Falsafa-e-Taqayya by Ayatullah Nasir Makarim Sherazi

-..\,-, .....

,-~

1~~I~~ll~.,P)A]'~ .~~

~ ~

,GU)~r'ft.;;d't:,d,II":: T ,~, !tIl:"

cJ..- , ~ J.:,b J". '~': .. ~D~t~j:;

~'''!!!'''''''" IIIIi ~--iMl!iiI '.

~' ... c:.A" ~., - _.'.,

. i 'i . ,-. - , .. -

, "," ~ Ii' .. _ .'

11111 - iii"

..

~d

;I. ..... iU, .. ~1 F~'

r

~I

~JJi:.".~ .. :,~. ~

r: ~~;;A'7'J:J1

,('~,,:,~~~,

f¥~~o/J~

..:.lJLid~4:~:("JlJJ.~' ", ... 1 J... &CJ!J: L

- ,~ ~

~L;;J"'~ _cl.Jo!11~~

IjA r~~'L.I'~~~~~L·'(~'if.e_~\~'i~

- I!""!II,{"""" "!!i!'.' II!!I ~ ' .. - - '~.;;I"'"".~

r~cr~ :~J:"CI~II

U'F' . I~t"lr'

1

II MIl

"rI~~

Iff

:J1. t,.

",~'~ fr

~~..y, ~',~ ~'P' ,"""I.;P,U;. './,<,;!f~~t.., ~.

~,- -:' u ........ ".J""} .. ( i"l

Ii;;:; I~JJ:.J:'(Lf I !'!I U)'~~.)· (~I' 1('

./ ~""Lf;lI q~)i r~' r l,t

"",~~L ~~.J#~al i~ lf~L ,c.e/ tw..J~" 'r.'

IIII!!i 'Ii

,~

I

4f" ti~,

0<: ,~I,

'''1'

'~ .'.

I'P'~' ,1P'6 U"'Q,

[,-- I

- .... ~.~ .•.. ~ .. ~:I-----~~==.~~.:..::~.:: ... ~~ ... ------~~~ .hl "='" .3.' .. '. . ... ~

L~

I.r''i I'P-itt

I'",

. I

I'~

!1r'4:

~tJ:1

l~r ll~t'"

r

"'0·~~~"~-~"····-··~-····· .

, " -'- ' -".,

..•. ". ,.-", .

-

.

I

·~~if~~ ~,U~I frlrp~~~·~~ ,.;

.~~~'I~ 1 .: c&JIcJN~~ , .. .Ll)r

J \£~ .

~~U

" ,r'I!'....;.,JJ.,&J~

,"---

,;oj Im'~' ~1~LJvl;rM

~"

~JliJj,~ jo,",~,,'l\'_ ·'lJ~~~j.r.~LJI~'J.J~' I ,£'~~

I" .':-",. " - W".~- _'..:...' -, - 11- ~.~. "II!IiJL"'.'oiIt~~~

,WJ;,~~VJ:I~~~' "i-v1}~;.'~ ~~~J~J;LJILl.l~ i,· ... ~t'~li~w2Lf&!--ir:rh l"1.1.

~'Jt'.iII._. .,~ -~. _ .. ':I!'I~ _ ,~-~"~-_L

Ir'~ ~"~, (PJ~,-'c.:-~-"'iU::J~~,·' "',11"U .. i!l(jV;.~t~· ,i ~.-'!..<'., ,~ 10."..1'/,:./,

'·~1r'oG:~~~,~ii~UJ~rJ~~J~fci;'utLtJ1

,~~d~.JI;!rf~~~,~L~~4ol~~/~ tJl~~,'~I'~k'fJb,r!M.t ~!d~}I:~'·,,-~~l.,- .~" t!~.J

-11~' '. ~'-- -'.- - J'~ -~ !!Ii --' I;

~ oi.J J'"' ii:~:).~

~~ld<.A.iolJ·,~\4tt~~j4~~':~"A

~"

~Glli .. 'Jl~o:t,~J'iA.j: :&.,~~ '~~l'.+

~,'~;~ /i,pl !. .... ,rl .... n .. '0'.· •• ,~ ~1!I .• ,r'''' i".'.,r. ' .... ,'.JJ' 1.,~.··.ll,'····~',O""i,. llii

W~~~~'-lIlav '~I~l~ M~_-..'~~)'.~' lo!J'

'", ."'~'. L. ~.

~i~~3r.

J.&...~ , . 'i: i "':,~~' ~~ "5.o;1Wit;l~" ,~ " J:..~' "~~f.·~.',;l~~V'1

'- ijf'~' t~, Wil~ .- I. r-~~ .. ~~,'~-.~ .. '-.' " -.'

.JJ,~,~l.;\ji~~U~~,l,.q*L!9'i.k~~~I'~"

.~y

J ~. ~

., . ., t, III _ ¢ -tJ1 "'---oil,·, .. "",J,

~ ~ !!! - I~ W ,iill

1i!1,i""II' .... ~III"~,...

,~i- :cJt)~1

PO"

.• d",- .. .;.:tf .. ~ : .. '~ "'~(~ . .i' ~ ~ .... ~' ~"1G' >.'~I __ l~.~

~"'.#{.~'h; AJiiIP,M£I'~ ~~~~~Ir..(

;ai;'i51::~k"r~)~'"/Jti·· .. ti:£~iF--~6~A""~

" m

'IW,.·;O;"'"," wul-U~

~,~~ '"..- - ,,-':" _ ..

-~~_'d{,J ... 'f

~,..::,.......

'.

dL.'J j 'I .... ~.. .

i....tb' . I

. .."

~~!l'" i·J!~It~"l'~~._ ~'d~;L~!~~~J,~,~;...:" _ ....l:! ... : . .!!.CU ... II.~. !L_ '~~j~i",..~ •.. ., ...... U ~ .. ~-" '::11'> . 'Illt-'.i~

r~~". "- .. , '!( ,,~ L , .~, •• ,~~ ,

,.."

... ~ .. ~ / r/

-li~+,~~~(ul~

UfJ~~'J}~avv~~tr~~",

~~~v1L~I.#~~~

J;.~",uYA

~.i ~r. ~l-C.. . I~ ' ..... ' ";' •. , ~!al ,. - '~(~. -~.'L.~ .. !!III.;..'-'"

~,~l' .~~U~.-iJ~W .1

- -.iiiF

e._~d.~O~N,~j;IL~~~+{"

,'r!~L!.J·,-;1" ~~#Lo

~~.I ~. U,il ~l.'~-.*

Iii!!'

;J~!'b . .u~.~.jJ'!ll~,.,.J,ot'»J\';..d;tlIW~,.:J~~~~ .. ~~~",:",ai~~ln,z,-.w:~ll~

'~ .... J-il.\;~.·A- ,,/;,.,.... ~,,: .. .:!J.I' ~~~~~jlJi~~I~,J~~~'"

~¥-L;f'-~I~frl~., ... !i!J"""'~1 ;po .oJ&-_ 'Ii, "'" ,._ .. " -~ '-'!!I' - - -..... 'I!!

U~..::...r' ~, .J '.~ /. _ .. ,~I~~ ".,"""-"-'",.iJllo.. • .J ,.., ,~,L •.. ,.

I.r -- ~ I .~~ ~01!~~~~~- oi!itl,-~~',~fF-

;;i'~~ plylil, .. IfA Ior"~""'" tJ ,,.. I ,~~b~~jlt~~~(l.:J;.lIf,t~I~~~""

~. 'olt'D.!---

,.. ,",,~ ,

~;-'!!!!'!!

Ij~ ~~,~~~ __ ~.:Il"~~~J'~I(~'.J·1.,...~,~. ~I~ .. !

i A ",~",>: ~,;,."",."' •• ,;!:, '.J.r/J!J"~' ! . .¥l''''''II:rl.'':IlJi, f;''- .' ,'~ ~.l' iJ, :.l;,' ... ~~1

~'",-.,;;il=~~'~~, .. -- "'-'~~~~'r' ,~, -'-'!:irf€-

-~~I;.1f~k

:~-.1'-,· .It Jio',-r"!'(';' ..... 4-. .... ". -~.", • ..iJb,-".J.l~ 18: ,1'J·~~.,oJidrlu-"'J-W_1"1

,,",~~~-"""\ _ --~~-.- ., _ -"" ,_,~ 1~14!I I~";;-;;:; ~

..-r~t.r-kL.~,,~~, ·~Jtj~1~~~~-,,~~:.~Wi' ~,~~y~.,..!!I_'~~

1"'"

, ............. __ ."., .. ~J0~~L~+-~

~.~~~JJ~:lt~~~='l;f.~~~.~~~~ l~:'r~f~;:--t~~~~'r~~"!"'" ""~. i1"':'~~ I.t~ ~ .. ~~~.~~~'~~~..h-~

~'P ~._:.pr.'- "'" 11lJ.!I.II.... l

'. cd I.~

1 ~'il,~'

at" '~~'!j~~~,~~d~~~U~I,JJII~' b-t·;~"

· L·· 0iiI'.--Jl'

~ I,· ,~,,,,,, '. ,_

-~".·.~I t _ ~4' C' J',-,~~

I ''-:'', J~, _ _. I Mi' II' ,,' - ~.

, .,

- _.- '-, u.:u- ilI!'

,'''- i r \I'~ --;:'-r-

I. V"7:'-----1 . -

..

'~I~II,"",' 1~""'I~~!;ir'ip~rl~~~!?~~t1',;f~I~.' ~V:?'!JbI&~ I,d

~t0t'~.

· .... ~r:& ·~·~~r~I,.~ i-'I~!\iJ.~~~~~W~il.'i .u.'.~ .' .... U L~. • J,~~l -;u'('.j .. wJj;;:.~J;":"""~IJ~J"""'!.~~ ""f _ . ..1 •. ..11.

I~~~· .. ~i_ .. ' I. i.... ?-

:~JLI I"",, ...... • .. ,... . .' J I

-'~r-.i!;-:!'Ir~'r_!Jj~~~", ," R:I.~l

ii!iiI,A .. '.~I~I

AI"

_ .,_.,,,j,~r~.,~ ..... LI!&- ~'i

~~. !l!i'_ . llf"~,

~'" ;l . ..,~," "~\I;~, ,j\ "r-.... , ~l'i~;~JJlJl<l!!'~~.f"" ',V lIiiiiIl~

· . .,.Ji ""',, 'f

.!!II _, W' dl JP.j -~ =tI v--

rL, ,A., ~.c -' ''',e ':', ..... ",""-_. -!!!I::_" .. , ..

,d ~W'j e., .,.- J'" 11' ., - #'

.. ~, ~. 4._,~.- _,:~

- - .

11'·"11

TO~.IIIOI! ""'"."' .,_1 .IJ '~

~ ... r--.~~.;':I'

.. ,

II'M' i-j~~~,~~(),j~:pihl...:Lv.U~L,.,·(",

- . . It"'J l~.~,J:[:",I1r'rN'-

~ u!~ -! ~ ~~- ii,

L;,A~~J;Lu~v~:ittyJJi,~~.~ ~M,)~j~o:3"~~~lL,~ .. ~:t l~e?~'P

~oj14~'+V":;b~.LJ~i'"L.

/7.. _ ... ' I ' '~i ~ • " Iii ':f 1'. I ~f.! - I ... / - "-I'/'

t'/,~LlIJ'/;,ii!...-UI-'If"~".JJr;r~/''''' J~ ,:.. ,#J'!~'"

,~

l'.:l'JI~ .' .~-'q./,"t:,,)}i4";'~""i,..r1 wkJ~.-:vJ;~JL:.'~-:- '.P~'r''f'1)

t. ,[ ...... l~:. ~·,;[;{.h ~.'". ~k.L;J,.(.-C\ .. :;;J, iJ-d

\~".'f"·~"11. '~~l!!' I~- -L ••.. \ :6- it!'-

_ iJ"';;~f;;;j.1.~"_;A~.U;~~"'~~~)JU"'~~J'

~1~~,~~:Jd4.JJ;~~~~»

r~O;~V~,;,..-;..Ii~tt.:'~""~ kr·,p:~~~~~;~;I~r~N~~4-

.:..~ Ii - ii, II _ ,. l!!!!., II' I.'

d~l~

,. ,. ",_, . i!i

"!!"'h. ..,!. J ~.,~

. ..., ..

fjJ;iJI''r'''!~)I~~~dW~~;i~L:'~l:ltrJ\1r.!')ol.-.M ~,

. Jj!IIi ,,' ,!WI' . I ~--'--'-'. I 'il!i,-' ill"" '-- '(1t., .!113' '~VII'

~~J~~;V:~tif1liJ~if~£;jrJ1:.ftd;:'lL, '~Jr}l~~~;,~~t::r~,j~d~~/q?)~~,

~y.vv1'i'P4tr,'''~dl~~4t·'''r'~.J.!!# l~tJlf~

;f, ,~, "~,LJ~,~~'Rl~~~\:/!~~~~ l~.~~t;j~~~

''''''f-~' -, l~ .,t .:.l -:if;Ii" '11" "!if -_.'!I!'j+' I. VOlt . :;

~.I(~~L.ft.,·~~lt~. '<~f~~~ ... 'oi!V~~'~uUrW' Jr/

~. liI·· y~~1 'Ii~ri--! _;!., ,.'''" .,l~fi!! LI!' _I~ !It! ,~_ .l.~

.l.lJ ~~ ..... JIr.'"!;~~~J ... W'....41",,,~;f+~r:Gil;l~· ~;'-, 'lJI ~:.~~

. 1J~'-iIi ~~.~._ rill! .~~~~. ~,! ,£~i . '. 'I!i!iJ~

~40tA~.t'L...~:i!l',""iI,,'il .. ~»~~~~,'i;!~Ri.~ .... / .UJfJ..~j~

:li' •. 'OO' '.. ' .... '- ~' -' ,~- - F •••• - " ;;;liJ7;i'~#' r,jJfiii'"

'.'J' '. l~,f"'.::;;il',~,~' ''''.J:lr.G;, "l~';(..e.,~,'.t:~~ ·if .... ,.'.j~

~~~-,~~.t, 1II1~\~~.~~ ~~~- ~~'III~'\I' '!Ii!i!',- "'~I~~' '!I_" _ ~If,

1~,.;I~,~;tlJi ~,.~~~m,,",i~W' ~bl;ifjf

/ji).il:~"·~e~'4.;if;VJ~~~~f~'~I~rW'toJJ" ,~j~~~~j,

ft~.'·I·'. ~~,,cl4P~ ·.;....fc'tH~;.!i§~~~IIIt""',

.rr -'I ill ~ 'W ~""!I!!I': !"',Ii'!J 71.~

1£ c~'lrl~UJ~,~I~J"

~~~"'1Il414;11~~~~ ~"'~'rjj

.... ~'~·~~~,~Vji!~ 6.. ~

(,Jr if - -,~' r - l'l~ ,. III!' -" - ~I

, ~ == = .. -'~~~'~I

"~ U~i.1"WJ"'· .'~A'·'.I;..!""J&ot.r""~",,~J:-,,.··Y

\', ._,., rl~ ,~;, .. -~:: ,- .~ - -- !l"'!Ii 11' __ ~~""'~J

~""I~I~J'~d:dtf~~L -h,~ ~::l~l'diJ\ '1P)~[.;4J;vl~~~~'-f#ijt~~JJd~~~I.,jf~

~~~.;t'::W~~·-·· .~ I~~;~"'~~:,;-' 7'~ii,~~+~~t '~, ", .... ~

~~w~.tcfjhr~~x ·W~~~f.~!1#~~~k ~~~.MtI~~ ~~P~~f~~~.I~i~:h~t!;~~~~~'~~' ,

~l~~~;;; ~;~" ';·Lo

~~~.&e~Qj~.ri;~ ~~J

~~ _ '~:~4~r~~ tmP~:.trd'~~

~(~;T~~JQ=~C(~Z.J;~a ~~t;~~, ., ·.~"~~~~:~i..tJ1U*~~~ - 'j(~',~~/VJj\f

~.~Jw,~~ .. 1~.'~:~1~~.'-: ')I!.::J)~'.'; ~ .. Jri1' "'J,j,ith,I~~'~_1

1-' pJ'~. 'f!" ... ;.~ I~-" .. Y:i. I!!!!I~ ". ,i:J 1111 - 'if1'w~ .

-- iI~ -'

,J~~j;y,;S:trt~~~~OiiIf~lj~Pt1 '~

~,~n~ y, -'~' I~!"';;;...· ~~~..:b....;;;;

, ~I>~ .. "~M.!'..~~ .~~"i~J,~i.·~~'.-~.t!1·...: .. J'~I~~j'

G·,.... -~; .n''-'-~~t; - - ·X.,lit( _:.~~:t~U~r'"-I"'"t.

~~r~k>I~_lw,;~r~f:;t:.,:, ~iII:·lj, -~'~~~I,_~Li1IJ

'''~-~~I~ &1" III!' ~-, ~!i ~1Wii~ '"W~ iii " "'-i

tJ;~wt~.;iI}aii4"Jt~~~X~1.:;a'lr~~~

"~Je'~lktr"?.IJ:".~ _ ~~<~.- - jlv~~'li-I~,.Jr~~L"~II"'o!'".' ,"' i~~

T··1rJ~ .<,,~~I"'~Lt ~ji!~V~ ~~IIo~JIj"_!I!~t~,)iF~~11

ft'u~r';I~~~r~~",Jid~J(i~: :o/'1(~,~af~' ~1~~LI~~~d;£,Pt~~~~4: V~I~~»;~;tr ~J~i.J'~i""~~!lIEl. ~, .~~. : .. ';1: tJ~~4JizI~&~'

IPI~p:~O/J.(;#V~Jy;JWt1*~ jJ¥~~,~'I!"'tyF 1£$~~iJt~'~:(.JIi!:~r· ~ .. ~~~ltlJ..p.·' ..j(lli~/~~ijJC:l'

'7 I' .... rl~~ .. , 'Il tI 1ii!!'· - /..i/}~JT ii

!~t:t~'"':tul~~~4.j1~~v~;

~~,~d~.?'·r'~JlLJ,~~v4~~ ',Jt)~(ftot.I4'LwPd~

..... '4C,

JIUJ,;~.·;!:j.rJJrJpJ(JtJji=l~lJ.',.:.$?~tJ,f~!tV);

1'" -- - 'it' .. . " ,-,,;r-, !!IiIf'~, .. -..,;i'lC

?~ttd~"+-1~"~~~~!1J,4t~iJ~U'~I~~~~j;,d},~'f

i·~~J~"t:tr~,t1~~ni,Jj1~d;t~,i!,~~QJ'iJd~ '~~t!L~I~~lo#l~VlD~~; • .Il;W~~~'~'~I~J}I.i.:.llr~.-. -,~~' ,:;

- I;iIIt.!r ' 'I' ~ ,_ ,:rJI~~'" Mil.!

~4~J}«d~~~~~~if~'~·~.J~;VJ)~~J.J.~~,ji'It'1

~ !Ii -, 71'" -" ~'IiIC~J.· ... "'" .r.! ~b

'~"~~1d.~~Mh"'IJ'~.~: ~.1} .• '-ld~~(V~,,~\.'·t¥ol ~~,

- ~g --r- to 'IP T 'tJrJ!ji' U'!i,L-~ . .-~__ 'Ii.' ~d~lf.;t~

'~~~J1'~ur~!.~,. . .-- _~: ... , 'r!:J~··-M -~ ;1,iIi .~~c:.

- - _I . '"1 ,.,1U' --:li!:il~ ,.;;.,r;r#:!ly,Jr~ 'II] ;,iI!~~.r.~·T-

~lio>,"l.;~"r~·:t:Ve.-~A_ .. r': •• ~~J,,:,n.~,- ~~;~~'.J./~· l' .-.:lld-,.

tt :r.]~rir! ~ ~ Y~:'I. ~~J ~_. -~'. ~:JIi!~.

,#iVSl~~l~~J?/tfi'u~~~~-~~.:; 4~;~'~L ~~. .~ .~hJ~,i,\~;'~~£u,' ~ ~- ~ ~1~~

~I'~ __ ~ _'!!!' F~lI~l !!' r ,_ ~:...,.' ~

~()p~~~Gt~'JtJ1~L~;_~- i t(jJ;l~~I-.d

~.I #. -

, - 'J~~~~~(tc.rYvL.:v1~&r4;eJJI)~;V

~~."''=''~~~~~'':'JJI~if..~

oPt.::",~~k;'~~rL·fl"~'~VLJ.4I/~vl.nvJlLt'

*'~;-- ,(.'. ~~ I~J._.,,{ -,.,. • . ~,;. i/i"'" ~ -. ,,."

'~~~~;''''~~;':~;J,,,,,-~,g;\I;I~W..:l'~~~'' I'

I~AvLdi'J?Uttt(~~~'~J;J~fIr/l~J}Q~u

~~~ .~:},~',~~:,~i~~~J:;'J),~I~;,.d ...•.. ,~:,:;~

. !III II!I' ~I I ~ 'f'.~- ~ - ~- '=.l ,.11_ ~'=7<; I ,,.. L ,!lY

,~tJI~r?;tJ}!,f;;' .. J:ln!t. '~I?'~'~".~C.!r'l·~~I ... t"~'" .. ~'

.'-,~ - f~ "., -1f,,/.~·,·,,"',r:'ltr-r~"'~I"'1'fii.l.i;

Q~Ur'~f"U:?~I'JJ'~J:~rJ(z/'(JJJq~~~ ,-4tk-J,~."r'~J~f'~~.JJJ, ,J-'~,).hb~J'~~rf.'~ .P'

I!!!I - ,. '!!II!! - ~~"'~' - ~ I~"~' !Lt!!il~r

~~~~~~~)~'Q")!~AJ~~J1,~"-~ ~ ;~ ~~9j.J,Jtf'#d~i.~~1;;·JM.d,}·U)JuJ~'i1l

u .. ··q 1"~~.;.I''-':'\~lftt:I~2J}~JJ'~~,,",;....n1H'~~1' -o!!§cJ~

,~~-" --. ~ .Jl~ !",I ,.. - '." - L~ '.' ." ,~" iii ,~.1 ... ,~' - 1~"IIiiIl":'" ',_ "II!!

~.IU.i.tJ~~';;~~t.&U~~liAt~L~ '_~'.~}'

(~~.~~tt. ... ~;dP~;~'-i4;t. .. .;

- -"~1'/tL!t!' . - - I~gd~it· ... WI.~""

.~ .. d.~;:~" - "'~~ I~:·' U~~~I~I

~4i;~v!~~fi~';;4.'#

~~JJ:,(~;1;;~, .- ,~~~"tJfl~~~~.Ge",~,,«~

-' '~. if .J!~I~T -'- rl;ltJi~!!j II U~r<!! ""Fl- '-: ",_', .

Jill: '~~'~~ .~ -'JI~~~J~r~·'~:I'IrJ\

~~Y"$:.tii;/J~, _ ~~~~~.J~tI.;.il~II:A!i.:

j$~'.- ~l: .. ;·~tJfUJ~~~' \'~~~~ ... ~~n,,·"'~Z~~' .1',tI'

,~~". 7" tr' '"F "7-- f - -""ro-.. ,_ 11oliI'",~;

fi:J~~J("fJi"dJ~/+t;;"9~f;T.L;~1fJI..liWJ~~~tI~

4 :.;,~ -~C~"~~:';~~~~UI~~~U' IJnll~~'~J'~~~

~;~' ~t~r~~;l ~ II' L![If-" ~ - ~~I L~- _ j-ilJ _ 11l.J!!I,~ ~_. " ~_ !

II" , Jt.JI,~~~,p>/'~I~JLl'~-rjl.l ~t;.o~'~J;i')~u;)l

, .. - .,,, .,. I - - - ,-.' . ., -I~' .• , ~- ~ . ~ L I

IfJI~Ji,,~.y~~fQ,J{J1~ 'f_ .5r'(~'jJ;~~}iw.:l~/'

+!,~4AI~~~:.lIi(/~ J U'U'I~!M't'jj:,,~-JJ~'cJ~' . .{~'~!,;",~J.<I,~~~i.-t~:~i·~4l .j.i:J: ~ c·,J'~~''''~'i~tbj:c!o,di,

'~LoI!jl ,!!,L...~li.i!f.!' _~~'!!!II~lJ.iLtIioi.i. ~ ~/-.~ ~;',"l~~\-' . "'-":i!":'~-:"

I~' .:ft, , ".. . i , . ./'; I' "'~:i:!' ~i!' -, J •

*~!{i,rd~"''J'H,~~~~~~lrU,lJ~ ,L.lt,,·fl~ J~I~I';~.H:'P

~tlJ.r-J~d,,~,.~iJO' ~ ,'~~~ I elL"; ''!!~.,t,.Iil~,Jr"l

'!I!' II! :'" "I'" ~n~ H ~~ -r-, I~~' -~

'Ldf~,,~j'~~~,(~1 if'~~l,. PIt;,;J~lJ'

I'

~IPJ~.1~.tL~, r.JV4J~uL L, -=====~

4'.t:~,~-.;:;~;o;il_ ~ii~#l-"'""~ L~!;ILillr;.lf,."ftIf~ 'rJ\~ -'~iF"" .. -. ~

~1i:"!.~{,tJ!7~\tI~~~~,,,,l'~ _."... I"_-.Q ~"', .. u, ... ~.-j ~" .. _':. ~':I~ "1,_, .. I"';~~ •... ~ .. ' ' ,if,' I'

~: 1~"7-~ 'iP"'" -. .;-~~" '-fiil' yv-- ",.~·~I~ i!~'111

1Q,~'~4lP'Abw'l!i~/'~9l"D· I~"~ ~,d,tJuA)~,,~~'d'

,-c:...~I~,l!& cJ~~I" ~ "'~

1;C~<Ii(~~,.t:r~;~~~~~~

!.» 'Ii,~ ,I cA,9",J"l11 ~ -I I "l,i'!'~, .. ,.L ..

jJ' 1',~' .. :('f'i~~~~IIIit"'1t'J~,t!fl'Q,'''~~~~L(;';~I~~:1''-'~[;.r.

~,:I!~~W)~~U~.,J{~~~~C'j ... ,~J,b-fi-'~.t~~~

,"~t~,.l.l,..·'-~·rtul'L,~f.f'W'~, .·~·Jih:~;/.1~~j#tI..6t~~~

~ T'r Ii ~''!~ ~ - .~.~,iJ A=V9 e '-~' . .I./' f 1:~;~':T"

.. ,~ ""J,1~il:'I",",;.r~b/~ .. ' -~~ji:.ll:;LJ..tc,uJu~~4l'!1I'~i

~~IU~. if" ,iii I( JJ.J~ . - -~; , , - W'!iL11 _ .

."g.~~'vur~!)~j~t.; .~~£~ .. ~:~~1~~11

~-- [II -, ~~"

~~~~I~/ti"1~,~~&r~~ij.1Ut I~I::-;;--~~' ;:--1 ,;;;;o:;;",w .... , '_-.~=r~~i":"!F----:l, :~r"'"'.~.-.!"""!' ...• T.'"~I_..;~:~·

~,?'JJf~,~~bf'~~t-·~.··~~~, .J :~~~elliJ..I~:u· .... ·~hLr< r

-" (Ji '-'T-"'!J'"i~~ ~r r ~~. ~- ~"- - TQU'

,I'll"" 1"'"

J..!. i' "_~i'~.'~'J _ri "'"' 6~(iJi& ;;:"--oDj(U.-!1 t21~Y~A'.~i1J~~ '- ~~7~:~~~'\lI~)Ui. V'.,: lI'il"" ..... ·_"'iI'

:fdlJ'i',jilJ..uIilil/Ji1~";";!JI1Lu-i~J;!' '~~~Uo/dj~J ....( ... ~~Iw.~.J~tJi4.,~JG~uL,,''- .. ~tfPd~lt,tJ'eJJd 'I ~,!oi..r:~.; . ~{.iV';JI~' .. r .;~~;,J.j .. ~r: r:t)l~~~~' ~~'

l!lll~~',!~~'.-,"':'I'" V'~:irl~ v -'!!Ill I!fi!!'!! . I .

*~~~"AtIf .. t/o~"~I9J1JCl

..ij~~~ ~,.t!"'~~;.A"!\, f~JU~~'i,. ,,~' :,",ltL.~i

"""a.V"'KtI""'I..-~,","I-F-r~i - , ~.. r

llo'1:..1;.,.!;I'IJ,lll\!IFAJ.,j T;, ~£tt..6.cl~J",i~J~', ~il1:1C.,.~Jr' l[!..Lt

... 'f!t'~·'t, l,;,., . .Jr~ WP . ~ ,- ~illt1l ~I" . . -W-l, ...

"'~~JJ,J"~,!",,~~~~ttJL,tt r;:,_

- ~ I

~~L~~I~ttAl~wht~l-"I~J\riJ~~~~,f4~

"'f-pjl

'~fM'i4~l)lJ~~~I~ibJr~~ t..f'P~j~ot~lJWI' J1J~~~4{t.tI~~~lfJt~.:cL;'~ ~W:V"P~P~!,~ ,t~"'bO~J,IJ'~c:l~~~~J4;;1 ,'\)'U~f;I'fJ",~.#

i~~~~~~i,04/lw~~AliI>jJ"" I:!~"~~~..f~, .. ~f It~.:l1!.~t~Arll.f~I~t~1fl'c~~·~~'~JijJG~~aJJu.l

"J.ll.r'4,tlyJ.lJv...?~rEU\J,f~4 ~;.d'~V~1;! ~it;"

.. ,I1JL~,·&xs.LAjJ;£;J:M'1- L-~==~::::::~_.

JJi;!J4I

{f.ii~~~~JV~"'i1Jr4:!a ''-GJ,-j,,,-. ~1rJ~~~cfl~ .. ···~-·,· ~-,. __ ~.~!'::""lI:_ ,~,~- ~f·~.r· .

i . ~ At .. - _.J' " ,Jj :' j, .;t •. ~ : "I '~~I'" '.. Jii1i.cj. iL.."t. .

try~~t~;i!d ~1+t)l".,;Llii",~g~~ I "':i!l: ....... J p;o"~~~d!1J:"'1

:~~lfq,/J'l;!~hli~lI?~I",,'''ft~~~.J,tJ~(~.:r

'r",~

--(,,:r't.,., ,~.iiJ,l,;tLf;:ft~~~'J'~J'~I~ '.: ~ 'II~ &.J' :~'~~\Ju;'

~~j# !I';~, ~]., rL~ =

~~!oI':,1;~v'iJ"~~;~~~-e~J. k?I' 4;; o/i;tJJ'

.J. J~.:4A'-lf~!;.,,~ .. )d';:£i.t'~C/Jt.if ,~ t1·\f~.J1

~P.; ... II!' r '.I.I~'v·~. -

.. ~It':''C{J~,i.' co - - -

~lf'ld",JwV(;iI.tJ~·.~.l/~i~.:JJQ-!J:~'v~~~ z..,i.J";{fT-J~~(f~YJ~j~dJ"i.i~~r~T~~"'~~.Jf

I. '~. I

·J(17~j't~2!&r."Jf4fY/~i;Ii~/'i"LlL(~~~~~

ti!J,~,/~~qr'~J?V",jiu.;J1~JI\t~~,~1(JYAj' t\.~I~,;.,,~.:~:I~{&- ;~"'lI'r.t"~~~··~~.;{vii&.i·('}P~

~@ '!I! V'i!..- - ~~ ,I! '-"1 -~. '= ,.- .. -

.;o1~fJZI/¥~'g4~J}.J,~J~~JJ'i'j(J~ LOrL.,!;l~

,~t!lll 7"'-[11"

~~.t;i~Q'f~'J'~'I,~J~j1~ij:.' :W~'1!'711""-, -·~:-1;I"'7,tJr::::·~'7'"'lf'""'C':iV~"\1"!~ .. 1J1....,..~tp;~' ,r.,,' •.

~ .. ~f~(4~t'~,>: ~,' :-Ji; '·~:U".Y'Jll l·"i_~.ilJ.',!,~,pI';eJ ,!t~)-.;.~~t

I II~_'~~' I ;Jf"h."}t-· I ~JL ~~ ~ -.T"!I. 'I!~.ar ~

~tto. ,p~ '·t!!i .... r: U j,.~~J'~, ~;/ IiJJltI lJ.I . ..tI',.' • .!! ,w~ :?-cJr:J~JyP;i!P'

w 'I!!I~',jfJIW/~ _ ~7· + .~t oil • ~"Itr"." r-'! -

1P"1"

-,A.::{,~il~{JJ~~£ iP:,l-!f>J~t' ,x;:'~~'~~,",.))Jr~d!itt~'~6~IJ r'af',~;~YIBk}~~~~YI4~JJ~~~~~1~,~[.;tj~hr~~ . ~,~a}J;'t.d&r-~~~~.'~~~Ll;.~:J~,:t~~~i«~' ,g: J. ,'~, .. ~t~i.,;',"~; ';;,. ;f' •• ~~~,"li..4,-.:J.~'~, -.' ., (3 ~~'~~,~~,j:J1~.'-,~.

".- . ~~;. 'rH!I!~"-"- ~~ "P~ v/, .. --~f'~'I~'I~'~i~ ~

iJJ~~, ... Ji~I.I):[~tit~W-",~ _ '~.;';~t,J.,JJ~/J. '§cJN'bi..,/~j,· ~~9~~J·!.M~'~i ~,.,tt='., . e -

"I!i .. '_ . L~ •• II '~!I!Ir/ .

'~!V~J~'~~Y~~li!.j!.Jj"q.'ri1~~~h~t~f.'~

'r~\f"~~l;r"·~~!'~kj'~A1~Y~~1\11

- .',- .. , .,' ~,~rt~~, - if

'~~~JU' ,

,~N'e<~~~'I,; ..... ~i'~tJ~~~:.t'V· '::" ';;:~~I~';;"'-¥/1-.&5"".r."":!:Jt~,~~:~r- tJ~I~-~-·JJ~~j,IJl'~:/-·

1~4:~j £!j{b"t., hf:r:;t.(~:,·;..,J"M2l!: "u"::Jif . '''''~ I''''''~;d':ll ;tP~ , j,',~:~'

~. - l~ .~-, .~- f ..,1.'- &fl~I~'-" ." ~~ ~.~. I~'':' L ... :~\~I\I!

IL~~~yl~~t"M~:~,t~~ .~_ ~r~'1Jratt'Gr~~~~

,~/}!" ~fjt~~'iri'iiI'~· .. d.tJ~! ..J.o'!~~II~ "[G,O-I~~~£I,'.!o:W.~,"~·

~ - ~~J~~' ... ,.~~. ,-.J._ .:J!""".:..U .' - _~,~~I -, ~~

Jr~~~~~}ii~~H.tJ~~:tffi~~b~~li~'i~l~

·~~'·""I· ;,.~;,~AH\J,...t:~L,..J,~jk.;r8'L" i' .~,I::",'.· .,J.,J.'~' '~U";or ~'Fj~,i";':iIJ_","", !~ ~ .... ~. ~i~ll ~~. i!!!" ~L!lJ l~ "'~ iJl"U',.,·~; t:.lflil!.~~.

Jrfi~,·.+~·~J~~~.f~ ... QZrJJ~:~ ~ ,.71 "tf~Jjji~'l;J#j,'~rJ~' ~~46t'fi))i~/~,ij'Jfwt#· ~"~';r'¢~4j~~ ( rJ'4~·~Gt)<u)1)liJt'Jtif(:.I~~, .. ,J'$L. ~'.' ,,' ' - '. ~

_ -" L~"~,~.y' 1'-.' !iii ,CiI'J -'!,.~~ -~I '~, ._ _ 'l~ -._ .:..:;o.,~·'-W'·--

• "P' ~ii\~"''''~I~!iw::"I'+"r''1r' q ~>'J'A.J'4

. I

",~"~J ... J; Uili'l _iJJ..:r'~·"~L~~' lliti' vnJ.I~,Id~J!"1

/_.; ~" •• J'" • _. • i{jI.: I' Q' .•. ~7· ... <f'" . - -,o'

rJtf~~'~vfJdJPi~.)1,1 c: .~t;!rUt;i)i~JII{f#,~

JiI\f-u:.""'tJ.I""iF'pIJ~~.:JI~?I;JI" ~,jU»,,,~}If,,,, tIIlJI);';dI*,'~

~'~/~i~~~~":J.;tI&,,I.ik.,;~;t)Y~~·.ll ,.IJ.A .. I}d.VJtJlll~JtJ'If'

,rw ... · -lilT"' , . -. 7#', .

• ,~J" )~,J,~'I~~oJl\r~I.#.it.~,~jr.~r-:~~J _~.ij.lJ.~~1!d"UI,L.o ~'~.

_,_ i .. ' 'T'!'" ~ '..;1-.,.... ~ tIl- ." ~yP" . .'." · . - . ~ .'IJf" '.,

~ka,!:::Jl.t' 11i"'1'i'II'J~ • U""'~,/:; Ii?"'). _I ,,,,,,,,,~_'.'..!-~ll"'{~~.:JI.it,Ji:!~.ILf·I' ,)"" '~i.~rb& .. U'./l.Il.rl:

u'" __ I"'~~'~ ,~!f;'~r .. if" " .{ ~trJ~~ .

~ "'II '/,jI'o' .:l:l L. _ J,'i'3t .r: ".. 'I!'-U'~.: Ii _.II "t""".Jji.r.",.!I'" ~ •. ,II;,a.1 '. r.......t:II,..;:i'...L~.'*"rw< .... ~lli:f ~ llOlllo;"~. "''-' ',l~''::'"

.. ,'1(""W,;l ,:...".~. '." ',' -.. "'.. ' ' -

~~H~"ll~!-~~)1IJ~bdJ<:l~J' JWJ .. ".ltJ,e.~.Jy, ..... r;..;I' , •. ~ f)''i1d1,;pt 11

l!J:lJu:~~a;J#ih.I~, tiI~AI\"LlI?,e-!,fIJI ": .' "'.t... ~.." hid C· wi - ~~.el'.!-i!<'!i~MOI ,pclj-Il';r» !Ill

~fiWJ.t.{.:}~!lt/..Jr-iil~ ~~r"""p

· "jp,(IYliI.."JPWlIit/; ri'U&:§JJIPd!.V'" ,yd»"'1il..r-JU.6.tIJ'J.,;,; ..hJ~IW/..ht.!;:lj fi 1;.IJN';~~!n;"..,v.. J. ~IJI'W"~' ~~~..6H1~~~J" r- ~ yt#lil:l&'r!i'Ji

If'~~.?,.M,,,j..AIi.h.11 '~';")lrI'l"'"

~~~~,S¢~~~~'" JPtaiD~q..

.. /~j~~u/~J# "tYl~~d t' ~JJ.t;~!JJJlJ~'iJ:.i)/~~,!:;r.jr'~

r(i?I;~,';jJ'e; ~~~4J ~j, ; tJ:;U+Jj~~~~I~l)

'.e~U .~U,~ "~,.~,~'ii:";U·h.t·;iL;~UtJ: ~.,ri:JI~J.d..,~J

~. ~~;.n. _,~II,~~I~~' W/" L!!" ~ ... ~.~ _' ~~~j .. '_

1~~i?'I4Jfj1[i(·Ob~~{i~~~~J~~~J'~ ~'·"r:;Jlt; .... ~:,."Z; 1 ,if. ,.#ijN~~'liA~4J ~. ''''JJ~~\tI

~'.I CUI) '-' '!"f ~ ~~~_ aiy,~~ ~ I'''' r!!~;" U-\jiiiliL!!' I~ ... ~I !"II!' '!!!I'

'Mtt)~I~~-" ~~~~~&~,J~J#o"l.i! .. ~~16~1"

~.Lt .... '-.-_ ' ,Mt .~··t.-·'·.· ... ,..I!.rrJl(·.·.·~.,~l" .. ~,i.' '~.' ~,~. d./"" .. ~ t

r: V"~W~'''' .... i"""u-, _ .. _, f' 71:1

':;;U,~~, 1~ -"' ~ £..1' ~"j'" .!""b~~

~' .-' ,iii, i'/~' li«- _' :.;J"~l'--j

t; L;"~~"'"

, "'~ - ,:.,.',.,' 1,-·' -"

~ " .: , . . . .

....... . . ,' .. . ": "

".' 'M ' .. '

4, .

".- .":

.

.

ti~- *-'. ~'41~': ~ - .,/ - .Jf'.w' liP"

.

r~ ~, .. .r .II~'C IL:J~'~_ ..N,II (..7

_.,' --.' ' .

cJ j (;"';'I~ ' . ." J-i~'

~'~ ~ ., rll ~: ....

I W7~_,..N .. '"

'-,", -

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful

Master Your Semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Special offer for students: Only $4.99/month.

Master Your Semester with a Special Offer from Scribd & The New York Times

Cancel anytime.