You are on page 1of 16

h%CONOMICSCANHELPSOLVECLIMATECHANGE BUTECO

4OGETHER
NOMICRATIONALISMCANNOT)TSNARROWFOCUSONINDI
VIDUALSLEAVESITINCAPABLEOFOFFERINGUPEFFECTIVE
SOLUTIONSTOMULTI FACETEDENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS
SUCHASCLIMATECHANGEv

)N4OGETHER!T,AST%CONOMISTS
%NVIRONMENTALISTS2ICHARD$ENNISS
ARGUESTHATECONOMICSHASTHE
TOOLSAVAILABLETOHELPDEALWITH
CLIMATECHANGEANDOTHERENVIRON
.EVERTHELESS WHILEECONOMICS
SHOULDPLAYABIGGERROLEINHELPING
USACHIEVEOURNATIONALOBJECTIVES
ITSHOULDPLAYAMUCHSMALLERROLE
ININmUENCINGWHATTHOSEOBJEC
!T,AST
%CONOMISTS%NVIRONMENTALISTS
MENTALPROBLEMSBUTTHATTHEECO TIVESSHOULDBE
NOMICSREQUIREDISDIFFERENTFROM
&INALLY THEESSAYARGUESTHATWE

THATBEINGCURRENTLYPRACTISED
NEEDANEWLANGUAGEOFECONOMICS
7HATISLACKINGISNOTTHEKNOW
HOW BUTTHEPOLITICALWILLTOINITIATE
WHICHMIGHTBECALLED%CONOMIC
.EO RATIONALISM

2ICHARD$ENNISS
CHANGEANDTHEMACHINERYOFGOV
$R2ICHARD$ENNISSISANECONOMIST
ERNMENTTODELIVERONTHATWILL
WHOWASPREVIOUSLYANECONOMICS
)FABROADRANGEOFECONOMICTOOLS
LECTURERATTHE5NIVERSITYOF.EW
ISCOMBINEDWITHTHEPOLITICAL
CASTLE(EHASBEEN$EPUTY$IRECTOR
DESIRETOOVERCOMEOBSTACLESTO
OFTHE!USTRALIA)NSTITUTEAND#HIEF
CHANGE THENEFFECTIVESOLUTIONS
OF3TAFFTO3ENATOR.ATASHA3TOTT
FORENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSCAN
$ESPOJA(EISCURRENTLY3TRATEGIC
BEQUICKLYFOUND
!DVISERTOTHE!USTRALIAN'REENS
3ENATORS(EWRITESREGULARLYFOR
NEWSPAPERSANDMAGAZINES HAS
PUBLISHEDEXTENSIVELYINACADEMIC
JOURNALSANDWASTHECO AUTHOROF
!FmUENZA

h4HEOPINIONSEXPRESSEDINTHISESSAYAREPERSONALANDDONOTREmECTTHE I=:6JHIG6A>6C8DAA67DG6I>DC
VIEWSORPOLICIESOFANYPOLITICALPARTY4HEAIMOFTHEESSAYISTOILLUSTRATE
INWHATWAYECONOMICSCANBESTHELPTODEALWITHCLIMATECHANGEANDOTHER !#ONSORTIUMOF.ATIONAL#OMMUNITY/RGANISATIONS
ENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSvˆ2)#(!2$$%..)33
0REFACE 4OGETHER!T,AST%CONOMISTS%NVIRONMENTALISTS

4OGETHERATLAST%CONOMISTSENVIRONMENTALISTSFORMSPARTOFASERIESOFESSAYS %CONOMISTSANDPOLITICIANSKNOWHOWTOUSEMARKETMECHANISMSTOPROTECT
BEING PUBLISHED BY THE !USTRALIAN #OLLABORATION ON SOCIETAL AND ENVIRON THEENVIRONMENT4HEPROBLEMIN!USTRALIAOVERTHEPASTTWODECADESHAS
MENTALISSUESFACING!USTRALIA BEENTHATONLYAVERYNARROWVERSIONOFECONOMICS REFERREDTOTHROUGHOUT
4HE ESSAY IS ALSO ONE OF A SEQUENCE OF SHORT PAPERS ON THE ECONOMICS THISESSAYASECONOMICRATIONALISM HASBEENAPPLIEDTOPOLICYPROBLEMS!S
NEEDEDFORASUSTAINABLESOCIETY!LREADYPUBLISHEDISAPAPERON"EHAVIOURAL A RESULT EFFECTIVE POLICY SOLUTIONS TO ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS HAVE BEEN
%CONOMICS HTTPWWWAUSTRALIANCOLLABORATIONCOMAUFACTSHEETSINDEX LARGELYOVERLOOKED
HTML 4OGETHERATLASTWILLBEFOLLOWEDBY,IVINGSTANDARDS ECONOMICGROWTH %CONOMICS CAN HELP SOLVE CLIMATE CHANGE BUT ECONOMIC RATIONALISM
ANDENVIRONMENTALPRESSUREBYECONOMIST$R3TEVE(ATlELD$ODDS CANNOT4WODECADESOFECONOMICRATIONALISMHAVEDELIVEREDFUNDAMENTAL
4HE!USTRALIAN#OLLABORATIONISANASSOCIATIONOFSEVENLEADINGNATIONAL CHANGESTO!USTRALIASBANKING COMMUNICATION ENERGYANDTRANSPORTSYS
COMMUNITYORGANISATIONS TEMS3IMILARLY BOTHTHEROLEOFGOVERNMENTANDTHEDELIVERYOFGOVERNMENT
SERVICESHAVEBEENTRANSFORMEDASARESULTOFECONOMICRATIONALISM"UTITS
!USTRALIAN#OUNCILOF3OCIAL3ERVICE
SINGULARFOCUSONTHEROLEOFINDIVIDUALSCOMBINEDWITHITSASSUMPTIONSOF
!USTRALIAN#ONSERVATION&OUNDATION
PERFECT INFORMATION AND THE EXISTENCE OF WELL DElNED MARKETS LEAVES ECO
!USTRALIAN#ONSUMERS!SSOCIATION
NOMICRATIONALISMINCAPABLEOFOFFERINGUPEFFECTIVESOLUTIONSTOAPROBLEMAS
!USTRALIAN#OUNCILFOR)NTERNATIONAL$EVELOPMENT
MULTIFACETEDASCLIMATECHANGE
&EDERATIONOF%THNIC#OMMUNITIES#OUNCILSOF!USTRALIA
/VERALL THISESSAYARGUESTHATSOLVINGENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSISMOREA
.ATIONAL#OUNCILOF#HURCHESIN!USTRALIAAND
POLITICALTHANANECONOMICISSUE%MERGINGSOCIALANDECONOMICPROBLEMS
4RUSTFOR9OUNG!USTRALIANS
CANBEEFFECTIVELYADDRESSEDIFPOLICYMAKERSAREWILLINGTODELVEDEEPERINTO
4HE#OLLABORATIONCARRIESOUTRESEARCHANDPUBLISHESBOOKSANDOTHERPUBLI THEECONOMISTSBAGOFTRICKS4HEEXISTENCEOFTHEECONOMICKNOW HOWAND
CATIONS)TSOVERALLAIMISTOHELPACHIEVEASUSTAINABLESOCIETY THE ABSENCE OF POLITICAL WILL IS ILLUSTRATED BY THE DISPARITY BETWEEN WHAT
!RANGEOFFREEEDUCATIONALANDINFORMATIONRESOURCESCANALSOBEFOUND 0RIME-INISTER*OHN(OWARDSAIDWASNEEDEDTOTACKLECLIMATECHANGESOON
ONTHE#OLLABORATIONSWEBSITE4HEYINCLUDE&ACT3HEETSONSOCIETALANDENVI AFTERHETOOKOFlCEANDWHATHASSUBSEQUENTLYHAPPENED
RONMENTAL ISSUES WRITTEN AND PEER REVIEWED BY EXPERIENCED RESEARCHERS )N THE0RIME-INISTERCOMMITTEDHIMSELFTOTACKLINGTHEPROBLEMOF
$EMOCRACY7ATCHDEVOTEDTOTHREATSTOANDANDWAYSOFENHANCINGDEMOC CLIMATECHANGEANDANNOUNCEDSOMESIGNIlCANTPOLICYINITIATIVES(ESETA
RACYIN!USTRALIAAND2EFERENCE3OURCES ALISTINGOFKEYNATIONALANDINTER TWOPERCENTMANDATORYTARGETFORRENEWABLEENERGYHEDECLAREDTHATTHE
NATIONALSOURCESOFSTATISTICALANDOTHERINFORMATION !USTRALIANCARINDUSTRYWOULDBEREQUIREDTOINCREASETHEFUELEFlCIENCYOF
ITSmEETBYPERCENTBYHESAIDTHATGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTPRAC
$AVID9ENCKEN TICES WOULD PRIORITISE ENVIRONMENTAL ATTRIBUTES AND HE ANNOUNCED THAT
#HAIR 4HE!USTRALIAN#OLLABORATION #OMPRESSED .ATURAL 'AS A LOW EMISSION TRANSPORT FUEL WOULD BE MADE
WWWAUSTRALIANCOLLABORATIONCOMAU AVAILABLEFORCOMMERCIALVEHICLESINMETROPOLITANAREAS
4/'%4(%2!4,!34

.OTONLYHAVETHESECOMMITMENTSNOTBEENMET BUTOVER THEPASTDEC 3%#4)/.


ADE ARANGEOFPERVERSEPOLICIESHAVEBEENINTRODUCEDTHATHAVEINCREASED
THERATEOFGROWTHOFGREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONS&OREXAMPLE WITHTHEINTRO
%XPANDINGECONOMICSBEYONDECONOMICRATIONALISM
DUCTIONOFTHE'34CAMEAREDUCTIONINTAXESONPETROLWHILEAPERCENT
TAXWASPLACEDONTHEPRICEOFPUBLICTRANSPORT
4HEDEREGULATIONOFTHEELECTRICITYMARKETRESULTEDINASIGNIlCANTINCREASE %CONOMICSDESCRIBESITSELFASTHESCIENCEOFTHEEFlCIENTALLOCATIONOFSCARCE
INTHEUSEOFBROWNCOALlREDELECTRICITYTHEMOSTGREENHOUSEGASINTENSIVE RESOURCES)NORDERTOJUSTIFYTHEIRPREFERREDPOLICYSOLUTIONSOFDEREGULA
FORMOFELECTRICITYGENERATIONIN!USTRALIA  TIONANDSMALLGOVERNMENT SOMEECONOMISTSANDMOSTPOLITICIANS FOCUS
4HE ABOLITION IN  OF INDEXATION OF FUEL EXCISE RESULTED IN A STEADY ONASMALLSELECTIONOFTHEAVAILABLEPOLICYTOOLSDESIGNEDBYECONOMISTS
DECLINEINTHEPERCENTAGERATEOFTAXATIONOFFUEL4HECOSTOFTHISMEASURE $EPENDINGONTHENATUREOFTHEPROBLEM ECONOMICTHEORYPROVIDESSTRONG
WASESTIMATEDTOBEINEXCESSOFBILLIONOVERTHEPASTYEARS SUPPORTFORAMUCHWIDERRANGEOFPOLICYSOLUTIONS4HEISSUETHATSHOULD
4HERESULTHASBEENTHATGREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONSHAVERISENEVENFASTER BEADDRESSEDISNOTWHICHISTHEBESTAPPROACHTOPOLICYOVERALL BUTWHICH
THAN0RIME-INISTER(OWARDPREDICTEDTHEYWOULDGROWWITHOUTANYACTION POLICYISMOSTAPPROPRIATEGIVENTHESPECIlCCIRCUMSTANCESOFTHEPROBLEM
ONHISPART ATHAND
4HROUGHOUTTHISESSAYTHETERM@ECONOMICRATIONALISMALSOREFERREDTO
ASECONOMICLIBERALISMINOTHERPARTSOFTHEWORLD ISUSEDTODESCRIBETHE
VIEWPOINTOFECONOMISTSANDPOLICYMAKERSWHOCONCLUDETHATMARKETFORCES
AREALMOSTEXCLUSIVELYPREFERABLETOGOVERNMENTINTERVENTION7HILETHISIS
ALSOANIMPORTANTCONCLUSIONOFWHATISOFTENCALLED@NEOCLASSICALECONOM
ICS NEOCLASSICAL ECONOMICS GENERALLY ALLOWS FOR A MORE NUANCED DEBATE
ABOUTTHERELATIVEMERITSOFMARKETFORCESANDAWIDERANGEOFGOVERNMENT
INTERVENTIONS
4HERE ARE MANY PARADIGMS WITHIN ECONOMICS INCLUDING INSTITUTIONAL
ECONOMICS POST +EYNESIANECONOMICSANDPOLITICALECONOMY7HILEALLTHESE
APPROACHESHAVETHEPOTENTIALTOADDTOTHEANALYSISPRESENTEDINTHISESSAY
THEDISTINCTIONSBETWEENTHESESCHOOLSOFTHOUGHTHAVEBEENIGNOREDFORTHE
SAKEOFBREVITYOFEXPOSITION7HENTHETERM@ECONOMICSISUSEDITSHOULDBE
INTERPRETEDTOMEANNEOCLASSICALECONOMICS

7HYECONOMICRATIONALISTSJUSTCANTCOPEWITHTHEENVIRONMENT

%CONOMICSWASMEANTTOBEEASY2ATIONALPEOPLE ANDRATIONALlRMS WERE


SUPPOSEDTOMAKERATIONALDECISIONS4HERATIONALROLEFORGOVERNMENTWAS
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/.

SIMPLYTOGETOUTOFTHEWAYANDLETEVERYONEELSEGETONWITHSOLVINGPROB CASEFORGOVERNMENTINTERVENTIONINTHEFAILINGMARKETTOIMPROVEEFlCIENCY
LEMSANDSATISFYINGTHEMARKET&ROMAPOLICYPERSPECTIVE IFTHEREWEREPROB ANDEQUITY
LEMSINTHEDELIVERYOFASERVICE THENTHEGOVERNMENTSHOULDEITHERPRIVATISE )TSHOULDCOMEASNOSURPRISE THEREFORE THATECONOMICRATIONALISMHAS
ITOR IFITWASALREADYAPRIVATEMARKET THENSIMPLYREDUCEANY@REDTAPEAND ENORMOUS DIFlCULTIES IN DIAGNOSING AND SOLVING ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS
LETTHERATIONALPRIVATEINDIVIDUALSGETONWITHSATISFYINGTHEMARKET THATARELARGELYARESULTOFMARKETFAILURE4HEREALSURPRISEFORMANYISTHAT
7HILESIMPLETODESCRIBE THEREAREMAJORLIMITATIONSTOTHEEFFECTIVE AFTERDECADESOFPUBLICDEBATEWHICHHASASSUMEDTHATECONOMICRATIONALISM
NESSOFTHEECONOMICRATIONALISTAPPROACHTOPOLICYFORMULATION0UTSIMPLY ISECONOMICS ECONOMICSIS ANDALWAYSHASBEEN MUCHMORETHANECONOMIC
IT CANNOT COPE WITH COMPLEX POLICY PROBLEMS OF @MARKET FAILURE SUCH AS RATIONALISM-ARKETFAILURESWERERECOGNISEDBYECONOMISTSALONGTIMEAGO
WHERETHEDECISIONSOFINDIVIDUALSIMPACTONOTHERCITIZENS ONPEOPLEOUT ANDECONOMISTSHAVEALWAYSPROPOSEDARANGEOFSOLUTIONSFORMARKETFAIL
SIDE OF THE REGULATORY JURISDICTION OR ON FUTURE GENERATIONS -ARKETS ARE URESWHICHINCLUDETHEIMPOSITIONOFTAXES GOVERNMENTPROVISIONOFSERVICES
SAIDTOBEGOODATALLOCATINGRESOURCESONLYWHENALLOFTHEFOLLOWINGCONDI ANDVARYINGDEGREESOFREGULATION4HEPROBLEMIN!USTRALIAHASBEENTHAT
TIONSEXIST THESEPOLICYOPTIONSHAVEBEENIGNOREDINRECENTDECADES
4HEWIDESPREADACCEPTANCEOFECONOMICRATIONALISMHASCREATEDASTRUC
4HEREAREALARGENUMBEROFBUYERSFORAPRODUCT TURAL BARRIER TO THE KINDS OF POLICY REFORMS REQUIRED TO ADDRESS CLIMATE
CHANGE AND A RANGE OF OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS !S OUTLINED BELOW
4HEREAREALARGENUMBEROFSELLERSFORAPRODUCTIETHEREARENOMONOP
HOWEVER THEREISNOECONOMICPRINCIPLEWHICHPREVENTSTHEDEVELOPMENTOF
OLIES 
CREATIVEANDEFFECTIVESOLUTIONSTOENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS)NFACT ECONO
%VERYONEHASFREEANDCOMPLETEACCESSTOINFORMATIONABOUTALLPRODUCTS MISTSONCEEXPECTEDTHATGOVERNMENTSWOULDIMPLEMENTEXACTLYTHOSESORTS
IETHEREISNONEEDFORANYADVERTISING  OFPOLICIESIFANDWHENTHECIRCUMSTANCESDEMANDEDTHEM

4HEPRODUCTIONORCONSUMPTIONOFAPRODUCTHASNOEXTERNAL ORSPILLOVER
4HETRUTHABOUTGOVERNMENTREGULATION
COSTSTHATAFFECTOTHERCITIZENSEGNOPRODUCTSPRODUCEPOLLUTIONORPOS
ITIVELYORNEGATIVELYAFFECTTHEHEALTHOFOTHERS 
'OVERNMENTREGULATIONOFBUSINESSISOFTENDERIDEDAS@REDTAPEANDGOVERN
4HEREARENOECONOMIESOFSCALEIEMASSPRODUCTIONDELIVERSNOBENE MENTREGULATIONOFCONSUMERSISOFTENLABELED@NANNYSTATE ISMDESPITETHE
lTS AND REALITYTHATTHEREARENOMARKETSIN!USTRALIATHATARECOMPLETELYUNREGU
LATED&OREXAMPLE
4HEREISNOTHINGPREVENTINGNEWCOMPETITIONFROMEMERGINGIETHERE
ARENOREGULATORYRESTRICTIONSTHATPREVENTNEWlRMSENTERINGAMARKET
4HERE ARE LAWS THAT PREVENT FARMERS SPRAYING POISONS ON THEIR CROPS
SUCHASTHEMONOPOLYRIGHTSPREVIOUSLYENJOYEDBY!7"ORTHELIMITOF
BECAUSEBEFORETHELAWSEXISTEDTHATISEXACTLYWHATHAPPENED
THREECOMMERCIAL46LICENCES 
4HEREARELAWSTHATREQUIRECARMANUFACTURERSTOINSTALLSEATBELTS AND
5NLESSALLOFTHEABOVECONDITIONSAREMETMARKETFAILUREISSAIDTOEXIST OTHERLAWSTHATREQUIREALLPASSENGERSTOWEARTHEM BECAUSEBEFORETHOSE
AND ECONOMIC THEORY CONCLUDES THAT UNDER SUCH CIRCUMSTANCES THERE IS A LAWSSEATBELTSWERERARELYINSTALLEDORWORN
 4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/. 

4HEREARELAWSTHATREQUIREALLEMPLOYERSTOPROVIDEAWORKPLACETHATIS EFFECTIVE4HEANALYSISOFTHECOSTSANDBENElTSOFALTERNATECOURSESOFACTION
SAFEANDFREEFROMHAZARDSBECAUSEWITHOUTSUCHLAWSWORKPLACESHAVE ALLOWSECONOMISTSTOPROVIDEAGOODFOUNDATIONFORPOLICYDECISIONMAKING
BEENAMONGTHEMOSTDANGEROUSPLACESIN!USTRALIA 4HEPROBLEMWITHECONOMICRATIONALISMISTHATITISBASEDONTHEASSUMP
TIONTHATASMALLSUBSETOFPOSSIBLEPOLICIESISALWAYSTHEPREFERREDSOLUTION
4HEREARELAWSTHATPREVENTCOMPANIESFROMSELLINGDANGEROUSANDDEFEC
TOANYPROBLEM
TIVEGOODSBECAUSEBEFORESUCHLAWSCOMPANIESDIDEXACTLYTHAT

7HATTRADITIONALECONOMICSREALLYHASTOSAYABOUTTHEENVIRONMENT
4HESUGGESTIONTHATTHEREISACHOICETOBEMADEBETWEEN@REGULATIONAND
@FREEMARKETSISASMISLEADINGASITISUNHELPFUL4HEREAREALARGENUMBEROF
!S DISCUSSED ABOVE ECONOMICS IS CONCERNED WITH THE ALLOCATION OF SCARCE
WHOLLY GOVERNMENT PROVIDED SERVICES -OST GOODS AND SERVICES lT SOME
RESOURCES%CONOMISTSBELIEVETHATWHENARESOURCEISSCARCEITSUSESHOULD
WHEREBETWEENTHETWOEXTREMES4HEREALQUESTIONIS@7HATISTHEAPPRO
BERESTRICTEDTOENSURETHATITISALWAYSUSEDINTHEMOSTSOCIALLYUSEFULMAN
PRIATEEXTENTANDFORMOFREGULATIONFORAPARTICULARMARKET
NER7HENCIRCUMSTANCESCHANGE ANDARESOURCETHATWASONCEABUNDANT
)NDUSTRYDEMANDSFOR@DEREGULATIONOFAMARKETMADETHROUGHTHEMEDIA
BECOMESSCARCE ECONOMICTHEORYMAKESITCLEARTHATEITHERPRODUCERORCON
ARE OFTEN NOTHING MORE THAN A DISTRACTION FROM PRIVATE DISCUSSIONS ABOUT
SUMERBEHAVIOURMUSTADJUSTTOSUITTHENEWCIRCUMSTANCES%CONOMICTHE
WHICHFORMSOFREGULATIONWILLMOSTBENElTINDUSTRYINCUMBENTS&OREXAM
ORYALSORECOGNISESTHAT INTHEEVENTTHATPRODUCERORCONSUMERBEHAVIOUR
PLE THE(OWARD'OVERNMENTSCHANGESTOTHEINDUSTRIALRELATIONS)2 SYS
DOESNOTALTERTOREmECTTHESCARCITYOFARESOURCE GOVERNMENTINTERVENTION
TEMWEREDESCRIBEDAS@DEREGULATIONYETTHEYRESULTEDINPAGESOFNEW
MAYBEAPPROPRIATE!SOUTLINEDINTHEFOLLOWINGSECTIONS HOWEVER POLITICAL
)2LEGISLATION3IMILARLY THERECENT@DEREGULATIONOFTHEMEDIAINDUSTRYNOW
IMPEDIMENTSTYPICALLYDOMINATEPOLICYSOLUTIONSTHATAREBOTHECONOMICALLY
ALLOWSMOREMEDIAPROPRIETORSTOPURCHASEADDITIONALMEDIAASSETSBUTSTILL
ANDENVIRONMENTALLYDESIRABLE
PREVENTS NEW MEDIA COMPANIES ESTABLISHING NEW TELEVISION STATIONS OR
4HE BIGGEST ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS IN !USTRALIA TODAY ARISE FROM THE
BROADCASTING NEWS LIKE CONTENT OVER THE INTERNET THROUGH THE CONTROL OF
FACTTHAT WHENTHELAWSANDPRACTICESWHICHDOMINATETHE!USTRALIANECON
BROADCASTINGLICENCES
OMYWEREBEINGDEVELOPED WATER FORESTS lSH FRESHAIRANDTHECAPACITYOF
3IMILARLY 1ANTASHASUSEDTHETHREATOFINTERNATIONALCOMPETITIONTOJUS
THEATMOSPHERETOABSORBCARBONDIOXIDEWERENOTCONSIDEREDSCARCE)NFACT
TIFYREDUCTIONSINEMPLOYMENT WAGESANDCONDITIONSWHILESIMULTANEOUSLY
THEYWERERARELYCONSIDEREDATALLBECAUSEOFTHEIRRELATIVEABUNDANCE7HEN
LOBBYINGSUCCESSFULLYTOPREVENTINCREASEDFOREIGNCOMPETITIONONTHEROUTES
%UROPEANSlRSTBEGANTOCOLONISE!USTRALIAITWASCLEAREDLAND LABOURAND
BETWEEN!USTRALIAANDTHE5+AND!USTRALIAANDTHE53
INDUSTRIALCAPITALTHATWEREINSHORTSUPPLYAND APPROPRIATELY ITWASTHEDIS
!USTRALIANINDUSTRIALISTSADOPTAPRAGMATICAPPROACHTOREGULATIONAND
TRIBUTION OF THESE RESOURCES THAT ATTRACTED THE ATTENTION OF LEGISLATORS AND
GOVERNMENTASSISTANCETHEYAREINFAVOUROFGOVERNMENTPOLICIESTHATARE
POLICYMAKERS4HISISNOLONGERTHECASEASNATURALRESOURCESSUCHASWATER
GOODFORTHEMANDOPPOSEDTOPOLICIESTHATTHEYBELIEVEWILLBEBADFORTHEM
FORESTS lSHANDFRESHAIRHAVEBECOMERELATIVELYSCARCE$ESPITETHISSHIFTIN
3ELFINTERESTISAMOREEFFECTIVEPREDICTIVEMODELOFANINDUSTRYSAPPROACHTO
CIRCUMSTANCES THEPRIORITIESOFLEGISLATORSANDPOLICYMAKERSHAVE RECENT
REGULATIONTHANTHEIDEOLOGICALPREFERENCESOFECONOMICRATIONALISTS
RHETORICALmOURISHESASIDE FAILEDTOSHIFTTOREmECTTHESECHANGESINRELATIVE
%CONOMICSPROVIDESAUSEFULFRAMEWORKFORANALYSINGBETTERANDWORSE
SCARCITY#ONSIDERTHEFOLLOWINGEXAMPLES
FORMSOFREGULATIONANDTHECIRCUMSTANCESUNDERWHICHTHEYWILLBEMOST
4HE PHRASE @ALL THE lSH IN THE SEA WAS ONCE MEANT TO IMPLY INlNITE
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/. 

RESOURCES.OW MORElSHINGVESSELSTHANEVERARETRAWLINGWITHNETSLONGER RAPIDLYTHEREGULATORYENVIRONMENTHASCHANGEDSLOWLY IFATALL.EWREGU


THANCOULDHAVEBEENIMAGINEDINTHETH#ENTURY YETTHEYARECATCHING LATORYSTRUCTURESNEEDTOBEINTRODUCEDTOENSURETHATINDIVIDUALSANDCOM
LESSlSHTHANADECADEAGO4HEPROBLEMTODAYISNOTASHORTAGEOFlSHING PANIESAREVALUINGRESOURCESACCORDINGTOTHEIRCURRENTSCARCITYRATHERTHAN
BOATSORlSHERMEN BUTOFlSH4HE@LAWOFTHESEAWHICHALLOWSFORVESSELSTO THEIRHISTORICABUNDANCE)RONICALLY THELOUDESTCALLSFORANEWREGULATORY
TAKEUNLIMITEDQUANTITIESOFlSHINTHEDEEPOCEANMADESENSEWHENWOODEN STRUCTURE ARE NOW COMING FROM THE BUSINESSES THAT ONCE SUGGESTED THAT
VESSELS WITH NO REFRIGERATION SAILED LITERALLY THE SEAS .OW THAT CIRCUM CHANGEWOULDBECATASTROPHICFORTHEECONOMY
STANCESHAVECHANGED LAWSMUSTCHANGEASWELL"UTTHISISAPOLITICALPROB #ONSIDERTHEFOLLOWINGEXTRACTFROMTHERECENT3WITKOWSKIREPORTINTO
LEM NOTANECONOMICONE ASTHOSEWHOAREUSEDTOCATCHINGlSHATWILLAND THE FUTURE OF NUCLEAR POWER IN !USTRALIA 4HIS REPORT WHICH WAS BOTH
PAYINGNOTHINGFORTHEM AREUNWILLINGTOCHANGE COMMISSIONEDANDWARMLYRECEIVEDBYTHE0RIME-INISTER *OHN(OWARD
)NANERAOFAXESANDHORSEDRAWNCARTSTHESUPPLYOFTIMBERWASCON STATES
STRAINEDBYTHENUMBEROFLOGGERSANDNOTTHENUMBEROFLOGS4HEREWASNO
NEEDTOPREVENTTHEFELLINGOFTHEOLDESTANDLARGESTTREESINTHEFORESTBECAUSE 4OADDRESSCLIMATECHANGETHERENEEDSTOBEALEVELPLAYINGlELDFORALL
THEYWERESOBIGTHATTHEYCOULDNOTBEHAULEDOUTOFVALLEYSREGARDLESSOF ENERGYGENERATINGTECHNOLOGIESTOCOMPETEONACOMPARABLEWHOLE
HOWMUCHHORSEPOWERLITERALLY COULDBEMUSTERED.OW TWOMENDRIVING OF LIFE BASIS )N A WORLD OF GREENHOUSE GAS CONSTRAINTS GREENHOUSE
TWOBULLDOZERSCONNECTEDBYAGIANTCHAINCANCLEARMORELANDINADAYTHAN GASPRICINGUSINGMARKETBASEDMEASURESWOULDPROVIDETHEAPPRO
MENCOULDHAVEONCECLEAREDINAWEEK%CONOMICTHEORYSUGGESTSNEW PRIATEFRAMEWORKFORTHEMARKETANDINVESTORSTOESTABLISHTHEOPTI
CIRCUMSTANCESREQUIRENEWPOLICIES BUTTHOSEWHOHAVEGROWNRICHUSING MALPORTFOLIOOFENERGYPRODUCINGPLATFORMS,EGISLATIONWOULDBE
NEWTECHNOLOGYUNDERTHEOLDLEGALFRAMEWORKARE NOTSURPRISINGLY RELUC NECESSARYTOESTABLISHARELIABLEANDEFlCIENTREGULATORYFRAMEWORK
TANTTOCHANGE 3WITKOWSKI  P 
4HEPROBLEMOFCLIMATECHANGEARISESFROMASIMPLE BUTUNDERSTANDA
BLE OVERSIGHTONTHEPARTOFPREVIOUSGENERATIONSOFLEGISLATORS7HENTHE 3WITKOWSKISSUPPORTFORAREGULATORYFRAMEWORKTHATWOULDPUTAPRICE
INDUSTRIALREVOLUTIONBEGANANDCOALBEGANTOREPLACEWOODASTHEMAIN ON THE COSTS OF POLLUTION FROM BURNING COAL COMES AS NO SURPRISE 4HE
SOURCEOFFUEL THEREGULATORSOFTHETHCENTURYDIDNOTHAVETHEFORESIGHT APPROACHHERECOMMENDSISENTIRELYCONSISTENTWITHTHECENTRALPROPOSALOF
TOENSURETHATTHOSEWHOBURNEDFOSSILFUELSWEREREQUIREDTOPAYFORTHE THERECENTLYPUBLISHED3TERN2EPORT WHICHSTATES
WASTEDISPOSALSERVICESPROVIDEDBYTHEATMOSPHERETHATSORAPIDLYABSORBED
THECARBONDIOXIDERELEASEDDURINGCOMBUSTION4HELEGISLATORSOFTHETH #LIMATE CHANGE PRESENTS A UNIQUE CHALLENGE FOR ECONOMICS IT IS
CENTURYNAIVELYASSUMEDTHATTHEAMOUNTOFCARBONDIOXIDEBEINGRELEASED THE GREATEST AND WIDEST RANGING MARKET FAILURE EVER SEEN 3TERN
WAS TRIVIAL AND THE CAPACITY OF THE ATMOSPHERE TO ABSORB IT WAS INlNITE  PI 
"ECAUSETHEYTHOUGHTTHATTHEATMOSPHEREWASNOTASCARCERESOURCETHEY
DIDNOTSEEKTORATIONIT4ODAYSREGULATORSHAVENOSUCHEXCUSE BUTITIS &URTHER
POLITICS NOT ECONOMICS THAT PREVENTS EFFECTIVE ACTION TO ADDRESS CLIMATE
CHANGE 4HElRSTELEMENTOFPOLICYISCARBONPRICING'REENHOUSEGASESARE IN
4HEPRIMARYCAUSEOFTHESEPROBLEMSISTHATWHILETECHNOLOGYHASEVOLVED ECONOMICTERMS ANEXTERNALITYTHOSEWHOPRODUCEGREENHOUSE GAS
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/. 

EMISSIONSAREBRINGINGABOUTCLIMATECHANGE THEREBYIMPOSINGCOSTS 4HECONSENSUSAMONGECONOMISTSABOUTWHATNEEDSTOBEDONETOTACKLE


ONTHEWORLDANDONFUTUREGENERATIONS BUTTHEYDONOTFACETHEFULL PROBLEMSOFMARKETFAILURELIKECLIMATECHANGEISASWIDESPREADASTHECON
CONSEQUENCESOFTHEIRACTIONSTHEMSELVES SENSUSAMONGCLIMATESCIENTISTSOVERTHENEEDFORURGENTACTIONTOREDUCE
CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS 4HE ECONOMIC COMPLEXITIES ASSOCIATED WITH
0UTTING AN APPROPRIATE PRICE ON CARBON EXPLICITLY THROUGH TAX OR ADDRESSINGCLIMATECHANGEARENOTASSOCIATEDWITHTHENEED ORMECHANISMS
TRADING OR IMPLICITLY THROUGH REGULATION MEANS THAT PEOPLE ARE TOREDUCEGREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONS/NTHECONTRARY THEECONOMICDIFlCUL
FACEDWITHTHEFULLSOCIALCOSTOFTHEIRACTIONS4HISWILLLEADINDIVIDU TIESASSOCIATEDWITHCLIMATECHANGEARECONlNEDALMOSTEXCLUSIVELYTOPOLI
ALSANDBUSINESSESTOSWITCHAWAYFROMHIGH CARBONGOODSANDSERV TICSANDTHEIMPACTSOFTHETRANSITIONFROMTHESTATUSQUOTOALOWEMISSION
ICES AND TO INVEST IN LOW CARBON ALTERNATIVES %CONOMIC EFlCIENCY ECONOMY
POINTSTOTHEADVANTAGESOFACOMMONGLOBALCARBONPRICEEMISSIONS !NYDIFlCULTIESASSOCIATEDWITHPLANNINGTHETRANSITIONTOALOWCARBON
REDUCTIONS WILL THEN TAKE PLACE WHEREVER THEY ARE CHEAPEST 3TERN ECONOMY AND THE CONSEQUENT POLITICAL DIFlCULTIES OF WHO SHOULD BEAR THE
 PXVIII  COSTS OF THAT TRANSITION SHOULD BE VIEWED SOLELY IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ECO
NOMICDIFlCULTIESANDDISTRIBUTIONALCOSTSASSOCIATEDWITHTHEEXPECTEDLEVEL
4HERECOMMENDATIONSOFBOTHTHE3WITKOWSKIREPORTANDTHE3TERNREPORT OFCLIMATECHANGE7HETHERORNOTDEMOCRATICDECISIONMAKINGISCAPABLEOF
AREENTIRELYCONSISTENTWITHTHEREQUIREMENTOF!RTICLE 0ART6 OFTHE+YOTO FRAMINGSUCHSHORTTERMCHALLENGESINTHECONTEXTOFSUCHALONGTERMCON
0ROTOCOLWHICHSTATESTHATSIGNATORYCOUNTRIESSHALLIMPLEMENT SEQUENCEISYETTOBESEEN4HISISEXAMINEDINFURTHERDETAILIN3ECTION

0ROGRESSIVEREDUCTIONORPHASINGOUTOFMARKETIMPERFECTIONS lSCAL
INCENTIVES TAXANDDUTYEXEMPTIONSANDSUBSIDIESINALLGREENHOUSE
GASEMITTINGSECTORSTHATRUNCOUNTERTOTHEOBJECTIVEOFTHE#ONVEN
TIONANDAPPLICATIONOFMARKETINSTRUMENTS5.&### 

,IKEWISE THESE RECOMMENDATIONS ARE ENTIRELY CONSISTENT WITH TRADI


TIONALECONOMICS7RITINGSOONAFTER7ORLD7AR)) 0AUL3AMUELSON INONE
OFTHElRSTMODERNECONOMICSTEXTBOOKS STATES

THEEQUILIBRIUMOFACLOSEDECONOMYUNDERCOMPETITIONISCORRECT
EXCEPTWHERETHEREARETECHNOLOGICALEXTERNALECONOMIESORDISECON
OMIES 5NDER THESE CONDITIONS SINCE EACH INDIVIDUALS ACTIONS HAVE
EFFECTSONOTHERSWHICHHEDOESNOTTAKEINTOACCOUNTINMAKINGHIS
DECISION THEREISAPRIMAFACIECASEFORINTERVENTION3AMUELSON 
P EMPHASISINORIGINAL 
3%#4)/. 

3%#4)/. PROCESSIN!USTRALIA ANDINTURNFORTHOSEINTERESTEDINSOLVINGARANGEOF


ENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS ISNOTWHETHERGOVERNMENTSAREABLETOADJUSTTO
4HEPOLITICSOFECONOMICS CHANGINGCIRCUMSTANCESBUTWHYGOVERNMENTSREACTTOSOMECHANGESINCIR
CUMSTANCESANDNOTTOOTHERS
&URTHER WHYDOGOVERNMENTSTHATPROFESSAHIGHLEVELOFFAITHINTHEEFl
4HE SECTION ABOVE HIGHLIGHTS THE FACT THAT ENVIRONMENTAL DEGRADATION IS CIENCYOFMARKETPRICESTOSOLVEPROBLEMS INAREASSUCHASHEALTH EDUCA
CAUSEDBYTHEFAILUREOFPOLICYMAKERSTOIMPLEMENTNEWREGULATORYREGIMES TIONANDEVENTHEINCARCERATIONOFPRISONERSANDREFUGEES REFUSETORELYON
AS NEW PROBLEMS EMERGE AND RESOURCES THAT WERE ONCE ABUNDANT BECOME MARKETPRICINGMECHANISMSTOINCREASETHEEFlCIENCYOFTHEUSEOFWATER
INCREASINGLYSCARCE4HISSECTIONILLUSTRATESINWHATWAYTHEFAILUREOFTHE ENERGY TRANSPORTANDTIMBER)FPOLLUTERSWEREFORCEDTOPAYFORTHEDAMAGE
REGULATORYSTRUCTURESTORESPONDTOENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSISCAUSEDBYA THEYCAUSETOOTHERS THENTHEIRCOSTSWOULDRISE THEPRICESOFTHEIRPRODUCTS
LACK OF POLITICAL WILLINGNESS RATHER THAN BY ANY SHORTFALL IN ECONOMIC OR WOULD RISE AND CONSUMERS WOULD SWITCH TO LESS HARMFUL PRODUCTS %CO
POLICYKNOW HOW NOMICTHEORYSUGGESTSTHATTHISISTHEBESTWAYTODEALWITHPOLLUTANTS BUT
2EGULATORYSTRUCTURESIN!USTRALIAANDINOTHERDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESCAN ECONOMICRATIONALISTSRESISTSUCHPOLICIESIN!USTRALIA
AND DO CHANGE RAPIDLY 2ECENT EXAMPLES OF RAPID REGULATORY RESPONSES TO #ONSIDERTHEINCONSISTENTAPPROACHOFTHE.ATIONAL&ARMERS&EDERATION
EMERGINGPROBLEMSINCLUDE .&& TOTHEBENElTSOFAMARKETBASEDAPPROACHTOPOLICYPROBLEMS/NETHE
ONEHAND
s 4HEDECISIONTOALLOWEMBRYONICSTEMCELLRESEARCHINRESPONSETOPRES
SUREFROMTHEMEDICALCOMMUNITY &REE4RADEHASBEENAHARDSELL BUTITSTHEONLYWAYFORWARDnESPE
CIALLYFOR.37AND1UEENSLANDFARMERSWHOAREPROVIDINGTHEBULKOF
s 4HEPROVISIONOFREGULATORYPROTECTIONTONEWFORMSOF{PROPERTYSUCHAS
!USTRALIASHIGHVALUEAGRICULTURALEXPORTS4HEREISSIMPLYNOWORK
WEBADDRESSEESINRESPONSETOBUSINESSESWHOWANTEDTOUSETHEINTERNET
ABLE OR SUSTAINABLE ALTERNATIVE TO A MARKET ORIENTED ENVIRONMENT
FORCOMMERCE
.&&0RESIDENT0ETER#ORISH  
s 4HE DECISION TO EXCISE !USTRALIAN TERRITORY FROM IMMIGRATION LAWS IN
RESPONSETOINCREASEDNUMBERSOFAPPLICATIONSFORASYLUM "UTONTHEOTHER

s 4HERECENTDECISIONTOREVERSE!USTRALIASPOSITIONONTHEUSEOFNUCLEAR
.&&DOESNOTSUPPORTTHEINCLUSIONOFENVIRONMENTALIMPACTASPART
ENERGYANDTOALLOWTHEEXPORTATIONOFURANIUMTOCOUNTRIESWHICHARE
OFBESTPRACTICEPRICING7ATERPRICINGMUSTNOTBEUSEDASAPOLICY
NOTSIGNATORIESTOTHE.UCLEAR.ON 0ROLIFERATION4REATYINRESPONSETO
INSTRUMENTFORDELIVERINGENVIRONMENTALOUTCOMESORMODIFYINGTHE
CLIMATECHANGEAND
BEHAVIOUROFWATERUSERS0ETER#ORISH 
s 4HEDECISIONTOBANHANDGUNSANDHEAVILYRESTRICTTHEOWNERSHIPOFOTHER
lREARMSFOLLOWINGTHEMASSACREAT0ORT!RTHUR 4HE&EDERAL'OVERNMENTSVIEWSONTHEROLEOFGOVERNMENTINTERVENTION
EXHIBITSASIMILARDEGREEOFINCONSISTENCYINRELATIONTOTHEABILITYOFPARENTS
4HEINTERESTINGQUESTIONFORTHOSEINTERESTEDINUNDERSTANDINGTHEPOLICY TOMAKEDECISIONSABOUTWHATISINTHEBESTINTERESTOFTHEIRCHILDREN
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/.

7EVERECOGNISEDTHATTHEREISACONCERNFORYOUNGPARENTSWHOGETA EFFECTIVE AS BANNING CIGARETTE ADVERTISING HAS BEEN !LTERNATIVELY WHILE
VERYLARGESUMOFMONEYANDTHATITMAYBEMISUSED)NSOMEINSTANCES THEREISAPERCEIVEDPOLITICALBENElTINSUGGESTINGTHATSINGLEMOTHERSCANNOT
THEREHAVEBEENCONCERNSTHATTHEPARENTHAS INFACT HADOTHERSUSE MAKEGOODDECISIONSONBEHALFOFTHEIRCHILDREN THEREISNOINDUSTRYGROUP
THATMONEYONTHEIRBEHALF NOTTOTHEBENElTOFTHECHILD4HISISERR THATWOULDBENElTFROMARGUINGAGAINSTSUCHANINSULT
INGONTHESIDEOFBEINGMORERESPONSIBLEANDENSURINGINTHOSECASES 7HILEECONOMICRATIONALISTSARGUETHATSELFINTERESTISWHATDRIVESAMOD
WHEREWEHAVEYOUNGERMOTHERSTHEREARESAFEGUARDSINPLACETOPRO ERN ECONOMY THEY ARE TYPICALLY SILENT ON COMMUNITY IMPACT OF SELF INTER
TECT THE MOTHER AND TO PROTECT THE CHILD -AL "ROUGH -INISTER FOR ESTEDLOBBYINGFROMLARGEINDUSTRIESWHICHSEEKTOINmUENCETHEREGULATORY
&AMILIES   ENVIRONMENTINORDERTOMAXIMIZETHEIRPROlT
4HERE HAS BEEN LITTLE REAL SCRUTINY APPLIED TO !USTRALIAN GOVERNMENTS
(OWEVER (EALTH-INISTER4ONY!BBOTTTAKESADIFFERENTAPPROACHWHEN INCONSISTENTAPPROACHTOTHEBENElTSOFGOVERNMENTINTERVENTION4HISSTEMS
EXPLAININGWHYREGULATIONTOPREVENTJUNKFOODADVERTISINGAIMEDATCHIL LARGELY FROM THE FAILURE OF ECONOMISTS AND OTHER ANALYSTS TO INCORPORATE
DRENISNOTREQUIRED POLITICALFACTORSINTOTHEIRANALYSISOFGOVERNMENTPOLICY&OREXAMPLE THE
COALINDUSTRYHASOPPOSEDTHEINTRODUCTIONOFACARBONTAXWHILETHERENEW
4HEONLYPERSONRESPONSIBLEFORWHATGOESINTOMYMOUTHISME AND ABLEENERGYINDUSTRYHASSUPPORTEDONETODATETHECOALINDUSTRYHASPRE
THEONLYPEOPLEWHOARERESPONSIBLEFORWHATGOESINTOKIDSMOUTHS VAILED !N ANALYSIS OF RELATIVE POLITICAL INmUENCE PROVIDES A MUCH SIMPLER
ARE THE PARENTS 7HAT WE REALLY NEED IS MORE RESPONSIBLE DIETARY EXPLANATIONFORSUCHANOUTCOMETHANANYPURELYECONOMICANALYSISCOULD
BEHAVIOUR FROM PARENTS FROM INDIVIDUALS AND SCHOOL CANTEENS ) 4HEOTHERREASONTHATTHEINCONSISTENTAPPROACHTOTHEROLEOFREGULATION
WONTATTHISPOINTINTIME OR)SUSPECTDOWNTHETRACK BEDEMANDING IN!USTRALIAHASESCAPEDEFFECTIVESCRUTINYISTHEABUSEOFLANGUAGEINHERENT
THATTHEYBANADS4ONY!BBOTT  INTHEAPPLICATIONOFECONOMICRATIONALISM&OREXAMPLEWEARETOLDTHATTHE
!USTRALIANCARINDUSTRYNEEDSSUBSIDIESTOMAKEITINTERNATIONALLYCOMPETI
4HE &EDERAL 'OVERNMENT IS WILLING TO BE PRESCRIPTIVE AND INTERVENE IN TIVE7EAREALSOTOLDBYTHESAMEGOVERNMENTTHATSUBSIDIESINTHETEXTILE
RESPONSETOSOMECONSUMERBEHAVIOURYETITCITESAPREFERENCEFOR@FREEMAR INDUSTRYMUSTBEREMOVEDTOMAKEITINTERNATIONALLYCOMPETITIVE
KETSAND@INDIVIDUALRESPONSIBILITYWHENITCHOOSESNOTTOACT/VERPER 7E ARE TOLD THAT WE SHOULD NOT BAN OLD GROWTH LOGGING BECAUSE SOME
CENTOF!USTRALIANSAGREETHATTHEREISTOOMUCHADVERTISINGAIMEDATCHIL PEOPLE WILL LOSE THEIR JOBS BUT WE ARE TOLD BY THE SAME GOVERNMENTS THAT
DRENBUTTHE&EDERAL'OVERNMENTINSISTSTHATSUCHCONCERNSAREMISGUIDED UNFAIRDISMISSALLAWSMUSTBESCRAPPEDBECAUSEOTHERWISEITISTOODIFlCULTTO
7HILE A PREMISE OF ECONOMIC RATIONALISM IS THAT INDIVIDUALS KNOW BETTER SACKWORKERS
THANGOVERNMENTS WHENINDIVIDUALSEXPRESSAPREFERENCETHATISUNPALATA 7E ARE TOLD THAT IN ORDER TO GROW THE ECONOMY !USTRALIA MUST ALLOW
BLETOTHE'OVERNMENT THE'OVERNMENTFEELSFREETOSAYTHATITKNOWSBETTER MININGTHATDESTROYS!BORIGINALHERITAGEYETTHESAMEGOVERNMENTSCRITICISE
THANINDIVIDUALS 0APUA.EW'UINEAFORWANTINGTOMINENEARTHE+AKODA4RAILASSUCHACTIV
! SIMPLE WAY TO EXPLAIN THE APPARENTLY CONTRADICTORY APPROACH TO THE ITYWOULDDESTROY!USTRALIANHERITAGE
DESIRABILITYOFREGULATIONISTOCONSIDERWHICHGROUPSBENElTFROMREGULATION 4HE REAL POWER OF ECONOMIC RATIONALISM HAS BEEN IN THE SKILFUL USE OF
ANDWHICHGROUPSLOSEOUT4HEREISSTRONGINDUSTRYOPPOSITIONTOBANNING LANGUAGE7HENTHECIRCUMSTANCESSUIT ECONOMICARGUMENTSAREUSEDTO
JUNKFOODADVERTISINGPRESUMABLYBECAUSESUCHABANWOULDLIKELYTOBEAS DElNE THE SCOPE OF PROBLEMS AND WHEN THE CIRCUMSTANCES DO NOT SUIT THE
4/'%4(%2!4,!34

ALLEGED@ECONOMICRATIONALISTSRELYINSTEADONNATIONALISM PROTECTIONISMOR 3%#4)/.


COMMONSENSE2ATHERTHANACKNOWLEDGINGTHATSUCHSELECTIVEAPPLICATION
OFECONOMICRATIONALISMISINCONSISTENT THESEDOUBLESTANDARDSAREUSEDAS
7HERETOFROMHERE
EVIDENCETHATTHEADVOCATESOFECONOMICRATIONALISMAREANYTHINGBUTIDEO
LOGUES
4HELANGUAGEOFECONOMICSISANIMPORTANTPOLITICALTOOL4HEABILITYTO ,ANGUAGEISTHEARMORYOFTHEHUMANMIND ANDATONCECONTAINSTHETROPHIESOFITS
CONTROLTHEDElNITIONOFWORDSSUCHAS@EFlCIENCY @PRODUCTIVITY @COMPETI PASTANDTHEWEAPONSOFITSFUTURECONQUESTSˆH6BJ:AI6NADG8DA:G>9<:
TIVENESS @GROWTH AND EVEN @PROSPERITY PROVIDES A SUBSTANTIAL RHETORICAL
ADVANTAGETOINCUMBENTGOVERNMENTS )FNAMESARENOTCORRECT LANGUAGEWILLNOTBEINACCORDANCEWITHTHETRUTHOFTHINGS
4HOSEWHOOPPOSETHEPOLICYPRESCRIPTIONSOFTHEECONOMICRATIONALISTS ˆ8DC;J8>JH
ARE BYDElNITION OPPOSEDTOEFlCIENCY GROWTHANDPROSPERITY2HETORICALLY
BUTNOTLOGICALLY THOSEWHOOPPOSEECONOMICRATIONALISMARE BYDElNITION 7ASTING NATURAL RESOURCES IS NOT EFlCIENT 0EOPLE AND PRODUCTS STUCK ON
ECONOMICALLYIRRATIONAL CONGESTEDROADSARESIGNSOFANUNPRODUCTIVETRANSPORTSYSTEM3UBSIDIS
ING POLLUTING INDUSTRIES DOES NOT MAKE !USTRALIA COMPETITIVE 3PENDING
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS ON AIR CONDITIONERS TO PROTECT OURSELVES FROM CLIMATE
CHANGE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE GROWTH !ND A SOCIETY THAT CANNOT AFFORD TO
LEAVETHEPLANETINBETTERCONDITIONTHANITINHERITEDCANNOTBECONSIDERED
PROSPEROUS
4HEMEANINGOFWORDSSUCHASGROWTHANDEFlCIENCYHASBEENNARROWED
ALMOSTBEYONDRECOGNITION BUTTHESEWORDSRETAINTHEIRPERSUASIVEPOWER
!USTRALIANSWANTTOLIVEINASOCIETYTHATISIMPROVING4HEYWANTGOVERN
MENTSTHATWILLENHANCETHEIRQUALITYOFLIFE4HEYWANTPERSONALGROWTHAND
THEYWANTMOREVIBRANTSOCIETIESANDECONOMIES4HEYTAKEPRIDEINBEING
EFlCIENT PRODUCTIVEANDINTERNATIONALLYCOMPETITIVE7HYWOULDTHEYSUP
PORTPOLICIESTHATDELIVERDECLINEANDINEFlCIENCY7HYWOULDTHEYWANTTO
BEUNCOMPETITIVEONTHEWORLDSTAGE
4OECONOMISTS PRODUCINGTHESAMELEVELOFOUTPUTWITHFEWERHOURSOF
WORKISATRUESIGNOFEFlCIENCY3OISUSINGLESSENERGYANDWATERTOMAKEA
PRODUCTANDHAVINGATRANSPORTSYSTEMTHATALLOWSCOMMUTERSTOGETTOWORK
QUICKLYWHILEGOODSCANBEMOVEDQUICKLYACROSSANDBETWEENCITIES4HERE
IS NOTHING INEFlCIENT ABOUT MINIMIZING THE USE OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND
THEREISNOTHINGUNCOMPETITIVEABOUTMAKINGPOLLUTERSPAYFORTHEDAMAGE
THEYDOTOTHEENVIRONMENT
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/. 

4HEBROADCONCLUSIONSOFECONOMICSAREINHARMONYWITHTHEPERSONAL )DENTIFYINGTHEOBSTACLES
REmECTIONOFNON ECONOMISTSWHOEXPRESSDOUBT BUTSTRUGGLETOARTICULATE
CRITICISM OFTHEPOLICYPRESCRIPTIONSOFECONOMICRATIONALISM!NYSUCCESS 2ECLAIMING THE LANGUAGE OF ECONOMIC DEBATE IS A NECESSARY CONDITION FOR
FULATTEMPTTOREFORMULATEENVIRONMENTALPOLICYIN!USTRALIAMUSTINCLUDEA ACHIEVING REAL POLICY CHANGE BUT IT IS NOT SUFlCIENT TO ENSURE THAT SUCH
COHERENTSTRATEGYTOTAKEBACKCONTROLOFTHELANGUAGEOFHOPE3OMEEXAM CHANGEWILLOCCUR%NVIRONMENTALISTSWONTHEDEBATEOVERTHELANGUAGEOF
PLESFOLLOW SUSTAINABILITY WITHFEWGOVERNMENTSORBUSINESSESNOWWILLINGTOOPPOSE
)TISTIMETOREFRAMETHEDO GOODINGDESIRETOINCREASEENERGYEFlCIENCY THENEEDTOBECOME@MORESUSTAINABLE BUTTHISVICTORYOVERLANGUAGEHAS
ASTHESERIOUSTASKOFIMPROVINGENERGYPRODUCTIVITY7EMUSTENSURETHAT BEENACCOMPANIEDBYPOLICYDEFEAT-ININGCOMPANIESNOWPUBLISHREPORTS
BUSINESSESBECOMEMOREPRODUCTIVEBYINCREASINGTHEIROUTPUTWHILEREDUC ONTHEIRGROWINGSUSTAINABILITYTOACCOMPANYREPORTSONTHEIRRECORDEXTRAC
INGTHEIRENERGYUSE)TISTAKENFORGRANTEDTHATGOVERNMENTSHAVEAROLETO TIONOFFOSSILFUELSANDURANIUM
PLAY IN INCREASING LABOUR PRODUCTIVITY IT IS TIME THAT GOVERNMENTS WERE 2ECLAIMINGLANGUAGECANHELPBUILDPUBLICSUPPORTFORCHANGE#LEARER
MADEACCOUNTABLEFORTHEIRFAILURESTODRIVEENERGYPRODUCTIVITY LANGUAGE CAN ALSO HELP CLARIFY POLICY OBJECTIVES "UT SUCCESSFUL OUTCOMES
7EMUSTENSURETHATPROTECTINGTHEENVIRONMENTISSEENASIMPROVING REQUIRENOTJUSTNEWPOLICYGOALS BUTMECHANISMSFORACHIEVINGTHEM
OURNATIONALCOMPETITIVENESSRATHERTHANALLOWINGGOODENVIRONMENTALPOL !USTRALIALACKSTHEPOLITICALANDBUREAUCRATICSTRUCTUREFORDRIVINGENVI
ICYTOBEFRAMEDASSIMPLYANADDITIONALCOSTTOOUREXPORTINDUSTRIES!US RONMENTAL POLICY REFORM 3TATE AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENTS HAVE LEGISLATION
TRALIAISARICHCOUNTRYBUTITUSESASMUCHENERGYTOPRODUCEEACHDOLLARS ANDDEPARTMENTSDEDICATEDTOPROTECTING@THEENVIRONMENT BUTSUCHDEPART
WORTH OF '$0 AS DEVELOPING COUNTRIES SUCH AS #HINA )F !USTRALIA COULD MENTSDEDICATELITTLEORNORESOURCESTOENFORCEMENT!SASOCIETYWEDONOT
INCREASEITSENERGYPRODUCTIVITYTOTHELEVELOF*APANOR'ERMANYTHISWOULD RELYONLEGISLATIONANDCIVICMINDEDNESSTOPROTECTOURSELVESFROMDRINKDRIV
DELIVERASUBSTANTIALCOSTSAVINGTOEXPORTERSAND!USTRALIANCONSUMERS)N ERS WE SPEND HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS PAYING POLICE TO DETECT SUCH
ADDITIONTOLOWERINGlNANCIALCOSTSANDGREENHOUSEGASSES THEPURSUITOF BEHAVIOUR 3IMILARLY TAX LAW ALONE IS NOT EXPECTED TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE
SUCHENERGYPRODUCTIVITYWOULDSIGNIlCANTLYREDUCE!USTRALIASRELIANCEON RATHER THETHREATANDCONDUCTOFTAXAUDITSENSURESMOSTPEOPLETAKETAXLAW
IMPORTEDSOURCESOFENERGY SERIOUSLY
4HECREATIONANDDESTRUCTIONOFJOBSISINEVITABLEINAMARKETECONOMY 7HENITCOMESTOTHEENVIRONMENT HOWEVER WESIMPLYHOPETHATCIVIC
7HENGOVERNMENTSPRIVATISEBUSINESSESORREDUCETARIFFSWEARETOLDTHAT MINDEDNESSWILLPREVAIL
JOBLOSSES WHILEUNFORTUNATE AREANUNAVOIDABLECONSEQUENCEOFPOLICIES %NFORCEMENT OF EXISTING LAWS WOULD BE AN IMPROVEMENT ON THE STATUS
THATWILLIMPROVETHEOVERALLWELLBEINGOFALL!USTRALIANS(OWEVER CALLSTO QUO BUTITALSOWOULDNOTBESUFlCIENTINITSELF4HEBIGGESTENVIRONMENTAL
ENDOLDGROWTHLOGGINGORRICEFARMINGINDESERTSAREMOCKEDFORSUGGEST PROBLEMSARENOTCAUSEDBYTHELACKOFINVESTIGATIVERESOURCESDEDICATEDTO
INGSUCH@JOBDESTRUCTION)TSHOULDNEVERBEFORGOTTENTHATTHEECONOMIC PREVENTINGILLEGALLANDCLEARING ILLEGALlSHING ILLEGALWASTEDUMPSANDTHE
RATIONALISTS WHO ARE SO CONCERNED ABOUT JOBS IN LOGGING AND MINING ARE ILLEGALWATERHARVESTING4HEREALPROBLEMCOMESFROMTHESTRUCTUREOFTHE
THESAMEGROUPWHOSUPPORTEDTHEWHOLESALELOSSOFJOBSVIATHEINTRODUC POLITICALDECISIONMAKINGPROCESSTHATPLACESTHEENVIRONMENTATTHEPERIPH
TIONOF.ATIONAL#OMPETITION0OLICYINTHEEARLYS ERYOFDECISIONSCONCERNINGENERGY TRANSPORT TRADE DEVELOPMENTANDINDUS
TRYASSISTANCE
-INISTERS FOR THE %NVIRONMENT HAVE A ROLE TO PLAY IN ENVIRONMENTAL
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/.

POLICY BUTUNTILCENTRALAGENCIESSUCHAS0RIME-INISTERAND#ABINETAND POLITICAL ARGUMENT OVER LAND USE THAN CITY RESIDENTS ARE IN REGARD TO
4REASURYAREASCONCERNEDWITHTHEDEVELOPMENTOFACOHERENT GOVERNMENT WATER
WIDE APPROACHTOTHESOLUTIONOFENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSASTHEYCURRENTLY
AREINRELATIONTOECONOMICPROBLEMSTHEREISUNLIKELYTOBESIGNIlCANTPOLICY #REATINGNEWSTRUCTURES
PROGRESS
)NORDERTOACHIEVEGREATERINTEGRATIONOFENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSINTO 0OLICY CHANGE WILL NOT OCCUR IN !USTRALIA UNTIL THE POLITICAL BARRIERS TO
THEPOLICYPROCESSITISNECESSARYTOIDENTIFYTHEMAJOROBSTACLESTOSUCHINTE CHANGEHAVEBEENOVERCOME7ESHOULDNOTBESURPRISEDTHATPOWERCOMPA
GRATION$ESPITEDECADESOFDEBATE !USTRALIAISYETTOIMPLEMENTEFFECTIVE NIESARERELUCTANTTOPAYMOREFORTHEIRCOAL THATFARMERSARERELUCTANTTO
REFORMSTOTHEUSEOFOURENERGY WATER AGRICULTUREORTRANSPORTINDUSTRIES PAYMOREFORTHEIRWATERORTHATlSHERMANANDLOGGERSARERELUCTANTTOPAY
4HISFAILURECANBEBESTUNDERSTOODBYANALYZINGTHEPOLITICALOBSTACLESTO MOREFORTHElSHANDLOGSTHEYHARVEST"UTWESHOULDALSONOTLETSUCHSHORT
CHANGERATHERTHANBYREDOUBLINGEFFORTSTOCOLLECTMOREDATAONTHEBENE TERMSELF INTERESTDETERMINETHELONGRUNPOLICYSETTINGSFOR!USTRALIA
lTSOFREFORM !DDRESSING CLIMATE CHANGE AND OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS WILL
.UMEROUSGOVERNMENTINQUIRIES ATALLLEVELSOFGOVERNMENT HAVEREC REQUIRE SUBSTANTIAL CHANGES IN !USTRALIAN SOCIETY BUSINESS AND GOVERN
OMMENDEDTHATTRUCKSSHOULDBECHARGEDFORTHEDAMAGETHEYDOTOROADS MENT4HEBARRIERTOSUCHCHANGESISNOTOURWITBUTOURPOLITICALWILL4HE
THATRAILISAMOREEFlCIENTMEANSFORINTER CITYFREIGHTTRANSPORTTHATFARM INTRODUCTIONOFTHE'34HADASUBSTANTIALANDDIRECTIMPACTONEVERYBUSI
ERSNEEDTOPAYFORTHEFULLCOSTOFTHEWATERTHEYUSEANDTHATCOALlREDPOWER NESS AND EVERY CONSUMER IN !USTRALIA 4HE REMOVAL OF LEAD FROM PETROL
STATIONSNEEDTOPAYFORTHEDAMAGETHEYCAUSETOTHEENVIRONMENT$ESPITE REQUIRED THE CREATION OF A SEPARATE RElNING TRANSPORTATION AND STORAGE
THESE POLICIES lTTING NEATLY WITHIN THE ECONOMIC RATIONALIST WORLD VIEW OF INFRASTRUCTUREFORTHENEWFORMOFFUELASWELLASTHEREDESIGNOFEVERYPAS
{USERPAYSTHEYHAVEYETTOBEIMPLEMENTED SENGER VEHICLE SOLD IN !USTRALIA !USTRALIAN GOVERNMENTS KNOW HOW TO
4HE TRUCKING INDUSTRY IS OPPOSED TO DAMAGE BASED ROAD PRICING 4HIS CHANGE!USTRALIA
ENSURESTHATTHECOSTSOFROADS ANDROADREPAIRS ARECOVEREDBYTAXPAYERSIN 0ERHAPSTHEBESTEXAMPLEOFSUCHGOVERNMENTLEDCHANGEWASTHEINTRO
GENERAL4HEPUBLICPROVISIONOFHIGHQUALITYFREEWAYSBETWEENCITIESENSURES DUCTIONOF.ATIONAL#OMPETITION0OLICYBASEDONTHERECOMMENDATIONSOFTHE
THAT ROAD FREIGHT IS RELATIVELY CHEAP AND QUICK COMPARED TO RAIL FREIGHT (ILMER2EPORT4HE(ILMER2EPORTPROVIDESAUNIQUEMODELFORPOLICYCHANGE
WHEREASTHECOSTOFBUILDINGNEWFREIGHTLINESISEXPECTEDTOBEBORNEEXCLU IN!USTRALIA2EGARDLESSOFVIEWSABOUTTHEDESIRABILITYOFTHEPOLICYCHANGES
SIVELYBYTHEFREIGHTUSERS THATRESULTEDFROMIT THERESHOULDBENODOUBTABOUTTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFTHE
&ARMERSHAVEFOUGHTHARDTOENSURETHATTHEYDONOTHAVETOPAYFOR STRUCTURESTHATTHE(ILMER2EPORTRECOMMENDEDINDRIVINGSUCHCHANGES
THEFULLOPPORTUNITYCOSTOFTHEWATERTHATTHEYUSE7HENFARMLANDON 4HE (ILMER 2EPORT IS OFTEN WRONGLY CONSIDERED BY ITS CRITICS TO BE THE
CITY FRINGES IS LOST TO RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IT IS JUSTIFIED ON THE BASIS SOURCEOFECONOMICRATIONALISM/NTHECONTRARY THEIDEASBEHINDTHEREPORT
THATLANDISMUCHMOREVALUABLETOHOUSEHOLDSTHANITISTOFARMERS"UT HADBEENCIRCULATINGFORNEARLYTWODECADES4HEGENIUSOF&RED(ILMERAND
WHENTHESUGGESTIONISMADETHATSOMEFARMERSSHOULDSTOPUSINGSCARCE HIS#OMMISSIONWASTODEVISEAPLANTOOPERATIONALISETHOSEIDEAS
WATERBECAUSEITISOFHIGHERVALUETOOTHERFARMERSORTOCITYRESIDENTSTHE )TMUSTBEREMEMBEREDTHATINTHESTHEIDEATHATPATIENTSSHOULDBE
TERMSOFTHEDEBATEARESHIFTEDTOWARDS EQUITY HISTORYANDCULTURE4HE SEEN AS CUSTOMERS THAT CHARITIES SHOULD BE SEEN AS WELFARE PROVIDERS AND
ONLY DIFFERENCE IS THAT PROPERTY DEVELOPERS ARE BETTER PLACED TO WIN THE THAT SERVICES SUCH AS PRISONS COULD BE RUN IN ORDER TO MAKE A PROlT WERE
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/.

ANATHEMATO!USTRALIANSOCIETY4HEREWASSTRONGOPPOSITIONBYTHEPUBLIC 7HILE THE POLITICAL WILL FOR SUCH A PROJECT WOULD NEED TO BE BUILT FROM
BY THE UNIONS AND EVEN FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO THE (AWKE SCRATCH MUCH OF THE BUREAUCRATIC INFRASTRUCTURE IS ALREADY IN PLACE 4HE
+EATINGREFORMAGENDAOFPRIVATIZATIONANDDEREGULATION4HE(ILMERREPORT #OUNCILOF!USTRALIAN'OVERNMENT#/!' FOREXAMPLE ALREADYPROVIDESA
PROVIDEDABLUEPRINTFORANEWSETOFGOVERNMENTSTRUCTURESTOENSURETHAT FRAMEWORKFORDISCUSSIONANDDECISIONMAKINGBYTHE0RIME-INISTER THE
ANUNPOPULARREFORMAGENDAWASIMPLEMENTEDDESPITETHEWISHESOFPOWER 0REMIERSANDTHE0RESIDENTOFTHE,OCAL'OVERNMENT!SSOCIATION3IMILARLY
FULVESTEDINTERESTS IF THE BATTLE TO RECLAIM THE LANGUAGE OF PRODUCTIVITY AND EFlCIENCY CAN BE
)NBRIEF THE(ILMERREPORTIDENTIlEDTHEMAJOROBSTACLESTOCHANGEAND WON THENEXISTINGBODIESSUCHASTHE.ATIONAL#OMPETITION#OUNCIL ALONG
PROPOSEDMECHANISMSFOROVERCOMINGTHEM3OMECHANGESWERELEGISLATIVE WITHSTATEANDFEDERALTREASURIES CANBECHARGEDWITHTHETASKOFENSURING
BUTTHEMOSTEFFECTIVEMECHANISMSWERESTRUCTURALANDlNANCIAL3TATEAND THATTHEEFlCIENTUSEOFSCARCENATURALRESOURCESISRELENTLESSLYPURSUED3UCH
LOCALGOVERNMENTSWEREBRIBEDINTOPARTICIPATING WITHLARGEGRANTSBEING ATRANSFORMATIONMAYSEEMOPTIMISTIC BUTITISIMPORTANTTOREMEMBERTHAT
MADEBYTHE#OMMONWEALTHTOJURISDICTIONSWHICHMETSPECIlCTARGETS4HE THE0RODUCTIVITY#OMMISSIONGREWOUTOFTHEASHESOFTHE)NDUSTRIES!SSIST
.ATIONAL #OMPETITION #OUNCIL WAS ESTABLISHED TO BOTH DRIVE THE REFORM ANCE#OMMISSION
AGENDAANDTOSANCTIONSTATESWHICHWERENOTMEETINGTHEIRTARGETS3TATES &INALLY ITISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATWHILENEWMACHINERYOFGOVERNMENT
STILLRECEIVE@COMPETITIONPAYMENTSFROMTHE#OMMONWEALTHEACHYEARIN ISNEEDED ITMUSTBEACCOMPANIEDBYANEWPOLITICALCONSCIOUSNESS4HROUGH
EXCHANGEFORTHEIRONGOINGCOMMITMENTTOTHEREFORMPROCESSOUTLINEDIN OUTTHESANDS!USTRALIASAWTHEPROMINENCEOFECONOMICISSUESIN
THE(ILMER2EPORT3TATE4REASURERSHAVEBECOMEACCUSTOMEDTORECEIVING MEDIAANDPOLITICALDEBATERISEEXPONENTIALLY4HENIGHTLYNEWSNOWINFORMS
THESEPAYMENTSFROMTHE#OMMONWEALTHANDARERELUCTANTTORISKLOSINGA ALLGOODCITIZENSOFTHEPERFORMANCEOFTHE$OW*ONES THE!LL/RDSAND.IKKEI
SIGNIlCANTSOURCEOFREVENUEINORDERTOACCOMMODATETHEPOLITICALCONSID STOCKINDEXESDESPITETHEFACTTHATFEWPEOPLEHAVEANYIDEAWHATTHEYARE
ERATIONSOFOTHERSTATEMINISTERSWHOMAYPREFERTODRAGTHEIRFEET "UTWHATEVERYONENOWUNDERSTANDSFROMALLTHISEXPOSURETOSTOCKINDEXES
4HE(ILMER2EPORTSUCCEEDEDINBRINGINGANIDEOLOGICALPREFERENCEFOR ISTHATTHEECONOMYISIMPORTANT4HEREISNOREASONTHATDAILYWATERUSE
THEPRIVATEPROVISIONOFSERVICESINTOTHEHEARTOFDECISIONMAKINGATALL ENERGYUSEANDPUBLICTRANSPORTUSECOULDNOTBEPROVIDEDTOBOTHPOLITICIANS
LEVELSOFGOVERNMENT7HILEPASSAGEOFLEGISLATIONREQUIRINGCOMPETITIVE ANDTHEPUBLICTOINFORMTHEIRDAILYDECISIONMAKING4HENATURALENVIRON
TENDERINGFORGOVERNMENTSERVICECONTRACTSWASANIMPORTANTPARTOFTHIS MENTWILLONLYBETRULYSAFEWHENITHASBEENFULLYINTEGRATEDINTOTHEPUBLIC
ACHIEVEMENT THE PROVISION OF LARGE UP FRONT BRIBES TO PARTICIPANTS COM ANDPOLITICALCONSCIOUSNESS
BINEDWITHONGOINGlNANCIALSANCTIONSFORRECALCITRANTSTATEGOVERNMENTS 7ITHTHATINMINDITISIMPORTANTTORECOGNIZETHATIN!USTRALIATHEREIS
ENSUREDTHATTHESPIRITOFTHEREFORMAGENDAREMAINSCENTRALTOGOVERNMENT NO-INISTERFORTHE%CONOMY4HEREISA4REASURERWHOISPRIMARILYRESPON
DECISIONMAKINGPRACTICES SIBLE FOR TAXING AND A &INANCE -INISTER WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR SPENDING
7HAT!USTRALIANEEDSNOWISTHEENVIRONMENTALEQUIVALENTOFTHE(ILMER 4HEREARE)NDUSTRY-INISTERS %MPLOYMENT-INISTERS 4RADE-INISTERSAND
2EPORT4HEREAREALREADYMANYREPORTSDESCRIBINGTHENATUREOFTHEENVI !GRICULTURE-INISTERSWHOWOULDALLCLAIMTOBECENTRALLYCONCERNEDWITH
RONMENTALPOLICYREFORMSTHATARENEEDEDBUTTHEYNEEDTOBESYNTHESIZED DELIVERINGGOODECONOMICOUTCOMES)NTURN THE0RIME-INISTERWOULDSEE
INTOAREPORTTHATGOESONTOIDENTIFYTHEBARRIERSTOCHANGE PROPOSETHEMOST HIMSELFASHAVINGACENTRALROLEINDELIVERINGASTRONGECONOMY4HEPOINTIS
EFFECTIVE MECHANISMS FOR OVERCOMING EACH OBSTACLE AND SET OUT THE NEW THAT THERE IS NO ONE -INISTER WHO SPEAKS FOR THE ECONOMY BECAUSE ALL
MACHINERYOFGOVERNMENTNEEDEDTOINITIATEANDDRIVESUCHCHANGE -INISTERS INCLUDINGTHE%NVIRONMENT-INISTER SEETHEIRROLEASFOCUSEDON
 4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/.

ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE )F AS IS PLAIN THE ENVIRONMENT NEEDS PROTECTING %CONOMICTHEORYPROVIDESNOJUSTIlCATIONFORTHEPURSUITOF'$0GROWTH
THENPOLICYORPOLITICSISFAILING3HOULDTHEENVIRONMENTBECOMEASCENTRAL OVER THE PURSUIT OF INCREASED LEISURE )NDEED WHILE THE TH CENTURY
TODECISION MAKINGINTHENEXTYEARSASTHEECONOMYBECAMEINTHELAST BEGANWITHMOSTWORKERSHAVINGNOHOLIDAYS NOSICKPAYANDNOFORMAL
YEARSTHENITWILLNOLONGERNEEDLONEVOICESTO@SPEAKONITSBEHALF WEEKENDS THElRSTYEARSOFTHATCENTURYWASASTEADYMARCHTOWARDS
MORELEISURE)N!USTRALIATHATMARCHENDED WHILETHE7ESTERN%UROPE
3ETTINGTHERIGHTGOALS ANS HAVINGSTUCKTOTHEIRGOAL ARENOWAVERAGINGOVERWEEKSPAIDLEAVE
PERYEAR!USTRALIANSHAVEBEENTOLDTHATTHEPURSUITOFLEISUREWASUNPRO
%CONOMICS CAN DELIVER THE SOLUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE AS WELL AS A WIDE DUCTIVE INEFlCIENTANDMAKEUSUNCOMPETITIVE3UCHCLAIMSAREBASEDON
RANGE OF OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS 7HAT IS LACKING IS NOT THE KNOW THEPREFERENCESOFECONOMICRATIONALISTS NOTTHECONCLUSIONSOFECONOMIC
HOW BUTTHEPOLITICALWILLTOINITIATECHANGEANDTHEMACHINERYOFGOVERN THEORY
MENT TO DELIVER ON THAT WILL 4HIS ESSAY HAS ARGUED THAT IF THE BROAD %CONOMICTHEORYVIEWSINDIVIDUALPREFERENCESASSACROSANCT!FOUNDA
CONCLUSIONSOFECONOMICTHEORYARECOMBINEDWITHPOLITICALDESIRETOOVER TIONALPREMISEOFECONOMICRATIONALISMISTHATINDIVIDUALSKNOWBETTERTHAN
COMEOBSTACLESTOCHANGE THENEFFECTIVESOLUTIONSFORENVIRONMENTALPROB GOVERNMENTSWHATTHEYWANTFROMTHEIRLIVES9ETWHEN!USTRALIANSREPEAT
LEMSCANBERAPIDLYIMPLEMENTED EDLYSTATETHATTHEYWANTTOPAYMORETAXESTOFUNDBETTERHEALTHANDEDUCA
(OWEVER WHILETHEREISNODOUBTTHATECONOMICSSHOULDPLAYABROADER TION AND TO IMPROVE THE ENVIRONMENT THEY ARE TOLD THAT TO PURSUE SUCH
ROLEINTHEPOLICYFORMULATIONPROCESSTHEREISALSONODOUBTTHATECONOMICS PREFERENCESWOULDDESTROYTHEECONOMY!CCORDINGTOTHEECONOMICRATION
SHOULDPLAYAMUCHLESSSIGNIlCANTROLEINTHESETTINGOFNATIONALGOALS4HAT ALISTS 'OVERNMENTKNOWSBESTAFTERALL
IS ECONOMICSSHOULDPLAYABIGGERROLEINHELPINGUSACHIEVEOURNATIONAL )T IS IRONIC THAT ECONOMIC RATIONALISTS CITE THE NEED FOR !USTRALIANS TO
OBJECTIVES BUTITSHOULDPLAYAMUCHSMALLERROLEININmUENCINGWHATTHOSE SUBJUGATE THEIR PERSONAL PREFERENCES IN PURSUIT OF THE COLLECTIVE GOAL OF
OBJECTIVESSHOULDBE GREATERECONOMICGROWTH"UTINPOLITICS THEPRESENCEOFIRONYISNOBARRIER
-ANY !USTRALIANS WOULD RELY ON ADVICE FROM THEIR ACCOUNTANTS ABOUT TOBADPOLICY)F!USTRALIAISTOPLAYITSPARTINREDUCINGGLOBALWARMING AS
HOW TO ORGANIZE THEIR lNANCIAL AFFAIRS BUT THERE ARE UNLIKELY TO BE MANY WELLASSOLVINGAWIDERANGEOFENVIRONMENTALANDSOCIALPROBLEMSTHENIT
WHOWOULDCONSULTTHEIRACCOUNTANTSONHOWMUCHTHEYSHOULDSPENDON MUST EMBRACE THE FULL TOOLBOX OF ECONOMISTS )N EMPLOYING THOSE TOOLS
#HRISTMAS PRESENTS OR WHICH FAMILY MEMBERS SHOULD RECEIVE THE BIGGEST HOWEVER ITISESSENTIALTOWORKAROUND ORTHROUGH THEPOLITICALOBSTACLESTO
GIFTS CHANGETHATHAVEHALTEDTHEWORKOFREFORMTODATE"UTTHEGREATERRELIANCE
4HEROLEOFECONOMISTSINADEVELOPEDDEMOCRACYSHOULDBETHATOFFUNC ONECONOMICSTOSOLVEPROBLEMSMUSTBESEPARATEDFROMTHEPROCESSOFIDEN
TIONARY NOT THAT OF VISIONARY )T IS FOR THE !USTRALIAN PEOPLE THROUGH THE TIFYINGWHICHPROBLEMSNEEDTOBESOLVED)NTHATREGARD ALLCITIZENSVIEWS
!USTRALIAN0ARLIAMENT TOSAYWHATITISTHEYWANTTOACHIEVEANDITISFOR AREEQUAL
ECONOMISTSTOPROPOSEOPTIONS ANDTOCOMPARETHEALTERNATIVES FORACHIEV
INGSUCHOBJECTIVES
%UROPEANS WORK SHORTER HOURS AND HAVE LONGER HOLIDAYS THAN !US
TRALIANS AND !MERICANS !S A RESULT THEY HAVE LOWER ANNUAL INCOMES
%CONOMIC THEORY PROVIDES NO FOUNDATION FOR JUDGING SUCH PREFERENCES
4/'%4(%2!4,!34 3%#4)/. 

!NEWLANGUAGEOFECONOMICSnTHEPRINCIPLESOF%CONOMIC.EO 2ATIONALISM INEQUALITYCANBEJUSTIlEDIFITISACCOMPANIEDBYFASTERGROWTHISAMORAL


QUESTIONBESTANSWEREDDEMOCRATICALLY RATHERTHANANECONOMICQUES
7ENOWNEEDANEWLANGUAGEOFECONOMICSWHICHMIGHTBECALLED%CONOMIC TIONTOBEANSWEREDBYECONOMISTS
.EO RATIONALISM)TSPRINCIPLESSHOULDBE
 3OCIAL CULTURAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL OBJECTIVES ARE AS IMPORTANT AS THE
PURSUITOFECONOMICGROWTH7EALTHYCOUNTRIESCANAFFORDTOPURSUEA
 -ARKETS ARE A POWERFUL FORCE AND HAVE THE CAPACITY TO DRIVE EFlCIENCY
WIDERANGEOFENDEAVOURS ANDTHEROLEOFECONOMISTSISTOASSISTSOCIETY
ANDINNOVATION
INACHIEVINGTHEIRDEMOCRATICALLYDETERMINEDGOALS
 -ARKETFAILUREISCOMMONANDCANARISEFROMTHEEXISTENCEOFEXTERNALI
TIES DIFFERENCES IN BARGAINING POWER ASYMMETRIES IN INFORMATION AND
THEFAILUREOFDECISIONMAKERSTOCONSIDERFUTUREGENERATIONS

 7HENSIGNIlCANTMARKETFAILUREEXISTSTHEREISANIMPORTANTROLEFORGOV
ERNMENTINTERVENTION

 7HILEGOVERNMENTINTERVENTIONCANTAKEMANYFORMS ITISTHESPECIlC
CIRCUMSTANCESOFTHESPECIlCMARKET NOTTHEGENERALPREFERENCESOFANY
GROUP OF ECONOMISTS THAT SHOULD DETERMINE THE BEST FORM OF POLICY
RESPONSE

 )NDIVIDUALPREFERENCESSHOULDPLAYANIMPORTANTROLEINTHEALLOCATIONOF
RESOURCES BUTTHECAPACITYOFGOVERNMENTPOLICY ADVERTISINGANDMAR
KETINGTOEFFECTTHESEPREFERENCESSHOULDNOTBEIGNOREDBYPOLICYMAK
ERS

 )NDIVIDUALSAREBESTPLACEDTOMAKEVALUEDECISIONSABOUTWHATISBESTFOR
THEM BUTTHECAPACITYOFSOMEPEOPLETODECEIVEOTHERSINTOMAKINGDECI
SIONSTHATAREDEMONSTRABLYBADFORTHEMSHOULDNOTBEIGNOREDBYPOLICY
MAKERS

 )NDIVIDUALS HAVE THE CAPACITY TO THINK LONG TERM "UT POLICY DECISIONS
THATIMPROVETHEWELLBEINGOFTODAYSCITIZENSBYIMPOSINGCOSTSONFUTURE
GENERATIONS HOWEVERPOPULAR SHOULDBEAVOIDEDWHEREVERPOSSIBLE

 %QUITYISANIMPORTANTGOALINANDOFITSELF7HILEINDIVIDUALREWARDIS
AN IMPORTANT DRIVER OF INNOVATION AND EFFORT THE NOTION THAT GREATER
2EFERENCES ¥#OPYRIGHT2ICHARD$ENNISS 

!LLRIGHTSRESERVED

!BBOTT 4 CITEDIN@*UNKFOODBANRUNOFFROADHTTPWWWPARENT


0UBLISHEDBY
SJURYORGAUTPJ?BROWSEASP#ONTAINER)$JUNK?FOOD?BAN?RUN?OFF?ROAD 4HE!USTRALIAN#OLLABORATION
"ROUGH -  CITED IN @"ABY BONUS CHANGES TO STOP MISUSE BY TEEN 3T6INCENT0LACE !LBERT0ARK 6ICTORIA
MUMS HTTPWWWNEWSCOMAUSTORY    HTML 7EBSITEWWWAUSTRALIANCOLLABORATIONCOMAU

#ORISH 0 @&REETRADE THEWAYFORWARD -ARCH HTTPWWWNFF 


ORGAUPAGESPOLICIES?PRINTlLES/P%D?4RADE-ARCHPDF
)33. 
#ORISH 0 @.ATIONAL7ATERREFORMS 7ESTERN!USTRALIAN2URAL7ATER
5SERS 3UMMIT .ANNUP 7! 7EDNESDAY  $ECEMBER  HTTPNFF
4HEVIEWSEXPRESSEDINTHISESSAYTHEARETHOSEOFTHEAUTHORANDDONOTNECESSARILY
ORGAUPAGESSPEECHES.ANNUP3PEECH?0ETER#ORISHPDF REmECTTHEVIEWSOFTHE!USTRALIAN#OLLABORATIONORITSMEMBERORGANISATIONS
(OWARD * @3AFEGUARDINGTHEFUTURE!USTRALIASRESPONSETOCLIMATE
CHANGE 3TATEMENTBYTHE0RIME-INISTEROF!USTRALIA .OVEMBER
HTTPWWWPMGOVAUNEWSMEDIARELEASES'2%%.HTML
3AMUELSON 0 &OUNDATIONSOF%CONOMIC!NALYSIS (ARVARD5NIVERSITY
0RESS%NLARGEDED
3AMUELSON 0 %CONOMICS!N)NTRODUCTORY!NALYSIS -C'RAW (ILL
3TERN .  @3TERN 2EVIEW ON THE ECONOMICS OF CLIMATE CHANGE (-
4REASURY HTTPWWWLUNTREASURV OVUKINDE ENDENT REVIEWSSTER I EVIE
ECONOMICSCLIMATE?CHANEESTERNREVIEWREPORTCFH I
3WITKOWSKI : @5RANIUM-INING 0ROCESSINGAND.UCLEAR%NERGY
/PPORTUNITIESFOR!USTRALIA HTTPWWWDPMCGOVAUUMPNERREPORTSCFM
5.&###  +YOTO 0ROTOCOL TO THE 5NITED .ATIONS &RAMEWORK #ON
VENTIONON#LIMATE#HANGE HTTPWWWGLOBALWARMINGAWARENESSFOR
COMP