5Zaw,@~

cY~!!,~~
GEORGE R. SAPONARO* *Member NJ and MD Bars

0/

The Newbold House 27 Cedar Street Mount Holly, New Jersey 08060
609-518-1256 609-267-8080 FAX 609-518-1257
WILLIAM EMMETI SITZLER Member NJ Bar

September 9, 2011

Via Fax wlo encls. and regular mail w/encls. Katz & Dougherty, LLC 4020 Quakerbridge Road Mercerville, NewJersey 08619 ~......
, ( ,,/' r _. .~ J .......

Attention: GeorgeT. Do¥g~J:erty,Esquire
.

."_' ".' r~
'.

Re: CtirlucCi/and Chilson v. City of Trenton

i

'_ t .il -'/
./.;/
} I; ; ~

'i .

Docke'lNo. MER-L-1739-11
"'".

.

Dear Mr. Dougherty:

-,-.. ·..r_.~,'.;'

'f"'"

I am enclosing herewith a copy of all employee history records, as well as various pay stubs (redacted) for both employees for David G. Tallone and Johnnie Vaughan Jr. With respect to these please note that there are no time sheets kept for these employees. All of these records are complete as they are the only records within the City's possession. They include employee history records for both employees, as well as various pay stubs. Please note that the various pay stubs go though August 2011, and as such this should be deemed complete. Should you have any disagreement with this, kindly advise me promptly and I will see that any subsequent request is fulfilled. I would also confirm a message from your secretary wherein you had indicated that you also deemed Mayor Civic Association Appreciation Day records to be complete, as I had advised you that no City money was spent for this event. My understanding is that your clients also verified that this was paid through the Mayor's campaign fund or through some other source.

Attention; George T. Dougherty, Esquire Re: Carlucci and Chilson v. City of Trenton September 9,2011 Page 2

The only remaining issue at this point in time remains the Heritage Day Festival. I provided you some information with regard to this, and as I have indicated in the past an investigation is ongoing. You have been provided with all records presently in possession of the City of Trenton, Mayor Mack or Mr. Berry; I will keep you updated as other records become available in the immediate future. Sincerely,

GRS:amc Enclosures cc: Mr. Eric Berry, Administrator, City of Trenton( vi

EMPLOYEE EFECTIVE DATE 5/3/1978 TYPEQF ACTION NEW HIRE

HISTORY

RECORD
:

SERVICE RECORD TYPE POSITION TITLE Maintenance Repairer Pending open camp exam OF APPT. PAOe PW,

SECTION

DEPT

ORDIV Sewer

SALARY

2/26/1979

CONVERSION

Maint Rep Cert from PIC list dated 2/26179

RAP

PW

Sewer

10/30/1980

PROMOTION

Mechanic Pending prom procedures

PAP

PW:

Sewer

$11,555

9/4/1984 1012/1984

LOA RET FROM LOA

Mechanic Mechanic

LOA RET LOA

w/outpay

ret 10/1/84

w/outpay
ANN dates $16,829

No change in DOH and

1/7/1985

CONVERSION

Mechanic Cert from PIC list dated 1n/85

RAP

PW

Sewer

9/23/1987 912811987

LOA RET FROM LOA

Mechanic Mechanic

LOA RET LOA

w/outpay wfout pay.

ret 11/23/87

No change in bOH and PAP PW

ANN dates $21,444

6/8/1988

PROMOTION

Senior Mechanic Pending prom procedures

Sewer

10/19/1988 1/911989

LOA RET FROM LOA

Sr Mechanic Sr Mechanic

LOA

w/out pay

ret 1/19189

Sick leave

RET LOA w/out pay ADJ DOH 7/3/1978 ADJ ANN 8/8/1988

8/1/1989

CONVERSION

Sr Mechanic Cert from PIC Ilst dated 8/1/89

RAP

PW

Sewer

11120/1989

PROMOTION

Supervising Maintenance Repr Cert from OIC list dated 11/13/89

RAO

PW

Sewer

$24,770

1/1/1990 10/2/1990

WOT RET FROM WOT

Maint Supt Supervising Maint Rep

WOT Return

various days from WOT

from Jan to

Jul-90

Name

I

(Last)

(First) DAVID

(Middle)

Position Title

Fund

Type of Appt

Salary

TALLONE

G. EMPLOYEE

SUPV MAINT REP/LANSep HISTORY RECORD '

~-~{,;;,

SERVICE RECORD TYPE OF TYPE SECTION DEPT w/pay letferfrom w/pay letter from PW
1

EFECT1VE

DATE
1/1/1995 5/31/2004 LOA

ACTION

POSITION TITLE
Supv Maint Rep

OF APPT. LOA leave per RET LOA leave per

ORDIV ret 5/30/95 NJ DOP NJ DOP Sewer

SALARY
Paid Union in file

RET FROM LOA

Supv Maint Rep

Returned from Paid Union in file

6/1J2004

PROMOTION

Supervising Maintenance Repairer/Supervisor Landscape Pending prom procedures

PAP

$64,902

i

i

i

11/16/2006

CONVERSION

Supv Maint Rep/Supv Landscp

RAQ Passed

PW
Q~aHfying
I

Sewer ExamE & E

i
i
I

,
! :

: j_
I

I
1

;

,

! !
i
j

I !

,;

I

Name!

(last)

(First)

(Middle)

Position Title

Fund

Type of Appt

Salary

TAlLONE

DAVID

G,

SUPV MAINT REP/LANSep

!

I !
.>0

"-

:~1 r::" 0
C

I

D

c

,~

I"
o

t-

" 0-

...

,0 f,:"~

-o

Cro

N

0
o-

_?-,

,0
;;u

.0;

~

'" ·e

.c:

81

I

u

z; <6

<'

............ VOID VOID VOID '"~...... VOID VOID VOID .... " .... : ••• One Tllouund Seven Hundred Ninety Five and 671lM Dollars u. P.~ roTIWOrd,rof DAVID G TALLONE

Sl,795.671

.U ... Th-to...... VOID

,

VOID VOID ........ ~H .. ·

~DV~
Au:b':II'i~dSigtl:ih.t:t'e

City of Trenton 319 East State Skeet Trenton, NJ 0860B

DAVID G TALLONE

IMPORTANT DOCUMENT ENCLOSED

th .... ,.........

VOlD VOID VOID u-dotU.,.. VOID VOlD VOID ~."""If:l'..,ni ••• One Tnousand Seveu Humlred Ninety Five and 66/IDO DGlI~r5 •••

Is.1
.

SI,795.66I

VOID VOID VOID
.

:~

~OVOIDVOJD AI1-~horizc.d

........
Si,il.lWUIC

~

City of Trenton

319 East Stale Street Treruon, NJ 08608

DAVID G TALLONE

IMPORTANT DOCUMENT ENCLOSED

............

VOID VOIO vOle

•• ~......

VOID VOID VOlO •• - ......

••• One Thou;~n~ Seven Hundred Ninety Five ami 661100 Dollars •••
fWTo7~(J,d",of

j '

,
SI,795.661

DAVJD G TALlONE

VOID VOlO VOID

!

.

--kic~
·~ .. :::~IO

VOID VOID .--.-. A'IIII~!!ri~~ignlm:n:: S

City of Trenton 319 East State Street Trenton, NJ OB608

DAVID G TAlLONE

IMPORTANT DOCUMENT ENCLOSED

............... u ·

VOID VOlO VOID

";uu"'".

VOIO VOID VOID

uu",uu

[

.... On. Tholls.nu
PuyToTII.ONk,of

Seven Hundred Ninety Five and GGIIOO Dolbrs···

'

Is!

DAVID G TALLONE
'1(01D VOID VOID •••• ~.-.

W~th-avhl ~D

:.~

VOIOVOIO"~"""

City of Trenton 319 East Slate Sfreel Trenton,NJ 08606

DAVID G TALLONE

IMPORTANT DOCUMENT ENCLOSED

•• ,.........

VOID VOID VOLD ......

,...

VOID VOID VOID

....... One Thousand Seven Hundred Ninety Five and 65/1DQ DQUars ......
Poy r. TI",",*'01

~"~'''i
~OID VOID VOID .

Sl,795.6Sj

DAVID G TALLONE

~DV~

~ ~

Cify of Trenton

319 East Stole Street
Trenton, NJ 08608

DAVID G TALLONE

IMPORTANT DOCUMENT ENClOSED

Payroll Account

[s I

S1,795.68/

TAlLONE

W~chovia

Cily of Trenfon

319 Eost Stote Street Trenton,NJ 08608

*** One Thousand Seven
'~VtD G TALLONE

\~t ~hdre:

I

I
i

Wachovlu

I

/1
Cily ofTrenton 319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

;j.~.

**'" One Thouss

Wach[)via

2.00000050

~:

,.

City of Trenton }~ 319 East Slate Slre"i1t Trenton, NJ 086 -.~! .

***

0

waenevta

.....

,:..p'

City of Trenton 319 East Stote Street Trenton,NJ 08608

***

One

Wachovla

City of Trenton 319 Eost State Street Trenton,NJ 08608

Wacbovfa

City 319 Eos!

'] ·Cli~~kNo.

I

510611

,

Trenton, NJ

Payroll Accouut

City of Trenton

31 9 East State Street

0/100 Dollars

***

WacIlOV!A

2.00000050

It 21.,;111

WachQv;a

N

l'\J'J :cxi ON-Ooo 0000

'

0000

:0
I

i.~'I·
!:>

I

:

~.

.,

! $·1

$1,699.981

City of Trenton
31 9 Eost Stote Str

,
en Hundriand

'*~,

00/100

Waohovb

Cily ofTrenton iitO -'~J.i:. 319 East Stote Stre'~ .•

I)
;'lk>i Six

Trenton, NJ 0860~l

***

OnJ£housand
~~)

ii
~.

Orr/era! DAVID G Tlr&i10NE

I. ....1
f}
L. 211·1~02. 2000\

1.'

.

.~

ift

City of Trenton ~ 319 East Siale Stre&t ?~,/

Trenton, NJ 08608~1

::1.

*** . .,e Thousand
NE

~~J

S

Waclmvia

Cily of Trenton 319 East State Street , Trenton, NJ 08608

.f:

~~1r

"1;&-

,kf

.. V1D G TALLO~E

,

.

"'''''''One Tho&j~lldSix Hun

W~chovia

• n ~ 2000 2 11'2
.i~-

·lfl'
j

I

~i

J~: .

c.~~Tmnt
31 9 East Stole!IDreet
Trenton, NJ

°1608
(}

*** ~, e Thousan
ALLONE

\

Wachovta

:i.
!;~C

,

City of Trento~f
319 East Stole

!;"fleet
;

Trenton, NJ 08'~.08
;

***

OfI~ Thousand ';: ~.

Wacllovia

.•..

Dollars **~

o Dollars *t*
i

i

Wacboyja

City of Trenton 319 Eos1 Stote Street

!~,~.
~~¥
I

Trenton, NJ 0860~

*"* O~eThousand
+\t

{.

Sev

nd 00/100 Dollars

n· di

City ofTrenf~JiI 319 East Slale\Slreet Trenton, NJ ~::.?J

~~H

osJba
:i t~.:
! ~~.

*.,'" OWe Thousand ·n:i ~~I;:
.~~-~,

S

'wachovia

2.000·

City of Trenton 319 East Stote Street
T~enton.NJ 08608

Wacllovia

2

* 2000

251:

City of Trenton 319 Eost Stote Street
Trenton, NJ 08608

*** One Thousand
DAVID G TALLONE

Wachavl,

~;.':

City of Tre~~on 31 9 East Sloie Street Trenton, NJ ,08608

"f'

r
t

of

DAYJd; ':0- TALLONE
.-~:~

Wachovla

1:0 2 ;I,; 2000

251:

o Dollars *1.
I.

i

l:
!

Authorized Siguature.

02.2000251:

2.00000050"
.: ".-:; . <i

.:.~<;.fi;
.

."

~..

c

~.

.

......

~,,,,,.~,,

....

-

*** otic Tho

*H One Tho

.

:110.

DAVIDGiAllO

Ii

j"'.

Wac!Jovi2

I
~

i

....
••• ........_:....-I

City of Trenton
319 East Slcte Street

Tr ton, NJ 08608

r···· ,.:.
and Six Hundred Eig
I§~
~!.

-ItH

One Th

i~~

Pay To Tlte Order of D.

lD G TAlL ~ E

T.u:j
.

:£'r
:,

~.

Wachovla

EMPLOYEE HISTORY RECORD
SERVICE RECORD EFECTIVE DATE 7/19/2010 TYPE OF TYPE
i

i
j

i
I

ACTION
NEW HIRE

POSITION TITLE
Aide to the Mayor

OF APPT. UA

I
I
;

i

SECTION

DEPT

ORDIV Mayor's Off

SALARY $40,000

Mayor's Off
!

!,

i

i
! ,
i
!

,

I i

I
i

iI

i

I
1

!
I
i

~

i

!

!

!
!

i

i
i I ,

!

I

I

I

I
I

I I I i
i
I

I

I

I I

I

!

I I

I

I

I
I

I

j

!

;

1

,I
i

Name

I

!

(Last)

(First)

(Middle)

Position Title

[

Fund

Type of Appt

Salary

VAUGHANJR

JOHNNIE

AIDE TO THE MAYOR

.'

t

I
'II,
7. b'
e 0

;g 'c
.. ..l:J
N

"

ro o· 0 '" ~0 .~ ,..,

.o

C

~.

City of Trenton

Check Date IRei'crence No.

31 9 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

08/18/2011

I

2040998

!
I
I

Amount

$1,169.94]

Payee

JO~NNJE .......

VAUGHAN Jr

Dw: f / Dept: fOll 0

Non-Negotiable

~'.".,","

O-Re';!.ulor Poy
36·HOUDAY HOURS 43-?ERSOtlAl. FAY

51·S1CKMUR5
54NACATION HOUR 56-fUNERAl. lEAVE

Company;\Olema:

Private. MeJno;

35

City of Trenton

1·.Che.~k"barc lRefcrence No.1

~

319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

I

OB/04/2011

I

20400B4

1

Amount

$1,169.941

i

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: I /Depl: )0) 10

Non-Negotiable

""""""~.

City of Trenton

319 Eost State Street ~ Trenton, NJ 08608
Amount

$1,169.921

I

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: J / Depl: JOIl 0

Non~Negotiable .. ",,",w m

CUnlpanr Memo,

Private Memo,

35

City of Trenton

Check-Date \Reference

319 East Stote Street Trenton, NJ 08608

07/07/2011

I

No.1

2038219

I
I

Amount

$568.50\

Payee

JOHNN!E VAUGHAN Jr
Div~ J / Dept: 10/10

.Non-Negotiable

"""""".\"

Company Memo:

l'r;valo Memo:

35

City

of Trenton

[. Cher;k·Date IReference No.

319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

I

06/23/2011

I

20372~

!
I

r I

..tUnount
$568.49\

hyco

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1

! Dept:

tone

Non-Negotiable

."",,.,,,,.,,

0'.",'" O",,,""'UlPay

3b·HOLIDAY HOURS
4J.PERSOIlAl PAY 51·510: HOURS 54-VA£ATlON HOUR 56-FUN~RAl tEAVf

Co,up.ny Menla:
!,

35

Private Memo:

Ciiy

of Trenton

319 East State Street Treoton, NJ 08608
Amount

!

$1,169.931

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Diy; )

I Dept:

10110

Non-Negotiable

_"".,. ..

Ciiy of Trenton 31 9 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608 Amount

I

$1,052.43

!

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Di..,: 1/ Dept:

JOI JO

Non-Negotiable
Fold

""~'J'W'

Company Memo:

City of Trenton
319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

Check Date IReference No.

05/1V2011

I

2034355 I

Amount

$1,170.03j

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
t»: 1/
Depl: 10110

Non-Negotiable

""~''''''

'.'~U.OOIIIJ·~~I!II"'

Poy 36·HOLlDAV KOURS 43·PERSONAL PAY 5l·SICK HDURS 54·VACATlOII HOUR 56·fUllf&Al.lEAVl'

City of Trenton 319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

Check Date

04/28/2011

I

IReference No.l
2033384

I
1

Amount

$1,170.021

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN
Div: r I Depl; 10110

Jr

Non-Negotiable

"-""'''',,,

City of Trenton 319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608 Amount

I

$1,136.451

Payee

JOHNNIE
Div: J

VAUGHAN
10J J 0

Jr

!Dept:

Non-Negotiable

"".""J«"

Ci1y of Trenton

31 9 East State Street
Trenton, NJ 08608
Amount

I

$1,247.871

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: I / Dept: 10) 10

Non-Negotiable

"""~" ....

Ci1y of Trenton . 31 9 East Slate Street Trenton,NJ 08608
Amount

$1,169.931

I

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1 J Dept: 10110

Non-Negotiable

~""n"."

Company Memo:

PrJ."le Memo:

35

City

of

Trenton

Check Date IReference

319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

03/03/2011

I

No.1

2029434

I

Amount

$1,169.94

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div; 1/ Depf: 10110

NOll-Negotiable

'_""",,,

O·Regu!DI foy 36-KOLlOAY HOURS 43-ffRSONAl PAY 51-SICK HOURS 54-VA(AIiOH HOUR

City ofT renton 31 9 East Stote Street Trenton, NJ 08608 Amount

!

$1,169.931

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1 J Dept: lalla

Non-Negotiable

"'~ ..'''.,''

City of Trenton

31 9 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608
Amount

I

$181.871

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: J

!Dept:

10) 10

Non-Negotiable

=~",'"''

City of Trenton 319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

CheckDate

01/20/2011

IReference No.1

I

2026459

I

Amount

$867.82

I

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: I

I Dept:

JOllO

NOll-Negotiable

oor"",,,~~.

City of Trenton

_.. 31 9 East State Street ~ Trenton, NJ 08608
Amount \

$1,169.941

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1/ Dept: 10110

Non-Negotiable

..,"", .... '

Company Memo:

Private Memo:

35

City

of Trenton

319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608
Amount

I

$575.14!

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1/ Dept: 10110

Non-Negotiable

"".""".,.

Company Memo:

Private Memo:

35

City of Trenton

r CheckDateI
12/09/2010 I·

319 East State Street
Trenton, NJ 08608

I

[Reference No.

2023478

I
i

!

I

Amount

$1,159.981

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: J I Depl: 10110

Non-Negotiable

,.,""'""'"

City of Trenton

31 9 East State Street
Trenton, NJ 08608
Amount I

$1,159.96i

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: ) I Dept: JOllO

NOll-Negotiable
FoMHcri!

"''''''''''''

Company

Zlrlema:

Private Menlo:

35

of Trenton 31 9 East Stote Street Trenton, NJ 08608
City

Amount

1

$1,1.59.991

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1/ Depl: JOI

ro

Non-Negotiable

.., ...,..",,,

City of Trenton

319 East State Street ~ Trenton, NJ 08608

I

I: Check.Date
10/28/2010

I

IRefcrence

2020280

No·1

I

J'

. Amount
$1,159.96

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1/ Dept: ]0110

Non-Negotiable

""..""""

City of Trenton

319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

Amount I $1,159.971

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div:

1/ Dept: lalla

Non-Negotiable

"" ...,,,,.,,.

City

of Trenton

319 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

r- Ch'eek Date !R~fel'~nccNo·1 I 09/30/2010 I 2018163
Amount \

$1,247.00/

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div! J

!Dept; J 0])0

Non-Negotiable

'...... "..,.,

Company Memo:

35

Private Memo:

City of Trenton

3 T9 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

r
I

Amount

$1,169.111

I

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Oi.,.: I /
Dept:

JOIIO

NOll-Negotiable

~_".~,

Coml'~n)' Memo:

Prfvate Memo:

35

City of Trenton

31 9 East State Street Trenton, NJ 08608

r .Clleb¥,:n:are
I
09/02/2010

fRefi:~e·nCeNo.

I

I
\

2016078

Amount

I

$1,169.081

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: 1 /
Dept:

10110

Non-Negotiable

"",,., .... ..

Company Memo:

PrJvlIti: Memo:

35

City of Trenton

319 East State Street . Trenton, NJ 08608 Affiount

I

$1,169.091

Payee

JOHNNIE VAUGHAN Jr
Div: I /Oepf: 10110

Non-Negotiable

"""''', ...