and inform one another, is a somewhat
larger-scale version of the same thing. In such contexts, where re­
ality is determined consciously and collectively, one's freedom is
the sum of all others' freedom, not the narrow space left over in
the margins.
Those who desire this freedom face the challenge of transform­
ing crowd dynamics. Actual throngs are excellent laboratories for
studying ways to do this. In close proximity, the processes by which
people read and respond to one another speed up; thanks to this
feedback loop, new realities can quickly be generated in the collec­
tive psyche. This is why guardians of the status quo always malign
Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility. 113
the mob:* small, tight-knit crowds can be pressure cookers of so­
cial transformation. In our society, every effort is made to prevent !
people from coming together in masses, to prevent masses who have
come together from recognizing themselves as masses, to prevent
masses that recognize themselves as such from gaining a sense of
their power, and to prevent those who participate in masses that
have a sense of their power from recognizing their own individual
part in this power. But all it takes to unleash the crowd is to name
it for what it is and engage with it; we are, after all, living in the
most crowded era in history.
A small group that behaves confidently as if they are living in a
different world can call into question things everyone else takes for
granted; if they take their departure far enough at the right time, they
can render the impossible possible by persuading others that it is so
on the strength of their own conviction. This can be done without
coercion or instruction: one need only demonstrate options with
one's behavior that were invisible before, and others will join in if
what they see is attractive to them. Thus the yearning of a very few
can be taken up by a mass and become a self-fulfilling prophecy; all "
it takes is for a few dreamers to practice believing and desiring out­
side the lines while resisting the quarantine of pigeonholing, then
publicly demonstrate those dreams and their faith in them.
• Just as they frame "minority groups» as groups in a way that downplays the
agency of the individuals that comprise them, authorities usually describe type
four crowds ascrowds (or cult groups, extremist sects, etc.) in order to obscure
the enhanced liberties they can offer participants.
114. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility
I returned to the university two days after my first visit, and again
two days after that. At first I told myself I was staying abreast of
things for a follow-up story; as the situation intensified, I decided
I was taking notes for a potential book. Most of the occupiers, es­
pecially the non-students, regarded me with polite suspicion, but
thanks to Kate taking me under her wing I wasn't run off the way
other reporters were.
I would never have acknowledged it to my coworkers, but the
more time I spent around the barbarians, the more sympathetic I
was to their quixotic crusade. Didn't I myself hate the media and
the corporate world more than these youngsters possibly could,
having squandered the best years of my life in a rat maze? Wasn't
the duplicity of the university administration loathsome enough
to justify just about anything? All the same, I was glad they were
the ones fighting this impossible battle while I took notes from the 'j
sidelines. It takes more emotional energy than most people have to ,I
invest yourself in a contest you can only lose.
I missed the fire drill and the eviction, though by that time I:,
was sitting in on meetings and even taking the odd shift on dishes. i'
That night I chipped in a few hundred dollars for bail and waited ),
outside the station with a dozen others to serve hot soup and apple 'j
cider to the arrestees as they were released. The barbarian I took to '
"
be Kate's boyfriend, a wiry young savage with an aquiline nose and;
perpetually furrowed brow, still refused to acknowledge me even;
as I passed him a steaming styrofoam cup. That stung, and the sting \
drove home to me that I was more emotionally involved in my sub- '
ject than a journalist should ever permit himself to be. I
After that night, the momentum that had begun on campus frag-,:i
mented into the university employee strike, a new wave of student "
activism, a renewed off-campus anti-sweatshop campaign, and spo- ~
radic attacks throughout the city that implied a politicized hooligan-",
116, And the Crowd Goes Wild
ism. It was clear that something was still afoot, but that something
was more diffuse and more difficult to follow. Some of the aspects
of the previous weeks that had interested me most, such as the re­
lationship between the black-clad barbarians of the encampment
and the black and Latino employees of the school, seemed to have
disappeared entirely into a subterranean realm.
I went to the benefit concert in hopes of recovering the thread.
A band was performing to raise funds for the upcoming court case,
and workers from campus were speaking there too. I was shocked
how fast the club filled up; if all these people were part of an emerg­
ing movement, there was a future for my book after all.
Canetti suggests that all demands for justice and all theories about
equality ultimately derive from the experience of actual equality fa­
miliar to anyone who has been part of a crowd. Indeed, I felt no sting
of exclusion there, pressed tight in the darkness with hundreds of
strangers. Student protesters I hadn't seen since the last days of the
occupation greeted me as if I was one of them; it was the first time
I'd exchanged sincere embraces with acquaintances in longer than
I could remember. Pressed together listening to Walter speak about
the strike and the power of people who cannot be appeased, I was
sure even those who hadn't heard of the occupation until that night
felt like they were part of something greater than themselves.
All this evaporated as we passed through the exit doors; instantly
everyone was on their cell phones, splitting up into little cliques en
route to their cars. The clock struck midnight and, as in the fairy
tale, the others became young music consumers again and I was
once more the reporter. The show had been an anomaly, a sort of
nature preserve in which togetherness was still permitted to run
wild-under close supervision and at a price.
But here, suddenly, people were passing out sticks and plastic
buckets fashioned into drums and unfurling an enormous roll of
painted canvas. Afterwards, I couldn't say exactly who it had been,
though I had the impression I knew some of them; I was sure they'd
been part of the crowd inside the club-otherwise, who would have
followed their example? At any rate, they were not alone for long:
the dissipating crowd regrouped around this new focal point, and
others began picking up drums and joining in.
The district's main thoroughfare lay right across the parking lot.
Perhaps some of the radicals in the audience had fantasized about
And the Crowd Goes Wild. 117
blocking or seizing it, but that had never happened before, ergo it
must not be possible. Everyone knew that the street was for car traf­
fic, just as the sidewalk was for pedestrian shoppers; the question
of whether these limitations were oppressive or constraining never
crossed most citizens' minds, for their roles were not negotiable.
And yet a few of the drummers stepped into the street, right into
the middle of it, halting traffic; they were joined by three masked
barbarians carrying a great banner. Now the street was also for
drumming, for shouting and dancing and marching. The rest of us
watched from the sidewalk, as if to see what would happen to those
who crossed this threshold.
Later, I looked back at this as a crucial moment. At first it seemed
things would go no further-the crowd was stretched out, a few
rushing ahead and everyone else lingering behind, and it looked like
we were about to rupture and disperse-but then the momentum of
the first ones off the sidewalk spread to the rest of us, and what had
been a flow of consumers returning to their cars became a parade.
A subtle transformation took place after we moved onto the as­
phalt. Clearly, taking the street was possible after all, and was pos­
sible because a critical mass had deemed it so. Once again, as we
had been in the club, we were conscious of ourselves as a collective'
force; only here, outside its confines, we had the magical power to
renegotiate reality.
From this new vantage point, it was as if we were passing through
a different city. Traffic was backed up behind us as far as I could
see, a cacophonous symphony of honking horns, but the sound only"
mingled with the drumming and added to the ambience. Were those ;
actually torches up in the front? Returning to the same spot a few;
days later, I had the uncanny impression that I could not find the
streets we'd traversed that night: the distances seemed shorter, the;
lighting less dramatic, the buildings less imposing.
A police car arrived, followed by two more with their lights flash­
ing, but they remained at a distance, presumably waiting for further
orders or backup. Had ten people attempted to block traffic here
at this time of night, they would certainly have been arrested; but
when two hundred did, the laws dissolved. Another officer appeared'
ahead of us, turning his car sideways across the street, Flushed with,
the confidence that had blossomed out of thin air in the past few
minutes, we simply walked around it, leaving the driver huffing
118. And the Crowd Goes Wild
and impotent behind the wheeL When I saw the car pull up again
at the next intersection, one of its lights had been kicked out and a
streak of spray paint ran along its side.
As we approached the car again, a bottle rocket shot up into
the air and exploded overhead, This must have been the work of
one individual, or perhaps a couple; but feeling it to proceed from
the context we had authored together, the whole crowd cheered
in ownership. Several more rockets whistled over our heads, one
ricocheting off the brick facade of a bank. We turned left unexpect­
edly, following the banner to one side of the police car this time,
and picked up our pace. A new sense of urgency and expectation
was spreading through the crowd; looking around, I saw that many
of those around me had pulled up their hoods or wrapped scarves
around their faces.
We were entering one of the city's most expensive commercial
districts; one after another, we passed corporate cafes, jewelry shops,
restaurants and boutiques. I'd driven down this street countless
times, even shopped on it-but from within the crowd I experienced
it as something alien, a manifestation of the system that exploited,
that evicted, that policed. We turned again, and again our pace in­
creased; I almost had to break into a run to keep up, Now the po­
lice cars were nowhere to be seen. Suddenly, as we swung around
another corner, a storefront half the length of the block came into
view. Six-foot-high letters proclaimed the name of the corporation
involved in the sweatshop scandal on campus.
Time froze here for a second. Then the windows were crashing
in, great sections of plate glass falling free and shattering across the
concrete, I remember it reminded me of footage I'd seen of the gla­
ciers at the polar caps melting, massive vertical sheets of ice coming
loose in slow motion and tumbling into the sea.
There's something singular about watching a person commit
a flagrantly illegal act in full public view. No one ever looks more
decisive than a masked figure swinging a crowbar against, a display
window. Normally, a person's actions gain their meaning from the
validation of a whole society; in that single transgressive movement,
the vandal appears entirely self-governing, sufficient unto himself
or herself, infinitely free and powerfuL
A second later we were sprinting down a side street, dropping
glass still ringing out behind us. Fear hadn't set in yet, though I'm
And the Crowd Goes Wild, 119
sure most of us had gone further over the line than we had ever
imagined ourselves venturing. The only sensations I experienced
at that moment were euphoria and the impression that I was
over the concrete beneath me without touching it. I felt connected
to the strangers around me as if we had grown up hunting together
in a rainforest-I was boundlessly grateful to them for being there
with me, for rendering that moment possible. I had done nothing
more myself than witness and approve, but that had been enough. '.'
My determination to identify with the insurgent parts of myself '
was finally bearing fruit. .
Now we heard sirens in the distance-they were closing in from .j
several directions at once. Before we could reach the end of the
block, two police cars whizzed by ahead; when we arrived at the
intersection, police officers were jumping out of cars on either side. :
Masked groups were breaking off from the crowd and disappearing
down alleys, calling out to each other in code. The rest of us paused
in indecision and distress.
When a crowd of people take over a street or carry off some ,"
similarly impossible action, all their strength comes from the sense,
that they can count on each other, all their confidence as individuals
is founded upon their collective morale. What the group believes­
to be possible becomes possible; what some believe impossible be-s
comes impossible, and thus none can believe in it to make it so.
soon as some visibly doubted that we could maintain our cohesio
120. And the Crowd Goes Wild
and the power that derived from it, everyone else suddenly doubted
it as well and fled as if following orders.
In flight, the bulk of us remained together, but now we were a
very different crowd. We were no longer bound by a sense of shared
strength, but by fear of the police-and, more importantly, of re­
sponsibility for ourselves. In a dangerous situation, no risk could
be more terrifying than the fact that every individual is ultimately
responsible for the decisions that bear him to safety or misfortune.
This is why people almost always flee en masse if they can, whether
or not it is the wisest decision: by doing so, each hopes to evade the
obligation of making wise decisions, placing it on the shoulders of
those around-who are doing the same, unfortunately. A fearful
crowd can be exponentially more fearful than a fearful individual,
just as a courageous crowd can be more courageous than a coura­
geous individual: this is why it is important for anyone who dabbles
in crowd participation to know how to extricate himself from the
crowd's groupthink at a moment's notice.
I didn't understand that at the time, but fortunately I couldn't
keep up with the others either. I followed a dozen of them down
an alley and when they ran one way out of it I headed the other
direction at a brisk walk, trying to project professional calm and
disinterest: Me, I'm a journalist. What do you mean, what am I doing
here?I'm a journalist! My chest was heaving. Three police cars sped
past me in the direction the others had run. I'm a fucking journal­
ist, I tell you,journalist JOURNALIST! In retrospect, it was the safest
thing I could have done, short of concealing myself in a dumpster
as I later learned Kate had.
One tense block on I reached a public park. It was closed for the
night, but I surprised myself by lurching over the fence. The roar of
helicopters rose over the city behind me. I huddled in the shadows
behind a line of bushes and exhaled.
As my eyes adjusted, I realized I was not alone behind my bush:
a few dozen feet away, there were homeless men sleeping on the
grass. I felt the same anonymous kinship with them I had with the
others in the club and then in the march; they too were hiding out,
they too were fugitives. They would never turn me over to the po­
lice or despise me for getting myself into this situation.
The ones who set the march in motion hadn't given any orders­
they Simply opened a window of possibility by carrying out actions
And (he Crowd Goes Wild. 121
that left room for others to join in. There was no master with a
megaphone, no media spokesperson, just the disparate desires and
goals each individual brought to the street. At the same time, not all
of us were ready to be equal participants in an action like this. Was
it irresponsible that the ones who had kicked out the headlight of
the police car and smashed the windows of the superstore had put
me in harm's way? Or was I irresponsible for not being prepared to
conduct myself wisely in this situation, for not taking ownership
of my desire to be part of it?
One thing was certain-everything looked a lot different from
that bush than it had from my desk at the office. I'm not writing a
fucking book, I said to myself. This is really happening, and I'm not
going to miss another minute of it. My pulse was racing like a freight
train. I actually pinched myself: This is really happening.
One-Dimensional Man in the
Three-Dimensional World
Why abstractions and absolutes are an assault
on humanity and existence itself
___9UT THAT'S
A FA/,.SS DICHOTOMY,
/,.IKE: SVSRY DICHOTOMY!
CIRCUMSTANTIA/... SVIDSNCS,
/,.IKE: ANY SVIDSNCS!
A6ROSS
j
6liNliRAI-IZATION-­
1-1J<1i liVliRY
6liNliRAI-IZATIONJ
.>
1ll . And the Crowd Goes Wild One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World. 113
"A woman can never be too rich or too thin."
The anorexic and the body builder are both pursuing ideals that
recede before them. Once you start to measure yourself by a one­
dimensional standard such as strength or slimness, too much is
never enough: the goal is always ahead of you, no matter how far
you pursue it. These ideals cannot be reached in this world; if you
follow them far enough, they lead you out of it, into the abyss that,
is their true domain-as the heart problems of bodybuilders and '
the suicides of our rock stars and sex symbols attest.
True, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Hollywood actresses, and others:
like them were practically factory farmed by our hyper-competitive
society, but the rest of us are also infected with the values that pro­
duced them-we're just free-range versions of the same livestock.
All our ways of judging and conceptualizing are comparative: Sara
is pretty, but not as pretty as Diana, who is not as pretty as the girl
on the magazine cover; Jane is smart, but not as smart as the boy
who was just accepted to Harvard, who is not as intelligent as Albert,
Einstein was; serving free food is revolutionary, but not as revolu..
tionary as setting police stations on fire. We are one-dimensio
thinkers, unable to see each individual quality or action for wha
it is in itself, only able to apprehend them in terms of how the:
rate against others-the implication being that there is some f
damental scale by which everything can be rated. This is one way
conceiving of the world, yes, but not the only way-and not us
the best way, either.
This way of thinking makes life into a contest in which all m
struggle to distinguish themselves by finding inferiors; it makes
disregard the unique qualities of every event and entity in favor C
finding a place for them in some universal calibration
,
of value. AlJ,
"I

other way of looking reveals that every human being has qualid
unlike any other, every moment is unique and unrepeatable, every
radical action and approach is important to "the" revolution in irre­
placeable ways. But we have no language that can articulate this, no
means of expression that celebrates through description rather than
comparison. Even when we aspire to value things in and of them­
selves, we are trapped by the assumptions implicit in our speech:
"I love you," whispers the young girl.
"Do you love me more than anyone else, more than anqthinql" de­
mands the boy.
"I love you . . . differently, because of what you are. Not more, not
less-there's no comparison with love, for love cherishes what is. Love is
not judgment, it is measureless, matchless . . . " she replies-but he has
already turned away.
Where did this obsession with one-dimensional standards come
from? Perhaps it originated with language itself: where one word
serves to represent many different individual experiences, abstrac­
tion is already present.* When you say "sunlight," the implication
is that you are referring to something changeless and uniform-but
all that can be said for sure is that the term designates a multitude
of diverse sensory data and potential sensory data.
One might argue that what is most precious in life is not the
lowest common denominators but the once-in-a-lifetime particu­
lars, which words are least equipped to convey. What use is a word
that refers to only one instant of one individual's experience? Words
serve as currency precisely because they are vague and simplistic;
no word or concept could ever capture the infinite depth and com­
plexitv of a single instant of life.
Western civilization is founded upon one-dimensional think­
ing: monotheism, monoculture, monogamy, monopoly, monotony.
• It could be argued that speaking a language doesn't give you a means to de­
scribe and discuss "the" world so much as it affords you entry to the addi­
tional world of description and discussion, which is often only connected to
the world of sensory experience by the most tenuous abstractions. The urban
environment, in which everything is mass-produced according to the same
, ideological framework through which it is experienced, could be considered
a physical manifestation of this world of abstractions: conceptualization im­
posing itself upon reality. '
124. One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World. 125
Our cyclopean vision of the cosmos can be traced back to ancien!,
.
'
,"
'
Greece, where Plato took the abstraction inherent in language 0
step further. He declared that our abstractions refer to some "hig
plane" in which abstractions like "justice" exist in their pure for
in doing so, he turned everything backwards, placing our bro
generalizations before the experiences they summarize and cl
ing that they are truer than the raw materials they purport to re
resent. Thus he took the reference point of our concepts out of
world altogether, suggesting that our real experiences in it are Ie.
important than our ideas about it. Paul, the founder of Christiani
expanded this philosophy into a religious doctrine: the ideal e
in heaven and the earth is only a flawed, evil imitation.
Doctrines alone were not enough to make people see everyt
in terms of absolutes, of course. Against the wisdom of bodily ex
rience, in which the unique qualities of every entity and event
encountered up close, they were powerless. But slowly, it bee
possible to force even the world of sensory perception onto
Procrustean bed of abstraction and judgment.
This began with the twin developments of currency and su
vided time. Suddenly, everything had an exchange value that co
be determined according to an external standard, and likewise
day was divided into quantified segments. Time and worth c
really be measured-the woman who has truly lived knows
no stopwatch can register the way time speeds up when she is
bed with her lover and slows down when she is "on the clock"
work, she knows that the best and worst things in life cannot
"deserved" or earned, let alone appraised-but wage labor and
change economics forced people to measure them anyway, and
habit sank in.
Soon, everything was measured and calibrated: women's clo
sizes, for example. Until the end of the nineteenth century, wom
• "That's funny," she said, "I have a similar equation in my journal, only with
terms the other way 'round." She sketched it out on the napkin:
0.::;
I was dumbfounded. Our equations were strikingly gendered-mine
exhortation to an infinite and therefore impossible task, while hers sugg'
an infinity that could neither be sought nor evaded: eternity within the
of an instant, outer space within the smallest atom,
126, One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World
clothing was made by hand for individual women, and a woman was
seen as possessing distinct personal qualities, not as a "size 6" or "plus
size." It's telling that over the last few decades, the ideal woman has
been described numericallY-"36-24-36"-and anyone who varies
from that Platonic form is considered less beautiful. Every morning
women weigh themselves and experience just how inadequate any
scale is for measuring the diverse beauty of human beings.
It only remained for corporate branding to standardize the real
world according to our abstractions. Once upon a time most human
beings ate from gardens, or else from the wild; in those days every
fruit and vegetable was unique and looked it. Now our food is sci­
entifically engineered to total uniformity, and each item comes with
a brand name identifying which absolute it represents: the super­
market's generic brand is the Platonic form of the inferior banana,
the name-brand banana is the perfect incarnation of the banana as
abstraction, and the archetypal banana of wealthy, ceo-elitist con­
sumers comes marked "organic."
Those who would resist these attempts to press the real world
to the flatness of the conceptual world often fall into the same
practices. The world of political theory is rife with abstraction and
one-dimensional thinking-the words you are reading right now,
for example." Many make it through childhood without losing the
ability to appreciate the irreplaceable details of life, only to succumb
• Intellectuals have quite an aptitude for displacement-when they suffer from
the ennui of their dry, disembodied existence, they respond to this suffering
not with action but with more desiccating and disembodying. All too often
their real discontent is diverted into theory and abstract analysis, and thereby
into career and status ... and thus, more status quo.
Ideology creeps quickly into any language, languages that seek to oppose it no
less. If you want to experience passion and liberty, the last thing you should do
is make up slogans about them. This footnote itself is a pernicious little thing,
just more abstractions about abstractions-put the book down, stop concep­
tualiZing, get out there and live, whatever that means! Enough expounding,
rationalizing, glorifying. .. distrust any words or symbols intended to cap­
ture the things that make life matter, political pomposities above all! Words
only express reality accidentally, and then only briefly. Cornered by the
mertia of our own rhetoric, we must finally take a stand against speech itself­
and for expression, but in action alone, the only place where it can avoid being
burdened by the dead weight of ideology. That is to say-it is only sufficient
to speak when, in speaking, you are acting. So unless you have hit upon a way
to turn all this theory into actual life-throw this treatise aside!
treatise, of course, goes on undaunted, forgetful of its own demands, as
Ideology always does and is.]
One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World. 127
to the maladies of generalizing and idealizing when they begin to
read theory and attempt to form an analysis of the cosmos: their im­
pressions and emotions are converted into an ideology, and where
their struggles and goals once referred to real people they now see
people only as playing pieces in a contest of symbols.
There are no more obvious or prevalent examples of vampiric
archetypes than whiteness and masculinity. White supremacist pa­
triarchal society still rewards certain superficial traits and ways of
comporting oneself above all others, despite the fact that the race and
gender divisions that supposedly form the justification for this are
increasingly seen as arbitrary constructions-their being construc­
tions simply makes them more useful for dividing and conquering.
Whiteness is not just a quality some possess and others lack, but
a way 0/comparing people; proof of this can be found in nations in
which no one is "white" by European standards, but some groups
still benefit from white privilege in relation to others. Likewise, the
fact that they are all men doesn't stop football players from compet­
ing against one another to be the most manly-on the contrary!­
It is only now that I can
recognize your beauty and
deny no part of my own.
while even in women-only groups people can be seen playing the
role of "the man." Insofar as one-dimensional cultural norms are
constraining and dehumanizing, everyone-even the whitest of the
white and manliest of men-has a stake in overthrowing white su­
premacy and patriarchy, though people experience this differently
according to their places in the hierarchy.
Ultimately, the pursuit of ideals that cannot be realized in this world
constitutes a rejection of the world and thus of life itself-as dem­
onstrated by the sad fate of the body builders and anorexics who
take that pursuit to its logical extreme, the grave. We are so used
to denigrating this world, saying it is an imperfect, even intolerable
place. So it appears, compared against ideals that seem perfect pre­
cisely because they cannot exist; so it becomes, when we attempt
One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World. V·9
to navigate it according to those ideals rather than the real things
around and within us. A truly radical resolution would be to em­
brace existence just as it is, as the only thing that matters, to pro­
claim that this world itself is heaven, made for our total enjoyment
and fulfillment. .. and then to ask: If that's the case, how do we act
accordingly? What have we been doing wrong all this timer
In doing so, we would finally have to accept and embrace our­
selves as we are, in all our diversity and variety, and emerge from
the shadow of the false heaven of Plato and the advertising agents
where real beauty supposedly resides. Liberated from one-dimen­
sional standards and standardization, from the lingering ghost of
Christian judgment and condemnation, we could see that what we
are must itself constitute the measure and meaning of beauty, of
significance and magnificence, if such concepts are to exist at all.
* He flipped to another page. "Listen to this: 'Man looksfor the miracle, and to ac­
complish it he will wade through blood, he will debauch himself with ideas, he will
reduce himself to a shadow iffor only one second of his life he can close his eyes to
the hideousness of reality. Everything is endured-disgrace, humiliation, poverty,
war, crime-in the belief that overnight something will occur, a miracle, which will
render life tolerable.' Sound familiar?"
"Yeah-I don't know whether I'm fighting that mentality, or I'm infected with
itmyself-maybe fighting it has infected me. Surely it's utopian to think capi­
talism can go on forever without destroying the entire planet, but it's also op­
timistic to think we can stop it first."
"That's what I don't like about all this anarchist rhetoric-it just offers a com­
peting utopia. The majority of people in this SOCIety already subsist on vi­
sions of other worlds-it's practically banal. He's arguing here that the exist­
ing world-precisely because it exists, a quality without which any world is
worthless-is a heaven more wondrous than any of those others, if we live in
it attentively."
"Yes, of course, Pablo-but it's equally utopian to think we could live that at­
tentively, except perhaps by accident for instants at a time. Maybe it makes
Just as much sense to vacillate Wildly between rejecting the entirety of what
is for something which is not, yet-you know, being a Revolutionary with a
capital R-and rejecting all futures, all abstractions, all ideals, for the impos­
sible project of trying to find perfection in that which exists."
130. One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World
,
Diego was still stewing about the legal number. " ... and after three;
hours of going straight to the answering machine, I was like 'OK'd
fuck these people, they might as well be the cops!' I had no idea'
whether you guys were in jail, or dead, or what! It's not that hardJ
you know? You say you're going to do something, you do it. If you're'
not going to do it" -he pounded out each syllable on the
wheel-"don't fucking say you'll do it!"";
"Diego, those are practically the last students still involved." Kate
was always trying to smooth over conflicts. "The others I started
out with are all back in their dorms, studying for finals. OK, they;
don't have their shit together, but they're all we've got. If we can't ';
make things work with them, who are we going to work with? At;
least we know what to watch out for with them. We can talk abouti
"I'J
this next-"
He cut her off dismissively. "Whatever, I'll never do anything with ..
them again. Bunch of privileged white kids playing at revolution! I'd .
rather do things with people I know will come through, like-"
"Hey," I opened Sarma's cell phone and held it in the air so Diego
could see its glowing screen in the rear view, "can we talk about this \,;
later?" Sarnia was gazing out the window at the woods along the
road; we were well into the countryside and the world was a blurred
black silhouette against the sky. It had to be approaching five in the'
morning. At the time I thought Diego was right, but I didn't want
Sarnia to hear us arguing like this-or anyone else to, either.
Everyone's spirits lifted when we turned onto the dirt road.
When I go into the country it's like a muscle relaxes that other­
wise is perpetually clenched. The last time I'd left town had been
132. Other Encampments
before the encampment, when I still had my apartment; since the
eviction I'd been carrying my toothbrush in my jacket, moving from
couch to couch to keep up with the action. Tonight, it had seemed
like a bad idea to go back to any of the busy, well-known houses
we had to choose from, and Kate had offered to guide us out to her
father's place.
The car bucked and dragged across stretches of the long drive­
way; at times it seemed we were in danger of getting entirely stuck.
Stepping into the darkness, our voices and slamming doors echoing
in the winter night, we suddenly felt a lot smaller. It really was dark
out there; only a couple stars peered down through gaps in the has­
tening clouds, and the house looming ahead was a black silhouette.
We had all started carrying flashlights as well as knives, sewing kits,
and water bottles, and we made our way to the steps in a hushed line,
each following a tiny spot of light across the crunching leaves.
The door was unlocked. "My father doesn't have electricity,"
Kate explained in a whisper as she struck a match and lifted the
smoke-stained glass silo off an oil lamp. Lit, it illuminated rough
wooden walls, mud-caked gardening tools, and a pitch-black wood
stove. "Lay your bags out on the floor here. The toilet's through
there-there's sawdust next to it, just put some in after you use
it." She returned the lamp to the table, casting dancing shadows on
my sleepy, squinting friends, and laid her hand on my arm. "Do you
want to sleep outside with me?"
Outside, I wrestled with the familiar tent as the wind picked up
and tiny drops of rain began to fall. I was afraid it would be cold,
but by the time we had managed to get into our sleeping bags, awk­
wardly jostling elbows and knees and pushing against the tight can­
vas walls, we were warm enough.
Kate turned over to face me and put her lips to my ear. "I'm go­
ing to check out my cervix to see if it looks like I'm pregnant. Will
you give me a hand with the flashlight?"
No one had ever asked me to do that before. "Urn, sure, if you tell
me what to do. Can you tell if you're pregnant from ... ?"
"As I understand it, it should be bluish if I am-it's not guaran­
teed, though." She extracted a mirror and speculum from her pack
and shimmied out of her jeans. "It's never happened before, anyway.
But I was fertile that time on the rooftop, and I always try to keep
up with what's going on in my body." She tore open a tiny sampler
Other Encampments. 133
of lube in her teeth and maneuvered the speculum into place. "0
posite of the dish room where I'd lost so many months. That was
now hold the flashlight here and aim it at the mirror." She held th,
terrifying as well as liberating-more terrifying the more I wished
to cling to it. I stayed awake until I heard birds venturing the first
mirror with one hand, angling it delicately between her legs; it too":
her a couple minutes to find the view she wanted. I gazed at her shy: notes of morning.
in the dim glow-I'd never seen anyone so at home in herself. I wa$
When I finally closed my eyes I was in a moving car again, packed
tight with people I didn't recognize but took to be my beloved
being granted access to a private ceremony, like a hunter stumblin§
upon fairies in the woods. "Never mind-it doesn't look blue at aJ.Uil,
companions. The driver pressed the accelerator to the floor and
the landscape opened out around us into a painted desert, alien
Want to have a look?")
"OK, yeah." She unzipped the sleeping bag further and I blun­ and sublime.
dered down to the other end of the tiny tent, straining against the'
canvas and bumping into her knee, my own sleeping bag still up',
around my waist. "I've never done this before. It's really ... I think'
it's the most intimate I've ever been with anyone."
"Yeah?" She looked at me with gentle amusement.
Now that I reflected on it, it was crazy how many women I'd:
been involved with without ever seeing their bodies this way. I could!
hear the wind outside the tent sweeping leaves past us inwhispering l
gusts. "Thank you," I murmured. "You're really beautiful."
She was silent a minute. "I struggled with that for a long time," !
she began as I settled back into place beside her. "Feeling beauti­
ful, I mean."
"Sorry-s-I didn't ... I mean, I don't want to bring up anything,
difficult. Do you want to tell me about it?"
"Sure." She shifted, folding her arms behind her head. "Just the
usual stuff, really. I tried all sorts of diets, I wore makeup and shaved
every hair and tried to match my outfits to my eyes; then I quit doing (J
all that stuff, but I just felt worse. I finally came to the conclusion
that it would take as much energy to like myself the way I was as
it did to count calories and style my hair every morning-but if I
could, it would be under my control. I could go to the gym every day ,
and keep losing weight, but how I felt about myself would never be
under my control no matter how much weight I lost. It's still seri­
ous shit to look at my thighs and really believe they're perfect just
the way they are, but it's a struggle I want to fight and the other one
isn't anymore. Anyway-thank you. You're beautiful, too."
Long after her breathing had slowed and thickened, I lay awake
on my back, listening to the wind and feeling how far I was from
everything familiar. I have never been in this place before, I thought
to myself, and I'll never be here again. In that regard it was the op-
Other Encampments. 135
134. Other Encampments
You Can Run But
You Can't Hide
Tourism? Escape Routine!
I I; i

., ,
' ',' ;;,.. 1:
. i liL ':' i '
If tu T"f:1r'!'fr
.

.. "
, i , , , , ',', i , ,::'f."

.

136, You Can Run but You Can't Hide
On the flight back from Sao Paulo a year and a half later, I shut my­
self in the airplane bathroom, took off my paint-splattered jacket and
shirt, and gazed at myself in the mirror, I saw something reflected
there that I'd only glimpsed before in the eyes of my most adoring
lovers: the shades and textures of my skin and the scars and lines
carved into it told of a life of wild gambles and undreamable extremes,
a story as poignant and thrilling as any novel. I was beautiful­
beauty was incarnated in me, the vessel of a world of-struggles and
longings and triumphs more incredible than anything that could fit
between the covers of a book. This was a blinding revelation, but I
rested comfortably in it as if I had known through all my doldrums
and desperation that I was simply being primed for this.
When the weekend arrives, the college students pack their cars and
drive to the beach. They arrive shortly before sundown and spend a
full hour and a half unpacking, setting up tents and tarps, and heat­
ing up the grill. Then they crank up the sound system, charbroil
hamburgers, and drink and shout and argue until midnight. When
they wake up the next morning, they spend another hour and a half
taking down the tents and, if they're environmentalists, cleaning up
after themselves before driving back to the city. Everything they've
done at the beach they could have done more easily at home, but
the beach is fetishized as a zone of recreation and leisure: if you're
there, you know you're off the clock and having fun-whether or
not you swim in the surf, walk in silence .under the stars, or find
the carcass of a shark washed up by a tide pool, tiny crabs dancing
across its flesh.
Years later they will return with their families, setting up play
tents for the kids and folding tables for the adults and sipping wine
as they watch DVDs. If they do well for themselves, they'll visit
beaches on other continents, never leaving the bubble of beach
towel, hotel room, cruise ship, resort.
But it would be unfair to accuse all vacationers of ignoring their
surroundings-on the contrary, you can always identify high-class
tourists by their video cameras and learned guides. Let's examine
these more sophisticated specimens to get to the bottom of tour­
ism as a phenomenon.
All Roads Lead to Roam / You Can Run but You Can't Hide. 137
Coming from a subculture in which owning and appearing are
emphasized over feeling and acting, bourgeois vacationers seek
diversion in the symbolic possession of parts of the world other
than those they normally occupy. They establish this by the act of
looking-"sightseeing," to use their redundant expression-just as
the conquerors of old surveyed newly subjugated peoples. This is
the real significance of all the photographing and videotaping: the
pictures may not be important later on (except for those insuffer­
able slideshows to which one imagines Roman emperors would have
subjected their courts, had they possessed the technology), they may
not be taken with any artistic aspirations, but they serve to establish.
the tourists as collectors-they collect images the way others collect i
butterflies or war booty. This is the only way the bourgeois know to •
relate to foreign things:* the beautiful and the wild are quite scenic, c
but lack meaning until they are hunted, captured, pinned.
The hastily snapped images are preserved as if in formaldehyde,
and the vacationers congratulate themselves on knowing all about,
• Witness ecotourism, which is predicated on the idea that a small fragment·
of an ecosystem deserves to be left alone as long as it is entertaining to the
tourist class. They go on vacation to ooh and aah at exotic wildlife when they':
won't even recycle bottles in their own kitchens. They speak about
places that should be made parks and reserves, neglecting the fact that the vel)Ji
ground they live on was once just as wild and beautiful before it was destroye4j
by the lifestyles they refuse to question.
Norway, Italian architecture, the wildlife of the Pacific Ocean, the
struggles of the first Polar explorers, the troubled childhood of
Van Gogh ("arid that," intones the tourist as he guides his audience
through a slideshow of photos taken from behind a rope under the
direction of another tour guide, how's that for postmodern, "is the
very room he spent his first six years in!"). The lenses never leave the
eyes of the tourists in the course of their vacation, literally or figu­
ratively. Mediation is integral to the tourist experience-anything
to keep the world at arm's length, to avoid getting involved.
The tourist arrives from a world of control mania, already an
expert at protecting himself to death. The bourgeois insist on be­
ing safe wherever they go-not just from actual danger, but from
everything not already anticipated, comprehended, controlled. The
travel guides and guidebooks, the painstakingly planned itineraries,
the tourist buses and museums and hotels, the armies of salesmen
who cater to every fabricated need-all these combine to ensure
that being in Oslo or Zimbabwe is as similar as possible to being in
Oklahoma. And yet beneath everything, tourism is still a desperate
bid to experience something different, something "exotic," which is
to say-something not quite as lifeless, meaningless, tedious, banal,
and insipid as daily life under the tyranny of the hair dryer and the
cellular phone.*
And so the worst tragedy is that tourism destroys the observed as
it maintains the alienation of the observers. Just as explorers have cut
wider and wider swaths through the natural environment in the course
of their exploits until all that remain of it in some places are fish tanks
and potted plants, the tourist crushes beneath him exactly that which
he seeks. The human being in the bourgeois man needs variety, danger,
adventure, but the bourgeois in him channels these needs into surro­
gate enterprises and hedged bets: traveling Honduras, he still wants
to speak English; rafting the rapids, he still needs a release to sign and
a "historic path" to follow (as all meaningful experience is held hos­
tage in the past, or in the lives of other peoples); landing on Mars, he
• Indeed, when one listens closely to the ghost stories about kidnappings and
stolen kidneys shared by bourgeois youth on the summer vacation backpack­
er/hostel circuit, it becomes clear that they are practically fantasies, legends
of something real and endangering-that is to say, engaging!-happening to
someone just like you, told in desperate faith that something crazy and new is
still possible even in this world and couched in the only terms the bourgeois
have to describe the unfamiliar: terror!
138. YouCan Run but YouCan't Hide YouCan Run but YouCan't Hide. 139
would look around for a sign announcing the next guided tour. Wield­
I
- <,
ing the power of the angry god Dollar, he is able to compel everyone
he encounters to confine him in this safety net. Wherever the tourist
tramples, soon little remains but the detritus of his own creative and
cultural bankruptcy-visit Tijuana, Mexico for proof. Whole cultures
have been annihilated in his wake; tourism is not the heir of ancient ,1
quests and pilgrimages but of colonial imperialism.
In the absence of the real thing, the tourist is left with simu- ,:
lation. Even the most wild and crazy travel handbooks ("Europe ,\
on two dollars a day!" «Antarctica for hitchhikers!") are museums'
of fossilized adventure by the time they go into circulation-as if
there could be such thing as an adventure guide, when adventure is .
precisely that which happens off the map. The most the daring tour- "
ist can hope to find is the cooling trail left by those who embarked
without maps-in their wake, he has to make do with monuments, ;,
museums, and theme parks, forever asking rhetorical questions ("I Ii
wonder what it would be like to ... ?") without connecting the pos­
sible answers to his own life. Distraught, he buys more guidebooks, \:
characteristically seeking a solution from the market rather than.
shaking off his alienation to try a different approach.
The common quality that unifies all tourists is disconnections'[
they are totally uninvolved in what they see, pursuing the sight>.
alone without all the entanglements, liabilities, and challenges that:!
come with real life engagement. They can passively vote on their"
favorite place or painting, or, at most, develop some paternalisticj]
picturesque Hallmark sentiment that exceptional environments 0,1
cultures should be protected, but it never occurs to them that
are interacting with the worlds they view with such detachmend
This is why they are unable to acknowledge the part they play'
eradicating them, let alone confront their own spiritual malaise
restlessness. They could be at home-or anywhere-giving them
selves to a project, involving themselves in something outside
demands of work and social status, holding themselves accoum .
able for the effects of their actions and considering their decisio
with appropriate seriousness; instead, theyvacation in never-nevi ...
land, extending their own alienation to the furthest corners of
globe. This alienation replicates itself there, driving them to e
more expensive ocean cruises and souvenir hunts in a listless a,
diets' pursuit of stimulation-when all it would take to break
140. You Can Run but You Can't Hide
spell would be for them to commit themselves to some value or
dream, one that would drag them into danger and heartbreak and
ragged glory and all those other things one must experience to live
an engaged, fulfilling life. They could do that without ever booking
flights or packing suitcases. The fact that they are able to maintain
their distance from life as easily ten thousand miles from home as
in the midst of their daily routines is a testament to the global tri­
umph of universal self-estrangement.
Ultimately, tourism is not a leisure activity but a way of life, an
expression of the vacuum at the heart of consumer society. The ex­
ecutive does the same thing in the Louvre and the Himalayas and
Jamaica that he does in his own neighborhood when he drives past
a stand of trees being cut down to make way for a new gas station.
What would it take to snap him out of this trance, to make him
relate himself to those around him and take responsibility for his
actions? The fate of the planet rests on us answering this question,
or else disarming and disabling him.
To do either, we have to locate the parts of ourselves that are not
yet totally detached, to seek out the passions that might still stir
within us. For good or for ill, most of us long to travel-our hearts
leap at the thought of dropping everything and setting out free
and empty-handed across an unfamiliar landscape, and this must
run deeper than bourgeois conditioning. Travel is associated with
human liberty and romance; it was the original state of our species,
and we still pine for it. In traveling we can shake off our old selves
and hunt down others that wait in alternate worlds-travel enables
a special kind of freedom, for without new horizons we tend to re­
peat the well-practiced choices we have already made, in thrall to
inertia if no other master.
I Jmbt Nt\UIOtk
.. ".".... _._____ ,..WYOR -...... ,------- .. c,;§
ToURRORIST ATIACKS INCREASE
THROUGHOUT THIRD WORLD
u.s. ,Japan responsible, claims anarchist group
.. ....::,I..-.

"
PuJ&iBhmentfor'Evil'
-­ ..............
..

--
,....,. Tft6I
....
..
lluildi... _ IIIll FIII

................-..
­
.-....-ct.....,
........ -.-.,...._ - ....
.......... ,...,. IS Onloolans.dI
-.-.-......... ,.... .. --. .. _.......
..
lor EhIshe SItIIY ....
ftIr
.....- ..,.,.........,-.

_ ....,.................
___

'
But with the whole planet standardized under corporate impe­
rialism and industrial capitalism, when we bear the seeds of these
poisons within our own breasts as colonized colonizers, where is
there left to go? How are we now to travel?
In place. The adventures of the future will be created, not by
Westerners who destroy civilizations in their desperate bid to escape
their own, but by people who seize familiar parts of this planet and
make them unfamiliar. Washington, D.C. could become the Paris of
1968, just as Paris, boring as usual until that May, became the Bar­
celona of 1936; small towns in the Midwest could host social cen­
ters and upheavals like those in Oaxaca and Berlin; a sense of one's
own significance and capabilities can transform even a suburban
bedroom into the setting of a real life epic. Really, this was always
the case: one either regards the world passively, or approaches it as
a participant-all things hinge on this, whether you are at home or
on the peak of Mount Ararat.
In traveling in place, we can rediscover the art of participation
that is essential for any adventuring-and finally set out on a jour­
ney, rather than yet another flight.
Escape Escapism!
142. You Can Run but You Can't Hide
The administration couldn't take the heat; they broke their con­
tract with the corporation and signed a new agreement with cam­
pus workers only a few months after the night march. I was off like
a bottle rocket as soon as they caved in. Flushed with the thrill of
victory and equipped with nationwide connections courtesy of my
new friends, I set out to seek my fortune.
So many of us begin our novels in our heads and fear to finish
them on paper-or begin our lives on paper and finish them too
soon on earth. Our songs go unsung, our throats remain mute, the
expectant trembling before the strings are struck goes on and on
into infinity; the whole world echoes with that pregnant silence, if
you have ears for it. I was going to take revenge for all the squan­
dered potential of my species: I was going to live the life I wanted,
and nothing could stop me.
I felt irrationally guilty towards Daniel, though. Enjoying my­
self seemed like a betrayal, especially doing things he would have
wanted to do.
I can still hear the clack-clack of the tracks amplified inside
the train car that carried us out of town, speeding up in a deafen­
ing polyrhythm until it sounded like a thunderous drum circle. A
day later we were dodging the flashlights of security guards in the
train yard outside a bigger city, life as tense and dramatic as it had
been at the high points of our struggle with the university. It was
a revelation to discover that there were people like us everywhere,
fighting similar fights and chasing dreams that resonated with mine.
In one city they'd occupied a big building, filling it with discarded
objects in a post-industrial bricolage: barbershop chairs, a jungle
gym nailed to the ceiling, refrigerator doors that opened into bed­
rooms. In others they ran programs that put Marshall's produce
All Roads Lead to Roam. 143
distribution to shame: occupied community gardens, clandestine
abortion clinics, tenants' rights groups ready to march on landlords
with torches and pitchforks.
On a rural commune, I walked through blossoming fields at
dusk to dance around a tremendous fire with a hundred exquisite
strangers. Have you ever heard the deep bass growl of a fire that
size, sparks and cinders rising overhead to mingle with the stars?
In Europe, we arrived in one metropolis the evening after riots left
the city center in ruins, armored police vans patrolling streets of
burnt cars and boarded-up shops. We had to get through a police
line to reach the squat where we were to stay, and all night officers
and lookouts shouted insults back and forth in a foreign tongue;
I'd never felt so at home. We saw social centers there that could fit
a thousand people in their event halls, stewarded by multigenera­
tional councils with decades of experience.
I hitchhiked to the top of the Alps where the earth disappears
into the stratosphere and rode with a Dutch pilot all the way down to
Ljubljana, where anarchists and artists had occupied a whole neigh­
borhood. That night I sat up talking to old Slovenes about life under
communism and walked back in the early morning through a fog so
thick I couldn't see ten feet. In Latin America I toured shantytowns
bigger than the suburb I'd grown up in, and stayed on twenty miles
of occupied farmland; I learned Spanish quickly because everyone
spoke to me as if I already knew it. Rita even made it to Kenya to
visit the workers in the sweatshops we'd protested-I heard all about
it over coffee in Santiago. A week later I was at the front of a charg­
ing crowd, paint bombs sailing overhead from behind me and riot
police thirty feet ahead firing warning shots in the air.
Until I'd set out, there had been no train yards, no squatted so­
cial centers or Alps or favelas-I'd never heard of them, never con­
sidered whether they might exist. Had I stumbled across the same
places in the distracted rush of a business trip, I might have stood at
their gates or even passed through them without ever recognizing
them for what they were. Now I was ready to believe that every­
thing I'd ever dreamt of might exist somewhere in the world-just
as before the globe was circumnavigated it was possible to imagine
that the world of dreams was a physical place to which spirits trav­
eled by night, which you might reach by day if only you traveled
far enough.
144. All Roads Lead to Roam
It takes a real shock to cut through the veneer of routine and ap­
prehend the world we actually live in. I imagine astronauts set foot
on earth for the very first time when they leave the spacecraft that
took them to the stars. I felt present in those unfamiliar places in a
way I never had in familiar ones-and when I finally stepped from
the airplane at the end of my trip, I felt as if I were laying my feet
upon the surface of the moon.
It didn't last. My mother and sister were waiting anxiously for me
at the top of the escalator. It was nice to see them, but disturbing to
find that while I had been off discovering new expanses of possibil­
ity everything at home had remained unchanged. I felt with terror
that I was returning through time to the moment I'd departed, to
pick up again from there as if all that had transpired in the mean­
time had been a hallucination.
In the short year of my vagabondage, some of my new friends
had already returned to default setting, concluding that indeed it
had been "only a dream" and reintegrating themselves into the world
we'd escaped. I should have recognized this as an ominous warning,
but at the time I was too busy meeting new people and setting off
for new destinations. When I finally caught up with them later, they
spoke about their periods of travel as closed parentheses in their
lives and expected me to do the same.
But I was still sworn to my impractical quest for adventure; I
seemed constitutionally incapable of resigning myself to the life
everyone else accepted as normal. Everybody assumed I'd returned
because I was exhausted and broke, but that had never stopped me
before. The truth was I'd come back on a mission. I'd left home to get
away from it all, but as I'd traveled, I'd found "it all" waiting wher­
ever I went: border controls and advertisements in English, familiar
fast food joints and squat evictions, improbably blonde bombshells
in the soap operas and subtle references to Hollywood movies pep­
pering my foreign friends' speech. These were the harbingers of an
imperialism that would homogenize the entire world unless people
dug in their heels somewhere to halt its advance.
All Roads Lead to Roam. 145
The city I'd left in uproar was quiet when I returned, like Hame­
lin after all the children were lured away. If no one stayed to bring
it back to life, travelers like myself would be doomed to wander
endlessly like earthbound ghosts, combing the world in search of
wonder and community and struggle without ever stopping any- .
where long enough to cultivate them. Now that I'd seen riots and
social centers and other miracles, I was determined to bring them
home with me.
But first, there was a demonstration a thousand miles away that
I couldn't resist attending.
146. All Roads Lead to Roam
Infighting the Good Fight:
Why We're Right
and You're Wrong
Towards a Non-D'[enjominational Revolution
"Just like every coddled middle class liberal, he'll just run back home when things
get tough." "Those lifestylists don't care about anything but themselves.
Don't they understand if everyone lived like them, there would be
no system to leech off?" "If they're not going to abide by the
decisions of the spokescouncil, they shouldn't be here at all.
I'd rather they were at home doing nothing than
messing up our protest like this!" "How can
you expect to without ? If you
reallycared about __~ you'd __! [likeme]"
"I don't want to be an activist or
an anarchist or a part of this
at all if it means I have to .. "
Infighting the Good Fight. 147
Why We Can't All Just Get Along
Can we get along} Even for those of us who would prefer to be her­
mits, there is no question today more important than this one-the
fate of our species and planet will be decided by the answer.
There is no shortcut around this dilemma. Any kind of capital-R
Revolution, any redistribution of wealth and power, will be short­
lived and irrelevant without a fundamental change in our relation­
ships-for social structure is a manifestation of these relationships,
not a factor external to them. Revolution is not a single transfor­
mation, but a way of living: anarchy and hierarchy always coexist
in varying proportions, and the important question is which you
foster yourself.
We are ill-qualified to reconstruct human relations if we can't
even get along with each other in the attempt-and nothing seems
to create dissension and division like our attempts. Often it seems
that the people who know least how to relate to others are the self­
professed activists who set out to save them. Yet these conflicts are
not an inescapable consequence of human nature, but rather a pat­
tern of cause and effect that can and must be altered.
The Scarcity Economy of Self
In a world where free, creative action is hard to get away With, we
all feel impoverished, cheated of the experiences and sensations we
know should be ours. We compensate as best we can, and often this
compensation serves only to preserve our destitution. We seek status
in wealth, power, strength, beauty, reputation, anything to soften
the blows of wasted days. We compensate by seeking another kind
of status, too: feelings of superiority, status in our own heads.
We live in a society that teaches there is not enough of any valu­
able resource to go around, including selfhood. People on television
or in books are held up as more important, more attractive, more
heroic than the rest of us. We grow up in households where our
parents don't have enough time for us; we are sent to schools that
employ a grading system that permits only a handful to excel, and
are discharged into a market that enriches a few of us while exploit­
ing or discarding the rest. We internalize the values of this system.
We become used to judging our value by what we are "better than."
148. Infighting the Good Fight
With a little hard work,
you can make yourself
feel alienated by just
about anything.
We rush to despise others, their plans and ideas andhabits and be­
liefs, in order to reassure ourselves that we have worth of our own.
When we should be looking for what is positive in everything, we
denounce and criticize instead-just to reassure ourselves! The most
insecure among us are not even able to enjoy movies and music, be­
cause it is so important to them that they have "refined" tastes; they
don't realize that when they succeed in failing to enjoy something,
no one loses more than them. If you're going to get anything out of
any movie or song or interaction-so as not to have simply wasted
your time!-you must take responsibility for finding ways to enjoy
and benefit from it.
In its advanced stages, this hypercritical status-seeking engenders
a spectator mentality: from a distance, the critic passively votes for or
against the efforts of others, unable to discern that such things as art,
activism, and community are entirely what he makes of them-and
that he must make something of them himself in order to get anything
out of them. This spectatorship reinforces the sense that everything
everyone else is doing is uninteresting and unintelligent, and thus the
feeling of superiority the spectator so desperately needs. You seldom
encounter a genuinely active, engaged person who feels the need to
proclaim her actions superior to others'; but in the spectator's scarcity
economy of self, any expression of selfhood, even the most generous
and positive, can be interpreted as an encroachment, an attack.* Every
achievement is something to rebel against, to assail, to deride-as if
we don't all feel worthless, abused, and hunted enough already!
• The other expression of this same affliction is hero worship, in which one
projects all the qualities one admires onto others. This is similarly crippling, of
course, and inevitably leads back to the same hostility and scorn-for the only
thing you can do with those you have put on a pedestal is knock them off.
Infighting the Good Fight. 149
Those who would oppose this scarcity system face the additional
challenge of unlearning its conditioning. Many of us have come
to this resistance from a life of conflict and struggle, the effects
of which still exert a great influence over us. Having been abused,
neglected, harassed, and intimidated, having had to fight peers, par­
ents, teachers, bosses, and police to establish ourselves, we see self­
hood as something that is obtained by fighting. We come to think
of being radical as a war-hence the more wars we fight, the more
radical we must be. We profess intentions to create peace, but the
only tools we possess are weapons," Small wonder we end up fight­
ing among ourselves.
Justice and Judgment
Scarcitythinking and the destructive insecurity it fosters have played
a large part in shaping our notions of justice.' Passing judgment
can be the ultimate compensation for one's own shortcomings. It's
easy to get self-righteous about someone else's mistakes, flaws, and
-inconsistencies, for the more we focus on others' the less we have
to think about our own. Witch-hunters who believe that they have
found a real live criminal (or racist, lifestylist, class traitor, etc.) just
like the ones in the movies can reassure themselves that they have
isolated the contagion and need look no further-and the more vit­
riolic their denunciations of the enemy, the more afraid everyone
else is to admit what they have in common with the accused.
Again-we live in a violent, oppressive world. It's as sensible to
blame anyone of us for being colonized by this violence and domi­
nation as it is to blame the oceans for being polluted. The question
should not be whether an individual is guilty-we all are, at least of
complicity-but rather how to enable individuals to confront and
• Ironically this combativeness is especially prevalent in some pacifist circles, in
which people eschew physical violence but impose this disavowal upon others
with incredible self-righteousness and belligerence.
t The self-righteous activist's sense of justice is derived from the same origins
as the "justice system" which feeds today's prison-industrial complex: a Chris-,
tianity that emphasizes individual responsibility over the cause and effect of
social conditions in order to invent, advertise, and sell the ultimate scarce
commodity-salvation. In a state of truly mutually beneficial social relations,
threats like incarceration and hellfire would not be necessary to make people
behave themselves.
150. Infighting the Good Fight
I 7' -- RI6HTSOUSNSSS
IS A PRSMIUM CURRSNCY IN
THIS POST-CHRISTIAN S O C I S ~
THOU6H IT RSFSRS TO
A MYTHICAL- WORt-D.
transform the violence and ignorance within themselves. Often noth­
ing can help a person to do this more than to give him the benefit of
the doubt, trusting that he is interested in coexisting with others;
this makes it easier for him to drop his defenses, communicate, and
question himself. This is not to say we shouldn't defend ourselves
by any means necessary whenever we have to-but let's do this for
practical reasons, not out of lust for revenge and superiority.
Objectivity versus Subjectivity
Our scarcity-oriented, authoritarian civilization is predicated on the
idea that there is onlyone truth; privileged access to that truth is called
objectivity, and many compete for this prize. According to this school
of thought, those who want to explain human behavior or overthrow
capitalism should make different propositions regarding the best way
to do this and debate them until the correct one is recognized. So it is
that in ivory towers and squalid basements, intellectuals and armchair
revolutionaries debate incessantly, coming no closer to consensus, de­
veloping more and more exclusive jargon while others in the field labor
to forge the compromises necessary to accomplish anything.
Infighting the Good Fight. 151
To prioritize subjectivity is to accept that there is no "the" reality;
by inference, any "objective" reality must simply be one subjective
reality institutionalized as Truth by those in power. Thinking this
way means recognizing that people have arrived at their particular
beliefs and behaviors as a result of their individual life experiences.
This has an important bearing on how we interact with each other, .
especially in our efforts to change the world.
Different people are bound to have different beliefs, tactics, and
goals. They don't necessarily think differently thanyou because they
are less intelligent, experienced, perceptive, or compassionate­
they may be your equals in all these regards, but come to different.
conclusions based on different evidence from their own lives. Upon
hearing a person's position on an issue, you needn't immediately
commence debating which of you is right. It might be more worth­
while to establish whether there are projects that can further both
your interests,* or at least ways you can coexist. Whatever ideologi­
cal issues need to be worked out can be worked out in practice, if
they can be worked out at all-they certainly will not be resolved
by another contest of egos disguised as a debate about theory.t
Obviously, it's impossible for anyone to legislate for everyone
else, since every life experience is unique; nevertheless, you can
offer your own experiences and conclusions for others to do with
what they will-and if you speak honestly for yourself, you will
probably find you have spoken for others as well. This may be seen
as legislative by those who believe there is only one right way, but
those who attack you for offering your own perspective or analysis
on the grounds that it doesn't apply to them (or isn't relevant to all
people, starving mothers in Somalia, transgendered Republicans,
etc.) are still working within the scarcity model.
Remember-every value you espouse, every decision you make,
you make for yourself alone. When people attack you as if you are
• Of course, when interests genuinely conflict, sometimes there is nothing to do
but fight it out. The communists who attempted to coexist with Hitler's fascists
in the late 1930S sealed their own fates and those of countless others.
t In taking sides against others, you can forget that everyone's positions are flu­
id-andforcing someone to act as a partisan of an opposing side can trap them
into identifying themselves with that side exclusively. Often it happens that
a person adopts a position impulsively, but upon being attacked entrenches
himself and defends it for the rest of his life.
152. Infighting the Good Fight
" deciding for everyone, don't fall into the trap of arguing for your own
methods and ideas as universals. Simply point out that you act accord­
ing to your own conscience, and hope to integrate your approach into
those of others-just as it is up to others to do with you.
The Capitalism of Ideas
Those who still hold that there is such a thing as objective truth
generally feel a compulsion to persuade others of their truths. This
is the self-perpetuating consequence of the power struggles that go
on in the market of ideas; as in any economy based on scarcity, that
market is characterized by competition between capitalists who
strive to preserve and increase their power over others.
In our society, ideas function as capital in much the same way
money does.*Individuals who can get others to buy into their ideas
obtain disproportionate control over their surroundings; large con­
glomerates such as the Catholic Church and the Communist Party
have come to rule large parts of the world this way, and indeed one
cannot long hold political or financial power without ideological
capital to back it up. Little start-up companies contest these mo­
nopolies with newvisions, and sometimes one unseats the reigning
creed to become the new dominant paradigm; but as in any capital­
ist system, power tends to flow upward to the top of the hierarchy.
In this state of affairs, anyone with a value or viewpoint has to rush
to sell it to others before being run out of business.
From this vantage point, it's hard to imagine what a world free
from this war of ideologies would be like. Obviously, it would have
to be free from analogous wars for money, power, and selfhood as
well, for it's foolish to insist that one can think however one wants
when some ways of conceptualizing the cosmos are punished by
exclusion or embargo. Those who fight for freedom from gods and
masters must contest the dictatorships of ideology that always ac­
company and enable them,'
• Ideas, like other forms of capital, are considered private property and pro­
tected by law from plagiarism, copyright infringement, and other methods of
redistributing wealth.
t Paradoxically, this statement rests on ideological assumptions of its own­
but perhaps this kind of self-contradiction is the first necessary step in the
disarmament of ideology.
Infighting the Good Fight. 153
,
"
'
'
'
,I
Why PeOPle Don't Want to"Join theMovement"
Considering t
l
b f
pu
oubli lati 1 I'
'Ie num ers 0 ic re ations agents, te evange ists,
self-help guru '
, s, and other assorted fanatics and salesmen compet­
rng to convert h' ,
t em, the hesitance of the masses to get involved
in any kind Of" d f
, social movement is actually a healthy self- e ense
mechanism. C
onsequently, the greatest challenge for those who
seek common c ith h k luti h '
ause Wit ot ers to rna e revo utionary c ange is
to avoid maki
h
th d f '
<.g em e ensrve,
The tendetl. f di 1 1" kIf 1d f '
cy 0 ra ica po itics to rna e peop e ee e ensrve
may currently b "
e a greater obstacle to SOCial transformation than
any corporate t 1 ' I' d '
ontro or government repressiOn, t is cause in part
by the attitude, f " hernselvesrmanv acti have i d
~ 0 activists t emse ves: many activists ave mveste
in their activist id " f '1 h
i entities as an act 0 compensation at east as muc
as out of a gen.. ' d ' k hi h f h '
, ....me esrre to rna e t ings appen- or t em, actrv­
ism
,
serves the s
arne
f
unction
ion th
t at mac
hi
ismo,
f
as
hi
ron, an
d
pop
ul
ar­
ity
.
serve for
,
0th A" h '11'
serving t
,
ers, ctrvists w 0 are sti
he
e
i
imperatives
of msecunty t ~ d ' ,
, ,n to alienate others; they may even unconsciously
desire to alien. '
ate others so they can stand alone as the virtuous
vanguard, Seei", h " " 1 h 1 h '
, '" <.gsue actrvists m action, peop e wop acate t eir
insecurrties 11\ h '
, ot er ways frequently conclude that revolutionary
struggle has n()th' do wi h
t
h
err
' I'
ing to 0 Wit ives,
Whenever '-. 'd ' 1 ' ,
"'Ve are consi enng a revo utionary project, we must
ask ourselves: ~ e we certain of our motivations? Will our words
and deeds mob'l' d bl ' bili d di .. It._
, .. ize an ena e, or immo i ize an iscourager rue
we trymg to c '
, , t'eate a spectacle of our freedom or compassiOn or
erudition, to ~ " t
.. a
bli h our status
our
as
status as
revoluti , 1
ea
d
ers or is revo utionanes or
intellectuals t() lai h 1hi h d ' h hildi h
" ' Cairn t e mora ig groun ,to Win at t e CiS
compention Of h ' di 1 d ( if ff
w 0 is most ra rca or most oppresse as i su er­
ing was quantrj, bl f\ 'II ki d '
, ,"La e.)-are we sti see mg power an revenge In
.. PIll hen vou are lordi the guise of lib., ,
eop e can te w mg your-: "ratiOnr en you are or
self over them......, , h
, "r playmg a role, Just as t ey can sense when you are
acting honesth, f 1 f desi d d fai h Th' h
Y rom a pace 0 esire an goo aitn. ey re muc
more likely to t' d h ' h '1' 1 dv i 1 d
espon to t at, Since t err rves a rea y inc u e too
much role-plau'n d ri al
T .. g an nv ry.
We would ..J h
'-10 better to abandon the crusade to convert t e
masses with i ,,",
" , , ts patromzmg implications that others are lazy,
weak, vlCtiIlliZ""'d ' d f id I db' by
" ,or in nee 0 gUi ance, nstea ,we can egin
154, Infighting t h ~ Good Fight
reaching out to those with whom we have the most in common,
to whom our perspectives can be most useful and with whom
cooperation comes most naturally," Likewise, we can work with
those who are already active in other communities, insofar as we
share values and goals-this is vastly preferable to entering oth­
ers' communities and attempting to organize them according to
the doctrines of outsiders.' We can help others defend themselves
from the encroachments of power and ideology, offering them
the tools we have developed in our own struggles to apply as they
see fit! Finally, we can find common cause with people on the ba­
sis of all the social and "antisocial" things they are already doing
and feeling: theft, vandalism, graffiti, "laziness," rebelliousness,
apparent nihilism, not to mention compassion and cooperation
wherever they appear.
This is the real purpose of the glorification of shoplifting, va­
grancy, and so on that some radical propaganda indulges in: not
to argue that shoplifting itself is revolutionary (or that one must
shoplift to be radical, as if revolution was a commodity in a scarcity
economy!), but to establish connections to the daily lives and resis­
tances of individuals who have not necessarily articulated a desire
for revolution but are already acting, however impetuously, outside
the logic of the ruling order,
The private longings and frustrations people feel-their hatred
for busywork, the pleasure in transgression they find they share with
teenagers and anarchists, the instinctive suspicion with which they
view all totalitarian systems-provide a starting point for a resistance
that proceeds from the individual motivations and standpoints of
* I grew up as a middle class rebel, but I thought I had to put that behind me to
work towards social change, When I gave up trying to push reforms through
the bureaucracy and began to practice direct action with others of my back­
ground, I realized what a vast, untapped force my demographic has to offer,
t It turned out that just one neighborhood over there was a group in the Chicano
community working according to the same principles, using different words
for similar ideas. When I sat in on one of their meetings, it became clear how
much more we could be doing.
*When the locals started joining in the fighting, we showed them how to make
their shirts into masks so the police couldn't identify them and how to use
lime juice to treat the effects of tear gas-that's anarchist "leadership," or what
we have in place of it: sharing our skills with others, spreading power rather
than concentrating it,
Infighting the Good Fight, 155
all who comprise it rather than the demands of political parties and
dogmas.* This is the only kind of resistance that can rescue us from
authoritarian power and authoritarian ideology alike.
Not Unity, but Harmony
Any resistance movement is going to develop conflicts over strat­
egy (violence vs. pacifism, coordination vs. autonomy) as different
individuals construct their own analyses and test them out in prac­
tice. To contest this diversity rather than seeking to benefit from
it-to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by turning chances to
address important issues into squabbles, as liberals do whenever
radicals use direct action to give their petitioning teeth-is need­
lessly counterproductive; more than this, it is tantamount to wish­
ing everyone had the same life history and perspective. By and large,
teenage hoodlums are not going to find the same things liberating
middle-aged librarians do-but both have a stake in liberation, and
must be a part of any struggle for it. Those who would set rules for
the unruly and regulations for the irregular deny the complexity
not only of human beings but also of the struggle it will take to
win our freedom.
Again, others' approaches and goals are bound to differ from
yours; the challenge is not to convert them to your own strategy (for
who knows-they might actually know better than you what is good
for theml), but rather to find ways to integrate divergent methods
into a mutually beneficial whole. Similarly, if you share another's
goals but feel that their tactics are ineffective or counterproduc­
tive, it is up to you to find and add the missing ingredients that can I!
make them effective-if you don't, you have yourself to blame for
all the energy you feel they're wasting.
* When it comes to underrepresented perspectives-if they are not your own,
don't try to represent them, the way politicians "represent" us. Better repre­
sent yourself, and encourage others to do the same ... for example, by making
an effort to listen to those who already are. Some people may dismiss your
perspective (as "middle class," "reformist," "extremist," etc.), but there is no
such thing as an illegitimate perspective-it is only illegitimate to act as if
someone else's perspective is not legitimate. A lot of that goes on, sometimes
perpetrated in the name of the underrepresented by those who aren't neces­
sarily underrepresented themselves.
Don't be intimidated-you can be sure that if you are feeling something some­
one else is feeling it too, and needs to know she is not alone.
156. Infighting the Good Fight
Approaches that speak clearly to some people may alienate oth­
ers, including self-proclaimed activists. In these cases, it's impor­
tant not to feel too threatened, since you may not actually be-and
to keep in mind that with the vast diversity of lives on this planet,
we'll need an equally diverse arsenal of outreaches. In some cases,
approaches that seem to contradict each other may actually form
a perfect symbiosis, as in the relationship between masked rioters
and well-behaved, well-spoken proponents of social change. No one
in power would take heed of the latter without the former behind
them-imagine Martin Luther King's nonviolence without the im­
plicit threat of Malcolm X's confrontational stance-and without
"respectable" support, insurgents can easily be marginalized and
destroyed. In these situations, all parties should remember that
others may even have to publicly disavow their tactics in order to
continue playing their parts effectively;* there should be no hard
feelings when this happens.
Certainly it can be difficult to work alongside people who profess
beliefs entirely different from yours-and you should never work
with those you fear will betray you or hijack your efforts to serve
their own ends. But, again, ask yourself: are your positions impor­
tant to you as positions-that is to say, as status symbols, badges of
identity, distinctions that separate yourself from others-or as means
of achieving a more fulfilling life? It's common sense to integrate
• As the masked window-smasher yelled at the law-abiding liberal protester
who tried to restrain her, "It's not your job to stop me from 'making your
cause look bad,' but to distance yourself from my actions as much as you have
to to keep the respect of the demographic you're trying to reach! It's my job
to make something happen here so they'll have to listen to you in the fuck­
ing first place!"
Infighting the Good Fight. 157
the differing tactics of those who share' a common goal; it's more
challenging, though no less constructive, to put aside the compul-:'
sion to persuade everyone else of your opinions and work to create
harmony between individuals who live in totally different worlds.
Such harmony will never be complete, but it's a nobler objective
than any unity that demands conversion by the sword.
Working in Collectives
Just as a band needs musicians who play different instruments,
healthy associations don't restrict the participants with compromis­
es that limit them to the things they have in common, but instead
integrate their dissimilarities into a whole greater than the sum of
its parts. Working and living in such associations, in which every
person is conscious of being responsible for making the projects
and relationships work, helps one learn to see oneself as a part of
the web of human relations rather than as an isolated individual.
In order to coexist, we must take others' desires as seriously as our ,
own-recognizing this enables an individual to be a more complete
person, as her companions can represent parts of herself that she
would not otherwise express. Everyone is ultimately a product of the
same world-we are all interconnected, each manifesting different
aspects of the same interplay of forces. Without this insight, coop­
eration and community can only be incidental and haphazard.
For the individual experienced in living communally, it becomes
possible to regard the entire cosmos as one vast, albeit dysfunc­
tional, collective; the problem is simply how to make its workings
more to one's liking; This is not to say fascists, sexists, and other
oppressors can go about their merry business and still be "part of
our collective"-they'd be the first ones to deny that, and follow up
with proof! But the chief argument of fascism and reactionary think­
ing has always been that cooperation and autonomy are mutually
exclusive, that people must be ordered and controlled or else they
will be lazy and/or kill each other. The more we demonstrate this
to be untrue, the less appeal their claims will have.
158, Infighting the Good Fight
War or Revolution?
Would-be revolutionaries so frequently frame our project in mar­
tial terms: we set out to Fight Racism, Smash Fascism, Destroy
Capitalism, Eat the Rich. This enables us to see ourselves as noble
crusaders-and more importantly, to have adversaries, which reas­
sures us of our own righteousness. This reassurance is more seduc­
tive than the success it replaces and prevents-at least, it is so long
as one hasn't yet tasted that success. We have to remember in every
extremity that our enemies are not human beings, but rather the
conditions that make human beings enemies.
A world entirely without enemies is not possible-it might not
even be desirable-but remember, war is business as usual for capital­
ist society: Exxon vs. Shell, USA vs. Iraq, Communists vs. Anarchists,
lover against lover and parent against child. Even if we could kill
every last rapist, C.E.a., head of state, police officer, and housemate
who won't do the dishes, that violence would remain in the world
as the venom and fury of those who survived them, not to mention
the effects on the killers themselves-that's karma for you. Revolu­
tion happens when you create situations that make the old conflicts
irrelevant, that dispel all that inertia of resentment and insecurity
and antagonism.
Warfare is necessary sometimes-we have to defend ourselves,
and sometimes this requires violence. But, as any child can point
out, "if it's you against the world, bet on the world." So many of us
alienate ourselves needlessly from others, eventually relying on
abstractions ("the working class," "the imminent insurrection")
for allies once every flesh and blood companion is gone or, worse,
concluding that cooperation is simply impossible-when history
shows that it is possible, at least for those who are patient, consid­
erate, humble, forgiving.
Doing things you enjoy will help you resist taking your frustra­
tions out on others-as will working with people you like whenever
it's possible," There's nothing noble or revolutionary about sacrific­
ing yourself for a cause, especially when it makes you impossible to
* Organizing autonomously and trying another free association whenever one
isn't working can give you the freedom you need so you will not resent others.
Revolution may involve learning to live and act cooperatively, but it doesn't
mean everyonehas to be friends.
Infighting the Good Fight .159
be around. At the same time, it won't-and shouldn't-always be
possible to surround yourself with people who see things the way
you do: be ready to leave your comfort zone, and bring a generous
heart when you do.
When you forgive others for their incoherence, selfishness, and
errors, you can discern what they have to offer you. When you
practice a form of justice that takes responsibility for setting things
right, you can heal rather than impotently dispensing guilty verdicts.
When you are patient with impatience, when you refrain from be­
ing self-righteous even and especially with the self-righteous, when
you approach every conflict as an opportunity to learn from your
own mistakes, you can do your part to liberate all of us prisoners
of war.
This is dedicated to all those who have done this over the years,
who have taken it for granted that for all their clumsiness, people
from other backgrounds and advocates of other tactics really did
want to coexist and cooperate with them: to the working class
men and women who took the time to explain to bourgeois activ­
Perhaps the most important thing you can do is be there for others,
ists how they were alienating them, even when the latter did not
help them believe in themselves, offer real compassion-not the
at first know how to listen; to the women who not only demanded
condescension of charity-when it is needed. But there is no for­
men recognize the existence and effects of their sexism, but also
mula for this; mercy comes in the least predictable forms and from
acknowledged the fears and anxieties men feel; to the survivors of
the most unexpected sources. Often it takes a person who has suf­
abuse who went on to counsel both abused and abusers. Without
fered something similar to be able to offer real succor to someone
them, we would assuredly have torn each other to pieces already. It's
in distress. That's another reason why it is good that we have all
frightening to let your guard down, it's hard to swallow your pride
chosen different paths and suffered different things, even things
even when clinging to it would mean betraying yourself-but this
that seemed to isolate us-why there is a place even for spoiled
is the only way to help others do the same.
rich kids and homeless drug addicts and lovers who have lied and
Don't be intimidated by the colossal challenge of "saving the
betrayed in this struggle: for who else could relate to others in those
world"; there are as many worlds as there are people-save !lours,
difficult situations, offer them guidance and hope? When you rec­
the one made up of the life you share with those around you. Where
ognize how your tribulations have prepared you to help others, it
one flower blooms, a million more will follow.
can make sense of experiences that seemed senseless; at the same
time, this may help you to see the importance of others who previ­
ously appeared without worth.
Often we have our hands full dealing with our own pain, too
consumed by bitterness and confusion to be able to offer others any­
thing, least of all mercy. This means it is all the more critical that we
not miss the opportunities we have to be good to others-whether
or not they have "earned" it, whether or not we understand them,
whether or not we think it will make a difference.
160. Infighting the Good Fight
Infighting the Good Fight. 161
I would like to be someone with whom
no one would be ashamed of any part of
herself I would like to be able to regard
the actions of others without feeling
threatened or becoming defensive, even
when they are defensive with me-to see
others in the context of their lives, not my
own. I would like to know how to set the
right limits on how far I trust others, so
I never risk losing my respect for them or
my ability to trust. I would like to be able
to look those adversaries who should be
allies in the eyes and say Like it or not,
this is who I am. This is what the world
has made of me, and we all must live
with the consequences. I can't change
the decades of life behind me that have
wrought this, only take responsibility
for what I am and what I do. I don't
want to compete with you for moral
high ground or anything else. Unless
you're prepared to kill everyone who
doesn't live up to your standards or
else to endure this impasse indefinitely,
you're going to have to accept me on
my own terms, as I hope to accept you.
You are as responsible as I am for mak­
ing what goes on between us positive
for us both-or for the world of strife
we will suffer in otherwise.
162. Infighting the Good Fight
The announcement that the administration was severing all ties
with the sweatshop industry marked the final splintering of our
precarious confederation. This was apparent in the way the strike
ended and in the increasing distance between groups employing
different tactics-more and more people were getting involved,
but they crossed paths less and less. Part of the initial magic of the
encampment had been the c o n f l u e n c ~ of disparate demographics;
the unlikely alliances made it seem the whole world was reconfig­
uring itself. Yet once we'd succeeded in forcing the administration
to stop using sweatshop labor and improve working conditions, we
lost track of each other-there wasn't even a celebration to bring
us together one last time.
We'd won a victory I'd assumed was impossible-but now there
was no more "we" and the fundamental structures we'd taken on
remained unshaken. Perhaps the ones who initiated the campaign
should have set their sights higher from the beginning.
In place of working with other locals, each group began to or­
ganize with its counterparts in other cities. Thus the expansion of
the struggle corresponded with its local disintegration, though no
one put this together at the time. This expansion enabled us to act
on a more dramatic scale; but also drew disproportionately more
repression-that scale was the province of our enemies, the terrain
on which they could mobilize the most force.
By the end of the following year, local activity had died down
significantly; everyone was busy preparing for a demonstration that
was happening halfway across the country. This was the first major
event in recent memory we all agreed was important; it would be
a testing ground at which we would see if we could work together
in our new configurations.
Hitting the Wall. 163
I hadn't seen Samia since the debriefing that followed the night
march; her friends had been in and out of town, but as far as I could
tell she'd been gone the entire time. Kate and Marshall and their ,;
crowd were still around, though we rarely saw each other. I'd re­
mained something of a loner, partly on account of my age, though
I'd begun working with an independent media collective to put my
skills to use. As was becoming typical, most of the collective resided
elsewhere in the country.
I arrived in the city less than a week before the summit was to
begin. Night had fallen, the kind of frenetic night that falls in big
metropolises, and the atmosphere was tense and portentous. The
red and blue lights of police cruisers flashed at every intersection;
lines of police in black riot armor were drilling in the square next
to teams of workmen assembling walls of chain link and concrete.
Downtown had the air of an occupied nation during wartime. Si­
rens resounded constantly in the distance; in my new persona as
an enemy of the state, I hoped each one indicated a new challenge
to their control.
Kate had invited me to a privatemeeting the evening before the
first big day of action. She'd known me long enough that she trusted
me to participate in such things, though Marshall and Diego still
treated me with thinly veiled disdain on account of my social class
and suspect profession. I hadn't turned our adventures into a book'
after all, but the stigma of being able to still lay upon me.
The meeting took place in a classroom at the local university- ,
here was the fantasy Marshall had talked about in the occupation'
days coming true in humble reality. A stocky young man in a black,
flight jacket stood guard at the door. He didn't step aside until I told ,'j
him who had invited me.
The fluorescent lighting and spotless white walls of the class- "
room contrasted starkly with my companions' somber attire and J:
visages. Most people were already there-barbarians of the sort I'd
first encountered at the occupation, conversing in twos and threes.
I knew perhaps six out of the three dozen present, and two of those l
only by sight.
A tall woman with an authoritative air exchanged whispers'
with the young man outside, then locked the door and addressed ,
the room. "Before we begin, I want everybody to touch someone
they vouch for."
164 . Hitting the Wall

