Planet Debate Politics 1.16.

13 General, Hagel, Guns, Climate, Debt, Citizenship

p. 1 of 62

General – Obama Approval High .................................................................................................................. 3 General – Winners Win ................................................................................................................................ 4 General – Economy Key to Approval ............................................................................................................ 5 General – Agenda Link Turn ......................................................................................................................... 6 General – Political Polarization High ............................................................................................................ 7 General – Executive Action = No Link ........................................................................................................... 8 General – Political Capital Loss Inevitable .................................................................................................... 9 General – Political Capital Loss Inevitable .................................................................................................. 10 General – Political Capital Loss Inevitable .................................................................................................. 11 General – Obama Must Watch Out for Democratic Opposition ................................................................... 12 General – AT: Capital Fleeting in Second Term ........................................................................................... 13 Hagel Nomination – Yes – Schumer ............................................................................................................ 14 Hagel Nomination – Yes – Schumer ............................................................................................................ 15 Hagel Nomination – Yes – Boxer ................................................................................................................ 16 Hagel Nomination – NO – AT: Schumer ...................................................................................................... 17 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Good ................................................................................................................ 18 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Good ................................................................................................................ 19 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Good ................................................................................................................ 20 Hagel Nomination – Uncertain – Needs Political Capital ............................................................................. 21 Hagel Nomination – No Impact .................................................................................................................. 22 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Good ................................................................................................................ 23 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Good ................................................................................................................ 24 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Good – Iran ...................................................................................................... 25 Hagel Nomination – Not Certain ................................................................................................................ 26 Hagel Nomination – Hagel Bad................................................................................................................... 27 Gun Violence – Brink ................................................................................................................................. 28 Gun Violence – Control Works ................................................................................................................... 29 Gun Violence – Obama Will Push ............................................................................................................... 30 Gun Violence – Obama Needs Political Strength ......................................................................................... 31 Gun Violence – Public Supports Control ..................................................................................................... 32

Planet Debate Politics 1.16.13 General, Hagel, Guns, Climate, Debt, Citizenship

p. 2 of 62

Path to Citizenship – GOP Can Defeat ........................................................................................................ 33 Path to Citizenship – Will Pass ................................................................................................................... 34 Path to Citizenship – Won’t Pass ................................................................................................................ 35 Path to Citizenship – Internal Link – Agenda Crowding ............................................................................... 36 Path to Citizenship – Inevitable .................................................................................................................. 37 Path to Citizenship – Inevitable .................................................................................................................. 38 Path to Citizenship – Already Done Border Enforcement ............................................................................ 39 Path to Citizenship – Obama Will Push ....................................................................................................... 40 Path to Citizenship – Not Inevitable ........................................................................................................... 41 Climate Change – Obama Can Boost Renewables ....................................................................................... 42 Climate Change – Renewables Not Growing ............................................................................................... 43 Climate Change – Obama Key to Climate Change ....................................................................................... 44 Climate Change – Government Action Necessary ....................................................................................... 45 Climate Change – Obama Global Leadership .............................................................................................. 46 Climate Change – Coal Coming Back ........................................................................................................... 47 Climate Change – Coal Regulations Help the Economy ............................................................................... 48 Climate Change – Carbon Tax Helps Economy ............................................................................................ 49 Affirmative – Climate Change – Carbon Tax Hurts Economy ....................................................................... 50 Affirmative – Climate Change – Carbon Tax Hurts Economy ....................................................................... 51 Affirmative – Climate Change – No Carbon Tax Solvency ............................................................................ 52 Affirmative – Climate Change – No U.S. Solvency ....................................................................................... 53 Affirmative - Climate Change – Regulation Has Huge Benefit ...................................................................... 54 Affirmative - Climate Change – Pressure to Enact Regulations .................................................................... 55 Debt Ceiling – Dollar Impact ...................................................................................................................... 56 Debt Ceiling – Impact................................................................................................................................. 57 Debt Ceiling – Impact - Economy ................................................................................................................ 58 Debt Ceiling – AT: Dollar Scenario .............................................................................................................. 59 Debt Ceiling – AT: Dollar Scenario .............................................................................................................. 60 Debt Ceiling – AT: No Impact – Can Make Selective Payments .................................................................... 61 Debt Ceiling – Threat Alone Won’t Hurt Economy ...................................................................................... 62

Planet Debate Politics 1.16.13 General, Hagel, Guns, Climate, Debt, Citizenship

p. 3 of 62

GENERAL – OBAMA APPROVAL HIGH
OBAMA’S APPROVAL RATING IS HIGHEST IN 3 YEARS – ANGUS REID POLL
Angus Reid Public Opinion 1.10.13

[http://www.angus-reid.com/polls/48569/approval-rating-for-president-obama-improvesmarkedly-in-u-s/] Barack Obama heads to his second term as President with his best approval rating in more than three years, a new Angus Reid Public Opinion poll has found. In the online survey of a representative national sample of 1,006 American adults, 54 per cent of respondents approve of the way the United States President is handling his duties (+4 since December), while 41 per cent (-4) disapprove. This is Obama’s highest rating since August 2009. The American President currently has the highest level of support in the Northeast (56%), and the lowest in the South (52%). OBAMA HIGH APPROVAL RATING – ZOGBY POLL
Forbes Magazine 1.13.13

[http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnzogby/2013/01/13/president-obama-rides-high-intoinauguration/] A new Zogby Poll shows President Barack Obama with his highest approval ratings in years. The poll of 826 likely voters nationwide, conducted by Zogby Analytics January 10-12, gives the President a 56% approval rating, while 42% disapprove. Mr. Obama receives majority approval ratings from men (52%) and women (59%), Democrats (91%) and independents (55%); 18-29 year olds (68%), 30-49 year olds (60%), and 50-64 year olds (53%); Hispanics (65%), African Americans (95%), the Creative Class (57%), and Weekly Wal-Mart Shoppers (58%). Moving beyond his base, the President gets a 40% approval among evangelical voters, 25% among conservatives, and 16% among Republicans.

Senate Democrats fare poorly (36% positive-56%). but not as badly as both Senate Republicans (14%-77%) and Speaker John Boehner (16%-68%). who are pounded by all sides. 4 of 62 GENERAL – WINNERS WIN SPENDING CAPITAL ON THE FISCAL CLIFF HELPED OBAMA VS. THE GOP Forbes Magazine 1.com/sites/johnzogby/2013/01/13/president-obama-rides-high-intoinauguration/] In terms of handling the recent legislation averting the “fiscal cliff”.13.Planet Debate Politics 1.13 General.forbes. Guns.13 [http://www. President Obama receives a net positive approval rating (52%-43%) as does Vice-President Biden (47%-46%). Debt. Climate.16. Hagel. . Citizenship p.

1.16. Debt.politicususa.13 [http://www.11. .Planet Debate Politics 1. Obama has been impeded in every effort to restore the economy – by those selfsame Republicans – and the American people have noticed. 5 of 62 GENERAL – ECONOMY KEY TO APPROVAL THE PRESIDENT’S APPROVAL WILL RISE AS THE ECONOMY IMPROVES Hrafnkell Haraldsson. Climate. Guns.13 General. while Congress remains less popular than lice. Politics USA.com/president-obama-popular-term. Hagel. as polls demonstrate. It is almost a certainty that Obama‟s approval will continue to rise as the economy improves. Citizenship p.html] President Obama inherited the economy Bush and the Republican destroyed.

The plan seems to be to have Republicans running from fight to fight that they cannot find a central point on which to unite and oppose him. Defense cuts. This time Obama is actually hoping to overload Congress.16. While Congress was still getting over the massive stimulus spending package. Hagel. 6 of 62 GENERAL – AGENDA LINK TURN OVERLOADING THE AGENDA WORKS IN OBAMA’S FAVOR Chris Stirewalt. The president’s vision is of a Republican fire brigade running from blaze to blaze.com/politics/2013/01/14/obama-looks-to-overload-gop-opponents/] Gun control. 1.13 General. Climate. Obama overloaded the circuits of a Democratic Congress with lots of big plans. Guns.13 [www. Fox News. In 2009.Planet Debate Politics 1. two controversial nominees. . Debt. even with majorities in both houses of Congress. but it was a heckuva battle. Obama ended up getting what he wanted on insurance. Citizenship p.foxnews. more borrowing without offsets and amnesty for illegals: that‟s a menu designed to give Republicans indigestion. but never able to focus on putting one of them out. Obama came back with fees for carbon emissions and his new health-insurance entitlement program. The global warming fees and other initiatives mostly went by the wayside.14. Digital Politics Editor.

realclearpolitics. Climate. he said. Debt. many members of which are second-term Tea Party proponents who believe that holding a majority in half of one of three co-equal branches of government should give them an equal say. but the partisan polarization within the new Congress may be even greater than in the old. . And so. the prevailing view is that the country is spiraling down a deep spending crevasse from which there would be no climbing out. By way of thanks. the time to use what leverage the GOP has is now: "Two generations from now.‖ Similar dynamics are at work in the Senate -.14.com/articles/2013/01/14/obama_and_boehner_in_need_of _couples_counseling_116672. McConnell was greeted in the New Year by attack ads from a conservative advocacy group asking ―which side‖ the Kentucky Republican is on. . ―If we don’t use the opportunity where we have a divided Congress and White House to try and get the best thing for the future . Guns.13 General. Hagel. Boehner’s inability to keep House Republicans in lock-step is well-documented. 7 of 62 GENERAL – POLITICAL POLARIZATION HIGH PARTISAN POLARIZATION IN CONGRESS HAS INCREASED Caitlin Huey-Burns. his voice trailing off in dismay. we can say we were the ones who helped assist saving Social Security and preserving Medicare." Florida Republican Rep. From inside that restive GOP caucus.13 [http://www. however. Real Clear Politics. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell helped the nation avert the fiscal cliff by cutting a deal with Vice President Joe Biden.Planet Debate Politics 1.16.and in both parties. 1. The gist of the problem is a Republican caucus.html] The Democratic-controlled Senate might be a vehicle for future deals between the White House and Capitol Hill. Tom Rooney told RCP. . Citizenship p.

are high in public thought. and there is substantial opposition.13 [http://www. Citizenship p. . Yet such action would require little political capital on his part and would not distract from his efforts on something voters still say is their top priority – keeping the economy on track. Guns. even among some Democrats.com/USA/DC-Decoder/Decoder-Wire/2013/0115/Obama-andgun-control-What-actions-could-he-take-on-his-own] The reasons the White House might see the executive action route as attractive are obvious. Climate. Hagel. to banning whole weapon classes such as assault rifles. 1. Debt.. Congressional action is uncertain. Christian Science Monitor.15.13 General. 8 of 62 GENERAL – EXECUTIVE ACTION = NO LINK EXECUTIVE ACTIONS DON’T DRAIN THE PRESIDENT’S POLITICAL CAPITAL Peter Grier.csmonitor. Executive action could allow Obama to trumpet some progress on gun control at a time when the tragic shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown.16.Planet Debate Politics 1. Conn.

Obama’s choice for CIA chief.16. Sen.). 9 of 62 GENERAL – POLITICAL CAPITAL LOSS INEVITABLE OBAMA FACES CONTROVERSY AND BATTLES WITH CONGRESS ON MANY FRONTS – LOSS OF POLITICAL CAPITAL INEVITABLE Russell Berman. The House. Chuck Hagel (R) for defense secretary an ―in your face‖ move. All of which explains why the word “honeymoon” has not been uttered in Washington since early 2009. 1.) angrily denounced his pick of Jack Lew to head the Treasury. Republicans are signaling they could hold up his nomination until the administration provides long-sought answers to their questions about the deaths of four Americans in Benghazi last September. Climate. but a set of new fights with Republicans is already well underway. Hagel. spending cuts and broad tax reform.13 General. Another major budget battle. called Obama’s nomination of former Sen. A potential ally on immigration.C. As for John Brennan. Guns.Planet Debate Politics 1.12. Lindsey Graham (R-S. The Hill. Most troubling for the president is that the latest vitriol is coming from the Senate. on the other hand. Citizenship p. . immigration reform and gun control top his 2013 agenda. is verging on a lost cause for Obama. and there appears to be minimal overlap between Obama‟s top priorities and those of House Republicans – namely entitlement reform. while the top Republican on the Senate Budget Committee. the chamber of Congress with which the administration has gotten along (relatively) well in the last several months. The president and Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) are barely on speaking terms after their latest failed bid to strike a grand bargain on the deficit.13 [http://thehill. Debt.com/homenews/senate/276797-new-year-but-no-fresh-start-for-obama-gop] President Obama‟s second term hasn‟t begun yet. and this week he announced a trio of key Cabinet nominations that could complicate all three of those priorities. Jeff Sessions (Ala.

1.13 [http://www. and we’re going to have one hell of a contest about the direction and the vision of this country. .com/articles/march-madness_693767.14.Planet Debate Politics 1. Climate. Hudson Institute. The Congressional Budget Office reckons that last week‟s deal will increase the deficit over the next 10 years by some $4 trillion. despite adding $600 billion to our tax bill. which he says is ―coming. think again.html?page=3] If you think that the last-minute deal to avoid going over the fiscal cliff solves anything. Guns. the table is now set for what Republican senator Lindsey Graham calls Round Two.16. during which three interrelated problems will give Congress another set of opportunities for late-night sessions. To understand why.weeklystandard. its tax relief for mortgage-debt forgiveness and other goodies. Citizenship p. director economic policy studies.13 General.” Others call it the politicians‟ version of March Madness. Hagel. pore over the 154-page bill and consider its handouts to windmill operators and producers of all sorts of fuels other than those God put in the earth (a continuation of the president’s transformation of the energy sector). Worse still. 10 of 62 GENERAL – POLITICAL CAPITAL LOSS INEVITABLE THE NEXT BUDGET BATTLE WILL BE BIGGER THAN THE LAST Irwin Stelzer.‖ The White House puts it slightly differently: ―We are headed for 60 days of nastiness. Debt. its extension of unemployment insurance.

Eric Cantor. and persuade his party that entitlement reform is not inconsistent with Democrats‟ historic support for an expansion of the welfare state. He knows that his majority leader. Republicans are even less likely to make the concessions needed for a grand bargain. even if that change were to affect only those Americans still far from retirement. and what “tax reform” really means.13 [http://www. slower-rising index.16. although the president had said such a change makes sense. the consequences of looming entitlement spending. director economic policy studies. . but another display of reasonableness by Boehner might make the Ides of March a troublesome day for the speaker. In short.14. Climate. In the course of the negotiations Senate Democrats even refused to change the inflation index for Social Security to a more accurate.com/articles/march-madness_693767.000 to $450. But many of the politically savvy folks here in Washington very much doubt that 2013 will be the year of the grand bargain. Only a minority of House Republicans voted in favor of the cliff deal.13 General. and then force the nation to confront. the left has yet to be persuaded that there aren‟t enough “rich” people to pick up the bill for the lavish entitlement buffet that liberal politicians have laid before them. Hagel. Republicans would have to accept more wealth redistribution than they like. and as the 2014 primaries loom. For that to happen the president would have to admit to himself. for that is what means-testing of benefits is.html?page=3] Perhaps. Citizenship p. none of the events leading up to last week‟s deal suggest such a bargain is in the offing.000 for families. For the moment Cantor has decided to sheath his blade. even fewer will sign on to any tax increases the president demands. Surely. Guns. It took substantial arm-twisting by Vice President Joe Biden to get Senate and House Democrats to agree to move the level at which taxes would go up from $250. Hudson Institute. voted against the deal as a predicate to a leadership challenge. Debt. is also likely to hang tough in the March negotiations. Speaker John Boehner. 1. a man who has a lean and hungry look.Planet Debate Politics 1. 11 of 62 GENERAL – POLITICAL CAPITAL LOSS INEVITABLE A GRAND BARGAIN IS VERY UNLIKELY Irwin Stelzer. On the other side. Or even to consider increasing the age at which certain entitlements will become available.weeklystandard. who voted for the deal. and they remain sullen if not mutinous.

But that isn‟t welcome news to many of the Democrats who need him the most in the short term--the seven Democratic senators in conservative states facing tough reelection bids. Guns. and. On gun control.11. The New York Times reports.13 General. former GOP Sen. . Senators from the president’s own party are the ones giving him trouble over his nominee for Defense secretary.nationaljournal.13 [http://www.com/politics/obama-s-ambitious-second-term-agenda-couldbackfire-20130111] The White House‟s ambitious agenda on gun control.16. Citizenship p. perhaps. with one of the president’s most partisan backers privately expressing doubt about whether he’ll support his nomination. National Journal.Planet Debate Politics 1. Just one week into the new year. even climate change is a sign that President Obama believes he locked up precious political capital with his reelection and intends to spend it quickly. Chuck Hagel. Hagel. 12 of 62 GENERAL – OBAMA MUST WATCH OUT FOR DEMOCRATIC OPPOSITION DEMOCRATS COULD BLOCK THE PRESIDENT’S AGENDA Josh Kraushaar. Obama has already hit some unpleasant stumbling blocks with his own party. immigration reform. 1. Climate. Debt. the White House is now calculating that it will be ―exceedingly difficult‖ to pass broad measures. a sharp U-turn from its optimism heading into the new year.

13 General. Debt. Climate. He can back them into a corner or woo them one-by one.huffingtonpost. Now he has a feel for the game.com/howard-fineman/obama-second-term-the-roadforward_b_2468998. Laws he passed in his first term can be implemented without going back to a nettlesome Congress.html] For most reelected presidents. . The world economy could be poised for a new round of growth. Huffington Post. 1. Hagel. as he did recently on the "fiscal cliff." He was a novice at Washington and at the give-and-take of politics four years ago.Planet Debate Politics 1. power fades quickly. His Republican foes are in retreat and disarray.16.14. 13 of 62 GENERAL – AT: CAPITAL FLEETING IN SECOND TERM OBAMA’S POLITICAL STRENGTH MAY HAVE STAYING POWER Howard Fineman. That may not be true in Obama's case.13 [http://www. Citizenship p. Guns.

13 [http://www.) did Monday night. 1. Debt. Schumer‟s backing is a major sign that Democrats who have expressed squeamishness over his nomination are starting to come on board.politico. given his clout within the Senate Democratic Caucus and his deep ties to pro-Israel hawks on and off the Hill. Citizenship p. 14 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – YES – SCHUMER SCHUMER SUPPORT MAKES HAGEL NOMINATION VERY LIKELY Manu Raju. Hagel‟s prospects greatly brightened with Schumer‟s support for his nomination. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.html] Schumer‟s support may mean a major tipping point for Hagel‟s nomination. Hamas and Hezbollah rather than push tougher measures preferred by proIsrael members of the Senate Democratic Caucus. removing a major obstacle to his nomination and greatly increasing the chances he‟ll be confirmed.13 General. Chuck Schumer announced Tuesday he‟d support Chuck Hagel‟s nomination as defense secretary. Most notably.politico. Hagel. And they’re an important sign that Democrats who have expressed concerns over his nomination are starting to come on board. 1.15. Climate. as Sen.Planet Debate Politics 1. Politico.13 [http://www.html] New York Sen. But Hagel has appeared to have alleviated those fears ahead of his crucial confirmation hearings before the Senate Armed Services Committee in the coming weeks. . Democrats have raised concerns that Hagel has been too quick to call for direct engagement with Iran. SCHUMER’S SUPPORT WILL BRING ALL DEMOCRATS TO HAGEL Manu Raju. Guns. And with Democrats now holding a 55-45 majority in the Senate.15. Politico. even as Hagel continues to face opposition from the right.com/story/2013/01/chuck-schumer-says-hell-support-chuck-hagelsnomination-86215.com/story/2013/01/chuck-schumer-says-hell-support-chuck-hagelsnomination-86215.16.

