In SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) conventional wisdom has it that the probability of direct
contact by interstellar travel is vanishingly small due to the enormous distances involved, coupled with the
velocity-of- light limitation. Alcubierre's recent "warp drive" analysis [Class. Quantum Grav. 11, L 73
(1994)] wit hin the context of general relativistic dynamics, however, indicates the naivete of this
assumption. We show here that Alcubierre's result is a particular case of a broad, general approach that
might loosely be called "metric engineering," the details of which provide yet further support for the
concept that reduced-time interstellar travel, either by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations at present or
ourselves in the future, is not, as naive consideration might hold, fundamentally constrained by physical
principles.

Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

29 views

In SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) conventional wisdom has it that the probability of direct
contact by interstellar travel is vanishingly small due to the enormous distances involved, coupled with the
velocity-of- light limitation. Alcubierre's recent "warp drive" analysis [Class. Quantum Grav. 11, L 73
(1994)] wit hin the context of general relativistic dynamics, however, indicates the naivete of this
assumption. We show here that Alcubierre's result is a particular case of a broad, general approach that
might loosely be called "metric engineering," the details of which provide yet further support for the
concept that reduced-time interstellar travel, either by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations at present or
ourselves in the future, is not, as naive consideration might hold, fundamentally constrained by physical
principles.

Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

- Convert Csv
- Expt 5 KMnO4 Beers Law
- Physics Eng
- Rules of Engagement 2
- Fuzzy Interface Scheme for Color Sensor System
- Hydrogen ATOM; THE ALTERNATIVE BIG BANG THEORY
- Wonders Cosmic
- Past and future of cosmic topology
- Graviton
- XLamp_EyeSafety
- special relativity ebook
- lrr-2003-4_bw
- Physics_Bookbot_freekidsbooks.pdf
- Basic Physics Second Edition b v2 s1
- Cribsheet 13
- Special Relativity
- VERY - Regular Coordinate Systems for Schwarzschild and Other Spherical Spacetimes
- Class 09th Science Motion Test 02 Answer
- Apple Thesis
- describing motion mi

You are on page 1of 4

(Physics Essays, Vol. 9, No. 1, pp. 156-158, 1996) H.E. Puthoff, Ph.D. Abstract

In SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) conventional wisdom has it that the probability of direct contact by interstellar travel is vanishingly small due to the enormous distances involved, coupled with the velocity-of- light limitation. Alcubierre's recent "warp drive" analysis [Class. Quantum Grav. 11, L 73 (1994)] wit hin the context of general relativistic dynamics, however, indicates the naivete of this assumption. We show here that Alcubierre's result is a particular case of a broad, general approach that might loosely be called "metric engineering," the details of which provide yet further support for the concept that reduced-time interstellar travel, either by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations at present or ourselves in the future, is not, as naive consideration might hold, fundamentally constrained by physical principles. SETI, velocity of light, general relativistic dynamics, space-time metric, interstellar travel, vacuum energy, Casimir effect, vacuum engineering, warp drive, superluminal travel

Key words:

SETI researchers routinely subscribe to the view that interstellar travel between civilizations is exceedingly improbable due to the velocity-of-light limitation, with but few dissenting views offered.(1,2) . Hence there has evolved, on the one hand, the emphasis on searches of the electromagnetic spectrum for information-bearing signals and, on the other, the reasoned dismissal by the scientific community of any evidence purported to be a signature of extraterrestrial visitation. (3) As shown recently by Alcubierre, however, rejection of the concept of hyperfast (superluminal) travel is not justified when one takes into account the possibility of engineered dynamic space-times within the context of general relativity. (4) Specifically, Alcubierre showed by example that by distorting the local space-time metric in the region of a spaceship in a certain prescribed way, it would be possible to achieve motion faster than the speed of light as seen by observers outside the disturbed region, without violating the local velocity-of- light constraint within the region. Furthermore, the Alcubierre solution shows that the proper acceleration along the spaceship's path would be zero and the spaceship would suffer no time dilation, features presumably attractive in interstellar travel. We present here a supporting viewpoint that further explicates the Alcubierre approach as a special case of an overarching concept of metric engineering that can be stated in an especially compact form, fully incorporating general relativistic dynamics. To elaborate the metric engineering perspective, we begin with the apparent velocity-of- light limitation. As a physical concept this limitation is based on the fact that mass and energy find mathematical expression in a form proportional to 1/[l-(v/c)2 ]1/2 , which implies that an infinite amount of energy would be required just to accelerate a mass to the velocity of light v = c. A hidden assumption in the argument

that this constitutes a practical limitation with regard to interstellar travel, however, is the idea that the value c is a fixed, immutable constant of nature, understood in a straightforward, natural way. It is this crucial assumption that is called into question and redefined, however, by the metric engineering approach. In engineering terms the velocity of light in free space c is given by the expression c = 1/(0 0 )1/2 , where in mks units 0 = 4 x 10-7 H/m and 0 = 8.854 x 10-12 F/m, are, respectively, the magnetic permeability and dielectric permittivity of the vacuum. Therefore, the argument that c is fixed is, at base, an argument that 0 and 0 are fixed and not subject to manipulation by technological means. If, on the other hand, these vacuum constants were subject to change such that within a localized region the value c could be made to assume a new value, say c' = 10c, then, without violating the governing equations of physics, travel at speeds greater than the conventional velocity of light would be possible; it is just that a new restriction would apply involving the (elevated) local velocity of light, and travel inside the local light cone would still obtain, a point demonstrated in detail in the Alcubierre example. Although perhaps surprising to the nonspecialist, within the context of general relativity and vacuumenergy physics, such variability of the free space velocity of light c (as seen from a distant frame) under certain conditions has long been part of the literature. For the case of propagation near a massive body, for example, we have a reduction in the velocity of light by an amount proportional to the gravitational potential, a result first noted by Einstein himself. (5) For the case of propagation between closely spaced conducting boundaries as in discussions of the Casimir effect, we have an increase in the velocity of light which is associated with the reduction of vacuum fluctuation energy between the plates. (6) In short, as emphasized by Wesson, the speed of light c is context-dependent and not as fundamental as widely believed.(7) Such variations in c, considered in terms of its subcomponents and , are routinely treated in a compact form that recommends itself for simplicity of concept, the so-called "TH " formalism used in comparative studies of gravitational theories.1 This approach has its foundation in the recognition that the covariant Maxwell equations in a Riemannian space with arbitrary metric are identical in form with the usual vector Maxwell equations for a material medium with variable and , where these parameters are themselves now a function of the metric.(8) This concept can be extended to nonmetric theories as well, and in the TH context goes under the name "gravitationally modified Maxwell equations. "1 The formalism is then completed by casting the Lagrangian for particle motion under the influence of electromagnetic and gravitational fields into a canonical form involving two additional metric-dependent functions, T and H. Such a formalism leads naturally to the concept of metric engineering in which one's familiarity with variable - media can act as an intuitive guide. 3,(8) Although under ordinary conditions effects involving variations in vacuum values of , , and hence c typically are vanishingly small, they nonetheless indicate the possibility under extraordinary conditions of "vacuum engineering," as Nobel Laureate T. D. Lee put it.(9) The Alcubierre warp drive example, which can be reframed within the TH context, is an especially pithy example of such, and additional space-times with desired properties can be derived at will within this context. 4 Therefore, the proper conclusion to be drawn by consideration of engineered metric/vacuum-energy effects is that, with sufficient technological means to appear 'magic" at present (to use Arthur C. Clarke's phrase characterizing a highly advanced, technological civilization), travel at speeds exceeding the conventional velocity of light could occur without the violation of fundamental physical laws. And, we

might add, this could in principle be done without recourse to concepts as extreme as wormhole traversal. (10) (However, clearly, exotic matter/field states, e.g., macroscopic Casimir- like negative-energy-density vacuum states, would be required.) As a result, the possibility of reduced-time interstellar travel, either by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations at present or ourselves in the future, is not fundamentally constrained by physical principles.

Acknowledgment

I wish to acknowledge the Fetzer Institute in Kalamazoo, Michigan, for their support of this work.

Endnotes

1

A.P. Lightman and D. L. Lee, Phys. Rev. D 8, 364 (1973). See also, C. M. Will, Phys. Rep. 113, 345 (1984) for a later overview perspective. Extens ions of the Lightman and Lee approach (point charges interacting classically with electromagnetic and gravitational fields) to include quantum mechanical analysis of atomic clocks and the standard model of fundamental (electroweak and strong) interactions are given in, respectively, C.M. Will, Phys. Rev. D 10, 2330 (1974) and J.E. Horvath, E.A. Logiudice, C. Riveros, and H. Vucetich, Phys. Rev. D 38, 1754 (1988). In the TH approach the functions T and H are introduced by requiring that the Lagrangian for the motion of charged particles under the joint action of gravity and the electromagnetic field Ai be expressed in the canonical form L = Ldt = [ -m0 (T - Hv 2 )1/2 + eAi v i]dt, where T and H, as well as and , are functions of the metric, that is, of a gravitational potential U. For standard theory of interest in this note (a metric theory), the four functions TH are related by = = (H/T)1/2 . Although for ease of application in comparing a broad range of gravitational theories (e.g., scalar, vector, tensor, scalar-tensor, metric, and nonmetric) the required Lagrangian form is typically met by restricting consideration to static, spherically symmetric gravitational fields, Lightman and Lee emphasize that the TH approach is sufficiently general that all the results obtained can be shown to hold "even if U is an arbitrary but time- independent function of position."1 Thus for a well-behaved standard metric type of theory of interest here, generation to nonsymmetric conditions can be carried out on a case-by-case basis without undue difficulty.

For a detailed and explicit discussion of the isomorphisms between variable - media and general relativistic (metric) theories, see R.H. Dicke, Rev. Mod. Phys. 29, 363 (1957). See also as modified and corrected in R. H. Dicke, "Mach's Principle and Equivalence," Proceedings of the Intentional School of Physics "Enrico Fermi" Course XX, Evidence for Gravitational Theories, edited by C. Moller (Academic Press, NY, 196 1), p. 1. A detailed examination of the Alcubierre warp drive example within the TH -type framework is in preparation (to be published).

References

1. T.B.H. Kuiper and M. Morris, Science 196, 616 (1977). 2. J.W. Deardorff, Q. J. R. Astron. Soc. 27, 94 (1986).

3. See, for example, F. Drake and D. Sobel, Is Anyone Out There? The Scientific Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (Delacorte, NY, 1992). 4. M. Alcubierre, Class. Quantum Grav. 11, L73 (1994); see also I.A. Crawford, Q. J. R. Astron. Soc. 36, 205 (1995). 5. A. Einstein, Ann. Phys. 35, 898 (191 1). 6. K. Scharnhorst, Phys. Lett. B 236, 354 (1990). 7. P. Wesson, Space Sci. Rev. 59, 365 (1992). 8. A.M. Volkov, A.A. Izmest'ev, and G.V. Skrotskii, Sov. Phys. JETP 32, 686 (1971). 9. T. D. Lee, Particle Physics and Introduction to Field Theory (Harwood Academic, London, 1988), p. 826. 10. M. Morris, K. Thorne, and U. Yurtsever, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 1446 (1988). H.E. Puthoff Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin 4030 Braker Lane W., #300 Austin, Texas 78759-5329 U.S.A. puthoff@aol.com

- Convert CsvUploaded byWumbo Lo
- Expt 5 KMnO4 Beers LawUploaded byBryan
- Physics EngUploaded byPrasad C M
- Rules of Engagement 2Uploaded byremow
- Fuzzy Interface Scheme for Color Sensor SystemUploaded byijflsjournal
- Hydrogen ATOM; THE ALTERNATIVE BIG BANG THEORYUploaded byidownloadbooks3133
- Wonders CosmicUploaded bysamia2105
- Past and future of cosmic topologyUploaded byjosolaz
- GravitonUploaded byAshwin Balaji
- XLamp_EyeSafetyUploaded bymachinator2
- special relativity ebookUploaded byapi-18367735
- lrr-2003-4_bwUploaded byGonzalez Luis
- Physics_Bookbot_freekidsbooks.pdfUploaded bySridhar Bandi
- Basic Physics Second Edition b v2 s1Uploaded byMuhammad Imran
- Cribsheet 13Uploaded byjorgeheymann
- Special RelativityUploaded byRyo Kinase
- VERY - Regular Coordinate Systems for Schwarzschild and Other Spherical SpacetimesUploaded byahsbon
- Class 09th Science Motion Test 02 AnswerUploaded byGovind Chetty
- Apple ThesisUploaded byjonathanapple
- describing motion miUploaded byapi-207957230
- 1. How BrightUploaded bysurabhi
- guide01.pdfUploaded byKelvin Lee
- Modern PhysicsUploaded byUangi In
- Magnetic TestUploaded byMajid Dawood Khan
- Lab-1.pdfUploaded byFaisal Md A Al
- lightlensmirrors-100212171433-phpapp01Uploaded byAnonymous xagGSId
- Detailed Lesson Plan-JOHNUploaded byCathlyn Joy Ganaden
- fisica4aUploaded byRafael Barnoza
- Principle_of_Local_Conservation_of_Energ.pdfUploaded byshivram Meena
- 12.5-motion-cie_igcse_physics_ext-theory-qp__2_files_merged_ (1).pdfUploaded bysara

- Tesla's Metaphysics and Cosmology (Velimir Abramovic)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- The Essential Nikola Tesla - Peacebuilding EndeavorUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Milka Kresoja - Tesla's Tower, the Biggest Invention of All TimesUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- DISTRIBUTED SOLAR ENERGY IN BRAZIL: FABIO ROSA’S APPROACH TO SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIPUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Tesla Energy Global CooperativeUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Tesla Energy Cooperative - Moscow Economic Forum 2014Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Tesla Memorial Conference 2014Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Gravitation water vortex power plantUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- New Earth Project - The New Earth Tesla AcademyUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- HIGH FREQUENCY PLASMOID IN VORTEX AIRFLOW (A.I. Klimov)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- TECHNOLOGY OF LARGE-SCALE SOLAR ENERGETICSUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- StrebkovUploaded bykmurthy439
- TESLA ENERGY GLOBAL COOPERATIVEUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- The Broadcast Power of Nikola Tesla (Gerry Vassilatos)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Noosphere - The Natural Principles of EducationUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- The Transition From the Biosphere to the NoosphereUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Analysis of Stimulated Electrophotonic Glow of Liquids (Korotkov, K; Orlov, D)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- The Influence of the External Qi of Qigong on the Radioactive Decay Rate of the Radioactive Isotope 241AmUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- An Investigation Into the Human Energy Field (Christopher John Bradshaw)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- 4 Way Analysis of Body Talk Technique on Body and Energy Fields (Abadi, Streeter)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- BIOENERGY, BIOFIELD, AURA - WHAT KIND OF ENERGY THEY ARE, AND WHETHER IT IS POSSIBLE TO MEASURE AND TO VISUELISE THEM (Ljubo M. Ristovski)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Measurement of the Human Biofield and Other Energetic Instruments (Beverly Rubik)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Pulsed Discharge Plasma for Pollution ControlUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Characteristics of Ozonizer Using Pulsed PowerUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- ipi1707.pdfUploaded byHan Arif
- Ozone Generation by Pulsed Streamer Discharge in AirUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Ozone Generation Characteristics Using a Rotating ElectrodeUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Characteristics of Ozone Production by Using Atmospheric Surface Glow Barrier DischargeUploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Dielectric Barrier Discharge, Ozone Generation, And Their Applications (Jose L. Lopez)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE
- Application of Coaxial Dielectric Barrier Discharge for Potable and Waste Water Treatment (M. M. Kuraica)Uploaded byTHE NIKOLA TESLA INSTITUTE

- Diffusion Through a Stagnant Gas FilmUploaded bySuleman Tariq
- Theory of a generalized helmholtz resonator.pdfUploaded byRamondePaoli
- mecanica vectorial para ingenieriaUploaded byxhelass
- 00018892[2] asphaltenesUploaded byropehes
- Dynamic analysis in transverse (horizontal) planeUploaded bymctsou
- Physics TutorialUploaded byhuycuong4326
- lab 12Uploaded byPrinces Katherine Vergara
- Henry AdamsUploaded byIsaúl Ferreira
- Electrostatic paper charges.pdfUploaded bySappi Houston
- Tutorial 2 SolutionsUploaded byMuhammad Anwar
- 12 Physics NcertSolutions Chapter 7 ExercisesUploaded byAbhishek Kukreti
- infrared Characterization of Linkage IsomersUploaded byCarolyn Charles
- Design of Machine Elements ME1302Uploaded bySengottaiyan Malaisamy
- 229254576 RT Formulas for CalculationsUploaded bydanemsal
- pg597Uploaded byrafiee
- Che 0411 Steam Heat Exchangers Are Underworked CopyUploaded byXpizmon
- unit-66-tof-juny (1).docxUploaded byMohammed Rizwan
- RT II QueastionsUploaded byEbin Charles
- Vector Groups of TransformersUploaded byShrikant Kajale
- Procesos Adiabaticos.pdfUploaded byEdder Romero
- Cera to Scale Effects BgafhgfgUploaded byAnkur Ghosh
- Optical fiber a Photonics journal portionUploaded byArone Asadas
- amca.210.1999Uploaded byAlfredo Jara Munar
- coolprop.pdfUploaded byakbarfarraz
- Experiment 1.1.docxUploaded byCasie Robles
- Inverse Problem Gun BarrelUploaded byRodrigo Guedes
- Capacitors that recharge themselvesUploaded bydakkid
- V2I6_IJERTV2IS60650Uploaded byAkhilesh Kumar Mishra
- CrankshaftUploaded byAnirudhreddy Safal
- Thermo Powerpoint Lecture 01Uploaded byRich Garr

## Much more than documents.

Discover everything Scribd has to offer, including books and audiobooks from major publishers.

Cancel anytime.