,i,
'
Everyone laid their hands on the people around them, forming
a lattice of limbs extending from row to row-with one exception:
Kate and the others I knew were on the other side of the room. All
eyes fell on me. It didn't help that I was the oldest by a full decade.
"I'm with those people," I offered sheepishly, gesturing at Kate and
Marshall and Diego, whose arms rested on each others' shoulders.
. Then we went around giving our names and fields of activity;
Kate was Hecate, Marshall Mars, and so on. I explained that I was
there on behalf of the independent media, to make sure there were
photographers and reporters where activists desired them. Others
specified the number of people in the contingent they represented,
or the equipment they'd brought: "One hundred hockey pucks; thirty
gas masks; thirty improvised shields; enough fireworks for ourselves
and another group our size; one reinforced banner, twenty-five feet
wide, with two joints."
It soon came out that there were still disagreements as to what
we were here to accomplish. Some people wanted to mount a di­
rect assault on the security perimeter around the summit; others
thought that foolhardy. The spokesperson of the locals was utterly
despondent: "We can't go to the wall, it's impossible. They'll shoot
us, they'll kill us all."
In my sexism, I had taken it that Samia was a sort of protegee
of Marshall, but here she appeared at the head of a contingent of
her own-which, if her companions in the meeting were any indi­
cation, seemed to be composed of starry-eyed vagabonds from the
four corners of the earth. She proposed an alternative: "If we can't
go to the wall, let's head the opposite direction with the liberal
march, and break off to visit the shopping district. They won't be
prepared for that."
Marshall countered this. "I can trash the McDonald's in my
neighborhood any time I want. We're going to the wall." His tone
didn't permit discussion or dispute.
"But what's to stop them from shooting us, really?" Samia was
talking out of turn. "You know the police have a free hand when
it's only us in the streets. The real problem here is it's only us in
this room! Why aren't we meeting with all the other groups that
will be out there tomorrow? Look around the faces here-do you
think this is representative? What happened to the coalitions we
had a year ago?"
Hitting the Wall. 165
This sent Diego into a rage. "What happened? Where the fuck
have you been? While you were out cavorting around the world,
we were struggling to keep things going, we were showing up every
week to shovel beans! Don't ask me where everyone else is after you
fucking abandoned us!"
Everyone froze. This was the critical moment, when someone
had to speak up to calm tempers and get the discussion back on
track, but no one dared. Instead, Samia lashed back: "If you're go­
ing to speak to me like that-no wonder I left! No wonder there's
no one else here!"
Several other people broke in at once. "Come on, we don't have ,,1
time for this! There are serious things we have to decide by tomor-!
row-" "Y'all should have talked this out already before you brought
it in here!" "Christ, here we go again ... "
I left in the hopeless rage of those who watch powerlessly as .
their loved ones destroy something precious. We'd gotten nowhere. !
My comrades' critiques of each other were all true enough, but that ]
was beside the point; they were fighting each other rather than our
common enemies.
This, too, had become increasingly common over the preceding
year. Of course, no external forces prevented them from acknowl­
edging and curbing this behavior, and the advantages of doing so..
were obvious-but they could not. One might say of an animal tha
persists in some counterproductive activity that it is incapable 0
behaving differently, and an animal observing my companions woul
have said the same of them. Up close, this inability manifested itse
as their endless excuses, defensive responses to criticism, dwelli
on each others' faults, and efforts to discredit former friends rathe
than hear out their critiques-anything to avoid having to set asid
their insecurities and work through differences like adults.
They had been sculpted by our times as sure as the crenellatio
and parapets of medieval castles were sculpted by theirs. Historia
teach that those parapets were invented by men, but just as a stre
of water will erode a cliff into an accommodating shape it was
inventions and decisions of generations of men and women th
forced those inventors to design parapets or perish. Likewise, mi.
friends had been shaped by their atomized society into individ
walled fortresses, and it was futile to expect them to let down rhei
guard and stop fighting each other.
166. Hitting the Wall
And this was why no revolution had taken place: no one had
succeeded in introducing a new element to this equation, so it
perpetually produced the same results. Every collective ended in
acrimonious division, every alliance broke off before it bore fruit.
Each of us went through friendship after friendship, using them up
and burning them out, then moving on to do the same with others.
Crowded into cities, our planet teeming with billions of people,
this seemed a sustainable approach to social life. In fact, it was like
releasing pollution into the ocean: if only one person does it, it dis­
solves harmlessly, but when everyone does so perpetually, the re­
sults are catastrophic. The wreckage of our planet was simply the
physical manifestation of the disposable nature of our relationships
and commitments.
Hitting the Wall. 167
·, the grimanarchists pull down masks
clenched teeth. As the sun rises through the
we still have a common enern
i.?utpff()urrifts and rivalries for another day. We c
in ourselves, in each other, and
.. ......a,tld also our shame,our arrogance and fear,
, 'ma.rtyrcomplexes, our despair. We know better than to h
for victory: after this fight, even after any revolution, there
always be another conflict, another line to draw. Even if e
government and board of directors abdicated and no one ste
forward to replace them, we would simply commence fig
each other. This is what we do, it is all we have learned, it
we can do with our bitterness.
That day we marched to the wall and tore it to the ground. The mar,
was striking in that it was utterly silent-no chants, no songs, just
dour mass of people going somewhere to do something. When th
media appeared, we smashed their cameras and stomped in the wind';
shields of their vans. The police withdrew before us-theyhadn't bar.
gained on us being so numerous and so fierce. That was the day th
finally recognized the threat we posed; in all the subsequent demon,
strations, they mobilized every mercenary within a thousand m i l e ~
to intercept us before we could even come together. It was our one,
chance to penetrate their defenses, and we did-we cut the bars with'
bolt cutters and smashed the metal poles free of their concrete bases'
and rocked the whole structure until it crashed to the asphalt.
Ahead of me, through the first puff of the tear gas that was to;
saturate the air for the next two days, I could see the high-rise in
which the summit was taking place. There, men had gathered to '
ensure that dishwashers stayed in dish rooms, Africans and Asians'
and Latin Americans stayed in mines and sweatshops, and the ne- ,
cessities of life remained hostage behind shop windows; they signed
their names in our blood on documents milled from our forests.'
they forked flesh from our bones into their insatiable mouths and'
called it freedom. It was not their power that kept us on our knees.
of course, so much as our willingness to abide it; but here we were
at last, ready to contest it, almost ready to test our own.
And there we stopped. It was incredible; we hadn't imagined we
could possibly get to this point, we had spent all our time bickering ;"
about whose fault it was that we couldn't, so now that we'd arrived'
we were unprepared to do anything. That hush was bone-chilling.
That was our moment, our once in a lifetime chance, and we squan­
dered it in frozen disbelief.
, Then, finally, the slow apparatus of the state roused itself and lurched
into motion. No one ever stepped forward through the holes we had
knocked in the wall; instead, an hour later, we found ourselves three
blocks back, fleeing a police charge calculated to sweep us into the arms
of an arriving army unlike anything we'd seen before. We paused again,
our escape routes blocked by a new wall of beige and green.
Standing there facing the assembled might of the police state, ar­
mored tanks and water cannons and concussion grenades, we thought I
we had lost, we thought we had grievously miscalculated the strength "
of our foe and were about to be crushed without even leaving a smudge
on history. We didn't realize that we had already fought nine tenths
170. On the Battlefield
of the battle, that the last lines of defense were being brought out to
. restrain us because we had triumphed against all the repressive forces
within, all the inertia and insecurity and self-imposed impotence­
all but our own internal conflicts, which were our real undoing. If
only we had understood that the battle lines were not in front of us
but within, in our planning meetings and conversations, our neigh­
borhoods and our bedrooms! If we had arrived at the wall with our
relationships and confidence in one another intact, the only way we
could have lost would have been to turn back at that moment, fore­
swearing our struggle and begging to be forgiven our heresies.
It took a lot of doing, but with great effort, we managed to lose.
This took years to accomplish; it was too massive an undertaking to
complete in the moment we found ourselves surrounded. We had to
call off the crusade to which we had given our lives, disconnect vast
international networks, persuade our friends that all the commitments
to which we had pledged ourselves were pipe dreams; hardest of all, we
had to return to siding with the police and bosses and billboards against
ourselves and the desires we had nurtured beyond their control.
We were fools. We didn't believe in ourselves enough, nor in each
other; had we apprehended the gravity of the war we were fighting,
how much depended on us, we would have put aside our pride and
sorted out our petty feuds. Even throwing molotov cocktails at armored
personnel carriers, we still weren't convinced of the reality of what we
were doing-we were still playacting, dubiously testing what was pos­
sible in the world rather than shouldering the task of changing it.
After that, we didn't deserve another chance. But history always
doubles back on itself, trying the same experiments endlessly over
until they produce different results.
Next time we won't hesitate when we've pulled down the wall, nor
when we have to apologize to one another and talk out our disputes.
When only riot police stand between us and our freedom-only guns
and shields, and nothing more-we can win, for the contest between de­
sire and military might is not played out according to military rules.
Ironically, everything we'd idly charged against capitalism and
hierarchy was borne out beyond our wildest nightmares by what
followed. We'd given up so easily in part because we weren't pre­
pared for the grisly implications of our own conclusions, because
We weren't ready to handle the responsibility of being the first
line of defense against the wholesale destruction of life on earth.
We thought we still had time for quarreling and second thoughts.
On the Battlefield. 171
Q
J
- .
.
0
:
s

o

'
-
f

.
.
.
.
.

.
.
c
=

u :
s

e

~

·
0

.
.
c
=

THE END OF THE WORLD
When the world ends, white dust will fill the air like the curtain
at the end of a play. A rain of desperate bodies will fall from the
windows of burning buildings, drumming the concrete below. Men
with splinters in their eyes will stumble through streets choked with
debris; women clutching babies will pick through the rubble and
tear out their hair. Our generation will go to its grave shouting its
last words into a cell phone.
Or perhaps it will arrive as a thief in the night, step by invisible
step. Factories will disappear overseas and corporations vanish into
thin air, taking jobs and retirement funds with them. Cities dying
from the inside out will spread like ringworm, the shrapnel spray
of suburbs slicing through forest and field. Wars will reach from
continent to continent and neighborhood to neighborhood-the
terrorists who won't make peace against the horrorists who would
enforce it at any price, who keep trying to impose harmony between
oppressed and oppressor with fear and firepower. Gas prices will
rise with global temperatures and tides, acid rains fall with the last
'of the redwoods, computer systems crash with stocks and stock
markets ... until one day everyone has cancer.
Or else nothing will happen at all, business will continue as usual:
prison guards pace concrete tombs, psychiatrists contemplate mad­
ness, demons glare from the eyes of ministers, consumers are bought
and sold in the marketplace. It's after the end of the world, whispers
the homeless man on the corner-don't you know that yet?
Others, mysterious and knowing, who have held themselves aloof
from the discussion until now, finally interject: "Which world?"
The End of the World. 183

.
Then the catastrophes began: terrorist attacks, wars, hurricanes.]
pandemics. Or perhaps they'd been going on all along, but we'd been]
oblivious to them until our own lives were sufficiently disrupted. It;
hadn't occurred to me that the cancer that killed Daniel might be the-';
harbinger of our species' extinction, nor that the alarmist presenta-'
tions I'd made about the water table in my former life as an environ-s
mental activist would return as chilling front-page headlines.
Faced with actual upheaval, those of us who had been playing)
at revolution froze, wracked by guilt as if our own subversive de­
sires had somehow invited that chaos into the world. It was absurd
to think that the burning buildings on our patches and posters had;
caused the real buildings of our cities to catch fire, but we
like penitent criminals, disguising ourselves in the rhetoric of the,
dupes who were marching lockstep into the waiting maw of
apocalypse. Our entire approach had been predicated on the exag­
gerated placidity of the order we opposed; now that the curtain had
been pulled back from the abyss, we were utterly at a loss.
Young children, being hypersensitized to the unspoken, often:
unconsciously devote themselves to the fulfillment of their parenu':
unacted desires; likewise, it might be that our own revolts had j
been early indicators of the ruptures that were to come. As we hal
all found our paths to resistance one by one, painfully breaking
of the roles assigned us, we thought of ourselves as uniquely inde-'
pendent from history-but perhaps the forces that sent us spiral-,
ing out of orbit were the same ones that were soon to tear
our entire society, and our painful trials were simply that society;'
wresting itself from its prepared track in microcosm.
184. Some Run for Cover-We Rush to Bear \Nitness
Some of my friends concluded that the world was indeed coming
to an end and attempted to act accordingly, but this only seemed
to further immobilize them. They floundered about in millenarian
desperation, preparing for a doomsday that never arrived or await­
ing some watershed until their sense of agency had atrophied en­
tirely; the specter of the world ending was too vast to address with
any particular course of action. If the world really was ending, it
wasn't ending fast enough-the end seemed to drag on forever, in­
distinguishable from the calamities that had always made up our
daily lives.
Only in the smoke and tumult occasionally unleashed by real
catastrophes was it possible to escape that malaise-and so some
of us who once had circled the globe in search of adventure now
flocked to those, both to lend a hand and to learn about life after
the end of the world.
Some Run for Cover-We Rush to Bear Witness .185
When the world ends, people come out of their apartments and
meet their neighbors for the first time; they share food, stories, com­
panionship. No one has to go to work or the laundromat; nobody
remembers to check the mirror or scale or email account before
leaving the house. Graffiti artists surge into the streets; strangers
embrace, sobbing and laughing. Every moment possesses an imme­
diacy formerly spread out across months. Burdens fall away, people
confess secrets and grant forgiveness, the stars come out over New
York City; and nine months later, a new generation is born.
"Disasters bring people together, imparting a common
context and project. In this suddenly opened and
democratized atmosphere, individuals whose lives were
formerly separated identify with each other. This sense
of community offers intimations of a different kind
of society, turning calamity into a harbinger of better
things. Disasters are often the crucibles of millenarian
and revolutionary movements: in such extremes,
Disaster
people experience the broad possibilities of life and
subsequently set out to realize them."
-National Research Council Committee on Disaster Studies,
Convergence Behavior in Disasters: A Problem in Social Control
Yes, birth rates increase immediately following disasters, just as the
rate of natural death declines during them. People don't often die of
old age-that is to say, boredom-in the midst of catastrophes," Life,
however precarious, is worth staying awake for; in fact, it's never
tasted so sweet. The urgency of emergency provides just the spice
that the constant low-intensity stress of daily life never could.
* It's not just birth and death rates, either-domestic violence decreased dramati­
cally in South Central Los Angeles during the riots in 1992, for example, while
it hits a national peak on the day of the Super Bowl. As a French student com­
mented back in May of 1968, having had the good fortune to experience both,
"ONE ORDINARY WEEKEND IS BLOODIB THAN A MONTH OF INSURRECTION."
Disaster. 187 186. Disaster
But what about the people who do die in disasters? It's trill'
that people lose their lives in heat waves, flash floods, and airp
hijackings; they also die in automobile collisions, workplace ac ,:"
dents, of drug overdoses and heart attacks and lung cancer­
in unprecedented numbers, alone and forgotten in rest homes.
really strange thing is that, as a society, we fixate so fearfully on •.,
sasters, when everyday life is statistically more dangerous to us;
that, at the same time as we fear them, we find them so fascina .
To get to the bottom of this, we must reexamine both disasters
their supposed opposite, normal life, and figure out which is re
which. Let's begin by looking at disasters from the dissident pe
spective, through the forbidden eyes of the secret part of each
us that rejoices in them.
Disaster as Interruption
It's a public secret: disasters are exciting. Trying as they may be, 1'"
come alive in them. In our "normal" lives, we accommodate oursel
to the smallness of what seems to be the world, and that accomm
tion becomes itself a prison. Disasters throweverything into disarz
and into question: the wide world reasserts that anything is inde
possible, and we find ourselves tossed out of our prisons, ready or n
shivering on the sidewalk before the ruins. In these new conditio.
we can become heroes, work and witness miracles, suffer tragediCli
rather than mere indignities; we find ourselves fully engaged, thankf .
for each other and everything we have, even for what we have 10
Danger and distress do not always arrive uninvited; to trade one·'
tiresome old fears and frustrations for new and compelling ones c
be a real relief. In the wake of a disaster, everything has weight
meaning-tears and laughter both come easily, and no one kno
for sure what will follow next. Afterwards, many find it difficult
readjust, to resign themselves again to all that knowing.
Disasters deliver the equality law promises but fails to f
When disaster strikes, a boy in a wheelchair is no less than a haugh
executive: the two watch the burning high-rise side by side. Outsj .
ers and outcasts can find themselves elevated to positions of presti81
and approval-indeed, they may be the only ones prepared for
situation: when the Is evaporates, people who have invested eve
thing in it must rely on those who have spent their lives ponder'
188, Disaster
Nadia --, quoted in Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's atlas of
human suffering and inhuman repression The Gulag Archipelago,
recalls the time when she was being taken to interrogation by
an impassive, silent guard With unseeing eyes-when suddenly
the bombs began to explode right next to the Big House and it
sounded as if at the next moment they would fall directly upon
them. The terrified guard threw her arms around the prisoner and
her, desperate for human companionship and sympathy
in the face of the end. Then the bombing stopped. And her eyes
became unseeing "Hands behind your back! Move along."
That was a disaster that didn't go far enough.
the Could Be. Skills that seemed specialized and irrelevant-fighting
riot police, surviving in the woods-suddenly become essential for ev­
eryone, and dissident futures the pragmatic once dismissed as impos­
sible take over where the former chains of cause and effect leave off.
Disasters render the social facts that comprise reality nego­
tiable; abrupt freedom takes the place of hackneyed choice. Lost
hikers teach themselves to start fires with wristwatches, errand­
running mothers lift automobiles off children, docile airplane pas­
sengers commit cannibalism and are celebrated for it. When school
is closed and the roads are impassable, when everything is up in the
air, one is no longer at the mercy of routine, atrophying commit­
ments, cowardice and inertia: complete self-determination, in the
new and alien landscape of upheaval, is inescapable. Catastrophes
are sometimes described as experiences of total liberation, hereti­
cal as such a notion is in our safety-first society. It's no coincidence
the Millennium referred to in so many religious traditions is to be
ushered in by a phase of terrible destruction: the kingdom of heaven
arrives through the smoke.
That the notion of such an apocalypse-whether as nuclear war,
, final judgment, or total revolution-is so pervasive in our civilization
suggests a popular fascination with extremes in which conventions
no longer apply. Our preoccupation with danger and tragedy implies
a barely disguised longing for risk and uncertainty. "What would you
do if you learned you had only twenty four hours to liver From inside
our cubicles and confessionals, we can only envision total freedom
Disaster. 189
and authentic living in the context of imminent destruction
we do, constantly.
Here in the world of structure, safety, and routine, we know
saster only from afar, as spectacle: news reports, motion pictux,
rumors. These representations serve a host of purposes, the forem,
being intimidation: they keep us cowed, grateful for the protectio:'
of our noble leaders. The disaster we see through these screens, •.- ,
the wilderness allegedly beyond the walls of civilization, is a nigh,"
mare in which life is short, brutish, and ugly. These portrayals
more tellingly, serve an economic role: they cash in on the immen .
popularity of the apocalypse-vicarious living, through action mov,
ies and video games and the like, is bound to be in great demand ill
a society that stifles first-hand adventure. In the process, they teacl
\.
the important lesson that the moments of truth we secretly
for are distant, inaccessible, perhaps only fictional; certainly nOth
4
j
ing we could participate in or, for that matter, precipitate. That.\
to say: those noble leaders are simply protecting us from
Or is it themselves they are protecting? .
After all, where do our leaders fit in the anatomy of calamity?:)!
Airlifted in by private jet to address the mourners (and cameramenR
they speak as if they suffer our own tragedies more than we do, but;'
they're not the ones who bear the brunt when something goes
Students of disaster tell us that while disasters can increase the
portunities for exploitation, they also reduce the motivations for i4:;
at least among the population that experiences them; thus the
exploitation in disaster conditions is usually perpetrated by outsiders,
profiteers who take advantage of the situation to fleece survivors",
And our leaders are the ultimate profiteers of disaster: they rely on.
it-more precisely, on the terror the thought of it provokes-to main....
tain their power. Disaster works for them-especially if we never '.
experience it ourselves but only see it on television, in the papers.]
in our nightmares. In fact, these leaders are the ones endangering .
us-it is their policies that give us cancer and turn suicide bombers. {
against us. Our protectors run the ultimate protection racket.
But are they protecting us? Once upon a time oil spills and shoot­
ings were considered disasters; today these are practically standard \.
features of our society, built into the social fabric and accounted for
in advance. They are not anomalies, but routines. Real interruptions
in which the system breaks down, on the other hand, such as black­
190 . Disaster
outs and bomb threats, are still described as disasters, whether or
not anyone dies. Already harrowed by the vicissitudes of the system
itself, we dutifully fear them, but those who have lived through such
disruptions know how sweet it can be when Something Happens.
The essential quality of disasters as we know them is the break
with the status quo; this is the one feature they all share. It is not de­
structiveness that sets disasters apart: the slaughterhouses, suicides,
and collateral damage of Business As Usual take more lives than all
the worst catastrophes combined, while many disasters don't result
in any deaths at all. If the casualties of all disasters were tallied and
compared to those of "normal life," disaster would lookvery safe in­
deed, just as the number of deaths and injustices that have resulted
from people obeying authorities far outnumber those perpetrated by
those who have broken laws. Yet there are some who live in horror
of disasters while unflinchingly extolling the virtues of war: these,
then, must be people who fear the boundlessness and unruliness
of life but are quite at home with the orderliness of its opposite.
War, in particular, is a safe ritual-it is the protector of the status
quo, the reassertion of normality. It is no coincidence that the run­
away disaster of September 11, 2001 was followed immediately by
a series of wars-and which calamity hasultimately been bloodier,
especially if you count foreigners as human beings?
So only the coward fears disasters-that is to say,there is a cowardly
part of each of us that would keep everything familiar, whatever the
cost in lives and life. This is fear of the unknown in its purest form:
it projects chaos, destruction, and death onto everything beyond the
pale of the ordinary, projections all the more ironic in that they can
only be modeled on that which is known. From this irony, we can con­
clude that those who most fear the unknown reveal in doing so that
the world they know is a place of terror. It is precisely the terrorized,
those caught in thrall to fear, who most dread to leave its territory. The
free and fearless, ready to live and all too aware of what is insufferable
in the everyday, welcome new horizons-disasters included.
The Disaster as Permanent Condition
Wait-how could that be, that disasters are the apex of adventure,
community, life itself? Does that mean that if we really want to live,
we have to spend our lives as disastourists, quixotically chasing the
Disaster. 191
few brief moments of upheaval destiny affords each of us, longing
for the fleeting, borrowed wings of destruction and rebirth as we
wade through years of deadening routine in the meantime? Is that
practical, practicable, worthwhile? Does the woman fed up with her
car payments and marriage really crave tornadoes and typhoons, or
is she just desperate for an honorable way out?
Perhaps we have everything backwards here-maybe disasters
aren't so great after all, but the real Disaster, the worst one, is the
Disaster we live every day: the emptiness of our full schedules, the
trivia that trivializes us, the machinery that runs on rivers of blood.
That would explain why we feel so free whenever something, any­
thing, however dangerous or difficult, interrupts all this. Perhaps the
excitement and immediacy that break out in emergencies are simply
indications of a return to our natural state, in the break they herald
from the full-scale slow-motion train wreck that is our society. If
that is the case, then it is not disasters per se that are liberating-it
is, rather, a question of perspective: a "disaster" that disrupts a life
of constraint is experienced as a moment of liberation, when that
"normal life" is actually Disaster in disguise.
Most of the disasters we really suffer from can be traced to this
invisible Disaster, anyway. The destruction of rainforests and the
ozone layer, holocausts perpetuated with biological weapons and
smart bombs, even global pandemics like mad cow disease, anorexia,
bulimia, depression-these would not be possible without central­
ized state and corporate power, and the meaningless busywork of
billions that engenders it. To live with the unknown ahead of and
around us, to struggle only with the "natural disasters" our ances­
tors faced, would almost be idyllic after all this.
Could we fight Disaster with disaster? If we stopped feeding its
flames with our hard work and attention, if we ceased paying trib­
ute, the Disaster would surely crash and burn once and for all. If this
status quo is the ultimate Disaster, if it really is disorder and trag­
edy normalized as a system, no lower-case disaster could be worse.
Interrupt the Disaster!
Disaster. 193
Some of us are already practicing this. We don't live in the Disast
but in encampments at its edge-yes, in a state of ongoing disast
and difficulties, but nothing compared to the misery of life in
Disaster area proper. We don't fall for popular propaganda abo
disasters; we're conducting our own experiments with them.
don't have to wait for catastrophe to strike to enjoy its benefits·,'
we can throw a disaster any time we like. And we are.
194. Disaster
II Enough about the disintegration of our little movement-let's ret
to the subject of flight, where we started. During the Second Wor:
War, Colditz Castle, a thousand-year-old fortress near Dresden, w;
chosen by the Nazis to serve as a high security POW camp.
was the prison to which the Nazis sent the most dogged Allied esca .
artists, and consequently it became an elite school of escape.
After several failed attempts involving standard tactics such
hiding places, disguises, and ropes, the top secret Escape Committl'
approved a plan to depart by air. In 1943, prisoners began buildiii.,
a glider that was to be launched from the rooftop of the castle
piloted to a field across the nearby river. The glider was
entirely out of parts of the prison: floorboards, bed sheets,
vised fasteners, adhesives and tools. The craft was nearly
fly just as Colditz was liberated by Allied troops; later tests
that it could have succeeded. Under the most difficult
the prisoners had invented the airplane!;
As a means of escape from the physical confines of prison,
glider was a ridiculous scheme: it took years to build, demandedf
tremendous quantity of resources, and would only have been ah
to convey two people a scant thousand meters from the walls.
plan looks different, however, if we adjust our notion of what cot
stitutes prison. If prison is not simply the condition of spatial co
finement but a spectrum of confinements ranging from iron b
to debilitating despair to suburban ennui, what qualifies as a stii
cessful escape looks different as well.
The soldiers who were imprisoned in Colditz would probabl
never have become inventors if they had not been captured. I ri
fleeted on this as I traveled the country reporting on floods, fir',
tornados, and industrial accidents. By and large, the survivors'
pressed me as more courageous, inventive, and emotionally pres
196, Off the Cliff
.

than anyone in the towns that had been spared. Even those who had
lost all their possessions had gained the one thing you couldn't buy
on the market at any price-urgency. This gave them something in
common with those of us who had made disasters of our own lives
in trying to chart a path out of our disastrous society.
The popular fascination with accounts of disaster survival seemed
to me a tacit admission that something was lacking in most people's
daily lives. Businessmen in hotel bars never tired of the Colditz sto­
ry; the subtext was that they, too, might be able to invent airplanes
if only they weren't trapped in their well-paying careers. Provided
the protagonists were suitably middle class, even the most extreme
cases-such as the famous rugby team who survived by cannibal­
ism after their airplane crashed in the Andes-provoked more cu­
riosity than horror. The charm of that particular story was that it
permitted college graduates to violate the most fundamental taboo
that separates civilized humans from savages and wild beasts. It
was a case study proving that even the basic prohibitions of God
and Nature are negotiable-a sort of coded map to a loophole in
the social contract.
A scenario like that calls all manner of lesser rules and morals
into question. The airplane is a metaphor for civilization, govern­
ment, social institutions: systems that purport to offer services or
protection in exchange for obedience. A contract exists between
the passengers and the plane: the plane safely transports the pas­
sengers, the passengers behave within certain limits. But as soon as
the plane crashes, all deals are off.
As a reporter dispatched to disaster areas, it was my job to portray
life outside the plane as ugly, brutish, and short, to balance the titilla­
tion of that escape against the terror and misery that must inevitably
result. They sent me to ghettos destroyed by natural disasters, where
Whole districts were sealed off and the inhabitants left to die. First
I was supposed to paint the savagery of the locals in vivid colors, to
sensationalize the looting and arson that followed the breakdown of
order and praise the bravery of the sheriffs and National Guardsmen
who quarantined it. Then the story changed and I was permitted to
decry the sluggish response of federal disaster relief agencies and
bewail the senseless deaths of the poor. But long before the storms
hit, those ghettos had been disaster areas wracked by malnutrition
and drug addiction, devastated by slumlords and waste dumps, and
Off the Cliff. 197
patrolled by militarized police-and not one newspaper had run a:!

('

'
8
, !
.'
\') I
"I

story about them. Our disaster coverage was just a smokescreen
obscure the real holocausts that were taking place.
I was fed up with bullying people into the arms of the status quo. ,
Every time I sat down at my desk to hammer out another exercise "
in prevarication, disgust washed over me in a tidal wave. I wanted \
every ski resort to burn down, every stadium to cave in, every gated
community to flood-I wanted to see snide executives standing ,i,
out in the hot sun on the freeway median, desperately entreating ?
sealed windows and averted eyes. If bombs had to drop somewhere,
shouldn't they drop on the ones who ordered bombings? If anyone
had to live in prison or in fear, shouldn't it be the bigots and homo­
phobes who believed it was right for people to languish in cells and
closets? Maybe it wasn't sensible or defensible, but I wasn't afraid
of disasters anymore-I was practically praying for them.
I started where I could, in my own life: I gave notice at the office.
I'd been waiting all along for them to fire me, but it had turned out
my employers needed me more than I needed them. From now on,
I might indeed starve to death or get deported, but I would never
write another word I didn't wholeheartedly believe. It was absurd
to think that for so many years I had been less frightened of hurri­
canes, suicide bombers, and terminal illnesses than of simply losing.
my job. I was finally throwing myself off the cliff; I would invent
the airplane, or perish in the crash.
198. Off the Cliff

__ -=l
It is the final night of junior musicians' camp, and the campers'
parents have gathered at a gala dinner event to see their young
prodigies perform. Awkward at the threshold of adolescence,
embarrassed in the presence of their families, the fidgeting stu­
dents count the minutes, each waiting in terror for his turn to
come. Most awkward of all is the star pianist, a shy boy with
tousled hair and wrinkled clothes whose performance is to be
the highlight of the evening.
His instructor has picked a particularly difficult piece, ea­
ger to show off his pupil's rapidly developing abilities-not to
mention his own coaching. Nobody has asked the youth what he
would like to play-no one has asked him anything of the sort
since his mother signed him up for his first lessons: they take
it for granted that he knows his responsibilities as frontrun­
ner of a new generation of musicians. For his part, he wants so
desperately to please them that he has not thought to consider
the question either.
The girl before him is playing her violin solo, and he can't
stop his hands from shaking. What if he misses a note, what if
his fingers knot and stumble? There is a minefield in the middle
of the composition, a series of difficult chords practically right
on top of each other. He would give anything to be on the other
side of the next twenty minutes, to have this behind him.
The girl ruefully bows to polite applause, and he takes his
place on the piano bench. The hush now in the air is not eti­
quette alone; all eyes are on him, all ears alert. He opens the
sheet music to the proper page, positions his hands above the
keys, and begins.
The music that pours forth is elegant and precise. Mothers
fold their hands and smile; fathers nod approvingly, silently re­
proaching their own offspring for failing to apply themselves.
Even the instructor looks pleased with himself.
The minefield looms closer and closer; now the boy is in
the thick of it, sailing through like a true maestro; and now it
is behind him! There remains only the final stretch of the song,
a victory march of sorts, a real walk in the park.
t
\
,

I
i
!
I
I


- ----

Failure. 199
------

I
But suddenly, inexplicably, he hits a wrong note. Just one­
but that's not all: far, far worse, contrary to everything he has

I
I ,I,
been painstakingly taught about concert performance, he stops
r Ii
cold, freezes.
I II
There is nothing for it: he goes back, takes up the piece again
'!
from the beginning of the phrase, playing forward with all the
grace and finesse he had been as if nothing has happened-and
hits the same wrong note. This has never happened in this piece
before, or any piece he has played in years. In shock and disbelief,
he breaks off again, then inwardly kicks himself for doing so.
His face burning, he backs up and begins once more-and,
once more, hits the note, freezing as if jolted by electricity. In
the total stillness of the ensuing instant, he becomes aware of
the others in the room-not just the monolithic pressure of
their expectations, but their presence as individuals. They too
I
(.
are uncomfortable-they need him to get through this to rescue
i
G\
both the evening and their pride, to protect their faith in the
investments they have made. It is up to him to save everybody
from the impending catastrophe, to fight his way to the end of
the composition and then go home to hide his face forever.

He hits the wrong note again. At this moment he would be
"
'I
grateful if a bolt of lightning struck him down, or he suddenly died
of a heart attack. Everything he has built his young life upon-his
prospects as a musician, his attempts to do what is expected of
him-is in shambles. Faced with the unendurable, the boy must
either perish or change. No bolt of lightning strikes; his heart goes
on beating in his chest.
Once again he backtracks and plays up to the note again­
but this time when he reaches it, he plays it wrong deliberately,
blasting through all his deepest fears and values to redefine the
meaning of the previous sour notes. The audience is none the
wiser-they are too overwhelmed, mortified at having to witness
this fiasco. Every father in the room is on the edge of his seat,
every mother holds her breath; they would give anything to be
elsewhere, to be spared this. Every note the boy plays wrong,
every successive time he tries and fails, it is as if that failure re­



200 . Failure
-

, fleeted upon all of them, upon all humanity. Mediocrity they
, can stomach, even the professional musicians in the audience;

I outright failure is a contagion they fear worse than death, a
I harbinger of utter breakdown.
I He botches the part again-and again. The dynamic is re-
I versed, now: all the pressure that bore down upon the boy, the
I weight of the expectations of parents and teachers and students
I and by extension the whole civilization they represent, is turned
upon them. The boy is in total control, free for the first time in
his life, and they are helpless, paralyzed in a situation for which
I
!I nothing has prepared them. The tension is absolutely unendur­
able. There is a nervous laugh, coughing, helpless fidgeting. The
recalcitrant note sounds again and again, like a skipping record,
like a fire alarm.
I I A few feet from the stage, the violinist's eyes light up: she
understands. She turns and looks back at the anguished faces
et \-.! " behind her: it is truly a vision of damned souls in hell. Peering
, , around the room, she catches the eyes of another young girl a
I few tables away-they are shining like hers. The two nod to
\ each other, grinning from ear to ear.
l
,
..

Failure. 201
Defeat, the Greatest of Feats
True failure, tragic and heartbreaking as it is, is proof that you've
Failure
Sorry, you are not a winner.
Failure is disaster on an individual scale. Suffered consciously, it '
makes everything painfully intense, bringing meaningful and mean­
ingless into sharp focus; faced with courage, it becomes a fortifying
draft, a powerful teacher; embraced, it can even become a channel .
from one destiny to another-and in a civilization which is itself a
colossal failure, we desperately need such channels. Feared, denied,
or stigmatized, however, it becomes a monstrous enemy and master. '.
In our success-obsessed society, where our horror of failure enables.
it to rule over us in disguise, we have a lot to learn from failure it­
self, and the ones we call failures.
202 . Failure
reached beyondyourself, that you are pushing at your own limits and
the limits of the world. The one who fails in the course of really try­
ing needn't fear she is failing to live life to the fullest. Heroic failure
is greatness that does not depend on success or approval-not just
greatness, but inalienable greatness, the greatest greatness of all.
Here we are speaking of good old-fashioned failure, such as can
be experienced by those trying hard to achieve something worth­
while: in failing to achieve their goals, they achieve something even
more valuable, the experience of giving all. But there are other ways
to define failure. Failure is relative, according to the standards by
which one judges success: and woe to him who does not judge for
himself what is success and what is failure, but unquestioningly
receives his standards from others.
We'd thought we'd had it tough before, but the years after the as­
sault on the wall taught us new meanings of the word struggle. At
times, as everything collapsed, I had the distinct sensation of vertigo.
Every nadir we reached, a new depth opened beneath us.
Once we no longer thought of ourselves as fighting a winning
battle against capitalism, there was nothing to stop us from turning
all our frustration on each other. All our collectives and networks
broke down in bitter recriminations. The workers were to blame
for only being interested in their own needs; the activists were to
blame for not organizing with the workers; the students were to
blame for being too privileged to commit to real struggle; fuckups
like me were to blame for scaring people off with our criminal ac­
tivity and violent tactics; men and white folks and straight people
were to blame for alienating our more oppressed allies. Sure, it was
all true, but bickering about it got us nowhere.
Some insisted that we weren't self-sacrificing enough, that our
revolution never got off the ground because we were just fighting
for ourselves rather than the truly oppressed. I didn't agree; in my
version of the story, our resistance had begun when Kate linked
her personal struggle for liberation to the more abstract activism of
the students, and foundered from the moment we started choosing
abstract battles ourselves. As far as I was concerned, hitching our
Failure / Crash and Burn. 203
desire for a radically different life to the cart of service-oriented ac­
tivism was like killing the goose that laid the golden eggs. I did my
grocery distribution for the same reasons I stole food for myself-I
wanted everyone to have enough to eat, regardless of the laws or the
economy. There was no way I was going to take marching orders
from some professional activist or union rep who claimed to speak
for the people I'd grown up with, worked with, and fought beside.
Others, mostly delinquents like myself, pushed for the remnants
of our network to escalate to guerrilla warfare, but I knew where
that would lead-I still remembered what had happened to our
friends who had split off to pursue criminal careers back before
we were politicized. Our momentum had been contagious because
we were acting openly and others could join in; isolating ourselves
in clandestine cells would guarantee we wouldn't be followed by
another generation.
As it became clear the world wasn't changing for the better, ev­
eryone vanished, even the ones I'd met at the encampment. Most of
them returned to what they knew: dropouts went back to school,
travelers drifted to more exciting towns, the employees who had
been most active had lost their jobs and gotten hired elsewhere.
For all I knew, Samia was getting a PhD somewhere and Pablo was
seeking publishers for his inevitable book. I imagined her getting
tenure for her edgy essays about the actions that sent my friends
to prison, and him eating from a deli tray at a book signing while I
waited to salvage the scraps. Maybe their texts would offer astute
insights on our failure to mobilize the working class or establish
enduring
All that was left for my crowd after things died down was petty
crime-we still had to survive somehow-and drinking. The drink­
ing was a real problem; it expanded to fill every vacuum that opened.
"Which do you think will fail first-capitalism, or my liver?" I al­
ready had serious problems maintaining my mental health, so I
didn't start again; but not drinking distanced me from my remain­
ing companions, who took it as a comment on their choices that I
didn't join in.
If nothing else remained of the old days, there were still bills com­
ing due. I'd been lucky enough the times I'd been arrested not to be
recognized for the more serious things I'd been involved in, but Diego
was not so lucky. The legal aid collective was on its last legs by then,
204 . Crash and Burn
and they declined to help because the action he was being charged
for had been controversial and that mobilization was long over. I
remember going to see his grandmother to tell her that her son was
being held for fifty thousand dollars bail and we couldn't raise half of
it; it was painful to realize how bad my Spanish still was, how little
work I'd put into it over the years. Nothing feels worse than calling
around to friends and then acquaintances after something like that,
waking them up one by one, trying to find somewhere to sleep on the
couch. The worst of it was I had to borrow her phone.
All the while, the world was falling in around our ears-but
regular folks were taking the brunt of it, not the ones who set that
destruction in motion. Terrorists were blowing up public transpor­
tation, prisons were overflowing, deserts were spreading across con­
tinents, storms generated by industrial pollution were decimating
entire cities. One night the news showed white vigilantes forcing
refugees back at gunpoint into a ruined neighborhood awash in
toxic chemicals. We should have been there in our affinity groups,
backing the racists down with guns of our own, helping coordinate
evacuation on the survivors' terms. It was all our side could do to
get together some relief efforts alongside the Red Cross.
On top of everything else, my relationship with Kate was on the
rocks. It was an old, sad, typical story-the passionate lovers who
try and fail to sustain their romance in a world fatal to romance. We
didn't live together anymore; I'd visit her at the shed she stayed in
behind a collective house on the other side of town, and we'd argue
without saying a word. As everything crashed and burned, I swore
myself again and again to that old impossible dream: that we'd make
a world of magic in which the magic of love, too, could survive.
Failure as Exercise, Success as Obstacle
Let's look at failure in a vacuum, if such a thing is possible, to see
what secrets it holds for us.
If you want to subject yourself to a real test of mettle, try fail­
ing. Struggling to succeed can be demanding, but failure is trying
like nothing else. Attempt an impossible task everyone around you
considers senseless and stupid-you'll be surprised at what a chal­
lenge it is to exist in exile from the world in which people can make
sense of your actions. Commit yourself to a project you know to
Crash and Burn / Failure . .i05
be beyond your powers; note how hard it is to bear your own hurt
pride when things go awry, even if you knew from the start they
were bound to.
Failing that, start out small: make a habit of telling jokes that
fall so flat people flee your company, announce in a public square
that you are a juggler of great expertise and then try to juggle for
the very first time before the crowd that gathers. Even frivolous ex­
ercises like these, which sound like mere child's play on paper, can
be excruciating in practice. This seems senseless-failing should not
be difficult, unless one is invested in success. That it is so hard for
most of us to fail even in meaningless ways reveals how much we
covet success for its own sake. Being able to fail fearlessly before
others is one of the hardest skills to master; being able to fail before
yourself without shame is harder still.
But readiness to fail is a prerequisite for being able to do anything
great. Pride, self-consciousness, insecurity, cowardice, the qualities
which demand triumph after triumph and nothing else-these are
the same qualities that impede the total freedom of action needed to
achieve any genuine triumph. Artists, for example, must be prepared
to abandon everything they have learned and begin failing again, and
to repeat this process over and over, if they are to evade stagnation.
Fearing to fail, one cannot accomplish anything-not even failure.
Too much success makes you weak, anyway. As a success, how
can you know how you stand up under the ultimate duress of disas­
ter, or for that matter what your motivations are in the first place?
Failure, for the one who needs to think of himself as successful, is
truly an enemy to be feared. But a person experienced in misfor­
tune and disappointment is less likely to be unnaturally afraid of
failing; if she has not yet given up, she is stronger and knows both
life and herself better than the protagonist of any success story. Fail
once, and it feels like the end of the world; live through the end of
the world a few times, and you'll learn how much more durable
you are than it is.
Some of us have spent years, lifetimes, whole generations in failure
and disappointment. We know exactly how much poverty, humilia­
tion, suffering we can take-we're well versed in these things, we've
been getting plenty of practice. We're not easily intimidated-we
have nothing to lose. We persist with a patience that is inconceiv­
able to celebrities, star athletes, spelling bee winners. Just as the
'<06. Failure
homeless man who greets the dawn with his will to live intact after
walking around all night to keep from freezing to death is tougher
than the most high-powered corporate financial officer, we failures
are better equipped than any other class to take the risks one must
take to work miracles.
There is an ominous side to opening yourself up to miracles rarely ac­
knowledged by those who celebrate them. Once you leave the beaten
track and anything is possible, the world can indeed bestow won­
drous gifts upon you; but if things can occur that are miraculously
good, things can also befall you that are supernaturally awful.
I reflected on this as I arranged my shoes under my sleeping bag
so the cold metal roof wouldn't be too uncomfortable against my
knees. I lay down and looked up past the radio antennas, the spew­
ing smokestacks, and the ringing police sirens that designated that
neighborhood occupied territory. The moon hung overhead, an inex­
tinguishable golden lamp. I'd forgotten there was anything beyond
the frontiers of the nightmare around me. The yellow disc blurred;
I blinked and tears poured down my temples.
When you're totally disenfranchised, your fantasies veer to the
extreme opposite your daily experience: so it was that I developed
a rich inner life that winter. In utter deprivation and disappoint­
ment, I could easily imagine all the empty buildings around me as
social centers with free childcare and drug treatment programs, all
the empty lots as community gardens in full bloom, all the strangers
who hurried past me with downcast eyes as neighbors with whom
I shared camaraderie and good cheer. Diego would walk free in the
sunlight again, my mother would be treated for her back problems,
and the three of us would meet for dinner at a dining hall in the foyer
of a converted mansion. The folks from the encampment would be
there, even the ones who had gone to prison or become economists
or committed suicide, and afterwards we'd all line up to wash our
own dishes. It was just psychological compensation, a last-ditch de­
fense against despair; but if so much suffering and misery was pos­
sible, god damn it, how much joy must be possible too!
Whether or not any of that ever came to pass, I was satisfied that
I'd made the right choice staking everything on our fight. I was hap­
pier freezing to death alone than I would have been as employee of
the month, even if they'd given me a restaurant of my very own.
Failure / Crash and Burn. '<07
Success as Failure, t'ClIIUI v ....__
In this world turned upside down, in which misery masquerades as
happiness and truth is simply falsehood with powerful friends, the
right kind of failure can protect you from the most insidious dan­
ger of all-capital-S Success. It is important to know which battles
not to win, what callings not to excel in; some victories are more
humiliating than any defeats, some fiascos are triumphs in disguise.
The miserable waitress who is promoted to manager and stays at
the restaurant long after she had planned to quit might have been
better off getting fired, after all, just as the Russian working class
could have given themselves a better shot at liberation by losing the
revolution of 1917; likewise, it was for the best that Allen Ginsberg
didn't make a well adjusted stockbroker.
This kind of failure is a blessing in disguise. Even when suffered
by one who desires so-called success, it can be an antechamber of
transformation, a sort of cocoon. In failing at an enterprise of ques­
tionable value, the individual's condition and activity already diverge
from the norms set out for him; it only remains for his values and
standards to cross that fissure and join him on the other side. When
this happens, he can redefine success and failure for himself, so he
will not be so busy succeeding that his hands are tied when he has
the chance to try them at something that really matters.
Fighting a losing battle against the capitalist system gave me a deeper
respect for my fellow losers. All our lives we'd heard that the work­
ing class was composed of failures who hadn't tried hard enough or
hadn't gotten enough education or, at best, hadn't been given a fair
shot. The implication was that everyone would choose to be suc­
cessful and middle class, if only they had the chance.
On the contrary, many of us had willfully chosen not to play the
game, whatever the consequences. The wrecked black neighborhood I
visited on mygrocery distribution route was still suffering the aftermath
of the Black Panthers' heroic defeat; in retaliation, the forces of white
supremacy had arranged for landlords, drug dealers, and arsonists to
ravage it, then hacked it in half with a freeway. In the trailer parks I'd
played in as a kid, middle-aged women wore skimpy clothes fashioned
for emaciated models, brazenly flaunting bodies the corporate media
deemed more obscene than pornography; in retrospect, I saw them a'
heroes in the struggle against patriarchal beauty norms. The hom; ,
less were supposed to be the ultimate examples of failure, but once 1', 0
spent enough time among them I learned that some of them were 0 .
the streets by choice-as I was myself. They were heroes too: no homes
less person ever produced enough chlorofluorocarbons to damage
ozone layer or evicted anyone's grandmother from her home.
Once I'd despised these people, swearing I would escape their fates!
at all costs; now I saw them as comrades who refused to disgrace them-'
selves for worthless prizes. The shiftless hoboes and migrant workers
who'd seen half the world without ever looking at a travel brochursj
the minimum-wage employees who never wanted to be anyone's b o S S i ~
the workers at the cash registers with cameras pointed at them from!:
all sides-theywere no less worthy than the big-name anarchists who'
had beaten back imperial armies and escaped maximum security pris­
ons only to die of tuberculosis and alcoholism. We were all glorious.
failures; it only remained to us to triumph at long last.
Success as Impossibility, Failure as Besistance]
~
It is ironic enough that so many dedicate their lives to succeeding!
at projects that fail to fulfill their dreams; it is more ironic still that
it is practically impossible to succeed at these projects in the first.
place. Still worse is that, living in fearful denial of this failure, most
people are not even able to learn from it.
Ours is a civilization of losers. Faced with the impossible ideals of "
beauty and perfection set for us, we fail without fail. This is an open
secret, the open secret of our era: no one, but no one, is a winner. The
harder we work to measure up to these standards, the faster they recede
before us. That's why models are more insecure about their bodies than
we are about ours, why millionaires read books about how to be more
efficient. If you're so successful, what's with the antidepressants?
Even a superstar like Madonna, who presumably represents the ,
pinnacle of status in our society, has in common with all of us that she
is not actually Madonna, not the two-dimensional caricature of success
and sex appeal that saturates the airwaves. At the endof the day, lines
on her face and doubt in her gut, she too turns on the television and
feels her heart drop at seeing that flawless goddess cavorting through
a digital paradise. In fact, she is worse off than the rest of us: for not
only is she not Madonna, but she is also nothing else besides.
.210. Crash and Burn / Failure
Face it-you're never going to look like the models in the maga­
zines, no matter how much skin cream and lip gloss you apply. Hell,
without airbrushing, even they don't look like that! Once you embrace
this failure, you'll be free to excel at becoming something else.
A new revolutionary class, the proletariat of failures, could count
even members of the ruling class in its ranks, were they able to own
up to the hard truth that they are no more like the satisfied, svelte
executives in Wall Street Journal commercials than we are like the
brainless, well-adjusted working families next door on Channel
11. Having sought and failed to find happiness according to their
prescriptions, having sincerely given it our best shot, we all have
something at stake in making it possible to live differently. All that
is needed is for us to come out of the closet, to come to terms with
what we are and begin to fail at these roles deliberately, to explore
the forbidden territory we already occupy.
Of course, there are safeguards in place to discourage us from doing
this. In this civilization, failure is the ultimate abomination. Obscenity,
drug use, sexual and religious heresy, these may become acceptable­
but in our hierarchical society, failure itself will always be anathema.
Under capitalism, failure to compete is punished by the severest mea­
sures: for if people are to keep on capitulating, non-participation must
look utterly undesirable, must be associated with the worst dregs of so­
ciety and the most unendurable tribulations. The homeless and chroni­
cally unemployed playas fundamental a role inour economy as bosses
and bureaucrats do: they teach us to equate life off the treadmill with
alcoholism and mental illness, they are visual cues reminding us that
annihilation is the only alternative to wage slavery. But this intimida­
tion tactic can only succeed so long as the unemployed cooperate by
accepting their misery and the miserable cooperate by accepting em­
ployment. As soon as a new class of self-proclaimed failures appears,
visibly finding happiness by rejecting both options and making a joy­
ous catastrophe of their lives, the jig will be up.
Pride would hold us forever in no-win situations, insisting we
are happy and everything is going according to plan, struggling to
prove we are "good enough" to make them work somehow. This is
not even tragedy-it's just foolishness. We're good enough to deserve
to be happy, for once, whether that be called winning or losing.
Enough of being successful failures-let us finally succeed in
our failure!
Failure . .211
When Samia reappeared that spring, I sought her out and askei!
,
,J.
IJ
\
I
, "
II
her to set some time aside to talk. My period of exile had given
new powers of humility: I was going to apologize for the way
last meeting had gone. Whether or not she felt she had anything
apologize for, whether or not she was still invested in
struggle, I had nothing to lose by taking responsibility for my own;"
unconstructive bullheadedness.;:'
It turned out she'd just returned from working in the very
borhood I'd seen on television the previous fall; she hadn't gone back!
to graduate school after all. Her skin was rough and already a rich'
brown in early March, and her eyes flashed with a light I hadn't seen'
in a long time. I felt a pang of envy that grew bitter as I recalled ourJ
first meetings. At the same time, it was interesting that she was stilt:,
involved in things; maybe I'd been wrong assuming everyone like.;!
her had disappeared into retirement.
Grimly, my eyes fixed on the leaves in front of our park benchj
,
I went over every time I felt I'd been insensitive, overbearing,
arrogant in the years we'd known each other. She heard me out
tiently, with a lightness in her bearing that contrasted sharply with::
my condemned man's slouch.'"
"Thank you for telling me all this. I really don't know what to:"
say."
I shrugged. "Don't say anything, I guess. Just know I've been;:;
thinking about this stuff. I wanted it all to end differently, and 1"
understand how I contributed to it not working out."
She was silent for a minute. "You know, I respect a lot that you're;)'
still here keeping the same projects going. What Diego said was true,';;1
really-we basically went off and abandoned you."
Now I was silent. She shifted her legs and went on.
"The ironic thing is I'd come back determined to get involved',"
again just before that meeting, but after that it was hard to want to
stay and I got swept up in the next thing I heard about out of
Who knows if I would have stuck around, really-maybe that fight ,:
just gave me the excuse I wanted. It's so intimidating to commit to
rooting yourself in one place instead of following the battle lines:",
to wherever it seems we have a chance of winning."
"Maybe staying wouldn't have been the right thing for you-I
feel like we've totally failed here. At least you seem to have kept';
some sparks alive." I met her eyes for the first time since I'd started "
214, Crash and Burn
talking, then looked away. "I have too much here to leave. This is
my home. I can't be running around Europe while people here go
hungry and my friends rot in prison."
"You shouldn't say you've failed." She was looking at me intently
now; my eyes were back on the leaves. "You're still here. It's a vic­
tory any of us are even alive, let alone free to sit here talking, after
some of the things we've been through."
"The only victory I give a damn about is making sure everyone
has what they need-that and burning those prisons to the ground.
You know that."
"OK, look at it this way: to fail, you have to be totally committed
to something, to desire it with all your heart-to believe that life
will be unlivable if it doesn't come true. Everyone has things they
want that badly, what they call impossible desires-they just don't
pursue them because it would hurt too much if they never caught
up to them. I think most people don't even acknowledge what they
really want to themselves, they're so scared of not getting it. You've
failed: that's a real achievement."
Certain Failure Imposed by Fear of Failure
If a person's dearest dreams can come true, then real failure, too, is
possible. As failure is the most feared of misfortunes, being respon­
sible for pursuing and perhaps failing to achieve precious dreams
is everyone's ultimate terror. On the other hand, if the realization
of such dreams is impossible, then we are free of this terrible re­
sponsibility: many people find it easier to endure the idea that ev­
erything they want is impossible than to face down the terror of
being responsible for attaining it. And once they decide that what
they really want is impossible, from that moment on they are in­
vested in that being the truth-otherwise they are fools who have
thrown away their lives for nothing. They may even work, subcon­
sciously, to prevent their dreams from coming true, to prevent the
things they long for from becoming possible. Imagine that, a planet
of six billion people working around the clock to push what they
Want out of reach! It must require that much work-what most of
us want is not really all that difficult or complex. It takes a Disaster
of billions to hold us back!
Crash and Burn / Failure. 215
Dusk was falling and it was getting chilly, but our conversation c .
tinued meandering from topic to topic. Finally, we returned to
meeting. There was something still I needed to say about it.
"You know we did try to work with everyone else, don't y'
There was a big spokescouncil meeting before you got there, o'
a hundred representatives from different groups-mostly NG
people like that, since our folks hadn't made it to town yet or WI
busy with other things. I was washing the dishes in the
center-Diego was there for us, and anyway I trusted that they".
make decisions that would work for everyone. I couldn't fucki '
believe it when I heard they'd resolved over all objections to d,
nounce direct action and organize a march to lead people awa,'
from the wall."
"Honestly, I had no idea at the time-I'd just gotten there. I wa4
spouting off, I was used to other people already having put thi "
together before I showed up. I only found out about the spokescoua
cil afterwards. I felt dumb, but by then the die was cast, and I w •
angrier about how you'd handled yourselves-it was closer to
because I'd trusted you more than I'd ever trusted those liberals."
"Those fucking authoritarians!" Thinking about the spokescoun-j
cil m'ade me furious all over again. "The ironic thing is those are thee
same motherfuckers that want to know who would collect the gar- ',
bage when you talk about an anarchist society. We take out their
fucking garbage right now! They're just afraid of having to get their
hands dirty. They think this system works great because they never
have to get close to their own trash-while some of us have to live
next to it, or off it!"
Samia cut back in. "We had to deal with those people this past
winter-we didn't have our own media team, so they were able to
take credit for everything we did. We were all there as volunteers
while they were there on salary, and they kept trying to give us or­
ders! Half their work went into getting donations from people who
really wanted to help-but those donations paid for advertisements
on the backs of fucking pizza boxes all around the country, while
the people they were supposed to be helping were crammed into
trailers or staying with their families in other cities!"
"Yeah, I've seen those pizza boxes. What a scam-our tragedies
pay their salaries."
216. Crash and Burn
"It's ironic that those people criticize direct action on the grounds
that only privileged white people can participate, and then when
people of color take direct action they write it off as apolitical
criminal activity-calling it looting, for example. Not all of us have
the option of limiting ourselves to legal means! I'm so fed up with
white activists saying militant tactics are only for young white
males when people like me are clearly involved as well. Talk about
paternalism-my existence is so inconvenient for them they won't
even acknowledge me! If they did, would they have to say out loud
that they think I'm mistaken about what's best for me?"
"They might as well be honest and admit direct action is alienat­
ing to them, as middle class organizers who don't want to lose their
legitimacy."
"But look-why didn't we just bypass the spokescouncil and
reach out to people directly? Before, when we were doing things
around here, we always went straight to people in a bunch of dif­
ferent communities, not just the kids in black. I know there were
security issues, but we could have organized openly with others and
privately among ourselves."
"We got outmaneuvered, I guess. Once those leeches figured out
how much momentum we had, they all latched onto us. Every party
was there recruiting at every meeting, all the old has-beens came out
of retirement to try to hijack everything. They set up front groups
and coalitions camouflaged to look just like us so they could absorb
everyone who wanted to get involved, they-"
"I remember all that. But if we'd done the work-"
"Of course, sure, but you said yourself"-I slowed down and
tried to speak more softly, the way Kate would have-"you didn't
show up ready to do that, either. We were exhausted, we'd already
been through so much just to get to that point." We both paused,
withdrawing into private recollections. "The real question is why
so many people who say they want what we want back out when it
counts. It's like you were saying before about failure-I think we
only failed because no one could imagine us winning. All the people
who joined the spokescouncil and went along with it even when it
turned against them-they were used to defeat, to accepting that
everything they wanted was impossible; they didn't know how to
do anything else, just like we didn't know how to stop fighting even
when we were the only ones on the battlefield."
Crash and Burn. 217
"Like the black uniform all the new kids wear, as if they're at
a funeral-it's practically a glorification of failure, an admission
that the most we can do is refuse to participate and be destroyed. I
That's the opposite of really trying and failing-it's a farce, not a ;,
tragedy."
"And all the groups that say they want radical changes but al­
ways try to stop anyone who tries to make them, I think they do
that because they don't want to win, because they're invested in
failing. They don't dare risk what they have, so for them it's never i:
the right time to act, there's always more preparation to be done. So
long as they keep their roles as conscientious objectors, so long as
their hands are clean, they don't care what happens to the rest of us,
they don't care if people have to sleep on rooftops and rainforests
are turned into pulp and cities are bombed into dust."
Beyond Success and Failure
Here's an exercise, then, for the impetuous freedom fighter:
fail at the duties you are most afraid to, and struggle with all your
heart to succeed at the challenges you never dared undertake. What
doesn't kill you can only make you stronger, whether it be the mor­
tification of not being able to explain to your parents what you're
doing with your life or the utter heartbreak of giving everything to
follow a dream only to see it burn to ashes.
Such a practice sharpens and strengthens, but it also can
reveal just how arbitrary most of our deep-seated values are. Ulti­
mately, liberation is not a question of succeeding or failing, but of
moving beyond such binary ways of thinking. Our pathological fear
of failure exists only by virtue of our superstitions about success; to
emancipate ourselves from the former, we must forgive ourselves ,<:
enough to stop pining for the latter. The mystique of victory gives
rise to the fiction of defeat.
To be free of internal as well as external pressures to achieve, I
to cease to judge oneself by one-dimensional yardsticks of value or
success, to be able to do and live anything and appreciate it for what
it is, itself, without imposing systems of evaluation-wouldn't that
be a triumph sweeter than any victory?
Perhaps our fear of failure is a symptom of our inability to release
ourselves to the present. To be capable of anything-even failure,
:1.18. Crash and Burn / Failure
and thus even success-one must be able to give oneself entirely to
the doing, neither fearing the future nor judging by its standards.
To fail and overcome that failure is to grow; this is one of the ways
we come to know each other and ourselves. Setting out to fail-not
by attempting too little, so one succeeds in not succeeding, but by
attempting so much that one can only fail gloriously-could be a
way to re-center one's life around action, not consequences.
That is to say:
around courage,
not fear.
Around the present,
not the future
or past.
Around destruction
and creation,
not stasis.
Failure. :1.19
o hours later, we were still on the bench, huddled together for
armth in the cold night air. Samia was recounting a story from her
.ildhood. I could picture everything she described vividly, though
childhood had never included recitals or summer camps or
" .ything like them.
I felt giddy. To be able to speak with someone about these things
,gain without all the tension and resentment that had become so
was a relief, a kind of absolution. At the same time,
';1 had the sinking feeling that my giddiness was a warning sign: I
. 'anted desperately to make things work with Kate, and the last
·thing I needed was complications with someone else. But inching
,,'a little closer as we spoke, just because it was so chilly and we'd fi­
l nally talked out a conflict that had stood between us for years-by
t', itself, that couldn't be a problem. It felt good; could it really be a
I
, crime to want to feel good again for once, just for a minute, in such
/ a harmless way?
,I,
, " ... so we can't be afraid to desire or believe in outrageous things,
We have to give ourselves to them without fear of loss, or regret,
or disappointment." She seized my hand between hers and looked
right into my eyes. "Would you like to kiss me?"
I swallowed hard and hesitated, then nodded. So much for sorting
out the consequences of my old mistakes; now I had new troubles
to deal with.
Crash and Burn. 221
Adultery
(and other half revolutions)
If the two-party relationship system is the pinnacle achievement of
a hundred thousand years of human loving, why is adultery so com­
mon that it forms the most reliable material for bourgeois draw­
ing room humor-not to mention employment for a whole army
of marriage counselors? If all any of us truly desire is our one true
love, why can't we keep our hands off everyone else?
If you really want to know, you should cut straight to the source
and ask the adulterers themselves. Or maybe you don't have to go
that far-maybe you've had adulterous affairs or inclinations of your
own, as the statistics suggest.
, Adultery
Good Marriages Take Work
Growing up in an environment dominated by capitalist economics
teaches certain psychological lessons that are hard to unlearn: Any­
thing of value is only available in limited supplies. Stake your claim now,
before you're left alone with nothing. Unable to imagine that love and
pleasure could multiply when shared, we come to measure commit­
ment and affection by how much others sacrifice for us. An outsider
might counter that in a healthy relationship, friends or lovers enable
each other to be able to do and live and feel more, If you feel, in your
, gut if not your head, that having a romantic partner means giving
something up-your "freedom," as they say-then the patterns of
exploitation and control have penetrated even into your love life.
We all know that Good Marriages Take Work. There it is again,
;' work: the cornerstone of our society. Wage labor, relationship labor­
;'! are you ever not on the clock? Do you accept stifling limitations in
return for affection and reassurance the same way you trade time for
money at your job? When you have to work at monogamy, you are
:' back in the exchange system: just like the capitalist economy, your
"; intimacy is governed by scarcity, threats, and programmed prohibi­
( tions, and protected ideologically by assurances that there are no
I
, viable alternatives. When relationships become work, when desire
. is organized contractually with accounts kept and fidelity extract­
;: ed like labor from employees, when marriage is a domestic factory
'.: policed by rigid shop-floor discipline designed to keep wives and
'. husbands chained to the machinery of responsible reproduction­
; then it should come as no surprise that some individuals cannot
help but revolt.
Adultery, in stark contrast to the Good Marriage, comes naturally,
, arriving without even being invited. Suddenlyyou feel transformed,
. awakened from the graveyard of once-vital passion that your part­
: nership has become to feel that excitement again. You shouldn't be
any of this, damn it, and yet it's the first time you've been
"i'carried away by pure, unforced happiness in who knows how long­
;':andoh, the sweet optimism of something new, something that isn't
'yet fucking predictable ... it's as if surprise, risk, gratification, and
fulfillment were again genuinely imaginable possibilities. Who, if
':they could feel what you're feeling right now, could possibly de­
,IIland you resist?
Adultery ,
Stolen Moments
The adulterer gets a crash course in the extent to which his space
and time is controlled. It immediately becomes clear how little time
he possesseswhen he is not underobservation-it turns out that the
workday does not end when he leaves the workplace, but extends
before and after it, consuming practically his entire life. The domi­
nation of the space around him is revealed, as well: how many places
are there for him to spend time with his new lover, places he need not
rent with money, respectable explanations, and the image of social
propriety? In what few moments of his life is he not held to guide­
lines imposed by outside forces, guidelines which plainly no longer
have anything to do with his emotional and physical needs?
The adulterer becomes a virtuoso of petty theft, stealing the mo­
ments of his life one by one from their rightful owners: his spouse, his
employer, his family and social obligations. Just like the vandal, he resists
the domination of his world in the only way he knows how-by tiny,
symbolic acts of daily sedition, out of which he carefully constructs an
infinitelyfragile alternate universe. There he hides, in spirit when he can­
not in body, hoping not to be found out and called to account for what
he has become: a traitor to the entire civilization that raised him.
"Honesty isthe Best Policy"
Society, personified by her unfortunate spouse, demands that the
adulterer be honest and frank about all things when it will only
punish her for this. It attempts to secure her compliance through
routine interrogations ("who was that on the phone, dear?,,), sur­
veillance ("do you think I didn't notice how much time you spent
talking to him?"), search and seizure ("and just what the hell am I
supposed to think this is?"), and more serious intimidation tactics:
the threat of total expulsion from the only home and community
she likely knows. The adulterer who would like to tell the truth is
forced to compute whether she really can permit herself this luxury:
divideyour currentunhappiness by theharmful consequences of admitting
it, multiply by your fear of the unknown, then think twice about whether
you reallyneedtosay anything after all. This is the same formula used
by exploited migrant workers and children locked in private school
hells, by battered wives and sexually harassed secretaries.
224 ' Adultery
'.
,
'.
What our society is missing here is the wisdom to know that tell­
the truth is not just the responsibility of the teller. If you really
.t to know the truth, you must make it easy for people to tell it
• you: you must be genuinely supportive and ready for whatever it
, Iybe, not just make self-righteous demands or play good coplbad
; 'pnust tell me, I promise I'll understand ... you did WHAT?!,,).
.t can only lead to evasive action, or else to the subject of your
55-examination finding ways to lie to herself as well as to you.
ither our society nor, consequently, its cuckolds are ready for the
'elation of truth that the adulterer has to offer; it is only safe in
,e sheltering ears of her illicit lover.
eople Will Get Hurt"
itably, despite the best intentions and most secretive schemes
the adulterer, people get hurt. More to the point, people already
re hurting, only invisibly, in the enforced happily-ever-after of
mestic silence-or else such drastic measures would not have
necessary in the first place to bring dead hearts to life. Would
':have been better for the routines and illusions of the marriage to
ain undisturbed forever, to stay the course in mutual ennui to
embittered end? Could it be preferable for your unsuspecting
ner to go on measuring her value as a lover and spouse accord­
to a standard of fidelity that boils down to self-denial, a stan­
d which has already been violated in spirit if not in letter? Of
urse, instead of cheating you could always have gone to counsel­
stayed faithful to your spouse rather than yourself and turned
'wayfrom the new landscapes you saw about to be born in the eyes
,:.your potential lover, trying instead to achieve a passable substi­
:ewith your officially sanctioned partner-or resorted to dulling
ur senses with television or Prozac, if that failed.
.Tocut to the heart of the matter: can it possibly be wrong to
not to be emotionally dead? What vast measures of self-con­
nee and entitlement would it take the modern married man or
to risk feeling alive, unarmed with the twin weapons of
:"justification and self-abasement, the excuses and apologies and
.,-recriminations? The adulterer discovers that he is trapped in
life he had adopted under the encouragement and threats of the
;"...blished romantic norm-and, despite his best efforts to restrain
Adultery i zz ;
self, has begun plotting an escape. Were he to reflect lucidly on
situation, his secret self might rebel and begin to ask the impor­
t questions: What kind of life does he really aspire to live? How
..uch freedom and fulfillment does he deserve to feel? How has it
me to be that he hurts others just by expressing his own needs?
The fact is, people always get hurt whenever someone contests
e long-entrenched order, and often the victims are "innocent."
. t's why anything less than complete prostration to the status
o is considered bad ethics-standing up for yourself is just too
dangerous for everyone else. But once the itch to mutiny takes
Id, the alternative becomes unthinkable: so the adulterer takes it
,pon himself, often unwillingly but without being able to resist, to
things that can hurt others.
The problem is that he generally does this without admitting it
himself; his situation is untenable, but he does everything to avoid
appling with the reality of it. If he were prepared to embrace and
-oclaim his outlawed desires (rather than ultimately rejecting them
a fit of rueful revisionism: "I didn't knowwhat 1was doing!") and
cept full responsibility for the further pain that would cause, he
would finally be positioned to step out of the circle of hurt that is
e scarcity economy of love. But he lacks the courage and analysis
,r this final act: that is why he is an adulterer.
hat about the Children?"
at about the children?" demand the shocked sentries of the bour­
isie when they hear about yet another marriage endangered by an
air, terrified that their own strayings might come out next. Well,
'hat about them? Do you think you can protect the next generation
m the tragic tension between the complexity of desire and the sim­
icity of social prohibitions just by knuckling under yourself? If you
other your own aspirations for happiness, displacing them instead
to future generations, you will end by smothering your children as
Uasyourself. Yourchildren wouldbe better off growing up inaworld
'here people dare to be honest about what they want, regardless of
i ~ consequences. Would you prefer that they learn to beat their own
·:»ngings into flattened reminders of shame and remorse, as you do?
And it's worth pointing out that nuclear-family monogamy, which
ese self-appointed judges would protect from the assault implied
Adultery. 227
'\ by adultery, is the very thing that replaced the broader, more fluid,
I extended family structures of the past. By all accounts, children
i. were better cared for in those environments, and their parents had
i! more freedom as well. Could it be that adultery is a blind, desperate
lunge from the cage of the contractual relationship towards the ex­
, tended community we once had? More importantly, can it serve as a
stepping-stone towards a new resurgence of that community?
. Faithful to Many
'h
( What would it look like to have relationships in which there was no
: such thing as adultery, or at least no cause for it? First, it would neces­
,I, sitate that communication be prized above obedience to social norms.
\.:The conditions that foster honesty-trust, self-awareness, unconditional
!:love-would have to be safeguarded by extensive support structures.
Communities would be interlinked by networks of close relationships
I' in which everyone could count on assistance from and intimacy with
. others even if one relationship changed. There would be no social or
;legal rewards for any particular relationship format, and no looking
askance at any format either. We would have to grapple with our own
,insecurities rather than attempting to limit others' autonomy. In short,
Iit would demand maturity in the same way monogamy monoculture
rewards childishness-including the childishness of adulterers.
Of course, we don't live in a society that equips us in any of these
(ways, or else you wouldn't have gotten yourself into this predica­
':ment. The question now is how you get yourself out of it: do you
on the path that compelled you to cheat in the first place,
i or try something else?
. And here the ultimate irony awaits: even if you leave your spouse
.for your partner in crime, you will probably find that he expects the
.same kind of relationship you just escaped. When he got involved
lWith you, he knew you were capable of loving more than one per­
';.son at a time, that monogamy imposed impossible choices upon
Iyou-and now he wants to return you to the situation you were in
J
'when he took up with you, with the same pressures and perils. But
it's different with him because he's "the" one, right? Small wonder
,if one day you cheat again.
Adultery. 229
Marriage and Other Affairs of State
It serves the interests of the powers that be to have everyone sepa­
rated into couples and nuclear families, with all unions suitable
licensed and policed. A divided people is a conquerable people; the
fewer the ties connecting individuals and the narrower the range
of permissible associations, the better. When you're attached to
and responsible for only a handful of people, your enemies always
have potential hostages: "But I can't run any risks-who would take
care of Sheila?" On the other hand, when you feel passionately con­
nected with and accountable to an entire community, you're more
likely to conceive of your interests in collective terms-and better
situated to fight for them, too.
Marriage exalts the bond between two people with the-unspoken
implication that it is them against the world-and the stress of this
setup often turns them against each other. But like it or not, we all
have to live on this planet together and bear the consequences of
each others' actions: effectively, we're all married, and it's high time
we start thinking and acting accordingly. Once the false promises of
two-in-a-coffin matrimonial bliss have utterly failed you, is it any
more utopian to fantasize about conceiving of your relationships as
One Big Union? Imagine being close and comfortable with every­
one around you, letting each relationship evolve independently of
other relationships, and-yes-making love with anyone who also
wanted to make love with you without it bringing about the end
of the world as you know it. You can't, can you?
Adultery is Marriage's Loyal Opposition
Ultimately, adultery is only possible because it leaves the questions it
asks unanswered. Just like the shoplifter, the hooligan, and the suicide,
the adulterer makes only half a revolution: she violates the decrees of
authoritarian convention and law, but in such a way that they remain
in place, still dictating her actions-be those actions obedient or reac­
tive. She would do better to expose what she is and wants to the whole
world without guilt or regret and demand that it find a place for her
and her desires, whatever they might be. Then her struggle could be
the starting point for a revolution in human relationships from which
everyone might benefit, not just a flash of isolated passion and insur­
gency to be stomped out before it illuminates anything.
230, Adultery
Adultery. 233
I)
---­
because this truth would destroy us all. I shoulder this crime, dis­
honesty, as a defender of humanity and all things beautiful ...
because there are sides to this truth that are inexpressible, invisible to
outside eyes, and these have become precious to me. Such treasures
are crushed beneath the weight of words, become mere scandal,
wreckage, dust. I love you, but I will not raze my secret cities to
rubbish heaps and shame for you.
to preserve something, anything, of my own, in this impersonal, im­
poverishing world.
-so the alternative is silence. I lie to you because I won't accept
despair, because I am an optimist: I hope to catch the truth by some
miracle or voodoo in my web of lies.
because words lie in my mouth-in any mouth. Words cannot express
anything that matters-
because I am a coward, of course. Or is it because a hidden demon
in me delights in trouble?
,
'Ii

