Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1999
Network Neutrality debate began in 1999 Mergers: cable TV and broadband companies AT&T/MediaOne and AOL/TimeWarner Lessig and Lemley FCC submission:
The end of End-to-End
Non-discrimination Transparency:
information concerning network management and other practices as is reasonably required for users and content, application, and service providers to enjoy the protections.
2009 10 FCC, CRTC and European Commission introduce vague broad principles of non-discrimination
2011-12 devil lies in the detail
These use the IP pipe, but a reserved section How big is the private pipe? 10% or 90% Who gets access? Anyone who pays?
Or only those preferred partners to ISPs? Do you only see certain IPTV channels on Videotron? Its making part of the pipe back into cable!
Throttling
For time-sensitive traffic (ie. real-time audio or video) managed services? where throttling creates noticeable degradation,
"amounts to controlling the content and influencing the meaning and purpose of the telecommunications"
Prior approval required for such activities. Non-sensitive traffic: If slowing down de facto amounts to blocking, requires prior approval
CTRC - Disclosure
ISPs to disclose traffic management practices: why they are being introduced who is affected when it will occur what Internet traffic is subject to the traffic management how it will affect user's experience, specifically speed New privacy requirements ISP use of information obtained from deep-packet inspection
"not to use for other purposes personal information collected for the purposes of traffic management and not to disclose such information."
CRTC Enforcement
There is now more guidance and guidelines but it will take more than just this decision. E.g. Bell throttles 4pm-2am peaktime? Cogeco throttles 24/7! New complaint expected CRTC wanted a test case Wireless: this applies to all networks, wireless included Wholesale: where incumbents (Bell) treat independents in the same manner as their retail customers, the same complaintsbased approach applies. Where the approach is more restrictive, prior approval is required.
DIRECTIVE 2009/136/EC
New Articles 20 and 22, Recital 26: Consumer protection/citizen rights NOT SMP
http://eurlex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2009:337:0011:0 036:EN:PDF
safeguard NRA powers to prevent service degradation hindering or slowing down of traffic over public networks
USD Article 22(3) http://eurlex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2009:337:0037:0069 :EN:PDF
Commission will monitor the impact of market and technological developments on net freedoms reporting to Parliament and Council before end-2010 Was actually April 2011!
on whether additional guidance is required, and
[2] If that produces evidence of widespread infringement - only Madison River Skype blocking? recommend setting EU guidance rules
"more stringent measures...[in] the form of guidance."
[3] "If this proves to be insufficient, I am ready to prohibit the blocking of lawful services or applications. I think that means guidance 2012 - regulatory action
2013, if ever.
Neutrality Lite
Common carriage Quality of service guarantee Lowest through-put guarantee
Not maximum speed 2Mbps is universal service broadband definition Should be feasible with LTE
What s the minimum speed at peak-time? Not up to lab-tested maximum! NOT blocking Skype Building High Definition VOIP fast lanes
Losing liberty?
ISPs important intermediary limited liability Based on their wise monkeys role Behavioural advertising PHORM Blocking and filtering Throttling on non-transparent basis Removes 2000/31/EC Art.12-14 exemption Freedom of expression vital to democracy
1. Information regulation
to require service providers to inform consumers
NN enforced via reporting requirements: 1.incentive for market players, and 2.co-regulation or formal regulation
if insufficiently unanimous cooperation.
2011 articles
Three Wise Monkeys www.globalpolicyjournal.com/ Mobile Net Neutrality ejlt.org//article/view/32 More ssrn.com/author=220925 www.essex.ac.uk/law/staff/profil e.aspx?ID=832