Before

The Copyright Office
Library of Congress

In the Matter of )
)
Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention ) Docket No. RM 2011-7
of Copyright Protection Systems for )
Access Control Technologies )







Reply Comments of Public Knowledge










Public Knowledge
1818 N St. NW
Suite 410
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 861-0020


March 2, 2012

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&
!"#$%&'(#)%"*+"&*,'--+$.*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*0!
1)2('22)%"*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*3!
4/! 567*879)2#7$*:'2#*;%"2)&7$*56)2*<=7->#)%"*)"*?)96#*%@*;'$$7"#*;%"&)#)%"2/*//////*3!
A/! 567*87B'72#7&*<=7->#)%"*!->%272*4*:)")-+C*A'$&7"*%"*;%>.$)96#*DE"7$2/*///*3!
"#! $%&&'()*"%+!,'*-''+!)..'//!.%+*&%(/!)+0!0"1"*)(!0"/*&",2*"%+!"/!+%*!+'.'//)&"(3!
.)2/)*"%+#!############################################################################################################################################################!4!
""#! 5')&/!*6)*!*6"/!'7'89*"%+!-%2(0!"+.&')/'!2+)2*6%&":'0!&'9&%02.*"%+/!%;!8%*"%+!
9".*2&'/!)&'!2+-)&&)+*'0#!###########################################################################################################################!<!
"""#! =6"/!'7'89*"%+!&'>2'/*!-"((!+%*!'("8"+)*'!$??#!######################################################################!@!
"A#! =6'!9&%9%/'0!.()//!"/!)0'>2)*'(3!&';"+'0#!#################################################################################!B!
A#! =6'!/9'.*'&!%;!92,(".!.%+;2/"%+!6)2+*"+1!*6"/!9&%.''0"+1!82/*!,'!,)+"/6'0#!############!C!
;/! 567*879)2#7$*F+2*#67*4G)C)#.*#%*<H+C'+#7*#67*?79)#)-+(.*%@*I7$2%"+C*,>+(7*
,6)@#)"9/*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*0J!
1/! 4C#7$"+#)H72*#%*;)$('-H7"#)%"*+$7*!"+&7B'+#7/*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*03!
"#! ?.&''+!&'.%&0"+1!)+0!.)9*2&'!)&'!"+)0'>2)*'!/%(2*"%+/#!####################################################!DE!
""#! ?2,/.&"9*"%+!)+0!.%29%+!/%(2*"%+/!)&'!)(/%!"+)0'>2)*'!/%(2*"%+/#!##############################!D4!
;%"(C'2)%"*///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*0K!


1
Introduction and Summary

Public Knowledge submits the following reply comments in this proceeding and
urges the Register to recommend that the Librarian of Congress grant the requested
exemption. Nothing in the comments submitted by others (in particular, the Joint
Comments of AAP, ASMP, MPAA, et al. and the DVD Copy Control Association)
rebuts the underlying legitimacy of consumers’ desire to space shift motion pictures they
own on DVD, users’ need to circumvent technical protection measures in order to do so,
or the conclusion that granting the exemption would have a minimal, if any, impact on
online copyright infringement.
These reply comments address several arguments raised by other commenters.
The granting of the requested exemption does not burden copyright holders – the ability
for deliberate infringers to create illicit copies is not enhanced by granting the exemption,
nor would lawful users circumventing access controls increase the number of infringing
reproductions. The requested exemption is narrowly drawn, and consumers who have
purchased DVDs and desire to space shift them will not be confused by this rulemaking
into assuming that illegal downloads of motion pictures are suddenly fair game. In
addition, the Register is fully capable of recognizing the noninfringing nature of a use
without requiring that some federal litigation have mirrored the facts of the proposed
exemption. Finally, proposed alternatives to the exemption, including camcording,
screen capture, and repurchase of motion pictures as downloads, are inadequate
substitutes for the ability for consumers to circumvent access controls for the lawful
purpose of space shifting.
2
Discussion

A. The Register Must Consider This Exemption in Light of Current Conditions.

Paradoxically, Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA)
1
and the DVD
Copy Control Association (DVD CCA)
2
are correct both when they insist that the
Register must review each exemption independently of past determinations and when
they extensively cite the Register’s prior findings. If societal conditions have changed
since previous rulemakings, the Register, and the public, would be ill served by relying
on inaccurate, out-of-date findings. However, if prior recommendations contain
determinations based on underlying facts that have not changed, it is reasonable for the
Register to consult those conclusions.

B. The Requested Exemption Imposes A Minimal Burden on Copyright Owners.

As the Register recognized in the 2010 proceeding, the connection between CSS
and the availability of motion pictures in digital formats is tenuous.
3
Circumvention tools
have long been available online, and MPAA member studios regularly recognize that
CSS-protected DVDs are already the source of illegal reproductions of motion pictures
available online.
4


1
Joint Comments of AAP, ASMP, BSA, ESA, MPAA, PACA, and RIAA (MPAA
Comments). Although the MPAA filed jointly with a number of rightsholders, Public
Knowledge will refer to these comments as the comments of the MPAA alone on the
assumption that, of all of the Joint Commenters, only the MPAA has a specific interest in
motion pictures contained on DVD.
2
Comments of the DVD Copy Control Association (DVD CCA Comments).
3
See Recommendation of the Register of Copyrights in RM 2008-8; Rulemaking on
Exemptions from Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for
Access Control Technologies (June 11, 2010) at 57, 71-72, available at
http://www.copyright.gov/1201/2010/initialed-registers-recommendation-june-11-
2010.pdf (2010 Rec.).
4
See Public Knowledge Comments, 16-20.
3
It must be acknowledged that DVD CSS has been compromised for over a decade.
From a technical standpoint, it no longer prevents unauthorized reproductions of motion
pictures contained on DVDs. However, the existence of CSS can provide additional legal
protections for motion pictures distributed on DVD. The Digital Millennium Copyright
Act (DMCA) gives rightsholders an additional legal avenue of recourse to punish those
who make unauthorized copies of motion pictures.
Unfortunately, that legal protection can be construed broadly. Congress
recognized this and granted the Librarian of Congress, upon recommendation of the
Register and the Copyright Office, the authority to intervene in instances where the
powers created by the DMCA extend beyond discouraging wrongdoing and instead
prevent legitimate activity. That is the purpose of this proceeding, and of Public
Knowledge’s requested exemption. Public Knowledge is not seeking the elimination of
CSS, nor of the ability that rightsholders have under the DMCA to punish its
circumvention for unlawful purposes. Instead, Public Knowledge merely hopes to
remove DMCA provisions that serve as a barrier to the legitimate activity of space
shifting motion pictures contained on DVD.

i. Correlation between access controls and digital distribution is not
necessarily causation.

Both the MPAA and DVD CCA describe the growth of digital media distribution
as a function of the availability of legal protections for access controls.
5
However, while
the rise of the digital marketplace for media is temporally correlated with the
implementation of the DMCA, direct causation is less clear.

5
See MPAA Comments at 8-9; DVD CCA Comments at 2.
4
Digital distribution of media existed, and was even widespread, before the DMCA.
Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) members first released music on
digital compact discs almost twenty years prior to the passage of the DMCA.
6
MPAA
members released the first motion picture on DVD in early 1997, well before the passage
of the DMCA.
7

More recently, content owners have begun the process of shifting away from
distributing all of their content with access controls. Once one of the most vocal
supporters of access controls, the music industry has virtually abandoned it in recent
years.
8
In December of 2011, comedian Louis C.K. released a wildly successful concert
film without any sort of access controls.
9
Similarly, the show runner of the ABC
Television-produced sitcom Cougar Town has released access control-free versions of
unaired shows to fans.
10

It is impossible to prove how digital media distribution would or would not have
evolved in the absence of legal protections for access controls. Public Knowledge merely
urges the Register not to simply assume that, in the absence of legal protection for access
controls, no rightsholders would feel comfortable distributing content in a digital format.

6
Sony History: A Great Invention 100 Years On http://www.sony.net/Fun/SH/1-
20/h5.html (accessed via The Internet Archive).
7
See Lawrence B. Johnson, Could the DVD Possibly Live UP to Its Hype? Yes, N.Y.
Times, April 13, 1997.
8
See Cary Sherman, Chairman & CEO, RIAA, Comments, Questions, Concerns: RIAA
CEO Reflects On Reponses To His New York Times Op-Ed, Feb. 23, 2012,
http://riaa.com/blog.php?content_selector=riaa-news-blog&content_selector=riaa-news-
blog&blog_selector=RIAA-CEO-Reflects-
&news_month_filter=2&news_year_filter=2012.
9
See Louis CK – Live at the Beacon Theater.
10
See Bill Lawrence: A Modern Day Show-Runner, The Business, Feb. 13, 2012,
http://www.kcrw.com/etc/programs/tb/tb120213bill_lawrence_a_mode.
5
In fact, considering the current state of CSS, one could argue that MPAA member studios
have been doing just that for a decade.
ii. Fears that this exemption would increase unauthorized reproductions of
motion pictures are unwarranted.

The MPAA and DVD CCA express concern that Public Knowledge’s requested
exemption would lead to an increase in unauthorized reproductions of copyrighted
works.
11
This concern suggests a fundamental misunderstanding of both the current
availability of unauthorized reproductions online and the essential nature of digital
technology.
As Public Knowledge explained in its exemption request, drawing primarily on
sources attributable to MPAA members, we already live in a world with the
“unauthorized distribution of a large number of unauthorized copies”
12
of motion
pictures.
13
It is hard to imagine that the Register’s decision in this proceeding could have
any impact on the number of unauthorized copies of motion pictures available to the
public.
This is a result of the essential nature of digital technology. While the number of
“sources” is incredibly relevant to the availability of unauthorized copies of physical
goods, it is a nonsensical way to think about the availability of digital goods. Digital files
can be copied quickly and easily. For all intents and purposes, once there is one file “in
the wild” there are one thousand, or one million, files.

11
See MPAA Comments at 35, DVD CCA Comments at 26-29.
12
DVD CCA Comments at 33.
13
Public Knowledge Comments at 16-21.
6
MPAA member studio Paramount’s ability to track the source of unauthorized
reproductions to a single source is a vivid illustration of this.
14
Once there was a single
copy of Star Trek available at a given quality level and language, there was no need for
the public to find a second source. The file from that original source was simply
replicated as needed. It was only displaced when a higher quality file appeared online.
That is how the Chief Operating Officer of Paramount Pictures was able to trace specific
copies – first Russian, then Filipino, then Ukrainian, and so on – as the files propagated
across the internet.
15

The fact that Public Knowledge recognizes this reality should not be viewed as
any sort of endorsement of copyright infringement. Unauthorized reproductions of
copyrighted works are illegal, and in a perfect world would never happen. However,
suggesting that an exemption allowing personal space shifting would somehow increase
the number of unauthorized copies available to the public ignores current realities –
realities that MPAA members are happy to detail in most other forums.
Furthermore, MPAA’s assertion that “Congress also recognized, however, that
access controls ‘support new ways of disseminating copyrighted materials to users, and to
safeguard the availability of legitimate uses of those material to individuals’”
16
is correct,
but not clearly relevant to this proceeding. Motion pictures have been distributed on
DVD for over a decade, and CSS has been compromised for almost as long. It is hard to
imagine that granting the public a narrow exemption to facilitate personal space shifting

14
Id. at 18-19.
15
Id.
16
MPAA Comments at 8 (quoting Staff of House Committee on the Judiciary, 105th
Cong., Section-By-Section Analysis of H.R. 2281 as Passed by the United States House
of Representatives on August 4, 1998 (Comm. Print 1998), reprinted in 46 J. COPYRIGHT
SOC’Y U.S.A. 635 (1999).
7
could be the decision that finally convinces MPAA member studios to abandon support
for the format.
iii. This exemption request will not eliminate CSS.

Public Knowledge has no intention of using this proceeding to undermine the
general use of technical protection measures, or to end the practice of protecting motion
pictures on DVDs with CSS. Public Knowledge is merely concerned that the current
combination of section 1201 and CSS prevents the public from engaging in otherwise
lawful activity.
Nothing in the requested exemption would change the ability of MPAA member
studios from pursuing individuals who circumvent CSS for illegitimate purposes. The
exemption would not suddenly make it legal to circumvent CSS for the purposes of
publicly distributing a motion picture.
DVD CCA points to discussion in its case against Kaleidescape, Inc. to legitimize
its concerns about the integrity of CSS.
17
However, the facts at issue in Kaleidescape
18

are beyond the scope of this proceeding. Kaleidescape dealt with an alleged contractual
breach regarding the CSS license by a hardware manufacturer. Kaleidescape was not
trying to circumvent a technological protection measure in order to make a personal copy
– an activity within the scope of section 1201(a)(1)(A) – and thus would not be covered
by any exemption issued by the Librarian. Kaleidescape was not trying to circumvent
technological protection measures at all – it specifically designed its system to maintain
the sanctity of CSS.
19
Furthermore, even if Kaleidescape was interested in manufacturing

17
DVD CCA Comments at 27-28.
18
DVD CCA, Inc. v. Kaleidescape, Inc., 176 Cal. App. 4th 697 (2009).
19
Id. at 704.
8
a device that could circumvent an access control, that activity would implicate section
1201(a)(2), not section 1201(a)(1)(A). As such, the court’s opinions on the potential
impact of Kaleidescape’s activities on the effectiveness of CSS are not relevant to this
proceeding.
CCA’s characterization of the court’s finding as illustrating “the fact that licensed,
compliant DVD playback products continue to dominate the marketplace,
notwithstanding the availability of ‘hack’ programs through rogue websites” further
unnecessarily clouds the issue in this proceeding.
20
There is nothing in the DMCA to
suggest that Congress was concerned with stymieing alternative ways to view motion
pictures, or that the relative success or failure of those existing playback products should
have any impact on the public’s ability to make legitimate use of motion pictures that
they have legally purchased.


iv. The proposed class is adequately refined.

Public Knowledge’s proposed exemption is not so broad as to swallow the rule
against circumvention. In fact, the exemption is precisely tailored to address a single
legitimate need: that of individuals to make personal copies of motion pictures they own
on DVD in order to watch them on other devices that they also own.
21

This exemption is precisely as narrowly tailored as the exemption put forward as
a paradigm of precision by the CCA, that for “motion pictures in the educational library
of a college of university’s film or media studies department, when circumvention is
accomplished for the purpose of making compilations of portions of those works for

20
DVD CCA Comments at 29.
21
See Public Knowledge Comments at 1.
9
educational use in the classroom.”
22
Both exemptions begin by implication with the
entire universe of motion pictures available on DVD, and move quickly to limit that
universe to motion pictures purchased by the relevant individual or institution. Tying
circumvention to a legitimate purpose – noncommercial space shifting or educational
compilations – further refines that limitation. While CCA is correct that education is a
purpose explicitly enumerated in the statute, the relevance of that enumeration is
diminished significantly by the fact that it is part of one factor among five to be
considered, the fifth of which is the open ended “such other factors as the Librarian
considers appropriate.”
23
There is nothing in the statute to suggest that Congress
intended to limit exemptions to purposes specifically enumerated in section
1201(a)(1)(C), and much to suggest that it did not.

v. The specter of public confusion haunting this proceeding must be banished.

According to CCA, the proposed exemption will lead to widespread “public
confusion” and the total breakdown of the marketplace for digital goods.
24
Once again,
CCA suggests that the public is so feebleminded as to be unable to wrap its collective
mind around a limited exemption to the DMCA’s anticircumvention provisions.
25
As
recounted in Public Knowledge’s exemption request, this baseless concern was dismissed
by the Register in 2010 and there is nothing to suggest that evaluation is incorrect
today.
26
The public makes the distinction between authorized and unauthorized copying
on a regular basis. To cite an obvious example, the public recognizes the difference

22
DVD CCA Comments at 33.
23
17 U.S.C. § 1201(a)(1)(C)(v).
24
Id.
25
DVD CCA Comments at 35-36.
26
Public Knowledge Comments at 9.
10
between copying a song from a CD to an iPod and illegally downloading a song from the
internet. Copying a motion picture from a DVD to an iPod is not so fundamentally
different as to completely upend that distinction.

C. The Register Has the Ability to Evaluate the Legitimacy of Personal Space
Shifting.

As the Register has recognized in prior recommendations, the statutory
requirement to evaluate exemptions necessarily requires a degree of independent
examination.
27
Nothing in the statute has changed since 2010 to alter this conclusion.
Taken to its logical extreme, an edict to restrict exemptions to activities explicitly
allowed in either statute or case law would render this entire process a nullity. This is
especially true with exemptions relating to fair use. By its very nature, fair use requires a
case by case analysis that balances a number of facts. While a legal determination is
binding on the individual parties involved, any broader application necessarily requires
additional evaluation and analysis.
The plain language of the statute anticipates that the Register evaluate whether or
not the exemption involves a noninfringing use. The Register is tasked with producing a
recommendation, after consulting with other agencies, that contains a determination “of
whether persons who are users of a copyrighted work are, or are likely to be in the
succeeding 3-year period, adversely affected” by the prohibitions in section
1201(a)(1)(A).
28
The process of recommending, consulting, determining, and speculating
necessarily requires the Register to draw conclusions beyond parroting the statute and
existing case law.

27
See 2010 Rec. at 49-53, 91-100, 183-186.
28
17 U.S.C. § 1201(a)(1)(C) (emphasis added).
11
In the past, the Register has correctly evaluated the applicability of fair use to
requested exemptions:
“If, for example, based on a review and application of the statutory factors
set forth in Section 107 and a review and analysis of judicial precedents,
the Register and Librarian conclude that a particular use, although never
before adjudicated in courts, is a fair use, the Librarian may designate a
class of works based upon the conclusion that the use in question is fair if
all the other requirements for designating the class have been satisfied.”
29

The Register’s ability to consider fair use in this proceeding does not mean that it
is standing in for judicial review of a specific activity. The requested exemption only
applies to the extent that the underlying activity (in this case, noncommercial personal
space shifting of motion pictures contained on DVD) does not conflict with copyright law.
If a court were to find noncommercial personal space shifting of motion pictures
contained on DVD to be an infringement, the Register’s determination that this
exemption was warranted would offer the infringing party no protection from a copyright
infringement action.
Confident in its evaluative power, the Register would be correct to determine that
noncommercial personal space shifting of motion pictures contained on DVD constitutes
a fair use.
30
Commenters MPAA and DVD CCA have been unable to suggest any
justification or cite to any case law that would lead to a contrary conclusion. Although
MPAA does make mention of UMG Recordings, Inc. v. MP3.com, Inc.,
31
that case does
not address the question of personal space shifting.
32
MP3.com examined the legality of
a service purchasing recordings on CD and then making those recordings available to

29
2010 Rec. at 12.
30
See Public Knowledge Comments at 3-7.
31
92 F.Supp.2d 349 (S.D.N.Y. 2000).
32
MPAA Comments at 49.
12
consumers, not of consumers purchasing recordings on CD and making them available to
themselves.
It would be incorrect to view a shortage of recent case law on the topic of
personal space shifting as an indication that it is a legally questionable activity. In fact, it
suggests just the opposite. Personal space shifting is widespread and has been practiced
openly for a number of years.
33
MPAA’s co-filer, RIAA, has all but endorsed the
practice in front of the Supreme Court.
34
High-ranking employees of MPAA member
studios openly discuss their own personal space shifting.
35
Both MPAA and RIAA have
extensive partnerships with Apple to distribute their content through the iTunes program
– a program that incorporates the ability to space shift songs from CD to a computer. It is
reasonable to assume that the reluctance of large rightsholders to attempt to punish
personal space shifters does not flow from an absence of opportunity, but rather from the
confidence that such an attempt would end in failure.

D. Alternatives to Circumvention are Inadequate.

If we have not, as the MPAA insists, “entered a ‘pay-per-use’ society where each
use of a copyrighted work demands payment,” it is not for lack of trying on its part. The
requested exemption applies exclusively to motion pictures that individuals have already
lawfully acquired – most likely by paying for them. However, every alternative to
circumvention proposed by MPAA and DVD CCA requires an individual to pay an
additional fee to access a motion picture he already lawfully owns a copy of.
i. Screen recording and capture are inadequate solutions.

33
Public Knowledge Comments at 7.
34
Id. at 6-7.
35
Id. at 7.
13

Instead of simply copying the contents of a DVD to another device, DVD CCA
suggests two alternatives. The first is that users re-film their motion picture and then
engage in post-production editing and enhancement. The second is to make use of screen
capture software.
Both of these alternatives are inferior to the simple act of dragging and dropping
files from a DVD to another device. They require significant investments in time,
equipment, and expertise.
36
Even then, the final product is a poor substitute for an exact
digital copy that would be possible if the Register were to grant this exemption.
The need for quality extends beyond the walls of media studies classes and
documentary editing rooms. MPAA member studios do not spend millions of dollars on
set designers, costume designers, makeup artists, and others in order to satisfy media
studies professors and documentary film makers. The time, money, and effort that goes
into creating small details in motion pictures is done for the benefit of the general movie-
going public. It is nonsensical to deprive individuals who have lawfully acquired motion
pictures on DVD of the rich nuance that these details bring by forcing them to re-film the
motion picture with their mobile phone.
The example of transferring music from CD to other devices is instructive. The
process of making an exact digital copy is almost instantaneous. No one proposes that
individuals play their CD on a stereo and set up microphones to re-record the sound.
Similarly, no one should be required to do the equivalent in order to make a legitimate
copy of a motion picture.
ii. Subscription and coupon solutions are also inadequate solutions.

36
Id. at 11-16.
14

MPAA and DVD CCA also suggest that consumers could make use of other
services to access motion pictures on other devices.
37
While Public Knowledge
commends studios for working to make motion pictures available to consumers in ways
they want, these solutions are inadequate substitutes for simply making use of motion
pictures that consumers already own on DVD.
As an initial matter, all of the suggestions put forward by MPAA and DVD CCA
fail to recognize two important points. First, this exemption includes motion pictures that
consumers have lawfully acquired. In almost all cases, this means that the consumer has
already paid for the motion picture in question. Additional payments, especially when
they represent a significant percentage of the original purchase price, should only be
required if no other reasonable option is available. That is surely not the case here.
Second, and perhaps more importantly, motion pictures are not fungible.
38
The
fact that another movie may or may not be available is not relevant to a consumer who
made an affirmative decision to acquire a specific motion picture. A date night built
around Something Borrowed will not be the same if it is switched out for Saving Private
Ryan. A child who wants to watch Toy Story 3 will not be satisfied with Good Night, and
Good Luck. The fact that a movie may be available is of no concern to someone who
wants to watch the movie she has lawfully acquired.

37
DVD CCA Comments at 4-7; Comments of MPAA at 49-50.
38
See, e.g. United States v. Loew’s Inc., 371 U.S. 38 at 48 (1962). While collections of
motion pictures, such as those available through services such as Netflix and Hulu may in
some cases present consumers roughly comparable choices, that choice is not at issue in
this proceeding. This exemption focuses on specific, individual motion pictures lawfully
acquired by individuals.
15
The individuals who have weighed in during this proceeding often own tens, or
even hundreds, of individual motion pictures on DVD.
39
They chose each of these
motion pictures individually. These consumers did not walk into a store, or log on to an
online retailer and say “here is some money – just give me anything.” The number and
selection of movies available on digital services thus has a very real effect on whether
they could, even absent additional costs, serve as an alternative to consumers format-
shifting their own media.
a. Subscription Services

Although subscription services such as Netflix and Hulu can provide value for
consumers, that value is not equivalent to the ability to make noncommercial personal
copies of motion pictures already own on DVD.
First, while these services do have thousands of motion pictures available, they do
not have all, or even most, motion pictures available on DVD. This is true both of
popular new releases and of niche titles that appeal to small, dedicated fan bases.
Furthermore, MPAA member studios are constantly changing the motion pictures that are
included in the catalog of any streaming service. Even if an individual was interested in
using the subscription service as a substitute for personal space shifting and that
subscription service contained that motion picture in its catalog, there is no guarantee that
the title would be available in the future. Of course, motion pictures that an individual
owns are not subject to such seemingly random fluctuation.

39
See attached Appendix.
16
Second, subscription streaming services rely on an always-on high speed internet
connection. All too often, this is not available.
40
While carriers are beginning to roll out
high speed wireless data networks capable of streaming reasonably high (although
usually not DVD) quality video, those networks are often crippled with restrictive data
caps that functionally prevent any consumer from streaming more than a single motion
picture in a month – if that.
41
Moreover, these networks are expensive to access and are
far from ubiquitous. For instance, high-speed internet access is unavailable in remote
areas of the country, on airplanes, and in many foreign countries – all excellent examples
of places where individuals might prefer to take a single device containing a number of
motion pictures they already own.
Third, it is hard to rationalize MPAA’s insistence that these services obviate the
“need to ‘purchase’ a copy of a movie at all” while, in the prior sentence, noting that
these services require consumers to pay “low, subscription prices.”
42
For the purposes of
this exemption, the precise nature of the transaction is not as relevant as the fact that a
transaction exists. There is no getting around the fact that MPAA’s suggestion for
consumers who wish to access motion pictures they own on DVD on other devices is for
them to pay again. Regardless of the nature of the payment, the end result is the same: a
second payment going to an MPAA member studio to access the same motion picture.
b. DVD2Blu


40
See, e.g. FCC, Seventh Broadband Progress Report and Order on Reconsideration, GN
Docket No. 10-159 (May 20, 2011) at ¶ 23.
41
See Michael Weinberg, 4G+Data Caps = Magic Beans (Aug. 2011); see also
www.WhatIsMyCap.org.
42
MPAA Comments at 50.
17
Alternatively, MPAA points to member studio Warner Bros.’ “DVD2Blu”
program as an example of the legitimate alternatives available to consumers. The
suggestion that a DVD couponing program is a reasonable substitute for this exemption is
ridiculous. Public Knowledge only comments on it here because it highlights MPAA’s
inability to recognize the purpose of this exemption.
43

Warner Bros.’ DVD2Blu program essentially turns consumers’ existing DVDs
into coupons that can be exchanged for discounts on a handful of Warner Bros.’ back
catalog titles.
44
In order to participate in the program, consumers send any motion picture
on DVD in to Warner.
45
That allows them to purchase a motion picture on Blu-Ray at a
discounted price (between $4.95 and $6.95, plus shipping). It is possible that, in order to
make use of this new disc, the consumer would also have to purchase a Blu-Ray player
and/or a Blu-Ray drive. An unknown number of those Blu-Ray discs come bundled with
“digital copy,” a service that allows a limited version of space shifting.
Perhaps the most striking way that DVD2Blu fails to provide a reasonable
substitute for the requested exemption is that it is limited to only 100 motion pictures.
Further, that number overestimates any individual’s capability to participate in the project
by 400%. No household can purchase more than 25 motion pictures through the
program.
46
Numerous comments in this proceeding describe ownership of tens, if not
hundreds, of DVDs. The likelihood that a significant number of those motion pictures

43
This shortcoming is especially curious in light of the fact that both MPAA and DVD
CCA comments highlight attempts to build functionality similar to the requested
exemption – but in no way resembling DVD2Blu – into the Blu-Ray protection scheme.
44
The most recent film in the program was released in 2008.
45
See Blu-ray Upgrade Program FAQs, http://www.dvd2blu.com/faq.html.
46
http://www.dvd2blu.com/faq.html
18
will overlap with the 25 that the commenters would be able to obtain through this
program is vanishingly small.
Finally, when put in context, the cost of this program is significant. If a consumer
were able to find 25 discs that interested them in Warner Bros.’ offering, it would cost
them at least an additional $123.75 (lucky for them, purchases over $35 receive free
shipping). For many motion pictures, $4.95 is virtually identical to the price to purchase
a digital copy from a site like Amazon.com.
47

Conclusion

Public Knowledge commends MPAA and DVD CCA for working to provide
consumers a variety of ways to access motion pictures. It is undeniable that there are
more ways to access motion pictures digitally today than at the time of the first
proceeding in 2000. It is especially encouraging that MPAA and DVD CCA appear to
recognize the legitimate desire of consumers to space shift motion pictures they own in
developing technical protection measures for Blu-Ray.
However, this exemption request does not address motion pictures available on
streaming services, or next generation physical media. This request specifically
addresses motion pictures lawfully acquired on DVD and should be considered in that
context. And that context argues strongly for the Librarian to grant the requested
exemption.
For over a decade, DVD has been the most popular medium to distribute motion
pictures to the public. For years many motion pictures – new and classic, mass market

47
For example, DVD3Blu offers the title American History X for $4.95. Amazon.com
offers the same title as a digital file for $4.99.
19
and niche – were only made available on DVD. As a result, consumers have purchased
millions of motion pictures on DVD.
48

The widespread compromise of DVD CSS had no impact on that trend.
49
For
almost as long as consumers have been able to purchase motion pictures on DVD, they
have had the technical means to circumvent CSS. Arguments suggesting that this
exemption would somehow release pent-up demand to circumvent CSS, or add “more”
copies of unauthorized motion pictures online simply ignore reality. CSS no longer
imposes any restraint on individuals intent on making unauthorized copies of motion
pictures. Today, the only acts that CSS prevents are those of law-abiding individuals
who wish, for example, to space shift motion pictures contained on DVDs they lawfully
acquired.
The proposed exemption is narrowly tailored to address that specific situation. It
does not cover individuals intent on illegally distributing copies of motion pictures (either
online or on physical media). It would not “confuse” the public by suggesting that
unauthorized widespread distribution of copyrighted works is somehow legal.
As noted in the original exemption request, the Register is in an enviable position.
Evaluating this exemption requires balancing an unquestionable public good against a
total absence of harm to rightsholders. The day after this exemption is granted, copyright
infringement will still be illegal. Circumventing technical protection measures for
illegitimate purposes will still be illegal. The only thing that will change is that
consumers will finally be able to make use of motion pictures on DVD the same way they

48
Public Knowledge Comments at 2.
49
See id. at 20-21.
20
make use of musical works on CD – as works they have lawfully acquired and are free to
move to whatever personal device is most convenient.


Respectfully submitted

Public Knowledge
1818 N St. NW, Suite 410
Washington, DC 20036




! "!
APPENDIX

This appendix contains 395 statements from individual users who wish to be able
to space shift motion pictures from DVDs they have lawfully acquired onto their digital
devices for their personal use. Their individual personal comments on the issue, if any,
follow the first two paragraphs of their statements. The statements are followed by
illustrative lists of the motion pictures they own on DVD.
! !
2

Iustin Aplin
0vieuo, Floiiua
S276S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iustin Aplin

S
juuy savaiu
laona, Wisconsin
S4S41

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

juuy savaiu

4
Asbuiy Williams
Kansas
67114

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Asbuiy Williams

S
uaiy Ehilich
2u8Su

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uaiy Ehilich

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

A Nighty Winu
Buckaioo Banzai
Boctoi Who (new seiies)
Saiah Iane Auventuies
Rush in Rio
Rush RSu
6
Chailes Phillips
Boonville, Nissouii
6S2SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chailes Phillips

7
chiistine failey
chevy chase, Naiylanu
2u81S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

chiistine failey

8
Ivan vasin
21SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ivan vasin

9
molly biewei
milwaukee, Wisconsin
SS2u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

hi

Sinceiely,

molly biewei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

shiek the thiiu
1u
steve lucas
787u4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

steve lucas

11
Tiisha Stanuen
veimont
S68u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu love to be able to let my uaughtei watch hei BvBs on my iPau. It seems
logical to me that this shoulu be alloweu, since I have legally puichaseu all of these
BvBs.

Sinceiely,

Tiisha Stanuen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Neaily eveiy Bisney¡Pixai movie
12
Naiy Bouuei
Califoinia
94u41

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I want to be able to legally back up my BvBs in case the uisks fail. I want to be able
to watch them on a playei that uoesn't take ovei my machine, anu if I iip them, i can
uo that.. but BvBs tiy to make me only watch the BvB insteau of letting me uo what
I want to on my laptop.

Sinceiely,

Naiy Bouuei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

about Suu.. too many to list..
1S
Ranuall Nichols
Nassachusetts
214S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ranuall Nichols

14
Bain Binuei
Waie, Nassachusetts
1u82

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bain Binuei

1S
Bave Nount
St. Louis, Nissouii
6S112

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bave Nount

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I have moie than 2Su BvBs anu the physical space to stoie them neai my main
watching location is limiteu in both capacity as well as appeaiance. I have investeu
in technology that allows me to uigitize my meuia (such as music anu my own
photogiaphy) to uisplay them without having to put the physical puichase iight
wheie I watch. I shoulu have this ability with the BvBs I've puichaseu. It is not faii
to those who have puichaseu the physical meuia to make it illegal just because you
aie afiaiu that I uon't have the ethics to keep me fiom shaiing this without iegaiu to
copyiights. Change this please. I am not willing to ciicumvent copy piotection when
it makes me legally susceptible to infiingement.
16
Rogei Lauience III
Floiiua
SS176

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

With viueo playing being watcheu moie anu moie on mobile uevices, it's time to
tieat BvBs anu CBs the same way. Iust like I can buy a CB, put it on my computei
anu then move it to my phone, I shoulu be able to buy a BvB, put it on my computei
anu then put it on my phone as well.

Sinceiely,

Rogei Lauience III

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nonty Python anu the Boly uiail
The Baik Knight
Chicken Run
Bow I Net Youi Nothei Season 1-6
Big Bang Theoiy Seasons 1-4
17
Naicus Rauemachei
Lansing, Nichigan
4891u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Naicus Rauemachei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Loiu of the Rings
v foi venuetta
Suu
Cleiks 2
Ace ventuia
Finuing Nemo
Bogma
Iionman
Spiuei-man
18
Iack Zektzei
98126

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iack Zektzei

19
Shaila Neekei
Athens, 0hio
4S7u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Shaila Neekei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Ba vinci Coue
Baiiy Pottei Seiies
Loiu of the Rings Seiies
Chionicles of Nainia
Wanteu
etc.
2u
Iames Liuuy
Wauswoith, 0hio
44281

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have owneu moie movies then this, but the BvB's have become unieliable ovei
time uue to sciatches etc. If I hau been able to iip these I woulun't have to
iepuichase them. A luxuiy that I cuiiently can't uo.

I own that BvB, I own the iights foi piivate use of that BvB, if I can uo it with a CB a
BvB shoulu not be excluueu.

Sinceiely,

Iames Liuuy

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Inception
Boonuock Saints
The Piestige
The Illusionist
Finuing Nemo
Nonsteis Inc.
Wall-E
Cais
Batman Begins
The Baik night
v foi venueta
! #"!
_A(&!(&!U%&'!5!&R5,,!&5R+,/C!
22
Wenuy Richaiuson
Chapel Bill, Noith Caiolina
27S16

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Wenuy Richaiuson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

12 monkeys
witness


2S
Iulie ueivais
Nichigan
4822u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iulie ueivais

24
Chiistophei Aulei
San Biego, Califoinia
921uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chiistophei Aulei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Staik Tiek Tv seiies
BBC Life of Biius
BBC Planet Eaith
Spiiiteu Away
2S
Lacey Kammeiei
Fiesno, Califoinia
9S72u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lacey Kammeiei

26
Negan Biamlette
Biooklyn, New Yoik
1121S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Negan Biamlette

27
Bon Biancaccio
1uu11

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own close to two uozen movies anu Tv shows on BvB. Please note the use of the
woiu "own". I am not a thief oi a piiate. I stiongly believe in the iight of a
puichasei to use what I have legally bought as I see fit. This incluues making a
backup copy.



Sinceiely,

Bon Biancaccio






28
Phillip I Ciabill
Bighlanu village, Texas
7Su77

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Phillip I Ciabill

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

a libiaiy of ovei Suu BvB's that I want to be able to watch on my Tv, my iNac anu
my iPau, So long as I uo not give away oi sell any of my copies I shoulu be able to
make as many copies as I want. I will not give oi sell copies that will ieuuce the
maiket foi commeicial piouucts!!!
29
Athanasia Sky
Austin, Texas
787u4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

You guys shoulu nevei have taken away the BvB glass casings system. We woulu
have been able to just switch out the casings if they got sciatcheu. They wanteu to
be gieeuy. So this pioblem was causeu by theii own gieeu.

Sinceiely,

Athanasia Sky

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I uon't own BvB movies. I stieam movies I watch. Soiiy, but those things bieak anu
get sciatcheu. I uo film anu I always make back ups.
Su
valeiie Nucci
Beep iivei, Connecticut
6417

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

valeiie Nucci

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Loiu of the iings seiies
S1
Beibeit Sweet
Byue Paik, New Yoik
12SS8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I also finu it unacceptable that BvB iecoiueis with haiu uiives aie no longei solu in
the 0S while they aie solu in eveiy othei countiy in the woilu.



I unueistanu that the enteitainment inuustiy maue this happen.



The iecoiuing level is not even BB -- it is S viueo level so the piocess coulu haiuly be
useu commeicially.

Sinceiely,

Beibeit Sweet

S2
I0STINE TILLEY
Richmonu, viiginia
2S22S-7871

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

I0STINE TILLEY

SS
Sage Ross
ulenshaw, Pennsylvania
1S116

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Sage Ross

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Fiiefly
Nysteiy Nen
The Piincess Biiue
The Incieuibles
Stuait Little
S4
Bob Thomas
Nyitle Cieek, 0iegon
974S7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bob Thomas

SS
Steve Byine
8S2u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Steve Byine

S6
Lauienellen NcCann
Washington, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuu8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lauienellen NcCann

S7
Pace Willisson
Neuway, Nassachusetts
2uSS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu like to view the Teaching Company lectuies on my Anuioiu phone while
iiuing the commutei iail tiain on the way to anu fiom woik. This company has
pioposeu to offei theii content thiough a stieaming website, but much of the
commutei iail path has pooi iauio coveiage, anu the uata chaiges woulu be
excessive. I woulu like to puichase the oiiginal content on BvB, anu then copy some
lectuies to my phone myself. That way, when I have time to watch a lectuie at
home, I can see it in high quality uiiectly fiom the BvB, but I woulu have the
flexibility to watch on the poitable, small scieen too.

Sinceiely,

Pace Willisson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Noie than a uozen college level lectuie seiies on BvB fiom The Teaching Company,
each consisting of many sepaiate BvB's.
S8
Rob Keenan
Washington
9827S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Rob Keenan

S9
Steiling Robison
84121

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Steiling Robison

4u
Wenuy 0sei
Beikeley, Califoinia
947u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Wenuy 0sei

41
Ben Boeinbeig
Chailottesville, viiginia
22911

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I also own seveial uozen seasons of television on BvB. Caiiying aiounu a six-uisc
set is hugely impiactical.

Sinceiely,

Ben Boeinbeig

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

ulauiatoi
Bloou Biamonu
A Biief Bistoiy of the Woilu: Pait I
Eu Woou
Pleasantville
Requiem foi a Bieam
Bozens of othei films


42
Esau Kesslei
B0ISE, Iuaho
8S7u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I uon't ieally use my Tv anymoie just my iPau. I want to be able to watch my movies
on my iPau. These iestiictions appeai to favoi the copyiight holueis, anu not the
geneial public anu aie not consistent with pievious copyiight law. This backwaius
iestiiction makes it look like you woik foi business's not foi me.

Sinceiely,

Esau Kesslei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bob Bope "Roau To Noiocco"
Fiank Beibeit's "Chiluien 0f Bune"
Rat Race
Biuce Almighty
4S
john egan
new iochelle, New Yoik
1u8u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

john egan

44
Iohn Wilcox
ARLINuT0N, viiginia
222uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have small chiluien (ages S & 7), who love to watch the same movie ovei anu ovei
again. Even as we tiy to limit theii scieen time, we'ie still iegulaily confionteu with
the most impoitant fact about BvB's that any family knows: they bieak. They
sciatch, shattei, anu just stop woiking. Naking a backup so my thiee-yeai olu can
watch Buzz Lightyeai uefeat Zeig foi the 2uth time shoulun't be against the law.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Wilcox

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Toy Stoiy
Toy Stoiy II
Toy Stoiy III
The Incieuibles
Cais
Cais II
Stai Wais I
Stai Wais II
Stai Wais III
Stai Wais Iv
Stai Wais v
Stai Wais vI
4S
uan cappelllo
1SuSS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uan cappelllo

46
uieg Noneman
4SSS6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uieg Noneman

47
Kylee Feueiico
2S18S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kylee Feueiico

48
William Apiea
Chatham, New Ieisey
7928

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I believe that my faii use of these legally puichaseu BvBs shoulu be piotecteu, anu
specifically, I shoulu be able to view these BvBs on the peisonal electionic uevice of
my choosing in the foimat that I choose.

Sinceiely,

William Apiea

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

ovei 1,uuu movies, television shows, uocumentaiies anu live music viueos.
49
Baviu Ziuek
Cockeysville, Naiylanu
21uSu

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have hau to spenu hunuieus of uollais ieplacing uamageu viueo uvus because they
weie sciatcheu by abuse, use, anu just the uaily hazaius of being hanuleu by
chiluien. I am sick of not being able to copy my own piopeity to piotect it fiom
uamage, foi my own peisonal use! It is iiuiculous. Why am I a ciiminal foi making a
backup copy , oi moving my meuia to a moie secuie location - like my haiu uiive.
It's time foi a change. If I want to copy my own piopeity to anothei uevice to be
watcheu by myself oi my family - aftei we have LEuALLY P0RCBASEB it - it shoulu
not be a ciime.



Sinceiely,

Baviu Ziuek

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Youi Baby Can Reau (Full Set)
Finuing Nemo
Beavis Anu Buttheau Collection
The Simpsons Seasons 1 - 1u
Bunuieus moie
Su
Robeit Rogan
Betioit, Nichigan
482u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Robeit Rogan

S1
Lee L'Enfant
Benvei, Coloiauo
8u22u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lee L'Enfant

S2
Ciystal Tiacy
Chesapeake Beach, Naiylanu
2u7S2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ciystal Tiacy

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

the Expenuables
Iane Eyie
Iion Nan
uattaca
0vei the Beuge
SS
Ian Stevenson
0klahoma
749S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ian Stevenson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais, Elizabeth
S4
Natthew Legei
Atlanta, ueoigia
SuS29

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natthew Legei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Staigate, ualaxy 0uest, The 1u Commanuments, Family Nan, 1776, When Baiiy Net
Sally, Baiispiay, The Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy, Iustice League: New Fiontiei
SS
Ruuy Aguiiie
Nichigan
48197

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ruuy Aguiiie

S6
Stephen Bilgaitnei
148Su

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Stephen Bilgaitnei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Insiue Iob
anu many otheis.
S7
Ieff Lawience
New Yoik
11746

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ieff Lawience

S8
Leslie Cassiuy
New Yoik, New Yoik
1uu28

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Leslie Cassiuy

S9
Thomas L. Phinney
ulenuale, Aiizona
8SSu8-SS21

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own ovei 6uu BvBs anu BBs (Blu-iay BvBs). I own two houses, one in Phoenix, AZ
wheie I live most of the yeai, anu anothei 12uu miles away in the Pacific Noithwest
wheie I go in the summei, at the time when Phoenix uaytime high tempeiatuies can
be ovei 1uuº F foi ovei 1uu uays in a iow.



Eveiy summei I have to select among my BvBs anu BBs, then box up Su of them oi
so, to tianspoit to my summei house in eaily Summei anu then biing back to
Phoenix in the Fall. A single 2TB S"x8"x1.S" haiu uisk uiive, such as I use to back up
the laptop on which I am wiiting this e-mail, can holu copies of 2Su BvBs oi 4u BBs,
oi a combination theieof, pioviuing a much moie convenient means of
tianspoitation that also leaves the oiiginal BvBs anu BBs unuamageu shoulu an
auto acciuent occui while tianspoiting the copy.



Some of the BvBs anu BBs I tianspoit aie in languages othei than English, which
help me maintain my language skills ovei the Summei anu thioughout the yeai.



In total my BvB¡BB collection coveis ovei 27 lineai feet of piime shelf space.
Copying these to a small numbei of haiu uisks woulu also have the benefit of fieeing
6u
up this piime shelf space foi books oi othei mateiia, peimitting the hunuieus of
uisks to be inuexeu anu boxeu, then placeu in weatheipioof backup stoiage.

Sinceiely,

Thomas L. Phinney

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

- classic movies such as
Ninotchka,
Casablanca,
Key Laigo,

- maitial aits movies such as
Fists of Fuiy,
Bouse of Flying Baggeis,

- uance movies such as
Shall We Bance,
Tuining Point,

- musicals such as
A Choius Line,
Fiuulei on the Roof,

- opeias such as

Alcina,
uiulio Cesaie,

- complete Tv seiies such as all the episoues of
Sheilock Bolmes,
The West Wing,

- anu othei categoiies
61
uavin Bakei
Washington, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuu9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The BNCA shoulu not piohibit activities that woulu otheiwise be faii use.

Sinceiely,

uavin Bakei

62
Nichael Tomczyszyn
San Fiancisco, Califoinia
941S2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nichael Tomczyszyn

6S
uieg Koshak
S4947

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

As long as I uo not chaige aumission oi sell copies of mateiial, I shoulu be able uo as
I please with what I own. Woulu you aiiest me foi wiiting a iecipe fiom a cookbook
on a caiu so that it is easiei to use in my kitchen.



ARE Y00 REALLY u0INu T0 ARREST EvERY ANERICAN WB0 BREAKS TBIS LAW
0R WILL IT I0ST BE TBE 0NES Y00 WANT T0 BARASS.

Sinceiely,

uieg Koshak

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

None of youi business!
64
Cailos Paieja
New Yoik
11216

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

As an euucatoi with "faii use" legitimacy to incluue meuia examples foi classioom
uiscussion anu as a piouucei of piogiamming that analyzes anu ciitiques meuia
messages, the oneious technical piotections imposeu by the BNCA bai me fiom my
authoiizeu anu piotecteu use of meuia.

Please uo all within youi powei to iemeuy this unjustifiable infiingement on lawful
use of copyiighteu BvBs.

Sinceiely,

Cailos Paieja

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Young Fiankenstein
Loiu of the Rings
The Battle of Algieis
Eteinal Sunshine of the Spotless Ninu
Blaue Runnei
Logan's Run
Iails, Bospitals anu Bip Bop
Sketches of Fiank uehiy
Samuiai Iack: Seasons 0ne & Two
Chapelle's Show: Season 0ne
6S
The Nuppets Take Nanhattan
Stai Wais: Clone Wais, volumes 0ne & Two
Piincess Nononoke
Escape to Witch Nountain & Retuin fiom Witch Nountain (2-movie collection)
Kius
The Yeai Without a Santa Claus
The Best Yeais of 0ui Lives
Naiia Full of uiace
Niiioimask
Baieuevil
Iesus Chiist Supeistai
66
uieg Ncmanus
Whitestone, New Yoik
11SS7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uieg Ncmanus

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nightmaie befoie Chiistmas
Tion
0ffice space
Stai wais
Way of the uiagon


67
victoiia Neuman
0hio
44u74

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

With the piice of BvBs touay, it only makes sense to allow the puichasei to tiansfei
the files to a moie flexible foimat. Please allow people to make the most of theii
BvB collections!

Sinceiely,

victoiia Neuman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Chicago
Amelie
The Najestic
The Phantom of the 0peia
The Legenu of Baggei vance
68
Ryan Almanu
Floiiua
S4479

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Even though I paiu foi the movie I still uon't own it. This makes no sense to me. I'm
not tiying to steal anything anu my uvu¡blue-iay collection continues to giow. I
woulu like to iip my uvu¡BRs so I always have a copy of them incase something
weie to happen to them.

Sinceiely,

Ryan Almanu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Noneyball
I Bon't Know Bow She Boes It
Waiiioi
Kung Fu Panua 2
Fiienus with Benefits
The Bebt
The Change-0p
Stiaw Bogs
Supei 8
The Smuifs
Ciazy, Stupiu, Love
Su Ninutes oi Less
Niunight in Paiis
69
Fiight Night
Bostel: Pait III
Conan the Baibaiian
Laiiy Ciowne

7u
Leighton Iames-Thompson
S1 2BS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Leighton Iames-Thompson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Kick Ass
Biaveheait
Scott Pilgiim vs The Woilu
The Inbetweeneis
Wall:E
Saving Piivate Ryan
Full Netal Iacket
Tiopic Thunuei
The Bangovei
Repo


71
Ambei Keik
Inuiana
479u6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ambei Keik

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Phantom of the 0peia
The Last Samuiai
Spiueiman 2
Stai Tiek
Euwaiu Scissoihanus
Piincess Nononoke
The Loiu of the Rings
vampiie Buntei B: Blooulust
The Bobbit
Fullmetal Alchemist: Season 0ne
anu many otheis!
72
uingei Anueison
66212

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uingei Anueison

7S
Ioseph Kesselman
2474

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This is *piecisely* the same issue as uubbing a iecoiu to a tape foi playing in the cai
useu to be. As long as the two copies iemain unuei contiol of the same inuiviuual,
this has always been consiueieu Faii 0se. I see absolutely no justification foi
changing that.



If you want to go aftei piiacy, fine: uo the job piopeily anu go aftei the piiates. Bon't
ciiminalize legitimate use.



I, too, woik in the Intellectual Piopeity aiena. I'm vERY awaie of IP law. It ieally
uoes alieauy pioviue eveiything that you neeu foi all legitimate puiposes. Bon't let
youiself be piessuieu into passing an unnecessaiy anu abusive law.

Sinceiely,

Ioseph Kesselman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

... It's an ungouly long list, ianging fiom out-of-copyiight classics to some faiily
iecent.
74
Annie uieen
S98u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have small chiluien who want to be able to opeiate the BvB playei by themselves.
I think this is gieat that they want to be inuepenuent, but it usually means that the
BvBs eventually get sciatcheu anu in a few cases bioken. It woulu be nice to be able
to make a back-up copy of a BvB so when this happens I am not foiceu to buy
anothei copy of the same viueo that I spent goou money on once alieauy. This iule
seems iiuiculous. Theie is no uiffeience in copying a CB oi BvB, but one is illegal
anu the othei not.!.





Sinceiely,

Annie uieen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Raising Aiizona, A Chiistmas Stoiy, Boia the Exploiei, uo Biego uo, The
Backyaiuigans, Pocoyo, Togethei, anu moie
7S
Ioyce Pusel
Buiham, Noith Caiolina
2771S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ioyce Pusel

76
Patiick Bion
Wooustock, ueoigia
Su189

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Patiick Bion

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Payuay, Entouiage seasons 1-S box sets, Balfbakeu.
77
Tylei uiay
Washington, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuu7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It's all foi nothing if you uon't have fieeuom.



Sinceiely,

Tylei uiay

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Feai anu Loathing in Las vegas
Blue Ciush
Top uun
Fight Club
The Biiuge on The Rive Kwai
Bi. Zhivago
Supei Tioopeis
Staiship Tioopeis
Bau Boys II
Tommy Boy
Cauuyshack
Last Boy Scout
Back to the Futuie Paits 1, II, III
Full Netal Iacket
78
Entei the Biagon
Pieauatoi
Commanuo
0nuei Siege II
Pulp Fiction
Point Bieak
Team Ameiica
Pulp Fiction
The Rock
24: Seasons 1-7
The West Wing


79
Amy Simmons
S8Su1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Amy Simmons

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

v foi venuetta
8u
Annette R Nolan
Waupaca, Wisconsin
S4981

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Annette R Nolan

81
Teiiy Beislen
Plano, Texas
7Su74

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Puichasing a BvB shoulu mean puichase of the iecoiueu content theieon, meaning
non-commeicial use (incluuing uuplication foi home use). Aftei all, ioyalties aie
paiu on the sale of the content--if I'm not buying the content, fiom whence aie saiu
ioyalties ueiiveu. The iuea that buying a BvB equates to some kinu of limiteu lease
on the iecoiueu content is luuicious.



Please note that, among othei things, I am a musician who peifoims anu iecoius
oiiginal copyiighteu mateiial, anu am a BNI affiliate. I uo have some unueistanuing
of intellectual piopeity! I also have an unueistanuing of how the sales patteins of
iecoiueu mateiial actually opeiate. Restiictions on enu-useis, in the ieal woilu,
uepiess sales anu inciease piiacy. That's the pioven pattein of expeiience.

Sinceiely,

Teiiy Beislen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

A Nighty Winu,
What Woulu Iesus Buy.,
Cais,
Nonty Python anu the Boly uiail,
82
It Night uet Louu,
Nuppets fiom Space,
numeious conceit films,
etc.
8S
Bipesh Navsaiia
Nauison, Wisconsin
SS7uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bipesh Navsaiia

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy
84
S u
0tah
8411S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

S u

8S
anthony maikesino
staffoiu, Texas
77477

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Foimat shifting is not a ciime, shoulu not be a ciime noi shoulu being able to mess
aiounu with anything that you have puichaseu fiom a company.



Any item that I puichase oi lease anu biing into my own home in which the
coipoiation I bought it fiom oi Siu paity ietailei has no ieasonable assumption that
they will evei have it ietuineu to them (no mattei what BS they wiite into a E0LA),
belongs to me. I shoulu be alloweu anu will uo whatevei I please with it as long as I
uo not uistiibute it oi attempt to piofit off theii haiu woik.



This means bieaking theii uigital lockeis, uownloauing tools to bieak theii locks,
moving it fiom foimat to foimat to take auvantage of all the technology my haiu
eaineu uollais pay foi fiom the veiy same companies anu even taking paits of theii
woik anu using it foi paiouy oi political statement.

Sinceiely,

anthony maikesino

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

86
I own numeious BvBs, CBs anu BluRays to incluue the Stai Wais Saga anu piobably
hunuieus of Anime that I buy eveiy yeai.
87
Luz Naiina Caiuona
Fieeuom, Califoinia
9Su19

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Luz Naiina Caiuona

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Yes
Sex anu Lucia
Bitch
Benny anu Ioon
Iunebug
Nona Lisa Smile
...
88
Ioyce Lahna
1uuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ioyce Lahna

89
Ieiiy Nastiiano
New Yoik
11S7S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I useu to make copies of all of my music anu softwaie installation CBs, in case of
uisk failuie. This is now unnecessaiy foi softwaie because the manufactuieis will
allow the application to be installeu via uownloau. Theie is no such piovision with
BvBs, so when they ciap out, I have to puichase a new copy, which I've uone seveial
times.

Sinceiely,

Ieiiy Nastiiano

9u
Al NcCullough
Alabama
SS2SS-1624

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I bought these movies at ietail stoies. I believe I must have the unobstiucteu iight to
tiansfei them to othei uiscs in oiuei to back them up.



Foi example, I am piesently finuing that a numbei of my olu viueo tapes aie
ueteiioiating anu uo not piouuce goou pictuies. Bau I tiansfeiieu them to BvBs
long ago I woulu still have them foi viewing anu my investment in them secuieu.



Let's be cleai. The only ieason we eveiyuay citizens puichase these movies anu
othei piogiamming is so that we can view them whenevei we wish. Ciiminalizing
eveiyuay citizens foi piotecting oui puichases is outiageous anu yet anothei
coipoiate infiingement on oui iights.



I woulu like to ieminu you that, in spite of the iogue Supieme Couit's iulings,
coipoiations have no iights. coipoiations aie aitificial constiucts, gianteu existence
by a soveieign citizeniy foi anu at the pleasuie of the citizeniy. Coipoiations, like all
businesses enjoy PRIvILEuES gianteu, tempoiaiily, by the citizens.


91

Coipoiations aie piopeity. Citizens aie soveieign. Bo not tiy to allow the tail to
continue to wag the uog. 0ltimately, we will, metaphoiically, bite oui abuseis.

Sinceiely,

Al NcCullough

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

A Rivei Runs Thiough It, The Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy, anu othei movies.
92
Biian Nuitagh
South Caiolina
2948S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have a computei hookeu up to my BBTv anu just want to iip my BvBs onto a haiu
uiive so I can easily pick anu view one without taking a fiagile, sciatchable uisk out
of the case anu putting it back afteiwaiu. Even moie so I'u like to enable my
auoiable but klutzy chilu to uo the same.

Sinceiely,

Biian Nuitagh

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Back to the Futuie seiies,
Schinuleis List,
The Bay The Eaith Stoou Still,
Beniy Fool,
Fay uiim,
Netiopolis,
0theis.
9S
Lynette Stiangstau
Nineial Point, Wisconsin
SSS6S-1241

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lynette Stiangstau

94
jaieu hyzei
st johns mi, Nichigan
48879

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

i have always wanteu to use these on my mp4 playei but nevei thought it to be
possible now that i know it is i woulu like it to be legal because as a ieligious peison
i uo not want to bieak the law. thanks

Sinceiely,

jaieu hyzei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

stai wais 1-6
9S
Loii Nulvey
49S21

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Loii Nulvey

96
uiant Sieu
Tucson, Aiizona
8S7Su

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uiant Sieu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

- The Shawshank Reuemption
- Tom & Ieiiy & The Wizaiu of 0z
- Foiiest uump
- Bespicable Ne
- Negaminu
- Papiika (film uiiecteu by Satoshi Kon)
- Ny Neighboi Totoio
- Phineas & Feib: Acioss the 2nu Bimension
- Inuiana Iones & The Kinguom of Ciystal Skull
- Bisastei Novie
- The Natiix Reloaueu
- Shiek the Thiiu
- Clouuy with the Chance of Neatballs
- The Aiistocats
- Bumbo
- Wall-E
- Toy Stoiy S
- Scaiy Novie S
! K7!
L!Z/0'(R/!D'14(/&!
L!DE1''!;(,=4(R!.&C!_A/!I14,0!
L!Z,5E[!DM5)!
L!D,%R01=!:(,,(1)5(4/!
L!_A/!?%4(1%&!?5&/!1>!Z/)U5R()!Z%''1)!
L!_A/!-%'&(0/4&!
L!-4+A5)!
L!D%+/4!D(\/!:/!
L!;41R!`(=A'!]#FFX!3(,R^!
L!H(=A'!?45\@!`(=A'&!
98
Kym Rich
Washington
98u87

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I want to keep watching my movies, even when I'm away fiom my home office.

Sinceiely,

Kym Rich

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bisney's Snow White anu the Seven Bwaifs
The Tuxeuo
The Neuallion
Bisney's Alauuin
Bisney's Beauty anu the Beast
99
Bawn Albanese
Elk uiove village, Illinois
6uuu7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bawn Albanese

1uu
Nayeem Aslam
villa Paik, Illinois
6u181

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nayeem Aslam

1u1
Ezia Cohen
Telluiiue, Coloiauo
814SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ezia Cohen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais
The Bieakfast Club
The Loiu of the Rings
Ray
Reseivoii Bogs
Thelma anu Louise
1u2
ueo Svinos
Fulleiton, Califoinia
928SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This law uoesn't affect me one way oi anothei, but we shoulu still be able to legally
iip oui own BvBs.

Sinceiely,

ueo Svinos

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I uon't own any movies on BvB. I uon't even watch any.
1uS
Kathy 0ppenhuizen
West 0live, Nichigan
4946u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kathy 0ppenhuizen

1u4
Cassanuia Anueison
Tucson, Aiizona
8S712

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have an iPhone anu tiavel fiequently. Insteau of buying a movie multiple times, I
want to be able to put my movies on my iPhone foi my tiips. Please help my tiavel
be less teiiible.



Thank you,

Sinceiely,

Cassanuia Anueison

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tiansfomeis Tiilogy
Spiueiman Tiilogy
Staiwais 1-6
Natiix Tiilogy
Nummy Tiilogy
Teiminatoi
Expenuables
ATeam
Comanuo
Baiiy Pottei 1-7
! "F9!
DA4/[!"L6!
*,,!5)(R5'/0!J(&)/@!R1.(/&!
;,%&!A%)04/0&!R14/!
1u6
Shane Wilkins
Washington
99S44

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have kius who sciatch the BvBs

I woulu like to make a backup copy

So they coulu watch it iight fiom the

Computei without iisking the BvB.

Sinceiely,

Shane Wilkins

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Shawshank ieuemption
Nothing to lose
Sons of Anaichy
Wizaiu of oz
Blue stieak
Couiageous


1u7
Tiffany Baigiove
Alabama
SS4uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Tiffany Baigiove

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Set It 0ff
Biown Sugai
Iason's Lyiic
Waiting to Exhale
Biiuesmaius
Piemonition
0nbieakable
Catch Ne if You Can
Bow Stella uot Bei uioove Back
Pietty Woman
King of 0ueens final season
anu at least 1uu moie
1u8
ueoffiey Webstei
Pinckney, Nichigan
48169

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ueoffiey Webstei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avatai
Inception
1u9
michael wohlleb
Lou, Kentucky
4u222

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

michael wohlleb

11u
Shane NcAnuiew
19u76

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Shane NcAnuiew

111
Biian vaughan
San Fiancisco, Califoinia
94117

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Biian vaughan

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Seienity
The Fellowship of the Ring
The Two Toweis
The Retuin of the King
112
Iohn viaciucis
S6S6u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iohn viaciucis

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Wings of Besiie
Stiangeis on a Tiain
Bobby
Befoie Suniise
11S
Auiian Azzopaiui
BZN99SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Auiian Azzopaiui

114
Ban uoiuon
972u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It is silly that I can legally:

(a) iip a CB I own anu auu it to my itunes libiaiy, anu

(b)play that "CB" on my computei, my mpS playei, anu my phone



anu yet uoing the same thing with any of my BvBs (anu¡oi Blue Rays) woulu be
consiueieu illegal anu coulu cause me to be sueu.



It is time to make a BNCA exception to tieat BvBs & Blue Ray uisks like CBs! C'mon,
shoulun't the law ieflect the ieality of touay's electionic¡uigital woilu.

Thanks foi listening!!

Sinceiely,

Ban uoiuon

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

11S
Beck, I own well ovei 1uu (legally puichseu!!) BvBs, ianging fiom kius' faie to
action classics, to PBS uocumentaiies. It is so fiustiating that I can't use that BvB
content on my many uevices I own that coulu potentially play them.




116
uale iiehait
Califoinia
941u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uale iiehait

117
William Peltz
Albany, New Yoik
122u8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

William Peltz

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The King's Speech
The Razoi's Euge
118
Robeit Linzmeiei
Palatine, Illinois
6uu74

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Robeit Linzmeiei

119
Kaien Beuwig Backman
98uuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kaien Beuwig Backman

12u
Ranuy Wieck
St Fiancis, Kansas
677S6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I quit buying BvB's completely because I was unable to back them up. Aftei buying
the same movie (Fuiiy vengeance) thiee times, I quit. Let me back up my BvB's anu
I woulu piobably buy moie, especially if the piice came uown to ieasonable.

Sinceiely,

Ranuy Wieck

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avatai
21
Fuiiy vengeance


121
Naic Schoenbeig
Faimington Bills , Nichigan
48SS6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Naic Schoenbeig

122
uaiy Ncuath
Nashua, New Bampshiie
Su62

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I am an acauemic libiaiy employee anu conceineu about the uisappeaiance of
iecoiueu movies that go out of piouuction.

Sinceiely,

uaiy Ncuath

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tion, Cyiano ue Beigeiac, Not the Nessiah, Ring uei Nibelungen, many otheis.
12S
Bianuen Allen
Ninnesota
SS96u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bianuen Allen

124
William Fisk
Benueisonville, Noith Caiolina
287S9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

William Fisk

12S
Baviu Wilson
Nyitle Point, 0iegon
974S8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Baviu Wilson

126
Thomas Keenan
Coeui u' Alene, Iuaho
8S814-4876

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Thomas Keenan

127
Tau Nannes
Lawienceville, ueoigia
Suu44

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Tau Nannes

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Too many to list heie...
128
Fiancisco Toiies
New Yoik
1uu4u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fiancisco Toiies

129
Iessie Elias
uiants Pass, 0iegon
97S27

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iessie Elias

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Batman¡The 1989 film
Teiminatoi
Nighty Noiphing Powei Rangeis The Novie
1Su
Anuiew Thackiay
Rotheiham,
S66 1AS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Anuiew Thackiay

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Fight Club
Natiix (Tiilogy)
Stai Wais Iv
Stai Wais v
Stai Wais vI
Stai Wais I
Stai Tiek
Ameiican Bistoiy X
Ali
Anchoiman
Back to the Futuie (Tiilogy)
Cleiks
Biity Sanchez
Foui Lions
uet Bim To The uieek
La Baine
La vie en Rose
Les Choiistes
! "6"!
:/=5R()0!
`(=A'R54/!Z/>14/!?A4(&'R5&!
-)/!3,/M!-./4!_A/!?%E[11c&!`/&'!
;1()'!Z4/5[!
<5=()=!Z%,,!
</&'4/+1!
<(0()=!W(5)'&!
<150A1%&/!
<1E[@!]*,,!1>!'A/R^!
Dd?!;%)[!
D/./)!;1%)0&!
_5Q(!J4(./4!
_/4R()5'14!
_/4R()5'14!#!
_A/!b%4'!d1E[/4!
_A/!DA()()=!
_A/!-R/)!]-4(=()5,^!
_A/!_A()=!]"KX#^!
_45()!D+1''()=!
S!>14!S/)0/''5!
->>(E/!D+5E/!
*)0!R5)@!R14/!
1S2
Linua Sheii
Ciumpton, Naiylanu
21628

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have two homes anu I like the concept of being able to copy BvBs that I own so I
can have copies at both houses.

Sinceiely,

Linua Sheii

1SS
Iohn Fiumento
9u24u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Fiumento

1S4
Alyssa 0libaiii
Tempe, Aiizona
8S281

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It woulu be pietty fantastic that if I weie stuck in a boiing situation anu I coulu just
whip out my phone oi iPou anu watch Ace ventuia to pass the time. I can't uo this
howevei because I cannot iip the BvB. Anu I ceitainly uo not want to have to buy a
movie that I alieauy own, again.

Sinceiely,

Alyssa 0libaiii

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

17 Again
Zombielanu
She's the Nan
Step 0p
Builesque
Role Nouels
Step Biotheis
Ace ventuia
1SS
michael heastings
Pennsylvania
1S2uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

michael heastings

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uont be afiaiu of the uaik
1S6
Ioe Cisneios
Texas
78212

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ioe Cisneios

1S7
Tayloi vainuell
Chicago, Illinois
6u647

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Tayloi vainuell

1S8
PATTI C0NSTANTIN0-NARTIN
SPRINu BILL, Floiiua
S461u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

PATTI C0NSTANTIN0-NARTIN

1S9
Shastina Belmeis
Califoinia
9288u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu like to be able to enjoy the movies that I puichase without having to spenu
extia money on puichasing uigital copies. I cuiiently own an iPou Classic,
PlayStation Poitable, anu an Anuioiu cell phone with viueo playback capability. It
seems unieasonable to me that I shoulu not be able to watch my own movies when I
tiavel oi when I am on vacation without neeuing to puichase a laptop oi poitable
BvB playei. Fuitheimoie, I feel that extenuing the usei capability of legally
puichaseu BvBs foi non-commeicial, peisonal use will help cuib piiacy, which
often happens because it is cuiiently illegal to "iip" BvBs, even foi the ieasons
listeu above.

Sinceiely,

Shastina Belmeis

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Banna, Silent Bill, Repo Nen, etc.
14u
Robeit Szaika
Noiwich, Connecticut
6S6u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Robeit Szaika

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Repo Nan, When Baiiy Net Sally, The Nanchuiian Canuiuate, anu many, many moie
141
nick allen
Nichigan
48884

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

nick allen

142
Eleanoi Iones
Someiville, Nassachusetts
2144

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Eleanoi Iones

14S
Chellee Saiz
Silvei City, New Nexico
88u61

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chellee Saiz

144
Chiis Bauley
Louisiana
7u8u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chiis Bauley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Iaws
Noith By Noithwest
The Toweiing Infeino
Netwoik
Cauuyshack


14S
Natt Kiamei
Ranuolph, Nassachusetts
2S68

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natt Kiamei

146
Bean Lewis
Atlanta, ueoigia
SuS18

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bean Lewis

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uilmoie uiils, Futuiama, Nonty Python anu the Boly uiail, The Pink Panthei, Alvin
anu the Chipmunks, anu uet Smait
147
Loiene Rowlanu
Nontana
S91u6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Loiene Rowlanu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

T0 Kill A Nockingbiiu, Iion Nan & many moie
148
ueialu Piikle
Boonville, Inuiana
476u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ueialu Piikle

149
Paul Neumann
Lynbiook, New Yoik
11S6S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Paul Neumann

1Su
Naik Nagelky
Bianuon, South Bakota
S7uuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Naik Nagelky

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Baik Knight
Inuiana Iones anu the Ciystal Skull
Nen in Black
Nen in Black 2
1S1
petei solt
CBICAu0, Illinois
6u618

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

petei solt

1S2
Whitney Anyanwu
Coloiauo
8u92S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It woulu be nice to be able to take movies anu put them on my ipou oi computei so
when I'm tiaveling, I can watch a movie without inteinet access.

Sinceiely,

Whitney Anyanwu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bigh School Nusical
Zoolanuei
Bouse Paity
1SS
Cailos 0iopeza
Someiuale,
8u8S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Cailos 0iopeza

1S4
Paul Binman
Tennessee
S72u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Paul Binman

1SS
Shane Ballnan
New Yoik
14222

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.



Please ieconsiuei the legality of tiansfeiiing legally owneu mateiial to othei legally
owneu uevices. It is an unfaii buiuen to have to ie-puichase a single title iepeateuly
just to be able to watch it on the seveial uevices any one peison might own.



The aveiage peison may possess a home computei, a laptop, a smait phone, anu a
tablet computei. That is, foui uevices that aie capable of playing viueos anu foui
puichases which woulu neeu to be maue foi a single title, insteau of legally
puichasing a title once.



It is my opinion that, in the inteiest of consumei piotection, the puichase piice of a
title shoulu confei a limiteu owneiship which woulu assume the iight of the buyei
to iepiouuce anu play that paiticulai title on any piivate uevice which they legally
own foi piivate enjoyment.



Thank you veiy much foi youi consiueiation in this mattei.

1S6


Sinceiely,

Shane Ballnan

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Raiueis of the Lost Aik
Inuiana Iones anu the Temple of Boom
Inuiana Iones anu the Last Ciusaue
Inuiana Iones anu the Kinguom of the Ciystal Skull
Ameiican Psycho
Nonty Python's The Neaning of Life
Platoon
Rocky Balboa
Stai Wais: Episoue Iv - A New Bope
Stai Wais: Episoue v - The Empiie Stiikes Back
Stai Wais: Episoue vI - Retuin of the Ieui
Apocalypto
Suu
1S7
kifei tioxell
47SuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

kifei tioxell

1S8
Anuiew Piince
Chailotte, Noith Caiolina
28226

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Cais, Cais 2, Nemo, lots of kius movies that woulu be nice if the kiu coulu watch on
my anuioiu uevice while uiiving. I own the BvBs why can't I watch them like I want
to legally.

Sinceiely,

Anuiew Piince

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Cais, Cais 2, Nemo, lots of kius movies that woulu be nice if the kiu coulu watch on
my anuioiu uevice while uiiving. I own the BvBs why can't I watch them like I want
to legally.
1S9
Camille uilbeit
9S1u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Camille uilbeit

16u
Samuel Robison
Russellville, Aikansas
728u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I am not going to list them all, but I have well ovei 2uu uvus anu woulu love to be
able to watch them on my ipou anu uigital meuia playei in my house. I just hau
twins anu they aie going to be haiu on a uvus health anu the only way i can see to
pievent my puichaseu copies of movies fiom being iuineu is to make a uigital copy
foi peisonal home use.

Sinceiely,

Samuel Robison

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tion
Bespicable Ne
Cast Away
Ice Baivest
The Bone Collectoi
The A-Team
Inception
Lawience of Aiabia
Easy A
Iust a small sampling of the many movies that I own.
161
Fiank Bill
916u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fiank Bill

162
Iustin Steinhouse
New Yoik
1121S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iustin Steinhouse

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nonty Python anu the Boly uiail
Apocalypse Now
Blaue Runnei
Stai Wais
The Natiix
Loiu of the Rings
Futuiama
The Simpsons


16S
Ion Anueisen
Coconut Cieek, Floiiua
SSu66

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ion Anueisen

164
iich wainei
Schenectauy, New Yoik
12SuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

iich wainei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I neithei own noi possess any movies oi othei copyiighteu mateiials on BvBs but
stiongly suppoit this pioposal.
16S
Ann uaith
Long Beach, Califoinia
9u8uS-4414

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ann uaith

166
Banny Nilligan
Aiizona
8S282

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Banny Nilligan

167
Seth Rasmussen
Sunnysiue, New Yoik
111u4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Seth Rasmussen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uozens of Tv shows anu movies
168
Linusey NcNillen
Riveisiue,
92Su7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

BvBs uon't last foievei. They uegiaue ovei time, anu aie easily uamageu anu
ienueieu useless by sciatches anu blemishes. Bue to a giowing numbei of my BvBs
affecteu by such pioblems I have iecently ueciueu to cease acquiiing any moie
BvBs unless anu until BvB meuia is manufactuieu to last much longei, 0R the
BNCA is changeu to allow foi the cieation of single backup¡aichival copies of BvBs.

Sinceiely,

Linusey NcNillen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I cuiiently have ovei 6Su lawfully acquiieu BvBs, anu Blu-Ray BvBs in my libiaiy.
169
Scott Walck
Annville, Pennsylvania
17uuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Scott Walck

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Natiix
The Natiix Reloaueu
The Natiix Revolutions


17u
I0BN R0uERS
4824u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Why make it a ciime foi peisonal use copying.

Sinceiely,

I0BN R0uERS

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tokyo Stoiy
Fanny anu Alexanuei
The Roau




171
Iames Conley
Chicago, Illinois
6u622

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please consiuei the implications of this exemption, copyiight law in its cuiient foim
penalizes anyone who puichases a film legally in one foim foi wanting to view it on
multiple uevices. Rights holueis ceitainly have the iight to pievent piiacy but not at
the expense of the millions of honest consumeis, if I puichase a BvB legally theie is
absolutely no logical ieason I shoulu not be able to put that same BvB onto my
computei to watch on vacation oi on my iPau oi iPhone to watch uuiing a commute.

Sinceiely,

Iames Conley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I own hunuieus of BvBs anu Blu-iay uiscs, incluuing but ceitainly not limiteu to
Iuiassic Paik
Rachel uetting Naiiieu
Biiuesmaius
the Stai Wais Tiilogy
Beaven
the Ice Stoim
Lust, Caution
All About Eve
Chaiaue
Lost Boiizon
! "7#!
d1&'!b(=AM5@!
Z,%/!S/,./'!
O(,,!Z(,,!.1,&!"!i!#!
*,(/)!
*,(/)&!
_1!?5'EA!5!_A(/>!
b1M!'1!D'/5,!5!:(,,(1)!
</54!I()01M!
17S
Ioan Shelby
98118

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ioan Shelby

174
Natthew Smith
Thointon, Coloiauo
8u6u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natthew Smith

17S
mike monson
94u14

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

mike monson

176
Nolly Rabbitt
Califoinia
92868

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nolly Rabbitt

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Inception, Supei 8, The X-Files Seasons 1-9, Fiinge Seasons 1-S, many foieign films
unuei 0S uistiibution, etc.
177
Will Foley
Nassachusetts
2u48

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Will Foley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Loiu of the Rings
Stai Wais
Appleseeu Ex Nachina
Fullmetal Alchemist
Saving Piivate Ryan
178
Bowaiu 0ienstein
21u74

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bowaiu 0ienstein

179
Bannah Fiank
Yaiuley, Pennsylvania
19u67

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bannah Fiank

18u
Iohn Bennison
Newaik, Belawaie
197u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Bennison

181
Phillip Boff
ulaustone, 0iegon
97u27

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Phillip Boff

182
Lois Ioiuan
8S749

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lois Ioiuan

18S
Beboiah Fox
197u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Beboiah Fox

184
Nate S
0hio
44444

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nate S

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Space Iam
18S
kyle sousa
uighton, Nassachusetts
271S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

kyle sousa

186
Naik Boyuen
Austin, Texas
7872S-S2SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

We can alieauy uo this with CBs legally. We shoulu be able to uo the same thing
legally with BvBs anu Blu-Ray anu such - to watch on oui own teims oui legally
licenseu copy.

Sinceiely,

Naik Boyuen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Planet of the Apes
Biazil
Ameiican Beauty
Alice in Wonueilanu
Ciusaues
The Life of Biian
The uieen Nile


187
Nichelle Pieice
Ianesville, Ninnesota
S6u48

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nichelle Pieice

188
Iames Shaltes
Caimichael, Califoinia
9S6u8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I unueistanu a possible ieasoning behinu why the cuiient policy is in place. Theie
aie people who woulu uistiibute the alteinate foimats to people without a license to
uo so even without commeicial intent. Bowevei, I uo not see it as appiopiiate to
iequiie consumeis to puichase a copy of a movie on BvB, BLu-iay, anu uigital
foimats foi use on my peisonal viueo uisplay uevices (iPau, anu Cieative Stone) all
sepaiately. I shoulu not have to pay auuitional amounts foi ieuunuant uata.



Thanks!

Sinceiely,

Iames Shaltes

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Willow
Piiue anu Piejuuice (BBC)


189
Biian Wiles
San Fiancisco, Califoinia
9411S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Biian Wiles

19u
Baviu Kaufman
Baitonsville, Pennsylvania
18S21

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own, anu have owneu but uamageu anu hau to uiscaiu, many Bisney BvB's that my
kius typically sciatch oi otheiwise uestioy, foicing me to buy them again (if anu
when Bisney makes them available foi sale again which, foi the ieal gieat classics, is
seluom -- what's up with that "back in the vault" business.) that I woulu love to be
able to legally make backup copies of, so that we can play them (anu uamage them)
without woiiy, because we keep the "oiiginal stoie-bought copy" in a safe place, so
that we can enjoy these classics ovei anu ovei again, foi yeais, without having to
pay foi them ovei anu ovei again, foi yeais.

Sinceiely,

Baviu Kaufman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Allauin, Alice in Wonueilanu, The Aiisocats, Bambi, Beauty anu the Beast, Bolt, A
Bug's Life, Cais, Cinueiella, vaiioos Little Einsteins, Banuy Nanny, Ny Fiienus
Tiggei anu Pooh, Buck Tales anu Nickey Nouse Clubhouse titles, Bumbo, 1u1
Balmations, Fantasia, Finuing Nemo, The Iungle Book, Lauy anu the Tiamp, Lilo &
Stitch, The Lion King, The Little Neimaiu, Nais neeus Noms, Naiy Poppins,
Nonsteis, Inc., Petei pan, Pinoccio, Pocahontas, Pooh's Beffalump Novie, The
Piincess anu the Fiog, Schoolhouse Rock, Snow White anu the Seven Bwaifs,
Tangleu, The Thiee Nusketeeis, Tinkei Bell, Toy Stoiy, Toy Stoiy 2 anu S, Tion,
Tion Legacy, 0p, WALL-E, Winnie The Pooh, A Wiinkle in Time,
191
AB AC
9SSS2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

AB AC

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bill anu Teu 1 anu 2, Tiaining Bay, vaiious tv shows, anu moie.
192
Eueaiu Ciaig
Eugene, 0iegon
974u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Eueaiu Ciaig

19S
ueoige Bauuau
21SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ueoige Bauuau

194
Buntei King
Nountain view, Califoinia
94u4u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu like to legally tiansfei these movies off of BvB onto my computei so my
thiee yeai olu can watch them without uestioying the physical uvus.

Sinceiely,

Buntei King

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Piincess Biiue
The Fifth Element
Cais
Eveiy pixai movie
19S
Iohn Kiichnei
Foit Wayne, Inuiana
468u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Kiichnei

196
Leah Papcke
4962S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Leah Papcke

197
bill gabbaiu
46uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

bill gabbaiu

198
Iulie Slatei-uiglioli
Califoinia
9uu46-6S12

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iulie Slatei-uiglioli

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

0nknown
The Time Tiavelei's Wife
199
Baviu 0libaiii
Chicago, Illinois
6u6S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Baviu 0libaiii

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bullit
Close Encounteis of the Thiiu Kinu
uhostbusteis
Stai Wais
2uu
Chailes Knight
ueoigia
SuS42

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chailes Knight

2u1
Alan Baggaiu
San Biego, Califoinia
921uS-S1u4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Alan Baggaiu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avatai, Blaue Runnei, The uoufathei, The Teiminatoi, Teiminatoi 2, uooufellas,
Casino, uone With The Winu, BBC's Planet Eaith, Stai Tiek, Staiship Tioopeis, A
Clockwoik 0iange, Loiu of The Rings Tiilogy, Stai Wais 0iiginal Tiilogy, Pulp
Fiction, Lawience of Aiabia, etc.
2u2
Nike Leaiy
9811S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nike Leaiy

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Eiic the viking
Fight Club
Requiem foi a Bieam
2uS
Ken Buike
0aklanu, Califoinia
9461S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I teach film histoiy anu ciiticism at a Califoinia college. It is essential foi me to
make back-up copies of the BvBs that I own in case the oiiginals aie somehow lost
oi uamageu anu cannot immeuiately (oi at all) be ieplaceu. I uo nothing that
involves iesale, file shaiing, oi any othei foim of copyiight violation, but I uon't
want to be consiueieu a ciiminal just foi making piotection copies of uiscs that I
have legally puichaseu.

Sinceiely,

Ken Buike

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Boyz N the Boou
Chinatown
Citizen Kane
Beio
Netiopolis
Rules of the uame
Snow White anu the Seven Bwaifs
Toy Stoiy S
Thelma anu Louise
0nfoigiven
anu way too many moie to list heie
2u4
Nick Bayes
Noith Caiolina
27S26

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu love to be able to watch the movies I own on BvB on my iPhone on the go. It
isn't faii that I shoulu have to buy a movie again that I alieauy lawfully bought to
watch it on an aiiplane oi in a long cai tiip. I believe I'm being swinuleu, having to
buy movies again to watch them on my phone oi tablet.

Sinceiely,

Nick Bayes

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

National Tieasuie
Napoleon Bynamite
Avatai
Finuing Nemo
Toy Stoiy
2uS
Nichael Kempei
San Fiancisco, Califoinia
941u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own these uisks. They aie NY piopeity. You have N0 iight to uictate to me what I
will uo with NY piopeity.

Sinceiely,

Nichael Kempei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Blaue Runnei, The Belp, The Yeai of the Boise, anu many, many moie.
2u6
Baviu Lee
Chico, Califoinia
9S928-S8u8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Copying youi own BvBs is not a ciime.

Sinceiely,

Baviu Lee

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Blaueiunnei
The Thiiu Nan
Role Nouels


2u7
Tim 0eitel
New Yoik
1462u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Bollywoou has been the big uiivei behinu the BNCA, but they aie not the only ones
that shoulu have input on this issue. Copyiight shoulu always be a balance, but it
ceitainly looks like they been getting the bettei enu of this ueal foi quite a while,
between the BNCA, continuous copyiight extensions, anu veiy neaily S0PA¡PIPA.



Theie aie cleaily uisconnects between what Bollywoou wants anu what the public
wants. Bollywoou wants complete contiol anu wants us to pay, iepeateuly, foi the
same mateiial. The public wants to pay once, piefeiably cheaply, anu view that
same mateiial in whatevei foim is most convenient. See the piolifeiation of auuio
playeis, conveiteis, stoiage systems, etc.



As if the uisconnect wasn't cleai enough in the tieatment of BvBs vs CBs, Bulu
(which is mutually owneu by Bisney anu NBC0niveisal, among otheis) allows you
to watch ceitain shows on one uisplay (youi computei monitoi) but not on othei
uisplays (like youi Tv).



2u8
This soit of bizaiie tieatment of meuia will only be iesolveu if the Copyiight 0ffice
plays it's pait in N0T giving in to eveiy teiiifieu uemanu the movie¡tv inuustiy
makes, while they aie tiying to stay fiimly entiencheu in the 198us.

Sinceiely,

Tim 0eitel

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Suu
Iion Nan
Sheilock Bolmes
Real uenius
2u9
Boug Lanuau
SS7u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Boug Lanuau

21u
Kyle Nichols-veinon
Castle Bayne, Noith Caiolina
28429

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The uoveinment is getting too pushy with copyiight laws to the point wheie I'm not
even ceitain that it will be possible to use the inteinet oi even watch Tv at all. I
woulu ieally like people to chill out on Copyiight. It's all a big mess causing
conceins. I'm glau S0PA uiun't pass, but I'm woiiieu that ACTA will completely iuin
my ability to watch movies.



Some of my BvBs aie bauly uamageu which is why I've investeu into Netflix, but I
have continueu to buy BvBs as vaiious titles aie not available. With a music CB I can
just iip my uamageu uiscs onto new ones anu that pievents fuithui skipping, but I
cannot uo this with my BvB playei.



Please, we neeu to take away unessential laws that take away the fieeuoms of the
people, especially in these tioubling times.

Sinceiely,

Kyle Nichols-veinon

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

211
Titan AE
Saw 1-S
Final Bestination 1-S
The Simpsons Novie
Iohnny Bangeiously
Piiates 0f The Caiiibean 1-S
The Fiist 7 Baiiy Pottei movies
Poultiygeist:Night 0F The Chicken Beau
Epic Novie
Piince Caspian
The Lion The Witch anu The Waiuiobe
Twilight
Iion Nan
The Incieuible Bulk
Fantastic Foui:Rise 0f The Silvei Suifei
Futuiama volumes 1 anu 2
The Fiist Season of The Biak Show
Aqua Teen Bungei Foice volumes 1-4
Blue Baivest
Eveiy Stai Wais Novie
Watchmen
Scott Pilgiim vs The Woilu
Iuiassic Paik 1-S
Zombielanu
The Lion King


212
Kenneth Loafman
Plano, Texas
7Su9S-S8u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kenneth Loafman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Titanic, Blaueiunnei, Wanteu, anu about Suu moie.
21S
Nuiiel Couuuiiei-Cuiveui
9S1uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nuiiel Couuuiiei-Cuiveui

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Bouine Iuentity
The lion king
shiek
Stai Wais (all 6)
Nulan
Loiu of the iings (all S)
etc.
214
Connoi Baitzog
0swego, Illinois
6uS4S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Connoi Baitzog

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Baik Knight
The Big Bang Theoiy Seasons 1-4
Baiiy Pottei 1-7
The Niuule Season 1
Batman Begins


21S
Chiistophei Fiazei
New Yoik
1211u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chiistophei Fiazei

216
vivianne Nosca-Claik
Williams, 0iegon
97S44

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

When theie to many laws, they tiip ovei each othei. this seems to be one of those
times. Please iepaii is situation.

Sinceiely,

vivianne Nosca-Claik

217
Baviu Neissnei
Washington
981u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have a mouest collection of Suu oi so CBs, anu I have tiansfeiieu most of them to
iTunes anu my iPou. This way I can put the physical CBs into stoiage, so they uon't
take up valuable space, anu still listen to my music whenevei I want, eithei on the
iPou uiiectly, oi by plugging my iPou into my steieo system.



But the situation with BvBs is uiffeient. I own a numbei of computeis anu mobile
uevices such as iPaus, anu it is fiustiating that I can not watch movies anu othei
content that I have paiu foi on a uevice of my choice.



I believe that I shoulu be alloweu to use my meuia as I wish foi noncommeicial
puiposes, anu it is unfoitunate that the law on this mattei cuiiently piohibits what
shoulu be legal faii use.





Sinceiely,

Baviu Neissnei
218

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Somewheie in Time
Aii Foice 0ne
Nonty Python anu the Boly uiail
West Siue Stoiy
many otheis
219
Chailes Boisey
Buibank, Califoinia
91SuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Since I am able to backup music, please allow us to backup oui BvBs.

Sinceiely,

Chailes Boisey

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bigh Noon, 0utlaw Iosey Wales, Basic Instinct
22u
Iames Nulcaie
Claikston, Washington
994uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iames Nulcaie

221
Negan Cainey
Ninnesota
SS1uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Theie aie some shows I woulu like to puichase BvBs of except that no BvBs have
been ieleaseu foi Region 1 anu they aie not available uigitally.



Foi these shows theie is no legal way foi me to puichase the uesiieu content, shoit
of investing in a new BvB playei that's iegion fiee anu¡oi uses the PAL foimat.
Allowing iipping of BvBs foi space shifting woulu allow me to suppoit these shows.

Sinceiely,

Negan Cainey

222
Naik Pelusi
Pittsbuigh, Pennsylvania
1S224

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Naik Pelusi

22S
S.I. Anueison
4S4u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

S.I. Anueison

224
Allen ueoige
Nichigan
48S12

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Allen ueoige

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Finuing Nemo
August Rush
Initial B
Case Closeu
The Empeioi's New uioove
Nonsteis Inc.
22S
Stefan Kozinski
Wilmington, Belawaie
198u2-11u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Stefan Kozinski

226
Iohn Noszyk
St Louis, Nissouii
6S129

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Noszyk

227
Evan Biiuges
0iegon
972u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I think that I shoulu be alloweu to back up copies of the movies I own to my
computei: what if one of them becomes unieauable.

Sinceiely,

Evan Biiuges

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Amelie
Almost Famous
Acioss the 0niveise
Bo The Right Thing
Noulin Rouge
The Reu violin
I Beait Buckabees
The Tiiplets of Belleville
The 0.S. veisus Iohn Lennon
Waking Life
Casablanca
Reai Winuow
Wonuei Boys
Piincess Nononoke
228
Blake Buthou
6S1u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Blake Buthou

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Yes Nan
Avatai
Stai Wais
Inception
(Suu) Bays of Summei
Blast fiom the Past
229
Thomas Lee
WASBINuT0N, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuu1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I feel that, having legally puichaseu this meuia, I shoulu be able to choose which
uevice(s) I want to use to view it.

Sinceiely,

Thomas Lee

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Pieuatoi
The Natiix
The Big Lebowski
2Su
uaiy Benese
Pennsylvania
1S21S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uaiy Benese

2S1
Nonika uieene
Floiiua
S2S7u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I alieauy paiu foi anu now own these BvBs. I shoulu be legally alloweu to use them
any way anu on any uevice I please, in the piivacy of my own home.



Sinceiely,

Nonika uieene

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

0h Biothei, Wheie Ait Thou
The Big Lebowski
August Rush
Benny anu Ioon
The Seciet Life of Bees
Buin Aftei Reauing
No Countiy foi 0lu Nen
The Nen Who Staie at uoats
The Life Aquatic
Ace ventuia, Pet Betective
anu hunuieus moie....


2S2
Ionathan Sanueis
Castaic, Califoinia
91S84

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This woulu be gieat, college in 2 yeais, if I coulu just have all my movies anu Tv
Shows on my laptop foi school I won't have to woiiy about the uisks. Anu also if you
uo iemove this iestiiction but place one on uigital files, it will cut back on illegal
uownloauing of movies.

Sinceiely,

Ionathan Sanueis

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Without a Pauule
Inception
Chuck
Psych
2SS
Annemaiie Piaiiie
Coloiauo
8uSuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Annemaiie Piaiiie

2S4
Ann Khambholja
Aiizona
8S7S6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ann Khambholja

2SS
Ramon Bushee
Texas
7S4u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ramon Bushee

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nonsteis, Inc.
2S6
Ken Beuges
Lemon uiove, Califoinia
9194S-Suuu

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ken Beuges

2S7
Anastasia Chebeienchick
Biiugeville , Pennsylvania
1Su17

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I think it's peifectly ieasonable foi people to be able to make a uigital backup of any
meuia they puichase a haiucopy of in case the oiiginal meuia is uamageu by
bieakage oi sciatching, also not all viueo playback enableu uevices I own aie
capable of ieauing fiom optical uisc such as a BvB oi CB R0N.



0bviously the ability to uo this is alieauy piesent, anu this woulun't encouiage
piiacy as someone intent on illegal uistiibution oi copy isn't going to be ueteiieu by
the legality of one auuitional step when the entiie act is ciiminal. Ciiminalising
Ripping foi peisonal use only haims consumeis of legitimate meuia.

Sinceiely,

Anastasia Chebeienchick

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Six Feet 0nuei Boxeu Set
The Ciow
Planet Eaith
Wateiship Bown
2S8
Nichael Nachtigal
Tampa, Floiiua
SS647

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It uoesn't make sense to iestiict what I uo (faiily) with the meuia I puichase, the
meuia on which I spenu my money. People who obtain movies online fiom
unauthoiizeu uistiibution channels have zeio hassle, wheieas if one pays foi a title
anu acquiies it thiough authoiizeu uistiibution channels, one has to jump thiough
uozens of hoops anu has to live with BRN iestiictions on one's meuia. It's patently
cleai that movie files obtaineu thiough unauthoiizeu uistiibution channels have
highei value, iiiespective of the monetaiy piice of the BvB on a ietailei's shelf.



See just these two links, founu by seaiching foi "piiacy is not a pioblem" in a
populai Inteinet seaich engine:

http:¡¡unueiuesign.files.woiupiess.com¡2u1u¡u2¡gxzev.jpg.w=7uu&h=721

http:¡¡eiicsiiley.woiupiess.com¡2u11¡11¡24¡piiacy-is-the-symptom-not-the-
pioblem¡



0nauthoiizeu fileshaiing is not a pioblem, anu ceitainly not a pioblem to solve with
Inteinet censoiship anu iegulation (ahem, PIPA, S0PA, ACTA): inueeu, it is a
symptom of a uecaying system, a system that pioviues uecieasing value foi
inuiviuuals who uemanu high value anu can obtain it elsewheie with little
2S9
consiueiation foi the cost of obtaining it. Paying foi a, e.g., movie title will get you a
title with BRN that is illegal to bypass even foi legal use (we seek to change that
now moie than evei), anu that's only if you can finu a copy of that title in a legal
uistiibution channel! Bistuibingly anu incieasingly fiequently movies, songs, anu
books aie impossible to finu in authoiizeu uistiibution channels, so inuiviuuals seek
alteinative uistiibution channels in oiuei to obtain what they seek, anu again, with
little thought given to cost: one woulu pay if one coulu uo so!



Please consiuei the iights anu libeities of the public when consiueiing extenuing oi
stiengthening copyiight legislation. Nuch haim has been uone in the past with bills
like CTEA anu BNCA. The BNCA hasn't cuibeu anu bills like it shoulu not seek to
cuib the shaiing of infoimation on the Inteinet, just as bills shoulu not seek to cuib
the shaiing of physical books, CBs, physical BvBs, infoimation, oi iueas. Anu if the
goal is to have moie people pay foi meuia, foi goouness's sake, entice them! uet iiu
of BRN, oi make it legal to bypass it foi faii use.



Thanks foi youi consiueiation. I'm a computei engineei at a state univeisity in
Floiiua.

Sinceiely,

Nichael Nachtigal

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Fifth Element
Eveiybouy Loves Raymonu (Su+ BvBs)
Sciubs (2u+ BvBs)
Wings (2u+ BvBs)
Speeu Racei
Saw
Saw II
Saw III
Saw Iv
Saw v
Saw vI
Stai Wais (6 BvBs, the entiie saga)
Inuiana Iones (S titles)
Iumanji
...anu uozens of othei titles
24u
angela fazzaii
9721S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

angela fazzaii

241
Zachaiy uuenthei
Sunman, Inuiana
47u41

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Zachaiy uuenthei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

ulauiatoi
S:1u to Yuma
Taken
uameis: Boikness Rising
uous anu ueneials
Anu many otheis...
242
Benjamin Ciopp
Lawience, Kansas
66u44

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Benjamin Ciopp

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Auaptation
uieen Nile
Bottle Rocket
Patiiot
Neet the Paients
Spanglish
Spiuei Nan
Apocalypse Now
24S
Bouglas Bennett
Bella vista, Califoinia
96uu8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Bow many times uo we have to pay to own a BvB anu view it. Sometimes, in touay
uigital age, we have a neeu to have oui movies on othei uevices to view. The woilu
is not as simple as it useu to be. Please, make it simple anu legal foi us to use oui
own piopeity in any way we choose.

Thank you.

Sinceiely,

Bouglas Bennett

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nany, too many to list.
244
Fiancisco Ramiiez
Chicago, Illinois
6u617

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fiancisco Ramiiez

24S
Nichael Iohnson
Salem, 0iegon
97SuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

in one of the Collectoi's Euition of Tim Buiton's The Nightmaie Befoie Chiistmas, it
came with a Bigital Copy. 0ne that you coulu Rip to youi ITunes oi WNP. I think this
is a step in the iight Biiection, i uon't see why it shoulu mattei weathei i watch the
movies i buy on my Tv oi my IPou, as long as you pay foi it once you shoulu be able
to watch it on whatevei you please.

Sinceiely,

Nichael Iohnson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bleach
0ne piece
Naiuto
FLCL
Beath Note
Biagon Ball z
Pokemon
South Paik
Family uuy
Resiuent Evil
Bawn of the Beau
Baka anu Test anu many many moie (believe me)
246
Nichael W Evans
Los Angeles, Califoinia
9uuS4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nichael W Evans

247
Ieffii Fiontz
Columbus, 0hio
4S2u2-1444

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ieffii Fiontz

248
William Schunke
Washington
98uu1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

William Schunke

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Tiek
Baiiy Pottei
Seienity
WallE
249
Natthew uueieio
96816

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natthew uueieio

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais (Entiie Collection)
Chionicles of Riuuick
Seconuhanu Lions
Lion King
Saving Piivate Ryan
Fifth Element
2Su
Pamela Check
Chico, Califoinia
9S926

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Pamela Check

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Sita Sings the Blues
2S1
Natthew Beining
Foit Wayne, Inuiana
468SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natthew Beining

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Fight Club
The Piestige
Nemento
The Boonuock Saints
Shawshank Reuemption
uieen Nile
Inception
Batman Begins
Batman: The Baik Knight
Bistiict 9
2S2
Kelly Lanueis
Columbia, Connecticut
62S7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kelly Lanueis

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

All eight Baiiy Pottei films
The Loiu of the Rings tiilogy
The entiiety of Nonty Python's Flying Ciicus
The Fiiefly television seiies
The Stuuio 6u on the Sunset Stiip television seiies
Spiiiteu Away
Piincess Nononoke
Bow to Tiain Youi Biagon
Reu, Sheilock Bolmes
R.E.N.T.
v foi venuetta
anu many, many moie.
2SS
Natt Kiaai
91786

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natt Kiaai

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uiounuhog Bay
Bappy-uo-Lucky
2S4
Anuies Pacheco
Kellei, Texas
76248

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Anuies Pacheco

2SS
Eiic Nay
SS4S6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please make it legal

Sinceiely,

Eiic Nay

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Finuing nemo
Batman
2S6
Ioseph Ranghelli
Biooklyn, New Yoik
112u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

In this age of inuiviuuals owning multiple inteiactive uevices it makes sense to allow
useis the flexibility to have access to the contents of theii legally puichaseu BvBs
among theii legally puichaseu uevices. Piivileging one inuustiy above useis anu
othei inuustiies smacks of favoiitism, anu in the enu is not economically sounu foi
the countiy.

Sinceiely,

Ioseph Ranghelli

2S7
Natalie Batovsky
0nion Biiuge, Naiylanu
21791

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natalie Batovsky

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

School of Rock
Nobouy's Fool
Bigh Fiuelity
Lost in Tianslation
2S8
annette biyant
kansas city, Nissouii
641S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

annette biyant

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

We own ovei 1uu BvB's
2S9
Theouoie Wintei
21uSu

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I think that it is iiuiculous that I cannot copy uata that I have paiu foi on to a uevice
that I own.

Sinceiely,

Theouoie Wintei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I have paiu foi ovei 1uu movies on BvB.
26u
Anuiew Neikle
1484S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Anuiew Neikle

261
Kaia Novak
Washington, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuu9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I'u like to watch the BvBs I own, like the ones above, on my iPhone anu Kinule Fiie.

Sinceiely,

Kaia Novak

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Piiates of the Caiibbean
0ncle Buck
27 Biesses
262
Kiik Patton
Antioch, Califoinia
94SS1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I use Linux foi much of my woik anu leisuie. Theie aie no legal BvB playeis foi
Linux. It is iiuiculous that I woulu be consiuei to be bieaking the law by simply
playing a movie I have puichaseu on that 0S.



Please fix this

Sinceiely,

Kiik Patton

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Weuuing Singei
The Natiix
Bighlanuei
Complete Sienfielu Seiies
Teiminatoi
Total Recall
0vei a hunuieu othei legally puichase movies...
26S
Caiiie Phyliky Rimes
Cabot, Aikansas
72u2S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Caiiie Phyliky Rimes

264
Astiiu uiese-Zimmei
Califoinia
947uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Astiiu uiese-Zimmei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Rocky Boiioi Pictuie Show
uoou Noining vietnam
Beau Poets Society
Fight Club
Bonnie Baiko
Pietty In Pink
26S
William Buuley
Iackson, New Ieisey
8S27

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It is also technically illegal foi me to watch BvBs on my Linux computei since the
piogiam to uecoue the BvB isn't "appioveu". I uon't BAvE anothei computei, anu I
want to watch my BvBs on NY computei.



Thanks foi youi attention,

Sinceiely,

William Buuley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Natiix (1, 2, S)
Spawn (1, 2, S)
0utlanu
2u1u
Tuckei
X-Nen
266
Teii Lamoui
0io valley, Aiizona
8S7S7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Teii Lamoui

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The entiie Baiiy Pottei 8-uvu seiies
The Fellowship of the Ring extenueu veision + extias
The Two Toweis extenueu veision + extias
The Retuin of the King extenueu veision + extia
The Runuown
The Expenuables
Ninoiity Repoit
Nission Impossible
Nission Impossible 2
anu much, much moie
267
Lucas Bissong
4S2S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lucas Bissong

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avatai
Fiist Knight
Batman Begins
The Incieuibles
Boiton Beais A Who
many many moie
268
Naneesh Pangasa
Yuma, Aiizona
8SS6S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I believe consumeis who own majoi motion pictuies on BvBs incluuing live action
full length featuie films like Captain Ameiica: The Fiist Avengei, Thoi, Spiueiman
etc oi even animateu films like Buck Tales Tieasuie of the Lost Lamp shoulu legally
be able to copy the contents of theii BvBs anu¡oi Blu Ray Biscs to theii computeis
to conveit the viueos to othei foimats. I agiee with the movie stuuios that iipping
ienteu BvBs is not iight but I'm asking to uo so only foi the BvBs I own.



Suppose I buy the movie Spiueiman on BvB anu have a tablet like Apple's iPau oi
othei uevice like Apple Tv I want to use to play the movie I shoulu not have to ie-
puichase the film fiom iTunes Stoie. Imagine if I alieauy owneu a copy of
Spiueiman on BvB why shoulu I have to ie-puichase it fiom Apple's iTunes Stoie
foi viewing on iPaus, iPhones, anu¡oi iPou Touches I might own. Time shifting anu
place shifting of content I own copies of shoulu be legal. I shoulu have a faii use iight
to copy a movie I own on one foimat to anothei so I can play it on the mobile
uevices of my choice. That incluues Niciosoft's Zune BB anu poitable meuia playeis
compatible with Winuows Neuia Playei. It also incluues tiansfei of the copieu
movie file to an Apple Tv, Roku, PSS oi othei uevice foi viewing films on Tv using a
set top box.



269
A lot of times when I want to watch films I uon't feel like changing the BvB in my
BvB Playei. I'u much iathei piefei to copy my films to a uevice with a haiu uiive
like the oiiginal Apple Tv which alloweu syncing content anu watch what I want
when I want just by selecting the film on the uevice anu playing it uiiectly. That is so
much easiei than having to get up to put in¡take out a BvB oi Blu Ray Bisc eveiy
time you want to watch one. I know theie aie BvB Playeis that can fit 6 uiscs at a
time but have one that can only fit 1 uisc. So each time I want to watch a uiffeient
BvB have to take out the BvB alieauy in theie.





Sinceiely,

Naneesh Pangasa

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Captain Ameiica: The Fiist Avengei
Bocus Pocus
Thoi
Stai Wais 0iiginal Tiilogy
Spiueiman
The Ba vinci Coue
Piiates of the Sillicon valley
BuckTales Tieasuie of the Lost Lamp


27u
Chiis Thompson
Nechanicsville, viiginia
2S111

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chiis Thompson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uumb anu uumbei
tioy
the blinu siue
cleiks
supeibau
olu school


271
Beni Albiecht
Aubuin, Califoinia
9S6uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

SSu-82S-6SS6

Sinceiely,

Beni Albiecht

272
Aithui Foie Ii
New Biaunfels, Texas
781S2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Aithui Foie Ii

27S
Caioline Peit
Bouluei, Coloiauo
8uSu1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Caioline Peit

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Cat Retuins
FInuing Nemo
Spaceballs
The Nightmaie Befoie Chiistmas
Ny Neighboi Totoio


274
Naneesh Pangasa
Yuma, Aiizona
8SS6S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own BvBs!



I own uevices with scieens!



I want to combine them!



I own movies on BvB. I own mobile uevices with scieens anu it is stupiu that useis
cannot legally copy a movie they own fiom one meuium to anothei.



Buh. 0nlike CBs BvBs have uigital locks anu the veiy act of bieaking them even foi
a legitimate puipose can be a violation of the law anu get one sueu. Bowevei, eveiy
thiee yeais the 0.S. Copyiight 0ffice looks foi pioblems with the BNCA anu giants
exemptions. This yeai Public Knowleuge is asking the Copyiight 0ffice to giant an
exemption letting useis bieak uigital locks on the BvBs they own to copy them anu
watch them on the uevices they also own.

27S
Sinceiely,

Naneesh Pangasa

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Captain Ameiica: The Fiist Avengei
Thoi
0iiginal Stai Wais Tiilogy
Spiueiman
Bocus Pocus
Bucktales Tieasuie of the Lost Lamp
Piiates of the Sillicon valley
276
Anthony Aicuie
Califoinia
9S722

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Anthony Aicuie

277
Anthony Bommaiito
94121

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Anthony Bommaiito

278
Ryan Klein
Wisconsin
SSuS1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ryan Klein

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Fai to many movies to list.
279
Baibaia Iua
Nelbouine, Floiiua
S29SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Baibaia Iua

28u
uieg Fostei
Nebiaska
871u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It is iiuiculous that I cannot make a copy of something that I have puichaseu. Some
of my BvBs aie ten yeais olu oi moie anu aie getting sciatcheu. I shoulu have the
iight to make a copy of that BvB so I can continue to watch it without having to go
out anu buy anothei copy.

Sinceiely,

uieg Fostei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I have hunuieu of BvBs. To many to mention heie but some of the highlights aie
Biaveheait, Saving Piivate Ryan, Rocky, anu all the Stai Tiek anu Stai Wais movies.
281
K Naiu
Connecticut
69uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

K Naiu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais
282
Kevin Noiiison
Iuaho
8SSu1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This notice is asking if I can move the movie, how about just the simple fact that the
meuia the movie is piinteu on is fiagile anu I want a backup!

Sinceiely,

Kevin Noiiison

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Liteially thousanus
28S
Claie Peaison
Illinois
6u61S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I use my uvus to teach anu have to loan my peisonal copies to the libiaiy foi
stuuents to check out-- that leaves me having to buy a seconu copy to piep my class,
which is not faii. I have also hau a numbei of uvus get sciatcheu oi woin oi bieak,
anu a backup copy piotects my investment. I also have liveu in othei countiies anu
have bought uvus fiom a numbei of uiffeient iegions, anu shoulu be able to play
these on any piece of playback equipment I own. Being able to make a iegion-fiee
backup is only faii.

Sinceiely,

Claie Peaison

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

0nfoigiven
Loiu of the Rings
Bouse of Sanu anu Fog
Waking Neu Bevine
The Natiix
Blaueiunnei
0 Biothei Wheie Ait Thou
Lawience of Aiabia
Kunuun
Bo the Right Thing
! #XV!
_A/!:(&&(1)!
_A/!DA()()=!
_A/!;(5)(&'!
?11,!b5)0!d%[/!
HR+(4/!1>!'A/!D%)!
5)0!5)!/)'(4/!N11[&A/,>!1>!1'A/4&!
!
28S
Robeit Kellei
New Ieisey
7uS4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Robeit Kellei

286
Rhonua Bolt
4SS42

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Rhonua Bolt

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bancock
Biinging 0p Baby
Cauuyshack
The Roau to Wellville
Nonstei Bouse
287
Ioseph Baussmann
Baytona Beach, Floiiua
S2118

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Copyiights aie supposeu to "piomote useful piogiess in the science anu aits".
Insteau, cuiient copyiight law is useu to stifle innovation anu ietaiu piogiess, all foi
the benefit of the caitels that contiol the enteitainment inuustiies. The aitists
themselves uo not benefit, inueeu, the cuiient system wiests contiol of an aitists
woik fiom them.

Sinceiely,

Ioseph Baussmann

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Extiaoiuinaiily Beluxe Euition of Nonty Python & the Boly uiail
Life of Biian
Buel In The Sun
Bancing at the Blue Iguana
0ne Eyeu Iacks
Seienity
Beaitbieakeis
The Insatiable
Bitchhikei's uuiue to the ualaxy
Also on BvB:
All 7 seasons of "Buffy the vampiie Slayei"
The complete season of "Fiiefly"
288
Season 0ne of "The Tick"
Season Two of "The Tick"
The complete seiies of "Bilbeit"
The Complete Nonty Python's Flying Ciicus 16 Ton Negaset
anu moie...
289
Silvia Ball
Floiiua
SS4S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Silvia Ball

29u
Steven uiay
Noith Caiolina
27uS4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have bought anu paiu foi all the movies in my collection. I shoulu be able to make
copies of these movies to piotect them fiom uamage. If one of my BvBs oi CBs
becomes uamageu then I have to spenu the same money again. Some of my music
CBs aie not available any longei anu the same with some movies.I shoulu have the
iight to make uuplicates of my entiie collection to pievent loss. The ieason foi this
is that theie is no piotection oi ieplacement waiianty that comes with any of these
piouucts. It is theiefoie unfaii to me as a consumei not to be able to make back-ups
of my collection to pievent loss. If the music oi movie inuustiy wants to lowei the
cost of these items to $1 then buying a ieplacement is not cost piohibitive. Insteau
music CBs aie $1u-2u pei copy anu BvBs aie even moie. I have multiple playeis foi
both music anu movies. I shoulu not have to buy the same piouuct ovei anu ovei foi
each of my uevices. By all iights consumeis shoulu be able to chaige the music
piouuceis anu movie piouuceis foi use of the piouucts that we buy in oiuei to
piotect oui investments.

Sinceiely,

Steven uiay

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Fast & Fuiious
Biaveheait
Boine Tiilogy
! #K"!
'11!R5)@!R14/!'1!,(&'!
292
Anuiew Bezella
SAN FRANCISC0, Califoinia
94117

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Anuiew Bezella

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Aiiesteu Bevelopment
News Rauio
The West Wing
Spoits Night
Aiiplane!
Cauuyshack
0ffice Space
Animal Bouse
N*A*S*B
Big Tiouble in Little China
Natiix
The Ciow
Young Fiankenstein
Cleiks
Blazing Sauules
29S
mohammau almoayyau
uenton, Texas
762u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

mohammau almoayyau

294
Robeit Caii
Leicestei, Noith Caiolina
28748

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Robeit Caii

29S
Scott Fianklin
El Paso, Texas
799SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Scott Fianklin

296
Tylei Ruuy
Baileyville, Illinois
61uu7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Tylei Ruuy

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

stai wais
loiu of the iings
jason vs fieuuy
fiiuay the 1Sth


297
chiistophei claik
Plymouth, Nichigan
4817u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

If possible, I tiansfei all of my movies to a computei (a meuia PC), which is intenueu
only to play music anu movies on my Tv. I uo this to conseive space in my
apaitment anu oiganize a faiily laige collection of movies.



I finu it annoying, anu entiiely unjust, that I am pieventeu fiom using the uevice of
my choice to piivately view movies, which I have legally puichaseu. I feel that the
same law which applies to music shoulu be applieu to all foims of meuia. It is a
uouble stanuaiu to allow people to copy theii legally puichaseu music onto a
computei haiu uiive, an iPou oi a tablet PC, but not to allow them to uo the same
with theii legally puichaseu movies.

Sinceiely,

chiistophei claik

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

8NN -Eight Nilimetei
12 Angie Nen
28 Bays Latei
Suu
1984 (19S6)
298
1984 (1984)
2uu1: A space 0uyssey
A.I. -Aitificial Intelligence
Alauuin
Alice in Wonueilanu
All 0uiet on the Westein Fiont
Along Came a Spiuei
Ameiican Beauty
Ameiican Ciime, An
Ameiican Bistoiy X
Ameiican Psycho
Ancient Rome: The Rise anu Fall of an Empiie
Apocalypse Now
Apt Pupil
Aquateen Bungei Foice Colon Novie Film Foi Theateis
Ailington Roau
Assassin of Youth (19S7)
Avatai
Baiiy Lynuon
Batman
Batman Retuins
Batman Foievei
Batman anu Robin
Batman Begins
Batman: The Baik Knight
Beautiful Ninu, A
Beauty anu the Beast
Ben-Bui
Bible vs. The Book of Noimon, The
Big Lebowski, The
Big 0ne, The
Biius, The
Black Bahlia, The
Black Snake Noan
Blaue Runnei
Blow
Blue Lagoon, The
Boonuock Saints, The
Bouine Iuentity, The
Bouine Supiemacy, The
Bouine 0ltimatum, The
Bowling foi Columbine
Biam Stokei's Biacula
Biiue of Fiankenstein, The
Biiuge to Teiabithia
Biief Bistoiy of Time, A
299
Butteifly Effect, The
Captain Bloou
Capitalism: A Love Stoiy
Casino
Chalie Wilson's Wai
Chasing Amy
China Town
Cinueiella
Citizen Kane
Cleiks
Cleiks II
Clockwoik 0iange, A
Cocaine Fienus, The (19SS)
Conan the Baibaiian
Conan the Bestioyei
Cieatuie fiom the Black Lagoon
Bay the Eaith Stoou Still, The (19S1)
Beathpioof
Beliveiance
Beppaiteu, The
Bevil Bat, The
Bevil Riues 0ut, The
BNA vs. The Book of Noimon
Bogma
Bonnie Biasco
Bonnie Baiko
Boubt
Bi. Stiangelove, oi: Bow I Leaineu to Stop Woiiying anu Love the Bomb
Biacula
Biacula's Baughtei
Bumbo
Euwaiu Scissoihanus
Evil Beau. The
Excalibui
Eyes Wiue Shut
Fahienheit 9¡11
Fight Club
Foibiuuen Planet
Fiankenstein
Fiankenstein Neets the Wolf Nan
Fiantic
Fieaks
Fiom Bell
Full Netal Iacket
uhost of Fiankenstein, The
uoufathei, The
Suu

uoufathei, The, Pait II
uoufathei, The, Pait III
uoumakeis, The
uoumakeis II, The
uous anu Nonsteis
uone with the Winu
uoou Night, anu uoou Luck
uoouFellas
uiass
uian Toiino
uiapes of Wiath, The
uieat Expectations (1946)
uieat Expectations (1998)
uieystoke - The Legenu of Taizan, Loiu of the Apes
uuys anu Bolls
Bannibal
Bannibal Rising
Baiiy Pottei
-anu the Soiceiei's Stone
-anu the Chambei of Seciets
-anu the Piisonei of Azkaban
-anu the uoblet of Fiie
-anu the 0iuei of the Phoenix
-anu the Balf Bloou Piince
Be Was a 0uiet Nan
Beltei Skeltei (1976)
Biue anu Seek
Bighlanuei
Bighlanuei 2 - The 0uickening
Bighlanuei S - The Soiceiei
Bighlanuei S - The Souice (Boiiible)
Bistoiy of Biitain, A
Bole, The
Bouse of Biacula
Bouse of Fiankenstein
Bunchback of Notie Bame, The (19S9)
Bunchback of Notie Bame, The (1996)
Bunt foi Reu octobei, The
I Know Who Killeu Ne
I Spit on Youi uiave
Iuiociacy
Inuiana Iones:
-anu the Raiueis of the Lost Aik
-anu the Temple of Boom
-anu the Last Ciusaue
Su1
-anu the Kinguom of the Ciystal Skull
Ingloiious Basteius
Inteiview with the vampiie
Iackie Biown
Iames Bonu:
-Bi. No
-Fiom Russia with Love
-Thunueiball
-0n Bei Najesty's Seciet Seivice
-Biamonus Aie Foievei
-Live anu Let Bie
-The Nan with the uoluen uun
-The Spy Who Loveu Ne
-uolueneye
-The Woilu is Not Enouogh
-Bie Anothei Bay
-Casino Royale
-0uantum of Solace
Iay anu Silent Bob Stiike Back
Iungle Book, The
Iust Cause
K-19: The Wiuowmakei
Kius
Kill Bill vol. 1
Kill Bill vol. 2
Kiss the uiils
Lauy anu the Tiamp
Legenus of the Fall
Lion King, The
Little Neimaiu, The
Logan's Run
Lolita (1962)
Lolita (1997)
Loiu of the Flies (199u)
The Loiu of the Rings:
-Fellowship of the Ring
-The Two Toweis
-Retuin of the King
Lost Book of Abiaham, The
Lovely Bones, The
Nalliats
Nan Who Knew Too Nuch, The
Nainie
Naiiy Shelley's Fiankenstein
Natiix, The
Natiix Reloaueu, The
Su2
Natiix Revolutions, The
Natt Belm Lounge:
-The Silenceis
-Nuiueiei's Row
-The Ambusheis
-The Wieking Ciew
Niunight in the uaiuen of uoou anu Evil
Noney Nasteis: Bow Banks Cieate the Woilu's Noney
Noimons, The -Ameiican Expeiience
Nummy, The (19S2)
Name of the Rose, The
Nazis, The - A Waining fiom Bistoiy
Ninth uate, The
No Countiy foi 0lu Nen
Nosfeiatu: A Symphony of Boiioi
0 Biothei, Wheie Ait Thou.
0f Nice anu Nen (19S9)
0ffice Space
The 0men (1976)
0nce 0pon a Time in Ameiica
0ne Flew 0vei the Cuckoo's Nest
0ne Boui Photo
0ne Nillion Yeais B.C.
0iphan, The
Patton
Petei Pan
Phantom of the 0peia (192S)
Phantom of the 0peia (194S)
PI
Pinocchio
Piiates of the Caiibbean:
-The Cuise fo the Black Peail
-Beau Nan's Chest
-At Woilu's Enu
Planet of the Apes:
-Planet of the Apes (0iiginal)
-Beneath the Planet of the Apes
-Escape Fiom the Planet of the Apes
-Conquest of the Planet of the Apes
-Battle foi the Planet of the Apes
Planet Teiioi
Pieuatoi
Pincess Biiue, The
Piofessional, The
Psycho
Public Enemies
SuS
Pulp Fiction
Race to Witch Nountain
Reaping, The
Reai Winuow
Reu Biagon
Reefei Nauness (19S6)
Religulous
Requiem foi a Bieam
Reseivoii Bogs
Retuin to the Blue Lagoon
Robin Boou (197S)
Rogei anu Ne
Romeo anu Iuliet
Root of All Evil
Rosemaiy's Baby
S. Baiko - A Bonnie Baiko Tale
Scannei Baikly, A
Scaiface
Seciet of Nimh, The
Seciet of 0z, The
Seciet Winuow
Septembei Bawn
Seienity
Seven
Shauow of a Boubt
Shining, The
Sicko
Silence of the Lambs, The
Simpsons Novie, The
Sin City
Sleeping Beauty
Sleepy Bollow
Snow White anu the Seven Bwaifs
Somewheie in Time
Son of Biacula
Son of Fiankenstein
Sounu of Nusic, The
Soylent uieen
Stai Tiek:
-The Notion Pictuie
-The Wiath of Khan
-The Seaich foi Spock
-The voyage Bome
-The Final Fiontiei
-The 0nuiscoveieu Countiy
-ueneiations
Su4
-Fiist Contact
-Insuiiection
-Nemesis
-Stai Tiek (2uu9)
Stai Wais:
-The Phantom Nenace
-Attack of the Clones
-Revenge of the Sith
-A New Bope
-The Empiie Stiikes Back
-Retuin of the Ieui
Stephen Bawking's 0niveise
Stoiytelling
Stiangelanu
Swingeis
Swoiu in the Stone, The
Taken
Taxi Biivei
Ten Commanuments, The
Teiminatoi, The
Teiminatoi 2
Theie Will Be Bloou
Time Nachine, The (196u)
To Kill a Nockingbiiu
To the Bevil a Baughtei
Total Recall
Tiainspotting
vampiie Ciicus
veitigo
viigin Suiciues, The
visions of the Futuie
Watchmen
West Siue Stoiy
White Zombie
Wickei Nan, The (197S)
Wilu Things
Witnesses of Iehovah
Wizaiu of 0z, The
Zaiuoz
SuS
Naiia Rausis
Nountain view, Califoinia
94u4u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Naiia Rausis

Su6
ueoffiey vonbaigen
Lewiston, Iuaho
8SSu1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu like to be able to Legally move movies anu viueos to my laptop, ipou anu
othei uevices so that I can watch them much easiei on the go.

Theie is ieally no ieason why this shoulu not be illegal, If I bought it, than what is
wiong with me watching it on a uevice that I own.

Sinceiely,

ueoffiey vonbaigen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uuiien Lagann
Natinal Tieasuie
The Loiu of the Rings
uunbustei
uenshiken
Nonty Python anu the Seich foi The Bolly uiail
Piiates of The Caiabean
Su7
valeiie gilbeit
New Yoik, New Yoik
1uu22-S742

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

what about when I hau iecoius in the 7us anu 8us anu iecoiueu them on cassette.
what's the uiffeience.

Sinceiely,

valeiie gilbeit

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

the matiix
Su8
melissa millei
Califoinia
94S2u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

melissa millei

Su9
jim baith
Nunstei, Inuiana
46S21

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

jim baith

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

open iange,
in biuges,
citizen kane,
anu hunuieus moie
S1u
Stephen Thompson
Chesapeake, viiginia
2SS2S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

If I puichase a copy of a viueo, I shoulu be alloweu to piotect anu pieseive that copy.
I shoulu also be alloweu to view that copy on whatevei peisonally-owneu uevice oi
scieen that I want to.



I place each viueo that I puichase into my peisonal uigital aichive foi safe-keeping,
ieplace my own sciatcheu meuia, anu tiansfei viueos to meuia playeis as neeueu foi
family viewing.



I uo not collect piiateu viueos noi uo I uistiibute my aichiveu copies oi piiateu
viueos.



Sinceiely,

Stephen Thompson

S11
Alice Smith
uioton, Nassachusetts
14Su

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Alice Smith

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tiopic Thunuei
Chaplin
Iulie anu Iulia
S12
Aufeno Buvlov
8822uuuu

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Beai Copyiight 0ffice.



We aie expeiiencing gieat changes in this centuiy. uepiive us to use the full
functionability of something is the same as:



- Nake a cake anu tell eveiyone they cannot eat anu touch it, just smell it.



- Wiite a book anu eiase the text, leaving just images anu lots of blank pages.



BR. Aufeno

Bave a nice uay.

Sinceiely,

Aufeno Buvlov

S1S
I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bonanza, 1st season (uift by my fathei):
Black Stallion:
Evita (Playeu only once, well maintaineu):
Into The Wilu.
S14
Kaiim Baiuai
ueoigia
Su188

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own movies in BvB anu now also in Blu-iay, sometimes even the same movie to
get the blu-iay expeiience.



I woulu like to be able to cieate a copy of the movies I own, legally, without bieaking
the law, onto my seivei so I can watch the movies fiom my netwoik attacheu
computeis using fiont enus like Winuows Neuia Centei anu XBNC.



I believe that bieaking the enciyption in oiuei to legally make a backup copy of
movies you own shoulu fall unuei faii use anu shoulu not be blockeu by the BNCA.

Sinceiely,

Kaiim Baiuai

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avatai
The Baik Knight
The Incieuibles
Iion Nan
! 6"9!
G41)!:5)!#!
O(E[!*&&!
I5,,LH!
_A/!:5'4(Q!
<5RN1!
O%)=!3%!;5)05!
S!>14!S/)0/''5!
nL:/)!
S16
Iohn Witmei
South Caiolina
296S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Witmei

S17
Nykle Bell
Chapel hill, Noith Caiolina
27S16

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please make it legal to take off the piotection because i uont want to buy a movie
again to put it on my cellphone.

Sinceiely,

Nykle Bell

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Boctoi 0uinn full season
Lost Season 1
Spiueiman 1
Avatai
Napolean Bynamite
S18
Kathleen uomez
6u4S9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kathleen uomez

S19
Saiah Cailsen
Califoinia
9u212

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

All the meuia on my uigital uevises eithei uownloaueu ovei the Inteinet oi thiough
online puichase incluuing my peisonal oi pie puichaseu uigital copies, that I put
online to use oi be useu was given to whom evei choose to ieau oi listen to what
I've posteu¡uploaueu..



I'm a mothei of S teenageis anu maiiieu 17yis I have a tv in eveiy ioom with
satellite anu inteinet available eithei thiough my sat company oi thiough my phone
home¡wiieless.. I own a 1uk sq ft home with 7 beuioom anu 2 living iooms all with
wi-fi access. Ny chiluien 1S-19 all own smaitphones anu multiple uigital uevices
that have online capability, I've alloweu my chiluien the same piivileges I so
giatefully expeiienceu in the late 9u's anu that was the www how exciting!,. Ny kius
when youngei knew the iules of the infoimation hwy as I uiu 1st nevei post
peisonal infoimation incluuing name,phone,auuiess,pics even posts anu comments
they know that any anu eveiything they uo on the computei¡phone¡game uevice oi
school pioject even sms&email aie all subject to eithei being ieau oi alteieu by
someone othei than them the authoi!! They've giown up knowing mom & uau sees
all anu anything they want kept piivate then say it in peison oi wiite with pen anu
papei otheiwise the love note in 6th giaue will be ieau anu than ieuone anu
ieposteu to otheis not intentionally fiist sent oi foiwaiueu too. The fiist time you
confiont the chilu with theii own woius oi pics oi chats they panic I uiu this on
occasion anu thioughout theie use on the Inteinet staiting uay one!! Piivate
nothing's piivate if you teach this lesson to them young then by 1S you have a
S2u
somewhat uecent kiu anu u can bet they uon't cybei bully oi haiass online with anu
pictuies posteu online aie vague anu u-iateu.

I believe that it's my job my families obligation to use anu expeiience the www with
an appieciation foi seaich anu cieativity they uo eveiything online school woik anu
fiee time, incluuing shopping,music,meuia oi whatevei thioughout the uay it's uone
on a uigital foimat with wifi, they woulun't even know how if it wasn't foi a
pieschool fielu tiip at age 4 to the post office to wiite out anu stamp¡auuiess an
envelope anu senu it. Ny goouness to think that all they know is email & viueo chats,
essays ieseaicheu anu wiitten then sent via email to teacheis all while on the net,
pick up an encyclopeuia what... They'u ask what site to use. Insteau of the volume
anu libiaiies unless it's in theie BB then it's foi homeless people.

I know I've uone eveiything to keep us safe fiom eveiyone tiying to get oui
infoimation because as a family we uon't post!! Anu ask someone online oi at home
befoie opening¡accepting an application oi upuate, if it bieaks oi stops then they
have lost theii meuia uevice anu eithei boiiows oi gets it fixeu with help again fiom
the Inteinet they've installeu haiuwaie¡softwaie all with the help of the web!

We love the open foimat anu the iuea that you cieate youi space anu only mom oi
uau in an auult case not paying the bills oi having access to the Inteinet will only
leave us looking foi infoimation anu finuing on othei ip sites not exactly what I
think of when I think of the woilu wiue web I want to go to any site ,anytime, any
time I choose. It's up to the peison to self monitoi anu watch what's sent anu
ieceiveu not ((((uoveinments))) it's ouis the human iace a iace to be fiist to be
wiong to be iight to be the one that otheis love oi hate follow oi uelete I want to
lookup pubeity in teens anu see & ieau ui ieviews oi map out anu use tiaffic cams
to see my commute oi locate a fiienu I haven't seen in 2Syis this is oui geneiations
yeaibook!!! Bow cool not 2 be censoieu anu policeu we have enough of that on a
uaily basis..Rules anu moie iules with auuitional iegulation oi case law enfoiceu...



uoveinment anu it's paiu oi nominateu office holuei stop being so iuue, we voteu
anu spoke up leave the Inteinet alone this isn't a communist society is it... No is the
answei anu no u i going to vote on policing the www.. Leave it be oi be voteu out of
office enough is enough!!!!



Thank you,

Nothei of cybeispace teens anu a usei of the web since 1996

Sinceiely,

S21
Saiah Cailsen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bisney
0niveisal
Sony
Fox stuuios
Bieam woiks
Pixai
Nanualay
Bau iobot
Flowei films
Twentieth centuiy films
Bbo
...... Anu seveial othei film, music, stuuio & piouuction company uigital ieleases
incluuing BvBs, CBs anu all uigital meuia.


S22
Naiia Stuuei
Levittown, New Yoik
117S6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The same way that I back up any uata that I own, I woulu like to be able to legally
back up my BvBs anu save the content to my own uevices foi my own use.

Sinceiely,

Naiia Stuuei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Ray
Bumphiey Bogait The Essential Collection
Finuing Nemo
Smithsonian Chionicles Bow the Eaith was Naue
S2S
Stephen Walls
Elkton, Naiylanu
21921

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Stephen Walls

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Akiia (1988)
Alauuin (1992)
Beauty anu the Beast (1991)
Chailie anu the Chocolate Factoiy (2uuS)
Chailotte's Web (197S)
A Chiistmas Caiol (1999)
Cinueiella (19Su)
Cleai anu Piesent Bangei (1994)
Biity Bancing (1987)
uhost in the Shell (199S)
uhost in the Shell 2 - Innocence (2uu4)
Inuyasha the Novie 1 - Affections Touching Acioss Time (2uu1)
Inuyasha the Novie 2 - The Castle Beyonu the Looking ulass (2uu2)
Inuyasha the Novie S - Swoius of an Bonoiable Rulei (2uuS)
Inuyasha the Novie 4 - Fiie on the Nystic Islanu (2uu4)
Kill Bill vol. 1 (2uuS)
Kill Bill vol. 2 (2uu4)
The Little Neimaiu (1989)
S24
The Loiu of the Rings - The Fellowship of the Ring (2uu1)
The Loiu of the Rings - The Two Toweis (2uu2)
The Loiu of the Rings - The Retuin of the King (2uuS)
The Natiix (1999)
The Natiix Reloaueu (2uuS)
The Natiix Revolutions (2uuS)
Ne, Nyself & Iiene (2uuu)
Nemoiis of a ueisha (2uuS)
Piiates of the Caiibbean - The Cuise of the Black Peail (2uuS)
Piiates of the Caiibbean - Beau Nan's Chest (2uu6)
Piiates of the Caiibbean - At Woilu's Enu (2uu7)
The Replacements (2uuu)
Romeo + Iuliet (1996)
Ruuolph, the Reu-Noseu Reinueei (1964)
Stai Wais - Episoue Iv - A New Bope (1977)
Stai Wais - Episoue v - The Empiie Stiikes Back (198u)
Stai Wais - Episoue vI - Retuin of the Ieui (198S)
The Sum of All Feais (2uu2)
Tangleu (2u1u)
Tinkei Bell (2uu8)
Tinkei Bell anu the Lost Tieasuie (2uu9)
Tinkei Bell anu the uieat Faiiy Rescue (2u1u)
Toy Stoiy S (2u1u)
v foi venuetta (2uu6)
S2S
uabiiel Baviu
Aiizona
86S26

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own moie than Suu movies on BvB, anu the list is giowing in auuition to the
stieaming anu iental seivices I belong to to legally watch content online. The fact
that I cannot legally uo what I want with things that I bought, things that I own, is a
hoiiible state of affaiis. Biop the anti-ciicumvention clauses in the BNCA.

Sinceiely,

uabiiel Baviu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

12 Nonkeys
Piiates of the Caiibbean
The Natiix
Little Niss Sunshine
Aimy of Baikness
Buuson Bawk
Ace ventuia
Snatch
The goou, the bau, anu the ugly
Seven Samuiai
Stai Wais
Iion Nan
Boia the Exploiei
! 6#8!
_45)&>14R/4&!
_A/!J54[!O)(=A'!
G!5R!d/=/)0!
34(/0!W4//)!_1R5'1/&!
DA/4,1E[!b1,R/&!
_M(,(=A'!
!
!
S27
Nigel Kilmei
Washington
98u77

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

0n piinciple, the goveinment shoulu not be alloweu to tell consumeis what they can
anu can't uo with theii own piopeity as long as they aie not haiming otheis. Simply
making a copy of a BvB foi peisonal use uoes not haim anyone.

Sinceiely,

Nigel Kilmei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

It is iiielevant how many BvBs I cuiiently own. See below.
S28
ERIN YARR0BIN0
11417

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ERIN YARR0BIN0

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

TBE S0RE TBINu
SEvEN P00NBS
S29
Ben 0lsen
8S2u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ben 0lsen

SSu
Lou Lueia
7SuSS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lou Lueia

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bumbo
uoonies
WALL-E
Cais
Chicago
Planet of the Apes
King Kong
Pulp Fiction
Piincess Biiue, The
E.T.
Bog Walkei, The
The voyeui
SS1
Natthew Biienen
Pasauena, Califoinia
911u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I can not auu any of these to my Ipou, Smait phone, oi Itunes libiaiy. This is veiy
fiustiating consiueiing I paiu full maiket value.

Sinceiely,

Natthew Biienen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Elf, Welcome to Noosepoit, Polai Expiess, Something's gotta give, Lizzie Ncu0IRE
Nove, Piincess Biaiies 2, Bambi, Nainia, Fielu of Bieams, Ratatouille, The wizaiu of
0z, The Incieuibles, Cinueiella, Bappy Feet anu many moie.
SS2
Ruben Levaiio
Ballas, Texas
7S2u4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ruben Levaiio

SSS
Scott Rushing
Louisiana
714S9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I want to uo this foi puiely legitimate puiposes.

Sinceiely,

Scott Rushing

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Baiiy Pottei anu Stai Wais
SS4
IoshuaKnowlesI Knowles
Bouston, Texas
77u42

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own ovei 2uu BvBs, all legally puichaseu, piimaiily bianu new fiom majoi
ietaileis such as Wal-Nait, Best Buy, etc. Ny family also owns two iPaus anu two
iPou Touches as well as a uvu playei. We shoulu have the iight to watch those
movies we own on any of those uevices at any time oi any place. Being able to put
my uaughtei's favoiite movies on the iPau foi times when we have to spenu a lot of
time uiiving oi waiting (uoctois office) woulu be wonueiful. Anyone who has oi has
hau small chiluien shoulu be able to ielate to how valuable it is to have the ability to
keep them enteitaineu in uifficult situations.



I uon't unueistanu why I can iip my music CBs to my iPau but not my BvBs. That
makes no sense to me whatsoevei. The cuiient law is inconsistent anu neeus to be
changeu.



Sinceiely,



Ioshua Knowles

Sinceiely,
SSS

IoshuaKnowlesI Knowles

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Bieakfast Club
Supeibau
Spiuei-Nan
Spaceballs
Sixteen Canules
Sin City
Scioogeu
0ffice Space
Nonsteis Inc
The Little Neimaiu
Toy Stoiy...
SS6
susyn iasmussen
8S2S7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Stop it.



Y00 have maue my 9u yeai olu fathei a felon foi just uoing what he's ALWAYS uone
(anu a few billion othei people).

Sinceiely,

susyn iasmussen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I am wiiting in suppoit of myself, as a consumei anu as someone who believes in
capitalism. All this ciony monopoly stuff is sickening. I uon't iecall moving to China.
SS7
Kiista Cauuill
Kiikwoou, Pennsylvania
17SS6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kiista Cauuill

SS8
uaiiy W Beikeley
Augusta, ueoigia
Su9u6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The list pioviueu above is a shoit list of movies in my libiaiy that I will love to have
available foi viewing on my peisonal own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes
when on planeu tiips.

Sinceiely,

uaiiy W Beikeley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Bouine Iuentity
The Bouine Supiemacy
The Bouine 0ltimatum
Rush Boui
Rush Boui 2
Rush Boui S
The Expenuables
Kill Bill
Kill Bill 2
Cowboys & Aliens
Colombiana
Avatai
Staigate
SS9
Beau Neiseieau
San Biego, Califoinia
92129

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I shoulu be able to watch my movie in any foimat I choose.

Sinceiely,

Beau Neiseieau

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bistiict 9
Tallauega Nights
S4u
Ryan Spencei
uieensboio, Noith Caiolina
2741u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I cuiiently have about 1uuu movies that I own. They aie a mix of BvB anu Blu-iay.



I can't legally touch these movies as fai as "iepuiposing" because of copyiight law.
All I want to uo is put my movies on my tablet¡smaitphone¡computei so that they
can be moie mobile. Especially consiueiing theie aie a ton of movies foi chiluien
that aien't available on uigital foimat, anu that piecluues my uaughtei fiom having
access to saiu movies while we aie on vacation. Especially the blu-iay foimat, since
theie aie iaiely playeis at hotels anu no one makes a blu-iay playei foi a cai.



All I want to uo is buy the copy of the movie, legally anu bianu new, anu be able to
tiansfei to multiple foimats as I neeu foi my own use. I'm not even talking about
loaning the movie to a fiienu. I'u only use it foi me anu my immeuiate family.

Sinceiely,

Ryan Spencei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Banu of Biotheis
! 6V"!
J%RN1!
DR54'!;/1+,/!!
D%)&A()/!
?54&!
_A/!W4//)!:(,/!
$5R/&!Z1)0!]5,,!1>!'A/R^!
D'54!I54&!D/4(/&!
?A41)(E,/&!1>!`54)(5!D/4(/&!
D'54!_4/[!:1'(1)!;(E'%4/!?1,,/E'(1)!
S42
Chiis Nelson
Feueial Way, Washington
98u2S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chiis Nelson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais
The Natiix
Toy Stoiy
Spy Kius
Fiienus (tv seiies)
S4S
Bebbie Sikes
Biyant,
72u22

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

We shoulu be able to use on all oui uevices - iPous, iPau, laptops, uvu playeis etc: If
we puichase foi viewing, we shoulu be able to view on all the uevices we own.

Sinceiely,

Bebbie Sikes

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Too many to tiy to list.
S44
Patiick Buikait
778u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Patiick Buikait

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Absolutely Fabulous


S4S
Baviu uoouman
Waukesha, Wisconsin
SS188

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Baviu uoouman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Back to the Futuie
Back to the Futuie 2
Back to the Futuie S
Beetlejuice
Blues Biotheis
Close Encounteis of the Thiiu Kinu
uhostbusteis
uhostbusteis 2
uoou Noining vietnam
Loiu of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
Loiu of the Rings: The Two Toweis
Loiu of the Rings: The Retuin of the King
Shawn of the Beau
v foi venuetta
Kill Bill vol. 1
Kill Bill vol. 2
Avatai: The Last Aiibenuei (Tv seiies)

! 6V8!
!
S47
euwaiu gonzales
8u8u8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

euwaiu gonzales

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

the chionicles of iiuuick
stai wais episoues 1-6
the goufathei 1-S
teiminatoi 1-4
loiu of the iings 1-S
S48
Iim Walkei
6SSS4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Theie is no ieason we shoulu be piohibiteu fiom copying movies that we puichaseu
legally foi oui own peison viewing oi foi back up up puiposes. Foi example, make a
copy foi the kius to use anu keep the oiiginal stasheu away in a safe place till
anothei copy is neeueu foi the kius.

Sinceiely,

Iim Walkei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

tiansfoimeis
lethal weapon
smuifs
S49
Linusay Baisley
Texas
78641

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Linusay Baisley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Baiiy Pottei - The Balf Bloou Piince
Avatai
The Baik Ciystal


SSu
Clayton Long
Floiiua
SS6uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I uon't why it's illegal foi me to watch a movie that I alieauy own on BvB on my
iPhone oi on my iPau. I alieauy bought it. I know the NPAA woulu love it if I woulu
buy my movies all ovei again just so I can watch them on the uevices that I own. But
this is boiueiline insanity. I shoulun't have to pay twice to watch one movie. Bow
uoes that benefit the consumei oi the aveiage citizen.

Sinceiely,

Clayton Long

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Back to the Futuie Pait I
Finuing Nemo
Austin Poweis
Biuce Almighty
Bambuigei Bill
0ffice Space
SS1
Bevon Touionu
Winnipeg, Califoinia
9u21u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bevon Touionu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Social Netwoik
Along came Polly
This Is It
Bane Cook: Touigasm
v Foi venuetta
SS2
Biian Timmeimeistei
Lima, 0hio
4S8uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Biian Timmeimeistei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais
Eastei Paiaue
The Thin Nan
The Big Lebowski
Bau News Beais
Rio Biavo
Appioximately 1Suu moie titles
SSS
Scott Boone
Pennsylvania
172u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have puichaseu moie than Suu BvBs with content that I'u like to be able to use on
my iPau, iPhone, anu Nac BTPC. I uon't want to use a BvB playei anymoie, anu I
uon't want to have to puichase these movies again. The only BvB playei that I have
that I even use is my Playstation S Blu-iay playei (neaily 1uu puichaseu Blu-iays):
it is louu anu annoying to use compaieu to Plex on my Nac mini BTPC.



Apple ievolutionizeu the consumei expeiience aiounu CBs with iTunes. I iemembei
people who useu to caiiy uozens of CBs in makeshift caiiieis in theii cai (I hau to
caiiy aiounu two laige CaseLogic boxes). Now, when I pull out my iPhone anu stait
watching I Love Lucy episoues oi Big Bang Theoiy episoues in my uowntime, my
colleagues aie ANAZEB! "Biu you buy that fiom iTunes. Aie you stieaming that
fiom Netflix." "No," I answei, "I iippeu them myself, fiom my BvBs." "Like a CB...
You can B0 TBAT." That is a typical conveisation.anu it is a shame. All of these
folks aie intelligent, capable inuiviuuals. But because of the state of maiket, they
aie!'Ⓙ.⏖楳ᮻ¹²|湯整⍫¹²""湯¹²ᦑⒿ捩)¹²"潮'慨! 汐 慥 ! ! 數
¯ ' ´ | | 晩 楴 ᮻ 映 + 桴 T ÷ 愠 ¨ 愠 ¯ " | 湯 畳 ø 獲 ¹ 獵 桴 ᴐ ც 慢 ! ⁤ᴏ | 慴
. ⍫ . ' | ¹ " 敗 愠 敲 ! ' ᴚ ៚ 整 ᅶ " 敲 ¹ ² ᮈ 潯 ⁤畧 ⋗ 敷¬#吠Tf©⁓=ì÷¹楨
瑳ᬖ "敬! 潦捲 桴 .⍫.'.¯:7 潴¹敲±⏖ |.+:ủ Æ潯Ï"×杲
±¹ᴖ正潮~!ᩕ}.=₵湯 . SSS7 V ´SSS#"±¨敲)漠 Ⓘ) 桷捩
:/+ 楳敬⍫映.V /!楳¯¯¯睹潯⁤敦±÷)愠¨:獵捩:映慥畴敲! =¨
SS4
⅄.|⍫ℤ+畤散⁤`歲! ᦑ5:.慴ᴜ)愠¨!牡愠¨湯整≃牡":浩
!映.錮SS4汐慥!¹⚎¹ᩖ⅄⏖"楷桴¹²映!'慰散⁤:⁤档:ᮻ映

Sinceiely,

Scott Boone

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Ace ventuia Beluxe Bouble Featuie
Ace ventuia, Pet Betective - The Animateu Seiies
Ameiican Baiucoie
Angei Nanagement
Apocalypse Now: The Complete Bossiei
Apollo 1S
Aiiesteu Bevelopment - Season 0ne
Aiiesteu Bevelopment - Season Thiee
Aiiesteu Bevelopment - Season Two
Back to School
The Big Bang Theoiy: The Complete Fiist Season
The Big Bang Theoiy: The Complete Fouith Season
The Big Bang Theoiy: The Complete Seconu Season
The Big Bang Theoiy: The Complete Thiiu Season
Bill Cosby, Bimself
The Black Bole
Blaue Runnei
Blazing Sauules
The Blues Biotheis
Biaveheait
Buck Rogeis in the 2Sth Centuiy - The Complete Epic Seiies
Califoinication - The Fiist Season
Califoinication : The Complete Seconu Season
Ciash - The Biiectoi's Cut
Beauwoou - The Complete Fiist Season
Beauwoou - The Complete Seconu Season
Beauwoou - The Complete Thiiu Season
The Bepaiteu
Entouiage - Season Thiee, Pait 2
Entouiage - The Complete Fouith Season
Entouiage: Season Thiee, Pait 1
Entouiage: The Complete Fifth Season
Entouiage: The Complete Fiist Season
Entouiage: The Complete Seconu Season
Entouiage: The Complete Seventh Season
Entouiage: The Complete Sixth Season
SSS
Eteinal Sunshine 0f The Spotless Ninu
Family uuy, vol. 1
Family uuy, vol. 2
Family uuy, vol. S
Family uuy, vol. 4
Family uuy, vol. S
Family uuy, vol. 6
Family uuy, vol. 7
Fanboys
Fiiefly - The Complete Seiies
Fletch
The Flintstones - The Complete Fifth Season
The Flintstones - The Complete Fiist Season
The Flintstones - The Complete Fouith Season
The Flintstones - The Complete Seconu Season
The Flintstones - The Complete Sixth Season
The Flintstones - The Complete Thiiu Season
Futuiama - Benuei's Big Scoie
Futuiama, vol. 1
Futuiama, vol. 2
Futuiama, vol. S
Futuiama, vol. 4
Futuiama: Benuei's uame
Futuiama: Into the Wilu uieen Yonuei
Futuiama: The Beast with a Billion Backs
The uiil Next Booi
ulauiatoi
uoou Will Bunting
uian Toiino
uieatest Ameiican Beio: The Complete Seiies
I Love Lucy: The Complete Seiies
Invauei Zim Complete Invasion
The Iamie Foxx Film Collection
The Ieik
Iohn Auams
Kentucky Fiieu Novie
Liai Liai
N*A*S*B - Naitinis anu Neuicine Complete Collection
Nau Nen - Season 2
Nau Nen - Season 0ne
Nau Nen: Season Foui
Nau Nen: Season Thiee
The Natiix Reloaueu
The Natiix Revolutions
Niami vice: The Complete Seiies
National Lampoon's Animal Bouse
SS6
Nick & Noiah's Infinite Playlist
The 0ffice - Season Foui
The 0ffice - Season Thiee
The 0ffice - Season Two
0ffice Space - Special Euition with Flaii
The 0ffice: Season Five
The 0ffice: Season 0ne
The 0ffice: Season Six
Pineapple Expiess
Pinky anu the Biain, vol. 1
Pinky anu the Biain, vol. 2
Pinky anu the Biain, vol. S
Planet of the Apes - The Legacy Collection
Piivate Paits
Pulp Fiction
Rescue Ne - Season S, vol. 1
Rescue Ne: The Complete Fifth Season
Rescue Ne: The Complete Fiist Season
Rescue Ne: The Complete Fouith Season
Rescue Ne: The Complete Seconu Season
Rescue Ne: The Complete Sixth Season
Rescue Ne: The Complete Thiiu Season
Rescue Ne: The Complete Thiiu Season
Reseivoii Bogs
Rocky & Bullwinkle & Fiienus - The Complete Fiist Season
Rocky & Bullwinkle & Fiienus - The Complete Seconu Season
Rocky & Bullwinkle & Fiienus - The Complete Thiiu Season
Rome - The Complete Fiist Season
Rome - The Complete Seconu Season
S Baiko: A Bonnie Baiko Tale
Satuiuay Night Live - The Best of Chiis Failey
Satuiuay Night Live - The Best of Chiis Rock
Seienity
The Simpsons - The Complete Eighth Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Fifth Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Fiist Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Fouith Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Ninth Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Seconu Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Seventh Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Sixth Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Tenth Season
The Simpsons - The Complete Thiiu Season
The Simpsons: The Complete Twelfth Season
The Simpsons: The Complete Twentieth Season
The Simpsons: The Thiiteenth Season
SS7
Sin City
Sky Captain anu the Woilu of Tomoiiow
Snatch
Spies Like 0s
Stai Wais - Clone Wais, vol. 1
Stai Wais - Clone Wais, vol. 2
Stai Wais Tiilogy
Stiange Biew
Stiange Bays
Supeibau
Tallauega Nights - The Ballau of Ricky Bobby
The Simpsons - The Eleventh Season
Tommy Boy Boly Schnike Euition
Tion
Tiopic Thunuei
Twin Peaks - Fiie Walk with Ne
Twin Peaks - The Befinitive uolu Box Euition
Twin Peaks - The Seconu Season
02: Rattle anu Bum
0nbieakable
0nueiuog - 0ltimate Collection
The Weuuing Singei
Weeus: Season Five
Weeus: Season Foui
Weeus: Season 0ne
Weeus: Season Six
Weeus: Season Thiee
Weeus: Season Two
What the Bleep Bo We Know!.
SS8
elizabeth mcmahon
biooklyn, New Yoik
112S8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please tiy to keep up with the fast paceu anu changing face of technologies anu how
they aie being useu, without copyiight infiingement. Thank you.

Sinceiely,

elizabeth mcmahon

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I own hunuieus of uvus, which incluue silent films, classic Bollywoou featuies anu
musical featuies, inuepenuently piouuceu woiks, uocumentaiies anu eaily anu
contempoiaiy animateu films.
SS9
nick noiwoou
77449

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

nick noiwoou

S6u
Amanua Lemon
0klahoma
7S118

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Amanua Lemon
S61
Tyson Noosman
Bebei City, 0tah
84uS2-11uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Tyson Noosman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Rise of The Planet of The Apes
The Lion King
Evangelion 1.11
S62
Robeit Bouine
Ashbuin, viiginia
2u146

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Although theie is ceitainly the possibility that people will abuse the piivilege anu
genuinely piiate BvBs, they won't be ueteiieu at all by the piohibition. 0n the othei
hanu, my ability to copy uata foi peisonal use fiom one meuium to anothei uoes not
affect the maiket foi the movies in question, anu theiefoie shoulun't be ueemeu
infiingement, as I woulu be unwilling to pay foi a movie twice.

Sinceiely,

Robeit Bouine

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nonty Python anu the Boly uiail, Blaue, Blaue II, Saw, Saw II, Saw III, Signs,
0nbieakable, Cauuyshack, Animal Bouse, Batman Begins, Bungeons & Biagons:
Wiath of the Biagon uou, South Paik: Biggei Longei 0ncut, Loiu of Rings:
Fellowship of the Ring, Loiu of Rings: Retuin of the King, Slap shot, Fifth, Sleepei,
Bananas, 0nueiwoilu
S6S
Cailos Planas, Ii.
Betioit, Nichigan
482u9-4SuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Theie is no haim in pieseivation. Because if you think about it, you have a BvB that
is in goou woiking quality now. But what will you uo if that BvB oi youi BvB playei
is uamageu anu the uisc is unieauable, to continue viewing its content woulu
iequiie making a "backup" copy. Youi oiiginal copy is still theie, though bioken
beyonu iepaii. This is what I mean by pieseivation anu nostalgia.

Sinceiely,

Cailos Planas, Ii.

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Cainivoie
R.P.N.
Casino
Supei Size Ne
Raging Bull
Back to the Futuie Pait III
Exit Wounus
Paycheck
The Last Bouse on the Left (1972)
Bowling foi Columbine
Fahienheit 9|11
Sicko
! 68V!
_A/!_(,,R5)!D'14@!
34(05@!
_5,[!'1!:/!
$5E[5&&!
$5E[5&&!`%RN/4!_M1!
S6S
Beathei Iohnson
Itacsa, Illinois
6u14S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

0sing a computei to tiansfei BvB uata fiom a uisk that I have paiu foi to anothei
uevice that I own is not theft by any ieasonable uefinition. The cieatois of the
content aie not being uepiiveu of income - they ieceiveu a faii shaie when the
physical uisk was puichaseu. While the intentions of the BNCA aie goou, it has been
applieu fai beyonu the oiiginal intention of the law. I uige you to allow this
exemption.

Sinceiely,

Beathei Iohnson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nightwatch
Fight Club
The Piincess Biiue
Bogma
Citizen Kane
anu ovei 1uu othei titles
S66
Nichelle Fiogge
Poitlanu, 0iegon
97216

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nichelle Fiogge

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Sling Blaue
Bigh Fiuelity
Pulp Fiction
West Siue Stoiy
The Big Lebowski
S67
Stephen Bailament
Wisconsin
SS7uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Stephen Bailament

S68
ualen Reyes
Califoinia
9S2uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ualen Reyes

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Intacto, Time Banuits, The Pioposition, Night 0f The Buntei, Rushmoie, The Aliens
0uauiilogy, Blaue Runnei Box set, The Stai Wais saga...etc.
S69
ioss gianfoitune
Washington, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuu2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ioss gianfoitune

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Batman begins
Some like it hot
uoufathei
S7u
Kaien Cohen
Silvei Spiing, Naiylanu
2u91u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kaien Cohen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Baiiy Pottei,
The Nuppet Novie,
Cais,
Tangleu,
anu moie!
S71
Alexanuei Kay
Boichestei, Nassachusetts
2124

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have an iPau. I like to watch movies on it. Theie's no ieason foi me not to uo so
with movies I have legally puichaseu.

Sinceiely,

Alexanuei Kay

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Seveial hunuieu films, both classic anu mouein, all puichaseu legally, fiom a wiue
vaiiety of stuuios.
S72
Sheii Felu
Silvei Spiing, Naiylanu
2u91u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The uvus sciatch, skip oi just weaiout. This aie eithei expensive to ieplace oi
unavailable foi ieplacement. Ny 2 1¡2 yeai olu loves them, but my 12 yeai olu
Austic son gets upset when the uvus skip. Be specifically consiueis some shows
comfoit spaces foi his anxiety. When he gets upset, he bites his hanu anu yells. We
have paiu to uownloau some shows uiiectly to oui laptop. While I iesent having to
pay multible times foi the same uvu to keep them playing, I am fiustiateu at the
inability to copy the uvus that aie not ieauily availible. We live on an income that
uoes not give us the luxuiy to buy the same BvBs eveiy couple of yeais. I feel that I
shoulu pay foi the use but shoulu be able to utilize the uvus as neeueu.

Sinceiely,

Sheii Felu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I own the new Lion King anu uvu like that. Bowevei the BvBs that aie impoitant to
my family aie moie like the Between the Lions, Nagic School bus anu signing time.
S7S
N. Wenuy Bennequin
Tennessee
S7211

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

N. Wenuy Bennequin

S74
Ellen Wiseman
Texas
78748

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ellen Wiseman

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

All of the Baiiy Pottei movies
Winnie the Pooh
Boles
All thiee Loiu of the Rings
anu many moie
S7S
Leisha Bussien
B9u 4T0

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Leisha Bussien

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avatai
The Social Netwoik
S76
Fiank Biice
Builey, New Yoik
1244S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fiank Biice

S77
Eiin Boiak
Columbia, Nissouii
6S2uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Eiin Boiak

S78
Kelly Kepschull
South Benu, Inuiana
46614

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Foimat shifting shoulu be available foi ebooks, too. Iust foi oui own peisonal use. I
uo not suppoit piiacy. In most instances I have actually paiu moie foi my uigital
books (especially with Agency Piicing) than the piint copies.



Niciosoft has ceaseu suppoit of LIT foimat so I woulu love to be able to change the
1uus of book I own in LIT to ePub. I ceitainly cannot affoiu to iebuy all of them, noi
uo I feel I shoulu have to. These aie books I paiu foi.

Sinceiely,

Kelly Kepschull

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nim's Islanu
An Iueal Busbanu
The King's Speech
Baiy Pottei
Buuuy
+ a lot moie
S79
Iohn uuaiente
Coloiauo
8u1S4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The BNCA fuithei limits me as to what I can watch on my computei while tiaveling.
I paiu foi the movie, then I feel that I shoulu be able to watch the movie when as
wheie I want.

Sinceiely,

Iohn uuaiente

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

the Bouine Seiies,
Stai Wais,
Iuiassic Paik to name a few.
S8u
I. Simmons
4S424

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

0ui BvB libiaiy is laige enough that we want to access it on oui Tv like we access
oui music on oui iPou (easily biowseable fiom oui playback uevice). Ripping oui
libiaiy suppoits that in a way no othei solution can.

Sinceiely,

I. Simmons

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

2u1u - The Yeai We Nake Contact
21
A Beautiful Ninu
A Niusummei Nights Bieam
About a Boy
Ameiican Beauty
Ameiicas Sweetheaits
Beu of Roses
Beuazzleu
Black Bole
Casablanca
Chailie Wilsons Wai
Chailies Angels
Chicago
Chiluien of a Lessei uou
! 6X"!
?A41)(E,/&!1>!`54)(5!
?,%/!L!_A/!:1.(/!
?1)'5E'!
J?!B)(./4&/!
J/50!*=5()!
J/5'A!'1!DR11EA@!
J())/4!M('A!34(/)0&!
J(.()/!D/E4/'&!1>!'A/!e5Le5!D(&'/4A110!
J4/5R!_A/5'/4!L!d(./!;/4>14R5)E/&!
J4/5R!_A/5'/4!L!:/'41+1,(&!#FFF!DE/)/&!>41R!`/M!e14[!
H54'AT%5[/!
H./4!*>'/4!
W5''5E5!
WA1&'N%&'/4&!
W1&>140!;54[!
W%@&!5)0!J1,,&!
b544@!;1''/4!
b11[!
b1M!'1!,1&/!5!=%@!()!"F!05@&!
G!5R!D5R!
G)!'A/!Z/0411R!
G)0(5)5!$1)/&!"!L!<5(0/4&!1>!'A/!d1&'!*4[!
G))/4D+5E/!
G)'1!'A/!I110&!
G41)R5)!
$%)1!
OL;5Q!
O()&/@!
d50@A5M[/!
d(,1!5)0!D'('EA!
d1E[!D'1E[!5)0!_M1!DR1[()=!Z544/,&!
d1&'!G)!D+5E/!
:5=)(>(E/)'!J/&1,5'(1)!
:54EA!1>!'A/!;/)=%()&!
:/R1(4&!1>!5!W/(&A5!
:1)5!d(&5!DR(,/!
:11)&'4%E[!
:14'5,!O1RN5'!
:1%,()!<1%=/!
:%EA!*01!*N1%'!`1'A()=!
:@!d(>/!
-!Z41'A/4!IA/4/!*4'!_A1%!
;(45'/&!1>!'A/!?54(NN/5)!L!_A/!?%4&/!1>!'A/!Z,5E[!;/54,!
;4()E/&&!:1)1)1[/!
k%(,,&!
</5,!W/)(%&!
! 6X#!
<1&/)E45)'\!5)0!W%(,0/)&'/4)!*4/!J/50!
<1.()=!:54&!
D5N4()5!
DA/4,1E[!b1,R/&!
D(0/M5@&!
D(Q!J5@&!5)0!D/./)!`(=A'&!
D[@!?5+'5()!5)0!'A/!I14,0!1>!_1R1441M!
D,(0()=!J114&!
D)/5[/4&!
D1R/1)/!d([/!e1%!
D+5E/N5,,&!
D+5)=,(&A!
D'5)0!5)0!J/,(./4!
D'54!_4/[!
D'54!I54&!
D'54=5'/!
D'54&A(+!_411+/4&!
D'/+R1R!
D'1R+!-%'!d1%0!
DM()=/4&!
_/4R()5'14!
_/4R&!1>!H)0/54R/)'!
_A/!*R/4(E5)!;4/&(0/)'!
_A/!*.(5'14!
_A/!J5@!'A/!H54'A!D'110!D'(,,!
_A/!J/.(,!I/54&!;4505!
_A/!b%)'!>14!</0!-E'1N/4!
_A/!GR+14'5)E/!1>!Z/()=!H54)/&'!
_A/!G)E4/0(N,/&!
_A/!d5&'!O()=!1>!DE1',5)0!
_A/!:5)!()!'A/!G41)!:5&[!
_A/!:5'4(Q!
_A/!:/&&/)=/4!bZ-!3(4&'!d11[!
_A/!:/&&/)=/4!
_A/!:(4414!b5&!_M1!35E/&!
_A/!</0%E/0!DA5[/&+/54/!?1R+5)@!b1R/!S(0/1!
_A/!</0%E/0!DA5[/&+/54/!?1R+5)@!
_A/!_A4//!:%&[/'//4&!
_A/!_4%'A!*N1%'!?5'&!5)0!J1=&!
_45)&>14R/4&!
_41)!
S1,'41)!
IA5'!J4/5R&!:5@!?1R/!
IA/4/!'A/!b/54'!G&!
IA(,/!e1%!I/4/!D,//+()=!
I14[()=!W(4,!
! 6X6!
nL:/)!
e1%)=!W%)&!
*.5'54!'A/!d5&'!*(4N/)0/4! ! !
Z%>>@!'A/!S5R+(4/!D,5@/4! ! ! ! ! !
?A54R/0! ! ! ! !
?1MN1@!Z/N1+! ! ! ! !
J/>@()=!W45.('@! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!
354&E5+/! ! ! ! ! !
3(4/>,@!! ! ! ! !
341R!'A/!H54'A!'1!'A/!:11)!
$%&'(E/!d/5=%/!B),(R('/0! ! ! !
d1&'! ! ! ! ! !
D,()=&!5)0!*441M&! ! ! !
D'54!_4/[!H)'/4+4(&/!! ! !
D'54!_4/[!_A/!`/Q'!W/)/45'(1)! !
_A/!I/&'!I()=!
S84
Elise Faubel-Ravely
4S2u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This law is stupiu anu makes ciiminals out of all consumeis. If I buy it, I own it.
Peiiou. I can't believe that it is illegal to copy my BvBs fiom one uevice to anothei
anu when I tiy to tell people about this, they uon't believe it eithei. I also can't
believe that the public's iights have been ignoieu to the point that they weie not
even consiueieu in this mattei. You have the ability to iestoie some balance anu
common sense, anu I hope that you uo.

Sinceiely,

Elise Faubel-Ravely

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

too many to list
S8S
Abigail uoben
Chicago ,
6u647

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Abigail uoben

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Alauuin
Beauty anu the Beast
Piiue anu Piejuuice
N*A*S*B
Bunt foi Reu 0ctobei
While You Weie Sleeping
Choius Line
Ni anu Nis Smith
Wally
Sleeping Beauty
Clue


S86
Luiz Peiez
East Bampton, New Yoik
119S7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Luiz Peiez

S87
Buane Bahm
Beavei Bam, Wisconsin
SS916

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I feel eveiy 0S citizen shoulu have the unalienable iight to copy theii leagaly
puichaseu BvB's foi theii piivate aichive!

Sinceiely,

Buane Bahm

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Blazing Sauules, Su fiist uates,Well 0vER Suu moie BvB's!
S88
Chau Thoinbuigh
Nuiiay, 0tah
8412S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chau Thoinbuigh

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The uoufathei
The 0sual Suspects
Bogtown anu Z-boys
uone in Su Seconus
The Piofessional
The Italian Iob
Taxi Biivei
Casino
Bolt
Robin Boou
Lauy anu the Tiamp
Subbeibia
The Becline of Westein Civilization
1S Bays
The Fog of Wai
Butch Cassiuy anu The Sunuance Kiu
The Bustlei
The Coloi of Noney
! 6XK!
;11,A5,,!$%)[(/&!
S9u
Iohn Peteison
Wesatampton, New Ieisey
8u6u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woik 1uu houis a week. The little time that I get to watch a movie can't possibly be
on a television at home. It must be on my ipau oi my x2uu laptop, neithei of which
can play a CB, BvB oi BluRay Bisc. I neeu to be able to access my music anu viueos
fiom stoiage whethei in soliu state memoiy, a laptop haiu uisk oi a clouu stoiage
system. If this is uenieu me, than ieally - I have been iobbeu. I am uenieu the iight to
view movies anu listen to music - which I puichaseu in goou faith.



Sinceiely,

I0hn Peteison

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais - entiie seiies
Inuiana Iones - entiie seiies
Loiu of the RIngs - entiie seiies
Bie Baiu - all movies
uiil with Biagon tattoo tiilogy - Sweuish veision
Baiiy Pottei - entiie seiies
Boine Tiilogy

S91
Iason Wilczak
6u16

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

We aie alieauy paying a piemium piice to own most of these movies, as it is. The
actois¡actiesses anu stuuios aie tuining ovei a high piofit anu living well above the
stanuaius of iegulai Ameiicans. Foi us to pay foi a sepeiate seivice oi iepuichase
the movie again is iiuiculous.



We aie getting unueiwatei with obscuie iules anu iegulations foi the consumei anu
being foiceu to pay highei piices foi movies of vaiying quality. We have alieauy
seen outiageous fines foi illegally uownloauing music anu movies, we uon't neeu
anothei angle wheie the law is giey anu uifficult foi the consumei. This is a
common sense uecision. If I buy a movie, I own 1 copy of that movie that I uo
whatevei I wish with. I shoulu be able to iesell it, watch on tv, oi on my pc, oi
mobile uevice. I can't physically uo both anu even if I uiu, it is iiielevant.



Let's keep laws common sense anu piactical foi the consumei anu the coipoiations.
As much as they neeu to make money, we neeu to not be bleu uiy.

Sinceiely,

Iason Wilczak

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:
! 6K#!
!
_A/!:5'4(Q!_4(,1=@!
d140!1>!'A/!<()=&!_4(,1=@!
b544@!;1''/4!D/4(/&!
b144(N,/!Z1&&/&!
-,0!DEA11,!
_5,,50/=5!`(=A'&!
b541,0!5)0!O%R54!W1!_1!IA('/!?5&',/!
b541,0!5)0!O%R54!H&E5+/!>41R!W%5)'5)5R1!Z5@!
D,//+()=!Z/5%'@!
d50@!5)0!'A/!_45R+!
Z5'R5)!'A/!J54[!O)(=A'!
5)0!R5)@!R14/CCC!
S9S
Clinton Calhoun
Texas
7Su19

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Clinton Calhoun

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy, Extenueu Euition
Baik Knight
Citizen X
S94
Iessica Nillei
viiginia
222u7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

The ability of the movie stuuios to chaige us multiple times foi the same movie is
not something which ought to be piotecteu by law. 0nce you buy a movie, you
shoulu be fiee to conveit it to any foimat you choose. This seems so utteily
common sense to me that I'm amazeu the issue is even in uispute.

Sinceiely,

Iessica Nillei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Fiuulei on the Roof
Beauty anu the Beast
Alauuin
A Walk To Remembei
Loiu of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
Loiu of the Rings: The Two Toweis
Loiu of the Rings: Retuin of the King
Evelyn
ulauiatoi
1776
Toucheu by an Angel Seasons 1-4
Follow the Stais Bome
Anna anu the King
S9S
The Phantom of the 0peia
The Choius
Two Weeks Notice
Aiabian Nights
Avatai: The Last Aiibenuei (all thiee seasons)
Stai Wais Episoue I: The Phantom Nenace
Stai Wais Episoue II: Attack of the Clones
Stai Wais Episoue III: Revenge of the Sith
Stai Wais Episoue Iv: A New Bope
Stai Wais Episoue v: The Empiie Stiikes Back
Stai Wais Episoue vI: Retuin of the Ieui
Naiuto Box Sets 1-1u
Saiunkoku Nonogataii Season 1
Ny uiil
Piiates of Penzance
Piosecutoi Piincess
anu many moie
S96
Caioline Small
Naiylanu
2u74u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Caioline Small

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

We own appioximately 2uu movies on BvB incluuing:
the BBS boxeu set
197us Sesame Stieet episoues
Aiiesteu Bevelopment
The Thunueibiius boxeu set
uouaiu's Naue in 0SA
uouaiu's Alphaville
Cionenbeig's viueouiome
Citizen Kane
Ciumb
The Limey
S97
William Apiea
Chatham, New Ieisey
7928

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

In its iesponse to Public Knowleuge's faii use iequest, the NPAA inuicates its
position that the fact that you cannot legally tiansfei a movie you own to a uevice
you own (say, youi iPau) is a "meie inconvenience." Foi those of us who paiu foi a
movie on BvB anu want to be able to watch it on othei uevices, the NPAA has a
simple answei: pay us again. That is unacceptable.





Sinceiely,

William Apiea

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

ovei a thousanu featuie films, television shows anu music viueos.
S98
Bianuelyn W
Poit Lavaca, Texas
77979

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Some of my uvus aie sciatcheu anu I woulu like to back them up on my pc oi put
them on inuiviuual thumbuiives to pieseive them anu be able to watch them on
othei uevices.

Sinceiely,

Bianuelyn W

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tiue Bloou Season 1
Tiue Bloou Season 2
Nabii no 0u Complete Seiies
Kill Bill vol 1
Kill Bill vol 2
S99
Iennifei Kelley
Illinois
6u647

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Bigital Rights Nanagement may be ueemeu necessaiy by the NPAA to piotect
against piiacy, but in the case of consumei space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB,
they aie oveily iestiictive. Please consiuei gianting this exemption which woulu in
no way haim the iights of the NPAA.

Sinceiely,

Iennifei Kelley

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bloou Simple
Kicking anu Scieaming, Ciiteiion Euition
Biazil
Papiika
Shaolin Soccei
Stiange Biew
The Blues Biotheis
Nillei's Ciossing
The 0ntouchables
The 0sual Suspects
Cowboy Bebop
4uu
Keef Waiu
Biooklyn, New Yoik
11221

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please be ieasonable. Youi policies neeu to auapt to the mouein state of technology.
You aie cieating a whole geneiation of Ameiicans that aie consiueieu "ciiminals"

Sinceiely,

Keef Waiu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Piiate Rauio,
Bigh Noon.
Fists of Fuiy
4u1
nicholas satteifielu
SSu6u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

nicholas satteifielu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

eiaseiheau
the man who wasn't theie
stiange biew
one flew ovei the cuckoo's nest
ui stiangelove
momento
iushmoie
anu about 2uu+ moie titles
4u2
Tom Wiight
6uu9S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Tom Wiight

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais - Episoue 1
Stai Wais - Episoue 2
Stai Wais - Episoue S
Stai Wais - Episoue 4
Stai Wais - Episoue S
Stai Wais - Episoue 6
The Sixth Sense
Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy
The Natiix


4uS
Biien Satzingei
Nemphis, Tennessee
S8119

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I believe that because I have paiu foi movies that I shoulu be able to play them on
my Tv anu on my iPau. I shoulu not have to pay twice foi the same movie anu I will
not.

Sinceiely,

Biien Satzingei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Beat
Bau Boys I
Bau Boys II
Saving Piivate Ryan
uoonies
Bouine Iuentity
Bouine Supiemacy
Bouine 0ltimatum
Clue


4u4
Sieia Leone
2882

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Sieia Leone

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Speeu
Inception
In Plain Sight
4uS
Biyana Bizic
221u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Biyana Bizic

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bozens of kius movies
4u6
eu keane
Biooklyn, New Yoik
1121S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This is a subjective iuling that piotects the inteiests of coipoiations at the expense
of inuiviuuals who aie being foiceu to buy the same intellectual piopeity ovei anu
ovei anu ovei anu ovei anu ovei again, acioss evei-changing foimats, stanuaius,
uevices, etc.



Woiu is spieauing anu if you want to ietain what at least some of youi cuiient
piofit maigin, please ieau Appetite foi Self-Bestiuction: The Spectaculai Ciash of
the Recoiu Inuustiy in the Bigital Age by Steve Knoppei, befoie it's too late.
Seiiously, this bullshit is going to stop one way oi the othei.

Sinceiely,

eu keane

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Teims of Enueaiment: Cain Nutiny: Chailie Chan in Nexico: Faigo
4u7
Richaiu Funes
Los Angeles, Califoinia
9uu4S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Richaiu Funes

4u8
Fiank vasquez
Long Islanu City, New Yoik
111u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I believe this senus a veiy mixeu message to consumeis: legally puichase motion
pictuie BvBs, but be consiueieu on paiole foi a ciime you can not commit once that
BvB is youi piopeity if even only because you bought it.

Sinceiely,

Fiank vasquez

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

In Biuges
Tiansfoimeis
Knockin' 0n Beaven's Booi
Inuepenuence Bay
Blue valentine
Zombielanu
4u9
Richaiu 0gin
7824S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Continuing to piohibit people fiom making copies of movies they've alieauy paiu foi
is not "a meie inconvenience", it's foolishness.



Sinceiely,

Richaiu 0gin

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Bouine Iuentity
At least a hunuieu moie
41u
Ionathan Alessi
Noiiistown, Pennsylvania
194uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I shoulu be able to use my legally puichaseu content on any uevise that I choose. I
want the ablity to iip my uvus in oiuei to maintain a backup uigital copy in case the
uvu is lost oi uamageu. I also want the ability to iip the uvu anu place the content
on any uevice that I own (ie, iPau, laptop, tv connecteu uigial tiansfei uevise, etc).
The NPAA woulu have me pay foi the same content mulitple times in oiuei to view
the content wheie anu when I want. This is not what Congiess hau in minu when
they implementeu the BNCA.

Sinceiely,

Ionathan Alessi

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Beat
Ameiican Bistoiy X
Blazing Sauules
X-Nen
Stai Tiek
Stai Wais
411
Iim Kellei
Califoinia
9S728

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I own hunuieus movies on BvB. The NPAA's suggestion that I shoulu simply pay
again in oiuei to obtain a uigital copy (which may oi may not be available) of a film I
alieauy own is simply outiageous. While I suppoit stiff ciiminal penalties foi piiacy,
cleaily pieventing people with legal copies of BvBs fiom tiansfeiiing the content to
othei viewing uevices is untenable.

Sinceiely,

Iim Kellei

412
Chiistophei vollentine
0hio
4S229

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have a uesktop PC, a laptop, a PSS anu Xbox S6u. It's easy enough to pop the uisc
into any of these anu ioll with it. Bowevei, especially as much anu as long a uistance
as I tenu to tiavel, my iPhone anu Asus tablet aie both acceptable substitutes foi a
bulkiei uevice that may not tiavel as well.



The aigument that the NPAA puts foith, that we shoulu pay them multiple times foi
the same content, is almost an obscene flaunting of theii insatiable cash-hungei.
We've paiu them once foi the content alieauy: why shoulu they be able to extoit us
foi it again anu again.

Sinceiely,

Chiistophei vollentine

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Eveiy Baiiy Pottei film
The 0ne
Sweeney Touu
Seienity
v foi venuetta
The Nist
! V"6!
;5@EA/E[!
J1\/)&!1'A/4&!
414
uieg Bughes
, Bistiict of Columbia
2uuS2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uieg Bughes

41S
Iustin huist
Califoinia
92119

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

0uit tiying to steal money fiom us, you have enough.

Sinceiely,

Iustin huist

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Biumline
Sweeny Touu
Batman Yeai 0ne
The Big Lebowski
Tons moie....
416
Amanua Whitt
Fontana, Califoinia
92SS7-9Su2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Amanua Whitt

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Rocky Boiioi Pictuie Show
Shock Tieatment
The Little Neimaiu
Beetlejuice
uhostbusteis
Back to the Futuie
0livei anu Company
The Infoimant
The Bangovei
Scott Pilgiim vs. The Woilu
Lanu of the Lost
Alauuin
417
Ronnie Rickaiu
satellite beach, Floiiua
S29S7

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ronnie Rickaiu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

"Avatai"
"Inception"
"Bie Baiu"
"The Natiix"


418
Saimau Siuuiqui
Pennsylvania
191u4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I think it is a bit backwaius (anu unnecessaiy) to not allow consumeis to space-shift
legally owneu BvBS to othei uevices. The NPAA's iesponse to public knowleuge's
pioposal is asinine at best, gieeuy at woist. Actually, if you flip the two aujectives, it
will still holu tiue. Thanks

Sinceiely,

Saimau Siuuiqui

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

loiu of the iings: fellowship of the iing
loiu of the iings: the twin toweis
loiu of the iings: the ietuin of the king
spiueiman 2
wickei paik
batman begins
smallville season 1
smallville season 2
smallville season S
smallville season 4
419
Natt Willaiu
Floiiua
S222S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I buy movies because I suppoit them. But the notion of paying twice oi moie foi a
BvB I alieauy own is luuicious anu the NPAA comments about using
NetFlix¡Bulu¡Wainei Biotheis' Blu-Ray uisc piogiam to buy the stuff I own alieauy
is iiuiculous as well. The iuea that they uon't want us to have convienent options in
an age of convienent options is ignoiant of ieality.



Though I fully unueistanu piiacy is a pioblem, I think it's also a pioblem to squeeze
moie cash out of the consumei with total uisiegaiu foi his wants. Please uo the
iight thing anu allow us to iip oui BvBs if we so choose. Lots of us want to suppoit
these films, but we'ie not up to paying ovei anu ovei again foi that same suppoit.

Sinceiely,

Natt Willaiu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Scott Pilgiim vS. The Woilu
The Ciow
Entei the Biagon
Kill Bill vol. 1 anu 2
Pulp Fiction
! V#F!
I5,,LH!
421
Chiistophei Nooie
Columbus, 0hio
4S22u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I feel like this is soita common sense. Bow many times must I buy the same movie if
the technology changes eveiy 2 yeais.

Sinceiely,

Chiistophei Nooie

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Bepaiteu

vanilla Sky

Foiest uump


422
Naik Watts
Texas
78741

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

0nce again, I concui with Public Knowleuge's claims anu suppoit theii pioposal. It
seems that theie shoulu not even be a question of whethei a peison can make
copies of something he owns foi his own use. Fuitheimoie, a piohibition baseu on
enciyption which can be uecipheieu by ieauily available tools is luuicious. Content
piouuceis cannot ieasonably claim that theie is a violation when they have full
knowleuge of the ineffectiveness of theii enciyption.

Sinceiely,

Naik Watts

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Seienity
Stai Tiek (2uu9)
Stai Tiek TNu episoues
Teiminatoi Collectoi's Euition
42S
Thomas Lynch
Nassachusetts
2S7S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I paiu foi these BvBs at stoies such as Taiget anu Best Buy--these weie legally
puichaseu BvBs allowing me to watch movies at home when I hau the fiee time--I
am cuiiently a full-time college stuuent. Seeing as how I have alieauy puichaseu the
iight to watch the movie when I choose to at my own convenience, I finu it laughable
that the NPAA wants me to continue subsiuizing them again anu again foi the same
content via "new business ventuies" oi whatevei the hell they call foicing me to pay
them twice, thiice, foi access to the same content I lawfully puichaseu befoie, just so
I can watch these movies on othei scieens besiue a stanuaiu television. This is
stupiu anu wiong. Please giant the exception Public Knowleuge is pioposing, it's a
veiy ieasonable stance to take.

Sinceiely,

Thomas Lynch

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Baik Knight
Inception
Casino Royale
0uantum of Solace
Back to the Futuie I
Back to the Futuie II
Back to the Futuie III
! V#V!
_A/!:5'4(Q!</,150/0!
_A/!Z,%/&!Z41'A/4&!
42S
Ioshua Naiino
0aklanu, Tennessee
S8u6u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ioshua Naiino

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Piincess Biiue
Finuing Nemo
Shawshank Reuemption
Biaveheait
Nission Impossible
The Bouine Iuentity
What About Bob
0p
Casino Royale
0uantum of Solace
Noonstiuck
King Kong


426
luis Filipe Costa Calauo
8uuu

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

luis Filipe Costa Calauo

427
Benjamin Allen
Annapolis, Naiylanu
214uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Benjamin Allen

428
Negan Iohnson
Naiylanu
21u4S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Negan Iohnson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Napolean Bynamite
Scaiy Novie S
Noon
A Seiious Nan
uhostbusteis 1
Stai Wais: A New Bope
429
Ioshua Castaneua
uoleta, Califoinia
9S117

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ioshua Castaneua

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Tiansfoimeis
4Su
Nack Noiiisen
2S4uS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please let me iip my BvBs!

Sinceiely,

Nack Noiiisen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Lethal Weapon
Lethal Weapon 2
Lethal Weapon S
Lethal Weapon 4
Big Bauuy
Bappy uilmoie
Funny People
Kiu-v!
Big Asses anu Boobs!
4S1
keith ungei
staten islanu, New Yoik
1uS12

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

i own neaily 22 television seiies which contain neaily 1uu uvus. i Finu it insane that
i neeu to pay foi a uigital copy that woulu piobably expiie oi subsciibe to an online
seivice that can at anything take away the shows i like. BvB iipping shoulu be legal
just like cu, iecoius, a-tiack, anu vBS.

Sinceiely,

keith ungei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

22 television seiies which contain neaily 1uu uvus. i Finu it insane that i neeu to pay
foi a uigital copy that woulu piobably expiie oi subsciibe to an online seivice that
can at anything take away the shows i like. BvB iipping shoulu be legal just like cu,
iecoius, a-tiack, anu vBS.
4S2
Stephanie Lilly
8918S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Stephanie Lilly

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Bloou uiamonu
Biity uancing
Shuttei islanu
vacation
4SS
Fiank Iones
Noith Caiolina
287S9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fiank Iones

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais episoues 1 - 6
The Natiix
The Sth Element
anu many of otheis
4S4
PA0L Y00NANS
78641

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have 8 chiluien anu they all like the same types of movies. They constantly sciatch
anu bieak uiscs, so it is much bettei to puichase 1 uvu anu make a backup to let
them use. Nakes buying othei things like clothes anu school supplies, toys, games,
etc. easiei on the family.

The way the NPAA wants us to uo things is just keep buying the same uvu's ovei
anu ovei anu ovei. If I hau to uo that then as a family we woulu not have money foi
the things we neeu.

A 1uu pack of blank uvu's costs $2S.uu. A new ielease uvu costs $22.uu.

So if my kius uestioyeu 1uu uvus thats $22,uuu. Theie woulu be no way I woulu
even consiuei that. That's just insanity.

When you puichase any othei piouuct, clothing, etc. they uo not tell you what you
can anu cannot uo with what you puichase so why is the NPAA alloweu to contiol
what we puichase.

What will happen with me if this alloweu I will stop puichasing ALL types of meuia,
they will nevei get anothei penny fiom me oi my family.

Sinceiely,

PA0L Y00NANS

4SS
I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The lost boys
The lion king
Tion
Chionicles of iiuuick
PLus hunuieus moie.
4S6
Scott Reffnei
16SSS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Scott Reffnei

4S7
Alex Bugan
Wateitown, Nassachusetts
2472

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Alex Bugan

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Noie than you coulu count.
4S8
Yechiel Kimchi
94u87

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Ny family have thiee laptops that have no BvB playei on them - but we all want to
view the movies on them, like when we tiavel.

Theiefoie, we must be able to legally copy the movies fiom the BvBs to the laptop's
haiu uiive.

Sinceiely,

Yechiel Kimchi

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Back to the Futuie
Iuiassic Paik
Petei Pan
anu 1uu moie.
4S9
Ieff Banson
Spiuce, Nichigan
48762

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

A laige poition of the 0niteu States still uoesn't have bioaubanu available with the
capacity to tiansfei a BvB-sizeu quantity of content. The best option in iuial aieas
is satellite which has inheient capacity limits anu latency, substantially less than
what is neeueu to tiansfei the quantity of uata on a BvB in ieal-time.

Sinceiely,

Ieff Banson

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais collection
44u
I. William Bays
Silei City, Noith Caiolina
27S44

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

I. William Bays

441
Iosh Nillei
Amity, 0iegon
971u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iosh Nillei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Yu-gi-oh! The Novie
X-Nen
valiant
The Tuxeuo
TNNT
Stiange Bays
Stai Tiek
Spiiiteu Away
Scooby-Boo
School of Rock
Robin Boou
Riuuick Tiilogy
The Retuin of Iafai
The Punishei
The Postman
Piiates of the Caiibbean: At Wo
The Pacifiei
0nce 0pon a Time in Nexico
442
Night Watch
Night at the Nuseum
The NeveiEnuing Stoiy
National Tieasuie
Naiuto: Shippuuen - The Novie
Nacho Libie
The Nummy: Tomb of the Biago
Ninu of Nencia: 0ncensoieu Se
Nickey's 0nce 0pon A Chiistma
Nen in Black II
Les 7 Nomies
Legenuaiy
Kung Fu Panua
King Aithui
Kaiate Kiu
The Italian Iob
Inkheait
Bighlanuei: Season Five
Bighlanuei: Season 0ne
Biualgo
The Baunteu Nansion
Bancock
Balloweentown anu Balloweentown II: Kalabai's Revenge
The uoonies
uhostBusteis 2
uhostbusteis 1 & 2
Fiight Night
Final Fantasy: The Spiiits Within
Evolution
Bogma
Bespeiauo
Baieuevil
Coialine
Conan: The Complete 0uest
The Cave
Categoiy 7
Biotheihoou of the Wolf
Blank Check
Blaue
Big Tiouble in Little China
Avatai
Alien vs. Pieuatoi
Suu
Bionicle 2: Legenus of Netiu-Nui
Nanny NcPhee
National ueogiaphic: Su Yeais 0f National ueogiaphic Specials
44S
I Am Legenu
Shaolin Wheel of Life
A Knight's Tale
Balf Bakeu
uhost Bog: The Way of the Samuiai
Alauuin
Titan A.E.
0ng-Bak: The Thai Waiiioi
The Last Samuiai
Futuiama volume 4
Biaveheait
Cheech Anu Chong's 0p In Smoke
Iion Nan
Supeiman Retuins
The Kaiate Kiu Collection
Bighlanuei: Season Two
Splitting Beiis
Signs
Resiuent Evil: Apocalypse
Kull the Conqueioi
The Count of Nonte Ciisto
The Loiu of the Rings: The Two Toweis
The Bobbit
uouzilla
Nim's Islanu
Spaceballs
Zack anu Niii Nake a Poino
Teenage Nutant Ninja Tuitles
Bumbo
Scooby-Boo 2: Nonsteis 0nleasheu
Shaun of the Beau
Shiek, felices paia siempie
Ronin
Young uuns
Bighlanuei 2: Renegaue veision
Aimy of Baikness
Iohnny Nnemonic
Babylon S: Signs anu Poitents: The Complete Fiist Season
Babylon S: The Coming of Shauows: The Complete Seconu Season
Rose Reu
INTERvIEW with the vANPIRE
Failuie to Launch
Biothei Beai 2
X2: X-Nen 0niteu
Shoit Ciicuit
The Natiix¡The Natiix Revisiteu
444
The Thiee Nusketeeis
The 1Sth Waiiioi
ulauiatoi
Spiuei-Nan 2
Snatch
Batman Begins
Baiiy Pottei anu the uoblet of Fiie
Baiiy Pottei anu the Soiceiei's Stone
Baiiy Pottei anu the Chambei of Seciets
Baiiy Pottei anu the Balf-Bloou Piince
Baiiy Pottei anu the Piisonei of Azkaban
Tioy
Baiby 0'uill anu the Little People
The Legenu of Zoiio
Alice in Wonueilanu
Staisky & Butch
Nauagascai
Blackbeaiu's uhost
Pathfinuei
0nueiwoilu
Naue in Ameiica
The Neveienuing Stoiy 2: The Next Chaptei
Spiuei-Nan
Insiue Nan
Iim Benson's Iack anu the Beanstalk: The Real Stoiy
Ciouching Tigei, Biuuen Biagon
Santa Clause 2
Naiy Poppins
Smackuown!: Best 0f Smackuown!: 1uth Anniveisaiy 1999-2uu9
The Loiu of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
Back to the Futuie
ualaxy 0uest
Alauuin anu the King of Thieves
The Santa Clause
The Nummy
Pooh's Beffalump Balloween Novie
All Bogs uo to Beaven
The Chionicles of Nainia: The Lion, The Witch anu The Waiuiobe
Aiounu the Woilu in 8u Bays
The Chionicles 0f Riuuick
Pitch Black
Coipse Biiue
White Noise
The Loiu of the Rings: The Retuin of the King
Piiates of the Caiibbean: Beau Nan's Chest
Piiates of the Caiibbean: The Cuise of the Black Peail
! VV9!
_A/!$5E[(/!?A5)!?1,,/E'(1)!
_A/!-4(=()5,!_/,/.(&1)!?A4(&'R5&!?,5&&(E&!
b(=A,5)0/4Y!D/5&1)!_A4//!
_A/!J54[!O)(=A'!
_A/!;4()E/&&!Z4(0/!
b544@!;1''/4!5)0!'A/!J/5'A,@!b5,,1M&!;54'!#!
b544@!;1''/4!5)0!'A/!J/5'A,@!b5,,1M&!;54'!"!
b544@!;1''/4!5)0!'A/!-40/4!1>!'A/!;A1/)(Q!
446
Scott Netcalf
Califoinia
9SSS6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Scott Netcalf

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Stai Wais 1-6 Blu-Ray (BR)
X Nen Fiist Class BR
uieen Lantein BR
Baiiy Pottei 1-8 BR
Balloween II BR
Twilight BR
Sex In the City BR
Tiansfoimeis 1-S BR
Plus 1uu othei Blu-Rays
anu ovei 4uu BvB's
447
Bomenic Fusco
Flowei Nounu, Texas
7Su28

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Bomenic Fusco

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Aimegeuon
448
Stephen Nie
2148

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Stephen Nie

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uattaca
449
Eugene Lytnev
Califoinia
94u24

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu like to ask if the piice of a BvB incluues only the piice of the physical object
with manufactuiing anu shipping cost, oi am I also paying foi the movie on the uisc
as well.

Sinceiely,

Eugene Lytnev

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Chicken Little
uiil with a Peail Eaiiing
Love Actually
4Su
Chiistophei Southwick
Nassachusetts
18SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Chiistophei Southwick

4S1
Fiank Ryuei
Libeityville, Illinois
6uu48

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fiank Ryuei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

uone with the winu
Naltese falcon
Casablanca
Some like it hot
Annie hall
4S2
Baiien uuainaccia
Newbeig, 0iegon
971S2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

This is a funamantal iight that I shoulu be able to use the mateiial I paiu foi as I
woulu like to use them foi my own peisonal consumption.

Sinceiely,

Baiien uuainaccia

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Aliens,
Robocop,
Sth Element,
anu 1uu's moie




4SS
Iames King IR
Pasco, Washington
99Su1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It is completely unieasonable that theie is a law that pievents me fiom uoing
whatevei I feel is necessaiy with NY (not the RIAA's oi NPAA's) possessions in NY
own house. I'm not copying movies to sale oi lenu, I'm copying NY movies foi NY
own peisonal use. I'm N0T going to puichase multiple copies of the same movie,
whethei physical oi uigital, just to be able to watch the movie when anu wheie I
want to: I'm also not going to puichase anothei copy of the movie if it gets uamageu
fiom use - I'll just make a copy, use the copy anu only use the oiiginal to make
backups fiom. The auuacity of the RIAA anu NPAA to insist that I ie-puichase new
copies of movies anu such is iiuiculous, boiuei lining on insanity anu those
institutions with those kinus of iueas aie a scouige to the Ameiican people. I want to
see pioof that the people at the RIAA anu NPAA uo what they'ie asking the iest of us
to uo befoie they even think about tiying to enfoice this kinu of gaibage.

Sinceiely,

Iames King IR

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Batman Begins
Alauuin
Blue Stieak
Chaily
Tiansfoimeis
! V9V!
?41E10(,/!J%)0//!
b5)E1E[!
WA1&'!<(0/4!
`5'(1)5,!D/E%4('@!
b544@!;1''/4!
_A/!Z,()0!D(0/!
D/4/)('@!
31%4!?A4(&'R5&/&!
_A/!G)E4/0(N,/&!
4SS
Anuiew Kingeiy
Pieumont, Alabama
S6272

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu like to be able to uownloau a movie that I own onto my computei. It uoesn't
make any sense that this is illegal.

Sinceiely,

Anuiew Kingeiy

4S6
Natthew Louevico
Los Angeles, Califoinia
9uuSS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Natthew Louevico

4S7
Iason Sweeney
San Biego, Califoinia
921u6

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

It's iiuiculous that the the NPAA is tiying to foice me to ie-buy content I alieauy
own just so I can pieseive it in uigital foim just like my family's music collection.



BvBs easily sciatch anu bieak. If I coulu legally copy my content onto my haiu
uiive, I coulu pieseive the movie collection that I have spent thousanus of uollais to
acquiie. I'm not going to ie-buy all of these movies in uigital foim. I alieauy own
them.



Copyiight 0ffice: Please make a sounu uecision that ieflects the mouein lanuscape
of uigital uata.

Sinceiely,

Iason Sweeney

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Almost 2uu
4S8
Iohn Shoit
Nesa, Aiizona
8S2u8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have thiee youngei chiluien anu as much as I tiy to teach them how to hanule a
BvB they still enu up sciatcheu anu unieauable. It woulu be nice to have legal
softwaie that I coulu use so I may backup of BvBs to eithei othei BvBs oi to
anothei stoiage uevice.

Sinceiely,

Iohn Shoit

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Rango
The Abyss
Tangleu
Suif's 0p
Ice Age
Coipse Biiue
uattaca
Pitch Black
4S9
Stephen Ryczek
Teiie Baute, Inuiana
478u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I woulu also like to make backups of my puichaseu BvBs anu BlueRays, as they can
easily be uamageu with use.

Sinceiely,

Stephen Ryczek

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Cais
Cais2
Remembei the Titans
uone with the Winu
Sounu of Nusic
Taizan
Ice Age
Couiious ueoige
Couiageous
Numeious WWII Shows anu Novies
Tv Seiies such as I Love Lucy
etc.
46u
Iose L Palacios
Niami, Floiiua
SS1SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Theie aie smait ways to piotect copyiight fiom piiacy, using intelligent people anu
Piogiammeis that still without job, they coulu piotect the oiiginal meuia thiough
smait coues that pievent the commeicial uistiibution, that's ielative easy way to
pievent piiacy anu also will help to cieate new jobs. Tell Bollywoou executives that
they can hiie these kinus of people anu uo goou thing insteau of attempt to limit oui
fieeuom anu tiy to make all of us, common ciiminals.

Sinceiely,

Iose L Palacios

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The ulauiatoi
uoou will hunting
Tioy
Toy Stoiy
The cionicles of Nainiua anu a lot moie motion pictuies
461
Lily Caiion
Naguabo, Pueito Rico
718

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lily Caiion

462
Naik Beakins
Califoinia
92uS4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Naik Beakins

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

All the Stai Wais Novies anu ovei 1uu othei movies on BvB
46S
Fieueiick Fianck
Rockfoiu, Illinois
611u8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Fieueiick Fianck

464
Ballas Beffian
Rockfoiu, Illinois
611u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I have ovei Suuu uiffeiant movies of wich 2¡S aie on vBS foimat iest aie on BvB
foimat I also have ovei 2S,uuu songs on CB foimat,I have a collection of 8 tiack
tapes anu iecoiues,all of wich i copy to cassett tape to save weai anu teai on the
oiignal copy foi my own use! I have put all my music into my computei to save
weai anu teai on the oiiginal that I puichaseu.I woulu like to pieseive my oiiginal
BvBs foi my own use by copying them saving weai anu teai anu possible L0SS
when tiaveling in my R.v. if a cosumei puichases something that can be uamageu oi
lost why cant they piotect that item fiom loss oi uamage by making a copy foi theii
own use I paiu foi it !!! thank you sinceily fiom a 0SN vetian anu tax paying citizen

Sinceiely,

Ballas Beffian

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The complete collection of the Woilu at WAR seiies,Stai Wais collection,victoiy at
SEA seiies,ALIEN 1,2,S. The vietnam Seiies,ECT.ECT.ECT.
46S
uene Nelies
Salina, Kansas
674u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

uene Nelies

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Avitai
Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy
The Natiix
Boine Iuentity
466
WALTER SNITB
NEW CASTLE, Pennsylvania
161u1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

WALTER SNITB

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

WBEN I B0Y A BvB 0R CB 0R TAPE IT BEL0NuS T0 NE T0 B0 AS I WANT IF I
NAKE A C0PY 0F A CB BvB 0R TAPE IF Y00 WANT TBE RIuBTRS Y00 SB00LB
uIvE Y00R CB BvB TAPE T0 TBE C0NS0NER
467
Bouglas Fish
Floiiua
S46SS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

0wning BvBs anu having the ability to make backups foi my own use shoulu not be
illegal.

Nany many folks have kius movies on BvB that theii chiluien love to watch ovei
anu ovei anu ovei. All that hanuling soonei oi latei weais out a BvB, anu the cost of
ieplacing all youi kius favoiites can get unmanageable. Nost of my fiienus neeu to
be able to make backups of the oiiginal they own, so the kius can watch anu hanule
the backup to uestiuction, without woiiy of loosing the movie oi show foi goou oi a
long time till mom anu uau can affoiu a ieplacement oiiginal. Its not faii to the kius,
also being able to put the movies on say a tablet so they can take the movie on a
ioau tiip is essential. Not being able to uo that with a movie I own because its
"illegal" is just ciazy. I'm not giving it away, anu I'm not selling it. I am just neeuing
to use it in a uiffeient way by tiansfeiiing it to anothei foimat. Its mine anu I bought
it. Why cant I use it as I neeu to oi see fit without someone saying its against the law
.

Sinceiely,

Bouglas Fish

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

all the loiu of the iings movies, all the stai wais movies, all the Bighlanuei movies,
the entiie seiies of seveial Anime shows, etc etc etc. I am a movie fan.
468
Ivoiy Benson
86S14

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ivoiy Benson

469
kiik Beimsen
S2722

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

kiik Beimsen

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

S stiikes
ueath iace 2uuu
ameiican pie
47u
Lenny Cook, PhB
Texas
781u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Lenny Cook, PhB

471
Emma Beveiage
Austin, Texas
78744

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

We buy these items with an expectation of being able to use them.

Sinceiely,

Emma Beveiage

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I an not going to give you a list of my peisonal piopeity.
472
Iim Bennett
1Su21

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Iim Bennett

47S
fieu kingeiy
Floiiua
S2u24

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

fieu kingeiy

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Nost of john waynes' movies
474
Logan Night
0KC, 0klahoma
7S1u9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Logan Night

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Amauaeus, Bances with Wolves, Feai anu Loathing in Las vegas

















! V79!
!
!
!
!
!
476
mickey payne
henlawson, West viiginia
2S624

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

yes

Sinceiely,

mickey payne

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

yes
477
ABB0RBNAN ABNNEB
khaitoum,
22214

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

ABB0RBNAN ABNNEB

478
Richaiu Pegley
Nasontown, West viiginia
26S42

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Stait keeping you nose out of my affaiis anu pay moie attention to youi own
messes.

Sinceiely,

Richaiu Pegley

479
Naitin Wilueimoth
ulenuale Beights, Illinois
6u1S9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I peisonally feel that companies like Sony BNu anu the Notion Pictuie Inuustiy aie
ieally nobouy to have any iights to any copyiight laws being passeu iegaiuing
uuplicating woik that a consumei has puichaseu fiom theii haiu eaineu uollais.
Aftei all I giew up in the eaily6u's at a time piioi to the uigital ievolution. A time
that Bollywoou anu the Nusic Inuustiy uiu absolutely nothing but capitalize not
only on the consumei but on the aitists that weie suckeu into theii gieeuy webs.A
time that an LP iecoiu consisteu of 1 oi 2 goou songs anu 1u to 1S filleis that the
consumei hau nevei heaiu befoie anu if that consumei was lucky 2 oi S of those
filleis might appeal to them. Neanwhile the aitists weie completely taken auvantage
of not only by the iecoiuing company they weie uealing with but toui anu ioau anu
business managei anu eveiyone got a piece of theii pie anu by the time they weie
finisheu with the aitist theie was nothing left oi almost nothing left foi the aitist
themselves. The uigital ievolution uiu nothing moie than to make things iight both
foi the aitist anu the consumei,so these oiganizations shoulu spenu less time anu
money tiying to get the goveinment to make laws enabling them to suck us uiy
again anu maybe they woulun't be ciying bioke so much,maybe they shoulu attempt
haiu woik like these aitists anu the consumeis have hau to woik at to keep feeuing
these voltuies.

Sinceiely,

Naitin Wilueimoth

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:
! VXF!
!
?,/4[&2?,/4[&#23()0()=!314/&'/42-)/!`(=A'!I('A!_A/!O()=!
481
lothai hienz
chaileston, West viiginia
2SSu4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I always neeu to make back up copies of movies anu iecoius because CBs anu BvB
uisks uo N0T last longei than a few plays, 4 yeais at the langest wheieas viueo tape
lasts 2u¡2Su yeais anu going.

BvB

CBs

uo not last noi have long life playing oi shelf life anu it is impoitant to back up each
copy.

We mean it sinceiely, LB

Sinceiely,

lothai hienz

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Piiates, all Iohnny Bepp movies anu some otheis.
482
BALE BEETLER
44uS2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I BELIEvE TBAT IF I'N N0T ALL0WEB T0 B0RN BvB'S TBEN TBE N0TI0N
PICT0RE C0NPANY SB00LB BE F0RCEB T0 B0Y ALL TBEN BACK AT F0LL PRICE
LIKE I PAIB F0R TAKINu ARE RIuBTS AWAY, BECA0SE 0NCE I PAIB F0R TBEN
TBEY ARE NINE ANB N0 L0NuER TBEIRS.S0 WBAT I B0 WITB TBEN IS NY
B0SINESS!!!!!!

Sinceiely,

BALE BEETLER

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

I 0WN TB00SANBS 0F N0vIES TBAT I PAIB F0R WITB NY BARB EARNEB
CASB!!!!!!
48S
Robin Tash
Texas
7S1S9

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I love being able to iip my BvB's to my laptop so that I may watch movies I have
puichaseu while tiaveling. I uo not see any ieason I shoulu have to pay again to
place these movies on my laptop, noi uo I see any ieason to subsciibe to a stieaming
movie site on the inteinet to watch movies I own. Tiaveling with a laptop with my
puichaseu movies pie-loaueu onto it saves me time, hassles anu caiiy-on luggage
space. I am getting sick anu tiieu of how the meuia inuustiy, along with many othei
inuustiies anu official oiganizations, take appaient uelight in nickle anu uimeing the
public to ueath in a time when most of us tiuly neeu to watch eveiy nickle anu uime
we have.

Sinceiely,

Robin Tash

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

The Loiu of the Rings Tiilogy, The Chionicles of Riuuick, Nission Impossible I anu II,
uhost Riuei, All six movies of the Stai Wais saga
484
nicholas whitfielu
spiingfielu, Illinois
627uS-492u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

nicholas whitfielu

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

note book ,hangovei2
48S
Kim L Baiiis
11226

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Kim L Baiiis

486
Ieiome Young
Nemphis, Tennessee
S8117

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Ieiome Young

487
Yvonne Baikei
West Allis, Wisconsin
SS214

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Yvonne Baikei

488
Beathei Ragsuale
Biyan, Texas
778u2

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Beathei Ragsuale

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Step biotheis
The othei guys
The uaik knight
The hangovei
Teiiible bosses
0iange county
Case S9
489
scott walkei
0iegon
97SuS

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I only back up anu copy Nusic anu Novies that i have peviously bought fiom youi
aitists,I have eveiy iight to back up my investments in these movies ¡music. i am an
Accomplisheu musician anu iespect the iights of aitists but you aie going to fai anu
invauing my piivacy with these lawa,besiues the fact that most of youi
enteitainment Coipoiations Nake WAY too much money alieauy, making it haiu foi
pooi people to enjoy youi piouuct as well.0uit Yei Bitchin!!!

Sinceiely,

scott walkei

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

hunuieus of legally owneu
49u
Nino uetts
0ssining, New Yoik
1uS62

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

Nino uetts

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Too many to list!
491
Naikus Cook
8u7S

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

If I want to tiansfei one of my movies to my Ipou, why shoulun't I be alloyeu to uo
this. I payeu foi the Ipou, I payeu foi my movies. Both inuustiies have gotten theii
money fiom me. If I own both anu I'm not making money oi giving them away foi
fiee, who aie you to tell me what I can anu can't uo with it.

Sinceiely,

Naikus Cook

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Accepteu
The abyss
Suu
2u12
goluen eye
tomoiiow nevei uies
balls of fuiy
Austin poweis
Aimageuuon
animal house
ameiican pie
ameiican pie 2
avp
aiifoice one
! VK#!
N,50/!
N,5E[!01=!
N(=!'41%N,/!()!,('',/!EA()5!
N/1M%,>!
N/05\\,/0!
N/5)!!
N5'R5)!5)0!41N()!'1!)5R/!5!>/M!
!
49S
Richaiu Neiona
187u

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I belong to a uemociatic countiy anu I think that the goveinment officials aie only
the iepiesentatives of the populace, the will of the people shall pievail.

Sinceiely,

Richaiu Neiona

494
Baiolu Lewis
496S1

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Please make it easiei to back the oiignals. The classics won't be aiounu the futuie.
Since some aie vaulteu, oi uiscountinueu. With the wiue vast veiy of new ones some
have to get pusheu to the siue.

Sinceiely,

Baiolu Lewis

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Shelves full of Bvu's, Examples aie titanic, Bisney classics like shailets web, pete's
uiagon, Chitty bang bang. Ect, list goes on.
49S
iafael patino
mexico,
124uu

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

my point of view the ancient films when theie was not beta, vhs, ucu oi uvu oi
otheis was bettei the quality anu theie weie not laws against the people to put in
jail anyone, but I believe that hollywoou anu othei places as film centeis they have
not the quality to iequest the law against people, but they aie the blameis foi the
actual moment of law faight, foi me I love the past pictuies, the 4u´s, Su´s, 6u´s anu
thats all, the films weie bettei than now, anu the stais weie bettei, foi me insteau to
be facing hollywoou anu its actual gaibage, anu I pieffei to eat the best than to be
watching the 6 points hollywoou uung movies, theii politic is the teiioi, the ciime,
the tiaition, the intiigue anu the falsehoou, anu the bau ones always come out with
theiis, in the othei hanu I pieffei the classics 1uu % best than mouein movies, ugly
stais, the women aie aitificial ones, anu eveiy one must copy the hollywou uung
anu bull shet, I believe hollywoou is too olu as theii owneis anu I believe to make a
pictuie they must smoke pot anu sniff uiugs, thats my commentaiy.

Sinceiely,

iafael patino

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

my point of view the ancient films when theie was not beta, vhs, ucu oi uvu oi
otheis was bettei the quality anu theie weie not laws against the people to put in
jail anyone, but I believe that hollywoou anu othei places as film centeis they have
not the quality to iequest the law against people, but they aie the blameis foi the
496
actual moment of law faight, foi me I love the past pictuies, the 4u´s, Su´s, 6u´s anu
thats all, the films weie bettei than now, anu the stais weie bettei, foi me insteau to
be facing hollywoou anu its actual gaibage, anu I pieffei to eat the best than to be
watching the 6 points hollywoou uung movies, theii politic is the teiioi, the ciime,
the tiaition, the intiigue anu the falsehoou, anu the bau ones always come out with
theiis, in the othei hanu I pieffei the classics 1uu % best than mouein movies, ugly
stais, the women aie aitificial ones, anu eveiy one must copy the hollywou uung
anu bull shet, I believe hollywoou is too olu as theii owneis anu I believe to make a
pictuie they must smoke pot anu sniff uiugs, thats my commentaiy.
497
austin buchiane
Kunkletown, Pennsylvania
18uS8

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

Sinceiely,

austin buchiane

498
Lynuale Staigell
Bouglasville, ueoigia
Su1S4

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

I uon't think I shoulu have to pay foi what I alieauy own just to it them in moie than
one ioom oi to have a copy in the cai just because iich people want to get iichei. If I
neeu to stop buying uvus just to piove a point, that is not a pioblem with me anu I
believe many otheis woulu join in that fight. Sometimes people can get gieeuy only
to finu out that they huit themselves. It may be tiue that they coulu make moie
money by enfoicing stiictei laws but it's also tiue that they can sometimes shoot
themselves in the foot anu enu up losing moie than they anticipateu.

Sinceiely,

Lynuale Staigell

I cuiiently own motion pictuies on BvB, incluuing:

Ray
Spiueiman 1 anu 2
The Rookie
The Empoiei's uioove
Beaiinstein Beais
Biagon Tails
Tom anu Ieiiy
Cais
Biffeient music conceits
Siu The Science Kiu
! VKK!
:@!Z5N@!?5)!</50!
D/&5R/!D'4//'!]0(>>/4/)'!1)/&^!
#V!]E1,,/E'(1)^!
d140!->!_A/!<()=&!]E1,,/E'(1)^!
CCC!5)0!R5)@!R14/!CCC!
Suu
Paul Newman
Iacksonville, Illinois
626Su

Naiia Pallante
Registei of Copyiights
0.S. Copyiight 0ffice
1u1 Inuepenuence Avenue SE
Washington, BC 2uSS9-6uuu

Registei Pallante,

I wiite touay in suppoit of Public Knowleuge's pioposal to exempt noncommeicial
space-shifting of motion pictuies on BvB. Cuiiently, the BNCA pievents me fiom
uisabling technical piotection measuies on my lawfully acquiieu BvBs in oiuei to
copy the motion pictuies containeu on those BvBs onto othei uevices that I own.

I have a ieasonable expectation that I can shift the motion pictuies containeu on
these anu othei BvBs to my own uevices foi noncommeicial puiposes. It is
unieasonable, anu unintenueu, that the BNCA shoulu inteifeie with this type of
activity. I uige you to giant the exemption.

To whom it may concein,

I finu it completely iiuiculous that I cannot make a copy of a BvB that I 0WN.

Please get youi heaus out of youi asses anu B0 the iight thing.

Sinceiely,

Paul Newman