\(
I oj
, I
I
__ ."_c•. _. ,
=/ c c cc __ c.-_­__ ._.-­__ - c

2]2 . Adultery
because I don't know how to communicate this truth to you. Should I
tell it in the words by which I would apprehend it myself, even if
you will interpret them to designate something entirely different?
Or should I tell with words I hope will make you feel the way I
believe you would feel if I could somehow convey it to you word­
lessly and without distortion? Which is honesty? Which is lie?
because I cannot accept the truth-at least not this truth. I delay, des­
perately, wishing each night as I fall asleep that I will somehow
awaken in another world. Each morning I do not, I steel myself
against reality so I might come through another day without ac­
knowledging it-and try my luck once more, more desperately,
that night.
because I fear you, as well as the truth. I am not prepared to confront
it, and neither are you, and you've made that absolutely clear.
I lie to you
I
I

t
(,
!
I :'

,11:1· ...
.",
(!)
'I
I It is absurd to demand unconditional honesty from others
and place the entire responsibility for this upon their shoul­
ders. We tell you exactly those truths you make it possible for
us to tell. What we withhold, we withhold in sorrow as well as
fear-for there is no sweeter bliss than offering yourself hon­
estly to companions who can comprehend and celebrate what
you are. Secrets are sweet-but sharing them, sweeter. If you
would know the truth, strive to be a person with whom no one
need be ashamed of anything, with whom nothing is forbid­
den. Reality, even in the cases of the ones we hold most dear, is
always wider and wilder than anything that could fit our pre­
scriptions. Let's be wide and wild enough ourselves to receive
it with open arms.
l



" Long before I fell in with the barbarians, I'd already learned every­
,,1 thing I know about clandestine activity. Smuggling secret passions
under my parents' radar and then my own lovers' noses prepared me
for researching targets without leaving a trail and sneaking video
. footage through police checkpoints. If I learned anything as a teen­
; ager, it was that the sweetest moments of bliss always came at the
; expense of being able to be honest with those in power.
This served me well in high school when I was sneaking out
the window to meet Linda and much later when I had to think on
my feet in front of a grand jury, but it didn't equip me to be honest
.about my needs when the people "in power" were my own partners.
(My marriage ended in a sordid mess after I fell in love with Chloe;
":when that well ran dry, Chloe and I betrayed each other and moved
,ion to repeat the same cycle with others.
Millions in every generation have to come to terms with their
;propensity for unfaithfulness on their own because no one dares
openly about the issue. There are no honest memoirs unob­
, ured by bravado or shame, no useful family advice is passed down
,n the subject, the phone book lists no harm reduction programs
"or serial cheaters. Yet there are probably more adulterers in North
erica than vegetarians! People will sooner admit to being criminals
,t War with God and Country than engage with the consequences
d implications of their own secret trysts.
234 . Adultery Betrayers and Betrayed. 235
It took decades to acknowledge to myself that I was the one in
power doing harm to those I loved and not the other way'around. I
experienced my lovers' expectations of me as a constraint, but over
and over I participated in setting up the same expectations. To be
fair, I couldn't imagine any other way. I wasn't exposed to polyamory
until after the university occupation; by that time I was old enough
that it felt like I'd never be in a relationship again, and certainly not
with one of those crazy young people. When it comes to romance,
once you reach a certain age you become invisible.
I accepted the isolation of middle age with a mixture of mel­
ancholy and relief. I'd broken off my last affair around the time I
canceled that business trip, joining the legions of single men mari­
nating in bitterness as the world goes on without them. If this was
what it felt like to be a middle-aged man, I could only imagine what
it must be like for women of my generation-but I was separated
from them, too, all of us invisible to one another. Lonely as I felt, at
least I didn't have to worry about breaking any more hearts; I felt
like damaged goods, a disease carrier who could only hurt people
by getting close to them.
What I missed most, it turned out, was not romance or sexbut
rather the intimacy of sharing a private world with someone. That
might explain why I responded so uncharacteristically to Kate's
warmth, why I went to such lengths to involve myself in a movement
that ostensibly had no place for people of my class and career. I loved
the fellowship of eating together, scheming together, charging down
a street together-in my eyes, that togetherness was the really revo­
lutionary aspect of the thing, far and above any window-smashing.
Even people like my former coworkers must long for that kind of
companionship. Their college years in fraternities and sororities are
the closest they ever get and they reminisce about that ridiculous
simulation of community for the rest of their lives.
With local activity at a standstill, though, I spent a lot of time
alone. Now that I'd quit my post at the paper, I barely saw anyone
at all except at the occasional meeting. I was working on a book, at
long last, but it was a guide for radical journalists, not the eyewit­
ness chronicle of insurrection and depravity I'd originally imagined
catapulting me to corporate fame; besides that, I busied myself doing
independent media work and rereading Tolstoy and Melville. I had
some money in savings, enough to put off exploring the job market
236. Betrayers and Betrayed
!
,

.
.
"it
It,
spent it sparingly. Finally, it occurred to me to get involved in
"--.e of the community projects I'd always been too busy to inves­
te. That was how I started seeing Marshall again.
along, even at the lowest ebb, Marshall had kept his gro­
distribution program running with whatever volunteers were
,hand. Union organizers had lost track of the workers who had
involved in the campus strike, as most of them had changed
s over the ensuing years; but Marshall still went through their
every week with a trunk full of bread and vegetables,
cting yet another chilly rebuff, I approached him and offered
services.
I was surprised by his response. He seemed at pains to make me
welcome and appreciated; within a few weeks, I was a regular
icipant, driving to all the stores and washing the produce we
and sometimes accompanying Marshall on his rounds. He
me as sadder now, his brow more furrowed than ever, but
more tolerant and mature. Of course, I'd never really gotten
know him before.
By the time I joined in, he'd gone through several generations of
ployees inside the stores. Each time one quit or was caught, we
to switch back to raiding the dumpsters until we found a new
ide connection; every once in a while a store would exchange its
pster for a trash compactor and we had to rework our whole
'ute. Even our sparsest hauls, however, were enough to feed doz­
of households. I could scarcely believe they'd been doing this
,r years without the authorities catching on; it was even harder
believe that, for years before that, all that food had rotted while
nilies spent their last dollars on ramen noodles.
Between back doors, dumpsters, kitchens, and apartment com­
'llexes,we began making conversation. At first our exchanges were
(uperficial, if painstakingly civil; it took us a long time to open up
other. Once we did, there was a lot to talk about: what our
, utual friends from the occupation were doing, why the move­
ent had died down, how much current technology and production
ould remain in a post-revolutionary world. In the end, Marshall
'en apologized for his previous haughtiness,
One thing that surprised me was how little I saw Kate, It ap­
axed she and Marshall were still involved, at least off and on, but
Ie seemed to be avoiding her the way I had started avoiding my wife
Betrayers and Betrayed, 237
when I didn't want to be defined by our relationship but wasn't ready
to break it off. I still had the highest regard for Kate; I'd initially
hoped that seeing more of Marshall would mean interacting with
her more as well. One night I got a hint of what was going on when
Marshall had me drop him off at a collective house where Samia was
staying; she greeted him with an embrace that was hardly platonic
and he twisted away, clearly uncomfortable about being affection­
ate in front of me. Samia, of all people! I was surprised the two were
even speaking after the last time I'd seen them interact.
I couldn't have been worse situated to bring this up, but I felt I
had a responsibility to. "This isn't my business, and I have no right
to pry," I began the next time we were alone in the car together,
"but does Kate know about you and Samia? You have been seeing
her, haven't you?"
He didn't answer. I glanced over at him; his eyes were fixed on
the glove compartment. My own history of infidelity was playing
back inside my head on a permanent loop. Had the world betrayed
us all so much that we could only betray each other?
"Marshall, you've got to talk to her."
238. Betrayers and Betrayed
Abomination
. is not difficult for rulers to justify their l'0wer: they need only
. ate and abuse their victims long enough that no one can imag­
the latter being responsible for themselves. For the first few
erations of colonization, it is necessary to subdue the savages
rifles; once the brutes have learned to fear and obey, the guns
Abomination. 239
can be kept out of sight, until finally the conquered are integrated
into the social order as willing beggars and employees. In the end,
the conquerors can parade themselves before the world as humani­
tarians: they provide jobs for the poor (hiring them to till the very
lands they once held in common), medicines for the sick (derived
from the natural environment that has been seized from them),
and mediation between tribes that would otherwise be slaughter­
ing each other (with weapons sold by the colonizers, over conflicts
generated by their colonization).
Every government that holds power today is descended in a di­
rect line from this brutality, however much they distance themselves
from it. Once the savages are resigned to the new order, theycan be
allowed to eat at the same lunch counters as the victors-presum­
ing they can afford it-and even run for congress; dead ones can
be put on postage stamps the way hunters hang trophies on their
walls, with the same hypocrisy a developer names a new subdivi­
sion "ShadyAcres." Democracy is the silence in the village after the
massacre, the signing of the peace treaty renouncing independence.
If it seems we are not fit to govern ourselves, it is because govern­
ment has systematically disabled us.
Insofar as it is possible, the powers that be maintain this veneer
of peace; but every time an individual or a people steps out of line,
the embargoes are reinstated and the guns come back out. Starved,
isolated, humiliated, beaten, a rebel cannot help but turn on him­
self. Force people to live in concentration camps: they will become
suicide bombers, and everyone will understand why the camps are
necessary. Punish children for their blind impulses towards free­
dom: when they become drug addicts, you can call for even stricter
limitations on the next generation. That which is pronounced evil
becomes evil; atrocity begets atrocity.
Crippled and disgraced, fulfilling every stereotype and judgment
of her enemies, the dreamer loses faith in herself, questions wheth­
er she even deserves to achieve her dreams. The downtrodden can
scarcely feel themselves worthy of a liberation struggle: they are so
messed up, so erratic and easily confused, while the powerful are
eminently evenhanded and informed. Everywhere a flower blooms
in defiance of the prevailing order, nothing remains afterward but
its antithesis. The generous are left paupers; the imaginative and
optimistic are driven to despair; the most faithful and courageouS
240. Abomination
end by betraying each other. Shackled and delirious, surrounded by
". scornful clergymen twice her age, Joan of Arc can hardly compose
her thoughts, let alone articulate the heavenly visions that guided
, her to take up arms against them.
I The abomination is the ultimate product of a society that re­
presses difference: the stuttering cretin behind the defendant's
bench, the misfit fit only to wear a straitjacket, the indefensible
and irredeemable. The monsters produced by our society indicate
the monstrous imbalances of power that characterize it, not the
necessity of those imbalances-but they provide exhibit A for its
apologists. The revolutionary must be a bloodthirsty ideologue, a
filthy malcontent jealous of others' success, or else, at best, a solitary
figure scattering flowers on the road of pain he walks. Otherwise,
who knows who else might join in?
Abomination. 241
Cain accepts the judgment that has been pronounced upon him, but
reverses the values upon which it is predicated. Against all counsel,
he chooses to assume responsibility for what he is, for what others
have made him-to become, in defiance of all, what all say he is: a
thief, a cheat, a beast, a devil. Shame is the only distinction between
above and below: he does away with this distinction, and thus knows
his triumph by his defeat, his worth by his worthlessness, his riches
by his poverty. By this inversion, he survives.
His accusers cannot imagine being branded thieves, cheats, beasts,
devils. It is unthinkable. These allegations are brandished as weapons
on the premise that no one could survive them. Embracing them,
Cain steps irrevocably beyond their world, inaugurating a new table
of values: The first shall be the last, and the last shall be the first.
242 . Abomination
:
I.
.,.;
/.

.i

["tvt/ o!({it- oWl
W J t!!!-Iv
10 lU'i-/c '.fIti- 1D 'do::. ,;, wrJ t/A1<f

#'fYl /J/J J sec YfMf/;.J eh? tJJ Ut.eI
J 1);
1hin!!, ef.,VI7 wi nid 1tJ ftLI.k- abJuf
we. 't4Mt- do 11ra:t
'Nf- tMl r o (JI.1 "'a VI '?- r .Jibv(, I..j1M ;
h sfill. IfJVl IA.AIfh LVJ'l'! tvtn apu- .evp,
yWf Jf,1LtlJ 4{
MM!f IlMJ'a»fi .
.•.•. J In fu1 to 5fa1 1lJ 1
fJV
W ai« fr.
to ttMfU(­
lAm I<IIUJW crfl;t1ti itH
t if Aarl-d. H()fNlW/ we.
wt.u we [,.r1M)l.--
l.O'J
j
!(UYfd/tA;- W.
flf (POkf .fi dtnfJ 1b it
Wl
bU /- d4e.
jtttUM we M..iLV
f.f1JfrU.­
I rMhrd- .nas, U.n J (ff/ 1J{f{) J1'U1
rnIIA t4 6'A 1tu.. J.,Uu... = I J. •. /I AM .u.. '-- . 0
. IIIN'-'J l.O aA
-to;u.e, M i:t k !Jar L/cJl). UIe-'/t>t

M-4. f!MLvl to to
{{lOfho/"
pJ).1M -tv t.,aW- . vv
r
-&M-, "4d.Mrut; l.:e lAMP 'r' t>lUoftr", .
tbUZd--- 1 k
Consequences. 243
Staying alive is reformist: you keep trying the same basic approach,
hoping for a different outcome. Suicide, on the other hand-guar­
anteed results. If you want to solve a problem, solve it.
It wasn't that I didn't love life-on the contrary, I had such a high
opinion of it, at least of what it could be, that it was unbearable to
be living such a ridiculous farce instead. I'd experienced moments of
incredible joy, fallen passionately in love, reclaimed neighborhoods
from police in pitched warfare-after all that, I wasn't about to re­
turn to the dish room. I would go through anything to experience
those things again, but I wasn't interested in adding fifty more bad
years to twenty-five good ones.
And there was no reason to believe I'd ever get a second chance.
The world was crashing in around our ears and I wasn't getting any
younger. I blamed myself for everything: I'd driven my friends away,
fractured coalitions when it counted most, ruined my relationship
with Kate. I was so angry with myself, so disappointed.
I couldn't stop thinking about suicide. I spent a disproportionate
part of every day thinking through the details, working out how to
be sure I would succeed and where to leave my body. Even apart from
the question of whether or not I should kill myself, it was hardly an
efficient use of time; I could barely focus on anything else. During
the worst of it, every half hour I had to sit down, focus on making
it from one breath to the next, and talk myself through:
01<, you're at the bottom of the pit now. Remember you're at war.
People like you aren't supposed to survive-you're supposed to kill your­
self and save them the trouble. You have to get through this for all the
ones who never lived to tell their stories. Just surviving is fighting in that
war. Just surviving.
244. Reform and Revolution
of
said
This won't be easy to read. When you spend
all but an hour of each day in solitary
confinement, fluorescent lights humming
overhead, it isn't easy to write.
Yesterday that reporter I told you about
came here, one of Pablo's kind. The pigs
never tell me who's out there when they
come to get me for visiting hourS. I
assumed it was my grandmother, and instead
I getsOIlle gringo in a starched shirt,
earnestly auditioning to be news anchor
for the revolution.
They didn't let him take in paper or pen,
but that didn't stop him: he was a real
investigative reporter, a credit to his
profession. He wanted me to explain ~ t h e
movement," when all I want is fOr someone
to explain something, anything! I'm
supposed to give a fucking statement of
purpose when my head seethes with all the
fluctuating statements of the past, which
I'm constantly presenting, with increasing
derision, in evidence against myself.
I couldn't tell him anything anyway,
course. I was polite, but I wish I'd
something like this:
I would like to rebel much more than I
actually do. I would like my hatred to
be pure and clean again, not diluted and
staged as it is. How I'd love to love and
not feel that I do it out of habit or
duty, how I want to suffer truly at these
tragedies, not in the empty, practiced
way I do! For all my talk of being my own
master, hoW I long for some new passion
or sensation to seize me and make itself
Marsh-
my master!
It would be convenient for you if I would
lock myself in ideas the way my enemies
have locked me in a cell. But there are
things in me that escape description and
prescription, and you must acknowledge
them, too, or else all your talk about
better worlds and people will be
worthless.
When you say "community," I permit myself
a furtive sneer, because I don't want to
hide from myself in the safety of your
numbers; I want to be alone in danger and
the agony of solitude, which I know and
love. When you speak of action, I cherish
my passivity, moving indifferently
through a distant world, wrapped up in
the turmoils of my own qloomy spirit.
I would rather sit here in a concrete
tomb than playact in some travesty of
togetherness.
When you celebrate romance with ribbons
and ceremony, I feel all. too painfully
how little of myself can fit that mold.
And then when I try to submerge myself in
crowds or isolation, suddenly I lonq for a
single companion with whom to nee, aqainst
whom I could smash my heart like a boat
on a reef in pursuit of that impossible
immersion for which lovers hunger as moths
do for names. Not that I will ever have
the chance again, thank God.
When you exalt the courageous and .the
good, there is a proud, evil part of
me that is possessive of my faults, my
cowardice, my stupidity, and I want to be
faithful to that part, too, rather than
split myself in pieces. When you hold
out the future as a happy answer to all
our prayers, a fiend within me wishes thiS
misery to stretch on forever, glorying in
inflicting it upon myself ... as I cannot
get my hands on anyone' else.
As soon as I've finished my plea for
acceptance, the devil in me will.strike
away your outstretched arms. Build a
paradise for mei I'll still revolt, I'll
brinq heaven down around my ears: for
every house is a set of walls, and I
only feel utterly myself in the act of
transqression, sailinq on its borrowed
winqs.
I am the uqly secret, the forbidden part
that must remain silent, invisible,
nocturnal, that can never reveal itself,
that· can only betray itself by tryinq.
Keep me in kitchens . a ~ d barrios and
cornfields, behind penitentiary walls
and border patrols; the more you try to·
bury me, the more you pledqe yourself
to ali thai is noble, permissible, and
intelligible, the more you need me, the
. more I am part of you. Offer me the
blondest hair, the cleane13taccent,
citizenship fo.r all lilY ;relatives; I'll
still end up in prison with the illeqals
who can't even speak your precious
Enqlish.
.. I would like to tell the story of the
most antisocial, indefensible man, to
qive voice to his untold treasures and
torments, toaxpose his wretched humanity
in so compellinq a portrait that you would
be made to see the absoluteness of his
needs as you see the absoluteness of
your own. Then all his unforgivable sins
would be on your conscience, and you'd
have to find a way to wash the world of
shame once and for all or else perish
How do you want to die?
Hanging from a rafter with the stool kicked to the floor beneath
you? From an overdose of sleeping pills, like an actress or a fed up
housewife? Opening your arteries with a razor, in a hot bath so you
won't shake so much when the warmth leaves your body?
All at once, in a spatter of brains and bone on the concrete at the
foot of the high-rise where you work? Or in increments, installment
by installment with cigarettes and saturated fat and air pollution,
high blood pressure, radiation, toxins in the water, carcinogenic
sugar substitutes and cell phones?
Do you want certainty, a gun to your temple? Or do you play
the lottery-driving on the freeway, having unprotected sex, pay­
ing taxes to a government that might send you to war or the police
to your door with guns in their hands?
Perhaps you're getting paid for it-how much are you worth
per hour? Do you wash dishes for minimum wage, give and receive
orders for a manager's salary, fight your way to the top to get a fair
price for your life?
Or are you buying it? Do you purchase it in single servings, buy­
ing yourself a taste whenever you can with alcohol, cocaine, heroine,
prostitutes, action movies, video games, television, whatever it takes
to go blank for an instant? Do you sometimes long to cut right to the
inevitable, flinging yourself into the abyss of some addiction, religion,
absolute negation of everything you've ever wanted, everything that
has disappointed you?
Do you savor every drop, stretching it out as far as you can? A
moderate dose every day for the rest of your life, with health insur­
ance to make sure you don't miss out on a single hour? Or are you
ready to get it all over with, consummate the affair with one defi­
ant gesture, flaunting your disdain for the absurd tragedies of this
world as you go down in a hail of bullets?
Or maybe it's not death you're after, after all.
But what else is there}
256. Despair
\ :\
,.
\ :
:1
:i
, .
YI
4 I
I I
# ;
• 1
Despair
Despair. 257
"I wish all the people who've killed
themselves were still alive-and all the
people who are alive would kill themselves!"
If there is a social stratum below the exploited underclass, a demo­
graphic that suffers most from the absurdities of our society, it is the
suicides. The suicidal class-every minute, more hit the pavement.
Who is more dispossessed than them? They are only recognized when
they absent themselves; only their blood speaks on their behalf. They
know better than anyone else what must change about this world,
and yet in despair of ever changing it they avenge themselves upon
the only victims in easy reach-giving a new meaning to the saying
that those who make half a revolution dig their own graves.
Imagine a person feeling that his life is out of his control to
such an extent that he can only regain possession of it by murder­
ing himself! Can a society really be free and healthy if people will
go to such lengths to escape?
So like theft and adultery, suicide is forbidden, an unspeakable
abomination. Self-satisfied den mothers who have never grappled
with debilitating depression feel entitled to sneer at the cowardice
of those who make the difficult decision to end their lives. Even the
terminally ill are not to choose for themselves when and how they
pass away-there are laws against it, as if the living could legislate
for those crossing over into death! What does it say of a civilization
that it not only forbids its denizens to kill themselves but does not
even permit the question of whether life is worth living?
Yet we commit a little suicide every moment we deny ourselves
the lives we wish to live. Wholesale suicide is off-limits, but most
settle willingly enough for death on the installment plan, whittling
their lives away hour by hour. No matter how unfulfilling life is, they
dare not back out, for God is waiting on the other side to punish
them for shirking their earthly duties-God, that is, or else Public
Opinion, which He has deputized in His absence.
Meanwhile, if a young man joins the military and mindlessly
obeys orders that lead to his senseless death, his conduct is coura­
geous and praiseworthy. Suicide, like Disaster, is perfectly acceptable
so long as it occurs on the terms of the powers that be; you can die
in their hands, but not of your own. The ones who shoot or hang
,themselves are daring heretics, like the upstart mystics who claim
flO receive divine guidance that bypasses the Pope: if self-destruc­
'tion is the order of the day, they're determined to have a firsthand
.relationship with it, whatever anyone else says. In rejecting both
,living death and the sovereignty of the authorities over their lives,
they are only one step away from rejecting death and domination
altogether: Neither death nor taxes!
But again, like theft, adultery, and other pressure valves, suicide
fis isolating-indeed, it is the most isolating act bar none. While it
", returns an instant of autonomy to an individual, it can only pre­
vent people from establishing collective ownership of their lives.
"Those who dig their own graves make only half a revolution. If no
"one could steal, if no one could cheat, if no one could end his life,
'yet all the tensions that run through our society today remained­
the massive upheavals that would ensue!
If all who have killed themselves could compare notes at some
-grand convention center in the hereafter, what would they be able
to tell us? Perhaps they would be capable of succoring one another
;where no one else could; perhaps they would regret that, rather than
. destroying themselves, they didn't launch a revolutionary organiza­
:;tion comprised of those who have nothing to lose; perhaps it would
, seem strange to them that it had felt so much easier to do violence
',to themselves than to respond to the violence done to them.
It's too late, of course-their lives are fixed in eternity, set apart
:like flies trapped in amber. But there is still time to find those who
are currently contemplating suicide, to encourage them to speak
"freely about their feelings and do our best to make a world no one
will wish to leave.
• •
. : .
.
.
"
.
. .•
258. Despair
"Put me out of my misery or take me out of it!"
Life is not simply a trap, a sentence. This occurs to everyone at least
once. We have an option that makes us freer than the gods, just as
every employee is freer than every boss: we can quit. One can savor
this idea in every extremity; it provides consolation when nothing
else can. Nothing obligates us to live-therefore, if we have the cour­
age for it, at every moment life can become a tabula rasa, a space in
which anything is possible and everything can be risked.
With such freedom, we can only be slaves if we choose to be.
Slavery is for those who still believe that their masters control the
domain of death as well as life-not for us. For us, there is only the
unknown. It may be awful, it may be salvation, it may be nothing­
ness, but it is unknowable, in life as well as death. Frontiers to be
crossed, new worlds to explore, abysses to be risked-yes, the pos­
sibility of joy, of the realization of your most cherished desires,
and risk, risk too. The risk of finally confronting fear, daring the
unknown, looking the ugliness of life in the face-of, one way or
another, quitting the job of existing.
For most of our contemporaries, life itself is a job, a desperate
struggle to juggle a thousand obligations-including the saddest
imperative of all, enjoying oneself. These unfortunates forget the
lightness of life, the weightlessness of every moment, every situa­
tion, in the face of nonexistence.
We can choose not to live. So there is no reason not to open oneself
to, to risk everything for, a life of joy. There is always the option
of putting an end to things-one may as well play for high stakes
if one chooses to exist. After all, the worst that could happen is al­
ready assured.
There is no reason to get up in the morning, then, but to live.
No boss, no law, no god can take from you the possibility of say­
ing No.
All this is useless, and not news, to the suicide, who has already
disconnected from life and wills death simply to finalize the ar­
rangement, to put an end to the inconvenience of feeling one thing
and living another. Once you're that exhausted and demoralized, no
mere mental exercise can change your mind; suicide bombers, con­
trary to idle speculation, must act from a tremendous investment
in this world to be capable of going to such lengths to die at others'
260. Despair
, expense. Your average suicidal person can barely vacuum his apart­
~ ment, let alone carry out an elaborate mission.
· But imagine if people lived as though they might die at any rno­
· ment, so every day it was as if they were born again! Imagine if no
· one let life become a job for himself or anyone else in the first place!
· Then howmany people would kill themselves? People commit suicide
· when it is harder for them to picture breaking off their commitments
than ceasing to exist-here again are our customs and investments,
become cancerous and inorganic, riding us to early graves.
·Life - Consider the Alternative
ii If we were brave or reckless enough for it, our despair could afford
us supernatural powers. Imagine being able to act without fear of
the repercussions, to choose the unknown over the intolerably fa­
,miliar, to withdraw from unhealthy obligations and relationships
· the moment you recognize them for what they are. It takes a ruth­
;: less mercy to discard sentimentality and remember all the things
· that never happened and still might never happen, all the dreams that
C' never came true-to acknowledge that we can't wait forever, there's
t., h ti f h
· not enoug time or tat.
Let the past go. All the old battles you're still fighting, all your
,'denial and defense mechanisms, all the addictions and inertia you've
-accumulated and all the fears that bind you to them. This is going
to be the hardest thing you ever live through-but let them go, let
.them die, have courage through the silent moments in the void as
:you wait, trembling, for your new life to be born. It willbe.
Despair. It's our only hope.
Despair. 261
When your friends misunderstand your works and your enemies
understand them all too well, when waking up every morning feels
like a defeat rather than a triumph, when the razor blade or the
cliff's edge beckons, remember-death is not pretty, only well-ad­
vertised. Remember what they did to Michelangelo, waiting until
he was buried to paint over all his masterpieces-just as the racist :
sister Nietzsche hated presented him to the world as a champion of
her own cause after he lost his sanity-just as Paul used Jesus, and
Plato used Socrates, and the Communists used Durruti. The dead
cannot defend themselves.
Give your enemies nothing. Let your tears freeze to stones we
can hurl from catapults. Write your own epitaph and shout it aloud.
This life is a war we are not yet winning for our daughters' children;
don't do your enemies' work for them-finish your own.
If you're fighting, you've already won.
262 . Despair
•.
Despite all our proclamations to the contrary, revolution had re­
mained a mere concept for us, a fantasy future-the social revolu­
tion, when we would put into practice at last all those abstractions
about transforming everything; the personal revolution, when we
would finally live life like it really was ending one minute at a time.
Calling for mass actions in the name of total liberation, we'd still
feared to confess our private trials and tribulations to each other;
defacing diet billboards, decrying patriarchal propaganda, we'd
still put off coming to terms with our own bodies and desires. All
those declarations of war and fables about insurrection-perhaps
they were just stuff and nonsense: such ideas spring from the psy­
chological needs of those who trade in them at least as much as
from any insight into what is desirable or possible. Looking back,
it seems we needed to be in unreciprocated love with some apoca­
lyptic event-:-just as many of us were, not coincidentally, with each
other-at least as much as we actually wished for or expected one.
This longing suffused everything with meaning, but it also made
everything bearable-when we'd once felt, and still continued to
insist, that it was all unbearable.
We'd found ways of surviving, after all: we, who prided our­
selves on our intransigence, who had lived through moments when
it seemed the old order was crumbling and had pledged ourselves
to defend and extend them or die trying, we too had found ways to
bide time and lose ourselves in routine, albeit a routine of resistance.
We'd developed our own rituals to commemorate the ghosts of in­
surrections past-and slowly, famished for something tangible to
live on, come to mistake those formalities for liberation itself.
.2.64. Believing in Miracles
Meanwhile, those who had lived their whole lives under the
burdens of work and rent and gender, who thought of these injus­
tices as inescapable forces of nature, still experienced resistance as
a shaking off of reality, a system shock, the way I had when I'd first
gone to campus in search of the encampment. The closest they got
to liberation was admiring the stars during a blackout, sharing re­
sources after a tornado, disrupting some staid wedding or school
assembly. If they stopped there, it was a failure of imagination, not
of character: however sweet those moments were, it was impossible
to picture anything beyond them. Perhaps one had to awaken, as I'd
been lucky enough to, under different constellations, surrounded
by beautiful foreigners, to be ready to invest in revelry, risk, and
revolt as a way of life. But there were not enough foreign lands to
accommodate everyone: we had to conjure them here, somehow,
on domestic soil.
I'd been telling myself this for years without following through.
Every time I came to this conclusion, it turned out it was too hard
: to conjure and too easy to flee. Perhaps once upon a time I'd been
waiting it out in good faith for the revolution, but I was no longer
convinced it was coming. I'd been wrong to leave it up to others; I
couldn't help anyone else make their big break with reality if I didn't
tbelieve it was possible myself. If no pivotal moment of transforrna­
tion was forthcoming, it was up to me to bring about the things I
idesired in the present.
I no longer think of revolution as a goal in the future; now I see it
,as something ongoing, a point of rupture. It is the threshold over which
!,people pass into believing in miracles, for lack of a better word-and,
,,'In that state of grace, find t h e m ~ e l v e s capable of changing things that
d seemed immutable. Sooner or later they return from across that
:rontier, even if they return as dedicated revolutionaries-and all the
orse for us to be burdened with revolutionaries who no longer be­
ieve in miracles! You have to be a real romantic, a maniac who trusts
fairy tales more than reality, to remain long beyond that horizon,
't alone expect everyone else to join you there. But that-believing
the unbelievable-is what it takes for our dreams to come true, is
trhat makes such dreams possible at all.
That some of us yet persist from one day to the next, believing
miracles in a world that denies all magic and mystery, is itself a
. iracle: and proof that we can, in fact, do anything.
Believing in Miracles . .2.65
The first step was to set things right with myoId friends and find
out who still had fight left in them. Then I imagined we'd recon­
vene the troops, open a social center like the ones I'd seen overseas,
and initiate another campaign like the one that had begun with
the occupation. I'd wanted those things all along, but I was finally
ready to take responsibility for making them happen. There was
no time to lose, either-everybody said there was another war on
the horizon.
I went to Kate the way Marshall had come to me, willing to
answer for my actions and do what I could to earn back her trust.
I feared the worst-people often forgive their partners' misdeeds
while blaming their partners' partners-but she made an effort to
be approachable. We spoke for a long time. I didn't expect things
to be the same between us for months, maybe years, but at least we
were talking.
Next I looked up Rita, who had just moved back to town. I hadn't
seen much of her since the march to the wall. I found out she was
living with Sherry, another friend from that era.
After we'd stopped seeing each other regularly, Rita had been
among those who had started preparing for industrial collapse; she'd
made a dramatic shift from mainstream environmental activism to
a kind of doomsday survivalism. The last time we'd spent time to­
gether she was living out in the country, learning to identify edible
wild plants and prepare animal hides.
266. Believing in Miracles
You can imagine my disbelief when I found a giant condominium
at the address she'd given me. I double-checked the crumpled slip of
paper in my pocket and looked around back just in case before lock­
ing my bicycle to the metal fencing. Sure enough, their names were
on the list by the intercom: Rita McKean, Sherry Lechleidner, B2..
She buzzed me in and met me at her door. Sherrywas in the kitchen
behind her, making coffee next to a brand-new chrome refrigerator.
I couldn't help myself. "How do you afford this place? It's so
fancy."
"One word-credit! But I've also got a job on campus. It's bullshit,
but it beats poverty! Turns out all that NGO stuff was good for my
resume."
This was unexpected, but I didn't let it put me off. Hadn't Pablo
done good things while working for a corporate newspaper?
Rita led me into the sitting room and pointed me to a love seat;
Sherry joined her on the couch. Once we'd caught up a bit, I started
to make my pitch.
She didn't let me get far. "Sarni, I'm not interested in anything
like that right now."
I was incredulous. "Wait, hear me out! Don't tell me you like
being back in an office!"
"Being in an office is dreadful, sure, but honestly it's a lot easier
to get on with my life without taking on more than I can handle. I
really had myself in a dead end."
Sherry nodded vigorously. "All that activism stuff-don't you
think it's just a way of making yourself unhappy, an alibi for put­
ting off coming to grips with things?"
"But what about all the people who can't work in offices?" That
wasn't what I meant at all. I was flustered, falling into platitudes.
"Do you really think any of the things we did helped them?"
"Well, first of all, the strike-"
"Sure, but I know you'll agree only a fundamental change in the
economic system could make a real difference. A big change like that
. is totally out of our hands. I'm just admitting that."
"You don't think it matters what we do?"
Breathlessly, with a mixture of sheepishness and pride, Rita
spelled it out for me: she had lost her idealism, and with it her com­
mitment to struggle. Throughout the conversation that followed,
With increasing enthusiasm, the two of them referred to this loss as
Believing in Miracles. 267
though it represented an important transition to a new stage of life,
perhaps even to a higher plane of consciousness. They spoke about
it, in short, like teenagers confessing they had lost their virginity.
When they moved on to complaining about having to fill out
income tax forms again, I had to bite my tongue. I wanted to say,
"So you're finally all grown up, huh? Don't worry-I hear the first
time's not so great, anyway! But sooner or later, you'll get used to
it-and in time, you'll even start to like it!"
"To like-what?" they answered, in my imagination.
"GETTING FUCKED!"
Storming down the street, banging my ankle against the pedal of
my bicycle every few steps, I tried to get to the bottom of my anger.
Rita had been a good friend, one of the few I'd kept up with since
my secretary days. She and I had gone through the same evolution
after that infamous City Council meeting. So I felt abandoned, that
was one aspect of it.
Rita had given up on waiting for the big changes she wanted to
see, just as I had: but for her, this meant there was no reason to do
anything except the things she had to do to be like everyone else of
her class. The polar ice caps might melt, the world might end, but
she would meet her fate with central heating and air conditioning,
pumping pollutants into the sky with the rest of them. She was right
back where she'd started-right back where both of us had started,
where I would be myself if I weren't so impractical. No wonder I
took it so personally.
You who no longer dance in the street
Who have given up on winning
But not yet on giving in;
Have you made your peace with war?
Did they bribe you to betray
Your scorn for bribery and betrayal?
Would you seek accommodation
With the ones who broke your heart
And trade the bitterness of struggle
For the sour grapes of defeat?
Hope .169
168. Believing in Miracles
tinope
~
Hope as a Martial Art
Hope is a magic power that grants further powers. It is not a conse­
quence of good fortune, but a precondition for it: not a conjecture
about the future, but a strength exercised in the present. As anyone
who has broken through a police line knows, when it really counts
morale is more important than organization, preparation, or even
intelligence..
This is not to say we should study self-delusion, but simply that
the revolutionary project takes place outside the domain of calcu­
lation and common sense. In setting out to transform the world,
we are attempting the impossible; supernatural faith may indeed
be better suited to the task than mundane pragmatism. A revolu­
tionary aspires to have a tight grasp on reality without the converse
being true.
Those who insist that there is no hope are thinking like scien­
tists: they look at hope as a measurable quantity outside themselves,
reducing it to a question of whether there are grounds to believe
something is true of the future. They are poor scientists, at that,
speculating from a static position rather than proposing a hypoth­
esis and conducting an experiment! It is never possible to answer
such questions accurately; one never has access to all the necessary
information, and one's own choices influence the outcome in un­
foreseeable ways.
In acknowledging the influence of our choices, we can begin to
formulate another conception of hope. Even if it were possible to
see into the future from an armchair, it wouldn't be as fulfilling as
consciously playing a role in determining it; conceptualized differ­
ently, hope can enable us to do this, even if it does not guarantee
the results.
Besides, why measure the value of any undertaking by its conse­
quences alone? If a revolutionary effort does not succeed in imme­
diately transfiguring the cosmos, that doesn't mean it was a waste
of time. Evaluating our activities that way is naive if anything is;
there's no sense privileging the future over the present and reject­
ing everything that exists in favor of things that do not. The point is
always what is happening: the process, not the product, the means,
not some overriding end-that, for a few minutes or years, some­
thing beautiful is happening. The paradise we deserve doesn't wait
Hope. 271
in a future that mayor may not arrive; it is comprised of these mo­
ments, whenever they occur. Which side are you on-the future,
or the present?
Utopia is notoriously unreachable as a destination, but equally
notorious for inspiring incredible voyages. By the time we arrive
at our goals they are often unrecognizable, or else we are. A preoc­
cupation with life "after the revolution" can be as debilitating as
the news constantly broadcast from Capitol Hill to distract us from
what we can do where we are. But unyoked from our addiction to
assurances and our expectation to be paid for everything, practiced
instead as the art of making self-fulfilling prophecies-as a martial
art-hope offers us tremendous power.
If this is so, then the real question is why people willfully disable
themselves by embracing resignation and defeatism. The cynic is not
coming to terms with the hard facts of reality, but imposing them
upon himself. If he really wants to learn whether the things he de­
sires are impossible, he has to start from the premise-no, from the
deep-seated conviction-that they are possible, and act accordingly.
272. Hope
" The fireball explosion of our affair cast all the relationships before
it as mere shadows. The first night we spent together, we were still
awake at nine in the morning gazing into each other's eyes. In that
moment all my solipsism fell away and I was able to feel another
person's consciousness as a palpable presence: another human be­
ing was there with me, looking back at me, a life story as intricate as
my own behind her. A wild idea gripped me then: in another world,
might it be possible to look out across the rooftops and be that grate­
ful for everyone's existence? That reverie lasted as long as it took me
to walk to the metro that morning. I certainly wasn't equipped to
establish bonds with all those miserable people; as it turned out, I
wasn't even prepared to protect the fragile connection I'd made with
her. I didn't feel anything like that optimism again until a decade
later I found myself racing away from a smashed storefront with a
crowd of masked hoodlums.
The cafe was practically empty that afternoon. I settled myself at
a small table by the window and waited for her to join me with her
cappuccino. We hadn't seen each other in years, but Chloe skipped
the formalities with her patented nonchalance: "So what have you
" been doing with yourself, stranger?"
" I explained that I had become a revolutionary. She looked at me
quizzically. "And what does it mean to be a revolutionary?"
"I don't know," I admitted. "It's an act of faith."
"Like being a writer," she ventured.
We compared notes on our respective writing endeavors, the
market for commercial writing, and the impact of the latest tech­
" nology on literature. Chloe's specialty was to be critical without
, offering solutions. "Everyone reads and writes in little thought­
" less bursts now. Can you imagine somebody writing Les Miserables
", with new messages in the inbox every five minutes and publishers
: demanding something that sells in airports? The novel, I mean, not
t. the musical!"
Explosions. 273
"Orwell said that reading skyrocketed among the British during
the Second World War-all those soldiers in the trenches and fami­
lies waiting in bomb shelters with nothing to do but read. Nowadays
we're in a different kind of war"-Chloe scowled; she hated anything
that struck her as hyperbole-"and no one reads actual books except
copyeditors and people serving long prison terms. But the prison
population in this country is up to several million; maybe you just
need to change your audience.'"
"But tell me-what do revolutionaries do these days?" She was
trying to keep things light. "Do you still storm prisons and over­
throw governments?"
That was a tricky question. As a means of actually overthrow­
ing the government and liberating prisoners, our efforts had been
as ineffectual as the Colditz glider; on the other hand, as a means
of escape-of finding our way to another life in a totally occupied
zone-we weren't doing badly. 1 tried to formulate an epigram to
convey this, but the distant wail of police sirens broke my concen­
tration. "Maybe right nowwe're more like the monks of the Middle
Ages, preserving a space without prisoners or governments, how­
ever limited. But that's not to say we can't expand it, link up with
others ..."
"Well, you know what they say about human nature." Through
the window behind her, 1could see a line of police cars racing across
the intersection a block away, lights flashing.
"Yeah?" 1 couldn't bring myself to let that pass. "What do you
think about what they say about it?"
"Come on! Do you really think people can get along without
those things? Today, 1mean, in this world." She'd restrained herself
as long as she could. "There's not going to be a revolution, not in
this country. You can't be serious."
"OK, look at things at a different level. With billions of people
on the planet, you can hardly talk about changing the world without
being autocratic. But that's the scale you see on the world news­
it's like looking at life through the wrong end of the telescope. Of
course everything you can do seems pathetically small on the stage of
history, but if you reverse perspective, starting from yourself-"
Another line of police cars passed. Chloe's cell phone was vibrat­
ing in her purse. Distractedly, she tried to change the subject. "OK,
what are you doing yourself, then?"
274. Explosions
"For one thing, I'm moving out of my apartment. I'm going in
on a building with a bunch of people in their twenties. It's a crazy
idea, really, but ..."
Chloe finally fished out her cell phone in exasperation. "Sorry­
hold on. Hello? Yeah, I'm fine, why? Oh my god. Are you serious?
OK, I'll call you back"
"What's going on?"
"There's something happening downtown. 1 don't know, let's
go out and look"
From the pavement, we could see a black cloud of smoke filling
the sky behind the buildings ahead. A fire truck passed us, deafen­
ingly close, followed by an ambulance.
"Wow." We stood beside each other in silence.
"Pablo, I'm sorry, 1 should go. Heaven knows what's going on."
"Chloe-" 1 caught her arm without thinking, then released it.
She didn't flinch. "I wanted to see you to talk about what happened
between us, to say all the things 1 should have said before. 1 ..."
"Don't you think it's a little late for that?" A helicopter roared
into view overhead.
"Not for the sake of the relationship we had. Just because you
deserved better-because everyone deserves better."
"Oh, I've already forgiven you for all that. 1 mean, 1 don't think
about it anymore, anyway."
"We can talk about it another time, if you prefer." We both
paused. "Here, I'll walk you to your car."
She turned to me inside the parking garage. "Just be careful withyour­
self. This isn't a safe time to be ..." She saw my expression and stopped.
"Don't think it's going to be easy, anyway. You can expect-"
"-resistance, 1 know," 1 finished. "Oh, 1 know!"
She paused again. "If you need anything, get in touch with me,
OK?"
"OK, 1 will. The same goes for you."
She looked at me then with a tenderness 1 hadn't seen in a de­
cade. "Tell the truth, I'm glad one of us is doing something crazy.
1 wish you could persuade me about human nature, though. 1 feel
like the whole world's going to hell."
"We can talk about that another time, too." She was getting
into her car. "I bet 1 could persuade you-or at least talk your ear
off about it."
Explosions.275
"I'm sure you could." She backed the car out, then rolled down
the window. "Anything else?"
"I don't think so. Just be good to yourself-"
"Sure."
"-and reassure Rachel than 1haven't traded her book for three
magic beans." I'd borrowed her friend's copy of The Annotated Hunt­
ing of the Snark at a dinner party back when 1 was still married.
She laughed. "Are you in the habit of trading things you borrow
for magic beans?" .
"Yeah, I've got a whole silo of them saved up. It's gonna be seri­
ous shit when all those beanstalks start to sprout."
276. Explosions
i
,
History as
We Live It
!. Whenever the question of human nature comes up, the programmed
always point us to their history books to show that all human beings
ever do is fight, command, obey. Before we look at those books, let's
look a little closer at history itself: when they say history, which his­
tory do they mean? Time and space are both so vast that one could
not hope to begin to record either in full: any record is inevitably
selective. Could one write a history of children's games, of kisses,
of picnics? And yet aren't these, proportionately speaking, a much
greater part of human history than anything in the history books?
Today we are in the belly of a hierarchical leviathan, which natu­
rally tells the stories of other hierarchical empires as the history of
the human race: contests for economic and political power, books
of laws and philosophical rationalizing, the trivia of the lives of
"great men." But most of human history has not been spent at the
Battle of Hastings or the crossing of the Rubicon; most of the time,
human beings were-and are, today, any time the boss has his back
turned-just preparing food, flirting, daydreaming, playing or work­
ing on projects cooperatively. The times when slavemasters seized
power and coerced masses of people have been exceptions-though
Western civilization has seen a disproportionate number of these,
to its discredit. Remember, our species has been around for hun­
dreds of thousands of years, but the kind of centralized power and
social control we see today is only a few thousand years old-and
only became globalized in the last few hundred.
History as We Live It . 277
If some of the earliest historical records are of wars and conquests,
it is because the first peoples to catch the disease of so-called civili­
zation were the first to conquer and keep tally. Unbelievably, these
records are the only ones taken seriously by historians, who discount
the oral traditions and folklore common to all human communities;
but we can tell by the very rarity of such records that they are not
representative of what all human beings were doing in those days,
let alone before then-or today.
Let's speak of proportions again. The human race has been around
for over a million years, but centralized power and warfare as we.
know them have existed for less than ten thousand. Over those ten
millennia, only a small minority of human communities have been
as bellicose and coercive as this one-and even today, only a small
part of human interactions actually express that violence and subser­
vience. Thus we Can see that, on every level, fighting, commanding,
and obeying comprise perhaps one percent of human history. What
about games, kissing, and picnics, then? Aren't they the heritage of
our species, representative of our "nature" if anything is?
We Are Continuously Giving
Birth to OurAncestors
The war to define the past is indeed a war to claim the soul of hu­
manity. Old demagogues brandished the Will of God at us; new
ones brandish Nature and History. When we want to prove an­
other world is possible, we instinctively fight them for these-but
we have to be careful not to win a Pyrrhic victory by reconstruct­
ing a past that outshines any possible present or future. It couldn't
hurt to remember that, as the bare remains must be interpreted to
be read at all, the chief activity of any people looking at the past is
always projection-historians tend to see what they are looking for,
not what they are looking at. People always cast behind themselves
whatever past they need to believe that what they want is possible.
Fine then! We'll do the same!
So let's not argue that things were better once, but that they
were different-and that they are still different.*The past behind us
* The politicians say, "Today things are more the way they are than ever before,"
and the newscasters agree with them. Don't fall for it!
History as We Live It . :179
is so vast it must hold more difference than we can imagine, great
multitudes of Atlantises with currencies and cosmologies unimag­
inable from this vantage point.' Compose your own stories about
what your ancestors did-they're probably true-and use them to
kindle the courage you need to live the stories you want. Tell those
fables around the fire before the next great adventure your clan un­
dertakes, be it a great journey or a dangerous engagement; whisper
them into your lover's ear when he needs reassurance that he is not
crazy for breaking ranks with this global village of cannibals. If any­
thing is certain, it is that your predecessors did the same.
No Future in Nostalgia
"In addition to shorter and moreflexible hours and the more reliable
safety net afforded by food sharing, foragers' labor was more satisfying
than most modern work is. We awaken to the alarm clock-they slept
a lot, night and day. We are sedentary in buildings in our polluted cit­
ies;they moved about freely, breathing the fresh air of the country. We
have bosses-they had companions. Our work typically involves one, or,
at most, a few hyperspecialized skills, if any; theirs combined handwork
and brainwork in a wide range of activities, exactly as the great uto­
pians calledfor. Our commute is dead time, and unpaid, to boot-they
could scarcely leave their campsites without experiencing an adventure
of some kind. Life, for us, is chiefly a cause of anxiety, and a source of
retinue for insurance companies;for them, it was a feast-or perhaps, at
times, a famine, but a famine nobler and more sensible than our greatest
sufferings and achievements here in the condominium and the cubicle."
• My first summer back I stayed up later and later, exploring the unseen dimen­
sions of our city as I had explored so many other cities and countries. At four
in the morning, everything seemed deserted; at a quarter past five, birds strut­
ted on streets cars would monopolize two hours later. I walked there, too-it
was a fairyland, an alternate universe in which this crowded, heavily policed
district was my own domain, a quiet paradise such as Adam and Eve might
have wandered. My joy in it was so profound I almost wanted to run out and
conceive a new race of offspring to populate it.
After months of enjoying this solitude, I was joined first by one, then a few
friends. Surprisingly, this did not spoil my pleasure, but increased it: now I
had a people with whom to share my secret world!
So late at night, we roamed the asphalt on which automobiles drove by day. We
didn't speak it aloud, but we knew that one day, when there were no more cars,
all the inhabitants of this land would follow in our footsteps. This was our
universe, extending before and behind us through eternity, and its past and
future were as real to us as the industrial revolution was to the motorists.
2.80. History as We Live It
\
"Tool-using primitive peoples were actually more accustomed to
exercising their intelligence than we are. They were used to in­
venting their tools and solutions, while we.for the most part, sim­
ply receive them. Similarly, they were more practiced in the arts
of enjoying life, as they weren't constantly struggling to catch up
to the progress of their civilization. Joy, wonder, and friendship
were the centers of life, not survival. Only today, in our world of
enforced artificial scarcities and unbridled social change, are the
nuts and bolts issues of mere survival the main focus."
"In that Golden Age, they lived as if they were gods, their hearts
free from all sorrow. When they died, it was as if they simply fell
asleep. The fruitfulgrainland yielded its harvest to them of its
own accord-while they, at their pleasure, quietly looked after
their works, in the midst of good things."
Here we find an amateur anthropologist, a professional sociolo­
gist, and a Greek poet (Hesiod, in 700 BC, to be exact) celebrating
the lifestyles of human beings immeasurably removed from them
by time and space-but you could as easily replace the foragers,
primitive peoples, and golden gods with more recent protagonists
to make the passages refer to the present day. After all, why let dead
people have all the fun? Why celebrate only the foragers of prehis­
tory when people are foraging in the suburbs at this very moment?
There's no sense glorifying the past at the expense of the possibili­
ties of the present unless you're trying to get yourself off the hook
by making your situation out to be hopeless. .
Those who declare that freedom existed before civilization and
vanished with its arrival have more in common than they might care
to admit with those who insist that freedom, impossible today, waits
ahead for us around the bend of some millenarian revolution. Both.
situate everything precious over some ultimate horizon, whether
before or behind us, without troubling to explain how we are even
able to conceive of that perfection without examples of it on hand.
The old-line Marxist who insists the world will be a paradise once the
proletariat takes power and can only be a hell until then is speech­
less in the face of the paradise discovered by a lovemaking couple;
the hard-line primitivist who writes of how magical everything was
before our fall from grace is similarly disoriented when it comes to
the question of what matters right now.
History as We Live It. 2.81
We would do better to orient our values around what we have
experienced in our own lives and what might be possible in them.
If we can't begin our project of liberation from what we know
and aim for something we can reach, we can't start or steer such
a project at all.
One Million Years of Do-It-Yourself Culture!
The Dreamtime, according to some Aborigines, is a time that runs
concurrent with mortal time as well as having taken place at the
inception of the cosmos. It is the world in which people dream new
worlds into being, and in which worlds dream themselves into be­
ing through people. The Dreamtime offers a model for an alternate
mythology: a heritage as old as our species that can become new in
an instant, an ongoing history we participate in by conjuring it, a
time and space in which it is always the first day of Creation. Invok­
ing this story, any time, any place, we reenter the Garden of Eden to
invent our universe from scratch. In that spirit, to orient ourselves
for looking ahead, let's look back:
One million years 0/exploration and discovery!The first human be­
ing to climb Mount Everest reached its peak 20,000 years ago. What,
you don't believe it? Do you think Columbus, or Leif Ericsson, or
the Phoenicians, for that matter, were the first to discover America,
too? Do you think people really spent the first nine hundred and
ninety millennia huddled in caves, motionless and terrified-is that
how human beings reached Greenland and Hawaii from the forests
of Africa? Imagine all the journeys we undertook in the past mil­
lion years-expeditions and escapades that would be unbelievable
to our historians even if they weren't invisible to their instruments.
Remnants of these linger in our fairy tales still.
In prehistoric times, energy not expended on survival must have
been employed as children still employ it during camping trips today:
to devise and narrate stories, explore untrodden spaces, plot impos­
sible voyages and sometimes carry them out. Surely, unconstrained
by apartment leases, border guards, and ticket prices, people expe­
rienced more joy in traveling than frequent-flier businessmen do
now; adventure was the order of the day, not something imitated
annually on tourist vacations. And just imagine what they encoun­
tered when they traveled! A week's trek brought them into another
282. History as We Live It
ecosystem, into contact with unfamiliar cultures and creatures-a
far cry from the identical airports and hotels our unfortunate busi­
nessmen deem their natural environment. We still set out on such
journeys today wherever one of us goes off the map; hitchhiking
for the first time from Amsterdam to Stockholm, exploring the dis­
used train tunnel that runs through the darkness under Providence,
Rhode Island, we cross paths with the woman who first ascended
Mount Everest.
One million years 0/ women's liberation and gender mutiny! It's
common knowledge that matriarchal societies preceded patriarchal
ones-but "matriarchy" is simply an abstraction coined by unimagi­
native men to describe what they can only picture as the reverse of
to day's gender relations. Those were days when gender as we know
it had yet to be invented, when women were revered as bearers of
the spirit world and anybody could be one.
The Amazons were only one among hundreds of tribes of pow­
I erful women who fought to keep these mysteries alive after the
emergence of patriarchy. Patriarchal empires built the Great Wall
of China as a desperate defense against the Samartians, a nation of
horsewomen who lived without masters and were buried in their ar­
mor; according to Herodotus, a woman of their tribe would not take
a lover for herself until she had slain a man in battle. The witches
who followed them eighteen centuries later were keepers of the same
secrets, as we are today when we organize underground abortion
services and share herbal alternatives to medical dogma. We gather
in trans- and woman-only spaces as our ancestors did at the dawn
of humanity and rediscover our powers as they discovered theirs,
History as We Live It. 283
guided by goddesses who have lost their names only to receive new
ones. We still refuse all attempts to define or silence us, still devise
and revise our own genders, still take each other fiercely and fear­
lessly in strong arms and gentle hands. As Sappho declared, in the
words of Rita Mae Brown, an army of lovers shall not jail.
One million years of squatting, graffiti, and punk rock! For over
50,000 generations, our ancestors didn't shave their legs or armpits
or wear deodorant. They scavenged food like modern trashpickers
do, traveled like hitchhikers riding rivers and hopping ocean cur­
rents around the world, celebrated life with folk music made by their
friends, passed down folk culture they devised. You can bet some
of them had dreadlocks, some homemade tattoos and scarification,
some patches proclaiming their allegiances.
There used to be as many human beings in the world as there are
avowed anarchists today. Where once there were saber-toothed tigers,
there now are security guards; where later we had to fight Sumerian
mercenaries and Roman legions to protect our liberty, today we face
corporate conglomerates and so-called democratic governments. We
were squatting caves before theyerected buildings-we painted graf­
fiti on those walls before sandblasting was invented-we were com­
posing our own songs before the radio waves were invaded-we met
to reach consensus long before the first ballot was tampered with!
When a few of us come together in any liberated, communal space
to share those songs and stories and strategies, we are participating
in the same tradition our ancestors practiced with their neighbors
one thousandgenerations ago. We can claim one million years of do­
it-yourself culture and resistance for our heritage; the tyrants only a
few senseless wars, asinine inventions, self-important treatises, and
short-lived empires-which we've always eventually razed to the
ground! The ruins of their failed nations, wrecked temples on hills
where metropolises stood mere centuries ago, foreshadow the end
they know awaits-our way stretches ahead of us infinitely, through
the entire future of our species: for as long as inhuman institutions
are made up of human lives, there will be resistance, and afterwards
there will be celebrations just as there are today. Our war can never
be entirely lost; theirs can never be won.
One million years of folk science, folk medicine, folk everything!
Did you know-people two thousand years ago took birth control
pills? They made them by boiling down the urine of female pigs.
284. History as We Live It
The early Egyptians, and those earlier than them in China and the
Middle East, having not invented a process for making iron, fash­
ioned iron tools from fragments of iron that arrived in meteors
fallen from the sky-there was an Egyptian hieroglyph represent­
ing "heavenly iron." The peoples of northwestern Greenland were
still doing this a century ago-polar explorer R.E. Peary was shown
three enormous meteorites which they had been visiting in yearly
pilgrimages for centuries to obtain tips for their harpoons.* As Thor
Heyerdahl demonstrated, several thousand years before the Roman
Empire, human beings were capable of circumnavigating the globe
in wash-through rafts hundreds of feet long; since solid-hulled boats
became common, the expertise to fashion such crafts has been lost
to all but a few isolated groups, but evidence suggests that the wash­
through model may have been better adapted for ocean travel than
its successor.
Proof remains at Stonehenge and on Easter Island that technology
is not a singular force that develops in a straight line, that different
technologies are always evolving and disappearing-the ones who
insist that such marvels must be the work of extraterrestrials just
reveal how colonized their imaginations are by modernist indoc­
• Here's the bad news: In return for the trust of those who shared this wonder
with him, Peary stole the meteorites and sold them to the American Museum
of Natural History in New York-decimating traditionallifeways for personal
profit as European explorers always have. Once the meteorites had been re­
moved, Knud Rasmussen set up a trading post nearby to sell the locals what
they had once gathered freely-that's progress for you!
Peary also took six indigenous people back to NewYork, including a father and
his tiny child, exhibiting them to tens of thousands at an entry fee of twenty­
five cents. Afterwards, they were shut away in a damp basement at the Mu­
seum; within months, all but two of them had died of tuberculosis. Prominent
anthropologists "studied" them even as they were dying, but no one offered
them adequate medical attention.
The child, one of die two survivors, begged to be allowed to bury his father
properly according to his people's customs, but the Museum considered his
father's body to be its property, so the Museum staff staged a fake burial to
appease the boy. The four corpses were sent to Bellevue hospital for dissec­
tion. Years later, the boy was heartbroken to discover his father's bleached
bones on display.
And this was less than a century ago-not our civilization's barbaric past, but
the savagery that always occurs whenever capitalists interact with so-called
uncivilized peoples. The American Museum of Natural History did not return
the remains of the four victims to their clan until 1993. Next time you visit a
museum, remember the brutality, fraud, and theft upon which institutional­
ized science is built.
286. History as We Live It
I
•.
,. trination. The folk-scientific method, familiar to every adolescent
,r· astronomer with a cheap telescope and a notebook of personal dis­
coveries, has more in common with science as most human beings
have practiced it than anything the books tell us about Archime­
. des or Einstein. Omnipresent cultural propaganda insists that the
. present is utterly unlike the past, glorifying the "unprecedented
progress" of the present day as it simultaneously portrays that past
as a golden age to which there is no return-but the technologies,
medicines, and arts of today have analogs dating back perhaps to the
very beginnings of our species. No need to cling in fear to "modern
, technology" and the scant comforts it provides-this is the Dark
Age, if ever there was one!
So how do Wft make our own Enlightenment? How do we follow
inthe footsteps of those from the last fifty generations who defected
to make their own way through the world, leaving only cryptic mes­
sages scratched into trees behind them: Gone to Croatatt ...
History as We Live It . 287
Correspondences: Thor Heyerdahl and Other
FolkScientists, FolkSingers, FolkWarriors
When his colleagues insisted, on account of the vast distances in­
volved, that similarities between the technologies and folklore of
the ancient peoples of the Mediterranean, the Americas, and the
Polynesian islands must be coincidental, Norwegian Thor Heyer­
dahl left the ivory tower to test their theory. He contracted reed
boat builders from Lake Titicaca in Peru, some of the only people
in the world who still understand the complexities of such design,
to fashion the kind of vessel those ancient peoples used, and set out
288. History as We Live It
with an international crew ("a Russian, an African, a Mexican, an
Egyptian, an American, an Italian, and a monkey,,) to find out just
how far they could sail in one. In this boat, the Ra II, they sailed
from Morocco to Barbados in only fifty-seven days.
One can interpret Heyerdahl's project in the framework of West­
ern civilization's supposedly linear development of knowledge and
technology-he was simply adding to "the" store of human knowl­
edge, albeit by returning to the lost lore of the past. But Heyerdahl
himself tells it differently: in rediscovering a prehistoric form of
ocean travel, he felt a close kinship with the human beings who
had made this same journey in a similar craft. Outside the linear
timeline, the men on Heyerdahl's ship stood beside sailors on ships
:'. perhaps four thousand years earlier, gazing upon the same stars.
Speaking proportionately, once more: even on excursions like this
one that end up in the history books, less than one percent of what
takes place is recorded. The other ninety-nine percent is concealed
from historians but familiar to the rest of us.
Such correspondences between past and present human activi­
ties can be found everywhere: A woman adjusts a recipe her mother
passed down to her as her ancestors did six millennia before. Spanish
squatters decorate and defend their walls with fragments of broken
glass the way their forerunners prepared for Roman attacks. Nomadic
volunteers till organic farms as Celtic peoples did before them. An
r, adolescent runaway beholds Paris with the same wide eyes Rimbaud
did over a century earlier, as the first human beings to reach that site
must have at the dawn of time. A singer-songwriter discovers she
can make her language her own, just as Percy Shelley did; both share
the same sense of wonder experienced by the human beings who
invented the first words. Knowing he would be denied legal entry,
an anarchist with full facial tattoos rides a freight train across a na­
tional border to fight in the streets against his enemies as they meet
to discuss some new "free trade" agreement: this is tribal war.
History as We Live It. 289
"At night, when the tropical stars twinkled from the black sky and
a myriad of phosphorescent plankton twinkled back from the sea,
we too felt like gods on a flying carpet in the universe. There was
nothing but us on the raft, surrounded by darkness and stars. We
could well understand the pre-Incan artists who depicted Kon Tiki
and other bearded and hook-nosed deities as traveling on serpents
undulating among the stars, symbolically pulled along by bird-head­
ed men while they themselves enjoyed pulling in fishlines that had
hooked rays, sharks, or sea monsters. We too pulled in giant fishes.
Aboard our balsa raft, real life became like a fairy tale. After all, this
real life was a fairy tale. How else could one describe the fact that
the twinkling plankton in the sea around us were the ancestors of
the six of us who sat above water and looked down upon them?"
-Thor Heyerdahl in Green Was the Earth on the Seventh Day
290. History as We Live It
So there we were in the park, seated in a circle, just like the old
days-our own old days, and the olden days of our ancestors-trying
to negotiate the terms of a new alliance. We were the slaves who
revolted with Spartacus, the so-called Iroquois nation, the heroes
of the Spanish Civil War. And like the slaves, the so-called Iroquois,
the Catalan anarchists, we couldn't work out our differences, so we
were doomed.
After the bombing, the local liberal coalition had split in two; the
younger, more militant faction accused the government of putting
everyone in harm's way by provoking terrorist attacks, and called
a demonstration to publicize that charge. This marked a dramatic
shift: the same liberals had responded to attacks elsewhere with
hand-wringing and paralysis, decrying one war after another with­
out connecting war and occupation to the cycles that produced ter­
rorism. It turned out that this demonstration was to coincide with
a protest about climate change, so the two were combined into one
event under the banner "Preempt the End of the World."
Thanks to Pablo's efforts, our new group had been invited to give
teeth to the event. It only remained for us to hash out the details
among ourselves, but that was proving impossible.
As the conversation dragged on, each of us began to fidget with
whatever was closest at hand. Marshall was making little forts out
of twigs that had fallen from the branches overhead; Diego absent­
mindedly took the twigs and snapped them into smaller and smaller
pieces, flicking these carelessly over his shoulder; I found myself
meticulously splitting blades of grass into finer and finer strands.
An anthropologist from some future society, looking on without
understanding our speech, might have concluded that this fidgeting
was our chief activity. Perhaps that's what modern anthropologists
mean when they say our ancestors spent so much time at play: they're
just acknowledging that they can't figure out what our predecessors
were doing any more than the old-fashioned anthropologists who
interpreted the same activities as work.
"OK, friends, we're getting nowhere." Kate had patiently waited
her turn to state the obvious. "Our only hope is to break up into
smaller groups. Otherwise we'll still be here tomorrow morning."
Extinction. 291
We looked at each other dubiously. For almost two hours now,
we'd been talking around this: all of us desperately wanted to be
back in action, but our relationships were fractured, our trust bro­
ken. Kate continued with the quiet courage that distinguished her
from the rest of us. "Each person should have a partner. Pablo, do
you want to try working with me?"
This was a pointed gesture; Kate and Marshall had worked to­
gether in everything since the end of the occupation, at least until
Marshall told her about his relationship with me. Pablo hesitated.
"I guess 1 could. 1 mean, I'm not really qualified ..." He trailed off.
Diego broke the silence. "All right, I'll roll with Marshall-but
only with him."
1 looked at Marshall desperately. He tried to take Diego aside:
"Diego, if-"
Diego addressed himself to the circle. "Listen, 1 just came out of
two years and by the end of it no one was writing me except Marsh
here. 1have a fucking suspended sentence, 1shouldn't even be doing
this shit-1can't trust anyone 1don't go back with like that. 1know
all y'all need partners, but that's what 1 need, otherwise I'm out."
The other side of the circle was all new kids, watching this train­
wreck in hushed discomfort. They were still young enough that their
friendships hadn't been tried; they would have no trouble pairing up.
1didn't know any of them well enough to work with them, though.
"Where does that leave me, then?"
Diego pounced. "Well, where are your friends? Where's Rita?
Shouldn't she be here? How about Flake, or Snowflake or whatever
her name was, and all those other traveler kids you ran with? Did
they just melt away?"
1was speechless. Hadn't we already been through this years ago?
Marshall was angrily hissing something in Diego's ear. My lips were
trembling and my face felt hot.
Kate unhelpfully attempted to move the conversation along. "Re­
member, we have to set up the Center tonight, too. If we can't-"
"Fine, I'll go do that. You guys can work this out on your own."
"Samia-e-"
1 was out of earshot before he finished the sentence.
292 . Extinction
It was painful to arrive back at our space precisely because 1was so
excited about it. If only 1 could be disappointed with everything,
I'd be able to give up and stop hurting-and here we had finally se­
cured a two-story building with an industrial kitchen and space to
pack in over a hundred people.
1 passed the shuttered front and let myself in the side door. The
. main room was still in disarray: tables and chairs from the university
stacked against the wall, boxes of books for the library, cans of mis­
mixed paint, bags of bagels. At least the freezers were working so the
grocery program could expand without overwhelming the cramped
house that had hosted it. When this space was finished-when the
walls were painted, the shelves stocked with books, the computer
lab running, the stage built-it would be amazing.
But how much worse to be wedded to an amazing project with
such fucked up people! Everything 1 was involved in depended on
people like Diego-it was vulnerable to their caprices, their resent­
ments and vendettas, their selfish refusal to take others' needs se­
riously. How could 1 set myself up for heartbreak by committing
to things with them when they weren't committed to looking out
for me?
At the same time, how could 1 leave everything I'd worked so
hard to build? If 1was trapped here just as 1 had been in that office
building years ago, it was all the more insidious inthat it was my
own desires and aspirations holding me rather than mere fear and
inertia. It was like an abusive relationship in which my projects were
being held hostage rather than my children. 1 set down an armload
of boxes in the back room and went back for more.
Speaking of power dynamics, wasn't it typical that as the only
woman of color in the group 1was here cleaning up while everyone
else played action hero? It was certainly convenient that they could
Extinction. 293
look at this as a private conflict between me and Diego-white
people are always afraid to get involved when people of color are
at odds. As for Kate, wouldn't she have stood up for me if Marshall
and I hadn't gotten together? Why is it so hard for people to deal
with their relationships changing?
I moved a stack of posters promoting the demonstration off an­
other box and heaved it up to my chest. What were we doing pro­
testing terrorism and climate change, anyway? They were killing
us, for sure, but no protest was going to stop them. A group had
come through town a couple weeks earlier on a speaking tour about
global warming. To hear them tell it, within a few generations our
species was going to join all the species we'd already killed off in
extinction.
Our own mortality is terrifying enough: if every passing moment
is irrecoverable, how could we possibly live accordingly? What would
it take to rise to that challenge and really suck the marrow out of
life? I certainly wasn't doing it lugging boxes around in the dust.
But the extinction of the human race-now that's unthinkable.
It makes you shudder just to try to picture it, even though everyone
knows that, global warming or nuclear winter or not, all species die
out sooner or later. If it's painful to confront our individual failures
to seize each day in the face of our impending deaths, multiply that
by six billion.
I dropped another stack of boxes and gave up on clearing the
floor. Every day, each of us accepts countless indignities and defer­
rals of happiness in the faith that one day it will not be so. Whether
or not you believe in heaven, the future is always on hand to redeem
the squandered potential of the present-and the future of our spe­
cies is the ultimate insurance policy, the ultimate afterlife. When
we neglect to live out our dreams, we foist that responsibility on the
next generation; if we don't win liberation in our lifetime, there's
always the future, shining in the distance, when all our prophecies
are bound to come true.
But if that future is just an illusion, a projection, what then?
What if there will never be any happily-ever-after, any redemption,
any revolution? Tomorrow will arrive as insufferable as today, and
people will postpone everything again until every last one of us
has become a corpse-and it becomes clear we've all been corpses
all along.
294 . Extinction
I'd arrived at the top of the stairs; now I started up the ladder
to the roof. Even if we could shut down every factory, even if we
could undo the hundreds of years of pollution that caused global
warming, even if we disabled every warhead and overthrew every
government and burned down every prison, we were still all doomed:
as individuals, as a society, as a species. The world to come was a
vast graveyard.
The view from the roof lifted me out of these gloomy thoughts.
Night was falling and the first stars were sparkling overhead. Some­
where under those same stars there were roads I'd never traveled,
coastlines I'd never set foot upon, beautiful people I'd never met.
If the present and the future were both inescapable and irredeem­
able, didn't that render me weightless, debtless, free? Shouldn't I be
out traveling those roads, walking those coastlines, meeting those
people? What was I doing in this dismal place, anyway?
I came back to myself with a start. This was exactly the way I
started thinking every time I ended up skipping town. It probably
wasn't all that far off from Rita's train of thought around the time
she moved back and renounced her old beliefs. If I wanted to stop
going around in circles, I had to try to work things out with Mar­
shall and Kate and even Diego. Maybe it would be impossible, but
I had to find out the hard way.
I would be dust soon enough, perhaps along with my entire
civilization. All the rebels and heroes of the past-all the escaped
slaves and indigenous warriors, every Crazy Horse and Durruti­
were already dust alongside the mercenaries who killed them, the
anonymous masses who stood by, and the cowards who had wanted
to join them but always found excuses not to. That didn't take away
from their deeds. To act when everything will one day be nothing,
to stake your brief life on the rebellion of the dead-that's a way of
stepping off the conveyor belt of history, of ceasing to be a corpse
in waiting.
If Daniel had lived long enough to stand with me on that roof­
top, I imagined he would have stayed to fight. I climbed back down
the ladder to find material for a banner.
ExtinctIOn. 295
Remember the future? That golden vessel into which we poured all
our creativity, all our longings and fantasies and faith? It was to be
our crowning achievement, our vindication, our retirement program.
Now we cannot retire. Well, so much the better. In retrospect, one
might say it invested us with a patience that was unbecoming.
This is not to say we're glad to see it go. On the contrary, we re­
member the future with fondness and love, as a beautiful but lost
idyll that brings a grateful smile to our lips and a wistful gleam to
our eyes. But we must not tarry in the future, we must not be senti­
mental, however tempting that is-for we are needed here, now.
296. Nostalgia
In Kolkata, people were just starting to wake up outside the train
station. Their bodies lined the sidewalks for blocks, crowded onto
the filthy brick. Some were travelers waiting to depart, others penni­
less families who had lived there for months. Two centuries earlier,
carts had traversed these streets bearing the opium the British East
India Company used to addict the whole of China; in those days,
Kolkata was divided into White Town and Black Town.
A few blocks away uniformed guards stood at the closed gate of
an expensive hotel. Inside its walls, empty acres of carefully watered
grass extended in stark contrast to the brown city streets, assuring
foreign businessmen that it was safe to invest in eastern India. Kol­
kata was becoming a hub for information technology services; news­
papers spoke of economic resurgences and emerging markets.
. Outside the hotel's white walls, the first light of dawn fell on the
11 ubiquitous billboards, illuminating handsome models so pale-skinned
Darkncss i zcy
and Caucasian-featured an outsider would never have recognized
them as Bengali. Their white faces gazed down in silent judgment
upon the shiftless, the beaten, the anachronistic.
On the other side of the world, near billboards advertising the
same cosmetics, soft drinks, and cell phones with the same seem­
ingly white faces, a labor organizer in Bogota had stayed late at
his office to talk to a visiting journalism student. He was endeav­
oring to convey how the cold war of competition and class strug­
gle that went on invisibly in the student's country was a hot war
there: rainforests were being decimated, union militants abducted
and murdered, entire villages gunned down by paramilitaries. He
spoke of an accomplice class overseeing the wholesale pillaging of
his homeland and the reduction ofhis countrymen to mercenaries,
wage slaves, and prisoners. The student nodded, making notes for
his homework assignment.
In the first class seating of a modern airliner a few thousand
miles north and west, an executive switched back and forth be­
tween a spreadsheet and a text file on his laptop. On the other side
of his window shade the setting sun illuminated silver clouds and
cast mile-long shadows across the darkening landscape; but the
real world was composed of tasks and data and ratios and deals, not
clouds or rainforests. There were business opportunities in Calcutta,
or whatever they were calling that place now, and in Colombia too
despite all that damn unrest.
Miles below, Samia and I beheld the horizon from our post atop
the high-rise. Standing there in tremulous expectation, already dizzy
from vertigo and suspense, I experienced the sunset as a physical
movement through space, a ten-thousand-mile-per-hour backwards
somersault into the night. I'd had to wrench myself out of everything
I knew and break off all my old commitments to arrive there-but
finally, like the pioneers before me, I was flying.
We had the banner spread out along the edge of the roof, ready
to toss over and unfurl if only the march would arrive; they were
already over half an hour late. If anyone came up here, we were
going to look awfully suspicious with fifteen yards of cloth and
chain stretched out. I paced back and forth, fingering the padlock
I'd brought to close the trap door behind us in my gloved hand. At
last, reverberating off the building behind us so it sounded like they
were coming from the opposite direction, we heard them. First it was
:2.98. Darkness
I,
')
\\'
\,
~ '
J ~
'"
just a distant bass rhythm, subtle enough that it could have been a
; figment of my imagination; then that pulse swelled to a roar, until
"it was unbelievable that we could be hearing such an incredible din
I, and still looking at an empty street.
He was still in the middle of his work, but the flight was draw- ,
;' ing to an end. The stewardess mechanically recited instructions over
the intercom: "Please turn off all electrical devices and return all
Lseat backs and tray tables to the upright and locked position." He'd
", heard those words so many times he could practically chant along
like a devout Catholic at Mass.
Irritated, he closed his computer and impulsively slid up his win­
dow shade as he might have decades ago in childhood. In the gath­
~ \ ering gloom, one could no longer see the remaining trees or rivers
" below-only the lighted streets, the cars on the freeway, the electrical
,':: grid. The city spread out before him like computer circuitry, pure
, architecture of power and transmission. It was reassuring, all that
magnificent order, like the endless cornfields in Iowa, the airwaves
'. sold and portioned out, the rigid timetables of the TV Guide. Those
,,;, poor saps, invisible and interchangeable below him-they had no
idea of the larger context they existed in. Only men like him, with
[; specialized skills that took decades to amass and what the Rand Cor­
rporation called "topview," could take it all in and act decisively. It
was a stressful job-the long hours, the gulf between him and others
who didn't understand-but someone had to take it on.
Suddenly he was staring into impenetrable blackness-all he
could see was his own spectral reflection in the airplane window.
The lights of the city had blinked out.
From our rooftop, breathless with anticipation, we watched the
march come into view around the corner. People poured into the
intersection, filled it, and continued down the street while more and
, more appeared around the corner behind them. I hadn't seen such a
crowd since our heyday. It gave the situation an air of unreality.
The moment was upon us. We double-checked the carabin­
ers that anchored the banner to a pipe along the roof, then Samia
took up position at one side and I went to the other. Each of us
gathered up an armful of the material and together we hurled it
out into space. The fabric that remained on the rooftop between
us was pulled after, then the chain snapped taut and our ban­
ner unrolled forty feet down the building for all to see, reading
Darkness. :2.99
" The world is coming to an end. Make no mistake about it, the days
, are numbered. Where you are, you can't even imagine what it will
,'be like when the bottom hits.
I,
Or, to put it differently, the world is always ending. What comes
next is up to us. Every morning we wake up and sweat and bleed to
put an exact duplicate of the previous day's world in its place. We
need not do this, but we do, out of fear, or despair, or psychotically
deluded petty ambition, or sheer stubborn lack of imagination, At
any moment we could all stop paying rent and going to work­
nothing could stop us if we all deserted together-and rebuild
society from scratch without landlords or loan payments. Heaven
knows we've all had that daydream at least once. It's not police or
politicians that keep the wheels turning and the bodies burning,
it's our own compliance and complacency, not to mention lack of
faith in each another.
Yet even if we insist on keeping at it, the Disaster is not sustain­
able. Capitalism as we know it is not going to be here in five gen­
erations-any environmental scientist can tell you that. Likewise
no one has to argue for the destruction of the middle class-it's
already destroyed: it is the class of people laid waste by their own
materialism and duplicity, suffering emotional and psychological
consequences to which any psychiatrist can attest. It's no longer a
question of whether the system we grew up in has created the best
of all possible worlds-everybody knows the answer to that ques­
tion by now-but of how we're going to handle the mess next time
the terrorists get through the checkpoints, the fuel supply runs out,
the computers and power plants break down. Considering other op­
tions, trying them out, that's not radical-it's just common sense
when the writing is on the wall.
But are we really going to live to see anything else? Do we dare
hold our breath for another world?
Despite the seriousness of our situation, the future isn't one
monolithic, inescapable doom. There are several futures ahead of
us, just as today there are people who live side by side but inhabit
different worlds; which one you live to witness will depend largely
on what you do in the meantime. This nightmare exists precisely to
the extent that we invest ourselves in it-every day we work for it,
buy from it, and stake our lives on it, we are buying into the protec­
tion racket that keeps it the only game in town. Correspondingly,
The Future. 305
the world of our dreams exists to the exact degree that we behave
as if we're already living in it-there's no other way it can come to
be. The turning point for each individual is the turning point of
society, in miniature. Don't ask when or whether that point will
come, but how you can reach yours; if you can get there yourself,
everyone else can too.
When you really start to go for it, when your actions open a bona
fide portal to another way of life, others will come out of hiding
and join in. What, did you think you were the only one going crazy
here? It takes an entire subjugated nation to keep things running,
and there are plenty of others among that number who know how
little they're getting out of it. They are the millions who don't get
consulted for newspaper polls, who might pick you up hitchhiking
but never appear on television. Ten thousand sleeper cells wait for
the point of criticalmass to arrive, ready to spring into action with
their own yearnings to breathe free and private scores to settle,
desperate for a war to fight in that really matters, a love to fall in
that can command their attention-killing time and themselves in
the meantime with anorexia and alcoholism, dead marriages and
deadening careers. Every day each of us puts off taking the risks we
know we need to take, waiting for the right moment to come or for
someone else to make the first move or just feeling too beaten to try,
we have the blood on our hands of every suicide who couldn't hold
out any longer, every ruined love affair that couldn't endure in the
vacuum, every sensitive desperado artist buried inside the corpse of
a miserable service industry employee.
Next time the end of the world comes, we won't be paralyzed
watching it on television. We'll be out there deciding for ourselves
what comes next, cutting down the transmitter poles with chain­
saws if need be to get others to join us.
It's not too late to live like there's no tomorrow-all hope for the
future depends on it. Say your last words now, and start from there
with whoever joins in. Dreams do rebel and come true.
306. The Future
"
'.
f.
.
"
.
; "There are pigs out front!" We were in the Center, in inky darkness,
, and the police were outside. I didn't know how many there were
; or how dose; they'd come after I'd arrived, and I hadn't made my
. way through the press of bodies around the side door yet to check
: things out.
"Someone who's on the lease go talk to them! Tell them this place
had nothing to do with the march! Try to figure out what they're
d I"
gomg to o.
I'd been trying without success to find Pablo or anyone else as­
sociated with the space since I arrived. I was lucky enough to be
f equipped with the flashlight I still carried from the days I'd camped
j with Kate at her father's place; everyone else was picking slowly
tthrough the crowded darkness with their cell phones open, looking
.for familiar faces in that ghostly light.
The police accompanying the demonstration had panicked the
moment the power went out. Most of them backed off and started
,radioing for instructions, but the officer near us got shoved in the
'confusion and started pepper spraying everyone around him. The
rowd fell back in panic and rage, and a second later windows were
rashing in up the street. Despite my years of experience, I lost track
,-:f Diego; it was impossible to differentiate between masked running
ures in the sudden darkness. I took the arm of a woman who had
en pepper sprayed and walked her through the fray.
"Can you see?"
"Yes-I mean, no." She was small, somewhat older than me, wear­
.ga floral dress. A police car rammed into the crowd behind us and
e spun around blindly: "Puck you, you FUCKING BASTARDS!"
r someone I assumed had never been in this situation before, she
emed pretty composed.
Countdown to Civil War. 307
"My name's Marshall. We're going to an alley, I'm going to help
you with your eyes. Step up" - I put my arm around her shoulders
to steady her and lifted her a bit against my hip-"now. Hey, can I
get some water here?"
I got somebody to give me a water bottle and found the steps
of a fire escape, where I held her eyes open and poured the water
across them. If I'd had any idea things could turn out like this, I'd
have argued for us to have medics, scouts, lawyers, and hard banners
like in the old days. I was getting slack.
We emerged from the alley to find groups of ten and twenty
wandering the streets, trying to avoid the police. Ahead I could see
the roving spotlights of their cruisers, stark and ominous upon the
lightless walls of the city. This new generation didn't know anything
about dispersal. I yelled for people not to follow us, but a small army
tagged along at what they must have thought was a respectful dis­
tance. After we arrived at the Center more and more people filed
in behind us until the darkness was electric with excited voices and
nervous energy.
My flashlight fell on someone I recognized from the planning
meetings. He had no cell phone to light his way, and this instantly
endeared him to me; I'd pegged him as the type who had no phone
or car because he had defaulted on the payments, not for ideologi­
cal reasons. "Have you seen Diego? Or Kate? Who have you seen?
Are you OK?"
"Wait, who's there? I heard they arrested a bunch of people.
Me, I'm fine."
A voice from somewhere behind me: "Marsh! Over here!" It was
Diego.
That was a fucking relief. "You should probably get out of here­
this is a bad idea, everyone coming back here like this."
"Ah, it's hard for me to take it seriously. It's like, oh yeah, I re­
member, this is the part where we're trapped in the convergence
center-this is pretty realistic!"
"Yeah,we'd have a hard time staging a drill like this on purpose! But
hopefully this'll give some of these new folks the experience-"
"OK everybody!" It was Sarnia's voice. She was standing on some­
thing, holding a flashlight so her face was a little star in the darkness.
"The police scanner says they've arrested four people. We don't have
names yet. If anyone saw people getting arrested, come over here."
308, Countdown to Civil War
,.'
.
People were shouting out questions around the room: "What
, about the cops? Are they going to raid us?"
"Forget it," Diego yelled. "There's no way they're gonna risk that
.when they don't know what this place looks like inside, they don't
.know how many of us there are, they can't see anything, and the pow­
,; er's out in the whole neighborhood-they got their hands full."
His tone reminded me. "Diego-as soon as things cool down,
we have to talk about shit with you and Samia and everyone else.
I'm serious."
"Yeah, all right." He sounded noncommittal.
Pablo was standing on the chair now with the flashlight. "If
anyone here was hit or pepper sprayed, I'll be in the back room in
five minutes shooting video. We can use these for lawsuits. It's ex­
tremely important that if you were injured or sprayed you make a
.f statement right now while your memory is still fresh."
I made my way back to the kitchen, where I'd last seen the woman
:\ I arrived with. There were two candles on the countertop, and in their
, flickering light she and a couple other people had stripped naked and
, were using the spray faucet from the sink to wash off. They were get­
ting water all over the floor, but under the circumstances that seemed
pretty insignificant. "Did you all hear that about the video footage?
If you want to make a statement, they'll be recording here in five
minutes." Someone in the front room was making an announcement
\ about proper care for those who had been pepper sprayed.
Where was Kate? I knew she could take care of herself, but it
was impossible not to worry. Another person was standing on the
chair: "So if you absolutely need to leave, go in a small group, one
.group at a time, and call as soon as you've gotten to safety!"
"Wait, my phone's not working! Is anyone here getting service?"
tAclamor of voices.
Somebody got up on a chair on the other side of the room, us­
"ing his cell phone for illumination. "OK, the power's out all around
'here, who wants to go out andluck shit up?"
That probably would have been me a few years earlier, but now I
just found it annoying and a security risk to boot. "Don't just smash
'Windows," I shouted. "Go to the supermarkets. Do you realize how
much food they'll be throwing away tonight? If all that comes back
here, the whole city will eat free for a week. We might need it, if
:this keeps up!"
Countdown to Civil War. 309
I heard Pablo's voice beside me. "You OK? Did you see Kate?"
"Yeah, I'm fine-no, I haven't. Is she here, is she all right? By the
way, thanks for going with Samia. That was fucking awesome."
"Kate's out front, dealing with the police. So what do you think,
was it one of ours or one of theirs?"
"The power, you mean? Fuck, you think this is terrorist shit again?
I just assumed it was an accident."
"It's possible it was an accident, or even one of us, but it's also
possible we got upstaged. We have to think about how to handle
this. If their actions outpace ours, they get to set the terms and
then all anyone sees is government versus terrorists, no space for
liberation at all."
Everything was coming to a head, whether we were ready or not.
Someone squeezed my arm. It was Kate.
"You're OK?"
"Yeah. You?"
"Yes. Come with me, there's someone who wants to see you." She
led me through the crowd to the side door; compared to the pitch
darkness within, there was actually a tiny bit of light there.
It was Walter. He was the last person I'd expected, especially in
the midst of all this. "Man, y'all got some chaos going on up here! I
thought it was crazy where we are!"
"Walt! What's going on! What brings you here?"
"I'll make it simple, 'cause I can see y'all are busy. Youknow they've
been threatening to evict Ethel, and it came out they're set to do it
tomorrow. We were wondering if you could get some of your folks
together to help us discourage them, if you know what I mean."
"Uh, yeah, um-" I looked at Kate in the glow of distant police
headlights; she raised her eyebrows and nodded. "Do you want to
make a statement about it? You're the public speaker."
"Naw, these are your people. You should do it."
"Well-" I hesitated. "OK, come with me." We made our way
back through the crowd into the darkness. Ethel, of all people!
Those motherfuckers!
"Do you know' what time? Should we be there all day?"
"I'd reckon so. Never know, they might not come at all if the
power's still out." Walter put his hand on my shoulder. "You know,
if this works, folks in our neighborhood are gonna be a lot less ea­
ger to pay rent."
310. Countdown to Civil War
I stepped onto the chair and pointed the flashlight up at my face.
It.I
"
t
.

![
l
, "Hey everybody!" A lot of people were still talking; I started over with
: the booming voice I'd used at a town council meeting once long ago.
'"HEY EVERYBODY! My friend Ethel has lived in the same house
rfor something like twenty years! I've been seeing her there every
, Thursday for the past five, and she is the most welcoming, gener­
IOUS person I know! Some of you might remember Ethel from the
'.strike at the university a few years back-maybe you thought we
that, but she lost her job a couple years later and now the real
'!'estate motherfuckers want to kick her out of her house!"
There was respectful silence in the room now. "I know some of
i!:yOU think you have to be at work or school in the morning, but I
to know how many of you are gonna be with me tomorrow at
';J\thel's house to make sure no one can get her out!"
There was raucous cheering from all around; it surprised me.
how many of you are down?"
"I'm serious!" a voice cried out. "Hell yeah!" another echoed.
Someone had found an oil lamp and was carrying it into the
,tenter of the room; titanic shadows raced across the high walls as
passed through the crowd. I stepped down off the chair. For the
irst time since I'd arrived, I could see the faces of the people around
, e; everyone pressed in, eagerly asking questions and suggesting
,rategies. I could see Walter, Kate, Samia, Diego, and a dozen newer
Pablo was in the back room, filming.
Only then did it strike me that the thought of suicide hadn't
rossed my mind once in weeks. I met Kate's eyes and my own filled
tears. We'd survived.
Countdown to Civil War. 311
Leaving the 21 st Century.. ~
When our ancestors first hacked down the forests that had sheltered
them since time immemorial to build fences, they laid the founda­
tions for the world we live in today. In place of gifts and sharing,
we have competition and imposed scarcity-corporations develop
and manufacture more and more new commodities in order that
something may still be scarce enough to fight over while our land­
fills overflow with surplus. In place of our faith that nature would
provide for us, we have the defenses science affords us as it spins the
last of our natural resources into war machines and toxic waste. In
place of the joys of wandering new and changing landscapes, we have
cities that double as corporate theme parks linked by dual tourist
and commuter tracks-while the final fugitive aspects of existence
are reduced to binary code for virtual reality.
Perhaps this world will never be free of misfortunes-people
will always die before they are ready, just as magical love affairs
will end in ruins, adventures be cut short by catastrophes, and mo­
ments of bliss be forgotten. But what is most heartbreaking is the
way we flee from those inevitable truths into more horrible things.
It may be true that every one of us is fundamentally on her own,
that life is capricious and cruel-but it doesn't have to be true that
some people starve while others destroy food or buy mansions. It
doesn't have to be that men and women are forced to squander their
lives working to serve the hollow greed of a few rich men just to
survive; it doesn't have to be that we let meaningless traditions and
doctrines autopilot our lives into bewildering voids. It doesn't have
to be that we never dare to tell each other what we really want, to
share ourselves honestly, to use our talents and capabilities to make
life more bearable-let alone more beautiful. Those are unnecessary
tragedies, stupid tragedies, pathetic and pointless. It's not even uto­
pian to demand that we put an end to farces like these.
Our fear of failure restrains us from letting ourselves believe
that these absurdities can be transcended. But fear, once recognized
for what it is, can serve a different purpose: if we make a practice
of doing what we fear most, our fears can guide us more reliably
than any compass beyond the unnecessary boundaries we have built
around ourselves and into new worlds.
31.1. Leaving the 21" Century
I think of you all the time, dear reader. Who are you? Why have
you read this far? What is your story? There are so many things we
could discuss-but time is drawing short. We'd better start tying
up loose ends.
You'll want to know how much of this is true. All these things
happened, but not precisely as described. Yes, we smashed the win­
dows, but not those particular windows. We sneaked into the caf­
eteria and pulled the fire alarm, but perhaps not at the same time.
We dropped out of school, divorced our spouses, and quit our jobs,
but over and over we went back to school and applied for other jobs
and returned to our partners on our knees. We struggled with de­
spair and dissension, but we also had to deal with addiction, sexual
assault, our own deeply ingrained racism. We changed our genders,
fought with our parents, had children and quarreled over how to
raise them; there's so much that doesn't appear here.
It would have been better to tell these stories they way they
happened, but we couldn't run that risk when the trails had yet to
cool. Besides, reality evades any net: to be true to life, we would
have had to tell the story of the whole world, extending infinitely in
every direction. We had to content ourselves with this, incomplete
as it is. Think of the tales we'll be able to tell around the fire after
all this is over and each of us can finally take credit for her feats of
courage and cunning!
Perhaps you'll want to meet us; unfortunately, that's not pos­
sible. You can never meet the characters in a book, even if they are
real people. Better you get to know us here and real people in real
life than conflate the two.
Anyway, the important thing is not who we are, but who you
are-and what you're going to do.
314. Dear Reader
i.
a building without a blueprint,
a party without a platform,
an experiment without a hypothesis,
a mission without end,
a quest without objective,
a desire without object
'!When they insist that you outline your alternative world for them,
~ i t h every possibility accounted for and every detail mapped out,
refuse. This isn't a new attempt to program everything and everyone,
~ r a new formula that will finally force all the organic complexity of
, ·,Ying into the mold of some theoretical ideal. This is a way of doing
,;hings, not a new standard to march under, not another system­
's an approach to life, to solving the problems we have right now
.d then solving the next ones. It works right now in some places,
morrow it will work in others, and we can hope that one day it
.ill work everywhere.
Would they hold up the ravaged present they've made as proof
r nothing else is possible? Better find out what else is possible in
. is present, and go from there. Would they brandish the vast un­
rtainty of the future as an objection to our fantasies of a better
rld? Better then throw out all planned futures, theirs first of all,
.dthen only this remains: what do we do now, continue around
circles or blast the fuck out?
Where We're Going. 317
In the middle of summer, when the dying sun bled the blue sky
orange, the movement began. At first it was no more than a tremor, .
but slowly it increased to a rumble, an upheaval, an earthquake,
and everyone ran to see what was going on.
"The reasonabl e adapt themselves to the world;

the unr easonabl e struggle to alte r it: therefore all
• I
progress depends on the creatively maladjusted,
The one who listens to reason is lost-reason
ensla ves all m inds not str ong enough to resist."
'Oil-Ut-TRA:!!JT!J TO ~
t-A990et:'_
e
.e- . ', ·',.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is the antidote to everything stifling in de-,
mocracy and polite society. Ultraists wage a life-and-death war against
consensus reality for the liberation of all and of all other realities.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is a provocation) that's for sure. Both the
devil and the devil's advocate ar e Ultraists, and they've done more
for freedom and range of thought than God ever has.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is the art of following every idea through to
its logical conclusion. It means never doing anything by half. Ultraists
mortify underhanded politicians by putting everything on the tabl e
for all to see. Even and especially when they are wrong, Ultraist s do
everyone the gre at service of revealing the virtues and weaknesses
of theories and strategies in their purest forms. Every community
needs a few Ultraists around to t est out new possibilities.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM opens up hori zons: every Ultraist is a
pioneer. The Ultrai st escapes disc iples, and yet enables others who
would never have dared before to try positions similar to her s. The
Ultraist set s a precedent) making it possible for the less openly radi­
cal to give themselves permission to explore the middle gr ound that
opens up between the "mainstream" and the radical.
Infl amed Appendix , 323

.
....
.
'.
./
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is not dogmatic or doctrinaire. To be an •
Ultraist is not to surrender one's self or senses; orthodoxy, fanaticism,
these are simply competing brands of Standard. The true Ultraist in­
vents her own ultimates and issues her own ultimatums.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM does not call for converts; it is a challenge
to all to establish themselves at extremes of their own.
324 . Infl amed Appendix
ULTRAISM is not a competition or a standard of mea­
sure for some new elite. More-ultra-than-thou is a contest without
meaning-there are extremes enough for everybody. Moreover, the
practice of transgressing boundaries and pushing limits reveals that
there is no "cent er," and so no extremes either:
Thus MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is non-hierarchical; no self-respecting
Ultraist looks down upon others as "less Ultra" than herself-to do
so would be to accept the conformist myth that there is a standard of
normalcy at all. The true Ultraist recognizes that all are extremists:
that the mainstream is a myth of the sheepish and sheeplike.
r_ MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is not about getting dolled up in a suit
. and tie for the administration, practicing diction for the cameras, or
adopting local customs to seduce recruits. Insincerity is the founda­
I tion of this sick society; people have learned to smell it a mile away
/ .
just to survive. You're not doing anyone any favors by reinforcing its
~ I ~ this \s t rue, then all are Ultraists whether or not t hey embrace Max­
• irhum Ultrai sm. In that case, an exhortation to Ultraism, su ch as this
. one, s ho uld not be re ad as an attempt to persu ad e peop l e t o choose
- one mariner of co mmi tt ing themselves ove r another, but rather as
,'.
.refutat ion of the alibis of moderation
nd deference to popular opinion.
'

' ."
Inflamed Appendix . 325:•.
.,
.'e' .' ..
·it­
ubiquity in your own activities, nor by insulting their intelligence
and passion assuming they aren't ready to be as radical as you secret­
ly are. Likewise, Ultraists don't disguise themselves as moderates to
work with others towards moderate goals-your average group of
moderates is just a bunch of closeted Ultraists waiting for partners
with whom to go for it.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is a deliberate attempt to alienat e the mass­
es-for who is the greatest enemy of liberty and individuality, if
not masses? Besides, let's not kid ourselves: those "masses" are the
ones forming militias, gunning each other down in post offices and
high schools, joining cult groups that promise immortality through
self-castration-these people crave extremism, they're desperate for
it! If all they ne eded to "join the movement" was a radicalism that
looked exactly like the politics they're familiar with, the Green Party
326 . Infl amed Appen dix
would have won the last election. No, people are holding out for a
• different way of life, If your radical stance has isolated you, maybe
. it 's because you haven't gone far enough.
/ .
Enthl,).81'asts.of MAXIMUM ULTRAISM aren't afraid of looking like
the radicals they are. Bashfulness, embarrassment, watering-down­
nothing makes us look mote like we have something to hide in our
politics than these. Ultraists' positions are more attractive for being
held with confidence and without apology; in the long run, endless
. alienate more people than they placate.
MAXIMUM ULTRA1:SM is failsafe, anyway. The Ultraist can set
people againsthimself and his ideas if he does something harmful
to others. This makes him less dangerous to society than the moder­
ate, ;""ho can do a great deal of damage through common, accepted
"Practices without attracting any attention at all.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM can complement positions and tactics
perceived to be less radical. Some, who take stances they see as
moderate, accuse Ultraists in the same camp of alienating their
constituency-but in fact , such Ultraists can make those positions
attractive to people and force their enemies to make concessions
by providing a less palatable alternative: "Parley with us, or you'll
have to deal with . . . the Ultraists."
Needless to say, no one associated with MAXIMUM ULTRAISM
conducts surveys or gives a good goddamn about statistics. You're
responsible for your opinions and choices; a glance at recent history
shows that the majority knows best only by chance. Life is not some­
thing to be voted on-you have one of your own, it's all you have to
work from, no one else can know better what's ri ght for you. The
paralysis of "wait ing until you've learned enough about the issues"
does no one any good-draw some conclusions from your experi­
ence and act on them! Those who see an expression of their secret
selves in your actions, or who stand to benefit from what you're
dOing, will take notice and join in.
MAXIMUMULTRAISMwill not alienate your peers-it will win you
the recognition of the most daring and passionate among them.
Inflamed Appendix 327
NIHIUSTS! Of« ....
tFf'QVF 'OJ .".,. 10.

.
I
But let it not be said that MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is not for the
"-'eak of heart-Ultraism"is a way to develop strength of heart. To
!n6ve daily through a world that contradicts and denies your values,
your very existence, is to forge a firmness of character that cannot
be undercut by any peer pressure or passing fad. Ultraists can be
counted upon to say what they feel and practice what they preach;
they have nothing to lose and nothing to hide. An Ultraist, if she is
of the same mind as you, is the most reliable ally you can find.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM buries treasures for the future. Think of
all the geniuses and visionaries who died marginalized and unsung!
If they had worked instead to water down their revelations and ad­
just their visions to their times, they would have cheated us all of
these riches. We should be thankful they were far-sighted enough
to isolate themselves so they could channel into being the world
that was to come. Seclusion, obscurity, the mask of insanity-these
can enable one to discover truths and possibilities invisible to those
blindered by expectation and the demands of being realistic. We can
all be such geniuses, if we trust and follow our own visions. A com­
mitment to Ultraism signifies faith in the boundless fertility of the
imagination and the endless possibilities of the universe.
]28 , Infl amed Appendix

MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is a holistic way of life wedding theory to
practice. The Ultraist's beliefs play an active role in her day-to-day
existence-hers are not mere conversation pieces to be trotted out
at dinner parties! By working out her own principles and acting io/
accordance with them, by taking herself and her destiny
enough to refuse any walk-on role in the scripted spectacle of some
Silent Majority, she is guaranteed a leading role in a life story of
adventure: high stakes to play for, triumphs to achieve, tragedies
to suffer. Boredom, feelings of insignificance and impotence, these '
will be the least of her many problems. When she laughs, she laughs
all of her laughter; if she cries, she cries all of her tears. An Ultraist
may live a life of desperation, but you can bet your bullet'S it won't
be a quiet one. .0
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is the opposite of the happy medium pro­
moted by the happy media. It is a challenge to those who oppose' .
concentration camps in the name of moderation-a moderate deg·ree/
of control, a moderate degree of freedom, a moderate degree of
and a correspondingly moderate degree of death. Ultraists cC?unter '
this with a passionate dedication to life-for the C?nes dedicated to '
death are no longer with us!
• w ­
MAXIMUM ULTRAISMis unique in its every manif est at ion.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM cannot be co-opted.
MAXIMUM ULTRAISM is radically
de m ocratic. Individual Ultraism is an
act of solidarity with all others believing,
dreaming, and acting outside the lines.
For a revolution without limits,
against restraints and restraint!
Lona live the suoerlative!
330. Inf lamed Appe ndix
Afew years before all this started, the environmental acti on group I
briefly worked for sent canvassers around to raise awareness about
the harmful effects of the nuclear power plant that supplies elec­
tricity to our whole county. One of them ended up at a doorstep out
past the edge of town-at Kate's father's house, as it turned out. The
young activist rang the bell and delivered his spiel to the grizzled
veteran who answered the door; the latter listened patiently for
its duration, interrupting only to swear in outrage at the accounts
of injustice and contamination. Concluding his pres entation, the
youngster politely explained that the action group was collecting
contributions, which were tax deductible, and invited the older man
to sign a petition. The latter was nonplussed: "You' re telling me these
scumfucks are destroying the land we live on, and you want me to
sign a petit.ion? What good is that going to do?"
"Well.. sir, we-"
"1£ what you say is true, we should be going after these mother­
Iuckers with guns! Seriously, that's just a piece of paper-are people
gonna do something about this, or what?"
"Yes, er, but-we have to start somewhere, and . . ."
"Son, if you're not gonna be any help, run along-you're on the
clock right now anyway, right? I'll take care of this myself."
Kate's father called up the power company and asked them if
what he'd heard about their plant was true. He found their evasive
swers unconvincing, and demanded that they send a truck to dis­
engage his house from their system. I can only imagine the bewil­
derment of the representative who took his call:
"Excuse me, sir?"
"That's right, I need you to send somebody right now to discon­
nect me from the grid. We're through with your services for good."
"I'm sorry, sir .. . I'm not sure there's any-I mean, I've never heard
of anyone asking to have their power disconnected like this-"
"Listen, I'm not just asking to have the power disconnected, I'm
telling you you better take down the whole rig, wires and all, and
get it the hell off my property, or else I'm gonna do it myself! And
don't think you can get away with this bullshit anymore. We're onto
your tricks now, you scum-sucking leeches."
That's why his house didn't have electrical power when we went
there after that march. Give us one hundred women and men like
him and we'll finish this thing right now.
Dlsconnecung t he Power. 331
What Is Crimethink?
Crimethink can be reached from the subway station only by means
of a daring double somersault. It is only a mad dash away from the
checkout counter of the grocery store and a mere lobbed brick dis­
tant from the witness box of the courtroom, but it is much harder
to access from the closed playpens of your homes, schools, work­
places, and nightclubs-you practically have to be Joan of Arc with
hair aflame.
Crimethink is the ether with which the bourgeois are put to
sleep, perchance to dream. Sour people, sweet dreams. Crimethink
cannot be captured by the cameras of the photojournalists. Crime­
think is the watchword of those who die on their feet rather than
live on their knees, but are more likely to be found on the run in
between-like you, perhaps.
Crimethink is the burning bush in the desert of industrial soci­
ety, which can still be found between the thighs of the most mer­
cilessly free and beautiful. Crimethink is revenge for that fucking
flag they put on the moon:
Crimethink is the homeland of the homeless, of Obermensch and
underdog. Crimethink isn't a manner of speaking, but of acting; it
only takes the form of speech when speaking is acting. Crimethink
explains everything in the whole world, ins tance by instance, stop­
ping short of the abyss of abstraction-a process that isn't quite
finished, of course. Crimethink says to you: I put a spell on you, be­
cause you're mine.
Militants and dilettantes, you do well to put your stock in
crirnethink!' For the market manages the managers, hierarchy bosses
the bosses, capitalism owns the owners, but those who crimethink
for themselves are truly fr ee and wild.
* Very clever, bureaucrats-finally a flag we can't burn .
t Invest in Crimethink! Crimethink is the on ly savings bank that will st ill pay
interest after the fall of global capitalism. Cr imethink stoc ks soar with heart
rates and flying bricks-even and especially when the stoc k market cra shes.
Crimethink will make you the kind of fort une that favors the brave-we chal­
lenge you to find a better deal. The wealth afforded by Crimethink increases
according to the laws of cellular division. Crimethink works on the abundance
model-the more you cas h in your investment, the more it increases in value!
When the twilight of th e old gods arrives, you' ll be glad you traded in your
currency before it was too lat e.
About the Aut hors. 333
What Is CrimethInc.?
One must be enough of a crimethinker to adopt a crimethoughtful
st ance towards one's own crimethink. Crimethink is not Crime­
thIne.; it is, rather, the spirit of pl ayful destruction that-we can
only hope-saves CrimethIne. from itself.
CrimethIne. throws up contradictions the wa y others erect fenc­
es: to protect itself from ideology, from stiffening. CrimethIne. is
a secret-yet sends out a call to revolt that will be heard in every
corner of the Occupied Territories by the time you finish this very
sentence,"
Listen hard to silence, and you'll hear thunder deep inside.
CrimethInc. is the hip gnosis of a new yout h rebellion that goes
beyond both youth and rebellion. CrimethIne. is a Non-Prophet Or­
ganization. CrimethInc. is beautiful: it's ugly; where beauty is ap­
portioned in pageants and every pretty thing has been copyrighted
by greeting card companies, it is a foray into the unknown to seek
new veins of joy before we all suffocate like yeast in our own ex­
crement.
CrimethInc. is the cure for the cancers with which they propose
to cure cancer. CrimethIne. sweeps through the streets with fire and
banners and steals through the classroom in xeroxes and whispers.
CrimethIne. pilots the rudderless ships of the movement movement,
coded into the paths of those who trade bondage for vagabondage;
CrimethIne. smashes tourism and all other despicable formulas for
running in place.
CrimethInc. is the Last Loosening: it is here by order of those
out of order, so that nothing may ever be in order, or made to order,
again. 0 ye rabble without a cause, CrimethInc. is the ticket out of
here you've been waiting for-if you're willing to cash it in yourself,
that is. Crimethlnc. is what you do y ourself, nothing more.
CrimethInc. is constantly in effect whenever workers daydream,
everywhere a bank is being robbed, on airplanes passing over the
Brazilian coastline at sunrise. It ma intains office hours in squats
under riot squad siege occupied by boys and girls who have escaped
* Do n' t belie ve us? You've heard it, haven't you?
~ ,
334 . About the Auth ors
the suburbs to fall in love. Take the last night train from La Plata t o
Buenos Aires, and if the doors are open so you can sit on the steps
of the train listening to the young passengers beating out a samba
rhythm on the seats and singing along behind you as the Argentine
night speeds past, you might realize there is a letter or a novel you
need to write-and at that moment, you'll enter an outpost.
CrimethInc. is present wherever anything or anyone is on fir e.
CrimethInc.'s field of operations extends as far as there is crimethought,
and beyond:
it speeds through Arctic waters in the wake of comets f allen
and swallowed up by the cold,
into Russian citi es ringed by vast rivers at the end of winter­
the crack of thawing ice bellowing into the night,
arriving at the magn eti c poles" where compasses spin, and
moving on
to the bottom of th e ocean where the waterlogged corpses of
whales lie.
• It's imp ortant to point out here that the ma gnetic poles are not fixed-they
wander across the surface of the earth. Th at is, in fact, exactly the kind of voy­
age sanctioned and undertaken by Crimethlnc. operatives: invisible, detect abl e
only by effects registered thousands of miles away, yet of global import . ..
336. About the Authors
In Conclusion:
Obviously, gentlemen, if you fear for the
morality of your wives, the education of.
your children, the peace of mind of your
investors, the submissiveness of your
mistres ses and house pets, the solidity of
your armchairs and privatized prisons and
factory farms, the manner in which your
whorehouses are licensed and the security
of the State . . . then you are right.
But what can you do?
You are rotten)
and the fire has been lit.
But as for you would-be revolutionaries,
radicals wedded to a license witho ut
limits, girls and boys who love without
leave, we urge yo u:
More rigor in your recklessnes s!
More ambition in your hedonism!*
When you're young) and it f eels like you're
invincible) it's because you are.
From this moment f orth) no one shall ever die.
• ... and vice vers a, vicebeing the key word.
About the Authors 337
The text of this book is set 10/1 3 in the unique and pleas urable
Absara, and it s lovely italic, designed by Xavier Du pre in 2005·
The display face is t he plucky and indomitable Helvetica,
created by Swiss graphic designer Max Miedinger in 1957·
338 . Colophon
W hen they send in the National Guard, we'll take chainsaws to the
tel ephone polls to halt their progress-and they'll throwdown their
guns when they see their nieces and nephews on the other side of
the barricades. Tha t night, we'll drag all the furniture out of the of­
fices and department stores to build great bonfires in the intersec­
tions; we'll sit around them, passing food and drink and telling the
unbelievable stories of how we arrived there.
The next morning we'll venture out one by one, then in pairs, to
survey the remains-and perhaps after the initial shock it will appear
to us as a great playground. We'll gaze at the carcasses of the dead rna­
chines in wonder that we lived in a society powered by things beyond
our underst anding; from that moment forward our understanding
will be honed sharp by the challenges of building anew.
Some of us will still be angry, some will still be hurting; others
will climb to the tops of the great wreckage heaps to look out 111to
the sunrise, trying to see beyond it into the future, and sit there in
silence for a long, long time. We'll trace each other's scars with our
fingers, squeeze our hands together and shake our heads; perhaps
someone will sing softly.
We1l stand outside looted supermarkets, pitching soda cans and
hi tting themwith axe handles to see themexplode in the air, spinning
like pinwheels. We'll dress the lampposts in satin curtains, paint our
own names on the street signs, throw Christmas ornaments at each
other like snowballs. We'll string extension cords around the old
monument s to pull them down like the Communards did in Paris;
we'll empty the TV dinners from our freezers and throw them off
rooftops as we eat fresh apples from new trees. This is what it will
rake to rediscover that we are the masters of things and not they of
us. Wearing bri dal gowns and firemen's jackets, leaving a swath of
shattered dinner crystal in our wake, we'll cut a path to the gates
of heaven so wide no one can ever shut them again.
We'll tattoo our faces to celebrate that there are no more bor­
ders t o cross, that we can meet our oppressors in open war in­
stead of having to smuggle ourselves through their checkpoints.
Pollee stations will be evicted wherever they appear, officers will
walk the streets in fear of being picked up and t aken to squats,
Hijack the Moon. 339
The earth will give birth to stars that humble the heavens, and
we'll have hospitals without sick people where today we have sick
people without hospitals. Blacksmiths will once again swing their
heavy hammers through the air, forging crowns great enough to fit
on all heads at once. Driving through the wilderness across over­
grown freeways on-our species' last tank of gas, we'll see fireworks
shooting up into the night sky on the horizon-a flare saying "don't
rescue me!"
A decade to track down technicians to disable warheads and de­
activate nuclear power plants; a generation to replace grocery stores
with gardens and cough syrup with licorice root; a century for dairy
cows and toy poodles to go feral; five hundred years to melt down
cannons into wine goblets, water pipes, and sleigh bells; a millen­
nium for the dandelions growing ou t of the sidewalk to become
redwoods.
Or else none of this will happen, but we will have the adven­
ture of our lives; and if we meet again, we will build another castle
in the sky.
Dear fr iend
Where
I end
You begin.
3 4 ~ . Hijack the Moon

Expect Resistance

XP CT

I had long awaited a book that resisted all parallels with other books save the use of ink and type: a book through which I might wander, losing myself in labyrinths and coming upon fantastic citadels to which I could not retrace my steps; a book into which I might plunge, skipping pages as a little girl skips rope, never to return to the world in which I'd began­ emerging instead in another, or at least equipped to build one.

But if you have a secret self. over the fields and oceans. never daydreamed desperately in a board meeting or math class. off the highway. somewhere beyond the shopping districts and suburbs. never been car­ ried away by extremities of emotion while every­ one around you remained unmoved and oblivious.If you've never doubted the integrity of your superiors or their right to demand your obedience. If you've never fallen so deeply in love that it seemed you had been sleepwalking through life until that moment. read on. nor felt the sting of wishing for something that could not be found on department store shelves or voting ballots. . If you've never suspected that real life must be elsewhere. If there is no part of you left unfulfilled by stock options and prime time programming and cutting edge digital technologythen perhaps this is not for you.

Printed in Canada by unionized workers post-consumer recycled paper with soy-based ink. his friends gathered by his bedside and imploredhim to rescind the parts of his book that had seemed incredible to them-to water down its miracles by means of judicious deletions. "When the great explorer was dying. Please reproduce.~ Crimethink is the stirrings of a new world. or by means of www. the city street liberated for an hour during a demonstration. A variety of similar materials can also be obtained from Crimethlnc. Hop on. the shared meal free when the manager is away. Anything composed in any language is obviously the handiwork of the millions who developed the words and ideas that constitute it. with or without citing sources. translate. motherfuckers. Come and get us. and adjust this and all books at will." on 100% All texts and images plagiarized and rearranged by collective process. ex-Workers' Collective.com . thrown through plate glass windows on notes tied to bricks. surviving in defiance of all odds and adversaries. the dream that rebels and comes true. This is a chronicle of things that are going to happen.crimethinc. Crimethlnc. It is everything that evades control-the stolen sick-day at the seashore. N©! 2008 Crimethlnc. Skeleton Crew / PO Box 13998/ Salem OR 97309. but he responded that he had not recounted even half of what he had in fact seen. This is neither a true story nor a work of fiction. not just the experts listed in the credits. is the underground railroad from this world to the next. smuggled across every border in the heads and hearts of a dissident nation of millions. Additional copies of this book are available for $8 + postage.

we liver-and so we give you these frag­ ments. hastily scribbled notes from bygone in days when freedoms were fought for and won. . to spit in their faces . Like all such dust. They will say that." They will praise the product-product being their specialty­ and deny the evidence. Don't stir them up unless you're in the busi­ ness of starting fires. * They will say this. these embers and ashes may retain a certain charge that could help precipitate explosions in other lives.. They will imply that we could not have lived-but we do live. like generations of nihilists before us. this poorly charted record.They will say* that we refused everything to make a beautiful but utopian negation-as if it were just a work of art we were out to create.. Otherwise. if we fail. we uttered that grandiose denial and then were driv­ en by it into the wilds of oblivion and annihilation. or whisper in their ears as they sleep. that "the air of crimethink is unbreathable for the masses of humanity. they're useless. at least. A book like this is just the scattered dust from explosions the lives of strangers.

BECOMES REALITY It Begins The Secret World New Wings for Flighty Youth The Invitation The Rebellion of the Dead On the Threshold The Stillest Hour The Fault Line Wolves Indulge and Undermine At Sea We Can Make Our Own Mapping AMap Dreams Alchemy Beyond Democracy Two Councils Divided and Conquered The Eviction Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility And the Crowd Goes Wild One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World Other Encampments You Can Run but You Can't Hide All Roads Lead to Roam Infighting the Good Fight Hitting the Wall 14 18 22 26 29 32 34 35 37 40 43 44 48 50 71 73 74 90 96 1°4 108 183 The End of the World 184 Some Run for Cover-We Rush to Bear Witness 186 196 199 203 222 235 239 243 256 264 269 273 277 291 296 297 304 307 312 314 315 Disaster Off the Cliff Failure Crash and Burn Adultery Betrayers and Betrayed Abomination Reform and Revolution Despair Believing in Miracles Hope Explosions History as We Live It Extinction Nostalgia Darkness The Future Countdown to Civil War Leaving the 21 st Century Dear Reader Where We're Going 116 123 132 136 137 147 163 III...I.. II. THE FANTASY REBELS ... AFTERWARD On the Battlefield 168 322 331 332 339 345 346 Inflamed Appendix Disconnecting the Power About the Authors Hijack the Moon The Explosion of Stars The Future is Unwritten .

.

.

For Kate to decide she could do the same thing was pure craziness. Kate wasn't a student. bringing with them a heady mix of wild ideas and grim determination. lest it become known that non-student squatters had in­ filtrated it. and soon we were bringing back more than anyone needed. 14 . Two weeks later. Finally. There were articles about the encampment in every newspaper. My friends and I had been waiting for something to do with the city's excess.I t all started when Kate got back from Seattle and swore she wouldn't pay rent anymore. but three days later Kate was setting up her tent in the quad with a big banner alongside it and student activists were stopping by between classes to hold signs and hand out fliers. it was clear that the administrators had no in­ tention of following through on their promises. they'd have to answer for it to a national audience. we refused to budge. but most of them were from wealthier fami­ lies and could rely on a whole network of couches maintained by others like them. The issue came up at sorneone's birthday party. Like Kate. school officials approached the organizers of the anti-sweatshop campaign. It Begins One of the students Kate had lived with was involved in the campus anti-sweatshop campaign. The newcomers had a different idea of politics than the student activists-they weren't just interested in changing school policy. the administration threatened to remove the encampment with or without the students' cooperation. it all started long before that-when Elijah showed me how to hide a chicken patty under my salad so I could afford a complete lunch from the school cafeteria. after high school she had proceeded im­ mediately to a series of retail jobs. the students had to announce that the occupation would continue. I'd never have expected them to be up for it. She knew people who had sworn off rent before. The next week. Little did they know what was brewing out there on the quad! Once it appeared the camp might last. we turned these into meals and camping gear and took them to campus as our contribu­ tion. then moved on to making deliveries to their neighborhoods. we'd made connections with the invisibles who It Begins. Along the way she discovered a passion for organic gardening and ended up living in collective houses with students and environmental activists who had a lot more money than she did. They'd waited too long to play that card. if the school sent po­ lice against us. others began filtering in. It had been sucking her dry trying to pay bills the rest of them barely noticed. offering to negotiate if they'd call off the occupation. they were more invested in continuing the occupation than working out a compro­ mise with the administration. We started send­ ing bags home with cafeteria staff and maintenance workers. when Pablo stormed out of the airport instead of flying to see his boss­ but those personal revolts didn't gain a common thread until we all met at the encampment. When the latter broached the subject to us. and the administration was still dragging its feet on the previous year's agreements. and Kate suggested the students set up a protest encampment that could double as housing. We invited others there to join us on our outings. 15 . but also in changing their own lives and everything else in reach. when Kate's father called up the power company and told them to disconnect him from the grid. the food and furniture and construction materials we gathered in our raids on its soft underbelly. More importantly. Of course. they were simply waiting for the protesters to return to their dorms.

great white snow banks reflecting the light of the city as they sped past. There were storm clouds close overhead. My companion behind the steering wheel was that messenger. Exiting the police station that night. far away. My friends and I began each day in the undergraduate library." Later on. Political science majors began concerning themselves more with the practical aspects of the struggle against hierarchical power than the theoretical objections their professors raised against it. Anthro­ pology students started looking at their own lives as experiments in subversive socialization. we had already assured the ones we knew that we could provide them with food and sup­ port through it. The enormity of what we were up against had yet to hit us. These meetings sometimes ended in bitter conflicts over how far we could go. dishwashers like myself discovered how much more gratify­ ing it was to wash our friends' dishes for free than strangers' dishes for pay. but those of us who were found each other and plotted accordingly. As a child. and I was still alive. and liberation with the students who came through. students were dropping out. Criminals and dropouts envisioned a thieves' guild that could coordinate citywide actions to power an underground gift economy. Diego and I would finish off the night driving around to every grocery store in town. days ahead when everything would be very different from what we'd known­ ourselves most of all. we thought we were unstop­ pable. A strike was brewing among campus workers. We laughed giddily in the back of the squad car. our camp was pitched on the far side of them. We brought these back to the encampment and set them out on a table of free literature. every time I walked past an empty. they spoke to us of other lands. all afternoon we'd discuss politics. Together we had traveled to the extreme limit of our notions of what was possible. Kate and I were in love. It Begins It Begins. my old life was behind me. and all the things we'd never noticed before about the world sud­ denly snapped into focus. 16. Still later I contemplated suicide. He would appear unannounced and whisper.powered the infrastructure through which the school drew life. Chefs fantasized about being able to cook whatever they wanted for people and purposes they cared about. and the whole campus was in an uproar. in a voice no one else heard. what our goals were. workers were on strike. not every student. utilizing a loop­ hole in the computer lab to print out hundreds of pamphlets and fliers. economics. we met with campus workers and other locals. We looked past our tents to the surrounding buildings: they too could be ours. The encampment became a nerve center for a community that hadn't existed until we all started sticking our necks out. we shuddered in the cool air. or worker was ready for a head-on confrontation with the authorities. the ve­ hicle we were riding in was that stolen car. Diego and I were driving back from a construction site with a trunk full of barricading supplies when I realized how long it had been since I'd had any such thoughts. the em­ ployees at some of them had started setting big boxes of produce aside just for us. which is what adults do when they can't bear their lives but can't imagine changing them. things to come. running car I would imagine leaping into it and driving far. squatter. I'd had a daydream in which a messenger came to res­ cue me. joking about what to do next. "Grab your things-I've come to take you home. and which compromises were worth mak­ ing. In the evening. 17 . By the time they finally evicted us.

For others. still lurking somewhere beneath the limitations of what we feel to be possible and permissible. When you're making love and you discover a new sensation or region of your lover's body. And perhaps you swore that you would never return from whence you'd come. it is a place of safety and sanctuary in a world of thoughtless brutality and destruction. Everything before became trivial. It's between the words when we speak of our desires and aspirations. Perhaps you've seen evidence of it scratched into bathroom walls in a code for which you had no key. Some find it in the sensation of danger: the feeling that. for one moment that seems to eclipse the past and future. 19 . The Secret World. or you've been able to make out a pale reflection of it in the movies that are supposed to keep us entertained. When teenagers vandalize a billboard to provoke all-night chases with the police or anarchists interrupt an orderly demonstration to smash the windows of an army recruiting center.You can taste it in the shock and roar of a first. once. that thrill of discovery and transformation-but return you did. When poets and radicals stay up until sunrise wracking their brains for the perfect sequence of words or deeds to fill hearts or cities with fire. and the two of you feel like explorers discovering a desert oasis or the coast of an unknown continent-as if you are the first ones to reach the north pole or land on the moon-you are charting its frontiers. how they lift and transport you in ways no science or psychology could ever account for. ridiculous as the ho­ rizons suddenly telescoped out around you and undreamt-of new paths offered themselves. they're trying to storm its gates. they're trying to find a hidden entrance to it. unexpected kiss. It blows in the wind you feel on the roof­ tops of a really reckless night of adventure. something real is at stake. Maybe you stumbled into it by accident. The old world splintered behind and inside you. or in the blood in your mouth that instant after an accident when you realize you're still alive. that you would live out the rest of your life electrified by that urgency. amazed at what you found. and no physician or metaphysician could ever put it back together again. irrelevant. When children es­ cape out the window to go wandering late at night or freedom fight­ ers search for a weakness in government fortifications. You hear it in the magic of your favorite songs. they're trying to steal into it-for they know better than the rest of us where the doors are hidden.

Please know that anything you've ever done or considered doing to get there is not crazy. We know. that this secret world is near. The Secret World . too­ some of us are even waiting ahead there for you. who never returned. You can see it in the flash in our eyes. that it is just the shock of transition and nothing more. in the protest or party that gets out of hand. to reveal the one beneath entirely. be­ cause we feel it in that atavistic chamber of our hearts that holds the memory of freedom from a time before time. We're out here.Common sense dictates that this world can only be experienced temporarily. When we talk about revolution. necessary. noble. the idea is that we could enter that secret world and never return-or that we could burn away this one. in the abandon of our dances and love affairs. zo . but the myths we share around our fires tell a different story: we hear of women and men who stayed there for weeks. waiting for us. but beautiful. who lived and died there as heroes. You're not the only one trying to find it. years.

an English monk modeled wings according to Ovid's de­ scription of the feathered cloaks Daedalus made. reflecting that my species' love affair with flying had cooled. Inspired. witches on broomsticks.Before the first arrow whistled from a bow. if not thousands. erasing borders and prejudices to inaugurate a new era of universal amity and understanding. though he broke both legs upon land­ ing. I reflected on this as my fellow passengers fussed with their cell phones. Hundreds. And if flying was not really flying. as we knew it. this explanation didn't account for the fervor in Antoine de Saint Bxupery's writing. after ignoring the droning safety presentation. A few generations later. Leonardo da Vinci drew up designs for a helicopter. orators declared that air travel would bring people together. life? What if they. launched himself off a mountain on a homemade glider. Sorcerers and shamans sought to elevate themselves through mystical experience. Once upon a time. fastidiously avoid­ ing eye contact with each other. friendship. Marco Polo returned to Europe to report that the Chinese were sending people aloft in kites. they lay on their backs in prickly fields. I sat in an airport waiting for a delayed flight. winged horses and sandals. wasn't flying at all? Emotionally insulated from the adventure of getting into the air. He was sixty-five years old. 2] . or din­ ing. watching birds. I closed the book and returned it to my briefcase. and its implications were more dramatic. Perhaps the shamans of prehistory had known more about flight than businessmen with their frequent flier miles ever could. Perhaps it was the long lines at the se­ curity checkpoints: there were new restrictions on liquids in carry-on bags. where the Wright brothers' hearts had pounded. one of the first avia­ tion pioneers whose name is still known to us. and we needed movies to numb our boredom in the air! Maybe flying was simply not that exciting. perhaps most do. were not themselves? Everyone around me was staring blankly into television sets hanging from the ceiling. impatient to get on with their busy lives. died in similar efforts to get a little closer to heaven. Their descendants exchanged tales of flying carpets. waiting on the runway. My fellow aeronauts would disembark at an airport identical to the one they had left. Of course. Some secrets are hidden in plain view. Futurists had raved that the speed and brilliance of flight would inspire transcendent bliss. sterile air. work. perhaps it was the itch of the stale. or the forces that impelled him and others to keep flying into increasingly perilous situations until their luck ran out. physically isolated from the landscape below. these bore him a full furlong through the sky. human beings dreamed of flying. Eleven centuries ago Abbas Ibn Firnas. an anonymous commuter in an irritated crowd. Nor did it account for the experiences of people I knew myself: hadn't Chloe described stealing her uncle's hang glider as the most exhilarating experience of her youth? The alternative was less readily apparent. too. and passengers had to make their way through several gauntlets of barking men in starchy uniforms just to vie for seating. folk scientists plot­ ted to steal flight from the angels as Prometheus had stolen fire from the gods. that they had anything in common with the daredevils and voyagers of times past. romance. three centuries before the famous flight at Kitty Hawk. my fel­ low passengers would flip idly through catalogs and pull down the shades to block out the sun. deprived of any sensation of being airborne save a mild nausea. Some long­ sought miracles turn out to be letdowns. their heirs would peer briefly out tiny double-plated windows at the carved-up landscape before settling back to watch-a movie! Ten thousand generations had dreamed of flying. a Turkish scientist shot himself a thousand feet in the air in a rocket and coasted safely into the Bosporus. Wingless. women who put on magic coats and became swans. there was no longer even a pretense that they were part of anything glorious. The challenge of flight had commanded the passions of the boldest and bravest of my ancestors. we might as well be crowding into the locker of an isolation tank. What if flying. what about travel itself. It was a worldwide obsession. sex. Perhaps it was the piercing tones over the intercom followed by announce­ ments of further delays. 22 . after all. or the bizarre idea that somewhere out there there were people who wanted to fly planes into buildings with us inside them. when our plane took off. New Wings for Flighty Youth New Wings for Flighty Youth.

parasites. I had voted for politicians and signed petitions. charity. I'd been reflecting on these questions for months before I'd ar­ rived at the ticket counter. instilled in me since childhood. food. but the situation at Gate Ten cast them in sharp relief. another layer of the cocoon. If I did. anyway? Plenty.Could it be that I had never lived? I had traveled. certain facts of life seemed non-negotiable: without an income. We all lined up dutifully to board in order of economic status. that those who do not play their parts in society are failures. never. affirmed my assumptions.. I had dreams and aspirations. but I'd spent a lot more time working to pay for that rent. I didn't know how to build a house. New Wings for Flighty Youth New Wings for Flighty Youth. I had no idea what to do or where to go. I imag­ ined I would never ride in an airplane again unless I somehow got myself deported. Perhaps I could find a way out. 25 . all I had to go on was the vague notion that there must be something else out there. a family to feed. Of course. that sold itself to its citizens on precisely the grounds that it made that impossible. but not many from my social class. How many people can say they've been deported. everyone I knew would accuse me of jettisoning myself from the world like a misguided Icarus. If I wanted anything other than the future that was already written for me. but it seemed I'd watched more action movies on television than I'd ever had adventures in real life. but never organized anything in my community. but every­ where I'd been people spoke my language. I could be an explorer like my ancestors. That plane was never going to alight in the Bosporus or fly too close to the sun. goals I hoped to achieve. a pioneer like Abbas Ibn Firnas. television. but the proverbial leap into thin air made my pulse quicken. However I looked at it. if .. accepted my currency. or a prescription drug habit to maintain. 24. but I was cocooned in a society that seemed to make that impos­ sible. or even fix my own plumbing. I would have to fight off the conviction. In making that leap. I wanted so earnestly to live. But at long last my flight had pulled into the gate. for example. What irony: the real flight my civi­ lization offered held no attraction for me. That was another kind of insulation. I considered that possibility. Was I really desperate enough to dive off a cliff. but never seriously done anything to address injustice or even interact with the ones who suffered it. On the other hand. I would have to strike out on my own. knowing I would land somewhere or cease to exist? I couldn't deny that something stirred within me at the thought. stopped a bulldozer or started a riot. I was like everyone else there except I didn't have a mortgage. I didn't know what it was to hunt and kill an animal or rely on a garden for sustenance. whatever that meant. I had donated to charities. I bought food products from the supermarket without any idea what was in them or where they came from. There were things I loved doing. I lived in rented apartments built and maintained by people I'd never met.

we're getting out of here. It hijacks history classes and funerals. all the stifled songs which. selfless or selfish. unleashed. possible or impossible. nothing is more precious than passages to new worlds. Movie di­ rectors endeavor to harness it. waylays secretaries on the way to the coffee machine. fantasy will always be at war with reality. unexploded dream. but fantasy. The Invitation. could create an upheaval like no one has ever seen. forbidden pleasure. Right or wrong. As revolutionaries. And when the dust settles afterwards. flashes in which anything feels pos­ sible. like those who pursue it in earnest. Mass-manufactured faiths are haunted by a thousand dreams of escape-and fancy weaves better wings for flighty youth than pragmatism ever fashioned our forebears. to give the seeds soil in which to grow. political parties to enlist it. Now that every continent has been conquered and every coun­ tryside explored. but providing it a port of entry-quietly metabolizing the garbage of the old world into the new one. just as other "parasites" do. The one who does this is not jettisoning herself from life after all.Until 'our most fantastic demands are met. Call this escapist-perhaps it is. peak experiences that may last only instants-and therefore with every inhibited impulse. we side with those moments we surprise ourselves. self-imposed outcast status may be established in order to receive the transmissions. of course we are fighting for our daydreams! When we cannot stomach another hour of this. travel agents to peddle it. but what class of people is most disturbed by the idea of escape? Jailers. can serve no employer. we will side with them again. 27 . The invitation to a new world may take a lifetime or more to extend. turns rails into slides and shopping malls into playgrounds-it sends lives spinning out of control.

they may one day serve others. in­ ventors of new values and architects of new paradigms have always hidden in the margins. All along. acted in the-shadows. It interrupts the storylines we project onto our lives. There were still things I wished I could ask him. but there was no one on the other end. a sort of archetype existing only in those he haunted. Even surrounded by others in mourning I still felt isolated. We fear the very thought of it because it forces us to acknowledge that we can never return to a single mo­ ment of our lives. in eternity. conversations I'd hoped to revisit. starved in the ghettos. doused the lanterns. the mystery of those unfinished discussions was carved into the world forever. I was still in shock when we went to the memorial service. but they can only contribute to the subjection of those who never dare attempt them. he'd assumed he was only at the beginning of the grand narrative of his life. so incapable of engag­ ing with my grief. and scattered on the wind. misjudged. fantasies can become vampires draining the life out of their hosts. set the vessel aflame. The crew abandoned their posts. What any of us would give for an audience with one of our ar­ chetypes! Some of them have passed into eternity without even having had to die. If there was a time to The Rebellion of the Dead. misheard or unheard? That fate is our distinction: we would not take ourselves seriously enough if we wished it were otherwise. from our own pasts. All that is great happens far from the marketplace and from fame. Only in the end did he discover that he'd been a peripheral character in a very different story. dispelling the connections between the isolated moments of our experience-leaving them trapped. There is not yet space in streets or newspapers for the parcels we have to deliver. He'd become a memory. 29 . I still had his emails in my account. mute. with no outlet for the desperate urgency that possessed me. rendering them all irrevocable and pre­ cious beyond measure. Death had been waiting from the outset for the decisive mo­ ment at which to call his body to mutiny. I hadn't reflected much upon death before Daniel died. Death finalizes the gulfs that separate us from each other-and from ourselves. That void not only circumscribes our existence but surrounds and isolates each instant. It was unnerv­ ing to feel so heartbroken and yet so numb. that he had time to kill before setting off on the adventures he described so compellingly to me in advance. But beware-left untried. alone in my thoughts and my sorrow.Have we ever complained because we are misunderstood. but it was too late.

I'd surreptitiously read the books he lent me and we'd shared some good conversations over the phone and instant messager. I said to myself. to swear to avenge his senseless death with our own momentous lives. but it only formalizes the renunciations we make ourselves. If someone could look at time from above. I was back on the fourth floor with the view of the identical building across the street. I hadn't reflected much on death until then. I picked up the box. even bored. What if I could know in advance when my own death would come? It was waiting ahead of me. shuffling through the faxes that had come in over the weekend. a pedestrian lurched back absurdly in surprise. taking in the sweep of history all at once. That is to say: I'd been bored from before I could remember with the fact of my own mortality. or simply so bored with everything else that it didn't matter? The next morning. lived differently? Would he have frozen up in the face of that terrible knowledge? Coffee had somehow spilled all over the counter. I imagined all the oc­ cupants of those office buildings rising in mutiny like the cells in Daniel's body. 31 . I let it ring and tossed the doughnuts in the trash. and other catastrophes. The Rebellion of the Dead The Rebellion of the Dead. paused with it in one hand and a wad of napkins in the oth­ er-I would be in trouble if there were no doughnuts. as sure as Daniel's had been. I hadn't always been bored. I let it go. eleven stories above the pavement. This is the rebellion of the dead. . They were like a physical manifestation of the inevitability of our lives and deaths. a summer had been an eternity. moving obliviously along our preordained tracks towards inexorable ends. but to my knowledge no one has yet set out to study why children and adults experience the passing of time differently. I got out at the top floor and walked to the spot where the jani­ tors sometimes went to smoke. innumerable other secretaries were struggling with innumerable other coffee machines. what then? Would he have counted backwards from that day. 30. I pressed the button for the top floor. No one was there. innumerable phones rang and rang and rang. Death is the ultimate imposition upon and boundary to our free­ dom. now entire years were flying by in a blur inter­ rupted only by deaths. moment by moment. it was upon us. An electronic memo arrived from down the hall: the coffee ma­ chine was jammed and it was up to me to fix it. throughout our lives. I unplugged the coffee machine and carried it with me to the elevator. That wasn't much of a stretch-I knew my work schedule day by day through the end of December. The faces around me looked listless. thefirst dawn the worldhas everseen. Fuck it.wail and rend our hair. My breakfast remained in the desk. moved to throw it away. uneaten. it was soaking into the box of doughnuts. and the phone kept ringing. In innumerable other office buildings. We were not up to the task. innumerable elevators bore innumerable employees to innumerable washrooms. Ten years ago. I opened the win­ dow and dangled the coffee machine out by its cord. What if he had known he was going to die. even though I'd known I was going to die since I was a child. we would all appear as the walking dead. as sure as all of ours are. There is no more commonplace observation than this. a machine pushing us at maximum speed along our preor­ dained tracks. Was I in denial. marriages. It shrank from view until there was a distant crash. could I save them somehow?-just long enough for the phone to ring. even in that office. Behold. to leap onto tables and shout out songs in his memory.

.

though increasingly at odds. Like a body in upheaval. though it ultimately had spectacular effects. The fundamental change that took place that afternoon was in­ visible. flirting with them but keeping them under wraps. I identified with the insurgent currents inside myself against the society that proscribed them. If my own habits and obligations obstructed my path. I knew there was commercial skydiving for people like me. I wasn't about to build a glider and launch myself into the abyss. were arranged in a strictly regi­ mented hierarchy. so much the worse for them. Oh. unaccountable tyrants. decimated wildernesses. with my own wildness. Every revolution is essentially the revolt of a people against itself. had always remained unshaken. and wanted more. behind-the-scenes machinations. hoarded treasures rusting in vaults. threw my wallet in the trash. there were vigilant police. but the essential order. as in the city where I lived. I harbored private resentments. the world had not come to an end. and above all the com­ mitments that safeguarded it. My associations with others were like the diplomatic relations between nations: non-aggression pacts. authoritarian powers negotiating over the heads of oppressed masses separated by well-guarded borders. I was mostly playacting.That day I quit my job. but all these were kept in check. but at the airport. and everything had to be reworked. 34 . I'd crossed the line between flirtation and indulgence. when I'd permitted them to take the reigns in broad daylight. I still mirrored my society. I was not the sort of person who cancelled a business trip after driving to the airport! It was not until much later that I would develop the ability to wrench myself out of routines without flinching. but I was determined to hold out for the real thing. if only that were true! I did no such thing. Internally. people seized by insurgent desires wrest themselves from everything they know and attempt to reconstitute themselves as a new society. impulses to rebel. painfully transforming itself into something else. The hands that raise skyscrapers are the same ones that as­ semble barricades. illicit longings. a chain reaction that could make the world hospitable for them. I had always regarded them as something foreign and dangerous. 35 . I would let the wild streaks within me deepen and spread until I could set off. Making that one defiant gesture was difficult enough-it felt like a rupture in the very fabric of reality. All the career options and status symbols I'd worked my whole life to accumulate were starting to look like so many constraints and cha­ rades. It took a very long time. There had been times when a renegade faction had precipitated an upheaval. restless ghettos. ad­ venture tourism and recreational drugs and all sorts of other pres­ sure valves. discovered that something lay beyond it. The forces that comprised me. In my heart. and set out to break every rule I knew. such as the affair with Chloe that destroyed my marriage. Even walking out of the airport.The Stillest Hour The Stillest Hour I The Fault Line. From that mo­ ment forward.

graffiti. at least it carved out a little territory apart from it. but it was a private war. now I smuggled every resource I could out of my workplace and sought a new calling in which to invest myself. If delinquency didn't enable me to escape all that entirely. addiction. just as our mothers had resented our fathers without using words like patriarchy. My colleagues didn't dare give any indication of their true feelings. The Fault Line I The Stillest Hour Wolves. That is to say-I was like them. and employees who. spouses yearning for forbidden romance. or drugs. So I kept my job-barely. 37 . we'd resented our teachers in school in the same instinctual way. after canceling that trip-but where once I'd focused on advancing my career. In this. Once I'd invested my earnings in the stock market. I didn't think of myself as opposing capitalism-for me it was much more specific: I wanted to escape the conveyor belt that brought piles of dirty plates into the dish room. Like Pablo. but I didn't know where to start to connect with them. I joined a nation of students doodling in anticipa­ tion of the bell. we thought of ourselves as being at war. We'd discovered petty crime-shoplifting. we were like wolves. I was so conditioned to my place at the bottom of the social ladder I stole the cheapest ones in the store. vandalism-and we prac­ ticed it the way other people practiced religion. scams. All that changed when I stumbled upon the occupation. an insurgent without allies fighting a war without fronts. savings accounts. I was accustomed to dining on the finest organic cuisine. nursing home inmates counting the days to their next visit. fear. My extracurricular activities became the center of my life. I felt separated from old friends and family by an unbridgeable chasm. At first. and the stench of industrial cleaner mingled with rancid grease. and inertia-that is. A year later. even golf clubs. sports. now I regarded my leisure­ time pursuits as my true vocation and aspired to increase their scope accordingly.Every struggle that takes place in a society plays out within each of the individuals within it. just out for ourselves. Like most service workers. we hated our bosses. like me. six of us against six billion of them. I barely ever saw my neighbors. had concluded that their professions were not paths to self-realization but barriers to it. if that which is oppressed within each individual triumphs-then likewise the entire society can remake itself. if I was risking the same charges? 36. I was at an impasse. but hadn't worked out a critique of authority. and the nights I woke up scraping filth off phantom dishes in my sleep. The first time I stole a pair of shoes. products intended for only the wealthiest shoppers: why not grab the most expensive items. The same fault line that opens in a bou­ levard between riot police and rioters runs through the private lives of each officer and dissident. If enough of them can win their per­ sonal struggles against servility.

even though it necessitated the exploi­ tation of others. Living in constant conflict with the law kept our senses sharp and spiced up a day-to-day existence that would other­ wise have been utterly demoralizing. which led to new trains of thought. and it sure wasn't going to be the owners. Diego and I would mock the ubiqui­ tous billboards.This shift in diet was accompanied by radical changes in my self­ esteem. that poor people throughout history should have had to go without all they had stolen. "I know how toget everything for free. After the first few arrests hit home. but our motives remained schizophrenic: we despised rich people." Diego deadpanned. What else am I gon­ na do with the rest of the night?" This was a couple months before we met the students who invited us to the encampment. Wolves Wolves. I could take some groceries over to my mom's place. gold watches. "Look at that one. A couple broke off to pursue careers as hard­ core criminals. In a very concrete way. Wage slaves like me were throwing away our entire lives working to make things we could never own. "Nice cowboy hat. it out­ raged me that anyone would condemn stealing as immoral. Everyone in the coun­ try was chasing that same mirage. but envied their lifestyle-even though it made them soft. to feel tough and powerful as we wreck our livers-but the barrel's pointed at us. 39 . designer sunglasses and furniture. who never got his hands dirty. somebody was going to have to wash the dishes. as well? So we developed a broader analysis of what we were fighting against. We focused more and more on the surplus of our society-it was less carefully guarded. we had to look for a more sustainable approach. And what bounty! Why fill our pockets inside the store with one eye on the security guard when we could fill up a whole pickup truck out back? That was how I finally came to question my own materialism. gringo! And to top it off it's called 'Colt 45'-ever notice how every fucking malt liquor company has a name like that? We're supposed to identify with the brand names. and our society was shoveling them right past us into the trash. I literally couldn't afford the products I stole. 38." "And the crazy part is I still want the stuff. we'll need a bigger gang. could take for granted luxuries I had to risk jail time just to taste. but I could see through that right away-wherever there were restaurants and cafeterias. gathering copper to sell or merchandise we'd damaged during the day. the rest of us scaled back the more hazardous ac­ tivities and stepped up everything else. Could anyone really argue with a clean conscience that all that privation was not enough. At distribution centers I would look into dumpsters packed to the top with perfectly good juice and shake my head in disgust. the foods I was permitted by law to eat reflected my value in society." "For that. their privileges and their sense of entitlement and above all the injustices they heaped on others. As a dishwasher. but it didn't make things any easier for others of our social class-at the most. When I reflected on the poverty I'd seen growing up and the centuries of destitution there must have been before that." he'd point out. Driving around at night. I didn't want anything to do with it. even as a thief. but I had no idea what to do for everyone else on her street. I'd been raised to want things I could never have-sports cars. and somewhere there were waste dumps overflowing with all those things-one of them wasn't far from my old neighborhood. but I've got no idea how to get free myself. The counselors at school had told us people ended up with jobs like ours because they didn't get enough education. did that mean I didn't deserve them? My manager. Some of my coworkers had been to college and had nothing to show for it but debt.

shelter. and a sense of accomplishment is already established and all that remains is for him to choose between prefabricated options. because processed supermarket food doesn't taste much better. We "have to" check our email because the dissolution of commu­ nity has taken our friends and kindred far away.·. in turn. consciously or not. but not because we would be free to feel our "natural" desires­ no such things exist.. necessarily.. because it's hard to imagine more pleasurable ways to spend time when everything around us is designed for commerce and consumption. is going on everywhere all the time-and everyone plays a part in it. If our desires are constructs. We must make our freedom by forging the realities which. everyone exhorts you to "pursue your desires. Every crav­ ing we feel. you have no "true" self-you are precisely what you do and think and feel. then our freedom is a question of how much control we have over that environment. salesmen grasp for handles to jerk you around . besides. because our bosses would rather not have to talk to us. 41 . Our lives are vastly different today than they 40. Does this mean we would want differently in a different world? Yes. And those much-contested desires are ill constructed. is framed in the language of the civilization that creates us. but that he makes them answer to reality rather than attempting the opposite. culture. every conception we form. Indulge and Undermine Indulge and Undermine. This sounds like a lot to ask. That's the real tragedy for the man who spends his life talking on his cell phone and attending business meetings and fidgeting with the remote control: it's not that he denies himself his dreams. because "time-saving" technol­ ogy has claimed the hours once used t? write letters-and killed all the passenger pigeons. The accountant regarded with such pity by runaway teenage lovers may in fact be happy when he arrives home from work in time for his favorite sitcom-but it is a very different happiness than the one they experience on the lam. It's nonsense to say a woman is free to feel however she wants about her body when she grows up sur­ rounded by diet advertisements and posters of anorexic models. We "like" fast food because we have to hurry back to work.. from new-age prophets to advertisers. from pornographers to radicals. fashion us. they're dependent on external factors. We "want" to go to work because in this society no one looks out for those who don't. Beyond the life you live. the whole context and history of our society. But change. if we are the products of our envi­ ronment. be­ cause the nuclear family-for those who still have even that-is too small and stressed to sustain much festivity in cooking and eating. revolutionary change.AND UNDERMINE Have you noticed that exhortations to indulge yourself are always followed by suggestions! Proselytizers seek footholds to claim ter­ ritory within you." but the question remains: which ones! The "real" ones? Who decides which those are? It's a war for your soul on every front. companionship. anyway-they change. It's nonsense to say a man is free to live as he pleases when everything he needs to do to acquire food.

one and all. That's no way to go about pursuing your desires. 43 . we can indeed create whatever world we want. retain some sort of guide through the wilderness. One of my most disappointing discoveries was that I desired so little. the world and I would both have to change. you'll find that indulgeand undermine is a far more effective program than the old heritage of "renounce and struggle" passed down from a humorless Christianity. But spending your life in reaction and adaptation. find leaders who will help you depose them from the pedestal you put them on. When school chil­ dren make up their own words to the songs they are taught. boring. conditions that foster new ones. I'd hoped to throw myself at their mercy. typical. hurrying to catch up to whatever is already happening. I was totally at sea. Don't be too hard on yourself about the fragments of the old order that remain within you. The question is simply whether we take responsibility for our part in the ongoing transformation of the cosmos. Indulge and Undermine At Sea. Based on my experience leaving the office. As it was. my savings trickling away as I Waited for the right opportunities and compatriots to come along. electrified by the world in every moment-but for that to be possible. I counted the days. when people show up by the tens of thousands to interfere with a closed­ door meeting of expert economists discussing everyone's lives.were even a mere decade ago. trying to choose between cliches. they are rediscovering that self-determination. in the process of satisfying the old desires. And yet I was determined that my life would be something out of the ordinary. if you have to fight against others. as idealists like us insist. I had no idea where to start. It offers you a chance to lead a life that matters. I couldn't imag­ ine a role for which I was less suited. participating in unfolding events . or apply to graduate school. The limits of my desire were a sort of cage. I surmised I'd be able to recognize them by the terror they would inspire in me. If you need to follow leaders. You can't sever yourself from the chain of cause and effect that produced you-not with any amount of will­ power. inspiring friends and former coworkers with hedonistic fervor the way others drove suitors to distraction. or frame our actions as reactions. whichever ones you choose to pursue. self and community. suicide. if you wish to lead others. Forget about whether "the" revolution will ever happen-the best reason to be a revolutionary is that it is a better way to live. I knew no one with whom I could undertake anything more audacious than a night out dancing. to follow their tyrannical dictates and thus. I wanted to be lit up. no less than the limitations imposed by civil society. find wars you can wage for everyone's benefit. at the mercy of history as it unfolds. Should I take my meager savings and go to Ecuador? Visit family in Southeast Asia? Move to New Mexico? Would life really be more immediate or authentic there? Should I take up mountain climbing. After long disuse. or dedicate myself to volunteer work? I was sur­ rounded by banality. keeps you conscious of the give and take always going on between individual and institution. I tried to imagine myself as a seductress. Without that. find eq uals who will help you dethrone yourself. Likewise. even in leaving the beaten path. acting deliberately and with a sense of our own power. at least I would avenge my own. When it comes to dodging the im­ peratives of your conditioning. then perhaps it's true that we could adapt to any world. Even after I followed the cof­ fee machine out of the office. it was up to me to infect them with new desires. The trick is to find ways to indulge your programming that simultaneously subvert it-that create. and feats of bravado. my passions were stunted like bonsai trees: trite. 42. if I was to share adventures with others. If. No institution can offer you freedom-but you can experience it in challenging and reinventing institutions. like power. gives you a rela­ tionship to injustice so you don't have to deny your own grief and outrage. too. if I could not undo Daniel's death. belongs only to the ones who exercise it. means being perpetually a step behind. accidentally as if we were purely victims of circumstance.

either. let alone working the checkout line at Wal-Mart. we're stuck buying mass-produced movies and compact discs made by corporate mercenaries. In the checkout lines of supermarkets. when we've spent those lives being conditioned to do the opposite? rt w. There is no civilization without us civilizing. no capitalism without us capitalizing and capitulating. technol­ ogy. we long to be protagonists in our own epics. science. we must reconstruct ourselves.History is not something that happens to people­ it is the activity of people. history. we must transform the world­ but to begin reconstructing the world. tradition. on the dialing and receiving ends of 900 numbers. struggling with other people's inventions and programs and theories that make less sense to us than sorcery did to our ancestors. The mass media encour­ ages us to feel sentimental about "our" achievements: the space shuttle soars. These things aren't inevitable. the star gets the girl at the end of the movie. the disease is cured. shamefacedly accept­ ing the judgments of priests and agony columnists and radio talk show hosts. 44. psychology. and neither fear nor falter. Today we are all occupied territory. listening to parents and counselors and psychiatrists and managers tell us we are the ones with the problems. Technological progress is not a force of nature. sitting faceless and immobi­ lized at arena rock performances and sports events. in the locker rooms before gym classes and cafeteria shifts. How can we take and share control of our lives. political power. Our appetites and attitudes and roles have all been molded by this world that turns us against our­ selves and each other. But we can make our own music. berating ourselves for not living up to the standards set by college entrance exams and glamour magazines. Culture does not dictate human behaviorit is the sum of human behavior. mythology. ethics. If we are to transform ourselves. Until we do. masters of our own fate. are the onl ones currenttq workin in meanina as a mediu m . 45 . literature. We Can Make Our Own These are hard things to remember in the boss's office. inescapable tragedies-they're consequences of the pas­ sivity to which we have relegated ourselves. buying our whole lives from the same specialists and entrepreneurs we sell them to-and gnashing our teeth in smothered fury as they cut down the last trees and he­ roes with the cash and authority we give them.

we attack the average. of answers and questions. we call it "ideology. Languages write our lives: they set the options whenever we make a choice. and nurture the anomalous. Languages enforce their constraints upon us-that is to say. A cancer of mass-produced. an interplay between us and the languages we think and speak and live in-not a monologue arriving out of a loudspeaker. It is in this constant redefining of terms. ' expectation. Culture is made up of languages-languages of words and num­ bers. prefabricated culture threatens our species. cancer out of control. cooperatively. language-writing is the ultimate collective activity. Neither is freedom to be found in unquestioning obedience to law: a free human being is not a law­ follower or a law-breaker. on a small enough scale that everyone could participate. deny the universal. we do not exist. We need a culture that is a dialogue. of concepts and assumptions. the common denominator of all social activity. a monster riding the humanity that gave birth to it into an untimely grave. Terms in languages work only because we hold them in common. but we cannot escape culture itself-we carry it with us as we flee. when its cells begin reproducing sameness at the expense of diversity.. but an inventor and reinventor of laws. We Can Make Our Own . One must make ! meaning with others. a part of a tribe. we remake ourselves. however free we may be in selecting." ture imposes. 46. leaving a trail of it in our wake." or "conformity". One cannot create meaning in a vacuum-but neither can one be anything but at the mercy of and alienated by a meaning that arrives from on high. A culture that sets up a million franchises with workers in matching uniforms executing identical tasks is a * In former times. Fighting for this. the ongoing creation and negation of forms and assump­ tions. Free. that universe not only is described by language but exists as language. it is our use of them that makes them what they are and reproduces them. that freedom becomes possible. impersonal.* When we want to rebel against the limits a cul. of conventions and expectations. those constraints are us-but every time we adjust a concept or subvert an. of problems and solutions. dom is not standing alone. man versus humanity-those who set out to "pursue their desires" as individualists forget that even those desires are socially constructed.Individuals cannot be autonomous ­ we are formed by relationships: without them. At the same time. culture was developed in tribal groups. To be free of language is impos­ sible in human relations-as we know it. A creature does not die "of" cancer-a creature dies by becoming cancer. for it to be meaning-ful.

we could wage our secret war out in the open. Time itself passed differently. were assets rather than barriers. now we looked at them in terms of how rewarding they were to experience and how beneficial they were for others. in a way that connected us to others rather than isolating us. I hadn't had much interest in college students before. Because I never knew what would happen next. our differ­ ent pasts and uncertain futures fell away and all that remained was the concentrated rush of the present. our rage and marginalization. and I imagined they resented me for my youth and mobility-but at the encampment. unjustly. we'd evaluated activities according to how much they paid. sharing the daily triumph of maintaining the occupation against all odds. but it was such an intense experience that it drew us all together. we were mapping an entirely new way of living. there was no young or old except in terms of how long people had been involved. staying up late preparing for rumored police attacks. In the heat of that urgency. Finally. I'd been on the opposite end of that same dynamic with older workers-I faulted them. the real turning point came when we got involved in the encampment. 49 .Like I said. it was only when all the barriers of Class and habit were removed and we were joined in a common project that we could interact as human beings rather than social roles. Coordinating to provide for everyone in the camp. finally. we'd sought our own material interests. At first. The encampment was the laboratory in which we began this experiment. it often felt like I'd lived through a week by the time I lay down at the end of the day. we grew together into one organism. Before. The fears that had kept me in place. I'd just wanted to get out of the dish room-now we were talking about making a clean break with Western civilization and building a new society in its midst. Day by day. for failing to escape the fate I feared awaited me. Mapping Mapping. the unhealthy assumptions I'd developed about human nature and my own potential-all these came into sharp focus as I discovered what it meant to do without them. My friends and I were very different from most people there. I grew more in the course of that month than I had in several years. now we sought social interests. taking it for granted that there wasn't enough of what we wanted to go around. 48. and found that even crowded four to a tent we felt wealthier than ever before. step by step. those who shared it as a common reference point were bonded for years afterwards regardless of how their paths diverged. and the ones with whom I'd crossed paths had made it clear they had no interest in me. the bad habits that had tied me down. Once. not to men­ tion our hard-won skills. but it was also a beachhead from which to extend it.

racism. isolated resistance to any I one symptom of that domination-the de. employee ennui-can only fail. 'nd re"r I( I· I t::J~ ~\~3\ . relinquishing everything to become what we hate or finding the faith to discover new possibilities ana new loves.)y. Those who desire change must I contest the totality itself.i. l'" h" own .. 7JI""" CI) ~ ~ 50. I child abuse. r ~O\ AMap·5 1 .. imploding ~ or expanding C>. but as a selecti~/rof I diagnostic tools for the individual e~ged ?! ~uman relations is dominated by patho- I ~ \\0 We move in spiral paths."'" f • ~ CU­ t) /' - • ..I ~a totalitarian order in which the whol:l logical patterns.I pletion of the ozone layer. police brutality.. I( • g <. CD _. A Map / "illtl. _ :J -. This sketch of six oppositions is not intended as a complete map of the wO"c of human relations.n.. the basic para­ II digms as well as their specific manifesta­ tions.

the more it is an experiencec:>~ liberty and pleasure The more you approach life as a game. the less you trust Abundance The more you can recognize the opportunities life offers. the feel the need to be ed for your sacrifice The less freely you receive. wher~. the er you have to work The more you the less you live Play The mprepleasure you take in your ad. and the more til:tatn.z~ what the world has to offer.The more you can recognize the opportunities life offers.d treasures it has to offer The lessyc:>u trust the world.uways present where be negotiated.\te the treasures life has to offer. exch~~e must Exchange ~. the more ~J. the more faith you have in it Fear The more ypu fear the world.. you have to fear The less you trust. the more you can. the more youtJife can be a game rather tha. the less you CWIJ::IVI:: and receive freely Love The more you love.: take advantage of them The more full and free-life is. the easier it is to recognize all the opportunities and treasures it has to offer Scarcity The less you trust the world.~ struggle comp Work more you work.. the more you trust The more you the more you can love The Force depend on force... you trust the world. the less you see what the world has to offer . the harder work to provide fo and have to rself Gift Giving The morlfiYOu share with others.kful you are for one another's existence The more you love. the less you ref9pgnize what it offers The less you recogni. the more wonderful things you recognize in it The more you recogiU. the less you see what it has to offer The less you live. the more freely you share the fruits The more freely you.. thf#less you see what the world has to offer Life The trt9te your life is in your own hands. you depend on ore Faith The mQ~t. the more freely you]. the easier it is to recognize all the opportunities ~tn.gwe and receive. the more you can take advantage of them The more full and free life is.1ey share with you..g~ving is not practiced for its own sake The more you depe force.q..~""ities. the less you$ee what it has to offer The less you live. the more ftUl and free it becomes Survival more you think you need to survive.

friendship. which become reflected in the world. faith or fear. Most of the things which set life apart from survival-love. It used to be said that the only free men are the hobo and the king. experience-are available in abundance: the more you partake of them.Abundance All of us can be rich . Homo Economicus is a construction. Our society institutes scarcity and deprivation. Neolithic man. mere parts of the world.etymologically speaking. It might seem that scarcity is simply an inescapable fact of life. while the possessive hus­ band regards it as a precarious prize obtained by sacrifice and hard labor. . sometimes produced a surplus. A scarcity economy is driven by the con­ siderations necessitated by those conditions: the "laws" of supply and demand are imposed first of all by a shortage. Everyone can have a full life-but not everyone can have a full wal­ let. If we restructure our values and assumptions about what the cosmos has to offer us. adventure. by framing life as a desperate rush for limited material wealth and status. who toiled in the fields.". Here's a story: once upon a time. but it's not that simple. Here we can see the paradigms of abundance and scarcity in action as philosophies of life. we impose them upon ourselves by the ways we assess and apply our assets. Scarcity .* • "Paleolithic man [sic. life under the yoke.throughout]. They are indeed the only ones who can claim to be lords of all they survey-though for utterly different reasons: the former pos­ sesses the entire world by releasing it. which must be hoarded and caged. they may even multiply when utilized. tools and amenities that were unheard of before are plentiful. egalitarian community generally attains self-confidence and happiness to the extent that she helps others around her do the same. . the more there is of them for you and everyone else as welL Abundance and scarcity are above all the manifestations of op­ posing approaches to life: ingenuity or inertia. for our social and economic systems depend on there not being enough for everybody. This should not be surprising. In out technologically advanced. The hunters and gatherers never curbed their materialistic impulses-but they never made institutions out of them. Abundance and scarcity are not just measures of the resources that exist to meet needs-they are different ways of regarding both re­ sources and needs. Scarce resources exist in limited supply. courage. yet most of us distinctly feel there to be a shortage of the things we need. we can enter a new world of plenty. real or perceived. not all of us can be wealthy. Likewise. imagination. either. while the latter still owns only what he can conquer. 'had' nothing-why hoard things when the whole world is yours? Later. seeing it as a wellspring of abundance.. the result of ten thousand years of 'subjugation': that is to say. which he bartered with others-and thus for him a shift occurred from being in the world to having things.Finnegan Bell in Hunters and Gatherers through the Ages 54. Not all scarcities are imposed by circumstances­ often. post-industrial civilization. Abundant resources exceed the need for them.. the scaven­ ger who thrives off the excess of his society sees opportunity and adventure where the executive sees only hunger and destitution. of needed goods. a hunter/gatherer who understood the value of sharing and mutual assistance. A Map AMap·55 . and there may simply not be enough to go around. the non-monogamous lover sees love as something that only increases in richness and depth by being shared freely. confidence. the would-be rock idol or movie star needs a million anonymous fans watching his actions to validate them-selfhood itself is subject to scarcity in a spectator society-while the woman in a supportive. human beings lived in a relation­ ship of trust with the earth.

. we can be sure that we are adding to the slow accumulation of garbage that . It's often ambiguous which class specific mandates fall into. and ergonomics presentations. everything '(1 is a transaction. Life is written about in epic poetry. which are manu-oj factured from plastics and chemicals foreign to nature. Liberty. never diminishing their faith in the . heartbreaking. which we must exchange our labor. housing. Today we eat candy bars. naturally wrapped in a \ biodegradable peel and containing seeds from which more fruit trees would grow after the fruit was eaten.. "yeah. an occasion for computation and calculation. The minimum standard of living to participate in society is always AMapo 57 560 AMap . haven't you?. burdensome. but not as much as you eat. 0 0 Life. and the Pursuit of Happiness Life is existence when it feels worth waking up for in the morn­ ing. whether biological (get air to breathe! get food to eat! get laid!) or cultural (get air conditioning to keep cool! get a television to keep up with what's going on! get a sports car to attract a mate!). for . Survival. which grew freely around us.~ tions of feast or famine. absurd. but the essential character of these needs is that they appear non-negotiable. but as the famous tramp responded to a bourgeois man's query ("you've got to eat.! makes fruit trees less and less abundant." Our era is characterized by ever-increasing standards of survival. Life is glorious. and the Pursuit of Property Survival is life reduced to imperatives.. Our ancestors lived in condi. extravagant. survival.). limited-and when we throwaway the wrappers. and medicine in the world. is ridiculous. water. Shakespeare's plays and sonnets. for us. survival is treated in medical textbooks. celebrating when their cups overflowed and: whistling through leaner times.We ate fruit. love songs. as in the case of the computer programmer who cannot feed himself without a can opener.~ bountiful earth by measuring what it gave them. Survival resources tend to be seen as scarce-there's only so much food.. Safety. of which supplies are strictly. without life. urban planning reports.

The more one plays. in which continuous innovation is necessary both to sell new products and to keep up with everyone who uses them. In play. ..using them to mow the lawn. with a struggle for domi­ nance as an ever-present subtext? How about when a young man comes home from work so exhausted that he doesn't have enough energy to do anything but "play" video games? Children come into this world knowing all about play-at least until they've spent a few years cooped up in small rooms with the television on. treating yourself with the new prescription drug . Play Head for horizons . learning to use the new computer program. This constant techno­ logical and cultural acceleration is the consequence of an economic system based on competition. the individual interacts with the forces around her rather than reacting to them. Many anthropologists believe that people spend more time working to meet their "basic" needs today than ever before. the more others are enabled and encouraged to do the same. waiting in traf­ fic to buy more batteries for them . while with all our labor-saving devices we waste most of our lives earning money to pay for them. in the break be­ tween skirmishes when the insurgents dance. Is it play when an office worker goes golf­ 58. as in the case of the successful executive. and it's a full-time job keeping up: getting the new format for video-viewing. it is the condition of freedom. The best-kept secret of capitalism is that play activities can also pro­ vide for our survival needs: think of all the retirees who start gardens and build bookcases! Except in extremities. and doesn't lend itself to much real. Play takes place in a condition of freedom­ that is to say. in the eccentric furnishing of squatted buildings. for them and for ourselves. It's ambiguous whether many of the things currently called "play" actually warrant the title.. and of course. Play is not constrained by exter­ nal demands-the player establishes her own goals and meanings in the course of acting. . One can't play long at others' expense-being "free" at such a price ends up taking a lot of work. true playfulness is infectious.. AMap·59 . as the ennui typical of the trust-fund playboy demonstrates. Prehistoric human beings spent the greater part of their days in creative leisure. Play is what takes place when all the problems of survival have been solved and time and energy remain. work is unnecessary. We can win back that lost innocence. spontaneous play.. creates the context for her actions as she acts rather than passively being shaped by the situation: it is thus that self-determination is possible. the less time we have to live. The resources for play are available in abundance. the more time we spend providing for mere survival. You can see play today in the collages on teenagers' walls. by approaching everything we do as a game rather than a struggle or responsibility-by creating environments in which we can run wild.rising. AMap ing with his boss? How about when a group of men play football together according to a strict set of rules. in the movements of lovers' bodies together.

Exchange Economies .. The machinery of exchange eats quality and shits out quantity..AMap Liberty ends where economics begins. is to flatten the world for yourself and everyone you touch. In a gift economy.. my world itself begins where yours begins. AMap. Everyone who has shared a real friendship or a morning of incredible lovemaking knows intuitively that when the opponunity presents itself.61 . the sensation of riding a galloping horse! Anyone who has lived and paid attention knows the best and worst things life has to offer are things no one could ever earn. . My liberation. the comparative worth of the sound of birds singing in the trees against the current market value of lumber? Those who would measure such things miss everything that is beautiful and unrepeatable about them. the free market-these are oxymorons: where systematized competition is free to bend all humanity to its prerogatives. once one recognizes this. they say everything has a price. let alone trade in the very lives of the human beings around you with an eye to your own advantage. it becomes clear how pathological such calculations are in any context. play creates its own rules. pledged to give all-and gratuitously. Work . according to which everything can be appraised: if an avocado costs a dollar.. In their eyes.000. the participants receive more the more they bestow. Work provides for survival. . Exchange economics presupposes a one-dimensional scale of value. any­ thing free is suspect at best-nothing obtained without sacrifice. Free trade. teaches that practical ne­ cessities and moments of joy and spiritual redemption alike must all be earned. which exists whenever anything is freely shared and no score is kept. Get your money's worth-earn your keep-there's no such thing as a free lunch: exchange economics posits life as a zero-sum sport between bargainers who maneuver to outbid and outwit each other in order to gain control of pieces of a fragmented world. whether that be the need for food and shelter and life insurance. Nobody can command my services because I have. It is absurd to think one could de­ serve life in all its complexity and magnanimity in the first place­ let alone good or bad fortune. gift-giving is its own reward. or the obliga­ tions of the Protestant work ethic. Life itself is the greatest gift. human beings return to this natural relationship. ultimately no one is free to focus on anything else. for that is the only way to give.the flavor of avocados. and a new sports car costs $20. Gift Economics We know everything is priceless . nothing more. my delight. of my own. In stark contrast to exchange trading. the exchange rate of a clever joke for a meal tenderly prepared. then a sports car must be worth exactly twenty thousand avocados. Work answers to imperatives. Can you calculate the financial value of a friendship. the establishment of social status. the moment of stillness at sunrise. enslaves process to despicable product. But such equa­ tions are absurd. It always appears as a re­ sponse to necessity. There is something of the old Christian theology of guilt and salvation in the ways those who hold stock in the values of exchange speak of hard work and entitlement. To assess the commercial value of experiences and sensations. 60. not destinations.

to feel for a moment that there is mean­ ing in existence. and future. present. on the other hand. can be worth anything-and the act of paying for things. for love is a ruthless enemy of senseless con­ * We. . generous. fearless. not without a little jealous spite. they would have to face the possibility that they have been wasting their lives. those who would refuse this system of exchange are confronted with the same accusations of valuelessness by their own bodies. AMap. is itself more important than anything they could buy. instead. but to gain a sixth sense with which to perceive the real splendor of the universe. To feel love is to be grateful for the past.without an exchange. or the time on this planet. and leave it at that. Love does not make demands or judge according to standards-love celebrates. to savor fully the magnificence the world lavishes upon us. have ceased to use words like earn and deserve. To be in love is not to be deluded or destitute. It is the way one buys oneself out of the hell of worthlessness to which the tramp and the failure are assigned. all who interact with them must adopt the same miserliness and self-interest to survive-and the most ruthless ones inevitably end with the most power. Once some people in a society begin hoarding and trading for their own benefit.63 . To experience love is to be connected directly to the tragedy of existence-which is not that there is not enough beauty in life. Love is self-assured. we ask. with the compensation they receive for abdicating their lives. . Love makes war upon any peace which in fact is war system­ atized and concealed. The world now waits for a generosity that can defend itself Relationships of Love Cooperate and celebrate . when they find that they cannot get food to eat or a soft place to sleep unless they give up some part of themselves for it. just as magnanimity and largesse find themselves disenfranchised. even existence itself. Revenge doesn't interest us-it's just another from of exchange. but that none of us has the breadth or depth of self. human beings do not "deserve" happiness. For such people. consecrates the unique. makes beauty and beautiful.* It should come as no surprise that some employees see things this way: if they didn't. what would be best for everyone. Likewise. unless they pay for it-with suffering. comfort.

Those in love come to identify each other's needs with their own. The hospitals. Coercion comes in more subtle forms than rape. Thus in love we find a way to surpass ourselves. and economic sanctions. A Map .. The hush in the air. It may be disguised as a seemingly trivial argu­ ments proposing an unreachable ideal for women's beauty. Some call this a democracy-did you get a say in what the bill­ boards you pass every morning say. or the conditions in the factories that produce them? What about your wages at work.ment between friends (for anyone who seeks to establish rank.. Just as the ones who see scarcity everywhere they look create a world of shortages. waiting like so many circling vultures for the bodies and minds of these people to weaken and betray them. "peace-keep­ ing" bombings. or how much money the IRS takes from you? These aren't just inevitable "facts of life"­ they are the manifestations of conflict as the system of human rela­ tions. AMap. The fruits and vegetables for sale in the grocery store. ultimately making no distinction and overcoming the self/other di­ chotomy that is at the root of Western alienation. insurance companies. body image standards. of liberty when not of one's fellow be­ ings. those who depend on force to relate to others create a necessity for it. the only way to approach the world that makes sense is with a gun in your hand. poised to plunder their bank accounts and drive them and their children back to work: violence.. laws enforced by public opinion as well as thugs in uniform. which will be thrown in locked dumpsters to rot before they are shared with the hungry a block away: violence. It is love. farther even than the palm-tree­ spotted scenes on the billboards advertising vacation resorts and malt liquor . which pay for prisons to hold men who will slave there as their ancestors did in chain gangs and slave plantations. the trees they cut down by your house to make room for the new gas station? How about the preservatives they put in the food you eat. one bruise. and their children inherit this cycle. violence.* The leagues of * Walk down the street. urg­ ing them to ransom their self-confidence by pouring their income into corporate coffers: violence. or that quiet self-mutilation which lovers and relatives sometimes use to manipulate each other-the inverse and identical twin of macho aggression.65 64. not to mention bombs to be sent as foreign aid to governments who oppress and kill their own: vio­ lence. You may not see one altercation. violence. manufacturers of prescription drugs. The employees who work at the stores. Relationships of Force . psychological pressures that compel people to repress their desires. of the shouts of children at play.. so they can afford a disproportionately small portion of the goods and services made by others like them: violence. even in knowledge of trifling things. to exalt each other and ourselves in the course of living. that makes it possible for us to coexist in pursuit of our own desires rather than languishing in thrall to that fat old god Discord. what they go on repeating inside your head all day. but the feeling in the air is the feeling of war. far away. Look around. The skin cream advertise­ flict and waste. psychiatrists. everyone wishes they were somewhere far. the absence of friends rejoicing together. seeks a lever with which to exert force on his fellows). for the children are all at home with video games and television and no one wants to be here. It comes camouflaged as . The taxes on the sales of those vegetables. or live and die by the sword? When you live in fear. every man for himself and force against us all.

too. all who cannot feel safe enough to create and pursue their own dreams seek compensation in wealth. just as police do. up to this point. The fact that hierarchy can be absent-between friends. all conflicts come down to relations of force-even those known. that the teenage hoodlum is moved to vandalism by insecurity and frustrated yearning. The terror-mongers insist that hierarchy is necessary to protect us from the violence inherent in our species-but hierarchy is simply the large-scale manifestation of the violence intrinsic to this particu­ lar system. as revolutions. no less so than the repression authorities insist is for our own good: conflicts distract. in other societies-is proof that we can live without its attendant violence. Living under the reign of coercion strips you of your faith. But competition and combat are themselves barriers to freedom. the biased news coverage and the inhumanity of factory farms.67 . how much self­ loathing and desperation must then be in the hearts of the moguls and power-brokers whose machinations keep the global market run­ ning? Whether dishwashers or directors. in moments of widespread teamwork. the jockeying for ascendance between colleagues and countries. Under such conditions.intimidating red tape and the battering of women. or more overt forms of power over others. control. Ultimately. on behalf of those beautiful moments when we can be thankful for each other's existence. but to stage a total revolution. a war against the condition of war. status. perpetuate it. it's no wonder many have a hard time imagining how human beings could live with­ out the coercion of supposedly beneficial forces. and simplify all who are subject to them. It is well known that the playground bully acts out of feelings of worthlessness. to treat them as the world has treated you. all these are simul­ taneously expressions of the strife at the heart of our civilization and weapons which. leaves you ready to use force on others. people come to see all human relations as a conflict between mutually exclusive interests. used by factions fighting for survival on its terms. Our dream is not to win another war. AMap.

faith is indispensable for capital-L living. One either invests oneself in the present or the future: either reacts to . We can deduce that those who fear the un­ known reveal the world they know to be a place of terror. and death are projected onto this un­ known. strikes out blindly. if not what she thinks she needs. Fear lies at the root of all violence and coercion.. Faith means trusting that the world is wider and richer than you could possibly see from where you are.Faith means embracing your desire: knowing what you want. fear. whose lives will never be greater than what they can imagine right now! Force cannot rule alone. Faith enables you to relax­ relaxing allows you to act freely and learn from the consequences. in the mind of the ruled. Whether yoUare confronting a police line or giving birth to a child or a song. you'll be able to make out new vistas and make new plans accordingly. there is only darkness. Faith means believing in the boundless possibilities of the universe and setting out to explore them. existing circumstances and their demands. she grows defensive and aggressive. 68. or acts to change them. . Fear. Chaos.. Faith is the engine of the self-fulfilling prophecy. you'll need faith. more powerful than any other desire: anything to take revenge upon the world that has made her feel so unwelcome and worthless. Force can establish domination only in combination with fear. It equips you to rely on your intuition and grants you power over your fear. and there­ fore not feeling pressure to plan out the rest of your life from here. beyond the frontiers of obedience. be­ comes possessed by resentment and cruelty. failure. To succeed in the latter. Faith Invest in the future . and that those who most fear setting out for the horizon stand to gain the most from doing so. You might be better off just sketching a route to the horizon: from there. can rule even in the absence of force. the expectations of your parents and peers. that it will come true. If she feels threatened by them. that it is good. on the other hand. When one trusts her companions and the surrounding world to provide. she spreads them to others like a plague. at least something equally weird and wonder­ ful. Acting on these impulses. He is no~ capable of free action-he is too busy reacting in advance to things that haven't even happened yet. Faith is the opposite of superstition. like faith. Fear dictates that. It means knowing that if you leap off a cliff. But the one who lives in fear moves only to consolidate the present. she too can be gentle and generous. is self-perpetuating-until something breaks the cycle. . and thus chance cannot entrust him with more than he already has. for one can only rule over the living. Vengeance becomes her motivating force. damnation. He can only conceive of the future-any future-as a threat. or protect yourself to death.69 . He trusts nothing to chance. and the weight of your own inertia-or you can risk everything to make those considerations obsolete. You can spend all your energy surviving according to the terms set by the market economy. the unthinkable. this is ironic. you're bound to land somewhere. A Map AMap. Fear . Heaven help those who make long-term plans today and stick to them. in that what one projects can only be based on what one knows. nothingness.

~ other is to follow your fear. let alone zip code. She was personable enough. It seemed inconceivable that something like this existed in my own century. Go search. I arrived at the university on assignment. One is to cower. coddling our fears rather than confronting them. to track it out past: the limits of the world you know. but didn't bother even pretending to take me seriously. The. Could it be that these savages truly didn't give a damn about good press? Dreams.:1 vation of the flesh is futile-we all die someday. we journalists are notoriously thin-skinned and have the instru­ ments of revenge continuously at our fingertips. t . ori do you deny yourself things out of fear? What are you afraid of?. do you?" "Is that what you think? No wonder you're a reporter. exhibitions of Victorian furniture. 71 70. The young barbarian who showed me around the site seemed to regard me as the anachronism.Whatever your path in life." I ges­ tured at the tents around us just as two bleary-eyed ruffians stumbled past with cardboard boxes full of produce.:) 1i There are two possible responses to fear. Don't spare yourself. Don't save yourself. . "You don't expect me to believe you're doing all this without sponsors. he was waiting for a suitable pretext to fire me. A Map . I had attended pie-eating competitions. . or else it will truly be a terrible master. My editor had long known that I'd lost faith in the racket. you must develop a healthy relatio~' ship to your fear. however. what happens first. Some things can't be written or told. We rea~ about "primitive" peoples' rites of passage-but we are the prim1~: tive ones. Wfi' never come of age. Are you living deliberately? Do you approach risk willfully." ~I What are you saving yourself for? Do you own your body? Preser. and in the meantime sent me to cover the least desirable stories. When I showed up the occupation was already in full swing. you must be drawing resources from somewhere. It looked like the outpost of a medieval army: banners painted with inscrutable proclamations. sooty-faced barbarians conferring in the crisp morning air. senior citizen golf tournaments. I didn't expect this to be much different." This was terrible form for anyone hoping for sympathetic cover­ age. The question is!. Every ques ­ tion I asked was turned back around at me: "And which organizations provide your funding?" "Which 'organizations' provide your funding?" "Come on. to use it as a guide. cauldrons of stew steaming over an open fire.

"Not everyone can drop everything and set up\camp here like you. or be paralyzed by them. I. I was. and the world we know. the tragic overture before a beautiful symphony-justifying and absolving ourselves. c her witth questions. to create new possibilities by rearranging existing elements. like the fairy in Pi­ nocchio. our histo­ ries. The alchemist understands it is the forces that count. "Like the king who never had any dreams until the wizard made him " sleep in a pigsty. You can't blame those who cannot imagine more-only show them it exists.That would be something new. a man ? I took to be a janitor rifled through a crate of tools. "Life is not retrospective. Without it. naked and androgynous. in a society that viewed. life itself." ment around us and the objectives of this protest. however dubiously they claimed to regard my employers. it was almost refreshing to encounter someone for .. I have bills to pay. she would have nothing to play against. hacksaw and a bowling pin. finally selecting a. action.of power and public.' pudiated two thousand years of Christian doctrine. On my right. But for the dancer. Instead of breaking off the ! interview to hammer out a dismissive dispatch." I mused aloud. let him have it-let him have it!!-and perish with it.. gravity is a force to be feared. if any even existed. It is up to us to shake it off-or turn it to our advantage. we must make fortune from misfortune and magic of the mun­ dane. 73 . at least until you experience otherwise. inviting her to help me excuse myself. not the materials-the relationships. entwined in an embrace that re. If there is anyone foolish enough to want this world the way it is.. every situation." That had come out more maudlin than I'd intended. For the rest of us. propriety. along with the medieval encamp. no counterpoint for her strength and skill. looking at me for the first time with compassion. "All this is like a dream. and I never dream. ." Scarcity.: once who had no interest in me at all. alchemy is our only hope. people fawned on me. with the weight of inertia. Any situation. cruelty. in the process. some people have careers and responsibilities.the only one who could make them real. either. a hated master. Just as the alchemists of bygone days strove to change lead irito gold. jostling each other out of the way for the chance to tell their' trifling stories. gravity is indispensable. "I don't get it. I was the doorkeeper at the gates. We must dance with our apprehensions. For the slothful man. appointments to keep . "Unfortunately. This was doubly true of radicals and protesters. routine-these things seem like laws of nature. not the things. opinion. Everywhere I went. a character straight out of Kafka. "Let's not be. though with less and less conviction. narrowly resisting the impulse to put my head in my hands." She took my hand and led me breathless from the ruins. the whole world 'through the media lens." I 7::1. With lightness of foot. our agonies. I gave up and sat down. I continued pressing. Finally. can be revolutionized-you simply have to enter know­ ing your life is at stake. I had to admit. My interlocutor didn't have any interest in becoming real-she was content to remain imaginary. Our contest is with gravity.. She seated herself at my side. he finds in it an argument against motion." The open tent flap to the left revealed three sleeping " young people. Dreams Alchemy / Dreams. She flies all the more gracefully for being born without wings. we can trans­ form our centuries-long history of destruction and disappoint­ ment into a mere prologue." she confided.

c::--. long the catchword of every revolu­ tion and resistance.Beyond Democracy?! . So why isn't everybody happy..t :'c "J ust be thankful you live in a democracy!" Nowadays. democracy rules the world. finally? For that matter-why do so few of the eligible voters in the United States. elections are taking place in all those third world countries you see on television. . Communism is long dead. 75 . is simply not democratic enough? What could be more democratic? Beyond Democracy. -~~_.:.~~~.--­ -~~~::~~~...':i~::~. even bother to vote? Could it be that democracy. i'r=. and world leaders are meeting to plan the "global commu­ nity" we hear so much about. the world's flagship democracy.

an informed citizenry is supposed to vote according to their enlightened self-interest-but who controls the flow of information under capitalism if not wealthy executives? They can't help but skew their coverage according to their class interests. the rich can always buy others' votes: either literally. the most transparent democratic political process will always be trumped by economic matters such as property ownership. or any other question that could seriously change the way we live? In such a state of affairs. Thus. It's no coincidem. both exist i. and yOU can hardly blame them-the newspapers and networks that didn't flinch at alienating corporate advertisers were run out of business long ago by com­ petitors with fewer scruples. or whether workers are entitled to the full product of their labor. 'Let'S suspend our misgivings about democracy long enough to consider wheth­ er. Intimidation may be oblique-"Those radicals want to take away your hard-earned property"­ or as overt as the bloody gang wars that accompanied electoral campaigns in nineteenth century America. just like being a billionaire: for every person who. This demoralizes dissidents and contributes to the general impression that they are impotent utopians-when nothing is more utopian than trusting representatives from the owning class to redress the grievances caused by their own dominance. a privileged world off limits to the rest of us. our economy isn't exactly democratic-capitalism distribut resources in absurdly unequal proportions. Beyond Democracy .* . and you have to st with resources if you're ever going to get elected. it could be compatible with capitalism. according to which possi­ bilities seem most desirable-but who sets the options. President. the two-party system has reduced politics to choosing the lesser of two identical evils. the essential func­ tion of the democratic process is to limit the appearance of what is possible to the narrow spectrum debated by candidates for office. democracy can only serve its purported purpose if it occurs among those who explicitly oppose capi­ talism and foreswear its prizes-and in those circles.: that billionaires and Presidents tend to rub shoulders. one vote. consensus makes a lot more sense than majority rule. in one vast general assembly.. both of which answer to their funders before anyone else. even at best. Being President means occupying a position of hil archical power. there have to be millions who are not. Likewise. what would prevent the same dynamics that rule the marketplace from spill­ ing over into that sacred space? So long as resources are unevenly distributed. who constructs desire itself but the wealthy patriarchs of the political establishment and their nephews in advertising and public re­ lations firms? In the United States. Ultimately. In a democracy. aires.Every little child can grow up to be President. Sure. and nothing more impotent than accepting their political system as the only possible political system. capitalists and convicts alike. Even if we could convene everyone. the parties differ over exactly how much to repress personal freedoms or spend on bombs-but do we ever get to vote on who controls "public" spaces such as shopping malls. voting means choosing between options. who establishes what is considered possible. or by promising a piece of the pie. if it were an effective means for people to share power over their lives. Speaking of billio. No they can't. or else by means of propaganda and intimidation. capitalism + democracy one dollar. = 76 .

The Tyranny of the Majority If you ever found yourself in a vastly outnumbered minority. does anyone really believe it makes sense to accept the authority of a group simply on the grounds that they outnumber everyone else? We accept majority rule because we do not believe it will threaten us-and those it does threaten are already silenced before anyone can hear their misgivings. and then they're back at work again} the next time the town council meets. ordinances displeases citizens. when one of those". he conceives of himself as having the power and moral authority of the majority: if not in fact.. In theory. because he believes everyone would be convinced by his arguments if only he had the opportu­ nity to present them.j elect a different town council from the available pool of politicians' and would-be politicians.. gerrymandering. they have to use what little leisure'[ time they have to contest it.. Corrup-~ tion. consciously or not. in which we are free from the mob rule of the majority as well as the ascendancy of the privileged class. thad wouldn't help the millions who inevitably don't. . the political apparatus itself is the foundation of that imbalance. 79 . The average self-professed law-abiding citizen does not consider himself threatened by majority rule because. the citizens could. who must still. To succeed in their objective. everyone could be made to see that there is only one right course of action-without this belief. theywouldj inevitably perpetuate it simply by accepting roles in the system-for .1' municipal affairs and pass ordinances all day without consulting. . Living under democratic rule teaches people to think in terms of quantity. to focus more on public opinion than on what their consciences tell them. and hierarchy aside. and inane party loyalty usually prevent them:! from going that far. and the majority voted that you had to give up something as necessary to your life as water and air. majority rule is not only inher-i ently oppressive but also paradoxically divisive and homogenizing < at the same time. voting: fraud. people still would have their individual perspectives and motivations and needs. assuming such a thing were possible. government was elected consisting of firebrands intent on undoing] the imbalance of power between politicians and citizens. live in the shadow of that power. at the local level as much as' at the top. to see themselves as powerless unless they are immersed in a mass. We need social and political structures that take this into account. by virtue of his being politically and socially "moderate.' But even if there were no Presidents or town councils. but the interests of politicians as a class. The root of majority-rule democracy is competition: competition to persuade everyone else to your position Whether or not it is in their best interest. But even if "the" facts could be made equally clear to everyone. Majority-rule democracy has always rested on the conviction that if all the facts were known. it amounts to nothing more than the dictatorship of the herd.:t the citizens of the town. would you comply? When it comes down to it. Even in the unlikely scenario that a whole new." then in theory. privilege." always remain essentially at odds with their own-besides.. competition to constitute a majority to wield power before others outmaneuver you to do the Even if it was true that anyone could grow up to be President. Beyond Democracy Beyond Democracy. who have to be at work. . This imbalance is intrinsic to the::: structure of representative democracy. ~j 78. democracy" as we know it would still be an impediment to freedom. The professional politicians of a town council discuss \ . they would have to dissolve the gov­ ernment and join the rest of the populace in restructuring society! from the roots up.

such laws can only institutionalize what is already the rule in a society. the sensible and compassionate are bound to end up as defendants. foreigners. 80 . Ironically. majority rule forces those who wish for power to appeal to the lowest common denominator. and good will. All the better if there are eve: more repressive dictatorships near at hand to point to as «the» alternative. and demagogic. impersonal regulations.. the less any individual can do on her own. mutual respect. just as no boss or bureaucrat would dream of giving his ." scarcely an eighth of the population was permitted to vote. it simply creates another arena of specialization. This is generally regarded as an early kink that time has ironed out. in which power and responsibility are ceded to expensive lawyers and pomp­ ous judges. power itself comes to be associated with confor ­ mity rather than individuality. he should work harder so he too can own a restaurant chain. Justice cannot be established through the mere drawing up and enforcement of laws. precipitating a race to . Democracy is the most sustainable way to maintain) the distinction between powerful and powerless because it gives the greatest possible number of people incentive to defend that distinction. only a minority can do this. In purporting to give everyone an opportunity to participate. and you can build . so in a roundabout way it turns out that. but that doesn't make it any less "! exclusive.the bottom that rewards the most bland. common front of destructive self-interest against the cooperation and coll tivity that make individual freedom possible. That's why the high-water mark of democracy-its current ascendancy around the globe-corresponds with unprecedented inequities in the distribution of resources and power. majority-rule democracy offers a perfect justification for repressing those who don't abide by its dictates: if they don't like the govern­ ment. and the distinc. why it isn't practical to allow everyone whose interests are involved to share' in decision making. the courts exist to protect the rights of at least a certain minority. to impose the legislation of the majority on the mi­ nority. and brainwash entire generations and their children will invent struggle for freedom anew. Where the law is the private province of an elite invested in its own perpetuation. a person is only able to use the courts to defend his rights when he can bring sufficient force to bear upon them in a currency they recognize. we are told that we need these institutions to protect the rights of minorities-even though the implicit function of the courts is. since their careers depend upon it. under democracy." At the same time. Common sense and compassion are al­ ways preferable to the enforcement of strict. didn't they • The disempowerment of losers and out-groups is central to democracy. Sure. but as a way of keeping power out of certain hands? . and oth ­ ers were excluded from citizenship. the «cradle of democracy. at best. this arrangement ensures that our communities' skills for conflict resolution and self-defense atrophy-and that those whose profession it supposedly is to discourage crime have a stake in it proliferating. And the more power is concentrated in the hands of the majority. in con­ trast to forms of decision-making in which everyone's needs matter. Every bourgeois property owner can come up with a thousand reaso~ . In actuality. you can glorify all this in the rhetoric of liberty. as women. you have to acknowledge that legal institutions are no substitute for fairness. employees an equal say in their workplace. everyone gets a chance to compete. Rather than serving to protect our communities and work out conflicts. superficial. WHat if-we must at least broach the hypothesis-democracy arose " in Greece not as a step in Man's Progress Towards Freedom. but one could also conclude that exclusion itself is i the most essential and abiding characteristic of democracy: millions who live j in the United States today are not permitted to vote either. we need a social system that fosters and rewards those qualities rather than blind obedience and impassivity. to be able to force the «will of the majority» upon his fellows rathe than work through disagreements like a mature adult. why don't they go into politics themselves? And if they don't win at the game of building up a majority to wield power. get their chance? This is the same blame-the-victim reasoning used to justify capitalism: if the dishwasher isn't happy with his salary." as fetishized by the stockholders and landlords whose interests' it protects. Beyond Democracy Beyond Democracy. But promise every man the opportunity to be dictator. the minorities) be damned.I tions between citizen and non-citizen have not eroded significantly in 2500 years. indeed. It is well known that in ancient Athens. 81 . Dictatorships are inherently unstable: you can slaughten imprison. slaves. thanks to capitalism. however unequal-but what about those of us who don't want to compete. The rule of "just and equal law. The Rule of Law Even if you don't believe their purpose is to grind out nonconformity wherever it appears. who never wanted power to be centralized in the hands of a government in the first place? What if we don't care to rule or be ruled? That's what police are for-and courts and judges and prisons.same-and the losers (that is to say. whether she is inside or outside that majority. offers no guarantees against injustice.

even though our labor ha~ built it. To get there from here. "Look. i For a better illustration of real freedom in action. television shows. not a possession that can be kept in the basement and taken out and polished up for parades. Beyond Democracy Beyond Democracy. as if freedom and political power could be held by proxy. We can make our own decisions as individuals and communities. Take . Freedom '. 83 . Real freedom has nothing to do with voting. musician in the act of improvising with her companions: in joy. Politicians make careers out of claiming to represent others. health care to doctors. In Contrast to representative democracy. you can only learn what your interests are by getting involved. Freedom is a quality of activity. seemingly effortless co­ operation. look at the. ballot before returning to work in an environment no more under his control than it was before. harmony in human relation­ ships and activity. the participants take part in the decision-making process on an ongoing basis and exercise real 82 . But we don't have to simply choose between presidential candi ­ dates. in fact. transforming the world that. we can establish a new society on the basis of freedom and cooperation. and political ideologies. ing able to choose between options. and control of our living environments to city planners and private real estate developers. not a condition that exists in a vac­ uum: it is a prize to be won daily. Voting in elections is an expression of our powerlessness: it is an admission that we can only approach the resources and capabili­ ties of our own society through the mediation of that priest class. but actively participating in establishing the options in the first place.It's no coincidence "freedom" is not on the ballot. they are a priest class that answers only to itself. cannot be given-the most you can hope is to free others from the' forces that prevent them from finding it themselves. then the heritage our emancipating forefathers and suffragette grandmothers have left us is nothing but a sham substitute for the liberty they sought. we have to dispense.] ent from our present system--'a . this model and extend it to ev­ ~ ery one of our interactions with . in turn transforms them. a ballot box-democracy!!" If the freedom for which so many generations have fought and died : is best exemplified by a man in a voting booth checking a box on a . ~. we relinquish control of our communities to these politicians in the same way that we have ceded technology to engineers. each other and you would have something qualitatively diffef. they create a sonic and emotional environment. soft drink brands. and their very existence is proof of our disenfranchisement. we can make our own delicious beverages and social structures and power.. No one can represent your power and interests for you-you can only have power by wielding it. with voting as the archetypal expression of freedom and par­ ticipation. Here's how. What are the democratic alternatives to democracy? Consensus Consensus-based decision-making is already practiced around the globe.f ous. for we have acted like sleep­ walkers hypnotized by the monopoly our leaders and specialists hold on setting the possibilities. being free doesn't mean simply be. We end up living in a world that is alien to us. Representative democracy is a contradiction in terms. from indigenous communities in Latin America and direct ac­ tion groups in Europe to organic farming cooperatives in Australia.. When we let them prefabricate our options for us.

Consensus can be as repressive as democracy unless the participants retain their autonomy. can only empower a group by disempowering the individuals who comprise it. Finally. Topless Federations Independent autonomous groups can work together in federations without any of them wielding authority. Groups that cooperate thus can contain conflicts and contradictions. it is everyone's responsibil­ ity to find a new solution that is acceptable to all. To claim these privileges for yourself and respect them in others is to cultivate autonomy. what it loses in efficiency it makes up tenfold in freedom and accountability. however hori­ zontally it is imposed. Instead of asking that people accept leaders or find common cause by homogenizing themselves. divides individuals who might otherwise form cooperative groups with no use for politicians. though it does require that everybody consider ev­ eryone else's needs. No one is more qualified than you _ are to decide how you live. you must have control over your immediate surroundings and the basic matters of your life. 84 . Autonomy To be free. so long as everyone benefits from everyone else's participation. Such a structure sounds utopian. Beyond Democracy . unless your fundamental goal is to control other people. it is one of the most significant obstacles to building communityr In contrast to this Western mirage. Autonomy is the antithesis of bureaucracy. if -one person is unhappy with a resolution. but it can actually be quite practical and efficient. and in ex­ panding the territory of autonomy and consensus by doing every-­ thing in ~heir power to destroy coercive structures. There is nothing more efficient than people acting on their own initiative as they see fit. Let's leave marching under a single flag to the military. Autonomous groups have a stake in defending themselves against the encroachments of those who do not recognize their right to self-determination. and nothing more inefficient than attempting to dictate every­ one's actions from above-that is. to name two examples: while individual postal and transportation Beyond Democracy _85 -Mohandas Gandhi t The politicians' myth of "welfare mothers" snatching hardworking Citizens' rightful earnings. obligatory uniformity. since our lives all depend on each other. Consensus-based decision-making does not demand that any person accept others' power over her. likewise. Top-down coordination is only necessary when people must be made to do something they would never do * ·Western man fills his closet with groceries and calls himself self-sufficient.control over their daily lives.* The glamorization of self-sufficiency in competitive society is an underhanded way to accuse those who will not exploit oth­ ers of being responsible for their own poverty. as such. just as each of us does individually. Autonomy is not to be confused with so-called independence: in actuality. con­ sensus values the needs and concerns of each individual equally. autonomy entails self-defense. consen­ sus process integrates all into a working whole while allowing each to retain his or her own autonomy. for example. no one is independent. no one should be able to vote on what you do with your time and your potential unless you invite them to. autonomy offers a free interdependence be­ tween people who share consensus. Unlike majority-rule democracy. Inter­ national mail delivery and railway travel both work on this system. and still empower the participants." j I~ of their own accord. Autonomous individuals can cooperate without agreeing on a shared agenda.

'. don't just give money to a bureaucratic charity organization­ find out where food is going to waste. may find themselves banished from social life­ but that is still better than exile in the mental ward or on death row. Take the initiative! discourage most destructive or disrespectful behavior.. that group can split into smaller groups that can achieve it internally-such a thing may be inconvenient and frustrating. that's the most difficult part. collect it.. Don't buy their . too-it only looks valid because they bought up the laws . ) products. and share. Direct Action Autonomy necessitates that you act for yourself: that rather than waiting for requests to pass through the established channels only to bog down in paperwork and endless negotiations. individuals who cannot agree enough to work together within one collective can still coexist in separate groups. sabotage their billboards and offices. and organize groups to defend them when the thugs of the absentee landlords show up. but it is better than group decisions ultimately being made by force by those who have the most power. Beyond Democracy Beyond Democracy. the threat of exclusion should be enough to 86 .. For this to work in the long run.systems are internally hierarchical. But we're not talking about just another social system here. If you want affordable housing. Serious disagreements within communities can be solved in many cases by reorganizing or subdividing groups. If you want corporations to have less power. of course. exclusion is certainly a more humanitar­ ian approach than prisons and executions. If you want hungry people to have food to eat. In consensus-based structures. living Without Permission . and we can hardly do worse at this ' task than the partisans of capitalism and hierarchy have. Violence should only be used by communities in self-defense.. don't try to get the town council to pass a bill-that will take years.1 prevent their meetings from taking place and their merchandise ~ from being delivered. they must be careful not to lose those values themselves in the process of defending them. in a world governed by force. take over abandoned buildings. who will not integrate themselves into any community. we need to instill values of cooperation. two of the possibilities awaiting such people today. Those who refuse to respect others' needs. don't work for them. Often individuals who can't get along in one social configuration have more success cooperating in another setting or as members of parallel commu­ nities. they all cooperate together to get mail or rail passengers from one nation to another without an ultimate authority being necessary at any point in the process. Simi­ larly. Even when it is impossible to avoid. As with individuals and society. Let's not kid ourselves­ until we can achieve this. that should be incentive enough for people to sort out their differences. the violence and strife inherent in con­ flict-based relations will continue to intensify. of course. and no law or system will be able to protect us. 87 .l ticipating individual. we're talking about a total transformation of human relations-for it will take nothing less to solve the problems our species faces today. don't petition the politicians they bought to put limits on their own masters-take that power from them yourself. i consideration. don't beg some higher power to organize your life for you. there are How to Solve Disagreements Without Calling the Authorities In a social arrangement that is truly in the best interest of each par-:. which corrupt police and judges as much as they embitter criminals. and must somehow negoti­ ate ways to achieve this . open them up to the public. Even drastically dissimilar communities still have it in their best interest to coexist peacefully. au­ tonomous consensus-based groups are likely to find themselves at odds with those who do not abide by cooperative or tolerant val­ ues. and tolerance in the coming generations-but that's exactly what we are proposing. you establish J your own channels instead. and values of your society long before you were born. If consensus cannot be reached within a group. not with the smug sense of entitlement with which it is applied by our present injustice system. so with different collectives: if the benefits of working together outweigh the frustra­ tions. Don't wait for permission or leadership from some outside au­ thority. while people sleep outside every night. Unfortunately. They use similar tactics to exert their power :) over you.

the virtues of this way of living are clear.no fake solutions. The first precious grains of this new world can be found in your friendships and love affairs whenever they are free from power dy­ namics. if your representatives will not do it for you-since they cannot do it for you. those who participate in them must learn to coexist without co­ ercion and submission. Whoever they vote for. Beyond Democracy . and' chase down freedom for yourselves. whenever cooperation occurs naturally. we are ungovernable! ! ~ I j I~ I 88. but the wonderful thing about consensus and autonomy is that you don't have to wait for the government to vote for them­ you can practice them right now with the people around you. Put " into practice. Imagine those mo­ ments expanded to the scale of our entire society-that's the life that waits beyond democracy. Form your i own autonomous group. It may feel like we are separated from that world by an uncross­ able chasm. answering to no power but your own. no ways to suppress conflict without resolving it.

"Watch this. which-" The councilman turned his attention to the second speaker. 91 . I might have said they did. get to the point!" It hadn't occurred to me until then that they intended to make the bureaucrats lose their composure. That was my state of mind in the audience of the city council meeting as I waited to speak about the water table.. your only hope of escape. businessmen putting in appearances to smooth over back-room deals-it was clear we were out of our league. besides a few people I took to be city '. The citizens there couldn't see beyond their own property rights. I had nothing to compare them to. Watching the speakers before us-homeowners outraged about speed bumps. there was only one name left on the ledger before hers. There is a standard policy for signing up to address the Town. I'd wanted to do something that mattered with my life. now. "You see. and those moments') succeed each other like Chinese water torture. he was better prepared to deal with this kind of disruption. The longer I sat there. the more it turned my stomach to think about trying to make a case to those bureaucrats.. But the councilmen had finished their remarks. and his dark eyes narrowed like a hawk's. I was applying to schools in hopes of getting funding to study abroad. Heaven only knew what kept the two of them there-it ') didn't look like they had any property to speak of. those who do battle with monsters-" The mayor had turned bright red and was pounding his fist on the table: "Get to the point. a councilman attempted to cut him off. "Let me remind everyone that those who speak out of turn will be removed. he began in a mumbling drone: "Several men meet their deaths at the hands of a monster.Nature abhors a vacuum. and began shuffling through a sheaf of dog-eared papers. The rustle of those papers over the PA speakers was the only sound in the room for almost a full minute. I had been living under that pressure since Daniel's funeral. I'd wanted wild romance. and had started to taktf' refuge from it in a contrived cynicism-the inverse of the enforced optimism I'd had to adopt for job applications and presentations like this one. When you've decided that spontaneity and passion are. employees. gripes. the boy next to me called out in a booming voice: "Your honor. Two Councils Two Councils. and pitches. My neighbor kicked his chair back and leaped onto it.i dous. and it is not fair to other citizens to mis­ use this venue. Rita and I had fidgeted quietly through a seemingly interminable succession of for­ malities. and civilization is no different. what my colleague is getting at is that it would be a grave mistake to evict the occupation from the university. One of them was the only other \~ brown face in the audience. These peo­ ple didn't give a damn about water or anything else. which anyone can make use of. if I remembered correctly. I might also have told you that I only made it from one moment to the next by imagining everything around me on fire. impossible that anything exciting will happen. I was dating a nice boy who went trespassing with me on the weekends. it was hard enough convincing myself it mattered what they thought or did. let me add something on the subject of monsters. I'd settled for a little environmental ac­ tivism. the pressure can be trernen. the only ones that struck me as remotely interesting were the two shabbily dressed". But first." he continued. waving his arms and roaring like a madman: 90. Had you asked me then whether these satisfied me. I'd longed for adven­ ture. young men seated at my right. The young man to my right leaned confidentially across the empty seat between us. after months of flailing around. At last. "But we have something of great importance to convey to you about this matter. if not your ! basis for life. so it was that one by one I found ersatz versions of everything I'd set out to experience." he whispered. brushed back disheveled black hair. Two monsters from the Department of the Interior come to look the situation over . At that point. Finally. in pompous parody of the officials. they had their ". " As he continued. and the woman who had been complaining in coded language about Latino youth appearing in her neighborhood was returning to her seat. hands full keeping up with their own bureaucracy and thought too highly of themselves to aspire to anything more. the faces around me shifted slowly from disin­ terest to disbelief." The hoodlum at the podium straightened up and threw back his shoulders. His companion stood up and walked slowly to the podium. Nothing is more terrifying than the moments when it seems.

"The point is, we all tried to be good citizens, behaving ourselves and trying to beat each other out for promotions and spending our money on soft drinks-and we ended up dishwashers and doormen, waiting in line at the free clinic to have our rotten teeth pulled by student volunteers! It's a fucking PYRAMID SCAM and you know it! The point is, there are fifty of us on that campus who aren't afraid of you because we have an entirely different future ahead of us than anything you can offer-and if there are fifty today, there'll be fifty thousand tomorrow, because people are dying for something else and some of us are ready to LIVE for it, TOO!! The point is, I'm warning you-you're dealing with fucking ANARCHISTS! We didn't sign your social contract! If you're willing to coexist with us, we'll share everything we have with you, we'll go to any length to work out conflicts-but if you want to be the boss, if you want to give orders and' always be in the right, then whether you', have a security guard or a whole civilization: behind you we're going to have to FIG HT until one of us is DEAD, because one thing we will NOTdo is BE RULED!!! Are you listening to me?"
92, Two Councils

A man in a uniform was struggling to make his way down our aisle; in the second subversive act of my life, I stretched out my leg, making him stumble just as he reached for the orator's arm, The lat­ ter, having completed his address, leaped to an empty chair behind us and bounded that way from row to row all the way to the back of the room, dodging audience members who clutched their purses and briefcases as he passed. His partner met him at the door, loose papers filling the air behind him; I could see now that these were handbills. It seemed certain that the two would be apprehended there, but at that instant there was shouting and movement from the other side of the room as a cloud of smoke appeared from between the seats. When I looked back to the door, they were gone. Even after the smoke had cleared and a functionary had gathered up most of the papers, the meeting did not resume for some min­ utes. Not only had the incident thoroughly rattled everyone, but it appeared the young man who had been at the podium had taken the microphone with him. Rita and I filed out along with much of the audience as more men in uniforms bustled about and town officials conferred in ir­ ritated knots. Some of the people around me were silent; others spoke in hushed tones. A few were actually laughing. I was relieved not to have to make our presentation, but the rest of what had hap­ pened hadn't yet sunk in. I glanced at the handbill I'd picked up:

If it were not for the prisons they threaten to lock us in, we might see that we are all in prison. If it were not for monsters like the sweatshop profiteers, we might see that capitalism has made us all monstrous. We visit zoos to see what becomes ofthe wild ones, we sit in audiences to learn that we are not musicians orprotagonists
-or city councilmen, I thought to myself. I pushed open the door and stepped out into the cool autumn air. Hanging across the building opposite Town Hall was a homemade banner as long as a city bus. In enormous scarlet letters it read, simply,

EXPECT RESISTANCE

Two Councils, 93

A few days later the ones who had instigated the fracas at the town council meeting were my new best friends, but it was another month before I learned of the protracted discussions that had preceded it. After the university announced that they were definitely going to evict the encampment, word had reached the occupiers that city police would be brought in for the eviction. There followed a series of meetings that began late in the afternoon and continued into the early hours of morning. Although I wasn't there, I can imagine based on later meetings how it must have played out. At first there was quite a bit of dissen­ sion: some argued that the occupation had served its purpose and it would be most empowering for the participants to quit while they were ahead, while others contended that if the goal was to exert leverage on the administration by offering a deterrent to working with noxious corporations, that could best be achieved by forcing them to carry out the most expensive and embarrassing eviction pos­ sible. Eventually implacable camps crystallized on opposite sides of this issue, and the group split up into two separate meetings so each could establish what its goals were and what it asked of the other. Some hours later, it had been negotiated that the fifty-odd occupi­ ers who desired a confrontation with the university would remain, but that they would release a statement to the effect that they no longer had anything to do with the student group. It had been im­ portant until then to blur the line between the student organiza­ tion and the rest of the occupiers to maintain the "legitimacy" of the occupation, but now that a messy eviction was inevitable that association was a needless liability. Those who remained faced the challenging task of organizing the defense of the encampment. This was particularly complicated because there were almost certainly police agents among them who would not only report proposed illegal activity but also attempt to steer the planning in the least advantageous direction possible. First, as a group, they agreed on their basic goals and guidelines: making

the eviction costly was a higher priority than positive media cover­ age; no one was to be injured, but destruction of property was not ruled out; resources for legal defense would be shared according to need with all those arrested, regardless of charges. Next, everyone split into smaller groups to strategize with people they knew and trusted. This ensured that those who shared longstanding friend­ ships could make the most of their comfort and experience while police agents ended up with other is~lated newcomers, planning the aspects of the defense that required the least security. Once some of those groups had hashed out their own plans, they sent delegates to other groups to propose collaborations, sharing only the information that was necessary for joint coordination. By this time, it was late at night; small circles of conspirators dotted the grass around the en­ campment, while elsewhere on campus spokespersons of the more cautious groups held hushed consultations in twos and threes. None of this happened easily, I was told. At every step, there were arguments, ruptures, hurt feelings and angry accusations. At the time, these must have seemed the inevitable price of organiz­ ing in stressful circumstances with people from such a wide range of perspectives; much later, it became clear that we hadn't taken conflicts seriously enough from the beginning. We lost the follow­ ing round of struggle because no one addressed the rifts when they first appeared.

!

i

94 . Two Council,

Two Councils. 95

Once upon a time, it was said that capitalism reduced the industrial worker to an appendage of flesh on a machine of iron. Today, that description can be applied across the board: each of us is a mere appendage of flesh on the vast machine that is our society, for our communities and lives are divided into isolated sectors to such an extent that the totality they comprise appears entirely beyond our control. If we want to change the whole of life, we must somehow become whole again ourselves.

Separation: The Disintegration of Self
Modern man's daily activity is as atomized as the cities that cir­ cumscribe it. He experiences existence as an ongoing conflict be­ tween achievement, romance, responsibility, fitness, relaxation, and pleasure because all these pursuits seem to be mutually ex­ clusive. He would like to spend more time with his wife, but if he doesn't stay at the office another hour he won't be able to advance his career, and then he has to go to the gym to offset the effects of lunch ... and there's that damn vacation to plan for, not to men­ tion world news to catch up on, before he can even think about ro­ mance. He downloads music over the internet, but never has time to listen to it; he would like to get involved insome kind of volun­ teer work, but doesn't know where it would fit in his schedule. It's hard enough just keeping up with his favorite radio program, and even that doesn't provide him with much relief from the strain of his busy life. Meaning, of course, is absent everywhere when life is this disjointed; as none of his activities engage him completely, he cannot find lasting satisfaction in any of them. Compare this with the integrated, holistic life of the hunter­ gatherer. For her, there is no distinction between working and playing, between taking care of her practical needs, enjoying her­ self, and spending time with her children, friends, and lovers. She moves through the world, deriving sustenance, physical fitness, and companionship from the same activities, weaving a daily life that is both challenging and familiar: at once adventure, livelihood, and religious ceremony. Perhaps you've experienced this kind of life before in an enter­ prise that incorporated every aspect of your being into a perfect equilibrium. If we cannot reintegrate our lives, we will squander them trying to make impossible choices between equally indispens­ able pieces of ourselves. Likewise, if we want to make revolutionary social change, we have to find ways of living that are revolutionary in their very nature; for activism, environmental conservationism, Or social responsibility as separate domains of life-as hobbies, or even as day jobs-can never outweigh the effects of the rest of our lives.

Divided & Conquered

Divided & Conquered. 97

Specialization discourages all of us from being well-rounded human beings. For an example of the impoverishing effects of specialization. Divided & Conquered Divided & Conquered. the fewer of us are able to exercise any control over our environments: "Call the repair man. the division of knowledge itself becomes authoritarian. from chemist to biochemist. Many question authority in the political sense. the more obscure the language used by those in the know. for it grants small groups of people vast power over others who are incapable of informed participation in decisions that affect their lives. there would be no nuclear weapons. our society is fragmented by ever-increasing specialization as every sphere of life is relegated to the care of experts. Every profession is divided and subdivided: from scientist to chemist. car mainte­ nance to automechanics. Thus engineers and computer programmers are willing to build weapons of mass destruction and crack the codes of "sub­ versive" groups for the government. each of these experts experiences so­ ciety as an external force acting on him without his participation. social change to professional politicians or amateur activists. At the same time. Homo Fragmens romance work Crime or Miracle: A Complete Human Being JOHN BROWN AT THE AGE OF 58. The more complicated technologies become. from biochemist to pharmaceutical neurobiologist until no one outside a handful of authorities can understand the questions. What is meaningful about a painting cannot be captured by purchasing it in a gallery and hanging it on "milY~ -. without such men. An expert who does his job well without ever reflecting upon how his work impacts the social whole is potentially extremely dangerous. Entertainment is left to movie directors. 99 . let alone the answers. At that point." we chant. without an analysis of the part they play in society. con­ sider how rarely adults who are not recognized as "artists" partake of the joys of aesthetic creation. even though it is comprised of people like himself. intimidated into ignorance and impotence. but few are prepared to question the authorities on technical matters. for they have never taken the time to reflect seriously on the effects of their efforts-they simply do what they have learned to do for whoever provides them the opportunity and salary to do it.ethics entertainment Specialization: The Division of Labor Just as our individual lives are fragmented by compartmentaliza­ tion. Becoming a specialist is a self-selecting process: only those will­ ing to concentrate on one subject to the exclusion of all others can excel at it. 98.

. can. or when they started bussing students from the ghetto. separated by the walls of gated communitieqj the windows of restaurants and automobiles. and has a sudden exhilarat." "Every man for himself" means" . The proverbial white picket fence of suburbs. . cannot sing.. all but a few of us have learned that we cannot paint.­ Crow laws." insofar as must renounce all the parts of himself that reside in other peopk if we were really out "for ourselves" we would demolish every b rier that separates us. . Classes and.. borders are open for commoditiesi and closed to human bodies. but an essential part of the capitalist world' order. from an earlier era. against himself.. just like the walls that separate Mexico from the United. Segregation: The Sub-Division of Communities' Any schoolchild knows racial segregation didn't end with the Jim.(' ___ . dicates a pathological drive to deprive oneself of all the nutrien . cannot dance. Loncelveo. but by the end of elementary school. the art critics who deify them-just like the genius of scientists and" the arcane knowledge of locksmiths-have fooled us into denying': ourselves some of the sweetest gifts life has to offer.. communities cannot learn from each other. This is not a holdover. At the most. This is something we could all take part in. now hypertrophied into cinderblock and barbed wire. each with our' unique talents. States and Palestine from Israel. for example.--0 . But this subtle apartheid goes further: wherever there are w: between communities.. .\" selves valuable commodities-tourists. not exchange resources or intermingle. and invisible barrierS! a thousand times more difficult to traverse. except when those bodies are them.:' to detention rooms at predominantly white schools." ing insight. races still live apart. they intersec_.ues with his comrades late one --'6 . ~ myth of the divine inspiration of artists and the expert credentials of. through the market and mass media-white kids buy hip hop al­ bums and think they know about life in the 'hood. With the barriers in place. for healthy relations with others are the m precious form of wealth.. there are inevitably walls between Indrvi uals within each community and walls within individuals as we_. oout narrative and form..

giving and receiving freely. she has adventures collecting fo~l and other supplies through urban hunting and gathering that does not. society. there need not be artificial boundaries between that group and oth­ ers. each group tends to blame others for its woes: the library:. but for the past few centuries we've been struggling to deal with the difficulties of not living in such communities-and we haven't had much success.!. '! or the oppressed peoples of the Third World? Such isolated. to suc~ an extent that over time they are able to lose some members and gain! others without losing their customs or closeness.. and psychologically. socially. limited only by their own sociability. Conquered Divided &. Conquered. it might as well be towards a uto­ pia in which our lives can encompass everything the cosmos has to offer. somewhere in the world there is an underground'] circus or punk rock band on tour./ whatever their individual strengths may be. not treat its symptoms one by one. Unbeknownst to themselves and'( others.'l find themselves in competition with other activists: Will Congress.] Responsibilities are shared and valued equally within the group.~ tually exclusive campaigns and frameworks can only maintain th¢'C. for the cooperation and" contentment of each is crucial to the functioning of the group.. we need to transform our sickl. Each . End Segregation! Reintegrate Our Lives! \ Divorces Production Art Work Lovers Intimacy Farms Management Theory Rich Youth White Men Entertainment Exercise Words Technology Self-interest Poetry Workplaces Business Consumption Life Play Friends Sexuality Supermarkets Labor Action Poor Age Color Women Education Relaxation Deeds Nature Generosity Resistance Apartments Pleasure As you read this. would get the necessary funding if only it wasn't going to the lin~j guistics department. conflict with her anti-consumerist ethics. They can move through a variety of social and cultural circles.\: ognize themselves in each other. able to pull itself up by its bootstraps if it wasn't for the Korean: merchants leeching off it. Even political activists. mu". the African-American community would be :1. we'd have to downsize and rework our whole civilization to follow the lead this merry little band offers.J member's daily activities satisfy her various desires: she feels at home with her friends while she travels through new environments. she gets exer1! cise loading and unloading equipment. andj whenever someone wants a break from something or is curious to learn': about something else she switches roles with another person. Best of all. people rarely seek common cause. she no longer haSJ to distinguish between her own needs and those of the people around~ her.Separated spatially. underpinnings of our powerlessness. sh~jl makes art that simultaneously entertains and educates. 102. This spills over into their interactions with those outside their clan. she learns new things repairing1 the van and interacting with locals. prioritize forest protection legislation this session. Together all the participants function as an extended family. unable to rec.t' Instead. Yes. or focus on abor-] tion rights? Is the revolutionary subject of history the proletariat. No one~ member's participation is any more or less important than any other's. and this eliminates most of the stress of interacting with others. If we're going to struggle anyway.. 103 . in taking on sin-i gle issues rather than addressing the root causes of modern misery. If there are no hierarchies or rigid divisions within a group. they carry with them the seeds of an ancient social structure. Divided &.

invisible to the students with their symbolic logic and art hi. I had to come up with something else. I grabbed a paper towel and held it doubled between my fingers and thumb. There were designer book bags unattended on the tables behind me. As soon as I was through the exit door. we'd evict the university first. I was completely at peace. probably the last time they'd see me on campus. No one was looking at me. In the course of hour. and split up. I inhabited my body like an animal. The sheer ton~ nage of unguarded food was exhilarating for someone used to hav'" ing to shoplift it one candy bar at a time. Now there was no time to worry about consequences and complications. the kids around me weren't paying attention. I'd underestimated: backpack was big. tory homework. There were a couple dozen of us in teams of twos and threes. I pulled my hood back. I upended the shelves of fruit one after another into the garbage bag. I'd never gotten over! the shock I felt every time I entered the cafeteria. as soon as it was done. 105 . Without glancing at the pandemonium around me. more food left on the conveyor belt into the dish room th my mother brought home in a month-and on the other side of wall. On the way out. I walked straight to the fruit display. then shook all the bagels out of their display case into my backpack and pushed in the one-gallon pea­ nut butter can for good measure. let alone the bagels I had my eye on. I hung aroundl the back door until a couple students came out. I strolled up to the fruit display. but however privileged and ignorant their owners were they were just innocent civilians in the war I was fighting now. I pulled my hood up and took a left out of the bathroom. I'd woken up twice in the three hours I'd tried to sleep. and shouting for their friends to save them seats without the slightest idea what was coming. exchanging a wink with Wl ter as he refilled one of the cereal machines. I dropped it in with the fruit as I took off at an oblique angle to the flow of students making for the exit. I got the main cafeteria on account of my rapport with the em­ ': \ ployees. so we de­ cided to upstage them: if the administration was going to evict our encampment. sure enough. there was a part of me that could not believe it was really going to happen. Walter had left a full cereal bag by the cereal dispensers. Until that instant. I sprang up the:: remaining stairs three at a time before anyone else appeared. We hit a bottleneck at the stairs. I didn't glance up again.We knew we couldn't hold out against the city police. unappreciated and often unused. but it was also infuriati to see it here. orang' and bananas would fit in it. agreed on a time. and if anyone behind us was 104.. but there was no way all those apples. The watch I'd borrowed read 11:59. since this was . guys like ~e were dodging jets of scalding wat to process all that waste. In ten paces I reached the fire alarm. I wanted to check in once more anyway. I gripped the lever through the paper towel and pulled down. there were no cameras here. but it was heavy. right up to the moment the buzzer tore the air and everyone leaped up in shock. with tasks to accomplish and predators to escape. three hundred students were gossiping. I struggled to hold it Out to the side. trembling in fear of the deed I was to perform. there were several unused bags folded neatly in the bottom of the can. I snapped a bag open in the air and slipped it into the front pocket of my sweat ­ shirt. I'd always done the same so I didn't have to get a new bag from the utility closet every time. The Eviction The Eviction . shoveling food into their mouths. I: After two watchful circuits around the building. Unexpect­ edly. In the weeks I'd spent at the university. When I'd taken out the trash at the diner two jobs ago. I went into the restroom and pulled out the garbage bag under the paper towel dispenser. we divided the campus into nine zones. The garbage bag bumped against my legs as I ran. my whole being had been taut. Another group of students was coming down the stairs close on their heels. after they' passed I waited on the landing until the door clicked shut before! slipping the can out of my pack and spraying NO SWEATSHOPS: NO EVICTION NO QUARTER across the wall.

"I'm sorry-can you direct me to the encampment?" I broke and glanced over my shoulder. librarians. I could hear other alarms in the distance alternating faintly with the one immediately behind us in a complex call and response pattern. It was my neighbor from the previous evening. and maybe you can help me to-" "All right-listen. The Eviction The Eviction. 107 . which was cheerfully singing gospel music in a tinny. As we reached the stairs and began our slow descent. What the fuck was she doing here? "Tell Luis we'll go over to the apartments. little dismay. Conversations grew more animated. someone let out a whistle. I recognized a woman in the crowd from the action the night before-she'd been sitting right next to me in the audi­ ence. administrators. janitors. I'll see you soon. I'm not headed there right now. then I'll meet you right here. It was time to get my bag and go. others silently taking in the spectacle-and interspersed among them professors. It was ironic that only a total interruption could bring together all the different people who . There was already a thick crowd around the building mingling with the crowds pouring out of other build­ ings: students holding half-eaten hamburgers or notebooks they'd just been writing in. laughing at something with Joe. Normally. "It's across the quad. that's all! How you doing?" "Pretty good! Listen. I sped up and scanned my surroundings for escape routes. lugging my great big bag and hurrying as fast as I could without breaking into a run. NO SWEATSHOPS NO EVICTION came into view over the heads of the crowd below. OK?" She was with Kate and me that evening when all of us were ar­ rested. segregated accord­ ing to class and position. Resisting the urge to look around." With surprise and a . eteria. I'd never seen anyone look so disagreeable in my life. 106. What had been a routine drill for some and a frightening situation for others suddenly took on a new character. dining hall managers. As we stepped outside. too. Someone had brought out a little radio. and only a few of us had known there was going to be an action there. seeing you here for a while"-I nodded in the direction of the caf. I did some quick thinking-she and I had crossed paths at the town council meeting." "All right then! Be safe!" Ethel raised an eyebrow meaningfully. I was too. I've gotta get going. I'd made it twenty paces from the crowd when I sensed someone behind me. but here it was as if all the buildings on campus had been upended and shaken out to show the true compo­ sition of the university. including the Latino dishwashers whose existence was such a carefully guarded secret. how's it going?" "Enjoying the sunlight." "I'm sorry to bother you-" She was panting a bit to keep up. most of these people would be inside. All the cafeteria employees were sitting or leaning along one low brick wall.constituted it and give them something in common. from which the awful buzzing could still be heard-"but we'll " be by with a bunch of stuff again Thursday. it really was intolerable that anyone would have to be inside on such a lovely sunny day. "-I just want to get involved. indomitable voice. some yammering into cell phones.. ! A couple campus policemen were making their way through the crowd with sour looks on their faces. I need twenty minutes to take care of some­ thing. Ethel and Velma were there. so it was unlikely she was working for the police.interested in me they'd have to fight through a lot of traffic. I want you to know I probably won't be'. "Hey y'all. secretaries. The mood shifted here. I set down the heavy garbage bag behind a trash can and made my way over.

]. and that is all there is to it. etc. "This fascinating spectacle of dread surged past my vision in con­ crete waves of wrath. flocks of sheep that must be properly dominated lest they become packs of wolves. AMONG THE "It was not a column but a mob. festering youth and festering age. The crowds they purport to explain are dissident microcosms of the same form. demoniacal horde. crooked. so much bigger that it is un­ recognizable as one so long as the observer remains within it. "A sociologist is an authority on crowds like a policeman is an authority on people." -Bill Buford. The rabble long to be roused. snarling and growling. women and children in rags and tatters. these can be identified as crowds only because they are distinct in some way from the colossal crowd that is the theorists' society. anemic consumptives and great hairy beasts of burden. And you'd almost be right. gone through their ghettos. 109 . mad with drink and wrongs. narrow windows of their ivory towers. an awful river that filled the street-the people of the abyss. screeching. Such crowd theory gives the impression that the theorists are simply apologists for their patrons' crowd control. apes and tigers. wan faces from which vampire soci­ ety had sucked the juice of life. screaming. and thought I knew them. that you'd think the closest they ever came to the subject was in peering down from the high. The Iron Heel THUGS If you go to the experts to learn about crowds. you will read that they are mindless monsters: people gone mad or returned to their primitive state." -Jack London [socialist. the tone so superior.Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility An account of spatial movement. But in fact. to be hypnotized by their own brute force. up at last and roaring for the blood of their masters. they too are submerged in a crowd: it is simply a bigger one. reformist. a raging. drunk with hatred. twisted. I had seen the people of the abyss before. misshapen monsters blasted with the ravages of disease and all the horrors of chronic malnutrition-the refuse and the scum of life. these smaller masses look crazed and irrational to 108. bloated forms swollen with physical grossness and corruption. dim fero­ cious intelligences with all the godlike blotted from their features and all the fiendlike stamped in. the analysis is so one dimensional. drunk with lust for blood-men. drunk with whisky from pillaged warehouses. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility.. withered hags and death's-heads bearded like patriarchs. an allegory of social movement. carnivorous. but I found that I was now looking on them for the first time. animals out of control. etc. Inevitably.

110. It is their money. their atten­ dance. the Rolling Stones or Atlanta Braves. Thus. according to what people believe to be so. they only persist because people choose to reproduce them. stock market works. but the power it has rarely does anyone any good. What is possible. and what they consider realistic' depends on what they believe others consider realistic-this is how the. any given social order rests on. and filing in and out of stadiums. who won't acknowledge that they form a crowd at all. that's an example of such a crowd in action. people make choices based on what they consider to be "re. uncivilized behavior. People will go to great lengths to come together in such settings. but it is * People in crowds types two and up tend to lose their borders-think of the audience packed tight at a concert. when eighty million televisions sets go on in unison at the end of the workday. but. that takes it for granted that that space is best utilized for buying and selling. only a more entrenched and institutionalized one. as it is never wielded consciously. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility. that owns the shops and organizes advertising cam­ paigns to promote their wares. The world we inhabit is not made up merely of physical or sensory facts. But sports fans don't always limit themselves to buying tickets. It is these social conditions that create individuals.by crowds. that makes such affairs interesting. something fundamentally pleasurable about feeling your experiences and reactions mirrored in the ones around you. a collective psychosis-and is by no means" l' guaranteed to be in the best interests of those who comprise it. Why does this happen. 111 . Crowds of this type are characterized by an inability to question their own assumptions and a total denial of responsibility for their actions. Every promoter who brings together a great crowd in order to sell them back their own togetherness runs the risk that some of his customers will take things too far and engage in some street sports of their own-football hooliganism. shop. Yet the members of such crowds do not think of themselves as the authors of the situations they create. tend to emphasize and reinforce the borders that separate them: imagine the same people packed tight in a city bus the following morning. By contrast. and miserable employment? Generally. people in type one crowds. to feel the excitement in the air when a great number share a common space and focus. This is the first kind of crowd. This sort of crowd is no less powerful than other kinds. any equation: in the case of the eSRNARO _ mob that riots and loots a shop­ ping district. and so on from their social context. and the resulting forest of signs is the greater part of what we mean when we say reality. When people do not recognize themselves as part of a crow but think of themselves only as sovereign individuals who just so happen to speak. shouting chants. think. the most primitive kind-a crowd that lacks awareness of its own existence. ~ the specialists of the status quo. The disappointment many voice at low-turnout events indicates a com­ mon awareness that it is the atmosphere generated by the mass. because-for however brief a time-they are acting accord­ ing to a dissenting sense of I'M ASKIN6 reality and value. and feel the same way thousands or millions of others do. from the perspective of one of the looters. Sometimes they get carried away. including the values-that influence their choices.* Let's not be coy about this: there is something thrilling about being part of a crowd. pollution. for example. but not its power. a kind of mob mentality. customs.i alistic" rather than on what they desire. but they attri­ bute this power to others outside themselves-the organizers. The usual pundits decry this as barbaric. tools. as these conditions are themselves the result of individual decisions. for example. vote.HOW L-ON6 CAN A MA!?JS HAL-L-UCINATION L-AST. the promoters. the other crowd is the one that built the shopping district. The fact that this dominant crowd is also a mob. for example. what is impossible: these are decided collectively. A good example of this is the mass of fans at a sports or entertainment event. may only be apparent from outside it-for in­ stance. The second'kind of crowd is a crowd that is aware of its exis­ tence. not the supposed main attraction. So there are MYSSL-F THS SAMe always at least two crowds in QUSSTION. their interest alone that make these possible. then. these raw materi­ als gain meaning as signs. they tend to see reality as fixed and undis­ putable. Reality itself is determined by consensus-that is to say. PROFSSSOR? AND CAN IT as AS OSTAIL-SO AS THISft.. in the case of notoriously unpopular social conditions such as war.

to the extent that each participant is unaware of how to employ his agency in the group. new realities can quickly be generated in the collec­ tive psyche. then. than mere spectatorship: these are people initiating their own activities. Individuals who know they are powerful together aren't always aware of the part ' each plays in creating that power. The do-it-yourself music counterculture. * This stands in stark contrast to the military model of group participation. 113 . flexible. nor do they necessarily know how to join in deciding how it is applied. Actual throngs are excellent laboratories for studying ways to do this. is a somewhat larger-scale version of the same thing. but also of how desperate they are to experience themselves as something other than passive vessels of commerce. and likely to act in the best interests of its mem-. to create defenseless crowds un. the processes by which people read and respond to one another speed up. bers to the exact degree that all within it are conscious of their own ' power and familiar with applying it. In such contexts. in which pleasure itself is refined and redefined through collaborative experiments in aesthetics that influence and inform one another. This is why guardians of the status quo always malign 112. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of POSSibility Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility. in which decisions are made by consensus among a group of friends who not only have de­ veloped their conception of what is meaningful together but also are in the habit of acting on it decisively. not just following instruc­ tions like automatons. a crowd is capable.* The fourth kind of crowd. but this is no guar­ antee that any of them are free within the crowd. a crowd that has a sense of its own power is not necessarily liberating for those who form it. is the crowd made up of individuals who recognize that the crowd: is nothing more than the sum of their individual choices. In close proximity. provoking riots and confrontations with police-these otherwise senseless ac­ tivities give the participants the opportunity to form the third kind of crowd: the crowd that is aware of its own power to determine reality. and make. peanuts and popcorn-even front row seats to someone else's game-lose their luster. self-determined group activity is se­ ductively subversive. in a society based on segregation and passivity. not the narrow space left over in the margins. more civilized. The affinity group of political activists. they may be free from the domination of other crowds. one's freedom is the sum of all others' freedom. unpleasant activities is not just evidence of how screwed up they are. armies is to strip power from their members. once a crowd gains a sense of its ability to r reinvent situations.actually more cultured. to being controlled by mi­ norities or outsiders. thanks to this feedback loop. This is not to say that every renegade crowd is a good crowd-lynch mobs are. hierarchical unity that gives power to a group-but could it be that one of the primary purposes of . for people to multiply themselves by one another-not a cover un­ der which to abdicate responsibility. For such a group. mass activity is a chance to share selfhood with others.: der the pretense of defending them? those choices accordingly. Those who desire this freedom face the challenge of transform­ ing crowd dynamics. The implication there is that it is conformist. after all. Joining in large-scale street fights. All the same. This is the crowd as protagonist. Crowds are vulnerable to authority. any self-generated. is a microcosm of such a crowd. Conversely. As a crowd. where re­ ality is determined consciously and collectively. the fact that people willingly join in such violent. in . mobs­ but only to point out how. which each individual is systematically broken of his sense of autonomy and t independence so he can function more efficiently in a strict chain of como' ' mand. . Small wonder such misbe­ havior is so contagious. as subject rather than ob­ ject.

extremist sects. after all. This can be done without coercion or instruction: one need only demonstrate options with one's behavior that were invisible before. we are. tight-knit crowds can be pressure cookers of so­ cial transformation. In our society. if they take their departure far enough at the right time. to prevent masses that recognize themselves as such from gaining a sense of their power. they can render the impossible possible by persuading others that it is so on the strength of their own conviction. and others will join in if what they see is attractive to them. • Just as they frame "minority groups» as groups in a way that downplays the agency of the individuals that comprise them. authorities usually describe type four crowds ascrowds (or cult groups. to prevent masses who have come together from recognizing themselves as masses.) in order to obscure the enhanced liberties they can offer participants.the mob:* small. 114. and to prevent those who participate in masses that have a sense of their power from recognizing their own individual part in this power. then publicly demonstrate those dreams and their faith in them. every effort is made to prevent ! people from coming together in masses. etc. But all it takes to unleash the crowd is to name it for what it is and engage with it. A small group that behaves confidently as if they are living in a different world can call into question things everyone else takes for granted. living in the most crowded era in history. Thus the yearning of a very few can be taken up by a mass and become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Crowd Dynamics and the Mass Psychology of Possibility . all " it takes is for a few dreamers to practice believing and desiring out­ side the lines while resisting the quarantine of pigeonholing.

perpetually furrowed brow. if all these people were part of an emerg­ ing movement. Indeed. All this evaporated as we passed through the exit doors. Didn't I myself hate the media and the corporate world more than these youngsters possibly could.I invest yourself in a contest you can only lose. Canetti suggests that all demands for justice and all theories about equality ultimately derive from the experience of actual equality fa­ miliar to anyone who has been part of a crowd. That night I chipped in a few hundred dollars for bail and waited ). At first I told myself I was staying abreast of things for a follow-up story. having squandered the best years of my life in a rat maze? Wasn't the duplicity of the university administration loathsome enough to justify just about anything? All the same. Student protesters I hadn't seen since the last days of the occupation greeted me as if I was one of them. regarded me with polite suspicion. es­ pecially the non-students. I was glad they were the ones fighting this impossible battle while I took notes from the 'j sidelines. I couldn't say exactly who it had been.~ radic attacks throughout the city that implied a politicized hooligan-". though I had the impression I knew some of them. the momentum that had begun on campus frag-. The district's main thoroughfare lay right across the parking lot. the others became young music consumers again and I was once more the reporter. A band was performing to raise funds for the upcoming court case. though by that time I:. The show had been an anomaly. instantly everyone was on their cell phones. suddenly. The barbarian I took to ' be Kate's boyfriend. a wiry young savage with an aquiline nose and. The clock struck midnight and. there was a future for my book after all. But here. the more sympathetic I was to their quixotic crusade. i' ism. a new wave of student " activism. I went to the benefit concert in hopes of recovering the thread. such as the re­ lationship between the black-clad barbarians of the encampment and the black and Latino employees of the school. a sort of nature preserve in which togetherness was still permitted to run wild-under close supervision and at a price. Pressed together listening to Walter speak about the strike and the power of people who cannot be appeased. I decided I was taking notes for a potential book. I was shocked how fast the club filled up. Perhaps some of the radicals in the audience had fantasized about 116. That stung. and again two days after that. It was clear that something was still afoot. people were passing out sticks and plastic buckets fashioned into drums and unfurling an enormous roll of painted canvas. and the sting \ drove home to me that I was more emotionally involved in my sub. I missed the fire drill and the eviction. Most of the occupiers.I returned to the university two days after my first visit. was sitting in on meetings and even taking the odd shift on dishes. and workers from campus were speaking there too. as the situation intensified. pressed tight in the darkness with hundreds of strangers. I was sure even those who hadn't heard of the occupation until that night felt like they were part of something greater than themselves. who would have followed their example? At any rate. but the more time I spent around the barbarians. After that night. Afterwards. and spo. they were not alone for long: the dissipating crowd regrouped around this new focal point. I felt no sting of exclusion there. but thanks to Kate taking me under her wing I wasn't run off the way other reporters were. and others began picking up drums and joining in.' I ject than a journalist should ever permit himself to be. a renewed off-campus anti-sweatshop campaign. still refused to acknowledge me even. I was sure they'd been part of the crowd inside the club-otherwise. outside the station with a dozen others to serve hot soup and apple 'j " cider to the arrestees as they were released. 117 . splitting up into little cliques en route to their cars. but that something was more diffuse and more difficult to follow. I would never have acknowledged it to my coworkers. Some of the aspects of the previous weeks that had interested me most. it was the first time I'd exchanged sincere embraces with acquaintances in longer than I could remember.:i mented into the university employee strike. as I passed him a steaming styrofoam cup. seemed to have disappeared entirely into a subterranean realm. And the Crowd Goes Wild And the Crowd Goes Wild. It takes more emotional energy than most people have to . as in the fairy tale.

leaving the driver huffing and impotent behind the wheeL When I saw the car pull up again at the next intersection. that policed. it was as if we were passing through a different city. though I'm 118. one ricocheting off the brick facade of a bank. From this new vantage point. Several more rockets whistled over our heads. A subtle transformation took place after we moved onto the as­ phalt. Traffic was backed up behind us as far as I could see. right into the middle of it. even shopped on it-but from within the crowd I experienced it as something alien. Once again.blocking or seizing it. turning his car sideways across the street. Fear hadn't set in yet. the vandal appears entirely self-governing. the buildings less imposing. There's something singular about watching a person commit a flagrantly illegal act in full public view. just as the sidewalk was for pedestrian shoppers. they were joined by three masked barbarians carrying a great banner. Flushed with. The rest of us watched from the sidewalk. I saw that many of those around me had pulled up their hoods or wrapped scarves around their faces. I'd driven down this street countless times. A police car arrived. As we approached the car again. lighting less dramatic. but when two hundred did. presumably waiting for further orders or backup. No one ever looks more decisive than a masked figure swinging a crowbar against. the laws dissolved. but they remained at a distance. Clearly. a display window. a few rushing ahead and everyone else lingering behind. we simply walked around it. a person's actions gain their meaning from the validation of a whole society. the. I had the uncanny impression that I could not find the streets we'd traversed that night: the distances seemed shorter. and was pos­ sible because a critical mass had deemed it so. we had the magical power to renegotiate reality. one after another. And the Crowd Goes Wild And the Crowd Goes Wild. one of its lights had been kicked out and a streak of spray paint ran along its side. or perhaps a couple. they would certainly have been arrested. Time froze here for a second. outside its confines. we passed corporate cafes. the question of whether these limitations were oppressive or constraining never crossed most citizens' minds. jewelry shops. I looked back at this as a crucial moment. And yet a few of the drummers stepped into the street. a manifestation of the system that exploited. a cacophonous symphony of honking horns. This must have been the work of one individual. as we had been in the club. We were entering one of the city's most expensive commercial districts. Then the windows were crashing in. Now the street was also for drumming. looking around. for their roles were not negotiable. Suddenly. for shouting and dancing and marching. Had ten people attempted to block traffic here at this time of night. taking the street was possible after all. Everyone knew that the street was for car traf­ fic. infinitely free and powerfuL A second later we were sprinting down a side street. restaurants and boutiques. ergo it must not be possible. days later. as if to see what would happen to those who crossed this threshold. We turned left unexpect­ edly. we were conscious of ourselves as a collective' force. actually torches up in the front? Returning to the same spot a few. Later. that evicted. but that had never happened before. Now the po­ lice cars were nowhere to be seen. A new sense of urgency and expectation was spreading through the crowd. a storefront half the length of the block came into view. and again our pace in­ creased. Normally. a bottle rocket shot up into the air and exploded overhead. and what had been a flow of consumers returning to their cars became a parade. halting traffic. only here. I remember it reminded me of footage I'd seen of the gla­ ciers at the polar caps melting. as we swung around another corner. Were those . and it looked like we were about to rupture and disperse-but then the momentum of the first ones off the sidewalk spread to the rest of us. Six-foot-high letters proclaimed the name of the corporation involved in the sweatshop scandal on campus. sufficient unto himself or herself. following the banner to one side of the police car this time. in that single transgressive movement. but the sound only" mingled with the drumming and added to the ambience. dropping glass still ringing out behind us. and picked up our pace. Another officer appeared' ahead of us. great sections of plate glass falling free and shattering across the concrete. We turned again. but feeling it to proceed from the context we had authored together. followed by two more with their lights flash­ ing. massive vertical sheets of ice coming loose in slow motion and tumbling into the sea. I almost had to break into a run to keep up. 119 . the confidence that had blossomed out of thin air in the past few minutes. At first it seemed things would go no further-the crowd was stretched out. the whole crowd cheered in ownership.

police officers were jumping out of cars on either side. I tell you. it was the safest thing I could have done. I didn't understand that at the time. and thus none can believe in it to make it so. there were homeless men sleeping on the grass. And the Crowd Goes Wild And (he Crowd Goes Wild. but I surprised myself by lurching over the fence.' My determination to identify with the insurgent parts of myself ' was finally bearing fruit. Before we could reach the end of the block. but by fear of the police-and. I felt connected to the strangers around me as if we had grown up hunting together in a rainforest-I was boundlessly grateful to them for being there with me. In a dangerous situation. short of concealing myself in a dumpster as I later learned Kate had. I followed a dozen of them down an alley and when they ran one way out of it I headed the other direction at a brisk walk. all their confidence as individuals is founded upon their collective morale.sure most of us had gone further over the line than we had ever imagined ourselves venturing. all their strength comes from the sense. I realized I was not alone behind my bush: a few dozen feet away. unfortunately. everyone else suddenly doubted it as well and fled as if following orders. for rendering that moment possible. they too were fugitives. each hopes to evade the obligation of making wise decisions. As. that they can count on each other. I'm a fucking journal­ ist. One tense block on I reached a public park. The rest of us paused in indecision and distress. They would never turn me over to the po­ lice or despise me for getting myself into this situation. but now we were a very different crowd. what some believe impossible be-s comes impossible. no risk could be more terrifying than the fact that every individual is ultimately responsible for the decisions that bear him to safety or misfortune. I huddled in the shadows behind a line of bushes and exhaled. The only sensations I experienced at that moment were euphoria and the impression that I was flyi~g over the concrete beneath me without touching it. I felt the same anonymous kinship with them I had with the others in the club and then in the march.journalist JOURNALIST! In retrospect. of re­ sponsibility for ourselves. This is why people almost always flee en masse if they can. more importantly. '. whether or not it is the wisest decision: by doing so. The ones who set the march in motion hadn't given any orders­ they Simply opened a window of possibility by carrying out actions 120. Three police cars sped past me in the direction the others had run. but that had been enough. What do you mean. We were no longer bound by a sense of shared strength. but fortunately I couldn't keep up with the others either.~ soon as some visibly doubted that we could maintain our cohesio and the power that derived from it. placing it on the shoulders of those around-who are doing the same. two police cars whizzed by ahead. What the group believes­ to be possible becomes possible. When a crowd of people take over a street or carry off some . the bulk of us remained together. when we arrived at the intersection. just as a courageous crowd can be more courageous than a coura­ geous individual: this is why it is important for anyone who dabbles in crowd participation to know how to extricate himself from the crowd's group think at a moment's notice. trying to project professional calm and disinterest: Me. . I had done nothing more myself than witness and approve. The roar of helicopters rose over the city behind me." similarly impossible action. what am I doing here?I'm a journalist! My chest was heaving. I'm a journalist. As my eyes adjusted. : Masked groups were breaking off from the crowd and disappearing down alleys. In flight. they too were hiding out. calling out to each other in code. 121 . Now we heard sirens in the distance-they were closing in from . A fearful crowd can be exponentially more fearful than a fearful individual.j several directions at once. It was closed for the night.

SS DICHOTOMY.. At the same time.IKE: ANY SVIDSNCS! j A6ROSS 6liNliRAI-IZATION-­ 1-1J<1i liVliRY 6liNliRAI-IZATIONJ . And the Crowd Goes Wild One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World.. just the disparate desires and goals each individual brought to the street. not all of us were ready to be equal participants in an action like this. for not taking ownership of my desire to be part of it? One thing was certain-everything looked a lot different from that bush than it had from my desk at the office. This is really happening. /. 113 . no media spokesperson. There was no master with a megaphone. I actually pinched myself: This is really happening..IKE: SVSRY DICHOTOMY! CIRCUMSTANTIA/. My pulse was racing like a freight train. One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World Why abstractions and absolutes are an assault on humanity and existence itself ___9UT THAT'S A FA/. I said to myself.> 1ll . and I'm not going to miss another minute of it. I'm not writing a fucking book.. /.that left room for others to join in. Was it irresponsible that the ones who had kicked out the headlight of the police car and smashed the windows of the superstore had put me in harm's way? Or was I irresponsible for not being prepared to conduct myself wisely in this situation.. SVIDSNCS.

True. 125 . Arnold Schwarzenegger. ideological framework through which it is experienced. but not as smart as the boy who was just accepted to Harvard. it is measureless. who is not as pretty as the girl on the magazine cover. but not the only way-and not us the best way. monotony. Love is not judgment. This is one way conceiving of the world. Even when we aspire to value things in and of them­ selves. One might argue that what is most precious in life is not the lowest common denominators but the once-in-a-lifetime particu­ lars. unable to see each individual quality or action for wha it is in itself. Where did this obsession with one-dimensional standards come from? Perhaps it originated with language itself: where one word serves to represent many different individual experiences. only able to apprehend them in terms of how the: rate against others-the implication being that there is some f damental scale by which everything can be rated. Not more. is their true domain-as the heart problems of bodybuilders and ' the suicides of our rock stars and sex symbols attest. Jane is smart. not less-there's no comparison with love. "Do you love me more than anyone else." whispers the young girl. no matter how far you pursue it. . which words are least equipped to convey. monoculture. tionary as setting police stations on fire. These ideals cannot be reached in this world. "I love you . matchless ." The anorexic and the body builder are both pursuing ideals that recede before them. I· other way of looking reveals that every human being has qualid unlike any other. if you follow them far enough. What use is a word that refers to only one instant of one individual's experience? Words serve as currency precisely because they are vague and simplistic. " she replies-but he has already turned away. But we have no language that can articulate this. but the rest of us are also infected with the values that pro­ duced them-we're just free-range versions of the same livestock."A woman can never be too rich or too thin. they lead you out of it." the implication is that you are referring to something changeless and uniform-but all that can be said for sure is that the term designates a multitude of diverse sensory data and potential sensory data. no means of expression that celebrates through description rather than comparison. no word or concept could ever capture the infinite depth and com­ plexitv of a single instant of life. . The urban environment. AlJ. All our ways of judging and conceptualizing are comparative: Sara is pretty. for love cherishes what is. . We are one-dimensio thinkers. . Hollywood actresses. too much is never enough: the goal is always ahead of you. but not as pretty as Diana. which is often only connected to the world of sensory experience by the most tenuous abstractions. One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World.. • It could be argued that speaking a language doesn't give you a means to de­ scribe and discuss "the" world so much as it affords you entry to the addi­ tional world of description and discussion. and others: like them were practically factory farmed by our hyper-competitive society. monogamy. in which everything is mass-produced according to the same . This way of thinking makes life into a contest in which all m struggle to distinguish themselves by finding inferiors. every radical action and approach is important to "the" revolution in irre­ placeable ways. either. Western civilization is founded upon one-dimensional think­ ing: monotheism. yes. we are trapped by the assumptions implicit in our speech: "I love you. 124. Einstein was. Once you start to measure yourself by a one­ dimensional standard such as strength or slimness. "I finding a place for them in some universal calibration of value. but not as revolu.* When you say "sunlight. could be considered a physical manifestation of this world of abstractions: conceptualization im­ ' posing itself upon reality. it makes disregard the unique qualities of every event and entity in favor C . abstrac­ tion is already present. differently. into the abyss that. who is not as intelligent as Albert. every moment is unique and unrepeatable. serving free food is revolutionary. monopoly. because of what you are. more than anqthinql" de­ mands the boy.

The world of political theory is rife with abstraction and one-dimensional thinking-the words you are reading right now. One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World. they respond to this suffering not with action but with more desiccating and disembodying. stop concep­ tualiZing. for example. 126. get out there and live. let alone appraised-but wage labor and change economics forced people to measure them anyway. only with terms the other way 'round. So unless you have hit upon a way to turn all this theory into actual life-throw this treatise aside! ~he treatise. whatever that means! Enough expounding. and thereby into career and status .::. ing that they are truer than the raw materials they purport to re ' resent. rationalizing. Every morning women weigh themselves and experience just how inadequate any scale is for measuring the diverse beauty of human beings. Time and worth c really be measured-the woman who has truly lived knows no stopwatch can register the way time speeds up when she is bed with her lover and slows down when she is "on the clock" work.o~/\t I was dumbfounded. not as a "size 6" or "plus size. placing our bro generalizations before the experiences they summarize and cl . only to succumb • Intellectuals have quite an aptitude for displacement-when they suffer from the ennui of their dry. Our equations were strikingly gendered-mine exhortation to an infinite and therefore impossible task. in speaking. glorifying." she said. in those days every fruit and vegetable was unique and looked it.. the ideal woman has been described numericallY-"36-24-36"-and anyone who varies from that Platonic form is considered less beautiful. forgetful of its own demands. Thus he took the reference point of our concepts out of . languages that seek to oppose it no less. Soon. just more abstractions about abstractions-put the book down. he turned everything backwards. ceo-elitist con ­ sumers comes marked "organic. where Plato took the abstraction inherent in language 0 step further. . the only place where it can avoid being burdened by the dead weight of ideology." She sketched it out on the napkin: clothing was made by hand for individual women. for example. you are acting. suggesting that our real experiences in it are Ie.. everything was measured and calibrated: women's clo sizes. Against the wisdom of bodily ex rience. disembodied existence. If you want to experience passion and liberty. "I have a similar equation in my journal. Doctrines alone were not enough to make people see everyt in terms of absolutes. wom • "That's funny. we must finally take a stand against speech itself ­ and for expression. But slowly. He declared that our abstractions refer to some "hig plane" in which abstractions like "justice" exist in their pure for in doing so. Cornered by the mertia of our own rhetoric. and a woman was seen as possessing distinct personal qualities. goes on undaunted. Paul." It's telling that over the last few decades. and each item comes with a brand name identifying which absolute it represents: the super­ market's generic brand is the Platonic form of the inferior banana.. Until the end of the nineteenth century. and then only briefly. outer space within the smallest atom. and the archetypal banana of wealthy. ~'ltt"l tJ. political pomposities above all! Words ~ only express reality accidentally. 127 . of course. Now our food is sci­ entifically engineered to total uniformity.] 0. but in action alone. more status quo. the name-brand banana is the perfect incarnation of the banana as abstraction. and thus. This began with the twin developments of currency and su vided time. and likewise day was divided into quantified segments. That is to say-it is only sufficient to speak when. It only remained for corporate branding to standardize the real world according to our abstractions. This footnote itself is a pernicious little thing. as Ideology always does and is. Suddenly. All too often their real discontent is diverted into theory and abstract analysis. it bee possible to force even the world of sensory perception onto Procrustean bed of abstraction and judgment. and habit sank in. evil imitation. Ideology creeps quickly into any language. Once upon a time most human beings ate from gardens. distrust any words or symbols intended to cap­ ture the things that make life matter. they were powerless." world altogether. everything had an exchange value that co be determined according to an external standard." Many make it through childhood without losing the ability to appreciate the irreplaceable details of life. the founder of Christiani ' expanded this philosophy into a religious doctrine: the ideal e in heaven and the earth is only a flawed. in which the unique qualities of every entity and event encountered up close. or else from the wild. of course. important than our ideas about it." Those who would resist these attempts to press the real world to the flatness of the conceptual world often fall into the same practices. the last thing you should do is make up slogans about them. Greece.Our cyclopean vision of the cosmos can be traced back to ancien!. she knows that the best and worst things in life cannot "deserved" or earned. while hers sugg' an infinity that could neither be sought nor evaded: eternity within the of an instant.

the pursuit of ideals that cannot be realized in this world constitutes a rejection of the world and thus of life itself-as dem­ onstrated by the sad fate of the body builders and anorexics who take that pursuit to its logical extreme. despite the fact that the race and gender divisions that supposedly form the justification for this are increasingly seen as arbitrary constructions-their being construc­ tions simply makes them more useful for dividing and conquering. but a way 0/ comparing people. and where their struggles and goals once referred to real people they now see people only as playing pieces in a contest of symbols. We are so used to denigrating this world. but some groups still benefit from white privilege in relation to others." Insofar as one-dimensional cultural norms are constraining and dehumanizing. so it becomes.to the maladies of generalizing and idealizing when they begin to read theory and attempt to form an analysis of the cosmos: their im­ pressions and emotions are converted into an ideology. everyone-even the whitest of the white and manliest of men-has a stake in overthrowing white su­ premacy and patriarchy. proof of this can be found in nations in which no one is "white" by European standards. Likewise. though people experience this differently according to their places in the hierarchy. There are no more obvious or prevalent examples of vampiric archetypes than whiteness and masculinity. when we attempt One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World. while even in women-only groups people can be seen playing the role of "the man. the grave. even intolerable place. saying it is an imperfect. V·9 . compared against ideals that seem perfect pre­ cisely because they cannot exist. So it appears. White supremacist pa­ triarchal society still rewards certain superficial traits and ways of comporting oneself above all others. Whiteness is not just a quality some possess and others lack. the fact that they are all men doesn't stop football players from compet­ ing against one another to be the most manly-on the contrary!­ It is only now that I can recognize your beauty and deny no part of my own. Ultimately.

of course. of significance and magnificence. how do we act accordingly? What have we been doing wrong all this timer In doing so. war. and emerge from the shadow of the false heaven of Plato and the advertising agents where real beauty supposedly resides. from the lingering ghost of Christian judgment and condemnation. poverty. Pablo-but it's equally utopian to think we could live that at­ tentively. except perhaps by accident for instants at a time. we would finally have to accept and embrace our­ selves as we are. and to ac­ complish it he will wade through blood. A truly radical resolution would be to em­ brace existence just as it is." * He flipped to another page. a miracle. and then to ask: If that's the case. for the impos­ sible project of trying to find perfection in that which exists. Liberated from one-dimen­ sional standards and standardization. he will debauch himself with ideas. Maybe it makes Just as much sense to vacillate Wildly between rejecting the entirety of what is for something which is not. The majority of people in this SOCIety already subsist on vi­ sions of other worlds-it's practically banal. as the only thing that matters. or I'm infected with itmyself-maybe fighting it has infected me. but it's also op­ timistic to think we can stop it first. humiliation. in all our diversity and variety. "Listen to this: 130.to navigate it according to those ideals rather than the real things around and within us. to pro­ claim that this world itself is heaven." "That's what I don't like about all this anarchist rhetoric-it just offers a com­ peting utopia. He's arguing here that the exist­ ing world-precisely because it exists. 'Man looksfor the miracle. One-Dimensional Man in the Three-Dimensional World . if such concepts are to exist at all. all ideals. made for our total enjoyment and fulfillment." "Yes. yet-you know. he will reduce himself to a shadow iffor only one second of his life he can close his eyes to the hideousness of reality.. we could see that what we are must itself constitute the measure and meaning of beauty. . a quality without which any world is worthless-is a heaven more wondrous than any of those others. Everything is endured-disgrace. . being a Revolutionary with a capital R-and rejecting all futures. which will render life tolerable. if we live in it attentively.' Sound familiar?" "Yeah-I don't know whether I'm fighting that mentality. crime-in the belief that overnight something will occur. all abstractions. Surely it's utopian to think capi­ talism can go on forever without destroying the entire planet.

OK. studying for finals.. "The others I started out with are all back in their dorms." Kate was always trying to smooth over conflicts. though. Bunch of privileged white kids playing at revolution! I'd . But I was fertile that time on the rooftop." She returned the lamp to the table.. well-known houses we had to choose from. I'll never do anything with . each following a tiny spot of light across the crunching leaves. casting dancing shadows on my sleepy." She tore open a tiny sampler 132. at times it seemed we were in danger of getting entirely stuck. At the time I thought Diego was right. if you tell me what to do. I wrestled with the familiar tent as the wind picked up and tiny drops of rain began to fall. we were warm enough. "Diego. or what! It's not that hardJ you know? You say you're going to do something." She extracted a mirror and speculum from her pack and shimmied out of her jeans. Other Encampments Other Encampments. Kate turned over to face me and put her lips to my ear. but I didn't want Sarnia to hear us arguing like this-or anyone else to.. but by the time we had managed to get into our sleeping bags. those are practically the last students still involved. like-" "Hey. "It's never happened before. or dead.Diego was still stewing about the legal number. We had all started carrying flashlights as well as knives. our voices and slamming doors echoing in the winter night. it should be bluish if I am-it's not guaran­ teed. " . they might as well be the cops!' I had no idea' whether you guys were in jail. "Whatever. sewing kits.. If you're' not going to do it" -he pounded out each syllable on the steering~ wheel-"don't fucking say you'll do i t ! " " .~ . The car bucked and dragged across stretches of the long drive­ way. It really was dark out there. we were well into the countryside and the world was a blurred black silhouette against the sky. "I'm go­ ing to check out my cervix to see if it looks like I'm pregnant. It had to be approaching five in the' morning. and a pitch-black wood stove. I was like 'OK'd fuck these people. later?" Sarnia was gazing out the window at the woods along the road. Everyone's spirits lifted when we turned onto the dirt road. rather do things with people I know will come through. who are we going to work with? At." I opened Sarma's cell phone and held it in the air so Diego could see its glowing screen in the rear view. only a couple stars peered down through gaps in the has­ tening clouds. and after three. hours of going straight to the answering machine. and we made our way to the steps in a hushed line. it illuminated rough wooden walls. "Lay your bags out on the floor here. Lit. I was afraid it would be cold. and the house looming ahead was a black silhouette. awk­ wardly jostling elbows and knees and pushing against the tight can­ vas walls. it had seemed like a bad idea to go back to any of the busy. mud-caked gardening tools. them again. squinting friends. Tonight. "My father doesn't have electricity. Stepping into the darkness. "I'J least we know what to watch out for with them. The last time I'd left town had been before the encampment. and I always try to keep up with what's going on in my body. The toilet's through there-there's sawdust next to it. "can we talk about this \. ?" "As I understand it. but they're all we've got. 133 . they. since the eviction I'd been carrying my toothbrush in my jacket.." Kate explained in a whisper as she struck a match and lifted the smoke-stained glass silo off an oil lamp. anyway. you do it. Can you tell if you're pregnant from . and laid her hand on my arm. "Do you want to sleep outside with me?" Outside. either. We can talk abouti this next-" He cut her off dismissively. Will you give me a hand with the flashlight?" No one had ever asked me to do that before. If we can't '. when I still had my apartment. sure. just put some in after you use it. make things work with them. The door was unlocked. don't have their shit together. "Urn. When I go into the country it's like a muscle relaxes that other­ wise is perpetually clenched. and Kate had offered to guide us out to her father's place. we suddenly felt a lot smaller. and water bottles. moving from couch to couch to keep up with the action.

mirror with one hand. I lay awake on my back. I wa$ being granted access to a private ceremony. straining against the' canvas and bumping into her knee. When I finally closed my eyes I was in a moving car again." Long after her breathing had slowed and thickened. "I struggled with that for a long time. "Thank you. yeah. and keep losing weight. 135 . I stayed awake until I heard birds venturing the first notes of morning. angling it delicately between her legs. I tried all sorts of diets. too. Other Encampments Other Encampments." She unzipped the sleeping bag further and I blun­ dered down to the other end of the tiny tent. That was terrifying as well as liberating-more terrifying the more I wished to cling to it." "Sorry-s-I didn't . The driver pressed the accelerator to the floor and the landscape opened out around us into a painted desert. my own sleeping bag still up'. I mean. 134. "Just the usual stuff. but I just felt worse. I don't want to bring up anything. It's still seri­ ous shit to look at my thighs and really believe they're perfect just the way they are.. "Feeling beauti­ ful..Uil. listening to the wind and feeling how far I was from everything familiar." ! she began as I settled back into place beside her." "Yeah?" She looked at me with gentle amusement. it would be under my control. I wore makeup and shaved every hair and tried to match my outfits to my eyes. then I quit doing (J all that stuff. I could go to the gym every day .of lube in her teeth and maneuvered the speculum into place. but how I felt about myself would never be under my control no matter how much weight I lost." I murmured. around my waist." She shifted. In that regard it was the op- posite of the dish room where I'd lost so many months. I gazed at her shy: in the dim glow-I'd never seen anyone so at home in herself." She was silent a minute. "Never mind-it doesn't look blue at aJ. Now that I reflected on it. You're beautiful. it too": her a couple minutes to find the view she wanted. I thought to myself. I mean. like a hunter stumblin§ upon fairies in the woods. it was crazy how many women I'd: been involved with without ever seeing their bodies this way. I could! hear the wind outside the tent sweeping leaves past us in whispering l gusts. I think' it's the most intimate I've ever been with anyone. I finally came to the conclusion that it would take as much energy to like myself the way I was as it did to count calories and style my hair every morning-but if I could. and I'll never be here again. "I've never done this before.. folding her arms behind her head. difficult." She held th. I have never been in this place before. packed tight with people I didn't recognize but took to be my beloved companions. alien and sublime. "You're really beautiful. Want to have a l o o k ? " ) "OK. but it's a struggle I want to fight and the other one isn't anymore. Anyway-thank you. It's really . "0 now hold the flashlight here and aim it at the mirror. really.. Do you want to tell me about it?" "Sure.

and gazed at myself in the mirror. and drink and shout and argue until midnight. never leaving the bubble of beach towel. 1: .L~i .. ". . 137 .. If they do well for themselves.. if they're environmentalists.~ 'I~L~:~~. i .~~. They arrive shortly before sundown and spend a full hour and a half unpacking.. a story as poignant and thrilling as any novel.lr~~Fffi'it. you know you're off the clock and having fun-whether or not you swim in the surf. resort. Everything they've done at the beach they could have done more easily at home.~Lj' i ':' i . the vessel of a world of-struggles and longings and triumphs more incredible than anything that could fit between the covers of a book.liL . cruise ship. Let's examine these more sophisticated specimens to get to the bottom of tour­ ism as a phenomenon.under the stars.i'lt<.\f\c:. they spend another hour and a half taking down the tents and.'~" t. Years later they will return with their families. tiny crabs dancing across its flesh. When they wake up the next morning. I saw something reflected there that I'd only glimpsed before in the eyes of my most adoring lovers: the shades and textures of my skin and the scars and lines carved into it told of a life of wild gambles and undreamable extremes. FltJetOf~~.~~lWSt I I ."')~\"j~. the college students pack their cars and drive to the beach.' . '."~~:~ .. I was beautiful­ beauty was incarnated in me. .{Ij. cleaning up after themselves before driving back to the city.::'f. you can always identify high-class tourists by their video cameras and learned guides.. '.You Can Run But You Can't Hide Tourism? Escape Routine! On the flight back from Sao Paulo a year and a half later. I shut my­ self in the airplane bathroom. You Can Run but You Can't Hide All Roads Lead to Roam / You Can Run but You Can't Hide. . charbroil hamburgers. hotel room. If tu T"f:1r'!'fr 1~i~J!4 . but the beach is fetishized as a zone of recreation and leisure: if you're there. i ." ~~~{."~~!~~" "~'I '~ii . .'.~jT lIlltl~!f1~ When the weekend arrives. Then they crank up the sound system. setting up play tents for the kids and folding tables for the adults and sipping wine as they watch DVDs. they'll visit beaches on other continents."~". 136..!.. i ". walk in silence ." . but I rested comfortably in it as if I had known through all my doldrums and desperation that I was simply being primed for this. and heat­ ing up the grill. This was a blinding revelation.~: . . setting up tents and tarps. Li""¥~'11j~~~11 ' .-. or find the carcass of a shark washed up by a tide pool. . . But it would be unfair to accuse all vacationers of ignoring their surroundings-on the contrary.. took off my paint-splattered jacket and shirt.'~.

Coming from a subculture in which owning and appearing are emphasized over feeling and acting, bourgeois vacationers seek diversion in the symbolic possession of parts of the world other than those they normally occupy. They establish this by the act of looking-"sightseeing," to use their redundant expression-just as the conquerors of old surveyed newly subjugated peoples. This is the real significance of all the photographing and videotaping: the pictures may not be important later on (except for those insuffer­ able slide shows to which one imagines Roman emperors would have subjected their courts, had they possessed the technology), they may not be taken with any artistic aspirations, but they serve to establish. the tourists as collectors-they collect images the way others collect i butterflies or war booty. This is the only way the bourgeois know to • relate to foreign things:* the beautiful and the wild are quite scenic, c but lack meaning until they are hunted, captured, pinned. The hastily snapped images are preserved as if in formaldehyde, and the vacationers congratulate themselves on knowing all about,
• Witness ecotourism, which is predicated on the idea that a small fragment· of an ecosystem deserves to be left alone as long as it is entertaining to the tourist class. They go on vacation to ooh and aah at exotic wildlife when they': won't even recycle bottles in their own kitchens. They speak about "special~ places that should be made parks and reserves, neglecting the fact that the vel)Ji ground they live on was once just as wild and beautiful before it was destroye4j by the lifestyles they refuse to question. .~

Norway, Italian architecture, the wildlife of the Pacific Ocean, the struggles of the first Polar explorers, the troubled childhood of Van Gogh ("arid that," intones the tourist as he guides his audience through a slideshow of photos taken from behind a rope under the direction of another tour guide, how's that for postmodern, "is the very room he spent his first six years in!"). The lenses never leave the eyes of the tourists in the course of their vacation, literally or figu­ ratively. Mediation is integral to the tourist experience-anything to keep the world at arm's length, to avoid getting involved. The tourist arrives from a world of control mania, already an expert at protecting himself to death. The bourgeois insist on be­ ing safe wherever they go-not just from actual danger, but from everything not already anticipated, comprehended, controlled. The travel guides and guidebooks, the painstakingly planned itineraries, the tourist buses and museums and hotels, the armies of salesmen who cater to every fabricated need-all these combine to ensure that being in Oslo or Zimbabwe is as similar as possible to being in Oklahoma. And yet beneath everything, tourism is still a desperate bid to experience something different, something "exotic," which is to say-something not quite as lifeless, meaningless, tedious, banal, and insipid as daily life under the tyranny of the hair dryer and the cellular phone.* And so the worst tragedy is that tourism destroys the observed as it maintains the alienation of the observers. Just as explorers have cut wider and wider swaths through the natural environment in the course of their exploits until all that remain of it in some places are fish tanks and potted plants, the tourist crushes beneath him exactly that which he seeks. The human being in the bourgeois man needs variety, danger, adventure, but the bourgeois in him channels these needs into surro­ gate enterprises and hedged bets: traveling Honduras, he still wants to speak English; rafting the rapids, he still needs a release to sign and a "historic path" to follow (as all meaningful experience is held hos­ tage in the past, or in the lives of other peoples); landing on Mars, he
• Indeed, when one listens closely to the ghost stories about kidnappings and stolen kidneys shared by bourgeois youth on the summer vacation backpack­ er/hostel circuit, it becomes clear that they are practically fantasies, legends of something real and endangering-that is to say, engaging!-happening to someone just like you, told in desperate faith that something crazy and new is still possible even in this world and couched in the only terms the bourgeois have to describe the unfamiliar: terror!

138. You Can Run but You Can't Hide

You Can Run but You Can't Hide. 139

would look around for a sign announcing the next guided tour. Wield­ ing the power of the angry god Dollar, he is able to compel everyone he encounters to confine him in this safety net. Wherever the tourist tramples, soon little remains but the detritus of his own creative and cultural bankruptcy-visit Tijuana, Mexico for proof. Whole cultures have been annihilated in his wake; tourism is not the heir of ancient ,1 quests and pilgrimages but of colonial imperialism. In the absence of the real thing, the tourist is left with simu- ,: lation. Even the most wild and crazy travel handbooks ("Europe ,\ on two dollars a day!" «Antarctica for hitchhikers!") are museums' of fossilized adventure by the time they go into circulation-as if there could be such thing as an adventure guide, when adventure is . precisely that which happens off the map. The most the daring tour- " ist can hope to find is the cooling trail left by those who embarked without maps-in their wake, he has to make do with monuments, ;, museums, and theme parks, forever asking rhetorical questions ("I Ii wonder what it would be like to ... ?")without connecting the pos­ sible answers to his own life. Distraught, he buys more guidebooks, \: characteristically seeking a solution from the market rather than. shaking off his alienation to try a different approach. The common quality that unifies all tourists is disconnections'[ they are totally uninvolved in what they see, pursuing the sight>. alone without all the entanglements, liabilities, and challenges that:! come with real life engagement. They can passively vote on their" favorite place or painting, or, at most, develop some paternalisticj] picturesque Hallmark sentiment that exceptional environments cultures should be protected, but it never occurs to them that the~ are interacting with the worlds they view with such detachmend This is why they are unable to acknowledge the part they play' eradicating them, let alone confront their own spiritual malaise restlessness. They could be at home-or anywhere-giving them selves to a project, involving themselves in something outside demands of work and social status, holding themselves accoum . able for the effects of their actions and considering their decisio with appropriate seriousness; instead, they vacation in never-nevi ... land, extending their own alienation to the furthest corners of globe. This alienation replicates itself there, driving them to e more expensive ocean cruises and souvenir hunts in a listless a, diets' pursuit of stimulation-when all it would take to break
I

0,1

spell would be for them to commit themselves to some value or dream, one that would drag them into danger and heartbreak and ragged glory and all those other things one must experience to live an engaged, fulfilling life. They could do that without ever booking flights or packing suitcases. The fact that they are able to maintain their distance from life as easily ten thousand miles from home as in the midst of their daily routines is a testament to the global tri­ umph of universal self-estrangement. Ultimately, tourism is not a leisure activity but a way of life, an expression of the vacuum at the heart of consumer society. The ex­ ecutive does the same thing in the Louvre and the Himalayas and Jamaica that he does in his own neighborhood when he drives past a stand of trees being cut down to make way for a new gas station. What would it take to snap him out of this trance, to make him relate himself to those around him and take responsibility for his actions? The fate of the planet rests on us answering this question, or else disarming and disabling him. To do either, we have to locate the parts of ourselves that are not yet totally detached, to seek out the passions that might still stir within us. For good or for ill, most of us long to travel-our hearts leap at the thought of dropping everything and setting out free and empty-handed across an unfamiliar landscape, and this must run deeper than bourgeois conditioning. Travel is associated with human liberty and romance; it was the original state of our species, and we still pine for it. In traveling we can shake off our old selves and hunt down others that wait in alternate worlds-travel enables a special kind of freedom, for without new horizons we tend to re­ peat the well-practiced choices we have already made, in thrall to inertia if no other master.

<,

Ivo~cc JmbtNt\U IOtk mimt~ ~l'~
~::::..ToURRORIST ATIACKS INCREASE
THROUGHOUT THIRD WORLD
u.s. ,Japan responsible, claims anarchist group AQlEn~_. ~....::,I..-. ~vow.;Exaet " -­ .~
.. ".".... _._____
,..WYOR -...... ,------.. c,;§

PuJ&iBhmentfor'Evil'
.............. ~ _

lluildi... _

IIIll FIII

e-"~~

140.

You Can Run but You Can't Hide

IS Onloolan

s.dI lor EhIshe SItIIY
""L~

................-.. .-....-ct....., ....
.. -.-.,...._ -.-.- ,...,.
--. ,.... .......
­ ....

........ ......... .. .. _ ..
.......... .... .....- ..

..

,.,.........,-.
......,~ftIr~..-.~ ..,.... ___ -_~.~~~.:=..":n::.
ftIr

_

-..

,....,.

Tft6I

.............

But with the whole planet standardized under corporate impe­ rialism and industrial capitalism, when we bear the seeds of these poisons within our own breasts as colonized colonizers, where is there left to go? How are we now to travel? In place. The adventures of the future will be created, not by Westerners who destroy civilizations in their desperate bid to escape their own, but by people who seize familiar parts of this planet and make them unfamiliar. Washington, D.C. could become the Paris of 1968, just as Paris, boring as usual until that May, became the Bar­ celona of 1936; small towns in the Midwest could host social cen­ ters and upheavals like those in Oaxaca and Berlin; a sense of one's own significance and capabilities can transform even a suburban ' bedroom into the setting of a real life epic. Really, this was always the case: one either regards the world passively, or approaches it as a participant-all things hinge on this, whether you are at home or on the peak of Mount Ararat. In traveling in place, we can rediscover the art of participation that is essential for any adventuring-and finally set out on a jour­ ney, rather than yet another flight.

Escape Escapism!

The administration couldn't take the heat; they broke their con­ tract with the corporation and signed a new agreement with cam­ pus workers only a few months after the night march. I was off like a bottle rocket as soon as they caved in. Flushed with the thrill of victory and equipped with nationwide connections courtesy of my new friends, I set out to seek my fortune. So many of us begin our novels in our heads and fear to finish them on paper-or begin our lives on paper and finish them too soon on earth. Our songs go unsung, our throats remain mute, the expectant trembling before the strings are struck goes on and on into infinity; the whole world echoes with that pregnant silence, if you have ears for it. I was going to take revenge for all the squan­ dered potential of my species: I was going to live the life I wanted, and nothing could stop me. I felt irrationally guilty towards Daniel, though. Enjoying my­ self seemed like a betrayal, especially doing things he would have wanted to do. I can still hear the clack-clack of the tracks amplified inside the train car that carried us out of town, speeding up in a deafen­ ing polyrhythm until it sounded like a thunderous drum circle. A day later we were dodging the flashlights of security guards in the train yard outside a bigger city, life as tense and dramatic as it had been at the high points of our struggle with the university. It was a revelation to discover that there were people like us everywhere, fighting similar fights and chasing dreams that resonated with mine. In one city they'd occupied a big building, filling it with discarded objects in a post-industrial bricolage: barbershop chairs, a jungle gym nailed to the ceiling, refrigerator doors that opened into bed­ rooms. In others they ran programs that put Marshall's produce

142. You Can Run but You Can't Hide

All Roads Lead

to

Roam. 143

On a rural commune. I might have stood at their gates or even passed through them without ever recognizing them for what they were. but as I'd traveled. some of my new friends had already returned to default setting. It was nice to see them. Until I'd set out. improbably blonde bombshells in the soap operas and subtle references to Hollywood movies pep­ pering my foreign friends' speech. Had I stumbled across the same places in the distracted rush of a business trip. I felt with terror that I was returning through time to the moment I'd departed. That night I sat up talking to old Slovenes about life under communism and walked back in the early morning through a fog so thick I couldn't see ten feet. stewarded by multigenera­ tional councils with decades of experience. My mother and sister were waiting anxiously for me at the top of the escalator. But I was still sworn to my impractical quest for adventure. In Latin America I toured shantytowns bigger than the suburb I'd grown up in. I'd never felt so at home. clandestine abortion clinics. concluding that indeed it had been "only a dream" and reintegrating themselves into the world we'd escaped. there had been no train yards. Everybody assumed I'd returned because I was exhausted and broke.distribution to shame: occupied community gardens. where anarchists and artists had occupied a whole neigh­ borhood. 144. These were the harbingers of an imperialism that would homogenize the entire world unless people dug in their heels somewhere to halt its advance. sparks and cinders rising overhead to mingle with the stars? In Europe. It takes a real shock to cut through the veneer of routine and ap­ prehend the world we actually live in. When I finally caught up with them later. I imagine astronauts set foot on earth for the very first time when they leave the spacecraft that took them to the stars. All Roads Lead to Roam All Roads Lead to Roam. tenants' rights groups ready to march on landlords with torches and pitchforks. We had to get through a police line to reach the squat where we were to stay. Now I was ready to believe that every­ thing I'd ever dreamt of might exist somewhere in the world-just as before the globe was circumnavigated it was possible to imagine that the world of dreams was a physical place to which spirits trav­ eled by night. never con­ sidered whether they might exist. familiar fast food joints and squat evictions. but at the time I was too busy meeting new people and setting off for new destinations. I'd left home to get away from it all. A week later I was at the front of a charg­ ing crowd. but that had never stopped me before. I felt as if I were laying my feet upon the surface of the moon. we arrived in one metropolis the evening after riots left the city center in ruins. paint bombs sailing overhead from behind me and riot police thirty feet ahead firing warning shots in the air. I walked through blossoming fields at dusk to dance around a tremendous fire with a hundred exquisite strangers. It didn't last. The truth was I'd come back on a mission. I seemed constitutionally incapable of resigning myself to the life everyone else accepted as normal. Rita even made it to Kenya to visit the workers in the sweatshops we'd protested-I heard all about it over coffee in Santiago. I should have recognized this as an ominous warning. armored police vans patrolling streets of burnt cars and boarded-up shops. We saw social centers there that could fit a thousand people in their event halls. In the short year of my vagabondage. I hitchhiked to the top of the Alps where the earth disappears into the stratosphere and rode with a Dutch pilot all the way down to Ljubljana. no squatted so­ cial centers or Alps or favelas-I'd never heard of them. I'd found "it all" waiting wher­ ever I went: border controls and advertisements in English. and all night officers and lookouts shouted insults back and forth in a foreign tongue. 145 . which you might reach by day if only you traveled far enough. Have you ever heard the deep bass growl of a fire that size. I learned Spanish quickly because everyone spoke to me as if I already knew it. but disturbing to find that while I had been off discovering new expanses of possibil­ ity everything at home had remained unchanged. and stayed on twenty miles of occupied farmland. I felt present in those unfamiliar places in a way I never had in familiar ones-and when I finally stepped from the airplane at the end of my trip. to pick up again from there as if all that had transpired in the mean­ time had been a hallucination. they spoke about their periods of travel as closed parentheses in their lives and expected me to do the same.

he'll just run back home when things get tough. they shouldn't be here at all. Don't they understand if everyone lived like them. 147 . where long enough to cultivate them. there would be no system to leech off?" "If they're not going to abide by the decisions of the spokescouncil. All Roads Lead to Roam Infighting the Good Fight. I'd rather they were at home doing nothing than messing up our protest like this!" "How can you expect to without ? If you really cared about __~ you'd __! [like me]" "I don't want to be an activist or an anarchist or a part of this at all if it means I have to . I was determined to bring them home with me. combing the world in search of wonder and community and struggle without ever stopping any. But first. there was a demonstration a thousand miles away that I couldn't resist attending. Now that I'd seen riots and social centers and other miracles. like Hame­ lin after all the children were lured away.. travelers like myself would be doomed to wander endlessly like earthbound ghosts.The city I'd left in uproar was quiet when I returned." "Those lifestylists don't care about anything but themselves. " 146. If no one stayed to bring it back to life.. Infighting the Good Fight: Why We're Right and You're Wrong Towards a Non-D'[enjominational Revolution "J ust like every coddled middle class liberal.

We live in a society that teaches there is not enough of any valu­ able resource to go around. We grow up in households where our parents don't have enough time for us. We internalize the values of this system. You seldom encounter a genuinely active. they don't realize that when they succeed in failing to enjoy something." 148. The Scarcity Economy of Self In a world where free. and inevitably leads back to the same hostility and scorn-for the only thing you can do with those you have put on a pedestal is knock them off. can be interpreted as an encroachment. their plans and ideas and habits and be­ liefs. activism. abused. and often this compensation serves only to preserve our destitution. If you're going to get anything out of any movie or song or interaction-so as not to have simply wasted your time!-you must take responsibility for finding ways to enjoy and benefit from it. will be short­ lived and irrelevant without a fundamental change in our relation­ ships-for social structure is a manifestation of these relationships. This spectatorship reinforces the sense that everything everyone else is doing is uninteresting and unintelligent. We are ill-qualified to reconstruct human relations if we can't even get along with each other in the attempt-and nothing seems to create dissension and division like our attempts. People on television or in books are held up as more important. but in the spectator's scarcity economy of self. In its advanced stages. We compensate as best we can. in which one projects all the qualities one admires onto others. With a little hard work. to deride-as if we don't all feel worthless. too: feelings of superiority.* Every achievement is something to rebel against. power. and community are entirely what he makes of them-and that he must make something of them himself in order to get anything out of them. cheated of the experiences and sensations we know should be ours. to assail. but a way of living: anarchy and hierarchy always coexist in varying proportions. Any kind of capital-R Revolution. including selfhood. there is no question today more important than this one-the fate of our species and planet will be decided by the answer. no one loses more than them. an attack. be­ cause it is so important to them that they have "refined" tastes. more attractive. beauty. not a factor external to them. the critic passively votes for or against the efforts of others. We rush to despise others. you can make yourself feel alienated by just about anything. in order to reassure ourselves that we have worth of our own. of course. Infighting the Good Fight Infighting the Good Fight. Often it seems that the people who know least how to relate to others are the self­ professed activists who set out to save them. reputation. and hunted enough already! • The other expression of this same affliction is hero worship. any expression of selfhood. status in our own heads. Yet these conflicts are not an inescapable consequence of human nature. we are sent to schools that employ a grading system that permits only a handful to excel. this hypercritical status-seeking engenders a spectator mentality: from a distance. we denounce and criticize instead-just to reassure ourselves! The most insecure among us are not even able to enjoy movies and music. and thus the feeling of superiority the spectator so desperately needs. creative action is hard to get away With. We seek status in wealth. even the most generous and positive.Why We Can't All Just Get Along Can we get along} Even for those of us who would prefer to be her­ mits. We compensate by seeking another kind of status. we all feel impoverished. and the important question is which you foster yourself. When we should be looking for what is positive in everything. and are discharged into a market that enriches a few of us while exploit­ ing or discarding the rest. There is no shortcut around this dilemma. unable to discern that such things as art. anything to soften the blows of wasted days. This is similarly crippling. engaged person who feels the need to proclaim her actions superior to others'. strength. more heroic than the rest of us. but rather a pat­ tern of cause and effect that can and must be altered. We become used to judging our value by what we are "better than. any redistribution of wealth and power. Revolution is not a single transfor­ mation. 149 .

RI6HTSOUSNSSS IS A PRSMIUM CURRSNCY IN THIS POST-CHRISTIAN SOCIS~ THOU6H IT RSFSRS TO A MYTHICAL." Small wonder we end up fight­ ing among ourselves. not out of lust for revenge and superiority. According to this school of thought.WORt-D. 150. trusting that he is interested in coexisting with others. The question should not be whether an individual is guilty-we all are.) just like the ones in the movies can reassure themselves that they have isolated the contagion and need look no further-and the more vit­ riolic their denunciations of the enemy. de­ veloping more and more exclusive jargon while others in the field labor to forge the compromises necessary to accomplish anything. flaws. tianity that emphasizes individual responsibility over the cause and effect of social conditions in order to invent. advertise. Objectivity versus Subjectivity Our scarcity-oriented. communicate.I 7' -. authoritarian civilization is predicated on the idea that there is only one truth. this makes it easier for him to drop his defenses.' Passing judgment can be the ultimate compensation for one's own shortcomings. It's as sensible to blame anyone of us for being colonized by this violence and domi­ nation as it is to blame the oceans for being polluted. class traitor. the more radical we must be. etc. We profess intentions to create peace. and intimidated. We come to think of being radical as a war-hence the more wars we fight. Infighting the Good Fight Infighting the Good Fight. Justice and Judgment Scarcity thinking and the destructive insecurity it fosters have played a large part in shaping our notions of justice. we see self­ hood as something that is obtained by fighting. transform the violence and ignorance within themselves. Witch-hunters who believe that they have found a real live criminal (or racist. for the more we focus on others' the less we have to think about our own. t The self-righteous activist's sense of justice is derived from the same origins as the "justice system" which feeds today's prison-industrial complex: a Chris-. but the only tools we possess are weapons. having had to fight peers. and question himself. coming no closer to consensus. the effects of which still exert a great influence over us. Often noth­ ing can help a person to do this more than to give him the benefit of the doubt. teachers. 151 . bosses. in which people eschew physical violence but impose this disavowal upon others with incredible self-righteousness and belligerence. Again-we live in a violent. at least of complicity-but rather how to enable individuals to confront and • Ironically this combativeness is especially prevalent in some pacifist circles. the more afraid everyone else is to admit what they have in common with the accused. and police to establish ourselves. and many compete for this prize. privileged access to that truth is called objectivity. This is not to say we shouldn't defend ourselves by any means necessary whenever we have to-but let's do this for practical reasons. intellectuals and armchair revolutionaries debate incessantly. Many of us have come to this resistance from a life of conflict and struggle. those who want to explain human behavior or overthrow capitalism should make different propositions regarding the best way to do this and debate them until the correct one is recognized. Having been abused. Those who would oppose this scarcity system face the additional challenge of unlearning its conditioning. and -inconsistencies. In a state of truly mutually beneficial social relations. oppressive world. neglected. So it is that in ivory towers and squalid basements. and sell the ultimate scarce commodity-salvation. harassed. It's easy to get self-righteous about someone else's mistakes. lifestylist. par­ ents. threats like incarceration and hellfire would not be necessary to make people behave themselves.

Whatever ideologi­ cal issues need to be worked out can be worked out in practice. and selfhood as well. It might be more worth­ while to establish whether there are projects that can further both your interests. " by inference. They don't necessarily think differently than you because they are less intelligent. Those who fight for freedom from gods and masters must contest the dictatorships of ideology that always ac­ company and enable them.t Obviously. Simply point out that you act accord­ ing to your own conscience. 152. but upon being attacked entrenches himself and defends it for the rest of his life. tactics. This may be seen as legislative by those who believe there is only one right way. and indeed one cannot long hold political or financial power without ideological capital to back it up.* Individuals who can get others to buy into their ideas obtain disproportionate control over their surroundings. sometimes there is nothing to do but fight it out. but those who attack you for offering your own perspective or analysis on the grounds that it doesn't apply to them (or isn't relevant to all people. When people attack you as if you are • Of course. In our society. you will probably find you have spoken for others as well. ideas function as capital in much the same way money does. . as in any economy based on scarcity. and hope to integrate your approach into those of others-just as it is up to others to do with you. t In taking sides against others. since every life experience is unique. Upon hearing a person's position on an issue. In this state of affairs. it's impossible for anyone to legislate for everyone else. nevertheless.* or at least ways you can coexist. you needn't immediately commence debating which of you is right. experienced. conclusions based on different evidence from their own lives. This has an important bearing on how we interact with each other. you can offer your own experiences and conclusions for others to do with what they will-and if you speak honestly for yourself. From this vantage point.) are still working within the scarcity model. large con­ glomerates such as the Catholic Church and the Communist Party have come to rule large parts of the world this way. it's hard to imagine what a world free from this war of ideologies would be like. power tends to flow upward to the top of the hierarchy. but come to different.To prioritize subjectivity is to accept that there is no "the" reality. and goals. any "objective" reality must simply be one subjective reality institutionalized as Truth by those in power.' • Ideas. Obviously. anyone with a value or viewpoint has to rush to sell it to others before being run out of business. This is the self-perpetuating consequence of the power struggles that go on in the market of ideas. when interests genuinely conflict. every decision you make. t Paradoxically. are considered private property and pro­ tected by law from plagiarism. and other methods of redistributing wealth. especially in our efforts to change the world. 153 . don't fall into the trap of arguing for your own methods and ideas as universals. you can forget that everyone's positions are flu­ id-and forcing someone to act as a partisan of an opposing side can trap them into identifying themselves with that side exclusively. starving mothers in Somalia. if they can be worked out at all-they certainly will not be resolved by another contest of egos disguised as a debate about theory. perceptive. Different people are bound to have different beliefs. Often it happens that a person adopts a position impulsively. you make for yourself alone. it would have to be free from analogous wars for money. that market is characterized by competition between capitalists who strive to preserve and increase their power over others. power. Little start-up companies contest these mo­ nopolies with new visions. Remember-every value you espouse. The communists who attempted to coexist with Hitler's fascists in the late 1930S sealed their own fates and those of countless others. The Capitalism of Ideas Those who still hold that there is such a thing as objective truth generally feel a compulsion to persuade others of their truths. copyright infringement. Infighting the Good Fight Infighting the Good Fight. etc. deciding for everyone. and sometimes one unseats the reigning creed to become the new dominant paradigm. or compassionate­ they may be your equals in all these regards. like other forms of capital. Thinking this way means recognizing that people have arrived at their particular beliefs and behaviors as a result of their individual life experiences. transgendered Republicans. for it's foolish to insist that one can think however one wants when some ways of conceptualizing the cosmos are punished by exclusion or embargo. this statement rests on ideological assumptions of its own­ but perhaps this kind of self-contradiction is the first necessary step in the disarmament of ideology. but as in any capital­ ist system.

'" <. or immo biliize an d di ' . 'II ' . ' The tendetl.".. it became clear how much more we could be doing. not to mention compassion and cooperation wherever they appear. vlCtiIlliZ""'d."La f\ the guise of lib. . ' d esrre to rna k e t hiings h appen. s. This is the real purpose of the glorification of shoplifting. the instinctive suspicion with which they view all totalitarian systems-provide a starting point for a resistance that proceeds from the individual motivations and standpoints of * I grew up as a middle class rebel. When I sat in on one of their meetings. A" '11' . . actrv­ ' ' . apparent nihilism. . ity . ble. Just as t ey can sense when you are . *When the locals started joining in the fighting. Since t h err rves a1 dv i 1u d e too ' '1' rea y inc much role-plau'ng an d nv al ry. ctrvists w h 0 are sti serving t he i e imperatives of msecunty t~ d ' . graffiti. 155 . the pleasure in transgression they find they share with teenagers and anarchists. When I gave up trying to push reforms through the bureaucracy and began to practice direct action with others of my back ­ ground.g them d e f ensrve. f as hiron. we can find common cause with people on the ba ­ sis of all the social and "antisocial" things they are already doing and feeling: theft. revo utionanes or 1ea d ers or intellectuals' t() Cairn t h e mora1hiig h groun d .me ism serves the sarne f unction that machiismo. are consi enng a revo1utionary project. however impetuously. "laziness. desire to alien.. we showed them how to make their shirts into masks so the police couldn't identify them and how to use lime juice to treat the effects of tear gas-that's anarchist "leadership.. ey more likely to t' espond to t h at. ri T .. sue h actrvists m action.. but to establish connections to the daily lives and resis­ tances of individuals who have not necessarily articulated a desire for revolution but are already acting. the ' in any kind Of" movement is actually a healthy self-d e f ense . t It turned out that just one neighborhood over there was a group in the Chicano community working according to the same principles._ ..)-are we sti see kimg power and revenge In . outside the logic of the ruling order.." or what we have in place of it: sharing our skills with others. 0 f activists t hernselvesrmanv activists have imveste " d ~ emse ves: many acti ave in their activist i entities as an act 0 f compensation at east as muc id " '1 h as out of a gen. the greatest challenge for those who seek common cause Wit ot h ers to rna k e revo luti ith ' utionary c h ange is h to avoid maki <.. h ' "r playmg a role. to whom our perspectives can be most useful and with whom cooperation comes most naturally. "'Ve ask ourselves: ~e we certain of our motivations? Will our words and deeds mob'l'ize an d enable. The private longings and frustrations people feel-their hatred for busywork. ts patromzmg implications that others are lazy. and so on that some radical propaganda indulges in: not to argue that shoplifting itself is revolutionary (or that one must shoplift to be radical. struggle has n()th' ' ives. C onsequently.' We can help others defend themselves from the encroachments of power and ideology. peop1e wop1acate t h eir " " h ' . erudition. insofar as we share values and goals-this is vastly preferable to entering oth ­ ers' communities and attempting to organize them according to the doctrines of outsiders. offering them the tools we have developed in our own struggles to apply as they see fit! Finally. . ... It.or in nee d 0 f gUi ance.. . . untapped force my demographic has to offer. Seei". as if revolution was a commodity in a scarcity economy!)." Likewise. ' ate others so they can stand alone as the virtuous vanguard. Infighting th~ Good Fight reaching out to those with whom we have the most in common..we b ' 154.J h ' '-10 better to abandon the crusade to convert t e ' .serve for 0thers." rebelliousness. va­ grancy. i iscourager rue we trymg to c ' t'eate a spectacle of our freedom or compassiOn or . but I thought I had to put that behind me to work towards social change. f rom a pace 0 f desi an d goo d fai h Th' re much 1 Y esire aitn. We would . and pop ul ar­ ion t . we must 'd ' ' . social mechanism. P I lte w hen vou are lordi your-:" l "ratiOnr eop e can en you are or mg self over them. self-help guru ' .f or t h em. . vandalism. I' cause d in part ' ' t is by the attitude. they may even unconsciously ..g insecurrties 11\ oth er ways frequently conclude that revolutionary ' .I masses with i " . . em. n to alienate others. I nstead can egin by ' id " . acting honesth.. .. . ing to do Wit h t h err I' 0 wi Whenever '-. te 1 evangeI'ists. and other assorted fanatics and salesmen compet­ rng to convert t h hesitance of the masses to get involved . .to Win at t h e CiS h lai ' hildi " compention Of w h 0 is most ra di 1 or most oppresse d (as i su ff er­ ' if rca ing was quantrj... using different words for similar ideas. to ~"ta bliis h our status as revoluti . Infighting the Good Fight.Why PeOPle Don't Want to "Join the Movement" Considering t l'Ie numb ers 0 f pu ic re lati oubli ations agents.. spreading power rather than concentrating it. we can work with those who are already active in other communities. cy 0 f ra di 1 po1" ' ica itics to rna k I f ee 1 d e fensrve e peop e may currently be a greater obstacle to SOCial transformation than " any corporate t ontro1or government repressiOn. weak. I realized what a vast.

as liberals do whenever radicals use direct action to give their petitioning teeth-is need­ lessly counterproductive. No one in power would take heed of the latter without the former behind them-imagine Martin Luther King's nonviolence without the im­ plicit threat of Malcolm X's confrontational stance-and without "respectable" support. 157 . Don't be intimidated-you can be sure that if you are feeling something some­ one else is feeling it too. coordination vs. sometimes perpetrated in the name of the underrepresented by those who aren't neces­ sarily underrepresented themselves. Not Unity. as in the relationship between masked rioters and well-behaved. more than this. it's impor­ tant not to feel too threatened. By and large. distinctions that separate yourself from others-or as means of achieving a more fulfilling life? It's common sense to integrate • As the masked window-smasher yelled at the law-abiding liberal protester who tried to restrain her. it is tantamount to wish­ ing everyone had the same life history and perspective. But." "reformist. all parties should remember that others may even have to publicly disavow their tactics in order to continue playing their parts effectively. Similarly. but rather to find ways to integrate divergent methods into a mutually beneficial whole. and must be a part of any struggle for it." "extremist. others' approaches and goals are bound to differ from yours. don't try to represent them. pacifism. again. it is up to you to find and add the missing ingredients that can make them effective-if you don't. approaches that seem to contradict each other may actually form a perfect symbiosis. teenage hoodlums are not going to find the same things liberating middle-aged librarians do-but both have a stake in liberation. Some people may dismiss your perspective (as "middle class. we'll need an equally diverse arsenal of outreaches. including self-proclaimed activists.' but to distance yourself from my actions as much as you have to to keep the respect of the demographic you're trying to reach! It's my job to make something happen here so they'll have to listen to you in the fuck­ ing first place!" 156.. as status symbols. well-spoken proponents of social change. but there is no such thing as an illegitimate perspective-it is only illegitimate to act as if someone else's perspective is not legitimate. Again. I! Approaches that speak clearly to some people may alienate oth­ ers. if you share another's goals but feel that their tactics are ineffective or counterproduc­ tive. ask yourself: are your positions impor­ tant to you as positions-that is to say. since you may not actually be-and to keep in mind that with the vast diversity of lives on this planet.* there should be no hard feelings when this happens. but Harmony Any resistance movement is going to develop conflicts over strat­ egy (violence vs. In these cases. In some cases. by making an effort to listen to those who already are. Infighting the Good Fight Infighting the Good Fight. insurgents can easily be marginalized and destroyed. you have yourself to blame for all the energy you feel they're wasting.). and needs to know she is not alone. * When it comes to underrepresented perspectives-if they are not your own. the challenge is not to convert them to your own strategy (for who knows-they might actually know better than you what is good for theml).all who comprise it rather than the demands of political parties and dogmas.* This is the only kind of resistance that can rescue us from authoritarian power and authoritarian ideology alike. Those who would set rules for the unruly and regulations for the irregular deny the complexity not only of human beings but also of the struggle it will take to win our freedom. badges of identity. In these situations. for example. A lot of that goes on. Certainly it can be difficult to work alongside people who profess beliefs entirely different from yours-and you should never work with those you fear will betray you or hijack your efforts to serve their own ends.. Better repre­ sent yourself. "It's not your job to stop me from 'making your cause look bad. the way politicians "represent" us. To contest this diversity rather than seeking to benefit from it-to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by turning chances to address important issues into squabbles. and encourage others to do the same . autonomy) as different individuals construct their own analyses and test them out in prac­ tice." etc.

the problem is simply how to make its workings more to one's liking. But. Infighting the Good Fight Infighting the Good Fight .the differing tactics of those who share' a common goal. head of state. eventually relying on abstractions ("the working class. lover against lover and parent against child. USA vs.159 ." So many of us alienate ourselves needlessly from others. but it's a nobler objective than any unity that demands conversion by the sword. as her companions can represent parts of herself that she would not otherwise express. but rather the conditions that make human beings enemies. bet on the world. and other oppressors can go about their merry business and still be "part of our collective"-they'd be the first ones to deny that. Revolu­ tion happens when you create situations that make the old conflicts irrelevant. own-recognizing this enables an individual to be a more complete person.. Iraq. We have to remember in every extremity that our enemies are not human beings. 158. Working and living in such associations. Anarchists. at least for those who are patient. helps one learn to see oneself as a part of the web of human relations rather than as an isolated individual. Everyone is ultimately a product of the same world-we are all interconnected. that violence would remain in the world as the venom and fury of those who survived them. worse. especially when it makes you impossible to * Organizing autonomously and trying another free association whenever one Working in Collectives Just as a band needs musicians who play different instruments. Doing things you enjoy will help you resist taking your frustra­ tions out on others-as will working with people you like whenever it's possible. coop­ eration and community can only be incidental and haphazard. This enables us to see ourselves as noble crusaders-and more importantly. to have adversaries. and housemate who won't do the dishes. but it doesn't mean everyone has to be friends. The more we demonstrate this to be untrue. albeit dysfunc­ tional. Smash Fascism. isn't working can give you the freedom you need so you will not resent others. consid­ erate. as any child can point out. This is not to say fascists. not to mention the effects on the killers themselves-that's karma for you. In order to coexist. humble. C. though no less constructive. which reas­ sures us of our own righteousness. Without this insight. but instead integrate their dissimilarities into a whole greater than the sum of its parts. and follow up with proof! But the chief argument of fascism and reactionary think­ ing has always been that cooperation and autonomy are mutually exclusive. forgiving. Destroy Capitalism. the less appeal their claims will have. War or Revolution? Would-be revolutionaries so frequently frame our project in mar­ tial terms: we set out to Fight Racism. collective. that people must be ordered and controlled or else they will be lazy and/or kill each other. healthy associations don't restrict the participants with compromis­ es that limit them to the things they have in common. it is so long as one hasn't yet tasted that success. Eat the Rich. war is business as usual for capital­ ist society: Exxon vs. to put aside the compul-:' sion to persuade everyone else of your opinions and work to create harmony between individuals who live in totally different worlds. it becomes possible to regard the entire cosmos as one vast. Communists vs." There's nothing noble or revolutionary about sacrific­ ing yourself for a cause. A world entirely without enemies is not possible-it might not even be desirable-but remember." "the imminent insurrection") for allies once every flesh and blood companion is gone or.a. in which every person is conscious of being responsible for making the projects and relationships work. police officer. Warfare is necessary sometimes-we have to defend ourselves. and sometimes this requires violence. each manifesting different aspects of the same interplay of forces. "if it's you against the world. This reassurance is more seduc­ tive than the success it replaces and prevents-at least. Such harmony will never be complete.E. Even if we could kill every last rapist. it's more challenging. Revolution may involve learning to live and act cooperatively. Shell. we must take others' desires as seriously as our . that dispel all that inertia of resentment and insecurity and antagonism. concluding that cooperation is simply impossible-when history shows that it is possible. For the individual experienced in living communally. sexists.

