CORRUPTION AND CRIME COMMISSION

Your ref: Our ref: 02991/2011 CMISAuthNo.: 10625

vi 30 November 2011 Mr Ali Rachid Ammou cl- Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o Pri ce## Ave ue i $%& ' A()AN* +A ,330 ^ ^ & (- $ O&rC. (/ * &0#uear ivir Ammou ALLEGATION OF FALSE AND MISLEADING TESTIMONY I re1er 2o !our le22er received a2 2hi# o11ice o 10 November 2011. I i2 !ou alle"e 1al#e a d mi#leadi " 2e#2imo ! 3a# "ive b! Police a d 3i2 e##e# a2 a 2rial i 3hich !ou 3ere co vic2ed o1 a22em42ed murder. I a44recia2e 2hi# ma22er i# o1 "rea2 co cer 2o !ou a d 3ill e deavour 2o 4rovide !ou 3i2h a com4rehe #ive re#4o #e. To 1all 3i2hi 2he 5uri#dic2io o1 2he Corru42io a d Crime Commi##io 62he 7Commi##io 89 a alle"a2io o1 mi#co duc2 a"ai #2 a 4ublic o11icer a# de1i ed 3i2hi #ec2io : o1 2he Corru42io a d Crime Commi##io Ac2 6+A9 2003 62he 7Ac289 i# re;uired. <or !our i 1orma2io 7mi#co duc28 occur# 3he a 4ublic o11icer ha# mi#u#ed 2heir o11icial 4o#i2io 1or 4er#o al "ai = or ha# ac2ed 1rom a im4ro4er or corru42 mo2ive= i #hor2= 1ailed 2o ac2 i "ood 1ai2h. *ou have 4rovided a co4! o1 2he #2a2eme 2# o1 23o 3i2 e##e#> Michelle <armer= 6a 4aramedic em4lo!ed b! 2he S2 ?oh Ambula ce Service9 a d Adele Du@am4=6a cli ical ur#e em4lo!ed a2 2he <rema 2le Ao#4i2al Emer"e c! De4ar2me 29. +hil#2 a co 1lic2 i# o2ed be23ee 2heir re#4ec2ive de4o#i2io # rela2i " 2o 2he cu22i " o1 2he bra #2ra4= M# <armer i# o2 a 4ublic o11icer 3i2hi 2he mea i " o1 2he Ac2. I a ! eve 2 #uch a a omal! 3ould be more a44ro4ria2el! co #idered b! !our la3!er i decidi " 2he releva 2 4oi 2# 2o rai#e i Cour2 i !our de1e ce. coR5mr o21i mi##io ha# o 5uri#dicB /C2iBhaveD1ailedT&+2ocula2e a alle"a2io o1 mi#co duc2 a;ai #2 a ! There1ore= i accorda ce 3i2h #ec2io SSION e o ac2io re"ardi " !our com4lai 2 a# i2h 2hem. jjpifees Terrace iEOOO Telephone: +61 !"1# $ Toll Free: 1 %% %! %%%

The Commi##io 8# 1ile ha# o3 bee clo#ed. Ao3ever i1 !ou are able 2o 4rovide a ! evide ce 3hich 3ould #u44or2 a alle"a2io o1 mi#co duc2 a"ai #2 a 4ublic o11icer= 2he Commi##io 3ould be i 2ere#2ed i receivi " 2hi# i 1orma2io . Z.J

*our# 1ai2h1ull! Tere ce Dibb &O''()TION )'E*ENTION OFFI&E'

O+,-.s+an /es0ern A-s0ralia Ser1in2 )arlia+en0 3 Ser1in2 /es0ern A-s0ralians Our re1> CF2231G

E ;uirie#>Ma22He 2 Tele4ho e>Pri#o 12 ?a uar! 2012 Mr Ali Ammou Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o (oc@ed )a" No. 2 A()AN* +A ,331 Dear Mr Ammou Tha @ !ou 1or !our le22er o1 1: November 2011 #ee@i " a Ombud#ma i 2o !our com4lai 2 abou2 !our curre 2 co vic2io #. i ve#2i"a2io b! 2he Tele4ho e S!#2em

A# I u der#2a d i2= !ou com4lai 2ha2 !ou have bee 3ro "1ull! co vic2ed a d !ou are #ee@i " 2he a##i#2a ce o1 2he Ombud#ma i reBi ve#2i"a2i " !our ca#e a d lod"i " a a44eal a"ai #2 2he co vic2io . I have u der2a@e a a##e##me 2 o1 !our com4lai 2 2o de2ermi e 3he2her i2 ca be i ve#2i"a2ed b! 2he Ombud#ma havi " re"ard 2o 2he 4rovi#io # o1 2he !rl"!#e$t!r% Co##"&&"o$er Act 19'1 40he Ac056 3hich #e2# ou2 3ha2 2he Ombud#ma ca a d ca o2 i ve#2i"a2e. )a#ed o 2he i 1orma2io !ou have 4rovided= i2 #eem# 2ha2 2hi# o11ice doe# o2 have 2he 5uri#dic2io 2o co #ider !our com4lai 2. Thi# i# becau#e #ec2io 13 o1 2he Ac2 #4eci1icall! eIclude# all cour2#= 5ud"e#= a d ma"i#2ra2e# 1rom 2he 5uri#dic2io o1 2he Ombud#ma . Thi# mea # 2ha2 2he Ombud#ma doe# o2 have 2he 4o3er 2o i ve#2i"a2e !our co vic2io . *ou ma! li@e 2o co #ider co 2ac2i " (e"al Aid or 2he (a3 Socie2! o1 +e#2er Au#2ralia a# 2he#e or"a i#a2io # ma! be able 2o 4rovide !ou 3i2h 1ree or rela2ivel! i eI4e #ive le"al advice a dFor re4re#e 2a2io i rela2io 2o 2hi# ma22er. *ou ca co 2ac2 2he#e or"a i#a2io # b!>

