Question: ____________________________________________

Presented by: Draft #: Assessed by: Date: Proposed answer:

Evidence #1: Summarize in your own words the evidence for this idea

How does my real world experience support this?

Source is Evidence #2: Summarize in your own words the evidence for this idea

Reviewed? __

Recent? ________

Relevant? __

How does my real-world experience contradict this?

Source is

Reviewed?

Recent?

Relevant? __

__ Ask at least one clarifying question, such as… • “What exactly…” • “What’s an example of …” Ask at least one precision question, such as • “How much…” • “How often…” • “Where/When…” Cause • Make your own statement about cause if possible • OR Ask a question about cause Ideas that are supported by both sources

________ Questions that need to be answered in order to accept this idea

Questions for the future

Ideas that contradict themselves or each other Ideas from the model that support the proposed answer

Ideas from the model

that contradict the proposed answer

My conclusion:

□ Needs more detail

□ Needs to be tested

□ Accepted

□ Rejected

Master your semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Special offer for students: Only $4.99/month.

Master your semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Cancel anytime.