You are on page 1of 9

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

ALEX IS THE BEST, LLC, Plaintiff, v. BOOST MOBILE LLC Defendants.

C.A. No. ___________________ TRIAL BY JURY DEMANDED

COMPLAINT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT Plaintiff Ale is t!e Best, LLC. "#AITB$), %& and t!'o()! its (nde'si)ned *o(nsel, %'in)s t!is a*tion a)ainst Boost Mo%ile LLC, "#Boost Mo%ile$ and+o' #Defendant$). In s(,,o't of t!is Co-,laint, AITB alle)es as follo.s/ NATURE OF THE SUIT 0. T!is is an a*tion fo' ,atent inf'in)e-ent (nde' t!e Patent La.s of t!e 1nited

States of A-e'i*a, 23 1.S.C. 44 0 et seq., in*l(din) 23 1.S.C. 4 560. THE PARTIES 5. Plaintiff AITB is a li-ited lia%ilit& *o-,an& o')ani7ed (nde' t!e la.s of t!e state

of Ne. 8o'9 .it! its ,'in*i,al ,la*e of %(siness at 63 :5nd St., B'oo9l&n, Ne. 8o'9 005;<. 2. On info'-ation and %elief, Boost Mo%ile is a *o-,an& o')ani7ed (nde' t!e la.s

of t!e state of Dela.a'e .it! its ,'in*i,al ,la*e of %(siness at =5;; S,'int Pa'9.a&, Ove'land Pa'9, >ansas, ==500. Boost Mo%ile *an %e se'ved .it! ,'o*ess t!'o()! its a)ent T!e Co',o'ation Se'vi*e Co-,an&, 5600 Cente'ville ?d, S(ite @;;, Ail-in)ton, Dela.a'e 0<:;:.

@.

Defendant is in t!e %(siness of -a9in), (sin), sellin), offe'in) to sell and+o'

i-,o'tin) net.o'9Bena%led i-a)e *a,t('in) devi*es. JURISDICTION AND VENUE 3. T!is Co('t !as s(%Ce*t -atte' C('isdi*tion ove' t!is a*tion ,('s(ant to 5: 1.S.C.

44 0220 and 022:"a) %e*a(se t!e a*tion a'ises (nde' t!e ,atent la.s of t!e 1nited States, 23 1.S.C. 44 0 et seD. =. T!is Co('t !as ,e'sonal C('isdi*tion ove' Defendant %& vi't(e of its

s&ste-ati* and *ontin(o(s *onta*ts .it! t!is C('isdi*tion, as .ell as %e*a(se of t!e inC('& to AITB and t!e *a(se of a*tion AITB !as 'aised, as alle)ed !e'ein. 6. Defendant is s(%Ce*t to t!is Co('tEs s,e*ifi* and )ene'al ,e'sonal C('isdi*tion

,('s(ant to d(e ,'o*ess and+o' t!e Dela.a'e Lon)BA'- Stat(te, d(e to at least its s(%stantial %(siness in t!is fo'(-, in*l(din)/ "i) at least a ,o'tion of t!e inf'in)e-ent alle)ed !e'einF and "ii) 'e)(la'l& doin) o' soli*itin) %(siness, en)a)in) in ot!e' ,e'sistent *o('ses of *ond(*t, and+o' de'ivin) s(%stantial 'even(e f'o- )oods and se'vi*es ,'ovided to individ(als in t!is Dist'i*t. :. Defendant !as *ond(*ted and does *ond(*t %(siness .it!in t!is Dist'i*t, di'e*tl&

o' t!'o()! inte'-edia'ies, 'eselle's, a)ents, %& offe'in) to sell, sellin), and+o' adve'tisin) "in*l(din) t!e (se of inte'a*tive .e% ,a)es .it! ,'o-otional -ate'ial) ,'od(*ts in t!is Dist'i*t t!at inf'in)e t!e Asse'ted Patents. <. In addition to DefendantEs *ontin(o(sl& and s&ste-ati*all& *ond(*tin)

%(siness in t!is Dist'i*t, t!e *a(ses of a*tion a)ainst Defendant is *onne*ted "%(t not li-ited) to DefendantEs ,(',osef(l a*ts *o--itted in t!is Dist'i*t, in*l(din) DefendantEs -a9in), (sin),

i-,o'tin), offe'in) to sell, o' sellin) ,'od(*ts .!i*! in*l(de feat('es t!at fall .it!in t!e s*o,e of at least one *lai- of t!e Asse'ted Patents. 0;. Gen(e lies in t!is Dist'i*t (nde' 5: 1.S.C. 44 02<0 and 0@;;"%) %e*a(se,

a-on) ot!e' 'easons, Defendant is s(%Ce*t to ,e'sonal C('isdi*tion in t!is Dist'i*t, and !as *o--itted and *ontin(es to *o--it a*ts of ,atent inf'in)e-ent in t!is Dist'i*t. Ho' e a-,le, Defendant !as (sed, sold, offe'ed to sell, and+o' i-,o'ted inf'in)in) ,'od(*ts in t!is Dist'i*t. THE PATENTS-IN-SUIT 00. T!e'e a'e t.o ,atents at iss(e in t!is a*tion/ 1nited States Patent Nos. :,02@,=;;

"t!e #E=;; Patent$)F and :,@66,0<6 "t!e #E0<6 Patent$) "*olle*tivel&, t!e #Asse'ted Patents$). The 600 Patent 05. On Ma'*! 02, 5;05 t!e 1SPTO d(l& and le)all& iss(ed t!e E=;; Patent, entitled

#Inte'net Di'e*t Devi*e$ afte' a f(ll and fai' e a-ination to invento's H'an9 Cle-ente and Ted Hease'. AITB is ,'esentl& t!e o.ne' %& assi)n-ent of t!e E=;; Patent, !avin) 'e*eived all 'i)!ts, title, and inte'est in and to t!e E=;; Patent. AITB ,ossesses all 'i)!ts of 'e*ove'& (nde' t!e E=;; Patent, in*l(din) t!e e *l(sive 'i)!t to 'e*ove' fo' ,ast inf'in)e-ent. A t'(e and *o''e*t *o,& of t!e E=;; Patent is atta*!ed to t!is Co-,laint as E !i%it A. The 197 Patent 02. On I(l& 5, 5;02 t!e 1SPTO d(l& and le)all& iss(ed t!e E0<6 Patent, entitled

#Inte'net Di'e*t Devi*e$ afte' a f(ll and fai' e a-ination to invento's H'an9 Cle-ente and Ted Hease'. AITB is ,'esentl& t!e o.ne' %& assi)n-ent of t!e E0<6 Patent, !avin) 'e*eived all 'i)!ts, title, and inte'est in and to t!e E0<6 Patent. AITB ,ossesses all 'i)!ts of 'e*ove'& (nde' t!e E0<6 Patent, in*l(din) t!e e *l(sive 'i)!t to 'e*ove' fo' ,ast inf'in)e-ent. A t'(e and *o''e*t *o,& of t!e E0<6 Patent is atta*!ed to t!is Co-,laint as E !i%it B. 2

DESCRIPTION OF THE ACCUSED PRODUCTS 0@. DefendantEs net.o'9Bena%led i-a)eB*a,t('in) devi*es "!e'einafte', #I-a)eB

*a,t('in) Devi*es$), in*l(din) %(t not li-ited to t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J, a'e *onfi)('ed to ta9e still and video i-a)es and t'ans-it and 'e*eive t!ose i-a)es to and f'oot!e' I-a)eB*a,t('in) Devi*es, as .ell as to and f'o- a .e%site a,,li*ation, on .!i*! still and video i-a)es *a,t('ed %& t!e I-a)eB*a,t('in) Devi*es *an %e sto'ed and -ana)ed, (sin) a va'iet& of *onne*tions, in*l(din) %(t not li-ited to AiBHi and va'io(s 2J and @J *ell(la' net.o'9s. 03. Ho' e a-,le, t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J in*l(des %(iltBin

a,,li*ations t!at allo. a (se' to -a9e video *alls ove' AiBHi o' *ell(la' to anot!e' Inte'net di'e*t devi*e, and allo. still and video i-a)es *a,t('ed %& t!e devi*e to %e (,loaded to an inte'netBa**essi%le a'*!ive to %e sto'ed and -ana)ed. T!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J also allo.s a (se' to a**ess t!e Inte'net t!'o()! a va'iet& of *onne*tions, in*l(din) %(t not li-ited to AiBHi and va'io(s 2J and @J *ell(la' net.o'9s. A**o'din)l&, t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J is an Inte'net di'e*t devi*e .it! an i-a)in) s&ste- to *a,t('e still o' video i-a)es. COUNT I (INFRINGEMENT OF THE 600 PATENT) 0=. Plaintiff 'ealle)es and in*o',o'ates %& 'efe'en*e t!e alle)ations set fo't! in

,a'a)'a,!s 0B03. 06. In violation of 23 1.S.C. 4 560, Boost Mo%ile is no., and !as %een di'e*tl&

inf'in)in) and+o' ind(*in) inf'in)e-ent of t!e E=;; Patent.

0:.

Defendant !as !ad 9no.led)e of inf'in)e-ent of t!e E=;; Patent at least as of t!e

se'vi*e of t!e ,'esent *o-,laint. 0<. Boost Mo%ile !as di'e*tl& inf'in)ed and *ontin(es to di'e*tl& inf'in)e at least

*lai- 0 of t!e E=;; Patent %& -a9in), (sin), i-,o'tin), offe'in) to sell, and+o' sellin) I-a)eB *a,t('in) Devi*es, s(*! as t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J, .it!o(t a(t!o'it& in t!e 1nited States, and .ill *ontin(e to do so (nless enCoined %& t!is Co('t. As a di'e*t and ,'o i-ate 'es(lt of Boost Mo%ileEs di'e*t inf'in)e-ent of t!e E=;; Patent, Plaintiff !as %een and *ontin(es to %e da-a)ed. 5;. Boost Mo%ile !as indi'e*tl& inf'in)ed and *ontin(es to indi'e*tl& inf'in)e at least

*lai- 0 of t!e E=;; Patent %& a*tivel& ind(*in) t!ei' 'es,e*tive *(sto-e's, (se's, and+o' li*ensees to di'e*tl& inf'in)e %& (sin), sellin), offe'in) to sell and+o' i-,o'tin) I-a)eB*a,t('in) Devi*es. Boost Mo%ile en)a)ed o' .ill !ave en)a)ed in s(*! ind(*e-ent !avin) 9no.led)e of t!e E=;; Patent. H('t!e'-o'e, Boost Mo%ile 9ne. o' s!o(ld !ave 9no.n t!at its a*tion .o(ld ind(*e di'e*t inf'in)e-ent %& ot!e's and intended t!at its a*tions .o(ld ind(*e di'e*t inf'in)e-ent %& ot!e's. Ho' e a-,le, Boost Mo%ile sells, offe's to sell and adve'tises inte)'ated I-a)eB*a,t('in) Devi*es in Dela.a'e, s(*! as t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J, s,e*ifi*all& intendin) t!at its *(sto-e's %(& and (se said ,'od(*ts. As a di'e*t and ,'o i-ate 'es(lt of Boost Mo%ileEs indi'e*t inf'in)e-ent %& ind(*e-ent of t!e E=;; Patent, Plaintiff !as %een and *ontin(es to %e da-a)ed. 50. To t!e e tent t!at fa*ts lea'ned in dis*ove'& s!o. t!at DefendantEs inf'in)e-ent

of t!e E=;; Patent is o' !as %een .illf(l, AITB 'ese'ves t!e 'i)!t to 'eD(est s(*! a findin) at t!e ti-e of t'ial.

55.

As a 'es(lt of DefendantEs inf'in)e-ent of t!e E=;; Patent, AITB !as s(ffe'ed

-oneta'& da-a)es and is entitled to a -oneta'& C(d)-ent in an a-o(nt adeD(ate to *o-,ensate fo' DefendantEs ,ast inf'in)e-ent, to)et!e' .it! inte'ests and *osts. 52. AITB .ill *ontin(e to s(ffe' da-a)es in t!e f(t('e (nless DefendantEs inf'in)in)

a*tivities a'e enCoined %& t!is Co('t. As s(*!, AITB is entitled to *o-,ensation fo' an& *ontin(in) o' f(t('e inf'in)e-ent (, (ntil t!e date t!at Defendant is finall& and ,e'-anentl& enCoined f'o- f('t!e' inf'in)e-ent. COUNT II (INFRINGEMENT OF THE 19 PATENT) 5@. Plaintiff 'ealle)es and in*o',o'ates %& 'efe'en*e t!e alle)ations set fo't! in

,a'a)'a,!s 0B52. 53. In violation of 23 1.S.C. 4 560, Boost Mo%ile is no., and !as %een di'e*tl&

inf'in)in) and+o' ind(*in) inf'in)e-ent of t!e E0<6 Patent. 5=. Defendant !as !ad 9no.led)e of inf'in)e-ent of t!e E0<6 Patent at least as of t!e

se'vi*e of t!e ,'esent *o-,laint. 56. Boost Mo%ile !as di'e*tl& inf'in)ed and *ontin(es to di'e*tl& inf'in)e at least

*lai- 0 of t!e E0<6 Patent %& -a9in), (sin), i-,o'tin), offe'in) to sell, and+o' sellin) I-a)eB *a,t('in) Devi*es, s(*! as t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J, .it!o(t a(t!o'it& in t!e 1nited States, and .ill *ontin(e to do so (nless enCoined %& t!is Co('t. As a di'e*t and ,'o i-ate 'es(lt of Boost Mo%ileEs di'e*t inf'in)e-ent of t!e E0<6 Patent, Plaintiff !as %een and *ontin(es to %e da-a)ed. 5:. Boost Mo%ile !as indi'e*tl& inf'in)ed and *ontin(es to indi'e*tl& inf'in)e at least

*lai- 0 of t!e E0<6 Patent %& a*tivel& ind(*in) t!ei' 'es,e*tive *(sto-e's, (se's, and+o' li*ensees to di'e*tl& inf'in)e %& (sin), sellin), offe'in) to sell and+o' i-,o'tin) I-a)eB*a,t('in) =

Devi*es. Boost Mo%ile en)a)ed o' .ill !ave en)a)ed in s(*! ind(*e-ent !avin) 9no.led)e of t!e E0<6 Patent. H('t!e'-o'e, Boost Mo%ile 9ne. o' s!o(ld !ave 9no.n t!at its a*tion .o(ld ind(*e di'e*t inf'in)e-ent %& ot!e's and intended t!at its a*tions .o(ld ind(*e di'e*t inf'in)e-ent %& ot!e's. Ho' e a-,le, Boost Mo%ile sells, offe's to sell and adve'tises inte)'ated I-a)eB*a,t('in) Devi*es in Dela.a'e, s(*! as t!e Boost Mo%ile HTC EGO Desi)n @J, s,e*ifi*all& intendin) t!at its *(sto-e's %(& and (se said ,'od(*ts. As a di'e*t and ,'o i-ate 'es(lt of Boost Mo%ileEs indi'e*t inf'in)e-ent %& ind(*e-ent of t!e E0<6 Patent, Plaintiff !as %een and *ontin(es to %e da-a)ed. 5<. To t!e e tent t!at fa*ts lea'ned in dis*ove'& s!o. t!at DefendantEs inf'in)e-ent

of t!e E0<6 Patent is o' !as %een .illf(l, AITB 'ese'ves t!e 'i)!t to 'eD(est s(*! a findin) at t!e ti-e of t'ial. 2;. As a 'es(lt of DefendantEs inf'in)e-ent of t!e E0<6 Patent, AITB !as s(ffe'ed

-oneta'& da-a)es and is entitled to a -oneta'& C(d)-ent in an a-o(nt adeD(ate to *o-,ensate fo' DefendantEs ,ast inf'in)e-ent, to)et!e' .it! inte'ests and *osts. 20. AITB .ill *ontin(e to s(ffe' da-a)es in t!e f(t('e (nless DefendantEs inf'in)in)

a*tivities a'e enCoined %& t!is Co('t. As s(*!, AITB is entitled to *o-,ensation fo' an& *ontin(in) o' f(t('e inf'in)e-ent (, (ntil t!e date t!at Defendant is finall& and ,e'-anentl& enCoined f'o- f('t!e' inf'in)e-ent. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL 25. a*tion. AITB de-ands a t'ial %& C('& as to all iss(es t!at a'e t'ia%le %& a C('& in t!is

PRAYER FOR RELIEF AHE?EHO?E, AITB ,'a&s fo' t!e follo.in) 'elief/ A. T!at Defendant %e adC(d)ed to !ave inf'in)ed t!e Asse'ted Patents, di'e*tl&

and+o' indi'e*tl&, %& .a& of ind(*e-ent and+o' *ont'i%(to'& inf'in)e-ent, lite'all& and+o' (nde' t!e do*t'ine of eD(ivalentsF B. T!at Defendant, its offi*e's, di'e*to's, a)ents, se'vants, e-,lo&ees, atto'ne&s,

affiliates, divisions, %'an*!es, ,a'ents, and t!ose ,e'sons in a*tive *on*e't o' ,a'ti*i,ation .it! an& of t!e-, %e ,e'-anentl& enCoined f'o- inf'in)in) t!e Asse'ted PatentsF C. An a.a'd of da-a)es ,('s(ant to 23 1.S.C. 45:@ s(ffi*ient to *o-,ensate AITB

fo' t!e DefendantEs ,ast inf'in)e-ent and an& *ontin(in) o' f(t('e inf'in)e-ent (, (ntil t!e date t!at Defendant is finall& and ,e'-anentl& enCoined f'o- f('t!e' inf'in)e-ent, in*l(din) *o-,ensato'& da-a)esF D. An assess-ent of ,'eBC(d)-ent and ,ostBC(d)-ent inte'est and *osts a)ainst

Defendant, to)et!e' .it! an a.a'd of s(*! inte'est and *osts, in a**o'dan*e .it! 23 1.S.C. 45:@F E. T!at Defendant %e di'e*ted to ,a& en!an*ed da-a)es, in*l(din) AITBEs

atto'ne&sE fees in*(''ed in *onne*tion .it! t!is la.s(it ,('s(ant to 23 1.S.C. 45:3F and H. ,'o,e'. T!at AITB !ave s(*! ot!e' and f('t!e' 'elief as t!is Co('t -a& dee- C(st and

O*to%e' 2;, 5;02

BA8A?D, P.A. /s/ Stephen B. Brauerman ?i*!a'd D. >i'9 "'9;<55) Ste,!en B. B'a(e'-an "s%@<35) Ganessa ?. Ti'adentes "vt32<:) Sa'a E. B(ssie'e "s%3653) 555 Dela.a'e Aven(e, S(ite <;; P.O. Bo 5302; Ail-in)ton, DE 0<:<< '9i'9K%a&a'dla..*os%'a(e'-anK%a&a'dla..*ovti'adentesK%a&a'dla..*os%(ssie'eK%a&a'dla..*o"2;5) =33B3;;; Attorneys for Plaintiff Alex is the Best, LLC

<