You are on page 1of 3

A Different Model for Design Education | Metropolis POV | Me

http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode

http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode Search SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER MAGAZINE ARCHIVES MEDIA KIT
http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode Search SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER MAGAZINE ARCHIVES MEDIA KIT

Search

Search SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER MAGAZINE ARCHIVES MEDIA KIT PRODUCT

SUBSCRIBE

NEWSLETTER

MAGAZINE

ARCHIVES

MEDIA KIT

PRODUCT INFO

CONTACT US

CURRENT ISSUEMAGAZINE ARCHIVES MEDIA KIT PRODUCT INFO CONTACT US CELEBRATING 30 BLOG MULTIMEDIA BOOKS EVENTS NEOCON NEXT

CELEBRATING 30

BLOG

MULTIMEDIA

BOOKS

EVENTS

NEOCON

NEXT GENERATION

DESIGN COMPETITION

STATE OF DESIGN

CEU

NEW PRODUCTS

DESIGNMART

CONNECT WITH US

STATE OF DESIGN CEU NEW PRODUCTS DESIGNMART CONNECT WITH US A Different Model for Design Education
STATE OF DESIGN CEU NEW PRODUCTS DESIGNMART CONNECT WITH US A Different Model for Design Education
STATE OF DESIGN CEU NEW PRODUCTS DESIGNMART CONNECT WITH US A Different Model for Design Education
STATE OF DESIGN CEU NEW PRODUCTS DESIGNMART CONNECT WITH US A Different Model for Design Education
STATE OF DESIGN CEU NEW PRODUCTS DESIGNMART CONNECT WITH US A Different Model for Design Education
STATE OF DESIGN CEU NEW PRODUCTS DESIGNMART CONNECT WITH US A Different Model for Design Education

A Different Model for Design Education

By Sherin Wing

Thursday, March 14, 2013 9:33 am

Agility and adaptation are central to any professional field.

Those about to enter a profession must learn practical and intellectual skills. But the days when specialized and narrowly defined skill-sets guaranteed a steady and reliable “living” are gone. Today’s practical skills need to be accompanied by rigorous and critical modes of thinking.

One case in point is the graduate program at Art Center College of Design’s Media Design Practices (MDP). In conjunction with the school’s initiative, Designmatters, which provides a blueprint for design education, the Field track of MDP provides students with a unique foundation of theory and on-the-ground training. Faculty member Sean Donahue describes the program as structured around “Investigation and intervention—how designing can be an inquiry and mode of knowledge production to inform other disciplines and issues in a unique way. Also, how can these be combined with work being done in areas of ‘good’ and social impact?”

work being done in areas of ‘good’ and social impact?” Proposals for collective farming models for

Proposals for collective farming models for women, image via mediadesignpractices/judytoretti /Six-Weeks-in-Uganda

While “activist” design has been around for years, the Art Center model unites critical analysis with design skills. The goal is to provide useful solutions for people locally and abroad without being culturally reductive or condescending. Too often, designers try to reinvent social intervention in their haste to be in the vanguard of a “new” approach and school-based design projects. These can be equally misguided. The result can waste material resources, human capital and money, while reinforcing cultural assumptions about the “other.” This is especially true of built interventions. These can be unnecessary, unusable, and often are left to decay. Wasted resources and human effort that fail to correct culturally essentializing narratives have been well documented in ecotourism and voluntourism. These consumer-based activities exemplify the perils of modern cultural colonialism. And while there are many defenders of the “good” they do, the fact remains that they, educational institutions, and even NGO’s like Oxfam struggle with their long histories of colonialism hidden yet still entrenched in many current activities.

RECENT POSTS

With the growth of micro apartments in the US and abroad, furniture that can transform is … » in the US and abroad, furniture that can transform is»

Convertible Furniture for Micro Apartments

Agility and adaptation are central to any professional field. Those about to enter a profession… » »

A Different Model for Design Education

I have satisfied my first order for a large retailer, Anthropologie, and I must say I feel great. I … » large retailer, Anthropologie, and I must say I feel great. I»

How a New Product Gets Recognized

“Was James Stirling modernism’s last great prophet, or postmodernism’s original poster… » »

New Book on James Stirling

As head of the Health Product Declaration (HPD) Collaborative, Peter C. Syrett comes to the… » »

Q&A: HPD, The Chairman’s Point of View

Photo by Toto Ong, Courtesy Urban Omnibus. How do you measure life in a city? For its second… » »

Call for Essays: Fuzzy Math

In 1975, musician Brian Eno and painter Peter Schmidt created a deck of cards called “Oblique… » »

Creative Leadership Is Gardening, Not Architecture

Photo: Lynn Saville If I could write about something for more than four lines that didn't have… » »

Light After Dark

Working With Nature four lines that didn't have … » Light After Dark In the age of ecology and

In the age of ecology and sustainability, landscape architecture, like other design»

The U.S. EPA, the European Union Commission on the Environment, the State of California are among … » Commission on the Environment, the State of California are among… »

Q&A: HPD, the Manufacturer’s Point of View

MOST COMMENTED

Welcome to Detroit (42) You Are So Wrong, Frank Gehry! (41) Duany vs Harvard GSD (40) An Open Letter to Dwell Magazine (37) Science for Designers: Scaling and Fractals

(31)

A Different Model for Design Education | Metropolis POV | Me

http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode

http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode Organization chart displaying the roles and structure of the
http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode Organization chart displaying the roles and structure of the

Organization chart displaying the roles and structure of the [anti-NGO] NGO, image via

mediadesignpractices/filter/field/mlamadrid/Planification-and-Self-Evaluation-Guide-

for-Social-no-empowerment

To avoid producing solutions based on invalid, often fantastical cultural projections, proposals must be rooted in a deep understanding of the culture, people, economy, and politics of the places chosen for intervention. This is, after all, an intervention. The key, according to Donahue, is “to start not with what has been created by others to ‘solve problems’ but instead start with the realities of lived life. This more holistic and community-led approach develops an understanding of the conditions as they are now—not as they were 50 or even 20 years ago. These social conditions are a set of ongoing and changing situations that are embedded in social contexts.”

The hope is that Art Center’s MDP Field Track model will influence other design programs. Anchored by three core faculty members, the program has an anthropologist, professor Elizabeth Chin; and two design faculty members, Chris Csikszentmihalyi and Donahue who provide a design perspective. Together, the team creates an educational framework that allows students to explore intelligent interventions. What’s more, these interventions are proposed within existing structures such as UNICEF. The results are intellectually rooted, design-oriented solutions spanning a range of class, economic, and political issues.

spanning a range of class, economic, and political issues. Diagram of factors involved in food production/consumption,

Diagram of factors involved in food production/consumption, image via mediadesignpractices/filter/field/betsykalven/Reductive-Food

Still Modern After All These Years (23)

View all recent comments

METROPOLIS BOOKS

These Years (23) View all recent comments METROPOLIS BOOKS LINKS AJ Notebook AMNP ArchDaily Archinect Architecture

LINKS

AJ Notebook AMNP ArchDaily Archinect Architecture for Humanity Architizer ArchNewsNow The Architects Newspaper Arkhitekton BLDG BLOG BOOMSPDESIGN Bustler

Core77

Curbed (NY, LA, SF) A Daily Dose of Architecture Design Corps Design Observer designboom Dexinger Dezeen The Dirt GreenSource The Infrastructurist designgeist theive.com Life Without Buildings Planetizen Project H Design Pruned Subtopia Treehugger UnBeige Urban Palimpsest Worldchanging

The students, guided by professor Chin, establish a solid intellectual foundation by exploring ethnography, ethics, social history, as well as develop research competencies. This type of approach is not often embraced by designers, as Chin says, “Thinking through making immerses students in works about ethnography, colonialism, and post colonialism. They also delve into political economy, feminism, structuralism, post structuralism, and other theoretical perspectives.” This, in addition to “exploring related social theory, design projects, research studies from a variety of disciplines, and the development of students’ own arguments and points of view,” she adds,“Key to this approach is taking the time to immerse ourselves in the culture and context as much as possible, rather than coming in with an idea of what needs to be done.”

After this immersion comes the first six-week trip. When they return to the states, the students develop their proposals. Then they return to the site for another three-to-five weeks to present their proposals to the community. The program is structured for inherent flexibility: students explore their own interests within a larger discursive field but that are contained by the project’s parameters.

A Different Model for Design Education | Metropolis POV | Me

http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode

http://www.metropolismag.com/pov/20130314/a-different-mode Diagram, land ownership, image via

Diagram, land ownership, image via mediadesignpractices/filter/field/mlamadrid/Balloon- Mapping

This year’s program is working with UNICEF in Kampala, Uganda. This is not intervention by “helicopter” in which students drop in, make some arbitrary “innovations,” document them for their blogs, and then leave. Nor is this styled as a work-for-hire mediation. Instead, MDP Field track requires more than one trip to the community site. As Donahue explains, “Students work with groups supported by the UNICEF country office. Equally important is that they work directly with CBO’s [Community Based Organizations] groups and families outside of UNICEF. Our students find that even though our partners’ mission may be about supporting children, addressing and providing that support requires engaging a range of actors from grandparents to teachers to local council members.”

The program provides a useful model for other design programs, whether they are associated with academic or other NGO’s and charity organizations. It offers an example of how to begin a productive exchange with communities who need help without replicating cultural colonialism, either intellectually or in practical interventions.

Surely the time has come for restructuring the way we engage each other and divesting ourselves of the condescension that has for too long dominated our interaction with people less materially fortunate than ourselves.

Sherin Wing writes on social issues as well as topics in architecture, urbanism, and design. She is a frequent contributor to ArchDaily, Architect Magazine and other publications. She is also co-author of The Real Architect’s Handbook. She received her PhD from UCLA. Follow Sherin on Twitter at @SherinWing

Comments (0) / Add a comment

on Twitter at @SherinWing Comments (0) / Add a comment Categories: Design , Education , Social

Categories: Design, Education, Social Sustainability, Socially Conscious Tags: Art Center College of Design, Designmatters, Media Design Practices, UNICEF