You are on page 1of 2

AvondaleAvondale-Waterview Historical Society Incorporated

January—February 2013 No. 61 Prepared by Lisa Truttman, President and Editor

Guest Speakers
February: Bruce Harvey, author of a number of books on West Auckland, will talk to us on the wreck of the HMS Orpheus (1863) at the Manukau Heads. Next year marks the 150th anniversary of the disaster.

trigger further consideration rather than protection (vii) The Whau Local Board is concerned that past local heritage planning in the Roberton Road area, Avondale has not been brought into the Unitary Plan and urgently requires further consideration in the overlays.” I do urge AWHS members to be aware of the start of public submissions on the Unitary Plan from March this year — and to make submissions on the points raised in the plan. If we want to see a reasonable but real level of protection for our city’s heritage, now is the time to get involved.

Auckland Council Unitary Plan
Further to my report in the last newsletter, I was given an opportunity to submit my feedback to the Whau Local Board via Mark Allen, Senior Local Board Adviser, on 14 November (day of the eclipse of the sun). I sincerely thank Mark for taking the time to listen to my concerns, that was very much appreciated. In response, I received a copy of the Whau Local Board’s feedback summary for the Unitary Plan proposals. Here is the heritage section of their feedback. “On the Historic Heritage and Historic Character Package that: (i) The Whau Local Board agree with rolling over existing schedules (ii) Note that urgent work needs to be done checking Category C/3 buildings and to identify other potential sites (iii) Current approaches for notification with regard to heritage are too limited so for example demolition should be notified (iv) The Cultural Heritage Inventory is a best practice and must be referenced in the Unitary plan to be taken account of when considering developments and notification (v) More work is needed on defining character areas and that Council need to provide adequate resourcing to enable this to be progressed (vi) The Whau Local Board is concerned with a blanket age protection approach around access to aerial photographs and suggest instead that age should

WLB Heritage Group meetings
The Local Board have initiated meetings between staff, Board heritage portfolio holders, and representatives of the three historical societies in the area — AWHS, Blockhouse Bay HS and West Auckland HS. A meeting scheduled for 15 November didn’t eventuate (I was the only one to turn up from the historical societies), so another meeting is now planned for 22 January.

Information Stall at Avondale Community Centre, 10 November
This went fairly well. One new member, lots of chat and conversation (I hurriedly put together a photo display), the reduced 1/3 sheet brochure I quickly printed was picked up by passers by, and we may have a future guest speaker.

What’s in a name? Saxon to Kuaka Reserve
At the AWHS meeting in December last year, a few came up to me remarking on the renaming of Saxon Reserve, a piece of green space at the corner of Saxon Street and Oakley Avenue, to Kuaka Reserve. I was also surprised that the name Kuaka had been chosen by the Albert-Eden Local Board, considering the strength of the ties of the Goodwin family (who owned part of the now-enlarged reserve, land fronting Alford Street) for much of the last century (see Tony Goodwin’s article in the last Avondale Historical Journal.) [over page]

Next meeting: Saturday 2 February 2013, 2.30 pm St Ninians Church St Georges Road, opposite Hollywood Cinema

Well, they officially opened the renamed reserve in December — and I went looking through the agendas of the local board to find out how the name Kuaka got into the mix. Eleven iwi had been contacted. According to the report submitted to the local board (5 September 2012), eight didn't respond, one was “happy for other iwi to do it”, and "two, Ngati Whatua and Ngati Te Ata-Waiohua, wrote back in support of a nonancestral name, and suggested ‘Kuaka’. This refers to the Bar-tailed Godwit (Limosa laponica), which has been a traditionally valuable food source for Maori. Kuaka is well documented as a champion long-haul migratory species that flies over this part of the Waitemata Harbour en route to the Kaipara Harbour, before returning to its breeding sites around the China Sea, and in Kamchatka and Alaska." The choices presented to the public on voting papers were therefore these: Oakley Park: “The original name given to the park when it was gifted to the Crown in 1922.” (True — due to the adjoining Oakley Avenue.) Saxon Reserve: “The existing name of the park. The original name of Oakley Park was changed to avoid confusion with nearby Oakley Creek Reserve. There is no historical significance attached to this name.” (Except, of course, that a lot of folks in Waterview knew the original reserve by this name, and Saxon Street is right there.) Goodwin Reserve: “Mr John Goodwin and his descendants owned the land that was recently purchased by NZTA to enlarge the park since 1907.” Kuaka Reserve: “Kuaka is the Maori name for the Godwit, a wading bird that migrates to Waterview from Alaska every year. This bird was a valuable food source for Maori and can still be seen over our summer months feeding in the nearby intertidal zones.” According to “Populations of the godwit embark on some of the longest migrations known among birds. They start arriving here in New Zealand about mid–September and disperse throughout the country including the Chatham Islands. They flock in a few favoured places, including the Firth of Thames and Ohiwa Harbour. They leave New Zealand in March and early April and arrive in the northern hemisphere in May and early June.” The godwit is therefore not specific to Waterview — if anything, it has and has had more to do with the Manukau and Kaipara Harbours. One might as well have suggested any other NZ bird name — it would have had just as much local relevance. Now, not that I'm against Maori names on our landscape -- I tried to get the Avondale Community Board to go with "Motu Manawa Place" instead of "Jomac Place" on Rosebank a few years back. But when only two iwi responded with a suggestion (one of which simply backed the other), and more people connected with Waterview or that particular piece of land responded saying they either wanted no change, or the name Goodwin if there had to be a change ... we are now left with a generic name for a reserve. I challenge anyone to tell me godwits landed there, when they're more likely to have headed for the shellbanks of Motu Manawa Reserve. “Kuaka” is more a Rosebank heritage name, rather than Waterview. At the 11 August community open day to put in votes for a name for the reserve, there were only 22 votes cast: Oakley Park (2 votes), Saxon Reserve (6 votes), Goodwin Park (8 votes) [five family members voted, as the staff noted], Kuaka Reserve (4 votes), Taylor Park (2 votes) [another former land owner family], and Goodwin-Taylor Park (1 vote). According to the Council staff's report: "The fact that local community feedback from the 11 August open day produced 23 responses indicates a lack of broad community support or concern for a specific name. The Local Board may wish to regard this as evidence in support of no change, or it may decide in favour of one of the names voted on at the open day." And so, as I said earlier, the Albert-Eden Local Board decided to go with Kuaka Reserve. Farewell, Saxon Reserve — it was nice to have known you.