Where one flower blooms. but also acknowledged the fears and anxieties men feel. you can discern what they have to offer you. you can do your part to liberate all of us prisoners of war. offer real compassion-not the condescension of charity-when it is needed. But there is no for­ mula for this. we would assuredly have torn each other to pieces already. even when the latter did not at first know how to listen. and errors. and bring a generous heart when you do. there are as many worlds as there are people-save !lours. it won't-and shouldn't-always be possible to surround yourself with people who see things the way you do: be ready to leave your comfort zone. That's another reason why it is good that we have all chosen different paths and suffered different things. at the same time. even things that seemed to isolate us-why there is a place even for spoiled rich kids and homeless drug addicts and lovers who have lied and betrayed in this struggle: for who else could relate to others in those difficult situations. when you refrain from be­ ing self-righteous even and especially with the self-righteous. to the women who not only demanded men recognize the existence and effects of their sexism. least of all mercy. a million more will follow. When you practice a form of justice that takes responsibility for setting things right. help them believe in themselves. This means it is all the more critical that we not miss the opportunities we have to be good to others-whether or not they have "earned" it. to the survivors of abuse who went on to counsel both abused and abusers. 160. who have taken it for granted that for all their clumsiness. when you approach every conflict as an opportunity to learn from your own mistakes. Often it takes a person who has suf­ fered something similar to be able to offer real succor to someone in distress. It's frightening to let your guard down. 161 . this may help you to see the importance of others who previ ­ ously appeared without worth. selfishness. Perhaps the most important thing you can do is be there for others. Often we have our hands full dealing with our own pain. people from other backgrounds and advocates of other tactics really did want to coexist and cooperate with them: to the working class men and women who took the time to explain to bourgeois activ­ ists how they were alienating them. Without them. Don't be intimidated by the colossal challenge of "saving the world". At the same time. it can make sense of experiences that seemed senseless. too consumed by bitterness and confusion to be able to offer others any­ thing. Infighting the Good Fight Infighting the Good Fight. offer them guidance and hope? When you rec­ ognize how your tribulations have prepared you to help others. When you are patient with impatience. whether or not we think it will make a difference. whether or not we understand them. This is dedicated to all those who have done this over the years. mercy comes in the least predictable forms and from the most unexpected sources. you can heal rather than impotently dispensing guilty verdicts. it's hard to swallow your pride even when clinging to it would mean betraying yourself-but this is the only way to help others do the same. When you forgive others for their incoherence. the one made up of the life you share with those around you.be around.

This is what the world has made of me. I don't want to compete with you for moral high ground or anything else. it would be a testing ground at which we would see if we could work together in our new configurations. we lost track of each other-there wasn't even a celebration to bring us together one last time. so I never risk losing my respect for them or my ability to trust. We'd won a victory I'd assumed was impossible-but now there was no more "we" and the fundamental structures we'd taken on remained unshaken. Infighting the Good Fight Hitting the Wall. as I hope to accept you. This was the first major event in recent memory we all agreed was important. Perhaps the ones who initiated the campaign should have set their sights higher from the beginning. but also drew disproportionately more repression-that scale was the province of our enemies. Yet once we'd succeeded in forcing the administration to stop using sweatshop labor and improve working conditions. everyone was busy preparing for a demonstration that was happening halfway across the country. though no one put this together at the time. This was apparent in the way the strike ended and in the increasing distance between groups employing different tactics-more and more people were getting involved. but they crossed paths less and less. You are as responsible as I am for mak­ ing what goes on between us positive for us both-or for the world of strife we will suffer in otherwise. In place of working with other locals. 163 . The announcement that the administration was severing all ties with the sweatshop industry marked the final splintering of our precarious confederation. local activity had died down significantly. this is who I am. the terrain on which they could mobilize the most force. not my own. This expansion enabled us to act on a more dramatic scale. the unlikely alliances made it seem the whole world was reconfig­ uring itself. even when they are defensive with me-to see others in the context of their lives. you're going to have to accept me on my own terms. I would like to be able to look those adversaries who should be allies in the eyes and say Like it or not. By the end of the following year. each group began to or­ ganize with its counterparts in other cities. and we all must live with the consequences. I can't change the decades of life behind me that have wrought this. Part of the initial magic of the encampment had been the confluenc~ of disparate demographics.I would like to be someone with whom no one would be ashamed of any part of herself I would like to be able to regard the actions of others without feeling threatened or becoming defensive. 162. I would like to know how to set the right limits on how far I trust others. Thus the expansion of the struggle corresponded with its local disintegration. only take responsibility for what I am and what I do. Unless you're prepared to kill everyone who doesn't live up to your standards or else to endure this impasse indefinitely.

they'll kill us all. partly on account of my age. but here she appeared at the head of a contingent of her own-which. her friends had been in and out of town. thirty gas masks. Hitting the Wall Hitting the Wall. though I'd begun working with an independent media collective to put my skills to use. to make sure there were photographers and reporters where activists desired them." Everyone laid their hands on the people around them.." It soon came out that there were still disagreements as to what we were here to accomplish. The meeting took place in a classroom at the local university. "I'm with those people. really?" Samia was talking out of turn. then locked the door and addressed . lines of police in black riot armor were drilling in the square next to teams of workmen assembling walls of chain link and concrete. Kate and Marshall and their . crowd were still around. thirty improvised shields. Others specified the number of people in the contingent they represented. whose arms rested on each others' shoulders." His tone didn't permit discussion or dispute. though we rarely saw each other. the kind of frenetic night that falls in big metropolises. others thought that foolhardy. They'll shoot us. if her companions in the meeting were any indi­ cation. She proposed an alternative: "If we can't go to the wall. only by sight. Kate had invited me to a private meeting the evening before the first big day of action." room contrasted starkly with my companions' somber attire and J: visages. . I had taken it that Samia was a sort of protegee of Marshall. "Before we begin. forming a lattice of limbs extending from row to row-with one exception: Kate and the others I knew were on the other side of the room. "I can trash the McDonald's in my neighborhood any time I want. and break off to visit the shopping district. All eyes fell on me. Then we went around giving our names and fields of activity. and two of those l . "You know the police have a free hand when it's only us in the streets. He didn't step aside until I told . let's head the opposite direction with the liberal march. but as far as I could tell she'd been gone the entire time. I hoped each one indicated a new challenge to their control. The real problem here is it's only us in this room! Why aren't we meeting with all the other groups that will be out there tomorrow? Look around the faces here-do you think this is representative? What happened to the coalitions we had a year ago?" 164 . or the equipment they'd brought: "One hundred hockey pucks. She'd known me long enough that she trusted me to participate in such things. seemed to be composed of starry-eyed vagabonds from the four corners of the earth. conversing in twos and threes.I hadn't seen Samia since the debriefing that followed the night march. the room. in my new persona as an enemy of the state. gesturing at Kate and Marshall and Diego. I arrived in the city less than a week before the summit was to begin. It didn't help that I was the oldest by a full decade. As was becoming typical. We're going to the wall.'j 1· him who had invited me. Marshall Mars. twenty-five feet wide. A stocky young man in a black. ' A tall woman with an authoritative air exchanged whispers' with the young man outside. one reinforced banner. 165 . here was the fantasy Marshall had talked about in the occupation' days coming true in humble reality.. I want everybody to touch someone they vouch for. I knew perhaps six out of the three dozen present. I hadn't turned our adventures into a book' after all. I'd re­ mained something of a loner. it's impossible. though Marshall and Diego still treated me with thinly veiled disdain on account of my social class and suspect profession. but the stigma of being able to still lay upon me. Night had fallen. I explained that I was there on behalf of the independent media. most of the collective resided elsewhere in the country. and the atmosphere was tense and portentous. Most people were already there-barbarians of the sort I'd first encountered at the occupation. "But what's to stop them from shooting us. Si­ rens resounded constantly in the distance. enough fireworks for ourselves and another group our size. Kate was Hecate. Some people wanted to mount a di­ rect assault on the security perimeter around the summit." In my sexism. They won't be prepared for that. The fluorescent lighting and spotless white walls of the class." I offered sheepishly. with two joints. The spokesperson of the locals was utterly despondent: "We can't go to the wall. Downtown had the air of an occupied nation during wartime." Marshall countered this.i. flight jacket stood guard at the door. and so on. The red and blue lights of police cruisers flashed at every intersection.

here we go again . Of course. My comrades' critiques of each other were all true enough.. the re­ sults are catastrophic. mi. but that ] was beside the point. we were showing up every week to shovel beans! Don't ask me where everyone else is after you fucking abandoned us!" Everyone froze. 167 . This.This sent Diego into a rage. They had been sculpted by our times as sure as the crenellatio and parapets of medieval castles were sculpted by theirs. Likewise.1 time for this! There are serious things we have to decide by tomor-! row-" "Y'all should have talked this out already before you brought it in here!" "Christ. Hitting the Wall Hitting the Wall.. no external forces prevented them from acknowl­ edging and curbing this behavior. it was like releasing pollution into the ocean: if only one person does it. One might say of an animal tha persists in some counterproductive activity that it is incapable 0 behaving differently. Samia lashed back: "If you're go­ ing to speak to me like that-no wonder I left! No wonder there's no one else here!" Several other people broke in at once.. it dis­ solves harmlessly. had become increasingly common over the preceding year. and the advantages of doing so. when someone had to speak up to calm tempers and get the discussion back on track. Every collective ended in acrimonious division. and it was futile to expect them to let down rhei guard and stop fighting each other. " I left in the hopeless rage of those who watch powerlessly as . defensive responses to criticism. Instead. their loved ones destroy something precious. Historia teach that those parapets were invented by men. were obvious-but they could not. And this was why no revolution had taken place: no one had succeeded in introducing a new element to this equation. Crowded into cities. "What happened? Where the fuck have you been? While you were out cavorting around the world. The wreckage of our planet was simply the physical manifestation of the disposable nature of our relationships and commitments. we were struggling to keep things going. but just as a stre of water will erode a cliff into an accommodating shape it was inventions and decisions of generations of men and women th forced those inventors to design parapets or perish. Each of us went through friendship after friendship. using them up and burning them out. and an animal observing my companions woul have said the same of them. every alliance broke off before it bore fruit. friends had been shaped by their atomized society into individ walled fortresses. this seemed a sustainable approach to social life. this inability manifested itse as their endless excuses. we don't have . "Come on. In fact. dwelli on each others' faults. We'd gotten nowhere.. and efforts to discredit former friends rathe than hear out their critiques-anything to avoid having to set asid their insecurities and work through differences like adults. too. our planet teeming with billions of people. This was the critical moment. Up close. they were fighting each other rather than our common enemies. ! 166. then moving on to do the same with others. so it perpetually produced the same results. but no one dared. but when everyone does so perpetually.

·.the grim anarchists pull down masks clenched teeth..our arrogance and fear. As the sun rises through the t~~~()url~ckystarswe still have a common enern ?utpff()urrifts and rivalries for another day.a. it is all we have learned. ourdi1e~IIls.. another line to draw. . there always be another conflict. This is what we do. We know better than to h for victory: after this fight. i... We c 1:1!t'ri~~gso~gisapPointments in ourselves. our despair. 'ma. even after any revolution... it we can do with our bitterness. and . . Even if e government and board of directors abdicated and no one ste forward to replace them.tld also our shame. we would simply commence fig each other. in each other.rtyrcomplexes.

That day we marched to the wall and tore it to the ground. And there we stopped. But history always doubles back on itself. That was our moment. so much as our willingness to abide it. saturate the air for the next two days. we found ourselves three blocks back. everything we'd idly charged against capitalism and hierarchy was borne out beyond our wildest nightmares by what followed. no songs. It was incredible. The police withdrew before us-they hadn't bar. and we did-we cut the bars with' bolt cutters and smashed the metal poles free of their concrete bases' and rocked the whole structure until it crashed to the asphalt. they signed their names in our blood on documents milled from our forests. was striking in that it was utterly silent-no chants. and we squan­ dered it in frozen disbelief. ready to contest it. we would have put aside our pride and sorted out our petty feuds. instead. cessities of life remained hostage behind shop windows. but here we were at last. We didn't believe in ourselves enough. we hadn't imagined we could possibly get to this point.' they forked flesh from our bones into their insatiable mouths and' called it freedom. Then. gained on us being so numerous and so fierce. That hush was bone-chilling. of course. all the inertia and insecurity and self-imposed impotence­ all but our own internal conflicts. nor when we have to apologize to one another and talk out our disputes. we didn't deserve another chance. dubiously testing what was pos­ sible in the world rather than shouldering the task of changing it. men had gathered to ' ensure that dishwashers stayed in dish rooms. trying the same experiments endlessly over until they produce different results. No one ever stepped forward through the holes we had knocked in the wall. If only we had understood that the battle lines were not in front of us but within. After that. had we apprehended the gravity of the war we were fighting. On the Battlefield On the Battlefield. nor in each other. We thought we still had time for quarreling and second thoughts. We were fools. We paused again. We had to call off the crusade to which we had given our lives. almost ready to test our own. our once in a lifetime chance. That was the day th finally recognized the threat we posed. and the ne. Even throwing molotov cocktails at armored personnel carriers. an hour later. we managed to lose. through the first puff of the tear gas that was to. that the last lines of defense were being brought out to . we had to return to siding with the police and bosses and billboards against ourselves and the desires we had nurtured beyond their control. We didn't realize that we had already fought nine tenths I of the battle. our neigh­ borhoods and our bedrooms! If we had arrived at the wall with our relationships and confidence in one another intact. in all the subsequent demon. Next time we won't hesitate when we've pulled down the wall. restrain us because we had triumphed against all the repressive forces within. Ironically. how much depended on us. we had spent all our time bickering . persuade our friends that all the commitments to which we had pledged ourselves were pipe dreams. but with great effort. we thought we had grievously miscalculated the strength " of our foe and were about to be crushed without even leaving a smudge on history. I could see the high-rise in which the summit was taking place. which were our real undoing. disconnect vast international networks. When only riot police stand between us and our freedom-only guns and shields. the only way we could have lost would have been to turn back at that moment. shields of their vans. When th media appeared. finally. The mar.. This took years to accomplish. so now that we'd arrived' we were unprepared to do anything. There. fore­ swearing our struggle and begging to be forgiven our heresies. fleeing a police charge calculated to sweep us into the arms of an arriving army unlike anything we'd seen before. our escape routes blocked by a new wall of beige and green. 171 . we smashed their cameras and stomped in the wind'. ar­ mored tanks and water cannons and concussion grenades." about whose fault it was that we couldn't. the slow apparatus of the state roused itself and lurched into motion. Africans and Asians' and Latin Americans stayed in mines and sweatshops. just dour mass of people going somewhere to do something. in our planning meetings and conversations. It was our one. it was too massive an undertaking to complete in the moment we found ourselves surrounded. It was not their power that kept us on our knees. we still weren't convinced of the reality of what we were doing-we were still playacting. 170. we thought we had lost. hardest of all. Ahead of me. because We weren't ready to handle the responsibility of being the first line of defense against the wholesale destruction of life on earth. . chance to penetrate their defenses. strations. and nothing more-we can win. It took a lot of doing. for the contest between de­ sire and military might is not played out according to military rules. We'd given up so easily in part because we weren't pre­ pared for the grisly implications of our own conclusions. they mobilized every mercenary within a thousand mile~ to intercept us before we could even come together. Standing there facing the assembled might of the police state.

.

QJ

..0

o '-f ..... ..c= u

:s

:s

e

·0

~

..c=

.

consumers are bought and sold in the marketplace. 183 . business will continue as usual: prison guards pace concrete tombs. Gas prices will rise with global temperatures and tides. the shrapnel spray of suburbs slicing through forest and field. Factories will disappear overseas and corporations vanish into thin air. Our generation will go to its grave shouting its last words into a cell phone. women clutching babies will pick through the rubble and tear out their hair. finally interject: "Which world?" The End of the World. mysterious and knowing.. who keep trying to impose harmony between oppressed and oppressor with fear and firepower. drumming the concrete below. computer systems crash with stocks and stock markets .. Cities dying from the inside out will spread like ringworm. step by invisible step. Men with splinters in their eyes will stumble through streets choked with debris. demons glare from the eyes of ministers. Or else nothing will happen at all. acid rains fall with the last 'of the redwoods.THE END OF THE WORLD When the world ends. A rain of desperate bodies will fall from the windows of burning buildings. whispers the homeless man on the corner-don't you know that yet? Others. who have held themselves aloof from the discussion until now. until one day everyone has cancer. taking jobs and retirement funds with them. Or perhaps it will arrive as a thief in the night. psychiatrists contemplate mad­ ness. white dust will fill the air like the curtain at the end of a play. It's after the end of the world. Wars will reach from continent to continent and neighborhood to neighborhood-the terrorists who won't make peace against the horrorists who would enforce it at any price.

often: unconsciously devote themselves to the fulfillment of their parenu': unacted desires. ing out of orbit were the same ones that were soon to tear throu~ our entire society.] pandemics. As we hal all found our paths to resistance one by one. caused the real buildings of our cities to catch fire. we were utterly at a loss. If the world really was ending. They floundered about in millenarian desperation. it might be that our own revolts had j been early indicators of the ruptures that were to come.1 8 5 . Our entire approach had been predicated on the exag­ gerated placidity of the order we opposed. nor that the alarmist presenta-' tions I'd made about the water table in my former life as an environ-s mental activist would return as chilling front-page headlines. hadn't occurred to me that the cancer that killed Daniel might be the-'. in­ distinguishable from the calamities that had always made up our daily lives. It. but we'd been] oblivious to them until our own lives were sufficiently disrupted. likewise. It was absurd to think that the burning buildings on our patches and posters had. Some Run for Cover-We Rush to Bear \Nitness Some Run for Cover-We Rush to Bear Witness . and our painful trials were simply that society. Young children. we thought of ourselves as uniquely inde-' pendent from history-but perhaps the forces that sent us spiral-. Faced with actual upheaval. Some of my friends concluded that the world was indeed coming to an end and attempted to act accordingly. hurricanes. but we behave~ like penitent criminals. preparing for a doomsday that never arrived or await­ ing some watershed until their sense of agency had atrophied en­ tirely. harbinger of our species' extinction. Or perhaps they'd been going on all along. painfully breaking ou~ of the roles assigned us. . being hypersensitized to the unspoken. disguising ourselves in the rhetoric of the. but this only seemed to further immobilize them. the specter of the world ending was too vast to address with any particular course of action. now that the curtain had been pulled back from the abyss. wars. dupes who were marching lockstep into the waiting maw of th~ apocalypse. both to lend a hand and to learn about life after the end of the world. -­ 184. wracked by guilt as if our own subversive de­ sires had somehow invited that chaos into the world.Then the catastrophes began: terrorist attacks.' wresting itself from its prepared track in microcosm. Only in the smoke and tumult occasionally unleashed by real catastrophes was it possible to escape that malaise-and so some of us who once had circled the globe in search of adventure now flocked to those. those of us who had been playing) at revolution froze. it wasn't ending fast enough-the end seemed to drag on forever.

Graffiti artists surge into the streets. "Disasters bring people together. either-domestic violence decreased dramati ­ cally in South Central Los Angeles during the riots in 1992. having had the good fortune to experience both. Disasters are often the crucibles of millenarian and revolutionary movements: in such extremes. * It's not just birth and death rates.When the world ends. people confess secrets and grant forgiveness. The urgency of emergency provides just the spice that the constant low-intensity stress of daily life never could. for example." Life. No one has to go to work or the laundromat. the stars come out over New York City. boredom-in the midst of catastrophes. This sense of community offers intimations of a different kind of society. stories. while it hits a national peak on the day of the Super Bowl. "ONE ORDINARY WEEKEND IS BLOODIB 186." -National Research Council Committee on Disaster Studies. Disaster THAN A MONTH OF INSURRECTION. in fact. nobody remembers to check the mirror or scale or email account before leaving the house. they share food. individuals whose lives were formerly separated identify with each other. Every moment possesses an imme ­ diacy formerly spread out across months. people experience the broad possibilities of life and subsequently set out to realize them. sobbing and laughing. Convergence Behavior in Disasters: A Problem in Social Control Disaster Yes. strangers embrace. and nine months later. As a French student com­ mented back in May of 1968. just as the rate of natural death declines during them." Disaster. turning calamity into a harbinger of better things. People don't often die of old age-that is to say. com­ panionship. a new generation is born. imparting a common context and project. In this suddenly opened and democratized atmosphere. 187 . it's never tasted so sweet. however precarious. birth rates increase immediately following disasters. Burdens fall away. people come out of their apartments and meet their neighbors for the first time. is worth staying awake for.

in the new and alien landscape of upheaval. The terrified guard threw her arms around the prisoner and ~~mbraced her. In our "normal" lives. we accommodate oursel to the smallness of what seems to be the world. ready or n shivering on the sidewalk before the ruins. To get to the bottom of this. And her eyes became unseeing again~ "Hands behind your back! Move along. workplace ac .:" dents. when everyday life is statistically more dangerous to us. Disaster Disaster. and no one kno for sure what will follow next. everything has weight meaning-tears and laughter both come easily. Nadia . final judgment. . Catastrophes are sometimes described as experiences of total liberation. work and witness miracles. That the notion of such an apocalypse-whether as nuclear war. When school is closed and the roads are impassable. we can become heroes. we must reexamine both disasters their supposed opposite. really strange thing is that. recalls the time when she was being taken to interrogation by an impassive. through the forbidden eyes of the secret part of each us that rejoices in them. Lost hikers teach themselves to start fires with wristwatches. or total revolution-is so pervasive in our civilization suggests a popular fascination with extremes in which conventions no longer apply. "What would you do if you learned you had only twenty four hours to liver From inside our cubicles and confessionals. Disasters render the social facts that comprise reality nego­ tiable. and dissident futures the pragmatic once dismissed as impos­ sible take over where the former chains of cause and effect leave off. atrophying commit­ ments. abrupt freedom takes the place of hackneyed choice. alone and forgotten in rest homes. cowardice and inertia: complete self-determination. Afterwards. when everything is up in the air.. suffer tragediCli rather than mere indignities. surviving in the woods-suddenly become essential for ev­ eryone. they also die in automobile collisions." That was a disaster that didn't go far enough. silent guard With unseeing eyes-when suddenly the bombs began to explode right next to the Big House and it sounded as if at the next moment they would fall directly upon them.But what about the people who do die in disasters? It's trill' that people lose their lives in heat waves. at the same time as we fear them. quoted in Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's atlas of human suffering and inhuman repression The Gulag Archipelago. In the wake of a disaster. even for what we have 10 Danger and distress do not always arrive uninvited. Skills that seemed specialized and irrelevant-fighting riot police. 189 . normal life. and that accomm tion becomes itself a prison. sasters. to trade one·' tiresome old fears and frustrations for new and compelling ones c be a real relief. that.. Trying as they may be. people who have invested eve thing in it must rely on those who have spent their lives ponder' ti81 the Could Be. It's no coincidence the Millennium referred to in so many religious traditions is to be ushered in by a phase of terrible destruction: the kingdom of heaven arrives through the smoke. and we find ourselves tossed out of our prisons. ers and outcasts can find themselves elevated to positions of p res and approval-indeed. hereti­ cal as such a notion is in our safety-first society. docile airplane pas­ sengers commit cannibalism and are celebrated for it. of drug overdoses and heart attacks and lung cancer­ in unprecedented numbers. Let's begin by looking at disasters from the dissident pe spective. In these new conditio. to resign themselves again to all that knowing. thankf . Then the bombing stopped. errand­ running mothers lift automobiles off children. we can only envision total freedom 188. we find ourselves fully engaged.. one is no longer at the mercy of routine. Outsj . for each other and everything we have. Disasters deliver the equality law promises but fails to f When disaster strikes. Disasters throw everything into disarz and into question: the wide world reasserts that anything is inde possible. and airp hijackings. a boy in a wheelchair is no less than a haugh executive: the two watch the burning high-rise side by side. desperate for human companionship and sympathy in the face of the end. as a society. 1'" come alive in them. flash floods. Our preoccupation with danger and tragedy implies a barely disguised longing for risk and uncertainty. we fixate so fearfully on •. Disaster as Interruption It's a public secret: disasters are exciting. is inescapable. we find them so fascina . many find it difficult readjust. and figure out which is re which. they may be the only ones prepared for situation: when the Is evaporates.

whether or not anyone dies. this is the one feature they all share.. on the terror the thought of it provokes-to main. community. brutish. that disasters are the apex of adventure. who most dread to leave its territory. being intimidation: they keep us cowed. such as black­ 190 . The essential quality of disasters as we know them is the break with the status quo. After all. These portrayals more tellingly. we dutifully fear them. Already harrowed by the vicissitudes of the system itself. The disaster we see through these screens. for that matter. and ugly.. profiteers who take advantage of the situation to fleece survivors". in the papers. These representations serve a host of purposes. And our leaders are the ultimate profiteers of disaster: they rely on. the wilderness allegedly beyond the walls of civilization. is a nigh.' they're not the ones who bear the brunt when something goes awryi~ Students of disaster tell us that while disasters can increase the OP-~I portunities for exploitation.and authentic living in the context of imminent destruction we do. but those who have lived through such disruptions know how sweet it can be when Something Happens. motion pictux. That. The Disaster as Permanent Condition Wait-how could that be. just as the number of deaths and injustices that have resulted from people obeying authorities far outnumber those perpetrated by those who have broken laws. This is fear of the unknown in its purest form: it projects chaos. exploitation in disaster conditions is usually perpetrated by outsiders.] in our nightmares. In the process. the forem. we have to spend our lives as disastourists. these leaders are the ones endangering . and death onto everything beyond the pale of the ordinary. { against us. In fact. perhaps only fictional.inei~ for are distant. and routine. is a safe ritual-it is the protector of the status quo. It is not de­ structiveness that sets disasters apart: the slaughterhouses. whatever the cost in lives and life. rumors. but. they teacl the important lesson that the moments of truth we secretly p. and collateral damage of Business As Usual take more lives than all the worst catastrophes combined. while many disasters don't result in any deaths at all. those caught in thrall to fear. at least among the population that experiences them. Here in the world of structure. on the other hand. Our protectors run the ultimate protection racket. through action mov. ies and video games and the like. is bound to be in great demand ill \. precipitate. •. The free and fearless. experience it ourselves but only see it on television. suicides.. today these are practically standard \. 2001 was followed immediately by a series of wars-and which calamity hasultimately been bloodier. where do our leaders fit in the anatomy of calamity?:)! Airlifted in by private jet to address the mourners (and cameramenR they speak as if they suffer our own tragedies more than we do. must be people who fear the boundlessness and unruliness of life but are quite at home with the orderliness of its opposite. as spectacle: news reports. welcome new horizons-disasters included. quixotically chasing the Disaster Disaster. but routines. Real interruptions in which the system breaks down. 191 . us-it is their policies that give us cancer and turn suicide bombers. we can con­ clude that those who most fear the unknown reveal in doing so that the world they know is a place of terror. a society that stifles first-hand adventure. it-more precisely. are still described as disasters. tain their power. the reassertion of normality.\ to say: those noble leaders are simply protecting us from ourselv~~ Or is it themselves they are protecting? . they also reduce the motivations for i4:. especially if you count foreigners as human beings? So only the coward fears disasters-that is to say. we know saster only from afar. thus the onl~. projections all the more ironic in that they can only be modeled on that which is known. But are they protecting us? Once upon a time oil spills and shoot ­ ings were considered disasters. safety.. popularity of the apocalypse-vicarious living. serve an economic role: they cash in on the immen . inaccessible." disaster would look very safe in­ deed.there is a cowardly part of each of us that would keep everything familiar. ready to live and all too aware of what is insufferable in the everyday. They are not anomalies. If the casualties of all disasters were tallied and compared to those of "normal life. constantly. destruction. certainly nOth 4 j ing we could participate in or. Disaster works for them-especially if we never '. features of our society. then. It is no coincidence that the run ­ away disaster of September 11.. in particular. built into the social fabric and accounted for in advance. grateful for the protectio:' of our noble leaders. life itself? Does that mean that if we really want to live. Yet there are some who live in horror of disasters while unflinchingly extolling the virtues of war: these. From this irony. outs and bomb threats. It is precisely the terrorized. War.." mare in which life is short.

If this status quo is the ultimate Disaster. in the break they herald from the full-scale slow-motion train wreck that is our society. a question of perspective: a "disaster" that disrupts a life of constraint is experienced as a moment of liberation. the trivia that trivializes us. to struggle only with the "natural disasters" our ances­ tors faced. borrowed wings of destruction and rebirth as we wade through years of deadening routine in the meantime? Is that practical. holocausts perpetuated with biological weapons and smart bombs. is the Disaster we live every day: the emptiness of our full schedules. That would explain why we feel so free whenever something. or is she just desperate for an honorable way out? Perhaps we have everything backwards here-maybe disasters aren't so great after all. interrupts all this. depression-these would not be possible without central­ ized state and corporate power. Perhaps the excitement and immediacy that break out in emergencies are simply indications of a return to our natural state. and the meaningless busywork of billions that engenders it. would almost be idyllic after all this. however dangerous or difficult. the machinery that runs on rivers of blood. the worst one. bulimia. The destruction of rainforests and the ozone layer. 193 . if it really is disorder and trag­ edy normalized as a system. anyway. if we ceased paying trib­ ute. any­ thing. To live with the unknown ahead of and around us. anorexia. Interrupt the Disaster! Disaster. when that "normal life" is actually Disaster in disguise. Most of the disasters we really suffer from can be traced to this invisible Disaster. longing for the fleeting. practicable. worthwhile? Does the woman fed up with her car payments and marriage really crave tornadoes and typhoons. then it is not disasters per se that are liberating-it is. the Disaster would surely crash and burn once and for all. rather. If that is the case. even global pandemics like mad cow disease. but the real Disaster. Could we fight Disaster with disaster? If we stopped feeding its flames with our hard work and attention. no lower-case disaster could be worse.few brief moments of upheaval destiny affords each of us.

And we are.' we can throw a disaster any time we like. we're conducting our own experiments with them. don't have to wait for catastrophe to strike to enjoy its benefits·. in a state of ongoing disast and difficulties. We don't live in the Disast but in encampments at its edge-yes. but nothing compared to the misery of life in Disaster area proper. Disaster . We don't fall for popular propaganda abo disasters. 194.Some of us are already practicing this.

Businessmen in hotel bars never tired of the Colditz sto­ ry. If prison is not simply the condition of spatial co finement but a spectrum of confinements ranging from iron b to debilitating despair to suburban ennui. however. The charm of that particular story was that it permitted college graduates to violate the most fundamental taboo that separates civilized humans from savages and wild beasts. Under the most difficult conditio~ the prisoners had invented the a i r p l a n e ! . Provided the protagonists were suitably middle class. the passengers behave within certain limits. too. and emotionally pres than anyone in the towns that had been spared. and would only have been ah to convey two people a scant thousand meters from the walls. the top secret Escape Committl' approved a plan to depart by air. social institutions: systems that purport to offer services or protection in exchange for obedience. brutish. Coldi'~ was the prison to which the Nazis sent the most dogged Allied esca . The popular fascination with accounts of disaster survival seemed to me a tacit admission that something was lacking in most people's daily lives. all deals are off. where we started. a glider that was to be launched from the rooftop of the castle a~ piloted to a field across the nearby river. The craft was nearly ready'~ ". inventive.. The glider was assembl~ entirely out of parts of the prison: floorboards. a thousand-year-old fortress near Dresden. and ropes. prisoners began buildiii. where Whole districts were sealed off and the inhabitants left to die. As a means of escape from the physical confines of prison. Colditz Castle. But long before the storms hit.~ fly just as Colditz was liberated by Allied troops. and industrial accidents.. later tests sho~ that it could have succeeded. disguises. The airplane is a metaphor for civilization. tornados. A scenario like that calls all manner of lesser rules and morals into question. w. By and large. Even those who had lost all their possessions had gained the one thing you couldn't buy on the market at any price-urgency. During the Second Wor: War. to the subject of flight. Off the Cliff Off the Cliff. demandedf tremendous quantity of resources. After several failed attempts involving standard tactics such hiding places. might be able to invent airplanes if only they weren't trapped in their well-paying careers. and consequently it became an elite school of escape. In 1943. This gave them something in common with those of us who had made disasters of our own lives in trying to chart a path out of our disastrous society. even the most extreme cases-such as the famous rugby team who survived by cannibal­ ism after their airplane crashed in the Andes-provoked more cu­ riosity than horror. chosen by the Nazis to serve as a high security POW camp. fir'. govern­ ment. artists.II Enough about the disintegration of our little movement-let's ret . adhesives and tools. 197 . bed sheets. I ri fleeted on this as I traveled the country reporting on floods. The soldiers who were imprisoned in Colditz would probabl never have become inventors if they had not been captured. those ghettos had been disaster areas wracked by malnutrition and drug addiction. impr:~ vised fasteners. ~' glider was a ridiculous scheme: it took years to build. the survivors' pressed me as more courageous. As a reporter dispatched to disaster areas. Then the story changed and I was permitted to decry the sluggish response of federal disaster relief agencies and bewail the senseless deaths of the poor. if we adjust our notion of what cot stitutes prison. But as soon as the plane crashes. devastated by slumlords and waste dumps. and short. it was my job to portray life outside the plane as ugly. They sent me to ghettos destroyed by natural disasters. First I was supposed to paint the savagery of the locals in vivid colors. It was a case study proving that even the basic prohibitions of God and Nature are negotiable-a sort of coded map to a loophole in the social contract. to balance the titilla­ tion of that escape against the terror and misery that must inevitably result. and 196. the subtext was that they. what qualifies as a stii cessful escape looks different as well. A contract exists between the passengers and the plane: the plane safely transports the pas­ sengers. to sensationalize the looting and arson that followed the breakdown of order and praise the bravery of the sheriffs and National Guardsmen who quarantined it. plan looks different.

silently re­ proaching their own offspring for failing to apply themselves. and terminal illnesses than of simply losing. Our disaster coverage was just a smokescreen to~' obscure the real holocausts that were taking place. I would invent the airplane. Most awkward of all is the star pianist. a shy boy with tousled hair and wrinkled clothes whose performance is to be the highlight of the evening._~-'--------'--'-~-~~=-=C--~'_'7~-_-----'. "I out in the hot sun on the freeway median. but it had turned out my employers needed me more than I needed them. Nobody has asked the youth what he would like to play-no one has asked him anything of the sort since his mother signed him up for his first lessons: they take it for granted that he knows his responsibilities as frontrun­ ner of a new generation of musicians. now the boy is in the thick of it. I started where I could. It was absurd to think that for so many years I had been less frightened of hurri ­ canes. all ears alert. Mothers fold their hands and smile. For his part. If bombs had to drop somewhere. He would give anything to be on the other side of the next twenty minutes. 199 . The girl ruefully bows to polite applause. Even the instructor looks pleased with himself. He opens the sheet music to the proper page. the fidgeting stu ­ dents count the minutes. and he takes his place on the piano bench. a victory march of sorts. each waiting in terror for his turn to come. what if his fingers knot and stumble? There is a minefield in the middle of the composition. suicide bombers. desperately entreating ? sealed windows and averted eyes. and the campers' parents have gathered at a gala dinner event to see their young prodigies perform. The hush now in the air is not eti ­ quette alone. __ ~~-------. ! . embarrassed in the presence of their families. but I wasn't afraid of disasters anymore-I was practically praying for them. The minefield looms closer and closer.-- ~~-­ --~ Failure. I was finally throwing myself off the cliff. to have this behind him. fathers nod approvingly.' \') I ' It is the final night of junior musicians' camp. Awkward at the threshold of adolescence. Every time I sat down at my desk to hammer out another exercise " in prevarication.i. he wants so desperately to please them that he has not thought to consider the question either.-=-- ~_~~---=_=_==-=---==-=_--. and begins. I'd been waiting all along for them to fire me. Off the Cliff . I wanted \ every ski resort to burn down. a series of difficult chords practically right on top of each other. every stadium to cave in.~. shouldn't it be the bigots and homo ­ i~ phobes who believed it was right for people to languish in cells and closets? Maybe it wasn't sensible or defensible. I might indeed starve to death or get deported. The music that pours forth is elegant and precise. and he can't stop his hands from shaking. What if he misses a note. \ . every gated community to flood-I wanted to see snide executives standing . disgust washed over me in a tidal wave. shouldn't they drop on the ones who ordered bombings? If anyone had to live in prison or in fear. From now on.~~-----~----~--~---------~. and now it is behind him! There remains only the final stretch of the song. The girl before him is playing her violin solo. sailing through like a true maestro. positions his hands above the keys. a real walk in the park. ea­ ger to show off his pupil's rapidly developing abilities-not to mention his own coaching. in my own life: I gave notice at the office. I was fed up with bullying people into the arms of the status quo. ~ t I i ! I I ~ ~"-­ Q-~198.==~ -=l patrolled by militarized police-and not one newspaper had run a:! story about them. . or perish in the crash. 8 ~\ (' . my job. but I would never write another word I didn't wholeheartedly believe. all eyes are on him. His instructor has picked a particularly difficult piece.

There is nothing for it: he goes back. every successive time he tries and fails. he plays it wrong deliberately. the violinist's eyes light up: she understands. This has never happened in this piece before. In shock and disbelief. His face burning. grinning from ear to ear. then inwardly kicks himself for doing so. like a skipping record. ~-- Failure Failure.=--=-~=~:--~=-~~-----=-~~=-- ~ I I . takes up the piece again from the beginning of the phrase. far worse. Once again he backtracks and plays up to the note again­ but this time when he reaches it. r Ii II '! I (. the weight of the expectations of parents and teachers and students and by extension the whole civilization they represent. ~ ~) et ! " \-. even the professional musicians in the audience. A few feet from the stage. It is up to him to save everybody from the impending catastrophe. once more. upon all humanity. freezing as if jolted by electricity. like a fire alarm. but their presence as individuals. He botches the part again-and again. Everything he has built his young life upon-his prospects as a musician. hits the note. The tension is absolutely unendur­ able. free for the first time in his life. his heart goes on beating in his chest. . There is a nervous laugh. mortified at having to witness this fiasco. Just one­ but that's not all: far. a harbinger of utter breakdown. At this moment he would be grateful if a bolt of lightning struck him down. she catches the eyes of another young girl a few tables away-they are shining like hers. to fight his way to the end of the composition and then go home to hide his face forever. he backs up and begins once more-and. to be spared this. outright failure is a contagion they fear worse than death. every mother holds her breath. i ~I G\ 'I " ~ But suddenly. to protect their faith in the investments they have made. She turns and looks back at the anguished faces behind her: it is truly a vision of damned souls in hell. No bolt of lightning strikes. now: all the pressure that bore down upon the boy. playing forward with all the grace and finesse he had been as if nothing has happened-and hits the same wrong note. The two nod to each other. ~ I_~ . I I I I !I I I ~! l . In the total stillness of the ensuing instant. and they are helpless. freezes. is turned upon them.I ! ~~~ -=-~-=--~~~~--~~=~~_~~I - I I . contrary to everything he has been painstakingly taught about concert performance. The audience is none the wiser-they are too overwhelmed. The boy is in total control. blasting through all his deepest fears and values to redefine the meaning of the previous sour notes. paralyzed in a situation for which nothing has prepared them. or any piece he has played in years. his attempts to do what is expected of him-is in shambles. he stops cold. he hits a wrong note. it is as if that failure re­ ~---- ~ I I I !I . ------ C-~ 200 . they would give anything to be elsewhere. He hits the wrong note again. Faced with the unendurable. Every father in the room is on the edge of his seat. . The recalcitrant note sounds again and again. the boy must either perish or change. or he suddenly died of a heart attack. 201 . The dynamic is reversed. Mediocrity they can stomach. .I. he becomes aware of the others in the room-not just the monolithic pressure of their expectations. coughing. I \ fleeted upon all of them. helpless fidgeting.. he breaks off again. inexplicably.~. Peering around the room. They too are uncomfortable-they need him to get through this to rescue both the evening and their pride._-. Every note the boy plays wrong.

Failure / Crash and Burn. the activists were to blame for not organizing with the workers. As far as I was concerned. is proof that you've reached beyond yourself. it to rule over us in disguise. there was nothing to stop us from turning all our frustration on each other. But there are other ways to define failure. however. as everything collapsed. Every nadir we reached. it ' makes everything painfully intense.Sorry. Failure is relative. The one who fails in the course of really try­ ing needn't fear she is failing to live life to the fullest. we have a lot to learn from failure it­ self. Failure Defeat. but unquestioningly receives his standards from others. faced with courage. and foundered from the moment we started choosing abstract battles ourselves. 203 . our resistance had begun when Kate linked her personal struggle for liberation to the more abstract activism of the students. the greatest greatness of all. the experience of giving all. tragic and heartbreaking as it is. it becomes a monstrous enemy and master. I didn't agree. we desperately need such channels. At times. hitching our Failure is disaster on an individual scale. that you are pushing at your own limits and the limits of the world. Sure. the students were to blame for being too privileged to commit to real struggle. Heroic failure is greatness that does not depend on success or approval-not just greatness. Failure 202 . The workers were to blame for only being interested in their own needs. the Greatest of Feats True failure. where our horror of failure enables. it can even become a channel . embraced. Feared. according to the standards by which one judges success: and woe to him who does not judge for himself what is success and what is failure. but the years after the as­ sault on the wall taught us new meanings of the word struggle. such as can be experienced by those trying hard to achieve something worth­ while: in failing to achieve their goals. bringing meaningful and mean­ ingless into sharp focus. In our success-obsessed society. you are not a winner. denied. Some insisted that we weren't self-sacrificing enough. but inalienable greatness. All our collectives and networks broke down in bitter recriminations. it was all true. Suffered consciously. in my version of the story. Here we are speaking of good old-fashioned failure. a new depth opened beneath us. but bickering about it got us nowhere. it becomes a fortifying draft. they achieve something even more valuable. from one destiny to another-and in a civilization which is itself a colossal failure. We'd thought we'd had it tough before. fuckups like me were to blame for scaring people off with our criminal ac­ tivity and violent tactics. a powerful teacher. or stigmatized. Once we no longer thought of ourselves as fighting a winning battle against capitalism. men and white folks and straight people were to blame for alienating our more oppressed allies. that our revolution never got off the ground because we were just fighting for ourselves rather than the truly oppressed. '. and the ones we call failures. I had the distinct sensation of vertigo.

One night the news showed white vigilantes forcing refugees back at gunpoint into a ruined neighborhood awash in toxic chemicals. mostly delinquents like myself. We didn't live together anymore.desire for a radically different life to the cart of service-oriented ac­ tivism was like killing the goose that laid the golden eggs. it expanded to fill every vacuum that opened. prisons were overflowing. The drink­ ing was a real problem. "Which do you think will fail first-capitalism. too. storms generated by industrial pollution were decimating entire cities. I did my grocery distribution for the same reasons I stole food for myself-I wanted everyone to have enough to eat. even the ones I'd met at the encampment. how little work I'd put into it over the years. I'd visit her at the shed she stayed in behind a collective house on the other side of town. As it became clear the world wasn't changing for the better. Failure as Exercise. Most of them returned to what they knew: dropouts went back to school. not the ones who set that destruction in motion. or my liver?" I al­ ready had serious problems maintaining my mental health. ev­ eryone vanished. travelers drifted to more exciting towns. I remember going to see his grandmother to tell her that her son was being held for fifty thousand dollars bail and we couldn't raise half of it. but not drinking distanced me from my remain­ ing companions. isolating ourselves in clandestine cells would guarantee we wouldn't be followed by another generation. and him eating from a deli tray at a book signing while I waited to salvage the scraps. who took it as a comment on their choices that I didn't join in. trying to find somewhere to sleep on the couch. if such a thing is possible. but Diego was not so lucky. the world was falling in around our ears-but regular folks were taking the brunt of it. Nothing feels worse than calling around to friends and then acquaintances after something like that. sad. regardless of the laws or the economy. It was all our side could do to get together some relief efforts alongside the Red Cross. All that was left for my crowd after things died down was petty crime-we still had to survive somehow-and drinking. to see what secrets it holds for us. the employees who had been most active had lost their jobs and gotten hired elsewhere. . All the while.i05 . and we'd argue without saying a word. worked with. Others. backing the racists down with guns of our own. I'd been lucky enough the times I'd been arrested not to be recognized for the more serious things I'd been involved in. The legal aid collective was on its last legs by then. As everything crashed and burned. so I didn't start again. There was no way I was going to take marching orders from some professional activist or union rep who claimed to speak for the people I'd grown up with. waking them up one by one. If you want to subject yourself to a real test of mettle. and they declined to help because the action he was being charged for had been controversial and that mobilization was long over. It was an old. If nothing else remained of the old days. We should have been there in our affinity groups. Maybe their texts would offer astute insights on our failure to mobilize the working class or establish enduring counter-institution~. helping coordinate evacuation on the survivors' terms. but I knew where that would lead-I still remembered what had happened to our friends who had split off to pursue criminal careers back before we were politicized. and fought beside. my relationship with Kate was on the rocks. Crash and Burn Crash and Burn / Failure . Samia was getting a PhD somewhere and Pablo was seeking publishers for his inevitable book. pushed for the remnants of our network to escalate to guerrilla warfare. Commit yourself to a project you know to 204 . there were still bills com­ ing due. On top of everything else. The worst of it was I had to borrow her phone. typical story-the passionate lovers who try and fail to sustain their romance in a world fatal to romance. it was painful to realize how bad my Spanish still was. I swore myself again and again to that old impossible dream: that we'd make a world of magic in which the magic of love. Attempt an impossible task everyone around you considers senseless and stupid-you'll be surprised at what a chal­ lenge it is to exist in exile from the world in which people can make sense of your actions. I imagined her getting tenure for her edgy essays about the actions that sent my friends to prison. Our momentum had been contagious because we were acting openly and others could join in. Success as Obstacle Let's look at failure in a vacuum. Terrorists were blowing up public transpor­ tation. could survive. Struggling to succeed can be demanding. For all I knew. try fail­ ing. deserts were spreading across con­ tinents. but failure is trying like nothing else.

start out small: make a habit of telling jokes that fall so flat people flee your company. even if they'd given me a restaurant of my very own. We know exactly how much poverty. if she has not yet given up. how much joy must be possible too! Whether or not any of that ever came to pass. '<06. or for that matter what your motivations are in the first place? Failure. things can also befall you that are supernaturally awful. '<07 . I reflected on this as I arranged my shoes under my sleeping bag so the cold metal roof wouldn't be too uncomfortable against my knees. announce in a public square that you are a juggler of great expertise and then try to juggle for the very first time before the crowd that gathers. Just as the homeless man who greets the dawn with his will to live intact after walking around all night to keep from freezing to death is tougher than the most high-powered corporate financial officer. the qualities which demand triumph after triumph and nothing else-these are the same qualities that impede the total freedom of action needed to achieve any genuine triumph. It was just psychological compensation. my mother would be treated for her back problems. spelling bee winners. and to repeat this process over and over. Fail once. god damn it. must be prepared to abandon everything they have learned and begin failing again. There is an ominous side to opening yourself up to miracles rarely ac­ knowledged by those who celebrate them. I was hap­ pier freezing to death alone than I would have been as employee of the month. but if so much suffering and misery was pos­ sible. I blinked and tears poured down my temples. all the empty lots as community gardens in full bloom. I'd forgotten there was anything beyond the frontiers of the nightmare around me. even the ones who had gone to prison or become economists or committed suicide. Failing that. That it is so hard for most of us to fail even in meaningless ways reveals how much we covet success for its own sake. an inex­ tinguishable golden lamp. and it feels like the end of the world. but if things can occur that are miraculously good. all the strangers who hurried past me with downcast eyes as neighbors with whom I shared camaraderie and good cheer. The folks from the encampment would be there. and afterwards we'd all line up to wash our own dishes. insecurity. Some of us have spent years. I lay down and looked up past the radio antennas. the world can indeed bestow won­ drous gifts upon you. suffering we can take-we're well versed in these things. whole generations in failure and disappointment. star athletes. humilia­ tion. and the three of us would meet for dinner at a dining hall in the foyer of a converted mansion.be beyond your powers. Diego would walk free in the sunlight again. being able to fail before yourself without shame is harder still. unless one is invested in success. for example. We're not easily intimidated-we have nothing to lose. This seems senseless-failing should not be difficult. we failures are better equipped than any other class to take the risks one must take to work miracles. But a person experienced in misfor­ tune and disappointment is less likely to be unnaturally afraid of failing. and the ringing police sirens that designated that neighborhood occupied territory. The moon hung overhead. When you're totally disenfranchised. anyway. We persist with a patience that is inconceiv­ able to celebrities. your fantasies veer to the extreme opposite your daily experience: so it was that I developed a rich inner life that winter. I could easily imagine all the empty buildings around me as social centers with free childcare and drug treatment programs. self-consciousness. As a success. one cannot accomplish anything-not even failure. we've been getting plenty of practice. cowardice. a last-ditch de­ fense against despair. if they are to evade stagnation. Artists. and you'll learn how much more durable you are than it is. she is stronger and knows both life and herself better than the protagonist of any success story. Once you leave the beaten track and anything is possible. The yellow disc blurred. Fearing to fail. note how hard it is to bear your own hurt pride when things go awry. Even frivolous ex­ ercises like these. even if you knew from the start they were bound to. for the one who needs to think of himself as successful. Too much success makes you weak. Pride. how can you know how you stand up under the ultimate duress of disas­ ter. live through the end of the world a few times. lifetimes. which sound like mere child's play on paper. the spew­ ing smokestacks. Being able to fail fearlessly before others is one of the hardest skills to master. is truly an enemy to be feared. But readiness to fail is a prerequisite for being able to do anything great. I was satisfied that I'd made the right choice staking everything on our fight. In utter deprivation and disappoint­ ment. Failure Failure / Crash and Burn. can be excruciating in practice.

__ In this world turned upside down. the right kind of failure can protect you from the most insidious dan­ ger of all-capital-S Success. whatever the consequences. it only remains for his values and standards to cross that fissure and join him on the other side. All our lives we'd heard that the work­ ing class was composed of failures who hadn't tried hard enough or hadn't gotten enough education or. On the contrary. so he will not be so busy succeeding that his hands are tied when he has the chance to try them at something that really matters.. in retaliation. at best. Even when suffered by one who desires so-called success. he can redefine success and failure for himself. The wrecked black neighborhood I visited on my grocery distribution route was still suffering the aftermath of the Black Panthers' heroic defeat. in retrospect. a sort of cocoon. it can be an antechamber of transformation.Success as Failure. the individual's condition and activity already diverge from the norms set out for him. It is important to know which battles not to win. In failing at an enterprise of ques­ tionable value. it was for the best that Allen Ginsberg didn't make a well adjusted stockbroker. what callings not to excel in... brazenly flaunting bodies the corporate media deemed more obscene than pornography. middle-aged women wore skimpy clothes fashioned for emaciated models. then hacked it in half with a freeway. In the trailer parks I'd played in as a kid. I saw them a' . many of us had willfully chosen not to play the game. drug dealers. some fiascos are triumphs in disguise. likewise. The miserable waitress who is promoted to manager and stays at the restaurant long after she had planned to quit might have been better off getting fired. in which misery masquerades as happiness and truth is simply falsehood with powerful friends. The implication was that everyone would choose to be suc­ cessful and middle class. t'ClIIUI v . and arsonists to ravage it. after all. When this happens. just as the Russian working class could have given themselves a better shot at liberation by losing the revolution of 1917. This kind of failure is a blessing in disguise. some victories are more humiliating than any defeats. if only they had the chance. the forces of white supremacy had arranged for landlords. Fighting a losing battle against the capitalist system gave me a deeper respect for my fellow losers. hadn't been given a fair shot.

Having sought and failed to find happiness according to their prescriptions. must be associated with the worst dregs of so­ ciety and the most unendurable tribulations. pinnacle of status in our society. they are visual cues reminding us that annihilation is the only alternative to wage slavery. for once. Crash and Burn / Failure . the proletariat of failures. even they don't look like that! Once you embrace this failure. well-adjusted working families next door on Channel 11. Enough of being successful failures-let us finally succeed in our failure! Failure . . these may become acceptable­ but in our hierarchical society. who presumably represents the . but no one. failure is the ultimate abomination. A new revolutionary class. drug use. the faster they recede before us. They were heroes too: no homes less person ever produced enough chlorofluorocarbons to damage ozone layer or evicted anyone's grandmother from her home. Hell. As soon as a new class of self-proclaimed failures appears. no matter how much skin cream and lip gloss you apply. The hom. failure to compete is punished by the severest mea­ sures: for if people are to keep on capitulating. Under capitalism. Still worse is that. But this intimida­ tion tactic can only succeed so long as the unemployed cooperate by accepting their misery and the miserable cooperate by accepting em­ ployment. to explore the forbidden territory we already occupy. the jig will be up. but once 1'. it is more ironic still that it is practically impossible to succeed at these projects in the first. you'll be free to excel at becoming something else.211 . there are safeguards in place to discourage us from doing this. Pride would hold us forever in no-win situations. place. Failure as Besistance] It is ironic enough that so many dedicate their lives to succeeding! ~ at projects that fail to fulfill their dreams. we fail without fail. failure itself will always be anathema. non-participation must look utterly undesirable. without airbrushing. most people are not even able to learn from it. swearing I would escape their fates! at all costs. We were all glorious. Faced with the impossible ideals of " beauty and perfection set for us. is a winner. The harder we work to measure up to these standards. 0 Success as Impossibility. Obscenity. All that is needed is for us to come out of the closet. If you're so successful. spent enough time among them I learned that some of them were 0 . Ours is a civilization of losers. visibly finding happiness by rejecting both options and making a joy­ ous catastrophe of their lives. having sincerely given it our best shot. struggling to prove we are "good enough" to make them work somehow. svelte executives in Wall Street Journal commercials than we are like the brainless. whether that be called winning or losing. The shiftless hoboes and migrant workers who'd seen half the world without ever looking at a travel brochursj the minimum-wage employees who never wanted to be anyone's boSSi~ the workers at the cash registers with cameras pointed at them from!: all sides-they were no less worthy than the big-name anarchists who' had beaten back imperial armies and escaped maximum security pris­ ons only to die of tuberculosis and alcoholism. the streets by choice-as I was myself. to come to terms with what we are and begin to fail at these roles deliberately. now I saw them as comrades who refused to disgrace them-' selves for worthless prizes. we all have something at stake in making it possible to live differently. This is not even tragedy-it's just foolishness.heroes in the struggle against patriarchal beauty norms. not the two-dimensional caricature of success and sex appeal that saturates the airwaves. The homeless and chroni­ cally unemployed playas fundamental a role in our economy as bosses and bureaucrats do: they teach us to equate life off the treadmill with alcoholism and mental illness. were they able to own up to the hard truth that they are no more like the satisfied.210. This is an open secret. why millionaires read books about how to be more efficient. could count even members of the ruling class in its ranks. Once I'd despised these people. We're good enough to deserve to be happy. she too turns on the television and feels her heart drop at seeing that flawless goddess cavorting through a digital paradise. insisting we are happy and everything is going according to plan. . she is worse off than the rest of us: for not only is she not Madonna. Of course. it only remained to us to triumph at long last. but she is also nothing else besides. sexual and religious heresy. In this civilization. Face it-you're never going to look like the models in the maga­ zines. failures. living in fearful denial of this failure. less were supposed to be the ultimate examples of failure. the open secret of our era: no one. has in common with all of us that she is not actually Madonna. At the end of the day.lines on her face and doubt in her gut. In fact. That's why models are more insecure about their bodies than we are about ours. what's with the antidepressants? Even a superstar like Madonna.

.

She heard me out pa":~ tiently. "Don't say anything. ' " "Thank you for telling me all this. It's a vic­ tory any of us are even alive. her had disappeared into retirement. Crash and Burn . What Diego said was true. with a lightness in her bearing that contrasted sharply with:: my condemned man's s l o u c h . after some of the things we've been through. "You're still here. it was interesting that she was stilt:. Whether or not she felt she had anything to.~ stay and I got swept up in the next thing I heard about out of town." unconstructive b u l l h e a d e d n e s s . a planet of six billion people working around the clock to push what they Want out of reach! It must require that much work-what most of us want is not really all that difficult or complex. my eyes were back on the leaves. look at it this way: to fail.~~ Who knows if I would have stuck around." Now I was silent." "Maybe staying wouldn't have been the right thing for you-I '~ feel like we've totally failed here." "You shouldn't say you've failed. As failure is the most feared of misfortunes. ." I shrugged. to prevent their dreams from coming true. thinking about this stuff." again just before that meeting. to desire it with all your heart-to believe that life will be unlivable if it doesn't come true. 215 214. too. rooting yourself in one place instead of following the battle lines:". is possible. then real failure. Just know I've been. Everyone has things they want that badly. then looked away. I respect a lot that you're.~ arrogant in the years we'd known each other. involved in things. and her eyes flashed with a light I hadn't seen' in a long time.! ." to wherever it seems we have a chance of winning.1 really-we basically went off and abandoned you. overbearing.: just gave me the excuse I wanted." She was silent for a minute.J. You've failed: that's a real achievement. She shifted her legs and went on. and 1" understand how I contributed to it not working out. they're so scared of not getting it. It's so intimidating to commit to .'. You know that. I wanted it all to end differently. from that moment on they are in­ vested in that being the truth-otherwise they are fools who have thrown away their lives for nothing. "The ironic thing is I'd come back determined to get involved'. At the same time.. then we are free of this terrible re­ sponsibility: many people find it easier to endure the idea that ev­ erything they want is impossible than to face down the terror of being responsible for attaining it." I met her eyes for the first time since I'd started " I talking. whether or not she was still invested in revolutionary~ struggle. II some sparks alive. I guess. Imagine that. she hadn't gone back! to graduate school after all. really-maybe that fight ." "The only victory I give a damn about is making sure everyone has what they need-that and burning those prisons to the ground. what they call impossible desires-they just don't pursue them because it would hurt too much if they never caught up to them. This is my home.:. I had nothing to lose by taking responsibility for my own. my eyes fixed on the leaves in front of our park benchj. My period of exile had given m~~ new powers of humility: I was going to apologize for the way o~ last meeting had gone. but after that it was hard to want to . I can't be running around Europe while people here go hungry and my friends rot in prison.~. I think most people don't even acknowledge what they really want to themselves.~i apologize for. let alone free to sit here talking. . Her skin was rough and already a rich' brown in early March. subcon­ sciously.. if the realization of such dreams is impossible.When Samia reappeared that spring.:. At least you seem to have kept'. I sought her out and askei! her to set some time aside to talk." She was looking at me intently now. They may even work. you have to be totally committed to something.)' still here keeping the same projects going. It takes a Disaster of billions to hold us back! C rash and Burn / Failure. : ' . On the other hand. oi. I went over every time I felt I'd been insensitive. to prevent the things they long for from becoming possible. "You know. I really don't know what to:" say." Certain Failure Imposed by Fear of Failure If a person's dearest dreams can come true. And once they decide that what they really want is impossible. being respon­ sible for pursuing and perhaps failing to achieve precious dreams is everyone's ultimate terror. maybe I'd been wrong assuming everyone like. It turned out she'd just returned from working in the very neigh~t! borhood I'd seen on television the previous fall. I felt a pang of envy that grew bitter as I recalled ourJ first meetings. IJ \ Grimly. "I have too much here to leave." "OK.

while the people they were supposed to be helping were crammed into trailers or staying with their families in other cities!" "Yeah. We take out their fucking garbage right now! They're just afraid of having to get their hands dirty. We were all there as volunteers while they were there on salary.'." "Honestly. they-" "I remember all that. but you said yourself"-I slowed down and tried to speak more softly." Crash and Burn. Not all of us have the option of limiting ourselves to legal means! I'm so fed up with white activists saying militant tactics are only for young white males when people like me are clearly involved as well. tinued meandering from topic to topic.Dusk was falling and it was getting chilly. I felt dumb. either. when we were doing things around here. for example. 217 216. I couldn't fucki ' believe it when I heard they'd resolved over all objections to d. "You know we did try to work with everyone else. not just the kids in black. the way Kate would have-"you didn't show up ready to do that. They think this system works great because they never have to get close to their own trash-while some of us have to live next to it. Once those leeches figured out how much momentum we had. But if we'd done the work-" "Of course. we'd already been through so much just to get to that point. all the old has-beens came out of retirement to try to hijack everything. bage when you talk about an anarchist society. o' a hundred representatives from different groups-mostly NG people like that. I wa4 spouting off. We were exhausted. to accepting that everything they wanted was impossible. "The ironic thing is those are thee same motherfuckers that want to know who would collect the gar. sure. or off it!" Samia cut back in. since our folks hadn't made it to town yet or WI busy with other things. they all latched onto us. as middle class organizers who don't want to lose their legitimacy. we always went straight to people in a bunch of dif­ ferent communities. There was something still I needed to say about it. Finally. I know there were security issues." We both paused.' from the wall." "Those fucking authoritarians!" Thinking about the spokescoun-j cil m'ade me furious all over again. and they kept trying to give us or­ ders! Half their work went into getting donations from people who really wanted to help-but those donations paid for advertisements on the backs of fucking pizza boxes all around the country. would they have to say out loud that they think I'm mistaken about what's best for me?" "They might as well be honest and admit direct action is alienat­ ing to them. "We had to deal with those people this past winter-we didn't have our own media team. Talk about paternalism-my existence is so inconvenient for them they won't even acknowledge me! If they did. They set up front groups and coalitions camouflaged to look just like us so they could absorb everyone who wanted to get involved. "The real question is why so many people who say they want what we want back out when it counts. I was used to other people already having put thi " together before I showed up. and I w • angrier about how you'd handled yourselves-it was closer to h~me~ because I'd trusted you more than I'd ever trusted those liberals. so they were able to take credit for everything we did. All the people who joined the spokescouncil and went along with it even when it turned against them-they were used to defeat. I've seen those pizza boxes." "It's ironic that those people criticize direct action on the grounds that only privileged white people can participate. Every party was there recruiting at every meeting." "We got outmaneuvered. and then when people of color take direct action they write it off as apolitical criminal activity-calling it looting. I guess. What a scam-our tragedies pay their salaries. nounce direct action and organize a march to lead people awa. It's like you were saying before about failure-I think we only failed because no one could imagine us winning. but our conversation c . don't y' There was a big spokescouncil meeting before you got there. we returned to meeting. just like we didn't know how to stop fighting even when we were the only ones on the battlefield. they didn't know how to do anything else. Crash and Burn . make decisions that would work for everyone. but we could have organized openly with others and privately among ourselves. I was washing the dishes in the convergen~ center-Diego was there for us. I only found out about the spokescoua cil afterwards." "But look-why didn't we just bypass the spokescouncil and reach out to people directly? Before. and anyway I trusted that they". I had no idea at the time-I'd just gotten there. withdrawing into private recollections. but by then the die was cast.

Beyond Success and Failure Here's an exercise. not the future or past. I think they do that because they don't want to win. because they're invested in failing. :1."Like the black uniform all the new kids wear. not consequences. but it also can reveal just how arbitrary most of our deep-seated values are.. liberation is not a question of succeeding or failing. for the impetuous freedom fighter: fail at the duties you are most afraid to. to emancipate ourselves from the former. Crash and Burn / Failure Failure. That is to say: around courage. an admission that the most we can do is refuse to participate and be destroyed. not stasis. so long as their hands are clean. not fear. Such a practice sharpens and strengthens. That's the opposite of really trying and failing-it's a farce. So long as they keep their roles as conscientious objectors.<: I :1." I and thus even success-one must be able to give oneself entirely to the doing. What doesn't kill you can only make you stronger. tragedy. but of moving beyond such binary ways of thinking. To be free of internal as well as external pressures to achieve." "And all the groups that say they want radical changes but al­ ways try to stop anyone who tries to make them. . as if they're at a funeral-it's practically a glorification of failure. Setting out to fail-not by attempting too little. to be able to do and live anything and appreciate it for what it is. whether it be the mor­ tification of not being able to explain to your parents what you're doing with your life or the utter heartbreak of giving everything to follow a dream only to see it burn to ashes. Around the present. Ulti­ mately. The mystique of victory gives rise to the fiction of defeat. they don't care if people have to sleep on rooftops and rainforests are turned into pulp and cities are bombed into dust. they don't care what happens to the rest of us. but by attempting so much that one can only fail gloriously-could be a way to re-center one's life around action. so one succeeds in not succeeding. this is one of the ways we come to know each other and ourselves. itself. neither fearing the future nor judging by its standards.18. to cease to judge oneself by one-dimensional yardsticks of value or success. so for them it's never i: the right time to act. then. Around destruction and creation. there's always more preparation to be done. not a . They don't dare risk what they have. and struggle with all your heart to succeed at the challenges you never dared undertake. To be capable of anything-even failure. without imposing systems of evaluation-wouldn't that be a triumph sweeter than any victory? Perhaps our fear of failure is a symptom of our inability to release ourselves to the present. Our pathological fear of failure exists only by virtue of our superstitions about success. To fail and overcome that failure is to grow. we must forgive ourselves enough to stop pining for the latter.19 .

ildhood. . now I had new troubles to deal with..I. though ~yown childhood had never included recitals or summer camps or " . '. then nodded. in such / a harmless way? .. Samia was recounting a story from her . At the same time. huddled together for armth in the cold night air.ything like them. just because it was so chilly and we'd fi­ nally talked out a conflict that had stood between us for years-by t'. But inching . or disappointment. So much for sorting out the consequences of my old mistakes.. and the last ·thing I needed was complications with someone else. that couldn't be a problem. just for a minute. itself. I felt giddy. 'anted desperately to make things work with Kate.gain without all the tension and resentment that had become so '~ommon-it was a relief. It felt good." She seized my hand between hers and looked right into my eyes. To be able to speak with someone about these things . 221 . crime to want to feel good again for once. so we can't be afraid to desire or believe in outrageous things. or regret.1 had the sinking feeling that my giddiness was a warning sign: I .o hours later. we were still on the bench. I could picture everything she described vividly. " . l I Crash and Burn. a kind of absolution. "Would you like to kiss me?" I swallowed hard and hesitated. could it really be a .'a little closer as we spoke. We have to give ourselves to them without fear of loss.

and fulfillment were again genuinely imaginable possibilities. gut if not your head. Unable to imagine that love and If the two-party relationship system is the pinnacle achievement of a hundred thousand years of human loving. . your ". intimacy is governed by scarcity. When relationships become work. Suddenly you feel transformed. and programmed prohibi­ ( tions. There it is again.. is organized contractually with accounts kept and fidelity extract­ . husbands chained to the machinery of responsible reproduction ­ . it's as if surprise. Wage labor. friends or lovers enable each other to be able to do and live and feel more. Adultery Adultery . that having a romantic partner means giving something up-your "freedom. awakened from the graveyard of once-vital passion that your part ­ : nership has become to feel that excitement again. Adultery. in stark contrast to the Good Marriage. could possibly de­ . and yet it's the first time you've been "i'carried away by pure. If you feel. the sweet optimism of something new. when desire .':and oh. Who. why is adultery so com­ mon that it forms the most reliable material for bourgeois draw­ ing room humor-not to mention employment for a whole army of marriage counselors? If all any of us truly desire is our one true love.Adultery (and other half revolutions) Good Marriages Take Work Growing up in an environment dominated by capitalist economics teaches certain psychological lessons that are hard to unlearn: Any­ thing of value is only available in limited supplies. pleasure could multiply when shared. risk.: ed like labor from employees. Stake your claim now. if ':they could feel what you're feeling right now. . and protected ideologically by assurances that there are no I . We all know that Good Marriages Take Work. before you're left alone with nothing. then it should come as no surprise that some individuals cannot . as the statistics suggest. damn it. ~~3 .IIland you resist? ~~~ . in your . help but revolt. An outsider might counter that in a healthy relationship. . threats. something that isn't 'yet fucking predictable . viable alternatives. unforced happiness in who knows how long ­ . you should cut straight to the source and ask the adulterers themselves. arriving without even being invited.'! are you ever not on the clock? Do you accept stifling limitations in I~ return for affection and reassurance the same way you trade time for money at your job? When you have to work at monogamy. you are :' back in the exchange system: just like the capitalist economy. we come to measure commit­ ment and affection by how much others sacrifice for us. when marriage is a domestic factory '. Or maybe you don't have to go that far-maybe you've had adulterous affairs or inclinations of your own." as they say-then the patterns of exploitation and control have penetrated even into your love life.: policed by rigid shop-floor discipline designed to keep wives and '. relationship labor­ . gratification. You shouldn't be ~feeling any of this. comes naturally..' work: the cornerstone of our society.~. why can't we keep our hands off everyone else? If you really want to know.

instead of cheating you could always have gone to counsel­ stayed faithful to your spouse rather than yourself and turned 'wayfrom the new landscapes you saw about to be born in the eyes . 224 ' Adultery Adultery zz . his employer. despite the best intentions and most secretive schemes the adulterer. it is only safe in . . . despite his best efforts to restrain "Honesty is the Best Policy" Society. . people get hurt. and more serious intimidation tactics: the threat of total expulsion from the only home and community she likely knows. by battered wives and sexually harassed secretaries.your potential lover. but extends before and after it..:. demands that the adulterer be honest and frank about all things when it will only punish her for this. unarmed with the twin weapons of :"justification and self-abasement.Tocut to the heart of the matter: can it possibly be wrong to '~ire not to be emotionally dead? What vast measures of self-con­ nee and entitlement would it take the modern married man or ~man to risk feeling alive. a stan­ d which has already been violated in spirit if not in letter? Of urse. or else to the subject of your 55-examination finding ways to lie to herself as well as to you. Just like the vandal. to stay the course in mutual ennui to embittered end? Could it be preferable for your unsuspecting ner to go on measuring her value as a lover and spouse accord­ to a standard of fidelity that boils down to self-denial.. guidelines which plainly no longer have anything to do with his emotional and physical needs? The adulterer becomes a virtuoso of petty theft. you must make it easy for people to tell it • you: you must be genuinely supportive and ready for whatever it . 'p nust tell me. as well: how many places are there for him to spend time with his new lover. Would ':have been better for the routines and illusions of the marriage to '.e sheltering ears of her illicit lover. Iybe. ither our society nor.-recriminations? The adulterer discovers that he is trapped in life he had adopted under the encouragement and threats of the .Stolen Moments The adulterer gets a crash course in the extent to which his space and time is controlled. consuming practically his entire life. symbolic acts of daily sedition. The domi­ nation of the space around him is revealed. It immediately becomes clear how little time he possesseswhen he is not underobservation-it turns out that the workday does not end when he leaves the workplace. ain undisturbed forever. personified by her unfortunate spouse.). It attempts to secure her compliance through routine interrogations ("who was that on the phone. respectable explanations. '. if that failed. trying instead to achieve a passable substi­ :ewith your officially sanctioned partner-or resorted to dulling ur senses with television or Prozac.. More to the point.". you did WHAT?!. out of which he carefully constructs an infinitely fragile alternate universe. sur­ veillance ("do you think I didn't notice how much time you spent talking to him?"). search and seizure ("and just what the hell am I supposed to think this is?"). What our society is missing here is the wisdom to know that tell­ the truth is not just the responsibility of the teller. If you really . multiply by your fear of the unknown.t can only lead to evasive action. There he hides. consequently.blished romantic norm-and. in spirit when he can­ not in body. i ... only invisibly. the excuses and apologies and . places he need not rent with money. then think twice about whether you really needto say anything after all.t to know the truth. and the image of social propriety? In what few moments of his life is he not held to guide­ lines imposed by outside forces. This is the same formula used by exploited migrant workers and children locked in private school hells.. he resists the domination of his world in the only way he knows how-by tiny. dear?.. its cuckolds are ready for the 'elation of truth that the adulterer has to offer.). eople Will Get Hurt" itably. in the enforced happily-ever-after of mestic silence-or else such drastic measures would not have !:~n necessary in the first place to bring dead hearts to life. people already re hurting. hoping not to be found out and called to account for what he has become: a traitor to the entire civilization that raised him.his family and social obligations. stealing the mo­ ments of his life one by one from their rightful owners: his spouse. not just make self-righteous demands or play good coplbad . I promise I'll understand . The adulterer who would like to tell the truth is forced to compute whether she really can permit herself this luxury: divideyour currentunhappiness by the harmful consequences of admitting it.

. t's why anything less than complete prostration to the status o is considered bad ethics-standing up for yourself is just too dangerous for everyone else. terrified that their own strayings might come out next.uch freedom and fulfillment does he deserve to feel? How has it me to be that he hurts others just by expressing his own needs? The fact is. 'hat about them? Do you think you can protect the next generation m the tragic tension between the complexity of desire and the sim­ icity of social prohibitions just by knuckling under yourself? If you other your own aspirations for happiness. But he lacks the courage and analysis . displacing them instead to future generations.r this final act: that is why he is an adulterer. which ese self-appointed judges would protect from the assault implied Adultery.self. people always get hurt whenever someone contests e long-entrenched order. to things that can hurt others. regardless of i~ consequences. but he does everything to avoid appling with the reality of it.pon himself. often unwillingly but without being able to resist. the alternative becomes unthinkable: so the adulterer takes it . Would you prefer that they learn to beat their own ·:»ngings into flattened reminders of shame and remorse. he would finally be positioned to step out of the circle of hurt that is e scarcity economy of love." . The problem is that he generally does this without admitting it himself. has begun plotting an escape. as you do? And it's worth pointing out that nuclear-family monogamy. his situation is untenable. 227 . Were he to reflect lucidly on situation. hat about the Children?" at about the children?" demand the shocked sentries of the bour­ isie when they hear about yet another marriage endangered by an air. and often the victims are "innocent. Yourchildren would be better off growing up in a world 'here people dare to be honest about what they want. you will end by smothering your children as Uas yourself. But once the itch to mutiny takes Id. Well. If he were prepared to embrace and -oclaim his outlawed desires (rather than ultimately rejecting them a fit of rueful revisionism: "I didn't know what 1was doing!") and cept full responsibility for the further pain that would cause. his secret self might rebel and begin to ask the impor­ t questions: What kind of life does he really aspire to live? How .

Communities would be interlinked by networks of close relationships I' in which everyone could count on assistance from and intimacy with . can it serve as a stepping-stone towards a new resurgence of that community? 'h .'\ by adultery..same kind of relationship you just escaped.son at a time. When he got involved lWith you. sitate that communication be prized above obedience to social norms. is the very thing that replaced the broader.I. and their parents had i! more freedom as well. \.legal rewards for any particular relationship format. tended community we once had? More importantly.if one day you cheat again.:The conditions that foster honesty-trust. Faithful to Many ( What would it look like to have relationships in which there was no : such thing as adultery. right? Small wonder . Iit would demand maturity in the same way monogamy monoculture rewards childishness-including the childishness of adulterers. or at least no cause for it? First. By all accounts. he knew you were capable of loving more than one per­ '. it would neces­ .~ lunge from the cage of the contractual relationship towards the ex­ . that monogamy imposed impossible choices upon Iyou-and now he wants to return you to the situation you were in J 'when he took up with you. more fluid.for your partner in crime. self-awareness. And here the ultimate irony awaits: even if you leave your spouse . i or try something else? . and no looking askance at any format either. you will probably find that he expects the . or else you wouldn't have gotten yourself into this predica­ ':ment. The question now is how you get yourself out of it: do you ~continue on the path that compelled you to cheat in the first place. But it's different with him because he's "the" one. with the same pressures and perils. We would have to grapple with our own . There would be no social or . were better cared for in those environments. I extended family structures of the past. unconditional !:love-would have to be safeguarded by extensive support structures. desperate . 229 . Of course. children i. In short.insecurities rather than attempting to limit others' autonomy. Adultery. Could it be that adultery is a blind. others even if one relationship changed. we don't live in a society that equips us in any of these (ways.

Once the false promises of two-in-a-coffin matrimonial bliss have utterly failed you. and-yes-making love with anyone who also wanted to make love with you without it bringing about the end of the world as you know it. can you? Adultery is Marriage's Loyal Opposition Ultimately. with all unions suitable licensed and policed. the fewer the ties connecting individuals and the narrower the range of permissible associations. when you feel passionately con­ nected with and accountable to an entire community. still dictating her actions-be those actions obedient or reac­ tive. Marriage exalts the bond between two people with the-unspoken implication that it is them against the world-and the stress of this setup often turns them against each other. not just a flash of isolated passion and insur­ gency to be stomped out before it illuminates anything. You can't. the better. When you're attached to and responsible for only a handful of people. adultery is only possible because it leaves the questions it asks unanswered. the hooligan. too. you're more likely to conceive of your interests in collective terms-and better situated to fight for them. She would do better to expose what she is and wants to the whole world without guilt or regret and demand that it find a place for her and her desires. Then her struggle could be the starting point for a revolution in human relationships from which everyone might benefit. your enemies always have potential hostages: "But I can't run any risks-who would take care of Sheila?" On the other hand. A divided people is a conquerable people. the adulterer makes only half a revolution: she violates the decrees of authoritarian convention and law. we're all married. But like it or not. but in such a way that they remain in place. whatever they might be. Just like the shoplifter. and it's high time we start thinking and acting accordingly. and the suicide. Adultery . letting each relationship evolve independently of other relationships. is it any more utopian to fantasize about conceiving of your relationships as One Big Union? Imagine being close and comfortable with every­ one around you. 230.Marriage and Other Affairs of State It serves the interests of the powers that be to have everyone sepa­ rated into couples and nuclear families. we all have to live on this planet together and bear the consequences of each others' actions: effectively.

wreckage. I I ! because there are sides to this truth that are inexpressible. because I don't know how to communicate this truth to you. and neither are you. I lie to you because I won't accept despair.I I ~ ~ . Should I tell it in the words by which I would apprehend it myself. as well as the truth. of course. invisible to outside eyes. because words lie in my mouth-in any mouth. because I am a coward. Such treasures are crushed beneath the weight of words. to preserve something. and these have become precious to me.~ c c. - . anything. more desperately. t (."_c•. dis­ honesty. I shoulder this crime. . in this impersonal.-_­__ . I delay. Words cannot express anything that matters- -so the alternative is silence. im­ poverishing world. as a defender of humanity and all things beautiful . dust. that night. I lie to you because I cannot accept the truth-at least not this truth. because I am an optimist: I hope to catch the truth by some miracle or voodoo in my web of lies. because I fear you. but I will not raze my secret cities to rubbish heaps and shame for you. des­ perately. c c cc __ 'Ii l~ \( oj I . 233 I) 2]2 . and you've made that absolutely clear..­ __ . I am not prepared to confront it. ~c ---­ ~-_::_--'===-~ Adultery. _ . wishing each night as I fall asleep that I will somehow awaken in another world. of my own. I steel myself against reality so I might come through another day without ac­ knowledging it-and try my luck once more.. Adultery . Each morning I do not. even if you will interpret them to designate something entirely different? Or should I tell with words I hope will make you feel the way I believe you would feel if I could somehow convey it to you word­ lessly and without distortion? Which is honesty? Which is lie? __ . I love you. =/ _. Or is it because a hidden demon in me delights in trouble? because this truth would destroy us all. become mere scandal.

is always wider and wilder than anything that could fit our pre­ scriptions. Let's be wide and wild enough ourselves to receive it with open arms. There are no honest memoirs unob­ .n the subject. even in the cases of the ones we hold most dear. we withhold in sorrow as well as fear-for there is no sweeter bliss than offering yourself hon ­ estly to companions who can comprehend and celebrate what you are. ~~---- -~ l " Long before I fell in with the barbarians.".~ . Secrets are sweet-but sharing them. 234 . ":w hen that well ran dry. ager. (!) .t War with God and Country than engage with the consequences d implications of their own secret trysts. Yet there are probably more adulterers in North erica than vegetarians! People will sooner admit to being criminals . Chloe and I betrayed each other and moved . We tell you exactly those truths you make it possible for us to tell.about my needs when the people "in power" were my own partners. but it didn't equip me to be honest . Adultery Betrayers and Betrayed. Millions in every generation have to come to terms with their . expense of being able to be honest with those in power. footage through police checkpoints.-. no useful family advice is passed down .I :' ~~ . ured by bravado or shame. 1 thing I know about clandestine activity. strive to be a person with whom no one need be ashamed of anything. ~. Reality. This served me well in high school when I was sneaking out the window to meet Linda and much later when I had to think on my feet in front of a grand jury. Smuggling secret passions under my parents' radar and then my own lovers' noses prepared me for researching targets without leaving a trail and sneaking video . If I learned anything as a teen­ .. I'd already learned every­ ..=5. 'I I It is absurd to demand unconditional honesty from others and place the entire responsibility for this upon their shoul­ ders. the phone book lists no harm reduction programs "or serial cheaters.ion to repeat the same cycle with others.propensity for unfaithfulness on their own because no one dares :~peak openly about the issue. with whom nothing is forbid ­ den. What we withhold. sweeter. If you would know the truth.=c. it was that the sweetest moments of bliss always came at the ._.11:1· . (My marriage ended in a sordid mess after I fell in love with Chloe.. 235 .

however. I could scarcely believe they'd been doing this . To be fair. there was a lot to talk about: what our . once you reach a certain age you become invisible. cting yet another chilly rebuff. as most of them had changed s over the ensuing years. 237 . it was even harder believe that. for years before that. at long last. I'd broken off my last affair around the time I canceled that business trip. By the time I joined in. driving to all the stores and washing the produce we ~nected and sometimes accompanying Marshall on his rounds. dumpsters. With local activity at a standstill. That was how I started seeing Marshall again. At first our exchanges were (uperficial. ~. but Ie seemed to be avoiding her the way I had started avoiding my wife 236. When it comes to romance. I felt like damaged goods. by that time I was old enough that it felt like I'd never be in a relationship again. far and above any window-smashing. I experienced my lovers' expectations of me as a constraint. That might explain why I responded so uncharacteristically to Kate's warmth. his brow more furrowed than ever. pster for a trash compactor and we had to rework our whole 'ute. but it was a guide for radical journalists. how much current technology and production ould remain in a post-revolutionary world. charging down a street together-in my eyes. why I went to such lengths to involve myself in a movement that ostensibly had no place for people of my class and career. and certainly not with one of those crazy young people. why the move­ ent had died down. What I missed most. it took us a long time to open up ~. Once we did. I'd never really gotten know him before. I could only imagine what it must be like for women of my generation-but I was separated from them. all of us invisible to one another. not the eyewit­ ness chronicle of insurrection and depravity I'd originally imagined catapulting me to corporate fame. I had some money in savings. I wasn't exposed to polyamory until after the university occupation. In the end. we to switch back to raiding the dumpsters until we found a new ide connection. Even our sparsest hauls. if painstakingly civil. Each time one quit or was caught. enough to put off exploring the job market spent it sparingly.e of the community projects I'd always been too busy to inves­ te. Now that I'd quit my post at the paper. joining the legions of single men mari­ nating in bitterness as the world goes on without them. It ap­ axed she and Marshall were still involved. at least I didn't have to worry about breaking any more hearts. but Marshall still went through their ~hborhoodsevery week with a trunk full of bread and vegetables. I loved the fellowship of eating together. too. within a few weeks. Even people like my former coworkers must long for that kind of companionship. and apartment com­ 'llexes. ~ I was surprised by his response. I was working on a book. Their college years in fraternities and sororities are the closest they ever get and they reminisce about that ridiculous simulation of community for the rest of their lives. Finally.hand. He seemed at pains to make me . scheming together. I approached him and offered services. . "it It. One thing that surprised me was how little I saw Kate. at least off and on. besides that.All along. If this was what it felt like to be a middle-aged man. but more tolerant and mature. a disease carrier who could only hurt people by getting close to them. though. every once in a while a store would exchange its . welcome and appreciated. I couldn't imagine any other way. I spent a lot of time alone. were enough to feed doz­ of households. Marshall had kept his gro­ ! distribution program running with whatever volunteers were . all that food had rotted while nilies spent their last dollars on ramen noodles. Of course. I accepted the isolation of middle age with a mixture of mel­ ancholy and relief. Marshall 'en apologized for his previous haughtiness. but over and over I participated in setting up the same expectations. Betrayers and Betrayed Betrayers and Betrayed. it turned out. I busied myself doing independent media work and rereading Tolstoy and Melville.r years without the authorities catching on. Union organizers had lost track of the workers who had '~n involved in the campus strike. Between back doors. He '~uck me as sadder now. that togetherness was the really revo­ lutionary aspect of the thing. I barely saw anyone at all except at the occasional meeting. even at the lowest ebb. kitchens. was not romance or sexbut rather the intimacy of sharing a private world with someone.we began making conversation.each other. utual friends from the occupation were doing. it occurred to me to get involved in "--. he'd gone through several generations of ployees inside the stores.It took decades to acknowledge to myself that I was the one in power doing harm to those I loved and not the other way 'around. Lonely as I felt. I was a regular icipant.

she greeted him with an embrace that was hardly platonic and he twisted away. the guns 238. you've got to talk to her. Samia. is not difficult for rulers to justify their l'0wer: they need only . of all people! I was surprised the two were even speaking after the last time I'd seen them interact.when I didn't want to be defined by our relationship but wasn't ready to break it off. and I have no right to pry. haven't you?" He didn't answer. clearly uncomfortable about being affection­ ate in front of me. I couldn't have been worse situated to bring this up. One night I got a hint of what was going on when Marshall had me drop him off at a collective house where Samia was staying." I began the next time we were alone in the car together. Had the world betrayed us all so much that we could only betray each other? "Marshall. Betrayers and Betrayed Abomination. "but does Kate know about you and Samia? You have been seeing her. "This isn't my business. ate and abuse their victims long enough that no one can imag­ the latter being responsible for themselves. it is necessary to subdue the savages rifles. My own history of infidelity was playing back inside my head on a permanent loop. his eyes were fixed on the glove compartment. 239 . but I felt I had a responsibility to. I'd initially hoped that seeing more of Marshall would mean interacting with her more as well." Abomination . For the first few erations of colonization. I glanced over at him. I still had the highest regard for Kate. once the brutes have learned to fear and obey.

the most faithful and courageouS end by betraying each other. or else. but every time an individual or a people steps out of line. over conflicts generated by their colonization). it is because govern­ ment has systematically disabled us. her to take up arms against them. In the end. questions wheth­ er she even deserves to achieve her dreams. beaten." Democracy is the silence in the village after the massacre. the signing of the peace treaty renouncing independence.can be kept out of sight. Force people to live in concentration camps: they will become suicide bombers. Abomination Abomination. a filthy malcontent jealous of others' success. fulfilling every stereotype and judgment of her enemies. If it seems we are not fit to govern ourselves. however much they distance themselves from it. The monsters produced by our society indicate the monstrous imbalances of power that characterize it. I The abomination is the ultimate product of a society that re­ presses difference: the stuttering cretin behind the defendant's bench. the embargoes are reinstated and the guns come back out. at best. isolated. The downtrodden can scarcely feel themselves worthy of a liberation struggle: they are so messed up. you can call for even stricter limitations on the next generation. and everyone will understand why the camps are necessary. The generous are left paupers. Every government that holds power today is descended in a di­ rect line from this brutality. Otherwise. 241 . atrocity begets atrocity. the misfit fit only to wear a straitjacket. Punish children for their blind impulses towards free­ dom: when they become drug addicts. so erratic and easily confused. a solitary figure scattering flowers on the road of pain he walks. the dreamer loses faith in herself. nothing remains afterward but its antithesis. the imaginative and optimistic are driven to despair. Starved. let alone articulate the heavenly visions that guided . and mediation between tribes that would otherwise be slaughter­ ing each other (with weapons sold by the colonizers. the indefensible and irredeemable. humiliated. the powers that be maintain this veneer of peace. scornful clergymen twice her age. the conquerors can parade themselves before the world as humani­ tarians: they provide jobs for the poor (hiring them to till the very lands they once held in common). until finally the conquered are integrated into the social order as willing beggars and employees. theycan be allowed to eat at the same lunch counters as the victors-presum­ ing they can afford it-and even run for congress. medicines for the sick (derived from the natural environment that has been seized from them). dead ones can be put on postage stamps the way hunters hang trophies on their walls. Shackled and delirious. with the same hypocrisy a developer names a new subdivi­ sion "Shady Acres. not the necessity of those imbalances-but they provide exhibit A for its apologists. That which is pronounced evil becomes evil. Once the savages are resigned to the new order. while the powerful are eminently evenhanded and informed. The revolutionary must be a bloodthirsty ideologue. who knows who else might join in? 240. a rebel cannot help but turn on him­ self. Insofar as it is possible. surrounded by ". Crippled and disgraced. Everywhere a flower blooms in defiance of the prevailing order. Joan of Arc can hardly compose her thoughts.

-. inaugurating a new table of values: The first shall be the last.~~Y. a devil..n J ~ (ff/ 1J{f{) ~ J1'U1 I. vv -&M-. l..l. "4 d.. .. These allegations are brandished as weapons on the premise that no one could survive them.t1ti ~ ~ ~ ~ t r~ if Aarl-d. J~ tl1wAili~ jtttUM we M.do 11ra:t ~fn'"e.AIfh LVJ'l'! tvtn ~ MM!f ~ ~ ~ IlMJ'a»fi fJV . devils.1h~ l.~ ~-f.O'J ~(u#/I !(UYfd/tA. It is unthinkable. AMIIIN'-'J. a cheat. a beast. Against all counsel. ~ wr J t/A1<f ~t1v rlfi-~' ~ 1'~1tf1Ut$ktM #'fYl /J/J J sec ~~rJ eh? tJJ Ut.w.~~ . to '~'k-t1U-e. •.. to ~ ai« fr.W. itH ."..r1M)l. and the last shall be the first.. H()fNlW/ ~ ~ we. v(.rl.1M -tv t.e.j1M .fi dtnfJ w~ 1b itWl bU /.evp.aW. ~ IfJVl l1ut~fS yWf "'a VI ~ '?.QJ~ CfA4~ j Cain accepts the judgment that has been pronounced upon him. Cain steps irrevocably beyond their world. ~ U.~·lj ~ ~. J In fu1 to 5fa1 ~!j~ ~J 1lJ 1 W ~ I. .abJuf 'Nf. we. Abomination . h~ 1hin!!. 't4Mt.i {)U+.. he survives.k. his worth by his worthlessness.. ~~ ~/f f. By this inversion.f1JfrU..~ ~ /.VI7 ~ 1).~ .J : ~. ~..k !Jar L/cJl). J. what all say he is: a thief. cheats.. His accusers cannot imagine being branded thieves. and thus knows his triumph by his defeat.1LtlJ ~ lI~ith apu- . ~ = J. e f. ~ •. Embracing them..O aA ~ ~tvetl1~-to.u l-7~V"~} we ~ [.Uu. UIe-'/t>t rnIIA I /I ~~ ~ M-4..­ I rMhrd. Shame is the only distinction between above and below: he does away with this distinction. . 243 242 ..~ J~ d4e . I. but reverses the values upon which it is predicated.Jib IA. his riches by his poverty.fIti... M i:t ~j. ~. ~'''iU.u. tlJe1"'M~1k ~ wi nid 1tJ ftLI. '.---~'rc t4 .Mrut..oWl CtJH~} W J ~t t!!!-Iv ~J1M1 tuvt~·j M­ h~ 10 lU'i-/c '.u.. he chooses to assume responsibility for what he is.. r ~~ ~~jt'~~~' ~ tbUZd--- 1 k Consequences..nas.~ {{lOfho/" pJ)... .1 h sfill. ~ Jf.eI J h~ ~ YfMf/. in defiance of all.r el. 6'A 1tu. 0 'V. wt.-~}e4ftwr. .jVL~f ~ ~ ["tvt/ o!({it.t. ~a.tMl r~ o (JI. for what others have made him-to become.iLV cg{. beasts. 4{ ~~ ttMfU(­ :~ lAm I<IIUJW ~ crfl.~ f!MLvl to ~a.:e lAMP 'r' t>lUoftr".1D 'do::. flf (POkf .

How I'd love to love and not feel that I do it out of habit or duty. working out how to be sure I would succeed and where to leave my body. Just surviving. how I want to suffer truly at these tragedies. hoW I long for some new passion or sensation to seize me and make itself my master! Staying alive is reformist: you keep trying the same basic approach. Suicide. fractured coalitions when it counted most. in evidence against myself. During the worst of it. I blamed myself for everything: I'd driven my friends away. one of Pablo's kind. reclaimed neighborhoods from police in pitched warfare-after all that. so disappointed. of course. fluorescent lights humming overhead.MarshThis won't be easy to read. Remember you're at war. I wasn't about to re­ turn to the dish room. every half hour I had to sit down. but that didn't stop him: he was a real investigative reporter. but I wasn't interested in adding fifty more bad years to twenty-five good ones. solve it. I spent a disproportionate part of every day thinking through the details. it was hardly an efficient use of time. 244. and talk myself through: 01<. focus on making it from one breath to the next. And there was no reason to believe I'd ever get a second chance. not diluted and staged as it is. I couldn't tell him anything anyway. People like you aren't supposed to survive-you're supposed to kill your­ self and save them the trouble. Even apart from the question of whether or not I should kill myself. you're at the bottom of the pit now. and instead I getsOIlle gringo in a starched shirt. anything! I'm supposed to give a fucking statement of purpose when my head seethes with all the fluctuating statements of the past. Just surviving is fighting in that war. It wasn't that I didn't love life-on the contrary. You have to get through this for all the ones who never lived to tell their stories. but I wish I'd said something like this: I would like to rebel much more than I actually do. Reform and Revolution . with increasing derision. They didn't let him take in paper or pen. He wanted me to explain ~the movement. I assumed it was my grandmother. practiced way I do! For all my talk of being my own master. ruined my relationship with Kate. If you want to solve a problem. on the other hand-guar­ anteed results. When you spend all but an hour of each day in solitary confinement. I would go through anything to experience those things again. The pigs never tell me who's out there when they come to get me for visiting hourS. earnestly auditioning to be news anchor for the revolution. that it was unbearable to be living such a ridiculous farce instead. I could barely focus on anything else. I'd experienced moments of incredible joy. hoping for a different outcome. I was polite. Yesterday that reporter I told you about came here. not in the empty. The world was crashing in around our ears and I wasn't getting any younger. I was so angry with myself. at least of what it could be. I had such a high opinion of it. i t isn't easy to write. fallen passionately in love. I couldn't stop thinking about suicide." when all I want is fOr someone to explain something. I would like my hatred to be pure and clean again. which I'm constantly presenting. a credit to his profession.

Build a paradise for mei I'll still revolt. aqainst whom I could smash my heart like a boat on a reef in pursuit of that impossible immersion for which lovers hunger as moths do for names. Not that I will ever have the chance again. the more you pledqe yourself to ali thai is noble. I would rather sit here in a concrete tomb than playact in some travesty of togetherness. the devil in me will.a~d barrios and cornfields. behind penitentiary walls and border patrols. evil part of me that is possessive of my faults. I'll still end up in prison with the illeqals who can't even speak your precious Enqlish. that can never reveal itself. I feel all.the good.strike away your outstretched arms. toaxpose his wretched humanity in so compellinq a portrait that you would be made to see the absoluteness of his needs as you see the absoluteness of your own.. Offer me the blondest hair." I permit myself a furtive sneer. I would like to tell the story of the most antisocial. invisible. the cleane13taccent. the more you need me. nocturnal.. there is a proud. because I don't want to hide from myself in the safety of your numbers. my stupidity. When you hold out the future as a happy answer to all our prayers. indefensible man. wrapped up in the turmoils of my own qloomy spirit. Keep me in kitchens . and you'd have to find a way to wash the world of shame once and for all or else perish . citizenship fo. glorying in inflicting i t upon myself . a fiend within me wishes thiS misery to stretch on forever. I'll brinq heaven down around my ears: for every house is a set of walls. and I only feel utterly myself in the act of transqression. thank God. As soon as I've finished my plea for acceptance. moving indifferently through a distant world. When you exalt the courageous and . Then all his unforgivable sins would be on your conscience. that· can only betray itself by tryinq. But there are things in me that escape description and prescription. more I am part of you. to qive voice to his untold treasures and torments. I cherish my passivity. When you say "community.r all lilY .. too. And then when I try to submerge myself in crowds or isolation. and you must acknowledge them. sailinq on its borrowed winqs.It would be convenient for you if I would lock myself in ideas the way my enemies have locked me in a cell. too painfully how little of myself can fit that mold. I am the uqly secret. the forbidden part that must remain silent. When you celebrate romance with ribbons and ceremony. When you speak of action. . permissible. I want to be alone in danger and the agony of solitude. and I want to be faithful to that part. as I cannot get my hands on anyone' else. suddenly I lonq for a single companion with whom to nee. and intelligible. which I know and love. my cowardice. or else all your talk about better worlds and people will be worthless. rather than split myself in pieces. the more you try to· bury me. the . too.relatives.

.

.

.

.

like an actress or a fed up housewife? Opening your arteries with a razor. religion. I YI I # 4 \ :\ . heroine. with health insur­ ance to make sure you don't miss out on a single hour? Or are you ready to get it all over with. prostitutes. action movies. Despair Despair Despair. carcinogenic sugar substitutes and cell phones? Do you want certainty. a gun to your temple? Or do you play the lottery-driving on the freeway. installment by installment with cigarettes and saturated fat and air pollution. Or maybe it's not death you're after. I . consummate the affair with one defi­ ant gesture. radiation. in a spatter of brains and bone on the concrete at the foot of the high-rise where you work? Or in increments. . fight your way to the top to get a fair price for your life? Or are you buying it? Do you purchase it in single servings. buy­ ing yourself a taste whenever you can with alcohol. But what else is there} 256. cocaine. 257 . high blood pressure. pay­ ing taxes to a government that might send you to war or the police to your door with guns in their hands? Perhaps you're getting paid for it-how much are you worth per hour? Do you wash dishes for minimum wage. stretching it out as far as you can? A moderate dose every day for the rest of your life. video games. after all. toxins in the water. absolute negation of everything you've ever wanted. give and receive orders for a manager's salary.How do you want to die? Hanging from a rafter with the stool kicked to the floor beneath you? From an overdose of sleeping pills. flaunting your disdain for the absurd tragedies of this world as you go down in a hail of bullets? • 1 \: :1 :i . everything that has disappointed you? Do you savor every drop. . flinging yourself into the abyss of some addiction. having unprotected sex. in a hot bath so you won't shake so much when the warmth leaves your body? All at once. television. whatever it takes to go blank for an instant? Do you sometimes long to cut right to the inevitable.

it is the most isolating act bar none. Who is more dispossessed than them? They are only recognized when they absent themselves. to encourage them to speak "freely about their feelings and do our best to make a world no one :~ will wish to leave. of course-their lives are fixed in eternity. The ones who shoot or hang .themselves are daring heretics. They know better than anyone else what must change about this world. . an unspeakable abomination. If no "one could steal. Wholesale suicide is off-limits.relationship with it. Despair . whatever anyone else says. seem strange to them that it had felt so much easier to do violence '. as if the living could legislate for those crossing over into death! What does it say of a civilization that it not only forbids its denizens to kill themselves but does not even permit the question of whether life is worth living? Yet we commit a little suicide every moment we deny ourselves the lives we wish to live. they're determined to have a firsthand . like theft. Suicide. The suicidal class-every minute. It's too late. : ."I wish all the people who've killed themselves were still alive-and all the people who are alive would kill themselves!" If there is a social stratum below the exploited underclass.• " ~. perhaps they would regret that. like the upstart mystics who claim flO receive divine guidance that bypasses the Pope: if self-destruc­ 'tion is the order of the day. destroying themselves. whittling their lives away hour by hour. "Those who dig their own graves make only half a revolution. returns an instant of autonomy to an individual. rather than . is perfectly acceptable so long as it occurs on the terms of the powers that be. that is. 'yet all the tensions that run through our society today remained­ ~picture the massive upheavals that would ensue! If all who have killed themselves could compare notes at some -grand convention center in the hereafter. what would they be able to tell us? Perhaps they would be capable of succoring one another . set apart :like flies trapped in amber. Self-satisfied den mothers who have never grappled with debilitating depression feel entitled to sneer at the cowardice of those who make the difficult decision to end their lives. But there is still time to find those who are currently contemplating suicide. his conduct is coura­ geous and praiseworthy. . and yet in despair of ever changing it they avenge themselves upon the only victims in easy reach-giving a new meaning to the saying that those who make half a revolution dig their own graves. In rejecting both .to themselves than to respond to the violence done to them. more hit the pavement. suicide f is isolating-indeed. if no one could cheat. . adultery. but not of your own. they are only one step away from rejecting death and domination altogether: Neither death nor taxes! But again. you can die in their hands. they dare not back out. if a young man joins the military and mindlessly obeys orders that lead to his senseless death. and other pressure valves. • • . perhaps it would . they didn't launch a revolutionary organiza­ :. suicide is forbidden. it can only pre­ vent people from establishing collective ownership of their lives. No matter how unfulfilling life is.living death and the sovereignty of the authorities over their lives. Imagine a person feeling that his life is out of his control to such an extent that he can only regain possession of it by murder­ ing himself! Can a society really be free and healthy if people will go to such lengths to escape? So like theft and adultery. like Disaster. While it ". which He has deputized in His absence.where no one else could. but most settle willingly enough for death on the installment plan. or else Public Opinion. a demo­ graphic that suffers most from the absurdities of our society. only their blood speaks on their behalf. if no one could end his life. it is the suicides. .tion comprised of those who have nothing to lose. Meanwhile. 258. for God is waiting on the other side to punish them for shirking their earthly duties-God. Even the terminally ill are not to choose for themselves when and how they pass away-there are laws against it.

but to live. Frontiers to be crossed. to the suicide. all your . no mere mental exercise can change your mind. looking the ugliness of life in the face-of. then. There is no reason to get up in the morning. not enough time f or tat. The risk of finally confronting fear. All the old battles you're still fighting. Your average suicidal person can barely vacuum his apart­ · But imagine if people lived as though they might die at any rno­ · ment. It may be awful. All this is useless. the worst that could happen is al­ ready assured. Despair Despair. just as every employee is freer than every boss: we can quit. 261 . in the face of nonexistence. Despair.them die. No boss. Once you're that exhausted and demoralized. it may be salvation. of the realization of your most cherished desires. Imagine being able to act without fear of the repercussions. to choose the unknown over the intolerably fa­ .: less mercy to discard sentimentality and remember all the things · that never happened and still might never happen. all the dreams that never came true-to acknowledge that we can't wait forever. become cancerous and inorganic. 260. the pos­ sibility of joy. have courage through the silent moments in the void as :you wait. a sentence. It takes a ruth­ . at every moment life can become a tabula rasa. abysses to be risked-yes. it may be nothing­ ness. all the addictions and inertia you've -accumulated and all the fears that bind you to them. For most of our contemporaries. who has already disconnected from life and wills death simply to finalize the ar­ rangement. ti h · ii C' Let the past go. It's our only hope. quitting the job of existing. if we have the cour­ age for it. and not news. It willbe. no law. One can savor this idea in every extremity. suicide bombers. trembling. .Consider the Alternative If we were brave or reckless enough for it. let alone carry out an elaborate mission. This occurs to everyone at least once. With such freedom. one way or another. Nothing obligates us to live-therefore. must act from a tremendous investment in this world to be capable of going to such lengths to die at others' ~ ment.. our despair could afford us supernatural powers. So there is no reason not to open oneself to. We have an option that makes us freer than the gods. Slavery is for those who still believe that their masters control the domain of death as well as life-not for us. enjoying oneself. the weightlessness of every moment. We can choose not to live. This is going to be the hardest thing you ever live through-but let them go. expense. to withdraw from unhealthy obligations and relationships · the moment you recognize them for what they are. in life as well as death. a life of joy. there's t. new worlds to explore.'denial and defense mechanisms. After all. riding us to early graves.miliar. a desperate struggle to juggle a thousand obligations-including the saddest imperative of all. These unfortunates forget the lightness of life. to put an end to the inconvenience of feeling one thing and living another. daring the unknown. life itself is a job. a space in which anything is possible and everything can be risked. For us. and risk. risk too."Put me out of my misery or take me out of it!" Life is not simply a trap. so every day it was as if they were born again! Imagine if no · one let life become a job for himself or anyone else in the first place! · Then how many people would kill themselves? People commit suicide ·when it is harder for them to picture breaking off their commitments than ceasing to exist-here again are our customs and investments. There is always the option of putting an end to things-one may as well play for high stakes if one chooses to exist. let . but it is unknowable. there is only the unknown. it provides consolation when nothing else can. for your new life to be born. ·Life . no god can take from you the possibility of say­ ing No. con­ trary to idle speculation. to risk everything for. we can only be slaves if we choose to be. every situa­ tion.

When your friends misunderstand your works and your enemies understand them all too well. Despair . Remember what they did to Michelangelo. Write your own epitaph and shout it aloud. This life is a war we are not yet winning for our daughters' children. waiting until he was buried to paint over all his masterpieces-just as the racist : sister Nietzsche hated presented him to the world as a champion of her own cause after he lost his sanity-just as Paul used Jesus. only well-ad­ vertised. Give your enemies nothing. when the razor blade or the cliff's edge beckons. and Plato used Socrates. don't do your enemies' work for them-finish your own. Let your tears freeze to stones we can hurl from catapults. 262 . If you're fighting. and the Communists used Durruti. remember-death is not pretty. you've already won. The dead cannot defend themselves. when waking up every morning feels like a defeat rather than a triumph.

albeit a routine of resistance. We'd developed our own rituals to commemorate the ghosts of in­ surrections past-and slowly. . even if they return as dedicated revolutionaries-and all the orse for us to be burdened with revolutionaries who no longer be­ ieve in miracles! You have to be a real romantic. come to mistake those formalities for liberation itself. Looking back. This longing suffused everything with meaning. not coincidentally. when we would put into practice at last all those abstractions about transforming everything. surrounded by beautiful foreigners. we too had found ways to bide time and lose ourselves in routine. I'd been wrong to leave it up to others. We'd found ways of surviving. famished for something tangible to live on. a point of rupture. but it also made everything bearable-when we'd once felt.64. who prided our­ selves on our intransigence. in fact. Perhaps once upon a time I'd been waiting it out in good faith for the revolution. It is the threshold over which !. is itself a .as something ongoing. disrupting some staid wedding or school assembly. we'd still put off coming to terms with our own bodies and desires. still experienced resistance as a shaking off of reality. it was impossible to picture anything beyond them. If no pivotal moment of transforrna­ •. iracle: and proof that we can. but I was no longer convinced it was coming. All those declarations of war and fables about insurrection-perhaps they were just stuff and nonsense: such ideas spring from the psy­ chological needs of those who trade in them at least as much as from any insight into what is desirable or possible. it was a failure of imagination. who thought of these injus­ tices as inescapable forces of nature. risk. That some of us yet persist from one day to the next. the way I had when I'd first gone to campus in search of the encampment. after all: we. believing miracles in a world that denies all magic and mystery. 't alone expect everyone else to join you there. Meanwhile. a maniac who trusts fairy tales more than reality. when we would finally live life like it really was ending one minute at a time. The closest they got to liberation was admiring the stars during a blackout. as I'd been lucky enough to. it was up to me to bring about the things I idesired in the present. for lack of a better word-and. somehow. sharing re­ sources after a tornado. Perhaps one had to awaken.65 . a fantasy future-the social revolu­ tion. But that-believing the unbelievable-is what it takes for our dreams to come true. is trhat makes such dreams possible at all. I'd been telling myself this for years without following through. Calling for mass actions in the name of total liberation. . a system shock.2. now I see it . with each other-at least as much as we actually wished for or expected one. decrying patriarchal propaganda.. it seems we needed to be in unreciprocated love with some apoca­ lyptic event-:-just as many of us were. who had lived through moments when it seemed the old order was crumbling and had pledged ourselves to defend and extend them or die trying. If they stopped there. . under different constellations. Believing in Miracles Believing in Miracles . Sooner or later they return from across that :rontier. to remain long beyond that horizon.people pass into believing in miracles. and still continued to insist.Despite all our proclamations to the contrary.2. to be ready to invest in revelry. But there were not enough foreign lands to accommodate everyone: we had to conjure them here. I no longer think of revolution as a goal in the future. defacing diet billboards. find them~elves capable of changing things that d seemed immutable. that it was all unbearable. not of character: however sweet those moments were. and revolt as a way of life. Every time I came to this conclusion. we'd still feared to confess our private trials and tribulations to each other. on domestic soil. tion was forthcoming. do anything. revolution had re­ mained a mere concept for us. the personal revolution. I couldn't help anyone else make their big break with reality if I didn't tbelieve it was possible myself.'In that state of grace. those who had lived their whole lives under the burdens of work and rent and gender. it turned out it was too hard : to conjure and too easy to flee.

It's bullshit. I hadn't seen much of her since the march to the wall. I couldn't help myself. the strike-" "Sure. falling into platitudes. willing to answer for my actions and do what I could to earn back her trust. and initiate another campaign like the one that had begun with the occupation. open a social center like the ones I'd seen overseas." "One word-credit! But I've also got a job on campus. With increasing enthusiasm. I'm just admitting that. Throughout the conversation that followed. but at least we were talking. their names were on the list by the intercom: Rita McKean. but I know you'll agree only a fundamental change in the economic system could make a real difference. and with it her com­ mitment to struggle. After we'd stopped seeing each other regularly." Sherry nodded vigorously. an alibi for put­ ting off coming to grips with things?" "But what about all the people who can't work in offices?" That wasn't what I meant at all. I feared the worst-people often forgive their partners' misdeeds while blaming their partners' partners-but she made an effort to be approachable. maybe years. Rita had been among those who had started preparing for industrial collapse. She buzzed me in and met me at her door. sure. who had just moved back to town. learning to identify edible wild plants and prepare animal hides. "Do you really think any of the things we did helped them?" "Well. Sherry joined her on the couch. Hadn't Pablo done good things while working for a corporate newspaper? Rita led me into the sitting room and pointed me to a love seat. The last time we'd spent time to­ gether she was living out in the country. but it beats poverty! Turns out all that NGO stuff was good for my resume. is totally out of our hands. There was no time to lose.The first step was to set things right with myoId friends and find out who still had fight left in them. I found out she was living with Sherry. I didn't expect things to be the same between us for months. I'm not interested in anything like that right now. Believing in Miracles Believing in Miracles. You can imagine my disbelief when I found a giant condominium at the address she'd given me. hear me out! Don't tell me you like being back in an office!" "Being in an office is dreadful. Sure enough. "All that activism stuff-don't you think it's just a way of making yourself unhappy. "How do you afford this place? It's so fancy. Next I looked up Rita. another friend from that era. Once we'd caught up a bit. first of all." "You don't think it matters what we do?" Breathlessly. I started to make my pitch. with a mixture of sheepishness and pride. she'd made a dramatic shift from mainstream environmental activism to a kind of doomsday survivalism. We spoke for a long time. "Wait." I was incredulous. but I was finally ready to take responsibility for making them happen. I really had myself in a dead end.. making coffee next to a brand-new chrome refrigerator. B2. Then I imagined we'd recon­ vene the troops. but honestly it's a lot easier to get on with my life without taking on more than I can handle. "Sarni. but I didn't let it put me off. 267 . the two of them referred to this loss as 266. A big change like that . She didn't let me get far. I double-checked the crumpled slip of paper in my pocket and looked around back just in case before lock­ ing my bicycle to the metal fencing. Rita spelled it out for me: she had lost her idealism. Sherry Lechleidner. either-everybody said there was another war on the horizon. I was flustered." This was unexpected. I went to Kate the way Marshall had come to me. I'd wanted those things all along. Sherry was in the kitchen behind her.

the world might end.169 168. I wanted to say. banging my ankle against the pedal of my bicycle every few steps. perhaps even to a higher plane of consciousness. So I felt abandoned. "So you're finally all grown up. just as I had: but for her. huh? Don't worry-I hear the first time's not so great. I tried to get to the bottom of my anger. pumping pollutants into the sky with the rest of them. you'll even start to like it!" "To like-what?" they answered. The polar ice caps might melt. She was right back where she'd started-right back where both of us had started.though it represented an important transition to a new stage of life. in my imagination. Rita had been a good friend. "GETTING FUCKED!" Storming down the street. Believing in Miracles . you'll get used to it-and in time. one of the few I'd kept up with since my secretary days. I had to bite my tongue. this meant there was no reason to do anything except the things she had to do to be like everyone else of her class. in short. that was one aspect of it. When they moved on to complaining about having to fill out income tax forms again. Have you made your peace with war? Did they bribe you to betray Your scorn for bribery and betrayal? Would you seek accommodation With the ones who broke your heart And trade the bitterness of struggle For the sour grapes of defeat? Hope . No wonder I took it so personally. where I would be myself if I weren't so impractical. like teenagers confessing they had lost their virginity. but she would meet her fate with central heating and air conditioning. anyway! But sooner or later. Rita had given up on waiting for the big changes she wanted to see. You who no longer dance in the street Who have given up on winning But not yet on giving in. She and I had gone through the same evolution after that infamous City Council meeting. They spoke about it.

conceptualized differ­ ently. hope can enable us to do this. supernatural faith may indeed be better suited to the task than mundane pragmatism. In setting out to transform the world. but simply that the revolutionary project takes place outside the domain of calcu­ lation and common sense. we can begin to formulate another conception of hope. and one's own choices influence the outcome in un­ foreseeable ways. A revolu­ tionary aspires to have a tight grasp on reality without the converse being true. The paradise we deserve doesn't wait Hope. why measure the value of any undertaking by its conse­ quences alone? If a revolutionary effort does not succeed in imme­ diately transfiguring the cosmos. It is not a conse­ quence of good fortune. As anyone who has broken through a police line knows. Evaluating our activities that way is naive if anything is. not the product. for a few minutes or years. In acknowledging the influence of our choices. but a strength exercised in the present. but a precondition for it: not a conjecture about the future. there's no sense privileging the future over the present and reject­ ing everything that exists in favor of things that do not. Even if it were possible to see into the future from an armchair. The point is always what is happening: the process. reducing it to a question of whether there are grounds to believe something is true of the future. 271 .Hope as a Martial Art tinope ~ Hope is a magic power that grants further powers. or even intelligence. when it really counts morale is more important than organization. This is not to say we should study self-delusion. it wouldn't be as fulfilling as consciously playing a role in determining it. Besides. the means. one never has access to all the necessary information. speculating from a static position rather than proposing a hypoth­ esis and conducting an experiment! It is never possible to answer such questions accurately. at that. They are poor scientists. we are attempting the impossible. even if it does not guarantee the results. not some overriding end-that. Those who insist that there is no hope are thinking like scien­ tists: they look at hope as a measurable quantity outside themselves. preparation.. some­ thing beautiful is happening. that doesn't mean it was a waste of time.

or else we are. A wild idea gripped me then: in another world. I wasn't even prepared to protect the fragile connection I'd made with her. I certainly wasn't equipped to establish bonds with all those miserable people. I settled myself at a small table by the window and waited for her to join me with her cappuccino. Which side are you on-the future. the musical!" 272. The first night we spent together. But unyoked from our addiction to assurances and our expectation to be paid for everything.in a future that mayor may not arrive. then the real question is why people willfully disable themselves by embracing resignation and defeatism." she ventured. but equally notorious for inspiring incredible voyages. and act accordingly. he has to start from the premise-no. If he really wants to learn whether the things he de­ sires are impossible. and the impact of the latest tech­ " nology on literature. I mean. If this is so. Can you imagine somebody writing Les Miserables ". A preoc­ cupation with life "after the revolution" can be as debilitating as the news constantly broadcast from Capitol Hill to distract us from what we can do where we are. not t. "Everyone reads and writes in little thought­ " less bursts now. Chloe's specialty was to be critical without . Hope Explosions. " The fireball explosion of our affair cast all the relationships before it as mere shadows. as it turned out. offering solutions. In that moment all my solipsism fell away and I was able to feel another person's consciousness as a palpable presence: another human be­ ing was there with me. I didn't feel anything like that optimism again until a decade later I found myself racing away from a smashed storefront with a crowd of masked hoodlums. The cafe was practically empty that afternoon. but Chloe skipped the formalities with her patented nonchalance: "So what have you " been doing with yourself. We hadn't seen each other in years. She looked at me quizzically. By the time we arrive at our goals they are often unrecognizable. a life story as intricate as my own behind her. with new messages in the inbox every five minutes and publishers : demanding something that sells in airports? The novel. we were still awake at nine in the morning gazing into each other's eyes." I admitted. it is comprised of these mo­ ments. The cynic is not coming to terms with the hard facts of reality. practiced instead as the art of making self-fulfilling prophecies-as a martial art-hope offers us tremendous power. "And what does it mean to be a revolutionary?" "I don't know. or the present? Utopia is notoriously unreachable as a destination. the market for commercial writing. "It's an act of faith. whenever they occur. but imposing them upon himself. from the deep-seated conviction-that they are possible. might it be possible to look out across the rooftops and be that grate­ ful for everyone's existence? That reverie lasted as long as it took me to walk to the metro that morning. We compared notes on our respective writing endeavors. looking back at me. 273 ." "Like being a writer. stranger?" " I explained that I had become a revolutionary.

" We both paused.. let's go out and look" From the pavement. It's a crazy idea. "Tell the truth. Nowadays we're in a different kind of war"-Chloe scowled. maybe you just need to change your audience." She'd restrained herself as long as she could. As a means of actually overthrow­ ing the government and liberating prisoners. you can hardly talk about changing the world without being autocratic. I'm fine. preserving a space without prisoners or governments. deafen­ ingly close. we could see a black cloud of smoke filling the sky behind the buildings ahead. Just because you deserved better-because everyone deserves better. how­ ever limited. With billions of people on the planet.. "Yeah?" 1 couldn't bring myself to let that pass. why? Oh my god." She saw my expression and stopped." "We can talk about that another time. A fire truck passed us. "Wow. I've already forgiven you for all that. Explosions Explosions. though. our efforts had been as ineffectual as the Colditz glider. "There's not going to be a revolution. if you prefer. But the prison population in this country is up to several million. But that's not to say we can't expand it. you know what they say about human nature. "OK. then?" "For one thing. "Not for the sake of the relationship we had. I'm glad one of us is doing something crazy. You can expect-" "-resistance. But that's the scale you see on the world news­ it's like looking at life through the wrong end of the telescope. This isn't a safe time to be . but if you reverse perspective." "Well. anyway." Through the window behind her. I'm going in on a building with a bunch of people in their twenties. lights flashing. The same goes for you." 1 finished. "Here. I'm moving out of my apartment. followed by an ambulance." Chloe finally fished out her cell phone in exasperation.'" "But tell me-what do revolutionaries do these days?" She was trying to keep things light..275 . I'll walk you to your car. 1 mean. Hello? Yeah. I'll call you back" "What's going on?" "There's something happening downtown. on the other hand. starting from yourself-" Another line of police cars passed.. "I wanted to see you to talk about what happened between us. what are you doing yourself." "Don't you think it's a little late for that?" A helicopter roared into view overhead. I'm sorry. Distractedly. "What do you think about what they say about it?" "Come on! Do you really think people can get along without those things? Today. get in touch with me. "Sorry­ hold on. 1 feel like the whole world's going to hell. OK?" "OK." 274. Heaven knows what's going on. not in this country. anyway. 1 know. then released it. she hated anything that struck her as hyperbole-"and no one reads actual books except copyeditors and people serving long prison terms. 1 tried to formulate an epigram to convey this. 1 ." "Chloe-" 1 caught her arm without thinking." We stood beside each other in silence. 1 don't know. Of course everything you can do seems pathetically small on the stage of history." "We can talk about it another time. You can't be serious."Orwell said that reading skyrocketed among the British during the Second World War-all those soldiers in the trenches and fami­ lies waiting in bomb shelters with nothing to do but read."Just be careful with your­ self.." She was getting into her car. link up with others . "Pablo.." "Oh. "Do you still storm prisons and over­ throw governments?" That was a tricky question. "Don't think it's going to be easy." She turned to me inside the parking garage. 1 wish you could persuade me about human nature. look at things at a different level. really. she tried to change the subject. She didn't flinch. "Maybe right now we're more like the monks of the Middle Ages. "I bet 1 could persuade you-or at least talk your ear off about it. 1 don't think about it anymore. but the distant wail of police sirens broke my concen­ tration. in this world. to say all the things 1 should have said before. "If you need anything.. 1could see a line of police cars racing across the intersection a block away. 1 mean. too. 1 know!" She paused again. 1 should go. Are you serious? OK. as a means of escape-of finding our way to another life in a totally occupied zone-we weren't doing badly." "OK. Chloe's cell phone was vibrat­ ing in her purse.. "Oh. 1 will." She looked at me then with a tenderness 1 hadn't seen in a de­ cade. but .

any time the boss has his back turned-just preparing food. Explosions History as We Live It . playing or work­ ing on projects cooperatively. Before we look at those books. obey. 277 . of picnics? And yet aren't these. the trivia of the lives of "great men."I'm sure you could. books of laws and philosophical rationalizing. a much greater part of human history than anything in the history books? Today we are in the belly of a hierarchical leviathan. !." I'd borrowed her friend's copy of The Annotated Hunt­ ing of the Snark at a dinner party back when 1 was still married. Just be good to yourself-" "Sure. She laughed. which natu­ i rally tells the stories of other hierarchical empires as the history of the human race: contests for economic and political power. then rolled down the window. It's gonna be seri­ ous shit when all those beanstalks start to sprout. which his­ tory do they mean? Time and space are both so vast that one could not hope to begin to record either in full: any record is inevitably selective. human beings were-and are. but the kind of centralized power and social control we see today is only a few thousand years old-and only became globalized in the last few hundred. the programmed always point us to their history books to show that all human beings ever do is fight. I've got a whole silo of them saved up. "Yeah. proportionately speaking. today. our species has been around for hun­ dreds of thousands of years." History as We Live It Whenever the question of human nature comes up. The times when slavemasters seized power and coerced masses of people have been exceptions-though . 276. most of the time. "Are you in the habit of trading things you borrow for magic beans?" ." "-and reassure Rachel than 1haven't traded her book for three magic beans. daydreaming. "Anything else?" "I don't think so. command." She backed the car out. let's look a little closer at history itself: when they say history. Could one write a history of children's games." But most of human history has not been spent at the Battle of Hastings or the crossing of the Rubicon. to its discredit. Remember. Western civilization has seen a disproportionate number of these. of kisses. flirting.

commanding. then? Aren't they the heritage of our species. "Today things are more the way they are than ever before. When we want to prove an­ other world is possible. but centralized power and warfare as we. as the bare remains must be interpreted to be read at all. not what they are looking at. only a small part of human interactions actually express that violence and subser­ vience. only a small minority of human communities have been as bellicose and coercive as this one-and even today. The human race has been around for over a million years. representative of our "nature" if anything is? We Are Continuously Giving Birth to Our Ancestors The war to define the past is indeed a war to claim the soul of hu­ manity. fighting. Fine then! We'll do the same! So let's not argue that things were better once. who discount the oral traditions and folklore common to all human communities. let alone before then-or today. we instinctively fight them for these-but we have to be careful not to win a Pyrrhic victory by reconstruct­ ing a past that outshines any possible present or future. Thus we Can see that. Let's speak of proportions again. these records are the only ones taken seriously by historians. it is because the first peoples to catch the disease of so-called civili­ zation were the first to conquer and keep tally. new ones brandish Nature and History. the chief activity of any people looking at the past is always projection-historians tend to see what they are looking for.If some of the earliest historical records are of wars and conquests. and obeying comprise perhaps one percent of human history. It couldn't hurt to remember that. kissing. Old demagogues brandished the Will of God at us. Don't fall for it! History as We Live It .*The past behind us * The politicians say. Unbelievably. What about games. :179 . but that they were different-and that they are still different. and picnics. People always cast behind themselves whatever past they need to believe that what they want is possible." and the newscasters agree with them. but we can tell by the very rarity of such records that they are not representative of what all human beings were doing in those days. on every level. Over those ten millennia. know them have existed for less than ten thousand.

at their pleasure. situate everything precious over some ultimate horizon. to boot-they could scarcely leave their campsites without experiencing an adventure of some kind. as they weren't constantly struggling to catch up to the progress of their civilization. After all. They were used to in­ venting their tools and solutions. When they died. this did not spoil my pleasure. if any. heavily policed district was my own domain." • My first summer back I stayed up later and later. then a few friends.for them. foragers' labor was more satisfying than most modern work is. for us. it is that your predecessors did the same. but increased it: now I had a people with whom to share my secret world! So late at night. when there were no more cars. "Tool-using primitive peoples were actually more accustomed to exercising their intelligence than we are.81 . We have bosses-they had companions. or. birds strut­ ted on streets cars would monopolize two hours later." No Future in Nostalgia "In addition to shorter and moreflexible hours and the more reliable safety net afforded by food sharing. History as We Live It History as We Live It. and a Greek poet (Hesiod. a famine. Our commute is dead time." "In that Golden Age. too-it was a fairyland. at most. they were more practiced in the arts of enjoying life. Life. their hearts free from all sorrow. breathing the fresh air of the country. quietly looked after their works. it was as if they simply fell asleep.' Compose your own stories about what your ancestors did-they're probably true-and use them to kindle the courage you need to live the stories you want. After months of enjoying this solitude. without troubling to explain how we are even able to conceive of that perfection without examples of it on hand. a professional sociolo­ gist. and a source of retinue for insurance companies. extending before and behind us through eternity. Those who declare that freedom existed before civilization and vanished with its arrival have more in common than they might care to admit with those who insist that freedom.they moved about freely.80. why let dead people have all the fun? Why celebrate only the foragers of prehis­ tory when people are foraging in the suburbs at this very moment? There's no sense glorifying the past at the expense of the possibili­ ties of the present unless you're trying to get yourself off the hook by making your situation out to be hopeless. 2. but a famine nobler and more sensible than our greatest sufferings and achievements here in the condominium and the cubicle.is so vast it must hold more difference than we can imagine. Here we find an amateur anthropologist. If any­ thing is certain. in the midst of good things. Joy. is chiefly a cause of anxiety. impossible today.for the most part. 2. waits ahead for us around the bend of some millenarian revolution. theirs combined handwork and brainwork in a wide range of activities. great multitudes of Atlantises with currencies and cosmologies unimag­ inable from this vantage point. but we knew that one day. we roamed the asphalt on which automobiles drove by day. We are sedentary in buildings in our polluted cit­ ies. not survival. night and day. an alternate universe in which this crowded. wonder. sim­ ply receive them. I was joined first by one. Similarly. a quiet paradise such as Adam and Eve might have wandered. and friendship were the centers of life. We didn't speak it aloud. and golden gods with more recent protagonists to make the passages refer to the present day. at times. are the nuts and bolts issues of mere survival the main focus. whisper them into your lover's ear when he needs reassurance that he is not crazy for breaking ranks with this global village of cannibals. Both. at a quarter past five. primitive peoples. in 700 BC. exactly as the great uto­ pians called for. Only today. it was a feast-or perhaps. Our work typically involves one. We awaken to the alarm clock-they slept a lot. all the inhabitants of this land would follow in our footsteps. My joy in it was so profound I almost wanted to run out and conceive a new race of offspring to populate it. At four in the morning. Surprisingly. I walked there. whether before or behind us. the hard-line primitivist who writes of how magical everything was before our fall from grace is similarly disoriented when it comes to the question of what matters right now. . Tell those fables around the fire before the next great adventure your clan un­ dertakes. they lived as if they were gods. everything seemed deserted. in our world of enforced artificial scarcities and unbridled social change. exploring the unseen dimen­ sions of our city as I had explored so many other cities and countries. The old-line Marxist who insists the world will be a paradise once the proletariat takes power and can only be a hell until then is speech­ less in the face of the paradise discovered by a lovemaking couple. a few hyperspecialized skills. and its past and future were as real to us as the industrial revolution was to the motorists. be it a great journey or a dangerous engagement. The fruitfulgrainland yielded its harvest to them of its own accord-while they. This was our universe. and unpaid. to be exact) celebrating \ the lifestyles of human beings immeasurably removed from them by time and space-but you could as easily replace the foragers. while we.

according to some Aborigines. Surely. hitchhiking for the first time from Amsterdam to Stockholm. plot impos­ sible voyages and sometimes carry them out. or the Phoenicians. It is the world in which people dream new worlds into being.We would do better to orient our values around what we have experienced in our own lives and what might be possible in them. The Dreamtime offers a model for an alternate mythology: a heritage as old as our species that can become new in an instant. exploring the dis­ used train tunnel that runs through the darkness under Providence. a nation of horsewomen who lived without masters and were buried in their ar­ mor. We still set out on such journeys today wherever one of us goes off the map. people expe­ rienced more joy in traveling than frequent-flier businessmen do now. is a time that runs concurrent with mortal time as well as having taken place at the inception of the cosmos. and in which worlds dream themselves into be­ ing through people. let's look back: One million years 0/exploration and discovery!The first human be­ ing to climb Mount Everest reached its peak 20. We gather in trans. Patriarchal empires built the Great Wall of China as a desperate defense against the Samartians. were the first to discover America. The witches who followed them eighteen centuries later were keepers of the same secrets. History as We Live It I ecosystem. Rhode Island. The Amazons were only one among hundreds of tribes of pow­ erful women who fought to keep these mysteries alive after the emergence of patriarchy. One Million Years of Do-It-Yourself Culture! The Dreamtime. an ongoing history we participate in by conjuring it. border guards. Remnants of these linger in our fairy tales still. If we can't begin our project of liberation from what we know and aim for something we can reach. you don't believe it? Do you think Columbus. And just imagine what they encoun­ tered when they traveled! A week's trek brought them into another 282. unconstrained by apartment leases.000 years ago. energy not expended on survival must have been employed as children still employ it during camping trips today: to devise and narrate stories. too? Do you think people really spent the first nine hundred and ninety millennia huddled in caves. What. we can't start or steer such a project at all. One million years 0/ women's liberation and gender mutiny! It's common knowledge that matriarchal societies preceded patriarchal ones-but "matriarchy" is simply an abstraction coined by unimagi­ native men to describe what they can only picture as the reverse of to day's gender relations. we reenter the Garden of Eden to invent our universe from scratch. or Leif Ericsson. and ticket prices. Invok­ ing this story. to orient ourselves for looking ahead.and woman-only spaces as our ancestors did at the dawn of humanity and rediscover our powers as they discovered theirs. Those were days when gender as we know it had yet to be invented. a time and space in which it is always the first day of Creation. motionless and terrified-is that how human beings reached Greenland and Hawaii from the forests of Africa? Imagine all the journeys we undertook in the past mil­ lion years-expeditions and escapades that would be unbelievable to our historians even if they weren't invisible to their instruments. any place. we cross paths with the woman who first ascended Mount Everest. when women were revered as bearers of the spirit world and anybody could be one. as we are today when we organize underground abortion services and share herbal alternatives to medical dogma. In prehistoric times. any time. History as We Live It. 283 . a woman of their tribe would not take a lover for herself until she had slain a man in battle. explore untrodden spaces. adventure was the order of the day. not something imitated annually on tourist vacations. into contact with unfamiliar cultures and creatures-a far cry from the identical airports and hotels our unfortunate busi­ nessmen deem their natural environment. according to Herodotus. In that spirit. for that matter.

there now are security guards. in the words of Rita Mae Brown. folk medicine. Our war can never be entirely lost. some homemade tattoos and scarification. graffiti. still devise and revise our own genders. our ancestors didn't shave their legs or armpits or wear deodorant. communal space to share those songs and stories and strategies. They scavenged food like modern trashpickers do. As Sappho declared. You can bet some of them had dreadlocks. wrecked temples on hills where metropolises stood mere centuries ago. folk everything! Did you know-people two thousand years ago took birth control pills? They made them by boiling down the urine of female pigs. today we face corporate conglomerates and so-called democratic governments. asinine inventions. We were squatting caves before they erected buildings-we painted graf­ fiti on those walls before sandblasting was invented-we were com­ posing our own songs before the radio waves were invaded-we met to reach consensus long before the first ballot was tampered with! When a few of us come together in any liberated. Where once there were saber-toothed tigers. where later we had to fight Sumerian mercenaries and Roman legions to protect our liberty. we are participating in the same tradition our ancestors practiced with their neighbors one thousand generations ago. an army of lovers shall not jail. there will be resistance. There used to be as many human beings in the world as there are avowed anarchists today. One million years of squatting. celebrated life with folk music made by their friends. through the entire future of our species: for as long as inhuman institutions are made up of human lives. 284. still take each other fiercely and fear­ lessly in strong arms and gentle hands. theirs can never be won. passed down folk culture they devised. and afterwards there will be celebrations just as there are today. History as We Live It . and punk rock! For over 50. One million years of folk science. foreshadow the end they know awaits-our way stretches ahead of us infinitely. the tyrants only a few senseless wars. self-important treatises. We still refuse all attempts to define or silence us. We can claim one million years of do­ it-yourself culture and resistance for our heritage.guided by goddesses who have lost their names only to receive new ones.000 generations. some patches proclaiming their allegiances. and short-lived empires-which we've always eventually razed to the ground! The ruins of their failed nations. traveled like hitchhikers riding rivers and hopping ocean cur­ rents around the world.

The American Museum of Natural History did not return the remains of the four victims to their clan until 1993. 286. the boy was heartbroken to discover his father's bleached bones on display." The peoples of northwestern Greenland were still doing this a century ago-polar explorer R. since solid-hulled boats became common. Knud Rasmussen set up a trading post nearby to sell the locals what they had once gathered freely-that's progress for you! Peary also took six indigenous people back to New York. The child. that different technologies are always evolving and disappearing-the ones who insist that such marvels must be the work of extraterrestrials just reveal how colonized their imaginations are by modernist indoc­ • Here's the bad news: In return for the trust of those who shared this wonder with him. No need to cling in fear to "modern .. glorifying the "unprecedented progress" of the present day as it simultaneously portrays that past as a golden age to which there is no return-but the technologies.E. 287 . and theft upon which institutional­ ized science is built. Proof remains at Stonehenge and on Easter Island that technology is not a singular force that develops in a straight line. they were shut away in a damp basement at the Mu­ seum. but the Museum considered his father's body to be its property. present is utterly unlike the past. one of die two survivors. leaving only cryptic mes­ sages scratched into trees behind them: Gone to Croatatt . Peary was shown three enormous meteorites which they had been visiting in yearly pilgrimages for centuries to obtain tips for their harpoons. has more in common with science as most human beings have practiced it than anything the books tell us about Archime­ . Years later. within months. Peary stole the meteorites and sold them to the American Museum of Natural History in New York-decimating traditionallifeways for personal profit as European explorers always have. so the Museum staff staged a fake burial to appease the boy. human beings were capable of circumnavigating the globe in wash-through rafts hundreds of feet long. Prominent anthropologists "studied" them even as they were dying. remember the brutality.r· astronomer with a cheap telescope and a notebook of personal dis­ I •. exhibiting them to tens of thousands at an entry fee of twenty­ five cents.The early Egyptians. Next time you visit a museum. . several thousand years before the Roman Empire. coveries. technology" and the scant comforts it provides-this is the Dark Age. The folk-scientific method. but no one offered them adequate medical attention. but evidence suggests that the wash­ through model may have been better adapted for ocean travel than its successor. fash­ ioned iron tools from fragments of iron that arrived in meteors fallen from the sky-there was an Egyptian hieroglyph represent­ ing "heavenly iron.. medicines. Once the meteorites had been re­ moved. the expertise to fashion such crafts has been lost to all but a few isolated groups. And this was less than a century ago-not our civilization's barbaric past. familiar to every adolescent . and those earlier than them in China and the Middle East. begged to be allowed to bury his father properly according to his people's customs.. des or Einstein. and arts of today have analogs dating back perhaps to the very beginnings of our species. including a father and his tiny child. History as We Live It History as We Live It . fraud. if ever there was one! So how do Wft make our own Enlightenment? How do we follow in the footsteps of those from the last fifty generations who defected to make their own way through the world.* As Thor Heyerdahl demonstrated. trination. having not invented a process for making iron. but the savagery that always occurs whenever capitalists interact with so-called uncivilized peoples. Omnipresent cultural propaganda insists that the . Afterwards. The four corpses were sent to Bellevue hospital for dissec­ tion. all but two of them had died of tuberculosis.

and set out with an international crew ("a Russian.. History as We Live It History as We Live It. to fashion the kind of vessel those ancient peoples used. In this boat. and a monkey. Such correspondences between past and present human activi­ ties can be found everywhere: A woman adjusts a recipe her mother passed down to her as her ancestors did six millennia before. and the Polynesian islands must be coincidental. an American. Outside the linear timeline. Nomadic volunteers till organic farms as Celtic peoples did before them. on account of the vast distances in­ volved. Speaking proportionately. A singer-songwriter discovers she can make her language her own. an Italian. an African. 289 . that similarities between the technologies and folklore of the ancient peoples of the Mediterranean. both share the same sense of wonder experienced by the human beings who invented the first words. as the first human beings to reach that site must have at the dawn of time. FolkWarriors When his colleagues insisted. gazing upon the same stars. Spanish squatters decorate and defend their walls with fragments of broken glass the way their forerunners prepared for Roman attacks. once more: even on excursions like this one that end up in the history books. the Ra II. Folk Singers. But Heyerdahl himself tells it differently: in rediscovering a prehistoric form of ocean travel. he felt a close kinship with the human beings who had made this same journey in a similar craft. less than one percent of what takes place is recorded. adolescent runaway beholds Paris with the same wide eyes Rimbaud did over a century earlier.Correspondences: Thor Heyerdahl and Other Folk Scientists. 288. they sailed from Morocco to Barbados in only fifty-seven days. One can interpret Heyerdahl's project in the framework of West ­ ern civilization's supposedly linear development of knowledge and technology-he was simply adding to "the" store of human knowl­ edge. an anarchist with full facial tattoos rides a freight train across a na­ tional border to fight in the streets against his enemies as they meet to discuss some new "free trade" agreement: this is tribal war. albeit by returning to the lost lore of the past. the Americas.) to find out just how far they could sail in one. some of the only people in the world who still understand the complexities of such design. He contracted reed boat builders from Lake Titicaca in Peru. just as Percy Shelley did. Norwegian Thor Heyer ­ dahl left the ivory tower to test their theory. the men on Heyerdahl's ship stood beside sailors on ships :'. An r. an Egyptian. The other ninety-nine percent is concealed from historians but familiar to the rest of us. Knowing he would be denied legal entry. perhaps four thousand years earlier. a Mexican.

After the bombing. sharks. when the tropical stars twinkled from the black sky and a myriad of phosphorescent plankton twinkled back from the sea. the local liberal coalition had split in two. Diego absent­ mindedly took the twigs and snapped them into smaller and smaller pieces." Kate had patiently waited her turn to state the obvious. might have concluded that this fidgeting was our chief activity. so the two were combined into one event under the banner "Preempt the End of the World. Perhaps that's what modern anthropologists mean when they say our ancestors spent so much time at play: they're just acknowledging that they can't figure out what our predecessors were doing any more than the old-fashioned anthropologists who interpreted the same activities as work. the heroes of the Spanish Civil War. this real life was a fairy tale. decrying one war after another with­ out connecting war and occupation to the cycles that produced ter­ rorism. our new group had been invited to give teeth to the event. As the conversation dragged on. we couldn't work out our differences. We too pulled in giant fishes."At night. or sea monsters. We were the slaves who revolted with Spartacus. It only remained for us to hash out the details among ourselves. seated in a circle. This marked a dramatic shift: the same liberals had responded to attacks elsewhere with hand-wringing and paralysis. Marshall was making little forts out of twigs that had fallen from the branches overhead. the so-called Iroquois. 291 . just like the old days-our own old days. "Our only hope is to break up into smaller groups. How else could one describe the fact that the twinkling plankton in the sea around us were the ancestors of the six of us who sat above water and looked down upon them?" -Thor Heyerdahl in Green Was the Earth on the Seventh Day So there we were in the park. Otherwise we'll still be here tomorrow morning." Thanks to Pablo's efforts. I found myself meticulously splitting blades of grass into finer and finer strands. and the olden days of our ancestors-trying to negotiate the terms of a new alliance. and called a demonstration to publicize that charge. History as We Live It Extinction. After all. There was nothing but us on the raft. but that was proving impossible. symbolically pulled along by bird-head­ ed men while they themselves enjoyed pulling in fishlines that had hooked rays. so we were doomed. It turned out that this demonstration was to coincide with a protest about climate change. "OK. An anthropologist from some future society. more militant faction accused the government of putting everyone in harm's way by provoking terrorist attacks. the so-called Iroquois nation." 290. We could well understand the pre-Incan artists who depicted Kon Tiki and other bearded and hook-nosed deities as traveling on serpents undulating among the stars. the Catalan anarchists. And like the slaves. real life became like a fairy tale. flicking these carelessly over his shoulder. looking on without understanding our speech. we're getting nowhere. we too felt like gods on a flying carpet in the universe. the younger. each of us began to fidget with whatever was closest at hand. surrounded by darkness and stars. Aboard our balsa raft. friends.

He tried to take Diego aside: "Diego." 1 looked at Marshall desperately. 1 know all y'all need partners. I'll roll with Marshall-but only with him. "Well. "Re­ member. wasn't it typical that as the only woman of color in the group 1 was here cleaning up while everyone else played action hero? It was certainly convenient that they could 292 . at least until Marshall told her about his relationship with me. otherwise I'm out.. "Where does that leave me. boxes of books for the library. 1 didn't know any of them well enough to work with them. If only 1 could be disappointed with everything. Extinction Extinction. the computer lab running. 1 have a fucking suspended sentence. where are your friends? Where's Rita? Shouldn't she be here? How about Flake. the stage built-it would be amazing. 1 just came out of two years and by the end of it no one was writing me except Marsh here.. they would have no trouble pairing up. "I guess 1 could. 1 mean. do you want to try working with me?" This was a pointed gesture. watching this train­ wreck in hushed discomfort." The other side of the circle was all new kids. 1 passed the shuttered front and let myself in the side door. we'd been talking around this: all of us desperately wanted to be back in action. My lips were trembling and my face felt hot. But how much worse to be wedded to an amazing project with such fucked up people! Everything 1 was involved in depended on people like Diego-it was vulnerable to their caprices. main room was still in disarray: tables and chairs from the university stacked against the wall. If we can't-" "Fine. but that's what 1 need. but our relationships were fractured. Pablo hesitated. Diego broke the silence. and all those other traveler kids you ran with? Did they just melt away?" 1 was speechless. You guys can work this out on your own. Speaking of power dynamics. I'd be able to give up and stop hurting-and here we had finally se­ cured a two-story building with an industrial kitchen and space to pack in over a hundred people. How could 1 set myself up for heartbreak by committing to things with them when they weren't committed to looking out for me? At the same time. It was like an abusive relationship in which my projects were being held hostage rather than my children. I'll go do that. At least the freezers were working so the grocery program could expand without overwhelming the cramped house that had hosted it. the shelves stocked with books. we have to set up the Center tonight. I'm not really qualified . "Each person should have a partner. it was all the more insidious inthat it was my own desires and aspirations holding me rather than mere fear and inertia.We looked at each other dubiously. cans of mis­ mixed paint. When this space was finished-when the walls were painted. For almost two hours now. Hadn't we already been through this years ago? Marshall was angrily hissing something in Diego's ear. our trust bro­ ken. It was painful to arrive back at our space precisely because 1 was so excited about it. if-" Diego addressed himself to the circle. 293 . Kate and Marshall had worked to­ gether in ev