You are on page 1of 36

Version

July 2011

Program

RSTAB
Structural Analysis and Design
Dynamic Analysis

Verification Manual

All rights, including those of translation, are reserved.
No portion of this book may be reproduced – mechanically, electronically,
or by any other means, including photocopying – without written permission of ING.-SOFTWARE DLUBAL.

© Ing. Software Dlubal
Am Zellweg 2 D-93464 Tiefenbach
Tel.:
+49 (0) 9673 9203-0
Fax:
+49 (0) 9673 9203-51
E-mail: info@dlubal.com
Web:
www.dlubal.com

RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.-Software Dlubal

Contents
Contents

Page

1. 

Introduction

1.1 

Disclaimer

1.2 

Introduction

2. 

Examples

2.1 

Design of Beam for Moment (AISC ASD
9th Edition)

2.2 

Multi-Story Frame (P-Delta)

2.3 

Simple Frame (P-Delta)

10 

2.4 

Cables

13 

2.5 

Modal Analysis of Frame

14 

RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.-Software Dlubal

Contents

Page

Appendix:
RSTAB printout reports for Examples 2.1,
2.2 and 2.3

3

ING. Yet they are kept simple to be able to manually follow the analysis. SOFTWARE DLUBAL does not resume responsibility for the validity of the results obtained from RSTAB and its modules or for the accuracy of this documentation. The examples were taken from available literature. RSTAB is meant to be a tool used in structural analysis and design.000 engineers worldwide. The user must verify his own results. This manual compares theoretical analysis results with the results obtained in RSTAB. All shipped versions of RSTAB have been extensively tested before delivered to the users.-Software Dlubal .1 Disclaimer RSTAB is a software package used by over 7. Nevertheless. The engineer working with RSTAB is responsible for a correct structural model and the interpretation of the results. ING.1 Introduction 1. Introduction 1. It has been developed by a team of highly qualified engineers and programmers. SOFTWARE DLUBAL 1. 4 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.2 Introduction The following examples were selected to provide a representation of a wide range of model types and analysis options.

2 Examples 2.000 5 . Material: Steel A36 Sections: W 24x76 Supports pinned at both ends Loads: See below Structural System 3.1 Design of Beam for Moment (AISC ASD 9th Edition) This example is taken from: Applied Structural Steel Design (Third Edition) by Leonard SPIEGEL.00 2 2 3 W 24x76 Z DX = 14.000 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing. George F.-Software Dlubal DX = 14. Examples 2. LIMBRUNNER ISBN 0-13-381583-8 Pages 120 – 122 Geometry The structural system is a two bay beam with a span of 14 ft each.00 1 X 1 W 24x76 6.00 3.

6% This example shows no differences in the results of RSTAB and the analytical results in the literature as can be seen on the following page.-Software Dlubal .00 Z 45.6 Max = 96.00 kipft Bending Stress Ratio X Z 96.00 -3.00.2 Examples Shear Forces V -45. Min V-3: -45.00 Max V-3: 45. 6 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.00 X 3.00 Max M-2: 336.00 kip Bending Moments M X Z 336.

-Software Dlubal 7 .2 Examples RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.

M.I GILMOR Canadian Institute of Steel Construction 4th Edition 1990 Chapter 9. KULAK.00 7 2 16 50.00 11 100.000 6 3 3 X 11 50.00 12 7 100. The RSTAB results are as following: 8 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.00 DZ = 3.F.L.2 Multi-Story Frame (P-Delta) This example is taken from: Limits States Design in Structural Steel by G.4 Geometry Dimensions: as shown below Material: Steel with E=20410 kN/cm² Sections: UB 533x210x122 (British steel I-beam) Supports: pinned Structural System 14 14 50. P.500 50.00 6 10 4 1 8 4 5 2 1 DX = 9.00 15 DZ = 3.00 9 13 9 50.500 12 DZ = 3. ADAMS.500 30.00 5 DX = 9.2 Examples 2.000 Z In the reference.-Software Dlubal . the maximum bending moment according second order analysis for the column of element 3 is 388 kNm.00 30.

75 194.64 120.48 -594.87/388=0.87.68 -213.68 -120.19 -110.56 213.64 -196.87 193.84 181.33 -22.81% RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.90 -171.19 -31.63 200.68 -426.89 kNm The differences in this example to the analytical value in the literature reference are: 384.97 -165. Min M-2: -594.92 363.68 111.68 83.34 -120.85 233.01 164.44 165.2 Examples -254.-Software Dlubal 9 .20 -456.71 -141.65 284.74 X Z Max M-2: 384.07 -28.84 188.36 384.23 -120.89 -550.49 -232.

00 40. GAYLORD.00 40.000 2 1 W 14x74 1 W 14x74 DZ = 18.3 Simple Frame (P-Delta) This example is taken from: Design of Steel Structures (Third Edition) by Edwin H..000 W 14x74 3 X Z DX = 40.000 10 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.-Software Dlubal . STALLMEYER ISBN 0-07-023054-4 Pages 446-447 Geometry Dimensions: as shown below Material: Steel A 36 Sections: W 14x74 Supports: pinned Structural System 80.00 2 3 5 4 DX = 10. James E. GAYLORD. Charles N. Jr.2 Examples 2.

RSTAB gives 2894.84 2894.50 60.51 Z Max M-2: 4512.32 kipin In the literature the maximum bending moment is 2889 kip in.56 kip in.44 12.-Software Dlubal 11 .02%.32 kip in. The difference is 0.56 4432.98 99. Min M-2: -2767.32 4512.81 X 12. RSTAB gives 2767. The corresponding pages from the literature follow.44.56 2767.56 kipin In the literature the maximum bending moment is 2767 kip in.18%. Min M-2: -2894. Results Non-Linear Second-Order Elastic -2894.00 Z Max M-2: 4432.98 X 12. RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.00 100.32 -2651.34 12.2 Examples Results Linear Elastic Analysis -2767.81 60. The difference is 0.34.56 -2767.84 -2651.56 -2767.

2 Examples 12 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.-Software Dlubal .

14kN H  8 f 8  0.4 Cables This example is analyzed according: Statik der Seilkonstruktionen By Szymon PALKOWSKI ISBN 0-387-51125-3 Geometry Cable with 10 m in length between two horizontally fixed supports Inelastic cable Structural System Distributed load of 2 kN/m The horizontal reaction in the support nodes is: q l2 2  10 2  135.2 Examples 2.-Software Dlubal 13 . The result can be still improved when more intermediate nodes are inserted.185 RSTAB calculates 135. RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.10 kN.

) EIR = 32. 99 ff.000 kNm² m1 = m2 = 30 t m3 = 8 t According to this example. Berlin ISBN 3-433-01326-8 m1 14 10 7 m2 8 7 1 6 5 10 X 6 11 2 1 9 13 5 4 12 9 8 12 4 m3 15 11 3 2 3 Z Example according to MESKOURIS.-Software Dlubal .105814 0. 0. Then the response of the frame to the following excitation is analyzed in nodes 4. the first three eigenmodes are analyzed. Eigenmode No.189607 0.761587 0. Konstantin (1999) Baudynamik.000 kNm² EIS = 30. The following table compares the RSTAB-DYNAM results to those of the literature.181723 3 0. (pp. 10. 14 Eigenperiod [sec] RSTAB-DYNAM Literature 1 0.0  For all modal participations a damping of 2% is chosen. and 117 ff.2 Examples 2. Modelle Methoden Praxisbeispiele Ernst & Sohn. K. f(t) = ( 0 sec = 0 kN .755128 2 0.0  P(t) = 10. 7 and 10.0  f(t). 1 sec = 0 kN ) 5.5 sec = 1 kN .105522 RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.5 Modal Analysis of Frame This example i staken from: MESKOURIS.

14 9.94 13.80 4.39 15.71 0.40 -2.63 3.08 36.55 -13.11 23.61 sec.2 Examples Next there is a comparism of the internal forces in RSTAB and in the literature at the time of 0.09 30.62 29. -4.92 4.33 -6.12 7.DYNAM at time = 0.26 -16.00 59.76 -36.72 -9.27 36.65 10.59 -7.61 sec Bending moments M-2 in literature at time t = 0.18 -36.-Software Dlubal 15 .77 X Z M 2 59 55415 kN Bending moments M-2 in [kNm] in RSTAB.61 sec RSTAB Verification Manual © 2011 Ing.08 -2.63 3.26 -3.

.......................................................... ASD1 .....................................................................Loadcase 1 .......................................................................................................................................... Software DLUBAL - Part No - Length [ft] 14.....................................................................2 Mat No 1 1 Section Description I2 [in4] W 24x76 2100.............. Loads General Data ................... LS 1 ... Graphic ............115E+04 Coeff Therm [1/°C] 2.................................0 1 1 Hinge Begin End 1 1 - Ing....... Design Parameters ................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Sections .......................000 28.......................................................................com .............Stress Contour ......................................................................................................................................000 Elem Location HORI HORI www..................................................................... General Data ........................................................................................................................................................................................ Materials .............................. Global Element Deformations ................................................................................... Governing Internal Forces ...................85049 ELEMENTS Elem No Elem Type 1 2 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Beam Beam Nodes Begin End 1 2 Section Begin End Beta [°] 2 3 0......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... LG Results Internal Forces by Element ..................................................0 E Modulus [ksi] Sec No 11...........Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.......................................................... Sections .......000 0.......................................................... Support Forces and Support Moments ......................................................................................................... Elements ......................000 14................900E+04 Spec Weight [kip/in3] 1..................................................................................................................................................................................................................40000 9....... Structural Data Nodes ........................................................................................ ASD .................................4 228............................................................................................................................................................. Supports ... General Data ..................................................................200E-05 SECTIONS W 24x76 17......................................................................000 MATERIALS Mat No Material Description 1 Steel A36 Shear Mod [ksi] 2.....................000 0.......................................................................892E-04 1.........................dlubal................................................................................... D-93464 Tiefenbach www.......................................................................................................................... Graphic ............3 533.........................................................Results ...0 0............................................com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 1 TEST for RSTAB CONTENTS Contents ...... 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 7 GENERAL DATA COMPUTING METHOD Structural Analysis Stress Analysis Dynamic Analysis 1st Order Analysis 2nd Order Analysis Cable Theory Load Systems LS Groups LS Combinations Design Cases Dynamic Cases Buckling Curves STRUCTURAL DATA PARAMETERS 1D Continuous Beam 2D Construction Type 3D Construction Type Grid 3 1 1 0 0 Nodes Materials Sections Element Hinges Element Partitions 2 0 0 0 0 Elements Cables Tapered Elements Elastic Foundations Sets of Elements NODES Node No CoordinatesSystem 1 2 3 Ref Nodes Cartesian Gelagert Cartesian Cartesian Gelagert Node Coordinates Y [ft] X [ft] Z [ft] - 0........................................................dlubal..................................Stress Analysis ......................00000 A [in2] A3 [in2] 22.................................................0 30............................................................................................................................... Results .......................................................................................................000 - 14....... Max Stresses in Elements ....................3 607................. LS....................................... Design Details in Elements ................... Material Parameters ...........................................................................................................................000 0.............................................................6 30.............................................................................................

000 Ing.000 ELEMENT LOADS Loaded Elements No 1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures 1.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2. ft.com .000 6.00 Permanent Dead Weight - NODAL FORCES LS 1 Loaded Nodes No 1 Nodal Forces P Y [kip] P X [kip] 2 0.0 Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes 0. kipft.000 P Z [kip] 0. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.0 0.com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 2 TEST for RSTAB SUPPORTS Support No Supported Nodes 1 2 1 Gelenkig 3 Rotation [°] Alpha Beta in X Fixed Support/Support Spring [kip/ft] [kipft/rad] in Y in Z ar X ar Y ar Z 0. °C. kip/ft.0 0.dlubal.2 LS 1 Type No Load Direction 1 Z Parameters [kip.0 No Yes Yes Yes No Yes GENERAL DATA LS No LS Description 1 Factor Loadcase 1 Combination Type 1. kipft/ft] P1 3.dlubal. Software DLUBAL www.

00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00000 .00 .000 MX PZ .00 .00 .00 -45.00 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 X Z 2.00 .00 .00 45.00 .00 -3.000 .00 .00 14.00 .000 .00 .00 .00 45.00 336.000 .00000 .00 M3 .00000 .00 14.00 .00 336.00 .00 .000 GLOBAL ELEMENT DEFORMATIONS Elem No LS/LG No 1 LS1 2 LS1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Node No x [ft] 1 2 2 3 Element Deformations [in] uY uX .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .000 .00000 .00 .000 .00 .00 14.00 .000 MZ .00 336.00 .00 .00 3.00 3.00 -45.00 .00 -3. [kip/ft] Opposite Y-direction 6.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00000 .466 ft INTERNAL FORCES BY ELEMENT Elem No LS/LG No 1 LS1 2 LS1 Node No x [ft] 1 2 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 2 3 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 Forces [kip] V2 N .00 .00000 Ing.00 .00 -3.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 14.00 14.00 .000 Support Moments [kipft] MY .000 .00 336.00 .000 .00 14.00000 .00 .00 .000 .00 .00 336.79583 .00 .00 Moments [kipft] M2 T V3 45.00000 www.00 .00 .00 .00 3.00 336.00000 uZ .79583 .00 3.00 .00 .00 45.00 .dlubal.00 336.00 -45.00 . Software DLUBAL .00 .00 .000 45.00 .000 45.00 .00 . D-93464 Tiefenbach www.00 -3.com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 3 TEST for RSTAB LOADS LS 1 .00 .00 .00 14.00 .00 3.00 45.00 .00 .000 90.00 .000 90.00 .00 .00 336.dlubal.com .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .000 .00000 .Loadcase 1 [kip].00 .00 14.00 -3.00 .00 SUPPORT FORCES AND SUPPORT MOMENTS Node No LS/LG No 1 3 ΣLoads ΣForces Support Forces [kip] PY PX LS1 LS1 LS1 .000 .00 .00 .00 .

Loadcase 1 Internal Forces V-3 Opposite Y-direction -45.00 1.509 kip45.dlubal.3701 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures 1.809 ft Max V-3: 45.dlubal. Software DLUBAL www.com .809 ft Max M-2: 336.80 Max u: 0.Loadcase 1 Deformations Opposite Y-direction X Z 0.80 in Factor for Deformations: 39.00 kipft LS 1 .809 ft Ing. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.Loadcase 1 Internal Forces M-2 Opposite Y-direction X Z 336.00 X 3.800 kipft 1.00 -3.com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 4 TEST for RSTAB RESULTS LS 1 .00 kip LS 1 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00. Min V-3: -45.00 Z 15.00 115.

00 -3.91 1.000 0.55 144.00 0.00 0.40 0.00 0.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.000 LS No LS1 LS1 Forces [kip] V-2 N 0.3 607.00 0.000 0.76 27.00 -22.24 cm cm cm cm^2 www.000 0.34 0. Software DLUBAL Value Unit 14.00 DESIGN DETAILS IN ELEMENTS Element Description 1 Element Length Effective Length Factor Buckling about 2-2 Effective Length Factor Buckling about 3-3 Geometric Slenderness about 2-2 Geometric Slenderness about 3-3 Section Type Table B5.35 87.0000 1.000 14.96 0.97 0.00 0.1 Depth of Section Flange Width Flange Thickness Area of Compression Flange RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Parameter L K-2 K-3 K-2*L/r K-3*L/r Compact d bf tf Af Ing.00 14.96 0.73 40.W 24x76 Tension Compression Bending Stress 2-2 Bending Stress 3-3 Shear Stress 2 Shear Stress 3 Torsion Stress Tension and Bending Compression and Bending Stress [ksi] S Point No LS No 0.STRESS ANALYSIS GENERAL DATA ELEMENTS TO DESIGN All LOAD SYSTEMS SELECTED FOR DESIGN LS1 .000 0.0 30.76 27.00 0.00 336.60 14.00 0.00 existing Stress Ratio allowable GOVERNING INTERNAL FORCES Elem No x Location [ft] 1 2 0.00 V-3 Moments [kipft] M-2 M-T 45.com .00 0.dlubal.00 -22.97 0.00 0.000 1 1 1 1 1 13 1 1 1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 0.00 0.00 -4.00 0.000 0.49 23.87 0.00 0.0 Yield Stress [ksi] Code 11.000 0. 9th edition Tensile Stress [ksi] 36 Modulus of Elasticity [ksi] 58 29000 SECTIONS W 24x76 Sec No 533.00 M-3 0.000 0.com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 5 TEST for RSTAB ASD1 .87 0.40 14.00 0.00 0.000 14.4 17.000 0.14 3433.000 0.54 60.60 14.00 0. Length Lcomp[ft] 14 14 Anet/Agross Ratio 1 1 1 1 MAX STRESSES IN ELEMENTS Stress Type x Location [ft] Element No 1: Section No 1 .49 23.60 1.000 0.00 21.000 1 1 1 1 1 13 1 1 1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 LS1 0.2 Mat No 1 Section Description Section Rotation 1 I-T [cm^4] A [cm^2] W 24x76 I-2 [cm^4] Alpha pl y 111.76 11.97 0.00 4.W 24x76 Tension Compression Bending Stress 2-2 Bending Stress 3-3 Shear Stress 2 Shear Stress 3 Torsion Stress Tension and Bending Compression and Bending Element No 2: Section No 1 .97 0.000 0.00 0.40 14.00 0.52 I-3 [cm^4] Alpha pl z 87408.000 ft 1. No Effective-length factor K2 K3 1 2 1 1 Coefficient Cm2 Cm3 1 1 0 0 Unbraced Lenght Lb2[ft] Lb3[ft] Coefficient Cb 0 0 0 0 14 14 Comp.6 30.0000 17.25 DESIGN PARAMETERS Elem.34 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.Loadcase 1 MATERIAL PARAMETERS Mat No Material Description 1 Steel A36 ASD.42 1.dlubal.00 0.40 14.000 0. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.00 14.40 0.40 14.000 0.3 228.00 21.000 14.00 0.000 0.

40 4.000 ft) 126.00 0.267 ft) fb3-3 (Point 1) Fb3-3 (x: 0.42 1.9665 ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi L K-2 K-3 K-2*L/r K-3*L/r Compact d bf tf Af h 14.000 ft) 51.96 23.60 ksi Ing.000 ft) 0.10 0.96 23.0000 ksi ksi ksi ksi fa Fa fb2-2 Fb2-2 fb3-3 Fb3-3 (x: 4.00 1.00 14.00 0.00 1.00 27. AXIAL TENSION AND BENDING Calculated Axial Stress Allowable Axial Stress Calculated Bending Stress about 2-2 Allowable Bending Stress about 2-2 Calculated Bending Stress about 3-3 Allowable Bending Stress about 3-3 Stress Ratio (H2-1) 2 Element Length Effective Length Factor Buckling about 2-2 Effective Length Factor Buckling about 3-3 Geometric Slenderness about 2-2 Geometric Slenderness about 3-3 Section Type Table B5.00 0.dlubal.00 0.489 1.00 0.0000 17.00 27.000 14.00 14.30 cm ft (Point 1) Ft (x: 0.000 ft) 0. AXIAL COMPRESSION AND BENDING Calculated Axial Stress Allowable Axial Stress Calculated Bending Stress about 2-2 Allowable Bending Stress about 2-2 Interaction Coefficient Bending about 2-2 Calculated Bending Stress about 3-3 Allowable Bending Stress about 3-3 Interaction Coefficient Bending about 3-3 Stress Ratio (H1-3) COMBINED STRESS.000 ft) 126.00 ksi 21. Software DLUBAL www.40 -4.0000 0.3488 -22.30 ksi ksi cm cm cm cm^2 cm ft (Point 1) Ft (x: 0.dlubal.000 ft) 9.3277 -22.00 0.1 Depth of Section Flange Width Flange Thickness Area of Compression Flange Clear Distance between Flanges TENSION Calculated Tension Stress Allowable Tension Stress (D1.27 0.000 1.54 60.24 57.000 1.00 ksi 14. on gross area) COMPRESSION Critical Slenderness Ratio Calculated Compression Stress Allowable Compression Stress (E2-1) BENDING Maximum unbraced Length F1-2 Compression Length for Allowable Bending Stress Unbraced Length Bending Coefficient Calculated Bending Stress about 2-2 Allowable Bending Stress about 2-2 (F1-1) Calculated Bending Stress about 3-3 Allowable Bending Stress about 3-3 (F2-1) SHEAR Ratio h/tw (beam member) Calculated Shear Stress 2 Allowable Shear Stress 2 (F4-1) Calculated Shear Stress 3 Allowable Shear Stress 3 (F4-1) COMBINED STRESS. Point 1) 0.0000 ft ft ft ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi fa Fa 0.49 ksi Lc Lcomp Lb Cb fb2-2 (Point 1) Fb2-2 (x: 4.76 11.000 ft 1.00 0.000 ft) fv3 (Point 13) Fv3 (x: 0.00 ksi 21.00 21. AXIAL COMPRESSION AND BENDING Calculated Axial Stress Allowable Axial Stress Calculated Bending Stress about 2-2 Allowable Bending Stress about 2-2 Interaction Coefficient Bending about 2-2 Calculated Bending Stress about 3-3 Allowable Bending Stress about 3-3 Interaction Coefficient Bending about 3-3 Stress Ratio (H1-3) COMBINED STRESS.com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 6 TEST for RSTAB DESIGN DETAILS IN ELEMENTS Element Description 1 Clear Distance between Flanges TENSION Calculated Tension Stress Allowable Tension Stress (D1.000 ft.000 14.00 1.00 ksi 14.00 h/tw fv2 (Point 1) Fv2 (x: 0.76 0.0000 1.00 1. D-93464 Tiefenbach www. Point 1) 0.00 ksi 21.60 ksi Cc fa (Point 1) Fa (x: 0.27 0.000 ft) fv3 (Point 13) Fv3 (x: 4.76 0.87 14.000 ft.267 ft.35 87.76 0.49 ksi Lc Lcomp Lb Cb fb2-2 (Point 1) Fb2-2 (x: 0.0000 0.60 ksi Cc fa (Point 1) Fa (x: 0.0000 0.00 h/tw fv2 (Point 1) Fv2 (x: 0.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 0.000 ft) fb3-3 (Point 1) Fb3-3 (x: 0.87 14. AXIAL TENSION AND BENDING Calculated Axial Stress Allowable Axial Stress RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Parameter Value Unit h 57.40 0.com .00 0. Point 1) 51.60 -22.96 23.40 ft ft ft ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi ksi fa Fa fb2-2 Fb2-2 Cm22 fb3-3 Fb3-3 Cm33 (x: 0.267 ft) fa Fa fb2-2 Fb2-2 Cm22 fb3-3 Fb3-3 Cm33 (x: 0.489 1. on gross area) COMPRESSION Critical Slenderness Ratio Calculated Compression Stress Allowable Compression Stress (E2-1) BENDING Maximum unbraced Length F1-2 Compression Length for Allowable Bending Stress Unbraced Length Bending Coefficient Calculated Bending Stress about 2-2 Allowable Bending Stress about 2-2 (F1-1) Calculated Bending Stress about 3-3 Allowable Bending Stress about 3-3 (F2-1) SHEAR Ratio h/tw (beam member) Calculated Shear Stress 2 Allowable Shear Stress 2 (F4-1) Calculated Shear Stress 3 Allowable Shear Stress 3 (F4-1) COMBINED STRESS.000 ft) 9.10 0.0000 0.73 40.00 27.

00 0.dlubal.00 27. Point 1) Value -22. Software DLUBAL www.96 23.dlubal. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.76 0.809 ft Max = 96.6 1.000 ft.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.com Project: TEST Position: Single Span Beam Page: 7 TEST for RSTAB DESIGN DETAILS IN ELEMENTS Element Description Parameter 2 Calculated Bending Stress about 2-2 Allowable Bending Stress about 2-2 Calculated Bending Stress about 3-3 Allowable Bending Stress about 3-3 Stress Ratio (H2-1) fb2-2 Fb2-2 fb3-3 Fb3-3 (x: 0.Stress Analysis Bending Stress 2-2 Opposite Y-direction X Z 96.com .9665 Unit ksi ksi ksi ksi STRESS CONTOUR ASD1 .6% RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Ing.

.................................................com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 1 TEST for RSTAB CONTENTS Contents .................................dlubal..... Materials ..................................... LS 1 .................................................................................................................... D-93464 Tiefenbach www. Loads General Data ........................................................................9 E Modulus [kN/cm 2] Steel Shear Mod [kN/cm 2] 2...................................................... 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 4 4 6 7 8 GENERAL DATA COMPUTING METHOD Structural Analysis Stress Analysis Dynamic Analysis 1st Order Analysis 2nd Order Analysis Cable Theory Load Systems LS Groups LS Combinations Design Cases Dynamic Cases Buckling Curves STRUCTURAL DATA PARAMETERS 1D Continuous Beam 2D Construction Type 3D Construction Type Grid 12 1 1 0 0 Nodes Materials Sections Element Hinges Element Partitions 15 0 0 0 0 Elements Cables Tapered Elements Elastic Foundations Sets of Elements NODES Node No CoordinatesSystem 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 9 11 12 14 16 Ref Nodes Cartesian Supported Cartesian Cartesian Supported Cartesian Cartesian Supported Cartesian Cartesian Cartesian Cartesian Cartesian Cartesian Cartesian Node Coordinates Y [m] X [m] Z [m] - 0...........................500 3...........................................................................................000 -10.........500 0.....................400 ELEMENTS Elem No Elem Type 1 2 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Beam Beam Nodes Begin End 1 3 Section Begin End Beta [°] 2 4 0......................................................................................................................................000 -7.000 -3..................................................... General Data ................. Structural Data Nodes ............................... Graphic ... Internal Forces by Element ................................... Supports ..................................................................................................... LS Groups ...................000 0....................................................................................................................000 - 0.............000 -3...................................000 -3...........................................................................................................................0 1 1 Hinge Begin End 1 1 - Ing..........041E+04 Spec Weight [kN/cm 3] 8.............................................................................................000 18..............................................................................................100E+03 Coeff Therm [1/°C] 7....000 - 18......................500 -7............................................ Sections ......................................850E-05 1..........000 18.....................................................................500 -10....5 211.............................................................................Full loading .................Results ...........000 9..................... Global Element Deformations ...........000 -7............................000 0................500 Elem Location VERT VERT www. Elements ..................................................................................................................................... Support Forces and Support Moments ...............................00 A3 [cm2] 155..............000 0................................3 544..............000 18..... LG Results 2nd Order Analysis Data .............................500 -10........................000 - 9...............................500 0........000 9...................com ............. LS...................... Software DLUBAL - Part No - Length [m] 3......................................................000 9...........dlubal......................7 Mat No 1 1 Section Description A [cm2] I2 [cm4] UB 533x210x122 76040.........0 0....Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2...500 MATERIALS Mat No Material Description 1 UB 533x210x122 21.................................................................................200E-05 SECTIONS Sec No 12............................................

000 0.000 VERT HORI HORI VERT VERT VERT HORI HORI VERT VERT VERT HORI HORI SUPPORTS Support No Supported Nodes 1 1.000 0.dlubal.000 100.00 Permanent Dead Weight - NODAL FORCES LS 1 Loaded Nodes No 1 2 3 Nodal Forces P Y [kN] P X [kN] 2 7 12 100. Software DLUBAL www. kNm.500 3.000 LS 1 Type No Load Direction 1 1 Z Z Parameters [kN.15 4.0 0.0 0.000 50.0 0.0 0.500 9.0 0.0 Fixed Support/Support Spring [kN/m] [kNm/rad] in Y in Z ar X ar Y Yes Yes Yes Yes No ar Z Yes GENERAL DATA LS No LS Description 1 Factor Full loading Combination Type 1.500 3.5. m.000 0. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.0 0.0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Hinge Begin End 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 - - Part No Length [m] - Elem Location 3.5 Hinged Rotation [°] Alpha Beta 0.000 9.9.0 in X 0.com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 2 TEST for RSTAB ELEMENTS Elem No Elem Type 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Nodes Begin End Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam Beam 5 2 4 2 4 6 7 9 7 9 11 12 14 Section Begin End Beta [°] 6 4 6 7 9 11 9 11 12 14 16 14 16 0.000 3.0 0. kN/m.dlubal.3.000 0. kNm/m] P1 30.000 9.500 9.000 50.000 0.500 3.000 Ing.000 ELEMENT LOADS Loaded Elements No 1 2 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures 14. °C.com .500 3.500 9.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.0 0.0 0.000 9.0 0.0 0.0 0.10 P Z [kN] 0.000 3.

[kN/m] Opposite Y-direction 30.00 50.00 100.Full loading [kN].dlubal.com .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 50.00 Load Systems in LG LS1 Ing.00 1.00 100.00 50.00 50. Software DLUBAL www.dlubal.00 X Z 1.00 50.com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 3 TEST for RSTAB LOADS LS 1 . D-93464 Tiefenbach www.338 m LS GROUPS LG No LG Description 1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures P-Delta analysis of LS 1 Coefficient Gamma M Factor 1.00 30.

28 10.00 9.16 -586.00 .00 .00 . D-93464 Tiefenbach www.00 .21 -478.00 .00 .00 .50 .59 8.00 .00 372.00 .00 .77 -1202.03 -659.92 -594.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .59 8.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .77 -1202.16 -481.16 -656.00 .00 .00 .00 9.00 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 9.00 .00 .00 .06 110.50 3.61 -128.46 -540.79 .75 21.03 -659.97 .00 43.75 .00 .00 .00 .00 3.06 110.00 .87 6.83 -128.com .68 105.00 .84 -2.00 .56 -287.80 -272.00 .00 .00 .00 .94 164.03 -659.00 .28 10.16 -481.00 .78 47.66 106.00 .00 .77 -1202.50 .00 .00 .00 9.59 8.00 .75 .00 .00 .21 -478.00 .00 .00 9.00 .25 -270.00 9.00 .00 3.71 99.61 -540.00 .00 .50 . Software DLUBAL T Moments [kNm] M2 .00 .97 363.07 -550.64 46.28 21.16 -656.87 162.00 .00 .97 .00 .87 .00 .00 .00 .77 -1202.75 21.68 100.00 .00 .00 .00 .77 -1202.50 .00 .00 9.00 .50 .16 -478.00 .00 .00 .16 230.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .75 21.00 .59 10.03 -659.00 .00 .75 165.00 .00 372.50 .00 .64 46.97 363.00 3.51 106.25 -270.00 .75 47.00 .00 .00 .78 43.00 .32 -38.00 .00 349.50 .50 .00 3.16 -656.16 177.03 -659.00 .00 .00 .03 21.69 -1202.61 -120.00 3.59 8.00 .96 179.00 .00 .00 .59 8.69 -1202.00 .00 .00 .16 -272.00 349.00 .78 43.96 -287.32 -586.00 .61 192.00 .50 .00 9.00 .00 .50 .77 -656.00 3.75 -.16 -28.44 -594.00 .00 .75 21.28 10.00 .00 .00 .00 3.00 3.50 3.00 .00 .00 .21 -478.00 .00 .94 108.00 153.00 .00 .28 10.00 .00 .59 8.00 .78 43.28 10.13 164.00 .00 .79 .00 .16 -481.00 .00 .00 .00 9.00 3.11E-04 Ny-fold Results Tension Force Effect Yes Yes 0.00 .50 3.00 .15 9.00 .13 -285.00 .01 INTERNAL FORCES BY ELEMENT Elem No LS/LG No 1 LS1 LG1 2 LS1 LG1 3 LS1 LG1 4 LS1 LG1 5 LS1 LG1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Node No 1 2 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 1 2 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 3 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 3 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 5 6 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 5 6 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 2 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 2 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 4 6 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 4 6 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 x [m] N .21 .00 .87 -285.00 .00 .51 106.00 165.03 21.00 .00 .00 .16 -656.00 .77 -1202.13 -285.00 .59 8.00 .69 -1202.00 .00 .50 3.00 -38.dlubal.63 -285.00 .00 .00 .00 .51 106.00 .00 .00 .00 .79 .02 -287.00 .25 179.00 9.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .62 -586.00 .71 99.00 .75 46.69 -1202.00 .00 3.50 3.00 .00 .16 -656.03 21.94 110.00 3.75 165.71 99.23 193.84 177.00 .83 -540.00 .00 .69 -1202.21 -1202.66 100.00 .00 3.00 .71 99.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 3.02 162.00 .00 .00 .51 106.00 .16 -481.00 .00 .03 21.00 384.00 .00 .00 .00 3.68 105.00 .00 .00 3.00 .66 100.03 21.89 -28.77 -1202.00 .00 .75 -270.00 .00 .50 .00 .00 .75 47.51 106.00 .00 .00 153.16 -481.00 .00 .50 .00 .00 .78 43.71 105.03 -659.78 43.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 165.00 .03 21.96 162.60 9.75 21.28 10.00 .00 .00 .21 -478.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .94 108.87 384.00 .00 363.96 4.00 .00 .00 .16 -656.00 .00 .03 8.87 164.06 108.00 .74 -550.00 9.00 .84 Ing.00 3.21 -478.00 .50 3.64 99.00 .87 384.75 21.07 -550.71 99.02 -287.dlubal.03 -659.000 2 .50 .16 -656.50 .00 349.00 .00 .00 .00 .07 -120.00 .66 105.84 -272.71 99.69 -1202.75 -270.00 .00 363.00 9.00 .75 21.00 .00 .51 106.83 -540.44 -594.16 -38.23 -120.00 .00 .00 349.75 179.com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 4 TEST for RSTAB 2ND ORDER ANALYSIS DATA LGNo Factor Ny LG1 Eps-Convergence Existing Wanted Number Iterations 1.16 -481.75 177.23 M3 .06 108.16 -272.32 -586.00 .00 .00 .00 .71 99.78 43.21 -478.00 .51 110.16 -481.21 -478.00 .00 .00 .00 .21 .00 .00 .00 .69 -1202.00 .00 3.75 46.03 21.89 -594.75 21.00 -481.60 9.00 .00 .00 .00 .89 233.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .51 106.00 .00 .64 47.78 43.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 3.00 www.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .87 .50 3.23 -550.00 .00 .16 -659.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 384.68 100.89 -128.00 .00 .15 9.28 10.69 -1202.44 -28.03 Forces [kN] V2 V3 .00 .00 372.00 .

05 9.40 -385.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .29 -120.00 .00 .00 .00 .36 284.03 -317.00 .00 .01 -456.00 .00 .00 .29 -120.55 86.53 191.00 .00 .41 -26.00 3.00 .00 .55 86.00 .00 9.63 -737.63 -737.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .29 194.00 4.00 3.00 .70 -198.70 -453.00 .00 .31 -35.11 -64.00 .70 -453.04 128.00 .00 .00 .00 .96 88.00 .82 281.00 .01 -456.00 .00 .00 .00 .88 -245.00 .19 188.00 .27 128.00 .69 -83.00 .00 .57 -737.00 .69 -83.00 .84 -165.86 -26.46 -83.00 .00 .85 -1.50 3.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .27 128.00 .31 194.35 -81.81 -64.12 204.com .00 .00 .00 .00 3.00 .13 -423.00 .81 -64.00 9.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 9.21 88.86 -26.85 -167.00 .00 .00 3.00 .00 .64 -426.00 .26 196.96 -246.81 -64.00 .23 -83.57 -737.81 -64.55 86.00 .00 .00 2.00 .00 .84 -165.86 -26.22 196.52 -81.00 .00 .19 -196.00 .00 www.11 -167.50 .14 -316.23 -386.00 .00 .82 -165.00 3.50 .00 .00 .23 3.14 -316.00 .71 -110.34 194.50 .00 191.00 .00 .00 .50 .00 .21 88.00 .57 -737.42 -232.00 .00 .00 .86 -26.19 194.50 .00 .00 .00 .00 .86 -26.49 -423.00 .11 -64.00 .00 .00 .00 9.23 -386.00 .27 128.46 -83.53 191.36 -198.00 .35 163.00 .00 .00 .26 -5.00 .00 .00 .46 -83.49 -235.00 .00 .00 .52 -246.00 .88 203.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .50 .34 -108.00 .03 -316.00 .00 .27 128.00 .35 164.00 .00 .04 128.00 .00 .64 -426.00 .63 -737.00 .69 -83.57 -737.50 .35 163.00 .00 .00 .49 -246.11 -64.00 .40 -385.66 284.83 204.00 .29 -120.00 .00 .29 -120.29 88.46 -83.00 .88 204.00 .50 .74 -253.49 -423.00 .00 .29 -120.49 163.00 .dlubal.40 -385.12 -245.00 .57 196.63 -737.00 9.00 .00 9.00 9.71 200.00 .63 -737.00 .05 9.00 .50 3.00 3.00 .00 .81 -64.04 128.00 9.50 .57 -737.00 .00 .39 -121.00 .00 .14 -316.00 .41 -26.22 -253.00 9. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.55 88.35 -81.14 -316.00 .00 .00 .69 -83.57 -737.00 .00 .00 .00 .03 -317.00 .81 -64.00 .00 .41 -26.00 .27 128.00 .11 -64.69 -83.35 -81.00 .00 .00 .00 .68 -108.00 .03 -317.00 .00 .36 -7.83 -253. Software DLUBAL T Moments [kNm] M2 .00 .69 -83.00 .84 284.14 -316.00 .03 -317.21 88.46 -83.49 -246.00 .22 -253.49 203.00 .com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 5 TEST for RSTAB INTERNAL FORCES BY ELEMENT Elem No LS/LG No 6 LS1 LG1 7 LS1 LG1 8 LS1 LG1 9 LS1 LG1 10 LS1 LG1 11 LS1 LG1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Node No 2 7 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 2 7 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 4 9 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 4 9 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 6 11 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 6 11 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 7 9 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 7 9 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 9 11 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 9 11 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 7 12 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 7 x [m] Forces [kN] V2 N .19 -456.35 -81.82 281.00 .82 -167.00 .00 .00 188.03 -317.55 86.00 .00 .00 .00 .27 128.23 -386.00 .50 3.00 .46 -83.70 -198.00 3.00 .46 -83.19 194.00 .33 M3 .69 86.40 -385.69 -64.00 .00 .55 86.29 -120.57 -737.39 -121.00 .00 .00 .04 128.34 194.41 -26.57 -737.00 -317.23 3.55 86.00 .00 .00 .34 -108.05 -453.00 .40 -385.00 .00 -64.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .83 -6.14 -316.00 .00 .81 -64.34 -110.00 .86 -26.00 .00 .00 .63 -456.11 -167.00 .63 -385.00 .76 -253.dlubal.00 .11 -64.88 1.00 .00 3.00 .00 .00 .00 4.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 3.00 .41 -26.12 -245.53 191.50 .35 -81.00 .00 .14 -737.00 .23 -386.00 .00 .53 -35.00 .50 .00 -196.00 .34 -108.00 .03 -317.29 -120.00 .00 .05 9.71 200.00 .00 .00 .00 .40 -385.00 .00 .00 .62 -245.68 194.52 203.42 -253.83 196.41 -26.21 88.00 .03 -317.46 -83.00 .00 .00 .35 -81.00 .55 86.00 .00 .00 .57 -108.50 .98 .26 196.00 .00 .50 3.00 .00 .00 .69 -83.00 .49 -232.50 .74 196.00 .00 3.19 -235.49 -426.85 200.05 9.11 281.41 -26.39 163.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 .00 .50 .71 -110.64 -232.00 .00 .00 .00 .71 -64.52 .19 2.00 .00 3.86 -26.35 -81.00 .23 -386.31 191.42 -235.00 .00 .35 -81.19 -31.39 -121.00 .63 -737.48 -426.00 .42 -423.00 .50 3.57 -108.50 3.00 .00 .69 -26.00 1.00 .00 .00 9.53 -35.00 .27 128.35 -121.40 -386.61 200.00 -198.14 -316.63 -737.34 Ing.00 4.00 .96 89.84 284.00 .00 .00 3.74 196.00 .00 3.00 .57 128.00 .00 .00 .00 .81 -64.00 .86 -26.27 128.00 .00 9.82 -167.96 128.00 .83 128.00 .01 -196.41 -120.00 .00 .00 .50 3.00 .00 1.42 181.40 -385.23 -386.00 .00 .57 128.07 V3 .49 181.00 .00 .00 .00 .19 -31.23 -386.74 -253.00 4.29 -120.00 .50 .

94 -22.00 .60 111.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 -120.19 -280.000 .64 -213.29 -149.00 .68 111.000 PZ MX 481.00 .50 .00 .68 .95 29.00 .33 -120.84 83.00 .78 -120.00 . D-93464 Tiefenbach www.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .84 -1.00 .44 30.00 9.000 .40 -101.00 .40 101.00 .00 .10 .00 .49 101.000 .00 .000 .00 .00 .00 .000 250.00 .00 .00 -81.157 478.88 81.000 .000 .00 .00 .07 -120.00 .50 3.768 656.40 101.71 120.00 .00 .68 164.40 -101.05 9.00 .23 120.69 -139.95 29.40 101.00 .65 -121.00 .00 .84 -142.52 -139.00 .00 .000 .00 .775 45.713 98.00 .24 -139.00 .95 29.00 .00 .00 .00 9.52 130.44 30.00 .40 -101.00 .000 Support Moments [kNm] MY .00 .00 .00 .19 -280.00 .00 .40 -101.44 101.00 .35 -131.00 .00 .00 .00 .55 -131.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .25 30.00 .00 .00 .40 -101.00 .000 .37 101.40 -101.00 .31 -142.60 -171.69 -139.24 -280.50 .00 9.94 81.23 -149.00 .40 -101.34 -81.94 -22.00 SUPPORT FORCES AND SUPPORT MOMENTS Node No LS/LG No 1 3 5 ΣLoads ΣForces ΣLoads ΣForces LS1 LG1 LS1 LG1 LS1 LG1 LS1 LG1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Support Forces [kN] PY PX 43.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 3.00 .00 .00 9.50 .78 119.00 .71 Moments [kNm] M2 .56 83.88 -22.00 .00 9.00 .00 3.35 130.71 -1.89 130.00 .00 .00 .95 30.00 .68 -141.40 101.40 101.00 M3 -120.00 .50 3.00 3.00 .68 -120.00 .48 -139.07 -280.00 .00 .000 .00 .00 .50 -212.037 99.40 29.000 .35 -139.00 .00 .19 -280.89 120.95 29.00 .00 .55 -131.69 -131.00 .35 -131.00 .29 -149.50 .00 9.00 .95 29.00 .00 .00 .000 .19 -280.40 -101.00 .35 -131.00 .00 .19 -280.35 -131.48 130.00 .00 .00 .00 .60 -171.89 -1.24 -280.52 83.35 -131.00 .46 30.00 .07 -120.40 -101.00 .00 .00 .37 101.00 .55 -131.00 .07 -120.60 -142.000 www.00 .29 120.00 9.00 .207 1202.19 -280.00 .00 4.60 -142.00 .48 -139.00 .50 .50 .00 .00 .dlubal.68 -254.00 .52 213.56 -22.35 -253.71 -4.000 .00 .60 -212.90 -171.000 .07 -120.71 130.00 .00 .00 .50 .68 -254.71 120.41 -149.00 .000 250.000 MZ .000 .00 .68 -120.00 1.07 -120.95 29.00 .88 -22.00 .40 T V3 .00 .31 212.00 .00 .com .52 -139.00 .00 .00 .000 .56 -22.34 -213.40 -101.781 250.00 .686 1202.00 .025 2340.00 .00 .23 -149.00 .50 9.94 81.00 .00 .000 2340.44 30.24 -280.34 -213.40 101.77 -253.00 .00 .00 .00 .55 -131.40 3.60 212.00 .37 101.00 .00 9.00 .00 .00 .34 -171.dlubal.00 .000 2340.69 -139.24 -280.52 -139.40 -101.00 .000 250.000 .90 120.05 9.24 -280.000 .55 -101.70 3.23 120.00 4.00 .52 -139.00 .00 .000 .00 .00 9.00 .40 -101.00 .00 .00 4.00 .00 .00 .00 .33 164.40 -101.00 .69 -139.00 .00 .00 .00 .78 -121.35 -253.00 3.68 -171.40 -81.21 -149.35 -139.50 3.00 .31 -142.00 .00 2.78 -253.00 .40 -101.00 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 .00 .71 -139.00 .65 .00 .157 659.69 -139.25 30.00 .00 .00 .33 -6.00 .00 .49 120.000 .52 -139.00 4.69 -139.00 .25 30.40 101.50 .65 -141.00 .95 29.19 -280.00 .00 .181 106.89 -171.00 .19 -280.52 -139.000 Ing.00 .00 .66 164.68 213.55 -131.00 .69 -139.50 .58 101.00 3.000 .52 -139.71 -139.55 -131.52 -139.31 -141.94 -22.00 .00 .00 .00 .89 -212.00 .00 .52 130.40 -81.00 .49 101.000 .40 101.00 .20 -254.50 3.31 212.00 .00 .00 .71 -149.35 -121.00 .35 -131.00 .00 .55 -131.50 3.49 101.00 .00 .00 .47 -81.00 .90 -120.00 .65 213.00 .00 3.000 .00 .00 .00 .00 .24 -280.512 106.50 9.89 -212.00 .50 .52 -139.00 .34 -81.000 .00 .00 .00 . Software DLUBAL .00 .00 .24 -280.000 .com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 6 TEST for RSTAB INTERNAL FORCES BY ELEMENT Elem No LS/LG No 11 LG1 12 LS1 LG1 13 LS1 LG1 14 LS1 LG1 15 LS1 LG1 Node No x [m] 12 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 9 14 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 9 14 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 11 16 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 11 16 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 12 14 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 12 14 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 14 16 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 14 16 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 Forces [kN] V2 N 3.00 .000 2340.68 -213.07 -120.00 .34 -81.35 -131.00 3.00 .00 .52 -139.35 -131.00 .00 9.00 9.68 -22.68 -141.00 .00 .00 .00 .52 -4.00 .00 .00 .00 .000 .84 -22.00 .40 -101.68 -120.

50 .58376 24.88137 .88080 1.88080 7.com .22178 7.00000 16.87704 1.00 3.00000 .00000 16.00 3.00000 .17032 24.50 .00 16.81161 1.50 .00000 .00 3.05 8.00000 .00000 16.00000 1.00000 .19469 .69063 23.53096 8.00000 .00906 5.00000 .91054 .88339 1.00000 1.00000 .72407 .73474 16.42169 27.87657 7.14937 1.00000 .00000 8.69063 26.62817 23.93441 16.19469 24.00000 .30333 5.73474 28.00000 .00000 .14108 2.72724 .00000 .63336 23.37819 16.00000 .05 .25642 .00000 uZ .81972 27.14937 .00000 .00000 .00 3.50 .00000 .50 .14049 1.60 8.00000 .55 3.00000 .50 .66232 24.00 4.00000 .50 .00000 16.05 9.03560 24.72724 7.42550 24.53284 27.14123 1.00000 .00000 .00000 .73474 24.00000 .25642 24.00000 .34562 27.01354 .00 3.00 4.91054 23.17032 16.87657 2.50 .50 .52770 7.60 .88262 .52770 2.00000 .30333 1.86917 .00000 .50 .55 3.41941 24.00 4.00000 .72025 .00000 .42169 16.00000 .00000 .00000 .01975 1.55 3.50 .50 .89304 16.00 4.00608 23.00917 1.97022 23.60 . Software DLUBAL .00000 .00 3.18007 16.00000 .00000 .00 3.00000 .05 9.72407 1.dlubal.00000 .18731 .00000 .45313 26.37819 26.14108 1.30759 1.00000 .00000 .00000 .96724 23.32726 .00 3.52770 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.50 .05 8.50 .30759 www.53096 .50 .19275 .37458 Ing.46361 23.15344 6.00000 .00906 .64814 .00000 .00 3.00608 27.32717 2.00 3.00 4.55 4.00 3.53096 .87657 .00000 16.50 .00 3.32717 .60 8.00000 .03560 26.00000 .49792 16.88137 23.00000 .17032 .21938 16.88080 .00 3.00000 .45027 2.82062 1.dlubal.38194 27.00 3.00000 .00000 .50 .00000 16.32726 1.14123 1.00000 .00 3.14795 7.00000 .50 .com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 7 TEST for RSTAB GLOBAL ELEMENT DEFORMATIONS Elem No LS/LG No 1 LS1 LG1 2 LS1 LG1 3 LS1 LG1 4 LS1 LG1 5 LS1 LG1 6 LS1 7 LS1 LG1 LG1 8 LS1 LG1 9 LS1 LG1 10 LS1 LG1 11 LS1 LG1 12 LS1 LG1 13 LS1 LG1 14 LS1 LG1 15 LS1 LG1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Node No Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z x [m] Element Deformations [mm] uY uX 3.50 .00000 .00000 .05 .00000 .45313 16.20072 .50 . D-93464 Tiefenbach www.50387 26.00000 .00000 .01354 6.88137 16.00 4.00 3.34562 23.97022 .00000 .45048 2.00000 .49792 27.84896 28.00000 .00 3.37458 24.00000 .15344 .00 4.00000 .69063 16.25333 16.00 3.00000 .

19 -110.01 -31.64 -196. Software DLUBAL www.20 -456.89 -550.74 X 1.84 200.dlubal.34 -120. Min M-2: -594.87.71 -141.84 181.270 m Max M-2: 384.44 165.64 120.com .75 194.P-Delta analysis of LS 1 Internal Forces M-2 Opposite Y-direction -254.68 -213.68 -426.87 193.49 164.07 -28.19 -232. D-93464 Tiefenbach www.com Project: TEST Position: P-Delta Page: 8 TEST for RSTAB RESULTS LG 1 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.63 -594.48 188.33 -22.65 284.90 -171.861 kNm 363.68 83.85 233.23 -120.89 kNm RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Ing.36 384.56 213.dlubal.68 -120.97 -165.92 386.68 111.

..... Materials ......................................000 40.......................... LS................................................................... Structural Data Nodes ......Second-order elastic ................................................................. LG Results 2nd Order Analysis Data ..........................................................................................................................200E-05 SECTIONS W 14x74 11......115E+04 Coeff Therm [1/°C] 2...................................4 19..................................892E-04 1.....................000 MATERIALS Mat No Material Description 1 Steel A36 Shear Mod [ksi] 2.....00000 A3 [in2] 21........................................................................................................................ Support Forces and Support Moments .........Results ......................................... Graphic ..........................9 255....................................................... General Data ... LS 1 .....000 Elem Location VERT VERT HORI www................................................................ Global Element Deformations ...............................................................4 279....................0 1 1 1 Hinge Begin End 1 1 1 - Ing................................................9 35..........................................................................................................Results ..All vertical loads ............................................................................dlubal.................................................................................................000 0........................................................................................................000 -18................. 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 4 4 4 4 5 6 GENERAL DATA COMPUTING METHOD Structural Analysis Stress Analysis Dynamic Analysis 1st Order Analysis 2nd Order Analysis Cable Theory Load Systems LS Groups LS Combinations Design Cases Dynamic Cases Buckling Curves STRUCTURAL DATA PARAMETERS 1D Continuous Beam 2D Construction Type 3D Construction Type Grid 5 1 1 0 0 Nodes Materials Sections Element Hinges Element Partitions 3 0 0 0 0 Elements Cables Tapered Elements Elastic Foundations Sets of Elements NODES Node No CoordinatesSystem 1 2 3 4 5 Ref Nodes Cartesian Supported Cartesian Cartesian Supported Cartesian Cartesian Node Coordinates Y [ft] X [ft] Z [ft] - 0.........................................000 -18......8 359...com ....... Internal Forces by Element ....................................................................................... LS Groups ......................000 10..........dlubal......................000 - 0................................................. Graphic ................................ Software DLUBAL - Part No - Length [ft] 18.......................................... Supports .................... Sections ........................000 40....................................................900E+04 Spec Weight [kip/in3] 1.........................000 -18...........first-order elastic ............................................................ 93464 Tiefenbach www..........................................................................0 0.....Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2...............80000 ELEMENTS Elem No Elem Type 1 2 3 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Beam Beam Beam Nodes Begin End 1 3 2 Section Begin End Beta [°] 2 4 4 0...................1 35..............................000 - 40.............1 E Modulus [ksi] Sec No Mat No 1 1 Section Description A [in2] I2 [in4] W 14x74 796.............. Elements ....................................................................................................................................................................0 0...............................................................................................................................000 0......................................................................... Loads General Data ............de Project: TEST Position: Single Frame P-Delta Page: 1 TEST for RSTAB CONTENTS Contents .............................................................................000 18....................

000 40.000 DX = 10.de Project: TEST Position: Single Frame P-Delta Page: 2 TEST for RSTAB SUPPORTS Support No Rotation [°] Alpha Beta Supported Nodes 1 1.3 Hinged 0.00 40.All vertical loads [kip] Opposite Y-direction 80.000 P Z [kip] 0.dlubal. kipft.000 3. Software DLUBAL www.com .00 Permanent - NODAL FORCES LS 1 Loaded Nodes No 1 Nodal Forces P Y [kip] P X [kip] 2.0 in X 0.dlubal.00 40. 93464 Tiefenbach www. °C.140 ft RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Ing.000 LOADS LS 1 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.000 ELEMENT LOADS Loaded Elements No 1 3 LS 1 Type No Load Direction 2 Z Parameters [kip.000 3 X Z DX = 40.000 10. kipft/ft] A P1 80.4 0. ft.0 Fixed Support/Support Spring [kip/ft] [kipft/rad] in Y in Z ar X ar Y Yes Yes Yes Yes ar Z No Yes GENERAL DATA LS No LS Description 1 Factor All vertical loads Combination Type Dead Weight 1.00 2 3 5 4 W 14x74 2 1 W 14x74 1 W 14x74 DZ = 18. kip/ft.

Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2. Software DLUBAL www.00 Load Systems in LG LS1 Ing.dlubal. 93464 Tiefenbach www.00 1.com .de Project: TEST Position: Single Frame P-Delta Page: 3 TEST for RSTAB LS GROUPS LG No LG Description 1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Second order results Coefficient Gamma M Factor 1.dlubal.

00 .000 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .81 -12.00 28.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .49 73.56 .00 .00 .00 .00 .32 -2894.000 .Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.000 160.00 .98 -12.70 -11.00 .00 .00 M3 .00 .00000 .00 .56 -2767.00 .00 .53 59.000 .56 4432.00 .00 60.000 .dlubal.00 .81 -12.00 .00 -100.00 .00000 .00 .32 2894.813 -12.00 .85 13.00 .00 10.00 .00 18.00 .000 Support Moments [kipin] MY .00 .03417 .00 .00000 .000 .98 -12.00 .00 .00 .00 60.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 2894.00000 uZ .00 59.00 .00 18.00 -20.81 -12.00 10.000 .50 -60.00 .00 18.50 -60.00 -100.00 .000 100.84 4512.00 .00 .000 .68 12.81 -12.00 .00 .00 2767.00 18.00 .00 18.32 .00 .00 18.00000 Ing.00 .00 .00 .00 40.50 -99.00 -100.70 -11.00 -60.00 -20.00 .00 18.50 -60.000 .00 .34 -2894.00 .00 .00 .73 -20.68 60.00 .00 40.50 -60.70 -12.00 .03399 .00 -99.00 .813 12.32 .00 -60.00 .00 .00 .00 -12.00 .00 -60.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .68 13.00 -2651.00 .00 .00 .81 12.00000 1.63 -20.00 2894.85 12.00 .00 .53 Moments [kipin] M2 .00 .000 99.00 40.00 .000 60.00 -100.00 .98 T V3 .000 LG1 MX PZ .84 .00 -60.81 -12.00 .000 160.00 -20.50 -60.00 .00 .56 -2767.34 4512.00 .00 -60.00 .00 .81 -12.00 .000 .98 -12.00 .84 .81 -12.56 -2651.00 -60.00 60.34614 .00 .81 12.00 .00 .00 .00 .000 .00 .00 .000 .00 40.00 60.00 .50 -60.00 .000 .24 4512.81 -12.00 .44 -2767.32 -2651.000 .00 .000 .00 10.00 -60.00 .98 -12.de Project: TEST Position: Single Frame P-Delta Page: 4 TEST for RSTAB 2ND ORDER ANALYSIS DATA LGNo Factor Ny LG1 Eps-Convergence Existing Wanted Number Iterations 1.00 .01 INTERNAL FORCES BY ELEMENT Elem No LS/LG No 1 LS1 LG1 2 LS1 LG1 3 LS1 LG1 Node No x [ft] 1 2 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 1 2 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 3 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 3 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 2 left right 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 2 left right 4 Max N Min N Max V-3 Min V-3 Max M-2 Min M-2 Forces [kip] V2 N .00 .00 .65 59.00 .32 .00000 .11E-02 Ny-fold Results Tension Force Effect Yes Yes 0.00 18.000 2 .00 .56 .00 .56 .00 .81 12.000 MZ .00 .00 .00 .70 -12.00 -100.56 .00 .00 .00 .81 -12.00 .00 .00 .70 59.000 160.00 .98 -12.00 .56 .00 -60.00 .84 .00 .000 GLOBAL ELEMENT DEFORMATIONS Elem No LS/LG No 1 LS1 LG1 RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Node No Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z x [ft] Element Deformations [in] uY uX 18.50 -12.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .980 12.53 -20.00 40.98 -12.81 -12.00 .45 -12.00 .00 10.505 160.00 .50 -99.00 .98 -12.00 .00 .50 -60.00 .00 .00 .000 .00 .000 .81 12.81 -12.81 -12.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .70 -11.00 .70 59.00 .00 .00 .50 -60.84 214.81 13.980 .00 -2651.00 18.00 40.68 13.50 -99.00 .00 .00 .000 .00 .00 .00 .00 .56 -2767.00 10.50 -99.00 .00 18.81 12.00 60.00 -2651.00 10.50 -99.00 .00 .00 .44 4432.00 .00 .00 .45 12.00 .com . Software DLUBAL .00 18.00 .00 .81 -12.00 .00 .68 12.00 1.00 .00 .00 .dlubal.85 13.50 -99.00 .81 -12.00 -2767.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 -100.00 .00 SUPPORT FORCES AND SUPPORT MOMENTS Node No LS/LG No 1 3 ΣLoads ΣForces ΣLoads ΣForces Support Forces [kip] PY PX LS1 LG1 LS1 LG1 LS1 -12.00 18.00 -2767.81 12.00 -2767.00 .81 -12.00 -100.50 -99.00 .000 .000 .43 -2767.63 -20.81 -12.00 .00 .495 60.45 -12.00 .81 -12.51919 .00 -20.00 .00 -100.00 .000 .56 -2767. 93464 Tiefenbach www.37 -20.00 .00 -2767.98 -12.00 .00 .00 .00 .81 -12.34 -2894.56 4432.98 -12.00 .00 2767.00 .00000 www.81 12.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 4.

33641 1.00000 .00000 .00 40.00 -2767.33641 .00000 .00000 .00 . Min M-2: -2767.00 .de Project: TEST Position: Single Frame P-Delta Page: 5 TEST for RSTAB GLOBAL ELEMENT DEFORMATIONS Elem No LS/LG No 2 Node No LS1 Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z Max u-Z Min u-Z LG1 3 LS1 LG1 x [ft] Element Deformations [in] uY uX 18.56 -2767.00 18.56 kipin RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Ing.00000 .00 Z 3280.00 16.com .44 12.00000 1.24739 .00 40.00 100.56 -2767.00000 .00000 .280 kipin 3.043 ft Max M-2: 4432.00000 1.00 16.00 1. 93464 Tiefenbach www.02067 .50934 uZ .00000 .27633 .02050 2.FIRST-ORDER ELASTIC LS 1 .00 40.All vertical loads Internal Forces M-2 Support Reactions Opposite Y-direction 80.02050 .56 4432.44.56 2767.34225 1.02067 RESULTS . Software DLUBAL www.81 X 12.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.00 40.81 60.00000 .50934 .00000 2.dlubal.dlubal.51525 1.

Second order results Internal Forces M-2 Support Reactions Opposite Y-direction -2894.50 3194. Min M-2: -2894. Software DLUBAL www.740 kipin 2.34 12.98 X 12.84 2894.98 60.dlubal.32 -2651.SECOND-ORDER ELASTIC LG 1 .com .de Project: TEST Position: Single Frame P-Delta Page: 6 TEST for RSTAB RESULTS .32 4512.32 kipin RSTAB Spatial Framed Structures Ing.34.84 -2651. 93464 Tiefenbach www.Dlubal Engineering Software Am Zellweg 2.dlubal.51 Z 99.911 ft Max M-2: 4512.