Panda Date: 06 July 2012 Venue: DG Shipping Internal: Capt. Saggi External: Capt.

Panda Atte pt: 2nd Appeared !"r !un#ti"n 1 $e%ult& Pa%%ed 1. A end ent% "! S"la% Ch ': ($I)* +,-AS* AIS 2. Prin#iple "! ($I). ($I) data #entre% in India: DG Shipping* .u /ai* Delhi* C"#hin i.e. t" %ay all ar"und Indian #"a%t. 0. Per!"r an#e %tandard% "! +,-AS. ("t "! #r"%% 1ue%ti"ning "n that "ti"n %en%"r% 2. .eaning "! E3,a4igati"n '. $elati"n "! E3,a4igati"n and ($I) 6. I! gyr" !ail% 5hat 5ill /e the e!!e#t "n ECDIS. 6"5 5ill u tran%!er p"%iti"n !r" ECDIS t" Paper Chart 7. Vari"u% eth"d% "! p"%iti"n !ixing 8. $ea%"n% !"r "#ean #urrent%* tidal %trea and tide% 9. -hy #urrent% "n 5e%tern %ide "! the "#ean% are %tr"nger than that "n ea%tern %ide 5ent "n !"r l"ng ti e "n thi% 10. Ve%%el in eye "! a )$S * -hat 5ill /e the 5eather li:e 11. $ea%"n% !"r !"r ati"n "! )$S* 5arning %ign% "! a )$S 12. V%l in danger"u% 1uadrant A#ti"n 10. ;u"te rule n" 6* 7* 8* 10* 12* 1'* and 19. ("t "! #r"%% 1ue%ti"ning "n rule n" 6 and 19 12. Apparently !"r5ard "! /ea %"und %ignal "! an"ther 4e%%el 5hat d"e% 5"rd apparently ean% 1'. Cr"%%ing %ituati"n and 4e%%el "4erta:ing in $V 16. Di!!eren#e /et5een %hip r"uting and %hip rep"rting 17. .a%ter in#apa#ited there i% an area "! high tra!!i# den%ity h"5 5ill u na4igate the 4e%%el 18. Steering !ailed a#ti"n 19. In and "ut "! E ergen#y t"5ing 20. V%l gr"unded a#ti"n 21. Syn"pti# and pr"gn"%i% #hart% 22. Ad4antage% "! ECDIS "4er paper #hart% date : 173"#t32010 4enue: DG %hipping Int : Capt Saggi Ext: Capt Panda All 1ue%ti"n% 5ere a%:ed /y Capt Panda $e%ult 3 P3P3P< appr"x 1.' h"ur%= >un#13 1=6"5 d" u #arry "ut V"yage planning in general and a% a #hie! "!!i#er 5hat all thing% t"

?#"ntent% and purp"%e? 8= An 5hi#h plate the de#: line<"! teh l"ad line%= i% dra5n? 9= -hat are %tringer%* #"!!in plate* %teeler plate%? 10= De!ine Pira#y?-hat i% .S+C? 0= 6ea4y li!t% and ("ad den%ity? 2= ("adi#at"r?<in general n"t %" deep= '= GBC heeling ar #ur4e? 6= 6"5 t" g" a/"ut l"ading C"n#entrate%? 7= Inta#t %ta/ility "! #arg" %hip% and tan:er%? 8= St"5age "! #arg" "n la%t %hip?<tan:er= 9= Ail tan:er "perati"n? 10= Shipping /ill% C +ill "! entry ?<%hipping /ill% 3 !"r #arg" exp"rted and /ill "! entry 3 !"r #arg" i p"rted ./e ta:en #are "!? 2=Di!!eren#e /et5een agneti# and gyr" #" pa%%e%? 0=Di!!eren#e /et5een terre%trial and #ele%tial p"%iti"n line%? 2=Di!!eren#e /et5een tidal %trea and #urrent? '=Ship@% r"utieng and 5eather r"utieng? 6=ECDIS* ra%ter and 4e#t"r #hart%? 7=Syn"pti# #hart%?6"5 t" !"re#a%t 5eather? 8=)r"pi#al re4"l4ing %t"r %? 9=.4 hind%hip 5a% tri ing %ta/ility pr"/le %= 12= Stre%%e% a#ting "n a %hip? >un#03 1= Statut"ry and andat"ry #erti!i#ate% 5ith eg? 2= (i%t "! %tatut"ry #erti!i#ate%? 0= PSC in%pe#ti"n* 5hy?preparati"n%?<he %aid there i% n" additi"nal preparati"n% needed a% the %hip i% already aintained in %ea5"rthyD #"nditi"n= 2= An#h"r dragging?A#ti"n% a% Chie! ate and in general? '= A#ti"n% t" ta:e in #a%e "! >"ul an#h"r? 6= -hat a#ti"n 5ill /e ta:en i! the #adet a:e% an "!!en#e?"r he d"e%nt !"ll"5 any parti#ular "rder? 7= IS.2010 ? and h"5 #hie! "!!i#er the %e#"nd in #" and th"ugh he d"e%nt ha4e a .ate% re#eipt? 10= Da age %ta/ility /"":let?Da age %ta/ility #riteria?)ri ing %ta/ility?<he %aid the #al#ulati"n% 5e did /y .S n"ti#e 01C2011 %ay a/"ut pira#y? 11= S)C."te "! pr"te%t? 12= +ill "! lading* .u"te $ule% 2*6*8*17*10*12*1' 10=$A$ %ituati"n%?(ight%? 11=-hy the 5e%tern #urrent% "! the earth i% "re %tr"nger than ea%tern part? Gul! %trea i% %tr"nger* 5hy? 12= IA(A /"uyage %y%te ? >un# 23 1= 6"5 t" g" a/"ut l"ading grain? 2= I.= 11= .)hi% i% 5hat he %aid.

A. 1 A.DAG = A))E.A.A( 3 CAP) PA. !"r e thi% #"n#ept 5a% ne5 and it did n"t at#h at all 5ith %u/ra /"": 9= gp% !ail% "n /"ard . he explained that there i% #y#li# r"ati"n "! the 5ater 5hi#h %et% in the 5ater %peed 8= 5hat i% up5elling < n"t %ati%!ied /y y an%5er= he explained /y dra5ing "n a paper h"5 up5elling "##ur%.E 3 EAS6I> 6A.00 t" 12:00 = e a% t"" .I> $A.GI(A VE.D 2 = Entered in a r"" "n 'th !l""r 5here "nly #apt Panda 5a% %itting.D EH)E$. 1ue%ti"n% are n"t in any "rder a% %tated /y any 1ue%ti"n% and t"pi#% 5ere #"4ered up.)E$.G DA)E 3 183JF(311 < . !"ll"5ing 1ue%ti"n% 5ere a%:ed.P) 3 2.EAPAA$ $ESF() 3 A(( C(EA$ 3 < >F.. %" in#rea%e teh %#ale in teh l"adi#at"r and then #he#: teh %tre%%e% i! they are a##epta/le at higher /eu!"rt %#ale 6= di!!eren#e /et5een #urrent and tide% 7= 5hat dri!t < n"t %ati%!ied /y y an%5er = he explained /y dra5ing "n paper .DA I.C)IA.a%ter% li#en%e= 12= 6ea4y 5eather pre#auti"n%? 10= Dryd"#:ing?Di!!erent type% "! dryd"#:%?h"5 t" d"#: a %hip tri ed /y head? 12= AAA?I% it triparty "r +iparty < )riparty 3 !"r indian %hip% a% Shipping a%ter i% al%" pre%ent al"ng 5ith a%ter and the #re5 and +iparty !"r !"riegn %hip% a% "n !"reign #" panie% there i% n" %hipping a%ter in4"l4ed and teh #"ntra#t i% %igned /et5een the #" pany and "!!i#erC#re5= 1'= Di!!eren#e /et5een C"de and C"n4enti"n? .FE 3 DG S6IPPI.A( 3 CAP) D. 1ue%ti"n% /y #apt panda < !r" !un#ti"n 1 1= h"5 5il u ta:e 5eather pre#auti"n% "n a 4"yage 2= detail% "n p"lar #"de 0= 5eather #riteria !"r %hip% 2= 5ith 5hat in%tru ent "n /"ard 5ill #hie! "!!i#er "nit"r e!!e#t "! 5eather "n the 4e%%el < l"adi#at"r = '= h"5 l"adi#at"r #an /e u%ed t" "nit"r %tre%% due t" /ad 5eather an%5er gi4en /y hi :3 l"adi#at"r %ea #"nditi"n i% gi4en !"r /eu!"rt %#ale 2. h"5 5il u #" e t" :n"5 "n e#di% < alar = 11.

