Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NOTE: This critique served as a mockup for an print article that appeared in Issue 10 of Global Outlook magazine.
It examines the feature article in the March 2005 issue of Popular Mechanics: 'DEBUNKING 9/11 LIES'. The Global
Outlook article based on this is more detailed than this early version. See these related documents:
Popular Mechanics Attacks Its "9/11 LIES" Straw Man: The original critique of the Popular Mechanics article, first
published on 911Research on February 7, 2005. The current critique grew out of this much shorter critiqe.
Popular Mechanics' Deceptive Smear Against 9/11 Truth: A more detailed critique of the article, including the entire
text of the original.
Popular Mechanics' Assault on 9/11 Truth: Sharing the same name as this critique, this longer version served as the
final prototype ofr the Global Outlook article.
The article brackets its distortion of the issues highlighted by 9/11 skeptics with smears against the
skeptics themselves, whom it dehumanizes and accuses of disgracing the memories of the victims, and
repeatedly accuses of harassing individuals who responded to the attack. More important, it misrepresents
skeptics' views by implying that the skeptics' community is an undifferentiated army that wholly embraces
the article's sixteen poisonous claims, which it asserts are at the root of virtually every 9/11 alternative
scenario. In fact much of the 9/11 truth community has been working to expose many of these claims as
disinformation.
Besides trashing the skeptics, and conflating this
The Lies Are Out There country with its corrupt leaders, Meig's attempts to
legitimate PM's investigation, saying:
This article has a page of We assembled a team of reporters and
Editor's Notes, The Lies researchers, including professional fact checkers
Are Out There, written by and the editors of PM, and methodically analyzed
James Meigs, whose all 16 conspiracy claims. We interviewed scores
previous columns have of engineers, aviation experts, military officials,
praised military eyewitnesses and members of the investigative
technology (such as the teams who have held the wreckage of the attacks
UAVs used in Fallujah). in their own hands. We pored over photography,
Meigs places outside of maps, blueprints, aviation logs and transcripts. In
society anyone who every single instance, we found that the facts used
questions the official James Meigs, appointed editor
by the conspiracy theorists to support their
of Popular Mechanics in May
version of events of 2004, trashes skeptics of the fantasies were mistaken, misunderstood, or
9/11/01: official story of 9/11/01 as
deliberately falsified.
irresponsible disgracers of the
We as a society accept memories of victims, apart from
This sounds impressive, but the article provides no
"we as a society."
the basic premise that a evidence to back up these claims. It provides no
group of Islamist footnotes to source its many assertions, and despite
terrorists hijacked four airplanes and turned them the scores of experts listed in its final section the
into weapons against us. ... Sadly, the noble article cites only a handful of them, and mostly to
search for truth is now being hijacked by a refute its straw-man claims.
growing army of conspiracy theorists.
Meigs throws a series of insults at the conspiracy Moreover, bold unsubstantiated claims in the article
theorists, saying they ignore the facts and engage in -- such as PM's assertion that there was only a
elaborate, shadowy theorizing, and concludes his single interception in the decade before 9/11/01 --
diatribe by saying: don't inspire confidence in PM's professional fact
checkers. It echoes the discredited assertions of
Those who peddle fantasies that this country
official reports such as FEMA's World Trade Center
encouraged, permitted or actually carried out the
Building Performance Study and the 9/11
attacks are libeling the truth -- and disgracing the
Commission Report. It provides no evidence PM
memories of the thousands who died that day.
investigated the attack -- only evidence that it
investigated the 9/11 Truth movement in order to
determine how best to discredit it through
misrepresentation.
9/11: DEBUNKING the MYTHS
Superficially, the four topics appear to address the
major physical evidence issues brought up by the
skeptics (while ignoring the mountains of evidence
of foreknowledge, motive, and unique means
possessed by insiders). However, the sixteen most
prevalent claims made by conspiracy theorists
which it attacks are mostly specious claims, many
of which were probably invented to discredit
skepticism of the official story in the first place. The
article debunks the more specious claims, and uses
distortion and falsehoods to counter serious claims.
Six of the alleged suicide hijackers turned up alive NORAD learned of the hijackings only after long
after the attack -- a fact that the 9/11 Commission and inexplicable delays. For example, NORAD's
failed to even acknowledge. [4] [5] [6] [7] timeline blames the FAA for 18 and 39-minute
There is no public evidence that the remains of any delays in reporting the deviations and transponder
of the alleged hijackers was recovered. shut-offs of Flights 11 and 77.
None of the flight crews on the targeted aircraft Once it learned that Flights 11 and 175 were
headed to New York City, NORAD failed to
reported hijackings to Air Traffic Control, either by
radio or the 4-digit hijacking codes. scramble interceptors from nearby Fort Dix or
None of the contents of recovered voice data Laguardia, choosing instead the distant Otis base
in Falmouth, MA.
recorder black boxes has been made public, even
though the 9/11 Commission has closed its doors. Once it learned that Flights 77 and 175 were
headed to the Captial NORAD failed to scramble
interceptors from Andrews Air Force base (just 11
miles from the Pentagon), choosing instead the
distant base in Langley, VA.
Fighters already in the air were not redeployed to
pursue the jetliners. For example, two F-15s
The FBI released its list of hijacking suspects within three days of the
attack. Five of the named suspects proclaimed their aliveness and flying off the coast of Long Island were not
innocence after seeing their mug shots on news reports. Yet the 9/11 ordered to fly cover over Manhattan until after the
Commission repeated the same list of suspects without even
acknowledging that there were any problems with their identities.
second tower was hit. [10] The F-15s from Otis
supposedly reached Manhattan a few minutes
after the second tower hit, but were not
Chain of Miracles
redeployed to pursue Flight 77, which was headed
toward the capital.
The hijacking scenario alleged by the official story is
F-15s and F-16s scrambled to intercept the attack
virtually impossible:
jetliners were flown at less than one-third of their
Several of the alleged hijackers frequented strip top speeds.
bars, consumed alcohol and pork, were rude in
bars, consumed alcohol and pork, were rude in
public, and left copies of the Koran behind; yet they Stand-Down Implementation
supposedly committed suicide out of fanatical
devotion to Allah. [8] PM's rehashing of the 9/11 Commission's
The takeovers of the four jetliners were staggered incompetence theory is absent any mention of the
over a one-hour period; yet any rational planner two methods likely used to freeze the air defenses:
would have executed the takeovers simultaneously.
[9]
A June 1st order consolidated intercept authority
The hijackers supposedly enjoyed 100% success in in the Secretary of Defense, requiring its approval
taking over the flights with "box cutters" in spite of for any intercepts that might involve deadly force.
the crews of the remaining flights having knowledge This order stripped commanders in the field of
of the first takeover. autonomy in responding to crises such as 9/11/01.
[11]
None of the alleged hijackers had flown jets before.
Multiple war games were conducted on the day of
9/11/01. While one exercise, Northern Vigilance,
involved the redeployment of interceptors far
from the northeast corridor, other exercises,
Vigilant Guardian and Vigilant Warrier likely
confused the coordination of response to the
attack.
The site OilEmpire.us provides evidence of five
war games right after the passage quoted by PM,
so the omission of this information is likely
intentional. [12]
Investigation Prevention
Each of the four flights commandeered for the attack either originated
from airports far from their targets or flew hundreds of miles west The crashes were not seriously investigated:
before turning around.
PM goes to lengths
THE to explain the
"puffs". It quotes
WORLD TRADE NIST lead
investigator Shyam
CENTER Sunder saying
When you have a
CLAIMS ATTACKED BY POPULAR significant portion
MECHANICS of of a floor
MECHANICS of of a floor
collapsing it's
In this section, PM attacks five claims of which only
going to shoot air
two are valid: that the Twin Tower collapses ejected
and concrete dust
clouds of concrete dust, and that Building 7 was
out the window At about seven seconds after the South
destroyed through controlled demolition. The other Tower's top stated to plunge, the event
without explaining
three claims are red herrings and are used to has become quite explosive. The red
where the concrete arrow points to puffs of dust emerging
overshadow the valid claims. PM dismisses the valid from the mechanical floor, about ten
dust came from, or
claims -- which are only the tip of the iceberg of floors below the zone of total
even attempting to destruction. If those puffs are due to
evidence of controlled demolition -- with the floors pancaking, then what is
quantify the amount
misdirection, omissions, and hand-waving. producing all of the dust in the
of dust that should explosion above, the floors containing
be expected in the the only concrete in the tower?
Widespread Damage absence of
explosives.
CLAIM: ... OTHER EXPLOSIVES (... such as
concussion bombs) HAD ALREADY BEEN PM fails to acknowledge any of the global collapse
DETONATED in the lower levels of tower one at the features that researchers often cite as proving
same time as the plane crash. demolition, such as verticallity, explosiveness,
The article's lead point in the World Trade Center pulverization and rapidity -- features abundantly
topic is an obscure idea that explosives in the documented in the extensive body of surviving
basements of the towers damaged the lobbies at photographs and videos. [16] [17] Instead it implies
about the time the planes hit. This claim is difficult that conspiracy theorists rely on the opinion of
to find in 9/11 skeptics' literature, and is entirely expert Van Romero:
distinct -- in both the support that exists for it, and Numerous conspiracy theorists cite Van Romero,
the support that it provides for "conspiracy theories" - an explosives expert and vice president of the
- from the contention that explosives brought down New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology,
the towers (56 and 102 minutes after the plane who was quoted on 9/11 by the Albuquerque
crashes). Journal as saying "there were some explosive
devices inside the buildings that caused the
Puffs Of Dust towers to collapse."
THE
THE
PENTAGON
CLAIMS ATTACKED BY POPULAR
MECHANICS
In this section, PM attacks three often-repeated
claims by proponents of the theory that no jetliner
crashed into the Pentagon. Like other mainstream
media attacks on 9/11 Truth, the article gives no
hint that many skeptics consider this theory a hoax,
and avoids the persuasive arguments against it. [36]
Instead, PM backhandedly promotes the theory It is counterintuitive to think that an aircraft could be reduced to
thorough sloppy and implausible refutations of the confetti by an impact with a reinforced barrier, but that is exactly what
this crash test demonstrated.
three claims. Meanwhile, PM totally ignores the
many facts about the Pentagon attack that point to
FACTS IGNORED BY POPULAR
an inside job.
MECHANICS
Maj. Douglas Martin defends the incompetence theory of the failure of military response.
Shyam Sunder attempts to explain the "puffs of dust" shooting out of the South Tower as the result of
floor "pancaking", and attempts to explain the collapse of Building 7 by likening it like a house of cards.
PM cites other experts to counter valid claims without it being clear that they are addressing the issue at
hand. For example PM cites airline accident expert Michael K. Hynes as asserting that aircraft parts can
bounce over 300 yards in high-speed crashes, without clarifying whether he is addressing the crash of
Flight 93: a vertical plunge into soft ground.
A privileged group acted as if they had The Bush administration thwarted any genuine
foreknowledge of the attack. investigation of the attack.
Several people received warnings not to fly Not a single official was demoted or reprimanded
canceled plans to fly on 9/11/01, including John for the failure of the military to defend New York
Ashcroft then-San-Francisco-mayor Willie Brown, City and Washington DC on 9/11/01.
Ashcroft then-San-Francisco-mayor Willie Brown, City and Washington DC on 9/11/01.
Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, author Salman NORAD head Richard Eberhart and JCS Chairman
Rushdie, and a group of top Pentagon officials. Myers were promoted after the attack.
Over tenfold increases in put options on the stocks The Bush administration stalled the creation of a
of the two airlines used in the attack -- American special commission for over 400 days. [54]
Airlines and United Airlines -- were recorded in George W. Bush initially named as head of the
the week before the attack. [51] commission coup and cover-up architect Henry
CEOs from the World Trade Center attended a Kissinger, but he declined to serve to maintain the
breakfast meeting hosted by billionaire Warren secrecy of his client list. [55] The figurehead chairs
Buffett at Ofutt Air Force Base in Nebraska on the of the commission would be Thomas Kean and Lee
day of the attack. Hamilton, both with ties to the Dept. of Homeland
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld disclosed on Security, but the actual work of the Commission
the eve of the attack that $2.3 trillion in was directed by Philip Zelikow, a Bush
transactions was unaccounted for, burying the administration insider.
scandal in the shadow of 9/11.
No Evidence Against Suspects
Complicit Behavior
Officials have produced no evidence linking the
Top officials behaved in a complicit manner during supposed perpetrators to the attack.
the attack.
The December 2001 bin Laden confession video is
President Bush remained seated in a televised, an obvious fraud. [56]
known location (reading "My Pet Goat" with Not a single suspect has been convicted for
second-graders) long after being informed that the involvement in the attack either in the United
country was under attack. States or abroad. [57] FBI director Mueller admitted
Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Richard Myers that "not a single piece of paper" linked the
remained in a meeting with Max Cleland as the officially named suspects to the attack. [58]
attack unfolded. [52]
Brig. Gen. Montague Winfield reported that "For
30 minutes we couldn't find" Defense Secretary
Donald Rumsfeld. [53]
Montague Winfield, National Military Command
Center commander, arranged for Capt. Leidig, a
rookie on the job, to relieve him of duty at 8:30
The Osama in the video released on 12/7/01 by the
AM on 9/11/01. Winfield returned to his command Pentagon (left) has a different facial structure that
post after the attack was over. the Osama pictured in earlier media reports (right).
