You are on page 1of 6

Case 2:06-cv-00481-GLL Document 70-1 Filed 04/25/2006 Page 1 of 6

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

CELESTE TAYLOR, et al., )


)
Plaintiffs, )
)
v. ) Civil Action No. 06-481
)
DAN ONORATO, et al. ) JUDGE LANCASTER
)
Defendants. )

AMENDED EXHIBIT LIST OF FEDERAL DEFENDANTS

The federal defendants Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States, and
Wan Kim, Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights, reserve the right to offer any of the
following exhibits at the preliminary injunction hearing:

1. HAVA Bulletin #1, June 18, 2003, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,


Department of State
2. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania State HAVA Plan, July 31, 2003, 69 Fed.
Reg. 14002-02
3. Order, Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, Kuznik v. Westmoreland
County, February 13, 2006
4. Order, Pennsylvania Supreme Court, Kuznik v. Westmoreland County, March
2, 2006
5. Petition for Review in Coalition for Voting Integrity v. Cortes
6. Complaint in Kleha v. Schuylkill County Board of Commissioners
7. Complaint in Kuznik v. Westmoreland County Board of Commissioners
8. Petition for Review in Lingenfelter v. Cortes
9. Petition for Review in Meztli v. Cortes
10. EAC Advisory 2005-005: Lever Voting Machines and HAVA Section 301(a),
September 8, 2005
11. EAC Advisory 2005-004: How to determine if a voting system is compliant
with Section 301(a) –– a gap analysis between 2002 Voting System Standards
and the requirements of Section 301(a), July 20, 2005
Case 2:06-cv-00481-GLL Document 70-1 Filed 04/25/2006 Page 2 of 6

12. EAC, Media Advisory, EAC Adopts 2005 Voluntary Voting System
Guidelines, December 13, 2005
13. EAC, 2005 Voluntary Voting System Guidelines (excerpts)
14. Letter from Gavin Gilmour to Marci Mustello, April 19, 2006
15. Letter from Gavin Gilmour to Pedro Cortes, March 31, 2006
16. Letter from Thomas Wilkey to Pedro Cortes, March 24, 2006
17. Letter from Harry van Sickle to Pennsylvania Counties, March 13, 2006
18A. Declaration of Edgardo Cortes, EAC (with attachment below)
18B. EAC, Federal Funds Awarded to States under HAVA, December 31, 2005
19A. Declaration of Toby Moore, DOJ (with attachments below)
19B. 1997 U.S. Census data
19C. 2000 U.S. Census data
19D. National Center for Educational Statistics 2003 Report
20A. Excerpts, HAVA webpage, U.S. Department of Justice (set forth below)
20B. Frequently Asked Questions, last updated March 20, 2006 (from HAVA
webpage)
20C. Letter from Ralph Boyd to Nancy Worley, March 17, 2003 (from HAVA
webpage)
20D. Letter from Joseph Rich to Ann McGeehan, May 20, 2003 (from HAVA
webpage)
20E. Whether Certain Direct Recording Electronic Voting Systems Comply with
the Help America Vote Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act, October
10, 2003 (from HAVA webpage)
20F. Letter from Hans von Spakovsky to John W. Eads, March 4, 2005 (from
HAVA webpage)
20G. Letter from Hans von Spakovsky to Angie Rogers LaPlace and Meritta
Spencer Norton, May 10, 2005 (from HAVA webpage)
Excerpts of record: Orders, pleadings, filings, exhibits and declarations filed
21A. in United States v. New York Board of Elections, Civil Action No.
06-Civ-0263 (N.D.N.Y.) (set forth below)
21B. U.S. Preliminary Injunction Memorandum (in U.S. v. NYSBOE case)
21C. Declaration of Edgardo Cortes (attached to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE case)
Case 2:06-cv-00481-GLL Document 70-1 Filed 04/25/2006 Page 3 of 6

21D. Letter from Hans von Spakovsky to Peter Kosinski, March 15, 2005 (attached
to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE case)
21E. Letter from Wan Kim to Eliot Spitzer and Todd Valentine (attached to PI
Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE case)
21F. Declaration of Brian Heffernan (attached to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE
case)
21G. Declaration of Michael Godino (attached to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE
case)
21H. Declaration of Diane Golden (attached to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE case)
21I. Declaration of Charles Reichardt (attached to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE
case)
21J. Declaration of Sharon Shapiro (attached to PI Memo in U.S. v. NYSBOE case)
21K. Order Granting U.S. Motion for Preliminary Injunction (in U.S. v. NYSBOE
case)
22. Registered Voter Data for Pennsylvania and Allegheny County
23A. Declaration of Curt Decker, NDRN (with attachment below)
23B. NDRN, Voting Machines and Individuals with Dexterity Disabilities, July 11,
2005
24. “Bucks to use old machines for voting in May primary,” Philadelphia Inquirer,
April 20, 2006
25. FEC, 2002 Voting System Standards (excerpts)
26. Petitioners’ Motion for Post-Trial Relief in Kuznik v. Westmoreland County
Board of Commissioners, February 15, 2006
27. Letter from Wan Kim to Tom Corbett, Albert Masland and R. Mark
Gesalman, February 21, 2006
28. iVotronic fact sheet (from ES&S website)
29. Declaration of Christopher Thomas
30. Declaration of Marci Andino
31. Declaration of John Tanner
32. Declarations from any witnesses listed on any of Defendants’ witness lists
33. Any exhibit attached to any declaration from any witnesses listed on any of
Defendants' witness lists
Case 2:06-cv-00481-GLL Document 70-1 Filed 04/25/2006 Page 4 of 6

34. Any document listed on the exhibit list of any Defendant


35. Any document necessary or appropriate for rebuttal
36. Any document necessary or appropriate for impeachment
37. Any document received through discovery

In addition, the federal defendants reserve the right to designate any additional exhibit
not yet identified, with prompt notice to Plaintiffs once that occurs.

Dated: April 22, 2006


Respectfully submitted,

ALBERTO GONZALES
Attorney General

MARY BETH BUCHANAN WAN J. KIM


United States Attorney Assistant Attorney General
Civil Rights Division

JOHN K. TANNER
Chief, Voting Section

/s/ /s/
____________________________ _______________________
JESSICA LIEBER SMOLAR T. CHRISTIAN HERREN JR
Bar Number: 65406 chris.herren@usdoj.gov
Assistant United States Attorney RICHARD DELLHEIM
700 Grant Street, Suite 4000 richard.dellheim@usdoj.gov
Pittsburgh, PA 15219 MAURA LEE
(412) 894-7419 (telephone) maura.lee@usdoj.gov
(412) 644-4549 (facsimile) Voting Section
Room 7254--NWB
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20530
(800) 253-3931 (telephone)
(202) 307-3961 (facsimile)
Case 2:06-cv-00481-GLL Document 70-1 Filed 04/25/2006 Page 5 of 6

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on April 22, 2006, I caused a true and correct copy of the foregoing

Amended Exhibit List of Federal Defendants to be served by electronic mail on the following:

Harry Litman Thomas J. Farrell


Litman Law Firm Jay K. Reisinger
One Oxford Centre Valerie A. Antonette
301 Grant Street Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC
34th Floor Suite 1000 – Koppers Building
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219 436 Seventh Avenue
(412) 456-2000 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219-1827
harry.litman@verizon.net (412) 391-3700
tfarrell@reichalexander.com
jreisinger@reichalexander.com
vantonette@reichalexander.com

Gregory M. Harvey Norman I. Eisen


Montgomery, McCracken, Walker & Eleanor H. Smith
Rhoads, LLP Zuckerman Spaeder LLP
123 South Broad Street 1800 M Street, N.W.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19109-1099 Suite 1000
(215) 772-7684 Washington, D.C. 20036-5802
gharvey@mmwr.com (202) 778-1800
neisen@zuckerman.com
esmith@zuckerman.com

Martin S. Himeles, Jr. Elliot M. Mincberg


Cyril V. Smith People For the American Way Foundation
Zuckerman Spaeder LLP 2000 M Street N.W. #400
100 East Pratt Street Washington, D.C. 20036
Suite 2440 (202) 467- 4999
Baltimore, Maryland 21202 emincberg@pfaw.org
(410) 332-0444 dliu@pfaw.org
mhimeles@zuckerman.com
csmith@zuckerman.com
Case 2:06-cv-00481-GLL Document 70-1 Filed 04/25/2006 Page 6 of 6

Michael Wojcik Gregory E. Dunlap


Solicitor Deputy General Counsel
Allegheny County Law Department Office of General Counsel
300 Fort Pitt Commons 333 Market Street, 17th Floor
445 Fort Pitt Blvd Harrisburg, PA 17120
Pittsburgh, PA 15219 (717) 783-6563
mwojcik@county.allegheny.pa.us gdunlap@state.pa.us

Mark A. Aronchick
Alan C. Promer
Shawn A. Weede
Sozi P. Tulante
Hangley, Aronchick Segal & Pudlin
One Logan Square
18th & Cherry Street
27th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103-6933
(215) 568-6200
maronchick@hangley.com
apromer@hangley.com
sweede@hangley.com
stulante@hangley.com

/s/
_________________________
T. Christian Herren Jr.