You are on page 1of 76

)

SPA 2013 DC STATUS OF CASES As of May 06, 2013


----------------- ^ ------------------------MUN. / CITY / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-001 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C ASE


Mayor Adelino B. Sitoy vs.

STATUS
Resolution (SD ) x^x the instant Petition is G RANTED. Accordingly,\the C O C of respondent Rex Ong Salud is hereby CANCELLED
w 1 MR (to the Resolution d lte d Dec. 26, 2012) filed by

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

1.

Cordova, Cebu

Decem ber 26, 2012

II

Rex Ong Salud a.k.a. W a k ee Salud

respondent-movant on January 10, 2013 Resolution No. 9614 - xxx In view of the foregoing, there being no order or resolution emanating from the higher courts restraining the implementation of the aforementioned final and executory decision, the Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby R ES O LVES , to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidacy filed by and REM O VE from the Certified List of Candidates the name of Rex Ong Salud a.k.a. W akee Salud as M ayor of Cordova, Cebu in the May 13, 2013 NLE for failure to comply with the qualifications of an elective local official/ Let the Law Dept, implement this Resolution 2. Councilor District 6, Quezon City 13-002 (DC) In Re: Petition to disqualify Ma. Theresa E. G ana as candidate for councilor of District 6, Quezon City Nino A. Holgado
I

January 15, 2013

Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESOLVES, to D IS M IS S this case for being M O O T and ACADEM IC

January 10, 2013

vs. Ma. Theresa E. G ana

-------------------- 1------------------------------------

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-003 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
\

STA TU S
I Resolution (SD ) 'D IS M ISS ED xxx the petition is hereby

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

3.

Lone District of Camiguin

Pedro P. Romualdo vs.

January 21, 2013 February 07, 2013

Order (SD) - xxx M R elevated to en banc

II

Homobono A. A daza For: To Deny Due Course or To Cancel COC

\
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby G R A F TE D . JULIU S S. S A Y S O N is hereby declared as NUISANCE C A N D ID A T E and his Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Mayor of Bacolod City, is hereby ordered C A N C E L L E D January 29, 2013

4.

Bacolod City, Negros Occidental

13-004 (DC)

In Re: Petition to declare candidate Julius S. Sayson as nuisance candidate in the coming May 13, 201 3 Midterm Election Jude Thaddeus A. Sayson vs. Julius S. Sayson

5.

Dingras, llocos Norte

13-005 (DC)

Erdio E. Valenzuela vs.

Marynette R. Gam boa

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S to G R A N T the Petition. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy for the position of M ayor of Dingras, llocos Norte filed by the respondent Marynette R. Gamboa is hereby D EN IED D UE C O U R S E AND C A N C ELLED for misrepresenting her eligibility to the position for which the Certificate of Candidacy was filed, pursuant to Section 78, in relation to Section 74, both of the O E C and Section 40 (e) of the Local Government Code Resolution (EB) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y this Motion for Reconsideration for LACK O F M E R IT. Consequently, March 6, 2013 Resolution of the Commission First Division is hereby affirmed

March 06, 2013

April 19, 2013

Page 2 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
STA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-006 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A SE
V Ester Abrina Lazaro vs. Jerry Urmatan Lazaro * \

6.

Science City of Munoz, Nueva Ecija

II

7.

Dipolog City, Zamboanga del Norte II

13-007 (DC)

Julius B. GajoViera vs. Cecilia G. Jalosjos-Carreon

Order {S D ) - xxx the Commission (SD) hereby orders as follows: 1. To N O T E the Manifestation/Motion To Withdraw Petition" filed on Oct. 24, 2012 with attached Sworn Affidavit of Withdrawal of C O C dated Oct. 15, 2012; 2. To C O N S ID E R this instant petition withdrawn as prayed for by the petitioner Ester Abrina Lazaro assisted by Atty. Francisco B. Sibayan, counsel for petitioner; and 3. To C A N C EL the C O N F E R E N C E scheduled on Nov. 9, 2012 Resolution (SD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D E N Y the Petition to Deny Course to Respondent Cecilia G. Jalosjos-Carreon's Certificate of Candidacy

Novem ber 06, 2012

January 24, 2013

8.

First District of Quezon City

13-008 (DC)

Rita Katherine D. Crisologo vs. Albert Crisologo

Resolution (FD ) - xxx the petition is hereby G R A NTED. Respondent Albert Crisologo is hereby declared as a N UISA N CE C A N D ID A TE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Congressman of District I, Quezon City, for the 13 May 2013 NLE is C A N C ELLED

January 31, 2013

9.

I Libon, Albay

13-009 (DC)

John Vasquez Dycoco vs.

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D IS M IS S this case for LACK O F M E R IT

January 10, 2013

1 Domingo B. Samson 10. Lone District of Bacoor, Cavite 1 *


Page 3 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

13-010 (DC)

Jessie B. Castillo vs. Leonardo C. Castillo

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to G R A N T the instant petition. L E O N A R D O C. CASTILLO is hereby DECLARED as a N U IS A N C E C A N D ID A T E and accordingly, his C O C is hereby C A N C ELLED Order (FD) - xxx hereby D E N IE S said motion for the

D ecem ber 11, 2012

)
M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 201x 3 \

TITLE O F THE C ASE

STATUS
following reasons: 1. Failure to pay the corresponding fee for filing a motion for reconsideration; and 2. Lacking the number of copies required by the rules / The motion for reconsideration will still be denied for being pro-forma

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

\ January 22, 2013

1
11. Tubao, La Union 13-011 (DC) ^ Wilfredo S. Garcia vs. Wilfredo G. Garcia
I

Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to G R A N T the instant Petition. Respondent Wilfredo G. G arcia is declared as a N U IS A N C E CANDIDATE, accordingly, his Certificate of Candidacy is hereby D E N IE D and C A N C ELLED Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby D ENIED for lack of merit

January 29, 2013

May 03, 2013

12.

Cortes, Bohol

13-012 (DC)

Atty. Claudita M. Gifard vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E D , as it hereby R ES O LVES , to D EN Y the Petition dated 29 October 2012

March 21, 2013

I
Roberto L. Tabanera 13.
Pagalungan, Maguindanao

13-013 (DC)

Giamaludin Nor vs.

il

Resolution (SD) - xxx resolves to uphold the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent M O H A M M A D S. A N D O Y for the mayoralty position in the Municipality of Pagalungan, Province of M aguindanao Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED

January 16, 2013

M ohammad S. Andoy April 24, 2013

14.

Turtle Islands, Tawi-Tawi II

13-014 (DC)

Mibaral M. Tang vs.

Resolution (SD ) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit

petition

is

hereby

January 16, 2013 February 21, 2013

O rder (S D ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc Mardan M. Julkanain

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-015 (DC)

TITLE O F THE CASE


Mibaral M. Tang vs. Rodolfo M. Velasquez

STATUS
Resolution (F D ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to G R A N T the Petition dated 08 October 2012. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent R O D O L F O M. V E L A S Q U E Z is hereby EXC LU D ED for failure to comply with Section 73 of the OEC Resolution (EB) xxx RESOLVES, to G R A N T respondent Rodolfo M. Velasquez Motion for Reconsideration (Of the Resolution dated 22 January 2013), S E T A SID E the Commission (First Division) Resolution dated 22 January 2013 and G IV E D UE C O U R S E to respondents Certificate of Candidacy. The Law Dept, is hereby D IR EC TED to endorse the records of this case to the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, Committee on Bar Discipline, for their appropriate action against Atty. Carlo B. G om ez

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

15.

Turtle Islands, Tawi-Tawi

January 22, 2013

\ \
\

\ \
1 f t
\

April 05, 2013

\
\

16.

Turtle Islands, Tawi-Tawi II

13-016 (DC)

Mibaral M. Tang vs.

Resolution (SD ) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit

petition

is

hereby

January 21, 2013


March 13, 2013

Order (S D ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc Sarajul M. Jihim 13-017 (DC) Mibaral M. Tang vs. Taha S. Sadalani 13-018 (DC) Herbert M. Bautista vs. II Rom eo Romy S. Acebedo
Page 5 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

17.

Turtle Islands, Tawi-Tawi 1

Submitted for resolution

18.

Quezon City

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U ISA N CE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the. May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 3. Acebedo, Romeo Sanchez - M ayor -

January 11, 2013

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Quezon City xxx

STATUS

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

\
19. Province of Agusan del Norte 13-019 (DC)

\ \ \

In Re: Petition for declaration of George M. Lumongsod as a nuisance candidate for Governor in the Province of Agusan del Norte in the M ay 13, 2013 Elections Ma. Angelica Rosedell Am ante-M atba vs. George M. Lumongsod

II

Resolution No. 961 0 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISA N CE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 23. Lumongsod, Jorge Maceda Governor - Agusan del Norte xxx

January 11, 2013

a
\

20.

Province of Surigao del Sur

13-020 (DC)

In the matter of Petition to declare Iberet Murillo Correos as nuisance candidate Manuel O. Alameda, Sr.

Resolution (SD ) D ISM IS SED

xxx

the

petition

is

hereby

January 02, 2013

II vs. Iberet Murillo Correos 21. Province of Surigao del Sur 13-021 (DC) In the matter of the Petition to declare Edwin G. Deligero as nuisance candidate for the Office of G overnor of Surigao del Sur Johnny T. Pimentel vs. Edwin Deligero
Page 6 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)
i

Resolution (S D ) - xxx R ES O LVES to D ISM ISS this Petition for LACK O F M E R IT

April 01, 2013

II

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-022 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C ASE


Andres Nautilus P. Salvacion vs.

STATUS \
Resolution (SD) xxx the D ISM IS SED for lack of merit petition v is \ hereby

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

22.

Leyte, Leyte

March 12, 2013 March 27, 2 01 3

II Arnold Jam es M. Ysidoro

Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc %


\

23.

Marcos, llocos Norte II

13-023 (DC)

Salvador S. Pillos vs. Arsenio A. Agustin

Omnibus Resolution (SD) hereby D ENIED for lack of merit

xxx the

petitions are \

January 28, 2013 April 23, 2013

Resolution (EB) - xxx the MR of Petitioner Stewart D. De La Cruz in SPA No. 13-024 (D C ) is denied fdy lack of merit. On the other hand, the Motion for Reconsideration of Petitioner Salvador S. Pillos in SPA No. 13-023 (DC) is granted; consequently, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Arsenio A. Agustin is hereby C A N C E L L E D and D E N IE D DUE COURSE Omnibus Resolution (SD ) - xxx the hereby D E N IE D for lack of merit petitions are

24.

Marcos, llocos Norte II

13-024 (DC)

Stewart T. De La Cruz vs. Napoleon A. Duldulao

January 28, 2013 April 2 3, 2013

Resolution (EB) - xxx the M R of Petitioner Stewart D. De La Cruz in SPA No. 13-024 (D C ) is denied for lack of merit. On the other hand, the Motion for Reconsideration of Petitioner Salvador S. Pillos in SPA No. 13-023 (DC) is granted; consequently, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Arsenio A. Agustin is hereby C A N C ELLED and D E N IE D DUE COURSE

r
Page 7 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
M U N ./C IT Y / P R O V IN C E

SPA 2013
13-025 (DC)

TITLE O F THE CASE


Ronald O. Diola & Tisha Aisha Y. Gonzalez vs. Augustus Jun G. Pe, Jr.

STATUS
\ Resolution (FD) - \ x x x RESO LVES, to G R A N T the Petition dated 10 O&tober 2012. A C C O R D IN G L Y , the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Augustus Jun G. Pe, Jr., is hereby D EN IE D and C A N C E LLE D Order (F D ) - xxx MRs elevated to en banc \ Omnibus Motion filed W pets-movants on April 29, 2013 ^

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

25.