Conclusion
Others have pointed out that the Popular Mechanics article is full of errors and sloppy analysis. While I
agree, I believe that the article's shoddiness is engineered to achieve certain ends -- such as drawing
attention toward red-herring issues. For example, PM is unpersuasive in debunking the Pentagon no-
jetliner theories and the Flight 93 shoot-down claim. The sloppiness is apparently part of PM's strategy of
setting up and attacking straw-man arguments: It leaves some its straw men relatively unmolested,
presumably because they have value in distracting from the facts that conclusively refute the official story.
presumably because they have value in distracting from the facts that conclusively refute the official story.
Popular Mechanics may have elevated the straw-man argument to a sophistication never before seen,
wherein specious arguments are nested within specious claims. The entire article is a kind of straw man
because it addresses only physical evidence topics while ignoring other bodies of evidence. Of the four
topics, one is a likely a hoax, and the other is incidential to the falsity of the official story. The other two
topics contain a mix of valid and specious claims, and the valid claims are attacked with false, deceptive,
and straw-man arguments.
References
[1] 9/11: Debunking the Myths, Popular Mechanics, [28] Video Evidence of an Explosion at the Base of WTC 1,
http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/defense/1227842.html?page WhatReallyHappened.com,
[2] The Twin Towers' Demolition, 911research.wtc7.net, http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/shake.html
http://911research.wtc7.net/talks/towers/index.html [29] Videos Show Building 7's Vertical Collapse, wtc7.net,
[3] Military Now Notified Immediately of Unusual Air Traffic http://www.wtc7.net/videos.html
Events, AP, 8/12/02, http://www.wanttoknow.info/020812ap [30] Progressive Collapse, 911research.wtc7.net,
http://911research.wtc7.net/disinfo/collapse/progressive.html
[4] Revealed: the men with stolen identities, telegraph.co.uk,
9/23/01 [31] Governor Pataki, Acting Governor DiFrancesco Laud
Historic Port Authority Agreement to Privatize World
[5] Hijack 'suspects' alive and well, BBC, 9/23/01,
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1559151.stm Trade Center, Port Authority on NY & NJ, 7/24/01,
http://www.panynj.gov/pr/pressrelease.php3?id
[6] Dead Saudi Hijack Suspect Resurfaces, Denies Involvement,
AllAfrica.com, 9/24/01, http://allafrica.com/stories/200109240325.html [32] Reinsurance Companies Wait to Sort Out Cost of
Damage, New York Times, 9/12/01, p C6
[7] 'Suicide hijacker' is an airline pilot alive and well in Jeddah,
Independent.co.uk, 9/17/01, [33] Double Indemnity, law.com, 9/3/02,
http://news.independent.co.uk/world/middle_east/story.jsp?story http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id
[8] Manager: Men spewed anti-American sentiments, AP, 9/14/01, [34] Secrecy surrounds a Bush brother's role in 9/11 security,
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2001/09/14/miami-club.htm SmirkingChimp.com, 1/20/03,
http://www.smirkingchimp.com/article.php?sid
[9] Timeline in Terrorist Attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, Washington
Post, 9/12/01, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp- [35] Heightened Security Alert Had Just Been Lifted,
srv/nation/articles/timeline.html NYNewsday.com, 9/12/01,
http://www.nynewsday.com/news/local/manhattan/wtc/ny-
[10] 'I Thought It Was the Start of World War III', Cape Cod nyaler122362178sep12,0,6794009.story
Times, 8/21/02,
http://www.capecodonline.com/cctimes/archives/2002/aug/21/ithought21.htm [36] The Pentagon attack, http://oilempire.us/pentagon.html/>
[11] CHAIRMAN OF THE JOINT CHIEFS OF STAFF [37] The Pentagon No-757-Crash Theory: Booby Trap for
INSTRUCTION, J-3 CJCSI 3610.01A, 6/1/01, 9/11 Skeptics, 911research.wtc7.net,
http://www.dtic.mil/doctrine/jel/cjcsd/cjcsi/3610_01a.pdf http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/pentagontrap.html
[12] The 9/11 Stand-Down Why there was NOT a 'stand down' [38] Pentagon Attack Errors, 911review.com,
