You are on page 1of 13

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON RATES QUOTED BY CONTRACTOR AND RATE IN SCHEDULE OF RATES (CONTRACT DOCUMENT)

301R WEST ENTRANCE LANDSCAPE SL# SECTION No. ITEM DESCRIPTION COMMENTS AMOUNT QUOTED BY THE CONTRACTOR REVISED RATE REVISED AMOUNT DIFFERENCE (AMOUNT) REMARKS

1 2 3

1.1. 2.1 3.1 TO 3.3 3.4 TO 3.7

Mobilization Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Man power

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

20,000 15,000 150,000 37,179 65,000 100,000

Lump sum Lump sum Lump sum As per SOR Lump sum 1 % of total amount

15,000 10,000 100,000 37,179 20,000 61,924

5,000 5,000 50,000 0 45,000 38,076 0

4 5 6

4.1 5.1

Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site

6.1

Project Manager

Rate not shown in SOR

4,200

420/DAY

4,200

Fair rate

6.2

Surveying Engineer

Correct

11,200

280/DAY

5,600

5,600

6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.1 6.11 6.12 6.13

Irrigation Engineer Agriculture Engineer Civil Engineer Mechanical Engineer Electrical Engineer Technician Foreman Welder Driver / Operater Pipe Fitter Labour Equipment

Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted Correct Wrong rate is quoted 200 / day Wrong rate quoted 110 /day Rate not shown in SOR Correct

11,200 12,600 8,400 2,800 2,800 16,000 16,000 5,000 43,200 8,000 99,000

280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY 120 / DAY 120 / DAY 120 / DAY 80 / DAY

11,200 11,200 4,200 1,400 1,400 16,000 16,000 1,200 27,000 3,600 72,000

0 1,400 4,200 1,400 1,400 0 0 3,800 16,200 4,400 27,000 0

Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. 3 new works and contractor gave separate surveying engineer for 3 projects- it is not corect only one SE for 3 site is enough.Please refer section 7-Area Contractor provided rate is wrong. They quoted the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. They quoted the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. They quoted the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. They quoted the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. They quoted the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Same rates Contractor given daily rate is 200 per day is fair Actual rate in SOR is 15 Dirham Per hour, so daily rate is 120 Actual rate in SOR is 15 Dirham Per hour, so daily rate is 120 110 per day is for skilled labourer, correct rate is 80 per day No need to give separate amount for this item, because mobilization and miscellaneous items will cover this item Identical rates

7
7.1 7.2

Surveying Equipment Pick - up

31,200 18,000

0 200 / DAY

0 18,000

31,200 0

7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7

8
8.1 to 8.8 8.9to 8.11 8.12 to 8.16 8.17 to 8.20 8.21 8.22 to 8.27 8.28to 8.38 8.39 8.40 to 8.51

JCB Bob-Cat Compressor Dumper Crane Materials Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Flushing polnts Pumping Systems Distribution system Distribution system

Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Most rates are matching Most rates are not matching Rates of most items not shown in SOR Rates of most items not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rates are not shown in SOR Most rates are not matching Rate not shown in SOR

24,000 19,200 9,600 16,800 59,200 1,272,704 106,160 586,590 114,700 20,160 27,556 364,983 800,000 3,174,490

800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY 1480 / DAY Multi-rates Multi-rates Multi-rates Multi-rates 0 Multi-rates Multi-rates Multi-rates 0

12,000 19,200 6,400 16,800 14,800 1,272,704 106,160 586,590 114,700 20,160 27,556 227,927 400,000 3,174,490

12,000 0 3,200 0 44,400 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 137,056 400,000 0

Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items

TOTAL

7,272,922

6,436,590

836,332

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON RATES QUOTED BY CONTRACTOR AND RATE IN SCHEDULE OF RATES (CONTRACT DOCUMENT)
CONTRACT No.301R 301R EAST ENTRANCE LANDSCAPE SL# SECTION No. ITEM DESCRIPTION COMMENTS AMOUNT QUOTED BY THE CONTRACTOR REVISED RATE REVISED AMOUNT DIFFERENCE (AMOUNT) REMARKS

1 2 3

1.1. 2.2 3.1 TO 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7

Mobilization Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Man power

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Correct Correct Correct Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

20,000 15,000 250,000 27,840 4,597 66,650 15,710 75,000 125,000

Lump sum Lump sum Lump sum As per SOR As per SOR As per SOR As per SOR Lump sum 1 % of total amount

20,000 15,000 250,000 27,840 4,597 66,650 15,710 25,000 98,694

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 50,000 26,306 0

4 5 6

4.1 5.1

Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Pit size noted by contractor is wrong, to be 075 x 0.75 x 0.75 m. Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site

6.1

Project Manager

Rate not shown in SOR

4,200

420/DAY

4,200

Fair rate

6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.1 6.11 6.12 6.13

Surveying Engineer Irrigation Engineer Agriculture Engineer Civil Engineer Mechanical Engineer Electrical Engineer Technician Foreman Welder Driver / Operater Pipe Fitter Labour Equipment

Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted Correct Wrong rate is quoted 200 / day Wrong rate quoted - 110 /day Rate not shown in SOR Correct

11,200 11,200 12,600 8,400 2,800 2,800 16,000 16,000 5,000 43,200 8,000 123,750

280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY 120 / DAY 120 / DAY 120 / DAY 80 / DAY

5,600 11,200 12,600 4,200 1,400 1,400 16,000 16,000 1,200 27,000 3,600 72,000

5,600 0 0 4,200 1,400 1,400 0 0 3,800 16,200 4,400 51,750 0

SOR rate SOR rate SOR rate SOR rate SOR rate SOR rate SOR rate Fair rate Actual rate in SOR is 15 Dirham Per hour, so daily rate is 120 SOR rate Actual rate in SOR is 15 Dirham Per hour, so daily rate is 120 110 per day is for skilled labourer, correct rate is 80 per day No need to give separate amount for this item, because mobilization will cover this item Identical rates

7
7.1 7.2

Surveying Equipment Pick - up

31,200 18,000

0 200 / DAY

0 18,000

31,200 0

7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7

8
8.1 to 8.9 8.10 to 8.12 8.13 to 8.22 8.23 to 8.26 8.27 8.25 (A) 8.26 to 8.31 8.32 to 8.42 8.43 8.44 to 8.55

JCB Bob-Cat Compressor Dumper Crane Materials Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Flushing polnts Pumping Systems Distribution system Distribution system Drainage system

Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct Most rates are matching Most rates are not matching Rates of most items not shown in SOR Rates of most items not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rates are not shown in SOR Most rates are not matching Rate not shown in SOR Most rates are not matching

24,000 19,200 9,600 16,800 59,200 3,513,189 23,282 510,880 57,744 51,200 82,080 33,748 693,290 800,000 4,359,820

800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY 1480 / DAY Multi-rates Multi-rates Multi-rates Multi-rates 0 Multi-rates Multi-rates Multi-rates 0 Multi-rates

12,000 19,200 6,400 16,800 59,200 3,513,189 23,282 510,880 57,744 51,200 82,080 33,748 529,467 400,000 4,359,820

12,000 0 3,200 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 163,823 400,000 0

Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items For most items need quotation, because SOR doesnt cover most items

TOTAL

11,168,180

10,392,902

775,279

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON RATES QUOTED BY CONTRACTOR

CONTRA 304 NEW RESERVOIRS (3 Nos.) 0.5 Million Gallon Capacity SL SECTION # No. ITEM DESCRIPTION COMMENTS AMOUNT QUOTED BY REVISED RATE THE CONTRACTOR 301R NEW RESERVOIR 0.1 Million Gallon Capacity AMOUNT QUOTED BY THE CONTRACTO R

300 & 307 N

REVISED AMOUNT

DIFFERENCE (AMOUNT)

COMMENTS

REVISED RATE

REVISED AMOUNT

DIFFERENCE (AMOUNT)

COMMENTS

1.1.

Mobilization

Rate not shown in SOR

90,000

10 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

41,810

48,190

Rate not shown in SOR

20,000

10 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

12,387

7,613

Rate not shown in SOR

2.1 to 2.3 Ground Preparation

Rate not shown in SOR

150,000

10 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

41,810

108,190

Rate not shown in SOR

40,000

10 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

12,387

27,613

Rate not shown in SOR

2.4

Excavation of tree pits

Correct

9,666

Same SOR rate 5 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

9,666

1,824

Same SOR rate 5 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

1,824

Testing Rate not shown Commissioning and in SOR after care

96,000

20,905

75,095

Rate not shown in SOR

25,000

6,194

18,806

Rate not shown in SOR

Miscellaneous works

Rate not shown in SOR

96,000

2 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

8,362

87,638

Rate not shown in SOR

25,000

2 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

2,477

22,523

Rate not shown in SOR

Man power

Project Manager

Rate not shown in SOR

5,400

600/DAY

1,800

3,600

Rate not shown in SOR

1,800

600/DAY

600

1,200

Separate Rate not available in SOR

Surveying Engineer

Rate not shown in SOR

8,400

280/DAY

1,960

6,440

Rate not shown in SOR

2,800

280/DAY

653

2,147

Separate Rate not available in SOR

Irrigation Engineer

Rate not shown in SOR

16,800

280/DAY

3,920

12,880

Rate not shown in SOR

5,600

280/DAY

3,920

1,680

Separate Rate not available in SOR

Agriculture Engineer Civil Engineer Mechanical Engineer Electrical Engineer Technician Foreman

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Correct Separate Rate not available in SOR Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted - 200 / day Wrong rate quoted - 110 /day

16,800

280/DAY

3,920

12,880

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Correct Separate Rate not available in SOR Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted - 200 / day Wrong rate quoted 110 /day

5,600

280/DAY

3,920

1,680

Separate Rate not available in SOR Separate Rate not available in SOR Separate Rate not available in SOR Separate Rate not available in SOR Correct Separate Rate not available in SOR Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted - 200 / day Wrong rate quoted 110 /day

8,400

280/DAY

1,960

6,440

2,800

280/DAY

1,960

840

8,400

280/DAY

1,960

6,440

2,800

280/DAY

1,960

840

7 8 9

8,400 8,400 16,800

280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY

1,960 8,400 8,400

6,440 0 8,400

2,800 2,800 5,600

280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY

1,960 2,800 2,800

840 0 2,800

10 11

Welder Pipe Fitter

4,200 4,200

120 / DAY 120 / DAY

720 2,520

3,480 1,680

1,400 1,400

120 / DAY 120 / DAY

240 840

1,160 560

12

Labour Equipment

46,200

80 / DAY

33,600

12,600

15,400

80 / DAY

11,200

4,200 0

6
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Surveying Equipment Pick - up JCB Bob-Cat Compressor Dumper Crane Material Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate Refer Estimate

Rate not shown in SOR Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct

8,190 16,800 24,000 26,850 13,440 11,760 0 56,385 95,400 23,850 1,889 1,512 390

0 200 / DAY 800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY

0 8,400 12,000 13,440 960 11,760

8,190 8,400 12,000 13,410 12,480 0 0 0 16,110 0 0 0 0 0

Rate not shown in SOR Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct

2,730 5,600 8,000 8,960 4,480 3,920

0 200 / DAY 800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY

0 2,800 4,000 4,480 320 3,920

2,730 2,800 4,000 4,480 4,160 0 0 0 3,040 0 0 226 350 0

Rate not shown in SOR Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct

7
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6

Incorrect rate quoted Correct Correct Rate not shown in SOR Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

25 / m3 200 / no 50 / no 360 / Ton 7/m 13 / no

40,275 95,400 23,850 1,889 1,512 390

Incorrect rate quoted Correct Correct Rate not shown in SOR Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

10,640 18,000 4,500 356 420 130

25 / m3 200 / no 50 / no 360 / Ton 7/m 13 / no

7,600 18,000 4,500 130 70 130

Incorrect rate quoted Correct Correct Rate not shown in SOR Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

7.7

Refer Estimate

216

6 / no

216

60

6 / no

60

7.8

Refer Estimate

495

165 / no

495

165

165 / no

165

7.9

Refer Estimate

7,560

360 / no

7,560

2,520

360 / no

2,520

7.10

Refer Estimate

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

12,000

4000 / no

12,000

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

4,000

4000 / no

4,000

Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

7.11 7.12 to 7.21 7.22

Refer Estimate

1,656

23 / m

1,656

552

23 / m

552

Refer Estimate

68,369

Fair rates

68,369

22,164

Fair rates

22,164

Refer Estimate

4,065

1355 / no

4,065

1,222

1355 / no

1,355

-133

7.23

Refer Estimate

42,750

14250 / no

42,750

14,250

14250 / no

14,250

TOTAL

1,011,643

540,660

470,983

275,293

159,138

116,155

D BY CONTRACTOR AND RATE IN SCHEDULE OF RATES (CONTRACT DOCUMENT)


CONTRACT No. 300 & 307 NEW RESERVOIRS (0.5M. X 6) AMOUNT QUOTED BY THE CONTRACTOR 307 NEW RESERVOIRS (0.25M. X 1) 307 NEW RESERVOIRS (0.1M. X 1) AMOUNT DIFFEREN QUOTED COMMENT CE BY THE S (AMOUNT) CONTRACT OR

REVISED RATE

REVISED AMOUNT

DIFFERENC E (AMOUNT)

COMMENTS

AMOUNT QUOTED BY THE REVISED RATE CONTRACTOR

REVISED AMOUNT

REVISED RATE

REVISED AMOUNT

DIFFERENCE (AMOUNT)

180,000

10 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

86,905

93,095

Rate not shown in SOR

28,000

12 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

17,253

10,747

Rate not shown in SOR

26,000

12 % of total amount(Excl uding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

14,504

11,496

300,000

10 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

86,905

213,095

Rate not shown in SOR

45,000

10 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

14,378

30,622

Rate not shown in SOR

40,000

10 % of total amount(Excl uding amount of SL # 1 to 4) Same SOR rate 5 % of total amount(Excl uding amount of SL # 1 to 4) 2 % of total amount(Excl uding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

12,087

27,913

19,332

Same SOR rate 5 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

19,332

2,982

Same SOR rate 5 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

2,982

1,824

1,824

192,000

43,453

148,547

Rate not shown in SOR

28,000

7,189

20,811

Rate not shown in SOR

25,000

6,044

18,957

192,000

2 % of total amount(Excluding amount of SL # 1 to 4)

17,381

174,619

Rate not shown in SOR

28,000

2 % of total amount(Excludin g amount of SL # 1 to 4)

2,876

25,124

Rate not shown in SOR

25,000

2,417

22,583

0 Rate not shown in SOR

10,800

600/DAY

5,400

5,400

Separate Rate not available in SOR

1,800

600/DAY

1,800

1,800

600/DAY

1,800

16,800

280/DAY

3,360

13,440

Separate Rate not available in SOR

2,800

280/DAY

653

2,147

Rate not shown in SOR

2,800

280/DAY

653

2,147

33,600

280/DAY

23,520

10,080

Separate Rate not available in SOR

5,600

280/DAY

3,920

1,680

Rate not shown in SOR

5,600

280/DAY

3,920

1,680

33,600

280/DAY

23,520

10,080

Separate Rate not available in SOR Separate Rate not available in SOR Separate Rate not available in SOR Separate Rate not available in SOR Correct Separate Rate not available in SOR Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted - 200 / day Wrong rate quoted - 110 /day

5,600

280/DAY

3,920

1,680

16,800

280/DAY

3,360

13,440

2,800

280/DAY

560

2,240

16,800

280/DAY

3,360

13,440

2,800

280/DAY

560

2,240

16,800 16,800 33,600

280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY

3,360 16,800 16,800

13,440 0 16,800

2,800 2,800 5,600

280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY

560 2,800 2,800

2,240 0 2,800

8,400 8,400

120 / DAY 120 / DAY

1,440 5,040

6,960 3,360

1,400 1,400

120 / DAY 120 / DAY

240 840

1,160 560

92,400

80 / DAY

67,200

25,200 0

15,400

80 / DAY

11,200

4,200 0

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Correct Separate Rate not available in SOR Wrong rate is quoted Wrong rate is quoted 200 / day Wrong rate quoted - 110 /day Rate not shown in SOR Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct

5,600

280/DAY

3,920

1,680

2,800

280/DAY

560

2,240

2,800

280/DAY

560

2,240

2,800 2,800 5,600

280/DAY 200/ DAY 200 / DAY

560 2,800 2,800

2,240 0 2,800

1,400 1,400

120 / DAY 120 / DAY

240 840

1,160 560

15,400

80 / DAY

11,200

4,200 0

16,380 33,600 48,000 53,760 26,880 23,520

0 200 / DAY 800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY

0 16,800 24,000 26,880 3,840 23,520

16,380 16,800 24,000 26,880 23,040 0 0 0 32,220 0 0 0 0 0

Rate not shown in SOR Correct Correct Correct Correct Correct

2,730 5,600 8,000 8,960 4,480 3,920

0 200 / DAY 800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY

0 2,800 4,000 4,480 320 3,920

2,730 2,800 4,000 4,480 4,160 0 0 0 4,970 0 0 0 0 0

2,730 5,600 8,000 8,960 4,480 3,920

0 200 / DAY 800 / DAY 640 / DAY 320 / DAY 280 / DAY

0 2,800 4,000 4,480 320 3,920

2,730 2,800 4,000 4,480 4,160 0 0 0 3,040 0 0 226 350 0

112,770 190,800 47,700 3,778 3,024 780

25 / m3 200 / no 50 / no 360 / Ton 7/m 13 / no

80,550 190,800 47,700 3,778 3,024 780

Incorrect rate quoted Correct Correct Rate not shown in SOR Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

17,395 29,400 7,350 582 455 130

25 / m3 200 / no 50 / no 360 / Ton 7/m 13 / no

12,425 29,400 7,350 582 455 130

432

6 / no

432

72

6 / no

72

990

165 / no

990

165

165 / no

165

15,120

360 / no

15,120

2,520

360 / no

2,520

Incorrect rate quoted Correct Correct Rate not shown in SOR Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

10,640 18,000 4,500 356 420 130

25 / m3 200 / no 50 / no 360 / Ton 7/m 13 / no

7,600 18,000 4,500 130 70 130

60

6 / no

60

165

165 / no

165

2,520

360 / no

2,520

24,000

4000 / no

24,000

Correct Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

4,000

4000 / no

4,000

3,312

23 / m

3,312

552

23 / m

552

136,739

Fair rates

136,739

22,424

Fair rates

22,164

260

8,130

1355 / no

8,130

1,222

1355 / no

1,355

-133

85,500

14250 / no

85,500

14,250

14250 / no

14,250

Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR Rate not shown in SOR

4,000

4000 / no

4,000

552

23 / m

552

22,164

Fair rates

22,164

1,222

1355 / no

1,355

-133

14,250

14250 / no

14,250

2,023,347

1,123,031

900,316

316,989

185,471 131,517

281,293

157,745

123,549

REMARKS

Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site

Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site

Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site

Lump Sum Provision. To judge and estimate the rate required to see the site

Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. 3 new works and contractor gave separate Project Manager for 3 projects- it is not corect only one PM for 3 site is enough Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. 3 new works and contractor gave separate surveying engineer for 3 projects- it is not corect only one SE for 3 site is enough.Please refer section 7-Area 2 part 7 to part 9 page 55 /55 of contract document 3 of 3 Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation.

Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Contractor provided rate is wrong. It is the deduction rate by PGD in case of contractual obligation. Same rates Contractor given daily rate is 200 per day is fair Actual rate in SOR is 15 Dirham Per hour, so daily rate is 120 Actual rate in SOR is 15 Dirham Per hour, so daily rate is 120 110 per day is for skilled labourer, correct rate is 80 per day No need to give separate amount for this item, because mobilization will cover this item Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates Identical rates

35 per m3 quoted to be changed as 25 per m3 as per SOR Correct Correct Fair rate Identical rates Fair rate

Fair rate Material of item to be specified, if it is brass the rate is Unfair No proper description is given regarding quantity of material (length of pipe).

Identical rates

Fair rate

Fair rate

Fair rate

Unfair rate