United States v McCarthy Complaint
|Views: 76
|Likes: 0
Published by TorrentFreak_
More info:
Availability:
See more
See less
:H'QW~'t1!'R~N2'tY~"
'~'r.'TfImN
'Oni,t.edS,t,a
t~:,'1;
Mf;JJ"
is;'e;ra,t;eU"udge
.SOtltJl:'l!~'lt:n:P.l,S'I;:,lEi,G
t,
0,:1:::r&rerw
'Yor'Jit
-;x
ViOla:ti'on,
o,f,
17O.S.
c.
:§
50S,i
18
'~J'.
S.
C'~
.~;§,
,:;tJ'1
S·
,(bl
(Jl.)
,and.
2.
De,fe;naan'it;."COllNITY
[].'I?'
O:FIFt:1fS~~
N!m~"'''fORK
------------------x
:C1·j\N,IEL
tot:.
:e.~I:M
l
be
i:Eli9'
dit"J:.;;{
~'i\rQ"rn
I
q;efose,Sl,
:~.:nd
Sla'j(.'S
tba.t.
b~
is.
a,
iSpe.ei.B!l~.e:nt.wi.t;h
t.P.t@l
tT.:B.
,OeparEIflIli8
i
nt
of
Homeland
Se;.curj'ty
J
lmrn.igra;t,io:n,a'lld.
CUa:t'OmS
En
f:orc,erne,nt,~
(:1.£
f
ioe'o;f
:Ho-rne,l~nd.
s~curit.y
I:nveiSt.iga,tians
{'L']LCiB-,H:5·I""}~,
and
c.JJ,a:rge:a
as
,fQ,LliDwa::
CQImrIONE
~Crirninal
,;r:'nfr.ing~m@ln,t
of.
iii
Cc·Wii.grn.t,)
'1~
:iF'rG'!m,a
'it:
l,ea.~t
in
o::r.anou't.
]D,ec:ember'
.2
O:JI..O
j
upt.o·
and
w~,ludin9'
in.
or
WJout;,
Jr:a'HulSLry'
:2
0
111
in
,t::hi'.:i::
out:.h~:rnD,i
st:'ri
Cl:1:;
of
N'eifi'l
'¥Q,lt"lk,a:t:!d
E!!
l:eE:!wbe.'l:E!!
I
:8'RlJUi',lM~CAR'THY
I
th,e
ije
f:e~nt;
unla'wiul'ly
s.
'will
fU:lly',
.i~t'Hd
knCi~:iif.l!g
1
y
di.d
inflr'i"ns·e~ciOpyri
gn:11::
::[01:
,plULrroo
~,i!:!:S
of
cotnllllerc
ia
1.fid!,van,ta,9'~
,and:I?iri.v'.:gj.
t,e,
f
inall:ci
a.Lg,a1
n;
and,
,by'
't:.'~!e
J;e-produo'j:
io~
~.:f~,'ddi,~'t::,~
bu;It,:;L,o:-n,
I
in~:J!;U8!.in91
b"/
elec
ti."Onic'
m€::ans
i
!QillrinS'
~iI1y
'19"0
-'day'
pe:r
i:oo,;
!iJf
'OiJ.1.e
andi,
JlifLO;reccp.ie,s,
and
~p.'Mno:r,a.U!Qrds
of:
Ol:lB
aTId
mo:re
oopyr.1,'ght@o;i3;,'\!iI'OlLks~'wh.::fi.dh
ihLa'V'ei
,i!!.
