Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CONFIDENTIAL
RenewalofpermissionforMBBScourse3rdBatchofAMCMET,Ahmedabad : Recognition U/S19COR NameofInstitution : AhmedabadMunicipalCorporationMedicalEducationTrustMedicalCollege Address : ShethL.G.HospitalCampus,Maninagar,Maninagar,Ahmedabad TelephoneNo : 07925461380 Email : ushavyas@yahoo.com Fax : 07925461384 Website : www.amcmet.edu.in&www.amcmet.com Management : AhmedabadMuncipalCorporationMedicalEducationTrust Applicant'sRegn.No. : No.Guj/14185/Ahmedabaddated5thJuly,2008 AssessmentDate : 27th&28thJanuary,2011 LastAssessmentDate : 23rdand24thFebruary,2010 ParticularsofAssesors EmailAddress CorrespondenceAddress Name PhNo. 1.DrRavinderKumarBatra Professor, 26546470& rkbatra27@gmail.com DepartmentofAnaesthesiology, 25884158 AllIndiaInstituteofMedicalSciences,New Mobile Delhi110029 99911189053 2.DrRameshSavrdekar Professor&Head, DepartmentofForensicMedicine, LTMMC<GHSion,Mumbai22 Professor, DepartmentofPaediatrics, JIPMER,Pondicherry6 24076381/317 1Mobil 9892901030 23406600413 Mobile 9443320498
RRSavrdekar@gmail.com
3.DrS.Mahadevan
smaha1232@rediffmail.com
No.:Academic/21087/2008dt21.08.2008 : : GujaratUniversity Collegecode 497 Coursecode : 2009&2010 MCG1008SFS101Jdt27.08.2008 : : 150 Dateandnumberoflastannualadmissionwithdetails Category No.admitted Year 200910 201011 S.C. 8 9 S.T. 17 18 Backward 34 34 Merit 67 67 Management nil nil Others(NRI) 30 30 Total 150 150 : Inprocess,partlyfurnished Date:
71
Datesofadmission
Commence
21.07.2010 27.09.2009
End
27.09.2010 30.08.2009
AdministrativeBlock&Dean/ Principaloffice
27th&28thJanuary,2011
MinimumAttendanceand InternalAssessment
requiredis75%intheoryandpractical 20%oftotalmarksforthedifferentsubjectsareassignedforinternalassessment minimumof35%prescribedforappearingatUniversityexamination Theinstitutionconductspostgraduatecoursesasunder:Informedasnilbyauthorities, butpostgraduatestudentsareworkinginallthemajorspecialities.Notclearwhythe institutionhasbeenwithholdingthisinformation.ThisInstituteinthepasthasbeen assessed/inspectedforpostgraduatecourses. Itwasalsoinformedthatmostofthehospitalworkisdonebythesepostgraduatestudents. ThefirstbatchofMBBSstudenthasnotpassedouttilldate.andthisInstitutehasnotbeen shownasPostgraduateInstituteintheirwebsite.Itneedsclarification Degreecourses Number permitted Recognitionstatus Diplomacourses permitted Recognitionstatus
Course
Numberadmitted(lastyear)
(b)
Course
Numberadmitted(lastyear)
: No information available Facility for Biostatistical work is : availableintheDeptt.Of Nil : PharmacoVigilanceCommittee Members Examination Hall-cumExamHall Auditorium: (800 sq.mt.) Capacity:
Recordofactivitynil Auditoriumdoesnotexist
Notavailable Notavailable
Buildings
: Twoseparatebuilding.Collegeis10storeyedintheprocessofconstructionconeectedwitha oldLGHospital Number : 42491sq.mt Totalavailablefloorarea Areaofcollegeinsq.mt LocationofPre&ParaClinicalDeptts: Samebuildingondifferentfloors : 16861.3 HospitalArea : TotalareaofInpatient&outpatientofLGHospitalis25630sq.mt Area added since last : 2169.5 sq.mt Assessment(ifany) seventhfloor Are the staff facilities and : Yes spaceadequate(Y/N) Comments : Buildingisstillintheprocessofconstruction.Someoftheareasarestillbeingplannedand moved.
Lecture theatres
Number Capacity A.V.Aids LectureTheatresaspernorms : (Y/N) AvailableAVaidsaspernorms : (Y/N) College Four 180 RecentlyInstalled Hospital Nil Nil Nil
Noprovisionforemergencyexit Recentlyinstalled
Common room
Boys Girls : CapacityNilAreaNilsq.mt..Attachedtoilet:No : CapacityNilAreaNilsq.mt..Attachedtoilet:No
Central Library
: Availableaspernorms Available (Y/N) Thenumberofseatsavailableforthereadingroomsareasunder: Rooms Students Tworooms Interns/Residents One StaffMembers One Total Four : No.ofAvailablestaffinlibrary Librarian Workinghoursoflibrary BooksandJournalsavailableas pernorms No.ofcomputerterminals InternetFacilitiesAvailable One Others: One Deputy/AssistantLibrarian: : One : 9amto6pm : Notadequate.Informedtohave5000textbooks,butmajorityofthesebelongedtooldLG HospitalwithAccNoof1997.Backupvolumesofthejournalwerenotavailbale. : nil IfYes,no.ofstationsonwhichinternetfacilityisavailable: : No
a. b. c.
: Arrangementformaking Nil slides/photographyofpatients whereverrequired Centralphotographycum : NotAvailable. NotAvailable. audiovisualunits : 1P.H.C.s15kmsawayfromthecollege HealthCentres{i}3P.H.C's PHCJetalpurhasbeendevelopedasR.H.T.C. ItisunderthecontroloftheDepttofH&FW,GovtofGuajrat Studentsandinternsarepostedinbatchesof:nil NoSeparateblocksforaccommodatingboys&noroom&girlsareavailableinthehostel. Numberofbedsprovided:4forthepatients Thelabourroomhasonebedsandonetables. : Distanceof4km.fromthecollege. Populationcoveredunderstudyarea:Noinformationcouldbeprovided CivilHospital.Ahmedabad financiallyandadministrativelycontrolledby: NumberofBedsprovided:Four Outpatientattendanceisperday:approximately1400/month : Nonfunctional
{ii} U.H.C
CentralWorkshopavailable
Hostels
Furnished(Y/N) Mess(Y/N) Hostels Number Rooms Capacity Boys Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Girls one 43 88 basic Nil Residents Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nurses Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil : Notadequate : Girlshostellocatedwithincampus : Thehostelsdonothaveanymessfacilty.Thefoodissuppliedtothegirlstudentsandresident doctors(PG)in"dibba"fromCollegecanteen.
No
NameofHospital
No.ofTeachingbedsinHospital
NameofMed.Supdt. Qualification
: : : :
Distribution of beds
Speciality Medicine&AlliedSpecialities GeneralMedicine Paediatrics TB&Chest Skin&VD Psychiatry Total Surgery&AlliedSpecialities GeneralSurgery Orthopaedics Ophthalmology ENT Total Obstetrics&Gynaecology Obstetrics&ANC Gynaecology Total Total Present Beds/Units 102/3 60/2 10 4 4 180 102/3 80/1 14/1 14/1 150 50 40 90 420 Deficiency(ifany) Nilbutoccupancyislessthan50% Nil,butoccupancyislessthan70% Nilbutoccupancyislessthan50% Nil,butoccupancyislessthan50% Nil,butoccupancyislessthan30% Nil,butoccupanceyisinadequate Nil, Nil,Occupancyis50% Nil,Occupancyis50% Nil,Occupancyis50% Nil,Occupancyisinadequate Nil Nil Nil Nil
In Wards
Clinicaldemonstrationareas Capacity Comments : NotSufficient : NotSufficient : Onlyfewwardshadclinicaldemonstrationroomswhichwerecreatedonthedayof assessment.
Clinical Material
Deficiencies,ifany O.P.D.attendance Recordsaremaintainedproperly Inadequateforteachingpurposes Casualtyattendance Inadequateforteachingpurposes No.ofadmissions/discharge Inadequateforteachingpurposes Bedoccupancy% Operativework No.ofmajorsurgicaloperations Inadequateforteachingpurposes 31 34 No.ofminorsurgicaloperations Inadequateforteachingpurposes 22 30 Inadequateforteachingpurposes No.ofnormaldeliveries 9 4 Inadequateforteachingpurposes No.ofcaesarianSections 3 1 RadiologicalInvestigations O.P.+ O.P. Xray Inadequateforteachingpurposes I.P=200 I.P=210 Ultrasonography Inadequateforteachingpurposes Four Six SpecialInvestigations Inadequateforteachingpurposes one one C.T.Scan Notavailable notavailable Inadequateforteachingpurposes LaboratoryInvestigations Biochemistry Inadequateforteachingpurposes 21 11 Microbiology Inadequateforteachingpurposes 11 7 Serology Inadequateforteachingpurposes 7 7 Parasitology Inadequateforteachingpurposes 7 4 Haematology Inadequateforteachingpurposes 75 4 Histopathology Inadequateforteachingpurposes 8 20 Cytopathology Inadequateforteachingpurposes 7 nil Others Nil Comments : FacilitiesforMRI,CTscanarenotavailable.Theseareveryimportantforthishospitalfor teachingpurposes.TheInstitutionisonlydoingthebasicinvestigationsofaveragequality. Departmentallibrarydoesnotexist. RegistrationandMedical RecordsSection(Yes/No): Separateregistrationcounter forOPD/Indooravailable Aretheycomputerized/not computerized Adequatestaffavailable IsICDXClassificationof diseasesfollowedforindexing : Verypriliminary,notcomputerizedandinadequatereceptionarea.Dataisnotmaintainedfor thepatientsvisitinghospitalforfollowup. : Available : Not compterized Nil : : Nil Dayof DailyAverage Assessment 800 170+oldcases 35 20 39 96 55 60
: : FacilitiesareinadequateinemergencyOTbothforanaesthesiaandsurgicalservices.
Clinical Laboratories
UndercontrolofDeptt.Of : Individualdepartments Separatesectionsavailablefor : Pathology,Microbiology& Biochemistry Yes Technicalstaffavailable : Onlyskeletonstaffwaspresent
Distribution of OT
a) Major Department Obs&Gyn Surgery Ortho ENT No. of OT Two Two Two Two OnesepticOTinGeneralOTcomplex Availablebutinadequatefacilities In OPD Availablebutinadequatefacilities&workload In Casualty There is shortage of nurses and OT technicians (zero) Eye one
b) Minor Comments
Intensive care: The following intensive care areas are available:Noofpatients onthedayof Assessment Four Eight Nil Nil Nil Central Oxygen/ Suction Nosuction Nosuction Nil Nil Nil
No :
Labour room
No.ofLabourRoomsavailable (a)cleancases (b)septic (c)eclamsia Facilities&equipmentin labourroom : : 8 beds : 0 beds : 4 beds Inadequate:Uncleanlooking,rusty&oldequipment,nocentralsuction,Neonateresuscitation : cotnotfunctioning
Radiological facilities
No.&rangeofstaticunits available(inmA) No.andrangeofmobileunits available(inmA) Ultrasoundmachines Facilitiesforspecial investigations Comments 300mA=3, : 500mA=1 200mA=1 : 60mA=10 : Five Notavailable : : CTscanandMRIfacilitiesarenotavailable.Improperlysupervisedandmaintainedforteaching purposes.Teachingroomisalsonotproperlyorganized.
Blood Bank
Availableandfunctional Space&equipment Licensedupto : Yes : SpaeandequipmentInadequate : 12/31/2011,G/775dt20thAug,1992
Pharmacy
Intercom:
Available IfIntercomavailable : No : No.ofincoming&extensionlines:Nil
: Notavailablebutoutsourcedtoprivateagency :
Totalno.ofcanteens
Deputy Asstt.Nursing Sisters incharge Staffnurses : NursingSupdt. NursingSupdt. Supdt. Total one one one 37 229 269 NursingStaffisinadequate.ThereisasevereshortageinOPD,Wards,operationtheatreand : casuality. : ShortageofNurses.Inciniratornotavailableandnofacilityforoutsourcing.Teachingfacilities arenotthereinthehospital
Teaching staff & facilities in Pharmacology, Pathology, Microbiology & Forensic Medicine Department Comments : Spaceinallthedepartmentsisadequatebutparamedicalandnonteachingstaffisinadequate innumber.Teachingmaterialisinadequateandequipment,librarynotmaintaninedproperly.
: Notfunctional
General Remarks 1. Following teaching staff could not be counted due to reasons provided there under
Name 1.DrShitalShah 2.DrDeepakS.Joshi Designation Tutor Prof&Head Department Anatomy Pathology Remarks Absent Reportedon2nddayofInspection,original appointmentletternotshown,Copyofservice recordappearedtemperedwithdateof appointment. Absent,submittedadvocateletterforcourt appearanceon27thJan2010 PostMDteachingexperienceis7months PostMDteachingexperienceis2years PostMDteachingexperienceis7months PostMDteachingexperienceinadequate Absent Formsnotforwarded Formsnotforwarded Formsnotforwarded CouldnotproduceauthenticForm16.No evidenceofactivecontributiontohospital workload SeniorforthepostofAssociateProfessorBorn 1951),Heappearedon27.1.2011.Didnot appearon28.1.2011(showntobeexaminer). Noactivecontributiontotheclinicalloadof thedepartment PostPGteachingexperienceinadequate Absentandveryseniorborn1951 Absent NoevidenceofdrawingsalaryfromAMCMET Absent Noappropriatejoiningletter Inadequateteachingexperience PassedMSin2000,NoForm16 PassedDOin2007,wenttoGermanyfor fellowship.ProbablyinsomeotherInstitute NoAppointmentorder&Joiningletter Inadequateteachingexperience Documentssubmittedon27.1.2011 NoICard,Formsubmittedon27.1.2011 NoICard,NoJoiningletter OverageDOB1954 NoICard,NoJoiningletter OverageDOB1983 Namenotinthelist,Formsubmittedon 27.1.2011 NoJoiningletter,NoIcard,Formsubmittedon 27.1.2011,namenotinthelist FormsubmittedforProfSurgeryon27.1.11, holdingadministrativepost.Nocontributionto cliniclaworklaodofthedepartment NoForm16,Nojoiningreport NojoiningletterandForm16 Teachingexperienceinadequate
3.DrSunitaMGoswami 4.DrKoshikaShamji 5.DrSangeetaRathod 6.DrDarjiZalak 7.DrDharaKarelia 8.DrVikramBPatel 9.DrBhadraDShah 10.DrRajeshNPandya 11.DrRomeshNChaudhary 12.DrMukukIShah
AssociateProf AssistantProf AssistantProf AssistantProf AssistantProf Professor AssociateProf Professor AssistantProf Professor
Microbiology Medicine Medicine Medicine Medicine Radiology Dental Dental Dental Obs&Gynae
Dr.HarshadLadola
AssociateProf Obs&Gynae
AssistantProf Ophthalmology
DrVinodHPanchal DrMonaBPanchal DrVidhiAGajjar DrG.A.Parikh DrRippleJShah DrNarendraLavingia DrRajeshDayarani DrKandarpTrivedi DrHardikRamsingha DrYuvarajJasubha DrR.G.Surela
JR
Ophthalmology
AssistantProf Anaesthesiology AssistantProf Anaesthesiology AssistantProf Orthopaedics SR SR SR JR Orthopaedics Orthopaedics Orthopaedics Orthopaedics
Professor
GeneralSurgery
TeachingFacultyshortage ShortageofResidents
: 36%(i.e.60outof166)asunder
Sr. Resident 23
Jr. Resident 58
PrincipalhasgivenundertakingthatcollegewilladmitthestudentsonlyaftergettingLOP&allclearancesfromGovt.ofIndia. Statusofverificationofthewebsite:
S. No
Detail information
Provided or not
Dean,PrincipalandMedicalSuperintendent Staff:TeachingandNonTeaching CME,conference,academicactivityconductedbyinstitution Awards,Achievementsreceivedbythefaculty. AffiliateduniversityanditsvicechancellorandRegistrar Detailsofclinicalmaterialinthehospital. Measuresundertakentocurbthemenaceofraggingintermsof PreventionandProhibitionofRagginginMedical Colleges/InstitutionsRegulations,2009. pdfofprojectreport(Applicationform) Listofadmittedstudentsforacademicyear201011 SpecificobservationsandoverallimpressionsontheMSRaswellasqualityoffacilities:
Department Anatomy
Physiology
Biochemistry
Pharmacology
Designation Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor
Available
1 2 1 5 1 3 3 4 1 0 2 4 1 2 2 3
Shortage
0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0
Remarks
60% shortage
1 non medical
Department Pathology
Microbiology
Forensic Medicine
Community Medicine
General Medicine
Designation Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof.
Available
0 3 4 6 1 1 2 4 0 2 0 3 1 2 2 4 3 4
Shortage
1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
50% shortage
Asstt. Prof.
0 6 0 0 0
1 prof considered as associate professors 1 prof can be considerd as Assistant Professor. 50% Shotage of Assistant professors
100% shortage of SR and JR
Paediatrics
2 1 2
1 Prof shown as Associate 100 % Shortage of S/R ( 3 SRs presented were above the age 45 years and JR, 3 JR presented but did not appear authentic
General Surgery
Orthopaedics
Ophthalmology
Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof.
0 2 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0
1 3 5 6 0 1 3 3 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 2 7 0 2 2
Oto-Rhino-Laryngology
Obstetrics &Gynaecology
Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof. Tutor Professor Assoc. Prof. Asstt. Prof.
1 1 0 0 2 2 2 0 1 3 2 0 1 0 1
100% shortage of SR
Anaesthesiology
Radio- Diagnosis
3 1 1 1 1
Dentistry
75% shortage of SRs. 1 doctor presented as filler for JRs (overage for the post) 3 dental faculty presented for the post of Prof, associate Prof and Assistant Prof. But there forms were not signed by the competent authority. None presented for tutor.
0 0 0 0
Tutor
Professor six Assoc. Professor nine Asst. Professor fifteen Tutor nil
ShortageofResidents : 66%(i.e.23outof35)asunder
Total
Dated :
TEACHINGFACULTY Deptt.wisenamesoffacultywiththeirdesignation(Prof.,Assoc.Prof.,Asst.Prof.,Tutor/Resident)onthedateofAssessmentare:
I) Department of Anatomy
: : : : :
II) Department of Biochemistry
Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr.
Professor&HOD Professor AssociateProfessor AssistantProfessor Tutor Professor&HOD Professor AssociateProfessor AssistantProfessor Tutor Professor&HOD Professor AssociateProfessor AssistantProfessor Tutor Professor&HOD Professor AssociateProfessor AssistantProfessor Tutor
IX) X)
Signaturewithstamp Dean/Principal/Director