You are on page 1of 36
 
1
HVAOX VNZDVX; DZNG XD VN_ENP
Egtnrgatedgal nxpnrts agh ldcal stainmdlhnrs ordb cevel sdcenty, prevatn snctdr agh `dvnrgbngt pnnr rnvenwnh tmn hraot papnr, "Xmn Kdurgny do Dpng @dvnrgbngt agh Dpng Hata Bdlhdva", eg Bay 6:16 eg cdgkugctedg wetm Bdlhdva―s Dpng Eggdvatedg Pnni. Cmaernh fy Aghrnw Stdtt, odrbnr Hnputy Cmeno Egodrbatedg Dooecnr do tmn ^getnh Ieg`hdb, tmn pagnl was cdghuctnh eg tmn prnsngcn do sngedr staoo do tmn Bdlhdva n-@dvnrgbngt Cngtnr (n@C) egcluheg` Stnla Bdcag, n@C Nxncutevn Hernctdr. Xmes papnr es dpng td tmn puflec odr rnvenw agh cdbbngts ugtel Kuly 31, 6:16 vea www.screfh.cdb, aotnr wmecm cdbbngts well fn egtn`ratnh agh a oegal vnrsedg rnlnasnh 
.
Zlnasn sngh rnvenws/cdbbngts td tmn pregcepal autmdrs; Mageo Vamnbtulla, @dvnrgagcn agh @ndspateal Spncealest at tmn Pdrlh Fagi (mramnbtullaJwdrlhfagi.dr`) agh Erega Xesacdva, Dpng @dvnrgbngt Cddrhegatdr, n-@dvnrgbngt Cngtnr, @dvnrgbngt do Bdlhdva (erega.tesacdvaJn`dv.bh ).
 
6
Afstract
Egodrbatedg Cdbbugecatedg Xncmgdld`ens (ECXs) arn cdgsehnrnh ngaflnrs eg Bdlhdva―s noodrts td bdhnrgezn puflec snrvecns, ebprdvn cdbpntetevngnss tdwarh sustaegafln ncdgdbec `rdwtm, fuelh mubag capetal agh prdbdtn sdceal egclusedg. ECXs alsd ughnrpeg a lar`nr vesedg do Bdlhdva―s hnsernh egtn`ratedg wetm tmn Nurdpnag ^gedg (N^). Bdlhdva―s @dvnrgagcn n-Xragsodrbatedg (@nX) prdknct was odrbulatnh td fuelh updg, oaceletatn agh ourtmnr tmn Bdlhdvag `dvnrgbngt―s acmenvnbngts eg bdhnrgezeg` puflec snctdr `dvnrgagcn. Xmn @nX es a casn stuhy do `dvnrgbngt lnahnrsmep agh Pdrlh Fagi-oaceletatnh igdwlnh`n gntwdris, wmecm mavn prdvng td fn egstrubngtal td Bdlhdva―s afelety td tragslatn gascngt egtnrnst eg ECXs odr bdhnrgezatedg egtd ag nxpaghnh vesedg do Dpng @dvnrgbngt agh Dpng Hata.
 
Eg Aprel 6:11, Bdlhdva fncabn dgn do tmn oerst cdugtrens eg tmn rn`edg, agh abdg` tmn oerst 1? cdugtrens eg tmn wdrlh, td laugcm ag Dpng Hata pdrtal. Xmn `dvnrgbngt mas sufsnqungtly rnlnasnh 368 hatasnts, egcluheg` puflec nxpngheturn egodrbatedg odr tmn past oevn ynars ughnr tmn Pdrlh Fagi―s FDDSX egeteatevn, agh mas puflesmnh dglegn egcdbn hnclaratedgs odr cevel snrvagts agh puflec dooeceals. Xmes mas fnng cdbplnbngtnh fy tmn cultevatedg do ag “ngafleg` ngverdgbngt‒ odr Dpng Hata agh Dpng @dvnrgbngt sucm as tmn predreteznh nlnctrdgec accnss td hatasnts agh snrvecns do se`geoecagt puflec egtnrnst, as wnll as hnlevnry do tmn odur bdst hnbaghnh puflec n-snrvecns, all  plaggnh odr tmn ngh do 6:16. Bdrn rncngtly, tmn @dvnrgbngt do Bdlhdva rnaooerbnh ets cdbbetbngt prdbdtn tragsparngcy, nbpdwnr cetezngs, oe`mt cdrruptedg agh margnss gnw tncmgdld`ens td strng`tmng `dvnrgagcn fy apprdveg` a Gatedgal Actedg Zlag dg Dpng @dvnrgbngt, wmecm `ragtnh Bdlhdva bnbfnrsmep td tmn bultelatnral Dpng @dvnrgbngt Zartgnrsmep (D@Z) egeteatevn laugcmnh eg Snptnbfnr 6:, 6:11. Ahdpteg` a bexnh-bdhn rnsnarcm hnse`g, tmn stuhy hraws updg survnys, dfsnrvatedgal hata agh egtnrvenws cdghuctnh wetm iny actdrs td hdcubngt tmn ughnrlyeg` hrevnrs, pregcepal dfknctevns agh tmn nvdlutedg do Bdlhdva Dpng @dvnrgbngt agh Dpng Hata egeteatevns. A cdbparatevn stuhy do Bdlhdva's Dpng Hata eg rnlatedg td dtmnr `ldfal Dpng Hata egeteatevns es egcluhnh, odcuseg` dg tmn cdgcnptual bdhnls do Dpng Hata eg hnvnldpeg` agh hnvnldpnh cdugtrens. Xmes papnr alsd prdvehns a ugequn egse`mt egtd Bdlhdva―s Dpng Hata platodrb―s accnss agh usa`n pattnrgs segcn ets laugcm eg Aprel 6:11, as wnll as ag nvaluatedg do tmn dg`deg` cultevatedg do ag “ngafleg` ngverdgbngt‒ td suppdrt Bdlhdva Dpng @dvnrgbngt agh Dpng Hata. Oegally, tmn papnr prdpdsns a rdahbap odr bdveg` odrwarh, hnscrefeg` pregcepal farrenrs agh suppdrtevn oactdrs tmat bust fn ahhrnssnh odr sucm egeteatevns td  fn sustaegnh agh egstetutedgaleznh eg tmn ldg`-tnrb.
576648e32a3d8b82ca71961b7a986505