Larkin

HoffiMw.

Larkin Hoffman Daly & Iindgren Ltd.
1500 Wells Fargo Plaza 7900 Xerxes Avenue South Minneapolis. Minnesota 554-31-1194
GENERAL:
FED ~AX

952·835·3800

,oil: 41·0953357

MINNESOTA SENATE A~: CAL LUDEMAN 231 STATE CAPITOL 75 DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BLVD. ST. PAUL, MN 55155

Invoice Number Invoice Date File Number

610287 05/2l! 12 35256.00000

REMITTANCE COPY
Re: EMPLOYMENT

ISSUE SERVICES RENDERED: THROUGH 03/31/12 46,150.50 0.00 $.4Q,J 5Q..50

FOR PROFESSIONAL

CURRENT FEES CURRENT EXPENSES TOTAL DUE l'PON RECEIPT

PLEASE RETURN THIS PAGE WITH YOUR REMITTANCE

111111111111111111111111111111111111 1111
Pro t!: 293399

Larkin HoffR12!1

Larkin Hoffinan Daly & Lindgren Ltd.
1500 Wells Fargo Plaza 7900 Xerxes Avenue South Minneapolis, Minnesota 55431-1194
GENERAL:

fED TAX 10#:

952·835-3800 41·0953357

MINNESOTA SENATE ATTN: CAL LUDEMAN 231 STATE CAPITOL 75 DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BLVD. ST. PAUL, MN 55155

Invoice Number Invoice Date File Number

610287 05/21/12 35256.00000

Re: EMPLOYMENT

ISSUE THROUGH 03/31112 Hours Begin review of all media publications; make notes for meeting with T. Bottern Telephone conference with C. Ludeman; review media reports; meet with T. Bottern Telephone conference with C. Ludeman Review file materials and make notes for telephone conference with client; telephone conference with client Review media reports Telephone conference with T. Bottern and C. Ludeman; telephone conference with E. Pugh Telephone conference with T. Bottern, C. Ludeman; review articles; review Almanac clip . Review notes and media reports to prepare for meeting with Senator Michel; telephone conference with T. Bottem; meet with Senator Michel Telephone conference with T. Bottern; review Senate video and media; review P. Villaume letter; draft response Telephone conference with T. Bottem Telephone conference with T. Bottern; draft letter to P. Villaume Review and revise notes from interviews; review file . documents; telephone conference with C. Ludeman; telephone conference with T. Bottem Review elements of claims; office conference regarding research; telephone conferences with T. Bottern; telephone conference with P. Villaume; review treatise; review news articles Legal research; office meetings with D. Nolan regarding same 2.00 7.70 0.10 1.90 0.25 0.90 1.00 4.00 Value 660.00 2,541.00 33.00 627.00 82.50 297.00 330.00 1,320.00

FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED: Date 01116/12 01117/12 01119112 01/20/12 01123112 0l/261l2 01/30/12 02(01/12 Tkpr DWN DWN OWN

D\VN
DWN OWN DWN

DWN DWN
OWN OWN DWN

02/02/12 02/07/12 02/08/12 02/09112

1.20 0.40 0.30 1.60

396.00 132.00 99.00 528.00

02110112

DWN

4.00

1,320.00

02110112

JAG

1.60

352.00

35256.00000 May 21, 2012 Date 02113112

MINNESOTA

SENATE

Invoice Number Page 2

610287

Tkpr

Hours
Review senate policies, rules, file notes and treatise; prepare for telephone conference; telephone conference with C. Ludeman and T. Bottem Telephone conference with P. Villaume; draft letter to P. to 5.20

Value
1,716.00

DWN
D\VN JAG

02/14/12 02/I4/t 2

0.30 8.20

99.00 0;00

Villaume
LegaJ research regarding claims and remedies; memorandum D. Nolan regarding same; office meeting with D. Nolan regarding same (No Charge) Review and revise letter to P. Villaume; review research regarding claims; review notice of claim statute Continue legal research regarding claims and remedies; memorandum to D. Nolan regarding same Revise letter to P. Villaume; telephone conference with T. Bottern Continue additionallegaJ Nolan regarding same research; office meeting with D.

021151I2 02/15/12 02116/12 02/16/12 02/17/12
02/20112 02/21112

DWN
JAG DWN JAG JAG DWN

6.80 1.50 1.30 2.20 1.90 0.30 2.75

2,244.00 330.00 429.00 484.00 418.00 99.00 907.50

Finalize legal research; office meeting with D. Nolan regarding same Review P. Villaume letter Prepare questions and notes for telephone conference; telephone conference with T. Bottern and C. Ludeman; draft letter to P. Villaurne Review letter; telephone conference with T. Bottem Telephone conference Telephone conference with T. Bottern with C. Ludeman and T. Bottern

DWN

02/22/12 03/01112
03/02/12 03/05/12

OWN DWN DWN DWN

0040
0.20 0.50 2.30

132.00 66.00 165.00

Telephone conference with C. Ludeman and M. Ferguson; prepare notes for meeting; telephone conference with T. Bottern Meet with T. Bottem and C. Ludeman; meet with Senators Office conference with C. Harristhal; telephone conferences with T, Bottern; draft nondisclosure agreement Office conference with D. Nolan regarding research on claims Telephone conference with T. Bottern; telephone conference with P. Villiaume; office conference regarding research for file; finish review of treatise Telephone conference Research Continue research Office conference with D. Nolan regarding results of research Telephone conference with P. Villaume; review emails and fax; telephone conferences with T. Bottern Office conference with D. Nolan (1'-JoCharge) with T. Bottern; telephone conference Telephone conferences with P. Villaume with T. Bortern

759.00

03/06/12

DWN DWN

4.50 2.50 0.50 1.20

1,485.00 825.00 165.00 396.00

03/07/12 03/08/12
03/08/12

cm
DWN

03/09112
03/10/12 03/11112 03/l2112 03112/12 03/13/12 03/13/12

OWN CJH CJH CJH DWN CJH

0.60 3.30 2.00

198.00 1,089.00 660.00 132.00 660.00 0.00 495.00 1,056.00

0040
2,00 0.00 1.50 3.20

DWN
CIH

03/14/12

Office conference with D. Nolan; review notice of claims; draft deficiency letter to P. Villaume; draft research memo

35256.00000 May 21, 2012

MINNESOTA

SENATE

Invoice Number Page 3

610287

Date
03fl4112

Tkpr

Hours
Research regarding defenses; review media; make notes for press release; revise draft release; multiple telephone conferences with T. Bottern and C. Ludeman; office conference with C. Harristhal Research legal issues Telephone conference with clients; draft press statement; telephone conference with C. Ludeman and T. Bottern; telephone conference with T. Bottern and W. Dwyer; meet with C. Ludeman, T. Bottern, et al; meet with Senators; telephone conference with T. Bottern Revise research Memorandum; counsel press conference Continue research Continue research; outline research memorandum Draft memo on results of research; office conference with D. Nolan; review ethics complaint . Telephone conferences with T. Bottern, Senator Koch, and G. Walsh; review materials; review press coverage Revise research memo Telephone conference with T. Bottern and C. Ludeman; review media reports; draft email to P. Villaume Office conference with D. Nolan regarding factual developments Telephone coverage; Ludeman; conference conference with C. Ludeman; review media telephone conference with Senators and e. telephone conference with C. Ludeman; office with C. Harristhal regarding research review video of plaintiffs 6.50

Value
2,145.00

DWN

03/15ft2

CJH DWN

3.50 7.00

1,155.00 2,310.00

03/15/12

03/16/12 03/16/12
03/17/12

em:
DWN

1.00 0.30 0.60 3.80 2.90 2.50 1.20 2.10 0.60 3.50

330.00 99.00 198.00 1,254.00 957.00 825.00 396.00 693.00 198.00 1,155.00

Telephone conference with Senator Senjem

03/18/12
03119/12 03/19/12

cm cm
C1H DWN

03/20112 03/20112 03/21112 03/2I112

cm
DWN C1H

DWN

03/22/12
03/23/12 03/23/12 03/26112 03/27112 03/28/12 03/28/12 03/29/12

DWN C1H DWN DWN

Telephone conferences with 1'. Bottern; telephone conference with Senator Michel; telephone conference with B. Maher Revise email of issues to D. Nolan Telephone conference with T. Bottern; attend hearing Travel to and meet with Senators; meet with T. Bottem and C. Ludeman Telephone conferences with 1'. Bottern; telephone conference with B. Maher Research privacy claim Draft and revise memorandum to employees and Senators; telephone conferences with T. Bottern Telephone conference with T. Bottern Telephone conference with T. Bottem

2.75 0.20 12.00 5.00

907.50 66.00 3,960.00. 1,650.00 396.00 1,188.00 495.00 132.00 132.00

DWN
C1H DWN DWN

1.20
3.60 1.50

0040

03/301l2

DWN

OAO

Litigation Support Technical Services

35256.00000 May 21,2012 Date 01116/12

MINNESOTA SENATE

Invoice Number Page 4 Hours

610287

Tkpr KES Create/set up a case file in the Summation application including creation of pleading directories and lookup tables for use with Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database Document coding in Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database; document coding in Summation database Document coding in Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database; document coding in Summation database Document coding in Summation database Scan document. images and load same to Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database; document coding in Summation database Load electronic document to Summation and create placeholder image for same Scan document images and load same to Summation database; download video files from Internet and load same to Summation database Modify form in Summation database and create new field Scan document images and load same to Summation database; document coding in Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database; document coding in Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database Search for press releases and news articles on the Internet and print same Capture video and audio files from the Internet and load same to Summation database Document coding in Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database Capture video files from the Internet and load same to Summation database Document coding in Summation database Capture video files from the Internet and load same to Summation database; scan document images and load same to Summation database Scan document images and load same to Summation database Capture video files from the Internet and load same to Summation database; scan document images and load same to Summation database

Value 15.00

0.20

01118112 01l19(l2 01126112 01126112 01/31/12 02/01/12 02/02/12 02/03112 02/06/12 02/07112 02110112 02/14112

KES KES DLG KES

1.10 0.10. 0.00 030 3.40 1.70 3.50 2.40 0.40 0.70 0.10 1.10

82.50 7.50 0.00 22.50 255.00 127.50 262.50 180.00 30.00 52.50 7.50 82.50

KES
KES
KES KES KES

KES
KES KES

02/20/12 02/21/12 02/22/12 03/09112 03/15112 03/19112 03/20112 03/20112 03/21112 03/22/12 03/22112

KES KES KES KES
KES

0.10 0.40 0.50 0.10 0.70 0.40 1.90 0.60 0.30 0.80 0.60 .

7.50 30.00 37.50 7.50 52.50 30.00 114.00 45.00 22.50 48.00 45.00

KES DLG KES KES

DLG KES

03/26/12 03/271l2

KES
KES

0.30 2.60

22.50 195.00

TOTAL HOURS

169.35

35256.00000 May 21, 2012

MINNESOTA

SENATE

Invoice Number Page 5

610287

TIMEKEEPER Timekeeper C. J. HARRISTHAL D. W.NOLAN lA.GODWIN K. E. SWENSON D. L GRIFFITH

SUMMARY Hours 26.80 ] 02.85 7.20 21.60 2.70

Title SHAREHOLDER SHAREHOLDER ASSOCIATE LITIGATION ASST LITIGATION ASST CURRENT FEES TOT At. DUE UPON RECEIPT

Rate
at 330.00 at 330.00 at 220.00 at 75.00 at 60.00

==

Value 8,844.00 33,940.50 1,584.00 1,620.00 162.00 46,150.50

$46,150.50