order, OilEmpire.us, http://www.oilempire.us/standdown.html http://911review.com/errors/pentagon/index.html
[13] CITIZENS' COMPLAINT AND PETITION TO ATTORNEY [39] Pentagon Plane Crash Photos, GeofMetcalf.com,
http://www.geoffmetcalf.com/pentagon/pentagon_20020316.html
GENERAL OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK FOR
INDEPENDENT GRAND JURY INVESTIGATION, [40] Timeline in Terrorist Attacks of Sept. 11, 2001,
JusticeFor911/org, 10/28/04, Washington Post, 9/12/01, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
http://www.justicefor911.org/Original_Complaint_10-28-04NY.php srv/nation/articles/timeline.html
[14] FAA Managers Destroyed 9/11 Tape, the Washington Post, [41] DCANG Yanks its Mission Statement,
5/6/04, p www.washingtonpost.com, http://911review.com/coverup/dcang.html
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A6632-2004May6.html [42] Pentagon, a Vulnerable Building, Was Hit in Least
[15] The 9/11 Commission Report: Omissions and Distortions, Vulnerable Spot, Los Angeles Times, 9/16/01,
Olive Branch Press, 2004, p 20 http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-
091601pentagon,0,2818328.story
[16] Photographic Evidence of the Twin Tower Collapses,
911Research.wtc7.net, [43] Navy Command Center, The Washington Post
http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/index.html [44] A Trainee Noted for Incompetence, New York Times, p
[17] Video Evidence of the Twin Tower Collapses, 10, http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res
911Research.wtc7.net, [45] Investigators locate 'black box' from Flight 93; widen
http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/videos/index.html search area in Somerset crash, post-gazette.com, 9/13/01,
[18] Explosives Planted In Towers, N.M. Tech Expert Says, http://post-gazette.com/headlines/20010913somersetp3.asp
9/11/01, http://www.911truth.org/readingroom/whole_document.php? [46] Cleveland Newschannel 5, 9/11/01
article_id
[46] Cleveland Newschannel 5, 9/11/01
article_id
[47] Pittsburgh Post Gazette, 9/12/01
[19] VP Van Romero Named Chairman of Domestic Preparedness
Consortium, NMT, [48] Cleveland Newschannel 5, 9/11/01
http://infohost.nmt.edu/mainpage/news/2002/11jan05.html [49] WPXI Channel 11, 9/13/01
[20] Wall Street Journal Names Tech 'Hot School', NMT, [50] St. Petersberg Times, 9/12/01
http://infohost.nmt.edu/mainpage/news/2001/wsj.html
[21] New Mexico Tech Vice President Romero Named a Top [51] Suppressed Details of Criminal Insider Trading Lead
Lobbyist, NMT, Directly Into the CIA's Highest Ranks,
http://infohost.nmt.edu/mainpage/news/2003/18dec01.html FromTheWilderness.com,
http://www.fromthewilderness.com/free/ww3/10_09_01_krongard.html
[22] Tech Receives $15 M for Anti-Terrorism Program, NMT,
http://infohost.nmt.edu/mainpage/news/2002/25sept03.html [52] US Armed Forces Radio and Television Service,
10/17/01, http://www.dtic.mil/jcs/chairman/AFRTS_Interview.htm
[23] How the World Trade Center fell, BBC, 9/13/01,
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/1540044.stm [53] Rumsfeld and Bush Failed Us on Sept. 11, Los Angeles
Times, 8/13/04,
[24] The World Trade Center Demolition, 911research.wtc7.net,
http://www.gailsheehy.com/9_11/9_11_art8_13.html
http://911research.wtc7.net/talks/wtc/index.html
[25] Fire Resistance of Steel Framed Car Parks, [54] The Great Conspiracy, 2004
corusconstruction.com, [55] Thomas Kean named to 9/11 panel, 12/16/2002,
http://www.corusconstruction.com/carparks/cp006.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/2002-12-16-kean_x.htm
[26] Speed of Fall:Meaning of the Seismic Records, [56] Waking Up From Our Nightmare: The 9/11/01 Crimes in
911Research.wtc7.net, New York City, I/R Press, p i,
http://911Research.wtc7.net/wtc/analysis/collapses/freefall.html#seismic http://www.wtc7.net/store/books/wakingup/
[27] North Tower Collapse Video Frames, 911Research.wtc7.net, [57] 9/11 suspect in Germany released, MSNBC.com, 4/7/04,
http://911Research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/videos/ntc_frames.html ttp://msnbc.msn.com/id/4683144/
[58] Robert S. Mueller, III, Director, FBI, Commonwealth
Club of California, FBI.gov,
http://www.fbi.gov/pressrel/speeches/speech041902.htm