You are on page 1of 4

Bombay High Court refers Vodafone share sale dispute to tax panel - The Economic Times

29/11/13 10:20 pm

Indiatimes | The Times of India | The Economic Times | More

| Log In | Join |

Like

1.4m

Follow

Telecom
New

Search for News, Stock Quotes & NAV's


In association with

Home

News

Markets

IPO

Personal Finance
News By Company

Mutual Funds
Economy

Tech

Jobs

Opinion

Features

Blogs

Slideshows

ET NOW ET Speed
PSU Press Releases
0

Top News

News By Industry NRI

Politics and Nation

International Business

Emerging Businesses

Other Press Releases


Auto Banking/Finance

Cons. Products

Energy

Ind'l Goods/Svs

Healthcare/Biotech

Jobs

Services

Media/Entertainment

ET Cetera

Telecom

Transportation 3

Education

Market Watch
04:00 PM | 29 Nov

SENSEX

NIFTY

Gold (MCX) (Rs/10g.)

USD/INR

20,791.93

257.02

6,176.10

84.25

30,192.0

33.0

62.44

0.02

Login to Track your Investment

VIEW MARKET

DASHBOARD

0
Share

You are here: ET Home News News By Industry Telecom

Hi there, Login with your Facebook ID to see what your friends are reading on Times of India and Economic Times.

Bombay High Court refers Vodafone share sale dispute to tax panel
By Maulik Vyas, ET Bureau | 29 Nov, 2013, 07.10PM IST
2 comments | Post a Comment

2
Share Share More

READ MORE ON Vodafone Group Plc | Tax | Hutchison Whampoa | Dispute Resolution Panel | Bombay high court

RELATED VIDEO
2 Post Your Comment

Retail Razzmatazz

MUMBAI: The Bombay High Court has directed British telecom giant Vodafone Realty Trends: Buzz in the sector Personal Finance: Things to know! Plc's Indian subsidiary to approach the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) with its petition against the Income Tax department's demand of Rs 1,300 crore. The court has given Vodafone two weeks to file its petition before the panel.

Power of Ideas

Bombay HC asked I-T dept to relook at Vodafone tax case

On Friday, the division bench comprising Chief Justice Mohit Shah and Justice MS GAP to come to India with Lodha Group buys property in Mis-sold insurance policy? Sanklecha disposing the petition filedwhat you can do Arvind Brands? London for Rswhile 3,120cr Heres Entering India may help the company claw The property known as McDonald House is Complaints from life insurance policyholders by Vodafone India Services (VISPL) back some of the ground it has lost to a stones throw from Buckingham about unfair business practice by directed DRP to give its Palace ruling within two Inditex, which dislodged Gap as the world's and will be converted into super-luxury companies have grown by over 67% in months of filing of the appeal.
largest clothing retailer. residences. 2012-13. IKEA looks to scale up furniture sourcing from India Indias top eight retailers say card payments on the rise

Online services prove biz for MMT, Quikr, Zom

The company, which has about

customers a month, also does b an additional fee. For them, the online services is endless.

Milestone Capital to raise Rs 500cr real How you can ease your parents financial Google launches Google Par Meanwhile, estate fund in Jan the court will hear the petition burden build ecosystem The Bombay HC told Vodafone to submit its objections to a tax Slump leaves many a hotel room empty; Lower EMIs on to car loans, processing fee After Facebook, Google sets filed by the Anglo Dutch oil major Shell claim the tax authorities' Dispute Resolution Panel. recovery only after polls waived to lure buyers portal in India

Plc's Indian subsidiary on December 11, where the Indian entity is facing a tax liability of about Rs 15,000 crore on similar grounds.

ET SPECIAL:
Save precious time tracking your investments

Most Read

Most Shared

Most Commented

Now Aadhaar link mandatory for card transacti... Delhi elections: AAP leader Arvind Kejriwal m... Gold price-fixing scandal: UK's FCA scrutinis... How steel can become the next oil for India Young B-School graduates give up dream jobs, ...

"The petitioner (Vodafone India) feels harassed because no opportunity was given to the company by revenue authorities," observed the division bench and said that the DRP will consider preliminary applicability of Chapter X (relating to the Transfer Pricing provisions) within 2 months. "The petitioner can approach court back if they have still any reservations." Income Tax department raised a red flag when Vodafone India issued shares to its Mauritius affiliate for Rs 246 crore at a fair market value of Rs 8,519 a share, for a transaction made during the assessment year 2008-09.

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-industry/telecom/vodafone-share-sale-dispute-to-tax-panel/articleshow/26589492.cms

Page 1 of 4

Bombay High Court refers Vodafone share sale dispute to tax panel - The Economic Times
More

29/11/13 10:20 pm

News in Pics

1/20

The tax department claimed that the fair market value was Rs 53, 775 a share. The differential amount is being sought to be taxed by the department as income in the hands of the company. "The court passed remarks on the manner in which tax proceedings took place" said Close X Dinesh Kanabar, Deputy CEO, KPMG India. "This is a very satisfactory ruling as court the has directed DRP to consider the preliminary matters on the basis of merits and a specific deadline has been set to deliver the Order. Vodafone has been given the liberty to Stay updated with latest news in telecom sector approach the Court thereafter, if needed," Kanabar added. Loading...

Hong Kong: Perfect place to experience East meets West

with our daily newsletter.Read what 10,000+ Industry Leaders everyday for tax free The DRP was set up in read 2009 to deal with income related transfer pricing disputes. It
Your email

was largely meant to sort out tax assessments of foreign firms. The transfer pricing is the Subscribe practice of arm's length pricing for transaction between group companies to ensure that a Invalid Emailis levied. fair price Thank you for subscribing to retail newsletter. We have sent a mail just "Prima facie, theyour share capital orby premium for of shares by an Indian now. Please conrm subscription clicking received on the link inissue the mail. company should be considered a capital receipt and not taxable in India," says Ravishankar Raghavan, Principal -Tax Group, at corporate law firm Majmudar & Partners. "What the tax department is trying to do is to bring that transaction into the transfer pricing ambit as an international transaction which includes capital financing, thereby making a transfer pricing adjustment." Transfer pricing provisions in a cross border transaction will not apply unless there is an 'income' which is arising in such transaction between two related enterprises where at least one of whom is a non-resident.
Rakhi Sawant says Baba Ramdev is hot and sexy

Most Watched Videos

"It will be interesting to wait for the finding of the DRP on whether the subscription to the share capital of the Vodafone Group entity in India resulted in any notional 'income' in the hands of the Indian entity," said Sanjay Sanghvi, Partner, Khaitan & Co.

Rakhi Sawant says Baba Ramdev is hot and...

First look: New Honda Mobilio MPV

SpeakAsia CEO Ram Sumiran Pal arrested


MORE FROM VIDEOS

More from The Economic Times Slide Shows


Sabarmati Riverfront project: Gujarat looks to promote tourism
Sabarmati Riverfront project is a project undertaken in order to promote tourism and preserve ...

More from the web


New Delhi hotel's most important marketing mechanism TripAdvisor How fuel efficiency is changing our transportation infrastructure Quartz Why Clients Don't Trust SEO - How to Overcome SEO's Bad Reputation Wallaroo
Media

If Homi Bhabha was honoured with Bharat Ratna, he wouldn't have left the!
17 Nov 2013

Delhi polls: AAP leader Prashant Bhushan's tea garden land buy raises storm 24 Nov 2013 Woman journalist quits Tehelka, blasts Shoma Chaudhary, Tarun Tejpal in! 26
Nov 2013

Ten upcoming car launches you would love to know about


Are you planning to buy a car? Consider these ten upcoming launches and facelifts before takin...

Viswanathan Anand made unusual blunders: Magnus Carlsen 23 Nov 2013

Big Data is Yesterdays News Integration Has Become Big Data 2.0 The
TIBCO Blog

Recommended by

Six start-ups that reached the Rs 1000 crore club


ET takes a look at six interesting start-ups that have managed to reach the Rs 1000 crore turn...
More Slideshows

AROUND THE WEB


Leaked - Renault India to launch new variations of Duster READ MORE ON Vodafone Group Plc | Tax | Hutchison Whampoa | Dispute Resolution Panel | Bombay high court

PREVIOUS STORY

NEXT STORY

Telecom Commission approves setting up Wi-fi hotspots in 2.5 lakh panchayats

Tata Teleservices launches WiFi enabled data card

Follow Economic Times Telecom Section, For The Latest News!


http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-industry/telecom/vodafone-share-sale-dispute-to-tax-panel/articleshow/26589492.cms Page 2 of 4

Bombay High Court refers Vodafone share sale dispute to tax panel - The Economic Times

29/11/13 10:20 pm

India to boycott South Africa tour?

Gavaskar's prestigious award to Sachin Tendulkar

Have something to say? Post your comment


Comments are moderated and will be allowed if they are about the topic and not abusive.

Your comment

Shocker - 1000 rupee note worth 3 and a half lakh online (slideshow)

Characters remaining (1500)

Readers' opinions (2)


Vinod Kambli hospitalised Condition serious
NEWEST OLDEST MOST DISCUSSED

Kasi Iyer Sheeravarneswaran Kasinathan (Chennai) 2 Hours ago


Exchange from: e-generator.com

Platinum: 45.3K Agree (0) Disagree (0) Recommend (0) Offensive

Bring the dispute to a closure sooner than latter so that the perception of investors change from negative to positive.The retrospective law is tantamount to changing the rule after the game is over.If the laws have loop holes,all will take advantage and instead of blaming the author of the law,why penalize who had used for his advantage.

Ramankutty Thekkumpurath (Pune) 3 Hours ago Bronze: 200

The subject is a hot potato to everybody.

Agree (0) Disagree (0) Recommend (0) Offensive

INFOCUS ON ET TODAY
TOP STORIES

Asian investors look to rare coins for big returns

Internal tensions: CFO and CIO exit from Tata AIA Life

Indias energy problem self-made: Roberto Zagha


"Indias energy problem is self-made. Appropriate use of infrastructure and resources can help in solving the problem," said Roberto Zagha.

UK shifts focus of lending program from housing to biz

Now, ministry wants to lower juvenile age

PERSONAL TECHNOLOGY

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-industry/telecom/vodafone-share-sale-dispute-to-tax-panel/articleshow/26589492.cms

Page 3 of 4

Bombay High Court refers Vodafone share sale dispute to tax panel - The Economic Times

29/11/13 10:20 pm

Ex-Nokia engineers launch new smartphone Jolla

ET review: HP Chromebook 14

Review: Nokia, HTC offer good, giant choices with Lumia 1520 and One Max

4G phones at reality in 18 m Broadcom

EMERGING ENTERPRISE

Indian entrepreneur Suresh Shankar launches Big Data site in Singapore Get a Quote
Type Company Name
Get Quote

Startup ventures grapple with pressures of hiring talent, finding clients

Play-i, startup on programmable robots by IIT alumni raises million dollars

Tips for wann entrepreneurs

Browse Companies
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Home | News | Markets | Personal Finance | Mutual Funds | Infotech | Jobs | Opinion | Features | Videos | My Portfolio | Budget 2013

Live Market

News

Portfolio

Mobile

Live TV

Newsletter

Commodities

Speed

QnA

Blogs

Alerts

Other Times Group news sites


Times of India | !"#$%&" '(!)* !"#$#%&" '(!)* | Mumbai Mirror Times Now | Indiatimes #+,(-. '(!)* | &/(-(01 '(!)* !"# $%&'$ | Lifehacker Gizmodo | Eisamay

Living and entertainment


Timescity | iDiva | Bollywood Zoom | Healthmeup | Luxpresso Technology | Guylife | Online Songs

Hot on the Web


Grand i10 Price | Online Shopping Movie Review Videos | Miss India Used Cars in Chandigarh | Bike Price India

Services
Book print ads | Online shopping | Free SMS | Website design | CRM | Tenders Matrimonial | Ringtones | Astrology | Jobs | Property | Buy car | Bikes in India Used Cars | Online Deals | Restaurants in Delhi | Movie Show Timings in Mumbai Remit to India | Buy Mobiles | Listen Songs

Networking
itimes | Dating & Chat | Email MensXP.com

About us / Advertise with us / Terms of Use and Grievance Redressal Policy / Privacy Policy / Feedback / Sitemap / Code of Ethics

Copyright 2013 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-industry/telecom/vodafone-share-sale-dispute-to-tax-panel/articleshow/26589492.cms

Page 4 of 4