This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?
Pavel V. Nikitin
Intermec Technologies Everett, WA 98203, USA email@example.com
Daniel D. Stancil
North Carolina State University Raleigh, NC 27695, USA firstname.lastname@example.org
Elena A. Erosheva
University of Washington Seattle, WA 98195 email@example.com
Abstract— In this paper, we estimate the number of propagating modes in rectangular and circular multimode waveguides and express it as a closed-form function of excitation frequency and waveguide cross-sectional dimensions. The presented formulas can be used to quickly estimate the number of modes which can propagate in multimode waveguide communication channels such as pipes, ducts, and tunnels. Keywords-waveguides, propagation
In this paper, we derive approximate formulas that can be used to calculate the number of modes in two most practical cases, rectangular and circular waveguides. The number of modes increases quadratically with the frequency. The quadratic coefficient is obtained using regression analysis on numerically computed mode cutoff frequencies. The same approach can theoretically be applied to waveguides of more complicated cross-section shape, such as elliptical. II. RECTANGULAR WAVEGUIDE
In antenna and microwave engineering, waveguides are well known  and are usually carefully designed to support only a small number of selected modes. In the past, for example, special waveguides with a few low loss modes were used for long distance communications [2, 3]. Nowadays there are emerging applications where structures which were not designed to be RF waveguides are now considered as propagation channels and behave as highly overmoded waveguides. Some examples include wireless propagation in tunnels and underground mines [4-6], heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) ducts and lift shafts [7-8], pipeinspecting robots wirelessly communicating through gas, drain, and other pipes [9-12], radio frequency identification (RFID) systems operating inside marine containers , drill pipes [14, 15], and ducts , RF communication systems inside aircraft fuselage [17-18], etc. In such cases, it is often useful to know the number of modes in order to understand the best way to model the channel using analytical methods, ray tracing, or electromagnetic simulation. Some formulas for the number of modes exist for optical fibers  and lasers  and for rectangular cavities used as reverberation chambers [21-22] but to the best of our knowledge none have appeared in literature for waveguides. It is very convenient if the number of modes can be quickly estimated from some formula, especially for circular waveguides where the mathematics is complex because wavenumbers are determined by the zeros of the Bessel functions.
For a rectangular waveguide with cross-sectional dimensions a (wide) and b (narrow), the mode cutoff frequencies of both TE and TM modes are given by the well known formula :
f crect =
c ⎛n⎞ ⎛m⎞ ⎜ ⎟ +⎜ ⎟ , 2 ⎝a⎠ ⎝ b ⎠
where for TE modes either n or m must be positive, and for TM modes both n and m must be positive. Let us first use an empirical approach to estimate the number of modes in rectangular waveguides. We numerically computed the total number of TE and TM modes in a square waveguide (a=b) as a function of normalized frequency for the first 1000 modes. We then carried out a regression analysis to find the best second order polynomial fit to these data. Using maximum likelihood estimates for regression coefficients, we obtain the following equation for predicted total number of modes in square waveguide:
⎛ f ≈ 1.5711⎜ ⎜ f rect ⎝ o
⎞ ⎟ - 0.1942 frect + 0.2077 ⎟ fo ⎠
The comparison between the exact number of modes in a square waveguide and the first term in formula (2) is given in Fig. 1. Note from Fig. 1 that formula (2) works very well even for small numbers of modes.
Figure 2. For example. In (3). For any excitation frequency f. etc. f c . the validity of regression approach was confirmed for rectangular waveguides with various aspect ratios (2:1. The quadratic coefficient in (3) confirms the validity of regression approach used to obtain (2) for large number of modes. in heavily multimoded case the total number of modes in rectangular waveguide can be approximately calculated as one quarter of the area of the ellipse times two (to account for both TE and TM modes): N rect ≈ where f πb⎛ ⎜ rect 2a ⎜ ⎝ fo ⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠ 2 . (3) fo rect = c /( 2a ) is the lowest cutoff frequency (mode TE10). One can recognize in (1) an equation for the ellipse with respect to mode indices n and m. This renders impossible an analytical derivation of the total number of modes vs. (4) where ' pnm and p nm are the m-th nulls of J n ( x ) and ' J n ( x ) . frequency in circular waveguides. It turns out that for rectangular waveguide an analytical solution for the number of modes is possible. it is known that the successive roots of the Bessel function J n ( x) are spaced ' n π apart at infinity (this also applies to its first derivative J ( x ) ). 2. which means that their For a circular waveguide of radius R. where J n ( x ) is the Bessel function of the first kind of order n .). The mathematics of Bessel functions is complicated and an analytical solution for the number of modes is not possible even though some asymptotic approximations for Bessel functions and their roots are available . and for TM modes both n and m must be positive which would add a first-order term to (3). . m ≥ 1 . Comparison between the exact number of modes in square waveguide and the first term of approximation given by (2) as a function of normalized frequency. TM mode indices must belong to the upper right quarter of this ellipse as shown in Fig.m) coordinate system. 3:1. CIRCULAR WAVEGUIDE f crect ≤ f ). All quadratic coefficients obtained via regression for various waveguide aspect ratios agreed with the coefficient in equation (3). we neglected the fact that for TE modes either n or m must be positive. Calculating the number of modes in rectangular waveguide as number of points inside quarter ellipse in (n. the spacing between the same (m-th) roots of the Bessel functions of successive orders n is irregular. the mode cutoff frequencies are given by another well known formula: circ ' c ⎧ p nm . TE = ⎨ 2π R ⎩ p nm .1100 1000 900 800 Number of modes 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 f/fo Square waveguide Exact number of modes N=1. at least in the same clear and straightforward way as for rectangular waveguides. only the modes whose cutoff frequencies are below the excitation frequency are excited ( In the similar way. Figure 1. However. f >> f o rect and b=a.57*(f/fo)^2 Hence. III. For both TE and TM modes the indices must satisfy: n ≥ 0.
Figure 3.g. For ellipticity ratio of 1.8507 ⎜ ⎜ f circ ⎝ o ⎞ ⎟ + 0. choosing which shape and size waveguide should be used for multimode communications. Comparison between the exact number of modes in circular waveguide and the approximation given by (6) as a function of normalized frequency.0. Note that circular waveguides do not have any other crosssection characteristic except for radius (unlike rectangular or elliptical waveguides which can have different aspect and ellipticity ratios). Figure 4.) in diameter. let us consider two types of hollow metal HVAC ducts: rectangular and circular. which are even more complex than Bessel functions. ⎟ fo ⎠ 2 (5) N rect ab ≈ 0. similar to the dependence given by (3). In the United States. The 12 in. 4. or 12 in. To give readers some idea about the practical accuracy of our formulas given by equations (3) and (6). However.5 cm. 1100 1000 900 Number of modes 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 0 4 8 12 16 20 f/fo 24 28 32 36 Circular waveguide Exact number of modes N=0. Hollow circular (cylindrical) metal HVAC duct 30.85. 3 that formula (6) works very well even for small number of modes..85 ⎜ (6) ⎜ f circ ⎟ ⎝ o ⎠ circ for a large number of modes ( f >> f o ). The comparison between the exact number of modes in circular waveguide and (6) is given in Fig. commonly used in buildings in the United States. one of the common rectangular duct sizes is 40 cm x 20 cm (the cutoff frequency is 375 MHz) and one of the common circular duct diameters is 30. we can approximate the total number of modes in circular waveguide as ⎛ f ⎞ ⎟ N circ ≈ 0. Thus. such as elliptical where cutoff frequencies are determined by roots of Mathieu functions. . and hence there can be only one formula for the number of modes which is already given by (6). Note from Fig. We know that the number of modes in a waveguide must increase quadratically with frequency. the regression analysis for elliptical waveguides would have to be repeated for different ellipticity ratios because quadratic coefficient in the expected mode formula will depend on the ellpiticity ratio. one can also easily find an approximation to the ratio between the total number of modes in rectangular and circular waveguides: N circ ⎛ f ≈ 0.85*(f/fo)^2 2 The same empirical regression-based approach that we described in this paper can theoretically be applied to waveguides of more complicated cross-section shapes. and analytical solution is not possible.3048 . 3.841 c /( 2π R ) is the lowest cutoff frequency of the circular waveguide (mode TE11). (7) where fo circ = 1. the same as in equation (6). We computed the total number of TE and TM modes in circular waveguide numerically as a function of normalized frequency for the first 1000 modes and performed analogous maximum likelihood regression analysis to find the best second order polynomial fit to these data: DISCUSSION Formulas (3) and (6) work well for both small and large numbers of modes and can help an engineer to analyze tradeoffs when. Using equation (5).IV. From (3) and (6).4799 fcirc . the coefficient is expected to be 0.63 2 N circ R . e. (the cutoff frequency is 577 MHz). cylindrical duct is shown in Fig. we use again an empirical approach to estimate the number of modes in circular waveguides.5 cm (12 in.
K. Journal of Optical Society of America. no. Harrington. vol. and D. Proceedings of the IEEE. International Symposium on Micromechatronics and Human Science. 3. pp. Crawford. 2004 J. no. no. 1985 D. 3. Sato. Henty. K. D. 294299. Fuchs.4 GHz 5. pp. Schempf. M. 39 . F. Altunbas. H. Stancil. 2009. 8. E.-G. G. New York. 51. M. Hill. 1661-1663. vol. 1991 . 2003. and V. 5. Sun. D. “Wireless signal transmission through non-metallic pipes with transmission gain”. O. 1909-1916.Tables 1 and 2 below give the number of modes that can propagate in those ducts at three frequencies which represent most of the current practical ISM bands: 900 MHz. Goltsberg. D. Blau. 2. Yee Hui Lee. no. 8.-P. Laniel. Stancil. no. 2004. 208 – 211 P. 2003. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters. REFERENCES       R. Harutyunyan. “Wireless propagation in tunnels”. Kai Chang. 57 – 62 M.[ Proc. Mahmoud. 3. BLow-loss waveguide transmission. 41. NY. Tonguz. Fontana. Kawahara. ducts. Mutschler. 11 – 26      P. Yichun Yeh. vol. Tsuruta. Snyder. D. Unger. “Long Range Passive UHF RFID System using HVAC Ducts”. Lienard. M. “Channel modeling and analysis for wireless networks in underground mines and road tunnels”. vol. vol. Degauque. 1. and D. New York. Stancil. IEEE Transactions on Communications. E. pp. and E. vol. E. "Circular Waveguide System for Trunk Communications" IEEE Transactions on Communications. Schnitger. vol. K. Mitchell. no. P. “Characterization of passive UHF RFID tags in toroidal metal pipes”. ”Integrated antenna system for wireless RFID tag in monitoring oil drill pipe”. An ability to quickly estimate the number of modes which can propagate in multimode waveguides is important for understanding and optimizing the properties of waveguide communication channels such as pipes. I. and Mathematical Tables”. ICCASSICE. 348–358. 3440. DIAMETER DUCT Frequency 900 MHz 2. Boon Chong Ng.2 N. “Number of modes in optical waveguides”. Arumugam. G. 945-951. F. IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Magazine. “Gas main robotic inspection system”. T. vol. 58 . V. Akyildiz. Hein. European Microwave Conference. “Propagation model for the HVAC duct as a communication channel”. 2010. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Magazine. “RFID behavior study in enclosed marine container for real time temperature tracking”. pp. V. 20. 2008 C. J. we estimated the number of propagating modes in rectangular and circular multimode waveguides and expressed it as a closed-form function of excitation frequency and waveguide cross-sectional dimensions. no. pp.8 GHz Exact 5 33 186 Estimated 5 32 188  TABLE II. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium. “Eigenfrequencies of a truncated conical resonator via the classical and Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin methods”. M. Mitumoto. “EM propagation in tunnel”.4 GHz 5. May 2003 Xiao Hong Mao. E. Sensing and Instrumentation for Food Quality and Safety. “Ultra wideband technology for aircraft wireless intercommunications systems (AWICS) design”. no. Stegun. The exact number of modes was calculated from the numerically computed table of all modes. 9. Shibata. C. 3667 – 3671 G.1377 Z. Nikitin. ”A review of electromagnetic compatibility/interference measurement methodologies”. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation. D. 56. no. Emond. Hirai. Dover Publications. Larsen. 1975 L. no. 3. 2005 Dongmei Wu. W. N. A. Chabalko. Abramowitz and I. Engels. pp. 3. pp. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation. 65. Miller and A. vol. T. 58 . NUMBER OF MODES IN CIRCULAR 12 IN. Arumugam. 1965 . Brodtkorb.73.4 GHz. pp. “How many longitudinal modes can oscillate in a quantum-dot laser: an analytical estimate”. pp. n. or tunnels. 356-357. E. vol. Beck.8 GHz Exact 2 17 91 Estimated 2 15 86     The difference between the exact and the estimated number of modes decreases as the number of modes increases and becomes less than 1% when the number of modes approaches 1000. 22. 2008 M. S. P. vol. D. Xhafa. Dudley. 36. 1629-1635. and the estimated number of modes was calculated using our simple approximate formulas given by equations (3) and (6). IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation. Ogai. vol. pp. A. Oct. no. Cepni. 2007 . 1758 – 1768 P. 388-411. Pask. 2009 B. R. pp. pp. and 5. 19. pp. McGrawHill. vol. Ameti. knight. NUMBER OF MODES IN RECTANGULAR 40 CM X 20 CM DUCT       Frequency 900 MHz 2. IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility. 7. 2. and D. 1994 M. 1961 S. TABLE I. Nikitin. no. D. “Drain pipe inspection robot using wireless communication system”. pp. 2009. Graphs. M. “Handbook of Mathematical Functions: with Formulas. pp. A.8 GHz. vol. Abe. US Patent 6917176. “Propagation Modes and Temporal Variations Along a Lift Shaft in UHF Band”. Strassner. 401 – 406 D. vol. Asryan. A. 743 – 746. 1374 . NY. 14-18. Kanda. K. Delogne. 98. no. September 2010 A. Mar. Sep 1974. 6 2010 . Ma. pp. Jiang and L. “Time-Harmonic Electromagnetic Fields”. Richley. 9. H. CONCLUSIONS  In this paper. We hope that the analysis and the formulas presented in this paper will be useful for the propagation community. 2001. pp. 49 . B. pp. G. 4. D. pp. D. “Wireless link system for communication and energy transmission of microrobot “. vol. Van’t Hof and D. 195 H. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. V. IRE. “Electronic mode stirring for reverberation chambers”. 2700 – 2709 H. and E. Proceedings of the IEEE. G.
This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?
We've moved you to where you read on your other device.
Get the full title to continue reading from where you left off, or restart the preview.