You are on page 1of 3

Chemical & Process Technology: Inert Gas or Fuel Gas For Flare Purge ?

Chemical & Process Technology

A place to share knowledge, lesson learnt... HOME ARCHIVE LINK FREE MAGAZINES



Chem & Proc Tech

Hot Posts
Ads by Google

Gas Furnace

Propane Gas

Oil Gas

Boiler Gas

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Inert Gas or Fuel Gas For Flare Purge ?

PermaPipe / Ricwil Major secondary contained pipe and leak detection manufacture South Stream Transport Official website of the planned gas pipeline through the Black Sea Daniel Orifice Fitting We Sell Replacement Parts for Seniors and Juniors, Plates. Bottle Leak Testing Worlds fastest bottle leak tester bottle, drum, part leak testing,
Display problem ? Click HERE Recommended :
- Tips on Succession in FREE Subscription

ENVIRONEMENT", OCT 15, 2007 is the Blog Action Day and the theme of the day is ENVIRONMENT. Have we ever ask ourself how much damage we have made to our environment ? I m sure many of us....... Useful Documents Related to Pressure Relief Valve (PRV) - Part 1 Pressure Relief Valve (PRV) has been widely use in


Free Newsletter Free Magazine

Latest Posts
Survey on Making CE More Interesting Estimating Heat Loss from Buried Pipe FREE Chemical Engineering Digital Issue for Aug 20... Relate Heat Radiation Level and Temperature Personnel Exposure Time For Heat Radiation Heat Radiation For Pain & Blistering Threshold Pneumatic Test Failure in Mississippi Pipeline Pro... FREE Chemical Engineering Digital Issue for July 2... Energy Input or E-method In Assessing AIV FAYF - Fluid Flow

Enter your email address:

- Subscribe FREE - Power Engineering Flare is commonly installed in oil and gas process plant to burn hydrocarbon and/or toxic gas to avoid formation of combustible mixture, to minimize green house effect (GHE), to minimize health hazards to personnel on site, etc. There are several earlier posts related to Flare : Quick Estimate Flare Stack Diameter Estimate Subsonic Flare Tip Pressure Drop With Graph Derived Correlation Quick Estimate Flare Tip Pressure Drop Flare Tip Type Quick Selection Chart Guideline on Quick Determination of Flare Stack Support Type Flare Smokeless Ringlemann Chart FLARE combustion efficiency Quick Estimate Ground Level Unburnt Flammable Gas For Vent Pipe or Flame-out Flare Stack Flare collection header is normally "NO flow" as most (if not all) devices connected to flare header are non-discharging fluid into flare system. Among all are pressure relief valve (PRV), blowdown valve (BDV), overpressure dump valve (PCV), etc. All these devices are kept as close position during normal plant operation and will only open in the event of overpressure, emergency situation i.e. fire, runaway reaction, plant shutdown/blowdown for maintenance . On the flare tip end, it is open to atmosphere. it is very likely that atmosphere air contain oxygen ingress and stay into flare collection header. PRV/BDV/PCV passing and open on demand will discharge large quantity of hydrocarbon gas into flare collector header filled with air and create combustible mixture , as this combustible mixture travel along flare header and reach flare tip which equipped with flare pilot, combustible mixture will be ignited and potentially created flash back to the flare header and flare knock-out drum (KOD). Subject to flare header capacity and mechanical integrity, large flash back lead to severe internal pressure act on the piping & vessel and vapor wave results severe vibration and movement of structure, this potential lead to catastrophe failure of flare collection system. Therefore a flare header is sweep or purge with fuel gas or inert gas i.e. Nitrogen. Advantages using inert gas compare to fuel gas as purge gas i) Environment & Green House Effect (GHE) IG : Inert gas has NO impact to environment FG : Burn fuel gas in atmosphere generate Carbon Dioxide (CO2) which contributes to increase of Co2 content in atmosphere and increases Green House Effect (GHE)


Chem & Proc tech Oil & Gas tech Heat Exch tech Gen Tech Webworm DC Chemical and Process Engineering Chemical Engineering World Smart Process Design ChEng


1 of 3

8/10/2012 5:52 PM

Chemical & Process Technology: Inert Gas or Fuel Gas For Flare Purge ?

(Since Apr. 21,2007) ii) Burn back damage flare tip - reduce life span of flare tip IG : Inert gas do not burn. NO burn back and potential damage of flare tip. FG : Potential FG burn back damage flare and shorten flare tip life span. iii) High OPEX avoid Burn back IG : NO burn back. Minimum purge rate and low OPEX. FG : Potential burn back lead to high purge rate (potential 10 times higher than purge rate of IG) and high OPEX iv) Visible Flame IG : Inert gas do not burn. No flame present. FG : FG continuous burn and continuous visible flare at flare tip. Potential create uneasy situation in environment sensitive area. v) Smoke Flaring IG : Inert gas do not burn. No smoke flaring issue. FG : Burning heavy FG lead to smoke flaring. Potential create uneasy situation in environment sensitive area. Increase likelihood of unburnt component and impact on environment. vi) Steam injection for smokeless flaring IG : Inert gas do not burn. No smoke flaring issue. FG : Burning heavy FG lead to smoke flaring. Steam injection to reduce/eliminate smoke flaring. This increases CAPEX (additional steam injection facilities) and OPEX (steam loss). vii) Radiation IG : Inert gas do not burn. No additional radiation. FG : Fuel gas burn lead to increase of radiation level (on top of solar radiation) to personnel working near flare stack. Disadvantages using inert gas compare to fuel gas as purge gas a) Fuel Gas Readily Available in Plant IG : Required Nitrogen generator or use of Liquid Nitrogen and evaporator. Additional CAPEX and OPEX. FG : Fuel gas readily available in plant. Minimum CAPEX and OPEX. Some plant generate hydrocarbon gas which shall be disposed off. This gas is readily serve as purge gas and inccur NO cost. b) Inert Gas Cloud IG : Flare system purge with inert gas, entire flare system is filled with IG gas (which potential heavier than air). Once any PSV/BDV open and release large amount of gas into flare header, it will "push" IG release through the flare tip. Heavy IG (compare to air) will sink create a IG gas cloud near plant. This is potential fatal thread (suffocation) to personnel on site. FG : Continuous flaring lead to no or nearly no potential of gas present in atmosphere c) Unburnt hydrocarbon gas emission IG : PRV/BDV/PCV leak or passing lead to low heating value mixure (less than 200 btu/ft3) which is non-combustible. Release of hydrocarbon gas into atmosphere directly has more GHE impact than burning it. For example 1 mol of methane create 1 mol of CO2 if it is burnt. 1 mol of methane create 20-21 mol of equivalent CO2 if it unburnt. FG : Continuous flaring lead to no or nearly no unburnt gas in atmosphere d) Combustible Cloud lead to Instant Ignition IG : Slowly hydrocarbon gas emission to atmosphere and built-up of combustible mixture in the plant, once the heating value for auto-ignition is reached, the combustible mixture potentially ignited. Its impact is just like a explosion and potential thread to personnel and surrounding facilities. FG : Continuous flaring lead to no or nearly no unburnt gas in atmosphere Concluding remark Inert gas purging is normally understood as clean, low CAPEX, low OPEX, etc and regards as most likely candidate for flare purging. However, the associated SAFETY related issue may needs additional attention and focus. All...use inert gas wisely...

6 users online

April 2007 May 2007 June 2007 July 2007 August 2007 September 2007 October 2007 November 2007 December 2007 January 2008 February 2008 March 2008 April 2008 May 2008 June 2008 July 2008 August 2008 September 2008 October 2008 November 2008 December 2008 January 2009 Ads by Google February 2009 March 2009 April 2009 May 2009 June 2009 July 2009 August 2009 September 2009 October 2009 November 2009
Chemical Process Engineer Anchorage, AK - David Evans & Associates Chemical Process Engineer Graham, KY - Dyno Nobel Senior Chemical Process Development Midland, MI - Dow Corning Corporation

Gas Furnace Propane Gas Combustion Gas

Recommended Jobs *Process Owner - Alloy/Chemical~ Dover, NJ - ALCOA Senior Process Chemical Engineer Greenville, SC - O'Neal, Inc.

December 2009 January 2010 February 2010 March 2010 April 2010 May 2010 June 2010

Related Topic
Flare related topics... CO2 related topics... Personnel Exposure Time For Heat Radiation Heat Radiation For Pain & Blistering Threshold Simplified Equation for Wind Speed Estimation At Different Height Estimate Wind Speed At Flare Tip At Different Height Assess AIV with "D/t-method" with Polynomial PWL Limit Line Model Fix Pressure Drop Device in FLARENET Labels: CO2, Environment, Fire , Flare

July 2010 August 2010 September 2010 October 2010 November 2010 December 2011 July 2012

2 of 3

8/10/2012 5:52 PM

Chemical & Process Technology: Inert Gas or Fuel Gas For Flare Purge ?

Process engineer jobs

Process Systems Engineer - Business

Emerson Process Management - Austin, TX
executives at Fortune 500 companies. The Process Systems Engineer position blends engineering expertise... Process Management is a leading supplier of process... Emerson Process Management more jobs

jobs by
posted by Webworm, 8:36 PM


Green house effect

Effect green house

Post a Comment
Let us know your opinion !!! You can use some HTML tags, such as <b>, <i>, <a>

Comment as:

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom ]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

2008-2010 Chemical & Process Technology | Design by Webworm

3 of 3

8/10/2012 5:52 PM