You are on page 1of 11

Index FC Judgements A 1 B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V

All cases
Issues of poor communication by court to public Positive action by court re guardian relationship Abduction Hague Convention overseas trip

Text reasonably well tidied after OCRing

Removal of right access to court

Punishment of parent by court

Relocation of custodial parent

Responsibility Duty of Care

Handling of real evidence

Priviledge psych reports

Favoured status parent

Manipulative parent

Guardians dispute

BFLR number

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29

1 1 1 1 1 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16

169

173 293 384 430 258 418 486 408 1 372 589 225 392 258 501 547 357 507 234 1 194

D v D removal of child subject to financial bond Hockey v Hockey defeating matrimonial property T v T joint custody survives wifes challenge mother W v W appeal under guardianship act Walker v Walker custody application procedure (unspecific allegations] B v Attorney G is there a duty of care in investigating sex abuse C v D child abduction by mother is acceptable mother Duncan v Videan child support formula assessment H v H restriction of access to psych reports not given father H v J children abducted by father/fathers family in India father H v S mother alleges sex abuse manipulation mother Jayamohan v Jayamohan habeas corpus removal of children mother L v S PAS children stay with father father R v Taualili child abduction father Re G removal of life support after motor accident S v M custody relocation of children to Tasmania father S v P domestic violence is there a relationship students Taylor v Oliver child support formula assessment Attorney G v Prince claim social welfare have duty of care B P S v M N S non biological father declared step parent mother B v B Hague Convention abduction mother Vol16 FRNZ357 DGSW v R child does not want contact with mother Haye v Psychologists Board Psychologist overturns guilty finding M v L priviledge of counsellors notes released ??? Moore v Moore mat property change of circumstances re S and S disclosure of psychologist report released Vincent v Vincent child support

1 good 1 equal

1 1

Pethig Ross

good mother good good poor poor poor equal equal mother equal father mother mother mother-none mother 1 mother

Gallen Father sued after Department Robertson Father had not been married t Moss Fathers access resricted after 1 GendallFather ordered to arrange for 1 Smellie Mothers allegations of sex abu Henry McGechan Mother removed Doogue children unla 1 BisphanChildren remain with father af 1 Richardson Gault Thomas Blanchard GendallMother allowed to relocate to T

good good

father-slightly 1 father-none 1 father mother-none mother-none possible 1 mother none 1 father 1 mother 1

good

good

good mother

mother-none mother

1 mother

Adopted child bevame murder Goddard Mother just wanted cash from McGechan Father did not protect his situa Chisholm Psych successfully argues he Giles Counsellors notes to be releas MacCormack Father wanted to use report fo

Judge

Index FC Judgements A 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73
16 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18

B
677 711 694 448 492 636 117 89 525 466 216 430 387 133 1 396 1 54 530 19 248 336 18

P
mother

L v F father retained children in NZ against US court order mother none mother 1 W v B mother tries to protect 14 year boy from marauding 16yr female good B v Attorney G sue for damages after botched sex abuse investigation B v B mat prop precedence with criminal proceedings good equal 1 Burns v Burns man seeks relief from psyhological abuse by wife equal 1 D v C child abduction by mother mother no mother mother 1 Edmonds v Disher consequences of reversal of paternity order previous hearing was poor G v G allegations sex abuse social welfare lack standing under guardianship mother Act good equal Gillard v Gillard mother wants to take child to england good equal 1 1 Hurst v Hurst spousal maintenance liability mother L v L appeal against prohibition of further applications onto father equal restored L v L custody jurisdiction R v R domestic violence evidence mother good good equal Ridden v Ridden wife wants half husbands annual leave equal? Swayne v Lush custody and access non speaking parents good equal 1 T v T lesbian child support equal T v T multi abuse by both parents PAS mother good vgood equal none 1 Wood v Wood matrimonial propperty wife seeks set aside agreement mother good equal Courts v Phelps child abduction by father father mother father-none 1 Koeberl v Webster dismiss overseas court order for maintenance Moore v Moore matrimonial property N v D duty of care by psychotherapist held refusal to strike out claim re B contemp of court mothers partner threatens psychologist mothers new partner mothers new partner Re P removal of child from mother S v S child abduction by mother part 1 and 2 mother mother-none 1 Shankar v Shankar custody access removal from NZ father father but refused Staite v Psychologists Board appeal against professional misconduct upheld

Blaikie Mother initially abducted child 1 Mather Court effectively declines to p Keith Blanchard Dept Social Tipping Welfare is not sub Inglis Judge considered issues and Inglis Mental health of ex wife not good 1 Adams Court rejects weakly based ap Inglis Giles Mother wants second bite at m

mother allowed

father

Inglis Grace Rejected Potter Brown Partner ordered to pay child s Boshier Fisher Wife sought setting aside mat Keith Gallen Children Paterson to be returned to mot

VenningPsychotherapist may have du Inglis Referred to High Court for pro Fisher Father had to appeal to win, th Inglis Young Psychologists actions were in

mother 1

19 151 Williams v Williams appeal matrimonial property 19 159 DEJANOVIC v KOUCHERENKO Matrimonial property - Separate property
19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 288 53 140 103 62 183 457 678 387 121 121 220 476 Coleman v Mathers child support overseas D v H Has court power to order guardian not to apply to court Fielding v Fielding matrimonial property R v H Appeal re priviledge of counsel for childs documents Sadgrove v Sadgrove spousal maintenance forever T v T allegation by mother ritual sex abuse Thom v Thom matrimonial property W v C joint custody is approved on application of father V v G evidence specialist reports B J v D T M costs re frustrated access is supported B v H father applies to be removed as guardian declined C v D child support from medical specialist with tables C v D child support from medical specialist Clarke v McLaughlin late submission of evidence against father Gray v McGill custodial father given permission to relocate father?? father but rejected 1 Robertson Father appealed against order

mother good

disastrous mother

mother-none

1 1 1

Inglis

Good analysis but not followed

mother good good equal 1 mother good mother mother poor poor mother mother mother mother father mother-minor father

1 1 1 1 1

father

needs more Inglisdetail from law library 1 Adams Report to be disclosed to police 1 Moss Mother frustrated fathers acce BoshierFather obviously an idiot Durie Mother gets additional child su Durie Mother gets additional child su 1 Callaghan 1 Inglis

Index FC Judgements A 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 21

B
304 433 500 440 335 1 532 236

P
1 ???

Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother K v B relocation to Australia by mother Vol20 FRNZ500 L v R protection order strange relationship Mazengarb v Ambler mothers child support mainly taken by government Millist v Millist dispute over childrens schooling good P v C dispensation testamentary guardians consent P v P mother takes children to Wales Paenga v Lemmon should siblings be raised together cultural issues R v H security for costs in appeal domestic violence 480 R v Moore specialist report discovery for criminal trial not given Re P return of child to birth mother 673 T v H guardianship by family court 42 TVNZ v W publication of case refused W v C joint custody approved D v C child support Vol21 FRNZ540 A v A child abduction mother good D v S relocation to Wales by mother good B v S domestic violence evidence mother good G M G v M A B application to revoke adoption Vol21 FRNZ1 G v B revoke open adoption H v H custody and access prisoner H v M matrimonial property I v I matrimonial property spousal maintenance K v C appeal relocation fathers hollow victory mother Koene v Powell costs awarded against wife after ex parte dishonest application mother R v M evidence of sexual abuse additional expert witness brought in by mother father good Vol21 FRNZ316 RE THE GUARDIANSHIP OF A C L Richards v Richards Taylor Edwards v Palmer admissibility of evidence

good mother

mother-none mother

1 Adams More analysis is required b

vgood equal idealistic mother only mother

Father wanted child to go to s 1 Callaghan Dadelszen Mothers happiness can be co 1 Adams

Inglis equal equal equal mother-none mother mother mother-none 1 mother 1

21 540 21 331 21 442 21 21 1 21 470 21 21 21 686 21 705 21 583? 21 316 21 21 21 21 21 21

yes good

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child get clarification BlanchaReversal from law library of decision at both le 1 Walsh Mother sought protection orde

equal equal equal

father loses access 1 mother mother to pay costs

1 Priestly Father had been abusive. Mot 1 Mather Laurenson

Vol21 FRNZ HIRSTICH v KAHOTEA non custodial mother applies to throw out judge mother 354 V v B application to discharge judge by noncustodial mother dismissed motherby mother ritual sex mother abuse 727 Wellington Newspapers v X publication file see Vol 19 183 T v T allegation Y v Y Y v L McKenzie friend in family court

mother

1 Inglis Inglis

Publication practically refused

Index FC Judgements A 109 B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V

Hague Convention - taking children overseas


Issues of poor communication by court to public Positive action by court re guardian relationship Abduction Hague Convention overseas trip

Text reasonably well tidied after OCRing

Removal of right access to court

Punishment of parent by court

Relocation of custodial parent

Responsibility Duty of Care

Handling of real evidence

Priviledge psych reports

Favoured status parent

Manipulative parent

Guardians dispute

BFLR number

110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135

1 20 15 18 15 15 16 16 18 21 21 17

304 258 396 293 486 547 677 248

D v D removal of child subject to financial bond Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother H v J children abducted by father/fathers family in India father Courts v Phelps child abduction by father father C v D child abduction by mother is acceptable mother Jayamohan v Jayamohan habeas corpus removal of children mother B v B Hague Convention abduction mother L v F father retained children in NZ against US court order mother S v S child abduction by mother part 1 and 2 mother mother good mother mother

good mother good equal mother mother poor equal mother

1 1 mother-none mother 1 father-none 1 father-none 1 mother-none mother 1 mother-none possible 1 mother 1 none mother 1 mother-none 1

1 ??? father father mother mother mother mother mother

Pethig 1 Adams More analysis is required b 1 GendallFather ordered to arrange for Keith Gallen Children Paterson to be returned to mot Robertson Father had not been married t Henry McGechan Mother removed Doogue children unla McGechan Father did not protect his situa Blaikie Mother initially abducted child Fisher Father had to appeal to win, th

540 A v A child abduction 686 K v C appeal relocation fathers hollow victory 636 D v C child abduction by mother

no

equal equal mother

mother-none mother 1 mother father loses access 1 mother 1 mother 1 mother allowed

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child 1 Priestly Father had been abusive. Mot
1

Duty of care - responsibility


21 18 18 20 686 54 18 678 K v C appeal relocation fathers hollow victory mother N v D duty of care by psychotherapist held refusal to strike out claim Staite v Psychologists Board appea against professional misconduct upheld V v G evidence specialist reports 1 equal father loses access 1 mother 1 1 1 1 1 Priestly Father had been abusive. Mot VenningPsychotherapist may have du Young Psychologists actions were in 1 Adams Report to be disclosed to police

Issues of poor communication by court to public


16 17 547 B v B Hague Convention abduction 636 D v C child abduction by mother mother mother no mother mother mother mother 1 mother 1 mother allowed 1 1 McGechan Father did not protect his situa

Judge

Index FC Judgements A 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174
1 17 20 16 17 20 15 16 21 15 20 21

O
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

P
1

Relocation of custodial parent


89 476 547 636 304 293 677 540 589 532 331 D v D removal of child subject to financial bond Gillard v Gillard mother wants to take child to england Gray v McGill custodial father given permission to relocate B v B Hague Convention abduction mother D v C child abduction by mother mother Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother C v D child abduction by mother is acceptable mother L v F father retained children in NZ against US court order mother A v A child abduction S v M custody relocation of children to Tasmania P v P mother takes children to Wales D v S relocation to Wales by mother mother good father?? good OK equal father mother no mother good mother mother equal good mother? idealistic mother only yes equal good 1 1 father mother mother mother-none mother mother-none mother none mother mother-none mother mother mother mother Pethig Inglis 1 Inglis McGechan Father did not protect his situa 1 Adams More analysis is required b Robertson Father had not been married t Blaikie Mother initially abducted child

mother mother allowed ??? mother mother

1 1

1 mother 1 1

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child


GendallMother allowed to relocate to T Dadelszen Mothers happiness can be co get clarification BlanchaReversal from law library of decision at both le

Punishment of parent by court


15 21 15 18 15 21 21 20 20 15 21 18 15 16 19 21 15 18 16 15 17 1 686 258 396 430 727 705 387 304 293 540 248 418 501 183 442 486 530 677 408 133 R v Taualili child abduction father mother? K v C appeal relocation fathers hollow victory mother equal H v J children abducted by father/fathers family in India father good equal Courts v Phelps child abduction by father father mother H v H restriction of access to psych reports not given father? good equal Wellington Newspapers v X publication file see Vol 19 183 T v T allegation motherby mother ritual sex mother abuse Koene v Powell costs awarded against wife after ex parte dishonest application mother equal B J v D T M costs re frustrated access is supported mother good poor mother Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother good mother C v D child abduction by mother is acceptable mother mother A v A child abduction S v S child abduction by mother part 1 and 2 H v S mother alleges sex abuse to restrict access B P S v M N S non biological father declared step parent T v T allegation by mother ritual sex abuse B v S domestic violence evidence Jayamohan v Jayamohan habeas corpus removal of children re B contemp of court mothers partner threatens psychologist L v F father retained children in NZ against US court order L v S PAS children stay with father T v T multi abuse by both parents PAS mother good equal mother mother good poor mother mother good mother good disastrous mother mother good good equal mother poor equal mothers new partner mother father good poor father mother good vgood equal father father loses access father-none father-none father-slightly mother mother to pay costs mother-minor mother-none mother mother-none mother 1 1 mother 1 father 1 father 1 1 1 Richardson Gault Thomas Blanchard 1 Priestly Father had been abusive. Mot 1 GendallFather ordered to arrange for Keith Gallen Children Paterson to be returned to mot Moss Fathers access resricted after Inglis Publication practically refused 1 Mather 1 Moss Mother frustrated fathers acce 1 Adams More analysis is required b Robertson Father had not been married t

1 1 ??? 1 mother mother mother

mother-none mother 1 mother-none 1 mother-none mother-none mother-none 1 mother-none mother-none possible 1 mothers new partner none mother 1 none 1 none 1

mother mother

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child Fisher Father had to appeal to win, th 1 Smellie Mothers allegations of sex abu Goddard Mother just wanted cash from Inglis Good analysis but not followed 1 Walsh Mother sought protection orde Henry McGechan Mother removed Doogue children unla Inglis Referred to High Court for pro Blaikie Mother initially abducted child 1 BisphanChildren remain with father af Boshier

Index FC Judgements A 175 B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V

Removal of right access to court


Issues of poor communication by court to public Positive action by court re guardian relationship Abduction Hague Convention overseas trip

Text reasonably well tidied after OCRing

Removal of right access to court

Punishment of parent by court

Relocation of custodial parent

Responsibility Duty of Care

Handling of real evidence

Priviledge psych reports

Favoured status parent

Manipulative parent

Guardians dispute

BFLR number

176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193

20 18 19 17

B v H father applies to be removed as guardian declined 336 Shankar v Shankar custody access removal from NZ 53 D v H Has court power to order guardian not to apply to court L v L appeal against prohibition of further applications onto father

poor father father??

mother

equal

father father but refused father but rejected restored

1 1

BoshierFather obviously an idiot Inglis Robertson Father appealed against order

Priviledge psych reports


15 20 16 20 16 430 480 234 678 1 H v H restriction of access to psych reports R v Moore specialist report discovery for criminal trial M v L priviledge of counsellors notes V v G evidence specialist reports re S and S disclosure of psychologist report not given not given released released released good equal father-slightly 1 Moss Fathers access resricted after Giles Counsellors notes to be releas 1 Adams Report to be disclosed to police MacCormack Father wanted to use report fo

Judge

Index FC Judgements A 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237
17 21 15 15 21

K
equal equal equal equal equal

Favoured status parent


686 258 430 705 L v L appeal against prohibition of further applications onto father K v C appeal relocation fathers hollow victory mother H v J children abducted by father/fathers family in India father H v H restriction of access to psych reports not given father? Koene v Powell costs awarded against wife after ex parte dishonest application mother good good restored father loses access 1 mother father-none 1 father father-slightly 1 mother to pay costs mother mother 1 1 Priestly Father had been abusive. Mot 1 GendallFather ordered to arrange for Moss Fathers access resricted after 1 Mather

21 540 A v A child abduction mother good equal mother-none mother 1 21 442 B v S domestic violence evidence mother good good equal mother-none 15 486 Jayamohan v Jayamohan habeas corpus removal of children mother poor equal mother-none possible 1 17 133 T v T multi abuse by both parents PAS mother good vgood equal none 1 17 89 Gillard v Gillard mother wants to take child to england good equal 1 1 21 331 D v S relocation to Wales by mother OK yes equal mother 1 1 169 T v T joint custody survives wifes challenge mother good 1 equal 1 17 448 B v B mat prop precedence with criminal proceedings good equal 1 17 492 Burns v Burns man seeks relief from psyhological abuse by wife equal 1 17 117 G v G allegations sex abuse social welfare lack standing under guardianship mother Act good equal 17 216 R v R domestic violence evidence mother good good equal 17 Swayne v Lush custody and access non speaking parents good equal 1 17 387 T v T lesbian child support equal 17 1 Wood v Wood matrimonial propperty wife seeks set aside agreement mother good equal 19 457 W v C joint custody is approved on application of father mother good good equal 1 20 335 Millist v Millist dispute over childrens schooling good vgood equal 1 21 583? R v M evidence of sexual abuse additional expert witness brought in by mother father good equal 17 430 Ridden v Ridden wife wants half husbands annual leave equal? 15 408 L v S PAS children stay with father father good poor father none 1 20 476 Gray v McGill custodial father given permission to relocate father father 1 20 B v H father applies to be removed as guardian declined poor mother father 1 18 396 Courts v Phelps child abduction by father father mother father-none 1 21 727 Wellington Newspapers v X publication file see Vol 19 183 T v T allegation motherby mother ritual sex mother abuse mother 20 387 B J v D T M costs re frustrated access is supported mother good poor mother mother-minor 1 20 304 Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother good mother mother-none mother 1 15 293 C v D child abduction by mother is acceptable mother mother mother-none mother 1 15 418 H v S mother alleges sex abuse to restrict access mother good poor mother mother-none 19 183 T v T allegation by mother ritual sex abuse mother good disastrous mother mother-none 1 16 547 B v B Hague Convention abduction mother mother mother 1 17 636 D v C child abduction by mother mother no mother mother 1 20 532 P v P mother takes children to Wales idealistic mother only mother 20 121 C v D child support from medical specialist with tables mother mother 1 20 121 C v D child support from medical specialist mother mother 1 15 1 R v Taualili child abduction father mother? father 1 15 589 S v M custody relocation of children to Tasmania father?? good good mother? mother 1

father

??? mother

mother mother allowed

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child 1 Walsh Mother sought protection orde Henry McGechan Mother removed Doogue children unla Boshier Inglis get clarification BlanchaReversal from law library of decision at both le Ross Inglis Judge considered issues and Inglis Mental health of ex wife not good Adams Court rejects weakly based ap Inglis Potter Brown Partner ordered to pay child s Fisher Wife sought setting aside mat needs more Inglisdetail from law library 1 Callaghan Father wanted child to go to s Laurenson Grace Rejected 1 BisphanChildren remain with father af 1 Inglis BoshierFather obviously an idiot Keith Gallen Children Paterson to be returned to mot Inglis Publication practically refused 1 Moss Mother frustrated fathers acce 1 Adams More analysis is required b Robertson Father had not been married t 1 Smellie Mothers allegations of sex abu Inglis Good analysis but not followed 1 McGechan Father did not protect his situa 1 Dadelszen Mothers happiness can be co Durie Mother gets additional child su Durie Mother gets additional child su 1 Richardson Gault Thomas Blanchard GendallMother allowed to relocate to T

Index FC Judgements A 238 B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V

Positive action by court re guardian relationship


Issues of poor communication by court to public Positive action by court re guardian relationship Abduction Hague Convention overseas trip

Text reasonably well tidied after OCRing

Removal of right access to court

Punishment of parent by court

Relocation of custodial parent

Responsibility Duty of Care

Handling of real evidence

Priviledge psych reports

Favoured status parent

Manipulative parent

Guardians dispute

BFLR number

239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264

17 19 15 20 20 15 15 20 1 15 15 21 17 17 17 19 20 15 21 17 20

636 D v C child abduction by mother mother 183 T v T allegation by mother ritual sex abuse mother 408 L v S PAS children stay with father father B v H father applies to be removed as guardian declined 387 B J v D T M costs re frustrated access is supported mother 418 H v S mother alleges sex abuse to restrict access mother 486 Jayamohan v Jayamohan habeas corpus removal of children mother 532 P v P mother takes children to Wales 169 T v T joint custody survives wifes challenge mother 258 H v J children abducted by father/fathers family in India father 430 H v H restriction of access to psych reports not given father? 442 B v S domestic violence evidence mother 89 Gillard v Gillard mother wants to take child to england 216 R v R domestic violence evidence mother Swayne v Lush custody and access non speaking parents 457 W v C joint custody is approved on application of father mother 304 Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother 589 S v M custody relocation of children to Tasmania father?? 331 D v S relocation to Wales by mother 133 T v T multi abuse by both parents PAS mother 335 Millist v Millist dispute over childrens schooling

none mother disastrous mother poor father vpoor mother good poor mother good poor mother poor equal idealistic mother only good good equal good equal good equal good good equal good equal good good equal good equal good good equal good mother good good mother? OK good equal good vgood equal good vgood equal good good

mother mother-none none father

mother-minor mother-none mother-none possible 1 mother mother 1 father-none 1 father father-slightly 1 mother-none 1 1 1 1 1 ??? 1 1 1 1

1 mother allowed 1 1 1 1

1 Inglis Good analysis but not followed 1 BisphanChildren remain with father af BoshierFather obviously an idiot 1 Moss Mother frustrated fathers acce 1 Smellie Mothers allegations of sex abu Henry McGechan Mother removed Doogue children unla Dadelszen Mothers happiness can be co Ross 1 GendallFather ordered to arrange for Moss Fathers access resricted after 1 Walsh Mother sought protection orde Inglis Inglis Potter needs more Inglisdetail from law library 1 Adams More analysis is required b GendallMother allowed to relocate to T get clarification BlanchaReversal from law library of decision at both le Boshier 1 Callaghan Father wanted child to go to s

mother-none mother mother mother none

Judge

Index FC Judgements A 265 B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V

Handling of real evidence


Issues of poor communication by court to public Positive action by court re guardian relationship Abduction Hague Convention overseas trip

Text reasonably well tidied after OCRing

Removal of right access to court

Punishment of parent by court

Relocation of custodial parent

Responsibility Duty of Care

Handling of real evidence

Priviledge psych reports

Favoured status parent

Manipulative parent

Guardians dispute

BFLR number

266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289

17 21 19 15 20 15 1 21 17 19 15 17 20

331 183 408 387 418 169 442 216 457 589 133 335

Edmonds v Disher consequences of reversal of paternity order D v S relocation to Wales by mother T v T allegation by mother ritual sex abuse L v S PAS children stay with father B J v D T M costs re frustrated access is supported H v S mother alleges sex abuse to restrict access T v T joint custody survives wifes challenge B v S domestic violence evidence R v R domestic violence evidence W v C joint custody is approved on application of father S v M custody relocation of children to Tasmania T v T multi abuse by both parents PAS Millist v Millist dispute over childrens schooling

mother father mother mother mother mother mother mother father?? mother

previous hearing was poor OK good equal good disastrous mother good poor father good poor mother good poor mother good good equal good good equal good good equal good good equal good good mother? good vgood equal good vgood equal equal equal equal equal equal

mother mother-none none mother-minor mother-none mother-none

1 1 1 1 1

mother none mother-none mother

1 1 1 1 1 mother 1

get clarification BlanchaReversal from law library of decision at both le Inglis Good analysis but not followed 1 BisphanChildren remain with father af 1 Moss Mother frustrated fathers acce 1 Smellie Mothers allegations of sex abu Ross 1 Walsh Mother sought protection orde Inglis needs more Inglisdetail from law library GendallMother allowed to relocate to T Boshier 1 Callaghan Father wanted child to go to s

21 540 17 448 17 117 17 1 21 583? 16 501 15 173 17 711

A v A child abduction mother good B v B mat prop precedence with criminal proceedings good G v G allegations sex abuse social welfare lack standing under guardianship mother Act good Wood v Wood matrimonial propperty wife seeks set aside agreement mother good R v M evidence of sexual abuse additional expert witness brought in by mother father good B P S v M N S non biological father declared step parent mother good B v Attorney G is there a duty of care in investigating sex abuse good W v B mother tries to protect 14 year boy from marauding 16yr female good

mother-none

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child Inglis Judge considered issues and Adams Court rejects weakly based ap Fisher Wife sought setting aside mat Laurenson Goddard Mother just wanted cash from Gallen Father sued after Department 1 Mather Court effectively declines to p

Judge

Index FC Judgements A 290 B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V

Manipulative parent
Issues of poor communication by court to public Positive action by court re guardian relationship Abduction Hague Convention overseas trip

Text reasonably well tidied after OCRing

Removal of right access to court

Punishment of parent by court

Relocation of custodial parent

Responsibility Duty of Care

Handling of real evidence

Priviledge psych reports

Favoured status parent

Manipulative parent

Guardians dispute

BFLR number

291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317

15 15 18 15 18 15 15 19 19 20 15 1 21 17 19 17

408 258 396 1 336 430 589 53 183 387 418 169 442 216 457 133

L v S PAS children stay with father father H v J children abducted by father/fathers family in India father Courts v Phelps child abduction by father father R v Taualili child abduction father Shankar v Shankar custody access removal from NZ father not given father? H v H restriction of access to psych reports S v M custody relocation of children to Tasmania father?? D v H Has court power to order guardian not to apply to court father?? T v T allegation by mother ritual sex abuse mother B J v D T M costs re frustrated access is supported mother H v S mother alleges sex abuse to restrict access mother T v T joint custody survives wifes challenge mother B v S domestic violence evidence mother R v R domestic violence evidence mother W v C joint custody is approved on application of father mother T v T multi abuse by both parents PAS mother

good

poor good

father equal mother mother? equal mother?

good good good good good good good good good

good good

disastrous mother poor mother poor mother good equal good equal good equal good equal vgood equal equal equal equal equal none mother poor equal good mother equal equal

none father-none father-none father father but refused father-slightly mother father but rejected mother-none mother-minor mother-none mother-none

1 1 father 1 father 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

none mother-none mother

1 1 1 mother

1 BisphanChildren remain with father af 1 GendallFather ordered to arrange for Keith Gallen Children Paterson to be returned to mot 1 Richardson Gault Thomas Blanchard Inglis Moss Fathers access resricted after GendallMother allowed to relocate to T Robertson Father appealed against order Inglis Good analysis but not followed 1 Moss Mother frustrated fathers acce 1 Smellie Mothers allegations of sex abu Ross 1 Walsh Mother sought protection orde Inglis needs more Inglisdetail from law library Boshier

21 540 17 117 17 1 21 583? 16 501 17 636 15 486 20 304 21 686 21 705

A v A child abduction mother good G v G allegations sex abuse social welfare lack standing under guardianship mother Act good Wood v Wood matrimonial propperty wife seeks set aside agreement mother good R v M evidence of sexual abuse additional expert witness brought in by mother father good B P S v M N S non biological father declared step parent mother good D v C child abduction by mother mother Jayamohan v Jayamohan habeas corpus removal of children mother Gumbrell v Jones mother fails to honour agreement removal child mother K v C appeal relocation fathers hollow victory mother Koene v Powell costs awarded against wife after ex parte dishonest application mother

mother-none mother 1 mother-none possible 1 mother-none mother 1 father loses access 1 mother to pay costs

Bisphan Mother ordered to return child Adams Court rejects weakly based ap Fisher Wife sought setting aside mat Laurenson Goddard Mother just wanted cash from
1 Henry McGechan Mother removed Doogue children unla 1 Adams More analysis is required b 1 Priestly Father had been abusive. Mot 1 Mather

mother allowed mother ??? mother 1

Judge

Index FC Judgements A 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329
21 15 16 20 20 18 16 17 21 18

B
727 293 547 121 121 248 677 525 354 530

O
1 1 1 1 1 1

P
mother mother

R
1

Wellington Newspapers v X publication file see Vol 19 183 T v T allegation motherby mother ritual sex mother abuse C v D child abduction by mother is acceptable mother mother B v B Hague Convention abduction mother mother C v D child support from medical specialist with tables mother mother C v D child support from medical specialist mother mother S v S child abduction by mother part 1 and 2 mother L v F father retained children in NZ against US court order mother Hurst v Hurst spousal maintenance liability mother V v B application to discharge judge by noncustodial mother dismissed mother re B contemp of court mothers partner threatens psychologist mothers new partner

mother mother-none mother mother

mother-none none mother

mother mother

mothers new partner

Inglis Publication practically refused Robertson Father had not been married t McGechan Father did not protect his situa Durie Mother gets additional child su Durie Mother gets additional child su Fisher Father had to appeal to win, th Blaikie Mother initially abducted child Giles Mother wants second bite at m 1 Inglis Inglis Referred to High Court for pro