MECBIOLOGICALPROJECT S A N O N O F R EN U C L E A R G E N E R A T I N GS T A T I O N M O N I T O R I N GS T U D I E SO N ICHTHYOPLANKTON ND ZOOPLANKTON A FINAL REPORT A P P E N D I C E S O L U M E1 V

Prepared by Arthur M. Barnett, Principal Investigator Contributing Staff: W i l l i a mW a t s o n Linda G. Gleye Susan D. Watts Karen D. Green T h o m a sD . J o h n s o n D o u g l a sN . B e a n a n Consultant: Janice D. Callahan

M A R I N E E C O L O G I C A L O N S U L T A N T S F S O U T H E R NC A L I F O R N I A C O 531 EncinitasBoulevardSuite 110 Encinitas, California 92024 8 October 1987 R E P O R T N U M B E R M E C O 3 2 8 7 O 5 5F I N A L

I

T h e a p p e n d i c e sg i v e n i n t h i s v o l u m e , e x c e p t A p p e n d i c e s B a n d C . 1 , h a v e b e e n revised and updated by ttre appendices given in: MEC Biological Project San Onofre

Nuclear Generating Station Monitoring Studies on lchthyoplankton and Zooplankton Final Report Appendices Volume 2: Revisions and Addenda. Specifically,

A p p e n d i c e sA , C . 2 , c . 3 ,

andtE of this volume are replaced by AppendicesA.2,

C.2, C.3, and E. respectively, of Volume 2. Appendix A.1 of Volume 2 is a new appendix. The Appendix D figures in this volumethat show patterns of distribution in the cross-shelf strata (e.g., Figures D-76, D-27, D-48) are replaced by the

c o r r e s p o n d i n g f i g u r e s o f d i s t r i b u t i o n s g i v e n i n A p p e n d i x D o f V o l u m e2 .

Clevelondio
lon/€a
EratRE lo ol| coNtFroL

ioe
AITEN AONOA

c

P-0.09
o. BE bAE om AM Al EN Itm EM bn OE OM .n DE DN m ON d

prcflcxlon
AFTEN AONOA

o

P-0.86
AE o. b. lE om Al EN OM Al bm Dn o EM OE ON on 0n 6

fl6xlon

P-O.18
q. Al5 b. ItE om AM EM DE Al cE bm EN s €n bn d-

poat-flcxlon
aEFISFiE Ect ('R q('NTFOL AFTEF' E<'NOS

o

P-0.o9
rE b. Al: .m At\a Ahl lN bm { t'M €n oC bn OL DN cm dn

Figure D-6

patterns for Clevelandia i-qE. Cross-shelf distributional the Bonferroni t-test. Shading denotes strata groupings based oE-EE-FEEITIt;'f Strata designations are orclbred frorn highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata not signifi6antty separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.9., A l u l = B t o ; kA m i d v a t e r ) ' a r e f o r s o N G S i n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v e r c a s e . a r e s t r a t a i n t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o t d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . a Only strata in which larvae dccurred vere tested. The resr,rtts of the MANOVAre also D-7

shovn

9:rtefgl-g
)AEc

Y-coudo
AFTER AONOS

lorvoe

P-O.02
€. BE AE b. om AM bm BN BM CE qn bn o. CM Ai.,t CN dm <ta on Oe om DM

preflexlon

P-O.O2
6. .m ba AM EM E,E bm CE OM E'N on bn o. dm ON C. om on AAt DE DM

flcxlon
BEFOFIE E'C OR CONTROL AFTER SONOS c

o.aa

I

o.o9 o.tg

o.2c,

o.oo

ru

io;3.i

o.oE ->>-

:E"=--= P-O.31
o. ,lE b. EE qm Al, bm bn cN at BM EN on OM o. CE om on

post-flcxlon
EEFOFIE BC o.22 t.5g OR CONTFIOL

o.oE

o.oo

r,b:aaJ
Ei"li

o.:ta

Be*

+
EN €m AM

o.oo

__a5E____.P-O.24
€n bn bm o. DE cE cM .AI{ DM 6n ffi <I. dm BM cN

EE

q.

b.

AE

Figure D-27 -

Cross-shelf disrributiona I DarLerns for Quietula y:s-aj!d.g.. Shading denotes straia qrot,i inqs nased o6-JhE- res[iiIE-6T the Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are-orderel from highest to lovest mean rank abundance. Strata not significantly separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e,9., AM=Block A midwater) are for soNcs in the After data set, lov/er case are strata in t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . Only strata in vhich larvae occurred vere tested. The results of the MANOVA re also a D-28

shohrn

llypnue
Erottc lo o'l ooNTioL

gllberti
AFTEi Alo .L.7tt AON6

loruoc

t t.o7

0.44

o.2,:l

St l t." r&:l}

1.12

\-

P-0.o9
tE o. At b. AM OE em lM bm lN { baAlomC'Lm

d.

dm

dn

oN

DM

DG

Dl.l

prcflcxlon
IETORE OR OONTRC'L

to

P-O.O6
Al tE c. b. AM on ItM bm Ot o. s bn !N Al oM om ON a. on dm dn Dl{ DN DE

flcxlon
tEFroltE lo otr coNTFtoL

P-O.18
@ tl! AE b. AAl cm FN lM ldr cn OE bn o A}{ CM ffi on dm CN DM

port-flGxktn
EEFOiE EO C,R CONT'|TOL A'TEII SC'NO' C'

P-O.02
ll e. JlE b. OE .m tM bm AM !N en { bn AD{ cn d. s OM EE ON

Figure D-48 -

Cross-shelf distributional patterns for I lypnus qi lberti. Shading denotes strata groupings based on-Jfr6leEliTE3-o-i the Bonrernoni t-test. Strata designations are ordered from highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata not significantty separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e,9., A M = B l o c k A m i d v a t e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v e r c a s e a r e s t r a t a i n t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . Only strata in vhich larvae occLtrred vere tested. The results of the MANOVAre also a D-49

shovn

Gobieeox

rheesodon
lorvoc

P-0.11
EE OE b. Ag o. o BM om Atit bm on C. dm bn on on Cf,a DM Af{ EN CN DE

praflcxlon

P-O.55
EE AE b. o. OE o BM qm Alyt bm om 6. dm 6 €n bn CM At EN ON DE DM

flcxlon

P-.OO5
CE b. EE o. o. At BM om bm C. AM Dt

poct-flcxlon

P-O.14
Atg b. !l! q. d. qm AM DM {m AE DE

Figure D-69

Cross-shelf distributional patterns for Gobiesox fhessodon. Shading denotes strara grouirings based ofi-EfrEEsrit-ts-6TThe Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are-orclbred from highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.9., lgt^:ignificantly A M = B l o c k A m i d w a t e r ) a r e f o r S o N G Si n t h e A f t b r d a t a s e t , l o w e r c a s e a r e s t i a t ; in t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d i n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . o n l y s t r a t a i n w h i c h l a r v a e d c c u r r e d w e r e t e s t e d . ' T h e r e s u l t s o f t h e M A N o V Ar e a l s o i D-70

shovn.

Porccllnue
lttE to l|: oR ooNTttctl
9Ato

lntegr.Iplnnle
lar,\/qa
AFTEi I('NO'

P-0.o2
otr ^L l|n AE tE b. orrr OE !N tM { OM bn o s cn A}.t d. Dt CN

prcflcxlon

P-O.O5
All At om brr !A b. tM o om Oe Ol. !N bo o ,rS{ €n da D! oN

ftcxton
llrFoic lo oi coNtfg-

P-O.63
bn AE AAa €m CE tE o DN 6t bn b. !M 6M

port-flcxlon

P-O.40
All cm AM C'E CtM b. bm .m !g s on !M €. Atl ON

Figure D-90

c r o s s - s h e I f d i s t r i b u t i o n a I p a t t e r n s f o r p a r a c Ii n u q i n t e q r i o i n n i s , s h a d i n g . d e n o t e s . s t r a t a g r o u b i n g s - b a s e do n t l e r e s u l t T - o f t h e B o n f e r r o n i tes s t r a t a d e s i g n a t i o n s a r e o r d i : r e d f r o m n i g h e i i t o - i o w J i t m e a n r a n k a b u n d a r -c e . t . n strata n o t s i g n i f i c a n t l y s e p a r a b l e a r e u n d e r li i e d . u p p e " . i i i t A M = B l o c k m i d w a t e r ) a r e f o r s o N G Si n t h e A f t ; ' r ' o a t i - i e t ,s t r a oa ed e s i g n a t i o n s ( e . g . , A t v r case are strata in t h e B e f o r e - c o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( s o N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p C r i J o c n o n l y s t r a t a i n w h i c h l a r v a e d c c u r r e d v e r e t e s t e d . ' T h e r e 6 n dt s oo ft r o t i n b o t h p e r i o d s . sul t h e M A N o v A r e a l s o sho\./n a 1 D-9

Gibbonsio
lorl/oa

type

o
AFTEFi EC 6ONOA

P-O.34
Al EM om AE b. bm aE e. o cE m
an da dn bn DE DM EN AN

prcflaxlen

Af\,|

EM

om

AE

o.

b.

bm

EE

o

OE

om

e

d.

.|m

bn

OM

BN

E'E

E,M

,lll

BM

Atrl

om

b.

bm

AE

EE

CM

o.

cn

om

Cm

CE

DE

..

C.

AI.t

DM

A\l

ItM

qm

a.

ItE

C!:

q.

b.

bn

AE

Figure D-111

Cross-shelf distributional patterns for qibbonsia type a. Shading.denotes strata groupings based o6-TIe-iEEtrlts of the Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are-ordbrei from highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata separable are underl ined, Upper case strata designations (e.g., lgt^lignificantly A M = B l o c k A m i d w a t e r ) a r e f o r S o N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o w e r c a i e a r e s t i a t l in t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . O n l y s t r a t a i n w h i c h l a r v a e d c c u r r e d w e r e t e s t e d . T h e r e s u l t s o f t h e M A N O V Ar e a l s o i D - 11 2

sho\,r'

%roEtrotus
oR coNTRoL ^ SootE D ,. " *"*** D

P-0.30
bn CM EN

praflcxlon ott coNTRoL ^ 3*"E D A " *o"o*o" o

------tr p-o.14
Altl B!! b. o. ItM om bm AE OE o. ffi bn CM !'N

=--.---_l

--

flsxlon oR coNTRoL ^ 3oo"E D A " *o"o** D

EE

o.

AM

CE

!,.

qm

ry,.,,.,
Irm o om EM AE cM Post-flcxlon

EEFoRE oFt coNT*oL AgoDAr*""ot*D

P-O.4 '
EE b q. Atvt c}tg am .AE o.

D-132. Cross-sheI f d i stribut ionaI patterns for lleterost ichus rostratus, .Shadingdenotes strata groupings based on the results of tfre Eonferroni t-test. Surata designations a re-orderei f rom highest to lo\,/est mean rank abtrndance. Strata not significantly separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.9., A M = B l o c k A m i d v a L e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o \ . r ' e rc a s e a r e s t r a t a i n t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . Only strata in which larvae occLrrred were tested. The resutts of the MANoVA re also a D-133

shovn

Seriphus
lorwog
EE:FORE FC OR CONTR('L

politus
AI8TER 6C,NOA AEC

P-O.64
o. AE b. EE om om cM bm EM Arr cN ctm DM on BN dn cE o bn DN Ail on DE d.

pr€flsxlon
EEFORE EO OR OONTROL AFTEFi AONOS

o

o

P-O.38
€. om oM AE b. BM om bm oN Arl EE DM cm on dn oE EN bn DN s A{ qn DE c.

flexlon
EEFORE OR CONTROL AFTER AONGTA

o

P-0.o1
c. AE lt. EE om EM |rm EN CE A[a oa A! CM cm DM DN CN Cm rJE on Cn on bn d.

post-floxlon
BEFORE AECDAEC OR CONTFIOL AFTER SONC)S

o.c,2 t.6e
L L'8.'

o.oo
1..t o

o.oo

o.oo

o.16

o.oo o-11

o.oo

o.oo

o-22

al
EE b. o. om BM

=-...-o'oo

----..-o.--i}.--..-

s

o.oo -\-q.ei.\---\

P-0.69
.AE q. AM bm CE .AN d. qn DE

Figure D-153. Cross-shelf distributional patterns for Seriphus politr-rs. Shading.denotes strata groufings based ofr-fFG-JEsiiTTET the Bonferroni t-test. st'rata designations are-ordbrea from highest to lovest, mean rank abundance. Strata not significantly separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.g., A M = B l o c k A m i d w a t e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o w e r c a s e a r e s t i a t i in t h e B e f o r e - c o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o t i n b o t h p e r i o d s . only strata in vhich larvae occurred were tested. The results of the MANOVAre also a D-154

sho\dn

Gen)zonernue
lqrvoc
ECFDRE OR CONTROL

llneotus
AFTEi AON<'S

to

DAF('

P-0.O2
o. CE EM om bn CM om C. DM DE dm AM ON EN s bn DN dn

.n

A!|

prGflcxlon
BEFORE EO OIt CONTROL

P-O.O2
o. 9E AE b. EM o. om CM trm CE om DM c|m DE d. ON AM EN on bn dn on DN Ahl

flaxlon
AFTER EONOA c

P-O.58
BE tt o. AE CE oo EM bm d. DE om At{ CM om EN dm DM on bn sn dn CN At.l DN

Fost-flsxlon
AFTE i BONO:3

c
o.oC' a.6tt
C'.9C' 5.$t 1.12

o.oo

o.ao

\P-0.o7
lE b. At: s. CE lM d. Al om qn DE bm CN DM CM !N dn s

i"-

F i g u r e D - 17 4 . C r o s s - s h e l f d i s t r i b u t i o n a l p a t t e r n s f o r G e n y o n e m u sI i n e a t u s . Shad i ng denotes st ra ta o rouo inqs ba sed ofi-TfiE-"iiEti I f3-TF-Tfie Bonfe rron i t-test. Strata designaLions are"ordbred from highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata not significantly separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.g., A M = B l o c k A m i d v a t e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v / e r c a s e a r e s t r a t a i n t h e B e f o r e - c o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . Only strata in which larvae occurred vere tested. The results of the MANOVA re also a D_175

shovn.

Chellotr€rnct
l6woG

eqturnurn

P-O.14
oN EM oM bm om om DM DN dm bn { dn AM on AE Bt! s b. o .r. ar BN oE 9:

prcflcxlon
AtTEta toNo3 lo

P-0.o7
oN lM oM om om DM bm DN dm dn bn n Atrr AE s b. q. d. € at lti !N c,E DE

Figure D-195. Cross-shelf distributional patterns for Chei lotrena saturnumShading.denotes strata groupings based on the Fesutts of tfre Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are-ordbred from highest to lovest mean rank abundance. Strata separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.g., ?9t^:ignificantly A M = B l o c k A m i d v a t e r ) a r e f o r S o N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v e r c a i e a r e s t i a t 6 ' i n the Before-Control data set (SoNcS in the Before period ind Control in both periods. only strata i n v h i c h l a r v a e 6 c c u r r e d w e r e t e s t e d . T h e r e s u l t s o f t h e M A N o V Ab r e a l s o D-196

sho\"/n

Mentlcirrh
tE lo €ir: o'| eoNTrtoL
DAlO

ue und u lotus
laryq.
AITE;I 'ONC

P-O.27
OU bm ON DM om om or'r DN dm .h Afra bn !N oa AE tt{ DE €. A{ OE tr. ct !E

prcflcxlon

P-O.18
oll oN bm DM om DN .h { dm dn !N bn !M on DE Atl AM og AE o b. d. rE

Fi gu re D-206. Cross-sheIf distributionaI patterns for Menticirrhus UndUIatus. Shading denoLes strata groupings based on-iTre resutts-ol-tfie 6onferroni t-test. 5 rat a o S tt r a Ea d e s i g n a t i o n s a r e ' -o rrd e rre d j f r o m h i g h e s t t o l o \ r ' e s t m e a n r a n k a b r r n d a n c e . S t r a t a l t o db ei r tt sir ni n.o g t _ : g9 n fl ircl a a nltyl y s e p a r a b l e a r e u n d le rrl l i n e d . Up p e rr c a s e s t r a t a d e s i g n a t i o n ss ( e . g . , cnt 9 c e cl u ppe aon A l 4 = B l o c kA m i d v a t e r ) a r e f o r s o N G S i n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o w e r c a i e a r e s t r a t t in t h e B e f o r e - Co n t t r o l d a t a s e t ( So N G S i n t h e B e f o r e p e rriio d a n d Co n ttrro ll i n b o t h p e r i o d s . c or rol s oNGS c on o De od o Only strata in \./hich larvae occurred were tested. The results of the MANOVAre also a D-207

shown

Porolqbrox
l€ra/oa

epp.

P-O.41
dm Dll m Ota ON DN. dn !l{ O! m bm

at

b.r

d.

b.

€n

AM

Dl

lN

AE

o

-l

dm

DM

om

ol,

oN

DN

dn

llt

oE

s

trm

,E

d.

o

€m

!.

br|

cn

DE

Af,t

rN

o

AE

al

dm

cN

om

DE

-

Du

dn

t'E

oM

.t

AE

cE

DN

!N

s

bm

b.

o

o

bn

Att

tM

cN

on

!N

s

bn

.o

rtm

oL

DM

aM

DE

dn

bm

o

tr.

-

o

.AE

A|.t

tg

lna

oE

Dtit

d.

patterns for Paralabrax-spp' ^ F i g t rr e D - 2 1 7 . c r o s s - s h e t f d i s t r i b t t t i o n a l based on-TEFEEf tts of the Bonferroni't-test' Shading denotes struiu-qiorting" Strata designations ire"ordbred from highest to lowest mean rank abttndance. Strata not signifi6antty separable are unrjerl ined. Uppef case strata designations (e.9., A M = B l o 6 k A m i d v a i e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A F t e r d a t a s e t , l o w e r c a s e a r e s t r a t a i n the Before-controi,iata s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p g r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . a onty straba in which iarvae 6ccurred were tested. The results of the MANOVAre also D-218

shovn.

Hypeopsetto
lorvqG tttFroRE EO oi coNTtto|. DAIO

guttuloto
AFTEF! AONOE

P-O.90
€m bm All Oll on EM ffi bn |'E A'.l tN b. AE OE gN DM DN dm € ff o dn

praflcxlon
ttltroRE oft ooNtlioL
AE A'.TER AONO'

o

P-0.95
bm om AM OM om lM b. tE lN on bn rtm Af lX OE eN DM m oc

flcxlon
AEFOiE OR CONTROL A' A|3TER AC'NOA

o

P-0.80
on cm bi AE Alia Al EE FM EN CE CM DN bm ffi rtn e. s b-

D-238. Cross-shel f d istributiona l patterns for llyggpos-g.l!e Ltttulata. s Shading denotes strata groupings based on the results of the Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are-ordered from highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata not significantly separable are underl ined. upper case strata designations (e,9., l.over case are strata in A M = B l o c k A m i d w a t e r ) ' a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a . s e t , t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . a Only strata in vhich larvae occurred vere tested. The results of the MANOVAre also D-239

shovn.

Por<:lichthys
lorvoa
EEFOFII ('FI CONTROL

colifornicus
AFTEF' AONOE c

P-O.75
om OM dm DM FM bm CN CE AM o. bn A{ on BN om DN dn b. d. AE Dt BE o.

pr6fl€xIon
BE:FOFIE B(' OR OONTFIOL AFTEFT 6ONOI3

.o

P-0.45
om CM dm DM bm CIM ON o on OE AM bn EN Al om DN dn b. en AE DE d. EE ..

fl6xlon
AEFORI Ecl OR CONTROL

P-0.44
CE Cm om CM DM o. EE bm d. DN E|M BN b. dn o. on bn AE CN DE

poat-ftsxlon
BEFOFIE EC OR CONTF'OL

P-O.62
cn A^. om AIJ dm OM BM EN qm bn CEDMoon dn bm b. q. Al! El! CN Dlt DN rr.

Figure D-254, Cross-shelf distributional patterns for Paral ichthvs cal ifornicus, shad i ng .denotes st rara g rouir i ngs based on--tIEIG3fiTs-67-EhE-E6iTe rron i r-resr. Strata designations are-ordbred from highest to lo\r'est mean rank abundance, Strata not significantly separable are underl ined. Uppef case strata designations (e,g., AM=BlogkA midwater) are for soNcs in the After data set, lover caie are strata in t h e B e F o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e n i o d i n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . o n l y s t r a t a i n w h i c h l a r v a e d c c u r r e d v e r e t e s t e d . ' T h e r e s u l t s o f t h e M A N o t Aa r e a t s o

D-2r5

shovn.

Atherinopsis
BEFORE OR OONTF'OL

coliforniensis
lorwoc
AFTER E('NO6

o

P-0.17
om bm ElM AE FE

preflaxlon
BEI'OFIE EC OF' CONTROL AFTE T AONOS c

P-0.43
Ar.f qn bn BN on E'N ON <tn J\M qm bm aM om oM AE BE o. b. Cm o. CE dc Dt DM

flexlon
AFTEII *ONOSI

o

P-O.94
qn bn EN DN CN q Cn .m bm AM. AE BM o. d. ffi b. EtE CM DE

poet-flexlon BEFORE OFi CONTROL ABCDABc
5;titll

AFTEFTSONG 1.ao .esl o.+9 o.oo o.oo

!$1t'{ri

7.V

o.56
aa

ilN s

s
dn om

o.1('

*l-"'""
P-O.77
DM DN t. dm

----==-ea--\a---

A*

o.oo

----=€>B--\

AN

qn

ttn

AM

EE

CN

Figure D-275. cross-shel f d i stribut iona I patterns

for Athgrinopsi s ca I i forn iens i s. shading.denotes strata groupings based on-Tnel6liTls-oF-tn6-EonTeFroni t- e s t r a t a d e s i g n a t i o n s a r e - o r d b r e d f r o m h i g h e s t t o l o w e s t m e a n r a n k a b u n d a n cre .s t . strata not significantlv separable are underl ined.,upper case strata OesignJiions (e.g., AM=BtockA midwaier)'are for soNGSin the ertb'r data set, tower case are strata n t h e B e f o r e - c o n t r o l a a f i s e t ( s o N c s i n t h e B e f o r e o g r i o o 6 n d C o n t r o t i n n o t n p e r i oid s . only strata in which larvae dccnrred vere tested.'The results of the MANovA are also D-276

shov/n.

Leureethes
lorv<rc
EEFORE lo OiI C('NTiOL

tenuiE

P-0.o8
qn AD{ bn e lN ON dn DN Ar'a AE am EM Et OM o 6 b. Irm ct DM dm OE OC

prcflcxlon
AFTE i BON€ o

P-O.35
bn oN tN cn DN dn AM Att om tM o. ffi 6 tC b. dm bm d. OM DM OE DE

flcxlon
BEFORE lC, OR CONTRC'L AFTER AONOB

o

P-0.64
A{ qn EN Dn DN cn CN dn o CM em b. bm AM m AE !g aM

po!t-flcxlon

P-O.51
.n J\l.l bn lN DN q dn CtN AE tE b. d. bn !M DE ..

Figure

Cross-sltelf distribtruional patterns for Leuresthes tentris. Shading denotes st,raia grorri:ings based ofi-TEE-F6llt[F-o-F-the Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are ordered from highest to lowest mean rank abundance. Strata separable are underl ined. Upper case strata designations (e.9., Itgt_significantly A l ' l = B t o c kA m i d v a t e r l a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v e r c a s e a r e s t i a t a in t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a b a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . Only strata in v/hich larvae occurred vere tested. The results of the MANOVAre also a

D-297

shovn,

Engroulle
lsryoa
IAEC

rnordox
AFTER AON(IA

P-O.O7
O. DM dm ffi EE CM AE o bm EM cE qm AA. oN DN DE dn on EN d. bn ,\I.

prsfl.xlon
trcRE EG| Ott CoNTROL

P-O.29
DM dm oM om EM bm oN DN dn tr. om AM 6 0E O tE lrn d. EN DE d. AE on Al

flsxlon
BEI'ORE EO OR OON"FIOL

P-0.39
DM dh om cM EM bm om b. qEE AE CE o Arrr DN DE CN dn d. on t'N bn qn rA|l

poat-flrxlon
BEFORE EC ('R C('NTFTG'L AITER A('NOA c

P-O.13
AE l!! s bm !M cm Gn c't DM AM dm CM Dtt ctN fN DN d. dn on bn Atl

patterns for Lnqratrlis mordax. D-317. Cross-slrelf distributionaI thc Bonrcrroni t-test. Shading denotes *traia groupings based on--lFffiLrTffi StraLa designations are'-ordbred from highest to lovest mean rank abtlndance. Strata noL signi ficantly separable arc underl ined. Upper case st.rata designations (e.9., A l 4 = t ] l o c kA m i d v a t e r ) ' a r e f o r s o N c s i n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v e r c a s e a r e s t r a t a i n t l r e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a t t d C o n t r o l i n b o t l t p e r i o d s . a Only strata in vhich larvae occurred vere tested. The results of the MANoVA re also 0.3 1B

shourn

|lEttrfut to

ott coNTRoL

P-O.16
dm DM DN ON Ot\l dn s BN qn EM om bm bn At AM on o to

prGflsxlon

P-0.39
DM dm ON OM DN dn o om EM t'N tsm €m bn At on o. o <1. EE Ar{ AE Of:

Figrrre D-338. cross-shelf distribUtional patterns for citharicllthys spp. Shading denotes strata groLtpings based on the resr.rlLsof the Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are ordered from highest to lo\,/est mean rank abtrndance. Strata noL signilicanLly separable are underl ined. Upper case straLa designations (e.9., A M = B l o c k A m i d w a t e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o \ r ' e r c a s e a r e s t r a t a i n the Before-Controt data set (SoNGSin the Before period and control in both periods. Only strata in vhich larvae occrrrred \r'ere tested. The results of the MANOVAre also a D-339

shown

Hypeoblenniue
l6rvo6 DABC

epp.
AFTEFI AONOS

cn

cN

a

EN

DN

Att

om

bn

on

dm

BM

Att

oM

DM

bm

om

o

cE

d.

DE

AE

o.

BE

b.

dn

CN

E'N

on

om

DN

dm

EM

All

bn

OM

bm

DM

Al

on

€m

o.

<t.

cE

OE

6.

A|:

b.

BE

DN

dN

dM

ON

CN

EN

DM

o-

bN

CE

CM

O'

DE

T'M

AT{

AAI

ON

OM

O'

D'

d.

Ag

EE

BM

post-flaxlon
AFTEF' 9C SONC)S

P-O.61
qn AN <h on bn EN DN CN AM lrt\| EE AE cM Cm om q. CE O!: DM bm qm d. b. o.

Figure D-3q9. Cross-shel f d istributiona I patterns for Hypsoblennitrs spp. Shading denoLes strat,a groupings based on the results of the Bonferroni t-test. Strata designations are-ordered from highest to lovest mean rank abtrndance. Strata not significanLly separable are underl ined, Upper case strata designations (e.9., A M = B l o c k A m i d w a t e r ) a r e f o r S O N G Si n t h e A f t e r d a t a s e t , l o v e r c a s e a r e s t r a t a i n t h e B e f o r e - C o n t r o l d a t a s e t ( S O N G Si n t h e B e f o r e p e r i o d a n d C o n t r o l i n b o t h p e r i o d s . only strata in which tarvae occurred were tested. The results of the MANOVA re also shown. a D-350

o
-g

o

iD

o ir)
o

o

!r)

r{t -c rt

o a

(/,

n
o

n
.th

>
.o
oo
R e n -

z o Hn
LL

{, fct

E,

6 a o
l.r)

+, ".- O (s (o. . L Or(! L C) +)p.+roL (,(/) (D (u O.(g -L O +, . +J-C< I O O (/) +r>
'(g'L

n

q)

o
o
-

t{t

cE+r(oc= oc$ Lf co c) s-o g)(D-.c O o.-.o o +, (nOL c.+)b cxo L (g >O +ro l, s

o
O

f

o

n

.JOL CJ OP.(Eo c- E (,.$ 0) +ro(,o .-0) oo6a S+)o(g(gLc (s->o+roF O (,LC (g L O OL g (D +, o.o o +) € o = 1J(F (/, q-O0) L.c+J .<ccl+) $+r(, <c-cooo0) ._._ lJ +J 0) s olJ-c> q-o Lcc (, E o.\.-.-E (D(5 Or5 OC.o L C!D(, LfL Lo L:c)c) z,z,=a o(a +ro)T|ooooo !coL(/)(ro (o.- L (E -O q o.o.o f! o o +t 0) -or-(F<I)tg tt > G L OO (E0) L CO) o oLL(o(E .-(gL(oC+Jf p$o. G f 6 o ^.O.9 aLooo c) .-+rc o-'L U} o >-c o-c p .--{Jr.)l (/)(,!rc+r :t,lJCc-OO.o c'ro.-o L C.--O- | (g -o(,Lol o! L (o o! o.-c ocEoL r c (o.-col o o o.- D 6 cD otf3ll> OOsL! C)(/)(, cco+ro
OCD ('l (F!

o
t-

o

lrl
ir)

a }D
-

o

C)
o
!r,

n
rt
J

a o

o
E
F.

trJ

r)

z. o o E, o o ulrl

4t n,

td E,

r cl rr,
t @ lrt d,
ID

o
a(,

F-

o

I

L

o

{t

;

o r)
o c,

g

n

J

o

!D

EI

o

o rt

z, o
@

E
!q,

E
!{
lrF

!r)

o r) v, ct

-

> 'o

o o rt
lU

'POL P! (,(t O (g O_A -g O) !J:< +r . I o(,'o+)>

6U' (o cEs ^'-O(g (o. . L O)(! L O)

poc

oo

o P o o o c o -c .t
f O

o n
C'
g

'- (c'-

g

n
lc, o rct

oc$ Lf co 0) L.? CnO--C o (g.- $ o +t (.(,oL co(s OO L fo >o (, -C C (g-E!(EL c: O +) \(! o .q- E o ! c) p !ooo .-C) 66OO -!o(!(cLE =->o+roF O ('!-g L 0)

a |r}
J |ql

$ L O OL

oo =pg{, (Foo c.c$ p! o .<cc +t ._._ePc) L oEc}l LCC GO o E o.-.-.o o 6 0a:, otc-o s c(/ou) gfL L:()c)L..) o t/, z.z,J a rrc'r13c)0()()0 trcC)L(/)(ro oJ.- L c -O -OL-qO€ (g g o-o

o

o
J

r tc,
bt
!r,

rr)

o E z, o o o
o
E,
]r) lrJ M,F

n n o
@

o

o >

o oLL$(g .-(oL$(g+)p!€o s f ($ o^'O-C -aL60a a .- ! c o-.L,ro>coa .__+,L] ! rro!$c! Erc(g-OO.q- c--.-O|,.FOl OE O.-

T
I

o oo'-()
U g E U L

P trJ

o, I (E Oe L (g

@ 6 @ @

ocn ct I c 6--Ql 6.-to @E(! il O(gt.P o/)(/) v; o
I

(-! O o co > o-

ccorJo

r-

;l

brl

L

;

o ro o rr) o
o
rr) o

td

a n
g,
?

U' E H

z, o
!r,

a (t

o n a !o

)

o .o

v,
C)
gt !r,

LF

+) . €-c< I o(,(/)+)> +)oc oo

ott (E CEP.'-O(E 6. . L orr(U I 0) +J9.!OL og) o (D q,(o vL o

@

o

o o
t-

n c

o

.- o.- L CEIJ(gC= oc$ Lf co o L-o crl('--c O (o.- o O lJ (F
Ci (/)O! rr(ts O

E)

E -c o r?

o

L(E>ot, .C C (!-E+J(!L tr: rO(, O+) LE(,r, 0) ' !o(,o .-o <aooo o +J 0) $ 6 L.E

o r.,

J

c->o+,oF
lr(,-LE € L O OL

o

o ir)
E ()
!r)

eo.oo+,

L

O)

+JO )tt(rO L.C +r L O 0) .<co+J Oto

C)
o r)

<c-coooo)
.-.L oE.c(, U)6 cc L o(, +, +r c) jF

-c

E o.-.-E 0r3 oft L cou) L60 q-=c)(,L.t zz,=l

lrl q)

+rcoL(r(ro -O G.- L .o - o L-qcJ L O.O o (g O >

F z, o o

o

lrJ

to
lr,

o oLL(!(E '-(E!-OODppG'oG
a a \ ^ A F

Dr6Ot' .- I C

a) O-.-

C) E
lc,

L u) o >-c c-c .-*!L> ! oo!+rc+J

P ur
TD

trj UF

o io T ct
!r)

rc +, c (!-0 o.o olo.-c) G c.-.o. I F -Oob-CllO+J L (o oE o-c t,c=oL q-+J (aOr o I c o.-ccl o o o.- D o c0 oE(o il > o6L! oo(/) (/, c co {)o (\t
I

q)

c,
J lql

{u

o
L

'?

o o lc,
lrl

c) to
o
tct
lrj @

@

o

U' E
lr.

z, o

a (t

o
d

{t

>
o

!r,

HE,

o tcl

I r'-O (!. . L OD(E L !!.+)o o(/)o(!0 vL o) I .cr('(,)+r 6.g

=
o
t-

n dI
!=

o_ o c
J

C)

o

d

cE+r(oc oc(o Lico l-,O Or o -

z. E
!

l{t

L ooL Ci< O +) G
m a

U' ct lct
lrl

L (! ]O !o o P -tr-tr(!-1t 'p6! c: O O+J i(o =LEo]J 0)
g

E

to
dt

Q-6 tt.t =!o(g(gL Oo L o

s(l)(,,o
F

o'c
t_

q)

(s->o1Jo
LE aL L

o

J

'-o =+)(b q-O L_C! L|)0.<co

+, o +,
L

lql
L .-.-+l+, o L

O
o
!r)

T E

>
L Lf) =l

E 0'-.-' +JO(,

o lq!

t

oo zz !o)Eooo
{J C O L&rJ(/) g o o.-oL-(FO (oLO!

o
F

E,

o

O
L

z, o () o
lrj

!r,

o !o -c rq
-g

o ogL(! .- $ L (0 (o €. €p(gq cg = G O^1t. -QLO(,v' .-!q o-. .--1)L ! 6(,D+rClJ Epc(g-oo. LC.---O-l -ot,q-ol O.l, O.- n F - a !

E,

L o o >!

o.

>

P
(D

iD trJ E,F

r o . lJ L I (-l p o I co : oL

o 6
E)

n

o('l c'r l c (u.-61 a.-eo oE(g lt OGLP

()(r(/, co!(

J tf)

o
I

I

L

lq,
u

o o
lF,

o ts, o
!r)

U'

o rct
qll

ld

tr)

z, o v,
E.

a (9

a, !r,
-c o tct E o
E

; >
o

.o
ocn $ cr5P.'-Oo o. .LOr(!gO +)p.!'0)L 4g) O $ O.$ -L 0

,k
q)

HE,

!. rrc< 6 (/) +r> I p oo r t oo
.- rg.- L cE+)(Gc= d

o rD

o
t(,

()

t{,

c

G CJ

oc€ L=co o L-O 0)(,-c o 6.- $ o +J (/,(.)L
O +r(F (/)

o
I (L

o o

cO(q OO L (g >O

EI
.

-C C (s-15poL Cf q(q(, O+) q-E(/)P o

o

o

oo so(,0

L

n 'c o_
O
c)
|D
J

EI q)

7)6ott (o +' O $ L:O $ o-

>-

) o p oF
(gO. l-E

.-O (! L-C

o
E' o

o or5 L O OL L O o +ro.oo+) .- o (,.) = (})q-O 0 ) ts LJ:+r
o"+J(, ,<cc+r

-o

@

rt

.-.-p+ro L O:o!> s-cc +(D o E o.-'-E (, 6 OE O|r\ Lo\ c.Q q coy) g- =(j}() 3-rt L o(, zz,=l po)!ooooo pcclL(.it(4() (5.- L $ vO - O L-qoLO.o (go c0t o oLL$$ '- (E L $ o €+J(sO.
- E

o

F z, o o

J !r)

O o o> tlJG

q) |I

o
Lrf EF

E

aLoo@ a) .-+jC O-.L (a 0 >.c o.g .--1JL) +, oo!+rqs t, {r c (o-0 o.o o)o.-(J q- c.-.o- | $ - o (,q- ol o +, L .E oE o-lccEor. -c ocn G+) ot I c o.-col o o o.-Do co oE(o l > O(oLr, O()(/)(r,ccoro

E
(l

@

P bI
o
C)

1., td
F)

o\

td

I

(t

o
L

o o

;

lrJ

o rr)
o o
tt,

ct

E}

rf)

o

T

o q
E

E z,

6 ro a o
iD

)
6 .6

-c ct tc,
bI !a

6a, $ cEd.._o(! (q. .Lor$Lo

Hlo

El '61

nl ol

KF

o fc,
rf)

J

o

-cl

EI a)l

@

o rc,
lrl ql

o

OJ

EI
ol

x

@

o

o -(t

c

J |ql

D O C OO '- (c'- L 91:, rr (g cE oc(! q:co o L-o O)o--c O (g.- (o ( t s ( , o L O+, C:< O {JL ocELco c!(! OO L € >c) o .o p !o (/)-g tr (!-€(l)+)$s cl rC iO(/) O€ .-LE',+, 0) O O OE L +)osro E .-O A@Oo -CDO(5GL! o.->o+:otF (B 0_ >5 0 - (,- Lrc oo o oE C-L O O.L L C) sooo$ co -{q-4 + L O ' Ot !+ t o J . < c o * ,O l CC O O O O ._._ +, +J O ! o.lr.c> q-o Lcc o E o.-.-E o (g OrC Or c-oLcir')l./,LCL t-s' $_:(,(, oo 1 p . ' r E q J oz z 1 ooo $coL(roo (9.- L $ vo 4

p-c< , . r o.,o{>

P! o(, o

.+JOL o (! Q,(l' vL

o_
o
J

o

o 19

tct
.g

n
F z,
a EI
|ql

o C) o
t-d

v,

E

- O s-qO o 6qo-o o> (gO c(') L O OLL(g(o .- (9 L (S $ tJ€+)€o' aE :: (E O^1f -C () .or.A66 .- rJ c o-.q t, o >-c > o,E .__!L ! ooDtcP Erc$-oo.o oo.-c) q- c.-.o. r (o -0)(,(i-Ol O€ L rc Ot O.c EcEO! o Cn c'r C-! I c (E'-ol o 4 o.- +t 6 co (n1r€ il > (l)o o q+J o!D(, c€€o

e
E,

iF

tct

v, o o
o

UI

@

:tr l!, o
.c
@

I

L

dt

:tr

;

ld

o |ql
o o o 6 n
J

et

n
ld

}D

o
E

E z
@

c' iD
q, E'

>
o

.o
tno (E CEp q.-O(0 $. .lc'l(gtO . + t 0 . 1L +r+) (r(,D o (! 0.(g (l) -L

HE, KF
'-

@

o

td irl

+r. +rc< I r p oo ) 6 o & o > c o
'- c'L c15!(gC= oc$

c o E =o lo
c

qt

o n
@

-

s-co c) L-o ctlo--c o (!.- cJ o +) (t(,OL

cj< (I)
-

o

rr(F

a

L(o]()(a !o +)
d - n -

{JTEL . O+r .-LE(/,&r

@

U'

co o:51c +to(,o .-0) 6OOu, E € o o (grc E->O+)OF
sf o 6CL L1t o o-

Cf 1(sg) 0)

c ro

(t)

-c
ct

o

o o rt
fo

L o oL L 0) +) o.o o.lJ o CO =+rL(,) LOO E-C+' .<co+, o+r(, > orc .-.L oE-c+, +) 0) )

Ll
o o o
o
J

o

!r) @

:tr

F z,
C) E.
ItJ E, f{, !-

-c o rD n o
E
J !r,

o E o.-.1J oooE oF c-o L c(tv) !-o q- 5()(J L !-5 ao zzaa +,arrltoooo6 +) c o L(/)(' o (9.- L (! -O lO.O.O =E O O e O - O L-L O (! (! L O.O O > (gO L Co! O OLt-ag(g .- (g L o (o l)+)!(oo $ -alouto a .- € C O-.L t' o >-c o! .--!l> tJ oo!+rc+) .-oGcocc -opc(o.oo.o oro.-() (F C.-.(l O- | - o (/)L olo +r L (! O:o O.E ECEOL dcn Lt oi I c (g.-col o o o._ +) tt co (,'o (c >> ll (DO 6 L ! o(,(/)g6rJo \o
I

o

P lrl
@

o
G

o'

rq

r)
L

EI

;

c) n 6 !r't o
rr)

o

o
]t,

lrj ld
?

E z,
o a
E

rD o o
ld
J
.o
oo cE$ ( u ." ' - o o . q or(E L o) ar€.+r0)L l,(, (D (o 0.(g C) -L . s +t-C< r o (, (/, !>
-vL vv '- (F'- L CEl)(5CE L:JCO O L-O o|r(l?-.C (g O +) O $'(,OL L +)L cxo L o )(J lro O -C C (o-E. r.g O+, (gLE(,+, L O O1t (, € O O L

{t

HEI

KF

o n
o |ql
q,

o t.t
.C

(D OJ

n
@

o

nl c -CI

o-

I

J

n
@

+ro(/,o o .-C) t6oO .-so(o(ot.c c-)oDoF

(D

I

o
hJ
J
,9,

@

a

C-(,- L! do o o! L o AL L o) 0J +, ao o ! c0) =$q-l/, +oc) !-c! .<ao+) (!$o > olc uJ c-c oJ o o o g .-.-!+ro oE-c ]! o E o.-.(' $ oc crz L gu)a ro oF) Le

o

@

!o

o t{t

-

o

.C |ql

E z, o o

o

z.zJJ cJ(,) !orEooooo {J c o l-(.D(, c) (!.- L (s vo L oo.o :i! o o +r o - c L-G o.s O > s L O.o (E{) L Cd) o OLg(E{u .- (g L ag $ +)+J4JOO,
- a

(o

g
F, !r) -g tcl

o
lrJ EF

E

a;a@o <) .-rlc o--L 6 0 >! O-C .--!r> ! ol/)P4Jcl) ]Cptr$OO.(FC.-.-Ot $ - o g)(F ol o+) qJ! o'L (D .C ECEOL 4Cn crl L€ I a (o.-€l o o o-- t,6 co orc(9 li > Orog! Oo(')(/) co+ro
^ R . 1 . - a t

o l!

lrJ

co
q)

a o !r,
g,

5
I

|ql

o

o

la

o ti,

o

@

o o

c,

n o
a

|q)

o

E =

o (n
@

I

c 3

@

E,

Hrl t-F

o
Ld @

-

(5 CE9.'-O(g (g. . , L o1(u L c) +)!.+JOL (/'(t O (g O.$ -l. O

.o oo

p-c< +) . r o(,)(/)+r> +, o c oo c o o-oz '(g'-

n 'c
+t

c:o {r (s C= oc(E L.o oDo-c o (o.- (g 0 |) L U)O5+J(ts CJ (D co$ oo L (g >(J (a *)o l, o .-c c 6-EoIJGL C5

L

o L
o .9
c

a

o

o o r/)

r o
o

tct

lrJ

.q(!(/' o+J LcFE4$ 0) +)o ooL o +ro(,o

E'

.-o ooo{, L ! O) (o $ LC '-->o+roF >f O $O
O 6l OLQ

o |ql
lrJ

o
O

o
OL

oE
L C)

pa.oorr - o :) +r+ co (|.O0) '-!+J Clro.<CO+J acroroo0)
!b g

tct

.-.-

{J
> L L

o_
o
J

(.)

,oPc;

- - >

,

Ol

o

ti,

o tc,
J

J

ra

c-OLCU)V)LF L lF 5()(, L.ir 0t 6 z.z.3 a +, 0)E OOO OO ! c QJ LV)(,) O (!.r (E vO

o E o.-.-E (4(o0E oo

F z, o c,

o n o !r,
E -

.-aEL(q(g+Jp9$e" (€ !to(,)(' .-1rc

- O !.-(F O (E (! r- 06 0 > (gO L c('l o oLLo(o

:r5

c) 0 |, o

o

o o-.-

o
lrl
E,F

E

.--!L> ! oo!pc+i 1C ! C (o-O O.O C'r O.L) L C.-.O_ | ro O o(ts Ol O +J s G op o.C ECEOL (aOl c.-$ crr (r) o r g (!.-€ol o.D o co 41C(s il > O6Lp Os-CPOlrl-CC OY)(, CcO+rc)

Loo>co!

e
trl @ C'

n
o !r,
lql

.c tct s o
F'

I

L

;

ld q,

a q)

o r)

@

o

@

-tr
o
n oo (g cE*r.'-o(g

xl r , E
7

v, (t z, o v,

(,

>
.o

hJ

o n o
I

(g. . L t)(s L 0) €9.rJoc(,(4 Ct (o O_rs -L O p . !-c< I o (, (a +r> '- S'L glt{r(ggE OC(g

sl ol
o) c o
ol ol
0l :ll

q)

o rt a o
lql

(D

g-o gl(,--Co) O $.- $ O +) (F (4OL

L:so

G)

q o I o.

u, |ql
o r)
o tct td lrl

L (E >C) o .-: c (g-Eo+r(oL c5

oLE('js .- o o€

J

O})

q(!('

o L

lJOOO '-0) o1tt ott C+r(D(!(EL.c $->o!oF LtJ

(4 (,- a \

Ol-OOLLO)

(E

+ro.oo|,
=+,G(,

OO

q-oo >.c+r L+)o .<co{,
(JC-COOOO .-.I oE-c+ q ! L L

OI

ol OI

-J
o
J

aJ +, C) :l

o c)

rr,

n

|ql

(, E O.-.-E (a (c OE Otll r-N c-o L coo L L$ G 3('O o(,: z,z5l +f d)u ooo oo ! c o L(/)(, o (E.- L (c vO

o E z, o ()

lr,

-Oa-LO(o (!Lo.o o> L co) rEo o oL!$(5 -- (g L G (E +J!+r(oc. 6
a a

|? tc,

aL6oo <) .-+rc o-.L o o >c o.c
$ .--{Jt-}

u o Ld u
o

oo$+rc+J

-c c,
lr,

P lrl
E)

() tq,

EPCc€-()O.o olo.-() G g,-.o. | $ -o(aq-0)l orJ L o 0)E o.C 1)CEOL ocn o) q-! I c (g.-col o (, o.-$o co o-c'G ll > ooL+r oL-c: +t OLrJ-C C

c) ra o
l.r,

J

N I

|ql

td

o
lt,

o c)
!r,

o

E)

o o n
lrJ

rD

z, o
U' E

(,

a

o r)
lrl
J

o

i >
e

.o

ct

HE
LF

o rt
o fo

oo ro cEs.'-Oo (9. . r- (t(g s c) +r€.$c)s (,(t O (! O(ll vL o p.s.c< I O (j1 (' +J> '- (9'- L cE +r(oc= Ocs Lo ol(/,-c (g o +, o o.(* (,oL +Jcci< o
6 F

c) o
l-

o c) +) o c o o_
O
o
J

()

n n n
(')

a

a

:J

o o' I o-

o

gt

-ooo .-c) +, o (o (o L.c @->o+JoF + J6 LE

Lcol()(' +)o +J o .-c g (g-Eolr6L cl i(E(, s O! >LE6! A) L O Oro L +ro(,o c

d,

o

(g L o oL L c) po_oo, c O1r (, .< cO!

a o
c) ro
-c (} o r)

L >u

._,_

!

{J

0)

oEc-

'

o c OE C)e L c(r(/) Lm c! ( + -= o o ! L:. oo z,z,=r ()0 e ot15 (I)00 pcoL(r(,/)o (!.- L 6 -O - O L-EO (u (E r o-o o > (gO L C('r O C)LL$(g .-coL(g(g.upp$o. (!
i a

(, g o.-.-E

E z, o ()
E,

rt c
I')

.-1Jg

a!ooo

<)

q 4 0 > cO - .o - t r .--pL> !

o(,!lJcaJ

o
0 l!

lrl EF

!r,

:tr c)
o
J

rD
-g

Lrl ID

n n

c (E-o o-O orO,-() r- C.-.O. I O -ooq_c'lop L (o oE o..c EcEoL oo) 01 q-! I g ro.-col o o o'- P o co o!(o il > o(gL! o!), (J(,(/,cco!o

q)
@

i o
I

t

!

r rq

;

o rct
lrl

o

o !q, o
EI

o

U'

v, o rD

o v,
E,

E z,

6 o
J
lr) 7

lq}

i )
o

o

.o
oo CEo +r ..- o (s (o. . L cir(o L c) rr+J.+JoL (,(, o (E 0-(g -L O +) . +r-c< r {)(,(/)+)> '- (o'cE.tJ
A F R

H E r!F-

ct

EI
o -o -o o
J

ol al ol cl ol nl

k

o n
(t

L $ C=

o tct
sf C\l
o r) .c tct

o

Lf co 0) L.o cn(,-.c O (o.- $ O +) q('oL rrq Cj< O .co{s oo L $ >C) (, c p o(D lro O-C C (!-icOr).(qo o-q-E(,r 0, L r, o o! +rog:o .+0) LOOO p{,0i}<o(gL-c - > o +t oF
L(,-L!

(l) O

o t-

o

o

l, [:'

n rt
@

oLooLLo :f Da(' !o .-.cD Lc)0) .<cn+) -Q*ro L .-.-

-c

o ti)

6
ld

J

|rl

LtrC LO U)E o.-.1f 4(o0E OF c-o L cg)(4 Lo L $- f o(, L5 0t(, 2.2.7] +jo)!ooooo !goL(o(to $.- L (€ -O :iltooro - O L-q_ O A tlr> 6gO! sC<') GO O OLL{gO .-(gg(l(o+J(g IJU(oO t!o@o a .- ! c o-.s io o >-c oc p .--!L> '-o.!cogc E, +, C 6-0 O.o oo.-(J (F c.-.o. I G -oloG0)los o D o . ! t c E o LL $ .-c (-! ocn or I C $'-cOlO o o.-to co oro c il > oo(gL*) ou)(.r) cco+jQ

oE-c-

+, +J Q)

>

o g
z, o () o
kJ tF

o
t

lrJ

t,

@

]r,

!r,

o

o lrtrl

o

.C |ql

@ @

o

T
J

\o o
I

lql

c)
L

EI

;

a o rr) o rt
o
o rr)
}D

o

o
>
?

o

E z,
@

o rct
trf

o

o

t HiD

k
El
ol t-l (t)t

@

3n o

6A o CEP.'-Oo (U. . L or(g L c) !!.{JOL (, (/) O rE 0,.(E -L o

+r .
'-

p-c<

1ro c
(g'-

1 O (, (' aJ>
L

oo

E) lrJ

oc(o L-o oDrr--C o(o'-(colJ (/)OL F +)G cio s $ >(J +)O
R - - -

r)

@ @

5l
ol

E

O
-

(,) +'

o

o-

I

t |.r)

-c #

o g o
o r,

.u(sL cf (o O*, q(oo q) Lq-Eo{J o o oE g g lJo(,o '-ooo '-0) E +t o (! o Lc =->opoF -f O q E. ! O Oo(g I o oL I c)

@

o

:)+r(+-(, oO p+) o .<CO +r

@

-

L

.-.-

*,

4J

()

o

o o tct
lqt

v '2,
o o E, o
trl
()
tlU!F

o

J

c,
rf) ld

t

.-(oL(g$lJP!oO DL-66O .-+JC

) (, = o.-.-! o (g o13 off) ccLc(/)(/)L:f L L f (,(, L5 o(, zz3l po)15()0<)(JQ pcoLu)(/)o (o.- L (! -O g o.o.o =13 0) 0 +, c) -oL-qo(E (g L O.o (' > (!o L col O Ol-L(g(E
(o O O-.-

orcc-

o
r)

!o

.-o(ucocc
E +) C (g0 L C.-.O_ I (o o oG ol o rr ! (6 O-o O.9sEV(ts! ocn 9r I c o.-€ol o o a.$ o cl) o15(o ll > OOsg+,

P 60P$C+t

L o o >.c oc .--+Jl-> o or o.- c)
0.-

n
J

lrl

o
@

iD (3

.s rt

c ) ( t ) ( / )c c o + r o A;
I

6 r/)
J

0)
g

o ro

;

@

v,
a

@

o

!D

!o

o
lrj

I

E z,
o o
E

o
lf,

]
!

o

o o
|q,

.o
tto
f r F f i-

HEr

k

o lq,
ct

. L C'r$ L 0) 4J{r.+roL v, U) Ct cs O.$ vL o

+j..-O(s s.

.p-c< *) . t o (, (/)+r>
.- o.C€.r L <gC=

al
ol

o

-l ol

=l

|ql

o

o |q,
.g

LA? (Ilo--C O cg.- !t O +, (r)Og lF $(F CJ O (D0 co(! (t l- $ >() po +r o .-g c (g-Eo!(ol. cf 5 e,)+r so@ (D >GE(,*r LO OlL +r!)(/)o c .- (l) o.h lo {J O (g (g LC o-)o+)oF c(,-L!

ct

g

a = c

o, q o

rt

c, tcl
E o tc,
Ld

o-

I

L

o O o lo
J

- L o QL L 0) +r o_o o.J $
O O = lcF (,

co

o

o€

rlJ(/'

.<cor)

o o rr)

s

@

o

(FO '^

o€-cC

.-.-

*) +J C)
LCC n\.-,-

>

n

l/) (g oE oo\ c-o L cu)(/) qs o(, zz.=r !o)Eooooo 4rcot.(,/)(.r)o L (o vO s.L oo_o :lEoo+)0)

irr

o

E z, o

J ()
lf'

-OL-(FO(g (gLO-O (a> (oO s Cg: O OLL(o$ .- (9 L (9 $ +r$+JsO s
: a i! ^n -

o
E,

C' E

o rt
IF'

!L4OO .- ! g

O O-.-

tdn

trj tq

P Lrl
E

o !r)
.g |ql

o

r- 6 o >c oc .--4rL> s u)(/)p})cp .-o(Ecocc !trc(E-oo.o o)o'-o Lc'-.-Ol 6 -oo+(Dl op L 6 O! O.c =cEoL q-+, ocn 0) I c (q--col o (, o.- D o co oE'(g > il OO(oL}j c)(,U' CCOpO

o

;
I

r |q,
J

o

n

.9
l!

o

o

v, o
o tn o
F'

|q,

@

r

z o (r,

E

@ |rl

]
o otA (o cE+r r.- O rg (o. . L or$ L O €+r.+JoL ou) o (o oc! +r ' P.g< I oo(,1J> +, o c oo
'6'L o vL

o o

x

&, Htc'

lrJ

KF

o

n
o
@

o

c!
A - R

+, (g c=

C)

'c
+t

o lct

L5CO O LO OtO--C C6 0 +, o 6.4oOL

c
:l
()

0)

s) o

o o

ro
EI J tq

-c

(€+J(EL Cf O O!.(!t .-(FE(D+) O +ro o.ltL

co(o oo L o >C) (, 'tro o +, '-c c (o-15-

'6J
ol nl
J

-Pl -Pl

ol

o-

I

.-o Lttth(2 o+, o o $ L-c c-)o.uoF OU)-L13 o o oc (o L O OL q O s +, o,o o +J €o 3+)q-(/| .-c q- o o +r Otlr (,) .<CO+r v) c-c o o o 0) .-.- +, € O) L oEc> LCC LO o g o.-.-E g) o O! Olr\ C.o q g:(/)(.r) Ltn q-fC,C'Ljf L o(, zzaa +, o)E ooo oo rrcoL(/)(/)c) (E.- L s vO - O L-gO (g (oLO.o t/)> L cc'l $(l) O 0)LLag(u -- (g L (s $ D+rP(go. 6
- d

.po(,o

:tr

ct ro

o o

.rtr
lql

rr)

F z, o ()

o

o tct
-

o
lrl E

E

o r/,
rr

aro66 a .-4JC O-.q o o >)- L > o ! c p .--{ ooprJcp lt+rC$-oO.o olo.-o (F C.--O- | (g - o og ( D lo p L o oE o.c EcEos @cD cn g-€ I c €.-ol o l, o.-+to co o!(s lt > o$L! o()(,(/) c€ $
I

td

EF

6
lrJ tct

e
o

o

J

!o

|ql 0t

c, ro
o rqt
lrj

0)
L

;

T, cl €

n

o ro

o C)
ld

c,
U' (9
U' E,

o c)
@

>
o .o oo CIC-

z, o
HE,
L

:tr

tc, tc,
gt

v,

+r . +rc< l o(/,(,+)> +)oc oo
'- (9.- L c1)!$cE
A f r

!.'-Od (9. .Loret0) +r€.SOl 6(4OoO(o -L O

a

:f

n
C)

O

a o

tct
lql

L:co 0) LQ cD(,--c O e.- (go, c_ ooL Cj<O +tG d)o oo L$>Oc) $o e o .gC(g-1:.poL cf o O+) "6(, SGEol, c) oo o'ttL !ooo .-O UO6tt '-+)Qo$sC o-)o*joF O.v: L1f ('LooLLo !o-oo+) f (tsoo (!-cs -!0l'.<co+) c)c-goooo .-.-+J$O L olJ!> LCq GO (4 E O'-.- 1' (! O! o OF L\o c-o L cou) L t- f o(, L5 o(, z,z.=r l)oltooooo +) C O l-OC) O (o.- L (O -O L oo.o - o L-qo (E oLo-o o> (DO L CO) O Ot-L(s$ .- o L 6 o D!!(5O. -n (!

'6
o n o o
o
!o

ct

ol

o

lrJ

o.

I

r/)
J

c

:J

tct

o

6

|ql -c

O

n

rqt

o
F

E,

z, o o

c, n
tfl

lrl

.ct-ooo ct .-! c o-.L o o >-c o-c

o

E

f.^'::il>

P lrJ
ET

lrl E

tct

o
o
tf,

c)

lct

o!c(i.oo.().- c) o q - c . - o1 .o. I (g -O(,q-Orl O{J L <g oE o.-c ltcEoL o0l cll qP l c o.-col o u @,- $ Ut co oro 6 lt > (r(r(') cco+)o

I ()

c) r) 6 ro o ro
J

\o
I

L 3

;

o

o

tn o o
o ct
rf, lq,

.c o
lrJ

E z,
o u,
E

n o ct
!r)

o

; >
o tro (o cro€ ''-oo (E. . q 01 (o ! O
*J!.+J0)L Q) -L

HFE , t-

n o

o

o(/) o $ o.$

+r . +J.c< ! O (, O +r>
'-

-Y

+t

o
@

c

|ql

o o r)
o

q13+JOCE oc$ r:co q-o (,rl,-.c o O (o.- 6 O +, g(tOL +roCj< O L (q )(-) (, €o +r c) -C C (o-1t.!(oL C= C O+, -(g (, o{F E o +r o s rro ot DO(/JO J .-c) c,660 (g+)o(BacLc -->o+roF O (,LE

(g'-

L

c o oo o
N

o
trj

lrl

E

o -+-t o
F
J

T

L O N L O qt - o :) +)L (, (o-c+t Lo0) +r+J(, .<co+)
L - F a r i ! n \ 6 \

o r/) o

lqt |ql

o rt o

GO

oac(,) (g Ot' L

L

._,_

+, +r 0)

(, E o.-.-€
Of-G5(,(,L3

LgC

>

o (' z.z.=l +)ot1:,0)c)()()0
lJCOL(r)g?C) (E.- L (o vO -OL-q-q)(o c L O!

o o

F z,

o

tc,

.c rt,

E, tr,l E uF

o

e
trt

@ J

o

co

ct
|r)

.-(!L(o6!ppsc 6 J € O^E.C nLaoO O .- p c o-.L o o >c oE .--+rt_> ! ooP+tcp .-0J(gcocc EPc(s-OO.o o)o.-o q- c.--o- | (9 - C.)(,.r- (Dl O ! L $ o-o O.q-! ocn ol I c o.-@l o (' o.-$a co (,)E(! il > O(ot-+J O()(,(/J C€ !O

s cor $o o oLL(g(o

O >

s o
@

rt, EI fit
J

\o
I

L

;

Master your semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Special offer for students: Only $4.99/month.

Master your semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Cancel anytime.