You are on page 1of 6
Software Verification CISC 95 Example 002 PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000 REVISION NO.: 0 W IDE F LANGE

Software Verification

CISC 95 Example 002

PROGRAM NAME:

SAP2000

REVISION NO.:

0

WIDE FLANGE MEMBER UNDER COMPRESSION & BENDING EXAMPLE DESCRIPTION

The frame object axial and moment strengths are tested in this example.

In this example a continuous column is subjected factored loads and moments C f = 2000 kN; M fx-top = 200 kN-m; M fx-bottom = 300 kN-m. This example was tested using theCSA S16-01 (CISC 95) steel frame design code. The design capacities are compared with Handbook of Steel construction (6 th Edition) results.

GEOMETRY, PROPERTIES AND LOADING

3.7 m

2000 kN

A

Mxf= 200 kN-m A W310x129 Mxf= 300 kN-m Section A-A
Mxf= 200 kN-m
A
W310x129
Mxf= 300 kN-m
Section A-A

Material Properties

Loading

Design Properties

E =

200,000 MPa

C f =

2000 kN

f y

= 300 MPa

ν =

0.3

M fx-top =

200 kN-m

 

G=

76,923.08 MPa

M fx-bottom =

300

kN-m

TECHNICAL FEATURES TESTED

  • Section Compactness Check (Compression & Bending)

  • Member Compression Capacity

  • Member Bending Capacity with no Mid-Span Loading

Software Verification R ESULTS C OMPARISON PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000 REVISION NO.: 0 Independent results are taken

Software Verification

RESULTS COMPARISON

PROGRAM NAME:

SAP2000

REVISION NO.:

0

Independent results are taken from Example 1 on page 4-108 of the Hand Book of Steel Construction to CSA S16-94 published by Canadian Institute of Steel Construction ..

     

Percent

Output Parameter

SAP2000

Independent

Difference

Compactness

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

Axial Capacity, C r (kN)

3797.3

3797.3

0.00%

Bending Capacity, M r33 (kN-m)

583.2

583.2

0.00%

COMPUTER FILE: CISC 95 EX002

CONCLUSION

The results show an acceptable comparison with the independent results.

Software Verification H AND C ALCULATION Properties: PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000 REVISION NO.: 0 Material: CSA G40.21

Software Verification

HAND CALCULATION

Properties:

PROGRAM NAME:

SAP2000

REVISION NO.:

0

Material: CSA G40.21 Grade 300W f y = 300 MPa E = 200,000 MPa G = 76923.08 MPa Section: W310x129 b f = 308 mm, t f = 20.6 mm, d = 318 mm, t w = 13.1 mm

h d

2

t

f

318

2

 

20.6

276.8

mm

A g = 16500 mm 2 r 33 = 136.626 mm, r 22 = 77.8499 mm I 22 = 100,000,000 mm 4 Z 33 = 2,160,000 mm 3 J = 2,130,000 mm 4

C

w

2.211 10

12

mm

6

Member:

l z = l e33 = l e22 = 3700 mm (unbraced length) k z =k 33 = k 22 =1.0

0.9

Loadings:

C

f

2000

kN

M

a

M

xf top

,

200

kN m

M

b

M

xf , bottom

300 kN m

Software Verification PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000 REVISION NO.: 0 Section Compactness: Localized Buckling for Flange: 145 145

Software Verification

PROGRAM NAME:

SAP2000

REVISION NO.:

0

Section Compactness:

Localized Buckling for Flange: 145 145     8.37 Cl .1 F 300 y
Localized Buckling for Flange:
145
145
 8.37
Cl .1
F
300
y
b
308
 
f
 7.48
2
t
2
20.6
  
f
Cl.1
, No localized flange buckling

Flange is Class 1.

Localized Buckling for Web:

300 16500  C  f A   4950 kN y y g 1000 1100
300 16500
C
f A
 4950 kN
y
y
g
1000
1100
C
1100 
1
0.39
f
1
Cl
.1
F
C
 
y
   
300  
y
276.8
 
21.13
t h
13.1
  
w
Cl.1
, No localized web buckling

0.39

 4950  
4950
 
  • 2000 53.50

Web is Class 1.

Section is Class 1

Member Compression Capacity:

Flexural Buckling n = 1.34 (wide flange section)

max(

 

22

,

33

)

22

k

  • 22 l

22

r 22

f y E
f
y
E

1.0

3700

77.8499

300 200000
300
200000

0.5859

Software Verification PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000 REVISION NO.: 0 C r   A F g y

Software Verification

PROGRAM NAME:

SAP2000

REVISION NO.:

0

C

r

A F

g

y

1

2 n

1

n

0.9 16500

300

1

0.5859

2

1.34

1

1.34

C  3797.3 kN r
C
 3797.3 kN
r

Section Bending Capacity:

M

p

33

Z

33

F

y

2,160,000

300

648

kN m

Member Bending Capacity:

 

M

 

M

b

200

300

2

 

M

 

M

b

200

300

2

1.75

2

1.75

So

2

2.5

M

 

2

u

l

22

 

M

2.5

u

M

3700

 

u

Since

M

u

M

r

33

1.15

M

r 33

 

1.05

1.05

  

M

1.15

0.9

a

0.3

  

0.3

  

a

2.5

 

2

2.583

2.5

EI GJ  C 22 22 w
EI
GJ 
C
22
22
w

E

2

22

l

I

8

  2  10 5  2 2  10 5   1 10
  2
10
5
2
2
10
5
 
1
10
76923.08
2.13
10
6
1
10
8
2.211
10
12
3700

3842.7039 kN m

  • 0.67 M

p 33

p 33

1

0.28

648

1

M

p

33

M

u

0.28

M

p 33

648

3842.7039

 

0.9

648

Software Verification M 639 r 33   583.2 M r 33  583.2 kN 

Software Verification

  • M 639

r 33

583.2

  • M r 33

583.2

kN m

PROGRAM NAME:

SAP2000

REVISION NO.:

0