You are on page 1of 5

' i"i *F: i r¿ jLl r H

i j i 1. .î" ]

DonaldEJ. KilnneqJr.,(SBN,{!PFq. 26 PTr2:02


',; S[:P
TA'WOTFICESOFDONÁT-DKILMËR
Co'rPoration
A Professional
løS Wilton'Strect,Suiæ150 - iil'lfìPifuh^
-r*tþ;;l'ït'R\:
SanJoEe,Catiforaia95L25-5l?o
rehohoáe' 40812ffi'El;89
Facsimile: 40812tu8Æ7
f-¡t¿it, Ðon@DKI'au¡Office'com
forPlaintift
AtûorneY

STaIESll¡srtfct
ÜFÍITED coÜRT
FOßTHE NORTEERNDISTNTCTOF CALIFORFMA

* |

trl No.:C 99 04389UIJJ


Case
RUS$ELLALLEI"INORDYKEand
13 SALLIEAT{NNORDYI(E,db¿TS TRADE PIIUNTIFÍ'S' NOTTCEand OBJECTTON
'ESSB. GTÍY,ÐUANB DARXI' ^-
ftnc.lnnnrcDnFrßtÐANIs-'
t4
SHOT¡I/S,
TfILLIAM J. JO¡IES,ÞAR]ILN. DAyIS*
ffiDFrrtÀRY ouÉÇTrorsAND
JEI\I\TI-ßF., MOTIONTO STKTIffi
TASIANATVERTYSCffiÍI-I,
l5 TODDBALTE$,ÐENMS BLAIR' R. t. IßCP ffidseq.
GOb)ADAT\dS, ROGERBAKEB"}'MIE
16 gdtpler 3' 20{16
ÈOU1T¡NTN andVIRGIL MCVTCKER' tearing llate¡ .
fi F.eeringlime¡ - o#0 A"lVÏ' -
Plaiotiffs,
18 Judgel iTlartfu¡J" Jenlnns
w. Courthouse: U"S,CourtHou¡e
19 450GoldenGsteAve.
IUARÏ V. KING, GAII STEBLEïVILIyIA $anFren*Ísco
2A California 941Û2
KEITIÍcAr*soN'scorÏ
CHAN,
2L IIAAGEßTY,TheCQ{Il.{llf OF
ATAIUEDAatrdTbeCOUNTYOF
22 ArÁfvlBDABoARDOFSUPERVISOR$'
Defendants-
23
24
Al'IÐ TFIBIRATf0RNEYS oF
25 To rHIs I{oNoR.ABtE coIJRT A}.ID DETENDANT$
26 RECORD:
wercsen¡edwitha
27 In addidonto Dsfendante'REPLYMËMORÆ'rÐIIM,-P1åintlffi
TO U¡IDTSPUTEÐ FATIS;
Poldlqt+ 7n IiIlEd:
dOCUMgNt DEFENDA}'ÏT$, RELEVAI*CEOBJECNONS
JlfúrÛoltttttr, æ
¡6{5Wltlo?¡t"flÐ
{5ImCåg5ltJ ãr^:-¡itf-t trta+J¡a. ç,viåa¡a'- anñ M/BttlkC
I AND EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONSTO AND MOTION TO STRIKE:(1) PLAINTIFFS'

2 EXPERTREPORT;AND (2) DECLARATIONSOF DONALD KILME& DARYL DAVIS,

3 DUANE DARR, JESSB. GITY,VIRGIL MCVICKER,MIKE FOURNIER,AND RUSSELL

4 wasserved14 davsbeforethe scheduled


AND SALLIE NORDYKE. This 40 pagedocuments

5 hearingin this mattersetfor October3,2006.

6 of this seconddocumentin ruling on


Plaintifß herebyobjectto the Court'sconsideration

7 the Motion for SummaryJudgment.

8 Defendant'sMotion to Strikeshouldbe summarilydeniedasit doesnot complywith the

9 setforth in Local Rule 7 -2. Plaintifß will havebeendeprivedof notice


noticerequirements

10 and an opportunityto heardif the Court takesthis untimely (40 page)motion to strike into

1l consideration
in ruling on the Defendants'Motion for SummaryJudgment.

t2 Furthermore,motionsfor summaryjudgmentarenot trials by affidavit. [See:United

l3 Statesv. OneTintorettoPainting, (2"dCir. 1982)691F.2d603, 6061Defendants'filing of

14 evidentiarytheseobjectionsanda motionto strikeat this stageof theproceedings,looksmore


l5 like a seriesof motionsin limine for a trial. FRCP56 andthe underlyingcaselaw requirethat

l6 the evidencepresentedon the motionbe viewedin the light most favorableto the opposing

t7 paÍty. "The evidenceof the non-movantis to be believed,and all justifiable inferencesareto be

l8 drawnin his favor."[See:Andersonv. LibertyLobby.Inc.,(1986)477 U.5.242,255]

19 Finally, thoughnot setforth in the PACERcivil docketreport,alongwith their

20 Plaintiffsconcurrentlyfiled the following documentswhich either


oppositionmemorandum,

2I provideevidentiarysupportfor the factssetforth in the Joint Statementof UndisputedFacts

22 and/orprovidesupportfor factsassertedin Plaintiffs' memorandumin oppositionascited

23 therein:

24 1. DECLARATION OF PLAINTIFFS' COUNSELDONALD KILMER RE:

25 TAPED INTERVIEV/SAT T.S. GUN SHOW AT SANTA CLARA COUNTY

26 FAIRGROLINDSAPRIL 819,2006andaccompanyingvideo.

27 2. DECLARATION OF DARYL DAVIS, Plaintiff.


Dotrsld KilEer
Attomey at Iåw 28 3. DECLARATION OF DUANE DARR. Plaintiff.
1645Willow St, #150
Su Jow, CA 95125
Yc:4081264-8489
Fxt408n6+8487 Nordvke v. Kine Page2of 4 Plaintiffs' Notice: EvidenceandlvfStike
DKI¿wOflice.@m
ü
ll
I 4. DECLARATION OF JESSGUY, Plaintiff.

2 5. DECLAIìr\TION OF VIRGIL McVICKER, Plaintiff.


a
J 6. DECLARATION OF MIKE FOURNIE& Plaintiff.

4 7. DECLARATIONSOF RUSSELLAND SALLIE NORDYKE, Plaintiffs.

5 8. COPIESOF THE DEPOSITIONSOF:

6 a. RandyC. Rossi,

7 b. IgnatiusChinn,

8 c. Rick K. Pickering.
9 9. Interrogatories
submittedto Defendantsandtheir Responses.

10 10. Requestsfor Admissionssubmittedto the Defendantsandtheir Responses.

ll 1 1 . Requestsfor Documentssubmittedto theDefendantsandtheir Responses.


t2

13 RESPECTFULLYSUBMITTED.

l4

15 Dated:September26, 2006
DonaldE. J. Kilmer, Jr.
t6 LAV/ OFFICESOF DONALD KILMER
A ProfessionalCorporation
t7 1645LincolnAvenue,Suite150
SanJose,California 95125
18 Phone:408/264-8489 Fax: 4081264-8487
E-Mail: Don@DKlawOffice.com
t9
Attorney for the Plaintiffs
20

2l

22

23

24

25

26

27
Donald K¡IEer
Attomey at Iåw 28
1645willow St.,#150
Sil Jose,CA 95125
Vc: 408/2ó¿L8,f89
Fx:448f26L8487 Nordvke v. King Page3 of 4 Plaintiffs' Notice: Evidenceand lvl/Strike
DKIáwOffice.@m
I Re: Nord)tkev. King
U.S.DistrictCourt.CaseNo. C 99 04389MJJ
2
PROOFOF SERVICE

I, Cally Van Drielen,declarethat I am employedin the City of SanJose,Countyof Santa


4
Clara,Stateof California. I am over the ageof 18yearsandnot a party to this action;my
5
businessaddress
is: 1645Willow Street;SanJose,California95125.
6
On September
26,2006,I servedthe followingdocuments:
7
l. PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE and OBJECTION REGARDING DEFEIIIDA¡ITS'
8 EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS AND MOTION TO STRIKE

9 on the following interestedparfy(s)in this action:

l0 SayreWeaver
T. PeterPierce
ll RICHARDS,WATSON & GERSHON
355 SouthGrandAvenue,40úFloor
12 Los Angeles,CA 90071-3101

t3 Fax: (213) 626-0078

t4 WA MAIL - CCP $$ 1031(al.2015.s

15 tXX] By placinga true copythereofenclosedin a sealedenvelope(s),addressed asstated


above,andplacingeachfor collectionandmailingon the datedfollowing ordinary
t6 businesspractices.I am readily familiar with my frrm's businesspracticeof collection
andprocessingof correspondence for mailingwith the United StatesPostalServiceand
t7 correspondence placedfor collectionandmailingwould be depositedwith theUnited
StatesPostalServiceat SanJose,California,with postagethereonfully prepaid,that
18 sameday in the ordinarycourseof business

1 9 VIA FACSIN{ILE
20 tXX] By faxing a true andcorrectcopy of the documentto the numberindicatedabovebefore
5:00p.m. on the datethis declarationwassigned.Seeattachedfax 1og.
2l
22
I declareunderpenaltyof perjury that the foregoingis true and correctandthatthis
23 declarationwasexecutedon September26,2006,at SanJose,Califomia.

24
25
26
27
DoualdK¡lmer
AttoEey at låw 28
ló45 W¡llowSt, #150
Sm Jose,CA 95125
Vq40En64-8489
Fx:408n64.8r'.87 Nordykev. Kine Page4 of 4 Plaintiffs' Notice: Evidenceandllf/Strike
DKIåEOfliæ.æm
TRANSMISSION
VERIFICATTONREPORT

TIME 89126/2øøEE9: L3
NAME LI4 ÙFC DONALDKILMER
FAX 488-99Ë-8487
TEL 448-998-S489
SER.# BRIA4J].84øøE

DATE,TIME ø 9 / 2 É 6 9 :L L
FAX N[. /NAME 1,2L36268ø78
DURATION Ø8:EL:49
PAGE(S) ø5
RESULT OK
MODE STANDARD