You are on page 1of 21

11.

String Telephone
Matthias Mller German Team

11. String Telephone p. 1/21

Task
How do the intensity of sound, transmitted along a string telephone, and the quality of communication between the transmitter and receiver depend upon the distance, tension in the line and other parameters? Design an optimal system.

11. String Telephone p. 2/21

Overview

Eperimental Set-up Theory Quality and Intensity Losses in Different Parts of the Telephone Transmission into String and Out of it Damping and Dispersion in String Parametric Optimiziation Materials, Dimensions Experimental Conrmation

11. String Telephone p. 3/21

Properties of Optimal System

High quality of communication low dispersion low frequency-dependence of transmitted intensity (no resonance in speaking range) Only of secondary importance: transmitted power as high as possible

11. String Telephone p. 4/21

Shape of Horns

Horns with no resonance within range Exponential horns (no reection no resonance) Short cans Eigenfrequency above 1000 Hz for length smaller 5 cm

11. String Telephone p. 5/21

Experimental Set-up
transmitter
membrane Itrans can string x can Irec

receiver

3 important parts:

Transmission from can into string Damping and dispersion in the string Transmission from string to can
11. String Telephone p. 6/21

Experimental Set-up

11. String Telephone p. 7/21

Intensity of Sound Wave


2 P =1 cA v 2

Abbreviation: Z c, Z ZA
2 Power: P = 1 Z v 2

Intensity: I =

P A

2 =1 Z v 2

11. String Telephone p. 8/21

Transmission through Membrane


Transmission of wave from one media through membrane into other media. Ptrans = mb (Pinc Pre ) vtrans = vmb = vinc vre
2 Remember P = 1 Z v 2 Therefore 2 4mb Ztrans Zinc Ptrans = )2 Pinc (Ztrans + mb Zinc

11. String Telephone p. 9/21

Oscillation of Membrane
transmitter-Membrane Equation of motion for small piece of membrane: z 2z kr 2b (F0 + Dz ) = p(t) 2 + Za + T z + e t t r z (r,,t) T F0 + Dz p(t) Radial Coordinate of membrane Elongation Tension of membrane Force excerted by string Incoming wave

11. String Telephone p. 10/21

Identities of Good Membrane


Good quality for high resonance frequencies High frequencies for low mass, high tension, stiffness Membrane should be stiff Tension in membrane increases with tension in thread

11. String Telephone p. 11/21

Optimization of Membrane
Input: White Noise; tension: 30 N, 40 N, length: 8.5 m
relative intensity

high tension low tension

f [Hz]

200

400

600

800

1000
11. String Telephone p. 12/21

Noise without Rush


relative intensity

f [Hz]

200

400

600

800

1000

11. String Telephone p. 13/21

Good Membran
Input: White Noise; tension: 40 N, length: 4.5 m
relative intensity

f [Hz]

200

400

600

800

1000

11. String Telephone p. 14/21

Minimizing of String-Damping

High tension, thin string to eliminate bends in string Intensity of damped wave: I = I0 e2 L

= 0 calculated by thermal losses rubber aluminium iron titanium 0 [106 s/m] 110 11 8.2 5.4

11. String Telephone p. 15/21

Dispersion in String

Dispersion if phase velocity c depends on frequency Occurs due to damping:

pressure wave: p = p e(tx)


c

= | ( )| = | + 0 |

Low damping low dispersion

11. String Telephone p. 16/21

Measurement of Dispersion
3
travelling time [ms]

2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5


f [Hz]

200

400

600

800

1000

11. String Telephone p. 17/21

Overall Transmission
Irec 1 Ptrans Acyl 4mb Amb Zcyl Astr Zstr
2

e20 L

Acyl should be small Amb should be large problem as Amb at end of can with Acyl

11. String Telephone p. 18/21

Pressure Chamber
Acyl

Amb

Effect of pressure chamber:

Larger Amb better transmission from can to string Lower Acyl

intensity I =

P A

highest at opening
11. String Telephone p. 19/21

New Overall Transmission


Including reection can pressure chamber Amb n Acyl 2 n3 16mb Zcyl 20 L Irec Ptrans Amb e Astr Zstr (n + 1)4 High receiver-intensity for:

Large crossectional area of membrane Maximum for n = 3, so Acyl = 1 3 Amb Small wave impedance Astr Zstr of the string Low damping in the string
11. String Telephone p. 20/21

Optimal System

System with pressure chamber diameter of membrane e.g. 15 cm diameter of can about 8.7 cm Membrane of stiff material, high tension in it String of suitable metal (aluminium, titanium,. . . ) Thin string with high tension (for no bends) Damping and dispersion increases with length

11. String Telephone p. 21/21