'tQIt.aJl
l:1et,a.:U
va.lue,
Q.f
more
th.an
g;,lrOO~~'
,and,
:by
't:ne
di,Bt,ri:but;
i,o.;n,ofa
wocr'lk:
be'i>n,g:prepi3lJ[ie.d,fol!;'
commer,c::i.BlldiS:'I;;r,ibutiQl1!1
by
lIl'!a'ki:ng'
it,
.ava11!!!!I~bl,e~a
C01i!\PlUt!2::r
,net,workaeeess'li:i
le,
tometrJberSi
0
f
the
publ
i.e
1
'whe.n
:MceARTHY
~ne,w
~d
ghculd,
hav,e
knoi;!'m,
t,i!.tat
:iti:!l@J
w.ork
W.;!!.:!;;I,n't;~nd9!d
£"0::["cOlil'lmllE!::E,C'i:f1Ll.
di:st.r-i
but
ion~
to
'wi
t,
,I
McC1!JtTH¥
·di
s
tt'
ibutaad·eopy~i'glh.t,
~'Pll:\ote;e
,ed
'sporting
ev:ent.
tel
eca!St.~
'a.ntl
Pat.;{'~',!l'?@;t"·-'Vi
eweV'·en,t,!l:O·Ve~
t:i'.I!e,
T:i'i,t.e:~n@:
t
wi.:I::JtO'Li,t;,
tJ;l~
~1..lIt~i:i:z
i!:i:.'ld.C{[1
'0.£
the
~ight
ful
co:pyr
ign·t
O\!FJilil!;!':r.',:$,
,'clC'
pe:rs,olfial
:pro,j;
lt.'
,t
'l''.i.'ELe11~tln!
ted
St;a..
t
e
S!
C'0d,g;~
g'!2i
eft;
i..
n
!S
(Ii;5:
f
T
it.,le
.l
a,
TJ'1'lIi.'I;.,~d
5'Htat:~,S·
'C,Qde:~
.s:e·~tilOns
4:"3
:t
5)
(b}
(,1).
~nd;:~'.)
Theba~e.:s,torIllY'
'k,no.w·I'E!dg'€l
and
the:fo:regoing'
c.'l\arge
are~
inpa.r'It.~all;
f!
0.110\'19~
:2~
.I
amag·peG
ia.lAgent
Wi'UlICE
-HS'I,.
and
I'
halVe
be.'en
1m-vol
veld
Lu
'Il:;be
inv,e;:,s
it;::i.
g-a
t
ion,
'0.
f
tItLE!
i!fI!atlt.
t:.er.,_
TM
infOirmat.io,R
co·nt.aLneain.
·t:h.i
saf
f
ictavl
t.
is..
based
upon
my
per,sonal
knowl€ldg0.
andrrL:YJr'ev,iew'of
docuf!l:t;!nt.a
and
.X'@Joords
'g.Eii!:tbe;r'eadU1:ingth...,e(;.;ou:t'se
o:f
t.hi,s:
.itt,"I\i'i!:;tiil
t.igat
i
on,
a,5
well
a:e!;.inf'orma.eion
e..bltained
I
dire!!;;!':ly
OJ::'
indi::r:,ec
t
1"y.
I
f·r,.OIiJI
o'tM·rsouree,B.:
and-
a:w'
e'il;f,o.rc-eft'len.t.
,agl2rl!.t:.S:...
Beca..u:se
thle
af';f'i,tlavit
i.:!:;i
,baing
sMmi'tt,ea.
:It)];
the
lim-i.ted
:.p'Q:t''pols.e.
of
'9,S
'tab'!
i.sh;i.:~'l9'robable
C:a.u,se~
it.
do
_:I!!!
n[J't.
il"l.c.lu,de:
a
11ofthe
fact,s
t.ha,t,·
I
'hve
1,e)Ia:rn,e;d
during
·the
co,urSe
Qf
tM
i'nv-estig,j,'t-ioll,
Wh.e~:
the
contE:::o.ta
Qf
-document
s
and
'the
act.Lcna,
is
tat
te,me.p;!:;s
and
conversat
i
I\i!1l
ofIErUler,s.
,Ei;r.~€I,
rspo,rt!ed,
be.:re
in~
'they'
arer<eporltedin
slibst,anc.:e
and
in
par.t
j
~:xGept.
wl1,sr€l.
othefl:7'wise1
ndl,ca,'t::ed.
::l"
I.nOraJO.out.
Dac,em'be:r
,2Cl'l·Q
I
ICE,-RSI
commlanc'lEd
an
i:n:v'Il11l,s;
t
bgat.
ion
in
t.o~,ert·a.ili':li.
'l;!J\@bs
i
t,§s
tha:t
we::t:'e,
eng'a,'g,ed
in
'the
illeg:<!l!.l
cl.i.;,'i'rt.r.ibu
t.:iionof
CQ'pyll:'ight:.~prot:e·rC
t€!il.
ccrreen
t
by
~,b;~a.ming
over'
tbe
Inl:.
'1"D.~t:
li.ve
s~o]ft.il.'lg
eVeIltt.elecas
t
a,
and
'l?ay·_
P@r~
Vi@;'1/11
ev"ent.s.,
:I
ltno1l!l
frOI
'my
pa:r.'ti,c;:1pation
in
't.be
in;ves:t.igation,'that
t.h.ii1!!
hO'.ldl@::t'"
of
the,cOPYlL"'i'gbts
·t'o
a.ll
ij:,e,l@.'V:i:siOfl.
D:r-oadcast;.:5l,and
footage
10
f
a.
p;gjj,re;l
mllarath.l.eti,c
eve-TIt:
:i.e!
the
aSia!o,~
i.13,.1i:.~
Ii
in.di
v.
id:ua.l
sport.s.l.ea.gui<!i~
'I'h~1
sporEsl,e.;a'g'uea
r-eJl.e-van;t
to
't:'ll!:is
compl,'int~.r·e:
th.~Nat'ii
o~al
flootl!.a11t..ea:gul!:
(the.
(i'NFL"')
r.
't.he
National
Baske:tbiiilll
A~:;;:ocia:tion
(the
"';N'B;A")
I
the
Nat.i,onal
aockey
hle'ague~
the.
....Nm.r
n)
J'
To!'lcrld
'H're,st,ing
:E:r;rtert~irnnen·t,(·t-be
'>'I:morE
I)
an,d,
01,1:
maA:,e
Figh.t,ing
Championship,(
the
''''Uf'c''''}
(c1olle;c
ti
ve£l.y
I
the
'!1L5agueii:l,~).~
I
al.~o,
klmw
[;~.t
thi3
iI'J.
8,.copyr:1ght
Act.
I'
Til:.le
l1~
'tllli
tedStat€1!'s
c.'Clde.
r
,sect.ions
101
j
!E!.t
s@q..
j
'giv€I;s
the:
lrolaerof
su;cheOPl"ri9-
:1:.s
·vcaJ.rious
~xell1sive
:righte:..
iucluding
t:he
right
t.o
!.'Jon'!:,rol
publ;i
c
;(;Iel":fo~aL1lL1'~.EI
a'nddi
str
ibu~i
on
Q
f
'thew,o'rks
In
turn
I
'I:l~.€l;
:Leagu,e.,B
enter
iID:t.O
c,on,'tr,a'ctual
a.rjC&n~"€;lrrll<i~lniE.,~·
wi
th.
t.e
JLe.v-JLs·;ll.on
,f.1il~rt"""O\rks·ueh
,a.s,
~:e.c
and.
'!S:fN.
whi
elipay
t-lhe:L~a'gues,f~eiS,for'
the
:r·i:gb.t.~
1:.0
br.!Qadcli.:Ei1:.
t,'(l:lecast,;E
Clf'
ithe.·:il'l;copyrighted
sport:.
i.rl$
e;ve:n'ts;~
,4..In
C)Q;r:m.E;N:;::tio!l]!
wi.th
t'ne
investig.a.,tio.tt
desoribli:!d!
above
j
I
knowtha.tICE-HS,I
se:i'z:~d,
ChillmeJ.,;:lUI"tinSJi.
net;"
'lJ;ogetbe:r
wi.th
nine
[otherwebs
i
t
e'B,
an
Or
a.bout
.F:ebruHl"Y
11
20:1,~
~rs'Uant
to,a
,s.,E:
i.~'iJ.':t;"e:
,'Ilar::raLn:e.
issued
b~y
the
Uh!
ted
s
tateo:§!
'Di-stric
t
COur.
for.
t.hB
Southern.D1
B
t:r.i,e.t
ct'
N'ew
Yorku_nde-r
T'i
tIe.
1
a
I
l:l'nit.lBc.
Stat,es,
Codle:"
S:!!;!:otions.
21126
fa)
(1)fA)~fB'and981.
(b)(tlletI'i''ebrua-r-y
:2
(i
11Sei.:zn•.
't:'e,i\I}.
.5_
Based,
on
my
pa.r,!:,j
C
ipa
tion
in
'the,
inve
at,igar.'t
iOiJi
l@ading-to
t;he
Feb:ru.a:t-y'~011,se.izu.re"I
know
that
C'll~nnE!!
i
sur:f
ing.netwasa;.;1
i!'lk.ing;ll
w€ibsi
te.Ba,!i;l!i=don
fIlY'
t:raining
aoo
e:xpe:t"ien'!:llra,
j[
mow
tba
t
'11
Jl.1nkl
ng"'"
we'i:;H3:itels
'!iEe;n,erall:ycol
Ie
c'!:,and
ea,t,alog1
inks,
't,o
f
1.19
S
~n
tbi.:ra
~ar'lt.y'We'tlsi-t'e:;l·
'thiilt,
cent.adn
illegal
eO'pile~;
of,
clop.yr
i!ghted
co.nti:!M:.'t:.
,inc.luding
sport.'
ngev~n.'t
S
andf/'alt=~er-'V'i.e'l,il
events.
Linking
w~-,bsit.es.
o:rgnni:z:e:tb,ese
:links
by
r
fore~pl,iEi:
I
s:po,rt
S:
typ€:;
or
sport'
ng'
even~
t
't::
0
'mak'
the:1.!Il.
[eaieily
;gjt<G':ces.a:,ible:,.
lJ's,e:t's
!Simply
;elic:lt
ona
link
too
beg'in,
tbE!!
p}."iQces.s,of
dc'Wn.laading
o.r
iElt:reaming
t:o[
t:~:1:r.
OWl'l
c:oi'C!P'Jlt,e:r
an
illegal
broadca.st
of
as:por1:.ing:
[e.v,ent
or'~ay',-per.-v'1'~w
'e'V@]l,'E
::E'rcm
tbet:hi~ro
pilrtywebe,i't.o:!
'I:.b.a't
i,Si
host;i:nSj:
the
s:treaclt!~
Linking
webs,itea,a,'re::po:pul
ii:t"
:be
r;;:a;~iS.e
't-b!e"?
~l"low
us~r9
t,!Q
quickl
y
b~owiS,e
c'ol':lre,ent
and,
lo.ca.t.:,;;;1.l1~
gal
l~iti!Ce'i~Jn!Sl
that
wOU
ld,o..'!.:.lierw,1
S€!!,
b~:
mo:rr:e:
dif'f1.c~IJlJl,t
to
find
through
manual!S<e'a.rches
of
the.
.I:FJ.t,e:t:"'"ne,t,',
l.inkin!ii'
w
Jos,j;tes
a,l,sa.
ott;€!]J],
m,llow'
USEl,rs
't.b
post,
'1ink
Ei
to
in.f~inSITiQgcon:ten,t,"
'i£•
P:ri:e!:r
'1:;,0
,th~:Febmary
:2
01
J!,
S'eizuril!,
I.
I
:piBlI':S!,ona
lJ_y
J:ev1ewl".O!~
the:·va!.1:'ioll!swe'bpages
t:ha..'1::
w.eire.
,a.va:1lab.1,e
at
't'~
Channel~'Ur::...tn9'.
netw'e:b.site.,:Ba,5ed
0',:"
tbat
rll:tvierH1'"
r
le.,azned
t.he,
f'oI1m""illH•a1i!'i.6ng
ot.her
'll:hingl'.9:'
a.~Pr'ior
'toO'
the'
F'ebrua.,r;r-'
.:lUIJI.'1
1S,e.
i
zare.,
w.hena
us€::r
ac:cestsed
t.he
Chta.:tm.@ls,ur'fing.n.et;.
webe!iite
I
'!th~:t
ust..:!r
'?J\8;S,
br,ou,g!'h.'t.,
[to
a
hO'mepa;ge",
wniCl'll
pr,ov1d.'@:d
links
'ito,
li;!e,levis'ion
and
mov,i,e
content;~
iijS
w.e,ll
as
d,aily
li.ve
spoer-tin!
'!3vent~,
anci
Pay-:e:e,;r-
V,iew
event
B•
'I'n
~ddi,t
iO'.fi
Ii'
ov,U'IlIerOUEil
adv.eft"t
i:S![em!!I:IJ.'t::E:
wer@.
Cii
s'pla:~f!!Eld,
in\il'ar
i
o.u~
10.
ca,t
Lonson,[~b:i!!lhOlJl!e-p~;ge,
!
b.Onadi3,Y'~o~~y:basi,a'J'l:.he'linksf'o'r~Qme
Q:f
't,l"letie
le-v.is
Lonprogra:ms
andbxoadc
aat
c:barm.e.l
s"woo.ldchan,gev'.r".(
1
.
t,t:
l,e..'
I
n
:Ea.'c:r~,
,th@l
i!,c,llowingwe:re
1.1:!;!!ed
on,a
cons
':stBn
t
r
,daily.
b8J.~is':
'iJo,south.
Pa;r:k,t'~
"T.:h'!2I
O:IE',£].ce
~.rr
'!;IoTn.ePokelt"
c:ha~l,
,Ii'
\io
E'SPN
,N
ij:KSl'mC
I'
HI
'Ii
'CNBC[,
lI'
and
'n~
N,sws;o,~
Eacn,
,0:
thofH~~!'
inkshad.
't-he
wo'rd
'I]j
,1
i
te,'"
di,~p-
ayed
ad'j
,ac[entto
the
Ib:!1::,
iMld
thli!
10910f'or
th~
,oorroe~,pondii!i.9
ne't""",'or.:kor
't
~'l~~
1!0ll.
15fl.I;;;'W'
WIS
alsodi.s,p,la.yed,-
By
l!i;i1I;,
l~(::t.,i
ngone
0
f
thS.S[i;
1
im;!er,"
'E.be.'Us
@::ir
was't,akiento
anew
C:ba,[uJ:~,J!.Elu;r'fing.
n~t:.
'W·indl.ow"
whic:b
ai,splayed
eh!:!!l
S8]_,~c:;E!€!:d.
teJl.ev.ision
content.or
'p~,ram".
,laE1lcau£.e:
the
ccnte~t.ran,
On,
?,
l;ILv,e
~tream
f,rom
,ang-tbe;t'
',!,;ebs
i
te
i
the~
e,l~cr..@d
show
dj
d
not;s'it;,artat
t:n-ebegrinn.ingof
'!:;.lle
p::bQ-!lram~,bu:t
I:'G!.
ther
:ran_
rOt'll.
what:~verr
po,in
t.
in.
[I:,he'
stream,
t;]18
,iEibo'W
W-8J,Si
,at
in~biitpa..;rt;lcul;G1.lr
'ItmOmen't:
in
tim,e.
In,
ad!ditien;
adv@'rti.sern.entEl,
w'ere.
perio.d
ieally'
'di.~pla::yedat
tbe
bottom
of
the
video'ciu.r1:ng
t'.Ail!!
li't'[EI~Brtrea.m~
thEH:ie
adve,rtisel'nen:ts
'~e:~e
sepa..rEl),t€t,
and
dIstinct:."
roOm
any
COI1!¥JL@rcia.l.s:
that
'i'lifly'
naV'1i1!1
app@ar,!!:dci'lJ'ringt:b..eet:t'iI!!!;an'Ii,
0.£
'eke,~po,rt,i,nq
e:'!f,ir-en.'I:,
b:r,oa.de.ast'.
