You are on page 1of 13
 
! # $ % & ' ( ) * !+ !! !# !$ !% !& !' !( !) !* #+ #! ## #$ #% #& #' #( #)
,-./0 1234535 672891-40: !
!"#$%& $()%&(%) *+,
-
 .
/
0
/
!!&#+ 4;<=>?@ .>ABC /;DEF !+! G?FH 1??FHC IDJKDHDA #$+&* L)+%M $%':*((+
0N3 N747.1O93 21./N1 PQ 836N214
 
1($)%! 2)+)%2 !$2)&$0) 0"1&) ,%2)%&( !$2)&$0) "3 ,+24$(5)"( +) 2%+))*%
NR74G N714GC AH DHBDSDB;A?C 8?ADHEDTTC S@Q 121U74Q672C -46QC A 5F?AVAJF <>JW>JAED>HC AHB -25OQ672C -46QC A 5F?AVAJF <>JW>JAED>HC 5FTFHBAHE@Q  4>Q #X!!:<S:+!(+*:2P8
 3$&2) +6%(!%! 0"6.*+$() 3"& !+6+5%2 +(! $(71(0)$8% &%*$%3 ,$)4 71&9 !%6+(!
8?ADHEDTT N;>HK N>AHKC YZ AHB E[J>;K[ [FJ ;HBFJ@DKHFB <>;H@F?C @EAEF@ A@ T>??>V@ ;W>H A<E;A? =H>V?FBKF VDE[ JF@WF<E E> [FJ@F?T AHB [FJ >VH A<E@ AHB ;W>H DHT>J\AED>H AHB YF?DFT A@ E> A?? >E[FJ \AEEFJ@ <>\W?ADHFB >T AKADH@E BFTFHBAHE@ 1\A]>HQ<>\C -H<QC A ^A@[DHKE>H <>JW>JAED>H L_1\A]>H`M AHB -25YQ<>\C -H<QC A 5F?AVAJF <>JW>JAED>H L_-25Y`MC L<>??F<EDSF?ZC _5FTFHBAHE@`MX
$/
 
(+)1&% "3 )4% 0+2%
!Q
 
1\A]>H D@ >HF >T E[F ?FABDHK -HEFJHFE <>\WAHDF@ DH E[F <>;HEJZQ 0[J>;K[ DE@ V[>??Z:>VHFB @;Y@DBDAJZC -25YC 1\A]>H WJ>SDBF@ TJFF A<<F@@ E> E[F V>J?Ba@ ?AJKF@E _-HEFJHFE 2>SDF 5AEAYA@F` AE E[F VFY@DEF VVVQD\BYQ<>\Q 0[F -HEFJHFE 2>SDF 5AEAYA@F D@ A SFJZ [AHBZ JF@;\F E>>? T>J F\W?>ZFJ@ DH E[F TD?\ AHB EF?FSD@D>H DHB;@EJZ A@ DE AEEF\WE@ E> ?D@E FSFJZ
Case 2:11-cv-01709-MJP Document 34 Filed 01/06/12 Page 1 of 13
 
! # $ % & ' ( ) * !+ !! !# !$ !% !& !' !( !) !* #+ #! ## #$ #% #& #' #( #)
,-./0 1234535 672891-40: #
!"#$%& $()%&(%) *+,
-
 .
/
0
/
!!&#+ 4;<=>?@ .>ABC /;DEF !+! G?FH 1??FHC IDJKDHDA #$+&* L)+%M $%':*((+
 NJ>B;<ED>H ;N>H OPD<P A OJDEFJC NFJQ>JRFJ >J <JFO RFRSFJ PA@ FTFJ O>J=FBU 9D=FOD@FC ;N:AHB:<>RDHK FHEFJEADHRFHE NJ>QF@@D>HA?@ JF?V >H EPF FWN>@;JF NJ>TDBFB SV EPF -HEFJHFE 2>TDF 5AEASA@F E> @FF= FRN?>VRFHE >NN>JE;HDEDF@ DH EPF FHEFJEADHRFHE DHB;@EJVU
 
#U
 
0PJ>;KP -25SC 1RAX>H A?@> >QQFJ@ A @;S@<JDNED>H @FJTD<F <A??FB Y-25S8J>CZ OPD<P NJ>TDBF@ YDHB;@EJV DH@DBFJZ DHQ>JRAED>H E> NAVDHK <;@E>RFJ@U -H >JBFJ E> @;S@<JDSF E> -25S8J>C 1RAX>H JF[;DJF@ <>H@;RFJ@ E> @;SRDE BFEAD?FB NFJ@>HA? AHB <JFBDE <AJB DHQ>JRAED>HC  N;JN>JEFB?V Q>J N;JN>@F@ >Q NJ><F@@DHK NAVRFHE Q>J EPF @;S@<JDNED>HU -25S8J> <>H@;RFJ@ A?@> R;@E A<<FNE -25S8J>U<>R\@ /;S@<JDSFJ 1KJFFRFHE AHB DH<>JN>JAEFB 8JDTA<V 8>?D<V LEPF Y/;S@<JDSFJ 1KJFFRFHEZMU -E D@ H>E N>@@DS?F Q>J A <>H@;RFJ E> @DKH ;N Q>J -25S8J> ODEP>;E  NJ>TDBDHK PD@ >J PFJ <JFBDE <AJB DHQ>JRAED>H AHB A<<FNEDHK EPF EFJR@ >Q EPF /;S@<JDSFJ 1KJFFRFHEU $U
 
0PF -25S8J> @;S@<JDNED>H NJ><F@@ N?ADH?V PA@ KJFAE <ANASD?DEV E> DHTABF EPF  NJDTA<V >Q EPF @;S@<JDSFJ@ AHB RD@ANNJ>NJDAEF EPFDJ NFJ@>HA? AHB <JFBDE <AJB DHQ>JRAED>HC @> 5FQFHBAHE@ K> >;E >Q EPFDJ OAV E> RA=F <>H@;RFJ@ QFF? @AQF AS>;E NJ>TDBDHK EPD@ PDKP?V <>HQDBFHEDA? DHQ>JRAED>HU ,>J FWARN?FC EPF Q>??>ODHK DHQ>JRAED>H ANNFAJ@ >H -25S8J>\@ @;S@<JDNED>H NAKF AHB]>J DH EPF /;S@<JDSFJ 1KJFFRFHE^
 
 
Y_F K;AJAHEFF EPAE FTFJV EJAH@A<ED>H V>; RA=F AE -25S8J>U<>R OD?? SF @AQFUZ
 
Y8AVRFHE NJ><F@@DHK D@ N>OFJFB SV 1RAX>HU<>RUZ
 
 
Y7;J @F<;JF @><=FE ?AVFJ L//9M @>QEOAJF D@ EPF DHB;@EJV @EAHBAJB AHB AR>HK EPF SF@E @>QEOAJF ATAD?AS?F E>BAV Q>J @F<;JF <>RRFJ<F EJAH@A<ED>H@U -E FH<JVNE@ A?? >Q V>;J  NFJ@>HA? DHQ>JRAED>H DH<?;BDHK <JFBDE <AJB H;RSFJC HARF AHB ABBJF@@ @> EPAE DE <AHH>E  SF JFAB A@ EPF DHQ>JRAED>H EJATF?@ >TFJ EPF -HEFJHFEUZ
 
 
Y-25S =H>O@ EPAE V>; <AJF P>O DHQ>JRAED>H AS>;E V>; D@ ;@FB AHB @PAJFBC AHB OF ANNJF<DAEF V>;J EJ;@E EPAE OF OD?? B> @> <AJFQ;??V AHB @FH@DS?VUZ
 
 
Y,;JEPFJC OPFHFTFJ OF BFA? ODEP ;@FJ DHQ>JRAED>HC OF OD?? A?OAV@ <>RN?V ODEP ANN?D<AS?F ?AO@ AHB JFK;?AED>H@ DH B>DHK @>UZ 5FQFHBAHE@ EP;@ AEEFRNE E> A@@;AKF NJDTA<V <>H<FJH@C S;E EPFDJ @EAEFRFHE@ AJF TAK;FC ARSDK;>;@C DHA<<;JAEF AHB ;HDHQ>JRAEDTF AS>;E 5FQFHBAHE@\ A<E;A? BAEA <>??F<ED>H AHB
Case 2:11-cv-01709-MJP Document 34 Filed 01/06/12 Page 2 of 13
 
! # $ % & ' ( ) * !+ !! !# !$ !% !& !' !( !) !* #+ #! ## #$ #% #& #' #( #)
,-./0 1234535 672891-40: $
!"#$%& $()%&(%) *+,
-
 .
/
0
/
!!&#+ 4;<=>?@ .>ABC /;DEF !+! G?FH 1??FHC IDJKDHDA #$+&* L)+%M $%':*((+
DHN>JOAED>H:PAHB?DHK QJ><FB;JF@C AHB OD@?FAB <>H@;OFJ@ DHE> EPDH=DHK EPAE EPFDJ QFJ@>HA? AHB <JFBDE <AJB DHN>JOAED>H D@ @ANF AHB RD?? SF ;@FB @>?F?T N>J Q;JQ>@F@ >N QJ><F@@DHK QATOFHEU
 
%U
 
9DEE?F B> -25S8J> @;S@<JDSFJ@ =H>RC H>J AJF EPFT ?D=F?T ARAJFC EPAE 5FNFHBAHE@ DHEFJ<FQEC @E>JFC JF<>JBC AHB ;@F EPF DHN>JOAED>H QJ>VDBFB B;JDHK EPF @;S@<JDQED>H QJ><F@@C DH<?;BDHK EPFDJ <JFBDE <AJB DHN>JOAED>HC E> JF@FAJ<P AHB <J>@@:JFNFJFH<F Q;S?D< JF<>JB@ AHB >EPFJ @>;J<F@ E> KAEPFJ A@ O;<P DHN>JOAED>H A@ Q>@@DS?F AS>;E FA<P DHBDVDB;A? @;S@<JDSFJC DH<?;BDHKC  S;E H>E ?DODEFB E>C PD@ >J PFJ ?FKA? HAOFC AKFC JA<FC KFHBFJC QFJ@>HA? @P>QQDHK AHB @QFHBDHK PASDE@C AHB -HEFJHFE A<EDVDETC RPD<P A<E@ AJF ;H=H>RH E> AHB H>E <>H@FHEFB E> ST EPF @;S@<JDSFJ@U &U
 
/;S@<JDSFJ@ RP> PAQQFH E> SF >HF >N EPF OD??D>H@ >N QF>Q?F ?D@EFB DH EPF -HEFJHFE 2>VDF 5AEASA@F @;NNFJ A @;S@EAHEDA? N;JEPFJ JD@= >N PAJO >N EPFDJ QJDVAEFC QFJ@>HA? DHN>JOAED>H  SF<>ODHK AVAD?AS?F E> EPF Q;S?D< AE RRRUDOBSU<>O AHB >EPFJ ANND?DAEFB AHB ;HANND?DAEFB RFS@DEF@ EPAE @DOQ?T <>QT AHB JFQ;S?D@P DHN>JOAED>H Q>@EFB AE RRRUDOBSU<>OU 'U
 
-H 8?ADHEDNNW@ <A@FC 5FNFHBAHE@ RFJF AS?F E> AHB BDB A<<F@@ 8?ADHEDNNW@ QFJ@>HA? AHB <JFBDE <AJB DHN>JOAED>H ST DHEFJ<FQEDHK AHB JF<>JBDHK PFJ <>HNDBFHEDA? F?F<EJ>HD< <>OO;HD<AED>H@ RDEP>;E >J SFT>HB PFJ <>H@FHEC N;JEPFJ ;@DHK EPAE DHN>JOAED>H E> <J>@@:JFNFJFH<F Q;S?D< JF<>JB@ AHB >EPFJ @>;J<F@ E> >SEADHC AO>HK >EPFJ EPDHK@C 8?ADHEDNNW@ ?FKA? HAOFC AKFC BAEF >N SDJEPC AHB >EPFJ QFJ@>HA?C <>HNDBFHEDA? DHN>JOAED>HC AHB OA=DHK @>OF >N EPAE ;H?ARN;??T:>SEADHFB <>HNDBFHEDA? DHN>JOAED>H AVAD?AS?F E> EPF Q;S?D< AE RRRUDOBSU<>O AHB >EPFJ ANND?DAEFB AHB ;HANND?DAEFB RFS@DEF@U (U
 
XT EPD@ QJA<ED<FC 5FNFHBAHE@ <>OODEEFB NJA;BC SJFA<PFB EPF EFJO@ >N EPF /;S@<JDSFJ 1KJFFOFHE AHB 8JDVA<T 8>?D<T FHEFJFB DHE> RDEP 8?ADHEDNNC AHB VD>?AEFB 8?ADHEDNNW@ @EAE;E>JT QJDVA<T AHB <>H@;OFJ QJ>EF<ED>H JDKPE@ A@ BF@<JDSFB PFJFDHU 8?ADHEDNN SJDHK@ EPD@ A<ED>H @FF=DHK BF<?AJAE>JTC DHY;H<EDVF AHB O>HFEAJT JF?DFN E> JFBJF@@ 5FNFHBAHE@W ;H?ARN;? <>HB;<EU
$$/
 
12&$3!$0)$"( +(! 4%(2%
)U
 
0PD@ 6>;JE PA@ >JDKDHA? Y;JD@BD<ED>H >VFJ EPD@ BD@Q;EF Q;J@;AHE E> #) ZU/U6U [ !$$#C SF<A;@F EPF Q?ADHEDNN D@ A <DED\FH >N A BDNNFJFHE @EAEF NJ>O EP>@F >N A?? BFNFHBAHE@C AHB EPF AO>;HE DH <>HEJ>VFJ@T F]<FFB@ ^(&C+++U *U
 
0PD@ 6>;JE PA@ QFJ@>HA? Y;JD@BD<ED>H >VFJ BFNFHBAHE 1OA\>H SF<A;@F DE D@
Case 2:11-cv-01709-MJP Document 34 Filed 01/06/12 Page 3 of 13

Reward Your Curiosity

Everything you want to read.
Anytime. Anywhere. Any device.
No Commitment. Cancel anytime.
576648e32a3d8b82ca71961b7a986505