THE INDEPENDENT MONDAY 23 DECEMBER 2013

Elephant Appeal

ebooks

i Jobs

Dating

Shop

NEWS IMAGES VOICES SPORT TECH
UK World OFFERS Bus ines s People Science

LIFE

PROPERTY
Media

ARTS + ENTS TRAVEL MONEY
Education Images Obituaries

INDYBEST BLOGS STUDENT
Diary Corrections News letter Appeals

Environment

Technology

New s > Science

'Untrue statements' anger over work to make H5N1 bird-flu virus MORE dangerous to humans

E LE PH A N T A PPE A L D ON A T E N OW >
Go

Advanc ed Searc h

Artic le arc hive

Topic s

Most View ed

Most Com m ented

Most Shared

INDEPENDENT IMAGES

IN PICTURES: CHRISTMAS JUMPER DAY

SPONSORED FEATURES

Coalition of leading scientists claim ferret experiments could lead to a pandemic
INDEPENDENT PARTNERS

STEVE CONNOR

SCIENCE EDITOR Friday 20 December 2013

Beautiful gloves. Made in England.
P RINT
A

A

A

Some of the world's most eminent scientists have severely criticised the arguments used by some influenza researchers who are trying to make the H5N1 bird-flu virus more dangerous to humans by repeatedly infecting laboratory ferrets. More than 50 senior scientists from 14 countries, including three Nobel laureates and several fellows of the Royal Society, have written to the European Commission denouncing claims that the ferret experiments are necessary for the development of new flu vaccines and anti-viral drugs. T hey also said it is "untrue" to state that the new mutations in the laboratory strain of H5N1, which have enabled the bird-flu virus to be airborne transmissible between ferrets and, potentially, people, have

PEOPLE

Winslet reveals weirdest baby name of the year
The Titanic star and her husband Ned Rocknroll are currently nursing baby Bear (we know…) at their home in West

FINANCIAL GUIDES & REPORTS

25 Proven Strategies for T rading Options
Get Your Free Guide

Award winning trading platform from CitiFX Pro – Free T rial Find Out More

already been seen in nature. T he letter signed by 56 eminent scientists, many of whom are national science academicians, was designed to correct "misstatements" made by the president of the European Society of Virology, Professor Giorgio Palu, who they claim made "incorrect" assertions about the need to carry out the research in an earlier letter he had sent to the Commission. T he ferret research is being carried out by Ron Fouchier and colleagues at the Erasmus Medical Centre in Rotterdam. He has been involved in a legal dispute with the Dutch government which has insisted that he needs an export licence before his H5N1 work is published in a scientific journal. T he Dutch government claimed that the work to study the mutations needed to make H5N1 airborne transmissible between ferrets or people has a possible dual civil-military function and could be misused by bioterrorists. Meanwhile, Dr Fouchier has argued that an export licence hampers his academic freedom to publish the results of his experiments in the open scientific literature. Professor Palu wrote to the president of the European Commission in October to lobby for a change to the EU regulations covering export licences on behalf of Dr Fouchier, arguing that the Dutch scientist has already suffered from bureaucratic delays that have enabled other researchers in the US to publish before him and so claim priority. Professor Palu said that Dr Fouchier's "gain of function" experiments are designed to see what kind of mutations are necessary to enable the birdflu virus to be transmissible between mammals in order to make better vaccines and drugs, and that these mutations have already been seen in nature. "It has to be mentioned that, in this specific case, the 'gain of function' was used to reproduce what nature already selected (as demonstrated by sequencing of field mutants) with the variation that the aim of the study was to predict/anticipate biological evolution and to provide us with critical information to specify preventive and therapeutic measures," Professor Palu wrote. However, the letter from the 56 scientists, including Lord May of Oxford, a former government chief scientist, states that this assertion is wrong and gives a false impression about the medical need to undertake such dangerous research. "T he sole purpose of the experiments in question was to generate H5N1 viruses that could be transmitted between mammals as readily as seasonable flu via respiratory droplets ie coughing and sneezing," the letter says. "Despite intensive field surveillance conducted by national health authorities, government agencies, local and regional disease surveillance networks in Southeast Asia and elsewhere over a period of 16 years, there is no evidence that efficiently mammalian transmissible H5N1 viruses have ever emerged naturally in the wild," it says. "In summary, the statement that 'gain of function' was used to reproduce 'what nature already selected (as demonstrated by sequencing of field mutants)' is simply untrue," it adds. T he signatories of the letter, who include eminent virologists, microbiologists and vaccine experts, as well as Nobel laureates Sir Richard Roberts, Harald zur Hausen and Richard Ernst, warned that there

their home in West Sussex ELEPHANT APPEAL

25 Proven Strategies for T rading Options
Get Your Free Guide

Award winning trading platform from CitiFX Pro – Free T rial Find Out More

Get your hands on an original Chapman Brothers artwork
Bidding ends at 11am TODAY, with 22 great lots up for grabs VIDEO

Video: Dog meets Pluto on board Disney cruise ship
There was some festive cheer on board a Disney cruise liner when man's best friend made friends with a man dressed as a dog PEOPLE

Finance Business Analyst with Oracle Financials required!
£50000 - £55000 per annum + excellent company benefits: Pro-Recruitment Group:...

Assistant Corporate Accountant
£28000 - £32000 per annum: Pro-Recruitment Group: This leading research charit...

Dennis Rodman attempts to explain his friendship with Kim Jong Un...
...and what the hell he’s doing playing B ball in North Korea...

IP Litigation Solicitor
£68000 - £83000 per annum: Pro-Recruitment Group: IP Litigation Solicitor 2+ y...

BUSINESS ANALY ST- OPERATIONAL CHANGE, REGULATORY CHANGE, WEALTH MANAGEMENT
£450 - £550 per day: Cornwallis Elt : BUSINESS ANALYST- OPERATIONAL CHANGE, R... View the latest from iJobs

VIDEO

TECH

DAY IN A PAGE

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat 23 December 201 3 Go

Digging up the story of the 'worst game ever'
A documentary on Atari's E.T. video game flop is to debut on XBox Live TELEVISION

is a serious risk of an accidental release of a pandemic H5N1 virus from laboratories undertaking such research. "T he potential for accidental release of a hazardous pathogen is real, not hypothetical, as demonstrated by an alarming increase in the number of potential and actual release events in laboratories working with highthreat pathogens," they say. "We are in a situation where the probabilities of a laboratory accident that leads to global spread of an escaped mutated virus are small but finite, while the impact of global spread could be catastrophic," they add. Professor Palu was unavailable for comment. Miss Piggy vs Lady Gaga?
The Weekend’s TV: The Muppets and Lady Gaga at Christmas was a bit of a dry and understuffed turkey ELEPHANT APPEAL

Suggested Topics : Biology EU Scientists Schools

Research Nobel Prize

Microbiology

Vaccines

Higher Education

Elephant appeal: UK pledges £10m to fight illegal wildlife trade
Cash and commitment are vital to stop criminal gangs INDYBEST

10 best... tablet cases
Fashion-forward covers, whether for yourself or as a Christmas gift TELEVISION

Baddiel and Twitter
The comedian on how digital media influence his new show Sit.Com FILM

'Anchorman 2' held off by 'Hobbit' at US box office
FOOTBALL

Barkley lifts Toffees into top four and boosts England claims
Swansea City 1 Everton 2: Everton extend unbeaten run to 10 games VOICES

So Godfrey Bloom thinks Ukip has no policies?
Nigel Farage: Let me put him right NEWS

John Lewis sells one iPad every 10 seconds
Many high-street retailers have already begun cutting prices to attract shoppers PUZ Z LES AND GAMES

Let’s get quizzical
What really makes a quiz fizz - by The Independent's quizmaster OBITUARY

David Coleman: Sports commentator
Giant of British sports broadcasting who was at the top for four decades ART

Pauline Boty: A revival for this marginalised artist of British Pop Art
TELEVISION

12 million watch as Abbey Clancy is crowned Strictly Come Dancing champion
FASHION

Truly, madly, Dali
How fashion got surreal

Independent Travel Shop

Bruges by Eurostar Three nights from £259pp Find out more

All-inclusive Malta seven nights from £249pp Find out more

Pompeii, Capri and the Bay of Naples seven nights from £719 Find out more

Go

Advanced Search Article archive Topics

Terms & Policies Privacy Policy Cookie policy Code of Conduct Complaint form Email newsletters RSS

Contact Us Subscriptions Apps Work for us Evening Standard Homes & Property iJobs

Advertising Guide Syndication Novaya Gazeta (English) ES Business Connections ES Rentals © independent.co.uk