Chief Science Advisor 'out of step with science' | Voxy.co.

nz

http://www.voxy.co.nz/health/chief-science-advisor-out-step-science/5...

Recommended NZ | Guide to Money | Gimme: Competitions - Giveaways
[ login or create an account ]

BLOGS

ENTERTAINMENT

NATIONAL

POLITICS

BUSINESS

SPORT

LIFESTYLE

HEALTH

TECH

Obesity | GST on Food | Hot Topics Index | Smoking

Chief Science Advisor 'out of step with science'
Home › Health

Voxy: Your Voice
About Voxy and how to Submit News

Contributor: Fuseworks Media
Monday, 17 June, 2013 - 07:55 "The science is settled" is one of the most unscientific things anyone can say, let alone the Chief Scientific Advisor. The UK Government’s York Review (2000) said it was poor and contradictory. "We were surprised how poor the research was. Until better research is available legitimate scientific controversy will continue" There is huge doubt that low levels of fluoride in water reduces tooth decay as it is now well established that the vast benefit from fluoride is topical not systematic i.e. has to be applied to teeth not swallowed. All large scale studies around the world show very little difference is decay rates. Australia 2004 found no difference by age 12. Spencer et al 2013 found maybe 1 less filling after 45 years, with low level of statistical confidence. Most of the world has low levels of fluoride naturally in their water. Where fluoride occurs naturally at high levels, such as in some parts of India and China, fluoride is removed at great expense. New Zealand’s levels are no less than the vast majority of supplies in Europe. It cannot be claimed that the very young and the very old especially benefit from fluoride in the water as these are the populations that are most likely to have no teeth. It is well established and agreed by all top fluoridation promoters in NZ and overseas, including those in Hamilton, the vast benefit from fluoride comes from contact with the teeth The National Research Council undertook the most extensive scientific review of fluorides in Drinking Water in 2006. This was a 12 member panel that took 3 years to review all the scientific evidence to determine if the Maximum allowable level of fluoride in water of 4ppm (in NZ it is 1.5ppm) was safe. They concluded it was not. They even concluded that 2ppm was not protective of health but were not allowed to say what level was safe. In NZ we are not "adjusting the natural levels" as the fluoride used is scrubbed from the smokes stacks of the phosphate fertiliser industry and is classified as a class 7 poison. The representative from the Poisons Board substantiated this at the Hamilton Tribunal but said "even though it is a poison when it goes in, it is not a poison when it comes out". The argument that one would have to ingest some huge amount to become toxic is a red herring because we are mostly talking about chronic, not acute toxicity. It is like saying the people of Minimata, Japan, could not have eaten enough fish in one meal to drop dead from mercury poisoning, so mercury is perfectly safe. It also ignores the huge dose that bottle fed babies are receiving compared to breast fed babies (over 150 times as much). Dental fluorosis is quite apparent in the population of NZ. NZ dental studies show 30% of children in fluoridated areas have some form of dental fluorosis compared to 15% in non-fluoridated areas. They classified most of this as mild or very mild dental fluorosis, both of which are clearly visible. It is also the first outward sign a child has been overexposed by fluoride i.e. poisoned. To dismiss dental fluorosis as merely cosmetic, which is what the pro-fluoridation lobby in NZ strives to do, is extremely unthinking. The comparisons of fluoridation to wearing seat belts or iodised salt are not valid. To do so, you would first of all have to ignore all warnings that there is risk from fluoride ingestion. Secondly, there are no serious risks in not consuming fluoridated water as illustrated by 97% of Europe which is non-fluoridated and thirdly iodine is an essential nutrient, fluoride is not. There is no scientific research that demonstrates that water fluoridation is safe. Despite well established evidence of health effects such as skeletal fluorosis, thyroid dysfunction, lowered IQ etc, associated with drinking water with high natural fluoride, and some evidence linking even fluoride at 1mg/L and less with health effects, no extensive epidemiological studies have been conducted by governments despite repeated calls from researchers to do so. The science is in no way settled and ultimately everyone has a right to informed consent to medication. Therefore, fluoridation, by nature of it being a medication added to community water supplies, will always be unethical regardless of where the science is at.

Join Voxy on Twitter, Facebook or Google+

Latest Health News
Top 10 wellness tips for winter

RSS

New $32m radiotherapy centre for Bay of Plenty Call for clinicians to use IT to improve health services Shine volunteers honoured by Minister of Health Arthritis NZ acknowledges thousands of volunteers

Most Popular Today
Serious Antarctic storm on the way

RSS

Wellington City Council 'has got it wrong' on super city Charlie’s backs down on recycling claims Chief Science Advisor 'out of step with science' Fatal car crash in Taranaki

Featured Offers
Win $15,000 with The Great Sites New Zealand Survey

Win $1000 Cash and receive the latest surveys, competitions and freebies.

Connect with Voxy

Join Voxy on Google+.

Like

Mojo Mathers, Judith Brenan and 1,112 others like this.

1 of 3

18/06/2013 10:22 a.m.

Chief Science Advisor 'out of step with science' | Voxy.co.nz

http://www.voxy.co.nz/health/chief-science-advisor-out-step-science/5...

$500 Dental Implant India
www.DentzzDental.com/Implants American Implants with 10 year Warranty. Treatment in Mumbai.

Tweet Like

2

0 3 people like this. Be the first of your friends.

What's this?

Waikato DHB 'very disappointed' with fluoride decision 'Delight' at Hamilton fluoridation decision NZ Public Health doctors say 'water fluoridation best option' Modern farming increasing hazard for human health - report

VIDEO: Like Nothing I've Ever Seen Ever How Obama Is Kin to 7 Presidents and 2 Kings How to Recharge a Cell Phone Battery Without a Charger Cicada Sex: All Together Now

0 comments

0

Best

Community

Share

Competitions and Giveaways from Gimme.co.nz
Popular competitions and giveaways from Gimme.co.nz: NZ's People Powered Guide to Free Stuff. Links will open on Gimme.

freestuffmyway.com: Win an iPhone 5 and sign up to get a $5 freebie freestuffmyway.com: Win $1000 and sign up to get a $5 freebie thriftysue.com: Win a $1000 vacation
MORE

Featured Recommendations from recommended.co.nz
Health Tips, Recommended Movies, Recommended Books, Recommended Places.

2 of 3

18/06/2013 10:22 a.m.

Chief Science Advisor 'out of step with science' | Voxy.co.nz

http://www.voxy.co.nz/health/chief-science-advisor-out-step-science/5...

Links will open on recommended.co.nz.

A Splashing Good Time At Wellington Regional Aquatic Centre Butlers Chocolate Cafe - Wellington
MORE

All articles and comments on Voxy.co.nz have been submitted by our community of users. Please notify us through our contact form if you believe an item on this site breaches our community guidelines.

BLOGS

ENTERTAINMENT

NATIONAL

POLITICS

BUSINESS

SPORT

LIFESTYLE

HEALTH

Copyright 2008-2013 Digi tal Ad van ce Li mited

Abo ut Voxy, Pr ivacy Po licy an d Ter ms of Use | Ad ver tise

3 of 3

18/06/2013 10:22 a.m.

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful