You are on page 1of 9

:

Author(s):
Reviewed work(s):
Source: Tarbiz / - ), ,), pp. 139-146
Published by: Mandel Institute for Jewish Studies/ "
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/70015702 .
Accessed: 04/11/2011 06:51
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Mandel Institute for Jewish Studies/ " is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Tarbiz / .

http://www.jstor.org

. 1

[]

*
.

,
: 1965
,

,
1 :
,.

,
/
.anti-structure
commumtas
2 ).(V Turner

,) (103-96 ,51-5
.

()

140

][2

,) (

.
3
.

,
, ,

;
:
.

(,
)=

.
,
,
:

)
(,()
)=
,(.

.
,
.

,
;

),(:

:
,
4
.

6
,

5
6
7

, )(
, ) ,0
/,(,)

,

.76

, ,,,

, )(
, , 1335 .72
:),
,
/, ,] .(25-22
,)[,] ,(82-81

:,.
, ;- , , .
:, , ) (; ;, .

, ),
] [(. , ) ( .

][3

141


.
9
,
/


;

11
10
).(.
(
)


,
12
.

:
)

,(.
14
13

10
11
12
13

, ) , (.-
, .

),,, ,(218
: , ,

,.
/

, (
,1 ., )
V
. ,

/
.
1
:) ,.,,

,
.
.(165-16%
4

;.

) (.
;

(.

,6
!),

,,
)(.
; .

,
:-,
: -
,] .98-88

,
,,
: ,, ;

,397 : ; 7,) ,(1 191 .165-164


, ,, ;, .
), ;,

(.

:
, ?

,.:

...
;
,

, (.-,
)
.

,
:

142

][4

,) (

,
,
. 15

,
.

,
16
.

,
,

), (
.:

,
;

;), (
)

),

(.
, :

,
), 0
...

(1
,

.
=

.
...

),(

) ,(:

:.

:
)(.

),(.

,
*

,
,

,
(;

.
!

14

,(3.68
,)

.B.P Grenfeil
:Fragment).A.s ,Hunt
840

,
,
.(ofan UncanonicalGospel from,Oxyrhynchus
Oxford1908
1
.

:-

,(1144-143
,)

..A,Buchier
(JQR ,(O.S.)20 ,(1908).pp33)-34
6
(,)
,

-
,
,
! ; 159

,:

,
:;98-97

,.256-225

,
,

1
.

15

,
,; 255
:
,
..
,,.870

,
16 !()
,

,(3.185
,)
.

,,

][5

143

[]

)(,
4QMMT
,,
,

17

,,
:

)
.

, ,-

.

)

,12-10

.
,
, :(5

[ 10

11[

12[

,
.
.

.(14-8,
,

.]

,
(....
...

)
,
, , . ,46 , ,5
, .(25-24
,, ,;9,

,
,
.

,
,, (,) .345-343
:
, ,()
,.,) ,(3 33 9
: 17 The Phansaic-SadduceanControversiesabout Purityand the.J.M ,Baumgarten
,JJS 30 ,(1980) .pp 157-170;Qumran ,Texts,) ,(3 .33-27

144

][6

,
; ,
. : !
: ?
: ,
.
: , : .
,
, .
; ,
, .
* , ,
: :


)
, , 17-12] ,

.([128-127

; , . , ,
;
,
/
, , ? 2 ,
...
: , !18

;
.
.

) , (:
18r
)
:),( ?
) , ;
][(
?

.(193
,

][7

145

.
,
.
,

. , ,
!19
, ,
. ,
. :
/
.

[]

.20
- ,
, ; -
, .
,
.
.

,


19
) , (

)=(. )(

,
, ,.

) , 12

107-106(;
) (.
.
20, .17

146

][8

.21

).(H

)(P

22

.
,

23
.

24

(.

;,,

25 ,
.

: 21,

,.

, .
,

, - ,) .32-11
)(H
22 ,
) .(P , ,)
.(21
23: ,) ,(16 ;138-137,) ,(3 .226
,

,
24
.
,

, )
25

(,

,

.
,,
.
.