15 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – YES – SCHUMER SCHUMER IS “THE DECIDER” ON THE HAGEL NOMINATION Chris Cilliza. But he can’t.14 [http://www.html] Schumer had become a key linchpin in the nomination battle. SCHUMER WAS THE KEY LYNCHPIN FOR HAGEL’S NOMINATION Washington Post 1. another prominent Jewish Democrat who is also a senior member of the Foreign Relations Committee. if personally Schumer has reason to oppose Hagel. politically he has every reason to support him.).washingtonpost. Debt. Hagel. . Schumer. as such. as many senior Republicans have expressed deep doubt about Hagel’s confirmation.16. our (educated) guess is that if Hagel is apologetic about some of his past statements during his meeting with Schumer. it would give cover for other Democrats to follow suit — a domino effect that almost certainly would destroy Hagel’s chances. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif. Citizenship p. understands that he likely holds Hagel’s fate in his hands. So. Washington Post. If Schumer had opposed Hagel. Climate.com/blogs/the-fix/wp/2013/01/14/how-chuck-schumercan-make-or-break-chuck-hagel/] What seems abundantly clear is that if Schumer could make his decision on Hagel in a political vacuum. Guns. then a crucial bloc of pro-Israel Democrats might have joined him and made confirmation impossible.13 General. he would probably vote no.15. being one of the smartest strategists in the Senate. make no mistake: Chuck Schumer is the decider on the fate of Chuck Hagel‟s nomination.com/politics/schumer-to-back-hagel/2013/01/15/ffd46fc85f23-11e2-9940-6fc488f3fecd_story. Schumer is widely regarded as the next leader of Senate Democrats and. the New York Democrat will find a way to say yes. Given those stakes. of course.washingtonpost.13 [http://www. knows that. If Schumer signaled that he would vote no. Regardless of where he ends up. Schumer‟s announcement follows the public endorsement of Hagel by Sen. And he doesn’t want to own the defeat of (and blame for) a Cabinet nominee put forward at the cusp of Obama’s second term. his opinion matters a great deal.14.Planet Debate Politics 1. 1. Schumer.

com/story/2013/01/chuck-schumer-says-hell-support-chuck-hagelsnomination-86215. Politico. Debt. Hagel.13 [http://www. a sign of growing support on the left. Hagel apologized for previously using the term ―Jewish lobby.‖ And Boxer — who does not serve on the Armed Services Committee — announced her support of Hagel.‖ calling it a ―very poor choice of words. 16 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – YES – BOXER SUPPORT FROM BOXER SHOWS HAGEL WILL WIN PROGRESSIVE SENATORS Manu Raju. also outlining a more hawkish stance toward Hezbollah and Iran.html] The White House and Hagel both clearly recognize that wooing Jewish Democrats — like Schumer and Boxer — are a top priority before the former Nebraska GOP senator‟s confirmation hearings.15.Planet Debate Politics 1. Climate.16. 1. Hagel sent a letter Monday to Boxer. .13 General. Guns.politico. Citizenship p.

Climate. Debt.S.politico.13 General. Hagel reportedly said he’d urge the president to decline joining in any NATO exercises if Turkey insists on excluding Israel. 1. and they say his words do little to correct a 12-year Senate record that didn’t fully advocate for Israeli interests.15. Among other things. 17 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – NO – AT: SCHUMER SCHUMER SUPPORT WON’T SWAY REPUBLICANS Manu Raju.16. saying that the former Nebraska GOP senator would push for delivering F-35 joint strikers to Israel. Politico.13 [http://www. Still. who believe Hagel espouses a doveish world view. Hagel.com/story/2013/01/chuck-schumer-says-hell-support-chuck-hagelsnomination-86215.html] Schumer added Hagel gave him several assurances that U.Planet Debate Politics 1. . Guns. such assurances alone are not enough to stop opposition among Republicans. which they call a success. they are quick to criticize his furious opposition to the troop surge in Iraq. Citizenship p.-Israeli cooperation would continue if he’s confirmed.

counterproductive nation-building in countries like Afghanistan and Iraq. military spending must come down. Korean War. Hagel called the Pentagon “bloated” and said that spending needs “to be pared down. .16. 1.com/sites/dougbandow/2013/01/14/the-dishonorable-smear-ofchuck-hagel-a-warrior-who-despises-war/] Moreover. Guns.14. 18 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL GOOD HAGEL IS RIGHT ON DEFENSE SPENDING Doug Bandow.Planet Debate Politics 1. Today the U. or Vietnam War. such as Europe. Debt.” Which is true. Few outlays go to the defense of America. South Korea. Cato Institute fellow. Washington devotes more money in real terms to the Pentagon today than during the Cold War. Military outlays have increased dramatically since President George W. and Japan. Climate. Citizenship p. Bush turned into a fiscal liberal. Much of the rest goes to foolish.forbes.13 [http://www. Most goes to protect populous and prosperous allies. Hagel.13 General. spends almost as much as the rest of the world combined.S.

competent. Hagel. More than a decade later they have no idea why Americans are still dying. Thousands of Americans and hundreds of thousands of Iraqis died as a result of a lie propagated by self-serving Iraqi émigrés and advanced by war-promoting Neocon activists. democratic governance in Kabul.com/sites/dougbandow/2013/01/14/the-dishonorable-smear-ofchuck-hagel-a-warrior-who-despises-war/] In this regard Hagel well-represents the American people. 1. which they recognize was terrible mistake. 19 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL GOOD HAGEL’S VIEWS REFLECT PUBLIC OPINION ON INTERVENTION Doug Bandow. They are angry after being lied to about the Iraq war.16. Cato Institute fellow.forbes. Debt. Guns. They supported destroying al-Qaeda for launching 9/11 and ousting the Taliban for harboring al-Qaeda.Planet Debate Politics 1.13 [http://www. Citizenship p. There is no citizen support for intervening in Syria.13 General. There was no popular enthusiasm for President Obama‟s questionable adventure in Libya. apparently in a dubious attempt to promote honest. Backing for war with Iran likely would dissipate once the high costs became evident.14. . Climate. Americans also are tired of Afghanistan.

16. even with diplomatic untouchables such as Hamas and Hezbollah. Someone has to challenge the generals to rethink the status quo. isn‟t likely to be intimidated by someone with stars on his shoulders. While recognizing that war can be necessary. he sees military force as a last resort. 1.13 General. Cato Institute fellow.forbes. Citizenship p.com/sites/dougbandow/2013/01/14/the-dishonorable-smear-ofchuck-hagel-a-warrior-who-despises-war/] It is hard to think of a better candidate to run the Pentagon under such circumstances than Chuck Hagel. Guns. Debt.Planet Debate Politics 1. Hagel. Climate. . For this reason he proposes negotiation. if possible. Hagel. 20 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL GOOD HAGEL BELIEVES USE OF MILITARY IS A LAST RESORT Doug Bandow. Unlike the war-happy Neocons. who could be the first enlisted man ever to end up as Defense Secretary. He also is likely to bring a jaundiced eye to Pentagon budget-making.13 [http://www.14. he understands—out of both personal experience and practical consequence—that war is best avoided.

THE HAGEL NOMINATION WILL BE DIVISIVE Senator Roger Vicker.html] The bitter tone of gridlock in Washington has left many Americans hoping for a more collaborative environment to face the country’s most pressing challenges. who was approved unanimously by the Senate. Guns. 1.com/sites/dougbandow/2013/01/14/the-dishonorable-smear-ofchuck-hagel-a-warrior-who-despises-war/] Nevertheless.politico. Unlike outgoing Defense Secretary Leon Panetta. Hagel. Chuck Hagel of Nebraska to be America‟s next secretary of defense. understands the human cost. Cato Institute fellow.14. Instead of seeking consensus. He fought in battle.13 [http://www.16. better yet. Hagel is expected to provoke a divisive confirmation process — at a time when Congress should be focused on urgent budget issues that could dramatically change America’s defense strategy and capabilities.com/story/2013/01/why-hagel-is-the-wrong-choice-to-lead-thepentagon-86098. opposition to Hagel is fierce.13 General. .Planet Debate Politics 1. as one would expect. Debt. Changes in the president’s Cabinet presented a prime opportunity for coming together. A liberal with no military experience and little confidence in military matters might be cowed or. Not Hagel.forbes. R-Mississippi. 1. Climate. offers skepticism rather than enthusiasm for new interventions. President Barack Obama has forced confrontation with the nomination of former Sen.13 [http://www.14. The overriding objection to him is that he is the living refutation of everything the War Party stands for. 21 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – UNCERTAIN – NEEDS POLITICAL CAPITAL OPPOSITION IS FIERCE – WILL TAKE POLITICAL CAPITAL FOR NOMINATION Doug Bandow. Citizenship p. coopted. and would be no Pentagon rubber stamp.

Planet Debate Politics 1.16.13 General, Hagel, Guns, Climate, Debt, Citizenship

p. 22 of 62

HAGEL NOMINATION – NO IMPACT
HAGEL JUST REFLECTS OBAMA’S FOREIGN POLICY
John Arquilla, Foreign Policy, 1.14.13

[http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/01/14/for_defense_less_beef_more_chuck? wp_login_redirect=0] So, whether the issue is the surge in Iraq, the looming drawdown in Afghanistan, or the size of the defense budget, Hagel's views offer insights that all should hear -- and should spark useful, long-overdue debate about military and security affairs. His clear agreement with what I see to be an emergent Obama Doctrine makes it possible to pursue a consistent, quite innovative strategic path in this age of irregular wars. HAGEL WON’T FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE OBAMA’S MIDDLE EAST POLICY
John Zogby, president Arab American Institute, 1.14.13

[http://www.middle-east-online.com/english/?id=56443] One thing should be clear, however, and that is if Hagel is confirmed there will not be a radical change in this Administration's approach to Israel or an American acceptance of an Iran with nuclear weapons. Hagel and Kerry, like Obama, are supporters of Israel. The Administration will continue to support that state's defense requirements and, in all likelihood, will not rush headlong into a new Middle East peace initiative since they appear to believe that conditions for that simply do not exist. At the same time, Israel will continue to face the U.S.'s growing displeasure with its occupation and settlement policies. And the Administration will not end its pressure on Iran to be more transparent with its nuclear ambitions and agree with international community's insistence that they forsake advanced enrichment. But the Obama Administration will now be fortified by a team that understands that engagement and not foolish adventurism is the best way to resolve the standoff while insuring that we not be dragged into another potentially devastating Middle East war.

Planet Debate Politics 1.16.13 General, Hagel, Guns, Climate, Debt, Citizenship

p. 23 of 62

HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL GOOD
HAGEL WASN’T WRONG ABOUT THE IRAQ SURGE – IT DIDN’T WORK
Arianna Huffington, Huffington Post, 1.15.13

[http://www.huffingtonpost.com/arianna-huffington/neocon-nightmare-thetrut_b_2478673.html] The relationship between Hagel and McCain goes back a long time. McCain was one of Hagel's earliest supporters and Hagel was one of the few who jumped on the "Straight Talk Express," back when McCain was taking on what he called "agents of intolerance" in the Republican Party. Unlike McCain, Hagel managed to stay on the Straight Talk Express. And now McCain is grasping at straws over Hagel's skepticism about success of the surge strategy in Iraq, something McCain finds "bizarre." Back when it was being considered, Hagel said "This is a Ping-Pong game with American lives," and that "we better be damn sure we know what we're doing, all of us, before we put 22,000 more Americans into that grinder." Since then it's become accepted gospel in Washington that the surge was successful. Accepted gospel that is, once again, wrong. Doug Ollivant was an army planning officer in Iraq who was one of those who actually implemented the surge. "The surge really didn't work, per se," Ollivant, now with the New America Foundation says, adding, "Fundamentally, it was the Iraqis trying to find a solution, and they did." A study by U.S. Special Forces officer Maj. Joshua Thiel came to the same conclusion. Thiel looked at where and when the additional surge troops were deployed and compared that to subsequent drops in violence. As Foreign Policy's Robert Haddick put it, Thiel concluded that there was no significant correlation between the arrival of U.S. reinforcements and subsequent changes in the level of violence in Iraq's provinces... the connection between surge troops and the change in the level of incidents seems entirely random.

Planet Debate Politics 1.16.13 General, Hagel, Guns, Climate, Debt, Citizenship

p. 24 of 62

HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL GOOD
HAGEL AVOIDS RECKLESS, IDEOLOGICAL POLICIES
John Zogby, president Arab American Institute, 1.14.13

[http://www.middle-east-online.com/english/?id=56443] I know Chuck Hagel. He is a thoughtful and sober advocate of the realist approach to foreign policy. His priority has always been to defend America's interests in the world through diplomacy and, only when absolutely necessary, to commit American forces to combat missions in defense of those interests. By disposition, he has an aversion to ideologically-based reckless behavior. His criticism of the war in Iraq, his opposition to the reckless use of force against Iran, and his critique of Israeli actions that impede peace are wellknown. So too was his refusal while in the Senate to participate in AIPAC's frequent "hoop jumping" exercises. He resisted signing, as he termed them, the pro-Israel lobby's "stupid letters."

In a very detailed statement. But he didn’t stop there. He said his “top priority” as secretary of defense would be the planning of military contingencies related to Iran. ―Senator Hagel rejected a strategy of containment and expressed the need to keep all options on the table in confronting that country.Planet Debate Politics 1. Hagel also pledged to continue supporting the delivery of F-35 Joint Strike Fighters to Israel and in general supported Israel’s right to a strong ―qualitative military edge. Hagel had been unique in positions calling for direct talks the Iranian regime and opposing unilateral sanctions by the United States against the renegade regime.html] Schumer said that his support was sown up after Hagel — whom Obama formally nominated last week after a month of preparation — committed to several positions regarding Iran that met with Schumer‟s preference. Debt. including the use of military force.‖ Schumer said. 25 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL GOOD – IRAN HAGEL WILL NOT BE SOFT ON IRAN Washington Post 1. Schumer said Hagel left no doubt that he would support a very aggressive posture toward Tehran. As a two-term senator. ―In our conversation.‖ as its leaders like to assert. .16. Climate.13 General.com/politics/schumer-to-back-hagel/2013/01/15/ffd46fc85f23-11e2-9940-6fc488f3fecd_story. Guns. Senator Hagel made a crystal-clear promise that he would do „whatever it takes‟ to stop Tehran from obtaining nuclear weapons. Hagel.washingtonpost. Citizenship p.15.14 [http://www.

forcing him to use the very shopworn language found the AIPAC letters he refused to sign when he served in the Senate. Hagel.13 [http://www. On the other hand should Hagel stay the course. 1.13 General. and should Democrats decide to choose to support their president instead of the lobby and the pressure from the neo-cons. 26 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – NOT CERTAIN HAGEL’S NOMINATION IS NOT A SURE THING John Zogby.13 [http://www.com/english/?id=56443] At this point.14.16. OUTCOME ON HAGEL FAR FROM CERTAIN John Zogby.middle-east-online. Debt. It is the entire neo-conservative enterprise that led the U. What is at stake for Republicans is far more than just Israel and Iran. Will Hagel fold? Will Obama surrender to pressure and pull his nominee. risking defeat and embarrassment? Or will the Senate defeat Hagel's bid for confirmation? Any of these would be a setback of substantial proportions. . I am bracing myself for a degree of disappointment. but have no way of knowing how this will play out.middle-east-online. president Arab American Institute. we know what the stakes are.14. into two failed wars in Afghanistan and Iraq (which they cannot admit were failures) and has them still advocating for more aggressive military engagements in Syria and Iran. but the outcome is far from certain.com/english/?id=56443] Republicans see the possibility of further weakening and distracting the president by "roughing up" his nominee and will in all likelihood subject Hagel to tough grilling when he finally appears before the Senate Armed Services Committee for confirmation. They will want him to demonstrate that he is more committed to Israel and more hawkish on Iran than he has been in the past.S. I am also prepared to acknowledge that Hagel's confirmation is not a sure thing. no doubt. Climate. focus on his support for Israel and his attitudes toward Iran. then we might well be on our way to a healthier political environment where realism trumps ideology and where honest political differences can be debated in our government without fear of retribution. making clear his support for Israel while asserting his freedom and independence to criticize Israeli policies when necessary.Planet Debate Politics 1. The stakes are high. Guns. They will try to beat him into submission. 1. Citizenship p. While I certainly hope that Hagel won't fold under the pressure. And while I believe the president is committed and will fight for his nominee. Their questions will. president Arab American Institute.

16.html] My opposition to this nomination stems in part from Hagel‟s flawed vision for America‟s role in the world and whether his selection signals a move toward a weaker defense by a second Obama administration. the president seems to suggest that his approach will be to downplay American leadership rather than strengthen it. R-Mississippi. Hagel’s decisions and statements have drawn significant concerns from Democrats and Republicans. Debt.com/story/2013/01/why-hagel-is-the-wrong-choice-to-lead-thepentagon-86098. his nomination calls into question the national security priorities of the president‟s second term.politico. 1.Planet Debate Politics 1. Hagel.14. .13 [http://www. 27 of 62 HAGEL NOMINATION – HAGEL BAD HAGEL AS DEFENSE SECRETARY WOULD BE A SIGN OF WEAKNESS Senator Roger Vicker. In choosing Hagel. Citizenship p. Climate. Guns.13 General. In the past. At the very least. One is right to wonder whether Hagel‟s views on issues affecting the country‟s national security interests would shape his doctrine as defense secretary.

Climate. 28 of 62 GUN VIOLENCE – BRINK OPPORTUNITY IS RIGHT NOW FOR GUN CONTROL New York Times 1. Guns.Planet Debate Politics 1..13 [http://www. Hagel. Vice President Joseph Biden Jr. Citizenship p.nytimes.16. . and it is vital that his panel gets it right and that Congress immediately takes action on its report. Conn. Debt. A month after the slaughter of 20 children and seven adults in Newtown.com/2013/01/15/opinion/the-moment-for-action-on-gun-laws.’s commission is about to present a series of recommendations for new laws.html] The next few weeks represent a once-in-a-generation opportunity to harden the nation‟s gun laws and reduce the threat of rapid-fire violence in America.13 General.14.

The reason that both the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence and Mayors Against Illegal Guns have made universal background checks their top priority is that 40 percent of gun sales now take place privately.nytimes. And it would have no effect on law-abiding buyers who want a hunting rifle or a handgun to keep at home. now that the Internet has made it easy for private individuals to buy and sell guns without screening.” This recommendation requires strong legislative language to require states to contribute information toward national databases used for assessing whether an individual should be allowed to purchase a weapon. . even among Republican lawmakers: If you buy a gun..csmonitor. 10 states have submitted a grand total of zero names to the FBI’s National Instant Criminal Background Check System.com/USA/DC-Decoder/Decoder-Wire/2013/0114/How-totackle-gun-violence-5-things-liberal-groups-want] Universal background checks. and 18 other states have submitted fewer than 100.13 [http://www. 29 of 62 GUN VIOLENCE – CONTROL WORKS UNIVERSAL BACKGROUND CHECKS WOULD MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE New York Times 1.13 General. Obama’s former chief of staff.Planet Debate Politics 1. no matter who it’s from. Hagel. who have a dismal record of pursuing charges against those who lie on a gun application. Federal prosecutors. parking-lot sales and Web sites would reduce the cashand-carry anonymity of millions of gun transactions.‖ Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel. private sellers make up about 40 percent of weapon transfers in the US every year.. Citizenship p. It is largely supported by legitimate gun dealers. need to enforce the system vigorously.16. that’s not a loophole. At present. Such a law should be supplemented by a presidential order requiring federal and state agencies to contribute to the background check system with criminal and mental health information. you have to pass a background check. Currently. That’s an exception. ―When you’ve got 40 percent of the guns that are going out [not receiving background checks].html] The need for background checks on every gun buyer has never been greater. What’s known in some places as the ―gun show loophole‖ means that those barred from buying guns by other statutes can effectively circumvent those laws by obtaining a weapon from a private weapons dealer. UNIVERSAL BACKGROUND CHECKS WILL CUT GUN VIOLENCE Christian Science Monitor 1.13 [http://www. This first proposal is one that Democrats believe has widespread support. Climate. putting buyers on notice that their sale is being recorded and can be traced. is essential.14.com/2013/01/15/opinion/the-moment-for-action-on-gun-laws. Requiring background checks at gun shows. Guns. ―Shutting that exemption. including most guns that are later used in crimes. who already have to conduct the checks and have long grumbled about competition from those who do not. according to CAP. said at an event Monday at the liberal Center for American Progress (CAP). Debt.14.

Planet Debate Politics 1. Obama has already promised to push for a renewal of the 1994 ban on some types of semiautomatic assault rifles. and could outline his plan publicly as early as Wednesday. 30 of 62 GUN VIOLENCE – OBAMA WILL PUSH OBAMA WILL PROPOSE BROAD GUN CONTROL MEASURES Mary Bruce. also known as the “assault weapons ban. Citizenship p. One month after the deadly school shooting in Newtown. Conn.com/blogs/politics/2013/01/obama-to-unveil-road-map-to-halt-gunviolence/] President Obama is expected to detail a broad plan this week to curb gun violence.go.15.” legislation to expand background checks. Guns.13 General. setting the stage for what could be the largest Congressional battle over gun legislation in decades. 1.16.. Debt. ABC News. which were delivered to him on Monday. . Obama is reviewing the recommendations of Vice President Biden’s task force. and limits on highcapacity magazine clips. Climate.13 [http://abcnews. Hagel.

RESTRICTING ASSAULT WEAPONS IS HIGHLY CONTROVERSIAL Christian Science Monitor 1. including the National Rifle Association which has already vowed to oppose efforts to limit access to guns and ammunition. Citizenship p.16. massacre at its current level. CAP endorsed a proposal by Sen.com/blogs/politics/2013/01/obama-to-unveil-road-map-to-halt-gunviolence/] The most contentious items on the president‟s to-do list will require Congressional approval and are expected to face fierce opposition from gun rights groups.. Conn. Feinstein and other Democratic Senators plan to introduce legislation to this effect early in the new session of Congress. Climate.‖ But others have been a bit more specific at reviving a policy created under President Bill Clinton but allowed to lapse under President George W.csmonitor. ABC News.15. Debt. Guns.14. transfer.13 [http://www. The Brady Campaign. importation and manufacturing of military-style assault weapons and highcapacity ammunition feeding devices. Bush.go. one of the most outspoken advocates for increased gun control. what to do about restricting access to assault weapons is perhaps the most controversial.com/USA/DC-Decoder/Decoder-Wire/2013/0114/How-totackle-gun-violence-5-things-liberal-groups-want] Restrict the sale of assault weapons and high-capacity magazines If background checks enjoy the most consensus.13 [http://abcnews.Planet Debate Politics 1.13 General. Dianne Feinstein (D) of California that would halt the ―sale. Hagel.‖ In other words. 1. 31 of 62 GUN VIOLENCE – OBAMA NEEDS POLITICAL STRENGTH OBAMA WILL FACE FIERCE OPPOSITION ON GUN VIOLENCE Mary Bruce. . gives only a single broad sentence to the subject in its policy recommendations: ―Limit the availability of military-style weapons and high capacity ammunition magazines that are designed for mass killing. it would freeze ownership of weapons like that used in the Newtown.

16.5165926. 32 of 62 GUN VIOLENCE – PUBLIC SUPPORTS CONTROL PUBLIC SUPPORTS SPECIFICS OF GUN CONTROL Los Angeles Times 1.0. A Washington Post-ABC News survey and another by the Pew Research Center found that more than 80% of respondents want federal background checks to be conducted for private gun sales. Climate.13 [http://www. Debt. including sales at gun shows. Hagel. Citizenship p. Much slimmer majorities expressed support for two other policy options mentioned by Obama — banning assault weapons and high-capacity magazines. where they are not currently required.story] Two polls released Monday found broad public support for stronger background check laws. Guns.latimes. .13 General.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-obama-guns20130115.Planet Debate Politics 1.14.

. 1.html] The last House GOP effort to split the high-tech visas question from the path to citizenship question was an absurd partisan ploy.html] Of the major policy issues under discussion in Washington. Climate. and help for DREAMers—they say they want. why would they block it? It packages three things—more skilled immigration.16.15. a comprehensive bill that includes a path to citizenship for the overwhelming majority of unauthorized migrants already living in the United States. you need to add a sweetener. Blocking it because it doesn't also do the broad amnesty that liberals want and conservatives hate would require the kind of fanaticism that is the exact opposite of Obama's approach to politics. more enforcement.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/01/15/immigration_reform_will_obama_g et_rolled. The centerpiece would be something on increased immigration of skilled workers. Slate. Guns.Planet Debate Politics 1. Slate. If Republicans want to get serious about it they should be able to make it work.15. But many other aspects of immigration law are in the mix as part of a proposed deal. Not the broad path to citizenship.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/01/15/immigration_reform_will_obama_g et_rolled. Citizenship p. Debt. Now you've got a package that falls massively short of what Latino groups are looking for. 33 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – GOP CAN DEFEAT GOP COMPROMISES SHORT OF A PATH TO CITIZENSHIP COULD DEFEAT IT Matthew Yglesias. For the major immigration-advocacy groups. the goal is clear.slate. High tech visas will easily generate revenue to pay for some stepped-up enforcement. Then instead of adding on a poison pill so Democrats will block the bill. and few influential people have any real beef with it. it's a great idea on the merits. "immigration reform" stands out for having unusually undefined content.13 [http://www.13 [http://www. but something small like the DREAM Act. After all. and it seems to me that there's a fair chance that a nimble Republican Party could essentially roll the Democratic coalition and pass an "immigration reform" bill that doesn't offer the path Latino advocacy groups are looking for. REPUBLICANS COULD BLOCK THE PATH TO CITIZENSHIP Matthew Yglesias. Hagel.slate. 1.13 General. but that I think Democrats will have a hard time actually blocking. That's something the tech industry wants very much.

htm] Diaz-Balart and Ros-Lehtinen say this is the year that Congress needs to pass immigration reform. he can get immigration reform done. . have had problems with their voters when it comes to immigration reform. Labor unions.15. And Republicans. Diaz-Balart said because it's not an election year. So there's less chance for hyper-partisan politics. which tend to support Democrats. It's also a new Congress. Citizenship p. might be more willing to vote for immigration-reform plans as the lessons of 2012's elections are still fresh. HispanicBusiness. that they're willing to support a comprehensive immigration package.15. too. Hagel.13 General.hispanicbusiness.16.html] A top technology lobbyist said Tuesday he believes President Barack Obama has the savvy and political skill to navigate an immigration bill through even a divided Congress. A major fault-line: Whether to give illegal immigrants a pathway to citizenship or a pathway to residency. this is the time. Still.” said Consumer Electronics Association President and CEO Gary Shapiro at a POLITICO Pro Tech Deep Dive focused on the 113th Congress.com/story/2013/01/obama-immigration-reform-congress86210. Debt. Diaz-Balart said.13 [http://www.13 [www. Unions now indicate. ―If President Obama can get health care reform through as divisive as it was.com/2013/1/15/rubio_obama_diazbalart_roslehtinen_jeb_bush. 34 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – WILL PASS PAST OPPONENTS OF CIR NOW LIKELY TO SUPPORT Marc Caputo. too. 1. Ros-Lehtinen pointed out that Democrats. however.politico. Climate.Com 1.Planet Debate Politics 1. Guns. OBAMA WILL GET IMMIGRATION REFORM – EASIER THAN HEALTH CARE WAS Steve Friess. have opposed guest-worker immigration programs in the past because they allow for an influx of cheap labor from overseas. Politico. who blocked major congressional immigration legislation in 2010 and 2006.

further souring relations with Congress. Partisan poisoning: One of the reasons a grand bargain was not reached was that President Obama was most intent on winning a partisan victory over Republicans on raising tax rates.16. 35 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – WON’T PASS OBAMA WILL COMPROMISE ON CIR DUE TO TIMING AND PARTISANSHIP Mark Kennedy. including immigration reform. President Obama moved on taxes from a $250.huffingtonpost.com/mark-r-kennedy/immigration-reform_b_2426718.html] Serious immigration reform will be addressed later and will be narrower than some may hope. Guns. Compromise requires an effort from both sides.com/mark-r-kennedy/immigration-reform_b_2426718. Climate. The sparse result of months of partisan wrestling over the fiscal cliff portends a reduced likelihood that any of President Obama's second-term priorities.15. the lever of the debt ceiling tilts the playing field back to even when it comes to resolving the new cliff that looms just two months away. Debt.000. the president chose politics over policy. Citizenship p. Continuing fiscal cliff battles: One consequence of not reaching a grand bargain on the fiscal cliff is that it ensures that further contests over how to resolve the nation's ongoing deficits will suck much of the oxygen out of the most opportune time slot for legislative action: the period immediately following the president's inaugural address and the State of the Union address.html] With a focus on the timing and the shape of immigration reform.000 threshold to one of $450. Professor political management. . Reaching an agreement takes time and requires each side to give.huffingtonpost. just as we witnessed in the tax debate.Planet Debate Politics 1. Hagel.13 [http://www. Professor political management. Resolving the even more contentious matter of reducing spending in such a pestilent environment is sure to consume much time and energy.15. 1. George Washington Univ. Republicans were forced to accept that they could not extend tax breaks for everyone. will be addressed in the manner he outlines in his upcoming inaugural address. FISCAL CLIFF PROVES THE PRESIDENT WILL HAVE TO NEGOTIATE ON CIR Mark Kennedy. five factors are operative: Awaiting lame duck status: Second-term presidents normally have a short window of time to pass serious legislation before Congress picks up the mantle and starts driving the agenda.13 General.13 [http://www. While President Obama clearly had the upper hand politically in the tax debate. 1. By choosing to focus more on the subsidiary goal of raising rates than on the primary goal of raising revenue to reduce deficits. George Washington Univ.

com/mark-r-kennedy/immigration-reform_b_2426718. a president must prioritize and avoid cluttering the playing field with numerous other initiatives at the same time. In his first inaugural address President Obama laid out a broad agenda but failed to achieve results until he narrowed his focus to health-care reform.13 [http://www. 36 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – INTERNAL LINK – AGENDA CROWDING ADDING ISSUES TO THE AGENDA. Clearly energy. Guns. Citizenship p. regardless of its merits. immigration and tax reform legislation are all desperately needed. George Washington Univ. LIKE THE PLAN.huffingtonpost.16. Hagel. Climate. 1.13 General. Professor political management.Planet Debate Politics 1. will decrease the likelihood of action on other priorities and will elevate the level of partisan rancor.15.html] Lack of focus: In order to really drive the direction of a major reform effort. RISKS CROWDING OUT CIR Mark Kennedy. Debt. but all cannot be done at once. Adding gun reform to the mix. .

16. Founder.huffingtonpost. with evident success. America’s Voice. 1. Meanwhile. 37 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – INEVITABLE CIR WILL PASS – IT’S INEVITABLE DUE TO POLITICAL INCENTIVES Frank Sharry.com/frank-sharry/immigration-reform-2013_b_2443025. They know that the party faces an existential crisis: The GOP has to regain its competitiveness with Hispanic voters or go the way of the Whigs. This is what Harry Reid in Nevada and Michael Bennet in Colorado did in 2010. In 2012 President Obama showed that it could work on a national scale. Hagel.html] For Democrats this proved that the best way to deal with this so-called Republican wedge issue is not to run from it but to lean into it. Debt. Guns. movement conservatives and Republican leaders alike are seeing the demographic writing on the wall and calling for the GOP to embrace immigration reform.13 General. . What does this mean for 2013 and 2014? It means that the president will make immigration reform his top post-fiscalcliff legislative priority. Democrats are more united than ever on immigration and are determined to make Republicans play or pay. Climate. (Read the new America's Voice report on immigration lessons from the 2012 elections for more 2012 analysis).15.13 [http://www. Citizenship p.Planet Debate Politics 1.

Debt.com/frank-sharry/immigration-reform-2013_b_2443025. Climate.16.13 General. With comprehensive immigration reform favored by the public by a 2-to-1 margin.html] So what is likely to happen? A broad legislative proposal. 1. Then it will be up to the House of Representatives.15.Planet Debate Politics 1. one that puts 11 million undocumented immigrants on the road to citizenship. Founder. In the end the House leadership will find a way. Citizenship p.huffingtonpost. law enforcement officials. evangelicals. drafted on a bipartisan basis and approved by the Senate. with bipartisan support. sometime this spring.13 [http://www. Once again Speaker Boehner will find a bipartisan majority in the House. 38 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – INEVITABLE REPUBLICAN OPPOSITION WILL BE OVERCOME BY OUTSIDE GROUPS – CIR WITH A PATH TO CITIZENSHIP IS INEVITABLE Frank Sharry. Americans want it. America’s Voice. he will feel at least as much pressure from others on the right." And while he will feel pressure from some on the hard right to resist reform. such as business executives. Latino Republicans and conservative thought leaders. Hagel. will be championed by the president. Guns. . They simply will not want to bear the blame for keeping the Senate and the White House out of reach for Republicans for a generation. The bottom line: Immigration reform is an idea whose time has come. Democrats have promised it and Republicans need it. a bipartisan breakthrough in the Senate could send those numbers as high as 3 to 1. but not if he insists on a "majority of the majority.

Climate. but Republicans are still calling for more before they will consider reform. . 39 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – ALREADY DONE BORDER ENFORCEMENT BORDER ENFORCEMENT HAS BEEN ACCOMPLISHED – THIS GETS BY ONE OF THE GOP’S KEY ISSUES ON CIR Elise Foley.com/news/the-road-forward] Last week. Enforcing the border. an author of the report and a former commissioner of the U. check. such as an enforcement mechanism and high-skilled worker visas.13 [http://www.13 General. while leaving out more contentious items such as a pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants.' and then you look at what we're actually doing.16. so it's really time." the official said. The administration is highly skeptical of claims from Republicans that immigration reform can or should be done in a piecemeal fashion. won't be enough to win over Republicans. 1. Guns. and devotes massive sums to policing the borders.huffingtonpost. Going down that road. The border is as secure as it's been in a generation or two. Hagel. Republicans have demanded that the border be secured first." STUDIES PROVE WE’VE PRIORITIZED BORDER ENFORCEMENT ALREADY Elise Foley.' We're there. Citizenship p. the White House has learned. but not sufficiently touting its record of doing so. "But if you go back and look at the 2006 and 2007 bills. before other elements of immigration reform. the White House worries.com/news/the-road-forward] It starts with a lesson from his first term. could result in passage of the less politically complicated pieces. In a briefing with The Huffington Post.S. The Huffington Post. "Enforcement is certainly part of the picture. The White House has met many of the desired metrics for border security.15. Debt. a senior administration official said the White House believes it has met enforcement goals and must now move to a comprehensive solution.15. Yet the administration has been by many measures the strictest ever on immigration enforcement. check. if you go back and look at John McCain's 10-point 'This is what I've got to get done before I'm prepared to talk about immigration. the enforcement-is-working argument was bolstered by a report from the nonpartisan Migration Policy Institute. The Huffington Post. it's like 'check. Immigration and Naturalization Service. There are some clear metrics to point to on the border in particular. 1.Planet Debate Politics 1. which found that the government is pouring more money into its immigration agencies than the other federal law-enforcement efforts combined. said she hopes putting out more information can add to the immigration debate.huffingtonpost.13 [http://www. although there is always more to be done. and Doris Meissner.

Guns. English tests and "going to the back of the line. Debt. . long time.15.Planet Debate Politics 1. 1.huffingtonpost. Climate." which means waiting for possibly a long.16. and it will be a non-negotiable in his plan.13 General. Hagel. It would likely involve fines. It wouldn't be the "amnesty" decried by some on the right. 40 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – OBAMA WILL PUSH THE PATH TO CITIZENSHIP WILL BE NON-NEGOTIABLE FOR OBAMA Elise Foley. Obama has consistently said that a path to citizenship is vital to immigration reform. The Huffington Post.com/news/the-road-forward] Citizenship will be another major question. Citizenship p.13 [http://www.

rejects the findings of the Migration Policy Institute and fears that reform might not prevent future swells in unauthorized immigration -.15. It's unclear now if 2013 is any different. They note that the administration has in some cases decided not to deport undocumented immigrants it detects. Guns. the emotions and the host of special interests involved in the immigration debate have paralyzed Congress for years.13 [www. 41 of 62 PATH TO CITIZENSHIP – NOT INEVITABLE FINAL PASSAGE OF CIR IS STILL POLITICALLY UNCERTAIN Elise Foley. a key figure in the ongoing debate and the former head of the House Judiciary Committee. The Huffington Post. "I don't think the basic reality has changed.com/2013/1/15/rubio_obama_diazbalart_roslehtinen_jeb_bush. executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies. 1. Lamar Smith (R-Texas). Republicans in Congress. Climate.16. if not most. Hagel.com/news/the-road-forward] It's not clear whether the politics have changed enough for a bill to pass. Citizenship p. Such concerns allow some Republicans to draw a hard line on the idea of citizenship for the undocumented. Mark Krikorian. Conservatives see too much of what they regard as lenience in Obama's actions to date. HispanicBusiness. Conservatives point to the deferred action policy for young undocumented immigrants and guidelines that put a low priority on removing some other categories of immigrants. of any new policy and the major sticking point for many." Krikorian said of immigration politics. Debt.Planet Debate Politics 1. The polarized Congress could barely stave off the so-called "fiscal cliff" debt-andspending controversy last month. .hispanicbusiness.huffingtonpost.15. STILL NO GUARANTEE THAT 2013 IS THAT DIFFERENT ON CIR Marc Caputo. although the percentage of criminals being deported has gone up. said on Monday that Congress shouldn't trust the president on "mass amnesty" and that a bill including citizenship "will have a hard time" in the House.Com 1. Conservatives who stress the “enforcement first” approach don‟t think so. Rep.a key goal.13 General.13 [http://www. after all.htm] But the complexity.

We need new and far more advanced technologies. are simply not yet ready to compete with fossil fuels.Planet Debate Politics 1. Solar power. such as a tax or some other price on carbon dioxide emissions. Hagel. you will need to rally the nation around the issue of tackling climate change. like solar and advanced biofuels. remains much more expensive than electricity generated from fossil fuels. And it will require market incentives. Open Letter to President Obama. Climate. 1. Perhaps most important. from increasing funding for energy R&D to helping establish facilities where companies can share the costs and risks of testing new technologies.16. for example. Guns. still generates less than 1 percent of our nation’s electricity and. Creating cleaner ways to produce energy will require inventions in physics and chemistry labs and innovations in how we scale up and test those inventions.com/featuredstory/508841/dear-mr-president-time-to-dealwith-climate-change/] Renewable energy sources. under most circumstances.13 [http://www. .technologyreview. 42 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – OBAMA CAN BOOST RENEWABLES OBAMA’S CLIMATE CHANGE POLICIES CAN BOOST RENEWABLE ENERGY Technology Review. Your administration can play a critical role in each of these areas.2. Only with broad public support can you hope to push a recalcitrant Congress into passing legislation that will establish some form of carbon pricing. to encourage consumers and industry to use clean energy. Debt.13 General. Citizenship p.

. 1. Open Letter to President Obama. Climate. Citizenship p. The inexpensive energy made available by these drilling activities is good news for the overall economy. the glut of cheap natural gas created by advanced drilling technologies and by the nation‟s vast supply of shale gas has made it difficult for renewable energy to compete on price.16. including natural gas and related deposits of shale oil.2.technologyreview. but it is also a stark reminder that the motive for adopting non-fossil fuels is not market-driven but is—and always has been—a simple one: we must do it to reduce carbon dioxide emissions and begin stabilizing our climate.Planet Debate Politics 1.com/featuredstory/508841/dear-mr-president-time-to-dealwith-climate-change/] Adding to our difficulties is the recent boom in our country’s production of fossil fuels. 43 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – RENEWABLES NOT GROWING NATURAL GAS AND SHALE OIL DISCOVERIES ARE UNDERCUTTING RENEWABLE ENERGY Technology Review.13 [http://www. Already. Guns. Hagel.13 General. Debt.

1. like you. It is quite possible that if this is not done over the next four years. To have a decent chance of limiting the average global temperature increase to 2 °C and avoiding the most devastating effects of climate change. You have the power and the opportunity to lay the groundwork for a new clean-energy policy that will help us avoid the worst consequences of climate change. you have a chance to take risks.Planet Debate Politics 1. we will need carbon emissions to peak at no more than 32. Climate.13 General.com/featuredstory/508841/dear-mr-president-time-to-dealwith-climate-change/] But as extensive and exacting analyses over the last decade have shown.16.13 [http://www. it will be too late. and to start falling no later than 2017.6 metric gigatons. The president who takes office that year will thus be facing a far more urgent problem—probably.technologyreview. Open Letter to President Obama. The International Energy Agency reports that global emissions of carbon dioxide from fossil-fuel combustion reached a record 31.2.6 metric gigatons in 2011. Citizenship p. But as a president in his final term. Debt. with no political consensus on how to solve it. . Guns. Hagel. 44 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – OBAMA KEY TO CLIMATE CHANGE OBAMA’S TERM WILL BE DECISIVE IN THE CLIMATE CHANGE BATTLE Technology Review. we can no longer wait without risking dramatic upheavals in global security and the health and welfare of hundreds of millions of the world‟s inhabitants.

federal agencies concluded that rising temperatures caused by fossil fuel emissions have directly contributed to increased wildfires.Planet Debate Politics 1. Guns.11. Hagel. On Friday.S. a new draft report by 13 U.16.13 [http://www. Climate.nationaljournal. the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration reported that 2012 was by far the hottest year on record in the contiguous U. the spread of insecttransmitted disease.S.com/magazine/obama-faces-dilemma-on-mother-of-allclimate-change-regulations-20130110] This week. rising sea levels.S. Obama heard a wailing siren warning him to stick to his pledge: On Monday. Debt. 1. Citizenship p. melting glaciers and decreasing water supply across the U. 45 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – GOVERNMENT ACTION NECESSARY NEW REPORTS SHOW GOVERNMENT ACTION NECESSARY TO PREVENT CLIMATE CHANGE Coral Davenport. worse destruction is on the way. It was also the nation‟s second-most-extreme year for destructive weather events. Scientists said the evidence is unequivocal that the heat and catastrophic weather are linked to climate change caused by fossil-fuel pollution—and that without governmental action to stop that pollution. with 11 disasters sustaining $1 billion each in economic losses. The National Journal.13 General. .

would reduce its carbon pollution 17 percent by 2020. At a 2009 United Nations summit. 1. There is no way. director of the climate and energy program at the World Resources Institute. can meet its existing climate pledge. It will make it very difficult for the U.13 General. the nations of the world are scheduled to come together to sign a landmark.‖ . experts say.13 [http://www. Obama signed an accord pledging that the U. The rest of the world is awaiting action from Washington.nationaljournal. binding global treaty to cut carbon emissions enough to stave off the most catastrophic effects of climate change. Hagel. Debt. is seen as not acting. Citizenship p. to meet its commitment internationally. Guns.S. then other countries can hide behind the U.Planet Debate Politics 1.S.com/magazine/obama-faces-dilemma-on-mother-of-allclimate-change-regulations-20130110] But the president doesn‟t have the luxury of time. without either a new climate law from Congress or new EPA rules on existing power plants.11.S. 46 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – OBAMA GLOBAL LEADERSHIP ACTION BY THE U.‖ said Jennifer Morgan. And if the United States—historically.S. And in 2015. there‟s no reason to expect the rest of the world‟s nations to live up to their obligations. let alone sign on with any credibility to a future global treaty. ―The new regulations on existing plants are going to be essential for the U.S.S. ―If the U.16.S. to have any credibility or influence. the largest globalwarming polluter—fails to show it can meet its climate pledge. Climate. that the U. IN THE NEXT YEAR WILL BE KEY TO GLOBAL LEADERSHIP ON CLIMATE CHANGE Coral Davenport. The National Journal. a think tank.

6% drop in electricity related emissions at the UN climate talks in Doha last month but rising shale gas prices are making coal cost competitive again. and emission levels will surely follow. Climate change envoy Todd Stern hailed the 8. Responding to Climate Change. 1. Coal emits around twice the CO2 of natural gas per unit of energy generated as well as generating greater levels of other pollutants that damage human health.13 [http://www. . Hagel.Planet Debate Politics 1.10. 47 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – COAL COMING BACK RISING SHALE PRICES MAKING COAL COMPETITIVE AGAIN – COAL CARBON EMISSIONS WILL START TO RISE John Parnell. In 2011 Coal’s share fell below 40% for the first time since 1978. Climate.13 General. Guns.16. Now those figures are heading up again. Citizenship p.rtcc.org/coal-comeback-threatens-obamas-climate-change-policy/] New figures released this week by the Energy information Administration (EIA) reveal that the use of coal by power plants is increasing again after being displaced by cheap domestic shale gas in recent years. Debt.

Planet Debate Politics 1. 48 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – COAL REGULATIONS HELP THE ECONOMY REPLACING COAL PLANTS INCREASES JOBS John Parnell. Climate. Two coal plants are also being converted by the company to burn cleaner.10. led by vocal climate change skeptic Fred Upton’s Energy and Commerce Committee. . ―This retirement announcement by Georgia Power is disappointing yet unsurprising. Already. creating 2000 jobs along the way. we have seen a number of coal plants fall victim to the Obama administration’s assault on coal and I would not be surprised if there are even more closures in the months ahead.16.13 [http://www.‖ said Energy and Power Subcommittee Chairman Ed Whitfield (R-KY) Georgia Power is replacing this coal capacity with two new nuclear reactors creating 5000 jobs during construction and 800 permanent positions afterwards. Debt. Guns. Hagel. cheaper gas. is jobs at coal power stations. Citizenship p.13 General. The latest press release by the committee states that Georgia Power is closing 15 coal units putting 500 jobs on the line.rtcc. Responding to Climate Change.org/coal-comeback-threatens-obamas-climate-change-policy/] The focus of the War on Coal accusations. 1.

com/2013/01/11/carbon-taxes-provoke-debate-oneconomic-impact/] The economist Robert H.blogs. made the basic case that high carbon taxes on gasoline would lead to more fuel-efficient cars. Frank. International Herald Tribune. ―This is a way to secure competitiveness in the future. Debt. of Cornell University.13 General. Frank. 49 of 62 CLIMATE CHANGE – CARBON TAX HELPS ECONOMY CARBON TAX WOULD ENCOURAGE FUEL ECONOMY AND GREEN REVENUES Christopher Schuetze. the Irish government is managing to balance its books. 1. Motorists in many countries already pay that much more than Americans do. would slowly rise by somewhat less than $3 a gallon. suggested that a carbon tax of $300 for a ton of carbon emissions might be enough to structurally change the kind of cars Americans drive. gas and even garbage. Dr.11.nytimes. Climate. in an opinion piece last year. .16. Elisabeth Rosenthal reported late last year that Ireland’s deficit has decreased from 32. Citizenship p. the European Union’s commissioner for climate action. in part due to carbon taxes on cars.4 percent in of gross domestic product in 2010 to 8.Planet Debate Politics 1.” An excellent article on Ireland‟s carbon tax boon points to the other part of the equation — despite three years of recession.3 percent of GDP in 2012 in part due to a new taxes on carbon — despite the economic downturn. and they seem to have adapted by driving substantially more efficient vehicles.‖ Connie Hedegaard. said in an interview with Elisabeth. Guns. Hagel.13 [http://rendezvous. He wrote: ―The price of gasoline. for example.

Citizenship p. Depending on where the carbon tax is applied. Climate. Debt. utilities and production costs go up.blogs. the head of the retail organization wrote in a statement: “The introduction of carbon pricing was a massive legislative change for small business and one which has had a significant impact. Meanwhile.13 General. Russell Zimmerman. the Australian Retailers Association released results of a survey in which they found that 80 percent of Australian retailers say their business has been negatively affected by the new carbon taxes in place in that country since July of 2012. 50 of 62 AFFIRMATIVE – CLIMATE CHANGE – CARBON TAX HURTS ECONOMY CARBON TAX HURTS SMALL BUSINESSES IN AUSTRALIA Christopher Schuetze. retailers are taking the hit of the carbon tax as consumers bypass the stores to pay household bills.com/2013/01/11/carbon-taxes-provoke-debate-oneconomic-impact/] Opponents of carbon taxes are not sure about that claim to competitiveness.13 [http://rendezvous. Last month. the cost of doing business has gone up for retailers due to higher utility bills and costs accumulated throughout the supply chain. Hagel. In a climate of already suppressed retail spending.11. International Herald Tribune. it can make transport. Guns.16. which eventually fall onto retailers’ bottom lines…‖ . 1.Planet Debate Politics 1.nytimes.

S. Debt.16. Guns. a tax that increases energy prices would disproportionately affect the budgets of the poorest American families. Citizenship p.8. which comes at a time when many companies.heritage. Economics Research Fellow. However. Climate.org/research/reports/2013/01/carbon-tax-would-raiseunemployment-not-revenue] Since an overwhelming majority of America's energy needs are met by carbon-emitting fossil fuels. lured by the prospect of abundant and cheap natural gas. gasoline. and fewer jobs. The result is higher energy costs. . the US market has transformed to become one of the most advantageous markets for chemical production in the world. Businesses. "With a new and abundant source of low-cost feedstock. are moving to the United States. would likely pass those costs on to consumers.Planet Debate Politics 1. thus depriving fossil-fuel-based companies much-needed cash for more efficient power generation." A carbon tax would unnecessarily reverse this resurgence. high energy costs would squeeze profit margins and prevent businesses from investing and expanding. LESS COMPETITIVE David Kreutzer. regulations of these fuels directly raise the cost of electricity. 1.13 General. Economics Research Fellow. and home heating oil.S. faced with higher energy costs. Heritage Foundation. A recent KPMG analysis of the U. energy-intensive industries and manufacturing would feel the adverse effects of a carbon tax. Hagel.org/research/reports/2013/01/carbon-tax-would-raiseunemployment-not-revenue] In particular. CARBON TAX WOULD MAKE THE U. 51 of 62 AFFIRMATIVE – CLIMATE CHANGE – CARBON TAX HURTS ECONOMY A CARBON TAX WOULD DAMAGE THE ECONOMY David Kreutzer. chemical industry emphasizes. Heritage Foundation. 1. lower income.heritage. Since low-income families spend a larger proportion of their income on energy.13 [http://www.13 [http://www.8. Investors might even move their funds away from energy companies and toward less regulated business enterprises. diesel fuel. if a company had to absorb the costs.

Economics Research Fellow.Planet Debate Politics 1. Guns.13 [http://www.8. Even if the U.S. CARBON TAX WOULD HAVE LITTLE IMPACT ON GLOBAL EMISSIONS David Kreutzer.13 General. 52 of 62 AFFIRMATIVE – CLIMATE CHANGE – NO CARBON TAX SOLVENCY U. consequently. it would reduce global temperatures by only a few tenths of a degree Celsius by the close of the century. . Climate. Hagel. would do next to nothing to reduce global temperatures. which shows little appetite for squeezing economic growth for the sake of the environment.S. Debt. Heritage Foundation. 1.org/research/reports/2013/01/carbon-tax-would-raiseunemployment-not-revenue] Unilaterally reducing greenhouse gases would not make a dent on global emissions and. This is because future carbon emissions will come overwhelmingly from the developing world (China and India. for example).heritage.16. Citizenship p. were to curb carbon emissions 83 percent below 2005 levels by 2050 (what cap-and-trade bills required).

13 [http://www.S. 53 of 62 AFFIRMATIVE – CLIMATE CHANGE – NO U. . 1. SOLVENCY AMERICAN INFLUENCE ON OTHER EMISSIONS IS WISHFUL THINKING David Kreutzer.8. Despite actions taken by the EPA to regulate carbon dioxide. leads in reducing emissions. there are plans to build nearly 1. Climate. the rest of the world would follow suit. Guns. Debt. Citizenship p. Heritage Foundation. Hagel. But this is clearly not the case. Economics Research Fellow. Developing countries want access to cheap.heritage. It is simply wishful thinking to assume that these countries would follow America's lead and curb economic growth to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.Planet Debate Politics 1. the developing world has massive expansions planned to increase coal consumption.16.4 million megawatts. reliable electricity (especially since many areas do not even have access to electricity) and have more pressing environmental needs.org/research/reports/2013/01/carbon-tax-would-raiseunemployment-not-revenue] A common argument is that if the U. According to a recent report from the World Resources Institute. China and India alone account for 76 percent of the proposals.13 General.200 coal-fired power plants in 59 different countries totaling over 1.S.

Guns.com/magazine/obama-faces-dilemma-on-mother-of-allclimate-change-regulations-20130110] Under the terms of a Supreme Court ruling and the nation‟s clean-air laws. .CLIMATE CHANGE – REGULATION HAS HUGE BENEFIT OBAMA CAN ENACT A MAJOR GREENHOUSE POLLUTANT REDUCTION REGULATION WITHOUT CONGRESSIONAL APPROVAL Coral Davenport. It will also be met with an avalanche of efforts by industry and lawmakers to overturn it. either in Congress or in the courts.13 General. this is the mother of all climate rules. Citizenship p.16.nationaljournal. 1. The new limits will ignite raging political opposition from the nation’s most powerful fossil-fuel interests and likely lead to the shutdown of many of the dirtiest coal plants. The question the administration is grappling with is when to roll out the rule. to slash their emissions of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming. president of the advocacy group Clean Air Watch.Planet Debate Politics 1. the Environmental Protection Agency is required to issue a regulation that will force existing industrial polluters. Hagel. Climate. The National Journal.13 [http://www.11. ―In terms of actual real emissions. The rule could have a profound environmental impact by reducing the nation‟s global-warming pollutants by up to 20 percent. such as coal-fired power plants and oil refineries. 54 of 62 AFFIRMATIVE . possibly costing jobs in the process.” said Frank O‟Donnell. Debt.

55 of 62 AFFIRMATIVE .13 General. Debt. in a rare show of unity.11.com/magazine/obama-faces-dilemma-on-mother-of-allclimate-change-regulations-20130110] The Obama administration has sat on the rule affecting existing polluters for months to avoid issuing a potential job-killer in an election year.16.000 small businesses sent Obama a letter urging him to use his executive authority to enact climate regulations on existing polluters. And advocates know it. Guns. Climate.13 [http://www. insisting that Obama has “the authority under existing law to achieve urgently needed reductions in the carbon pollution that is disrupting our climate and damaging our health. .Planet Debate Politics 1. Citizenship p. The National Journal. That excuse is now gone. 150.nationaljournal. 1.” On Friday.CLIMATE CHANGE – PRESSURE TO ENACT REGULATIONS OUTSIDE GROUPS WILL PRESSURE OBAMA TO ENACT STRICT CLIMATE CHANGE REGULATIONS ON CARBON POLLUTERS Coral Davenport. Hagel. 70 environmental organizations sent a letter to the White House. This week.

there is little that China or any other country can do to influence the outcome. could prompt foreign creditors to unload large portions of their holdings. "While the entire world will suffer if the negotiations reach a standoff. Citizenship p.13 [http://usa.Planet Debate Politics 1. inasmuch as many economies are tied to that of the United States.16.15. Debt. Hagel. But others say a sudden selloff would be damaging to other countries' economic interests. China and the rest of the world are basically bystanders in the fiscal-policy drama playing out in the US. .com. 56 of 62 DEBT CEILING – DOLLAR IMPACT DEBT DEFAULT WOULD RISK ABANDONMENT OF THE DOLLAR China Daily 1. Some analysts believe a loss of confidence in US debt. inducing others to follow and causing a run on the dollar in world markets. much less a debt default by Washington. according to a report by the Council on Foreign Relations. Climate.cn/epaper/2013-01/15/content_16120098.htm] Despite the stakes. Prasad said. The report also cites long-term concerns of some US officials that persistent volatility in the dollar caused by a debt default would bolster calls in the international community to end its status as the world's reserve currency." he said.13 General. Guns.chinadaily.

But as American politics has become more polarised. Citizenship p. furious that in the recent tussle over the ―fiscal cliff‖ they caved in on tax increases and have no spending cuts to show for it.economist. As a bipartisan litany of mainstream economists have warned. Defiant Democrats are floating crackpot responses such as issuing a $1 trillion coin to avoid the debt ceiling or invoking the 14th amendment to the constitution.12.13 General.ncpolicywatch. the debt ceiling has been an annoyance. highways.org/2013/01/15/will-us-house-refuse-to-pay-nations-bills-allowdefault/] The consequences of refusing a debt limit increase are very real. war-fighting expenses. REFUSING TO RAISE THE DEBT CEILING WOULD THROW THE ECONOMY BACK INTO A RECESSION The Progressive Pulse 1. including payouts to Social Security and Medicare beneficiaries. refusing to increase the debt limit will inflict significant damage to the national economy and likely pitch us into another recession—either by ensuring the federal government defaults on its existing debt or by significantly shrinking current federal expenditures. Hagel. Guns. . and research and development. affording whichever party was out of power the opportunity to extract concessions before allowing normal borrowing to resume. and on K-12 education. Debt. Climate.com/news/leaders/21569423-debt-ceiling-america-serves-nouseful-purpose-and-should-be-abolished-cliff] Most of the time.Planet Debate Politics 1. it has become an instrument of mass financial destruction. In the summer of 2011 Republicans openly used the threat of default to force Mr Obama and Democrats into a deficit-cutting deal. which they say forbids default.16.15. It may even have done some good by raising the political price of deficits.13 [pulse.13 [http://www. Republicans. are spoiling for another fight. healthcare. The episode prompted one credit-rating agency to strip America of its triple-A rating. 57 of 62 DEBT CEILING – IMPACT THREATS TO DEFAULT ARE WEAPONS OF MASS FINANCIAL DESTRUCTION The Economist 1.

16. the result would be national default.ncpolicywatch. And largely ineffective if the goal is deficit reduction. Hagel.13 General. if the Treasury foregoes paying bondholders.13 [pulse. as future borrowing would cost significantly more than it does now under ultra-low interest rates.org/2013/01/15/will-us-house-refuse-to-pay-nations-bills-allowdefault/] On the one hand. Debt. Guns. . Climate. the impacts on the stability of the global economy would likely be catastrophic.15.ECONOMY REFUSAL TO PAY BONDHOLDERS WOULD CAUSE A CATASTROPHIC IMPACT TO THE GLOBAL ECONOMY The Progressive Pulse 1. Citizenship p. Given the importance of the dollar as an international reserve currency.Planet Debate Politics 1. 58 of 62 DEBT CEILING – IMPACT . since—ironically—this approach would also likely result in more long-term debt than under the current approach. and a dramatic increase in interest rates by risk-averse investors. a significant downgrade in in our nation‟s credit-rating.

Hagel. Debt. Barry Eichengreen.16. Climate.alarabiya. greenback for the throne that sits currently. They have delayed the euro‟s emergence as a full-fledged rival while accelerating the emergence of the renminbi. Guns. India and emerging economies and that could suggest.11. the world may turn into a multi-currency system. but the size of the shift away from the dollar will be mainly depends on finding suitable competitor (or replacement) of the dollar.Planet Debate Politics 1.net/views/2013/01/11/259854.13 General. Naser AL-Tamimi. 59 of 62 DEBT CEILING – AT: DOLLAR SCENARIO THERE IS NO PLAUSIBLE ALTERNATIVE TO THE DOLLAR RIGHT NOW Dr. But they have done nothing to alter the central conclusions (…) the dollar remains the only true global currency for the time being. a professor of economics and political Science at the University of California. it’s safe to say that the center of gravity of the global economy is shifting toward China.” . in his excellent report ―Is the Age of Dollar Dominance Coming to an End?‖ published recently by the Global Financial Institute puts it bluntly: “Recent events in the world economy have reinforced the dollar‟s international role.13 [http://english. 1. Berkeley.S. Middle East Analyst. Citizenship p. As for the future.html] At present there is no alternative currency rivaling the dollar or it will displace the U.

FallStreet. Citizenship p. Debt. grotesque debt is permitted to grow unfettered thanks to the nearly universal conclusion that ending USD hegemony now would cause a global crisis of unthinkable proportions. beyond central banks slowly pecking away at gold. 60 of 62 DEBT CEILING – AT: DOLLAR SCENARIO CHALLENGERS ARE TOO INVESTED IN DOLLARS TO THREATEN IT Brady Willett.13 [http://news.Com. Guns.php] Be it dreams of a gold dinar and pricing oil in Euros.Planet Debate Politics 1.com/FallStreet/1358184058. not much has really changed: The vast majority of central banks carry more dollars than any other currency. the vast majority of institutional money prefers to run in the Treasury market.14. . With so many actors terrified of rocking the boat. 1. Climate.13 General. However.16. a bevy of anti-dollar sentiments have taken shape in recent years. Hagel. or harsh words from countries like Brazil and Russia.goldseek. and key countries like China are loath to stop using the dollar and/or purchasing Treasuries due to the negative shock that doing so would wrought on their economies.

61 of 62 DEBT CEILING – AT: NO IMPACT – CAN MAKE SELECTIVE PAYMENTS SELECTIVE PAYMENT IS NO SOLUTION The Economist 1.Planet Debate Politics 1.13 General. contractors and millions of others of money needed to meet their own obligations. Debt. Citizenship p. Even a few days‟ default would roil the global financial system. Disgruntled creditors could challenge the legality of prioritising interest payments. It would also deprive doctors. pensioners.12. driving up interest rates.economist. Guns. . setting off a chain reaction of defaults.16. not first. One miscalculation could leave the Treasury without enough money to make an interest payment. Hagel. The mere possibility could incite skittish investors to dump their holdings. Failure to raise the debt ceiling would force immediate spending cuts equal to 6% of GDP. which relies on Treasuries in countless transactions.com/news/leaders/21569423-debt-ceiling-america-serves-nouseful-purpose-and-should-be-abolished-cliff] The Treasury could try to soften the blow of hitting the debt ceiling by making interest payments on its debt the priority while leaving some other bills unpaid. populists could demand that Chinese bondholders be paid last. Nor would the sanctity of the debt be guaranteed.13 [http://www. Climate. Not only would that threaten to send the economy back into recession. Yet that would still wreak havoc. The federal government now borrows nearly 30 cents of every dollar it spends.

The recovery of the housing sector will continue and probably accelerate. boosted by some of the details in last week’s deal.16. 62 of 62 DEBT CEILING – THREAT ALONE WON’T HURT ECONOMY UNDERLYING ECONOMIC STRENGTH WILL OVERCOME POLITICAL UNCERTAINTIES IN 2013 Irwin Stelzer. .Planet Debate Politics 1. The dollar will fall and exports rise as the 2013 deficit tops $1 trillion and Ben Bernanke‟s Federal Reserve Board continues to churn out dollars to keep interest rates at close to zero. Fortunately. there is reason to believe that 2013 will be a year in which the economy does indeed overcome those headwinds. Guns. Climate.13 General. Debt. and the gnashing of teeth of the nation’s savers. Auto companies expect to move more than 15 million cars and small trucks from dealers to consumers’ garages.13 [http://www.html?page=3] So there will be substantial political headwinds that the private sector must overcome if growth is to be sufficient to reduce the unemployment rolls and increase the flow of tax revenues to the Treasury. Regulators will be unable to stifle completely the development of shale gas resources and the attendant growth of manufacturing industries dependent on that low-cost fuel. Hagel. Citizenship p. such as retention of the mortgage deduction.weeklystandard. despite doubts by an increasing number of Bernanke’s colleagues. director economic policy studies.14.com/articles/march-madness_693767. Growth in the important service sector is accelerating. about 1 million more than in 2012. 1. Hudson Institute.

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful