You are on page 1of 6

Defing the VET Policy Instruments for Developing the National Innovation System of Fuel Cell Technologies

Chi-Yo Huang
Department of Industrial Education National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei, Taiwan
Abstract—Fuel cells have emerged as one of the possible solutions for resolving the severe pollutions and petroleum consumptions by traditional vehicles. During the past decades, national governments worked aggressively toward the fuel cell innovations by national innovation systems (NISs). Albeit the universities play an important role in the NIS and the vocational education and training (VET) usually serve as an important subsystem, very few scholars tried to discuss how the VET system can be configured through the VET policy instruments so that the NIS can be enabled. Thus, the authors aim to configure the VET policy portfolio by defining a hybrid multiple criteria decision making (MCDM) framework aiming at resolving this problem. Components of the NIS as well as VET policy tools which are suitable for developing the VET system and enabling the NIS were first derived from literature review as criteria and alternatives. Then, a hybrid MADM (Multiple Attribute Decision Making) framework consisting of the modified Delphi method, the DEMATEL and the ANP will be introduced for deriving appropriate VET policy tools for developing the VET system and enable the NIS of the fuel cell technologies. Experts from Taiwanese research and academic institutes were invited for providing opinions for defining the VET policy instruments. Mandates, capacity building and system change were recognized by the experts as the most important VET policy tools for enabling the NIS of the fuel cell technologies from the aspects of firms’ R&D organizations, research institutes and research association. Keywords–fuel cell; Vocational Education and Training (VET); National Innovation System (NIS), MCDM (Multiple Criteria Decision Making, MCDM); DEMATEL; Analytic Network Process (ANP).

Chi-Cheng Chang
Department of Industrial Technology Education National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei, Taiwan Innovation is the engine for national technological development [3] while technological change is widely recognized as a key driver of economic development [4]. However, due to the public nature of the knowledge that underpins innovation, the uncertainty that often plagues the process of innovation, the needs for certain kinds of complementary assets, the nature of certain technologies, and plain politics [5], it is generally accepted that governments play a key role in innovation, and especially the development of radical innovation like the fuel cell technologies [1]. Although, the role of government in technology development differs between countries, most have some form of the national system of innovation [1, 6]. The most important nation-specific frame conditions for any sectoral S&T policies are the national institutional conditions for technological innovations. This institutional infrastructure is often referred to as a "National Innovation System (NIS)". This term is defined as: "the network of institutions in the public and private sectors whose activities and interactions initiate, modify and diffuse new technologies" [7]. Since the studies by Freeman, several other studies on NIS have been published [8-10]. All of these studies tried to understand regional innovative capabilities in relation to the various institutions that were present in the nations under study [11, 12]. A well-developed NIS, the system including wellestablished institutes and organizations including industry, government, university and research institutes as well as the strong linkages between them may enhance the creation, diffusion and application of a nation’s knowledge, and thus, the enhancement of a nation’s innovation capability. In the past decades, national governments have pursued planning in various NIS to pursue nations’ continuous growth. The vocational education and training (VET) system is the most important sub educational systems of an NIS and can affect a nation’s innovation productivity by providing sufficient high quality technical human resources. However, provision of VET is subject to several market failures: capital-market imperfections, risk arising from variability of future values of skills, mismatch of costs and returns owing to worker mobility, and general positive externalities of human capital. Thus, government’s intervention in the development of the VET system is rational. Meanwhile, very little research proposed appropriate quantitative VET policy instrument definition methodologies. Furthermore, how to develop a nation’s NISs of emerging industries like the fuel cell industry is the one of the most critical problems governments, policy makers and



Fuel cells, electrochemical devices that produce electricity through clean chemical reactions rather than environmentally detrimental processes like combustion [1], have emerged as one of the possible solutions for resolving the severe pollutions and petroleum consumptions by traditional vehicles. Fuel cells complement heat engines and reduce the ubiquitous dependence on fossil fuels and thus have significant environmental and national security implications [2]. During the past decades, national governments worked aggressively toward the innovation of fuel cells by national innovation systems.

978-1-61284-714-6/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE

innovation. and thus. Lundvall [8] and Nelson [9]. However. diffuse and exploit innovations. [23]. II. experts will be invited to configure the VET policy portfolios. traditional qualitative approaches could be subjective and misleading. (6) networking around knowledge. Ferrier. and Cluster analysis are all used to build an analytic structural framework to derive the nation’s vocational education and training (VET) policy instruments for developing emerging industries. (8) incubating activities. there are no straightforward answers to the questions: what elements should a VET policy include. Grey Relation Analysis (GRA). (6) time preference. there is a broad definition that encompasses all interrelated institutional actors that generate. reduce the over-complicated VET policy instruments to the most significant VET policy instruments. Discussions will be presented in Section 5. ten major activities/functions/factors influencing innovation are (1) research and development. Empirical studies on Taiwan’s emerging industries illustrate the derivation of the VET policy portfolios for developing NISs of Taiwan’s fuel cell industry. access to appropriate education and training is essential. (3) formation of new product. Therefore. and (3) operative/Technical skills. and (7) externalities. how a VET system should be configured to fulfill the needs of NISs of emerging industries have not been discussed much by past researches. the VET policy instruments will be reviewed as a basis for this research. and then map the most significant VET policy instruments to implement the NIS of emerging industries. These analytic results. The market failures are also the major reasons for Government’s intervene in vocational education. Greehalgh [26] summarized possible vocational educational policy instruments including public subsidy and information. (5) imperfect information. Section 6 will conclude the whole article with observations. There is also a narrow definition that includes the organizations and institutions involved in searching and exploring. C. (3) capacity building. e. conclusions and recommendations for further study. Despite conceptual advances and illustrative case studies. (9) financing innovation and (10) consultancy services. Leney also proposed that (1) mandates. (3) act locally and learn globally. (7) creating and changing institutions. it should be defined by specifying different functions. the concepts being related to the NIS. (4) general positive externalities of human capital [26]. which are the most important VET policy instruments. As Lundvall [8] illustrated. vocational education institutes should consider taking these strategies: (1) emphasize on innovation. the hybrid MCDM methods based research framework will be introduced to construct the decision framework. In Section 3. to continue the first authors’ former research in policy portfolio configuration and reconfiguration [13]. In the following Section. the Modified Delphi method. (4) form multiple partnerships. According to Edquist [21]. etc. will be necessary to develop Taiwan’s fuel cell industry. technical institutes and universities [12]. VET and Enhancement of NIS The European Training Foundation (ETF) and the European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training defined VET to be education and training that aim to equip people with skills and competences that can be used in the labor market [22]. Analytic Network Process (ANP). how the VET policy portfolio should be defined to assist the development of NISs of the emerging fuel cell industry has become the most important issue for developing the VET system.g. (2) competence building. the VET system development proposal . among others. property right improvement. R&D departments. shorttermism and risk aversion. DEMATEL (Decision Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory). (5) hortation and deliberative change are possible VET policy instruments [22]. (3) mismatch of costs and returns owing to worker mobility. (5) creation and change of. and finally. (4) articulation of user needs. However. Trood and Whittingham [23] suggests that innovation is likely to lead to increased needs for: (1) Technology-related skills. VET Policy and Instruments The concept of market failure has been the key to the development of VET policy of countries at the national level over the last decades [25]. 19]. To accomplish this. diffusion and application of a nation’s knowledge. Then in Section 4. Moodie [24] suggested that in addition to providing services to innovative firms and industries. labour market imperfections and the poaching of skilled workers [25]. By the way. (5) establish a national network of the vocational education innovation institutes and (6) act in the long term. they all involve the creation. (4) systems changing. NIS AND VET POLICY INSTRUMENTS A well-developed NIS enhances the creation. However. NIS Innovation systems can be defined in many ways focusing either on their functional or on their territorial aspects [14-17]. Freeman [18. Since the mid-1980s. the literature regarding to the NIS and VET policy instruments will be reviewed.researchers are facing. diffusion and use of knowledge. If new and changed skill needs are to be met. The provision of VET is subject to several market failures: (1) capital-market imperfections (credit constraints). A. workers-finance and training opportunity. (2) risk arising from variability of future values of skills. Due to the rationality of government’s intervention in VET development. have developed the concept of the ‘National System of Innovation’ (NSI) in order to study the interrelations between technological development and the institutional embeddedness of innovative organizations [17]. and how should such policies be implemented? An example of defining a VET system with a qualitative approach includes the VET system development for Austria by Ferrier et al. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. to enhance NIS by VET. Experts from the Taiwanese academic and research institute will be invited to provide opinions for the questionnaires being developed based on the hybrid MCDM framework. the objectives of this project is to develop a hybrid multiple criteria decision making (MCDM) framework to allow for configuring VET policy portfolios for developing NISs of emerging industries. (2) develop a distinctive role in the national innovation system. (2) inducements. Lundvall [20] mentioned that rather than defining the system as constituted by organizations. the relationships between the VET and the development of the NIS. Thus. Thus. (2) management skills. B. In Section 2.

Definition 1: The pair-wise comparison scale may be designated as eleven levels. Definition 6: Suppose ri denotes the row sum of ∑ ∑ the ith row of matrix T .10 represent the range from ‘no influence’ to ‘very high influence’. and if ( ri .. Huang et al.. provides a general framework to deal with decisions without making assumptions about the independence of higher-level elements from lower level elements and about the independence of the elements within a level as in a hierarchy [32]. i. A typical entry Wij = [ winx jny ] .. in terms of influences and directions between the objectives. nx ∈{1. The important NIS linkages between the VET systems and the industries as well as research institutes were not mentioned. This relative importance value can be determined using a scale of 1–9 to represent equal importance to extreme importance [32]. m. ny ∈ {1. ehm . 2. ANALYTIC FRAMEWORK AND METHODS FOR RECONFIGURING AN INNOVATION POLICY PORTFOLIO The analytical process for expanding a nation’s innovation capabilities is initiated by collecting the IIRs being needed to develop the national innovation capabilities as well as objectives to be achieved after a nation’s enhancing IIRs using the Delphi method. Definition 5: The row and column sums are separately denoted as r and c within the total-relation matrix T through T = [tij ]. ni } . n j } in the ∑ n a ) j =1 ij −1 . in which aij is denoted as the degree to which the ith objective affects the j objective.. eh2 .... The ANP Method The ANP method. lim N k = [0]n×n . n} .. A component of a decision network which was derived by the DEMATEL method in Section 3. N is a direct influence matrix and N = [ xij ]n×n . concepts of the ANP are summarized based on Saaty’s earlier works [32.. the vague correlations between policy tools as well as NIS components as well as linkages..1. lim ( N 2 + + N k ) stands for a indirect k →∞ supermatrix. The weights of every goal are based on the structure derived by using the ANP... Then. the total relationship matrix T can be obtained using T = N + N 2 + ...2. and assume that it has nh elements. 33]. Finally.1 will be denoted by Ch . Definition 4: Then. Chiu et al. The influence of elements in the network on other elements in that network can be represented in the supermatrix as Wij = [ wij ]. n} is obtained by pair-wise comparisons. + N k = N ( I .. the structure of the MCDM problem will be derived using the DEMATEL.. Here. respectively. Then.2. Since lim N k = [0]n×n . 2. To apply the DEMATEL method smoothly. and the lack of priorities of the policy tools deducted from the analysis procedure could cause governments to waste education resources. Since any goals to be derived by the Delphi may impact each other. i. A. The influences of a given set of elements in a component on any element in the decision system are represented by a ratio scale priority vector derived from paired comparisons of the comparative importance of one criterion and another criterion with respect to the interests or preferences of the decision makers.. The k →∞ . k → ∞ and T is a total influencerelated matrix. c j is the sum of the influences that factor i is receiving from the other factors. The DEMATEL Method The DEMATEL method was developed by the Battelle Geneva Institute: (1) to analyze complex ‘world problems’ dealing mainly with interactive man-model techniques.N )-1 .2.... is called a block of the supermatrix in the following form where each column of W ij is a principal eigenvector of the influence of the elements (objective) in the ith component of the network on an element (objective) in the influence matrix and 0 ≤ xij < 1 . then factor i primarily is receiving influence from other factors [31]. ⎡ n ⎤ ⎡ n ⎤′ r = [ ri ]n×1 = ⎢ tij ⎥ and c = [c j ]n×1 = ⎢ tij ⎥ .. ri is the sum of the influences dispatching from factor i to the other factors. the sum of the row sum and the column sum ( ri + c j ) represents the index representing the strength of the influence. j) element tij of matrix T denotes the direct and indirect influences of factor i on factor j . B. N k →∞ is called the normalized matrix. the ⎢ j =1 ⎥ ⎢ i =1 ⎦ ⎥ 1×n ⎣ ⎣ ⎦ n×1 r and c vectors denote the sums of the rows and columns.... In this section. Definition 3: The normalized direct relation/influence matrix N can be obtained through following equations in which all principal diagonal elements are equal to zero: N = zA where z = (max 1≤ i ≤ n th (i. Moreover. j ∈{1. Furthermore. and (2) to evaluate qualitative and factor-linked aspects of societal problems [27].by Ferrier et al.2. m} . Here. [23] focused on fulfilling skills needs for Austria’s emerging industries only. Definition 2: The initial direct relation/influence matrix A = [aij ]n×n .. So. j ∈{1.…. III.c j ) is positive. which we denote by eh1 . j ∈ {1. merely because either low or nopriority policy instruments are executed. i ∈{1. m} . Suppose that c j denotes the column sum of the j th column of matrix T . when i = j (i.e... the authors refined the definitions by Hori and Shimizu [28]. where I stands for the identity matrix.. both directly and indirectly. h = 1.c j ) is negative. In this case. where the scores 0. a multi criteria theory of measurement developed by Saaty [32]. [29]. If ( ri . [30] and produced the essential definitions indicated below..2. then factor i primarily is dispatching influence upon the other factors. 2. the innovation competence expansion process will be based on a multiple objective programming approach based on the concept of minimum spanning tree by introducing innovation competences being derived by Delphi and weights corresponding to each objective being derived by ANP in the former stages. both dispatching and receiving). ( ri + c j ) is the degree of the central role that factor i plays in the problem.

the concept of the fuel cell technology will first be briefed as a basis for the VET policy portfolio definitions. most have some form of the national system of innovation [1. etc. governments worldwide have aggressively launched several hydrogen-associated projects to establish infrastructures. Fuel Cell & Infrastructure Technologies Program” in 2004 for building hydrogen infrastructures. legislating regulations.S. In general. (6) Financial institutes ( nc6 ). xi (k )) = An Introduction to the Fuel Cell Technology Fuel cells are electrochemical devices. The procedure bears some similarity to pattern recognition technology. The U. and γ ( x0 . if the supermatrix has the effect of cyclicity. C. vector or called weights [34]. Configuring the VET Policy Portfolio for Enabling the NIS of the Fuel Cell Technologies Based on the literature review results. will be used as the weight for the k th objective in the following Section 3. the fuel cell technology offers many advantages including (1) high conversion efficiency. (min min ( x0 (k ) − xi (k )) + ζ max max ( x0 (k ) − xi (k )) ) × ∀i ∀k ∀i ∀k ( ( x0 (k ) − xi (k )) + ζ max max ( x0 (k ) − xi (k )) )−1 where ζ is the distinguished coefficient ( ζ ∈ [0. xi ) between the reference alternative ∀i ∀k γ ( x0 . sources of innovation as composing a complex system wherein any particular innovation may emerge primarily from one or more components of the system or the linkages between them. Based on Schilling’s definitions.. According to Brown [39]. enhance fuel cell technologies. (2) versatility of output. According to Schilling [42]. legislate policies. the limiting supermatrix is not the only one. Then. (4) Technical universities ( nc4 ). xi (k )). To apply the GRA. The whole energy conversion process is similar to that of a battery. xi ) = ∑ n k =1 ωk × γ ( x0 (k ). B. [30] and produced the essential definitions indicated below. namely ωk . the weighted supermatrix is derived by transforming all columns sum to unity exactly. A configuration of the VET policy portfolio follows based on the opinions of three experts from Taiwanese academic or research institutes.6]. ωk expresses the weight of the k th criterion. innovation can arise from many different sources including individuals. C. xi ) represents the grade of grey relation in xi (the k th strategy) correspondence to x0 . except that it will continue to generate electricity as long as there is a hydrogen and oxygen supply [1]. Next. private nonprofit organizations. which basically consist of a positive and negative electrode separated by an electrolyte and produce electricity through clean chemical reactions rather than environmentally detrimental processes like combustion [1]. government created a “Hydrogen. For examples. firms as well as networks of innovators that leverage knowledge and other resources from multiple sources. Some of its entries may be zero corresponding to those elements (objective) that have no influence. Deng also proposed a mathematical equation for the grey relation coefficient. the weighted supermatrix is raised to limiting powers. Fuel cells convert the chemical energy of a gaseous fuel directly into electricity and are widely regarded as a potential alternative stationary and mobile source [2]. 2. Japanese government held a Japan Hydrogen & Full Cell Demonstration Project (JHFC) in 2002 for EV promotion and hydrogen technology development [40]. The weights of the k th objective being derived by using the above ANP processes.j th component. k ∈{1. n} . . where k is the number of IIRs. When the grey relational coefficient is conducted with respect to innovation policies. universities. They complement heat engines and reduce the ubiquitous dependence on fossil fuels and thus have significant environmental and national security implications [2]. DEFINING THE VET POLICY PORTFOLIO FOR DEVELOPING THS NIS OF THE FUEL CELL INDUSTRY In the following Section.1] ).. (2) science parks ( nc2 ). we pick ζ =0. European Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Technology Initiative (JTI) focuses on hydrogen technology development. associated education. Generally. the components of the NIS as well as linkages between the components are summarized below as the basis of this research [42]: (1) firms’ R&D organizations ( nc1 ). we then can derive the grade of the grey relation γ ( x0 . IV. and (4) non-polluting. In this study.. This step is very much similar to the concept of the Markov chain in terms of ensuring that the sum of these probabilities of all states equals 1. After forming the supermatrix. One sequence of data is called the ‘reference pattern’ or ‘reference sequence.3. we make the order of the innovation mechanisms following the grade of grey relation. In addition. the role of government in technology development differs between countries.’ and the correlation between the other sequence and the reference sequence is to be identified [35-38]. the authors refined the definitions by Huang et al. EV technologies. (3) Incubators ( nc3 ).. the innovation system components and linkages between the components were first be derived from Freeman [41] and Schilling [42]. such as lim W θ to get the global priority θ →∞ A. VET policy instruments were derived based on the educational policy instruments being proposed by McDonnell and Elmore [43]. (3) easy maintenance. Governmental Efforts for Developing the Fuel Cell Technologies To promote fuel cell systems also the fuel cell EVs. and the Cesaro sum would need to be calculated to get the priority. Grey Relational Analysis GRA is used to determine the relationship between two sequences of stochastic data in a Grey system. There are two or more limiting supermatrices in this situation. government laboratories and incubators. (5) Research institutes ( nc5 ).5. [40] Although. as follows: γ ( x0 (k ).

.229 1.000 0. In this paper.196 1. 7 3 Figure 1. means not applicable. i.596 0. the components indeed influence the development of the fuel cell technologies. Meanwhile.000 0.130 1.085 1. McDonnell and Elmore proposed five educational policy instruments [43] as alternative policy instruments or mechanisms which translate substantive policy goals into concrete actions [44]. government-sponsored joint research programs ( nc11 ).267 0. VI.135 1.085 0.117 1.177 1.137 1.246 1. the results worth further investigations by inviting industry experts who really own experiences in fuel cell commercialization.000 0.000 0.060 0.113 1. Those five instruments include mandates ( i1 ).396 0.000 0.000 0.000 nc 3 0. licensing agreements ( nc9 ).031 0.103 1. research institutes and research association. 1. During the past decades.000 0.942 1.963 1.000 0.046 5 should define policies for encouraging technical universities and colleges emphasizing on the education of alternative energies.090 1.046 1.329 0. how the current VET system can be changed is worth discussing in future researches. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of Taiwan National Science Council through grant number NSC 97-2511-S-003-039-MY2 and NSC 98-2511-S-003-068-MY2. Based on the empirical study results.000 0.000 0.671 0. based on the experts’ evaluations on the VET policy tools.035 1.089 1.000 0. Meanwhile.122 1.271 1.149 1.Furthermore.163 1.059 1.153 1. a hybrid MCDM framework was proposed to resolve this issue.105 1. grey grades versus each tool can be derived as follows in TABLE II. Thus.000 nc 5 0.080 1. national governments worked aggressively toward the fuel cell innovations by national innovation systems (NISs).000 0.329 0.199 1.210 0.096 1.101 1.233 1.259 1. capacity building ( i3 ).178 nc 7 0.000 0.000 nc 8 0.086 0. research associations( nc10 ).300 1.120 1.000 0. unless the dominant design emerged.090 1.215 1.000 0. For the NIS components being recognized by the experts as important but neglected and weighted as “0”.000 0. joint ventures ( nc8 ).086 1.182 1.113 1. inducement ( i2 ). 1) can be derived by using the total relationship matrix T being derived by the DEMATEL at first.293 T= 1. financial institutes which can provide loans for fuel cell commercialization may not be essential.000 0.178 1.000 Grey Grades 0. being analyzed by the DEMATEL. CONCLUSIONS Fuel cells have emerged as one of the possible solutions for resolving the severe pollutions and petroleum consumptions by traditional vehicles.168 0.133 1. the decision framework can first be derived based on three experts’ opinions from Taiwanese commercial banks.131 1.179 1.116 1.105 1.957 1. The network of relation map (Fig.016 1.000 0.097 1.185 0. capacity building ( i3 ) and system change ( i4 ) were recognized by the experts as the most important VET policy tools for enabling the NIS of the fuel cell technologies from the aspects of firms’ R&D organizations ( nc1 ).167 1. Weights versus Each Criteria Component Weight nc 1 nc 2 nc 3 nc 4 nc 5 nc 6 N. By introducing the proposed hybrid MCDM framework being proposed.671 0. However.089 1. The VET policy tools 1.106 1.000 0.023 1. based on Shilling’s summarization [42] of an earlier work by Freeman [41].061 1.273 1. technicians may not really play an important role in fuel cell development and commercialization.195 1. investments in the development of the intellectual and human resources for fuel cells will be very helpful.094 1.164 1.162 1.263 1.000 0. research institutes ( nc5 ) and research association ( nc10 ). joint ventures and license agreements may not play an important role. nc 7 nc 8 nc 9 nc 10 nc 11 0.176 1.329 0. Finally.183 1. licensing agreement ( nc9 ) and Government-sponsored joint research programs ( nc11 ). However.004 1.115 nc 2 0. V.A.210 0.201 1.257 0. The NRM TABLE 1.000 0. 3 and 4 are the most suitable one for developing the NIS of the fuel cell technologies.983 4 8 9 11 10 1 2 The financial institutes were recognized as unimportant in the very beginning of the modified Delphi process though they are recognized as important in NIS literature.000 0.054 0.121 1. Technical universities ( nc4 ). TABLE II.000 0. mandates ( i1 ).231 1.000 0.128 1.000 0.151 1.253 1.148 1.170 1.000 0. the components are important but not influential. Grey Grades versus Each Policy Instrument NC PI i1 i2 i3 i4 i5 nc 1 0.154 1.000 0. Finally. DISCUSSION In this research.165 1. how the VET systems can be configured by policy instrument definitions so that the NIS can be enabled was seldom addressed.342 0.024 1.152 1. The weights versus each component of the NIS can be derived by using the ANP (TABLE I).000 nc 9 0.170 1.000 Remark: N.967 1.235 1.073 1. mandates.256 1. In the introduction stage of the product life cycles. Finally.e.191 1.124 1.101 nc 11 0.133 1.000 0.027 1. joint venture ( nc8 ).082 1.032 0. the Government .000 0.189 1.051 1.329 0. linkages between components in a NIS include technology clusters ( nc7 ).329 0. The results may due to the background of experts who are familiar with the embryonic phase of the fuel cells.A.000 0.077 1.342 0.217 1. before the product life cycle really enters the growth stage. Based on opinions by academic and industry experts.210 0.029 1. capacity building and system change were recognized by the experts as the most important VET policy tools for enabling the NIS of the fuel cell technologies from the aspects of firms’ R&D organizations. system changing ( i4 ) and persuasion ( i5 ).063 0.166 1.130 1.000 0.329 0.157 1.342 0.000 nc 4 0.908 1.093 1.000 nc 10 0.000 0.

755-767. 2008. 2004. "Formal Scientific and Technical Institutions in the National System of Innovation. pp. Freeman. Lundvall. 395-408.L. Jacobsson. 2010.. vol. Dosi. J. pp. Eds. Å.L. and K. A. vol. Kapoor." The Journal of Grey System." International Journal of Technology. 7. Decision Making with Dependence and Feedback: The Analytic Network Process. F. [12] H. ed London: Printer." Pattern Recognition Letters. pp.Z. 369-374. analysis. J. "Getting the Job Done: Alternative Policy Instruments. A. pp. 2003.H." Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis. [23] F. 2005. B. 2009. and profits. Liaw. Tzeng. [36] D. [28] S. ed London: Printer.REFERENCES [1] J. [19] C. 1986.H.-Y. Å. vol. L.. 169-187. "Adult vocational training and government policy in France and Britain. implementation. 1992. 1994." Research Policy." American Journal of Education. Strategic Management of Technological Innovation: McGraw-Hill. modeling. World Problems. ed London: Printer. [3] J. H." Control Engineering Practice. Freeman. [7] C. Eds. Introduction of Grey Analysis. Volume 3. [8] B. [35] J." in Technical Change and Economic Theory. "Designing methods of human interface for supervisory control systems. Grey Forecasting and Decision." Research Policy. "Innovation as an interactive process: from user producer interaction to the national system of innovation. A Comparative Analysis. pp. Pittsburgh: RWS Publication. QC. "Multidimensional data in multidimensional scaling using the analytic network process.Z. G. ed Norfolk: Oxford University Press. pp." R&D Management. "Marketing strategy based on customer behaviour for the LCD-TV.C. "NATIONAL INNOVATION SYSTEMS ANALYTICAL CONCEPT AND DEVELOPMENT TOOL. Lundvall. Huang." in The Oxford Handbook of Innovation. 1998." Research Policy. H. Saaty. Oxford: Oxford University Press. London: Pinter. [24] G. Paris: OECD. "The reconfiguration of National Innovation Systems--the example of German biotechnology.H. [16] B. A.. [34] J. Lai and Y. Hung. "Networks of innovators: A synthesis of research issues.. 6th. 1950.Y. Osaka. and J. [11] F. [37] G." Research Policy. [29] Y. 87-108. [47] L.J. et al. pp. pp. 20. 2002. Hori and Y. 1. [45] R.-H. [41] C. 2004. Tzeng. Technology policy and economic performance: lessons from Japan. pp. 2002. 1-9. 392-420. vol. an Invitation to Further Thought Within the Framework of DEMATEL. G. [44] W." in DRUID Tenth Anniversary Summer Conference 2005 on DYNAMICS OF INDUSTRY AND INNOVATION: ORGANIZATIONS. The Legal Environment of Business: Cengage Learning. 27. Schilling. Elmore. 7. [6] B. [4] C. 2007. H.: McGraw-Hill Education (India) Pvt Ltd. 1994. McDonnell and R. [27] A. Report to the European Commission. 2002. Trood. [14] J. [13] C. and Risks.. 2006. Nelson. Prange. Wuhan: Huazhong University of Science and Technology Press. New York: Oxford University Press. 744-765. Chen. et al. London: Pinter." Research in Post-Compulsory Education. 32. and feedback design: Springer. J. Gupta. [15] F. Whittingham. 2006. Peng. [40] C.L. Edwards. 1998. Pride. "Extraction and systems analysis of factors that prevent safety and security by structural models. the case of the Dutch biotechnological sector. 2007. "Vocational education institutions' role in national innovation. 38-66. [32] T. 31. National Systems of Innovation. Pavitt. [46] R.-S. 2005. 291-302." Technovation. 1995. [10] P.Y. "Innovation dynamics and environmental technologies: the emergence of fuel cell technology. 1988. and G. "Market Failure in Skills. Chiu. vol. G. ed. 1413-1419. vol. [38] H. Mon. Denmark. "Innovation systems: analytical and methodological issues. "National systems of innovations are "x-efficient" (and xeffective): Why some are slow learners. Moodie. 97113.. vol. and C. pp. Policy and Management. 396-421. Adelaide: NCVER. vol. M. 1987.. Kaiser and H. Janszen and G. Costs. Opportunities.. Brown. vol. [48] L. Going Boldly into the Future: A VET Journey into the National Innovation System. [26] C." International Journal of Management and Decision Making. Control of fuel cell power systems: principles. Holmén. Dosi. vol. pp. 102. and H. vol. Leney. Z. 2005. Afuah. Freeman and L. Deng. London: Pinter Publishers. [21] C. pp. 2005." Journal of Advanced Computational Intelligence and Intelligent Informatics (Forthcoming). et al. 2004. Lu. 27.. [2] J. Pittsburg. Meiners. Shyu. Tasur. pp. Hughes. National Systems of Innovation: Towards a Theory of Innovation and Interactive Learning. 1996. Soete. Keep. 31. Malerba. 2002. Tamura. [17] R. Business: Cengage South-Western. The nature and economic importance of national innovations systems. Freeman. London: The Lisbon-to-Copenhagento-Maastricht Consortium Partners. 131140. 1996. vol. Greehalgh. and H. [39] C. NETWORKS AND SYSTEMS. pp. and F." Journal of Cleaner Production. 2007. Ong. Tzeng. vol. 2011. 3rd. Edwards. Theory and Applications of the Analytic Network Process Decision Making with Benefits. [43] K. 11. L. [25] E. vol. Lundvall. Patel and K.C. 1994. Akazawa. 15. Kerr. "Japan: a new national system of innovation. pp. 1999. Gabus and E. 1997. World energy resources: Springer. Pukrushpan.-J." Oxford Review of Economic Policy. and K. Contemporary Auditing. Tzeng "Assessment of the Appropriate Fuel Cell Technology for the Next Generation Hybrid Power Automobiles. Eds. Huang. 11. pp.." Journal of Chung Chen Institute of Technology. S. vol. Ferrier.H. Wu. and A. Carlsson. [30] C. Innovation management: strategies. [18] C. M. Fontela. C. C. vol. PA: RWS Publications. pp. vol. Tzeng.Z. [20] B. Ringleb. Lundvall. 26. Nagata. Niosi. 27. ed. 233-245. 1991. Deng. 6. "Sectoral systems of innovation and production. Saaty. Geneva. pp." in Technical change and economic theory. 1993. Chiu. Shyu. [33] T. "The multiple criteria evaluation of Grey relation model. Japan. Switzerland: Batelle Geneva Research Center. 37-54. H. Tzeng and S. Stefanopoulou. Tzeng. Huang. ed. 744-765. 499-514. vol." Research Policy. "Evaluating effects of innovation policies on Taiwan's IC design industry: a fuzzy integral MCDM approach. 1987. G. Huang. 7. "Assessment policy as persuasion and regulation." Research Policy. 33. Copenhagen. 73-84. Y." in National Systems of Innovation: Towards a Theory of Innovation and Interactive Learning. pp.H. "A dynamic analysis of the relations between the structure and the process of National Systems of Innovation using computer simulation. and G. Wen. L. J. Shyu. 26. Degenaars. [5] A. vol." SSDA Catalyst. H. G. M.S. Taiwan: Gau-Li Publication Inc. C. 133-152. Shyu and Y."Grey decision making in weapon system evaluation. pp. 2002. H. R." Technovation. Freeman. Edquist. The Economics of Industrial Innovation. 2003. C. 1988. vol. Shimizu.H. "Reconfiguring the Innovation Policy Portfolios for Taiwan 's SIP Mall Industry. and G. 143-165. and J. Ed. Co-operative industrial research: a study of the economic aspects of the research associations grant-aided by the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research: Pitman. and K. 459-471. vol. pp. McDonnell. 1999. A. [31] M. Hall and R. 1972. "Systems of Innovation: Perspectives and Challenges. [22] T. "Reconfiguring the innovation policy portfolios for Taiwan's SIP Mall industry. 31. 1992. 9. 2006. "Innovation policy for developing Taiwan's competitive advantages. 2002. 1752-1759. . pp. Achieving the Lisbon goal: The contribution of VET. [9] R. 2004. 247-264. pp. Rickne. Fagerberg." in Proceedings of the 41st SICE Annual Conference. [42] M. pp.