- Black Holes Today
- Physics - Reflection Paper.docx
- 143061
- The Bekenstein bound, topological quantum field theory and pluralistic quantum field theory - Lee Smolin
- A J Janca- So you want to stop time
- J. Richard Gott, III and Li-Xin Li- Can the Universe Create Itself?
- mos depression and black holes
- Distributional SAdS BH spacetime-induced vacuum dominance 3ДОМRED1349769084-SDI Paper Template 2003
- UT Dallas Syllabus for phys5392.501.07s taught by Wolfgang Rindler (rindler)
- Borun D. Chowdhury- The Dynamics of Non-Extremal Black Holes
- Novel Remarks on Point Mass Sources, Firewalls, Null Singularities and Gravitational Entropy
- wheeler.pdf
- curriculum vitae sumanta chakraborty
- Roberto Emparan- Einstein in Mordor: Black Rings in Hi-D General Relativity
- astronomy notes
- 1028-2254-1-PB
- 2.pdf
- Lindsay Et Al-1995-Journal of Geophysical Research- Space Physics (1978-2012)
- Eric-Davis-2005.pdf
- How Einstein's Theories of Relativity Define Our Universe
- Quantization Book
- Physics - Viewpoint_ the First Sounds of Merging Black Holes
- Physics Document
- Filter Performance Comparisons for Some Common Nebulae
- NASA: 98-051
- End of Universe
- National Academies Press opens huge PDF library to free access
- Yet Another Proof That Event Horizon Is a Physical Singularity Implying Gravitational Mass of Black Hole=0
- Physical Time and Space In General Relativity
- Philosophical Aspects of Modern Cosmology
- Some Facts About Much Hyped Gravitational Waves
- Concept of Matter In Ancient Indian Philosophy
- EINSTEINIAN REVOLUTION'S MISINTERPRETATION: NO TRUE BLACK HOLES, NO INFORMATION PARADOX: JUST QUASI-STATIC BALLS OF QUARK GLUON PLASMA
- Event Horizon Is Detectable in General Relativity Contrary To the Propaganda of Black Hole Paradigm: Solution BH Mass M=0
- Music On ``Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Object'' Conceived By Abhas Mitra
- Why All Big Bang Models Correspond To Vacuum Solutions & Why Big Bang Should Be A Mathematical Illusion
- The RISE & Fall of Theoretical Physics
- Dr Pierre Marie Robitaille Claims That So-called Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation is of Non-cosmological Origin
- THE MODEL OF OPPENHEIMER AND SNYDER OF A COLLAPSING STAR
- Quantum Leap by Indian Scientists
- On Alternative Theories of Cosmolgies
- Cosmic Conundrums by Joseph Silk : New Scientist
- BLACK HOLES OR ETERNALLY COLLAPSING OBJECTS: A REVIEW OF 90 YEARS OF MISCONCEPTIONS
- Fractal geometry as the synthesis of Hindu cosmology in Kandariya Mahadev temple, Khajuraho
- Large Scale Galaxy Distribution Indicates a Fractal Dimension of Around 2
- Indian Math developed ZERO to describe God and the Universe
- Quantum Gravity For Dummies
- Towards a Self Organizing Universe
- This Indian Physicist Disproved Black Hole 13 Years Before Hawking : INDIA TODAY
- ``This Bengali Physicist Disproved Black Holes 13 Years Before Hawking''
- Fractal World: A World of Worlds
- An Innocuous Modification of General Relativity May Resolve The Galactic Dark Matter Paradox
- The Concept of Brahman in Hindu Philosophy
- Accelerating expansion or inhomogeneity? A comparison of the ΛCDM and Lemaˆıtre – Tolman models
- BICEP2 Has NOT Confirmed Cosmic Inflation
- The Truth Is Still Out There By PAUL GINSPARG: New York Times: August 3, 2004
- Sum of Principal Pressures Could Be The Gravitational Energy Density in General Relativity

)

In 2010, I received an invitation from Elsevier for writing an article on my research for their Electronic Science Portal http://www.scitopics.com/. It is then that, I put up an article "Eternally Collapsing Object" in SciTopics. However, few days back, I received another email from Elsevier that they are going to wind up or rather lock up SciTopics, and the contributors would not be able to edit their articles after Oct. 31, 2011. Then at the eleventh hour, I thought I would do some minor final updating for this article; but in hurry, I pressed the "delete" button, and it got lost for ever. I found that it had received more than 1100 hits in the past 18 months and got disappointed in not being able to retrieve it. Nonetheless, now I find that, the article is still available in google cache, though shorn off its link to SciTopics. -Here, I reproduce the body of this article from google cache: ---------------ETERNALLY COLLAPSING OBJECT-------------------------------An ``Eternally Collapsing Object'' (ECO) is a hot ball of ultra-compact self-gravitating plasma. It is so compact that even photons and neutrinos tend to move in closed circular orbits within it and find it extremely difficult to escape out of its gravitational clutch. The preceding compactification process renders it so hot that the associated radiation pressure (almost) counters the pull of self-gravity to help it remain in a quasi-static state. In a very strict sense, however, the object is always radiating and contracting at an infinitesimal rate and is striving to asymptotically attain the true Black Hole (BH) state. This is the reason behind the epithet ``eternally collapsing''. This degree of ultra-compactness of an ECO is expressed by the fact that its surface gravitational red-shift z »1. In contrast, the Sun has z ~ 2x10 -6, a typical White Dwarf has z~2x 10 -5 -10 -4 and a Neutron Star has z~ 0.15. On the other hand, a Schwarzschild/Hilbert Black Hole (BH) has z=∞ The radius of an ECO is practically equal to that of a supposed Black Hole of same mass: i.e., R=R s=2GM/c 2, the Schwarzschild/Hilbert radius. In view of the fact that an ECO has z»1, to a far away observer, it resembles a BH in many respects and accordingly it is a proposed alternative to the concept of a `Black Hole'. Despite such apparent similarities with a BH, there are important differences between an ECO and a finite mass Black Hole: 1. All matter in a static Black Hole is believed to be concentrated in a point like central singularity where both density ρ=∞ and the tidal gravitational field or the Kretshmann scalar K=∞. Otherwise, the region of the BH extending up to the Event Horizon (R=R s) is empty and without any matter or radiation. In contrast, as mentioned in the beginning, an ECO is filled

with plasma and radiation. Further though both ρ and K could be very high for an ECO, they are finite and there is no physical singularity. 2. Also unlike a Black Hole, an ECO has a physical surface at R≈R s. But unlike a Neutron Star, the ECO surface is soft rather than hard. Consequently matter falling onto an ECO just merges with the pre-existing plasma without generating much accretion luminosity or Type I X-ray bursts. 3. A neutral Black Hole has no intrinsic magnetic moment. In contrast, an ECO being an ultracomprssed astrophysical plasma, must have strong intrinsic magnetic field. Accordingly, a spinning ECO behaves like an extremely relativistic pulsar though steep spacetime curvature around the ECO obliterates the intrinsic pulsations. A spinning ECO is likely to have a magnetosphere and is thus often mentioned as ``Magnetospheric ECO'' or ``MECO''. The term ``ECO'' was first coined by the Indian astrophysicist Abhas Mitra in 1998 though the idea of ECO got developed later. In particular, American astrophysicists Stanley Robertson, Darryl Leiter, Rudy Schild and Norman K. Glendenning too contributed to the developments of the idea of an ECO. An ECO may also be considered as an extremely relativistic version of a Radiation Pressure Supported Star (RPSS) first conceived by Hoyle and Fowler in 1963. In 2006, Mitra showed that if one would allow the RPSSs to be extremely relativistic, i.e., z>>1, then radiation pressure supported stars are possible for arbitrary mass, high or low. In 2010, Mitra and Glendenning showed that , during continued collapse, as a massive collapsing star would enter its photon sphere (z> √3 -1) in its attempt to form a true Black Hole with z=∞, it would start trapping its own radiation in a dramatic fashion as ~(1+z) 2 . As a result, a stage will be arrived at an appropriate high z»1, where trapped radiation flux would attain its Eddington Value and the collapse would degenerate into an eternal quasistatic contraction. This above mentioned concept of an ECO is based only on standard General Relativitstic ingredients such as radiation trapping & Vaidya metric and the astrophysical concept of an ``Eddington Luminosity''. Since no new assumption/hypothesis is invoked at all, the concept of an ECO is no new theory, either mainstream or fringe! However, this concept of an ECO got strengthened by the following later theoretical developments: First, radiative gravitational collapse avoids trapped surface formation (Mitra 2009a), i.e., the ECO surface radius R(t)≥R s(t) even though both R (t) and R s(t) are shrinking ever. As a result an ECO always hovers just above its Schwarzschild/Hilbert radius and never plunges within the same.

Further there is an independent exact mathematical proof that the true Black Holes have necessarily zero gravitational mass (Mitra 2009b). This means that the so-called Black Hole candidates (or anything else with a finite mass) cannot be true Black Holes. Thus the concept of an ECO with z»1 and which is eternally contracting and radiating to attain a true Black Hole state having z=∞ and M=0 actually provides the missing link between the formation of a photon-sphere and a true Event Horizon. Note, the fact that M=0 for a true BH means that K~M -4 =∞ at the EH. And this resolves the century old mystery: why acceleration blows up at the EH and nothing can escape out of the EH. In addition, it has also been shown recently that the Active Gravitational Mass Density of a quasistatic sphere decreases rather than increases with its pressure p; ρ g = ρ3p/c 2 (Mitra2010). Therefore as an ECO would tend to become a perfect ball of radiation with p=(1/3)ρ c 2and z=∞, its ρ g= ρ -3p/c 2.→0, so that its gravitational mass M→0 in perfect accordance with the result that a true Black Hole has z=∞ and M=0. Hence, contrary to the likely misinterpretation, the concept of an ECO is actually in perfect conformity with the exact solution for a Schwarzschild/Hilbert Black Hole. The mean local temperature of an ECO is T≈600 MeV (M/M solar) -1/2. This means that stellar mass ECOs are so hot that the neutrons and protons with it are in the molten Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP) state. In fact Schild, Leiter and Robertson have already provided strong evidence that the central compact object s of the well studied quasars Q0957+561 and Q2237+0305 have strong intrinsic magnetic moment implying lthem to be ECOs rather than true Black Holes. Preliminary numerical computations of Cuesta, Salim and Santos have indicated that the collapse of a Newtonian supermassive star is likely to form an ECO rather than a true Black Hole. FURTHER READINGS:

Cuesta H.J.M., Salim J.M., Santos N.O., 2005. 100 Years of Relativity, Sao Paulo, Brazil, CBPF-NF-011/05 (Link ») Mitra A. & Glendenning N.K. (2006), A Secular Quark Gluon Plasma Preceding the Black Hole Formulation, Lawrence Berkley National Lab. Preprint No. . LBNL-59320 (Link ») Mitra, A. & Glendenning, N.K. (2010). Likely formation of general relativistic radiation pressure supported stars or eternally collapsing objects. MNRAS Lett. , 404(1), L50-L54, (arXiv:1003.3518) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2005). Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Objects: Likely New Class of Source of Cosmic Particle Acceleration. Proc. 29th Int. Cos. Ray Conf. OG. Vol 3, :125128; (arXiv:physics/ 0506183) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2006a). Radiation pressure supported stars in Einstein gravity: eternally collapsing objects. MNRAS, 369: 492-496, (arXiv:gr-qc/0603055) (Link »)

Mitra, A. (2006b). Sources of stellar energy, Einstein Eddington timescale of gravitational contraction and eternally collapsing objects. New Astronomy, 12( 2): 146160; (arXiv:astro-ph/0608178) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2006c). Why gravitational contraction must be accompanied by emission of radiation in both Newtonian and Einstein gravity. Physical Review D, 74(2): 024010; (arXiv:gr-qc/0605066) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2006d). On the non-occurrence of Type I X-ray bursts from the black hole candidates. Advances in Space Research, Volume 38(12,): 2917-2919; (arXiv:astroph/0510162) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2006e). A Generic Relationship Between Baryonic and Radiative Energy Densities of Stars. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. (Lett.), 367: L66-69 (gr-qc/0601025) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2006f). Black Holes or Eternally Collapsing Objects: A Review of 90 Years of Misconceptions' ' in Focus on Black Hole Research , (Nova Science, New York, 2006) ; Invited Book Chapter, 1-94 (Link ») Mitra, A. (2006g)., Masses of radiation pressure supported stars in extreme relativistic realm. Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union (2006), 2:409- 410 Cambridge University Press (Link ») Mitra, A. (2009a). Quantum Information Paradox: Real or Fictitious? Pramana, 73(3): 615 (arXiv:0911.3584) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2009b). Comments on ``The Euclidean gravitational action as black hole entropy, singularities, and space-time voids [J. Math. Phys. 49, 042501 (2008) . J. Math. Phys. 50(4): 042502.( arXiv:0904.4754) (Link ») Mitra, A. (2010). Does Pressure Increase or Decrease Active Gravitational Mass? Phys. Lett. B., 685(1): 8-11 Robertson, S.L. and Leiter D., (2002). Evidence for Intrinsic Magnetic Moments in Black Hole Candidates. Astrophys. J., 565: 447 (Link ») Robertson, S.L. and Leiter D., (2004). On the origin of the universal radio- X-ray luminosity correlation in black hole candidates. MNRAS, 350: 1391 (Link ») Robertson, S.L., and Leiter D., (2003). On Intrinsic Magnetic Moments in Black Hole Candidates. Astrophys. J. Lett., 596: L203 (Link ») Robertson, S.L., and Leiter D., (2003). Does Sgr A* Have an Intrinsic Magnetic Moment Instead of an Event Horizon? Journal of Cosmology: Vol 6, 1438-1472. (Link ») Schild, R.E., Leiter, D.J. (2010).Black Hole or MECO? Decided by a Thin Luminous Ring Structure Deep Within Quasar Q0957. Journal of Cosmology: Vol 6, 1400 – 1437. (Link ») Schild, R.E., Leiter, D.J., and Robertson S.L., (2006). Observations Supporting the Existence of an Intrinsic Magnetic Moment inside the Central Compact Object within the Quasar Q0957+ 561. Astron. J. 132: 420 (Link ») Schild, R.E., Leiter, D.J., and Robertson S.L., (2008). Direct MicrolensingReverberation Observations of the Intrinsic Magnetic Structure of Active Galactic Nuclei in Different Spectral States: A Tale of Two Quasars. Astron. J., 135(3): 947 (Link »)

SELECTED LINKS:

Harvard Press Release on MECO Nature India Science News on the Mathematical Proof that true black holes have M= 0 Preliminary numerical computation on ECO formation Nature India Science News: Black Holes or Balls of Quark Gluon Plasma? World Science: No black holes after all?

- Black Holes TodayUploaded byanishvancha
- Physics - Reflection Paper.docxUploaded byDaniele Talens Caguiat
- 143061Uploaded bykoluchaw
- The Bekenstein bound, topological quantum field theory and pluralistic quantum field theory - Lee SmolinUploaded byjottavhe
- A J Janca- So you want to stop timeUploaded byHerftez
- J. Richard Gott, III and Li-Xin Li- Can the Universe Create Itself?Uploaded byRtpom
- mos depression and black holesUploaded byapi-272820468
- Distributional SAdS BH spacetime-induced vacuum dominance 3ДОМRED1349769084-SDI Paper Template 2003Uploaded byLuke Lee
- UT Dallas Syllabus for phys5392.501.07s taught by Wolfgang Rindler (rindler)Uploaded byUT Dallas Provost's Technology Group
- Borun D. Chowdhury- The Dynamics of Non-Extremal Black HolesUploaded byJuazmant
- Novel Remarks on Point Mass Sources, Firewalls, Null Singularities and Gravitational EntropyUploaded byKathryn Wilson
- wheeler.pdfUploaded bykheck349598
- curriculum vitae sumanta chakrabortyUploaded byapi-288987327
- Roberto Emparan- Einstein in Mordor: Black Rings in Hi-D General RelativityUploaded byHuntsmith
- astronomy notesUploaded byapi-319058430
- 1028-2254-1-PBUploaded byTatjana Barthes
- 2.pdfUploaded byIra Agcaoili
- Lindsay Et Al-1995-Journal of Geophysical Research- Space Physics (1978-2012)Uploaded byCarlos Marín
- Eric-Davis-2005.pdfUploaded byTop Secret Antigravity Technology
- How Einstein's Theories of Relativity Define Our UniverseUploaded byjemoqcca
- Quantization BookUploaded byfunkee08
- Physics - Viewpoint_ the First Sounds of Merging Black HolesUploaded bybibbiblos
- Physics DocumentUploaded byGaurav Kundnani
- Filter Performance Comparisons for Some Common NebulaeUploaded byJim Aldous
- NASA: 98-051Uploaded byNASAdocuments
- End of UniverseUploaded bypascualangulo5424
- National Academies Press opens huge PDF library to free accessUploaded bySyncOrSwim

- Yet Another Proof That Event Horizon Is a Physical Singularity Implying Gravitational Mass of Black Hole=0Uploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Physical Time and Space In General RelativityUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Philosophical Aspects of Modern CosmologyUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Some Facts About Much Hyped Gravitational WavesUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Concept of Matter In Ancient Indian PhilosophyUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- EINSTEINIAN REVOLUTION'S MISINTERPRETATION: NO TRUE BLACK HOLES, NO INFORMATION PARADOX: JUST QUASI-STATIC BALLS OF QUARK GLUON PLASMAUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Event Horizon Is Detectable in General Relativity Contrary To the Propaganda of Black Hole Paradigm: Solution BH Mass M=0Uploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Music On ``Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Object'' Conceived By Abhas MitraUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Why All Big Bang Models Correspond To Vacuum Solutions & Why Big Bang Should Be A Mathematical IllusionUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- The RISE & Fall of Theoretical PhysicsUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Dr Pierre Marie Robitaille Claims That So-called Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation is of Non-cosmological OriginUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- THE MODEL OF OPPENHEIMER AND SNYDER OF A COLLAPSING STARUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Quantum Leap by Indian ScientistsUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- On Alternative Theories of CosmolgiesUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Cosmic Conundrums by Joseph Silk : New ScientistUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- BLACK HOLES OR ETERNALLY COLLAPSING OBJECTS: A REVIEW OF 90 YEARS OF MISCONCEPTIONSUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Fractal geometry as the synthesis of Hindu cosmology in Kandariya Mahadev temple, KhajurahoUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Large Scale Galaxy Distribution Indicates a Fractal Dimension of Around 2Uploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Indian Math developed ZERO to describe God and the UniverseUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Quantum Gravity For DummiesUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Towards a Self Organizing UniverseUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- This Indian Physicist Disproved Black Hole 13 Years Before Hawking : INDIA TODAYUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- ``This Bengali Physicist Disproved Black Holes 13 Years Before Hawking''Uploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Fractal World: A World of WorldsUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- An Innocuous Modification of General Relativity May Resolve The Galactic Dark Matter ParadoxUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- The Concept of Brahman in Hindu PhilosophyUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Accelerating expansion or inhomogeneity? A comparison of the ΛCDM and Lemaˆıtre – Tolman modelsUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- BICEP2 Has NOT Confirmed Cosmic InflationUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- The Truth Is Still Out There By PAUL GINSPARG: New York Times: August 3, 2004Uploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- Sum of Principal Pressures Could Be The Gravitational Energy Density in General RelativityUploaded byDr Abhas Mitra