You are on page 1of 6

Privacy and cookies

Log in

Register

Subscribe

Saturday 30 November 2013 | Home News World Sport Finance Comment Cult ure Trav el Life Women Fashion Luxury Tech Dat ing

UK News feed Offers Jobs

Politics

Inv estigations

Obits

Education

Earth

Science

Defence

Health

Scotland

Roy al

Celebrities

Weird

HOME NEWS UK NEWS

Combat tests 'watered down for women'


By Michael Sm ith, Defence Correspondent
12:00AM BST 26 Mar 2001

ARMY field trials designed to test the ability of women to serve in frontline combat units were so diluted that they amounted to little more than "aggressive camping", according to a senior officer who evaluated them. The exercises, a crucial part of the Army's "Combat Effectiveness Gender Study", have concluded that women are as capable as men of serving in combat units. However, Brig Seymour Monro, the Army's director of infantry, said this conclusion could only be reached because the tasks that women soldiers were not physically capable of performing had been made easier or dropped from the trials.

Share Facebook Tw itter Email LinkedIn 0

0 0 0

UK News New s

More From The Web

A scathing commentary on the trials, written by Brig Monro, had been suppressed by senior officers, defence sources said. He declined to comment on the issue yesterday. He said: "We have been told to keep our thoughts to ourselves while the whole thing is under review. But we have made our views clear to those above us and I understand they will be reflected in the study." The field trials are the key part of the Army's assessment programme which will determine whether women should be allowed to serve in frontline infantry, armoured and special forces units - the only ones they cannot join at present.
Related Articles

EXTERNAL LINKS

CNN Poll: More Down on St at e of Nat ion The Arm y Equal Opportunity Statem ent - The British Arm y Wom en's Roy al Arm y Corps The Com m ando Course Roy al Nav y Roy al Marines Britains Com m andos Civ v ie Street Equal Opportunities Roy al Air Force Wom en as Warriors in History - Lothene In UK News More From The Web Richard Simmons: Obamas 'Reject ed Me Tot ally ' Rov e: IRS Rules Take Aim at Conserv at iv es Bill Ay ers: I wrot e 'Dreams From My Fat her' Alec Baldwin: I'm Fired, Why Not Bashir? Do Y ou Approv e of Obama's Iran Deal? How t o Burn Thanksgiv ing Calories Twice as Fast Why Is FEMA Hoarding Surv iv al Food?

A woman could head military, says Hoon 22 Jan 2001 Women to join the front line 27 Jan 2001 Guthrie launches final assault on 'pc' forces 16 Feb 2001 Guthrie and Hoon clash head on over front line women 17 Feb 2001 Swearing ban for women's commando trainers 18 Feb 2001

A final recommendation is expected in the summer with ministers making the decision by the autumn. The practical trials took place over nine months last year. They were required to be "gender neutral", with the women expected to do the same as the men. The exercises did not include any heavy weapons or tanks, although there was live firing. The lack of tanks is seen as having diminished the value of the tests. The medical evidence uncovered during the study found that in strenuous situations women's bodies had to work 25 per cent harder than men's to achieve the same effect. Initially, the field trials stalled on the same problem. Women were not capable of a number of tasks under battlefield conditions, such as digging themselves in to hard ground under fire. One defence source said: "The girls could not do it. So they decided to reduce the level of the tests for everybody, which kept it gender neutral but meant that of course the girls did OK." The Ministry of Defence admitted that heavy weapons and tanks were

All Auctions In One Place


Search word, phrase or name of lot
SEARCH

Unleash your inner 007 with these spy gadgets

London sparkles at night

Ladies Platinum Brooch with Diamonds Made For Cowan's Auctions Marge Schott of The Cincinnati Reds

not used in the trials. "No attempt was made to replicate infantry battle conditions because, since women do not currently serve in the infantry, they are not trained as infantry. "The trials were designed to test physical ability, stamina and how women work together. They were not battlefield conditions and were never intended to be." Geoff Hoon, the Defence Secretary, has insisted that no decision will be made that damages operational effectiveness. Adml Sir Michael Boyce, the new Chief of Defence Staff, has also said he is "absolutely inflexible on the need to maintain operational capability". Sir Michael said: "Notwithstanding every field trial you do, the question you cannot answer is how is this person going to be when a mortar lands beside them or the shells are flying?" There were also concerns that women might not be aggressive enough to close with the enemy for hand-to-hand combat. This aggression was not a "natural female trait", said Sir Michael. The claim that the field trials were "dumbed down" comes on the day that three female soldiers begin the All-Arms Commando course at Lympstone, Devon. If they pass, it will give them the right to serve in the special forces units that support the Royal Marine Commandos and to

Cowan's Auctions 13 300


VIEW LOT!

See all auctions

Guinness World Records

News Most Viewed


TODAY PAST WEEK PAST MONTH

1. Mafia 'fed rival to pigs while he was still alive' 2. 'T eam Nigella's 1.2m bill on Charles Saatchis card' 3. Japan plans 250 mile solar panel belt around Moon 4. Allison Pearson: No one envies the Domestic Goddess now 5. Britain will pay 'severe price' if it quits EU, warns Sir John Major Victorian life in London

Must have Christmas toys

special forces units that support the Royal Marine Commandos and to wear the coveted green beret. Although they are not expected to succeed, there are concerns among some service officers that they may be pushed through the course in order to back up the calls for women to be allowed to fight on the front line.
Share 0 Facebook 0 Tw itter 0 LinkedIn 0 0

More from The Telegraph

More from the web

Concert pianist 'smooched' fan while fondling her teenage daughter at 21 Nov 2013 'Invisible pants': Who on earth would wear these? T hey're neither 26 Nov 2013 Egypt jails women protesters for 11 years 27
Nov 2013

Is Brooklyn Decker the Most Attractive Swimsuit Model in the World? StyleBistro Did Y ou Know T hese 20 Stars Are Gay?
Hollyscoop

How Caffeine Affects Y our Heart Health


Central

Wealthy Indian couple sentenced to life for slitting daughter and 26 Nov 2013 Why a cooked breakfast is good for you 29
Nov 2013

What Does a Rapid Heartbeat Mean? Local


Health

T he Ultimate Deep Diver The Boeing Company T he One Smell Women Cant Resist Nick Mom

Fear for house prices as 'estate resembles giant penis' when viewed 21 Nov 2013
what's this?

Ads By Google

Handgun Accuracy Secrets:


Avoid the 7 Deadly Sins of Handgun Accuracy:
w w w .InstantAccuracy.org

Navy VA Benefits
Dont Let Your Military Benefits Go To Waste. $0 Down - Up To $417,000!
w w w .VeteransUnited.com

More From The Web

Bad Food for Diabetes


Foods to eat & avoid to control blood sugar. From Today Show expert
w w w .JoyBauer.com

$139+: 4-Nt Bahamas Norwegian Sky Cruise l Reduced Deposit


Book Now & Save Click for More Offers

More from the web

Obituary describes woman as 'evil and violent'


(A r ca Ma x )

How Diet Soda is Destroying Y our Bones


(H ea lt h Cen t r a l)

MORE FROM TELEGRAPH.CO.UK


ARSENAL SUBSCRIBE DUNHILL TRAVEL DEALS BARNEBY'S AUCTIONS

Arsenal: latest news

Subscribe to the T elegraph for just 10 cents a day


View View

Search the best rates from the travel industry leaders all in one place now
View

T he auction revolution - buy a Munch, Picasso or a handbag online with Barnebys


View Back t o t op

HOME New s UK New s Politics Long Reads Wikileaks Jobs

World News Europe USA China Roy al Family News Celebrit y news Dating

Finance Education Defence Health Weird News Edit or's Choice Financial Serv ices Term s and Conditions

Pict ures Video Matt Alex Comment Blogs Crossw ord Today 's New s

Cont act Us Priv acy and Cookies Adv ertising Fantasy Football Ticket s Announcem ents Reader Prints Archiv e Sty le Book

Follow Us Apps Epaper Expat Prom otions Subscriber Sy ndication Weather Forecast

Copy r ig h t of T eleg r a ph Media Gr ou p Lim it ed 2 0 1 3