Annual Report
for Accredited Programmes 2005-2006
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 4
Contents
Summary 1
1. Managing the delivery of programmes 2
2. Retention and Attrition 6
3. Targeting 10
4. Analysing the results of the evaluations measures 12
5. Programmes update 14
List of Figures
Figure 1: Actual number of completions by year 2
Figure 2: Proportion of completions by programme 3
Figure 3: Actual Completions (Cumulative) 2005-06 3
Figure 4: Number of referrals made by year 3
Figure 5: Number of orders made compared to completions by year 4
Figure 6: Percentage of starters completing the programmes by year 4
Figure 7: Completion rate by programme commencement for 2005-06 5
Figure 8: Retention rate from referral through to completion 6
Figure 9: Retention rate by year for General Offending Behaviour Programmes
and Drink Impaired Drivers Programme 6
Figure 10: Retention rates by year for Violence Programmes 7
Figure 11: Retention rates by year for Substance Misuse programmes 7
Figure 12: Retention rates for SOTPs 7
Figure 13: Retention from referrals to licenses and orders 8
Figure 14: Retention from orders and licenses to commencements 8
Figure 15: Retention from commencements to completions 8
Figure 16: Comparison of retention rates by programme, prior to commencement
and during the programme 9
Figure 17: Reasons given by staff for offenders failing to complete programmes 9
Figure 18: OGRS scores for General Offending Behaviour Programmes 10
Figure 19: OGRS scores for Substance Misuse Programmes 10
Figure 20: ETS and Think First psychometric pre and post means 12
Figure 21: DID psychometric pre and post means 13
Figure 22: Substance Misuse psychometric pre and post means 13
Appendices
Appendix 1: Profile of programmes by area for 2005-06 16
Appendix 2: Programme Details 18
1
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 2
2
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 3
DID
27%
Figure 4: Number of referrals
made by year
1.4 Figure 3 shows that the cumulative number of Actual Completions (Cumulative) 2005-06
completions each month rose steadily, 18000
confirming that areas are generally delivering 16000
ay
ct
ov
ec
ar
Ju
Ap
Ju
Au
Se
Ja
Fe
O
3
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 4
Completions (%)
Figure 5: Number of orders made
80
60
compared to completions by year 40
20
0
Orders and Completions 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-05
Year
50000
40000
1.8 The percentage of programme starters
30000 remaining in the programme and completing
20000 has, however, fallen slightly from 68.2% in
2004-05 to 66% in 2005-06 as shown in
10000
figure 6. This dip in performance can be
0 attributed to two factors. Firstly, the
2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 implementation of domestic violence
Year programmes in many probation areas
Orders occurred during the second half of the year.
Completions Domestic violence programmes are lengthy
and so many areas would not get completions
within this financial year. Secondly, the
continued expansion of substance misuse
1.7 Figure 5 shows that as the number of orders programmes (in particular OSAP) essential to
has increased each year, so have the number meet the needs profile of offenders means
of completions. The figure also demonstrates that a greater number of offenders with
the gap between orders made and prolific offending histories and chaotic
completions, which was closing in previous lifestyles have been referred to programmes
years, widened slightly in 2005-06. This is and this may have impacted on drop out
mainly related to offenders not starting rates.
programmes rather than offenders failing to
complete them.
4
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 5
5
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 6
0 Commencements as
Referral Licences and Starters Completions % of Orders
Orders Issued Completions as %
of Commencements
6
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 7
70%
60%
50%
Figure 12: Retention rates for
40% SOTPs
30%
20%
10% Retention rates - SOTP programmes
0%
140.0%
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06
Year 120.0%
Orders Commencements
80.0%
60.0%
Programmes 0.0%
Referral to order & licence Order & licence to commencement Commencement to completion
80%
2.6 This is the first year that the SOTPs have
70%
%age Retention
7
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 8
Figure 13:
2.7 Figures 13 to 15 present the retention rates in
Retention Rate: Referral to licence and orders a format that allows easier comparison
100.0%
across programmes.
90.0% Average overall retention rate
80.0%
2.8 In terms of retention between referral and
licence or order (figure 13), 85% of all
70.0%
60.0%
referrals lead to an order or licence. The
50.0%
40.0%
highest retention rates are for ASRO and DID.
30.0%
ETS, OSAP and CALM are below average,
20.0% and the lowest rate is for WAC. It is difficult to
10.0% pinpoint why these differences occur.
0.0%
ETS TF OTO CSB DID OSAP ASRO IDAP CDVP ART CALM WAC
However, there does appear to be a
difference in the way the courts respond to
recommendations for WAC and for the other
Figure 14: accredited programmes.
Retention Rate: Order and Licence to Commencements 2.9 Figure 14 presents the level of retention by
100.0%
programme at the stage between
order/licence to starting the offending
90.0%
80.0%
80.0%
30.0%
20.0%
10.0%
0.0%
ETS TF OTO CSB DID OSAP ASRO IDAP CDVP ART CALM WAC
8
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 9
50.0%
20.0%
programmes
10.0%
0.0%
ETS TF OTO CSB DID OSAP ASRO IDAP CDVP ART CALM WAC Reasons for drop out 2005-2006
2%
the order. Revocation is the second most Sickness or ill health Other
9
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 10
2500 1500
Number of offenders
2000 1250
1500 1000
1000 750
500 500
0 250
ETS TF OTO WOMENS CSB
0
0-40 41-70 71+ ASRO OSAP
10
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 11
11
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:22 Page 12
12
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 13
Figure 21: DID psychometric pre better problem solving strategies. Offenders
and post means reported that they were more likely to be in
the contemplation stage of the Stages of
Psychometric Data
Change model prior to the programme and
for Offenders on DID more likely to be in the action stage
80 afterwards, indicating that motivation to
70 change had strengthened while attending the
60
programme. One measure of substance
dependence moved in an unexpected
50
direction. Offenders self reported higher
40
levels of dependence after the programme.
30 Although unexpected, this may not be a
20 negative result. It could be that having
10
completed the programme offenders are
more aware of their level of dependence and
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
more willing to acknowledge it.
Pre-Test Mean
Post-Test Mean
Figure 22: Substance Misuse
Key psychometric pre and post means
1. Alcohol Knowledge Quiz
2. Safe Driving Questionnaire
3. Attitude to Drinking & Driving Psychometric Data for Offenders
4. SPSI: Positive Problem Orientation on ASRO and OSAP
5. SPSI: Rational Problem Solving
35
6. BIS: Total Impulsivity
30
25
4.4 Figure 21 demonstrates that offenders who
20
complete the pre and post programme
assessments improve on all of the 15
13
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 14
14
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 15
Cognitive Skills - Think First / ETS By the end of the financial year, the Internet Sex
Refresh Offending Treatment Programme (i-SOTP) will be in
The ETS and Think First programmes have been in place across probation areas in England and Wales.
use for some time and require updating to reflect All 42 probation areas wish to take the programme
current practice. A joint project with HMPS has been and have submitted Implementation Plans to this
launched to develop a new national programme that effect within the year and many areas predict first
will replace both programmes and can be used in programme completions for within the first year. The
both services. Stakeholders will be consulted and internet programme enables us to address better this
recent advances in cognitive behavioural techniques particular type of offending and target the more
incorporated. The new draft programme will be ready general sex offending treatment programme better on
for piloting in July 2007 until December 2007, when it other types of sexual offending. During this financial
will be taken for approval to CSAP. year the Adapted Sex Offender Treatment
Programme is being piloted across six probation
areas: this programme is designed to cater for
Instrumental Violence Module developmentally disabled sex offenders and is
The Offending Behaviour Programmes team are catering fro previously unmet risk and need.
investigating the need for a programme or module for
offenders who use violence instrumentally. The
existing violence programmes cater primarily for Evaluation
offenders whose violence is associated with a
heightened emotional state, such as anger, or is Research and evaluation will focus on offender
reactive to a stressful situation. There are some feedback over the forthcoming year. As part of this
offenders who use violence or the threat of violence work programme there will be an examination of the
mainly in order to achieve their aims in a more factors which impact upon the level of offender
calculating manner. The domestic violence retention. NPD will work closely with areas and
programmes and the Cognitive Self-Change compile data through offender focus groups in the
programmes run by HMP cater for some of these field, structured interviews and questionnaires.
offenders. OBPT are examining if this group is large
enough in the community sentenced population to
justify developing a specialist intervention. A
systematic review of the literature has been
commissioned to investigate what type of intervention
might be best suited to this group.
15
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 16
North East
County Durham x x x
Northumbria x x x x
Teesside x x x
East of England
Bedfordshire x x x
Cambridgeshire x x x x
Essex x x x x
Hertfordshire x x
Norfolk x x x x x
Suffolk x x x x
North West
Cheshire x x x
Cumbria x x x
Lancashire x x x x
Greater Manchester x x x x
Merseyside x x x
East Midlands
Derbyshire x x x x x x
Leicestershire & Rutland x x x x x x
Lincolnshire x x x x
Northamptonshire x x x x x
Nottinghamshire x x x
South East
Hampshire x x x
Kent x x x x x
Surrey x x x x
Sussex x x x
Thames Valley x x x
South West
Avon & Somerset x x x
Devon/Cornwall x x x
Dorset x x x
Gloucestershire x x x
Wiltshire x x
London x x x x x x
Wales
Dyfed/Powys x x x
Gwent x x x x x
North Wales x x x x x
South Wales x x x x
16
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 17
North East
County Durham x x x
Northumbria x x x
Teesside x x
East of England
Bedfordshire x x x
Cambridgeshire x x x
Essex x x x
Hertfordshire x x x x
Norfolk x x x
Suffolk x x x
North West
Cheshire x x x
Cumbria x x x
Lancashire x x x
Greater Manchester x x x
Merseyside x x x
East Midlands
Derbyshire x x
Leicestershire & Rutland x x
Lincolnshire x x
Northamptonshire x x
Nottinghamshire x x
South East
Hampshire x x
Kent x x x
Surrey x x x
Sussex x x x
Thames Valley x x x
South West
Avon & Somerset x x x
Devon/Cornwall x x x
Dorset x x
Gloucestershire x x x
Wiltshire x x
London x x
Wales
Dyfed/Powys x x
Gwent x x
North Wales x x
South Wales x x x
17
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 18
18
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 19
Violence Programmes
19
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 20
Selection Criteria Sexual offence Sexual offence Sexual offence Internet sexual offence
Exclusion criteria General exclusion criteria General exclusion criteria General exclusion criteria apply High deviancy or contact offence
apply some discretion to take apply plus total denial of plus total denial of any incident
total denial of any incident any incident
Programme Sessions 50 hour induction module. 10 consecutive day Offenders assessed as High 70 hours focusing on internet
Low risk/low deviancy men Foundation Block Risk/Deviance attend Core related offending.
then go directly to 50 hour Victim Empathy block Programme (144 hrs min.)
Relapse Prevention twice weekly sessions of followed by Relapse Prevention
Programme. High risk/high 2 hours (60 hours) (36hrs), giving total programme
deviancy men undertake full Life Skills block twice length of 180 hours. Low
programme (250 hours) weekly sessions of 2 risk/deviance offenders will
consisting of 6 modules. Men hours (40 hours) normally complete individual
can join at the beginning of Relapse prevention work with Offender Manger
each module. weekly sessions of 2 followed by relapse prevention
Men who have successfully hours (44 hours) module. Offenders released from
completed Prison SOTP can Partners programme prison will follow similar route
go directly to the Relapse weekly sessions of 2 depending on assessment.
Prevention Programme. hours (36 hours) Sessions are normally run for
High risk/high deviancy 3.5 hours during the day, but can
men do whole be run as two evening sessions
programme, low risk, low a week. The Core Programme is
deviancy men can miss a rolling group and the RP
out Life Skills block. module is closed.
Men who have
successfully completed
Prison SOTP can go
directly to the Relapse
prevention programme
Pre-programme Flexible sessions included in Flexible sessions Offender Manager’s pack Flexible sessions included in
Offender Manager’s pack included in Offender Offender Manager’s pack
Manager’s pack
Post programme Monitoring risk factors and Monitoring risk factors Monitoring risk factors and Monitoring risk factors and
reinforcement included in and reinforcement reinforcement included in reinforcement included in
Offender Manager’s pack included in Offender Offender Manager’s pack Offender Manager’s pack
Manager’s pack
Core Programme Either 100 hours or 260 hours Either 196 hours for high Either 180 hours for High 70 hours
Duration depending on risk/deviancy risk/high deviancy men or risk/deviance or 36 hours plus
(excl.pre and post profile 156 hours for low risk/low individual work for low
sessions) deviancy men risk/deviance
Group Size 8 optimum. Max 10 8 optimum. Max 10 8 optimum. Max 10 1-2-1 or group up to 10 and 8
optimum
Implementation Completed Completed Completed Implementation across NPD
2006-07
20
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 21
Selection Criteria Offending is related to Drink drive related offence and Offending is related to substance Offending is related to substance
substance misuse, relevant skills or knowledge misuse misuse.
offender sufficiently deficits Offender sufficiently stable and Offender sufficiently stable &
stable & motivated. motivated. motivated.
Exclusion criteria As for general As for other GOBPs. Not As for general offending As for general behaviour
offending behaviour suitable for problem drinkers programmes programmes
programmes until they are stabilised. The
programme is unlikely to be
suitable for offenders with more
than four previous convictions
who are likely to have a wider
range of criminogenic needs
which cannot be met by this
programme.
Programme Sessions 20 sessions of 2.5 14 sessions of 2.5 hours to be 26 sessions of 2.5 hours. Twenty sessions from between
hours. Programme has delivered weekly Programme has modular 45 and 120 minutes. Sessions
modular structure. structure. Can be delivered from recommended
Sessions can be one to three times per week. twice weekly for sessions 1
delivered from one to – 4,
three times per week. weekly for sessions 5-12
and
2 x weekly or weekly for
sess. 13 - 20
Pre-programme Written guidance re 4 pre programme sessions 3 pre programme sessions Written guidance re preparatory
preparatory work for work for offender managers
offender managers
Core Programme 10 - 20 weeks (50 14 weeks ( 35 hours in total) 12- 24 weeks 10 - 20 sessions (50 hours in
Duration hours in total) total)
(excl.pre and post
sessions)
Post programme None specified, other Written guidance offender Minimum 4 maintenance None specified, other than action
than action post managers which details further sessions with case worker post programme report
programme report optional work in 6 areas
depending upon the progress
which the offender made in the
core programme
Group Size 8-12 Minimum 4, Maximum 12, 8-12 Not applicable
optimum 10
Implementation Completed Completed Pilot commenced June 2003 Under review
21
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 22
Domestic Violence
22
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 23
Research Portfolio
23
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 24
24
Intervenitons Report_v18.qxp 11/12/06 22:23 Page 25
Much more than documents.
Discover everything Scribd has to offer, including books and audiobooks from major publishers.
Cancel anytime.