E . $A$ A. VE$G S)$IC) I. i t"ld hi i 5"nt /e a/le t" 1u"te the rule /ut 5ud /e a/le t" %ay the !ull rule in the under%t""d 5ay.AEE A. i %aid i 5il try %ir.D $F(ES he :ept a/"ut ' "del% "! %hip% in !r"nt "! and an%5er !"r all the 4e%%el% gi4ing the y "del and t"ld e t" a%%e%% the %ituati"n %ituati"n 5ith all 4e%%el%* type "! a#ti"n i 5"uld ta:e * due t" 5hi#h rule* and then t" 1u"te the rule 5hate4er i u%ed in the %ituati"n.D >F.C)IA. 5hat 5il u d" ? < n"t %ati%!ied /y y an%5er = An%5er a% per hi 3 #hange t" paper #hart% * #" pare the %#ale "! the e#di% #hart and paper #hart* pl"t the dr "n the #hart* pl"t "5n #"ur%e !r" dr * #he#: !"r h"5 l"ng it i% %a!e t" #"ntinue "n that #"ur%e 11= h"5 d"e% a tr% !"r ? 12= in /ay "! /engal * 5here 5"uld a tr% de4el"p ? < anda an ni#"/ar = 10= 5hy 5il it de4el"p there ? 12= 5hat are #"n4e#ti"n #urrent% in !"r ati"n "! #l"ud% ? 1'= 5hat i% a %hip r"ueting %y%te ? $A$ )I. I A.IS)AEE A. he %aid that that i% n"t a##epta/le /y e. 1 IS AF) >A$ F.10= e#di% !ail%.E :3 6E )A(D F . u ha4e t" 1u"te the rule. 16= %ituati"n% in4"l4ed 3 a= #r"%%ing !r" p"rt /"5 3 r4 and n"r al /= !i%hing 4e%%el "n p"rt /"5 #= head"n %ituati"n d= %ailing 4e%%el "4erta:ing e= #r"%%ing !r" %t/d /"5 5ith %ailing 4e%%el "n %t/d /"5 "4erta:ing u% 17= rule% 1u"ated 3 6*10*12*1'*19 < /e%t i #"uld = 18= a%ter in!"r ed u that 4e%%el i% t" /e /ea#hed* a#ti"n a% #hie! "!!i#er ? 19= h"5 t" #al#ulate the %ta/ility "! the 4e%%el in thi% %ituati"n? < i didnt :ne5 = 3 he 5a% !ru%trated /y e at thi% p"int "! ti e 20= h"5 5"uld u #al#ute 4alue "! p 5hen dryd"#:ing? < i t"ld i d"nt :n"5 the !"r ula t" !ind "ut p at thi% p"int "! ti e = 21= h"5 d"e% the %ta/ilty "! teh 4e%%el i% e!!e#ted 5hen dryd"#:ing "! the 4e%%el? < i t"ld a/"ut 4irtual l"%% "! g a% 5eight "! p i% di%#harged 4irtually 5hen 4e%%el dryd"#:% = 22= 5hat i% di!!eren#e /et5een /ilging and da aged 4e%%el a/"4e 5aterline < i t"ld /ilged 4e%%el 5il #reate a l"%% "! /u"yan#y and .

0 < i t"ld it% 1 radian = 6= !r" the p"int %" #alled a% p"int "! #"ntra!lexture* he a%:ed e 5hat %hud /e the angle "n the x3axi% !"r it t" /e all"5a/le? <12 degree% = 7= tell e e4erything u :n"5 a/"ut ISGA)). '= 5hat i% tht angle '7.G )I(( . he 5a% t"tally pi%%ed "!! at e 5ith thi% p"int. i !"ll"5ed /y %aying that i a n"t t"" %ure "n h"5 that help% a:ing the #urrent% %tr"ngerK he replied F A$E . thi% p"int i% di!!erent !r" de#: edge i er%i"n p"int. he %aid that it thr"ugh p"int "! #"ntra!lexture.A) SF$E A+AF) A. he didnt agree 5ith e and t"ld e that all i% n"t al5ay% that that line 5il pa%% y #"n#ept% are t"tally 5r"ng.0 t" !ind "ut initial g .5ater plane area 5ill /e a!!e#ted and that 5"nt happen in da age 4e%%el a/"4e 5aterline= 3 he 5a% n"t %ati%!ied hi% an%5er :3 /ilging #an #au%e !l"5 "! 5ater in /"th dire#ti"n% in and "ut 5hile the "ther #an #au%e "nly ingre%% 20= prin#lipal "! gyr" #" pa%% 22= explain pre#i%%i"n and explain h"5 d"e% the "4e ent happen 5hen t"r1ue i% applied < he ga4e e a pen#il and t"le e t" explain = 2'= h"5 5il u a:e a gyr" n"rth %ee:ing ? < explained pre#i%%i"n in tilt and aIi uth and t"p hea4y /"tt" hea4y et# = 26= prin#ipal "! agenti# #" pa%% ? < tried t" explain /ut #"uld n"t %ati%!y hi = 27= #an agneti# #" pa%% u%ed in higher latitude? 28= rea%"n !"r n"t /eing u%ed? < i tried t" an%5er a% per nitin ahaJan 3 he g"t 5ild at e and t"ld e t" %t"p y n"n%en%e = 29= 5hy are #urrent% "n 5e%ter %ide% are %tr"nger than ea%ter %ide%? < 5e%tern inten%i!i#ati"n and #"ri"li% !"r#e . 3 he t"ld eu a:e "ne i%ta:e in thi% and .A-KK 00= pre#auti"n% !"r i#e na4igati"n? 01= 5hat happen% 5hen u u%e de3i#ing #" p"und ? < it pre4ent% i#e a##reti"n "n de#:% = 02= h"5 5ill u deter ine y"ur p"%iti"n in "pen %ea% 00= in 5hi#h rule d"e% it %ay D %#anty in!" %huld n"t /e u%ed D 02= di!!erent type% "! %hip rep"rting %y%te % in the 5"rld? 0'= rep"rt% t" /e %ent t" the ? !un#ti"n 2 1= grain l"ading pre#auti"n%? 2= %ta/ility re1uire ent% !"r grain l"ading? 0= inta#t %ta/ility re1uire ent% !"r n"r al %hip% 2= h"5 5il u !ind "ut the initial g "! the 4e%%el? a%:ed e t" dra5 teh graph "! gI #ur4e and explain 333 i dre5 a tangent !r" Ier" t" the p"int "! #"ntra!lexture 5here it rea#he% the 4erti#al line "! '7.G)6I.

)$AC) A. )I. a% it% n"t in pa#:aged !"r thi% i% all i #an re e /er 5hat #apt panda a%:ed.u 5il g" "ut "! thi% r""" !ailedK < i t"ld hi the part% "! i%g"tt and it% late%t a end ent% = 8= 5hat i% a ate% re#eipt? 9= 5hat i% a /ill "! lading? 10= 5hy /ill "! lading i% an EVIDE. %" /Cl i% n"t a #"ntra#t /ut an e4iden#e "! #"ntra#t 11= %e#uring arrange ent% !"r grain 12= "il l"aded "n a tan:er i% danger"u% g""d%?. e 1= 5hat d"e% ur !ather d"? 2= 5h" 5a% %a!ety "!!i#er "n ur la%t 4e%%el? 0= dutie% "! %a!ety "!!i#er 2= dutie% "! %a!ety "!!i#er 5hile #arg" 5"r: i% g"ing "n '= h"5 5il u g" a/"ut l"ading in a /ul: #arrier.A) A CA.< i %aid n" . !inally he t"ld e that he 5ant% t" gi4e e a /ene!it "! d"u/t and pa%% e in /"th !un#ti"n% /ut then re%t 5"uld depend "n internal. #ud n"t #"4er all the i p p"int%= he didnt %ee happy 5ith thi% 6= l"ading hea4y li!t% < i did n"t enti"n that i 5il #he#: all the gear a%%"#iated 5ith pi#:ing up the hea4y li!e= he %aid that 5hy u %traight Ju ping t" the %ta/ility and l"%% "! g 5ith"ut #he#:ing the gear% and r"pe% !"r pi#:ing up the hea4y .)$AC) ? hi% an%5er :3 /Cl i% %igned "nly /y a%ter and a #"ntra#t i% /et5een t5" partie%.D . he %tarted a%:ing !r" all !un#ti"n% again. e telling e D d"nt gi4e !""li%h an%5er% and = y an%5er%.E:3 122' )A 1'10 1ue%ti"n% 5ere a%:ed rand" ly !r" all !un#ti"n%. he t"ld e t" 5ait "ut%ide again and that #apt :ap""r 5"uld #all e in hi% #a/in 5hen he return% !r" the eeting. < i %aid a !e5 p"int% and %t"pped. he 5a% "%tly n"t happy 5ith "re than '0 per#ent "! th"r"ugh :n"5ledge!ull an%5er !"r all the 1ue%ti"n% 5hi#h 5a% /e#" ing di!!i#ult !"r e. he 5anted a deep and any a ti e% he /e#a e 4ery angry 5ith %ay anything u li:e D he :ept "n gi4ing ad4i#e regarding n"t /e /e "4er% art /y trying t"* /ut %h"5ing it 5ith ur "5n :n"5ledge. 3333333333333333 5ith #apt EAPAA$* it 5a% a% g""d a% a d"ing the !ull thing again.CE A> CA.

he %aid that u are !"rgetting "%t "! the thing% li:e pre#auti"nary area* d5 r"ute* !l"5 "! tra!!i# arr"5 et# 10= %hip rep"rting %y%te 12= a% an ""5* h"5 d"e% #hapter '3%a!ety "! na4igati"n "! %"la% and #"lreg% help y"u i an%5ered that all 0' reg% "! #hapter ' help% in na4igati"n... at thi% i% %t"pped* he a%:ed e t" #"ntinue and na e "re. %" i t"ld a/"ut andat"ry t%% * area% t" /e a4"ided* a%l lane%* et#. i 5a% t"tally %h"#:ed at thi% rea#ti"n% and th"ught that n"5 all% "4er. at thi% i Ju%t t"ld hi that i had %aid 4t% earlier. he g"t 4ery angry at thi% and t"ld e that he 5a% n"t dea! and d"nt a#t % art in !r"nt "! e. he a%:ed e t" g" "ut%ide and 5ait till he thin:% he ha% ti e t" ta:e y "ral%.. 1'= na e a !e5 "! the all i #"uld re e /er i% #arriage re1uire ent% !e5 p"int%* %r%* 4t%* t%%* a%ter "/ligati"n t" rep"rt. i #"uld n"t under%tand 5hat t" an%5er in ele ent% "! r"ueting %y%te .E :3 171' 3 1700 1'= t"ld e t" #"ntinue y an%5er "n #hapter ' "! %"la%. he #alled e agian a!ter a/"ut 2 h"ur%.li!t?? 7= h"5 5il u l"ad danger"u% #arg"? 8= 5hat all d"#u ent% and in!"r ati"n are gi4en /y the %hipper !"r l"ading danger"u% #arg" 9= 5hat i% the i p"rtan#e "! ti e %heet and %tate ent "! !a#t% in a 4"yage #harter party? 10= h"5 5ill u g" a/"ut l"ading a /ul: #arrier 5hi#h i% "n a 4"yage #harter party? < he 5anted t" hear the #lau%e% a%%"#iated 5ith 4"yage #harter party regarding l"ading ti e i gue%% = 3 An% a% per 4"yage #harter party it% 4ery i p"rtant e :3 i t"ld that in a t" !ini%h l"ading in the layti e and hen#e delay% %h"uld /e ini u he 5a% n"t happy 5ith thi% and t"ld e that i had expe#ted an an%5er 5rt arri4ed %hip* layti e et# 11= a% a #hie! "!!i#er * 5hat all #"r#ern% y"u in a 4"yage? < i an%5ered l"adline%* i#e* 5eather* tra!!i# * et# = 12= %hip r"uteing %y%te and ele ent% "! %hip r"uteing %y%te . he %aid that u are !"rgetting %r% 4t%. < thi% ti e i %aid h"ur% are en"ugh t" :n"5 "%t "! the any thing%. )I. n"thing in 5il /e gi4en /y hi . 2 y hand .

C"n4er%i"n "! gyr"%#"pe t" gyr" #" pa%%.D ate% +at#h (+S. 5hat pre#auti"n% u 5ill ta:e 5en na4igating in i#e? .. a#ti"n% and a% per 5hi#h rule 17= %ailing 4e%%el ahead * a#ti"n a% per 5hi#h rule 18= !i%hing 4e%%el ahead * a#ti"n a% per 5hi#h rule 19= "n agneti# /"ard* ade agr"und 4e%%el "re than '0 tr%. F ha4e #" e "n 5at#h 2nd ate tell u that pre%%ure ha% dr"p /y 0 / 5at all a#ti"n% u 5ill ta:e a% a ate ? 2.? '. al%" i 5il rep"rt thi% %ituati"n t" the #"a%t guardC4t%Cp"rt= during thi% an%5er he 5r"te p3p3 "n y !"r . Di!!eren#e /et5een Cele%tial and )erre%trial PC(. .in% Atte pt: 2..? 6. 1.regulati"n% "! #hapter '= 16= "n agenti# /"ard* re%e /ling t" r"r #ard%* %h"5ed e t"5ing 4e%%el "n p"rt /"5.D Atte pt $e%ult: >. a#ti"n ? 20= !"g %ignal !"r %u#h agr"und 4e%%el? 21= y"ur a#ti"n a% a ate 5hen u %ee %u#h 4e%%el right ahead? a%ter i% %leeping and d"e% n"t 5a:e up? < i %aid i 5il #he#: the #hart and %ee 5hy thi% %ituati"n ha% happened and 5hy it ha% #" e "n "ur #"ur%e.. and %tarted 5ith 1ue%ti"n%. -hat i% a##reti"n "! i#e? -at all %ta/ility re1uire ent% u 5ill ta:e a ate 5en tran%iting in the p"lar regi"n? 8.? 7... di!!eren#e /et5een gyr" #" pa%% and agneti# #" pa%%? 2.6e % iled and %aid ": ":. y ind 5a% "re "n %eeing 5at he 5a% 5riting than in an%5eringKK 22= 5h" i%%ue% na4 area 5arning in india < i %aid i d"nt :n"5 . i 5a% ha4ing a !eeling that he 5il #ut the letter p and put ! in Date : 01C07C11 Venue: DG Shipping Internal: Capt Shu:la External: Capt Panda <(+S guy= Durati"n: '0 . -hy PC( i% perpendi#ular t" AI. that ean% e4en "ur #hart% are n"t #"rre#ted "r "ur p"%iti"n i% n"t /eing pl"tted pr"perly a% per teh pa%%age plan . -hat i% %yn"p%i% #hart%.? 0. i 5il g" "n re#ipr"#al #"ur%e and then #he#: the next /e%t r"ute t" /e ta:en !"r tran%itting that area.31 PA%%ed Initially 5en #a e in%ide Capt Shu:la@% A!!i#e he a%:ed e i ha4e %een u %" e 5ere and i re inded hi :i 2.

)$S !a#t"r% and a#ti"n%? 12.)ype% "! #urrent? 12.. A#ti"n% t" /e ta:en a ate 5en 4e%%el agr"und? 10.Sh"5ed e $A$ 1'320 #ard% .)S S)$A.PA$ED )A EAS) A)(A. 1'.Di!!eren#e /et5een #urrent% and tidal %trea ? 11.6"5 gul! %trea i% !"r ed? 10.PASS.9.P$I. )6E -ES) A)(A.-6G A$E CF$$E.u"te $ule: '*6*9*10*10*18*19 17. .CIP(E A> A GG$A CA.GE$ I.)IC ? 16.)IC AS CA.