(e"al Aid I$for#!t"o$ ("$e: 1300 ,/0 /GJ )ele*ho$e: J322 GKGG

(a3 Socie2! o1 +e#2er Au#2raliaI ho4e 2ha2 b! 4ur#ui " 2hi# ave ue= !ou are able 2o achieve a #a2i#1ac2or! re#olu2io . *our# #i cerel! la22 He 2 EN7(I'Y IN*ESTIGATING OFFI&E'

2/ Oc2ober 2011 Mr Ali Ammou Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o (oc@ed )a" 2 A()AN* +A ,331 Dear Mr Ammou NOTE TO &OMMISSION I2 3ould be ece##ar! 1or !ou 2o 4rovide 1ur2her i 1orma2io 2o 2he Commi##io I re1er 2o 2he !ello3 #2ic@er !ou #e 2 2o 2he Commi##io re;ue#2i " 2o #ee #omeo e 1rom 2he CCC. be1ore 3e are able 2o decide ho3 3e ma! be able 2o a##i#2 !ou. I have e clo#ed a com4lai 2 1orm 1or !ou 2o com4le2e 3hich I ho4e 3ill hel4 !ou i 4rovidi " 2he addi2io al i 1orma2io 2he Commi##io re;uire#. *our# 1ai2h1ull!

I1

!ou have a ! di11icul2! com4le2i " 2hi# 1orm= 4lea#e 2ele4ho e 2he Commi##io o J21/B:KKK= a d a#@ 2o #4ea@ 3i2h a o11icer 3ho ca a##i#2 !ou i ma@i " a com4lai 2.I have e c o#ed 1ur2her de2ail# abou2 2he#e #ervice# 1or !our i 1orma2io . I1 !ou have i 1orma2io a ! ;ue#2io # abou2 2hi# le22er or i1 !ou 3ould li@e 2o 4rovide more 1or 2he Commi##io 2o co #ider= 4lea#e co 2ac2 me o 1300 ,/, :1J. *our#= #i cerel!= )aile! Com4lai 2 Com4lai 2# 1orma2io O11icer Aa dli " Sec2io .

1:2h Ma! 2012 EDITH COWAN ?00NDA(UP CAMPUS 2G0 ?oo dalu4 Drive= ?oo c +e#2er Au#2ralia ,02G Pho e 13:32K <ac#imile 6,1 K9J300 12/G Ali Ammou &8I&%S I)& %%"9!: )u bur! Re"io al Pri#o PO )oI ::: )u bur! +A ,230 Dear Mr Ammou =

Tha @ !ou 1or re2ur i " 2he A**l"c!t"o$ +or# a d 2he Ac,$o-le./e#e$t of 0$.er&t!$."$/ 1 2ele!&e of I$for#!t"o$ Author"t%.

*our# #i cerel!= +e 3ill 3ri2e 2o !ou a"ai o ce !our a44lica2io ha# bee revie3ed b! 2he EIecu2ive. Plea#e be a3are 2ha2 2hi# ma! 2a@e #ome co #iderable 2ime. Associa0e )rofessor )a+ela 8enr; Direc0or Sellen2er &en0re &ri+inal <-s0ice 'e1ie= )rojec0

LEGAL AID ABN 96 166 412 580 PERTH 55 St George’s Terrace Perth WA GPO Bo 1!916 Perth WA 6842 Te"e#ho$e% &08' 9261 6222 (acs)*)"e% &08' 9+25 54+0 ,,,!"ega"a)-!,a!go.!a/ 0N(O10NE% 1+00 650 529

TO%

Wester$ A/stra")a

PERTH 12 3a4 2012

RE(ERTO%

3r A") Rach)- A**o/$ 567 B/$8/r4 Pr)so$ Po Bo 444 B/$8/r4 WA 62+0 Assessor 9W o$ &08' 9261 65+0 for (e/!l A". 3uer"e& o$l% RE(% 22414 O:R RE(%12W00522+

;ear 3r A**o/$ RE<:EST (OR 1EGA1 REPRESENTAT0ON RE(:SE; :$=ort/$ate"4 "ega" a)- has 8ee$ re=/se- )$ re"at)o$ to Other O==e$ces 7 5r)*e! 0 $ote that a gra$t o= a)- has #re.)o/s"4 8ee$ #ro.)-e- =or the #/r#oses o= a##ea")$g 4o/r co$.)ct)o$ a$- se$te$ce! As s/ch a =/rther gra$t =or a$- a##ea" has 8ee$ re=/se-! 1 =/rther $ote that the )ss/e o= a$ )$ter#reter ,as ra)se- at that t)*e a$- )t ,as -eter*)$e- that there ,as $o gro/$-s =or a##ea" o$ th)s 8as)s! 1ega" a)- has 8ee$ re=/se- 8eca/se 1ega" A)- WA has $/*ero/s co*#et)$g )$terests =or )ts "ega" a)- reso/rces a$- 0 a* $ot sat)s=)e- that the *atter =or ,h)ch 4o/ see> a gra$t o= a)- )s a$ a##ro#r)ate e #e$-)t/re o= #/8")c "ega" a)- =/$-s! Note% 0= 4o/ are $ot sat)s=)e- ,)th th)s -ec)s)o$ a$- ,o/"- ")>e *e to reco$s)-er )t? 4o/ */st ,r)te to *e ,)th)$ 28 -a4s o= the -ate o= th)s "etter! P"ease *a>e s/re a$4 =/rther )$=or*at)o$ 4o/ ,a$t *e to co$s)-er )s )$c"/-e-! 0= see>)$g reco$s)-erat)o$ o= th)s -ec)s)o$? #"ease #ro.)-e =/"" -eta)"s o= ,hat has cha$ge- )$ re"at)o$ to th)s *atter s)$ce 4o/r #re.)o/s gra$t o= a)- =or a$ a##ea" ,as

@o/rs s)$cere"4

e te$-e- to 4o/!

;0RE5TOR O( 1EGA1 A0;

Au#2ralia Auma Ri"h2# Commi##io e4er%o$e5 e4er%-here5 e4er%.!%

Our re1> E)F2010012F<D 1G November 2011 Mr Ali Rachid Ammou Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o (oc@ed )a" 2 A()AN* +A ,331 Dear Mr Ammou = I re1er 2o !our le22er received 1: November 2011= re"ardi " !our curre 2 #i2ua2io . *ou #a! !ou have bee 3ro "l! co vic2ed o1 a22em42ed murder. *ou #a! !ou 3ould li@e a##i#2a ce i order 2o a44eal 2hi# deci#io . O-r la=s: The Au#2ralia Auma Ri"h2# Commi##io ha# 2he 4o3er 2o i ve#2i"a2e a d co cilia2e com4lai 2# abou2> L di#crimi a2io becau#e o1 a 4er#o 8# race= #eI= 4re" a c!= mari2al #2a2u#= a"e or di#abili2! a# 3ell a# #eIual hara##me 2 i #4eci1ic area# o1 4ublic li1e= #uch a# em4lo!me 2= educa2io = 4rovidi " !ou 3i2h "ood# a d #ervice# a d accommoda2io M racial ha2red 2ha2 2a@e# 4lace i 4ublicM di#crimi a2io i em4lo!me 2 becau#e o1 a 4er#o N# crimi al record= #eIual 4re1ere ce= 2rade u io ac2ivi2!= reli"io = 4oli2ical o4i io or #ocial ori"i M or breache# o1 huma ri"h2# b! 2he Commo 3eal2h o1 Au#2ralia.

L L L

)a#ed o 2he i 1orma2io !ou have 4rovided 2o 2he Commi##io i2 doe# o2 a44ear 2ha2 2he Com4lai 2 Aa dli " Sec2io ca a##i#2 !ou a# !ou do o2 a44ear 2o be rai#i " co cer # 2ha2 ca be co #idered u der our la3#. I2 a44ear# !ou are #ee@i " le"al a##i#2a ce a cour2 a44eal. The Commi##io 8# Com4lai 2 Aa dli " Sec2io ca o2 4rovide !ou 3i2h le"al advice or le"al a##i#2a ce. 'eferrals: &D>T Or?6@ con n *ou ma! 3i#h 2o "e2 #ome le"al advice or a##i#2a ce 1rom (e"al Aid +e#2er Au#2ralia o 1300 ,/0 /GJ or a commu i2! le"al ce 2re 2o di#cu## !our o42io #.

Au#2ralia Auma Ri"h2#(evel

3

Treas-rerA A00orne; General Our Re1>3/B1GJ0G

Mr A Ammou Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o A()AN* +A ,330

Tha @ !ou 1or !our le22er received i 2hi# o11ice o 10 November 2011 re"ardi " !our re;ue#2 1or a##i#2a ce 2o have !our co vic2io over2ur ed. I have o2ed 2he ma22er# i !our le22er. Ao3ever= i2 i# o2 4o##ible or i# i2 a44ro4ria2e 1or me a# 2he A22or e! Ee eral or a ! Eover me 2 Mi i#2er 2o become i volved i 4riva2e le"al ma22er#. There1ore= ma! I #u""e#2 2ha2 !ou ma@e arra "eme 2# 2o co 2ac2 (e"al Aid +e#2er Au#2ralia o 2ele4ho e> 1300 ,/0 /GJ. *our# #i cerel!

Ao C. Chri#2ia TREASURERM EENERA(

Por2er M(A ATTORNE*

3 " DE& "%11

(evel G1 CraFamor

cB O+,-.s+an /es0ern A-s0ralia Servi " Parliame 2 B Servi " +e#2er Au#2ralia # 1 ail6/5ombud#ma . 3a.;ov.au 1: November 2011 Mr Ali Ammou Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o (oc@ed )a" No. 2 A()AN* +A ,331 Dear Mr Ammou I am 3ri2i " 2o ac@ o3led"e recei42 o1 !our le22er received i 2hi# o11ice o 11 November 2011 #ee@i " a i ve#2i"a2io b! 2he Ombud#ma i 2o a com4lai 2 !ou have made. +e 3ill co 2ac2 !ou a"ai #hor2l! 3he 3e have had 2he o44or2u i2! 2o co #ider !our com4lai 2. *our# #i cerel! I 2he mea 2ime= 2ha @ !ou 1or bri "i " !our co cer # 2o 2he a22e 2io Ombud#ma . De i#e Aoc2or A>A.+inis0ra0i1e Assis0an0 Access an. 'esol-0io o1 2he

n1ST March 2012

EDITH COWAN ?OONDA(UP CAMPUS Ali Ammou Alba ! Re"io al Pri#o (oc@ed )a" 2 A()AN* +A ,331

2G0 /:3,1 ?oo :K/3,1 dalu4 Drive= ?oor +e#2er Au#2ralia ,02G Pho e 13: 32K <ac#imile 6,1 K9J300 12/G A)N &'I&%SI)& %%"1!: Dear Mr Ammou =

Tha @ !ou 1or !our corre#4o de ce da2ed 2J2h <ebruar! 2012. The Crimi al ?u#2ice Revie3 Pro5ec2 2rie# 2o a##i#2 co vic2ed 4eo4le 3ho are i oce 2.

(a3!er#= academic# a d #2ude 2# o1 Edi2h Co3a U iver#i2! (a3 School i ve#2i"a2e claim# o1 3ro "1ul co vic2io a d= 3here 4o##ible= aim 2o 1ree i oce 2 4eo4le. The Selle "er Ce 2re C?RP 3ill ormall! co #ider re;ue#2# 1rom a44lica 2# 2o revie3 a ca#e 3he co vic2io ha# occurred= 2he a44eal 4eriod ha# eI4ired a d DNA 2e#2i " or o2her 4rocedure# ma! 4rovide e3 evide ce 2ha2 lead# 2o eIo era2io . The Selle "er Ce 2re C?RP 3ill $ot !/ree 2o revie3 re;ue#2# 1rom a44lica 2# 3he eIo era2io 3ould eve 2ua2e becau#e o1 2ech icali2! a# o44o#ed 2o 1ac2ual i oce ce. 2he

I1 !ou 3ould li@e a deci#io o 3he2her !our ca#e 1all# 3i2hi 2he Pro5ec2N# "uideli e#= 4lea#e com4le2e a d re2ur 2he e clo#ed A44lica2io <orm. The 4er#o claimi " 3ro "1ul co vic2io mu#2 al#o #i" a d re2ur 2he e clo#ed Ac,$o-le./#e$t of 0$.er&t!$."$/ 1 2ele!&e of I$for#!t"o$ Author"t% +or#. I1 2he Pro5ec2 o11er# 2o hel4 !ou= i0 =ill no0 ac0 as ;o-r solici0or or @a=;er@ Thi# mea # 2ha2 3e do o2 4rovide le"al advice a d a ! docume 2a2io or i 1orma2io 2ha2 !ou 4rovide 3ill o2 a22rac2 le"al 4ro1e##io al 4rivile"e. )ecau#e o1 our limi2ed bud"e2= 3e ca o2 4a! 1or DNA 2e#2#. I1 !our ma22er re;uire# DNA 2e#2i " o1 evide ce= !ou or #omeo e el#e o !our behal1 3ill eed 2o 4a! 1or 2hi#. A 2!4ical DNA 2e#2 ca co#2 be23ee O2=000 a d O/=000. *ou al#o eed 2o be a3are 2ha2 al2hou"h DNA 2e#2 re#ul2# ca 4rovide #2ro " evide ce o1 o eN# i oce ce= 2he! ca al#o 4rovide 4roo1 o1 o eN# "uil2. I1 DNA 2e#2# are 4er1ormed i !our ca#e a d 2he! 1ail 2o eIclude !ou a# 2he 4er4e2ra2or o1 2he crime= 2he addi2io al evide ce crea2ed ma! harm 2he ou2come o1 a ! 1u2ure a44eal or a44lica2io 1or 4ardo a d ma! have e"a2ive co #e;ue ce# 1or !ou i o2her 3a!#. <or 2he#e rea#o # 3e e coura"e !ou 2o evalua2e !our 4ro#4ec2# ho e#2l! be1ore !ou decide 2o com4le2e

2he e clo#ed A**l"c!t"o$ +or#. A# 2he la3 curre 2l! #2a d#= 2here i# o le"al ri"h2 2o acce## DNA evide ce or 2o i #i#2 o DNA 2e#2i ". I1 a a al!#i# o1 !our ca#e #u""e#2# 2ha2 releva 2 ma2erial could be #ub5ec2ed 2o DNA 2e#2i "= 3e ma! #ee@ acce## 2o 2he ma2erial 2o have DNA i oce ce 2e#2# u der2a@e or 4lace !our ma22er o hold u 2il 2he la3 cha "e# 2o allo3 1or DNA 2e#2i ". Ao3ever= 3e ca o2 "uara 2ee 2ha2 2he#e e11or2# 3ill be #ucce##1ul. )u2= i1 3e are #ucce##1ul i arra "i "

DNA i oce ce 2e#2i " a d 2he Pro5ec2 de2ermi e# 2ha2 2he re#ul2i " evide ce ma! lead 2o !our eIo era2io = la3!er# 3ill be brie1ed 2o co #ider 2he 4o##ibili2! o1 a a44eal or 4ardo . )lease ,e a=are6 ho=e1er6 0ha0 =e .o no0 pro+ise 0o achie1e ;o-r eConera0ion or release@ Eive 2he Pro5ec2N# limi2ed re#ource#= 2he lar"e umber o1 a44lica2io # i2 receive#= a d i2# #2ric2 "uideli e#= ma ! ca#e# 3ill o2 be acce42ed. +e 3ill advi#e !ou a# #oo a# 4o##ible i1 !our ca#e ca o2 be acce42ed or i ve#2i"a2ed. )u2 4lea#e o2e 2ha2 1or le"al a d re#ource rea#o # 3e do o2 ormall! 4rovide rea#o # 1or decidi " o2 2o i ve#2i"a2e ca#e# or 1or 2ermi a2i " eIi#2i " i ve#2i"a2io #. Plea#e be a3are 2ha2 !our ca#e ma! 3ai2 1or a lo " 2ime be1ore a 2eam o1 #2ude 2# become available 2o revie3 i2. Al#o= i1 a ca#e i# acce42ed= 2he i ve#2i"a2io ma! 2a@e !ear#. I2 i# al#o 4o##ible 2ha2= de#4i2e care1ul i ve#2i"a2io = 2he Pro5ec2 3ill o2 be able 2o u cover evide ce o1 i oce ce. O ce !ou have #ubmi22ed 2he 23o 1orm# 3e 3ill evalua2e !our a44lica2io . Ao3ever= 2here i# li@el! 2o be a dela! be1ore !ou hear 1rom our o11ice. Plea#e do o2 2ele4ho e 2he Pro5ec2 or 3ri2e addi2io al le22er# duri " 2hi# 2ime.

*our# #i cerel!=

Sellen2er &en0re &ri+inal <-s0ice 'e1ie= )rojec0

I 2erm# o1 !our reli"iou# co cer #= i2 i# o4e 2o !ou 2o co 2ac2 2he ED-al Oppor0-ni0; &o++ission /A 2o 1i d ou2 i1 i2 ma! have broader covera"e o1 2hi# i##ue. I have e clo#ed i2# co 2ac2 de2ail#. I1 !ou have o2 do e #o= !ou ca al#o co 2ac2 Le2al Ai. /A or !our eare#2 co++-ni0; le2al cen0re or a pro ,ono le2al sche+e 2o di#cu## !our o42io #. I have e clo#ed co 2ac2 de2ail#. (a i +e#2co22 Com4lai 2 I 1orma2io O11icer

I1 !ou have a ! ;ue#2io # abou2 2hi# le22er= 4lea#e co 2ac2 2he Commi##io o 1300 ,/, :1J or 02 J2K: J,00.A-s0ralian 8-+an 'i2h0s &o++ission Our Re1> 2013B0122G 30 ?a uar! 2013 Mr Ali Ammou Acacia Pri#o (oc@ed )a" 1 +OORO(OO +A ,//K

Dear Mr Ammou I re1er 2o !our rece 2 le22er re"ardi " !our 2rea2me 2 a2 Acacia Pri#o . The Au#2ralia Auma Ri"h2# Commi##io ha# 2he 4o3er 2o i ve#2i"a2e a d co cilia2e com4lai 2# abou2> L di#crimi a2io becau#e o1 a 4er#o 8# race= #eI= 4re" a c!= mari2al #2a2u#= a"e or di#abili2! a# 3ell a# #eIual hara##me 2 i #4eci1ic area# o1 4ublic li1e= #uch a#= em4lo!me 2= educa2io = 4rovidi " !ou 3i2h "ood# a d #ervice# a d accommoda2io M racial ha2red 2ha2 2a@e# 4lace i 4ublicM di#crimi a2io i em4lo!me 2 becau#e o1 a 4er#o 8# crimi al record= #eIual 4re1ere ce= 2rade u io ac2ivi2!= reli"io = 4oli2ical o4i io or #ocial ori"i M or breache# o1 huma ri"h2# b! 2he Commo 3eal2h o1 Au#2ralia.

L L L

<rom 2he i 1orma2io !ou have 4rovided #o 1ar= i2 i# o2 clear 2ha2 2he Commi##io 8# I ve#2i"a2io a d Co cilia2io Service ca hel4 3i2h 2hi# ma22er. Plea#e o2e= i 2erm# o1 reli"iou# di#crimi a2io = 3e ca o l! co #ider claim# o1 reli"iou# di#crimi a2io i em4lo!me 2 or 3he 2he claim o1 reli"iou# di#crimi a2io i# a"ai #2 2he Commo 3eal2h 6<ederal9 Eover me 2. Plea#e o2e= i 2erm# o1 huma ri"h2#= 3e ca o l! co #ider claim# o1 huma ri"h2# breache# a"ai #2 2he Commo 3eal2h or o e o1 i2# a"e 2#. I1 !ou are de2ai ed u der a <ederal la3= i2 i# 4o##ible 3e ma! be able 2o a##i#2. Plea#e advi#e 2he Commi##io i1 !ou are de2ai ed u der <ederal la3. I2 i# o4e 2o !ou 2o co 2ac2 2he /es0ern A-s0ralian 4/A5 O+,-.s+an abou2 !our co cer # a# i2 ca co #ider co cer # abou2 2he admi i#2ra2ive ac2io # o1 +A "over me 2 bodie#= i cludi " correc2io al ce 2re#. I have e clo#ed i2# co 2ac2 de2ail#. Au#2ralia Auma Ri"h2# Commi##io ARM A' OPQ OOO c (evel 3 1G/ Pi22 S2ree2 EPO )oI /21K S!d ev NS+ 2001 Ee eral e ;uirie# &n+nlnln+n 1300 3,J G11

f LAs 4 &8*5 I STATES

I 3)che""e (AR3ER 2@

0 a* c/rre$t"4 +9 4ears o= age a$- a* e*#"o4e- as a Para*e-)c =or St Aoh$ A*8/"a$ce Ser.)ce! 0 a* stat)o$e- at the 5oc>8/* ;e#ot! 34 ser.)ce $/*8er 699! O$ S/$-a4 the 21st o= Aa$/ar4 2002 0 ,as ,or>)$g a $)ghtsh)=t! 34 ho/rs o= -/t4 ,ere =ro* 6%00#* to 8%00a*! 0 ,as ,or>)$g ,)th *4 #er*a$e$t #art$er? He$r4> 3)chae" S0EN90E W05B! +! 4! 5! ,@ At a8o/t 11%19#* that $)ght ,h)"st at the -e#ot ,e rece).e- a ca"" to atte$- at 4 Ste)$8ec> P"ace S#ear,oo-! We -e#arte- the -e#ot a$- arr).e- at that a--ress at 11%+0#* O$ arr).a" at the co*er o= Ste)$8ec> a$- Barratt Street ,e ,ere *et 84 a "a-4 ,ho to"/s that the ,orst #at)e$t ,as at 10 Barratt Street! She #o)$te- )$ the -)rect)o$! We -ro.e the A*8/"a$ce )$to the -r).e,a4 o= 10 Barratt Street! 2! The #eo#"e at that a--ress -)recte- /s to the .era$-ah o= that ho/se! 0 sa, a =e*a"e at the =ar e$- o= the .era$-ah! She ,as "4)$g o$ her "e=t s)-e! She ,as co.ere- )$ 8"oo- a$- -resse- )$ a 8"/e co"o/re- sh)rt a$- #a"e co"o/re>$)c>ers! She ,as co$sc)o/s a$- >e#t sa4)$g her h/s8a$- hatr)e- to >)"" her!

State*e$t o= 3)che""e (AR3ER &co$t)$/e-' J. 10@ 11@ 12@ 1+! 14! 0 $ot)ce- there ,as ora$ge4 8ro,$ co"o/re- ro#e $ear her! 0t ,as )$ se.era" #)eces a$- )t "oo>e- *ore ")>e horse ha)r tha$ ro#e! 0 >$e, )t ,as ro#e 8/t )t C/st a##eare- coarse! 0 a"so o8ser.e- a #a)r o= sc)ssors o$ the 8a"/stra-e! 0 as>e- a "a-4 ,ho ,as sta$-)$g $ear84 a8o/t the sc)ssors 8eca/se 0 -)-$’t >$o, )= the4 ,ere /se- 84 a$ o==e$-er a$- ,hether he or she *a4 ha.e 8ee$ $ear84! The "a-4 e #"a)$e- the4 ,ere /se- 84 the* to c/t the ro#e =ro* the "a-)es ar*s! 0 as>e- the #at)e$t? DHo, -)- 4o/ get hereEF She sa)-? D0 esca#e-! 0 ,as a8"e to r/$ -o,$ here a$- >$oc> o$ the -oor!F The other "a-4 sa)-? D0 hear- her 8ash)$g o$ the -oor? ca*e o/t a$sa, her o$ the .era$-ah!F 0 a"so o8ser.e- a 8ra t)e- aro/$- the "a-)es $ec>! 0 re*o.e- the 8ra =ro* aro/$- her $ec> 8eca/se )t a##eare- to 8e =a)r"4 t)ght a$- co/"- co*#ro*)se her a)r,a4! 0 tr)e- to /$t)e the 8ra 8/t )t ,as too t)ght! 0 too> aG#a)rGo= sc)ssors =ro* a 8ag 0 ha,)th *e a$- c/t the 8ra! 0 ca$’t reca"" e act"4 ,here o$ the 8ra 0 c/t 8/t 0! -o re*e*8er c/tt)$g )t =ro* the =ro$t r)ght s)-e o= her $ec>!

15! State*e$t o= 3)che""e (AR3ER &co$t)$/e-'

2+!

State*e$t o= 3)che""e (AR3ER &co$t)$/e-'

0 #ee"e- the 8ra 8ac> a$- )t =e"" to the gro/$-! 8eh)$- her! 16! 12! 0 chec>e- a"" her .)ta" s)g$s a$- she a##earea"" o>a4! 18! 0 -ec)-e- 0 $ee- to get the stretcher to ass)st the "a-4! 19! He$r4 ha- go$e 84 that stage 8eca/se there ,as a##are$t"4 a$other "a-4 that $ee-e- so*e he"#! 20@ 0 ,e$t a$- got the stretcher =ro* the A*8/"a$ce a$- set )t /# o$ the -r).e,a4 $e t to the A*8/"a$ce! 0 ,a$te- the "a-4 to ,a"> -o,$ the sta)rs herse"= as she a##eare- a8"e to -o so! 21@ 0 $ot)ce- He$r4 ha- ret/r$e- to the A*8/"a$ce ,)th a$other "a-4! He sat her -o,$ o$ a 8r)c> ,a""! 22@ He$r4 a$- 0 ha- a H/)c> co$.ersat)o$ )$ regar-s to the co$-)t)o$ o= the t,o "a-)es! ;/r)$g th)s co$.ersat)o$ ,e ,ere )$terr/#te84 a #o")ce*a$ ,ho to"- /s there ,as a$other #erso$ /$co$sc)o/s at the 8ac> o= the ho/se at 4 Ste)$8ec> P"ace!

State*e$t o= 3)che""e (AR3ER &co$t)$/e-'

0 as>e- h)* so*e H/)c> H/est)o$s )$ regar-s to the #erso$ he to"- *e a8o/t! He )$-)cate- to *e that th)s #erso$ ,as the o==e$-er! 0 -ec)-eto go a$- ha.e a "oo> at the #erso$ he to"- *e a8o/t C/st to 8e s/re a8o/t h)s co$-)t)o$!0 ,a">e- ,)th the #o")ce*a$ to the rear o= 4 Ste)$8ec> P"ace! He -)recte- *e thro/gh the =ro$t 4ar- a$- /# the r)ght ha$- s)-e o= the ho/se a"o$g the #a.e*e$t! Whe$ 0 got to the rear of the ho/se 0 sa, a *a"e "4)$g o$ h)s r)ght s)-e! He ,as$’t *o.)$g a$- -)-$’t a##ear to ha.e a$4 )$C/r)es! 0 assesse- h)* a$- $ot)ce- he ,as 8reath)$g a$- ha- a #/"se! 0 sH/eeIe- h)s tra#eI)/s */sc"e to get a react)o$! He -)-$’t res#o$-! 0 the$ sH/eeIe- h)s "e=t ear "o8e a$st)"" -)-$’t get a react)o$! 0 ,as co$sta$t"4 ta">)$g to h)* 8/t he ,as$’t res#o$-)$g to that e)ther! 0 tr)e- to ro"" h)* to,ar- *e 8/t 0 co/"har-"4 *o.e h)*! 0 "ea$e- o.er h)* a$=")c>e- h)s e4e")-s! 0 $ot)ce- h)s e4es ,ere =oc/se- a$- he a##eare- to 8e co$sc)o/s! 0 >$e, the$ he ,as a"r)ght! 0 tho/ght he ,as #"a4)$g ,)th *e a$- ,as #rete$-)$g to 8e /$co$sc)o/s! 0 >$e, there ,as a$other A*8/"a$ce o$ )ts ,a4 so 0 -ec)-e- to "ea.e the *a"e at that s#ot ,)th the #o")ce a$- 0 ret/r$e- to the A*8/"a$ce a$- the t,o =e*a"e #at)e$ts! 0 $ot)ce- He$r4 ha- ta>e$ so*e o 4ge$ to *4 #at)e$t o$ the .era$-ah! 0 ,a">e- /# to the* 8oth a$- together? ,e he"#e- her to her =eet a$- ass)ste- her -o,$ the sta)rs to the stretcher! She got o$to the stretcher!

State*e$t o= 3)che""e (AR3ER &co$t)$/e-'

0 he"#e- "oaState*e$t o= 3)che""e (AR3ER &co$t)$/e-' her )$to the A*8/"a$ce!+0! 0 ,e$t o.er to the other "a-4 a$- he"#e- He$r4 , 8e=ore #/tt)$g her )$ the A*8/"a$ce as ,e""!

a##eare- shoc>e- a$- st/$$e-! 0 he"#e- He$r4 c

+1! EJH0B0T

We e$-e- /# ta>)$g the t,o =e*a"es to the (re*a$

=or =/rther treat*e$t! O$ the ,a4 to hos#)ta" 0 as #ro-/ce those $otes as e.)-e$ce! +2!

=e*a"es a$- *a-e $otes )$ re"at)o$ to the)r )$C/

Wh)"st at the hos#)ta" 0 s#o>e ,)th a$ o"-er #o" ,o*a$?

,as there a$- 0 to"- h)* a8o/t the 8ra 0 ha- ta>

++! +4!

He e$-e- /# r)$g)$g so*eo$e a8o/t the 8ra!

0 -ec"are that th)s state*e$t )s tr/e to the 8

>$o,"e-ge a$- 8e")e= a$- 0 that 0 ha.e *a-e th

>$o,)$g that )= )t )s te$-ere- )$ e.)-e$ce 0 ,)"" 8

cr)*e )= 0 ha.e ,)"=/""4 )$c"/-e- )$ th)s state*e S)g$e- 2GJ 6c f75

,h)ch 0 >$o, to 8e =a"se or that 0 -o $ot 8e")e.e to

W)t$esse- at -cKc97>E/ 99 L477' O$L72!7oMF 0SOO:0A B4 Ra$> Reg 3 ) 1 S

F /ZJ% N

1

&$F0 'BA& 7

8^J9: A.ele D(EAM) STATES

1@

I a+ $1 ;ears of a2e an. li1e a0 an a..ress Fre+an0le Depar0+en0@ Fno=n 0o )olice@ I a+ e+plo;e. as a &linical N-rse a0 8ospi0al E+er2enc;

"@

On Mon.a; "" <an-ar; "%%9 I =as on .-0; a0 0he Fre+an0le 8ospi0al E+er2enc; Depar0+en0@

I
,@

G@

M; shif0 s0ar0e. a0 "1@%%hrs on "1 <an-ar; "%%9 an. finishe. a0 %9@G%hrs on 0he "" <an-ar; "%%9@

$@

A0 a,o-0 %%@G%hrs I assis0e. Hin 0he 0rea0+en0 of a pa0ien0 na+e. Tan;a <o;

There =as a lar2e a+o-n0 of ,loo. on AMMO(NHs clo0hin2@ i re+o1e. AMMO(NHs clo0hin26 =hich consis0e. of a p-rple j-+per6 a =hi0e T3 shir0 an. a ,ra@ A0 0his 0i+e she =as no0@ =earin2 an; clo0hin2 ,elo= 0he =ais0@ . . 2Rl OiB4T 2

I

AMMO(N an. 0his incl-.e. helpin2 0o -n.ress her@ #@ 3

Firs0 &lass &ons0a,le LAMONT an.

9@

S0a0e+en0 of A.ele D(EAM) 4&on0in-e.5 &ons0a,le 'ADE' =ere a0 0he 8ospi0al =i0h AMMO(N6 al0ho-2h 0he; =ere no0 presen0 in 0he c-,icle =hen I -n.resse. AMMO(N an. ,a22e. her clo0hin2@!@ 1%@ 11@ 1"@ The ,ra =as 0ie. fir+l; aro-n. AMM7(NIs oecF@ ai0ho-a, i0 =as no0 i+pairin2 her ,rea0hin2@ AMMO(NHs hair ha. ,eco+e en0an2le. in 0he Fno0 =hich =as posi0ione. on 0he lef0 si.e of her necF@ I .i. no0 =an0 0o -n0ie 0he Fno0 as I =as +in.f-l of 0he Fno0Hs e1i.en0ial 1al-e@ I 0herefore c-0 one of 0he si.e s0raps@ I also ha. 0o c-0 so+e of AMMO(NHs hair <o separa0e i0 fro+ 0he Fno0@ I place. 0he G i0e+s of clo0hin2 in separa0e ,l-e plas0ic hospi0al ,a2s an. 0hen in 0o 0hree ,ro=n paper ,a2s6 =hich =ere pro1i.e. ,; 0he )olice@ I 0hen carrie. 0he ,a2s 0o 0he N-rsesH S0a0ion =here I han.e. 0he+ 0o 0he a,o1e +en0ione. &ons0a,les6 =ho 0ooF possession of 0he+@ A0 a,o-0 %#@%%hrs on "" <an-ar; "%%9 I =as presen0 =hen Senior &ons0a,le MO'ELLINI a00en.e. 0he E+er2enc; Depar0+en0 an. 0ooF possession of 0he ,a2s con0ainin2 0he clo0hes fro+ 0he N-rsesH S0a0ion area@ I =as a=are 0ha0 0here =as ano0her fe+ale =ho ha. apparen0l; ,een in1ol1e. in 0he sa+e inci.en06 presen0 in 0he E+er2enc; Depar0+en0 0ha0 ni2h0@ !

S0a0e+en0 of A.ele D(EAM) 4&on0in-e.5

S0a0e+en0 of A.ele D(EAM) 4&on0in-e.5

I can s0a0e ca0e2oricall; 0ha0 I .i. no0 ha1e an; con0ac0 =ha0soe1er =i0h 0he o0her fe+ale or her clo0hin26 prior 0o AMMO(NIs clo0hin2 ha1in2 ,een re+o1e. an. ,a22e.@ Si2ne. I .eclare 0ha0 0his s0a0e+en0 is 0r-e 0o 0he ,es0 of +; Fno=le.2e an. ,elief an. 0ha0 I ha1e +a.e 0his s0a0e+en0 Fno=in2 0ha0 if i0 is 0en.ere. in e1i.ence I =ill ,e 2-il0; of a cri+e if I ha1e =ilf-ll; incl-.e. in 0his s0a0e+en0 an;0hin2 =hich I Fno= 0o ,e false or 0ha0 I .o no0 ,elie1e 0o ,e 0r-e@

/i0nesse. a0 On $. :;J

Page + o= +

'anFFranF Al,an MLA ril 2013 Member for Swan Hills Swan Hills includes: A.e"e4 li Ammou ia Pri#o ed )a" 1 9RO(OO +A ,//K Ba)"/# Mr Ammou @ !ou 1or !our le22er da2ed 2G March 2013 2o"e2her 3i2h 2he e clo#ure. 2he co 2e 2# o1 !our le22er a d 2he re#4o #e 1rom (e"al Aid o1 +A a d u2 a ! i 1orma2io a# 2o !our i##ue#= I am o l! i 2he 4o#i2io = havi " o eI4er2i#e or au2hori2!= 2o advi#e !ou 2o co 2ac2 2he releva 2 Mi i#2er#8 i#. i2 re"ard I 3ould re1er !ou 2o> Ao M Mi#chi (() 6Ao #9 )?uri# 6Ao #9 M(C A22or e! Ee eral 102h <loor= Duma# Aou#e 2 Aaveloc@ S2ree2 +e#2 Per2h +A ,00/ a d Ao ? M <ra ci# M(A Mi i#2er 1or Correc2ive Service# 102h <loor= (o do Aou#e 21, S2 Eeor"eN# Terrace Per2h +A ,00 Id al#o advi#e !ou 2o co 2ac2 2he la3!er 3ho ac2ed 1or !ou i !our crimi al ir 3ho ma!be i a be22er 4o#i2io 2o a##i#2 !ou. Bas>er.)""e Beech)$a Be"h/s Br)ga-oo$ B/""s8roo> 5h)-"o, E""e$8roo> G)-gega$$/# G"e$ (orrest Gorr)e He*e H)"" Ho.ea 3ahoga$4 5ree> 3a"*a"")$g 3)--"e S,a$

Page + o= +

3)""e$-o$ 3o/$t He"e$a 3/$-ar)$g Par>er.)""e Sa,4ers Na""e4 Sto$e.)""e The N)$es :##er S,a$ Wooro"oo rd# K Al,an MLA ,er for S=an 8ills

Page + o= +

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful