,:-" 'r"\[s STA COJ(L") F A PpEAL-.

5
t:o (2.. jl.-tE 5' EL. Of.> 'IV CJ: f?. C v .): \'
- Le.e. R,' c..

VI
(/;(:') -­
:r
Stew<A.\'*- (f< I )
rMot[VN <ro .Corr<.v'r c..Le.ri<:."'L. tl1-(2.0R i", 'r4,
·l \) E£vv S±eW CI\, tL-\- . . .
ot: VeNJQ
(.,OMe,S NJw\+k MOV4Nt\ Ct/K!V\
DrctK<.- G-rcthC,M J.j{g/CIt Ft\\ 5Ci\L \ (\?()\.I(' 5 :yt,tS \-'UNO(q IQ L<
Cvv\L-k- i 0 Lv' rrt.L\-' CA. c.. L..e.r) (."1.(, SRr<.o(2... \N tk. \)ovV-R.,+.fV,.J 0+ kNJ'-\N-f
MVl.r+-hv., ste.w/,-\rt ;,.J clt:,-k 0+ cuv,R.+ fvr:Jo+ +-0
\) 0 + M't r ·H·, Sk w4r4 .11'/ kIlt \ c:., V Kfl Ul.N rJ C1 S vJ t.. H...J\ IS
'Of(, AMq Le "Jh d \).R..,. AM"'NJC"..\ .. Tl..l5 p's
fvj -h) Vi ul4kJ q""vl j: WI tI C""'pl'-1 r.N,
.... r\- VIVJ..e., 01 AL.qS, Mt:.tr./--l-t vt SfevJetr-r 5-+t)l{.
+k .:tlvvt'ti-QtJ)(2. AM_" Le\c;h \N
\ -L- Pe 0rl<.. . ir,.. D(2, AMI.-(iv-l", Le ,,",]\r,. HVcJks 0r U(2.,Ar-". '-'1.NJ.
C{NJ. Yv J vJ' +l:J -tLe.. S"M€ .
pr[lvt:S4 4./kI", \)(2.., AM 1.A-.).......
·F!,-,vJ""Le..Nt- Cvtl.e;e Dejier<..t"f
vM
.l,t.Je,:ste.rN 0 AI, vI?. kJ!,,, II e
___ Sh.e.W>'\)IN G,.
il
-e1e. D(2.., AM"'NJ,tJ\ k",J, €
GlA.'5
V
..{..-\-bttl\ +cV\M\ *:LE!. \ CtlVl Gl.flt G0':1S' (1-'4."" f'1Qr.f\",,\J+tW<1,.('·r
.__ *0 r c,,- JVIo W\·-tI/L+l.t Gvrt"tvo.\. \rJ\) (2... AM",,..J.-V\
L.e..\ J"" J-h.l'-]h.es 'to War\,( ''\is GI, \)ts\\) St""C-{:
.Y\.+-+'4. \2.. \)A'f> ,500 \)rJj !4-\:;,\»)'<.., '-\1- .}le. kJ..er6'\l
{\tlv\tv",l ttt""kr t>R. t-TV",'hsz,'!::> 1-.,$
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 1 06/29/2010 61790 7
---------------- .....
CvtN'AJ±-ly fllvltM<.t _____ - ---- .. --.. ­
f urGe v /,d:0-1!.!L.tv
J
5i!.::i:v '-l L r- z L'\ hu,N'5.1J, l P W, H/) L., J:AJ.1Vt ,',r0
__ iZ-DJ?q:l 'f+"',r P''t tti<..L< So" p-;).{)N os S -0 3 +r(!L14
'1Jrk ('v-hdi'-i( c,:;t(.J j::'rSJ}l\J, '\l,-J .Lt.' I'-'JJ.les·t£.L \1[;J../)r1 kl/\.J(.L ____
,hl+v
7
l."vtS Ct l5 0 SI\/) v 1,;) I- , - J iJle 7c" ( U4fC ..; t I (. S \ L)(" '-t I N e \ vl\..L,_ i
- AL-i"I.; rL.tl \ n"r.' -. -'P"'q - \ (Ill f)i ·\0 J!",),}<t
C
v "'-. v' oJ, 00,"' ,"v_hU '- \ '-'- loA. 1 _-./ \ '-i""v. (., '----> i V I, TrJ .....
le-J.t.J1-(.\.1 t
l
) self +vr p(Qt'+Crl'vAN tje+- (.)fVJef"fl.e.J./\J-tt-./t,'-6t
I r.+ vk:)i ""'f:Jv,"'-'lblAiv-tLt:-, -(.\1)( -1+Jr.)2> C,lS.0 t_'\), :: ..,eJ ct,,-t)
"'J I l\t v e.s-t- l-(l IN :fk c;) Hd+ J ,·!I.J'Jcv',rA. be. w'
A.M4NJ l.-tv:;h::etj .. lkr ;V"tMk'.. I b N-1 +''i f<,: P'1 ft u ... k: J, 'j I !VI f'5 clN __ _
__ _Sv -:v
J
\) (<,. \ ..J \J "S1-r:(;-\- uP _
K?rJ+v".A?y, .> 1,'"'1 f';) J N Vi RI I r (2..1 eJ l?- tv .... !':J ''':'7 P'1 +n G k.
,.. <:2
t
,£VI f 1J IV i..-J IY\'" ",M rHo ',\ :) kvJ V\ r' + C (.) J L{ l:..;) J v( I 0 .}Ler cr. n e:':> +L.. "-+1.
l(l)uv-J .-\-\.1<. \)e '-'1t-stl(.
M4:",+l..11 o,...} ..., Pr.:.-'<.
\ljb+-4",J +4.. U,/'JiVJ<J Sl,owG-A)Q 01') :
c-'\,. (-f,IJ ].A!'"J. J.1JI'-f_ t fVlj' Q,0 \ t, )::. S"LvJ SKw'",-f"t
-etA+ \0'1 Ke../(..&k....\· C,jol(le..s ct1--- (\r--J.
:-,hJPL. kj C':"N:J of Cli",-v-<.. (;e .,tV..) ':'" [V11 NIfJO stcc't <-1 t +'4 fJ-V
I "'J ()d e(" '19 <L 'S·h/x, It 1- 5"4 vJ ,MIA;- -/--i. SkwGt t+ ev+ +4 iA) ::r
S+'->P U ·''V''t-.J...i
0
.J +It. 6'-1.(., k L.t;t- S-f-t,;V}.i":, vf' 2 FUJN(.,\ VV+
h',r :Iv + 'Fe e(J lLM. _0 .:r N t:u f!'!J ,,+, Au.+ f ck J rJ rJM I -S:) i 5 5'fr -'
__ \.e51 Le. bl 4pj Co,,,.rs+"'t'}(..k tv: c- /t1, j -erJ P -tQ i I .• '-t.
-to l:"y.J.t.,"'+Mt"A- -f.-:--e S't"" .,/'-'1.,;..l;'1-{ L
.. J. t-I) 'f. "'"'. tL-v DI"J '(L<?. C-v. t "-lC j N M-h.l '\ )' it be '-t,t. t. \.e. Pv.,,- Ibuwl v.. . __ _
__ M· L K.. Sk...... ·", 'le S-lot e... fl, Gl- ()().) ..\'r 17M (V1-.e W'-".l ".,'I,,,.)::!. w . __ _
ti""j +0 -\-0 M e'1. W 0 _\ M ",,+L'A. -S rv+- f'1J G _____
iJ\.l ,·tSSMU.N J-(. r-;; DIVA;s .s+t.F-tJ..
ft.J +-kre.. ...... Go· .
C0 \)vjl<. l,....,l.{;-.j iVt'\.1 :5-k.w .... (-f .___.__
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 2 06/29/2010 61790 7

+"0'1e:fk
r
ZOr;.L1 " \)c1Le
__ kn () (, keJ. t'" "'l r '-'\ .) '"" ,r·r's + h \.; J+ b.e4G '-VSQ. S+e w'-'\ :.- t-(")"I 5 ("1.. '--' '/-;:v +
ir-J t\Z C1, (2'-1<..4-e.L R!+'j C.;G.J\./Je.
L.J 1> I' j I PI Gkle5 CitA.).. Pek r P"'-N ckfvt 'J'i J. Pi4Aj b\.)(7
5le'1l Uv"'\.C' \-€ r-G iN (.2.() e..4-.'tI'\;} \:, t:. r 1 e. r: jt'V-\Q f(J;J{\A D't
C> S'-1 '1 L,.-\:: c..t vi e, q",,(..lJ?v <.If..J (frd k ci-e.JS·e 'f-. , .J P(?)'tVt-.;:) P 1\..)1
('J-.e C-tl'-J. fl',,:) 'E SOU +r: <:' /...,J AI <-t+vr l, t t:J Cf4 17 I t. j J e j.5 "!.-+u r c:·\ l\)
_, :'5 e, e.. «1C.h.e.) II. I 'J-'1"VtA (( tV)....e·;'5 Vr (20 e +-ke :5Ge
r
J<Z t<" . Jv"'+
, l'-t l -" \ ,)-h:.. ...... \,' 'r L",\{Vlir'\;' oJv('c. +C'_'fV'1 KuurJf'..J:; <::\,-J
Vl J Se"h yV i }k. M Del (JJJ\J) . .)Le .. IN. r V,.Jtv t L.... 'r s
(" ..... rJ \"6 l'\tk" h ...... t.:I..A- Gt·1e(:) ..
S,.:) ,j W€.I rJ. SC,t.Nvt:i /1"1r+h .5kw<-, -\ups ),e,("'r'<.+ r£<.'f)-e I ....___
__ .:t lAI1 S -tu i: su«n V "-, 1<- <.. h _NJ. J v -:...':1 +."<.- oIt" vi,!,:: ,-,..p A II I') tVce --'
f'vJ'1 r+ (\/{- e.- o.J +h..t (3A-1. L<. cJ.p Cot z {. 1\-" Lb-t;; (.'-1. r-4- 0 N \
hI "\ J Pow Ui-t-tr"N rlrv:.,(:; GVV;) J: W'-t,S
!'ll.c'l'-1UJ t'1-'lr--i·!,.."':5 +k (ire>."J
o.-Dkct;:) ):,J."erJ.-h!Jk..l fr",M ·e .... +ir::J ,Mhrti--'-\ rt"\v
IA
__ /"I'2'J (Z7'LrJ ;A-<Je<..tcJ
- .. 'VeNNIS .. i-Nkc5f"1,(A"'---.J- ev. ...j
..... J. c,'" Or..) f'Vt.,J' GL'1.lJV" .f1"'-r4t"'-v..
A"Ss''tvL.+tJ 5-h> te .f-ltd.... tL·\I.N !t?(I"rh, S-k""-,,... r·+w.;s
(-1"'fH.. '-1, 'S4-:e""",,[T v" T€.rr'1 CirV
SLIM (l"tc.}k"'l 5+uli(." {({0krJ ,±t..,.\r..-'!-s
4A-ti"'lto f' 54evi'e wV"-i ,leJe..... h",r..}kVl, 54-..>",-r+ v",,":lZ.w· ->J "·)l ",.J. i..e,
SJ./pR.-r htsL-"'Iiyt(YJe':1..L... . 54.e\.J:'lrt h.,:eJ. .G,jJVJ. -\0
IIIJ) () f"i!.. fur-\- +0 :sk"l ll"'j tvtVl-:) , 5 -v', ,t G./',A<"t.L-\t: J.
M,A,'-j'-1',Jtr \)f./ fJ t-o 1'-'" {":'j 1ver-c,tl\.lT- E
,_.. tr-ve... -\0 VtNU..:) (/v, lL (..,M:5 <) 4 u 4 -:> /V''turo,vS -A:.r '-1.H "!) ++
v' . OPt,--J; jhv-l:- TtK k }l€
C. ·"J.J/V'-\.*".cuJ ((I(..J..-e. JL..."", ,5k..J'-1r-\- i
\
\ :J .J:l'1..R.. I N (ColL
J<'\w Cl
j
oJ\. at C''''',)+UC c..":) ...... \- '.N,... lkJ. ,.. CJ
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 3 06/29/2010 61790 7
..
'5(->r'NkLeJ. W.1"" /'1",r-u"",SJ.e.t...JCcr-+­
-tl.e. ENf'O!\h j-hLl \.N
<t MVve 4-0 5(1-t"\ K -to fv'e V\Lc./\. ,J:; r1 opelV +0 Cot 1I Qv{ s+niN$ ....
Cv "J\ \,..it-- 01.e.. '-\-\- -FM <- 1- i N J"\-- U !"-l 0 r- P .1 \" LO 0 k r--e U f> 1
\rJ bVf'€"\V -lNf"1'-'\l..e toc.",,4-or.
V\ S4-c>. t.\""J. ElZec...\.\e. .f} (,fl.; E-.,:
J- 'Jo-t- 'S"\v LkJ.. fYl e.., q+ \)q \Cj Qve-eN wd",
MqrK (,.,UbI4.N o<.Jf. flqr . U hJl..:r-<'\ukJ.. .:rlR. U.N q .
CV\lS,,),'vN 'to VCnAV"'-(J LP.A/{'i'J cl(..Q,rl.e. rYJ€ .-, /VJR..; ,- r:v.-J
li''\Ah/(b wl Le..(..t.:>{4. W4,--.-tJ-Iv e.<..t\--cYJ k"J... .f(,A--S'v'f(kf+ Mezr}l.,,,,, skwVlrl
ML.-r::> \'"h:.H.[ Skflh.e./J 4+ Ac:L.N)tUN Nl.I\tJ...>V1L
l-iowLe.l CII.\- 4-\2, fV)Go..-J,. £Ve(,1 +uv"Q. -.t: ti..(;0'Sv.+ I {jr"1CK OBh VlUj
(A. re'"'\J, \"J lAV) 1)0",,( t\) cW""H,q"rJ
v.. f1CA(,+Ir.r., -tvtrJ
pe"\f'JON 5-k."\( tI:"::J LeVI'S, AN). IN t, C;'--A J,.
r
1'L(L .
o-t j 0 #-2:.\
SC v+\-( -\fv/V) 0+dlr t\' L{ \ ovt- +4'. ior 5
(It\l ,J'\-e\N, t"r+oJN8rawI'.-.:;vp Ape.. (.{",J M{2-,
\JtJJjA. :Skv.J
it
(+ t.6fN r:.fGl'N
AN}.re\,J":) \-e..., .... 19oJv.j ""':J GJfl6VNce.t\ Qeep I
-\t, JJ-e.w<.tc+ ev.e.('j Ar/'.ff\'CqN W,)(2.,t­
,{j.t:eJj t urcJlltvA-' -('{'./M (Vl",,1l !.V<.1/fr kollrv1-"lltJ;SJ: fvt lNj-v
-!\:l L",wsv;t-:], :l; -\vr (,r""", Jle-(Z., '. _"",,- -j-rJ. ",1.,,+ 1vJ Jo '_ (\ r J' II
X- qJ (<A I t\A1. hUN v r l{:. WLI a.. --\- uc re-l, .l-t . //,::1'
c,,""-tJ ("V\\'\ rh.e. IArrfA Nv., Q.. 0\ rel(lcv+ttb -"'//'"'///'____
I v I / ____ L....­
'NV V, -0W, -- __ /7 .(;,.,23-
/
0
/''dotJ 4.tV Le-e 1< I (. he.s
ff'1vCf
'f==elur..G \ ( t-e",kr
p Y-. l'i s0 0
i \ Vv'i Lfo S L'Z
-2 s S -- 10 DL Z
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 4 06/29/2010 61790 7
F-tiJ,u", C Me-J. ( c'"'" l L e!V+-cr l-e -ft 'I'V
J
fvAJ K'e Ntv
"3 3 () l Lee 5+OwN (2 J
Ie-i-. t'tv<:rt-ON \ k '1' t4 0 5 f ,
--:Yo N<A. Lee Rt. .:. h e, P-e j\J .s


\
" ----,----" -­
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 5 06/29/2010 61790 7
COvR-T 0 F A-PPEALS
Fo R. Y\-\- 'E S E COlV\) C.r /Z..c.. v .I'}
C3 LA- 'S S
VJ
CA-s.g,. 0 - 133 S
rM()"tION cro C'\e.-' ..c,.L £fZ..(2.o«,. IN Yk 0
0
(,/"(&+<;<-)1
L 0 f Iv l CO Le.. (3 ' -1
tJ
uvJ
" «.ICh£.s .(""'/k/tA.. UMt1.('"
c\/(p/q Joles \ MUv'e:!> +L,I.o5 kuA)UP-..'-tbk GuL-(2.+- -to c;.. GLent",L
E::!2-(2.o«. It--> OC"'i,v4J+ !vIGol-e
cl-frl.( ot- Guv(Lr f'ur'j\.)'f fo Ac\j, GDrS'c;'s ,A}Kl4 \.
Al,)0 J<fI()vJtJ IJr?-,. AMur..1I1&..
v
0+ (';JI'L-t- to AJ.cl NIGv
1
.c. B.... ss d/bf" \ 1$ ot), "'j
;\::, [.$ DR..
J: MJv't -w 4k P/'1u'J+,t'f r t\uvJ"..Jj !
tv; (..)-tj V\ 7) ':, L{ '"" f2.. AM l\J 1", ('1 \.h; 1 J'l Iq\)R, N +" L, f {0
R, Itj f0 \ 0V\k'.. \ J... ""-.J t!OM l'+l ':)':"'.\-1 UN II v 1"-'') V N \'
·Y\:rl 0 "nrc... AM '-'!.I\-J<A. J.fv, 4:) 1)(2....
Rtl-e), 'vu,t€,. i eM +lt2., l",,.{.lVkC' ;,r,J
,._.J-e'fi wvrU(fv:J,L>V -rk «.t)ArF'S<)i..> L. _,_ ....._
._.\\)rvJ+rt .... P(O';JrGtM, /V1(;ol+.:.. "" -\'''<.._
\.\v;\--.tS\ M.'V+-t() € \r-J.. _
\\v1he.,) GPQ:J l>((', u'b'5{(.
-fu r A+n AMer \J \ ri "'""1 er:5. wkJ"'2.., \) {L A tv'\ L..e"l., l--tv) k5
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 6 06/29/2010 61790 7
J
\b'-"\ &Il
t? L ... se'N°d.. d.C1) ,
W-v1 ') "e. (VJ t J... ',t '1J) f+ t
VP
'\l'vJ" Le Lj It Q 1". .0.)
__.. '1 \) '\) Hv')4J <; I1.<.1 hi 1(, 04- .£& &' S
qL-;so 2..-I'-l·lD -C1
J
+u
-\,\Jl,. \) N'-1+""L\C.
beeN :5k.'1.L'.'Vj .\:(ujVl L'"\f\.\c,.,e:" f"",·h'erJb ON \=v{
yt-J V"'+ 0+ J=M(. Skt:\;;Js
'N vvW t
ML,.I"'h.... 'v.v,.j -f'\e/V1 up qJl k''5 re.7)tLers
Sk\ol J..s t \){L fJ,-, g "'. Atf\tr v..J, J.-.er hv:> lo4J..1J {;J ..,
\' .
T)w''1'J
N
't, \<-0 vIA. J u lA.N 'J at 6\ '01,'\J jt-v N JVp H" M L,,, De A
r(vfV1+\.e f2..t) FT tP
C1.f't,,\ Gv;t '''--J \ rV <.. vNvU.:- W
G.A:::, S. J 1\ fG '\vl'-..; :v GQI 0 +le
B,.;rvJ.;j were) "''PC' X h +4!. _PIJ1(Cdv1-tvf" (l3(\'S \
G"X..iit ':) \\.,r-J. )''t 'I N;) j ( v i Jl f' v ':) t per)u,\Y:,d'; S<-.. v0 ;J:(;:,I e GASS
SN",{:"{\''''':7 G45 NC1.f'J\.'') (2e-"'';}'v
J
pJ 2vu l ot0 ct/J I "-t+
ej'i IV 'tA.,) kr N"'I.+ I vvc..c. A! rf'Fr-+ '" \) Me 1'-7 ,5
€ <1.L.5v fl.t ,/'V
'1 t '] J see.. i !LJ-t,:> v, \:.[0" .. {"'l u·.,.,Q.. u +' veAJ\,-R- ,;-J
fJ\(,ole. \,..1 .. J:t>(J.k
v1

/ " /
r \
?-/". // L:/ }
7 ('-L2-tv
JoN ""'+\"''-'lrJ Lee
---44 '1"0 ct '1 b (H"6" -- ,,'
e J,.e(....L ('VI.el<\.-'"l t.t,A k'
P,-,:'.J i-. 1'1')00·.·---­
':; i. v·v·Sll-
I Wt rJ.. r" 1. ."1 U. , .
-tu-Y;'L
Case: 10-1397 Document: 11 Page: 7 06/29/2010 61790 7

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful