You are on page 1of 16

First Appeal under section 19(1) of The Right to Information Act, 2005

Date: 5th Dec 2013. To, Vice Admiral HCS Bisht, AVSM, The First A ellate A!thorit" !#der $T% Act, Co#troller &erso##el Ser'ices, $oom (o. 2)1, %#te*rated Head+!arters Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce -(a'"., Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi 0 110011. Sir, As % am a**rie'ed 1" A!" #$%I&I'!( o, Ce#tral &!1lic %#,ormatio# 2,,icer, % here1" ,ile this a eal ,or "o!r 3i#d decisio#. 1. Details o, a 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.) 2. ella#t. : Shri. A 4 Mhatre : &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, : Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 : a'i#ash.mhatre5155<*mail.com : $T% cell, Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce : S= >! ta. Ca tai#8at8arms, C&%2 -(a'"., : %H? o, MoD -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011. : %H? o, MoD -(a'".,

F!ll (ame F!ll Address Mo1ile (o. ;mail %D

Details o, C&%2. 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.) (ame Desi*#atio# F!ll Address (ame o, &!1lic A!thorit" licatio# to C&%2. licatio#

3.

Details o, $T% a 3.1 3.2 3.3 Date o, A B"

: : :

20th Se t 2013. 2#li#e. 25th Se t 2013 thro!*h MoD6D-$T%.. : 2#li#e thro!*h SB% (et 1a#3i#*. : 7ith re,ere#ce to m" o#li#e $T% a licatio# 'ide ,ile #o. M2D;F6$620136@059: dtd. 9 th 2ct 2013 a#d ,or/arded to C&%2 (a'al H+rs., 'ide MoD %D (o. M2D;F6$62013-@059:.6D-$T%.

Date o, recei t 1" C&%2

). 5

&artic!lars o, a"me#t o, ,ili#* ,ee. Details o, i#,ormatio# so!*ht.

dated 1)th 2ct 2013 thro!*h MoD6D-$T%.. %t has 1ee# re+!ested to ro'ide the ,ollo/i#* i#,ormatio# 'ide ,ollo/i#* $T% +!eries:8 7hat is mea# 1" Doc3"ard Tem orar" Memora#d!m -DTM. i# %#dia# (a'". 7ho is a!thoriAed to iss!e a#d si*# s!ch DTM, /hat is the s!stai#a1ilit" 6 d!ra1ilit" o, DTM. 7hat is mea# 1" Doc3"ard &erma#e#t 2rder -D&2. i# %#dia# (a'". 7ho is a!thoriAed to iss!e a#d si*# s!ch D&2, /hat is the s!stai#a1ilit" 6 d!ra1ilit" o, D&2. Ho/ DTM B D&2 are im leme#ted6related ,or /el,are 6 romotio#s 6 Tra#s,ers etc o, De,e#ce Ci'ilia#s a1ide !#der CCS $!les, /or3i#* i# %#dia# (a'". C#der ro'iso o, /hich CCS $!les, s!ch DTM or D&2 circ!lated. Does s!ch DTM or D&2 s! ersede MoD, Do&BT or a#" CCS $!les i# %#dia# (a'". Does it re+!ired to 1e co#se#ted or to accord ermissio# o, %H? o, MoD -(a'". or MoD to iss!e a#d circ!late a#" DTM a#d D&2. @. $easo#s6*ro!#ds ,or this a @.1 @.2 eal. : C&%2 has #ot 1ee# ro'ided the i#,ormatio# !#der sectio# 5-:. o, $T% Act 2005 a#d C#der sectio# 19-e. /here % 1elie'e that % had 1ee# ro'ided /ith i#com lete i#,ormatio# !#der this Act. The artic!lars B +!eries 'ide $T% a licatio# /as acce ted 1" C&%2 a#d it is a**rie'ed to recei'e ,ollo/i#* re l" 1" the C&%2 -A##eD %%. recei'ed o# 5 th Dec 2013 :8 S eci,icall" /ith the ara E2E o, the a1o'e said re l" /hich sa"i#* F%t is i#timated that the i#,ormatio# so!*ht 1" "o! is #ot held at %H? MoD-(.. Go! are re+!ested to liaise /ith the co#cer#ed Doc3"ard ,or the re+!isite i#,ormatio#.H The a1o'e re l" is 'er" m!ch ,alse a#d i#correctI % ha'e so!*ht the re+!isite i#,ormatio# ,rom Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce to 3#o/ a1o!t the +!eries, ,!rther it /as tra#s,erred to C&%2-(a'"., /ho also ro'ided the a1o'e re l". &rima8,acie it mea#s 1oth MoD a#d %H? MoD-(a'". 1oth are #ot a/are o, the eDec!ti'e orders 1" #ome#clat!re li3e DTM - Doc3"ard Tem orar" Memora#d!m. a#d D&2 -Doc3"ard &erma#e#t 2rders. !sed i# %#dia# (a'" a#d other +!eries roJected to them thro!*h m" $T% a licatio#. Also it is d!t" o, C&%2 o tra#s,er the a licatio# !6s @-3. o, $T% Act 2005 or o o1tai# the i#,ormatio# ,rom its A&%2 6 s!18o,,ices, co#cer#ed Doc3"ards etc. 7hereas C&%2 strai*ht a/a" directed me to as3 the same ,rom co#cer#ed Doc3"ard -/hich % do#E 3#o/.

/hich is a act o, de ri'i#* me ,rom le*itimate i#,ormatio#. 5 &ra"er6relie, so!*ht ,or. 5.1 5.2 %#str!ct the C&%2, i# /riti#*, to *i'e complete and correct i#,ormatio# as re+!ested i# m" me#tio#ed $T% A licatio# as attached here/ith 0 A##eD %. %ss!e a /ritte# /ar#i#* to the C&%2, !#der the rese#t $!les a#d $e*!latio#s o, Ser'ice, i#str!cti#* him that he sho!ld adhere to the time limits s eci,ied i# the $T% Act 2005 as /ell as res ect the $T% Act i# its letter a#d s irit. %t is eD ected to ro'ide the re+!isite i#,ormatio# /ith tr!e s irit : G;S.

5.3 9. :.

&erso#al &rese#ce at heari#* ;#clos!res. 1. 2. &hotoco ies o, ori*i#al $T% a

licatio# to the C&%2 0 A##eD %.

&hotoco ies o, ori*i#al $T% re l" 1" the C&%2 0 A##eD %%.

10.

Declaratio#. % here1" state that the i#,ormatio# a#d artic!lars *i'e# a1o'e are tr!e to the 1est o, m" 3#o/led*e a#d 1elie,. % also declare that this matter is #ot re'io!sl" ,iled /ith a#" i#,ormatio# commissio# #or is e#di#* /ith a#" Co!rt or tri1!#al or a!thorit".

&lace: M!m1ai Date :

-A4 Mhatre. Si*#at!re o, a

ella#t

Applicant !ame #ate of receipt Te)t of Application

AV%(ASH 4AKMA( MHAT$; 2060:62013 The (a'al Doc3"ards6(S$Gs6(ADs6(A%s6(AGs a#d other i#d!strial esta1lishme#ts o, %#dia# (a'" -MoD. ha'e eDisti#* ,or re air, mai#te#a#ce a#d co#str!ctio# o, (a'al shi s a#d s!1mari#es. 1 %s there a#" MoD a!thoriAed ratio 1et/ee# artisa# sta,, -MTS, S=4, HS=8%%, HS=8% B MCM. a#d tech#ical s! er'isor" sta,, -Char*ema# B Forema#., eDisti#* i# (a'". 2 &ro'ide orders s! orti#* s!ch ratios also ro'ide !#it8/ise com leme#t sa#ctio# o, artisa# sta,, B tech#ical s! er'isor" sta,,. 3 7hat are the desi*#ated a#d (o#8desi*#ated tech#ical trades eDisti#* i# %#dia# (a'". ) %s there a#" cate*oriAatio# o, tech#ical trades o# the 1asis o, #at!re o, /or3,

ris3 i#'ol'eme#t B so histicatio#, ro'ide the list o, s!ch cate*oriAatio#. 5 Accordi#*l" is there a#" 'ariatio# o, ratio a#d ro ortio# 1et/ee# artisa# sta,, -MTS, S=4, HS=8%%, HS=8% B MCM. a#d tech#ical s! er'isor" sta,, -Char*ema# B Forema#., eDisti#* i# (a'". @ 7ho is the com ete#t a!thorit" ,or a#" re8allocatio# a#d ame#dme#ts o, ratio 1et/ee# artisa# sta,, -MTS, S=4, HS=8%%, HS=8% B MCM. a#d tech#ical s! er'isor" sta,, -Char*ema# B Forema#. o# the 1asis o, trades i# (a'", does (H? or MoD re+!ired to co#se#t. 5 7hat /ill 1e s!ch ratio 1et/ee# artisa# sta,, -MTS, S=4, HS=8%%, HS=8% B MCM. a#d tech#ical s! er'isor" sta,, -Char*ema# B Forema#. o# the 1asis o, trades i# (a'" roJected ,or #eDt 20 "ears.

Re*uest document (if doc!me#t #ot ro'ided any) $;?C;ST &HGS%CA44G T$A(SF;$$;D T2 2TH;$ &CB4%C &tatus ACTH2$%TG #ate of Action 2560:62013 Remar+s #etails of ,u-lic Authorit. /0 %#dia# (a'" i#al Stat!s o, M2D;F6$620136@0)90

Applicant !ame #ate of receipt

AV%(ASH 4AKMA( MHAT$; 1:60:62013 &ro'ide the ,ollo/i#* i#,ormatio#, total sa#ctio# a#d 1or#e stre#*ths o, Master Cra,tsma# -Artisa# cadre. i# e#tire Mi#istr" o, De,e#se -&lease i#cl!de all de artme#ts a#d directorates .. &ro'ide the stre#*ths de artme#t a#d directorate /ise.

Te)t of Application A#d total sa#ctio# a#d 1or#e stre#*ths o, Char*eme# -TSS Cadre. i# e#tire Mi#istr" o, De,e#se - lease i#cl!de all de artme#ts a#d directorates.. &ro'ide the stre#*ths de artme#t a#d directorate /ise. Re*uest document (if doc!me#t #ot ro'ided any) &tatus $;?C;ST F2$7A$D;D T2 C2(C;$(;D C&%2

#ate of Action Remar+s

2)60:62013 #etails of %,I' /0 (ote :8 Go! are ad'ised to co#tact the a1o'e me#tio#ed o,,icer ,or ,!rther details. M2D;F6$620136@0)@5

First Appeal under section 19(1) of The Right to Information Act, 2005
Date: 5th Dec 2013. To, Vice Admiral HCS Bisht, AVSM, The First A ellate A!thorit" !#der $T% Act, Co#troller &erso##el Ser'ices, $oom (o. 2)1, %#te*rated Head+!arters Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce -(a'"., Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi 0 110011. Sir, As % am a**rie'ed 1" A!" #$%I&I'!( o, Ce#tral &!1lic %#,ormatio# 2,,icer, % here1" ,ile this a eal ,or "o!r 3i#d decisio#.

1.

Details o, a 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.)

ella#t. : Shri. A 4 Mhatre : &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, : Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 : a'i#ash.mhatre5155<*mail.com : $T% cell, Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce : S= >! ta. Ca tai#8at8arms, C&%2 -(a'"., : %H? o, MoD -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011. : %H? o, MoD -(a'".,

F!ll (ame F!ll Address Mo1ile (o. ;mail %D

2.

Details o, C&%2. 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.) (ame Desi*#atio# F!ll Address (ame o, &!1lic A!thorit" licatio# to C&%2. licatio#

3.

Details o, $T% a 3.1 3.2 3.3 Date o, A B"

: 9th 2ct 2013. : 2#li#e. : 15th 2ct 2013 thro!*h MoD6D-$T%.. : 2#li#e thro!*h SB% (et 1a#3i#*. 'ide : 7ith re,ere#ce to m" o#li#e $T% a licatio# ,ile #o. M2D;F6$620136@059: dtd. 9th 2ct 2013 a#d ,or/arded to C&%2 (a'al H+rs., 'ide MoD %D (o. M2D;F6$62013-@059:.6D-$T%. dated 1) th 2ct 2013 thro!*h MoD6D-$T%.. %t has 1ee# re+!ested to ro'ide the ,ollo/i#* i#,ormatio# 'ide ,ollo/i#* $T% +!eries:8 7hat is mea# 1" Doc3"ard Memora#d!m -DTM. i# %#dia# (a'". Tem orar"

Date o, recei t 1" C&%2

). 5

&artic!lars o, a"me#t o, ,ili#* ,ee. Details o, i#,ormatio# so!*ht.

7ho is a!thoriAed to iss!e a#d si*# s!ch DTM, /hat is the s!stai#a1ilit" 6 d!ra1ilit" o, DTM. 7hat is mea# 1" Doc3"ard &erma#e#t 2rder -D&2. i# %#dia# (a'". 7ho is a!thoriAed to iss!e a#d si*# s!ch D&2, /hat is the s!stai#a1ilit" 6 d!ra1ilit" o, D&2. Ho/ DTM B D&2 are im leme#ted6related ,or /el,are 6 romotio#s 6 Tra#s,ers etc o, De,e#ce

Ci'ilia#s a1ide !#der CCS $!les, /or3i#* i# %#dia# (a'". C#der ro'iso o, /hich CCS $!les, s!ch DTM or D&2 circ!lated. Does s!ch DTM or D&2 s! ersede MoD, Do&BT or a#" CCS $!les i# %#dia# (a'". Does it re+!ired to 1e co#se#ted or to accord ermissio# o, %H? o, MoD -(a'". or MoD to iss!e a#d circ!late a#" DTM a#d D&2. @. $easo#s6*ro!#ds ,or this a @.1 @.2 eal. : C&%2 has #ot 1ee# ro'ided the i#,ormatio# !#der sectio# 5-:. o, $T% Act 2005 a#d C#der sectio# 19-e. /here % 1elie'e that % had 1ee# ro'ided /ith i#com lete i#,ormatio# !#der this Act. The artic!lars B +!eries 'ide $T% a licatio# /as acce ted 1" C&%2 a#d it is a**rie'ed to recei'e ,ollo/i#* re l" 1" the C&%2 -A##eD %%. recei'ed o# 5 th Dec 2013 :8 S eci,icall" /ith the ara E2E o, the a1o'e said re l" /hich sa"i#* F%t is i#timated that the i#,ormatio# so!*ht 1" "o! is #ot held at %H? MoD-(.. Go! are re+!ested to liaise /ith the co#cer#ed Doc3"ard ,or the re+!isite i#,ormatio#.H The a1o'e re l" is 'er" m!ch ,alse a#d i#correctI % ha'e so!*ht the re+!isite i#,ormatio# ,rom Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce to 3#o/ a1o!t the +!eries, ,!rther it /as tra#s,erred to C&%2-(a'"., /ho also ro'ided the a1o'e re l". &rima8,acie it mea#s 1oth MoD a#d %H? MoD-(a'". 1oth are #ot a/are o, the eDec!ti'e orders 1" #ome#clat!re li3e DTM - Doc3"ard Tem orar" Memora#d!m. a#d D&2 -Doc3"ard &erma#e#t 2rders. !sed i# %#dia# (a'" a#d other +!eries roJected to them thro!*h m" $T% a licatio#. Also it is d!t" o, C&%2 o tra#s,er the a licatio# !6s @-3. o, $T% Act 2005 or o o1tai# the i#,ormatio# ,rom its A&%2 6 s!18o,,ices, co#cer#ed Doc3"ards etc. 7hereas C&%2 strai*ht a/a" directed me to as3 the same ,rom co#cer#ed Doc3"ard -/hich % do#E 3#o/. /hich is a act o, de ri'i#* me ,rom le*itimate i#,ormatio#. 5 &ra"er6relie, so!*ht ,or. 5.1 5.2 %#str!ct the C&%2, i# /riti#*, to *i'e complete and correct i#,ormatio# as re+!ested i# m" me#tio#ed $T% A licatio# as attached here/ith 0 A##eD %. %ss!e a /ritte# /ar#i#* to the C&%2, !#der the rese#t $!les a#d $e*!latio#s o, Ser'ice, i#str!cti#* him that he sho!ld adhere to the time limits s eci,ied i# the $T% Act 2005 as /ell as res ect the $T% Act i# its letter a#d s irit. %t is eD ected to ro'ide the re+!isite i#,ormatio# /ith tr!e s irit : G;S.

5.3 9. :.

&erso#al &rese#ce at heari#* ;#clos!res. 1. &hotoco ies o, ori*i#al $T% a

licatio# to the C&%2 0 A##eD %.

2. 10.

&hotoco ies o, ori*i#al $T% re l" 1" the C&%2 0 A##eD %%.

Declaratio#. % here1" state that the i#,ormatio# a#d artic!lars *i'e# a1o'e are tr!e to the 1est o, m" 3#o/led*e a#d 1elie,. % also declare that this matter is #ot re'io!sl" ,iled /ith a#" i#,ormatio# commissio# #or is e#di#* /ith a#" Co!rt or tri1!#al or a!thorit".

&lace: M!m1ai Date :

-A4 Mhatre. Si*#at!re o, a

ella#t

First Appeal under section 19(1) of The Right to Information Act, 2005
Date: 11th Dec 2013. To, Vice Admiral HCS Bisht, AVSM, The First A ellate A!thorit" !#der $T% Act, Co#troller &erso##el Ser'ices, $oom (o. 2)1, %#te*rated Head+!arters Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce -(a'"., Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi 0 110011. Sir,

As % am a**rie'ed 1" A!" #$%I&I'!( o, Ce#tral &!1lic %#,ormatio# 2,,icer, % here1" ,ile this a eal ,or "o!r 3i#d decisio#. 1. Details o, a 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.) 2. ella#t. : Shri. A 4 Mhatre : &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, : Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 : a'i#ash.mhatre5155<*mail.com : $T% cell, Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce : S= >! ta. Ca tai#8at8arms, C&%2 -(a'"., : %H? o, MoD -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011. : %H? o, MoD -(a'".,

F!ll (ame F!ll Address Mo1ile (o. ;mail %D

Details o, C&%2. 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.) (ame Desi*#atio# F!ll Address (ame o, &!1lic A!thorit" licatio# to C&%2. licatio#

3.

Details o, $T% a 3.1 3.2 3.3 Date o, A B"

: :th 2ct 2013. : 2#li#e. : 21st 2ct 2013 thro!*h MoD6D-$T%.. : 2#li#e thro!*h SB% (et 1a#3i#*. 'ide : 7ith re,ere#ce to m" o#li#e $T% a licatio# ,ile #o. M2D;F6$620136@05:9 dtd. :th 2ct 2013 a#d ,or/arded to C&%2 (a'al H+rs., 'ide MoD %D (o. M2D;F6$62013-@05:9.6D-$T%. dated 15 th 2ct 2013 thro!*h MoD6D-$T%.. %t has 1ee# re+!ested to ro'ide the ,ollo/i#* i#,ormatio# 'ide ,ollo/i#* $T% +!eries:8 Ca# a#" MoD or (a'al a!thorit" recomme#ds 6com els to de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el -Char*ema# a#d Forema#. i# 'ie/ o, ce#tral ci'il ser'ice r!les 6 Ce#tral Acts, to /or3 on0-oard (a'al Shi or S!1mari#es -s eci,icall" d!ri#* Saili#* or i# trials.. &ro'ide the details o, ce#tral ci'il ser'ice r!les 6 Ce#tral Acts alo#* /ith the roced!re ,or de !ti#* de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el -Char*ema#

Date o, recei t 1" C&%2

). 5

&artic!lars o, a"me#t o, ,ili#* ,ee. Details o, i#,ormatio# so!*ht.

a#d Forema#. o#81oard Shi 6 s!1mari#e as o# o,,icial d!t". %# case a#" de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el de !ted on0-oard (a'al Shi 6 S!1mari#e, does he e#titled ,or ,acilities a#d all allo/a#ces at ar to ;+!i'ale#t $a#3 (a'al Ser'iceme#. %# case o, a#" !#,ort!#ate ,atal accide#t met to de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el de !ted o#81oard (a'al Shi 6 S!1mari#e, /ho is o# o,,icial d!ties, /hat are the medical, i#s!ra#ce com e#satio# allo/ed to him. Does he e#title to a'ail the *ro! i#s!ra#ce at ar to De,e#ce ser'iceme# @. $easo#s6*ro!#ds ,or this a @.1 @.2 @.3 eal. :

C&%2 has #ot 1ee# ro'ided the i#,ormatio# !#der sectio# 5-:. o, $T% Act 2005 a#d C#der sectio# 19-e. /here % 1elie'e that % had 1ee# ro'ided /ith i#com lete i#,ormatio# !#der this Act. The C&%2 did #ot res o#d to m" a licatio# /ithi# or 1e"o#d the sti !lated time limit, as re+!ired !6s 5-1. o, $T% Act 2005. %t is a**rie'ed to recei'e ,ollo/i#* +!er" /ise re l" 1" the C&%2 -A##eD %%. recei'ed o# 11th (o' 2013 :8 The comme#ts o,,ered L$e,ere#ce to "o!r a i#,ormatio# !#der $T% Act, 2005. licatio# dated 11.5.2013 see3i#*

The i#,ormatio# so!*ht e#!merated i# s!cceedi#* ara*ra hs:8 a. For +!er" -a.. Ci'ilia# &erso##el i# (a'" are re+!ired to do the d!ties ,or /hich the" are a oi#ted. 1. For +!er" -1.. Charters o, d!ties o, ci'ilia# erso##el i# (a'" are ,orm!lated 1" res ecti'e !#its. c. For +!er" -c.. ;#titleme#t o, ,acilities a#d allo/a#ces o, (a'al ci'ilia#s ca##ot 1e com ared /ith Ser'ice erso##el si#ce their co#ditio#s o, ser'ices are totall" di,,ere#t. d. For +!er" -d.. %# case o, ,atal accide#t o, ci'ilia# erso##el, ,ollo/i#* is admissi1le:8 -i. Com e#satio# as er 7or3me# Com e#satio# Ac -i# case o, i#d!strial ;m lo"ees.. -ii. ;D8>ratia l!m s!m com e#satio# to (o#8i#d!strial em lo"ees. -iii. %#s!ra#ce amo!#t as er Ce#tral >o'er#me#t ;m lo"ees >ro! %#s!ra#ce Scheme. -i'. &ost retireme#t 1e#e,its a#d e#ha#ced rate o, ,amil" *rat!it" !#der CCS -&e#sio#. $!les 1:52. e#sio# a#d

The a1o'e re l" is artic!larl" #ot i# 'ie/ o, the act!al +!er", it is re+!isite to ro'ide the a!thorities, r!les 6 acts im leme#ted ,or ,acilities a#d com e#sate /hile de !ti#* 6 de lo"i#* a#" de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el -Char*ema# a#d Forema#. em lo"ed ,or /or3sho s o, the co#cer#ed doc3"ard6shi "ard6de ots etc a#d i# 'ie/ o, the some ,atal accide#ts held o#81oard (a'al Shi a#d

S!1mari#es at shi "ards a#d d!ri#* saili#*s. 5 &ra"er6relie, so!*ht ,or. 5.1 5.2 %#str!ct the C&%2, i# /riti#*, to *i'e complete i#,ormatio# as re+!ested i# m" me#tio#ed $T% A licatio# as attached here/ith 0 A##eD %. %ss!e a /ritte# /ar#i#* to the C&%2, !#der the rese#t $!les a#d $e*!latio#s o, Ser'ice, i#str!cti#* him that he sho!ld adhere to the time limits s eci,ied i# the $T% Act 2005 as /ell as res ect the $T% Act i# its letter a#d s irit. %t is eD ected to ro'ide the re+!isite i#,ormatio# /ith tr!e s irit : G;S.

5.3 9. :.

&erso#al &rese#ce at heari#* ;#clos!res. 1. 2. &hotoco ies o, ori*i#al $T% a

licatio# to the C&%2 0 A##eD %.

&hotoco ies o, ori*i#al $T% re l" 1" the C&%2 0 A##eD %%.

10.

Declaratio#. % here1" state that the i#,ormatio# a#d artic!lars *i'e# a1o'e are tr!e to the 1est o, m" 3#o/led*e a#d 1elie,. % also declare that this matter is #ot re'io!sl" ,iled /ith a#" i#,ormatio# commissio# #or is e#di#* /ith a#" Co!rt or tri1!#al or a!thorit".

&lace: M!m1ai Date :

-A4 Mhatre. Si*#at!re o, a

ella#t

A((;KC$; FBH MSee r!le 5-1.N

Appeal under section 19(1) of the Right to Information Act, 2005


From: Shri. A 4 Mhatre, &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 To: Vice Admiral HCS Bist, AVSM A ellate A!thorit",

Co#troller &erso##el Ser'ices $oom (o. 2)1, %#te*rated Head+!arters Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011. 1 2 F!ll #ame o, the A Address ella#t : Shri. A 4 Mhatre : &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 : S= >! ta, Ca tai#8at8arms, The C&%2 -(a'"., %H? o, MoD -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011.

&artic!lars o, the Ce#tral &!1lic %#,ormatio# 2,,icer

) 5 @

Date o, recei t o, the order a ealed A*ai#st -i, order assed. 4ast date ,or ,ili#* the a eal : 1161262013 The *ro!#ds ,or a eal : C#satis,actor" a#d de'iated re l" to the s eci,ic +!er" as3ed thro!*h the $T% a licatio#. &artic!lars o, i#,ormatio# i. &artic!lars 6 S!1Ject o, i#,ormatio# 'ide &ara 3-i. o, $T% A licatio#s ii. (at!re a#d s!1Ject matter o, the i#,ormatio# re+!ired: iii. &artic!lars 6 S!1Ject o, i#,ormatio# 'ide &ara 3-iii. o, $T% A licatio#s :

5 9

%t has 1ee# re+!ested to ro'ide the ,ollo/i#* i#,ormatio# 'ide $T% +!eries:8 Ca# a#" MoD or (a'al a!thorit" recomme#ds 6com els to de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el -Char*ema# a#d Forema#. i# 'ie/ o, ce#tral ci'il ser'ice r!les 6 Ce#tral Acts, to /or3 on0-oard (a'al Shi or S!1mari#es -s eci,icall" d!ri#* Saili#* or i# trials.. &ro'ide the details o, ce#tral ci'il ser'ice r!les 6 Ce#tral Acts alo#* /ith the roced!re ,or de !ti#* de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el -Char*ema# a#d Forema#. o#8 1oard Shi 6 s!1mari#e as o# o,,icial d!t". %# case a#" de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el de !ted on0-oard (a'al Shi 6 S!1mari#e, does he e#titled ,or ,acilities a#d all

allo/a#ces at ar to ;+!i'ale#t $a#3 (a'al Ser'iceme#. %# case o, a#" !#,ort!#ate ,atal accide#t met to de,e#ce ci'ilia# erso##el de !ted o#81oard (a'al Shi 6 S!1mari#e, /ho is o# o,,icial d!ties, /hat are the medical, i#s!ra#ce com e#satio# allo/ed to him. Does he e#title to a'ail the *ro! i#s!ra#ce at ar to De,e#ce ser'iceme#. Comme#ts o,,ered The comme#ts o,,ered L$e,ere#ce to "o!r a licatio# dated 11.5.2013 see3i#* i#,ormatio# !#der $T% Act, 2005. The i#,ormatio# so!*ht e#!merated i# s!cceedi#* ara*ra hs:8 e. For +!er" -a.. Ci'ilia# &erso##el i# (a'" are re+!ired to do the d!ties ,or /hich the" are a oi#ted. ,. For +!er" -1.. Charters o, d!ties o, ci'ilia# erso##el i# (a'" are ,orm!lated 1" res ecti'e !#its. *. For +!er" -c.. ;#titleme#t o, ,acilities a#d allo/a#ces o, (a'al ci'ilia#s ca##ot 1e com ared /ith Ser'ice erso##el si#ce their co#ditio#s o, ser'ices are totall" di,,ere#t. h. For +!er" -d.. %# case o, ,atal accide#t o, ci'ilia# erso##el, ,ollo/i#* is admissi1le:8 -i. Com e#satio# as er 7or3me# Com e#satio# Ac -i# case o, i#d!strial ;m lo"ees.. -ii. ;D8>ratia l!m s!m com e#satio# to (o#8i#d!strial em lo"ees. -iii. %#s!ra#ce amo!#t as er Ce#tral >o'er#me#t ;m lo"ees >ro! %#s!ra#ce Scheme. -i'. &ost retireme#t 1e#e,its a#d e#ha#ced rate o, ,amil" e#sio# a#d *rat!it" !#der CCS -&e#sio#. $!les 1:52. (at!re a#d s!1Ject matter o, the i#,ormatio# re+!ired

There,ore it is re+!ired to a reciate the +!eries a#d their relatio# o, the re,erred MoD 2M, B it is eD ected to ro'ide the re+!isite i#,ormatio# /ith tr!e s irit. 1. (ame o, the 2,,ice or De artme#t to /hich the i#,ormatio# relates : 26o C>DA,

Cla# Batar $oad, &alam, Delhi Ca#tt 8 110010 &lace : M!m1ai Date : Se t 2012 Si*#at!re o, the A ella#t : ..................................

A((;KC$; FBH MSee r!le 5-1.N

Appeal under section 19(1) of the Right to Information Act, 2005


From: Shri. A 4 Mhatre, &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 To: Vice Admiral HCS Bist, AVSM A ellate A!thorit", Co#troller &erso##el Ser'ices $oom (o. 2)1, %#te*rated Head+!arters Mi#istr" o, De,e#ce -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011.

1 2

F!ll #ame o, the A Address

ella#t

: Shri. A 4 Mhatre : &55601, S&DC Colo#", Ma#3h!rd -7., M!m1ai8)00099, Mo1ile (o. 0:553103553 : S= >! ta, Ca tai#8at8arms, The C&%2 -(a'"., %H? o, MoD -(a'"., B8 7i#*, Se#a Bha'a#, (e/ Delhi8110011.

&artic!lars o, the Ce#tral &!1lic %#,ormatio# 2,,icer

) 5 @ 5 9 i. ii.

Date o, recei t o, the order a ealed A*ai#st -i, order assed. 4ast date ,or ,ili#* the a eal : 1160:62013 The *ro!#ds ,or a eal : C#satis,actor" a#d h" othetical re l" to the $T% a licatio#s /itho!t !#dersta#di#* the s!1Ject a#d clear8c!t B s eci,ic +!eries &artic!lars o, i#,ormatio# : 7ith re,ere#ce to m" $T% a licatio# dtd. 1160562013 &artic!lars 6 S!1Ject o, i#,ormatio# 'ide &ara 3-i. o, $T% A licatio#s (at!re a#d s!1Ject matter o, the i#,ormatio# re+!ired: Calc!latio# o, 2'ertime Allo/a#ces Char*ema# i# Mi#istr" o, De,e#se. ,or

The #at!re a#d s!1Ject matter o, the i#,ormatio# re+!ired /hich is *e#erated a#d !tiliAed /ithi# Mi#istr" o, De,e#se. %t is a act!al calc!latio# ,or the 2'ertime allo/a#ces to Char*ema# o, MoD.

iii.

&artic!lars 6 S!1Ject o, A,ter im leme#tatio# o, @th C&C, Mi#istr" had i#,ormatio# 'ide &ara 3-iii. o, iss!ed 2,,ice Memora#d!m to a" 2TA o# $T% A licatio#s re'ised rates to the em lo"ees /or3i#* i# De,e#se i#d!strial esta1lishme#t a#d it ma" 1e im leme#ted i# MoD thro!*ho!t the de artme#ts. Accordi#*l" /hat /ill 1e the re'ised 2TA rates ,or Char*ema# i# MoD, ro'ide the certi,ied co ies o, re'ised calc!latio# 6 Form!la ,or o'ertime Allo/a#ces -s eci,"i#* si#*le 6 do!1le ho!r 2T rates . to the L%hargemanO o, 2rd#a#ce Factories B %#dia# (a'" se aratel" ,or ,ollo/i#* Basic &a". Srl Basic &a" -$s.. >rade &a" -$s.. . 1 :300 )200 2 125)0 )200 3 125)0 )@00 ) 1@)00 )200 5 1@)00 )@00

Comme#ts o,,ered

L$e,ere#ce to "o!r a licatio# dated 11.5.2013 see3i#* i#,ormatio# !#der $T% Act, 2005. A co " o, #ecessar" clari,icatio# iss!ed 1" this Mi#istr" 'ides letter (o. 19-5.620096D -Ci'8%%. dated 22.05.2013 o# the admissi1ilit" o, 2TA is e#closed here/ithO. 02 2rders e#closed are 1. Mi#istr" o, De,e#se letter (o. 19-5.620096D-Ci'8%%. dated 22.05.2013 2. Mi#istr" o, De,e#se letter (o. 1)-1.6:56D-Ci'8%%. dated 01.05.1::9

(at!re a#d s!1Ject matter o, the i#,ormatio# re+!ired

There,ore it is re+!ired to a reciate the +!eries a#d their relatio# o, the re,erred MoD 2M, B it is eD ected to ro'ide the re+!isite i#,ormatio# /ith tr!e s irit. 1. (ame o, the 2,,ice or De artme#t to /hich the i#,ormatio# relates Cla# Batar $oad, &alam, Delhi Ca#tt 8 110010 &lace : M!m1ai Date : Se t 2012 Si*#at!re o, the A ella#t : .................................. : 26o C>DA,