South District, Cebu City

February 01, 2013

1 Petition for Disqualificaation and/or To Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC

March 12 & 17, 2013

\
26. Bacacay, Albay 13-026 (DC) In Re: Petition for denial of due course to Certificate of Nomination and Acceptance Luis B. Hefti II vs. Orlando Binamira 27. Tayum, Abra II Jose M arie Brillantes y Mailed 13-027 (DC) Placido Eduarte, Jr. vs. Resolution (SD) xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. The Certificate of Candidacy of JOSE M A R IE M. BRILLANTES for Mayor of the Municipality of Tayum, Province of Abra is hereby D E N IE D D UE C O U R S E and CANCELLED Resolution (EB) xxx the instant motion for reconsideration is hereby G R A N T E D . Accordingly, the January 28, 2013 Resolution of the Commission (SD ) is hereby R EV ER SED and S E T A S ID E Manifesttion filed by petitioner through counsel on April 22, 2 0 1 3 (no majority votes re Resolution April 12, 2013) January 28, 2013 Resolution (SD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D EN Y the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent Binamiras Certificate of Nomination and Acceptance and U P H O L D his status as an official nominee of the Nacionalista Party in the 13 May 2013 Elections January 21, 2013

April 12, 2013

i
Page 8 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

'

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-028 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A SE \
Antonio H. Cerilles vs. Dominador G. Jalosjos, Jr. \

STATUS
Resolution No. 9612 - xxx/ In view of the foregoing, the Commission R ESO LVED , as it hereby R ES O LVES , to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Dominador G. Jalosjos, Jr. as Governor of Zam boanga del Sur in the May 13, 2013 NLE/ Let the Law Dept, im plem ent this Resolution Resolution (SD ) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit Petition is hereby

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

28.

Province of Zamboanga del Sur II

January 15, 2013

29.

2 na Dist. of Zamboanga del Sur II

13-029 (DC)

Antonio H. Cerilles vs.

February 01, 2013 March 13, 2013 January 11, 2013

OrCJer (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc Marjorie N. Jalosjos 13-030 (DC) In Re: Petition to declare Bert L. Abella as nuisance candidate for the position of Member, Sangguniang Panlungsod of the 2nd District of Cebu City in the upcoming M ay 13, 201 3 Elections and To Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC Nendell Hanz L. Abella vs. Bert L. Abella 31. Lakewood, Zamboanga del Sur II Jean Paul Villaflor Jalosjos 13-031 (DC) Canuto Cavan Enerio, Jr. and Roger Bonghanoy Polinar vs. Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U ISA N CE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates' Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 2. Abella, Bert Leo - Member, S. Panlungsod (2 n d Dist.) - Cebu City xxx

30.

2 na District of Cebu City

II

February 01, 2013

-i ---------------Page 9 o f 7 7 (SPA 20 1 3 DC)

MUN. / CITY PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-032 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E \
In Re: Petition to Declare Edwin S. Teves a nuisance candidate and to deny due course to or cancel his C O C for Mayor, Tanjay City, Negros Oriental, pursuant to Section 69 of the OEC Lawrence S. Teves

STATUS
Resolution (SD ) xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED, Edwin S. Tevess Certificate of Candidacy is hereby C A N C ELLED with Separate Concurring Opinion of Comm. Padaca

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

32.

Tanjay City, Negros Oriental

March 21, 2013

II

Edwin S. ^eves 33. 1s ' District of Palawan 13-033 (DC) Roberto V. Rodriguez vs. II Randy M. Rodriguez Omnibus Resolution (SD ) - xxx the consolidated cases are resolved as follows: In SPA No. 13-033 (DC), the petition to declare Randy M. Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is hereby D ISM IS SED . However, Randy M. Rodriguez is ordered not to use and place 'Toto" as the nickname to appear in the official ballot/ In SPA No. 13105 (D C )(F ) the petition to declare Roberto Toto Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is also D IS M IS S E D Resolution (EB) - xxx the Omnibus Resolution dated January 28, 2013 is R E V E R S E D and S E T ASIDE. Accordingly, respondent Randy M. Rodriguez is declared a N U IS A N C E C A N D ID A TE. Consequently, his C E R T IF IC A TE OF C A N D ID A C Y is hereby CANCELLED 34. Santiago City, Isabela Province 13-034 (DC) Re: Petition for declaration of candidate as a nuisance candidate Armando S. Tan vs. II Resolution (SD ) xxx the instant Petition is G R A NTED. Respondent M AR K ALVIN A. TAN is hereby D EC LA R E D as a N U IS A N C E C A N D ID A TE and accordingly, his C O C is hereby C A N C ELLED Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ES O LVES , as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U IS A N C E candidates and January 28, 2013 w / SPA 13-105

May 02, 2013

January 04, 2013

January 11,

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
S TA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C ASE


Mark Alvin A. Tan

\
\

to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the C andidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 35. Tan, Mark Alvin Arquero - Mayor, Santiago City, Isabela xxx Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U IS A N C E candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the C andidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 10. Bersamina, Joel Bicera - Governor, - Province of Abra xxx Resolution (FD ) - xxx the petitionis hereby G R A N TE D . Respondent Emmanuel N. M eneses is hereby declared as NUISA N CE C A N D ID A TE , and his Certificate of Candidacy for Mayor of Bulakan, Buiacan, for the 13 May 2013 National and Local Elections is C A N C ELLED Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D IS M IS S this case for LACK O F M E R IT Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration filed by petitioner Derrick M. Vizcarra is D EN IED. Accordingly, the Resolution of the Commission (FD) promulgated on 23 Janaury 2 01 3 is hereby A F FIR M E D Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby D ISM IS SED

2013

35.

Province of Abra

13-03 A (DC) ^

Eustaquio P. Bersamin vs.

January 11, 2013

Joel B. Bersamina

36.

Bulakan, Buiacan

13-036 (DC)

Patrick Neil F. Meneses vs.

January 21, 2013

1
Em manuel N. Meneses 37. Ramon, Isabela 13-037 (DC) Derrick M. Vizcarra vs.

January 23, 2013 April 23, 2013

Wilfredo L. Tabag

38.

Tineg, Abra

13-038 (Dc)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or to Cancel C O C for Mayor of Cita Acosta Crisologo in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra Corinthia Dannang Crisologo

April 10, 2013

Page 11 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

\
\
\

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F TH E C ASE
vs. Cita Acosta Crisologo

STATUS

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

\
Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S to G R A N T the Petition. Accordingly, respondent Cita A. Crisologo is hereby DECLARED a nuisance candidate pursuant to Section 69 of the OEC Resolution (EB) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM IS S the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to A FFIRM the First Divisions ruling declaring Respondent Cita Acosta Crisologo a nuisance candidate January 22, 2013

39.

^ Tineg, Abra

13-039 (DC)

Corinthia Dannang Crisologo vs.

\ \
\

\
\ 1

Cita Acosta Crisologo March 22, 2013

\
\

\
a
\

40.

Tineg, Abra

13-040 (DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or To Cancel C OC for Mayor of Clemencio P. Ramirez in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra Edwin B.Crisologo, Sr. vs. Clemencio P. Ramirez

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit Resolution (EB) xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is D EN IED. Accordingly, the Decision of this Commission dated 16 January 2013 stands

January 16, 2013 March 22, 2013

II

41.

Tineg, Abra

13-041 (DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or To Cancel C O C for Mayor of Cromwell S. Luna in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra Edwin B. Crisologo, Sr., vs.

Resolution (FD) D IS M IS S E D

xxx the instant Petition is hereby

January 29, 2013 April 05, 2013

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is D EN IE D . The assailed Resolution of the Commissions First Division dated 29 January 2013 is hereby A F F IR M E D IN TO TO
i

Cromwell S. Luna
Page 12 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / CITY / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED

\
\

SPA 2013
13-042 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C ASE


Rodolfo Galido Plaza vs. Mauricio Cuevas Plaza, Jr.

REMARKS

\
42. Second District, Agusan del Sur Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N UISA N C E candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 29. Plaza, Mauricio Jr. C. - Member, House of Representatives (2n d Dist.) - Agusan del Sur xxx Submitted for resolution January 11, 2013

II

\ \
\

43.

Province of Agusan del Sur 1

13-043 (DC)

Victor Galido Plaza vs. Mariano Curato Plaza

\
\

44.

Zamboanga City II

13-044 (DC)

Marinao Isabelle G. Climaco-Salazar vs. Romeo Garcia Jalosjos

Resolution No. 9613 - xxx R ESO LVES, to C A N C EL and D E N Y due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Rom eo G. Jalosjos as M ayor of Zam boanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE

January 15, 2013

45.

Santiago City

13-045 (DC)

In Re: Petition to Deny Due Course and To Cancel C O C of Samuel Docsam Navarro E. Orestes S. Ferrer vs. Samuel Docsam" Navarro

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ES O LVES , to G R A N T the Petition dated 10 October 2012. A C C O R D IN G L Y , the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Samuel Navarro is hereby D E N IE D and C A N C E L L E D

January 15, 2013

Page 13 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-046 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
William M. Angos vs. Senonina P. Cuanan

STATUS \
Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESOLVES, t d D IS M IS S the Petition for LACK O F M E R IT ' Resolution (EB) - xxx Petitioner William A. Angos Motion for Reconsideration dated 11 March 2013 is hereby D E N IE D for lack of merit and the\ Resolution dated 30 January 2013 is hereby A FFIR M E D . Consequently, Respondent Senonina P. C iia n a n may be validly substituted in accordance with the provisions of Section 77 of the O E C \
\

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

46.

Cortes, Surigao del Sur 1

January 30, 2013 April 23, 2013

47.

Province of Kalinga 1

13-047 (DC)

Allen Jesse C. M angaoang vs.

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, instant petition for LACK OF M ERIT

to D E N Y

the

January 10, 2013 January 22, 2013 January 21, 2013

Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc G. Farnaw A. C laver

48.

San Fernando City, La Union

13-048 (DC)

Gerald C. T ab ac vs. Reynaldo T. Jucutan

Resolution (S D ) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Reynaldo T. Jucutan is hereby C AN C ELLED Order (SD) - Acting on the Motion for Issuance of Certificate of Finality filed by pet through counsel on April 18, 2013, praying that a Certificate of Finality be issued on the Resolution promulgated on Jan. 23, 2013 for the instant case, the Commission (SD ) hereby D IR EC TS Atty. Jado Rafael A. Bognedon, counsel for the respondent, to file his comment on said motion

April 23, 2013

II

Page 14 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-049 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C ASE \


Janet De Leon Mercado vs.

S TA TU S
Resolution (FD) V- xxx R ES O LVES , to G R A N T the petition praying to declare JESS IC A JA N ET C. DE LEON as nuisance candidate Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant MR is denied for lack of merit ^ Resolution (SD) - x x^th e Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Imelda A. Papin is hereby G R A N T E D . Accordingly, her Certificate of Candidacy^is C A N C ELLED Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby GRANTED. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated 31 January 2 0 1 3 is hereby R E V E R S E D and SET ASIDE

49.

Taytay, Rizal

Decem ber 19, 2012

Jessica Janet C. De Leon

March 14, 2013 January 31, 2013

50.

Lone District of the City of San Jose del Monte, Buiacan II

13-050 (DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course To or Cancel C O C of Imelda A. Papin as Congressional Candidate in the Lone District of the City of San Jose Del Monte, Province of Buiacan Arangkada San Joseno Political Party represented by its Secretary General, Mr. Zosimo B. Lorenzo vs. Imelda A. Papin

April 18, 2013

51.

Silang, Cavite

13-051 (DC)

In Re: In the matter of the Petition to Declare Pablito V. Angcaya as nuisance candidate Armando A. De Castro vs. Pablito V. Angcaya

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to G R A N T the Petition and D EC LAR E respondent PABLITO V. A NG CA YA as a nuisance candidate. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent is hereby C AN C ELLED

January 22, 2013

Page 15 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

1
STATUS

)
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-052 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C ASE


\ Antonio Jordan Tabares, Jr. vs. Antonio Dimayuga \ \

52.

San Pascual, Batangas

Resolution (SD) - xxx R E S O L V E S to G R A N T the instant Petition. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Antonio Dimayuga is hereby CANCELLED Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion is hereby G R A NTED. The January 28, 201 3 Resolution of the Commission (SD ) is hereby R E V E R S E D and SET A SID E 'Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is G R A N TE D . Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent R E G IN A O N G SIA KO R EY ES is hereby C A N C ELLED Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by respondent through counsel elevated to en banc Resolution (SD) D ISM IS SED xxx the instant petition is hereby

January 28, 2013

II

May 02, 2013

\
53.
Lone District of Marinduque

13-053 (DC)

Joseph Soccoro B. Tan vs. Atty. Regina Ongsiako Reyes

March 27, 2013

April 16, 2013 January 21, 2013

54.

San Pascual, Batangas II

13-054 (DC)

Antonio Jordan Tabares, Jr. vs. Ma. Brenda Kenrick, alias Ma. Brenda Dimayuga

55.

Bayugan City, Agusan del Sur 1

13-055 (DC)

Ferdinand Marcus Martir Banosia vs. Analiz Efren Sevandal For: Annulment/Render Void and consider as not filed C O C Due to Late Filing

Resolution (FD ) - xxx resolves to D E N Y the petition for LACK OF M ER IT Resolution <EB) xxx petitioners Motion for Reconsideration is hereby D E N IE D for utter lack of merit

January 21, 2013 April 24, 2013

)
MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-056 (DC)
w/SPA 13-057

TITLE O F THE C A SE \
Wigbferto R. Tanada, Jr. vs. Alvin J^hn S. Tanada

56.

4m District of Quezon Province 1

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the two Petitions, S P A No. 13-056 (D C ) and SPA 13-057 (DC) for LACK O F M ER IT Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration dated 18 February 2013 is PARTIALLY G R A N TE D . The Motion for Reconsideration for SP A No. 13-057 (D C ) is D E N IE D for LACK OF M ER IT. However, the Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-066 (DC) is G R A N T E D . Accordingly, Respondent Alvin John S. Tan ad as Certificate of Candidacy for the position of M em ber of the House of Representatives for the 4th district of the Province of Quezon is hereby C A N C ELLED Resolution (F D ) - xxx RESOLVES, to D IS M IS S the two Petitions, S P A No. 13-056 (DC) and SPA 13-057 (DC) for LACK O F M E R IT Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration dated 18 February 2013 is PARTIALLY G R A N TE D . The Motion for Reconsideration for SP A No. 13-057 (D C ) is D E N IE D for LACK O F M ER IT. However, the Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-056 (D C ) is G R A N T E D . Accordingly, Respondent Alvin John S. Tan ad as Certificate of Candidacy for the position of M em ber of the House of Representatives for the 4th district of the Province of Quezon is hereby CANCELLED

January 29, 2013


w /S P A 13-057

April 25, 2013

\ \
57. 4m District of Quezon Province
13-057

9
\

Wigberto R. Tanada, Jr. vs.

(DC)

January 29, 2013


w /S P A 13-056

w/SPA 13-056

Alvin John S. Tanada

April 25, 2013

r
Page 17 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

\
I

)
TITLE O F THE C A SE
Victor S. Ziga Edgardo T. Vosotros, Atty. Arsenio N. Base, Jr. Atty. Julian C. Cargullo vs. Edcel Burce Lagman, Jr. Perfecto V. Fidel vs. Lineth Espineli Abutin

)
STA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA \2013
\3 -0 5 8 \D C )

58.

District 1, Province of Albay

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D ISM IS S the Instant Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy dated 08 October 2012 for LACK OF M ER IT Resolution (EB) xxx the instant Motion Reconsideration is denied for lack of merit for

January 30, 2013

\
\

59.

Indang, Cavite

13-059 (D C )\

I
\

April 25, 2013

II Urgent Petition to Disallow Improper, Misleading and Confusing Registration of Last N am e of Candidate and to Correct Com elec Official List of Candidates Nam es to A ppear on the Official Ballot 60. 4 tn District of the Province ofCamarines Sur I 13-060 (DC) Gilmar S. Pacamarra, in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 7A, Barangay San Antonio, San Jose, Cam arines Sur vs. Ariel Aga A. Muhlach

Resolution (SD ) - xxx the Petition is G R A N TE D . Respondent LIN ETH ESPIN ELI-A B U TIN's use of the last name FID EL to appear on the official ballot is hereby D ISA LLO W ED . The Election Officer of Indang, Cavite is hereby D IR E C T E D to correct the Official List of Candidates who filed their Certificate of candidacy for the May 13, 2013 National and Local Elections to reflect the correct last nam e of respondent as ESPINELI-ABUTIN

January 11, 2013

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R E S O LV E S to D IS M IS S the Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel the Certificate of Candidacy of the respondent Ariel A g a A. Muhlach for LACK O F M E R IT Manifestation with Motion (To Withdraw Petitioners Motion for Reconsideration) filed by counsel for petitioner Gilmar S. Pacam arra on April 29, 2013

January 15, 2013

Page 18 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / c / r / / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-061 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A SE
Nardo M. Velasco vs.

STA TU S
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is D EN IED for lack of merit Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby D ENIED. The Resolution of the Commission (SD ) dated January 28, 201 3 is hereby A FFIR M ED Resolution (FD) instant petition xxx R ES O LVES , to D EN Y the

DATED/ PROMULGATED
\

REMARKS

\ *1 . \ Sasmuan, Pampanga January 28, 2013 April 24, 2013

\
\ \ \

II \
1

Pedro L. Velasco

\ 62. \

First District i of Quezon \ Province


9 \

13-062 (DC)

Romeo Laguador Villenas and Raffy Rosal Fernandez vs.

January 15, 2013 January 29, 2013

\
\

Order (FD) - xxx MRs elevated to en banc

\9
\

Wilfrido Mark Me. Cormick Enverga Pauline Ann Carpio Villasenor, Petitioner-intervenor

63.

Tangalan, Aklan

13-063 (DC)

In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancel Certificate of Candidacy o f Noel Teston y Delos Santos as Mayor of Tangalan, Aklan for the 201 3 National, Local and A R M M Elections G ene Torre Fuentes vs. Noel Teston y Delos Santos

Submitted for resolution

64.

1s t District of Bulacan I

13-064 (DC-F)

Ma. Victoria R. Sy-Alvarado vs. Sahiron Dulah Salim

Submitted for resolution

Page 19 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-065 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE CASE


Wilhelmino M. Sy-Alvarado vs.

V
65. Province o f Bulacan Resolution (FD ) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Ernesto D. Balite is hereby declared as N U IS A N C E C AN DIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Governor of Bulacan for the 13 May 2013 National and Local Elections is CANCELLED Resolution (EB) xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Decision of this Commission (First Division) dated 29 January 2013 stands 66. Province of Bulacan II Josephine Cagiw a Lopez 67. Province of Bulacan II Jayson Olarte Ocampo Resolution (EB) - xxx R ES O LVES , to DEN Y the Motion for Reconsideration dated 25 February 2013 for LACK O F M ERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 01 February 2013 is hereby A F F IR M E D 68. Viga, Catanduanes 13-068 (DC) Gilbert C. Olfindo vs. II Abelardo M. Abundo, Sr. Resolution (SD) D IS M IS S E D xxx the petition is hereby April 2 3, 2013 13-067 (DC-F) Daniel R. Fernando vs. Resolution (SD ) xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent JAYSON O LA R TE OC A M PO as a N U ISA N C E C A N D ID A TE is hereby D ENIED for utter lack of merit February 01, 2013 13-066 (DC-F) Daniel R. Fernando vs. Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit January 29, \2 0 1 3

Ernesto D. Balite

\
M a rc li2 2 , 201^
a

January 'l6, 2013

January 02, 2013

Page 2 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C I T Y / P R O V IN C E

SPA 2013
13-069 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C ASE


lluminado E. Pobre, Jr. vs.

STATUS
\ Resolution (SD) xxx the p^ition is hereby G R A N TE D . Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of M A R C IA N O DELA C R U Z PU LID O is hereby C A N C ELLED * t Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to G R A N T the instant Petition. Respondent JOSE A N T O N lb L. IBAYs Certificate of Candidacy is hereby dlENIED and CANCELLED \
9

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

69.

Mayantoc, Tarlac II

January 16, 2013

Marciano Dela C ruz Pulido 70. Fifth District of Manila I Jose Antonio L. Ibay 71. Ternate, Cavite 13-071 (DC) Jayson D. C abana vs. Francisco L. C abana, Jr. I 13-070 (DC) Richard C. Ibay vs. January 31, 2013

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D IS M IS S the Petition dated 11 October 2012 for being M O O T and A C A D E M IC . The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Francisco L. Cabana, Jr. is hereby C A N C ELLED . Let a copy of this Resolution be F O R W A R D E D to the Law Dept, of the Commission with regard to the finalization of the Official List of Candidates for the 13 May 2013 National, Local and A R M M Elections Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U ISA N C E candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their nam es from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 45. Bello, Fred Naim - Mayor Caloocan City xxx Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N UISA N CE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their nam es from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013

January 15, 2013

72.

Caloocan City I

13-072 (DC)

Dionisio F. Guillarte vs. Fred Naim Bello

January 11, 2013

73.

Caloocan City

13-073 (DC)

II

In Re: Petition to declare as a nuisance candidate, Luis San Pedro Razo, candidate for the Position o f Mayor of Caloocan City in the 2013 National and Local Elections, denying dife course

January 11, 2013

Page 21 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

\
J

\ I

)
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

m un. / c /r r / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E \
and/or cancelling his C O C Laura Bucao Vital vs. Luis San Pedro Razo

STATUS
Elections: xxk 53. Razo, Luis San Pedro - M ayor Caloocan City kxx

\
Resolution (FD ) - W x x the instant Petition is hereby DISM IS SED for LAC^K O F M ERIT Resolution (EB) xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is D E N IE D for utter lack of merit. The assailed Resolution is A FFIR M ED en toto January 22, 2013 April 24, 2013

74.

Cabagan, Isabela

13-074 (DC-F)

Rodolfo B. Albano, Jr. vs.

Francisco B. Flores, Com elec Cabagan, Isabela, Represented by E O Josephine Z. Mallannao 13-075 (DC) In the matter of the disqualification of Tom as N. Aguirre, as candidate for Municipal Councilor of Pililla, Rizal Eduardo Z. Vidanes, Brgy. Quisao, Pililla, Riza vs. Tom as N. Aguirre

75.

Pililla, Rizal

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

April 25, 2013

76.

Sipalay City Negros Occidental

13-076 (DC)

Rodolfo Divinagracia vs. Oscar Chua Montilla, Jr., Ma. Gina Montilla Lizares i . . . . .

Resolution (SD ) - xxx in view of the foregoing, the instant Petition is hereby D ISM IS SED for lack of merit Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to D E N Y the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to A F F IR M the Second Divisions ruling

January 28, 2013 April 23, 2013

II

...

Page 22 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

)
/Wl/W. / C /7 T /
PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-077 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C A SE \
In Re: Petition for d e c la ra tio n s Sherwin Calimag y C abasag a .lia . W in as nuisance candidate for the position of Congressman for the 2n d District of Cagayan \ Baby Aline Vargas-Alfonso ^ vs. Sherwin Calimag y Cabasag ^

S TA TU S
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R ESO LVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U IS A N C E candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates' Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 12. Calimag, Sherwin C. - Member, House of Representatives, (2nd Dist.) - Province of Cagayan xxx

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

77.

2 na District

of the Province of Cagayan

January 11, 2013

II

78.

Calbiga, Samar

13-078 (DC-F)

Santiago B. Abelido vs. Nicasio C as Labalan Abaigar

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ES O LVES , to G R A N T the instant Petition to Deny Due Course/ Cancel C O C . Accordingly, the C O C filed by Nicasio Labalan Abaigar for the position of mayor in Calbiga, Sam ar is hereby C AN C ELLED for containing false material representation pertinent to residence Resolution (EB) xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is D E N IE D , for LACK O F M ERIT. The Resolution of the First Division is hereby A F FIR M E D

January 28, 2013

M ay 03, 2013 April 03, 2013

79.

Toledo City, Cebu

13-079 (DC-F)

Lina Dela Pena Jalover, Georgie A. Huiso, and Velvet Barquin Zamora vs.

Resolution (SD) - xxx R E S O L V E S to D ISM IS S the Petition for LACK O F M E R IT Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

April 25, 2013

II John Henry R. Osm efia

f
Page 23 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-080 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE CASE \


Noe BVNeo and Cecilia Apurado ' Edoloverio vs.

S TA TU S
Resolution (SD) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Petition to Deny Due Course filed by Petitioners Neo and Apurado and D EC LA R E S that Respondent Yapha is qualified to run for Vice M ayor of Toledo City, Province of Cebu in the 13 May 2 0 1 3 Elections w/ MR filed by petitioners Resolution (FD) instant petition xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

80.

Toledo City, Cebu

January 24, 2013

II

Antonio P. Yapha, JR.

V
81. Candijay, Bohol
I

13-081 (DC-F)

S e rg i^ G . Amora, Jr.
\

January 29, 2013

vs.

Christopher B. Tutor 82. Balabagan, Lanao del Sur


II

13-082 (DC-F)

Edna Ogka Benito vs. A m er R. Sampiano

Submitted for resolution

83.

Sevilla, Bohol

13-083 (DC-F)

In Re: Petition to Cancel C O C of Juliet Dano y Bucag for the position of Municipal M ayor in the Municipality of Sevilla, Bohol on the ground of material misrepresentation Marie Karen Joy Digal y Bungagong vs. Juliet Dano y Bucag

Submitted for resolution

Page 24 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

SPA 2013
\

TITLE O F TH E C ASE
In Re: Petition to declare Michael Jimena Gorriceta a.k.a. Michael J. Gorriceta as nuisance candidate for the position of Municipal M ayor of the Municipality of Pavia, Iloilo and to Deny Due Course to or Cancel his Certificate of Candidacy as a nuisance candidate Michael Barrido Gorriceta

84.

Pavia, Iloilo

' 1

13-084 (DC-F)

Order (FD ) - xxx the instant Petition for Denial/ Cancellation of C O C of Michael Jimena Gorriceta is hereby D IS M IS S E D for being M O O T and A C A D EM IC

April 25, 2013

\
\\
\9 \

\ \

\
85. 5tn District of Cebu

vs. Miichael J. Gorriceta

13-085 (DC-F)

In the matter of the petition to deny due course or cancel the C O C of Gilbert W agas as Congressional Candidate in the 5th District of Cebu Joel Quino

Submitted for resolution

II

vs. Gilbert W ag as

86.

Ginatilan, Cebu II

13-086 (DC-F)

Dean Michael P. Singco vs. Patrocinio 'Pat" R. Singco

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion is D EN IE D en toto

January 16, 2013 April 24, 2013

Page 25 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-087 (DC-F)

TITLE O F TH E C ASE
Rene S. Cordero vs.

STATUS
Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit Resolution (EB ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Motion for Reconsideration dated 06 February 2013 for LACK O F M ER IT. The Resolution promulgated on 16 Januar 201 3 is hereby A F FIR M E D Resolution (SD ) xxx the petition is hereby G R A N TE D . Respondent Danilo Zartan Aquino is hereby declared a N UISA N C E C A N D ID A TE, and consequently, his C E R T IF IC A TE O F C A N D ID A C Y for the position of Member, Sangguniang Panlungsod, 1s t Dist., Antipolo City, Rizal is hereby ordered C AN C ELLED Resolution (EB) - xxx RESO LVES, to D E N Y the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK O F M ERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (Second Division) dated 21 January 2013 is hereby A FFIR M E D Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the Petition dated 06 October 2012 for LACK O F M E R IT

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

\
87 Estancia, Iloilo January 16, 2013 April 05, 2013
V

\ \ \
\

II

Mario B. Golingan

\ \

First District of Antipolo City

13-088 (DC-F)

In the matter of Petition to declare Danilo Uding Zaratan Aquino a nuisance candidate and his C O C be denied due course and be cancelled Prudencio Marco Aquino

January 21, 2013

II vs. Danilo Zaratan Aquino

April 05, 2013

89.

Guinsiiiban, Camiguin

13-089 (DC-F)

Joanne Marie C. Rubin vs.

January 15, 2013

I Saturnino S. Lumba 90. MambajaoC amiguin I Roberto L. Odarve 91. Carles, Iloilo 13-091 (DC-F) Petition for Disqualification of Rodolfo Dumayas as candidate for Sangguniang Resolution (SD ) xxx the Petitions for Disqualificationof respondents* Rodolfo S. Dumayas January 21, 2013 13-090 (DC-F) Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Resolution (FD ) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent R O B E R T O L. O D A R V E as a N U ISA N C E C A N D ID A TE is hereby D EN IE D for utter lack of merit April 16, 2013

Page 26 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Bayan M em ber of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo as provided under Rule 25 of the Com elec Rules of Procedure as amended by Resolution No. 9523 Alvin V. Barnes vs. Rodolfo Dumayas

STATUS \
and Arnel T. Francisco to run in the 13 May 2013 elections as Sangguniang Bayan Members of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo are D ISM IS SED and their Certificates of Candidacies are UPHELD

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

II

\
\

\
\

\
92. Milagros, Masbate 13-092 (DC-F) Florence P. De Jesus vs. II Luz Cleta R. Bakunawa Order (SD ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel the C O C of Luz Cleta R. Bakunawa 93. Carles, Iloilo 13-093 (DC-F) Petition for Disqualification of Arnel Francisco as candidate for Sangguniang Bayan M em ber of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo as provided under Rule 25 of the Com elec Rules of Procedure as amended by Resolution No. 9523 Alvin V. Barnes vs. Arnel Francisco Resolution (S D ) - xxx the Petitions for Disqualification of respondents Rodolfo S. Dumayas and Arnel T. Francisco to run in the 13 May 2013 elections as Sangguniang Bayan M embers of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo are D IS M IS S E D and their Certificates of Candidacies are U PH ELD March 27, 2013 Resolution (SD ) - xxx RESO LVES, to D EN Y the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent LUZ CLETA R EYES BAKUNAW AS Certificate of Candidacy March 07, 2013

January 21, 2013

)
MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-094 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE CASE


Hon. Conrado B. Nicart, Jr. vs.

STA TU S \
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition i^ D EN IE D for lack of merit ' Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is D ENIED. Accordingly, the Resolution of the Honorable Commissions Second Division promulgated on 28 January 2013 stands ^ Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D ISM IS SED for lack of merit \ *

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

94.

Eastern Samar

January 28, 2013 April 23, 2013

II

Alfredo C. Hobayan

95.

Mambajao, Camiguin II

13-095 (DC-F)

Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Pacundo Ebarle

January16, 2013

96.

MambajaoC amiguin 1

13-096 (DC-F)

Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Isabelo P. Paraiso

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM IS S the Petition for LACK O F M ER IT

January 11, 2013

97.

MambajaoC amiguin 1

13-097 (DC-F)

Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Gil G. Fabe

Resolution (FD) xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent GIL G. FA BE as a N U ISA N C E C A N D ID A TE is hereby D E N IE D for utter lack of merit

May 03, 2013

98.

MambajaoC amiguin 1

13-098 (DC-F)

Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Renato L. Tam ayo, Sr.

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM IS S the Petition dated 09 October 2 01 2 for LACK O F M ER IT

January 15, 2013

Page 28 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C I T Y /
P R O V IN C E

SPA 2013
13-099 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE CASE \


Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs.

STATUS
Resolution \( S D ) xxx the D ISM IS SED \for lack of merit Petition is hereby

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

99.

Mambajao, Camiguin
1 1

January 16, 2013

Jim S. Dagondon
i

100.

Mambajao, Camiguin
II

13-100 (DC-F)

M a. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Danilo M. Pabillan

Resolution (SD4 - xxx the instant Petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for sack of merit

January 16, 2013

101.

MambajaoC amiguin
1

13-101 (DC)

M a. Victoria J. Jansol vs. Diosdado B. Aranas

Resolution (SD) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit

Petition

is

hereby

March 21, 2013

102.

Mambajao, Camiguin

13-102 (DC-F)

Ma. Victoria J. Jansol vs.

Resolution (SD ) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit

Petition

is

hereby

January 16, 2013

II

Pepe E. Pabillore 13-103 (DC-F) Ma. Luisa D. Romualdo vs. Resolution (FD) - xxx RESO LVES, to D E N Y the instant petition filed against respondent Angustia H. Jadman for LACK O F M ER IT January 11, 2013

103.

MambajaoC amiguin
1

Angustia H. Jadman

Page 29 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-104 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C ASE \


Roldan A. Chan vs. V

104.

MambajaoC amiguin I

Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESO LVED , as it hereby RESOLVES, to D ISM IS S the instant Petition for LACK OF M ER IT

March 21, 2013

Antonio D. Gultiano \ 105. First District of Palawan 13-105 (DC-F) Randy Toto Rodriguez vs. II Roberto Toto Rodriguez \ ^ Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the consolidated cases are resolved as follows: In SPA No. 13-033 (DC), the petition to declare Randy M. Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is hereby D ISM IS SED . However, Randy M. Rodriguez is ordered not to use and place Toto as the nickname to appear in the official ballot/ In SPA No. 13105 (D C )(F ) the petition to declare Roberto Toto Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is also D IS M IS S E D Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ES O LVES as it hereby R ESO LVED, to D IS M IS S the petition filed against respondent G am al S. Hayudini for LACK O F M E R IT January 28, 2013 w /S P A 13033

106.

South Ubian, TawiTawi Province I Tandubas, Tawi-Tawi

13-106 (DC-F)

Mustapha J. O m ar vs. G am al S. Hayudini

January 31, 2013

107.

13-107 (DC-F)

In Re: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel COC Albert H. Kahong

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the petition praying to disqualify respondent Mindalyn Idlana Abubakar

January 15, 2013

I vs. Mindalyn Idlana Abubakar

Page 3 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-108 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
\

STA TU S
Resolution (SD) xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent NOLI J U N M. C A S T R O as a N U ISA N C E C A N D ID A TE is hereby D E N IE D for utter Jack of merit

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

108.

Mabalacat City, Pampanga Province

Noelito B. Castro vs. Noli M. Castro *

January 11, 2013

II

Petition to Beclare Respondent, Noli M. cas tro \a nuisance candidate 13-109 (DC-F) \ Senbnina P. Cuanan ' vs. Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is G R A N TE D . Respondent Alfonso G. Cuanan is hereby declared a N U ISA N C E C A N D ID A TE, and consequently, his C E R T IF IC A TE O F C A N D ID A C Y for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Cortes, Surigao Del Sur is hereby ordered C A N C E L L E D Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc January 16, 2013

109.

Cortes, Surigao del Sur

Alfonso G. Cuanan II Petition for Cancellation of COC

February 14, 2013 January 16, 2013

110.

Oras, Eastern Samar II

13-110 (DC -F)

Noel Ramonito M. Montallana vs. Aldin M. Montallana

Resolution (SD) xxx the Petition of N O EL R A M O N ITO M. M O N TA LLA N A is hereby D ENIED

111.

La Paz, Abra I

13-111 (DC-F)

Joseph Sto. Nino B. Bernos vs. Florencia B. Bernos

Resolution (FD) instant petition

xxx R ESO LVES,

to D EN Y the

January 28, 2013 March 22, 2013

Resolution (EB) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM ISS the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to A FFIRM the First Divisions ruling

)
TITLE O F THE C A SE
Teresita O. Dator Represented by Atty. Jorge B. Vargas as her Attorney-in-fact vs.

)
S TA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-112 (DC-F)

112.

1S I District,\ Quezon ^ Province II

Resolution (SD) xxx the D ISM IS SED for lack of merit

petition

is

hereby

January 16, 2013

\
\ \

\ \
113. Quezon Province 13-113 (\)C -F )

Isidro D. Dator Petition for the declaration of candidate Rolando M erano for position of Governor of Quezon Province as a nuisance candidate David C. Suarez vs. Rolando M erano Order (FD ) - xxx the petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for failure to file within the reglementary period Novem ber 20, 2012

114.

Gainza, Camarines Sur I

13-114 (DC-F)

In the matter of the petition to disqualify Romeo A. Gontang and/or to deny due course to or cancel his C O C for the position of Mayor of Gainza, Camarines Sur, pursuant to title 2, chapter 1, Section 40 (A) of RA 7160 in relation with Rule 25 of En Banc Comelec Resolution No. 9523 Serafin A. Encinas vs. Romeo A. Gontang

Resolution (FD) - xxx the Verified Petition is hereby D ISM IS SED

January 22, 2013

1 Page 32 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/
PROMULGATED

SPA 2013
13-115 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A SE
Roel B. Natividad, Arturo N. Onrubia & Ahmad Narzad K. Sampang vs.

REMARKS

\
115. Zamboanga City Resolution No. 9613 - xxx R ES O LVES , to C ANCEL and D EN Y due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NILE January 15, 2013

V
\ A_

II Romeo G. Jalosjos
...

j16.

\
\

Jaen, Nueva Ecija II

13-116 (DC)

S P 0 1 Wilson P. Hipolito vs. Rolando I. Manalo

Resolution (SD) D IS M IS S E D

xxx

the

petition

is

hereby

January 21, 2013

...- -

...........

117.

First District of Samar I

13-117 (DC-F) w/ SPA 13-168 (DC) 13-118 (DC-F)

Elmer M. Candido vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant consolidated Petitions are hereby DENIED O rder (FD ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc

January 29, 2013 February 14, 2013

Arnold Vasquez Tan

118.

Hernani, Eastern Samar

W ilmar Mema" Siguan Candido vs. W ilm ar M em o Daga Candido

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition to declare W ilmar M em o Daga Candido as a nuisance candidate is hereby G R A N TE D . Accordingly, respondent's Certificate of Candidacy is C A N C ELLED Resolution (EB) - xxx R ES O LVES , to DEN Y the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK O F M ERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (SD ) dated 28 January 2013 is hereby A F FIR M E D

January 28, 2013

II

April 08, 2013

r
Page 33 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N . /C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-119 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
James A. Ederango vs.

STATUS \

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

119.

Province of Camiguin I

Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISM IS S the^ February 01, i 2013 Petition dated 06 October 2012 for LACK of M E R IT

Luisito P. Ucab 120. Lagayan, Abra I Bernadine Sibayan-Joson 121. 7m District of Cavite 13-121 (DC) Laureano S. Mendoza, in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 0 1 14A, Saiz De Junio Village, Sungay East, Tagaytay City, Cavite vs. Gilbert C esar C. Remulla 122. Lagayan, Abra 13-122 (DC-F) Bernadine Sibayan Joson vs. Cornelio David M alangen I For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate Bernadine Sibayan Joson vs. II Joel Baduli Bilong, Sr.
Page 3 4 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC) t

13-120 (DC)

Antonio Maduli Bilong vs.

Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESO LVES, Petition dated 19 October 2012

to D E N Y the

\ Rebruary 01, 2013

\
Resolution (SD) xxx D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit thepetition is hereby Order (S D ) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

February 20, 2013 March 05, 2013

II

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D IS M IS S this case for LACK O F M ERIT

January 15, 2013

123.

Lagayan, Abra

13-123 (DC-F)

Resolution (SD) - xxx R ES O LVES to D E N Y the instant Petition for U TTER LACK O F M ER IT

January 28, 2013

)
MUN. /C I T Y / PROVINCE

')
STATUS \
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E
For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate

\
January 29, 2013

124.

Lagayan, Abra

13-124 (DC-F)

Bernadine Sibayan Joson vs. Ronnie Blaza Paingan

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESO LVES, to D E N Y the instant petition filed against respondent Ronnie Blaza Paingan for LACK O F M ER IT ^

I For: Declaration o f a candidate as nuisance candidate 125. Lagayan, Abra 13-125 (DC -F) Bernadine Sibayan Joson vs. Antonio Maduli Bilong I For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate 126. Lagayan, Abra 13-126 (DC -F) Bernadine Sibayan Joson vs. II Alberto Ci-o Pasiguen For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate

\
\

\a
\

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ESO LVES, Petition dated 19 October 2012

to D E N Y

the

January 22, 2013

Resolution (SD) - R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent Ci-o Pasiguens Certificate of Candidacy

January 16, 2013

Page 3 5 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-127 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C ASE \


Bernadine Sibayan Joson vs.

STA TU S
Resolutidp (FD ) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby D ISM IS SED for lack of merit

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

127.

Lagayan, Abra

April 10, 2013

Rubio Jimenez Sindon For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate \

V
\
Resolution (Ffy) - xxx R ESO LVES, to G R A N T the petition to d e n /,d u e course or cancel the certificate of candidacy of ADDULLAJID S. ALIH Order (FD) - xxx M R elevated to en banc January 29, 2013
-

128.

Banguigui, Sulu Province

13-128 (DC)

Whajid Indanan Sahidulla vs. Addullajid S. Alih

I Verified Petition to deny due course or cancel the C O C under Sec. 78 in relation to Sec. 74 of BP 881 129. Sallapadan, ABra 13-129 (DC) Nenita M. Cardenas vs. Wilbert Enostacion For: Petition to deny due course to or cancellation of COC 13-130 (DC) Nenita M. Cardenas vs. Wilbert Enostacion Submitted for resolution Submitted for resolution

February 14, 2013

130.

Sallapadan, Abra

I
t

For: Petition for Disqualificaiton

MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-131 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE CASE \


Renato A. De Los ReVes vs.

STA TU S
Submitted for resolution

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

131.

Calbayog City

Angelie T ee Tan \ Petition to deny due course andfor to Cancel C O C \ Re: In the m atter of petition to < h n y due course to or Cancellation of C$)C of candidate for Governor of the ProvTfice of Isabela, Pablo C. Guray, vs. Lilia Mijares Uy et al.

132.

Province of Isabela

13-132 (DC)

II

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R E S O L V E S , as follows: 1. To declare the following as N U IS A N C E candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their nam es from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 37. Uy, Lilia Mijares - Governor Province of Isabela xxx

January 11, 2013

133.

1s t District, Province of Isabela

13-133 (DC-F)

Rodolfo T. Albano III vs. Stephen G. Soliven

Resolution (SD) - xxx R E S O L V E S to D EN Y the instant petition for U TTER LACK O F M E R IT Resolution (EB) xxx petitioner R O D O LFO T. ALBANO Ills Motion for Reconsideration is hereby D E N IE D

January 17, 2013

April 24, 2013

II Petition to declare a candidate as nuisance candidate

134.

1st District, Province of Isabela *ll

13-134 (DC-F)

Rodolfo T. Albano III vs. Ray Anthony Claravall Bafiez

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for being moot and academic

April 23, 2013

Page 3 7 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013 \

TITLE O F THE C A SE
Petition to declare a candidate as ' nuisance candidate

STATUS

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

135.

4m District of Nueva Ecija

13-135 (DC)

Raul L. Villareal

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit

January 16, 2013

\
II

vs \O rlan d o A. Nagano

F o r\ Cancellation of COC
\

136.

Dingras, llocos Norte I

13-136 (DC)

Esteban Foz Romero vs. Joefrey P. Saguid For: Petition to deny due course to or Cancellation of C O C

Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Deny due course and/or to Cancel the COC of Respondent JO E F R E Y P. SA G U ID is hereby D ISM IS SED

April 29, 2013

137.

Dingras, llocos Norte

13-137 (DC)

Roderick R. Trinidad vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D IS M IS S the Petition for LACK O F M ER IT

January 11, 2013

Nathaniel Ruben D. Taylan II For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of C O C

138.

Dingras, llocos Norte

13-138 (DC)

Joel B. Toribio vs.

Resolution (FD) - xx RESOLVES, to D E N Y the instant petition for LACK O F M ER IT

January 23, 2013

Elsie P. Garces
Page 38 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of C O C

\
\

\
\

139.

Dingras, I 13-139 llocos Norte ^ ( D C ,

Roderick R. Trinidad vs.

Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit

January 16, 2013

\
\

II 140. Dingras, llocos Norte

\ 13-140 (DC)

Rowena Celerina P. Verzosa Joel Baraoidan Toribio vs. Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel C O C for LACK O F M E R IT February 01, 2013

Rosalinda Ruiz Castro For: Petition to Deny Due Course and/or to Cancel C O C

141.

Dingras, Hocos Norte

13-141 (DC)

Alem ar D. Rosqueta vs.

Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for lack of-merit

January 21, 2013

II

Enriqueto J. C anete, Jr. For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of C O C Bobby Perfecto R. Simeon vs.

142.

Dingras, llocos Norte

13-142 (DC)

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM IS S the Petition for LACK O F M E R IT

January 11, 2013

Osias A. Ballesteros
i

Page 39 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
S TA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED
\

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A SE
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of C O C

REMARKS

\
\

143.

Dingras, llocos Norte

13-143 (DC)

Esteban F. Romero vs.

Submitted for resolution

" '

t \

\
Jose Mari G enaro B. Albano For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of C O C

I
\ I

\
\

144.

Don Victoriano, Misamis Occidental

13-144 (DC)

Carlito M. Bongcac vs. Elsie M. Llanes

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is D ENIED. The assailed Resolution of the Second Division is hereby A F FIR M E D

January 21, 2013 April 24, 2013

II

Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel C O C of Respondent 13-145 (DC) Ricardo L. Solatorio vs. Danny V. Pata Resolution (SD) xxx the D ISM IS SED for lack of merit petition is hereby February 01, 2013

145.

Don Victoriano, Misamis Occidental

II 146. Don Victoriano, Misamis 13-146 (DC)

Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel C O C of Respondent Emilio C. Medel vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISM IS SED for LACK O F M E R IT
i

February 01, 2013

Page 4 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C ASE

STATUS \

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

\
150. Tuburan, Cebu 13-150 (DC) Antonio M. Primacion and Lourdes D. Esmero Vs. II Daphne A. Lagon For: Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of Daphne Arias Lagon as Vice-M ayor of Tuburan, Cebu 151. Catanduane s 13-151 (DC) Larry S. Que Vs. Joseph C. Cua I Petition to Deny Due Course and to C ancel C OC 152. Bangar, La Union 13-152 (DC) Joy Pinzon Merin Vs. Order (S D ) - xxx MR elevated to en banc II Saturnino Dingle Petition to Cancel C O C and to Disqualify Respodent due to ineligibility February 07, 2013 Resolution (SD) D IS M IS S E D xxx the instant petition is hereby January 24, 2013 Order (FD ) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 19, 2013, xxx elevated to the Commission en banc for proper disposition April 23, 2013 Resolution (SD ) - xxx the petition is D E N IE D for lack of merit \ Order (EB) - The Commission (Ej|3) hereby G R A N TS the Com m ent and/or Opposition tq Petitioners Motion for Reconsideration filed by respondent through counsel on March 19, 2013 xxxi The Motion for Reconsideration filed on March 4,' 2013 is hereby D IS M IS S E D for failure of petitioners to pay motion fees in the amount of One Thousand Pesos (Php1,000.00) Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is D E N IE D for lack of merit January 28, 2013 April 02, 2013

April 10, 2013

i Page 4 2 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

>

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-153 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A SE
\

STATUS
Resolution (FD ) - xxx R E S O LV E S to D ISM IS S the instant Petition for U TTER LACK O F M ER IT

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

153.

2 District,

Salvador S. Pillos Vs. Ignacio A. Agustin

Marcos, llocos Norte I

March 06, 2013

\ For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellationof C O C 154. Province of Camarines Sur 13-154 (DC) Luis R. Villafuerte Vs. Miguel R. Villafuerte I Verified Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of respondent Miguel Reyes Villafuerte as candidate for Governor of the Province of Camarines Sur 155.
2 nc District of Antipolo City

Resolution iF D ) - xxx R ES O LVES , instant petition for LACK O F M E R IT

to D EN Y

the

January 15, 2013 April 01, 2013

Resolution (EB) - xxx R ESO LVED , as it hereby R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Motion for Reconsideration dated 08 February 2013 for LACK O F M ERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (FD ) promulgated on 15 January 2013 is hereby A F FIR M E D

13-155 (DC)

In Re: Petition to disqualify candidate to elective position 'Avelino P. De Quiroz

Submitted for resolution

Vs. Nixon R. Aranas

i
Page 4 3 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-156 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E \
Frank Ong Sibuma andVDino Ong Sibuma ^ Vs.

S TA TU S
Resolution (SD ) xxx the D ISM IS SED for lack of merit petition is hereby

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

156.

Aringay, La Union

January 21, 2013 February 05, 2013

Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

II Napoleon Chan Ong 157. 4 m District of the Province of Camarines Sur II Ariel Aquino Muhlach 158. Datu Hoffer
Ampatuan, Maguindanao

13-157 (DC)

Crispin M. Imperial and Francisco Perico Dizon, in their capacity as registered voters of Brgy. San\Juan, San Jose, Cam arines Sur\ Vs.

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit Resolution (EB) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D EN Y the Motion for Reconsideration dated 12 March 2013 for LACK OF M ERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 05 March 2013 is hereby A F F IR M E D

March 05, 2013 M ay 02, 2013

13-158 (DC)

Bongbong M. Ampatuan Vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D ISM ISS the Petition for LACK O F M E R IT Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

January 30, 201 3 April 05, 2013

I 159. Datu Joffer Ampatuan, Maguindana 0 13-159 (DC)

Mhurphy P. Ampatuan Bongbong M. Ampatuan Vs. Yamashita B. Mangacop Resolution (SD ) DISM IS SED xxx the petition is hereby M ay 06, 2013

II

Petition to disqualify for lack of qualificationsor possessing some grounds for disqualification

Page 4 4 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
\

TITLE O F THE C ASE


\ Oscar R. Delos Reyes

STATUS
Resolution (SD ) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM IS S the instant Petition for Denial / Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

160.

2 na District of Bataan Province II

13-160 (DC)

March 19, 2013

'
Juan Miguel R. Bondoc, a.k.a. Onemig Bondoc

\
161. Estancia, Iloilo I 13-161 (DC) V ^
*

Mario B. Golingan N/s. ' Rene S. Cordero

Resolution (FD) - xxx this Commission R ESO LVED , as it hereby R ESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

April 29, 201 3

162.

Jipapad, Eastern Samar

13-162 (DC)

In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of Leoncio P. Mato, candidate for Mayor of Jipapad, Eastern Sam ar Ruben P. Go Vs. Leoncio P. Mato

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit

January 21, 2013

II

163.

Malinao, Albay

13-163 (DC)

Ofelia Zanosa Bigata and Evelyn Borja Cellona Vs. Salvador K. Moll

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ES O LVES , to G R A N T the instant petition. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Salvador K. Moll is hereby D E N IE D DUE C O U R S E TO A N D /O R C A N C ELLED Order (EB) - xxx hereby G R A N T S the Manifestation with Most Most Urgent Motion (To Deny Respondents Motion for Reconsideration for Lack of Jurisdiction) filed by pets through counsel on March 26, 2013, xxx/ The Motion for Reconsideration filed on March 4, 2013 is hereby D ISM IS SED for failure of petitioners to pay

February 01, 2013 w/ Separate Opinion of Comm. Lim April 02, 201 3

I Petition To deny due course to or cancel C O C )

Page 45 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

)
STA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A SE

\
164. Zamboanga City 13-164 (DC) Jose L. Lobregat & Adelante Zam boanga Party Vs. 165.

motion fees in the amount of One Thousand Pesos (Php1, 0 00.00) Resolution No. 9613 - xxx R ESO LVES, to C AN C EL and D E N Y due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zam boanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE January 15, 2013

\
\ \

\ \
\

\ \ 5tn District
op,

R om eo G. Jalosjos 13-165 (DC) Manuel V. Macabuhay, Jr. vs. Resolution (FD) - xxx R ESO LVES, Petition dated 29 October 2012 to D E N Y the January 22, 2013

\ \

9
\

Quezon City 1

Arnold Francisco aka Ogie Susano For: Petition for denial or Cancellation of C O C

166.

3 Legislative District of Camarines Sur II

13-166 (DC)

Nelson B. Julia Vs. Angel G. Naval Verified Petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby G R A N T E D . Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Angel G. Naval for the position of M em ber of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of the Third District of Camarines Sur is hereby C A N C ELLED Order (S D ) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

March 05, 2013

March 27, 2013 January 31, 2013 April 05, 2013 w/SPA 13-178

167.

3ro District of the Province of Albay

13-167 (DC)

Elm er Felix M. Pornel Vs. Fernando Vallejo Gonzalez

Joint Resolution (SD ) - xxx the two (2) Petitions are hereby D IS M IS S E D Resolution (EB) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Motion for reconsidedration dated 18 February 2013 for LACK O F M ERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 31 January 2013 is hereby A F FIR M E D *

II

Page 46 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

\ \

)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
S TA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED
\

SPA 2013
13-168 (DC)
w/SPA 13117 (DC)(F)

TITLE O F THE C A SE
Tito M. Aniban Vs. Pis. see SPA 13-117 Arnold Vasquez Tan

REMARKS

168.

1s l Legislative District of Samar

Resolution (FD ) - xxx the instant consolidated Petitions are hereby D EN IED

January 29, 2013

169.

Tineg, Abra

\
\
II

13-169 (DC)

Cromwell S. Luna Vs. Corinthia D. Crisologo Petition to deny due course/Cancel coc

Resolution (SD ) xxx the D ISM IS SED for lack of merit

Petition

is

hereby

March 12, 2013 April 17, 2013

Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 01, 2013 xxx elevated to en banc

< 5

170.

1s t District of the Province of Palawan

13-170 (DC)

Jesus L. Ustares, Sr., in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 003A,Brgy. Bancal Municipality of Cuyo, Province of Palawan Vs. Alvin Soteco Sandova

Submitted for resolution

171.

San Agustin, Romblon

13-171 (DC)

M ar Dominic Abrencillo Correa Vs. Linda Jean Moreno Abero

Submitted for resolution

Petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc

Page 4 7 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

)
STA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-172 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Antonio Bermejo C havez in his capacity as a registered voted of Brgy. Pugay, San Jose, Camarines Sur Vs.

172.

San Jose, Camarines Sur

\ Resolution (SD) - xxx R E S O LV E S to DEN Y the instant Petition for U TTER LACK O F M ER IT \

February 01, 2013

II Eduardo Patriarca Pilapil 173. Tarlac City 13-173 (DC) In Re: Petition for disqualification of Jerome H. La Pena as candidate for City Mayor, Tarlac City Esteban B. Aguas, Jr. Vs. Jerome H. Lapena 174. Lupon, Davao Oriental 13-174 (DC-F) In the matter of the petition for the disqualification of candidate Eva Afahalces Larrobis QuinonesMandalupe Lanie R. Gamurot Vs. Eva Afahalces Larrobis QuinonesMandalupe 175. San Ricardo, Southern Leyte 13-175 (DC-F) In the matter of the petition to invalidate and strike out respondents Certificate of Candidacy for VM ayor of San Ricardo, Southern Leyte in the M ay 13, 2013 Elections due to ineligibility Resolution (SD ) instant Petition xxx R ESO LVES, Submitted for resolution

\
\

*
\

to DEN Y the

February 01, 2013

II

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ESO LVES, to G R A N T the Petition dated 19 October 2012. Respondent JOVIC S. MEJIA is hereby excluded from the Certified List of Candidates

March 21, 2013

Page 4 8 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

>

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C ASE

STATUS
\

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

Generoso M. Herrera Vs. Jovic S. Mejia

With Motion to Declare Firfel and Executory Comelec Resolution Promulgated Inarch 21, 2013 filed by counsel for pet thru LBC reed on April 19, 2013

\\
176. Second Legislative District of Sarangani Province I Vs. Eugene L. Alzate 177. Inabanga, Bohol 13-177 (DC) Francisco L. Alesna, Jr. Vs. Atty. Epifanio B. Muneses I Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc 178. 3ra District of Albay 13-178 (DC) Renato M. Cervantes Vs. Fernando V. Gonzalez II Petition to deny due course and to cancfel coc
Page 49 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

13-176 (DC-F)

In a matter of the petition to disqualify Provincial Board candidate Eugene L. Alzate of Sarangani Province, Region XII Mary Ann Gam ino Gadian

Resolution (FD) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D IS M IS S the Petition for LACK O F M E R IT \ Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion V r Reconsideration is DENIED. The Resolution of the FiVst Division is hereby A FFIR M ED

February 01, 2013 April 08, 2 0 1 3

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O LV E S to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

April 25, 201 3

Joint Resolution (SD ) - xxx the two (2) Petitions are hereby D ISM IS SED

January 31, 2013 w /S P A 13167

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-179 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C ASE


Benjamin O. Matias Vs. Jose R. Ramirez, Jr. Petition to deny due course and to cancel coc

STA TU S
Resolution (SD) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Petiffon to Deny Due Course to Respondent Jose R. Ramirez, Jr.s Certificate of Candidacy

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

179.

Ligao City

January 16, 2013

180.

Zamboanga City

13-180 (DC)

Jose L. Lobregat Vs. Romeo G. Jalosjos Petition to deny due course to and/or to cancel COC

Resolution No. 9613 - xxx R ES O LVES , to C A N C EL and D E N \ due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zam boanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE

i A-

January 15, 2013

181.

District 1, PasayCity

13-181 (DC)

Florencio C. Mateo Vs. Richard M. Advincula and Lexter N. Ibay

Submitted for resolution

I
182. Taal, Batangas 13-182 (DC-F)

In the matter of the Petition to Cancel COC of Lino Vicente Montenegro y Masangkay as candidate for Mayor of Taal, Batangas Michael R ey Villano y Aseron Vs. Lino Vicente Montenegro y Masangkay

Resolution (FD) instant petition

xxx R ESO LVES,

to D E N Y

the

January 15, 2013

Page 50 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

>

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-183 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E \
Arip M. Basfyian Vs.

STATUS
Resolution (FD ) - In view of the Affidavit dated 11 December 2012, executed by respondent attesting to the fact that she had already withdrawn her certificate of candidacy for vice-mayor of Marawi City, the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for being moot and academic. Besides, petitioner informed the Commission that he will no longer pursue his case against respondent Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESO LVES, to C AN C EL and D E N Y due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zam boanga City in the M ay 13, 2013 NLE

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

183.

Marawi City

April 02, 2013

I Shahanie Yasmin C . Salic \

184.

Zamboanga City

13-184 (DC)

Elbert C. Atilano \ Vs. '

January 15, 2013

II

Romeo G. Jalosjos Petition to Deny Due Course to and/or to Cancel C O C

185.

Agno, Pangasinan

13-185 (DC)

In the matter of the petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc of Gualberto Ramirez Sison as a candidate for the position of Mayor of Agno, Pangasinan Jose Pajeta, Jr.

II

Resolution (S D ) - xxx the instant petition is hereby G R A N TE D . Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Gualberto Ramirez Sison for the position of M ayor of the Municipality of Agno, Pangasinan is hereby C A N C ELLED Order (SD ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc

February 01, 2013

Vs. Gualberto Ram irez Sison 186. 3ra District of Quezon Province 13-186 (DC) Rodolfo Reyes Rosales Vs. Ma. Lourdes C. De Luna-Pasatiempo Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, instant Petition for LACK O F M E R IT to D E N Y the

February 19, 2013

January 29, 2013

Page 51 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

>

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
\

TITLE O F THE C A S E
\ For: Disqualification and/or Cancellation of C O C under Sec 43(b ) of the Local Govt. Code pursuant to Sec. 1 of the 1987 Constitution

STA TU S

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

187.

Ligao City

13-187 (DC)

^ \

Bertito Latigay Vs. \ Manuel Laoang Garcia

Resolution (SD) - xxx R ESO LVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Course to Respondent Manuel Laoang Garcias Certificate of Candidacy

January 21, 2013

II

Petition to deny due course and to cancel C O C 188. Ligao City 13-188 (DC) Bertito Latigay Vs. II Patricia Gonzales-Alsua Petition to deny due course and to cancel C O C 189. Dingras, llocos Norte 13-189 (DC) Petition to disqualify Marynette Romero Gamboa as mayoralty candidate for the Municipality of Dingras, llocos Norte in the M ay 13, 2013 Synchronized National Elections under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure as amended by Comelec Resolution No. 9523 & Sec. 40, Local G o v t C ode Nathaniel Ruben P. Taylan
i

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D

February 01, 2013

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R R E S O LV E S to D ISM IS S the Verified Petition for Disqualification filed by Nathaniel Ruben P. Taylan for being M O O T and A C A D EM IC

March 21, 2013

Page 52 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C I T Y / P R O V IN C E

)
STA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

SPA 2013

TITLE O F TH E C A SE
Vs.

"

\ Marynette Romero Gamboa 190. Bulakan, Bulackn 13-190 (DC) Rosendo C. M eneses III Vs. Emmanuel N. Meneses Resolution (SD) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit Petition is hereby January 24, 2013

\ \
\

i, \ a
\

Petition to deny due course to/Cancel the C O C of Emmanuel N. Meneses 13-191 (DC) Faith C. M aganto Vs. Resolution (SD) - xxx R ES O LVES , to D ISM ISS the Petition to deny due course/ or cancel for lack of merit April 17, 2013

\
\

191.

5m District of Manila

II

Mario Flores Cayabyab Petition (To Deny Due Course to or to Cancel C O C )

192.

Lucena City

13-192 (DC-F)

Re: Petition to deny due course and/or cancellation of C O C of Marijoe Francisco Asensi Juanito Y. Diaz Vs. Marijoe Francisco Asensi

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx R E S O L V E S , as follows: II. To declare the following as IN ELIG IB LE candidates for the positions aspired for due to their failure to meet the age requirement / not a registered voter, as reflected and admitted in their C O C under oath during the preliminary hearings: xxx d. Asensi, Marjorie Francisco - Member, S. Panlungsod - Lucena City, Quezon xxx Further, to DENY due course to their CO C s and to cause the immediate cancellation/deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections; xxx i

January 11, 2013

Page 53 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-193 (DC-F)

TITLE O F THE C A SE
Engr. Leonilo B. Hulleza Vs.

STATUS
Resolution (SD) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D ISM IS S the instant Petition for Denial/ Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy

DATED/ PROMULGATED
\

REMARKS

193.

Cadiz City

April 01, 2013^

II

Hon. Patrick G. Escalante


\ \

For: Petition to deny due course to or cancel a COC 194. Cortes, Surigao del Sur 13-194 (DC) Senonina P. Cuanan Vs. Atty. William M. Angos I Petition for Disqualification / Cancellation of C O C 195. Cabugao, llocos Sur 13-195 (DC) Edgardo Cobangbang, Jr. vs. II Amelia Amparo Sunio Abarquez Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby G R A N T E D . Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Amelia Amparo Sunio-Abarquez for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Cabugao, llocos Sur is hereby CANCELLED O rder (S D ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc February 01, 2013 Resolution (EB) - xxx this instant M R D E N IE D for utter lack of merit is hereby April 24, 2013 Resolution (FD) - xxx RESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the Petition for LACK OF M ER IT January 30, 2013

\
\a
\

February 14, 2013 May 03, 2013

196.

Uyugan, Batanes

13-196 (DC-F)

In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancellation of C O C Jonathan Enrique V. Nanud, JR.

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O LV E S to G R A N T the instant Petition. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Caballero is hereby C A N C ELLED

I Vs. Rogelio Batin Caballero


Page 5 4 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)
i

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-197 (DC)

TITLE O F TH E C A SE
Re: Petition to disqualify Abdulazis A.M. Batingolo as candidate for Municipal M ayor Jamal Dansal Batalo and Fatima Itawa Macalinto Vs. Abdulazis M. Batingolo

STATUS
\

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

197.

Munai, Lanao del Norte

Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant Petition is Viereby D IS M IS S E D \

March 07, 2013 April 17, 2013

Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pets through counsel on April 01, 201 3 xxx elevated to en banc

II

\ \ \
Resolution (S D ) xxx the instant petition for' disqualification against respondent H E R M IN IG ILD O PAREJA P IM E N TE L, JR. is hereby D IS M IS S E D Order (SD ) - xxx M R elevated to en banc April 25, 2013 March 27, 2013

198.

Tago, Surigao del Sur II

13-198 (DC)

In the matter of the Petition to disqualify H E R M IN IG IL D O PA R EJA PIM ENTEL, JR. as candidate for M ayor of the Municipality of Tago, Surigao del Sur in 13 M ay 2013 Elections Rogelio M. Pimentel vs. Herminigildo Pareja Pimentel, Jr.

199.

Lone District of the Province of Nueva Vizcaya

13-199 (DC)

Francisco Aggasid y Acedo vs. Rodrigo Perez y Pajarillo Petition with Motion Ad Cautelam For Disqualification under Section 6 8 OEC

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for LACK O F M ER IT

April 02, 2013

i Page 55 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

>

MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-200 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
In the matter of the Petition to Disqualify Atty. Ramon P. Velasco as a candidate for Vice Mayor, Municipality o f Labason, Zam boanga del Norte in the May 13, 2013 Elections Dr. Roberto R. Galon and Glenn E. Sanchez

STATUS
\

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

200.

Labason, Zamboanga del Norte

Submitted for resolution \ \

II

201.

Uson, Masbate

13-201 (DC)

Jobelle C. Regular and Salvadora O. Sanchez Vs.

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby D ENIED. Consequently, the petition for\disqualification against ARLISA C. R E C IO -D E N IG R IS \4 ordered D IS M IS S E D Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

February 27, 2013

II Arlisa C. Recio-Denigris 202. Buguey, Cagayan 13-202 (DC)(F) Licerio M. Antiporda III Vs. 1 Wendelin C.Sibbaluca-Taruc For: Disqualification 203. Cortes, Surigao del Sur 13-203 (DC) William M. Angos Vs. Leticia Sonya B. Cuanan and the Municipal Election Officer o f Cortes, Surigao del Sur

March 14, 2013 March 21, 2013

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ES O LVES to D IS M IS S the Petition to disqualify Wendelin C. Sibbaluca-Taruc pursuant to the second paragraph of Section 1, Rule 25 of the Commissions Rules of Procedure as amended, and for utter lack of merit

Submitted for resolution

II

i Page 56 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

J
S TA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

M U N ./C IT Y / P R O V IN C E

SPA 2013
13-204 (DC)

TITLE O F THE CASE


\

204.

1s '
Congressional District of Bataan

Edmund Lee Castafieda Vs. Felicito Payumo

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S to D ISM IS S the Petition for U TTER LACK O F M E R IT

March 21, 2013

I 205. Dumalinao, Zamboanga del Sur 13-205 (DC)(F)

Petition to Deny Due Course To or Cancel Certificate of Candidacy Brgy. Captain Wilfredo Duhaylungsod of Upper Dumalinao, et al.

II Vs. Pruelo D. Jalosjos 206. Cortes, Surigao del Sur II 207. Tanauan, Leyte I Pelagio R. Tecson, Jr. Petition to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy 13-207 (DC)(F) 13-206 (DC) Alfonso G. Cuanan Vs. Leticia Sonya B. Cuanan Claudio M. Sabido, Sr. Vs.

Resolution (SD ) - xxx there being no order or resolution emanating from the higher courts restraining the implementation of the aforementioned final and executdry decision, the Second Division RESO LVED , as it hereby R ESO LVES to C A N C E L the Certificate of C an d id aiy filed by P R U E L O D. JALOSJOS for the office of Mayor of Dumalinao, Zam boanga del Sur in the M ay 13, 2013 NLE for failure to comply with the required qualifications for an elective local official Resolution (SD ) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for Disqualification

April 22, 2013

April 03, 2013

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R E S O L V E S , Petition dated 28 Decem ber 2012

to D E N Y

the

March 06, 2013 April 16, 2013

Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel elevated to en banc

t
Page 57 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013
13-208 (DC)(F)

TITLE O F THE CASE


\ In Re: Petition to D&ny Due Course or To Cancel the Certificate of Candidacy of Francisco C. Catayong, candidate for Mayor of MacArthur, Eastern Samar Elvira A. Navidad \

208.

MacArthur, Eastern Samar

Resolution (SD) xxx the D IS M IS S E D for lack of merit

Petition

is

hereby

March 27, 2013

II

v s \
Francisco C. Catayong 209. Mambajao, Camiguin 13-209 (DC)(F) Pedro P. Romualdo Vs. I Juan Margarito E. Neri For: Disqualification under Rule 25 of the Com elec Rules of Procedure as amended by Resolution No. 9523 210. Bogo City, Cebu 13-210 (DC) Antonio F. Condor Vs. II Rhett E. Minguez For: Disqualification 211. City of Manila 13-211 (DC) Atty. Alicia Risos-Vidal Vs. II Joseph Ejercito Estrada
Page 58 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

Resolution (FD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D E N Y the Petition dated 11 January 2013 for LACK OF M E R IT O rder (FD ) - xxx MR filed by petitioner through counsel elevated to en banc

April 02, 2013

April 16, 2013

Resolution (SD ) - xxx R ESO LVES, to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for Disqualification

April 17, 2013

Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D for utter lack of merit Resolution (EB) - xxx RESO LVES, to D E N Y the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK O F M ER IT.

April 01, 2013

April 23, 2013

V I

)
STATUS
Consequently, the April 1, 2013 Commission SD is hereby affirmed

)
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE

SPA 2013 ,
\

TITLE O F THE C A S E

\
Rodolfo R. Armea, Jr. \ \ Vs Jimmy Villete Delena

Resolution of the

212.

Presentacio n, Camarines Sur

13-212 (DC)

Resolution (SD ) - xxx the instant petition is hereby D IS M IS S E D Order (S D ) - Without giving due course to his motion to intervene, the Commission (S D ) hereby D E N IE S the Motion for Reconsideration with Motion to Intervene Ad C autelam (O f this Hon. S D s Resolution dated 22 March 2 0 1 3 ) filed by Manuel P. Realda through counsel on April 1, 2013, praying for the ff. xxx for LACK O F LO C U S STA N D I/ It must be emphasized that the Commission issued an Order on March 19, 2013 merely noting Mr. Realdas motion to intervene because it was filed after the case is deem ed submitted for resolution. This is also the reason why his name was not mentioned in the caption neither was his request to intervene included in the discussion of the assailed Resolution by this Commission Resolution (S D ) - xxx the petition is hereby D E N IE D . Consequently, the petition for disqualification against Pelagio Rudas Tecson, Jr. is ordered D IS M IS S E D Order (S D ) - xxx MR filed by pet through mail and reed on April 25, 2 0 1 3 xxx elevated to en banc

March 21, 2013 April 23, 2013

II

\ Verified Petition to Disqualify Respondent for Lack of Qualification

213.

Tanauan, Leyte II

13-213 (DC)(F)

Atty. Agapito P. Pagayanan, Jr. Vs. Pelagio R. Tecson, Jr. Petition for Disqualification

April 01, 2013

April 30, 2013

214.

Salcedo, Eastern Samar II

13-214 (DC)

Atty. Melchor Llego Mergal Vs. Benjamin Gagante, Jr.

Submitted for resolution

)
y

Page 59 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
SPA 2013
13-215 (DC)

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REM ARKS
\

\
\

MUN. /C I T Y / P R O V IN C E
\

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Librado G. Dim aunahan Vs. Brenda Dimayuga, a.k.a. Ligaya Santos, a.k.a. Ma. Brenda Kenrick

215.

San ipascual, Batangas

Resolution (SD ) - xxx RESO LVES, to D ISM IS S the instant Petition for Disqualfiication

April 01, 2013

\
\

216.

\" V Caintsk, Rizal \

\
13-216 (DC) Engr. Crispino P. Pablo, Sr. Vs. Resolution (SD ) - xxx R ES O LVES to D IS M IS S the instant Petition for Disqualification for lack of merit Order (SD) - xxx M R filed by pet through counsel on April 26, 2013, xxx elevated to en banc Submitted for resolution April 18, 2013

\
\

\
April 30, 2013

Arturo L. Sicat 13-217 (DC)(F) In Re: Petition to disqualify a candidate pursuant to Sec. 68 of the O E C and Petition to Disqualify for possessing some grounds for disqualifications Henry Ancog Uy Vs. Estrella Ancog-Anub

>

217.

Bilar, Bohol

218.

San Pedro, Laguna

13-218 (DC)

Norvic D. Solidum, Andres T . Reyes III, and Emmanuel A. Duran Vs.

Submitted for resolution

1 Calixto R. C ataquiz

Page 6 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-219 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Ricardo N. Santos Vs.

S TA TU S
Submitted for resolution

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

219.

Bustos, Buiacan II

Carlito Reyes

220 .

San Isidro, Surigao del Norte

13-220 (DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Disqualify Lalaine E. Dominos Rudy M. Camingue Vs. Lalaine Espadero Dominos Petition for Disqualification

Submitted for resolution

221 .

Davao City Valenzuela city, Buiacan, Pampanga, Camarines Sur

13-221 (DC)

Petition to Disqualify as Candidates the Nam ed Respondents, and those Similarly Situated, for being prohibited candidate under the Constitution as they are C lear and Obvious C ases of Political Dynasties Francisco Ashley L. Acedillo, et. al. Vs. Rodrigo Duterte, et al. and all similarly situated candidates

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby D ISM ISSED w/ Motion for Reconsideration filed by counsel for petitioners on May 02, 2013

April 17, 2013

222 .

Cabugao, llocos Sur


I

13-222 (DC)

Catherine Lacaste Vs. Josefina Vallejo

Resolution (FD) - xxx R E S O L V E S , to D ISM IS S the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

May 03, 2013

Page 61 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-223 (DC)

TITLE O F THE CASE


Alshid L. Mohammad-ali Vs.

STATUS
\ Submitted for resolution ^ \

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

223.

Sapa-Sapa, Tawi-Tawi

1 1

Putli Aisa S. Matolo Petition for Disqualification (of Respondent Putli Aisa S. Matolo from running as Municipal Mayor of SapaSapa, Taw i-Taw i in the May 13, 2013 Automated NLE)

\ \
\

\9
Submitted for resolution

224.

2n a Congr1 . District, Province of Bataan 1

13-224 (DC)

O scar R. Delos Reyes Vs. Enrique T. Garcia, Jr. For: Disqualification

225.

First District, Surigao del Sur 1

13-225 (DC)

Mary Elizabeth Ty-Delgado Vs. Phiip Arreza Pichay For: Disqualification

Submitted for resolution

226.

Kidapawan City

13-226 (DC)

Panfilo Ignalan Caingat Vs. Ernido Y. Gantuangco


i

Submitted for resolution

Page 62 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-227 (DC)

TITLE O F TH E C A S E
\

STATUS
Submitted for resolutidn
\

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

227.

First District of Surigao del Norte

Gertrudes C. Saberon Vs. Rep. Francisco T. Matugas

II For: Disqualification 228. Sulu 13-228 (DC) M uam m ar S. Tulawie Vs. 1 Abdusakur M. Tan Submitted for resolution

\ \
\

\a
*

229.

Mapun, Province of Tawi-Tawi

13-229 (DC)

In Re: Petition for Disqualification of Jaiman Hasim Kanding as candidate for Vice-M ayor in the Municipality of Mapun, Province of Tawi-Tawi Abdulharik Abdulhalim Kiram Vs. Jaiman Hasim Kanding, a.k.a. Elwin Bin Liol

Summons (resetting)

w/

NOC

set on

May

06,

2013;

2pm

II

230.

4th District of Nueva Ecija 1

13-230 (DC)

Pedro A. Fajardo and Desita C. Garcia Vs. Magnolia Rosa C. Antonino Nadres

Resolution (FD ) - xxx RESO LVED , as it hereby R ESO LVES, to D EN Y the Petition for Disqualification dated 27 Feb. 2013 for LACK O F M E R IT

April 30, 2013

Page 63 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-231 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E

STATUS

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

231.

San Andres, Romblon I

In Re: The Disqualification of Dr. ^Submitted for resolution Fernald Rovillos as candidate for Mayor of the Town of San Andres, Romblon Atty. Geminiano G. Galicia, Jr.

232.

Babatngon, Leyte

13-232 (DC)(F)

In the matter of the petition to deny due course or to cancel certificate of candidacy of Marcelina S. Engle for Vice-M ayor of Babatngon, Leyte Vice-M ayor Winston B. Menzon Vs. Marcelina S. Engle

\ Submitted for resolution \

II

\9
\

234.

Datu Saudi Ampatuan, Maguindanao II

13-233 (DC)

Kadil Kango M aslam am a Vs. Datuwata Utto Adzis

Submitted for resolution

234.

Datu Saudi Ampatuan,


Maguindanao

13-234 (DC)

Norodin Makung Ali Vs. Saudi Sean Biruar Ampatuan III

Submitted for resolution

I 235. Culasi, Antique II


i

13-235 (DC)

Joel A. Lomugdang Vs. Bibiano A. Herco

Submitted for resolution

Page 64 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
S TA TU S
Submitted for resolution

)
D ATED / PROMULGATED REMARKS

Ml/N. / C /7 Y /
P R O V I N C E

SPA 2013
13-236 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E \
In Re: Petition forlDisqualification from Continuing as Qandidate for Acts Declared by Law Grounds for Disqualification and Lack of Residency Requirement of a Candidate \ V Arturo S. (Sayao Vs. \ Rhandolf G. L iW d o t

236.

Manabo, Abra

II

237.

Madalag, Aklan

13-237 (DC)

Orlando B. Inosanto, Sr. Vs.

Submitted for resolution

Alfonso A. Gubatina For Disqualification under Sec. 68, BP Big. 881

238.

Kitaotao, Bukidnon II

13-238 (DC)

Lynard Allan S. Bigcas Vs. Lorenzo A. Gawilan, Jr.

Summons (resetting)

w/

NOC

set on

May

06,

2013;

2pm

239.

Province of Bukidnon

13-239 (DC)

Lynard Allan S. Bigcas Vs.

Submitted for resolution

Jose Maria R. Zubiri

Page 65 o f T 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

>

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 201 ^
13-24 (DC) '

TITLE O F THE C A S E
In the matter of Petition for Disqualification of Nassief Benito Sharrief as Mayoralty Candidate in Pagayawan, Lanao del Sur in connection with the M ay 13, 2013 National and Local Elections
\

STATUS
Submitted for resolution

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

240.

Pagayawan, Lanao de! Sur

Hanifa U. Aloyodan-Diamael \ \
9

Vs. Nassief Benito Sharief

241.

Pagayawan, Lanao del Sur

13-241 (DC)

In the matter of Petition for Disqualification of Oweida P. Dalidig as mayoraly candidate in Pagayawan, Lanao del Sur in connection with the M ay 13, 2013 National and Local Elections Hanifa U. Aloyodan-Diamael Vs. Oweida P. Dalidig

Submitted for resolution

242.

Sta. Catalina, Oriental Negros

13-242 (DC)

In the matter of the Petition for Disqualification of Ligaya Gam o Pacanza as candidate for the position of Vice-M ayor of Sta. Catalinga, Oriental Negros Ruben P. Melodia Vs.

Summons w/ NOC set (resetting) Reset to May 09, 2013

on

May

06,

2013;

2pm

II

Page 66 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E

STATUS

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

Ligaya G am o Pacanza 243. 13-243 (DC) In the matter of the Petition to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy of Maria Belen Maribel Andaya Eusebio as candidate for M ayor of Pasig City Anthony Panton Sanchez, Noel Maaba Medina, John G avierez Peralta, Fern Posis Rivera Vs. Maria Belen M aribel Andaya-Eusebio Petition for Disqualification 244.
1 District, City of Tandag, Surigao del Sur

\
Submitted for resolution

13-244 (DC)

Angelito G. Paurna Vs. Mary Elizabeth Delgado

Submitted for resolution

245.

Balanga, Bataan

13-245 (DC )(F)

Elmer Malixi Castrence, Norman Del Mundo Guila Vs. Ludovico Peter Paul Banzon Pascual Jr.

Summons (resetting)

w/

N OC

set on

May

06,

2013;

2pm

246.

Tubod, Lanao del Norte

13-246 (DC)

Carolyn E. Paclipan and Nelson L. Suan

Summons (resetting)

w/

NOC

set

on

May

06,

2013;

2pm

Page 6 7 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

V I

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013
13-251 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Arturo F. Dela Cruz, Dennis R. Giliberte, Jeric Isidor S. Sarmiento Vs. Alan Tarom a Aquino Petition for Disqualification

S TA TU S
Submitted for resolution

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

251.

Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro

252.

Pantar, Lanao del Norte

13-252 (DC)

Malik T. Alingan Vs. Mohamad Limbona For: Disqualification

Submitted for resolution

253.

Alangalang, Leyte

13-253
(D C )(F )

Loreto T. Yu Vs. Andres G. Yu Opposition to the Substitution and/or Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy of Andres G. Yu

Summons (resetting)

w/

NOC

set

on

May

07,

2013;

2pm

254.

Province of Antique, Anini-y, Antique, Valderrama,

13-254 (DC)

Cornelio P. Aldon and Raymundo T. Roquero Vs.

Order (SD -C O C ) xxx Conference scheduled today is hereby cancelled/ counsels are hereby given a period of 3 days from today within which to file their manifestations

April 29, 2013

Page 69 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A SE \
Gov. Exequiel B. Javier, Vice-Gov. Rosie A. Dimamay, SP M em ber J Tobias M. Javier, SP M em ber Edgar D. Denosta, SP M em ber Dino Roel T. Operiano, SP M em ber Rolando Plameras, SP M em ber Teopisto C. Estaris, Jr., SP M em ber Victor R. Condez, SB M em ber Maryvic H. Near, and Vice-M ayor Christopher B. Maguad

STATUS

DATED/ PROMULGATED

REMARKS

Antique

\
\
\

II

\
\
Summons (resetting) w/ NOC set^ on M ay 06, 2013; 2pm Submitted for resolution

255.

Lone District of Nueva Vizcaya

13-255 (DC)

Jose C. Aleta III and Antonio L. Abellon, Jr. Vs.

II Luisa Lloren C uaresm a 256. Caloocan City 13-256 (DC) Jonathan A. Garcia Vs. 1 257. City of Balanga, Bataan II 258. Alegria, Cebu 13-258 (DC) 13-257 (DC) Ricojudge Janvier RJ Echiverri Jimmy S. Bustamante Vs. Jose Enrique Garcia, III Edwin Sato, Miguel Lendio, Randy Rebalde, Fidel Libradilla, Nestor Endona, and Joel Aias-as * II
Page 7 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

Submitted for resolution

Submitted for resolution

Vs.

)
M U N . / C I T Y / P R O V I N C E

1
STA TU S

)
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

SPA 2013

TITLE O F THE C A S E \
Raul Guisadio Petition for Disqualification
\ \

259.

Lone Legislative District of Mountain Province

13-259 (DC)

Joseph Denver S. Puyongan Vs. Maximo B. Dalog, Sr. Verified Petition for Disqualification (Under Rule 25 of the Com elec Rules of Procedure as Amended by Comelec Resolution No. 9523)

Summ ons \resetting)

w/

NOC

set on

May

06,

2013;

2pm

\
* Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm

II

260.

Madridejos, Cebu

13-260 (DC)

Arvin Gido Rosales Vs.

II

Salvador S. Dela Fuente Petition for Disqualification (Of Respondent Salvador S. Dela Fuente from Running as Municipal Mayor of Madridejos, Cebu in the M ay 13, 2013 Automated National and Local Elections)

261.

Caloocan City

13-261 (DC)

Medina Victoria Laurino Vs.

Summons w / N O C set on May 06, 2013; 2pm

II
i

Luis Chito Abel


1 y

Page 71 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

I I

.)

)
STATUS
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE 262.

SPA 2013
13-262 (DC)

TITLE O F THE C A S E
\

Balangkaya n, Eastern Samar II

Atty. AlUan C. Contado Vs. Nita B. Aide


\

Summons w/ N O C set on May 06, 2013; 2pm

263.

Taraka, Lanao del Sur

13-263 (DC)

Nashiba G. Su^agayan Vs.^

Summons w / N O C set on May 06, 2013; 2pm

1
Faisal E. Usman 264. Kalayaan, Palawan 13-264 (DC) Eugenio B. Bito-onon, Jr. Vs.

Summons w/ N O C set on May 06, 2013; 2pm Reset to May 09, 2013

1
Noel F. Osorio 265. 2na Dist. Of Pangasinan And Lingayen, Pangasinan 13-265 (DC) In Re: Petition for Disqualification of Candidacies of Leopoldo N. Bataoil for Member of House Representatives 2n d District of Pangasinan and Ramon N. Bataoil for Municipal Councilor of Pangasinan Richard Beil P. Ortega Vs. Leopoldo N. Bataoil and Ramon N. Bataoil 266. First District of llocos Sur 13-266 (DC) Bertrand A. Baterina Vs.

Summons w/ N O C set on May 06, 2013; 2pm Reset to May 08, 2013

Summons w/ N O C set on May 06, 2013; 2pm Reset to May 09, 2 01 3

II
Ronald V. Singson

Page 72 of 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

)
S TA TU S
DATED/ PROMULGATED REMARKS
\

SPA 2013
\ 13-267

TITLE O F THE C A S E
Mary Ann Joy M. Jim enez Vs. Enrico Recom Echiverri

267.

1S l District of Caloocan City

Summons w/ N O C set on M ay 09, 2013; 2pm

TO

Xs

1 \ \
268. Tuburan, Cebu 13-268 \ (DC)

Petition for Disqualification In Re: Petition to disqualify the candidates of One Cebu Party for Elective Positions in the Municipality of ' Tuburan, Cebu pursuant to the provisions of Comelec Resolution No. Maricel N. Cajeras Vs. Rose Marie Gerona-Suezo, Daphne Arias Lagon Summons w/ N O C set on M ay 09, 2013; 2pm

II

269.

Angeles City

13-269 (DC)

Adelaido I. Bacani, Jr. Vs.

Summons w/ N O C set on M ay 09, 2013; 2pm

1
Edgardo D. Pamintuan

270.

Balanga City, Bataaan II

13-270 (DC)

Jose Enrique S. G arcia III Vs. Jimmy S. Bustamante

Summons w/ N O C set on M ay 09, 2013; 2pm

Page 73 o f 7 7 (SPA 2 0 1 3 DC)

\
\