You are on page 1of 4

11/15/13

Why Do Women Fall for Serial Killers? | Psychology Today

College writing in the modern era has expanded in length and intellectual complexity.
Ray Williams

Home

Find a Therapist

Topic Streams

Get Help

Magazine

Tests

Psych Basics

Experts

Evolution of the Self


On the paradoxes of personality
by Leon F. Seltzer, Ph.D.

Why Do Women Fall for Serial Killers?


Women frequently betray a strong erotic preference for dominant males.
Published on April 24, 2012 by Leon F. Seltzer, Ph.D. in Evolution of the Self

Leon F. Seltzer, Ph.D., who holds doctorates in English and Psychology, is a clinical psychologist and author of Paradoxical Strategies in Psychotherapy. more...

Subscribe to Evolution of the Self

276
Like

StumbleUpon 26 195
Tw eet

3
Share

Subscribe via RSS

In her post, Women Who Love Serial Killers, PT blogger, Katherine Ramsland, offers some suggestions about why some women can be so attracted to, or hopelessly beguiled by, the most terrifying of human predators. At first, she provides explanations from the women themselves, women who actually married these dangerously unhinged criminals. Their reasons (somewhat elaborated here) include the assumptions that:
Charles Manson

their love can transform the convict: from cunning and cruel, to caring, concerned, and compassionate.

theres a wounded child nested somewhere inside the killer that can be healed through a devoted nurturance that only they can provide. they might share the killers media spotlight, and so triumphantly emerge from their anonymity, and maybe in the process even land a book or movie deal (an aspiration about as cynical as it is narcissistic and self-serving). Since these mostly self-deceptive notions derive from these womens conscious minds, we need to delve much deeper if were to grasp the subconscious motives driving such melodramatically aberrant behavior. And here I should mention that Ramsland notes that some experts in the field regard these women either as incapable of finding love in more normal ways, or as seeking a relationship that romantically can never be consummated (or, I might add, domesticated). Probably closer to the mark are other theorists she alludes to who hypothesize a more evolutionary (or Darwinian) motive, kindred to female primates regularly attracted to larger, louder, more aggressive males. Up just one level to the human species, we discover women drawn toward super-aggressive males who, presumably, can offer them much more status and protection than the average man.
See All Stories In

Evolution of the Self


Recent Posts
How can you recognize the fragility behind the narcissists grandiosity?

Why is physical beauty so important? And is it actually an aberration? Can striving for perfection be freely chosennot just compulsive behavior? Can you think your way to orgasm?

The Allure of the Bad Boy


Why do we love them?

Related Articles

What Id like to do in this post is expand further on the biological, sexual, and psychological dynamics that Ramsland only touches upon. After all, in trying to adequately account for a most peculiar (not to say, bizarre) female preference, it only makes sense to explore its origins on as many levels as possible. My key reference here is a recent, provocative book on male vs. female sexual brains entitled A Billion Wicked Thoughts: What the Worlds Largest Experiment Reveals About Human Desire, by computational neuroscientists Ogi Ogas and Sai Gaddam (Dutton, 2011). This comprehensive undertaking (with a bibliography containing over 1,300 items) analyzes enormous amounts of data extracted mostly from the Internet to come to conclusions that at times confirm earlier research in the area and almost as frequently contradict what previously had been inferred (thereby boldly turning a good deal of conventional wisdom on its

Whats the single best way to deal with frustrations in your relationship?
More of Evolution of the Self blog

Most Popular
Most Read Most Emailed

Night Owls and Early Risers Have Different Brain Structures


by Michael J. Breus, Ph.D.

www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evolution-the-self/201204/why-do-women-fall-serial-killers

1/4

11/15/13
Sexualpedia Part 4: Why do I Like Billionaires? From Beatlemania to Fifty Shades of Grey: Why Human Courtship Is a Social Event Paradox and Pragmatism in Womens Sexual Desire Our Greatest Source of Sexual Creativity What Do Shemale Porn and the Twilight Novels Have In Common?

Why Do Women Fall for Serial Killers? | Psychology Today


head). To simplify this works findings for my present purpose, however, let me begin by emphasizing that Ogas and Gaddam find substantial evidence from Web searches, posts, and many 1,000s of romance novels that women demonstrate a strong erotic preference for dominant men. Or toward whats now commonly referred to as alpha malesin the authors words, men who are strong, confident, [and] swaggering [as in cocky, and the pun is intended]. Unfortunately, what these descriptors often imply is behavior sufficiently bearish, selfcentered, and insensitive as to often cross the line into a physical, mental, and emotional abuse that can be downright brutal. Consciously, most women would like their men to be kind, empathic, understanding, and respectful. But theres something in their native wiring that makes a great many of them susceptible to bad boys. Possibly because, as the authors quote Angela Knight as reflecting (in a sentiment that echoes the conclusions of most evolutionary psychologists): [Their] inner cavewoman knows Doormat Man would become Sabertooth Tiger Lunch in short order (p .97). Moreover, in responding to the question as to whether some men, such as serial killers, violent offenders, and rapists," might be too dominant for women to accept, Ogas and Gaddam note: It turns out that killing people is an effective way to elicit the attention of many women: virtually every serial killer, including Ted Bundy, Charles Manson, and David Berkowitz, have received love letters from large numbers of female fans (p. 98). The fantasy that seems to be operating in such devotees, and that constitutes the plot of virtually all erotic/romantic novels written with women in mind, is that the misogyny and jerkdom they might have to battle with in such super-dominant males is only temporary. That it doesnt really represent the mans innermost reality. That his violence and lack of tender feelings is only the beginning of the story, and that their unsparing love, affection, and dedication can ultimately transform his character by helping him get in touch with his, well, inner goo. Its no coincidence that the whole genre of fictional romance is so hypnotically enticing to so many women thatsurprise, surprise!it actually outsells the pornography everywhere out there thats expressly designed to appeal to the male brain (which, alas, focuses far more on female body parts than anything pertaining to romance). Women regularly purchase an astronomical amount of romance fiction (and, more and more, anonymously through the Web). And what this suggests is that while those who fall for serial killers may represent a pathological exaggeration of a females erotic mind, many women (at least secretly, or subliminally) cant help but be drawn toward cold-blooded, controlling, bad boys whose dominance symbolizes quite the opposite of what in relationships theyre consciously seeking. (And here I should probably mention the astoundingly successful e-book and New York Times bestselling erotic fiction trilogy, Fifty Shades of Grey, which graphically depicts so many scenes of BDSM. The books phenomenal popularity doesnt at all relate to its originality or creative prose, but to its striking a powerfully erotic chord in so many of its readers.) As repeatedly demonstrated in romance novels, heroes arent simply strong but competent also the best at what they do. And, however ironically, serial killers seem to fit the bill in this respect, too. They may not be corporate CEOs or Hollywood movie stars, but theyre extraordinarily

2 3 4 5

Confronting the Worlds Great Unrecognized Crisis


by Guy P. Harrison

A Theory About Why the Powerful Don't Care For the Powerless
by Eric Horow itz

The Power of No
by Judith Sills, Ph.D.

Breaking Free: You Are Worth It


by Dr. Susan Biali, M.D.

Find a Therapist
Search for a mental health professional near you.

City or Zip

Find Local:
Acupuncturists Chiropractors Massage Therapists Dentists and more!

City or Zip

Current Issue
The Power of No
How setting limits sets you free. MORE FROM THIS ISSUE ISSUE ARCHIVES SUBSCRIBE

www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evolution-the-self/201204/why-do-women-fall-serial-killers

2/4

11/15/13

Why Do Women Fall for Serial Killers? | Psychology Today


skilled at annihilating people. Additionally, the combination of dominance and competence is typically linked to age. So it follows that those who are attracted to serial killers tend to be much younger than the violent criminals they find so alluring. Again, much of this might well go back to prehistoric times when it was crucial that women choose mates who could best provide for them and their children, as well as defend them from various external threats. In todays society, women typically are far more independent and have the freedom to choose a partner based primarily on mental and emotional (vs. physical or material) needs. But if their hardwiring predisposes them to be attracted to alpha males, modern-day rationality can still be offset by primordial instincts having little or nothing to do with reason. And, frankly, as a therapist Ive encountered many women who bemoaned their vulnerability toward dominant men who, consciously, they recognized were all wrong for them. What might also be noted here is that many women experience as enticing the idea of surrendering to a powerful male figure because of its very riskiness. Curiously, such an acutely felt threat can actually be eroticized by womens minds into exceptional sexual excitement so compelling that (at least on a fantasy level) its almost irresistible. (And see here my earlier post "Fear-Inspired Sex".) Add to this the captivating illusion that their special womanly qualities eventually will diffuse the mans aggression to the point that hell come to reveal his inner mushiness (the norm in romance fiction plots) and you have a recipe for real-life disaster. For theres much evidence suggesting that female brains are cued to set out on a mission to tame, heal, or soften the alpha heros wild heart (Ogas & Gaddam, p. 99). So, returning to the women who fall for serial killers, such distorted notions about love would seem a perfect set-up for the rudest of awakenings. But fortunately, though women may frequently entertain fantasies of such an impetuous romantic involvement, and be tantalizingly turned on by all its forbidden elements, very few are actually swayed by such primitive instincts. NOTE: Here are the titles and links to each segment of this 12-part series: What Brain Science Can Teach You About Sex The Triggers of Sexual Desire (Part 1for Males, & Part 2for Females) Paradox and Pragmatism in Women's Sexual Desire Internet Rule #34Or, What Sexual Interests Are Normal? You Can't Much Help What Turns You On The Secret, Taboo Aspects of Male Sexual Desire Why Do Women Fall for Serial Killers [which you just completed] Gay or Straight, A Male Is a Male Is a Male Dominant or Submissive?The Paradox of Control in Sexual Relationships Six Recent Innovations in Porn and Erotica Internet Porn: Its Problems, Perils, and Pitfulls 2012 Leon F. Seltzer, Ph.D. All Rights Reserved. ----I invite readers to join me on Facebookas well as follow my psychological/philosophical musings on Twitter.

Subscribe to Psychology Today now and get a free issue!


www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evolution-the-self/201204/why-do-women-fall-serial-killers 3/4

11/15/13

Why Do Women Fall for Serial Killers? | Psychology Today

13 Reader comments join the discussion here!

Follow Psychology Today:

Twitter

FaceBook

Copyright 1991-2013 Sussex Publishers, LLC

Copyright 2002-2013 Sussex Directories, Inc.

About/Contact Privacy Policy Site Help/Customer Service Terms of Use

Therapy Directory Index Healthprofs Index Buildingpros Index

www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evolution-the-self/201204/why-do-women-fall-serial-killers

4/4